1 Auditing your personal information management Mark Gregory Teacher and Ph.D student ESC Rennes School of Business An action guide for the perplexed or merely curious
Dec 22, 2015
1
Auditing your personal information management
Mark GregoryTeacher and Ph.D student
ESC Rennes School of Business
An action guide for the perplexed or merely curious
2
An Healthy Uneasiness I
Did you ever feel … How many times have you felt … When was the last time you felt …
… that you did not have the right means to store, organise and retrieve your personal data?
3
An Healthy Uneasiness II Do you have an effective system of folders and
sub-folders on your computers?• Could you change it to make it better? How?
Do you use more than one computer and/or "platform" (e.g. Windows PC; Mac; smartphone)?• How do you synchronise them?
• How do you protect them? What happens to you when (not if!) you lose your
smartphone? your hard disk contents?
4
Good news…
You are not alone! In fact, you are a knowledge worker
• Peter Drucker (1999) You work in knowledge networks as part of
(real or virtual) teams Alvin Toffler (1990) observed that knowledge
workers must have at their disposal systems to create, process and enhance their knowledge and that of their subordinates
5
What is Personal Information Management?
Knowledge and information workers work as individuals within team structures to get work done
Computer-based tools can assist in the storage and management of the information they acquire
However, little is understood about • How people use these tools
• How they learn new ones
• The ways in which the tools constrain the ways in which people work and think
• How best to educate people to make the right choice of the right tools
Lots of tools (e.g. spreadsheets) – few people use them well!
6
Research context: a Ph.D in progress TOPIC: “Towards a better understanding of how
individuals and small groups use computer-based information and knowledge representation tools”
COLLABORATOR: Dr. Mario Norbis, Quinnipiac• We work together as KIMSPAG: Knowledge and
Information Management Supporting People And Groups
OPEN UNIVERSITY SUPERVISOR: Prof. David Weir, Liverpool Hope University
INTERNAL SUPERVISOR: Dr. Dirk Schneckenberg
7
Our Aims and Yours Part of our aim is to help you to become more
efficient and effective by managing your personal information better
As you do this, we want you to tell us what works for you and why• So that we can improve our understanding of what
works and why on the basis of your experiences and those of others
• 1 + 1 = 3, win-win…• You are invited to participate in our Action Research!
Before you can do this, here’s some background…
8
Structure of this presentation
What PIM is Productivity paradoxes How to “do” PIM using your office suite How to “do” PIM using specialist PIM programs Researching PIM: our overall agenda Auditing your personal information
management: a suggested agenda for you Challenges
9
“Err… Put it more simply, please…”
Q: • What is personal information management?
A1: • Storing the information you need to Get Things Done GTD
• Examples: diary (agenda), to-do list A2:
• Keeping information in a way in which you can find it again and evolve it – Keeping Found Things Found KFTF
• Keeping it up-to-date
• Restructuring it when that’s necessary
• Example: your Contacts / Address Book
10
Sample PIM (Ecco): Contacts + To-Do + Appointments
Folder hierarchy – itself an outline
Contacts / address list
Details of highlighted person
Appointment with highlighted person
11
Working better We are motivated by or paid for what we do,
what we achieve: for our work Doing things involves processes, resources,
information and knowledge Doing bigger things in accordance with
deadlines and budgets may require projects Work is usually done in a competitive context –
where we as individuals or as part of an organisation have to do and be better than others
Increasingly it is done collaboratively
12
The role of information management in work
Knowledge and information workers work as individuals within organisational departments • But departments are a relatively (and increasingly?)
unimportant organisational convenience More significant are work processes
• Work processes require information which the worker stores in a large number of arbitrarily complex ways
• Some are paper-based• But they’re increasingly computer-based• And they’re moving to the Web
• Processes are sometimes individual but very often involve collaboration, implying shared information
Some of the time we work in virtual team structures to do one-off particular tasks• This way of working is called project work
13
Processes and Projects Aims, objectives, goals… are achieved by processes and/or
projects Business process (or method)
• A collection of related, structured activities or tasks that produce a specific service or product for customers (external or internal)
Business project • A collaborative enterprise, frequently involving research or
design, that is carefully planned and executed to achieve a particular aim
Processes are repeated and ongoing Projects come into existence to address a specific
problem or issue and then come to an end• Social networking within and outside the enterprise is blurring the
distinction, which is still valuable however
14
Managing projects - 1
A project can be defined as • A temporary endeavour undertaken to create
a unique product, service or result
• A management environment that is created for the purpose of delivering one or more business products according to a specified business case
The project objectives define target status at the end of the project
15
Managing projects - 2 A project therefore needs
• Objectives
• Plan
• Execution
• Evaluation
• The evaluation (measurement) occurs at the project closure but also by continuously monitoring and evaluating during the execution of the project
Projects may be huge (build the Channel Tunnel) or they may be small (build an en-suite bathroom)
Smaller projects:• Don’t generally need complicated software like Microsoft Project
• But they do need managing – there may be sub-contractors (e.g. your partner!) and there are dependencies between tasks
16
The challenge of organisational productivity
Strassman, Paul (1999) identified an organisational productivity paradox
• Increasing technological possibilities raise the hurdles all the time
• Although you can do some things quicker…
• Overall you don’t get much more work done! Why? Organisations have to do things better in order
to compete with others who are reacting to and benefiting from the same new possibilities
17
Knowledge work
Drucker, Peter (1999) identified better knowledge work productivity as our most important economic need• He went so far as to warn that our long term prosperity
and even our economic survival depends upon it Knowledge work productivity is the measure
of the efficiency and effectiveness of the output generated by workers who mainly rely on knowledge, rather than labour, during the production process
18
The challenge of personal and small-group productivity Individual knowledge workers face a personal productivity
paradox of the same kind• Increasing technological possibilities raise the hurdles all the
time• Although you can do some things quicker…• Overall you don’t get much more work done!
Why? • Individuals and the teams of which they form a part have to do
things better in order to compete with others who are reacting to and benefiting from the same new possibilities
• We vary considerably in our efficiency and effectiveness, as individuals and as collaborators
• Most of us are not lazy – we just concentrate on the wrong things at the wrong time!
We have to improve, OK?
19
Auditing our processes, projects and information needs
We should audit the way we work and the way we manage our information in order continuously to improve them
• Better identification and understanding of the various processes of which we are a part
• Better managed projects
• Based (in part) on better information management
20
Two Key Productivity Issues
Individuals, teams and organisations need to carry out business processes; they have to Get Things Done: GTD• Allen, David (2001)
To do this, they need to Keep Found Things Found: KFTF• Data
• Information
• Knowledge
• Jones, William (2007)
21
What is the difference between Getting Things Done (GTD) and Keeping Found Things Found (KFTF) - 1?
GTD is about planning your work and doing it, as an individual and in the various teams of which you are part
Teamwork for students:
• Teams for coursework assignments
• Work or project teams when doing internships
• Student clubs and micro-enterprises
• In fact, whatever is done in small groups
• It includes things like diaries (agendas, personal and shared) and project plans
22
What is the difference between Getting Things Done (GTD) and Keeping Found Things Found (KFTF) – 2?
KFTF is about keeping all the information you need to learn, to work, to live
• Lecture notes
• Reading lists
• Contact lists (address book)
• Shopping lists
• Recipes for meals Note that some things, e.g. “When your team is
playing football”, can be in either the GTD category or the KFTF category or both
23
KFTF: Keeping Found Things Found
Searching is not always the best way to find things – if you have already found them and kept them organised
So we make lists (and lists of lists), such as:• Shopping lists
• Websites, perhaps using Google toolbar to store bookmarks on the Web
• Bibliographic references
Further reading: Jones, William (2007)
24
Classifying and tagging things Classification schemes: giving names to parts of
lists• You can use simple keyword classification schemes, or
more complicated classification schemes such as those used by libraries
Recently, social networking sites have introduced tagging. Such sites include:• Reddit• Digg• Del.ici.ous
Semantic network services may well be the next generation:• Radar Networks Twine
25
Classification versus tagging Classification decides where things are in a strict tree-
structured hierarchy• Advantage: it’s easy to find something because it can only
be in one place (or, of course, nowhere)
• Disadvantages:• Complicated, especially when more than one person classifies
• Unrealistic – Fred is both a professional footballer and a town councillor
Tagging permits the same thing to be found via different routes• But its anarchic!
Errr… both are needed
26
Computers and productivity Computers can be used to
• Store and manage information
• Represent and manage knowledge Computers can be used to improve efficiency
• This was the original justification for introducing computers into businesses from the 1950s onwards
Computers can be used to increase effectiveness “There is nothing so useless as doing efficiently
that which should not be done at all.”• Peter F. Drucker
27
Business information systems - 1
Most organisations identify and procure computer-based information systems
“Information systems are the means by which people and organisations, utilising technologies, gather, process, store, use and disseminate information” (UK Academy for Information Systems definition)
28
Business information systems - 2
These systems generally support the main ongoing processes of the organisation
Example: in a school or university• A student resource planning system supports the
assessment process
• A learning management system (LMS) or virtual learning environment (VLE) supports the teaching and learning process
These are examples of large, corporate information systems
29
Work Systems
Alter (2002) defined a Work System as:
A system in which people and/or machines perform a business process using resources (e.g., information, technology, raw materials) to create products/services for internal or external customers
30
Information System = a work system that processes information, thereby supporting other work systems
An Information System processes data:• Capture (input) the data• Transmit• Store• Retrieve• Manipulate – calculate, collate …• Display
Information Systems
31
Business Information System
Data Processing SystemSource Client
Data Information
Store Data
Retrieve Data
Database
32
How to store data - 1
Data is typically stored in files• E.g. Word documents, Excel spreadsheets
But sometimes in databases• E.g. Access databases
Word, Excel and Access are programs included in the Microsoft Office suite that enable users to create, update and delete data
33
Office productivity suites An office suite is a software suite (collection
of component programs) intended for use by people like clerical staff and knowledge workers
The components are generally distributed together, have a consistent user interface and usually can interact with each other• Best-known current examples of office suites are
Microsoft Office and OpenOffice.org
34
What do they do?Office suite functionality
Focus on the production of documents of various kinds Also offer various tools for managing and sharing
personal information; the facilities typically include:
• Word processor• Spreadsheet• Presentation program
Many people use general office applications such as spreadsheets (Microsoft Excel) and relational databases (e.g. Microsoft Access) specifically for personal and small-group information management
• Database• Graphics suite• Messaging and email client
35
How to store data - 2
Data is typically stored in tables: two-dimensional structures• In MS Office terms:
• Word tables (also PowerPoint)
• Excel worksheets
• Access tables
Tables can be linked, adding a third dimension• In MS Office terms:
• Excel worksheets
• These can cross-refer to each other, using functions like HLOOKUP, MATCH and EQUIV
• Access tables are related using primary and foreign keys
Storing data in Microsoft OfficeMethod
Advantages Disadvantages
Word Simple, well understood by people with weak computing skills
No formulae (or only very rudimentary ones)
Excellent formatting options Not a safe place to store critical or long-life data
Powerful built-in outliner for structuring lists (e.g. of tasks)
Excel Some degree of structure – rows and columns
Poor support for queries – searching is slow and finding information again is imprecise
Very powerful data manipulation using formulae
Size limits – 65535 rows (until Office 2007)
No design methodology or coherence
Not a safe place to store critical or long-life data
Access Relational data model gives method and coherence
More difficult to learn
Very powerful data structuring and querying
Requires thoughtful use and advance planning
Safer critical or long-life data Not as safe as MS SQL Server, etc.Note: this slide is a two-dimensional PowerPoint table
37
Outlining in Word – Table of Contents
Use Outline Mode (in French: “mode plan”)
Note that Outlining forces a strict tree-
structured hierarchy – a piece of text is
classified by where it is in the document
38
Using Excel for bibliographic referencing
39
Using Access to store details of paper documents - Tables
Note that here Docs are hierarchically
classified by subject – SubCategory within
Category within Context
Note that here Docs are hierarchically
classified by storage – Location within Unit
40
Using Access to store details of paper documents – typical Form / Subform / Sub-subform
41
Mindmaps – for those who prefer visual representation
42
Group Information Management
Shared agendas – meeting scheduling• E.g. use a Google shared Calendar
Collaborative development of documents• Advanced versions of MS Office offer many
facilities to enable this Shared classification schemes
• Keywords• Which may be hierarchical
• Tagging
43
Software for personal and small-group information management There are also a number of computer-based
tools, sometimes referred to as Personal Information Managers or PIMs which are intended particularly to assist in the storage and management of personal information, tasks and projects
PIMs are additional and complementary to the functionality of the so-called “office suites” (sometimes “office productivity suites”)
You may need both!
44
Why can’t I manage my work using Outlook, Excel, Access?
You can, to a large degree; but:• Outlook rigidly distinguishes messages from tasks
from contacts and doesn’t greatly help you to organise or link them
• What you have to do is partly in a task list, largely in your email in-tray!
• Using Excel or Access requires you to structure your information very carefully – and most of us will spend more time doing that than we can save!
• Not everyone is good at Do-It-Yourself!
45
Ready-made PIM or Do-It-Yourself? Need a new information system? Bespoke (custom-built)?
Packaged? Integrated-component system building? An analogy:
You need a new kitchen - What alternatives exist?• Bespoke (custom-built)?
Get A Man In (GAMI)!• Totally customised• Expensive• Depends on a partnership between client and supplier and on accurate
transmission of requirements• And then the client changes their mind…
• Packaged? Buy a kit - IKEA
• Integrated-component system building Do It Yourself (DIY) – Brico Depôt, Mr. Bricolage
Put more simply, Make or Buy?
46
Problems associated with approaches based on using particular programs in a suite
An analogy:• A carpenter who only uses hammers and
nails tackles badly, or not at all, problems which need screws and screwdrivers!
Similarly:• Someone who uses spreadsheets to do what
should be done with a database! Having a good toolbox doesn’t make you
a good carpenter…
47
Recap: we MUST manage our information better…
Some information belongs to organisations and has to be managed by them: they procure corporate business information systems
Employers also enable individual productivity by providing PCs together with an office suite
However we all store and manage information (and knowledge) which is personal to us and represents our own competitive advantage – it’s ours, to manage and to profit from• Implies our own PC + office suite + PIM:
personal information management
48
Ways of managing your personal information
Write your own PIM program?
• Not a sensible option! Life’s too short… Build your own customised approach
• By integrating parts of an office suite, e.g. using Outlook together with Excel or Access – fine for individuals, OK for small groups
• But if you and your collaborators need a shared, web-accessible, database, note the arrival of “Situational Applications” – briefly discussed later in this presentation
Select and procure one or more ready-made PIM program(s)
In practice: some combination is common
49
Using office tools for personal information management
Email, contact and event management software (e.g. Microsoft Outlook)• Many people manage what they have to do by
leaving uncompleted work as emails in their in-box
Hierarchical outliners (e.g. Microsoft Word / PowerPoint outlines)
Mind-mapping software (e.g. MindManager)
50
PIM and PIM programs
Specific computer-based tools (sometimes referred to as Personal Information Managers or PIMs) have been created in order to assist in the storage and management of personal information
Programs:• E.g. Ecco, EssentialPIM, InfoQube
Web services:• E.g. Basecamp
51
Getting smarter: Auditing your current approach to PIM
Why not set yourself the task of improving your personal information management?
You can ask for help from a friendly neighbourhood PIM specialist…• E.g. the authors of this presentation!
Or you can help yourself by carrying out a Self-Audit• And here are some suggested first steps…
52
Think about the personal information management style that suits you
Think about, describe, analyse and even write notes on:
How you Get Things Done (GTD)• That is, how you keep details of what you need to do
and when, and how you plan and organise your time How you Keep Found Things Found (KFTF)
• That is, what you do to store and manage all the personal information you need in order to learn well and to live well
• How should you classify things in order to be able to find them again? On paper? On your computer and other devices (phone, music)?
53
First necessity:Use folders and sub-folders
To group like, related, things together• Hierarchical classification
Organise your computer-based files better• Use Windows Explorer
• Not the same thing as Internet Explorer
• Or Apple Finder etc.
54
Think about group tasks Describe and analyse how you (plural) Get Things Done, that
is, how you keep details of what your various workgroups need to do and when, and how you plan and organise your time in that group• How might you use computer software (such as the programs you use
as an individual, or others) in order to improve this management of time? Can you get group “buy-in” (commitment) to your suggested approach?
Describe and analyse how you Keep Found Things Found, that is, what you do to store and manage all the information you need to work together effectively in groups
• How might you use computer software (such as the programs you use as an individual, or others) in order to improve this management of information?
55
Questions to ask yourself about personal information management - 1
What “platforms” (computers and mobile phones) do you currently use in your work and personal lives?
List the computer programs you use for personal and work-related purposes
List the web services you use for personal and work-related purposes
• Have you ever considered alternatives? Which? How do you keep a list of favourite web sites? Do
you use bookmarks in Internet Explorer, Firefox, Safari etc.? Do you keep an online list of favourites (e.g. Google Toolbar bookmarks)? Should you?
56
Questions to ask yourself about personal information management - 2
List the ways in which you store and manage personal information at the moment• How do you keep your agenda (electronic diary) (if any)? How
often do you lose it?• Which email clients do you use? Do you synchronise them?
What personal information matters to you? Make a list of the various kinds (or types) of information you store, and how you currently do it• Examples include shopping lists, inventory of possessions, bank
account details, references of books and articles you want to read…
List the processes you carry out to maintain and use this personal information
57
Kinds of data: What data do you keep?
These are the kinds of documents that people keep:• Contact management, address books, etc.
• Diary: Calendar and meeting scheduling
• To Dos: task management for self and others• Errands to run, films to see...
• Journal: a record of the use of your time
• Document creation and management• Word, Excel, PowerPoint, etc.
• Message management• Emails, instant messages, etc.
58
Rôle-specific information There is an overlap between personal information
and shared small-group There is also an overlap between
• Generic information – the information that almost anyone might keep
• Agenda, contacts, etc.
• Rôle-specific information
• For a lecturer: references / bibliographic details, shared agenda, student results etc.
Why? Different groups of knowledge workers (Drucker (1999)) keep different kinds of personal information
59
Processes associated with personal information: What processes? - 1
Among the processes associated with personal information are these; which matter to you? Describe them, in some detail. The items in bold italics are further
described on the next slide. Capture Store Secure Communicate / synchronise between devices and platforms Finding things again
• Classify• Find
Show Present Share Reuse Publish Reorganise
60
A bit more detail on such processes Capture: of text, pictures, audio, video, web clippings… Store for easy access
• Handheld, on PC, stored on the Web (“in the cloud”) Secure storage
• Keeping secrets – showing to some (but not others)
• Preserving investment• Potentially across decades
Finding things again• Classifying them when found or created/modified
• Searching for them later
• Filtering your lists to show only relevant items Presentation
• Visual aspects: getting a message across
• Communication and Sharing (read-only, or shared-update) Reuse: using material again: in a new presentation, book…
61
Processes associated with personal information: What processes? - 2
At a more detailed level, do you need: Journalising or Diarising: record “anything and everything”
• Personal notes/journal, annotations and note-taking in multiple media: a kind of electronic jotter
Transcription between media, e.g. handwriting recognition, voice recognition, scanning and OCR
Search across email, e-docs and other information forms, across multiple media types
Hypertext Authoring: writing documents that make links between each other Synchronisation between computers: Mobile/PDA devices and inter-
device synchronisation Coordination between people in hierarchies and in projects Visualisation of information resources
• Graphing, charting, mind maps etc. Export, e.g. to PowerPoint
62
Now get real… What are the really big frustrations in your personal information
management?• Do you forget where you’ve put things on your computer? How do you
find them again?• Do you have difficulty keeping and synchronising files between
computers?• Do you find it difficult to manage documents that you store locally on your PC
and the same or similar documents stored on work file servers, web services, etc?
• Do you end up with multiple, incompatible versions of more-or-less the same information?
• Do you succeed or fail in coordinating / synchronising address books, diary, etc. between computers?
• Do you succeed or fail in managing multiple email services (e.g. work/school, home Hotmail, home Gmail…)?
• How do you coordinate your activities when you work in groups / virtual teams?
What are you going to do to improve the situation?
63
Understand your style of work: How do you work best? - 1
How organised do you like to be? Do you thrive on organisation, or find that it
stifles your creativity? People oriented towards structure may
favour databases, or PIMs which offer powerful data structuring.
People oriented towards spontaneity and personal creativity may prefer more visual approaches – or to stick with paper!
64
Understand your style of work: How do you work best? - 2 What kinds of computer software do you
like, feel at ease with, or want to master? Are you at ease with classification and with
rigour? Try database. Do you enjoy a numeric, quantitative,
algebraic approach? Try spreadsheet. Do you think visually? Try mind mapping. Are you brave enough to try novel
approaches? Try a specialist PIM program, choosing one which suits you.
65
Choose software to improve your personal information management
One possibility is to use a ready made PIM
• We have already identified over 150 PIM/GIM (group information manager) programs
What if that is too restrictive, or you can't afford it?
• Another possibility is to "roll your own" personal information management using office tools
•Word processing
•Spreadsheet
•Database
• Etc.
Some examples of the kind of programs used for personal and small-group information management on different computer platforms
Platform PC Proprietary Open Source Mac Proprietary Cloud (SaaS, Software As A Service)
Type of program
Operating system, with connection to local area and global networks
Microsoft Windows
Mandrake or similar Linux distribution
Apple OS/X Glide
Web browser Microsoft Internet Explorer
Firefox Apple Safari n/a
e-mail client with built in basic PIM capability
Microsoft Outlook
Thunderbird Built-in n/a
Office productivity suite
Microsoft Office
OpenOffice.org; KDE
Microsoft Office for Mac; Apple iWork
Google Apps; Zoho
Word processing Microsoft Word
OpenOffice.org Doc
Microsoft Word; iWork Pages
Google Docs
Spreadsheet Microsoft Excel
OpenOffice.org Calc
Microsoft Excel; iWork Numbers
Google Docs
Relational database management program (RDBMS)
Microsoft Access
OpenOffice.org Base
FileMaker Pro Qrimp
Personal information manager (PIM)
InfoQube KDE Pim; OSAF Chandler
Tinderbox Basecamp
Group information manager (GIM)
Lotus Domino OSAF Chandler Lotus Domino Basecamp
67
Some significant PIM approaches – examples only! find your own personal preference! Microsoft Outlook
• Appointments, contacts, tasks, emails…
Microsoft Office• See in particular, Word, Excel,
Access, Outlook, OneNote, Visio, SharePoint, InfoPath, Groove
Web Services• Backpack• Remember The Milk• Google Calendar• Plaxo• Digg, Reddit, del.ici.ous• Twine – semantic web
Mind mapping• VisiMap• MindManager
Group Information Managers• Lotus Notes
Specialist PIM applications• Chandler• Info Select• Tinderbox (Mac only)• Ecco and EccoExt• InfoQube
Semantic desktop – mainly research prototypes• Gnowsis• Haystack
68
Important Note Most PIM and GIM tools are paid-for
software• Few are free-to-download or open-source
Many are available on a try-before-you-buy basis• Use this freedom
• Please don’t abuse it… “the labourer is worthy of his hire”!
69
Standard PIM features
Personal notes/journal Address books (contacts) Lists (including task, “to-do” lists) Significant calendar dates
• Appointments and meeting
• Birthdays
• Anniversaries Reminders Archives of email, instant messages, fax
communications, voicemail, etc.
70
Some advanced PIM features Example tool: InfoQube, IQ
• User-defined folders (IQ calls them fields) – so you build your own classification and cross-link information
• IQ permits:• Hierarchical classification – splitting things up into
categories and sub-categories• Multiple (network) assignment
• In IQ, one item can be classified by more than one field; this means that you can classify things in multiple, overlapping ways; the same thing can appear in more than one place. It also supports tagging.
• Auto-classification and auto-linking on the basis of rules Note implication: users only get the best from these tools as
they structure their data and also think about processes
71
Situational Applications There exist applications builders which can be used by non-
technical users to build customised multi-user business information systems• Captive databases, available only locally: e.g. Microsoft
Access• Relational databases deployed on the Web: e.g. Qrimp
Such applications are increasingly “in the cloud”• On Web servers • Which may not be under the direct control or ownership of the
organisation which owns the information IBM has suggested a new name for this category of simple
applications builders: "situational applications builders“• See Cherbakov, L. & A. Bravery & B. D. Goodman & A. Pandya
& J. Baggett (2007)• See also Gregory M.R. & Norbis M. (2009b)
72
Do you need a situational application?
Firstly audit your personal and small-group information needs, as above
Then list the “big” business information systems you use
Identify any gaps: do you and your colleagues / collaborators, in any context, need to procure a new system or build your own using a situational application builder?
Number of users
Degree of structure of the data stored
1
10
100
1000
Highly structured data, precise queries, limited
freedom to adapt
Semi structured knowledge representation, considerable
freedom to adapt
No obvious structure: interpretation depends on the (educated) eye of the
beholder
GIM: Group Information
Management
Text documents
Corporate transaction-
oriented applications
Situational Applications
Spreadsheets
Web 2.0 applications
1m
PIM: Personal Information
Management
A possible mapping of the Applications
Space
74
Action – Now!
You and I have only one life to live Sometimes we have to collaborate, to
wait while others get things done for us But mostly, our destinies are in our own
hands Let’s stop procrastinating and act – now
– to improve our own information management and personal productivity
75
Acting to improve your personal information management
Audit your information management, then act to improve it! Choose at least one software program which you will use over the
next few weeks in order to help you IMPROVE the ways in which you Get Things Done and Keep Found Things Found• Start to use it NOW• Set a time limit on your experiment – say five or six weeks• Do the necessary learning to get into the program• Take a LOG of what you do with the program, how you plan its
use, how you learn more about it, what your experiences are – good and bad
• A log is a list of things you have actually done – what they were and when you did them.
• At the end, complete your log with an EVALUATION of how effective your experiment was. What will you do in the future to improve?
• Maybe share the log online? Join our gang?
76
Further help in improving your personal information management
The main points of this presentation are available in the form of a template questionnaire, which you can fill in and – optionally – share with others• Helps you to get things done because you’ve
made a visible commitment
• Potentially helps us in our research
77
Making it easier to find things - Background
We nearly all classify things – that is, we group them by name or keyword (work, home, clubs and associations…)
A simple organization of kinds of things is to list them alphabetically. If we give a list a title which attempts to name or describe the items in the list, we begin to establish a vocabulary. If we make a list of football teams, each member of the list “is-a” football team.
Making items into lists, and deciding which list each member is a part of, is a process called taxonomic classification or just classification, and it is fundamental to science and to the communication of meaning: we are ascribing and defining a vocabulary, and grouping things by their classification or type• See Boardman, Richard (2004) for a fuller discussion, including the
limitation of hierarchical (tree) structures• See Golder, Scott A. & Bernardo A. Huberman (2009) for a
discussion of classification and tagging
78
Making it easier to find things – Applying this to your information
How do you group files into folders on your PC? Can you, should you, improve this? How have your classifications changed in the past, and what changes do you anticipate?
Do you find the inherent limitations of the standard folder structure (which is strictly hierarchic, and is in fact a taxonomic classification) troublesome?• Do you need ways to store things in more than one place at a
time?
• Do you need to take this further as an ontology?
79
Archives – finding old things
Have you previously used software and/or platforms which you no longer have or wish to retain?
Have you already exported the data / information to a current platform? Should you now do so?
Have you still got the use of the old software? Have you a way to access the old data / information?
80
Relevance to your self-audit: Why is it important to classify things?
We need to store lists in a way in which we can find the lists and their contents easily, name them, classify their contents, and relate them
Your personal information management may need to evolve in these directions
It is therefore wise to choose programs which permit you to • Create your own lists and then to name them
• To classify them either by a keyword within a hierarchy of keywords or by more than one keyword (like tagging in social networks)
• To search them
• To enable you to link one item to another Unfortunately, very few programs do all of these things!
• And the ones that do demand self-investment
81
Towards Personal Knowledge Management
What do your data mean? There is limited support in some PIMs for classification of
contents• User-specified keyword classification of information
structured in accordance with user design• Rule-based auto-classification, where the tool
automatically classifies items• Tagging
Semantic web approaches, such as semantic desktop, are just beginning to appear• Q: Why is this significant?• A: Emerging shared ontologies (shared vocabularies!)
should be a significant change enabler in groups of knowledge workers
82
Our research hypotheses (Why do people choose not to use PIMs and GIMs?)
Hypothesis 1• The data-centred approach adopted by most PIMs is not necessarily well
adapted to the working methods adopted by knowledge workers. Establishing what styles and functionalities appeal to (or repel) different types of users is not yet well understood.
Hypothesis 2• Current PIMs tend to emphasise one particular information management
technique, to the exclusion of others. The absence of complementary information management techniques is one of the factors which cause knowledge workers to reject current PIMs. Why do we have to choose between databases and spreadsheets?
Hypothesis 3• PIMs are not much used because PIMs either impose an ontology which does
not correspond to the user’s ontology, or do not permit that ontology to be made explicit and/or shared. The incorporation of explicit knowledge representation mechanisms which are tailored to their users’ (plural) needs will make a PIM more useful: by beginning to turn it into a small-group knowledge manager. Knowledge is about classification and association; let’s make that explicit!
83
Radically rethinking your personal information management: Ontology
An ontology defines a set of representational primitives which model a domain of knowledge
Ontologies extend taxonomy by applying a larger variety of relation types than just “is-a” • The representational primitives are typically classes (or
sets), attributes (or properties), and relationships (or relations among class members)
An ontology is a data model that represents a set of concepts within a domain and the relationships between those concepts; it can be used to reason about the objects within that domain
Ontologies are used in artificial intelligence, the semantic web, software engineering and information architecture as a form of knowledge representation about the world or some part of it
84
Ontologies generally describe Individuals: the basic or "ground level" objects Classes: sets, collections, or types of objects Attributes: properties, features,
characteristics, or parameters that objects can have and share
Relations: ways that objects can be related to one another
Events: the changing of attributes or relations• http://www.owlseek.com/whatis.html checked 26/03/2009
85
Ontology 101
So what is your ontology? Start off with a hierarchical classification,
and see if that works well enough for you If you or a project of which you are a part really
needs a full ontology, consider using an ontology editor
Much interest centres around Stanford’s Protégé open source ontology editor and knowledge-base framework• See http://protege.stanford.edu/
86
Post-implementation audit
After a suitable evaluation period, please revisit your original personal information audit and evaluate the extent to which your personal and small-group information management has improved• Good experiences (and bad ones…)
• Areas for further improvement
• What help you needed, where did you get it, what further help do you now need?
87
Self-Audit: A Summary
You should aim to Get Things Done You should aim to Keep Found Things Found Take into full consideration
• Personal work (and living, fun, e.g. music)
• Group work: work you do with others
Decide whether and how to self-audit We hope you’ll want to talk to us about your
experiences, and thereby contribute to our research
ReferencesAllen, David (2001) Getting Things Done: The Art of Stress-Free Productivity. Penguin Books.Alter, Steven (2002) Information Systems: The Foundation of E-Business. Pearson Education, Upper
Saddle River NJ. Boardman, Richard (2004) "Improving Tool Support for Personal Information Management" - Abstract
of PhD Thesis in Human-Computer Interaction. Intelligent and Interactive Systems Group, Dept. of Electronic and Electrical Engineering, Imperial College London.
Cherbakov, L. & A. Bravery & A. Pandya (2007) 'SOA meets situational applications, Part 1: Changing computing in the enterprise' Found at http://www.ibm.com/developerworks/webservices/library/ws-soa-situational1/
Drucker, Peter (1999) 'Knowledge Worker productivity: the biggest challenge.' In: The knowledge management yearbook 2000-2001.
Golder, Scott A. & Bernardo A. Huberman (2009) 'The Structure of Collaborative Tagging Systems' Found at http://www.hpl.hp.com/research/idl/papers/tags/tags.pdf accessed 09/07/2009
Gregory M.R. & Norbis M. (2008a) 'Towards a Systematic Evaluation of Personal and Small Group Information and Knowledge Management'. Paper presented to 5th International Conference on Cybernetics and Information Technologies, Systems and Applications: CITSA 2008, in July 2008.
Gregory M.R. & Norbis M. (2008b) 'The business of knowledge.' Paper given at 8th International Conference on Knowledge, Culture and Change in Organisations, Cambridge University, United Kingdom between 2008/08/05 and 2008/08/08.
Gregory M.R. & Norbis M. (2009b) 'Evaluating Situational Applications Builders.' Paper accepted for CITSA conference in July 2009 in Orlando Fa.
Jones, William (2007) 'Keeping found things found: the study and practice of personal information management.' William Jones, University of Washington. Morgan Kauffman 2007
Strassman, P. (1999) 'Paradox revisited.' Computerworld, Vol. 33 Issue 36, pp. 40, 1999.Toffler, Alvin (1990). Powershift: Knowledge, wealth and violence at the edge of the 21st century.
Bantam Books, 1990.
89
Thanks for reading so far!Now here’s a Request:
If you wish to comment further on this presentation or paper;
Or if you intend taking the Personal Audit Challenge(!);
Contact me: • Put your name on the list• Or email [email protected]
Join Our Gang! We are a community of people aiming to improve their information management
Please use our website (tbs) Over to you…