1
Jan 02, 2016
1
2
Does the Suit Mean Honesty?
Does the Suit Mean Honesty?
Spotting Inappropriate Investments and working with your Financial Professional
Spotting Inappropriate Investments and working with your Financial Professional
3
The Maine Office of Securities
The Maine Office of Securities
Part of Maine’s Department of Professional and Financial Regulation
www.investors.maine.gov
A source of objective and impartial information
Part of Maine’s Department of Professional and Financial Regulation
www.investors.maine.gov
A source of objective and impartial information
4
Useful brochures on our website
Useful brochures on our website
www.investors.maine.gov
Five Keys to Investing SuccessA Primer for Investing in StocksA Primer for Investing in BondsMutual Funds May be all You’ll Ever
NeedGetting Help with your InvestmentsMaximize Your Retirement Investments
www.investors.maine.gov
Five Keys to Investing SuccessA Primer for Investing in StocksA Primer for Investing in BondsMutual Funds May be all You’ll Ever
NeedGetting Help with your InvestmentsMaximize Your Retirement Investments
5
Topics CoveredTopics Covered
What the Office of Securities does
The Rise of investment abuse
Types of financial professionals and their obligations
Finding a financial professional and questions you should ask
Record keeping
Warning signs
What the Office of Securities does
The Rise of investment abuse
Types of financial professionals and their obligations
Finding a financial professional and questions you should ask
Record keeping
Warning signs
6
The Mission of the Maine Office of Securities
The Mission of the Maine Office of Securities
Protection of Maine investors
Licensing financial professionals
Reviewing registration statements and exemptions filings
Investor education
Protection of Maine investors
Licensing financial professionals
Reviewing registration statements and exemptions filings
Investor education
7
How the Maine Office of Securities can help youHow the Maine Office of Securities can help you
Verify whether your financial professional is licensed
Provide you with disciplinary history
Examinations
Prior work history
Red flags
Formal enforcement actions
Informal assistance
Verify whether your financial professional is licensed
Provide you with disciplinary history
Examinations
Prior work history
Red flags
Formal enforcement actions
Informal assistance
8
The Rise of Investment Abuse
The Rise of Investment Abuse
Weaker returns in the stock market
Shortfalls in retirement money
Investment decisions based upon fear or greed
Fewer government resources since 9/11
Financial illiteracy
Weaker returns in the stock market
Shortfalls in retirement money
Investment decisions based upon fear or greed
Fewer government resources since 9/11
Financial illiteracy
9
Why Directed at Seniors?Why Directed at Seniors?
“That’s where the money is.”
More trusting generation
Perception that you are an “easy target”
Demographics – more of you
“That’s where the money is.”
More trusting generation
Perception that you are an “easy target”
Demographics – more of you
10
Types of Investment Abuse
Types of Investment Abuse
Inappropriate investment recommendations
Misrepresentation of risk
Churning
Unauthorized trading
Failure to execute
Inappropriate investment recommendations
Misrepresentation of risk
Churning
Unauthorized trading
Failure to execute
11
More Serious Forms of Investment Abuse
More Serious Forms of Investment Abuse
Ponzi schemes
Sham promissory notes
Pump and dump market manipulation schemes
Prime bank schemes
Ponzi schemes
Sham promissory notes
Pump and dump market manipulation schemes
Prime bank schemes
12
Examples of Investment Abuse in Maine
Examples of Investment Abuse in Maine
The Portland AttorneyUse of position of trust
The Gourley caseSecurities are broadly defined
The Portland AttorneyUse of position of trust
The Gourley caseSecurities are broadly defined
13
Techniques used by Scam Artists
Techniques used by Scam Artists
Undercover tape Tactics used
Phantom fixation (dangling prospect of wealth and riches) Scarcity (marking the product offered seem rare to
increase its value) Source of credibility (claiming to be from a known
legitimate business) Comparison (juxtaposing a more expensive price with the
offered price) Reciprocity (the con will do a small favor putting pressure
on the victim to reciprocate) Landscaping (structuring the interaction leading to where
the con wants to go) Profiling (identifying victim’s psychological buttons through
extensive questioning) Fear (use of fear and intimidation to persuade) Authority (con plays the role of authority figure) Dependent (con plays the role of young helpless
dependent)
Undercover tape Tactics used
Phantom fixation (dangling prospect of wealth and riches) Scarcity (marking the product offered seem rare to
increase its value) Source of credibility (claiming to be from a known
legitimate business) Comparison (juxtaposing a more expensive price with the
offered price) Reciprocity (the con will do a small favor putting pressure
on the victim to reciprocate) Landscaping (structuring the interaction leading to where
the con wants to go) Profiling (identifying victim’s psychological buttons through
extensive questioning) Fear (use of fear and intimidation to persuade) Authority (con plays the role of authority figure) Dependent (con plays the role of young helpless
dependent)
14
Financial Professionals’ Responsibilities
Financial Professionals’ Responsibilities
Honesty and fairness
What does this mean?
Full and accurate information about the investment
Disclosure of risksDisclosure of costsDisclosure of obligations and restrictionsSuitable recommendationsAccurate records
Honesty and fairness
What does this mean?
Full and accurate information about the investment
Disclosure of risksDisclosure of costsDisclosure of obligations and restrictionsSuitable recommendationsAccurate records
15
Selecting a Financial Professional
Selecting a Financial Professional
Do you need one?
Types of financial professionals:Investment advisersBroker-dealers
Do you need one?
Types of financial professionals:Investment advisersBroker-dealers
16
Differences between Investment Advisers and
Broker-dealers
Differences between Investment Advisers and
Broker-dealers Investment advisers are fiduciaries –
they must put your interests first
Compensation Investment advisers are fee-based Broker-dealers receive commissions
A broker-dealer’s conflicts of interests Potential to over-trade Tied to particular securities products
Investment advisers are fiduciaries – they must put your interests first
Compensation Investment advisers are fee-based Broker-dealers receive commissions
A broker-dealer’s conflicts of interests Potential to over-trade Tied to particular securities products
17
Differences, continuedDifferences, continued
No such conflicts with investment advisers
One conflict may be a desire to manage all of your assets when not in your best interests
No such conflicts with investment advisers
One conflict may be a desire to manage all of your assets when not in your best interests
18
Investment AdvisersInvestment Advisers
How they charge: a percentage of assets under management
Example: 1% of $100,000 yearly equates to a fee of $1,000.
How they charge: a percentage of assets under management
Example: 1% of $100,000 yearly equates to a fee of $1,000.
19
Types of Broker-dealersTypes of Broker-dealers
Full-service
Discount brokers
Online brokers
Full-service
Discount brokers
Online brokers
20
Types of Broker-dealers, continued
Types of Broker-dealers, continued
Full-service brokers – will pay higher commission
Discount brokers – no specific recommendations
Online brokers – internet trading only
Full-service brokers – will pay higher commission
Discount brokers – no specific recommendations
Online brokers – internet trading only
21
Types of Investment Advisers
Types of Investment Advisers
Financial planners
Provision of financial planRelationship is not ongoingUsually hourly fee, or hourly fee with
a capYou are responsible for executing
Financial planners
Provision of financial planRelationship is not ongoingUsually hourly fee, or hourly fee with
a capYou are responsible for executing
22
Types of Investment Advisers, continuedTypes of Investment Advisers, continued
Portfolio Manager
Will manage your assetsOn an ongoing basisWill generally charge you a
percentage of your assetsGenerally, have discretionary
authority
Portfolio Manager
Will manage your assetsOn an ongoing basisWill generally charge you a
percentage of your assetsGenerally, have discretionary
authority
23
Finding a Financial Professional
Finding a Financial Professional
Yellow pages
If investment adviser, any credentials?
CFP (Certified Financial Planner) ChFC (Chartered Financial Consultant) CPA (Certified Public Accountant) PFS (Personal Financial Specialist)
Be wary of “Senior Specialist” designations
Yellow pages
If investment adviser, any credentials?
CFP (Certified Financial Planner) ChFC (Chartered Financial Consultant) CPA (Certified Public Accountant) PFS (Personal Financial Specialist)
Be wary of “Senior Specialist” designations
24
Finding a Financial Professional, continuedFinding a Financial Professional, continued
References from
Family, friends, co-workers Lawyers, accountants, insurance
agents
Always check first with our Office!
References from
Family, friends, co-workers Lawyers, accountants, insurance
agents
Always check first with our Office!
25
Other Organizations that may Assist
Other Organizations that may Assist
The Financial Planning Association
The National Association of Personal Financial Advisors
The American Institute of CPA’s
The Society of Financial Service Professionals
The Financial Planning Association
The National Association of Personal Financial Advisors
The American Institute of CPA’s
The Society of Financial Service Professionals
26
Questions to AskQuestions to Ask
Fee structure
Investment record
Other clients
How would they invest?
Demeanor
Fee structure
Investment record
Other clients
How would they invest?
Demeanor
27
How to Deal with your Financial ProfessionalHow to Deal with your Financial Professional
Give the matter your full attention
Does the suggestion fit in with your investment plan?
Ask for more information
Give the matter your full attention
Does the suggestion fit in with your investment plan?
Ask for more information
28
Record-keepingRecord-keeping
Log of all conversations
Documents and statements
Emails/notes
Clippings/research reports
Always review statements promptly and thoroughly and have mistakes corrected
Log of all conversations
Documents and statements
Emails/notes
Clippings/research reports
Always review statements promptly and thoroughly and have mistakes corrected
29
Warning SignsWarning Signs
Guarantees investments
Puts money into one investment only
Argues with you or ignores your instructions
Is vague about commissions or fees
Requests you to sign documents without giving you the opportunity to read them
Guarantees investments
Puts money into one investment only
Argues with you or ignores your instructions
Is vague about commissions or fees
Requests you to sign documents without giving you the opportunity to read them
30
ConclusionConclusion Clear communication is the key
Two-way obligation
Always be candid and specific about goals and financial assets
Let your financial professional know about major changes affecting your financial situation
Let your financial professional know about your comfort level with investment risk
Make sure you always understand any investments recommended
Clear communication is the key
Two-way obligation
Always be candid and specific about goals and financial assets
Let your financial professional know about major changes affecting your financial situation
Let your financial professional know about your comfort level with investment risk
Make sure you always understand any investments recommended
31
Any questions?
www.investors.maine.gov
Any questions?
www.investors.maine.gov