1 BUILDING DYNAMICS: Moisture, Airflows and Construction Technology James Biddle, Mansel Nelson Northern Arizona University Presentation Credit to: Joseph.

1

BUILDING DYNAMICS:BUILDING DYNAMICS:Moisture, Airflows and Moisture, Airflows and

Construction TechnologyConstruction Technology

James Biddle, Mansel Nelson James Biddle, Mansel Nelson

Northern Arizona UniversityNorthern Arizona University

Presentation Credit to: Joseph T. Ponessa, Ph.D.Presentation Credit to: Joseph T. Ponessa, Ph.D.

Professor Emeritus Housing, Indoor Environments and Professor Emeritus Housing, Indoor Environments and HealthHealth

2

GoalsGoals Review basic dynamics of moisture Review basic dynamics of moisture

movement, control in buildingsmovement, control in buildings Review basic dynamics of airflows in Review basic dynamics of airflows in

buildingsbuildings Proper management of moisture and Proper management of moisture and

airflows provides better buildings and airflows provides better buildings and reduces callbacksreduces callbacks

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Understanding of these mechanisms Understanding of these mechanisms

is essential for diagnosticsis essential for diagnostics

3

Objective: How does this fit with Objective: How does this fit with weatherization?weatherization?

Weatherization can improve comfort and Weatherization can improve comfort and save money. Downside is ‘inadequate’ save money. Downside is ‘inadequate’ ventilationventilation

When is ventilation inadequate?When is ventilation inadequate? When it is less than prescribed When it is less than prescribed

ventilationventilation When it is inadequate to take care of When it is inadequate to take care of

building excessesbuilding excesses– Too much moistureToo much moisture– Excessive pollution sourcesExcessive pollution sources

4

Overview of Today’s Overview of Today’s PresentationPresentation

Building ScienceBuilding Science Moisture dynamics; applications in Moisture dynamics; applications in

buildingsbuildings

Airflow mechanisms; applications in Airflow mechanisms; applications in buildingsbuildings

55

Section I:Section I: Moisture Dynamics Moisture DynamicsOutlineOutline

Basic moisture science: Vapor & Basic moisture science: Vapor & Liquid Liquid – Air – vapor – temperature relationshipsAir – vapor – temperature relationships– Relative HumidityRelative Humidity– Putting it all together – Psychrometric Putting it all together – Psychrometric

chart chart Vapor movementVapor movement

DiffusionDiffusion Bulk transfer – air flowsBulk transfer – air flows

66

Moisture Dynamics Moisture Dynamics Outline (cont.)Outline (cont.)

Basic moisture scienceBasic moisture science (cont.) (cont.) Water movementWater movement

Gravity; windGravity; wind Capillary actionCapillary action

Moisture sourcesMoisture sources Moisture MeasurementMoisture Measurement

AirAir Surfaces / solidsSurfaces / solids

7

Moisture DynamicsMoisture Dynamics

Water can exist in three statesWater can exist in three states VaporVapor LiquidLiquid SolidSolid

8

Moisture Dynamics (cont.)Moisture Dynamics (cont.)VaporVapor

Vapor-Vapor-Temperature Temperature relationshipsrelationships (At (At saturation)saturation)

The amount of moisture that air can hold increases directly with temperature.

Moisture content of air (GMS/m3) at various

temperatures

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Deg F 20 40 60 80

9

Moisture DynamicsMoisture Dynamics VaporVapor

Dew point: Dew point: SaturationSaturation

Air cooled to the limit Air cooled to the limit of its moisture of its moisture carrying capacity carrying capacity releases vapor as releases vapor as droplets droplets condensation (or condensation (or rain) rain)

This is the This is the Dew point Dew point temperaturetemperature

10

Moisture DynamicsMoisture Dynamics VaporVapor

So what does it all mean?So what does it all mean?

Moist air that is cooled downMoist air that is cooled down

OR…OR…

Moist air that meets a cool surface Moist air that meets a cool surface will will condense!condense!

Wet surfaces that don’t/can’t dry Wet surfaces that don’t/can’t dry rapidly will produce moldrapidly will produce mold

11

Moisture DynamicsMoisture Dynamics Vapor TransportVapor Transport

Vapor transport: how does vapor get Vapor transport: how does vapor get from point A to point B?from point A to point B?

POSSIBLE MECHANISMSPOSSIBLE MECHANISMS DiffusionDiffusion Bulk transport: AirflowBulk transport: Airflow

Which is more important?Which is more important?

12

Moisture DynamicsMoisture Dynamics Vapor Transport viaVapor Transport via AirflowAirflow

Moisture carried into wall via air flow / leakage Moisture carried into wall via air flow / leakage through openings. through openings. What is the driving force?What is the driving force?

Source: USDOE

13

Moisture DynamicsMoisture Dynamics

Which mechanism is most important?Which mechanism is most important?

Diffusion?Diffusion?

Air transport?Air transport?

14

Moisture DynamicsMoisture Dynamics

Diffusion vs. air transportDiffusion vs. air transport

While air transport accounts for bulk While air transport accounts for bulk of moisture migration in most of moisture migration in most buildings, there are circumstances buildings, there are circumstances when diffusion is most important when diffusion is most important factorfactor

15

Permeability – Bldg Permeability – Bldg MaterialsMaterials

Four classes of Four classes of vapor vapor retarders have retarders have been identifiedbeen identified

Vapor Imperm P Vapor Imperm P <0.1<0.1 * *

PE FilmPE Film

GlassGlass

Aluminum foilAluminum foil

Foil faced insul (non Foil faced insul (non perf)perf)Semi-imperm. P 0.1-1Semi-imperm. P 0.1-1

Kraft –backed fiberglass Kraft –backed fiberglass insulinsul

Oil based paintOil based paint

Vinyl wallpaper (most)Vinyl wallpaper (most)

Extr polystr >1” (unfaced)Extr polystr >1” (unfaced)

P = Perm

* Vapor Barrier

16

Permeability – Bldg. Permeability – Bldg. MaterialsMaterials

Vapor semi-perm Vapor semi-perm P1-10P1-10

PlywoodPlywood

Bitumen impreg kraftBitumen impreg kraft

OSBOSB

Unfaced Exp Unfaced Exp polystyrenepolystyrene

Unfaced Extr poly <1”Unfaced Extr poly <1”

Building paperBuilding paper

Latex paint (Most)Latex paint (Most)

Vapor perm P Vapor perm P >10>10

Fiberglass insulFiberglass insul

Unpainted gyp Unpainted gyp board, plasterboard, plaster

Masonry, Masonry, Fiberboard,Fiberboard,

Dimens. lumberDimens. lumber

15# felt, 15# felt, HousewrapHousewrap

Cellulose insulationCellulose insulationBuilding America Best Practices Series: Volume 4 –

…..Mixed-Humid Climate Version 1, 9/2005 • Design-

p13

17

PERMABILITYPERMABILITY

An important note about building An important note about building materials and watermaterials and water

Permability of many materials changes Permability of many materials changes when they are wet. Ppermeability of wet when they are wet. Ppermeability of wet plywood, for example, changes from plywood, for example, changes from 0.75 (dry) to 3.0 when wet0.75 (dry) to 3.0 when wet

Questions about Questions about vapor vapor

transmission/dynamictransmission/dynamics?s?

While vapor migration and While vapor migration and condensation can play an condensation can play an important role in moisture important role in moisture

problems, most problems are problems, most problems are caused by rainwatercaused by rainwater

19

Moisture DynamicsMoisture DynamicsLiquidLiquid

Liquid water can flow viaLiquid water can flow via Gravity (or wind pressure)Gravity (or wind pressure) Capillary action (wicking)Capillary action (wicking)

= against gravity= against gravity

20

Moisture DynamicsMoisture DynamicsLiquidLiquid

GravityGravity

““It flows downhill”It flows downhill”

Source: Builder Magazine

21

Moisture DynamicsMoisture Dynamics

Capillary actionCapillary action

Water can flow Water can flow against gravity against gravity when moving in a when moving in a tight space…tight space…

…and, by the same process, can wick through porous materials

22

Moisture DynamicsMoisture Dynamics

Practical applicationsPractical applications Water can travel up and behind Water can travel up and behind

flashing that is not properly flashing that is not properly dimensioneddimensioned

Water can diffuse/wick through Water can diffuse/wick through masonry, adding humidity to spaces masonry, adding humidity to spaces and wetting components (e.g. sill and wetting components (e.g. sill plates)plates)

23

Moisture DynamicsMoisture DynamicsCapillary actionCapillary action

Source: USDOE

24

Moisture dynamicsMoisture dynamics

Some builders, at least, have known about Some builders, at least, have known about capillary action for a long time…capillary action for a long time…

XXX barnAbbey grange,Great Coxwell, England

Photo: Barn. Houghton Mifflin, 1992.

25

Moisture dynamicsMoisture dynamics

Barn interior, Barn interior, showing posts set showing posts set on stone pierson stone piers

This barn, built in This barn, built in mid- 13mid- 13thth century, century, in use until 1966, in use until 1966, when deeded to when deeded to National trustNational trust

Photo: Photo: Barn. Barn. Houghton Houghton Mifflin, 1992Mifflin, 1992

26

Moisture dynamicsMoisture dynamics

Note detail on top of Note detail on top of pierpier

A sacrificial wood slab A sacrificial wood slab has been placed has been placed here. Moisture here. Moisture migrating through migrating through pier will enter slab pier will enter slab instead of end grain instead of end grain of post; slab is easily of post; slab is easily replacedreplaced

Photo: Photo: Barn. Barn. Houghton Mifflin, Houghton Mifflin, 19921992

27

Moisture SourcesMoisture Sources

Outline for this sectionOutline for this section Plumbing leaksPlumbing leaks RainwaterRainwater GroundwaterGroundwater Humid air (Including embodied Humid air (Including embodied

water)water) Mechanical equipment (Including Mechanical equipment (Including

Combustion equipmentCombustion equipment)) Occupant practicesOccupant practices

28

Moisture Sources:Moisture Sources:Plumbing leaksPlumbing leaks

Plumbing leaks should be obvious Plumbing leaks should be obvious but can be in concealed spaces, and but can be in concealed spaces, and may involve supply or drain linesmay involve supply or drain lines

Sweating may sometimes be Sweating may sometimes be significantsignificant

29

Moisture SourcesMoisture SourcesRainwaterRainwater

Gutters & downspoutsGutters & downspouts Water discharged next Water discharged next

to foundation and /or to foundation and /or against building is against building is almost certain to enter almost certain to enter

Most basement Most basement moisture problems moisture problems are due to rainwaterare due to rainwater

30

Moisture SourcesMoisture SourcesRainwaterRainwater

Discharge against Discharge against building may also building may also penetrate- penetrate- masonry masonry is not waterproofis not waterproof

(Consider masonry as (Consider masonry as a “Hard sponge”)a “Hard sponge”)

------------------------------------Low spots, backslope Low spots, backslope

next to building also next to building also cause problemscause problems

31

Moisture Sources:Moisture Sources:Rainwater and gradingRainwater and grading

32

Moisture Sources:Humid air (Summer)

Basement ventilation may add moisture / RH

Also consider air

conditioned interior

33

Moisture sources:Moisture sources:Mechanical equipmentMechanical equipment

Combustion Combustion produces a LOT produces a LOT of moistureof moisture

2O2O22 + CH + CH44 = CO = CO2 2

+ 2H+ 2H22OO

1 lb of nat gas 1 lb of nat gas

2.25 lb (1.125 2.25 lb (1.125 Q) water!Q) water! Gas furnace, blocked

flu, condensation

soaks brick in & out

Further discussion under

Airflows

34

Moisture MeasurementMoisture Measurement

Air Air measuremenmeasurementt

Sling Sling psychrometepsychrometerr

Hygrometer Hygrometer (electronic)(electronic)

35

Moisture Measurement Moisture Measurement (cont.)(cont.)

Surface / Surface / material material measurementmeasurement

Electronic deviceElectronic device

(eg Protimeter)(eg Protimeter)

Measures moisture Measures moisture content- wood, content- wood, drywall, masonrydrywall, masonry

36

Moisture Content in Moisture Content in Building MaterialsBuilding Materials

Mold growth can begin…Mold growth can begin… In lumber @16% moisture content In lumber @16% moisture content

(this represents equilibrium (this represents equilibrium @80%RH)@80%RH)

In gypsum sheathing @1% moisture In gypsum sheathing @1% moisture content content

Source: Lstiburek, ASHRAE Journal, 2/02Source: Lstiburek, ASHRAE Journal, 2/02

37

Keep Water Out: Drain the Building

38

Case study: Things Gone WrongCase study: Things Gone Wrong

Photo: Joe Lstiburek Photo: Nathan Yost, BSC

3939

Anatomy of a DisasterAnatomy of a Disaster

4040

Photo: Mark LaLiberte, Building Knowledge.

Flashing is Key: e.g., WindowsFlashing is Key: e.g., Windows

4141

Photo: Mark LaLiberte, Building Knowledge.

4242

Photo: Mark LaLiberte, Building Knowledge

Reverse Flashing: A Common Reverse Flashing: A Common MistakeMistake

43

Building Moisture: Take-Building Moisture: Take-away Messagesaway Messages

Building components that get wet Building components that get wet must be able to dry out quickly. must be able to dry out quickly. Assemblies must be able to dry!Assemblies must be able to dry!

If they don’t, mold and other If they don’t, mold and other organisms will grow, creating health organisms will grow, creating health hazard for occupants and ultimately hazard for occupants and ultimately destroying the buildingdestroying the building

A moisture problem is like a fire: it will A moisture problem is like a fire: it will not get better with time. It cannot not get better with time. It cannot be ignored. be ignored. Respond promptly!Respond promptly!

44

Section II:Section II: AIRFLOWS AIRFLOWS

OUTLINEOUTLINE Air moves according to Air moves according to pressure pressure

differencesdifferences; These can be created ; These can be created byby– Temperature differencesTemperature differences– WindWind– Mechanical equipmentMechanical equipment

45

• For air to move (leak) into or out of building, you need a hole and a pressure difference

• Air in must equal air out–same for moisture, but on a different time frame

• Pathways can be direct or indirect, natural or mechanical

EEBA BFG

AirflowAirflow

46

Airflows: Driving forces:Airflows: Driving forces: Temperature DifferencesTemperature Differences

Heating Season:

Source: USDOE

Aka THERMOSIPHONING

47

Airflows: Driving Forces:Airflows: Driving Forces: WindWind

Source: USDOE

48

Airflows: Driving forces:Airflows: Driving forces: Mechanical EquipmentMechanical Equipment

Airflows can also be influenced byAirflows can also be influenced by Ventilation fansVentilation fans Furnaces / boilersFurnaces / boilers Ductwork (leaking)Ductwork (leaking) Major Appliances (dryer, water heater)Major Appliances (dryer, water heater)

All of the above can remove air from All of the above can remove air from the conditioned space. the conditioned space. What about What about makeup air?makeup air?

49

Providing Fresh AirProviding Fresh Air

Best practiceBest practice to control moisture, to control moisture, pollutants and to save energypollutants and to save energy

Build a tight buildingBuild a tight building Tightly seal ductsTightly seal ducts (anything (anything butbut duct duct

tape)tape) Ventilate by design!Ventilate by design!

50

Building Ventilation by Building Ventilation by AccidentAccident

Typical Typical ducts ducts can lose can lose 25% of 25% of airflow airflow through through joint joint leakageleakage

Daylight!

51

……and some ducts lose more than and some ducts lose more than 25% of 25% of

their airflow!their airflow!

“Needs repair”

52

Typical Ventilation RatesTypical Ventilation Rates

100-year-old house: Two ACH100-year-old house: Two ACH Energy-conserving house (1970’s)”: Energy-conserving house (1970’s)”:

0.1 ACH)0.1 ACH) Estimated optimum, 1980’s: 0.5 ACHEstimated optimum, 1980’s: 0.5 ACH Present day: ASHRAE’s engineering Present day: ASHRAE’s engineering

standardstandard

53

Building Ventilation by Building Ventilation by DesignDesign

Various choicesVarious choices Passive vent open to buildingPassive vent open to building Outside air ducted to air return; Outside air ducted to air return;

dampers, controllersdampers, controllers Sealed combustion equipment Sealed combustion equipment

reduces need for makeup airreduces need for makeup air

54

ASHRAE Residential ASHRAE Residential Ventilation Standard 62.2Ventilation Standard 62.2

Goal: Reduce indoor pollutantsGoal: Reduce indoor pollutants

Approach Approach Whole-house ventilationWhole-house ventilation

50 CFM (typical house)50 CFM (typical house) Vent system rated @ 7.5 CF PP + Vent system rated @ 7.5 CF PP +

1CFM / 100SF (Some exceptions)1CFM / 100SF (Some exceptions) Local exhaustLocal exhaust

Mech exhaust, Kitchens & baths (Not Mech exhaust, Kitchens & baths (Not toilets, utility rooms) toilets, utility rooms)

Source: M. Sherman, Lawrence Berkeley Labs

55

ASHRAE Residential Ventilation ASHRAE Residential Ventilation Standard 62.2 (cont.)Standard 62.2 (cont.)

Source controlSource control Some sources addressedSome sources addressed

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Backdraft testing required in some Backdraft testing required in some

casescasesSome secondary requirementsSome secondary requirementsSome flexibilitySome flexibilityLots of controversyLots of controversy

56

ASHRAE Residential Ventilation ASHRAE Residential Ventilation Standard 62.2 (cont’d.)Standard 62.2 (cont’d.)

About whole house ventilationAbout whole house ventilation

Calculation: Calculation: House, 3 BR, 1500 House, 3 BR, 1500 sq ftsq ft

7.5 CFM/ BR+1 + 1CFM/100 sq ft7.5 CFM/ BR+1 + 1CFM/100 sq ft

7.5X4 + 100X15 = 30 + 15 = 7.5X4 + 100X15 = 30 + 15 = 45 45 CFMCFM

57

Airflows: Airflows: SummarySummary

Why be concerned about airflows into & Why be concerned about airflows into & out of buildings?out of buildings?

1)1) Energy transfers (losses)Energy transfers (losses)

2)2) Moisture transport (into bldg or into walls)Moisture transport (into bldg or into walls)

3)3) Pollutant transport (eg radon, ozone, Pollutant transport (eg radon, ozone, fireplace smoke, particulates, etc.)fireplace smoke, particulates, etc.)

And on the plus side, airflows provideAnd on the plus side, airflows provide

1)1) Fresh airFresh air

2)2) Replacement/ makeup airReplacement/ makeup air

58

Airflow Dynamics Airflow Dynamics SummarySummary

““Nature abhors a vacuum”Nature abhors a vacuum”

The law that gases (and other materials) The law that gases (and other materials) move from a region of high pressure move from a region of high pressure to low pressure is analogous to, and as to low pressure is analogous to, and as immutable as the law of gravityimmutable as the law of gravity

Pressures will equilibrate whenever Pressures will equilibrate whenever there is a pathway, no matter how there is a pathway, no matter how small or indirect small or indirect

59

Airflow Dynamics Airflow Dynamics Summary (cont.)Summary (cont.)

Amount of air entering (or leaving) Amount of air entering (or leaving) through various openings (such as through various openings (such as envelope leaks) vs. flue openings envelope leaks) vs. flue openings depends on relative sizes of openingsdepends on relative sizes of openings

ORORIf total envelope leaks are small relative If total envelope leaks are small relative

to flue opening(s), some flues may to flue opening(s), some flues may become main sources of makeup air–a become main sources of makeup air–a problem if flue is active!problem if flue is active!

Direct vent or sealed combustion betterDirect vent or sealed combustion better

60

Airflows Airflows SummarySummary

Take Home Message

If building airflow is not balanced

– inflow and exhaust not equal - the building

will become pressurized or depressurized

and bad things can happen.

Likewise, pressure differentials can happen

within the building.

61

References & Resources References & Resources for this Sectionfor this Section

Building Science Corporation Building Science Corporation wwww.buildingscience.comwwww.buildingscience.com

BFG: BFG: Builders Guide: Mixed Humid Builders Guide: Mixed Humid ClimatesClimates. Energy and Environmental . Energy and Environmental Building Association (EEBA): Building Association (EEBA): www.eeba.orgwww.eeba.org

Lstiburek, J. Lstiburek, J. Water Management Guide. Water Management Guide. Energy and Environmental Building Energy and Environmental Building Association (EEBA): 2004. www.eeba.orgAssociation (EEBA): 2004. www.eeba.org

Building America Best Practices Series: Building America Best Practices Series: Volume 4. USDOE Building America Volume 4. USDOE Building America program: program: www.buildingamerica.gov

6262

References (cont.)References (cont.)

Lstiburek, J. Moisture Control for Lstiburek, J. Moisture Control for Buildings. Buildings. ASHRAE Journal, ASHRAE Journal, Feb 02, Feb 02, pp36-41. pp36-41.

HUD HUD Moisture Resistant Homes. March Moisture Resistant Homes. March 2006. 125 pp. 2006. 125 pp. Available atAvailable at

http://www.huduser.org/publications/http://www.huduser.org/publications/destech/moisturehomes.htmldestech/moisturehomes.html

Or call 1-800 245 2691, option 1 for hard Or call 1-800 245 2691, option 1 for hard copy ($5.00)copy ($5.00)