1 Construction of Water Bars and Turn-Outs 2005, Mid Star Timber Harvesting, Inc.

11

Construction of Water Bars and Construction of Water Bars and Turn-OutsTurn-Outs

2005, Mid Star Timber Harvesting, Inc.2005, Mid Star Timber Harvesting, Inc.

22

PurposePurpose

This course has been designed to ensure all This course has been designed to ensure all equipment operators who work in forestry equipment operators who work in forestry operations have the knowledge and skills operations have the knowledge and skills necessary to properly and consistently necessary to properly and consistently construct, maintain, and repair water bars and construct, maintain, and repair water bars and turn-outs in accordance with Best Management turn-outs in accordance with Best Management Practices for Forestry. Practices for Forestry.

33

CourseCourse Objectives Objectives Demonstrate correct size, distances between, Demonstrate correct size, distances between,

and angle of construction for water barsand angle of construction for water bars Demonstrate correct size, distances between, Demonstrate correct size, distances between,

angle of construction, and outfall design for angle of construction, and outfall design for turn-outsturn-outs

Learn step-by-step procedures for constructing a Learn step-by-step procedures for constructing a water bar/turn-out system.water bar/turn-out system.

Consider alternative construction techniques for Consider alternative construction techniques for water bars and turn-outs when faced with non-water bars and turn-outs when faced with non-routine situationsroutine situations

44

The Erosive Effects of Moving WaterThe Erosive Effects of Moving Water

The purpose of water bars and turn-outs is to prevent The purpose of water bars and turn-outs is to prevent erosion of the road surface and ditches by forcing water to erosion of the road surface and ditches by forcing water to leave the road bed and enter the forest floor.leave the road bed and enter the forest floor.

As water moves down-grade, it picks up soil and carries it As water moves down-grade, it picks up soil and carries it away, resulting in erosion. The farther the water is allowed away, resulting in erosion. The farther the water is allowed to travel down the road bed, the more velocity it will gain.to travel down the road bed, the more velocity it will gain.

If the distance the water is allowed to travel is not If the distance the water is allowed to travel is not somehow shortened, the increasing velocity of the water somehow shortened, the increasing velocity of the water can result in increased erosion of the road bed and an can result in increased erosion of the road bed and an undesirable amount of silt being carried to the forest floor undesirable amount of silt being carried to the forest floor when the water finally reaches a point of discharge from when the water finally reaches a point of discharge from the road bed. the road bed.

55

Water Bar Design ConsiderationsWater Bar Design Considerations

Water bars must be designed so that water is not Water bars must be designed so that water is not allowed to travel great distances down the road bed allowed to travel great distances down the road bed before being discharged and should in most cases be before being discharged and should in most cases be constructed so that the road bed may still be used by constructed so that the road bed may still be used by light truck traffic.light truck traffic.

By constructing water bars of a sufficient height, By constructing water bars of a sufficient height, width, angle from the road edge, and distance width, angle from the road edge, and distance between them, erosion control objectives can be met between them, erosion control objectives can be met while maintaining aesthetic qualities that are pleasing while maintaining aesthetic qualities that are pleasing to forest road owners and users. to forest road owners and users.

66

Water Bar Construction TimeWater Bar Construction Time

To properly construct water bars takes time.To properly construct water bars takes time.

A good rule of thumb to use when A good rule of thumb to use when constructing water bars is to allow thirty constructing water bars is to allow thirty minutes for each water bar constructed on an minutes for each water bar constructed on an average road bed twenty-four feet wide.average road bed twenty-four feet wide.

Patience during construction will ensure the Patience during construction will ensure the water bar will continue to function properly water bar will continue to function properly for years to come.for years to come.

77

Water Bar SizeWater Bar Size

Water bars should reach all the way across the Water bars should reach all the way across the road, be approximately 12 feet wide at the road, be approximately 12 feet wide at the base, and 2 feet high from the uphill trough to base, and 2 feet high from the uphill trough to the crest.the crest.

12’

2’

88

Distance Between Water BarsDistance Between Water Bars

The table below shows recommended distances The table below shows recommended distances between adjacent water bars depending on the slope between adjacent water bars depending on the slope of the road.of the road.

Slope Distance

3% 200’

5% 135’

10% 80’

15% 20’

20% 45’

30% 35’

99

Distance Between Water BarsDistance Between Water Bars

Instead of having to remember the slope to distance Instead of having to remember the slope to distance relationship shown in the previous table, a good rule of relationship shown in the previous table, a good rule of thumb is to use the method shown below.thumb is to use the method shown below.

Standing at the crest (or trough)Standing at the crest (or trough) of the lower water of the lower water bar, the crest (or trough) of the next water bar uphill bar, the crest (or trough) of the next water bar uphill should be at approximately eye level.should be at approximately eye level.

1010

Angle of Construction for Water BarsAngle of Construction for Water Bars

Water bars should be constructed at approximately 30 Water bars should be constructed at approximately 30 degrees to the direction of travel on the road. This angle degrees to the direction of travel on the road. This angle will allow the water to flow off the surface of the road will allow the water to flow off the surface of the road with little or no obstruction in flow. with little or no obstruction in flow.

Although ideally there will be minimal silt carried in the Although ideally there will be minimal silt carried in the water diverted by a properly constructed water bar, during water diverted by a properly constructed water bar, during heavy rainfall, as water reaches a water bar built directly heavy rainfall, as water reaches a water bar built directly across the road, it tends to resist an abrupt change in across the road, it tends to resist an abrupt change in direction of flow and will either jump the water bar or direction of flow and will either jump the water bar or deposit excess silt in the trough during the change in deposit excess silt in the trough during the change in direction and velocity…..direction and velocity…..

1111

Angle of Construction for Water BarsAngle of Construction for Water Bars

Over time, excess silt deposited in the trough can Over time, excess silt deposited in the trough can reduce the working height of the water bar and render reduce the working height of the water bar and render it ineffective.it ineffective.

By building the water bar at an angle, the water By building the water bar at an angle, the water retains enough of it’s initial velocity to keep the retains enough of it’s initial velocity to keep the trough cleaned out and the water bar will remain trough cleaned out and the water bar will remain effective over a longer period of time.effective over a longer period of time.

1212

Angle of Construction for Water BarsAngle of Construction for Water Bars

A rule of thumb for achieving the correct angle of a A rule of thumb for achieving the correct angle of a water bar is shown below.water bar is shown below.

Step off the distance from the beginning of where Step off the distance from the beginning of where you want the water bar on one side of the road you want the water bar on one side of the road straight across to the other side. Divide that distance straight across to the other side. Divide that distance by three and step the resulting distance downhill to by three and step the resulting distance downhill to find the ending point of the water bar.find the ending point of the water bar.

1313

Turn-OutsTurn-Outs

It goes without saying that water bars would It goes without saying that water bars would be completely ineffective without a means for be completely ineffective without a means for water to exit the road. Turn-outs are used at water to exit the road. Turn-outs are used at every water bar and as needed along the road every water bar and as needed along the road to allow water an escape to the forest floor.to allow water an escape to the forest floor.

The proper construction of turn-outs is as The proper construction of turn-outs is as important as water bars to prevent erosion and important as water bars to prevent erosion and excessive siltation of the forest floor.excessive siltation of the forest floor.

1414

Turn-Out SizeTurn-Out Size

The size of turn-outs should be at least as wide The size of turn-outs should be at least as wide at the entrance to the turn-out as the width of at the entrance to the turn-out as the width of the water bar or ditch that feeds water into it. the water bar or ditch that feeds water into it. This prevents any bottleneck in the flow of This prevents any bottleneck in the flow of water from the water bar or ditch to the turn-water from the water bar or ditch to the turn-out. The turn-out should then broaden and out. The turn-out should then broaden and flatten out as it continues onto the forest floor.flatten out as it continues onto the forest floor.

1515

Distance Between Turn-OutsDistance Between Turn-Outs

Turn-outs should be placed at the exit side of Turn-outs should be placed at the exit side of every water bar and at every opportunity along every water bar and at every opportunity along the road.the road.

The bottom line is this:The bottom line is this:

You really can’t have too much road You really can’t have too much road drainage. Install turn-outs as often as possible drainage. Install turn-outs as often as possible along the road on each side to carry water off along the road on each side to carry water off the traveling surface of the road.the traveling surface of the road.

1616

Distance Between Turn-OutsDistance Between Turn-Outs The following table shows some guidelines for distances The following table shows some guidelines for distances

between turn-out installations based on the slope of the between turn-out installations based on the slope of the road.road.

SlopeSlope DistanceDistance

3%3% 235’235’

5%5% 180’180’

10%10% 140’140’

15%15% 125’125’

Remember, in most cases, you can’t have too much Remember, in most cases, you can’t have too much drainage!drainage!

1717

Angle of Construction for Turn-OutsAngle of Construction for Turn-Outs

Turn-outs should be built at the same angle as the Turn-outs should be built at the same angle as the water bar that feeds it.water bar that feeds it.

In the case of a stand-alone turn-out, it should In the case of a stand-alone turn-out, it should gradually curve away from the road toward the gradually curve away from the road toward the forest floor, but in no case should the outfall be forest floor, but in no case should the outfall be greater than 90 degrees from the direction of greater than 90 degrees from the direction of travel on the road.travel on the road.

1818

Angle of Construction for Turn-OutsAngle of Construction for Turn-Outs

RightRight

WrongWrong

1919

Outfall Design for Turn-OutsOutfall Design for Turn-Outs

The outfall section of a turn-out should be flat The outfall section of a turn-out should be flat andand about a dozer blade wide, if possible.about a dozer blade wide, if possible.

There should be no obstruction to prevent There should be no obstruction to prevent water from flowing freely out of the outfall.water from flowing freely out of the outfall.

Standing water in a turn-out after a rain is an Standing water in a turn-out after a rain is an indication of an improperly constructed one. indication of an improperly constructed one.

2020

Water Bar/Turn-Out ConstructionWater Bar/Turn-Out ConstructionStep 1Step 1

Determine the landowner/customer’s objectives. Determine the landowner/customer’s objectives. Some want a more thorough job than others based Some want a more thorough job than others based on financial or time constraints.on financial or time constraints.Some may want water bars built not only to Some may want water bars built not only to prevent erosion, but also to prevent access. In this prevent erosion, but also to prevent access. In this case, the water bars should be built higher and case, the water bars should be built higher and steeper than normal.steeper than normal.A clear understanding beforehand can prevent A clear understanding beforehand can prevent most dissatisfaction with jobs after completion.most dissatisfaction with jobs after completion.

2121

Water Bar/Turn-Out ConstructionWater Bar/Turn-Out ConstructionStep 2Step 2

Assess the terrain and soil type and develop a plan.Assess the terrain and soil type and develop a plan.

Based on terrain and soil type observations, Based on terrain and soil type observations, decisions can be made on water bar and turn-out decisions can be made on water bar and turn-out placement and frequency. Sandy soils need more placement and frequency. Sandy soils need more frequent water bars and turn-outs than rocky ones.frequent water bars and turn-outs than rocky ones.

Make a note of any stream crossings or streamside Make a note of any stream crossings or streamside management zones in your planned work zone. management zones in your planned work zone. These require special treatment in order to avoid These require special treatment in order to avoid water quality violations.water quality violations.

2222

Water Bar/Turn-Out ConstructionWater Bar/Turn-Out ConstructionStep 3Step 3

Remove any organic debris (leaves, straw, grass, Remove any organic debris (leaves, straw, grass, sticks) from the surface of the road in the areas sticks) from the surface of the road in the areas around where water bars are to be constructed. This around where water bars are to be constructed. This debris, if mixed in with the soil used to construct a debris, if mixed in with the soil used to construct a water bar, will not allow the soil to become cohesive water bar, will not allow the soil to become cohesive and stabilize.and stabilize.Also, remove any organic debris from the area where Also, remove any organic debris from the area where the turn-out leading out of a water bar is to be the turn-out leading out of a water bar is to be constructed. If at all possible, soil from the turn-out constructed. If at all possible, soil from the turn-out area should be brought back into the road and used in area should be brought back into the road and used in the construction of the water bar.the construction of the water bar.

2323

Water Bar/Turn-Out ConstructionWater Bar/Turn-Out ConstructionStep 4Step 4

Step off or visualize the correct angle and size of Step off or visualize the correct angle and size of construction.construction.Gather the soil into a pile shaped slightly larger Gather the soil into a pile shaped slightly larger than you think you will need for the finished water than you think you will need for the finished water bar. The lowest part of the trough should be cut out bar. The lowest part of the trough should be cut out of natural ground, if possible.of natural ground, if possible.Pack the entire pile by walking back and forth over Pack the entire pile by walking back and forth over it with your machine (dozer, skidder, etc.).it with your machine (dozer, skidder, etc.).

2424

Water Bar/Turn-Out ConstructionWater Bar/Turn-Out ConstructionStep 5Step 5

Finish shaping the pile with the blade of your Finish shaping the pile with the blade of your machine. If the road is to be used while the water machine. If the road is to be used while the water bars are in place, this step is crucial to the aesthetic bars are in place, this step is crucial to the aesthetic quality of the job. Any excess material bladed off the quality of the job. Any excess material bladed off the uphill side of the water bar should be placed on the uphill side of the water bar should be placed on the downhill side. Using a dozer, you should be able to downhill side. Using a dozer, you should be able to blade all the way over the water bar, keeping the blade all the way over the water bar, keeping the blade in contact with the ground. If not, the crest of blade in contact with the ground. If not, the crest of the water bar is probably too sharp. the water bar is probably too sharp.

2525

Water Bar/Turn-Out ConstructionWater Bar/Turn-Out ConstructionStep 6Step 6

If you were able to use dirt for the water bar from the If you were able to use dirt for the water bar from the turn-out area, complete construction of the system by turn-out area, complete construction of the system by finish grading the turn-out at the exit side of the finish grading the turn-out at the exit side of the water bar.water bar.

The turn-out should slope downhill from the water The turn-out should slope downhill from the water bar at about the same rate of slope as the water bar bar at about the same rate of slope as the water bar that feeds it.that feeds it.

2626

Non-Routine SituationsNon-Routine Situations

Inevitably situations will arise where these Inevitably situations will arise where these guidelines for water bars and turn-outs will not be guidelines for water bars and turn-outs will not be practicable. When faced with those situations, you practicable. When faced with those situations, you should study carefully any possibilities and options should study carefully any possibilities and options available. The most important thing to remember is available. The most important thing to remember is the reason you are building water bars and turn-outs the reason you are building water bars and turn-outs on the road to begin with:on the road to begin with:

ELIMINATE OR REDUCE THE POSSIBILTY OF ELIMINATE OR REDUCE THE POSSIBILTY OF EROSION!EROSION!