.0\ip (4)aii tit) - Ministry of Mines

$Page 1: .0\ip (4)aii tit) - Ministry of Mines$
tkcicei f Atrth-r{ .3) eid-1 RTI Appeal

Due date -08.11.2018

Trani Wiime Bound

ang 'Mohr(

rditiRr - .6;0 oil S Sr, 2005 *• ci6c-i Ms. Renu Singh, R/o New

Delhi # Ti-ati" z1 t

Ms. Renu Singh, R/o New Delhi #Ali ct air 311t1F ft*' 03.10.2018

rfr um- urn 3P4a- iz1--arer gar ar

2. 3171# 3it7 t ft 6 cf-rl 311:117itn. WI. Pit/RV' CirSich 08.11.2018 # rift

411 afc, 34h mi*-a41 Ter:a4- rfr.mrt. 71-R atr Yrttr

• --<\\ • .0\ip

(4)aii tit) 31:117F ari witr

rieferi. xra 314flM Dy. No. 119753 dt. 09.10.2018

Sh. Shersha, izAtRT 3inrcr*ltr fEstt.),

411.34. tt'alPI Cell U.O. Dy. No. 119753/2018 farlico/Dated 10.10.2018

Save The Tribal (Tribal Research Wing)

Office : U-74, Tirupati Complex. 1st Floor. Room No. 103, Shakar Puri Delhi-110092

g?eitaes# Secretary

APPEAL

Dated C' -3 -/c / 19 Ref. No.

To

fitiv, • ri Jai *nek,,..&23,2 3c9..

,r ./3 ,Szos7t A4h t:0

hdhisif ter SUB- APPEAL UNDER SECTION 19 (1) OF RTI ACT - 2005

- /$ Ph/ Vela/ELY isec.)1.4. ‘17.11-)

Please refer to your reply letter no: a-

u is stated that PIO/ CPIO o' your office has failed to provide the required information .The information provided

by P10/ CPIO is incorrect , incomplete and misleading . I am not satisfied from reply. So, I prefer to tile an appeal .

( copy enclosed) .

1. As per sec. 2(t) of RTI Act -2005 INFORMATION - means any material in any form, including records ,

document and RECORD includes any document . material and file U/s 2(1) (a) of RTI Act -2005 .As such,

the service book o' employee is a record and sought information is available in service book of all

employees Name of employee , emp No. DOB, Designation, office Address and present Address do not personal

information And al..o do not fall under section 7(9) , 8 (1) (e) and 8(11 0) of RTI Act - 2005. PIO / CPIO has

not provided complete Information . The requisite information may be provided to me in hard copy . This

information is large public interest.

2. As per C1C Decision No. CIC/SWA/21308/002481596 dt. 11.02.2009 . If person is using caste certificate /

community certificate to secure job in central /PSU/state Government and take all advantage on that

document then it a public document . It is not personal and third party information under section 8(1) (j)

of RTI Act - 2005 (o information cannot be denied and the same may be provided to applicant . (copy

enclosed).

3. Please provide details of Appellate Authority.

Note -The Applicant should be provided the information free of chase where a public Authority_failed

toeomply with time limktas persegiOn 716) of RTI Act • 200S.

Enclose As Above-

Your Faithfully

( Reno Singh )

RTI Activist

U -74 tirupati Complex

Floor Room No. 103 Shakarpur

Delhi -110092

. 5

k q 9 6 3 c.!;5-

Sir / Madam,

By Speed Post RTI matter

F.No. A-18/16/2018-ESTT. Government of India

Ministry of Mines * * * *

New Delhi, the 13 ilSeptember, 2018 To, /

VMs. Renu Singh, U-74, Tirupati complex; in Floor, Room No. 103, Shakarpur, Delhi — 110092.

Subject: Application under Right to Information Act, 2005- Application received from Ms. Renu Singh dated 06.08.2018.

Mam,

This is in reference to your letter dated 06.Q8.2018 on the subject cited above and to

say that the requisite information sought by you, regarding the number of Scheduled Tribes

presently working in Ministry of Mines (Secretariat Proper) is as under:

Group A: OS

Group B: 11

Group C: 01

4. Further. it is informed that the personal information including copy of caste certificates sought by you in respect of the Scheduled Tribes persons working in the Ministry (Secretariat Proper) can not be provided in terms of Section 8 (1) (J) of RTI Act, 2005.

In case you are not satisfied with the reply, you may file an appeal before the Appellate

Authority (Shri Shersha, Director. Ministry of Mines, Room No. 309, 'D' Wing, Shastri Bhawan,

New Delhi) within a period of 30 days from the date of receipt of this letter.

Yours sincerely,

(Yogesh R Patel) Under Secretary to the Govt. of India

Copy to: PI Cell, Ministry of Mines w.r.t. their U.O. No. 2/96/2018-PI dated 16.08.2018

CENTRAL INFORMATION COMMISSION Room No. 415, 4th Floor,

Block IV, Old JNU Campus, New Delhi — 110067

Tel: +91 11 26161796

Decision No. CIC /SG/A/2008/00248/ 1596

Appeal No. CIC/SG/A/2008/00248/

Relevant Facts emerging from the Appeal

Appellant

Respondent

Mr. Neeraj Kumar I louse No. 845, Sraswatipuratn, JNU, New Delhi-67

Mr. Jit Singh Public Information Officer DR(SC/ST Cell) JNU, New Delhi-67

RTI application filed .at PIO replied First appeal tiled on First Appellate Authority order Second Appeal filed on

The information Sought: I . Ms. Ahha Yadav was appointed as a Assistant Registrar against the advertised

positions in the Advertisement No. Admn. n005 tinder the 0I3C category. Provide

me the certified copy of her Educational Qualification and caste certificate.

2. Provide me the certified copy of the recommendation of the selection committee.

3. Whether she belonged to the creamy layer of OBC category at the time of application, if no, then provide me a certified copy of the enquiry report by which it was found that she does not belong to the creamy layer of the OBC category.

4. Provide me the information about her father's designation, promotions with scale of pay for the last 10 years and his net family income in the year 2005 and 2006.

5. Provide me the certified copy of the rules and regulations under which a person can be appointed to the public office who has pursued the two qualifying degrees courses simultaneously from same university or from different Universities from Jamia Miilia Islainia, New Delhi in the year 2001-2003 and LLB Centre —II. Faculty of Law, Delhi

University, Delhi in the year 2002-2005.

6. Mr. J.P.S. Dhaka was appointed as a Deputy Registrar against the advertised positions in the Advertisement under the OBC category. Provide me the certified copy of his

caste certificate. 7. Provide me the certified copy of the recommendation of the selection committee.

8. To the best of my Knowledge the information sought doeg not fall with in the restrictions contained in Section 8 & 9 of the Act and it pertains to your office.

12/08/2008 No Reply 16/09/2008 10/10/2008 21/10/2008

POI Reply: Since No Reply was received from the PIO the appellant filed a First Appeal on 16/09/2008.

The Fist Appellate Authority Ordered: `Relying on the decisions of the Central Information Commission and also taking in view the

submission of the third party the certificates/ caste certificates cannot be disclosed under section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act.'

Relevant facts emerging during hearing on 3 February 2009.: The following were present. Appellant: Mr. Neeraj Kumar Respondent: Mr. Jit Singh PIO Prof Jain first appellate authority

And Mr. Sebastian deemed PIO Third party: Ms. Abha Yadav Some of the information was supplied after the First appeal but copies of educational qualification and caste certificates were not given, since the First appellate authority had ruled that these were exempt. Ms. Abha Yadav as third party had objected claiming that giving these would he an invasion on her privacy. The PIO had asked the third party Ms. Abha Yadav whether she had any objection to the information relating to her being disclosed. Ms. Abha Yadav claimed that the information should not be given since it is exempt under Section 8 (1) (j). Ms. Abha Yadav quoted two decisions of the Commission — decision number C1C/MA/A/2008/1067 of 4/9/2008 and CIC/OK/A/2007/00770 of 21/9/2007 in support of her contentions. The appellant relies on a CIC decision CIC/WB/A/2007/0178 of 23/2/2007 to contend that the information must be given. The appellant had contended in his appeal, " The third party viz. Ms. Abha Yadav, Asst. Registrar (Legal cell)/JNU is holding a public office, getting salary from the public exchequer and discharging public functions in a public institution, therefore whatever documents she has submitted in pursuance of her appointment to public office in a public institution fulls in public domain." The order is reserved

Decision delivered on 10 February 2009:

Decisions cited by the Third party Ms. Abha Yadav:

I. Decision No. 1258/IC (A)/2007. F. No. CIC/OK/A12007/00770 dated 2151 September, 2007;

"The copies of certificates submitted by the candidates however denied by the CPIO on the ground of personal information of third parties. The marks obtained by him have been revealed to him. As regards disclosure of the copies of certificates submitted by the selection candidates, the denial of information, u/s 8(1) (j) of the Act, is justified on the ground that the information asked for is not an outcome of any public activity of the respondent."

2. Decision No. 323 I/IC(A)/2008, F. No. etc/MA/A.2007/01067 dated 4th September,

2008; "The appellant had asked for copies of certificates submitted by 'a retired employee of the respondent and other related information. The CP10 has furnished partial information . while the remaining information has been denied u/s 8(1) (j) of the Act.....

The information asked for has no relationship with any public activity of the respondents. Moreover. it pertains to personal information of a retired employee. The

.'

denial of information ids 8(1) 0) of the Act is therefore justified."

cited hr tl~e

The appellant Mr. Neeraj Kumar has relied on the decision in CIC/W13/A/2007/00178 dated

33'd Feb. 2007. In this case the appellant had been denied following information about the

selected candidates:

I. The educational, technical qualification and experience certificate of selection

candidates. 2. Fite noting. 3.

The Educational, Technical Qualification and experience certificate of selected

candidates V ‘.. Rekha Barasha (SC).

In this case the Commission had ruled, "In the present case information sotT Shri Re

.R.

ht is clearly & 14th sp.

information on a public activity which is selection for the post FIRoM on 13'

2006. Recourse. therefore, cannot he taken to sec. 8(1) 0) in providing information.

Kakdc. CP10 is therefore. directed to supply point wise information to each question sought

by appellant.

While deciding this case. the Commission agrees with the contention of the appellant that when a person "is holding a public office. getting salary from the public exchequer and discharging public Unctions in a public institution, therefore whatever documents she has submitted in pursuance of her appointment to public office in a public institution falls in

public domain.- The act of applying for a job or a selection process is not a private activit),

hut is clearly a Public activity, and disclosure of the documents and papers submitted to obtain the job cannot be held to be an invasion on privacy. This has also been held by the

Commission earlier in decision C1C/WIVA/2007100178, and the Commission agrees with the

same. The Commis,ion respectfully disagrees with the decisions relied on by the third party.

The Appeal is allowed. The PIO will provide the copies of educational qualification and caste

certificates to the appellant before 28 February 2009.

Notice of this decision he given free of cost to the parties

Shailesh Gandhi

Information Commissioner 10 February 2009

(For any fitaher correspondence, please mention the decision number for u quid, &pawl)

1.V)

BY SPEED POST RTI MATTER

No.18/ 16/2018-Estt. Government of India

Ministry of Mines ** * *

To Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi, 29.10.2018

Ms. Renu Singh RTI Activist U-74 Tirupati Complex, lat Floor Room No.103,Shaltarpur Delhi-110092

Sub: Decision on appeal under Right to Information Act, 2005-reg

Sir,

Reference to your RTI appeal dated 03.10.2018(received on 09 October 2018) preferring an appeal under Right to Information Act, 2005 on the ground that the response received against your RTI application dated 06.08.2018 is not satisfactory.

2. It is observed that you made a RTI request vide your letter dated 6.8.2018seeking information with reference to number of Scheduled Tribes presently working in Ministry of Mines (Proper). The CPIO vide his reply dated 13.9.2018 gave you the information keeping in view the provision of the RTI Act.

3. In the appeal, you have expressed dissatisfaction with the reply of CPIO, Ministry of Mines and filed appeal before the Appellate Authority, Ministry of Mines.

4. I have gone through the information furnished by the CPIO and the contents of your appeal and have also summoned necessary files/document from the Section. On perusal of the document/files and information sought by you, it is evident that the CPIO has furnished the information in so far as number of Scheduled Tribes working in Ministry of Mines (Secretariat Proper) is concerned.

5. The CPIO has rightly interpreted the provisions of the RTI Act as Caste Certificates of the employees is their personal information and, therefore, is exempt from disclosure U/S 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act. Moreover, the informati n is held by the CPIO in a fiduciary capacity. In this connection your atten is invited to decision dated 21.11.2016 in Appeal No. CIC/MP/A/2016/0012

6. In view of above, appeal received on 09 October, 2018 disposed of.

• (Shersha) Director and Appellate Authority

Tel: 23381172

Copy to : PI Cell with respect of UO Dy.No.119753 dated 10.10.2018

31-1t1-*-17 Sr, 2005

PAci fA/Due date 29.01.2019

TIME BOUND/RTI MATTER

airy{ 44•4.004

w~J : +1:4cri I 3ift1M-R 3TliaraT, 2005 3tFaa Ur-ci atr-d-c#

Sh. Nalin Shah, Director, M/s MetalliCS & Chemical (India) Pvt. Ltd.,

Mumbai 3Tt7 24.12.2018 "T T4:1 Tift-T 3In 3 ‘itcr

i41+.41 7r IT ti

2. NUvil 5T

acT

#-Fatztal c

SW.014.4 ei4.4

T2.40.114-Acc *011

aribird-zr# 2005 *F c4-11T 6(3)* 0-317117 4412, d-Ildfl dl

f:171 ritchiA) 1,14.ii car 21 .31$1/

311 $,Aq1 3Tra Ok71 aTZrrt, tr# 3irc a 1 4211%-r #4witr

3-0dcoi tr s01--cr *t aff1-43 -2Trzfra Altw 5 RA * afraT

7-44. aan 4r3' aer 3ird 9t aft a arraazrw t

3. 3.1784 # f (IJail WI SR' 31ferfezg, 2005 laziail WI Lilco{

cm() 3÷I4K * wrirart 7rct

IP() No. 04G 625712

Smt. Lakshmi Subramaman, US(Metal III) t*Z1'

tft.311t .Ac.i/131 Cell LJ.0 No. 2/158/2018-PI fa !Dated 31.12.2018

(Director

Tel r 91 -22-2267 3707

11, • ter•

24" December. 2018

Meta!lice is Chemicals (India) Pvt. Ltd.

25, Dalal Street, Das Chambers, 4th Floor, Fort, Mumbai - 400 001. India

To, Ms. Kini, AD Trade Issues (FTAs) Rooth No. 0-303. III Floor, Shasta Bhavan, New Delhi — 110001 Tel No. 011-23380610 Subject: - RTI Application under RTI Act, 2005

Nalin P. Shah — Director cf Metallics and Chemicals (India) Pvt. Ltd filing a RTI application under

section 6(1) of RTI Act, 200",.

We seek information from vour ministry who are in-charge of Mining Industry and empowered to

take all decisions for Minir Industry.

As you may know Copper 5 ilphate technical is one of the very essential raw materials to extract zinc

and percentage of Zinc recovered depends on the quality and availability of Copper Sulphate.

We have been informed that even for Copper Sulphate technical for Mining Industry, the mining

companies have to approach Ministry of Agriculture and secure license for import and storage.

Information remired

If the bags are clearly marked as Copper Sulphate Technical for Mining use only and a guarantee is

given by mining companies themselves that they will regularly submit audited reports on the

consumption to the department.

This does not serve the purpose of the reason of involving Ministry of Agriculture and making it

complicated for Mining Industry to secure this important raw material and loose precious quantity

and foreign exchange since there are no restrictions on import of Copper Sulphate under Import

Export Policy and mines require consistent hi-grade quality of standard specifications material for

continuous use.

Please inform whether you will be taking up this subject with Ministry of Agriculture and get

exemption for mining induc ry.

I am enclosing herewith th.- requisite fees of Rs.10/- by way of Postal Order, the order number is

04G 625712.

Thanking You, Yours Faithfully For Metallics & Chemicals (India) Pvt. Ltd.

f 1W

9t. s

CA A 11° vii)\

eArlf

1"..5Ptikt,;14.5":142-2267 3263 : drshinde(6)metallicsbv.com

MOST IMMEDIATE/RTI ACT By Hand

r•-• Government of India Ministry of Mines

No.5/4/2017-Met.III New Delhi, the oty January, 2019

To The RTI Nodal Officer Department of Agriculture and Cooperation, Ministry of Agriculture, Krishi Bhawan, New Delhi- 110001.

Subject: Application received under RTI Act., 2005.

Sir, Two RTI applications. dated 19.12.2018 and 24.12.2018/received from,

Shri Nalin Shah Director, Mettalics and Chemical Pvt. Ltd. in this gqinistry seeking information regarding license policy for import and storage of Copper Sulphate Technical, are enclosed in original.

2. Metal Section of Ministry of Mines is not concerned with the matter.

3. The two RTI applications are hereby transferred under Section 6(3) of RTI Act., 2005, as the matter relates to Ministry of Agriculture.

4. You are requested to provide the information relating to Department of Agriculture and Cooperation directly to the applicant.

Yours faithfully,

t;IkAt

(Lakshmi Subramanian) CPIO & Under Secretary to the Govt. of India

End:- As stated above

Copy to (By Speed Post):-

1. Six' Nalin P. Shah Director, Metallics and Chemicals (India) Pvt. Ltd, 25, Dalal Street,' Das Chambers, 40' Floor, Fort, Mumbai-400001 (with the request to contact the concerned department for further correspondence in the matter).

\241 Cell w.r.t. U.O.Nos. 2/154/2018-PI and 2/158/2018-PI dated 31.12.2018

i 31 g 3litiftPT, 2005 RTI MATTER

3117B-

TAW cliAlef1

F. No. 2/157/2018-P1

flit l 3raw, Rtfae•

ftFtw 31.12.2018

Sh. Nimish M. Kapadia, 5, Balgayatri Soc-2. Shyamal Cross Road, Satellite, Ahmedabad-380051.

Saws:'+tl01i air 3-rit4n I { 311 414-1 . 2005 3t a- Vita" 31raCa I

Sir, I am directed to reler to your RTI application dated 15.12.2018 and to state that as

your RTI application is meant for a public authority under the State Government, the same is returned herewith. You may file the same before the concerned public authority

under the State Government.

33-atRr.

Encl.: Your RTI application dated along with IPO No. 11F 738626 of Rs. 10/- .206

.1->k

(frgr

3951PT arff-m)

Form — A

Form of application seeking information

(See Rule 3)

I.D. No. : 223/18

(For official use)

To,

CPIO

Ministry of Mines

Ministry of Environment,

Forest and Climate Change,

Indira Paryavaran Bhawan,

Ali Ganj, Jorbagh Road,

New Delhi - 110003

[1] Name of the Applicant: Nimish M.Kapadia

[2] Address : 5, Balgayatri Soc-2,

Shyamal Cross Road, Satellite,

Ahmedabad

[3] Particulars of information:

[A] Concerned Department:

[B] Particulars of information required-

As per the Mines and Minerals Act, Gujarat Minerals,

[Prevention of illegal Mining, Transportation of Storage]

2005-2016 — criminal proceeding can be initiated against the

individuals who have committed offence/s stipulated under

the Act/Rules. The Act also provides for compounding of

offence and therefore it is humbly requested to provide the

details sought below: 1. Details of all the applications received for the purpose of

compounding of offence for last 10 years — along with the

details of all those applications which came to be granted.

stais.-42

I 2-2 (36 7

2, Details of all those applications (for compounding) which

came to be rejected — for last 10 years. 3. Copy of any policy or guidelines or instruction, if any, which

provides the criteria or circumstances under which the application for compounding can be permitted or can be

rejected.

(I) Details of information required:

(II) Period for which information asked for:-

(III) Other details:

[4] I State that the information sought does not fall within the restrictions contained in Sec.6 of the act and to the

best of my knowledge it pertains to your office. to

[5] A fee of Rs. 20 has been deposited in the of the g_p

authorized person vide no. dated

Place/ signature of Applicant:- C.)4---- --22-52je-Cr--Q.-C>Cf

Date 12.2018

E-mail address. - [email protected]

Telephone No. : - 079-26751545/26762762

Notes:-

[A] Reasonable assistance can be provided by

Authorized person in filing up the Form A.

[B] Please ensure that the form A is complete in all

Respect and there is no ambiguity the detail of

Information required.

If you have information in the form of CD or it is

On any websitel please inform accordingly instead

Of supplying the information in paper form.

5— Date: /12/2018 Place: Ahmedabad

o

Trk.ate /RAI. NOT NEGOTIAISLE

(gnu ccrwc-4 am cacti iZraatnrefaa ttatta-m ..,z3ot. tot; ti..,NchANI /POSTA 14-oRorst

• • • IRE Intlar DIRECTOR. GENERAL-OP POSTS.

PAY TO

E6.52,LtraWDO3, scal.t o5 nigE2 II•ra' 4I7 twizogt

C

6

sarsiscr4

4Wk "‘

avccate) Qi

S p MAY F114-ILIOSIS NAME MID AOORES8 REIM

Vasvi-11-.--1appedIa

• ..;irm riA4,0017,1 ik ,emu:

•

-(-Adveeate)- aro 4(

Socie%cL - :-• • 1,, Nsfmnartir.,Atz,m DO NOT WRITE CALM' INS UNE chvmlial .-s oo6 • raterite, kriinseDi.“-•pc. 051. i.1 1F 738626 jra :cf1ri...2.67515.45, 26262762.

VIIT MR THE SUM OF RUPEES TEN ONLY ?S1

xras ?etre POSTAGE STAMPS i

I - AT THE POST OFFICE AT

VRIHR COMMISSION kk 50 P

8

+molt W3litWIT31iti=n1R, 2005 RTI MATTER

WT-6 ta(cirtit

ZglWaile11-1

F. No. 2115612018-P1

an d WOW, 4iact-

gaiich X 1.12.2018

Sh. Bharatashree, Flat No. 303, Sachidanda Residency, In Front of Ocean Feral, Udupi. Karnataka-576104.

facial: ti,mten 31itWRS, 2005 31cila-111uc1 31Tar4" I

Sir. I am directed to refer to your online RTI application No. DOCOM/R/2018/80359

dated 20.12.2018 transferred under Section 6(3) of the RTI Act, 2005 from the Ministry of Commerce & Industry. In this context it is to state that as no business summit had been held in the Ministry of Mines, the information with regard to your RTI application may be treated as NIL.

Ratrzr, Pr -At cr"

3r.i33-Rr aritrwrtt

File No.R-18(21);2018-RTI

Rh APPLICATION No. R-16(21)12018-RTI

Government of India Ministry of Commerce & Industry

Department of Commerce RTI Cell

UdyogBhawan, New Delhi Dated the otl4k-December, 2018

OFFICE MEMOBAIDUM

Subject: RTI Application Registration No. DOCOM/R/2018/80359 dated 20.12.2018 under Right to Information Act, 2005 filed on the RTI Web Portal by Shri Bharatashree. Karnataka seeking information under RTI Act, 2005.

• 111 lee •

The undersig:ed is directed to forward an RTI Application Registration No. DOCOMIIR12018/80359, dated 20,12.2018, under Right to Information Act, 2005 filed by Sir Bharatashree. Karnataka on tne RTI Web Portal seeking information on the above mentioned subject.

2. Since the informalon sought pertains to different Divisions of DoC, all CPIOs (except E.I. E.II, E.III, EN, Gene-al Administration, Cash-1 & Cash-II. Protocol and TAfTC Sections}, are requested to furnish :he requisite information to the applicant directly as per RTI Act. 2005, under intimation to RTI Cell.

3. As the Informatior also pertains to all IVInistriesiDepartments under the Government of India, under Section 6 3) of the RTI Act, 2005 the application is transferred for providing the requisite information ti the applicant directly as per RTI Act. 2005.

4. In case the infornatior sought or any part thereof, pertains to oche: CPIOs/Public Authorityties1. the appl :a:icr, may be transfe-red to the CPIOs'Public Authority(ies concerned directly as pe Section 6(3) of the RT1 Act. 2005.

End' As above • ••••••• • .W1

4 (Mahender Chaudhary) CPIO & Under Secretary

Tel: 23061933 2_'x`1

To. 1. All CPIOs in Departmei t of Commerce. (As per list), (except El, ER E.11l, E.IV, General Administration. Cash-I & Cash-II, Protocol and TA/TC Sections) 2. All Ministries under the Govt. of India.

■

Copy to: Shri.Bharatashree, Flat Number - 303, Sachidanda Residency. In Front of Ocean Peral. Udupi. Kam itaka - 576104 — for information.

Cs 1220/2118

RTI Venal's

RTI REQUEST DETAILS

Registration No. : Dt COM 'R12028/80359 Date of 2012,2018 Receipt :

Transferred From : Department of Expenditure on 20,12/2018 With Reference Number : DO EXPIR/2018151547

Remarks : information may be available with MoC

Type of Receipt Electronically transferred from Other Public : Authority

Language of English Request :

Name : BHARATASHREE Gender : Male

Flat number:303, sachidanda residency, In front of ocean Pearl. Udupi, Udupi, Address : Pin:576104

State : /Cana:aka

Country : India

Mobile No.: +91- 8217462801

Phone No. +91-88676566/7

:

Email : bharatashreevmragmail.com

Status(Rural/Urban) : Urban Education Graduate Status :

Letter No.: Details not provided Letter Date: Details ,tut

provided

Is Requester Below NO Citizenship Indian Poverty Line ? : Status

Amount Paid : 0,1 RTI fee is received by Department of Expenditure (original recipient) )

Mode of Payment Payment Gateway

Request Pertains to :

1 .lotal number of business summits held from 2004-2014 and 2014-2018 2.Total amount spent on all business summits from 2004-2014 and 2014-2018

Information Sought : 3.Outcomes of business summits 2004-2014 and 2014-2018 4. rota! number of jobs created by business summits from 2004-2014 and 2014-2018

1.Total number of business summits held from 2004-2014 and 2014-2018 2.- Total amount spent on all business summits from 2004-2014 and 0182014-2

Original RTI Text : 3.( /Incomes of business summits 2004-2014 and '014-2018 4. Total number of jobs created by businessaunwaits from 2004-2014 and 2014-2018

Print Save Close

+1t1 *I I 311C-Thth-TT SR, 2005

raft1"/Due date 29.01.2019 TIME BOUND/RTI MATTER

34Trff

Nlal <1•111(141

ralSgr: Tier' .31SWIT .31-fMzP4, 2005 .3499* Wick 31M -Ca" I

Md. Hizbullah, Rio Noida 341-aCF it—Ht- 18.12.2018 1 T4:( 11"9" TM-

cl tq" CIWIF 141.41 aT RTE t I

31-iflwrz Sr, 2005 at t.IM 6(3) t .131717 .e1 fc

ran 3ina- %Ohl 01+-1 #

yra-ca Ir grar arrtca-

*f, 331-4-CF *t tAird 4t ar11-43- zretrera Af+-F 5 fail' altar

ortfl ra gr sira-cw straszlw t

3. .31712:1 3 .1-apt; t ITRT 31t1WR Sr, 2005 TAgieis wr MFa

chic; r" 3\4 t FX1711 wp*rt4 f ETC'

IPO No. 44F 173124 ),- (

33-11-171" Srlt

Sh. A.K. Mallik US(Mines iN/1/ inRf ch T 3a1M-Tft

11.34 .ttafP1 Cell U.O. No. 2/15.5/2018-PlikFiTtnated 31.12.2018

To,

Smt. Rima Puri Section Officer Ministry Of Mines, Government of India Room No.: D-301, Ill Floor, Shastri Bhawan,

New Delhi - 11000

Subject: - Request for Information under ftTI Act, 20CS.

Ma'am,

'ierewith the postal order worth Rs. 10/ Your good self is requested

Iformation:

nes given any Prospecting license to Rio Tinto in the state of Madhya

idly provide the copy of Prospecting license.

Kindly find enclosed

to provide the following

1. Has ministry of rt

Pradesh, if yes ,

2. Has ministry of m nes given any mining lease to Rio Tinto in the state of Madhya

Pradesh, if yes , k provide the copy of mining lease.

3. How may acre (total area) ministry have approved for mining?

4. There are any natsonal century effected by this mining?

S. Kindly provide the name of officer/responsible authority, who are recommended to

ministry to grant :he mining lease.

6. Rio Tinto done ar t diamond mining in the state of Madhya Pradesh. If yes, kindly

provide the detai • of mining.

Yours faithfully.

ye:9X_ r,...,3kikbe5

I-ut1/4"' 1. I • c. *1 tIck- nAnA / e

• / (Md. Hizbullah)

• •::Intiia Today Mediaplex FE 8, Sector-16A, Film City,

Noida, UP-201301

Dated: - 18.12.2018

e2 -2 ck

pc im CI I -7 i?

Government of India Ministry of Mines Mines-Iv Section

No.9/1 /20I 8-M.11/ (Pt.)

To

By Speed Post

11,1 Dated the January, 2019

Md. Hizbullah, India Today Mediaplex FC 8, Sector-I 6A, Film City, Noida, UP- 201301.

•

Subject: - Information sought under RTI Act, 2005 in regard to M/s Rio Exploration India Ltd.

Sir,

I am directed to refer to your RTI application dated 18.12.2018 on the subject cited above.

2. The point wise reply is as under:-

(i) Ministry of Mines had given prior approval for 2 PLs in favour of M/s Rio

Exploration India Ltd. Copies of that prior approvals granted by Ministry of Mines, Government of India has been enclosed.

(ii) Ministry of Mines had given prior approval for one ML in favour of M/s Rio

Exploration India Ltd. A copy of that prior approval granted by Ministry of Mines. Government of India has been enclosed.

(iii) Details of total granted area in favour of M/s Rio Exploration India Ltd. are given in attached approval letters.

(iv) Details with regard to (4) are not available with Ministry of Mines, Government of India.

(v) As per the provisions of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation)

(MMDR) Act, 1957, State Government is empowered to grant mining leases for all

minerals. However, before the MMDR Amendment Act, 2015, prior approval of the

Central Government was required under Section 5(1) of the MMDR Act for granting

mineral concessions in respect of minerals specified in Parts 'C' of the First Schedule

to the MMDR Act, 1957, which has been done away with. Now, prior approval of the

Central Government is required in only those cases which have been saved under

amended SeCtion 10 A (2) (b) of the MMDR Act, 1957, for which concerned State

Government is empowered to forward that such application to Ministry of Mines 1hr

prior approval.

(vi)

As State GoVernments are the owners of the minerals located within their respective

boundaries. They grant the mineral concessions (Reconnaissance Perniit (RP),

Prospecting Licence (PL) and Mining Lease (ML)) under the provision of the Mines

and Minerals (Development and Regulation) (MMDR) Act, 1957 and Rule &

guidelines made thereunder. Only previous approval of the Central Government is

required under amended Section 10 A (2) (b) of the MMDR Act, 2015 for grant of PL

and ML in respect of the Minerals speceed in part 'B' and 'C' of the First Schedule

to the Act. Therefore, the details with regard to confirmation whether the M/s Rio

Exploration India Ltd. has done any diamond mining or not is not available with

Ministry of Mines, Governmei it of India..

3. If you are not satisfied with reply / information, you may prefer an appeal to Dr. D.

Veena Kumari, Director and Appellate Authority, Ministry of Mines, Room No. 308 'D' Wing,

Shastri Bhavan, New Delhi within 30 days of receipt of information.

Yours faithfully.

(A.K Mallik) Under Secretary to the Government of India

Phone-011-23384743

Coy to:- P.1 Cell, Ministry of Mines with reference to PI Cell Registration No. ,u_A-IINES/R/2/155/2018-P1 dated 31. i 2.2018

EN=IMIN•

0:4 oil air 3.11WW arftriWzrxr, 2005

f-a4ici 'Mitt/Due date 29.01.2019


11"a

4_4101 4-1/211c-fel

kktierII Wir 3ritTh7T 3fitlirna:1, 2005 3i-6a* CrTra 31re-CF I

Sh. Nalin Shah, Director, M/s Metallics & Chemical (India) Pvt. Ltd.,

Mumbai 31-1-a-CW ftali 19.12.2018 WI pg. cm' * Firiat 3f 0'I t.6, Sot jci

14,411Bi rgT ti

z. mar a Jars 3rah-ftzraT, 2005 a trru 6(3) * 39FITT 44 *wit cil4

fal414i 317Z- r dicta Ch14*Ci CIS( FFirtZ srferziAtI,Itua arrtcR. atar ITZFT t erf% 3Tra-C1. +vac! 4114,111

3rftwitictifeAd4 3rrd r crifea- a artra trzusfru .#r4-F 5 Carli * atraT

P.irdtalta. ,,141 atrr A wt arr-d-cwaft Trita 3Tranr“

3. .31TE1*7 3T-VET f ff kuri 3Titted7n7, 2005 .41dH TT 41ere1

Wtft u-Rzr wrirart r -rcr

fielder. IPO No. 04G 625:11 -0 31

.3iTmer 31itr+itt

Smt. Lakshmi Subramaman, US(Metal III)/ t—litt eilch 7c-FT iiitrt-rti

%taut .ttRiPI Cell L1.0 No. 2115412018-P1 fart/Dated 31.12.2018

To, Snit. Rima Puri, Section Officer Room No. D-301. III Flog

Shastri Shaven, New Delhi - 110001 Tel No. 011•23384225

Metallic.* LAS Chemical* (India) P.4. Ltd.

25, Dalal Street, Des Chambers, 4th Floor, Fort, Mumbai - 400 001. India

Mr.; icitt‘ Dett ntbes\ C.:C

Subject: - RTI Application under RTI Act, 2005

I, Nalin P. Shah - Director of Metallics and Chemicals (India) Pvt. Ltd filing a RTI application under

section Gil) of RTI Act. 2)05.

We seek information frc --n your ministry who are in-charge of Mining Industry and empowered to

take all decisions for Miring Industry.

As you may know Coppe- Sulphate technical is one of the very essential raw materials to extract zinc

and percentage of Zinc recovered depends on the quality and availability of Copper Sulphate.

We have been informed that even for Copper Sulphate technical for Mining Industry, the mining

companies have to app' ach Ministry of Agriculture and secure license for import and storage.

Information required

If the bags are clearly rn

given by mining com pa r

consumption to the dep

This does not serve the I

complicated for Mining

and foreign exchange sir

Export Policy and mines

continuous use.

-Iced as Copper Sulphate Technical for Mining use only and a guarantee is

es themselves that they will regularly submit audited reports on the

rtment.

irpose of the reason of involving Ministry of Agriculture and making it

idustry to secure this important raw material and loose precious quantity

:c there are no restrictions on impon of Copper Sulphate under Import

equire consistent hisrade quality of standard specifications material for

Please inform whether v itt will be taking up this subject with Ministry of Agriculture and get

exemption for mining in. ustry.

I am enclosing herewith the requisite fees of Rs.10/- by way of Postal Order, the order number is

046 625711.

Thanking You, Yours Faithfully For Metallics & Chemica; (India) Pvt. Ltd.

'1

ac,(_,

Licit,' 4 3101

I I >3/40e t

Nalin Shah (Director) I

Fax ,-91 .22-2267 3263 e-mail : cifsktinde@metallreStran- n tz n , nay'

N jIO Litiii.;? 3 84H!ne.:71r-rt- 02%40 Tel . +91 -22.2267 3707

MOST IMMEDIATE/RTI ACT By Hand

Government of India Ministry of Mines

***

No.5/4/2017-Met.III New Delhi, the oy January, 2019

To The RTI Nodal Officer Department of Agriculture and Cooperation, Ministry of Agriculture, Krishi Bhawan, New Delhi- 110001.

Subject: Application received under RTI Act., 2005.

Sir, Two RTI applications. dated 19.12.2018 and 24.12.2018/received from,

Shri Nalin Shah Director, Mettalics and Chemical Pvt. Ltd. in this ministry seeking information regarding license policy for import and storage of Copper Sulphate Technical, are enclosed in original.

2. Metal -111 Section of Ministry of Mines is not concerned with the matter.

3. The two RTI applications are hereby transferred under Section 6(3) of RTI Act., 2005, as the matter relates to Ministry of Agriculture.

4. You are requested to provide the information relating to Department of Agriculture and Cooperation directly to the applicant.

Yours faithfully, r„n •

91 /4.SVC (Lakshmi Subramanian)

End:- As stated above CPIO & Under Secretary to the Govt. of India

Copy to (By Speed Post):-

1. Shri Nalin P. Shah Director, Metallics and Chemicals (India) Pvt. Ltd, 25, Dalal Street, Das Chambers, 4th Floor, Fort, Mumbai- 400001 (with the request to contact the concerned department for further correspondence in the matter).

\IR Cell w.r.t. U.O.Nos. 2/154/2018-PI and 2/158/2018-PI dated 31.12.2018

tkudi cr arit-wrr 3TitrTh-42:1; 2005

4-ici raitr/Due date 29.01.2019 TIME BOUND/RTI MATTER

arrest eichk

igtoi

-----

0.144: tarn Th-T 3iftWIT zW,2005 31*17 .31TtCa" I

Pft crichuoi az uantr4 3rraa4 fd-atw 16.11.2018 # SFr 9a arc 3Ra. wrztart sifier 14.)4r at Tri

2. :011 SittWri 3fitliWzrxr, 2005 Sr C-ITtr 6(3) 3171ZTR- t~Uoil air r&LI 3rc7-72 tlichhn mitileHT # aTatz t at ar 3Tftr#ti, FIZT# 3Tra-4F 31'71 dk41 3ira-47 a1 4-icsad +Rama. 3act4/Mleiiitua r, 31tr,W srrfirmt artur # zninfra #1%-a- 5 farti afar F4T-Htafta mtatraTttt airy ra• at 4 3fra-CW # aft Tkizaa cnioi ampzr-“

3. 3iTq 3itsrtz frE +kyr!i wr aft.twtr 3tftrf4zra, 2005 timer chid itr-Ft fAtfrre thi-1,4 4 wrzfrart Sr are-

IPO No. 38F 007630

Vo

3r4Datrat 3litr*ift

Smt. lakshmi Subramanian, USfMetal j-011/- +I urn 3litrth-Ttr 41134 .4eLlP1 Cell 12.0. No 2/153/2018-P1 itd* Dated 31.12.2018

/VIA kPb." ?Ot•

,,71 abirittelk - 10,4) ;24 co retAktiz-pri - k-get) .'\1.10$4") ' ttt: '414 ISicvlyik-- - ( or( .14; yffvti 141(d fa•Prb-,_.

9(11,— te41-4- • >4 - A .

i t n)q- el on roi 11-ov 8<fiehtt__

(c;•tli AR-r-T. .mftcb-i) I,

ri Yetg •

fThrai 3-644?-im

7.411.771

4:4-R4 *T; ;if f A 3114

q12191 i Tc t T V-R11 Annex-A , a >RN(

d -:-J11-%".(7 3111171

7-r 37FC-iN W€1,— c. t97

171ii -11151k1 cflRifC1R1 / Oto Tecie t?-i-t.:cEs?Firru•Ti

"1:741 thtT4 k 317-tT ctr<4 k rt5irs' 1:-.)tizT7

i It9tErti ;Pa

•tr-i git-43 i C C KiPiT (TRt Wit:1T 7391:1. v ;.$

e 0 r)(:. 3 C6 &1•17°

act,. (Q,wieb

te)an 4 - t

91

• • 1"n

61-Ytj

:et 2 7 I 7// n.

11/

\ 9 (

@Coe) 31-v14. &r

61)4 WM affil

alb

Annexure : A-1

Please provide the following information under R.T.I. Act — 2005 (23 of 5) :-

Ref:- Please provide the information regarding Annual return as per form A-1 1See rule 45(I)(C)(1)1 for the Financial Year 2001-2002 to 2018-2019 submitted by Company Hindustan 7inc Limited Plant kampura Agucha Mines retail Hurda, Distt. Bbilwava. Rniasittin as per submitted to the Controller General — Indian Bureau of Mines as ccr Part-I1 :-

Please provide the information regardintz above said matt•—• as per following ,,shone • -

PART II

EMPLOYMENT AND WAGES

I. Number of technical and supervisory staff employed at the mine alongwith names and address :-

Description Wholly employed Partly employed

ri) Graduate \dining rgirie-r

(ii) Diploma Mining Engineer

(iii) Geologist

(iv) Surveyor

(v) Other administrative. clerical and technical supervisory staff

2.(i) Number of days the mine worked:

(iii No. ur:.;hif, per J.

Oil) Indicate reason- nor work stoppage Re., ti bti. 0 f s in the Illiat during i tie year such as due to strike, 'orkm:it, monsoon, non-availahilire of 1.A boor. transpr.rs bottleneck, lack of demand. uneconomic operation etc. and the number of days of work stoppage for each of the factors separately.

3(1) Employment of Labour and wages paid Maximum number of persons employed on any one dati during the year:

(i) In worki4 below ground on

(ii) In all in the mine on la)

. :).(titi,..s 1 -kveracte dail-. , .. ;corked

i persons empis‘• :it 'tik,„:•,:s

.;bring the /salsr. „‘

year ... _ i01.

lift et ' Contract I •:.::i j Male Female i

(243) (2< (3) (4:1) (48) (Jr

I -- ---

i;;•,)

minino r1-::'

• .-•••••• ii!”,1 4o-H-

•ih tither:.

pencast workir-Lats:

Foreman mining 11,

Face IA ork!rs and loaliers

• iii) Others

hove gi

ki • ;i. texeluiline the superlic. .• • .- visory staff.)

Workers ;1 any littitcloo Z•lry. workshop or mineral •• r h ). Id an 10

Others

Iota,:

foto.' les ;;.:•. t. and sapervist.ir-, cart' ..-••• •

naen, ill: • r'

,T1 LkA. 61 I 't

tark

Aft Acwor or-e, Into/ mt ,ire

3irjr51 tfrti [2 2 (91)- a: gist, 1: --airRawr,

T--"÷-2TW-311001 I 2. b

. arc-t twtT.

31ii arrt kfimmui-415 tita. Caitr

nti; tiiebR

ly I al 4-1,11elei

F. 31ritt3nt-01 /26/20184134 4farc'froir, f 28.11.2018

?

tuart 3TftfiAz1H", 2005 i doe. e,144t *le.{ I 1 'carrels saTfreel

3i tit facii,t, 17.11.2018 tri 18.11.2018 S a r Tr-a-

311Ter34 3ifttiW2TaT, 2005 * Fra• tkvaritki-cliaoi kcial cnia a1t ti 3iTtcw Tim

tio Mrceent .3flt# /SW, st ir* 101- Frictr 4t4:rg 3Trtt 387:8 007627

LrE 387? 007630 t wt *44 Tint ci4ai orr r61.

2. Mg* 34 40T1 3TRa3Tit 31*C#iat rui ct, qi/1 mt at 2ft:-

tj1 31Teeri4 * ara •reiden Otzra tarcei arrtz -47za act, aria

44:41eiti artaT 3riciio elial 311 76, ZIT 3:1-41W14 2c.cti 2* ttita. Rt. nriu aiitch3i1 iRft

3. 3i13*R (r" 3ftZ Quaid *T raP4ib1o) t:XCI77, 2005" eri WITT, 3itir-a-

isT4611 31ftli caw 10 VW * .111451? 3T14-CR" q.T3 721T chta * rinTF 411 7T trcr+cffi

tl 71-t *.ff 'OUT arftrth-rft. arra xi-iritai 3i2RET TrJIW trt AMIT At m& arra fir' 4 ro * wet a! 134-ri.4 ptc4a-rararaia qta-* mrt-{ Tcr 3rw cii(i War

child t17416* cud eTW4t 3rd#, 3T. iiat.rA SW a, 4 raven-mow 31:d#

at ZEIM J-; 1 el.41 VI 1 TR a"-AT crlimi 7T I:War ti

4 3iimcbi ic4F1 cilta 4i izAV 30 fcr, Trr * Critlitta *I 7TaRT VIT .1-1 ioid xr

=Mat Bra 31wer3rrt ar-a-ca srrir t trfWftr * glivin

4), juivk plorNke sAti

+1 Ci it*. 10 w:1V SFr 3114crI3T1" A. 38i716 007627 vi 38C17 007630

File No.Met2-Z020/1/2019-METAL II

Met2-Z020/1/2019-METAL H Government of India Ministry of Mines

ShastriBhavan, New Delhi — 110001 Dated the 03/01/2019

Subject:- RTI Application of Shri Jeevraj Jaat, Sarpanch, Agucha, Rajsthan seeking information under the RTI Act, 2005.

Please find enclosed an RTI application dated 18.11.2018 (received by the undersigned on 31.12.2018) filed by Shri Jeevraj Jaat, Sarpanch, Aagucha, Rajsthan seeking information under the RTI Act, 2005.As the subject matter of the RTI application pertains to some Annual Report being submitted to IBM, the RTI request is hereby transferred, under section 6(3) of the RTI Act, to Mines III Section (dealing with IBM matters) with the request to send the reply directly to the applicant.

(Lakshmi Subramanian) Under Secretary

End.: As above.

To, Shri Adhir Kumar Mallik, CPIO/Under Secretary, Mines-III Section, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi — 01

Copy for information to — 1. Shri Jeevraj Jaat, Sarpanch, Aagucha, Panchayat, Tehsil — Hurda, Distt. Bhilwara,

Rajsthan - 311001.

‘4. PI Cell, M/ o Mines with the request to ensure that the RTI requests reach

the concerned CPIO so that such unnecessary exercise of transferring the

SignatUratittigitaahe Ministry could be avoided..

Digitallyt:argred by\ SHMI SUBRAMANIAN Date: 2019.01.0 :36:04 1ST

No.31/13/2018-M.III

larta-nrGyvernmentof indla----

zt97:4" / Ministry of Mines 414:14**

em New Delhi. Dated 21-4"January, 2019

To CP1O-Co-ord (Mgrs.) (Shri AD. Selokar) Dy. Mineral Economist. Indian Bureau of Mines. Nagpur.

Sub: Information asked under R ..1 Act. 2005

Sir, Please find enclosed he -ewith a copy of RTI

Sarpanch, Aagucha. Rajasthan late('7.11.201S and applicant relates to IBM. Therfore. the application of Section 6 of RT1 Act 2005 for further necessary ac

End: As above

application received from Sh. Jeevraj Jaat. I 8.11.2018. The information sought by the is transferred to IBM under sub-section (3)

tion.

Yours faithfully,

k (Adhir Kumar Mallik)

Under Secretary & CP1O Tel No.-23384743

Email: [email protected]

Copy to:

1. Sh. Jeevraj Mat, Sarpanch, Adg,ucha, 3hiiwara, Rajasthan -311029 with the request that the further

rrespondence may be mace with IBM.

L/CS:PIO, Pi Cell w.r.t. their Registration No. 2/152/2018-PI and 21153/2018-P1 dated 31.12.2018

AT.

311t1f4ZIP:1, 2005

ci) raTh/Due date 29.01.2019


3ITiF atom< 4.9101 cf-mey.4

ffe-osrz: rnt,0,1 5r 3ritrwr: 3ritfTh-43:1, 2005 3fraif3 urn 3.17teW I

cl,t101 otIC 21.44T4, UaTZTT# i 31-raC7 itorT4' 17.11.2018 a1 SFr q~ Frzr 3f46 wrirar-3- ,44-cr idien 7rrs-r t-1

34"itin aftrf#zp:r, 2005 tr tIRT 6(3) * 392:117 41 ail i$

fati71arzi +Ra-da chre6c44-4 F1 1$J/ mitr-*-Ttr, fra-g-*1- arra-c- zrzir tea 3Tr'dda a t #-Eft-6 4fosi.ft

3rrtc7r r grfe-6 Sr mew F1 zrzrrerEr #1%-w 5 farli j graT ai4 avir Tfr -r3* Sr arr-d--w1 gr #Tha- .33ra3ir“ I

3. Oct 31.RpT f Tai i SR 3rftAtt, 2005 4.4H11 Er_ a,ic1 Fr3 49 1:4tinta FRZT a1 OV

IPO No. 38F 00762

11 OH'

3f-lanar .3.1ftWrft

Smt. Lakshmi Sularamanian, US(Meta1111/ (74* arfewtr tf1.3ir4.+16/Pi Cell U.U. No. 2/152/2018-P1 itFtW/Dated 31.12.2018

N11) ""Ifvf 9 041

k,r41 el ,fs. -.7%) a - 744-; 1/2 f attArk et I" • 2;1 -aer -D-01 Ptt ei tiAlti

Ay" tv11 tiru ' Q.41 ^f ?..,-Pc4 al I tit? - 3 or, - 14. osi <vi set - ..241 Z14 t 017 1 1‘..,

;11 •E4 1'1 (41 31i-eiantx1)

frga :— Serif S' 3T5tr*Ti (200e) 3r-c4 41(13irsZ9

eiern-ra

--cf>rsfp:,* 71,1" "aiDcrli'n 3117 3TRIET: t zWq*:

ST 11,:!1 7.1T& t 74/1-1711 Annex-A — 4h' 337,119R TiAzi

art -a5-4

OICT i-11 1-M1 tid 1.1ft-iic414 Weicla ft() Mir .ft-if5":=frcr rs:o

'1 ro-; 7;217i 1:-1T-111,711 TR..;1 t f;'d11-12 117 rI1):.z.4".:i

(5•<-11 ft-t.c11 I ciitigT \ffrgl, T21-19 at F 18-11c0 -tc1c1 cbx

TeirlyeT icf -rt 10 7:C 77491 7:11 t ci•-77f 1/471-7 irsi 1./ • •

5$r 4> 1.1 u r 1741- 4kticr:

C~-~lcr (.5.51 2--

111 4 C

cS,AT9 •

17•t/,`)._

141 citcl • 4140-77-4

P-I ,---

\01t ‘. Q1 /40.37,C1

50-4gt eiN4

AI

Annexure : A-i

Please provide the following information ander:RA .1. \ ea 2005 (23 of S) :-

Ref:- Please provide the information regarding Annual return as per form A-1 'See rule 45(1)(C)(1)] for the Financial Year 2001-2002 to 2018-2019 submitted by Company Hindustan Zinc Limited Plant Rampura Agucha Mines Tehsil Hurda. Distr. Shilwara, Rajasthan as per submitted to the Coney-filer General -Bureau of per P3C- 711-0:1_91) 54. C--Y444 0111"14-5/ CI • v , •

Please provide tfl,- information regarding above said pttJ:ter as per following questions :-

PART 11

EMPLOYMENT AND WAGES

1. Number of technical and supervisory staff employed at the mine alongwith names and address :-

Description

Wholly employed Partly employed

(i) Gracioatst 'fining Engineer

(ii) Diploma 'Mining Engineer

(iii) Geologi.si ..

(iv) Surveyor

(v) Other administrative, clerical and technical supervisory staff

2.(i) Number o days the mine worked:

iii „\o. y:

latt;c:1-• for work :lioppage Nunthe; in tat. the year such as due it, iockout. monsoon, non-avai hility of labour. transport bottleneoc tack of demand, uneconomic operation etc. and thy number of days of work stoppage for each of the factors separately.

3(1) Employment of Labour and wages paid Maximum number of persons employ e' on day during the year:

0) In i;c4 below ground on • (a) (ii) in ail in the mine on .0

"1"•••••,-,

4? k)i, I Na. ;if .; ti worked

during Ow I year

Dirc”a . Coo k-ko..r Total . _

(1) (24

h2r) L (3)

yr1'2,• - person:. rr.;:l://eAt

/a I-,

14n r..1 Male female Total

- • (4A) ;43; (4C)

„At.

t17

(iii) Others

Opencast workings:

(i) Yorernan tnaln;

(ii) Face w-srke; and loaders

(iii) I Mien

Above 2r•,;:h1.1:

;:.(er„eh. , mnemisory sta(i'.)

(ii) •Voirty;:rs •n irry. factor'. worksh.:1 •:-

(Hi) Other --

'Iota!

,::-.3ployed 1:1 . 1(2; r);

File No.Met2-Z020/2/2019-METAL [I

Met2-Z020/2/2019-METAL 11 Government of India

Ministry of Mines

Shastri Bhavan, New Delhi — 110001 Dated the 03/01/2019

Subject:- RTI Application of Shri Jeevraj Jaat, Sarpanch, Agucha, Rajsthan seeking information under the RTI Act, 2005.

Please find enclosed herewith an RTI application dated 17.11.2018 (received by the undersigned on 31.12.2018), filed by Shri Jeevraj Jaat, Sarpanch, Aagucha, Rajsthan seeking information under the RTI Act, 2005.As the subject matter of the RTI application pertains to some report being received by IBM, the RTI request is being transferred herewith (under section 6(3) of the RTI Act) to Mines III Section (dealing with IBM matters), with the request to send the reply directly to the applicant.

Encl.: As above.

Copy for information to —

To,

(Lakshmi Subramanian) Under Secretary to the Govt. of India

Shri Adhir Kumar Mallik, CPIO/Under Secretary, Mines-III Section, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi — 01

Copy for information to:

I. Shri Jeevraj Jaat, Sarpanch, Aagucha, Panchayat, Tehsil — I4urda, Distt. Bhilwara, Rajsthan - 311001.

l. 2. pr. cell, pcin . ob— tel; nits

Signature Natyerified

Mk Mines 'M r 4 L Digitally. • ed 1 SHMI

SUBRAMANIAN Date: 2019.01.0 :49:35 1ST

No.31/13/2018-M.III

-----WRVITTWNITIMent of India.

/ Ministry of Mines 4****

New Delhi, Dated 441rjanuary, 2019

CPIO-Co-ord (1-1qrs.) (Shri A.D. Selokar) Dy. Mineral Economist. Indian Bureau of Mines, Nagpur.

Sub: Information asked under RTI Act, 2005

Sir, Please find enclosed herewith a copy of Rh' application received from Sh. Jeevraj Jaat.

Sarpanch, Aagucha, Rajasthan dated 17.11.2018 and 18.11.2018. The information sought by the applicant relates to IBM. Therefore. the application is transferred to IBM under sub-section (3) of Section 6 of RTI Act 2005 for further necessary action.

Encl: As above Yours faithfully,

(Adhir Kumar Mallik) Under Secretary & CPIO

Tel No.-23384743 Email: [email protected]

Copy to:

1. Sh. Jeevraj Jaat, Sarpanch, Aagucha, Bhliwara, Rajasthan -311029 with the request that the further

rrespondence may be made with IBM. PI Cell w.r.t. their Registration No. 2/152/2018-PI and 2/153/2018-PI dated 3112.2018

To

born 3iftrth-R .31f g71, 2005

fagot f-a1Z/Due date 19.01.2019

TIME 80UND/RTI MATTER

3.117a" +1,04+4

fttrzr: 4-kc4 01 I W- 3TitTh-R 3ftr"4-Erg, 2005 * 31-a71# 11I'-c1 .3Tra-CR- I

Shri Mukesh Kumar Chaudha, R/o M.P. 31T-4-4-A* itFiT 18.12.2018 set Ts/ 3-fta wrirart crl:Fra-1-4,qi TriI

3ritr+7 .31ThTh-zrxr, 2005 Sr tTRT 6(3) 3171-frg elfa *aft zit fa tazi 3rnz +N(chit1 op/

Sr, facial 31T-4-- gar aria arr-d-ca a t #iftra- +whia .31T4-CF• crftia. *1 Rita zro_Tmiru #f*R- 5 fail' gra-{

g. mt.* atr Tp-a. chicril afrazr*

3. 3ir9rf1 3tVv.i Ruch yftr-th-R- ar, 2005 * crr-ga a,tcl v 1Wcift #714 tr oill!

tiodo. IPO No. 44F 153586

(4).H, t) 3iTTPT 3iitr+-th

Sh. Prakash S. Mundharikar, SO(RC) / ei et, 11Uofl .31ftWiti 411.3f1t .11tF/P1 Cell U.O. No. 2/151/2018-P1 it-dtiDated 21.12.2018

) -stir)

2 j/1-120(9# \ • h•

P

To,

Public Information Officer

Ministry of Mines

New Delhi

Subject - Application under RTI Act, 2005

Respected Sir,

Kindly provide us the complete file of Revision Application No. 16/04/2018/RC-

II i.e Govind Das Chaudha Vs State of Madhya Pradesh alongwith Reply filed by

the State Government and any other documents. Also provide us the complete

Note-Sheet of the file as well.

It is submitted that the complete documents referred above should be supplied

to our advocate i.e Dr. Harsh Pathak, Address - 23, First Floor, Bazar Lane,

Bengali Market, New Delhi - 110001, Mobile No. - 08510003042.

rcluXcmil K.Lunan___ Date - 18th December 2018 Mukesh Kumar Chaudha

SR) Late of Govind Das Chaudha M/s Rajshree Traders

Sukhan Akhara Road, Jalpa .1-0 Asa- Katni - 483501. (M.P)

Mobile No. - 09977830768

Note - Rs. 10 Postal .Orders enclosed.

Po ,0!, 14c t5.358C

I

RTI Matter/Speed Post

No.01/02/2018/RC-1861I Government of India

Ministry of Mines Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi

Dated the ) traVanuary,2019

To

Shri Mukesh Kumar Chaudha S/o Late Govind Das Chaudha M/s Rajshree Traders Sukhan Akhara Road, Jalpa Ward, Katni-483501(MP)

Subject: Application of Shri Mukesh Kumar Choudha for seeking information under RTI Act, 2005.

Sir

Please refer to your RTI application dated 18.12.2018 on the subject mentioned above and to say that copy of desired information contains 141 pages.

2. As per Act, copy of the requisite information can be provided on depositing charges @ Rs.2/- per page copied. You are, accordingly, requested to deposit amounting to Rs. 282/- (Rupees Two Hundred and Eighty Two only) in the form of Cash/Demand Draft/Banker Cheque in favour of Pay and Accounts Officer, Ministry of Mines or deposit at Information Facilitation Counter, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan, Dr. Rajendra Prasad Road, New Delhi-110001.

Yours faithf 1

(Prakash S. un. arikar) Section Officer & CPIO Tel No. 011-23384070

A/o.py to CPIO, PI Cell, Ministry of Mines, w.r.t. their 00 No. 02/151/2018-PI dated 21.12. 2018.

STT .33*(124zIR, 2005

M.ZTF MTh/Due date 12.01.2019 TIME BOUND/RT1 MATTER

amd

itttot 5r 3TfE T7 affted-trgr, 2005 atata circa 3Tra-ca• I

Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment 41144 el+4 °itch

05.12.2018 c:41i1 sauF Ms. Rakta, R/o New Delhi arTaRT-ca" 31ra-d-R taiw

04.12.2018 TO la FPI 3flcl Wtart tg STfga it7T 71* ITT tr

2. tiro 3a 7 31-ftrd-zrg, 2005 *t tTRT 6(3) 39-87 zrt *air

itt1•1i fir 3TZT tptchal 4444imei * TT/

Trart.“a1 a8- aarwitr,faliT1 3rr-kcF sir nzff t tr# 3n- k-4-4

3ritm8richienclet arr-d-cF *r ;rft8* a art& zrarreru c11-4,0 5 goi gra-{ FITRTafta' t Mir TN lilt 7 311-4-CS 31t kipci c4,.&11 317-dltfW t I

3. 3179# 39-(11/ ff ituoi 31-fr4zPT, 2005 * S.-A(44 r 1:11WR

Wit r 5t14•4 Mtirlta" Trwr gr mita* a 7re- I

MoSJE's O.M. No. A-43011/291/2018-RTI dated 05.12.2018

is;Nc \

(ST q) 398117/ 3~1

Sh. YoKesh R. Patel. US(Estt.1/ <RI' et kVaT 3ift(*rit

Sh. M.R. Sathvanaravanan. SO(Mines I)1 calm 7FFT

Sh. R.R. Mandal, SO1Mines 111 / *-4R1" S turn 3iiti*Ter

Sh. A.K. Mallik. US(Mines 110 / j.4 encti KITAT 3~1

Sh. V.P.B. Singh. SO(Metal I) / *-41Z1 Act, 1:FaT Sr smt. Lakshmi Subramanian, US(Meta11111/**-IRT TIFAT 31Jiitt*TtI-

Smt. Lakshmi Subramanian. US(Metal IV) / a 1T 3t-ftmlr Etr.rt .mac /P1 Cell U.O. No. 2/150/2018-P1 fanial/Dated 14.12.2018

)0DAPIR.:2018150743

Online Receipt

Rakta

181 A, Street No 13, Near Pin:110043

Delhi

-91-9718722011

[email protected]

Urban

No

10

Date of Receipt : 04/12/2018

1,anguage of Request : English

Gender : Female

Given Valley Public School, Najafgarh,

Country : India

Mobile No.: 491-9718722011

Education Status : Above Graduate

Citizenship Status Indian

Mode of Payment Payment Gateway

RTI Details

ICI REQUEST DETAILS

Registration No. :

Type of Receipt :

Name :

Address :

State :

Phone No. :

Email :

Status(Rural/Urban) :

Is Requester Below Poverty Line ? :

Amount Paid :


Information Sought :

f5 {t

Nr,,t

Mkt , Met V

flow many Schools. Colleges , Monuments and Religious places are Disabled - Friendly in India Please give names and location of the places.

How many people with disability are currently working in aovernment offices of Delhi. What is the percentage of their with respect to people with no disability.

Which governuuzin offices of Delhi are not disable friendly.

Print Save Close

Or-

tr%

RTI MATTER Government of India

Ministry of Mines

No.25 (1)/2017-Med New Delhi Date 18.12.2018

To

Shri Javed Reyaz P.I.OJGeneral Manager(IE & Compliance) National Aluminium Company Limited Nayapally Bhubaneshwar — 751061(0disha)

Sub: Application seeking information by Ms. Rakta, New Delhi, under the RTI Act, 2005.

Sir,

The RTI application forwarded by Ministry of Social justice and Empowerment, Department of Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities (Divyangjan), vide letter No. A-43011/291/2018-RTI dated 05.12.2018, received from Ms. Rakta, Najafgarh, Delhi is being transferred under Section 6(3) of the RTI Act, 2005 for furnishing the information to the applicant as sought by him as the

subject matter pertains to NALCO.

2. You are requested to provide the information relating to NALCO directly to the applicant, as

per the provisions of RTI Act under intimation to this Ministry.

Yours faithfully,

(V inay ratap Singh) CPIO & Section Officer


End: Copy of application No PI Cell 0.0. 2/150/2018-PI dated 14.12.2018

Copy to PI Cell

RTI MATTER BY SPEED POST

No. 31/2/2016-M.II Government of India

Ministry of Mines

New Delhi, "1" December, 2018

To Shri S.C. Bose, Admin. Officer & Nodal Officer RTI Geological Survey of India, Central Headquarters (CHQ), 27-J.L. Nehru Marg, Kolkata-700016

Subject: RTI Request through P.I. Cell vide U.O. No. 2/150/2018-PI dated 14.12.2018 under RTI Act, 2005 — Reg.

Sir,

Please find enclosed a copy of RTI application transferred by Department of Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities, Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment vide O.M. No. A-43011/291/2018-RTI dated 05.12.2018 under the subject reference.

2. The information sought by the applicant pertains to GSI being an attached office of this Ministry. Therefore, a copy of the application is hereby transferred to you under Section 6(3) of RTI Act, 2005 for furnishing the reply within stipulated period under RTI Act 2005 to the applicant directly under intimation to this Ministry.

End: As stated

Yours faithfully,

927C>i. V.1/1°'

(Ram Rashik Mandel) Section Officer/CPIO

Email: [email protected] Tele: 23382818

Cony to:

1. Ms. Rakta, 181 A, Street No. 13, Near Green Valley Public School, Najafgarh, Delhi-110043 for information. A copy of your application has been forwarded as stated above. For any further query, concerned PIO of the GSI may be contacted directly. If you are not satisfied with the information furnished by PIO of the GSI, you may appeal to the

pellate Authority in GSI under the provision of RTI Act, 2005. 2. P.I. Cell w.r.t. their U.O. No. 2/150/2018-PI dated 14.12.2018

MOST IMMEDIATEMTI ACT FAX/SPEED POST


No.5/4/2017-Met.III New Delhi, the j7 December, 2018

To

Shri Kamlesh Kumar, CPIO, Hindustan Copper Ltd, 'Tamra Bhawan' 1, Ashutosh Chowdhury Avenue, Kolkata-700019.

Sub:- Application seeking information by Ms. Rakta, Rio New Delhi regarding Disabled friendly institutions in India.

Sir,

An RTI application No. DODAF/R/2018/50743 dated 04.12.2018 by Ms. Rakta, R/o New Delhi is being transferred (in original) under Section 6(3) of the RTI Act, 2005 for furnishing the information to the applicant, as sought by him, in respect of HCL,

2. You are requested to provide the information relating to HCL directly to the applicant, as per the provisions of RT1 Act, under intimation to this Ministry.

Yours faithfully,



Copy to:-1., Ms. Rakta, 181 A, Street No. 13, Near Green Valley Public School, Najafgarh, Pin- 110043 (with the request to contact the concerned organization for further correspondence in the matter).

2 PI Cell w.r.t. U.O.No.2/150/2018-PI dated 14.12.2018

113002294/2018 File No.Met4-16/1/2018-Metal IV/Record Cell 111/204


New Delhi, Dated: 18/12/2018

To, The Director,

National Institute of Miners' Health, JNARDDC Complex, Opposite Wadi Police Station, Amravati Road, Wadi, Nagpur-440023 ([email protected])

The Director,

Jawaharlal Nehru Aluminum Research Development & Design Centre, Opposite Wadi Police Station, Amravati Road, Wadi, Nagpur-440023 ([email protected])

The Director, National Institute of Rock Mechanics

Outer Ring Road, Eshwar Nagar, Banashankari 2nd stage, Bengaluru-560070 ([email protected])

Subject: Information sought by Ms. Rakta under RTI Act, 2005.

Sir,

Please find enclosed herewith an RTI application registration no. DODF/R/2018/50743 dated 04.12.2018 for the information sought by Ms. Rakta, under RTI Act, 2005. The RTI Application is transferred (under section 6(3) of RTI Act) with request to send the reply directly to the applicant under intimation to this Ministry, at the earliest.

Yours faithfully,

Encl: As above

(Lakshmi Subramanian) CPIO/Under Secretary to the Govt. of India


Copy to : 1. Ms. Rakta (181 A, Street no. 13, Near Green Valley Public School, Najafgarh Pin - 110043) ([email protected]) 2. PI Cell ([email protected])

/ L- 7Y.2-ti

RTI MATTER

GOVERNMENT OF INDIA MINISTRY OF MINES

No. 40(35)/2015-M.1

New Delhi, the 17.12.2018

To Shri Jayant Pophali, Public Information Officer (PIO), Mineral Exploration Corporation Ltd., High Land Drive Road, Seminary Hills, Nagpur-440 006

Subject: Application seeking information under RTI Act, 2005 by Ms Rakta, 181 A, Street No.13, Near Green Valley Public School, Najafgarh, New Delhi seeking information about MECL.

Sir,

I am directed to transfer under Section 6(3) of the RTI Act 2005, an RTI application of Ms Rakta, 181 A, Street No.13, Near Green Valley Public School, Najafgarh, New Delhi dated 4.12.2018 on the subject mentioned above which was transferred from Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment, Department of Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities(Divyangjan) vide their letter dated 5.12.2018 and received in this Section on 14.12.2018.

2 You are requested to provide the applicant, the information if any, sought by him/her directly within the stipulated time limit under intimation to this Ministry.

Yours faithfully,

(M.R. Sathyan rayanan) CPIO, Mines.l


1. Ms Rakta, 181 A, Street No.13, Near Green Valley Public School, Najafgarh, New Delhi. If you are not satisfied with the information furnished by PIO of Mineral Exploration Corporation Ltd.(MECL) you may appeal to Dr. C.S. Murthy, the Appellate Authority in MECL under provision of RTI Act. 2005.

2. PI Cell, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi w.r.t their U.O. No.2/150/2018-PI dated 14.12.2018.

0.1

(M.R. Bath elarayanan) CPIO, Mines.l

No.31 I3'2018-\:1 [I1

airta •thctibt I Uovernment of India

7:CM- / Ministry of Mines

New Delhi. Dated ig /12-12018

To Ms. Rakta, Rio 181A, Street No 13. Near Green Valley Public School. Najafgarh, Delhi-110043

Sub: Information asked under R11.1:1. 2,1105

Sir,

With reference to your online application No. DODAHR/2018/50743 dated 04.12.2018 on the above mentioned subject. it is informed that information in respect of Mines.III (IBM) is NIL.

2. In case you are nut “itit the reply furnished above. you may prefer an appeal wider the provision of R I I \c• 2no3 before the Appellate Authority. Smt. Athira S. Babu, Director, Shastri Bhawan. N l )1/4.111i .

Yours faithfully,

Copy to:


Tele No.-23384743 Email: ak.inallikfthnie.in

CPIO, P1 Cell w.r.t. their Regiciration No. 2 13u 2018-PI dated 14.12.2018

I t

F.No. A-18/1/2019-ESTT. Government of India

[Ministry of Mines * * * *

tlyiustii post

RTI matter

To, New Delhi, the 11.th January, 2019

Ms. Rakta, 181 A, Street No 13,

Near Green Valley Public School, Najafgarh, Delhi — 110043.

Mam,

This is in reference to your RTI application dated 04.12.2018 which has been transferred to this Ministry by Ministry of Social Justice

and Empowerment on 05.12.2018. It is to inform that as far as Ministry of Mines (Secretariat Proper) is concerned, 03 persons with

Disability are currently working in this Ministry. Their percentage w.r.t. people with no

disability in this Ministry (Secretariat Proper) is 1.98%. It is to further inform that the Office of Ministry of Mines (Secretariat Proper) is disable friendly.

2. In case you are not satisfied with the reply, you may file an appeal before the Appellate

Authority (Shri Shersha, Director, Ministry of Mines, Room No. 309, 'D' Wing, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi) within a period of 30 days from the date of receipt of this letter.

Yours sincerely,

(Yogesh R Patel) 1 i Copy to: Under Secretary to the Govt. of India

I• PI Cell, Ministry of Mines w.r.t. their U.O. No. 2/150/2018-PI dated 14.12.2018

Subject: Application under Right to Information Act, 2005- Application received from Ms. Rakta dated 04.12.2018.

WI Details

rtn REQUEST DETAILS

Registration No.: DODAP12/2018/50743 Date of Receipt : 04/12/2018

Type of Receipt : Online Receipt Language of Request : English

Name : Rakta Gender : Female

Address : Pin:110043 181 A, Street No 13, Near Green Valley Public School, Najafgarh,

State : Delhi Country India

Phone No.: +91-9718722011 Mobile No.: +91-9718722011


Status(Rural/Urban) : Urban Education Status : Above Graduate ▪ . •

Citizenship Status Indian Is Requester Below No Poverty Line ? : . .•• _ Amount Paid : 10) Mode of Payment Payment Gateway ,


How many Schools, Colleges , Monuments and Religious places are Disabled - Friendly in India Please give names and location of the places.

Information Sought : How many people with disability are currently working in government offices of Delhi. What is the percentage of their with respect to people with no disability.

Which government offices of Delhi are not disable friendly.

Print Save I: Close f• i•-:•siir •

7 dt.1%..CJ J ‘Ner,,..„, vi

.cik,t riti. r OH

v,;▪ ta

• /4

tkt-iru 31itTWR- a, 2005

fazict qi-4/Due date 01.01.2019


iga +NchR

rT +111c14.4.

fttErzr: ttt4cu 3IitP;R a,2005 *Ea-4F t.w-c1 3:11a,0" I

Shri Shrikant Deshpande, Rio Nagpur *.3tra-C-F itFtW 12.11.2018 T4T KR *TM chi4Mt S16 aT T tl

2. tiro Wr

.weir

TI Tat“ at at;

311tWir/chiqlei-1

Frdtafra email

siftrTh-zrxr, 2005 *t tTRT 6(3) 3TT4R 41a +ii - Fatrzr 31,7zr ,ti-tchhn chie.4W4 rl •s$1/

3-iftr+-rft,D+Rhl 3TT of &tar Trzir 31TaZa" w'r ci

±Tra-CW e atm- zrurerer #1'+-R. 5 Rom altaT aerr 5-4:r -rk- a 3fra"W air Tip -a. mteii afraw“

3. 31172:1 3c1-4-1IT f'W 44k-ur1 W• SR' a, 2005 4.4+1. TTT 41clorl

chit+) §tr fAtifta TP:RE WziraTt off .111Q I

IPO No. 08G 320827

(flail 4tl)

3T T1TaT Sr

Sh. V.P.B. Singh. SO(Vigilance)/

- •

el Ai +itlo-li

AW/P1 Cell V.0 No. 2/149/2018-PI 1tRTW/Dated 03.12.2018

Sh. Yogesh R. Patel,

Under Secretary & CPIO ( metal IV)

Room No.: D-303, III Floor, Shastri Shawan

Rajendra Prasad Marg. New Delhi - 110001

Sub: Request for inforr ation under Section-6(1) of RTI Act 2005

Dear Sir,

Please supply me the fc 'owing information with respect to my complaint dated 12/10/2017 to

CVC. New Delhi, detailed below:

Details of complaint:

The government of India is putting all its honest effort to ensure that differently able persons get

equal job opportunity and the common man is looking for strong action against those are involved

in discrimination and corrupt practices to deny their due rights. One case has come to my notice

wherein a physically fit person is recruited against the post reserved for PWD and therefor I

formally lodged complaint with CVC, New Delhi on 12/10/2017 and confirmed the same. In complaint dated 12/10/2017, the issues of securing job in JNARDDC with fraudulently medical

certificate of Physically Handicap by Mr Vipin Naik and malpractices of JNARDDC officials, who

abused their power and post to induct a person with absolutely no disability against a post

reserved for persons with' disability is raised. The officials of JNARDDC allowed the same person

to contest local body election and holding the post of Deputy Sarpanch while continuing in

Government service of JNARDDC. Subsequently, I was informed by CVC, New Delhi that the

above mention complaint (copy enclosed) is forwarded by CVC to Ministry of Mines for further

investigation and action. Thereafter, it is also learnt that Ministry of Mines deputed one officer to

conduct investigation in complaint dated 12/10/2017 to CVC, but till date no actions are taken

against Mr Vipin Naik and other persons mentioned in complaint dated 12/10/2017 to CVC.

Particulars of Information sought Under Section-6(1) of RTI Act 2005

1. Please inform about current status with respect to action taken and status of investigation proceedings on above mention complaint dated 12/10/2017 to CVC.

,.f

• q;;P\*.j.

yr-

2 \ -C1 ;

Er row a v•—' •t" , e•C

2. Name and address of the officer deputed to JNARRDC to investigate the complaint dated 12/10/2017 to CVC and date of visits of the deputed officer to JNARDDC, Nagpur .

3. Certified Copy of the investigation report, if the investigation proceeding is over and certified copy of evidences collected by investigating officer.

4. Copy of decision note of Chief Vigilance Officer of Ministry of Mines. Govt of India on above mentioned complaint dated 12/10/2017.

5. Copy of note sheet indicating the noting and comments of concerned officers.

6. Name of Chief Vigilance Officer of JNARDDC and copy of his appointment to the post of Chief Vigilance Officer in JNARDDC.

7. Certified copy of investigation report and written statement submitted by Chief Vigilance Officer of JNARDDC, Nagpur in the matter of the above mentioned complaint dated 12/10/2017 and Certified copies of oral / written statement of persons against whom complaint is investigated.

8. Certified copy of letter, directions and/or instructions issued to concerned authority / subordinate office as a follow up action based on investigation report on my above mentioned complaint dated 12/10/2017 to CVC.

I am attaching lPO for Rs.10/- payable to Xe kmJ c444...- payable at N°-LL' .°ceic towards RTI Application Fee. Please send the information to my below address by Speed post.

Yours faithfully.

Signature

(*Al

Name Shrikant Deshpande Address. Plot 9 /A Vinayak Nagar, , Hingna Road, Nagpur 440036, Mobile No 09850300765

Date: 12/11/2018

CC 1. Honorable Shri Narendra Singh Tomar, Minister of Mines, Govt of India. New Delhi 2. Chief Vigilance Commissioner, Satarkata Bhavan , GPO Complex, New Delhi 3. Secretary, Ministry of Mines. New Delhi 4. Shri Rakesh Moza Deputy Secretary & Nodal Officer (RTI) Ministry of mines, New Delhi

Complaint Under Public Interest Disclosure and Protection of Informer (PIDPI)

Date: 12.10.2017

To Central Vigilance commission . Satarkata Bhavan . F -Block. GPO Complex INA. New Delhi - 11C 023

Name of officer against whom

complaint is being Indged

Designation/Post held of officer

against whom complaint is being

lodged

1. Dr. Anupam Agnihotri

2. Mr Raghupati Sriniwasan

1. Director

2. Secretary cum Senior

Administrative Officer

Orgarusation/Deparment of officer

against whom complaint is being

I lodged :

Jawaharlal Nehru Aluminium Research

Development and Design Centre, Wadi,

Amaravati Road, Nagpur

(An autonomous body under

administrative control of Ministry of

Mines, Government of India)

Sub: Malpractices and use of extra-constitutional authority by the officials of

Jawaharlal Nehru Aluminium Research Development and Design Centre.

Nagpur

Sir,

I am enclosing cop,: of important letters and documents and I have reason to

believe that persons referred in para 2 and 4 are dishonest, disloyal and their

professional conduct s extremely doubtful. I am giving reasons for conducting probe

against erring officia of the Jawaharlal Nehru Aluminium Research Development

and Design Centre (JNARDDC) NAGPUR

1. It is very well on the records that Shri Vipin Kmar Naik, Lab Attendant was

arrested by the Polices at Khaperkheda Police Station, Nagpur and was

detained in Nagpur Central Jail for a period of 2 weeks during the his service

period . Besides this Shri Naik had contested Gram Panchayt election in the

year 2012 while he was in service with JNARDDC and also was holding the

post of Deputy Sarpanch while in government service. As such, he made

liable to be exposed under provisions of CCS (conduct) Rule 1964 and CCS

(CCA) Rules 1965 and Conduct Rules of JNARDDC rules 1999 at item no 10.

It is astonished to note that instead of initiating disciplinary action against Shri

Vipin Kumat Naik, Mr Raghupati Sriniwasan, Secretary cum Senior

Administrative Officer has simply closed the case which is evident from his

letter as enclosed herewith, stating that Mr Vipin Kumar Naik has contested

the election without obtaining NOC from office, having full knowledge that

there is no provisions exists in CCS (conduct) Rules, 1964 as well as in the

CCS (CCA) Rule 1965 to grant NOC for contesting election and taking part in

politics. JNARDDC Rules, 1999 also does not allow its employees to seek

NOC for contesting election. It is needless to mention here that the provisions

under the above said rules categorically provides that a employee detained

under Police custody for more than 48 hours is considered deemed

"Suspension" and no employee is allowed to take part in Politics and

Election. Therefore, Mr Raghupati Sriniwasan has favored with some vested

interest possibly in return of kick bag. Mr Raghupati Sriniwasan exercised

extra-constitutional authority to protect and allow Mr Vipin Kumar Naik to

continue in service without initiating disciplinary action as contemplated under

Rules.

2. It further glimpses that Mr Vipin Kumar Naik has obtained medical certificate

of Physically Handicap fraudulently as he competes in sports with normal

candidate and won many prizes.

3. Mr Vipin Kumar Naik was initially engaged in JNARDDC for Housekeeping

work .on a temporary basis and at that time he has no physical disability. Dr

Anupam Agnihotri was the house keeping in-charge during the tenure of

pervious Director Dr. Mukhopadhyaya. Later on in year May 2008. Mr Naik

was recruited as Lab Attendant against a post reserved for Physically

Handicap candidate. Dr Anupam Agnihotri was the chairman of the selection

F.No. 24/i/2016-Vig Government of India

Ministry of Mina

To, New Delhi, the 27th December, 2018

Shri Shrikant Deshpande Plot No. 9/A Vinayak Nagar Hingna Road Nagpur-440036

Sub: Information sought by Shri Shrikant Deshpande under RTI Act.

Sir,

Pease refer to your letter dated 12.11.2018, seeking information under RTI Act. This is to inform you that the documents sought by you are in 68 pages. The photocopy of the same can be provided to you on payment of Rs. I36/- @ Rs. 2/- per page as prescribed under RTI Act, 2005. You may deposit the amount in the form of Postal Order/Demand Draft or Banker's Cheque in favour of "pay and Account Officer" Ministry of Mines, New Delhi or deposit in canh at information Counter, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan, Dr. Rajendra Prasad Road, New Delhi-110001. 2. In case you are not satisfied with the reply, you ay file an appeal before the Appellate Authority Smt Farida Naik, Diretor, Room No. 312-D, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi.

Yours faithfully,

(Vina Singh) Section Officer & CPIO

Tel: 011-23382715 Email: soviail.domanic.in

to: P.I. Cell, Ministry of Mines w.r.to. PI Cell U.O. No. 2/149/218-PI dated 03.12.2018

F.No. 24/4/2016-Vig. Government of India

Ministry of Mines

h' New Delhi, the r • January, 2019

To Shri Shrikant Deshpande, Plot No. 9/A Vinayak Nagar, Hingna Road, Nagpur-44003

Subject: Information sought by Shri Shrikant Deshpande under RTI Act.

Sir, With reference to your RTI application dated 12.11.2018, seeking information

under RTI Act. As requested by you, following documents are hereby provided to you:-

(i) Copy of enquiry report submitted by Shri Naveen Kumar Singh, CVO, HCL, (ii) Copy of note sheet of Ministry of Mines vide which the report of CVO, HCL

was examined. (iii) Copy of appointment order of CVO, JNARDC

2. In case you are not satisfied with the reply, you may file an appeal the Appellate Authority Smt. Farida Naik, Director, Room No. 312-D, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi.

Yours faithfully,.

(Vinayprafap Singh ) Section officer & CPIO

Copy to: P.1. Cell, Ministry of Mines w.r.o. PI Cell U.O. No. 2/149/218-PI dated 03.12.2018

ekti ri I WI. .11f 31ftiTh'znr, 2005

Thitf/Due date 29.12.2018

TIME BOUND/RT1 MATTER

731171 cH

thtiZi: 1:1011+ R. .3iftr+-7 Ati*ZPT, 2005 *3iatif ;REF

Ministry of Women and Child Development * uv f4Whw 27.11.2018 4c lt1 ciWa" Shri Nikhil Patil, R/o New Delhi * 3ft-H--gro 16.I L2018 Th-t z19"c 2iT2T 3fta" Thlird*fr 11÷cri fd-Ieb aT TFT tl

31-ft7 3.1ftfizfxr, 2005 *r tagr 6(3) * 317frt a 4 3.fr rlt4,l <h1+41c1zl# up;

3arRtr, 11+I4,) 3T1t8W TRIT tRt sill-'a ct +li4+tdl 3iIacerl *t crrfea Sr artru t7 zrzinfru #.1%-- 5 faciii *

oit,ft t Mir 3rra-cwa1 atr chirn 3Trmzrw t

2-kt4011 3 T7 3.1fM-zpr, 2005 * f.444J-11 rrr- fAterfkri #Przr *r .7rcr

: MoWD's letter No. CRE 18/32/2018-Creche dated 27.11.2018

(41a-ii rift

3921-rir arftrwrfr

Sh. M.R. Sathvanaravanan 50(Mines 1) / 7rRI el c1, R.R. Mandel, SO(Minet. II / ch

5h. A.K. Mallik US(Mines 1111 / 1-4 N14+ 79T 3-iit-t-rtr Sh. V.P.B. Singh, SO(Metal I) /oi-tzt tilcb77-RT 311 4,i

Sint. Lakshmi Subramanian, US(Metal III) /unzf each 7-HT 34*-th-ft Eft3iTt .fra/131 Cell LO. No. 2/ 1 48/2018-P1 fed-FEW:Dated 30.11.2(118

2. rlUeil cif

rip it

arec- t aF

q

..-V-TriVta chid!

3. 3iftr-41- .317o-ef,

'h

-

ME

CRE 18/ 32 /2018-Creche Goverriment of India

Ministry of Women & Child Development

To

Sh. Nikhil Pad:, Block No. D 1, flat No. 90, Lodhi Colony, New Delhi- 110003.

Subject: Application under RTI Act, 2005 — reg.

Sir,

Shastri B'awan, New Delhi Dated:2,2 /November, 2018

Kindly refer to your RTI application having Registration nc.). MOWCD/R/2018/50812, dated 16.11.2018 received in this Section of e-office Dairy NO. 307634/2018/JD, dated

22.11.2018. In respect of National Crèche Scheme, the point-wise information is as furnished as under-. Point-I,11 & fl1

M/o WCD is implementing the National Creche Scheme through States/Las who in turn run creches through NGOs all over the country. National Creche Scheme is not directly concerned with creches run in Central Govt offices.

The RTI application is being transferred to all ministries and Govt of NCT of Delhi under Section 6(3) of RTI Ac! for providing relevant information directly to the applicant.

2. In case you are not satisfied with the reply, you may prefer an appeal

within 30 days to the Appellate Authority at the followi. g address:

Ms Anuradha S. Chagti, Joint Secretary & First Appellate Authority Room No. 645 'A' Wing, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi 110001- !" !!",---) -ET I

, 1c1 !Ntai47

Copy to

9- 3 ti 2

T.:41-ff*er •---

Yours faithfully,

wty (S.Sakumar)

Joint Director si & CPIO

i. .CP10 RTI Cell, Deptt of lomen & Child Development Govt of NCT of Delhi, 1-Pt Ravi Shenker Shukla Lane, K. G. Marg , New Delhi 110001, with a copy of RTI application of Sh. Nikhil Patti, dated 16.11.2018 for providing relevant information to the applicant.

•

•

jetPlOs concerned of All Ministries( as per list) for providing information the applicant . Copy of RTI application of Sh. N. ikhil Patil, dated 16.11.2018 f (

closed).

iii. Under Secretary. IFC. MWCD.

is/Joint Director

wrI REQUEST DETAILS (3-17refart 3.1Vti F4-4ITh

Type of Receipt et 14 a,7 cf*R) :

Address (4111) :

State (TM- :

Phone Number (th"ta7i<4<) :

Date of Receipt 1 G I 1201:, onfeer *r :

Online Receipt Language of Uglish Request (31-Teft7tt

&TNT) :

Gender (fg71) : ‘thic

Mork No. DI. flat No. 90. Lodhi Colony, New Delhi, Pin: I I 0003

Delhi Country taw : India

Mobile Number Details not (-sns ow) provided

Registration Number (ri#STOT TitziT) : NRDIVCD ;.f

Name camo NIKII1L PATII.

- 'f l -9699202970

Entail-ID (szt.6._3ritio nikhilpati129106p,gmail.corn

Status (fit2Tfa)(Rural/Urban) : Details not provided

Is Requester Below Poverty Line ? No 3Irta 7rfror 4t4t-4- t?) :

Amount Paid R Ta,73Frar4) : 10 ) (original recipienu

S. Sasikumar Request Pertains to prOt11:147;TThitire 4-iftra-b :

Education Status : Details not provided

Citizenship Status Indian (irfratittT)

Mode of Payment Payment orri—diff w-gm-m Gateway

i. Provide the address of' Dav Care Centers/Creche of (.7enual Government Offices or Central Govenunent Ministries in NDMC area of Delhi. 2. Provide

the address of Day Care Centers/C.'reche of Information Sought (71W+itt TIOlb: Central Public Sector Undertaking & Public sector hanks

in NDMC area Delhi. 3. Provide the address of Day Care Centers/Creche of

Delhi Government offices and Delhi PSUs Ministries in NDVIC area of Delhi.

• Print s Save • Close .

RTI MATTER


No. 40(35)/201541



Subject: Application seeking information under RTI Act, 2005 by Shri Nikhil Patil, Block No.D1, flat No.90, Lodhi Colony, New Delhi-110003 seeking information about MECL.

Sir,

I am directed to transfer under Section 6(3) of the RTI Act 2005, an RTI application of Shri Nikhil Patil, Block No.D1, flat No.90, Lodhi Colony, New Delhi-110003 dated 16.11.2018 on the subject mentioned above which was transferred from Ministry of Women & Child Development vide their letter dated 27.11.2018 and received in this Section on 30.11.2018.


Yours faithfully,

if L> -

(M.R. Sathya iayanan) CPIO, Mines./


1. Shri Nikhil Patil, Block No.D1, flat No.90, Lodhi Colony, New Delhi-110003. If you are not satisfied with the information furnished by PIO of Mineral Exploration Corporation Ltd.(MECL) you may appeal to Dr. C.S. Murthy,, the Appellate Authority in MECL under provision of RTI Act, 2005.

2. PI Cell, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi w.r.t their U.O. No.2/148/2018-PI dated 20.11.2018

(M.R. Sathyanarayanan) CPIO, Mines./


No.25(1)/2018-Met-I Government of India

Ministry of Mines

New Delhi, the 30th November, 2018 To

Shri Nikhil Patil, Block No. D1, Flat No.90, Lodhi Colony, New Delhi-110003

Sub: Seeking information under RTI Act, 2005

Sir,

This is regarding your application registration no. MOWCD/R/2018/50812 dated 16.11.2018 duly forwarded by Ministry of Women & Child Development on day care centres/ Creche. This is to inform that both Ministry of Mines and National Aluminium Company Limited (NALCO), a PSUs under Ministry of Mines does not have any day care centre/ Creche in the NDMC area of Delhi.

2. In case you are not satisfied with the reply you may preferred an appeal before the

Appellate Authority Smt. Athira S. Babu, Appellate Authority and Director, Room No. 311- D, 3rd

floor, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi within the stipulated period as per the provision of RTI Act, 2005.

Yours faithfully,

(Vinay P ap Singh) CPU) & Section Officer

Email : [email protected]

Copy to: (i) Shri S.Sasikumar, joint Director & CPIO, Ministry of Women & Child Development, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi, w.r.t. CRE 18/32/2018-Creche dated 27.11.2018.

(ii) PI Cell, Ministry of Mines, w.r.t. U.O. 2/148/2018-P1 dated 30.11.2018

MOST IMMEDIATE/RTI ACT FAX/SPEED POST


No.514/2017-Met.11l New Delhi, the 63 December, 2018

To

Shri Kamlesh Kumar, CP10, Hindustan Copper Ltd: 'Tamra Bhawan' 1, Ashutosh Chowdhury Avenue, Kolkata-700019.

Sub:- Application seeking information by Shri Nikhil Patil, r/o New Delhi regarding address of the Day Care Centers in NDMC area Delhi.

Sir, An RTI application dated nil by Shri Nikhil Patil, r/o New Delhi is

being transferred (in original) under Section 6(3) of the RTI Act, 2005 for furnishing the information to the applicant, as sought by himkpoint No. 2.

2. .You are requested to provide the information relating to HCL directly to the applicant, as per the provisions of RTI Act, under intimation to this Ministry.

Yours faithfully,



Copy to:-1., Shri Nikhil Patil, Block No. 01, flat No. 90, Lodhi Colony, New Delhi - 110003., with the request to contact the concerned organization for further correspondence in the matter. ralz.1- kt. i e. 3 ctov Ka- Ce-oualtki. Met l r Ce Lew; t ra ft mina

PI Cell w.r.t. U.O.No.2/148/2018-PI dated 30.11.2018

No.31/13/2018-MIII "TRW iftcnii I Government of India

1 4-imicv." / Ministry of Mines *****

New Delhi, Dated I 1 >/2018

To Shri Nikhil Patil, Block No. D 1, Flat No. 90, Lodhi Colony, New Delhi-110003


Sir,

With reference to your online application No. MOWCD/R12018/50812 dated 16.11.2018 on the above mentioned subject, it is informed that information in respect of Mines.III (IBM) is NIL.

2. In case you. are not satisfied with the reply furnished above, you may prefer an appeal under the provision of RTI Act 2005 before the Appellate Authority, Smt. Athira S. Babu, Director, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi.

Yours faithfully.


Tele No. 23384743 Email: [email protected]

Copy to:

I. CPIO, PI Cell w.r.t. their Registration No. 2/148/2018-PI dated 30.11.2018

0:a C 111 b cl

To Shy l S.C. Bose, Mm in. Officer BA Nodal Officer RTI Geological Survey of India, Central Headquarters (CHC2), 27-3.L. Nehru Marc?, Kolkate-700016

Subject: RT.! Request through P.I. Cell vide U.O. No. 2/148/2018-N dated 30.11.2018 under RTI Act, 2005 - Reg.

S!r.

Please find enclosed a copy of RE application transferred by Ministry of Women at Child Development vide Letter No. CRE 18/32/2018- Creche dated 27.11.2018 under the subject reference.

2. The information sought by the applicant at point no. 1 pertains to GSI

being an attached office of this Ministry. Therefore, a copy of the application is hereby transferred to you under Section 6(3) of RTI Act, 2005 for furnishing the reply within stipulated period under RTI Act 2005 to the applicant directly under intimation to this Ministry.

Brach As state ?

Yours faithfully,

(Ram Rashik Mandel) Section Officer/CPI°


Copy to,

1. Shri Nikhil 'Pail, Block No. 0 1, Flat No. 90, Lodhi Colony, New Delhi- 110003 for information. A copy of your application has been forwarded as stated above. For any further query, concerned PIO of the GSI may be contacted directly. If you are not satisfied with the information

1

furnished by PIO of the GSI, you may appeal to the Appellate Authority in GSI under the provision of RTI Act, 2005. P.I. Cell w.r.t. their U.O. No. 2/148/2018-N dated 30.11.2018

71-qm. 3ritm7 arferratm-, 2005

fir fa*/Due date 29.12.2018 TIME BOUND/RTI MATTER

3-1-7F NR-WIZ

Z910 <1.1 11(44 -----

fk-cr: artft# 2005 t 3.19-10 CiTra- 3TT a I

Ministry of Tourism i ER' it--4-* 19.11.2018 Sh. Adarsh Mohnot, Rio Rajasthan i 3Tra-CW ItFtW 12.11.2018 *t flf cra- * 31 r *Tztart tg Wmci f41e41 mfr Ti r

2. titi 01 I arit+1-{ 311triWzny, 2005 *2t UM 6(3) * 31Trr-4- zit a 71t +14troi1 l'Isrzr ift*Ttl• # Trartz t at a setwrft, 1 t 31-r-laa 11trr 71-zrr 3U item. Frthitr 3amtrhtbs4ilem T, 3rr-4-4-R sufe# t Tyra' zrzinftcr #1*a- 5 ft- 1 afraz mmi-arra 7F-tr t atu wt a1 sn-d-c-- m-1 alt #S-a-

3. 3iPzri1 3r f tiro r .31ibmi-i- afferizikzrxr 2005 k 14-4331 *T g1 Tc of cfr<c) #Rzr * wr4-art anT I

+ii4J0-r. Ministry of Tourism's letter No. E11I/2018-RP dated 19.11.2018

39111•4 arfe*Tif

Sh. V.P.B. Singh, SO(Metal 1) / *7-e- Rr M1q, Tr-awr 3ribwrt-cit.3irtAw./P1 Cell 11.0. No. 2/1417.2018-PlIt-dtwiDated 30.1 1.2018

1:#3 ltia- 3T1%311-64W

W.1(1if)/2018 airat.arrt

urra Ritept/Govemment of India wire# aielau/Ministry of Tourism

(3ITTIV.31Tt. zfiai) / MT, Cell]

#1•-1, so cti.

81# *OF tg, fave11-110011

R4e: 19.11.2018

197!

1. Mit 1173-71- tktivii 31 cm 44

2. 1f.41-.3rrt.a1t., ffrea4 f1.ic1

3. Inft rksma twrvit

f4tizr: 41- aunt N1 Cf faaitit iraTtita 85RT TIZTAT ¶1 31- chi(

* WV? WRIT 31Far•T WWI

3&11#77-C, 2005

diliei4*3117.tr388'. •4aT 7t Ng* a116o'1, faaltfi 1174-1/171 # kttMI

31Pti+T( 3TWA'471, 2005 W Gileitma mm7 * fv cm' mit.

12.10.2018 (edff4 ticoo t) T. 10/- * STrA4 1-l4-coi 3i-tk a. 41F 228771 *

5(sT( e' tr

Cid 1 * 3117# :391itl" l i 3108* Th-lf 3feireff onrichi 396111' cri•U a

asfwcz' wt K1W GileichVb TALr antrenit Th-t (rF 3Tra-47 79'

Irre, 2C )5 W'r Urn 6(3) * c c Tait ii of .1-ra 41:401 3liti*liVit &MAW

fi~4 4* 31"-{ mit r. trgt rot vita cr-4-rn wTA- * ?Ay a;ciati aft 90441 zrzt til

xratir

(wr. fitm)

Twziw 1Wa-cw (3Trt.tt.3ift.)

ta* Wr.):111...84ARta

.37-011W rAtF.yfrf

1. 4..,,VIzT 71# 39Mt "(4 3cf 1"ka-trq 1:tr#.31it.), Eft# #14#

Urea 7; 7.Str-1 ref T, gni 1 113', fac-A - 110011 I

2. a a;4)44 f tiw [(-=T14), ), (Tri-P4) 3#t

Aft

3S-ot 711-6.46, 337,..114 I3* 2TW.5 ytt-5, 717,77T, 71c.,77, TraTurA•

(zkv-fr. 'Pram

" ‘95141co Wall* (3iTt.tr.34.)

+1614+.,

r" \

Through Speed Post/ Registered Post

Date: 1 a _ n _ 2.018

To

The Public Information Commissioner

Ministry of Tourism,

Government of India

C-I Hutments Dalhousie Road

New Delhi -110011

Respected Sir/Ma'am,

Application for Information under the Right to Information Act, 2005

The undersigned applicant wishes to seek the following information regarding all

departments and/or Institutes having any Foreign Exchange Earning.

If any department and/or Departments having any Foreign Exchange Earning, kindly

provide us the list of all the departments, all above informational required for all 29

States and with their :-

a. Import and Export code number, state wise.

b. Gross Foreign Exchange Earning of Departments & Institutions wise and

state wise for the financial year of 2015-16 & 2016-17.

Net Foreign Exchange Earning Departments & Institutions wise and state

\ Slr)vAc wise for the financial year of 2015-16 & 2016-17. tam

kaN. N

Note:-

I. I have attached a postal order bearing No.111 F )28141for Rs. 10/- towards payment

of application fees as per DoPT circular no. F.10/9/2008 - IR dated 05.12.2008.

Kindly intimate me for the additional fees payable, if any.

2. In case the information is held by or related to another public authority,

application c7 such part of it as may be appropriate may be transferred to that other

public authol :ty under intimation to the undersigned as per Section 6(3) of RTI Act.

(It acts as a reminder for the PIO who is required to do it under the Act).

3. I undertake to pay further fees required by your department in furnishing the

information.

4. 1 am 'Citizen of India and I am asking the information as 'Citizen'.

5. I assure that I shall not allow/ cause to use/ pass/share/display/ or circulate the

information received in any case and under any circumstances, with any person or in

any manner which would be detrimental to the Unity and Sovereignty or against the

Interest of India.

6. 1 state that the information sought does not fall within the restrictions in section 8

and 9 of the Act and to the best of my knowledge it pertains to your office.

Sincerely,

AbPtR6

Adarsh Ivlohnot

337, Umrao Bhawan,5th Road, Sardarpura

jodhpur, Rajasthan

+91 9828171470



Ministry of Mines

New Delhi, the 30th November, 2018 To

Shri Adarsh Mohnot, 337, Umrao Bhawan, 5th Road, Sardarpura, Jodhpur- (Rajasthan)

Sub: Seeking information under RTI Act, 2005

Sir,

This is regarding your application duly forwarded by Ministry of Tourism on gross/net foreign exchange earnings for the period 2015-16 and 2016-17. This is to inform that Ministry of Mines does not directly involved in any trading, therefore earning of any foreign exchange through import or export so the information may be treated as NIL.

2. In case you are not satisfied with the reply you may preferred an appeal before the Appellate Authority Smt. Athira S. Babu, Appellate Authority and Director, Room No. 311- D, 3rd floor, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi within the stipulated period as per the provision of RTI Act, 2005.

Yours faithfully,

(Vinay Pratp Singh) CPIO & Section Officer

Email : metl.momOnic.in

Copy to: (i) Shri U.S. Mishra, Assistant Director (RTI) Ministry of Tourisim, C-1 Hutments, DharaShikao Road, New Delhi-110011 w.r.t. 1(11)/2018-RTI dated 19.11.2018.

(ii) P ell, Ministry of Mines, w.r.t (LO. 2/147/2018-PI dated 30.11.2018

,c) t1J-1r,1 WI aaMTT 3libiWzITT, 2005

ca•Lici Wit/Due date 28.12.2018 TIME BOUND/RTI MATTER

31-fra. riichR

(S101 01-141e14-1

31-ferdzw, 2005 i ii sw-ti

Department of Personnel and Training c ita* 15.11.2018 cow Shri Saurabh Rai, Rio Uttar Pradesh arR-gro• .3Trat-R. ita 06.09.2018

Tft r17 51-ad Wad* 71' TOT t 1

• 2. 41:14311 W• sawn- .34M-zp:r, 2005 *t MU 6(3) 3.178- ari..41. art (kt,di wr fa w41 3477:4. iftchl chi 4eter # #-Fitt t ar 3111).T11; fazWr arr-d-cw 4a-r Trza sira1 E,1 riei tichrtl sift q, Racoi *T CfrRia" r aftra 741.ffercr 1='7- 5 farli k afta-{ +11l-dlalAB eip(rdi r c92Tr qft 3iI 1 aft Trfta- chten 3fra-mw g-

3. 31-F* aiTM. t f ,1*-10-11 arfeWri- 3TitliWzig, 2005 fazrAt r tra-a• n+ILR itifftF ##Zi wrda-rt we- I

DoPT's letter No. 36(3)/1/2017-E0(CV0) dated 15.11.2018

Sh. M.R. Sathvanaravanan, SO(Mines / RIc11cn kT:IFT 3Titr+Ttr

Sh. V.P.B. Singh, 50(Metal I) / cach tlzleil alfttwItr Smt. Lakshmi Subramanian, US(Metal 11111 *-4314

41.311$ .4ei/P1 Cell 'Co. 21146/2018-PI It-RIW:Daled 29.11.2018

No.36(3)/1 /2017-E0(CV0) • f ,... Government of India

Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances & Pensions (Department of Personnel & Training)

RTI Cell ilicvet•-. All Ministries/Departments (As per list attached).

Subject: RTI Application of Shri Saurabh Rai.

Sir/ Madam

Shri Saurabh Rai sought information vide RN application dated 6/9/2018 (copy enclosed) regarding CVOs posts in PSUs. The information to the extent available with this Department was provided to the applicant. A copy of the reply is attached.

2. The applicant, however, preferred an appeal (copy enclosed) stating that the information

which is not dealt by ..hc section and dealt by other section, the copy of this application has to be sent to that conceimed section which has not been done yet. He further stated that the couplet information may be provided and if some other section is concerned with this RT1 application, then please forward it to concerned section.

3. The Appellate Authority, having examined the information sought by the RTI applicant and the reply of the CP10, has noted that the information with regard to point nos. (iv) & (v) of the application. the information is not available with the undersigned and might not be vaaabic IL 4 cornpiiid manner with any authority. Therefore. the only opt:on is io forward

the application to al: the Ministries/Departments of the Government of India and to the Division of DoPT dealing with the Central Secretariat Service cadre. The Appellate Authority further directed the 1:ndersigned to forward the RTI application accordingly. A copy of the

order of the Appellate Authority is enclosed.

4. A copy of :our RTI application is being, accordingly, transferred to all Ministries/Departrne:•ts and CS Division of DoPT, for providing the relevant information

directly to the applicant.

5. Shri Jagannath Srinivasari, Director(MNI), Department of Personnel & Training, Room No. 19-A, North Block. New Delhi is the first Appellate Authority in the matter under Section

19 of the Rn Act. Yours faithfully,

(Ch atra Mani) Under Secretary & CP10

Copy along with a co ,y of the RTI application to:

(i) CPIO & US(CS-I, [Shri Anil Tripathi], DOFF, North Block, New Delhi.

(ii) CPIO & US(CS-1' ;Shri Chandra Shekharb DOPT, North Block, New Delhi.

(iii) CPIO & US(CS-h [Shri Debabrata Banerjeel, DOFT, North Block, New Delhi.

(iv) CPIO & US(CS-P [Shri K Srinivasanj, DOM', North Block, New Delhi.

with the request to provide the information directly to the applicant under intimation.

Dated, the 15th November. 2018

(J. Director (MM)

Tel. No. 23092842

F.No36(3)/1/2017-E0-MM(CV0) Government of India

Department of Personnel & Training (Office of the Establishment Officer)

***** North Block, New Delhi

Dated the St-November, 2018

ORDER of the Appellate Authority

Reference appeal dated 01.10.2018 with respect to RTI application dated 06.09.2018 from Shri Saurabh Rai under Section 19(1) of RTI Act, 2005.

2. The information sought by the applicant, and the reply of the CPIO were examined. It was noted that the CPIO has provided the information available with him. It was however, noted that regarding the reply to point nos. (ii)&(iii), it is stated "Under Secretary level officers are posted as CVO in PSUs through DoPT". This should read as "Under Secretary level officers are not posted as CVO in PSUs through DoPT" and was confirmed to be an inadvertent mistake. It was noted that the CPIO has also sent the reply and the annexure by post. A copy of the same is being forwarded with is order.

3. • Regarding point nos. (v)&(vi), it is noted that the information is not available with the CPIO, Shri Chhatra Mani and might not be available in a compiled manner with any authority. Therefore, the only option is to forward the application to all the Ministries/Departments of the Government of India and to the Division of DoPT dealing with the Central Secretariat Service Cadre. The CPIO has been asked to do the same.

4. Accordingly, the appeal is hereby disposed off. In case of dissatisfaction, a second

appeal may be made to the Central Information Commission under sub-section (1) within 90 days from the date of receipt of the order.

End: As above.

To Shri Saurabh Rai, 108, Arazibagh Lane, Behind Prakash Medical Hall, Azaragarh-27600 I , Uttar Pradesh

` el"

. Copy to:-

Ch‘ 1. RTI Cell, Department of Personnel & Training.

../.2(. -She Chhatra Math, Under Secretary & CPIO (FA-UN), DoPT

\ , 3. PS to Dir(MM)

Fit( UM/ N

RTI REQUEST (au xe..4 aititt etelici)

Registration Number (Oafltsui Raltr) DOPesT R ,2; 1 Date of Receipt (cage A :" •

Receip: Language or Request

(3 tzrtJNT): :

N.„,„ cam) ; Rat Cender (Mit) ; Xlje

Ark Tess itta* : 1( - :hind Pinked: inettiaul hail. Ammearli Pire27Ontil

St.tte (Korot : tr Pt' .

Lela OS no: via,a Elea

Phone Number ..7'1W*41):

Email-ID . SautahlwairXr.:/tualan.COM

Stalls ale)(Rur it/Urban):

Is Reqiirsier Penn Poverty Lin,? I;FM' 31TettE Ni

Iseeer. uepal Intent at Peri & Amount Paid 131R1 aCT3171-ara): I rumor It ..r Ira:: 11

Country (hi) 111 "''

Mobile Number (altaTtR

Ant) ;

Education Status

Citizenship Status Ina

Mt I

Modeat Payment (31oette

1117:1.

Request Pertains to (3 Citif)zzarraltire •tiaftre : cith-11-74 mar4 ir. K:tufly cive I crormai ion on mane of all the L'S I_ where CVtd 1$ posted (la0,11:h

,..•1 -1.:- informahon on mune of all the PSU wk.::: Under Styretray ;eva: t.t•tc.:. ;no

c inf,,..nation on :roue of ad the PSI when: Under Secretary iere: &nap A -.1.. •.

Information Sunaht (iTP.".5ift Rive):

X.:\ "ion 011rame.bateliamdm controlling authority or *li the Covag• • . • ' , • : •

at Deputation in MI

: • ..:.0J1 toe name 01 II the where Unalet Segteguy lLve: (.1101;2 4. u.

'•1.0:ratron on tome.pay seek. C.1010011;f0iliag atitherity :.2! , ..•nr, •. aercp: ' level officer posted in Central government &part:tie-a t war: au

Kinisy itikn nuninn mule at all :ha PSI. where CVO is posted Mums'.

2 1(.04;y f inform:lien on name Mall the PSC when: Under Secret:a.. Lee. di'. Wet eta p..-Ird

2 K .•• oIii' 'ration en name el all the PSU where Under Sectary Lew:. ierviees ttle,:,'s pn::ed (NO

Original RTI Text (aF31117431TtRr6):

kit..1; :t. a.: otacnneitn: on namelgiteb.cadre euntroilmg 4010101Ey so' all :h.: tins's. A twesicCi CIO:CC; Depaution in PSI

"41. 1:.:kt min; elation on name of all the PSI) aa hoe I hider Sc; t1,ti y 11'..-1.1h0...j` A 'aria tt e..,11iit”. p0S1Cd on deputation. CI n I give infirmaciee:on nanumxty settle. cadres eunimiliny aulhotity of :111 6:‘,0p A a•anc.11 'tenicca coder Sreisisoy levet officer posted in Central •ativonment tkiXinnitill IT minnatv.

Print Savo Close

-14

Type of Receipt (171t: 51-+TO ;

F.No.36(3)/1/2017-E0-MM(CV0) Government of India


*****

North Block, New Delhi To Dated the NtSeptember, 2018 Shri Saurabh Rai, 108, Arazibagh Lane, Behind Prakash Medical Hall, Azamgarh-276001, Uttar Pradesh

Subject: Application seeking information under RTI Act, 2005.

Sir,

Please refer to your RTI application dated 06.09.2018 with the request to provide the relevant information under RTI Act, 2005.

2. • The point wise reply are as under.-

(i) The list of PSUs where CVOs (JS, Director and DS level only) are posted through DoPT is enclosed.

(ii)&(iii) Under Secretary level officers are posted as CVO in PSUs through Don. (iv) This division deals only CVO appointments in selected PSUs. A list of 64 officers

posted on deputation in PSUs as CVO is enclosed. (v)&(vi) No information on these points is available with this division.

4, Shri Jaganath Srinivasan, Director(MM), DoPT, Room No. 19-A, North Block,

New Delhi is the first Appellate Authority in respect of this CPIO, in terms of Section 19 of the RTI Act, 2005,

Yours faithfully,

(Chhatni Mani) Under Secretary to the Govt. of India & CPIO

Tel. No. 23093846

;

First Appeal Details Se A"( -;t7-(F9 6.

Page of 2

FIRST APPEAL DETAILS( MPT it'll?, fa clog)

Registration Number DOP&T/A/2018/60813 " Date of ReceipttOttRM (4.7114htui ThIRD) : *1701/11) :

01/10/2018

Type of Receipt Online Receipt Language of Request English (t 4 *I' Atli) : (stesati e WM) :

Gender (1 l) : Male Name (MR) : Saurabh Rai

Prakash medical hall, Azamgarh Address (tTaT) : 108 Arazibagh Lane behind

Country (all) : India State (Trap : Uttar Pradesh

Phone Number (w14 Details not provided Mobile Number (rilui5et 491- OWT) : 9415318888 gliR) :

Email-ID etstat Saurabhrai007®gmail.com 3Tr4t) :

1 .

1

Urban Status (RIYIa) : Educational Status Graduate

1

(toll on lika) :

Is Requester Below No Details not Poverty Line ? (WM 3tfa4w) Witt tan*

Does It Concern Life or provided. Liberty of a persion

RTI Request Registration No

(*.Ka en LT 3111,Mi 3t t1ei ti.allettit :

DOP&T/R/2018/54732/1 RTI Requst 01/10/20 1 8 Registration Date(VW1

aritm-rc amttr trg faeliqi) :

CPIO's Order/Decision No.

R*113;4341( WT aitter 4-4340 :

Details not provided Date of Receipt of Details not CPIO's Order/Decision provided

(*PVC 341 thaw) :

Provided Ground for Appeal Incompletc,Misleading or

False Information PA* WI tilt) :

Reason for delay(if any) N/A in filing this appeal

30ra wt Alzg AST4 at 1W6W, Wit *It 0, %7

emiui) :

Prayer or Relief PLEASE REFER TO YOUR REPLY REGARDING THE Sought(flim III INFORMATION WHICH WAS ASKED THROUGH THIS R.T.I.

39tir wiTrzw) : APPLICATION. 1. AS MENTIONED IN THE. REPLY THAT LIST OF CVOs HAS BEEN ENCLOSED WITH THIS REPLY BUT NO ENCLOSURES ARE FOUND. 2. THE INFORMATION WHICH IS NOT DEALED BY YOUR SECTION AND IS DEAL BY ANY OTHER SECTION,TRE COPY OF THIS APPLICATION HAS TO BE SENT TO THAT CONCERNED SECTION WHICH HAS NOT BEEN DONE YET.

PLEASE PROVIDE THE COMPLETE 1NFROMATION AND IF

https://rtionline.gov.in/RT1Mislc PIO/appealDctails.php?reg—HmR3FhEqgBZYV5C... 30-10-2018

First Appeal Details Page 2

SOME OTHER SECTION IS CONCERNED WITH THIS R.T.I APPLICATION ,THEN PLEASE FORWARD IT TO CONCERNED SECTION.

ACTION HISTORY OF RIT FIRST APPEAL No. ; DOP&T/A/2018/60813

Applicant Name (3Titk4+ Saurabh Rai W' RIR)

Text of Appeal (314tH *1 PLEASE REFER TO YOUR REPLY REGARDING THE INFORMATION WHICH WAS ASKED THROUGH THIS R.T.I. APPLICATION. I. AS MENTIONED IN THE REPLY THAT LIST OF CVOs HAS BEEN ENCLOSED WITH THIS REPLY BUT NO ENCLOSURES ARE FOUND. 2. THE INFORMATION WHICH IS NOT DEALED BY YOUR SECTION AND IS DEAL BY ANY OTHER SECTION,THE COPY OF THIS APPLICATION HAS TO BE SENT TO THAT CONCERNED SECTION WHICH HAS NOT BEEN DONE YET.

aro)

PLEASE PROVIDE THE COMPLETE INFROMATION AND IF SOME OTHER SECTION IS CONCERNED WITH THIS R.T.I APPLICATION ,THEN PLEASE FORWARD IT TO CONCERNED SECTION.

Reply of Appeal (3i4*W 3M1)

SNo. Action Taken Action Taken By Date of Action Remarks *43.rgr (minim) (mil 4 *f 74) (4111414 a Mho ‘41 )

I FIRST APPEAL RECEIVED

01/10/2018

2 APPEAL FORWARDED TO CONCERNED FIRST APPELLATE AUTHORITY

03/10/2018 Nodal Officer Online

Print Close

https://rtionline.gov.in/RTIlvliaMO/appealDetails.php?reg=limR3FhEagEZYV5C... 30-10-2018

P.No.36(3)/1/2017-E0-MM(CV0) Government of India


*****

North Block, New Delhi Dated the OK—November, 2018

ORDER of the Appellate Authority

Reference appeal dated 01.10.2018 with respect to RD applicatiOn dated 06.09.2018 from Shri Saurabh Rai under Section 19(1) of RTI Act, 2005.

2. The information sought by the applicant, and the reply of the CPIO were examined. It was noted that the CPIO has provided the information available with him. It was however, noted that regarding the reply to point nos. (ii)&(iii), it is stated "Under Secretary level officers are posted as (NO in PSUs through DoPT". This should read as "Under Secretary level officers are not posted as CVO in PSUs through Darr and was confirmed to be an inadvertent mistake. It was noted that the CPIO has also sent the reply and the annexure by post. A copy of the same is being forwarded with is order.

3. • Regarding point nos. (v)&(vi), it is noted that the information is not available with the CPIO, Shri Chhatra Mani and might not be available in a compiled manner with any authority. Therefore, the only option is to forward the application to all the Ministries/Departments of the Government of India and to the Division of DoPT dealing with the Central Secretariat Service Cadre. The CPTO has been asked to do the same.

4. Accordingly, the appeal is hereby disposed off. In case of dissatisfaction, a second appeal may be made to the Central Information Commission under sub-section (1) within 90 days from the date of receipt of the order.

Encl: As above.

To Shri Saurabh Rai, 108, Anizibagh Lane, Behind Prakash Medical Hall, Azamgath-276001, Uttar Pradesh

Director (MM) Tel. No. 23092842

TI Cell, Department of Personnel & Training. Shri Chhatra Mani, Under Secretary& CPK) (FA-UN), DoFT PS to Dir(MM)

f • ?..7c .

RTI MATTER


No. 40(35)/2015-M.I



Subject: Application seeking information under RTI Act, 2005 by Shri Saurabh Rai, 108, Arazibagh, Lane behind Prakash medical hall, Azamgarh-276001, Uttar Pradesh seeking information about MECL.

Sir,

I am directed to transfer under Section 6(3) of the RTI Act 2005, an RTI application of Shri Saurabh Rai, 108, Arazibagh, Lane behind Prakash medical hall, Azamgarh-276001, Uttar Pradesh dated 6.9.2018 on the subject mentioned above which was transferred from DOPT vide their letter dated 15.11.2018 and received in this Section on 29.11.2018.


Yours faithfully,

(M.R. Sathyanarayanan)

Copy for information to: CPIO, Mines.I

1. Shri Saurabh Rai, 108, Arazibagh, Lane behind Prakash medical hall, Azamgarh-276001, Uttar Pradesh. If you are not satisfied with the information furnished by

j

PIO of Mineral Exploration Corporation Ltd.(MECL) you may appeal to Dr. C.S. Murthy, the Appellate Authority in MECL under provision of RTI Act, 2005.

2. PI Cell, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi w.r.t their U.O. No.2/146/2018-PI dated 29.11.2018

\f',7

(M.R. Sathyanarayanan) CPIO, Mines.I


Ministry of Mines

New Delhi, the 30th November, 2018

To

Shri Javed Reyaz P.1.0./Company Secretary National Aluminium Company Limited P/1, Nayapalli, Bhubaneswar-751061 (Odisha)

Sub: Application seeking information by Shri Saurabh Rai, Azamgarh, under RTI Act, 2005.

Sir,

The RTI application forwarded by DOPT vide letter No. 36(3)/1/2017-E0(CV0) dated 15.11.2018 received from Shri Saurabh Rai, Azamgarh is being transferred under Section 6(3) on the RTI Act, 2005 for furnishing the information to the applicant as sought by him as the subject matter pertains to NALCO.

2. You are requested to provide the information on para 4 and 4B only, directly to the applicant as per the provisions of RTI Act, under intimation to this Ministry.

Yours faithfully,

(Vinay Pra ingh) CP10 & Section Officer

Email : [email protected]

End: Copy of application No. PI Cell U.O. 2/146/2018-PI dated 29.11.2018

Copy to: (i) Shri Saurabh Rai, 108, Arazibagh Lane, behind Prakash Medical Hall, Azamgarh-276001, Uttar Pradesh).

(ii) PI Cell, Ministry of Mines.

MOST IMMEDIATEIRTI ACT FAX/SPEED POST


t)

No.5/4/2017-Met.III New Delhi, the 5 December, 2018

To

Shri Kamlesh Kumar, CP10, Hindustan Copper Ltd, 'Tamra Bhawan' 1, Ashutosh Chowdhury Avenue, Kolkata-700019.

Sub:- Application seeking information by Shri Saurabh Rai, r/o Uttar Pradesh regarding CVOs posted by Government Organisations

in CPSEs.

Sir, An RTI application dated 06.09.2018 by Shri Saurabh Rai, do

Uttar Prades, has been received in this Ministry from DoP&T's vide their letter No. 36(3)/1/2017-EO(CVO) dated 15.11.2018 and the same is hereby transferred (in original alongwith its enclosure) under Section 6(3) of the RTI Act, 2005 for furnishing the information to the applicant, as sought by him,

in respect of HCL.

2. You are requested to provide the information relating to HCL directly to the applicant, as per the provisions of RTI Act, under intimation to

this Ministry. Yours faithfully,

4s\,610-r- (Lakshmi Subramanian)

CPIO & Under Secretary to the Govt. of India


Copy to:-1., Shri Saurabh Rai 108 Arazibagh, Lane Behind Prakash Medical hall, Azamgarh, Pin - 276001, with the request to contact the

concerned organization for further correspondence in the matter.

jP1 Cell w.r.t. U.O.No.2/146/2018-P1 dated 29.11.2018

By Speed Post CHRD/RTIA/ RN-235/2018-19/43

Date: 26.12.2018 To

Shri Saurabh Rai 108, Arazibagh Lane, Behind Prakash Medical Hall, Azamgarh -276001, (UP).

Sub: Information under the Right to Information Act, 2005.

Dear Sir,

With reference to your application seeking information under the Right to Information Act, 2005 (the RTI Act), received by us on 05.12.2018 from CPIO Et Section Officer, Ministry of Mines, GOl vide letter No. 25(1)2018-Met.I dtd. 30.11.2018 as a transfer of application under Section 6(3) of the RTI Act, 2005. The required information as received frorri the concerned department/ Unit(s) as regards National Aluminium Company Limited (NALCO) is furnished below:

Quote

Q.4. Kindly give information on name, batch, cadre controlling authority of all the Group A central services officers are posted on Deputation in PSU.

Reply: In Nalco, a central PSU, only one Group A central services officer is posted on deputation as Chief Vigilance Officer and the details as sought for is as under :

Name : Shri Biswaranjan Samal, IAS

Batch : 1992

Cadre controlling authority : The Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances Et Pensions.

Q.4(B) Kindly give information on name of all the PSU where Under Secretary level Group A central services officers are posted on deputation.

Reply: As regards Nalco, a central PSU, no such central services officer of Group A at the level of under secretary is posted on deputation.

Unquote

The particulars of the Appellate Authority of the Company under the Rn Act:

Shri Amiya Kumar Patnaik, GM (H&A) & Appellate Authority, National Aluminium Company Limited, NALCO Bhawan, P/1, Nayapalli, BHUBANESWAR,751 013, Tel No. 0674-2300520.

Contd...p/2.

i ..ant %Tan ,r4 i 4

ts ALL

1236g`+

CINIGHTY!)

DIFOIIMATION

-2-

In case, you are not satisfied with the given information, the time limit for preferring appeal to the Appellate Authority of the Company is 30 days as specified under Section 19(1) of the RTI Act.

Thanking you,

Yours faithfully, For National Aluminium Company Limited

(flu (JAVED REY & 45' et-

GM(IE a Compliancy ) & PIO

Copy to: Shri Vinay Pratap Singh, CPIO & Section Officer, Ministry of Mines, Government of India, New Delhi.

CiRISIITUF ItiFORPARTION

eic, aiRIW .3•TitftrF, 2005

faqd Wa/Due date 25.12.2018 TIME BOUND/RTI MATTER

&TR tRchNt

4A10-1

t40-11 311t*-TT 3ritrf4zpzr, 2005 *34-F#6 sw-ci arr -CF I

Sh. Pradeep Kumar Bera, R/o Jharkhand 311dcai farticr, 15.11.2018 Erg * Tuzr 314? wr-4-4 ar

3Titr*R" 3inizr#, 2005 Wu 6(3) 31 7d-21I-{ •441-2, midi) Ft

fawn( 3w # olai/

31itr*1tr,D+ichl arr-d-cF a-t7r arm t,#t3lI al a,Y rici +kg,' fY 3irta7 *r sui? Frtrur zrzinfru #f:'-# 5 faril. afta 4-

rat t a-zir pr art # 3ir-a4w wi aft #M-6b toil 3iMzi* t I

2. +I:401 WT

+ly rI I

TT-az t at

Sift --+-rttichitrici44

P-TrRiaita• mtolr

3. 3ircr# 3rVIT 1 3r R- 31itriWzrxr, 2005 * fa.4.)-() *r

chtcl Fr 3.14( TWRI. gr*Ri*S- oily I

.11)0 No. 74C 485520 and

74C 48S521

,\ (Zldil )

3iTir# aritrwrtr

Smt. Lakshmi Subramanian. US(Metal III)/ eilch •kly I SI' 1134 24-6"/PI Cell U.O. No. 2/145/2018-P1 it-a:Dated 26.11.2018

tcylipc4

!INss

-,h-11-1111/1 c>11q)-•t-r71-11 •)i-tz,4

'R.2kH ri'STroi?;T,Zira Pr i t-11 cis.] ...Fregrfir<- -.34-11?--ram-1 zoos ?)4.14,C,4 ;t1-4.41 /CT1*- tig t

WERT>:4 •,711 1\91-71- Cq ata Ze-f-Tre •-•fit 7

zinc-rt c-9"1114,--1' •f<=-=(:-I! CIT-714) "11#21-4Wr< Zz --off--2.4-ei el za:rii.;.„ fc-rie 2( cam 4.4 tyffil 7;713T,q 1-0.4T5-1 el

Lics-c20 \. . Ike S'S

en ""cf 2:1 Z9111341 ah-R f

ai-ftra °El -

t‘ real 7-14-0T-1-441 31Se1r-3 ~-Ichrci z-r41 <a lei gittl Cg2Tf-ni Z41r1 re17110-111 eP) 1-4‘7•/1 ( -MO I r4o.-

imelD 6-012ctelt3S- S7 9440,[n._0159arq mi co4.4 *47(41 4eA -rilT . rth ')-Tc e,k12e-re4 6:knail Cf.) Cffr-R si-71Tirva 2-171 "f° 44 fr

)-icrz.affar>b4 •)--TeA ohircrria +•- f-<<.13WirebAiel a571c C-5p

ns-fi 04 4 ag9-4-5r(kEir - g9Wifltrait)

wte-stetf ,7Tf•Z ''CK17=in jffteda-1*1 4j ornyd Ci l71,720 zrk

et:NI:f t Stirypreq-- C1--p •E-3-14 z-friThJ7 t fgl -ar

11,01,4o- 714c lig cs--".t) Lrc travtzt

.3--I it-i 1)1 aso-cfl

74-17 aTt

•zitif • Ea. GA. se-Th

-j \-.137?I (6-0-41:1-

CP:a-Ph ) S %a re;

[at (.1

\ -raft 1 =I

TrwN ;ft m-mici Prime Minister's Office nt rot- noon

New Delhi- 110011

140/SUB: 41 UdI'T rwt

ft

ifAchf/Petition of SHRI PRADEEP KUMAR BERA

ciFITIfUz4 Cr4ttl WRI7 tql -I tri 19/09/2018 t W3/i4 alltlear4 tiRRI

qtfirn‘a wrdil Ro-trt war ti t-qq1 TA.pietnif ,5101,4 itqf wq cfr41 wara

trT arcrab-

A letter/gist of oral representation dated 19/09/2018 received in this office from SHRI PRADEEP KUMAR BERA is forwarded herewith for action as appropriate. Reply may be sent to the Petitioner and a copy of the same may be uploaaed on the porcal.

ciiVRAJEEV RANJAN KUSHWAHA]

3111411 a-ft/SECTION OFFICER

41e44,8IF TITOTI/SECRETARY,MINISTRY OF MINES

it 4rW1I 4

c'Re tWin

VIM 3F *11.1-8321.03

turd: - fkmaa msi Rea tz m rau#1 https://Pgportal.gov.in/status

PMOPG/D/20t8/0355106 31-0101 trai*i TWA #1 Note:- Status of the grievance can be tracked through Internet at https://egportal.gov.inistatus

by entering

registration no. PM0PG/0/2018/0355106

:.i • • ; c.:-F. , .ii '.,

PMOPG/D/2018/0355106 -tic': 28/09/2018 PMO ID No.:PM0PG/D/2018/0355106 Dated: 28/09/2018

crit iit tl/Copy for information to : SHRI PRADEEP KUMAR BERA I C C HIGH SCHOOL MOUBANDAR PO- MOUBHANADR EAST SINGHBHUM MARKHAND-832103 qtanzur tf

fgls t1_ afftwiTiflrw

3417?Pik nik zcta Tr-Z-44

5/4/20174ig..1 I I offarkAt, 7 .33. 2018

ActI

s5TT Th7-11

gitc÷ci I ai chiq , 'ci I &A

3-71-(1)N a1 •tr-tr eiabrcii-700019.

Fa-tcrzr:- it *Tr it-qm TT 3lit-TR, 2005 c Maata• autilvoi WITTI 31,-{ coeiraintii Tit..T 4 14,v 7rtr cbiql atrr Mtn

4tileleiS *ail% at ** stftrwritart t laittrr Ti-itr ;in 311-1-4-4l ii fi 15.11.2018 I

Pr6tzi,

air wg te[bz dkI mar arftwrt, 2005 <k 3T RAF arr-d-c-R- fa-RTW 15.11.2018 surer pir f Hian dI41 T-1011 .4-45'-tra"i I 3)7: allt-CW la? +kc.frii <FT ST{ 3-iftithzP7r, 2005 dhl urn 6(3) k .attft, J-iidn art- tierti tA-

artftia ft-zir a-r (51 tl 2. 1:1ltT 1 PMO ID +14sell PM0PG/D/2018/0355106 fait 28.09.2018 Tt .517r.ld oni4cii61 iegaiw chick Diag. 14 ei CUI4I kW-675W TZ11.-Iicinci f rr di411 zu I

3. f* 3Trd-CT. cp, thir 3-gM6a mi-rt ..711L mr 4'=r rrzfr TOWI- Tfilr gt n

4T 3-11010110-1 3TCRtg I

641

(a"-Rti twain 31-a7 Trftd" . 3Treg ti cro

Hala=l -: ZnitCift

WM' . , AST ilk, LI ti, 3ntiltait. di411(44.4 attatgR, t. - atiltgrz

- vma- 832103 (trial! * 14-4:AW .644-11

Tfte chir) WdZa

ft= 34. U.O.No.2442018-PI 26.11.2018 *

+1:40-11 r .3a1M-TT .31ftrft2:1; 2005

fa-Rt./Due date 25.12.2018 TIME BOUND/RTI MATTER

33R-6 chl{

fir: +ktien 3a1- TT31tfiWz12:1; 2005 SWF t,BLd airsd-CW I

Ms. Lavanya. R/o Andhra Pradesh kc 3TEa-Ca- ar-Ri•W 14.11.2018 9r7 TTtT 3* -6 Ikkid 141Q41 31T r6T

2. TryFT 31ftWi 31itriWzrg, 2005 S1- £117T 6(3) * 3-171T .4Ifd atilt 1*

711 zia tat ar 3111 chi a if"-÷rW" 3Tra-CF 3-tai ;Tzrr 'er-a" 3 cfricw 1 tiesi eRa-d•11 3T citrr-tr, /chk4‘em a,Y, iira a r 1,111—c-r -Rr artrur * mem #t*--A- 5 larri grat Prdia-13# ntr Vatrr Tfrar3 a mr-d-cc a7 afr /pa. cho-f1 33M7FS t I

3. .3117* 39/1U t f +1:401 I W- 3db TZ .3fferfra% 2005 ch.4 Fr del (-1.4 #Trzr wrzl-art 1 rr

if odd'. IPO No. 34F 040378 and

34F 040379

tirfn 39arrar

Sh. A.K. Mallik, US(M-:1) eilcalter*-Tti T.311$. W/P1 Cell LI O. No. 2/144/2018-P1 WDated 26.11.2018

M.Lavanya D/o Divakara Rao Flat No.7, 2nd floor, Dr.K.K.Colonv, Arasavalli, Srikakulam Andhra Pradesh

: F.No.4/17/2011.M.I.V dt 24.10.2018 to Secratryr Mines & Geology, Government of Andhra Pradesh

from Ministry of Mines, GoI Suspension of mining operations of M/s Transwoeld Garnet India Pvt Ltd., Srikakulam over an extent of

95.085Ha. October, 2018

: above letter

: by post & E-mail

: Speed post

: No

: No

,skt.

: Yes

Yes. IPO No.34F 040378 & 34F 040379. Rs.10/- towards application fee and Rs.10/- cost of the

photostat copies.

FORM-A See Rule-4(1)

Application for information under section 6(1) of the RTI Act, 2005

\.-

To The Information Counter, Ministry of Mines, Government of India Shastri Shaven, New Delhi.

1 Full name of the applicant 2 Name of the Father 3 Permanent Address

4 Particulars in respect of identity of

the aoolicant 5 Particulars of information solicited

a) Subject matter of information

b) The period to which the information relates

c) Specific details of information

required

d) Whether information s required by post/in person/E- -nail

e) In case by post (Ordinarv/Reaistered or SDeed)

6 Address / E-mall ID to

7 Has the information been provided

earlier 8 Is this information not made

available by the public:eauired 9 Do you agree to pay the required

fees? 10 Have you deposited ap: lication fee

(if yes, please indicate Jetails of

such deposit) 11 Whether belongs to BP

Have you furnished the

same ? Place : Srikakulam Date :14.11.2018

Full signet of tie applicant

Address : Flat No.7, 2nd floor, Dr.K.K.Colony, Arasavalli, Srikakulam

category : No

proof of the

.......... ..................... Office of the Public Information Officer Received the application from .................................................................................. .........................

Address........... .................. ............ . ..........................................................................................................

on ........................... ............. .................. . Seeking information

Place : Date

Full name of Public Information Officer Designation & Seal

F. Nn. 9/1/2018-M.IV GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

MINISTRY OF MINES New Delhi, Date 21St December, 2018

To, Ms M Lavanya,

Flat No. 7, 2nd Floor, Dr. K. K. Colony,

Arasavalli, Srikakulam, Andhra Pradeh — 532001

Subject: Information sought under RTI Act, 2005. PI Cell, U.O. No. 2/144/2018-PI dated

26.11.2018.

Mam, I am directed to refer to your RTI application, PI Cell, U.O. No. 2/144/2018-PI dated

26.11.2018 and say that the information is denied under Section 8(h) of the RTI Act, 2005.

2. If you are not satisfied with reply / information, you may prefer an appeal to Dr.

Veena Kumari Dermal, Director and Appellate Authority, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan,

New Delhi within 30 days of receipt of information.

Yours faithfully,

(A KMalli)

CPIO/Under Secretary to the Govt. of India Telephone No. 011-23384743

E-mail address: [email protected]

Copy to: PI Cell U.O. No. 2/144/2018-PI dated 26.11.2018.

ric4crit 3S-17 3diriWzrg, 2005

qci tc 1 /Due date 25.12.2018 TIME BOUND/RTI MATTER

aiRa-

afferar 3S, 2005 3iFaT6 circa" 3iI cd I

Sh. S. Ravi Chandran, R/o Andhra Pradesh 3Trara'

14.11.2018 *I p:r Tritt 3f4i Wrztaft t .a3 1;192 f t 1T TAT ti

7it 3litIWzr S, 2005 *I UM 6(3) t 3177 t11d HI

WZ( 3 r twhiAl cbitilo,N4 assii

arltrafT,D+1,4,1 3irY r arzn- 4-1(4,1

3 r siffea- Fittur zrzTrera c ad 5 Ca.-6 attar

4r zt- azrr r a 310"CT air i:So. choli 31TVz1W t I

3. 3T7Rt 39tItT turn 3 31f ii 2005 t flu ~r

r oti iWtifftF TITRT at aim* 51 CT

twocn. IPO No. 34F 040385 and 34F040387

LI I Merl

3T-TTPT Atratr

$h. A.K. Mallik, uS(m-iv1/ el ITFM aitratt 4t.3Tit .Aeupt Cell U.O. No. 2/14312018-PI /Dated 26.11.2018


Applicatior: for information under section 6(1) of the RTI Act, 2005

To The Information Counter, Ministry of Mines, Government of India Shastri Bhavan, New Delhi.

1 Full name of the app:.cant 2 Name of the Father 3 Permanent Address


the applicant

5 Particulars of inform .tion solicited

: S.Ravi Chandran, 5/o Santhanam

: C/o Dharmanandam, D.No.15-5-38/7, Main Road, Arasavalli, Srikakulam

Andhra Pradesh

: 5786 1886 4906

: Letter No.F.No.4/17/2011-M-IV dt 20.08.2018 to the

PrI.Secretary, I&C, GoAP



* ) Specific details of information required

) Whether information is required by post/in person/E-mail

e) In case by post (Ordinarv/Reaistered or Speed)

6 Address / ID to


earlier 8 Is this Information rot made

available by the public reauired 9 Do you agree to pay the required

fees ? 10 Have you deposited application fee

(if yes, please indicate details of

such deposit) 11 Whether belongs to BPL category

Have you furnished the proof of the

same ? Place : Srikakulam Date :14.11.2018

: -do- : August, 2018

Proposal for inclusion of other heavy minerals in the existing mining lease of the Garnet of Transworld Garnet India Pvt Ltd in 95.085Ha. in Srikakulam

District. by post & E-mail

: Speed post

1 No

No "2_ ?

: Yes

: Yes. IPO No.34F 040386 & 34F 040387. Rs.10/- towards application fee and Rs.10/- cost of the

photostat copies.

No

Full signature of t a\pplkant Address : D.No.15-5-38/7, Matn Road,

Arasavalli, Srikakulam

Office of the Public Information Officer

Received the application from

Address

Seeking information


on

Place : Date

F. No. 9/1/2018-M.IV GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

MINISTRY OF MINES

To, New Delhi, Date 21n December, 2018

Shri S Ravi Chandran,

D. No. 15-5-38/7, Main Road, Arasavaili,

Srikakulam, Andhra Pradeh 532001

Subject: Information sought under RTI Act, 2005. PI Cell, U.O. No. 2/143/2018-pi dated 26.11.2018.

Sir,

I am directed to refer to your RT! application, PI Cell, U.O. No. 2/143/2018-PI dated 26.11.2018 and say that the information is denied under Section 8(h) of the RTI Act, 2005.


Veena Kumari Dermal, Director and Appellate Authority, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi within 30 days of receipt of information.

Yours faithfully,

(A K Mallik) CPIO/Under Secretary to the Govt. of India

Telephone No. 011-23384743 E-mail address: ak.malfikpnic.in

-py to: PI Cell U.O. No. 2/143/2018-pl dated 26.11.2018.

3d1 TT 3iftlfARTJT, 2005

+-Id 'Falk/Due date 25.12.2018


3-TTT?1 tl•tchIi

WM J-1.41e1zI

fr4-iTzr: rkurn ET arftr-TR- 3-11111A-zr4 2005 t- 3taird- Circa" 3TF T I

Dr. D. Dhaya Devadas, Rio Chennai 14.11.2018 Er $2I tia -TST 31T WRYaTt Ali-c-p i6}

2. atkll ER .31ThTh-R 3fitrd771, 2005 dl gird 6(3) t 31oi acid cil4 t4011 ws 3-n4- - chiLi 1$1/ 2-N chi

Trat - t at <46 3iftrwrtr,D÷Ieni arra'-ca- 24.311 dIelI t .‘") +1.(4)I1) 3TM---TtlYeriii-4)(>4.Li en), 3.1T 41 citfea- 1 attu .qzr-tht,4 41:Ta- 5 It-4- t aitaT

tlaiidfl dip'(.-11 azrr t& 4 3-Tr chi g-fr 3.11.4ch

3. .3i1L-N-i 3-1-Vtl• tArll3iftf- T-{ afftiTh'd-737, 2005 45 fadia-i

$Q 64-1LN Wirca. 4-1,1-N4 wrzi-Tt- ulIV I

IPO No. 42F 578439

3-1M1171 aarTrtr

Sh. A.K. Mallik, US(M-IV) 4-1

Sh. A.K. Mallik, US(M-VI) t*z.1 tir.40-11 3fferli

t.31* A e1 /PI Cell U.O. No. 2/142/2018-PI 26.11.2018

FEDERATION OF INDIAN PLACER MINERAL INDUSTRIES A movement to protect placer minerals & Industries

Registered Office :

Phone : 044-22772133, 22772033 Door No. 12/627, 7th Street, Veerabathran Nagar. Mobile 9444400113 Mambakkam Main Road, E-mail [email protected] Medavakkam, Chennai - 600100.

The Almighty. The Creator of the Universe is ContinuoUsliwatching over us, We are answerable to Him. Praise to the Almighty.

REF RTI/F-1022/706/2018-19

From

Dr. D. Dhaya Devadas, President,

To

The Central Public Information Officer, (Under Secretary) Ministry of Mines, Government of India, Shastri Bhawan, Dr. Rajendra Prasad Road, New Delhi -110 001.

Dear Sir,

"ehb •

.

I, Q._ ‘13 7-05' -cis

Date

•

: 14.11.2018

o's

ANC

FtY OP ~r7

‘Chk.:Pia4Ne

Vet tendtiv,'d RicaV 1413 ti t Daly NO .9 em 0819...0 litrOfra

144 n 014

Sub: Request to furnish information under RTI Act, 2005 — reg.

Ref : 1. Sec. 19 of MM(D&R) Act, 1957 2. Your letter No. 7/4/2018-M.IV dated 30.08.2017.

PL

3. The Suo Mottu PIL in WP.No.1592/2015.

1. With reference to the above, we draw the Ministry of Mines letter No. 7/4/2018-M.IV dated 30.08.2017 the Secretary to Govt. of Maharashtra, Mumbai in respect of M/s. Indian Garnet Sand Co.(P) Ltd and M/s. Southern Enterprises and M/s. Rare Minerals (P) Ltd on execution of lease deeds covering their 11 Nos. Ihnenite, Garnet, Zircon and Magnetite mining leases after 2 years of introduction MM(D&R) Amendment Act, 2015 on 11.01.2015 MM(D&R).

2.1. We bring to your kind attention that Govt. of Tamil Nadu have granted 68 Nos. Garnet, etc. mining leases out of 77 Nos. to M/s. V.V. Minerals and their Associates and 2 Nos. to others without complying the statutory preconditions prescribed in the Environment Protection Act, 1988 and the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act 1974 and Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981, etc in total violation of law in Tamil Nadu.

2.2. Moreover, the Govt of Tamil Nadu have directly granted 5 Nos. Garnet Mining leases on 27.09.2010, 27.12.2010, 29.12.2010 and 0.341.2010. without granting the Precise Areas as per Rule 22 .4. of MCR 1960 to an extent of area 23.95.5 Hects. covering one S.P. No. 390(P) in Kottathur Tank of Kottathur village, Musiri Taluk, Trichy District to Mis. Riverways Garnet Pvt. Ltd and M/s. S.S. Minerals that too without prior approval of mh.ing plans, Environment Clearance tinder Environment Protection Act, 1986, consent to establish and operate in compliance of the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Aci. 1974 and Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981, etc prescribed in the relevant Acts and

Rules applicable grant of mining leases.

V.V. Minerals

2. Beach Mineral Sand Co. Beach Mineral Co. Andhra P. Ltd

4 frzinsworicl Garnet India Pvt. Ltd Industrial Mineral India Pvt. Ltd

16. M. Ramesh r7-7- K. Than ara

Maruthi Minerals

1 9• 1 Cativci_yr Garnet Pvt. Ltd

170. Nexus Cor3orate 11 12.

4.The Govt. of Tamil Nadu have included the banned Monazite along with Zircon, Leticoxene and Sillimanite in the existing 18 Nos.

invalid Garnet, Ilmenite and Rutile mining leases granted in total violation of the Sec. 19 of MM(D&R) Act, 1957 in Thoothulcudi,Thirtinelveli and Kanyakumari Districts of Tamil Nadu that too without obtaining prior approval from the Ministry of Mines under Section 5(1) of MM (D&R) Act, 1957, without prior approval of the Mining Plan, Environment Clearances, etc

5. The Govt. of Tamil Nadu have granted over 30 Nos. PreCise areas :hat too with

LI 3 to 6 months for the Associated Minerals Garnet and Silimanite in the Coastal Areas in the same said 3 districts, omitting the other 5 Nos. Associated Minerals like Ihnenite Ruth, Zircon, Leucoxene and Monazite existing in total violation of law.

6. We furnish below the details of lessee wise Garnet, Ilmenite, etc mining leases c:

,vering M./s. V. V. Minerals and their Associates in Tamil Nadu and Andhra for your kind perusal.

No. Name of the Lessees No. of mining leas—esin-151-&o-InTlniiiiiieases Tamil Nadu Andhra 36 10 h,r

ISAL_ __________ L _ _

Nil

1 Riverwa s Garnet India Pvt. Ltd 4 S.S. Minerals

Tom f.,

i1

75 1

1

1 1 1 16 1

3.. The District Collector, Trichy have executed the S lease deeds covering the 5 Nos. Garnet Mining leases in April 2018 in total violation of the law.

7.1. The Government of Tamil Nadu have granted said 75Nos. teases M/s. V.V. Mineral5:

Associa(es and others without complying said st.!Htor, pre: prescribed in the relevant Acts and Rules.

7.2. The State Government have allowed the said mafia groups to operate dieir sver 55 Nos. Large Mineral Processing Industries in total violation of law wIthout complying said statutory preconditions prescribed in the relevant Acts and Rules.

7.3. They have illegally mined over 14 Crores MT of Run of Mines in total viciatio.: of law covering over 8,000 Flect. of non-leases land during the past 25

years inspice of our repeated complaints and filing Public Interest Litigations.

8.1. The Government of Tamil Nadu have constituted 5 Nos. Special Teams co carkidct

detailed enquiries and inspections based on the 3 PILs filed by our Federation of Indian Placer Minerals Industries and its2 members in W.P..(M.0) No. 5549/2007, 1233/2012

G.O.Ms .No and date

1 156 8.8.2013

179/27.07.2015

29 25.03.2017 41 07.04.2017

and 1592/2015 to avoid CBI and SIT enquiry based on our request and the details are furnished below.

Special Teams Headed and purpose of the Government

The Revenue Secretary- Mr. Gagandeep Singh Bedi. I.A.S to conduct Inspection and enquiries and total! bannin: the minin and trans ort. Taluk level & District level Committees, etc. to curb the Me al minin To quantify the illegally stored entities wise, mineral wise stocks including the Monazite.

Report I date

17.09.201:3 I 19.06.2014

09.11.2016 & 22.02.2017 9.7.2018

I

8.2. The Hon'ble High Court has converted the Public Interest Litigation in W.P. No. 1592/2015 as Suo-Motto PIL and appointed the Senior Advocate Dr. V. Suresh, as Amicus

Curiae in their interim Order dated 28.01.2016 in the said Writ Petition.

9.3. The Hon'ble High Court has directed all the concerned State and Central Government Departments to furnish the required information to the Antic= Curiae

9.1. The Special Team headed by Mr. Gagandeep Singh Bedi, IAS., has submitted their detailed reports dated 19.06.2014 containing 790 Nos. pages engaging over 185 staffs of various concerned departments for several months related to Thirunelveli and Kanyakumari Districts to the Government confirmed the illegal mining as stated in the Affidavits filed in W.P.(MD)Nos.5549/2007 and 1233/2012.

9.2. The above said Special Team headed by Mr. Satyabrata Sahoo, IAS has submitted his reports have confirmed that M/s. V.V. Minerals and their Assocaites have illegally mined, transported, processed, exported and locally sold minerals to the tune of over Rs. One Lakh Crores and illegally stored 1,49,96,224 M.Ts of Run of Mines, processed and semi-processed minerals including Monazite and in addition, 1,35,135 MT of Monazite tailing containing 23,608 MT of Monazite, as per the Atomic Mineral Directorate Test Report.

9.3. The Amicus Curiae has also submitted his Comprehensive Reports dated 20.06.2017 09.07.2018 with a request to cancel the entire mining leases granted to M/s. V.V. Minerals and their Associates.

10. The State Government haVe recently filed their counters in'the pending Suo Iviottu PIL and the W.A. Nos. 1168/2015 and 1169/ 2015 admitting the entire faces, based on the undisputable Reports of the said 5 Nos. Special Teams and the Amicus Curiae's Reports, after 25 years of continuous denial in the courts and also submitting false Remarks/ Information to Government of India.

11.1. M/s. V.V. Minerals and their Associates have illegally controlled the en Ore beach sand minerals businessin Tamil Nadu with their illegally amassed wealth.

11.2. Moreover, they have not allowed the other Beach Sand Mineral Companies in Tamil Nadu including the Indian Rare Earths Ltd, a Department of Atomic Energy Wit. of India owned company so as to get 100% monopoly in the beach sand mineral mining business in connivance with concerned officials.

12. We bring to your kind notice that the undersigned is Partner of Southern Enterprises, Chairman cum Managing Director of M/s. Indian Garnet Sand Co. (P) I.ul, emb president of Federation of Indian Placer Mineral Industries and the undersigned has only exposed the looting of over Rupees One Lakh Crores worth of minerals and illegal storage of 1.5 Crores MTs of run-of-mines, processed and semi-processed minerals with rich Monazite only to protect the interest of several millions of people, businessmen, officials, teachers, Industries, companies, Schools, Colleges temples dhurches , Schools, colleges, etc .

13. You are aware that the Income Tax Department have rece.:tly crmilL (evil raids about 5 days in 100 places of M/s. V.V. Minerals and their Associates and also freezed their bank accounts and lockers based on the detailed complaints submitted to them.

14. M/s. V.V. Minerals and their Associates have no valid mining leases in Tamil Nadu and Andhra and they have illegally mined and exported and locally sold beach sand minerals in total violation of the law and hence they have to pay the entire 100% cost of die illegally mined, processed, transported and exported and locally sold minerals with pewiliy ie, per the relevant Act and Rules and also the Supreme Court Order dated 02.08.2017 in W.:).(C) No. 114/2014.

6. We also extracted below the relevant portion of the pant 1.3 and 1.4 of the guidelines issued by the Ministry of Mines, Government of India vide their Notification No. 2/4/2012-M.IV (Part II) dated 30.10.2014 for your ready reference :

"11.3. These pronouncements require the State action to be unbiased, without favoritism or nepotism, and to be in pursuit of promotion of healthy competition and equitable treatment; and that it should conform to the norms Which are rational, informed with reasons and guided by public interest. It has also been held by the Apex Court that if a policy or law is patently unfair to the extent that it falls foul of the fairness requirement of Article 14 of the Constitution, the Court would not hesitate in striking it down.

1.4. The details of the judicial pronouncements need to be understood by all concerned. For quick reference, certain portions of these judicial pronouncements have been extracted separately and annexed to these guidelines in Annexure -1 (Page 10-12). These are only to the purpose of emphasizing the issue so as to ensure Chit the Government action is fair, reasonable, non-discriminatory, :tailspin-ern, non- capricious, unbiased, without favouritism or nepotism, in pursuit pitniotion of healthy competition and equitable treatment. If these objectives are nut mat, then such action by the Government (State of Central) can been called n question as being violative of the letter and intent of the Article 14 of the constitution".

15. In this connection, we request you to kindly furnish the following information under RTI Act, 2005.

1. Details of State wise, lessee wise, minerals 'wise lease cleec!i; • executed after 11.01.2015 in compliance of the MM(D&R) Amendment Act, 2015.

2. Details of State wise and mineral wise Ministry of Mines letters sent to all the State Governments throughout India for taking appropriate actions, as per similar instruction given in. the said letter dated 30.08.2017 covering the 11 Nos. mining leases granted to. the said 2 lessees.

3. Details of the actions taken against the State Government officials for not implementing the Act and Rules covering the 6 precise areas granted on es\ 17.10.2005 till the grant of the mining lease on 11.01.2017. •

4. Copies of the note file showing the Ministry of Mies taken

action on our Federation Complaints for not disposing the pending mining leases over 24 yrs in spite of the specific Time Bound orders of the High Court and also the guid ea

lines given by the Government of India as per the relevant Acts and Rules in compiiance

of the Articles of the Constitution of India. 5.

Copies of the relevant Act and Rules under which mining lease applicants are responsible for the State Governments officials willfully kept pending and without diSposing mining lease applications as per the law, Supreme Court Orders and the Articles of the Constitution of India.

6. Details of the state government wise • High Court Orders covered Mining Lease Applications kept pending without disposal covering the various minerals as on 11.01.2015 in compliance of the above said Ministries of Mines guide lines. Act and Rules and the High Court Orders.

7. Details of the action taken against the State Government officials for not disposing • the mining lease application as per the Ministries of Mines guide lines, Act and Rules and Time Bound High Court Orders in spite of repeated reminders particularly the Ministry of Mines, Government of india vide your Notification No. 2/4/2012-M.IV (Part II) dated 30.10.2014.

8. Copies of the Note files and letters of Ministry of Mines sent to the Govt. of Tamil Nadu for taking action against the officials for granting the mining leases without valid environment clearances under Environment Protection Act, 1986, consent to establish and operate under Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act 1574 and Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 in violation of the Sec 19 of the MM (D&12) Act, etc.

9. Copies of the Note files and letters of Ministry of Mines sent to the Govt. of T;.; rai Nadu for taking action against the officials for granting the precise urea for the Associated minerals of Garnet and Sillimanite without prior approval n•ain Ministry of Mines under Sec. 5(1) of MM (D&R) Act, 1957.

10. Copies or the Note files and letters of Ministry of Mines sent to be Con. ()Munn

Nadu for taking action for allowing illegal storage of 1.5 Crams of run of mines, processed and semi-processed minerals with rich Monazite.

We have enclosed herewith an Indian Postal Order bearing No. 42P 578439 dated • 16.10.2018 for Rs.10/- in favour of Pay and Accounts Officer, Ministry of Mines, New Delhi towards the prescribed fee under Rule 3 of the Right to Information (Regulation of fee and cost) Rules, 2005 for the same.

Thanking you

Yours faithfully

(Dr. I DRAVA DEVAD AS)

ftogtma) pd OS

Zut Mq Horeb*? G141 0;41

wArk41 Atm 4-tari2 Tet b"Tre

itt-431-Tirjitin • ' s INDIAN POSTAL OD

744 G4 MM a. DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POSTS.

NPT N q0TIABLE

0 Al I 4 qlqqi Zft TIERTHE SUM OF RUPEES TEN ONLY

MATH COMMISSION SHIT I Rupag: *vps writ Tat Ire vgiftt ), SLIIDER MAY FILL INHISe E Ao9n im.) •

thil 40. ler

vas fra---- ; POSTAGE STAMPS

AT THE POST OFFICEAT

. . ZTZFER 4" azzy 7E1

lET *RR DO NOT :MUTE BELOW THi3 LIRE (7

42F 57849

•. • - a • ./

eapni 6&&t&,

4f;

No. 16/02/2018-M-VI

STRW itThR" /Government of India

&w e rcfr /Ministry of Mines

Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi Dated the 25th December, 2018

To Dr. D. Dhaya Devadas President Federation of Indian Placer Mineral Industries Door No. 12/627, 7th Street Veerabbathran Nagar Mambqkkam Main Road, Meclavalckam Chennai — 600 100

Sir,

are as under:- I am to refer to your application, dated 13.11.2018 on the subject cited above, the information sought

With regard to point no-(1)

Ececution of lease deeds are done by the State Government. No such information is maintained in the Ministry of Mines.

With regard to point no-(2 and 3)

The information is denied under Section 8 (1) of RTI Act, 2005.


Taking a decision on the application for PL/ML comes under purview of State Government. You have not mentioned the details of your representation.


The Mines and Mineral (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 and the Rules framed thereunder are in public domain.


No such information is available/maintained.


The information sought at this point relates to State Government.

With regard to point no-(8-10)

No such information is available/maintained. 2. In case, you are not satisfied with the information provided, you may prefer an appeal before First Appellate Authority Dr. Veena Kumari Dermal, Director, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi within the stipulated period under the provisions of the said Act.

Ni:/ Copy to: 0, PI Cell w.r.t. U.O. No. 2/1 42/2018-PI dated 26.11.2018

Yours faithfiilly,

(Adhir Kumar Malik) CPIO and Under Secretary

Phone No. 2338 4743

Subject: Seeking information under RTI Act, 2005 PI Cell, U.O. No. 2/142/2018-PI dated 26.11.2018.


MINISTRY OF MINES New Delhi, Date 25th December, 2018

To, Dr. D. Dhaya Devadas,

Door No. 12/627, 7th Street,

Veerabathran Nagar, Mambakkam Main Road,

Medavakkam, Chennai — 600100

Subject: Information sought under RTI Act, 2005. PI Cell, U.O. No. 2/142/2018-P1 dated

26.11.2018.

Sir,

The State Governments grant mineral concessions for the minerals located within their respective boundaries under the provisions of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) (MMDR) Act, 1957 and the rules made there under. Therefore, the information pertains to respective State Governments.

The information is denied under Section 8 (h) of the RTI Act, 2005.

The information may be treated as NIL with respect to Mines-IV Section.


Veena Kumari Dermal, Director and Appellate Authority, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan,


Yours faithfully,

(A K Mallik)


E-mail address: ak.mallikPnic.in

Lyn to: PI Cell U.O. No. 2/142/2018-PI dated 26.11.2018.

With reference to your RTI application, PI Cell, U.O. No. 2/142/2018-PI dated

26.11.2018, reply to the RTI application is as under with respect to Mines-IV Section:

Information Reply

sought in point no

2 & 3

4 to 10

WI 311t1Th-R 3ariWzrxr, 2005

11-4/DUe date 25.12.2018 TIME BOUND/RTI MATTER

3-rma

4910 14776-4

raokt rktioit WT 31-ftWT ardzw, 2005 * 3ta-tra" 3S I

Dr. D. Dhaya Devadas, R/o Chennai 31T ital-w 13.11.2018 WI pi

1:17 35Wa• ‘Hici 1-4)441 rr 7> T tl

2. '1,NT1 Wr

nc.Z t at at

3ftwitthti1 411 ei

P-imiate<Htail

31 arsT, 2005 tTRT 6(3) 31T1IT 45234-41

faISPZ3TZr tlietthn. 0111404 14 .71e1/

fa et chl 31-ra-cF alter 7171' t trit .3.10-1 WI a'

31T Col r crftZ5 *1' FrtrEr t zrzzrergs #f l'i 5 fan gra-{

cit11 t Ta. art etyr-a-4w d- aft Tr"-a straizw t I

3. 3Trzr-41 3TitT TFaT arftri4-zw, 2005 ca4-44-1 1-116.-1

chic) r 3+11-1( elo"Iticifta. 4J-14

IPO No. 42F 57806k 5-7.3 ,-13";

enH,

3T-T-Trar 3ribwrtt

Sh. A.K. Mallik US(M-IV) I t-4-zT (.1 en aritm-ft

5h. A.K. Mallik. USIM-VI) t#14 Act+ turn 3a1MItt

qt34-14 Ata/PI Coll U.O. No. 2/141/2018-P1 it—WW•Dated 26.11.2018

FEDERATION OF INDIAN PLACER MINERAL INDUSTRIES A IT1-3Ve'n nl to protect placer minerals & Industries

Registered 011:ce

Door No. 12162 7th Street, Veerabathran Nagar Phone : 044-22772133. 2277273.'.Mobile 9444400113 Mambakkam Mien Road. E-mail president.fipmi©grnaii.corn Medavakkam, Chennai • 600100.

The Almighty. The Creator of the Universe is Continuously watching over us, We are answerable to Him. Praise to the Almighty.

RK.F:RTI/F-1021/703/:118-19 Date: 14.11.2018

Fri)

/4

Dr. D. Diniya Devadas, 4S, Preside/it,

111 * r;Lier4;;;;; °CI •

40%0 tit

The Central Public Information Officer, (tinder Secretary) Miinstry of Mines, Coveri. ment of kWh, Shipith Ifflawaii, Dr. Rajecdra Prasad Road,

*Nev., Delhi - 110 00 1.

Dear Sir, I 111 3 Kti

Sub: Request to furnis information under im Act, 2005 - reg.

Ref:. 1. Sec. 19 of MM(14.11i) Act, 1957 2. Your letter No. 74 /2018-M./V dated 30.08.2017. ;I. The Sue Moat] :11. in WP.No.1592/2015.

Rui

above said letter cited, we bring to your kind atter:LION Eliot

ted 68 Nos. Garnet, etc. mining leases out of 77 Nos. to Ws. V.V.

dates and 2 Nos. to others without complying the statutory, in the Environment Protection Act, 1988 and the Water

of Pollution) Act 1974 and Air (Prevention and tonirci of total violation of law in Tamil Nadu.

,1 Tamil Nadu have directly granted 5 Nos. Garnet 29.12.2010 and 03.11.2010. without granting the Pret::>, reas 1960 to an extent of area 23.95.5 llec!y. of Kottathur village, Musiri

:aid M/s. S.S. Minerals that too waluc.. :or r. !ce under Environment Protection Act. cons.•:. of the Water (Prevention and Contra! :::

of Pollution) Act, 1981, etc proscrii;;-.. „ leases.

2.1. With reference to 01 01 Tamil Nadu have gra: Minerals and their Assr pro ondit ions proscribe ;it Contra:

• !1)81, etc

:ire Govt. 3.201

racily have executed the 5 lease deeds n.t• i, 20 ; in total violation of the law. .., .T.19

3.1'he Govt. of Tamil Nadu have included the banned Monazite along with Zircon, Leucoxene and Sillimanite in the existing 18 Nos. invalid Garnet, Ilmenite and Rutile mining leases granted in total violation of the Sec. 19 of MM(D&R) Act, 1957 that too wIthout obtaining prior approval from the Ministry of Mines under Section 5(1) of MM (D&R) Act, 1957, without prior approval of the Mining Plan, Environment Clearances, etc

4. The. Govt. of Tamil Nadu have granted over 30 Nos. Precise areas for the Associated Minerals Garnet and Silimanite in the Coastal Areas omitting the other 5 Nos. Associated Minerats like Ilmenite, Rutile, Zircon, Leucoxene and Monazite existing in the precise are granted areas that too within 3 to 6 months in total violation of law.

5. We furnish below the details of lessee wise Garnet, Ilmenite, etc mining leases covering

M./s. V. V. Minerals and their Associates in Tamil Nadu and Andhra for your kind perusal.

36 10 Nil 16 1 1 1

Cauvery Garnet Pvt. Ltd Ni , •

Iaruthi Minerals Lp 19. 1

10. NeNLIS Corporate 1

loverwql Garnet India Pvt. Ltd 4

I2. 3.S. Minerals 1

TOTAL 75

6.1. The Government of Tamil Nadu have granted said 75Nos. tinning leases MR. V.V. Minerals their Associates and others without complying said statutory preconditio6s

:ileanitwit above

6.2. They have operated their over 55 Nos. Large Mineral Processing Industries in

total viola: ion of taw.

6.3. They have illegally mined over 14 Crores MT of Run of Mines in total violation of

law covering over 8,000 Ilea. of non-leases land.

7.1. The Government of Tamil Nadu have constituted 5 Nos. Special Teams to conduct detailed enquiries and inspections based on the 3 PILs filed by our Federation of Indian Placer Minerals Industries and its 2 members in W.P. (M.D) No. 5549/2007, 1233/2012 and 1592/201.5 to avoid CBI and SIT enquiry based on our request and the details are

furnished below. •

No. I Name of the Lessees

3.

Minerals ;mach Mineral Sand Co. iP). ;tch Mineral Co Andhra P. Ltd :.:nsworld Garnet India Pvt. Ltd

' Mineral India Pvt. Ltd

:P.:. Ramesh eta_ _ Nil

ilangaraj :Vii

Nil Nil

No. of mining leases ' No. of mining

in Tamil Nadu teases in Andhra 4

Nii Nil

t I1

Nil

•_ No. G.O.Ms .No and

___ __date •__ i _1 _ 1 156/ Ett3.2013_

I 2 1173/17.9.2013

Special Teams Headed and purpose of the Report

-

Government . . date

The Revenue Secretary- Mr. Gagandeep Singh 14;

Beth. LAS to conduct Inspection and enquiries 19.06.201.1 , and totally banning the mining and transport._

179127.07.20 IS

4 — L29/25.04.2 017

5 41/07.04.1617

TaMk level & District level Committees, etc. tit 09.11.2011. curb die illegal mining •

') • I

To quantify the illegally stored entities wise, 11.7.30 is mineral wise stocks including the Monazite.

7.2. The Hon'ble High Court has converted the Public Interest Litigation in 1592/2015 as Sun-Motto PH, and appointed the Senior Advocate Dr. V. St:1.0:4h, C.n•ind in their Interim Order dated 28.01.2016 in the said Writ Petition.

7.3The Honible High Court has directed all the concerned State .1 t. Government Departin nts to furnish the required information to the Amicas Cur.,

8.1. The Speck. Team headed by Mr. Gagandeep Singh Bedi, IAS., has subni;r....

t!PCa tied rkii r:s date 19.06.2014 containing 790 Nos. pages engaging over 185 various concerned lepartments For several months related to Thirune:i Nanyakuniari Distr:o to the Government confirmed the iliegai mining at: ::.red

Affidavits n:Cti in W.1; .MD)Nos.5549/2007 and 1233/2012.

8.2. The above said Special Team headed by Mr. Satyabrata Sahoo, LAS his reports have cord,. need that M/s. V.V. Minerals and their Assocaites have transported, processed, exported and locally sold minerals to the tune of Ovi.r Crores and illegally stared 1,49,96.224 M. of Run of Mines, processed and se.: .- tr-

minerals including Monazite and in addition, 1,35,135 MT of Monazite i 23,608 MT of Monazite, as per the Atomic Mineral Directorate Test Report.

Tlw Anti us Curiae has also submitted his Comprehensive Reports 1.1!.ed 2o.ef..2t.d7 o9.e27.20Le with a request to cancel the entire mining leases granted

Minerals.

1. 'i Suite (....vertu:lent have recent!), filed their counters in the lieuu. ra• ..ad the W.A. No:. 116tt/2015 anti 1169/ 2015 admitting the entire :11. ts. thisec: it IL'

Report of the said 5 Nos. Special Teams and the Amicus 1.2) ,

:liter 25 ,,•ears of c-ntinuous denial in the courts and also submitting ;also IL:. Information to clove] !gent of India.

10.1. M/s. V.V. Minerals and their Associates have illegally controlled tia• beach sand minerals business in Tamil Nadu with their illegally amassed wealth.

10:2. Moreov they have not allowed the other Beach Sand Nlineral tThicp :try u. -

Natki .neltitiii,;.; the Indian Rare Earths Ltd, a Department of Atomic lice: 'y 1.:!!%!.

India owitAcompa . so as to get 10014 monopoly in the beach sand on; era:

11: We brill t tit your kind notice that the undersigned is Partner .4 !;..0.;t:...trr. Citairri.in cunt Managing Director of NI/s. Indian Garnet Sand Co. (P) Ltd,

!):•;!!>tiont of l:•:,derzztion of indian Placer Minktral Industries and the Linden:AI:wee O!!;'.'

1.!filt.ISOd tilt- !outing .tfover Rupees One latch (,r'ot'es worth or minerals and tort'!-. )1:Ts run-of-mines, processed and semi-probessec miner. as

Modazite only to protect of several millions of people, business::.: k tetwhers, Industries. companies, Schools, colleges churches and temples , Diocese Sangain . Tana It,ad tl Mercantile Bank Ltd, etc.

1

•

12. You are aware that the Income Tax Department have conducted raids recently

about 5 days in 100 places of M/s. V.V. Minerals and their Associates and also Ircezed heir bank accounts and lockers based on the detailed complaints submitted to them.

13. M/s. V.V. Minerals and their Associates have no valid mining leases in Tamil Nadu

and Andhra and they have illegally mined and exported and locally sold beach sand minerals in total violation of the law and hence they have to pay the entire 100% cost of the dlegally mined, processed, transported and exported and locally sold minerals with penalty z.s per

the relevant Act and Rules and also the Supreme Court Order dated 02.08.2017 in

No.114/2014.

14. We request you to kindly furnish the following information untie:

. RTi Act, 2Gt:5.

1. Copies of the Note files and the Ministry of Mines letters ..t,ares

,..( the Sl.dd

Government showing the actions to be taken by the Govt. of nu. „ r

granting 63 Nos. Garnet, etc mining LeaseS to M/s. V.V. Mincrois ; ,,

without Site Specific Environment Clearances, Site Specific Consent I

operate in total violation of the Sec. 19 of the MM(D&R) Act, 1957.

2. Copies of the Note files and the Ministry of Mines letters addressed t:. Government showing the actions to be taken by the Govt. of Tamil Naduhi:

.

the mining leases only for Garnet, Ilmenite and Rutile without including minerals like Zircon, teucoxene and Sillimonite and also specific curet

-Liu:1s 4.

handover the Monazite accrued during the process of Garnet, limetiite, etc.

3. Copies of the Note file and letters of Ministry of Mines addressed to the Government showing the actions to be taken by the Govt. of Tamil Nad

esu :o :•ec

the cost of the non-included minerals in the existing 63 Nos. mining !eas from :.1,!,.

V.V. Minerals and their Associates.

4. Copies of the Note files and letters of Ministry of Mines addresspi 1a the State Government showing the actions to be taken. by the Govt. of Tamil Nadi, against the State Government officials for illegally allowing the mining the minerals to the tune ul over 1.4 Crores MTh of Run of Mines without valid mining lease based on

OUI

repeated complaints.

5. Copies of the Note files and letters of Ministry of Mines addressed to the State Government showing the actions to be taken by the Govt of Tantil Nadu for

included the banned Monazite along with Zircon, Leucoxene Satiamoite it. 7h;.•

existing invalid 18 Nos. Garnet, lime:lite and Rutile mina, Minerals without prior approval from Ministry of Mines MM(D&R) Act, 1957, without environment clearance. conaL•

operate in total violation of the law.

6. Copies of the Note files and letters of Ministry of Mines u.' es:

.

Government showing the actions to be taken by the Govt, of storing 1.5 Groves NlTs of run of mines, processed and semi-processed atiJ, per the report submitted by the Special Team head Mr. Satyabral

,

7. Copies of the Note tiles of Ministry of Mines showing the actions fepurts submitted by the sais 5 Special 'reams, the Comprel.( •

Amiens Curiae and the state government reports to the the. ti,

Sun-Motto PIL in W.P.Nu. 1592/2015. b. Copies of the Note files of Ministry of Mines showing the valid

.

their Counters it. the said Suo-Motto PH, related to the world placer minerals to the tune of over Rs. One Lakh Crores and m -; • ,.•

Mr; , 1 run o: ines, processed and semi-processed minerals .,s

!ne :pecial Team head Mr. SatdabrataSLIhoo. ItIS e !Iles of Ministry of Mines showing the valid reasons noi

IHM otticizds fur approving the minim), plans and Scok-me IgMary insitti ItSCITC, rep:0:1;SIld hie IrSt•I'Ve. it/Mr:Hy to the already published prospecting typo:- , woo,

• and also the minerals available wvering !lie “At; I:1 5 different colours for five year in :b: . , •

!liferenr 5 colours for each five years in the Sciienk• of • , ' .• showing the valid reasons for not taking any actiol, III.

or. •• 'Civil:ling without EnVil)11111(211r Clearance, Consent to F.N:ii:11

(1.• . ( Prevention and Control of Pollution) An 197.1 and Air :• ••.• •.. intro.! Or POlitlii(M) Act, 1981. and fetters showing action taken letters agal es: tho ;;:: .• .• • r:g Piaa with imaginary Bulk Density of /I instead 2 : .r. (.!.. And ectors snowing the actions taken againi ( !iv . ! Plans covering the MVOs located away frol;i I h;•I 11

rc•plenislimenz reserve upto 1,83,006 MI is! !:-

va.n! rt•aron Mr not talt,:2;. •orc .:; : • ": : onntiomkuiens Nagar Comma•oo ;,:. •:: El( prot2ct the National Minoral Wealth.

. ; ,,• we: :nd letters showing the actions taken

:ifl Pials‘vith imaginary mineral reserve comra:".. C ; • l..•

.• , :: : L.i cireaS ShOlVil in the approved mining plan an, Sc'; : •:!,:ret • •::

for lirst five years in the Mining Irian and sm,i! ::::• :IVO years in the Schemes of Mming .I,v Atomic Mineral Directorate for 1 •

; • omit. Energy covering the Mining Plan and Scheme

11;e.; di Id letters sent to the Stare Govern:nem shot \ :Ind: :a I:1! officials for giving fziise remarks :.:;pn:es..ir,y. Li( .1 . : •I.i: :

V,Y••linerals and their Assoc:::to;

• :•:. 1:4•!:.•. e - al t4rtier Leorio.• • ! .! 0111Cer, !'

. .

. . r I<t1IL S 0! Cr • Bight to lidornmuoi, . • .•• , • !. .• e :um.

.1: 1.

r c - J I

t‘Z. In £.A-\

No. 16/02/2018-M-VI 8TTO 111W /Government of India

181W *WWI' /Ministry of Mines ******


To Dr. D. Dhaya Devadas President Federation of Indian Placer Mineral Industries Door No. 12/627, 7th Street Veerabbathran Nagar Mambakkain Main Road, Medavakkam Chennai — 600 100


Sir, I am to refer to your application dated 13.11.2018 on the subject cited above, the information

sought are as under:-


The information sought by you is not specific. Moreover, this information relates to State Government. Therefore, you are requested to approach the State Government concerned in this regard.


Ministryof Mines has requested Indian Bureau of Mines (IBM) to file a counter affidavit in the matter vide letter dated 10.04.2015.


No such information is available.

2. In case, you are not satisfied with the information provided, you may prefer an appeal before First Appellate Authority Dr. Veena Kumari Dermal, Director, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi within the stipulated period under the provisions of the said Act.

End: As above.

Yours faithfully,

(Adhir Kuril& Malik) • CPIO and Under Secretary

Phone No. 2338 4743

Copy to: 10, PI Cell w.r.t. U.O. No. 2/141/2018-P1 dated 26.11.2018

F. No. 9/1/2018-M.IV

GOVERNMENT OF INDIA







26.11.2018.

Sir,

I am directed to refer to your RTI application, PI Cell, U.O. No. 2/141/2018-PI dated

26.11.2018 and say that the information may be treated as NIL with respect to Mines-IV

Section.

2. if you are not satisfied with reply / information, you may prefer an appeal to Dr.

Veena Kurnari Dermal, Director and Appellate Authority, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan,


Yours faithfully,

(A K Mallik)

CHO/Under Secretary to the Govt. of India Telephone No. 011-23384743

E-mai! address: ak.mallik(anic.in

to: PI Ceil U.O. No. 2/141/2018-PI dated 26.11.2018.

4-1t40-li 3a1 5RaritiWzr-g, 2005

fA4.4ciIMit/Due date 25.12.2018 TIME BOUND/RTI MATTER

47'6 +lichli

lol I el +-I

fit: 21:4011 31altrthM Sr, 2005 33--di chiArca" 31f C°1

Dr. D. Dhaya Devadas, R/o Chennai * 31ra-c7 era-71-* 13.11.2018

cm' * 7rzi 31t 7 wrtart t#) crFaa-a- 141411 7r Ts--r ti

3STt 3liti'd77, 2005 *r tIW 6(3) * 3 .17,77 I1uatift

1 IQ-1 an- #1Thitt chi 4 el4 #

311bWri#, ft#Th-1 310-4-A• air #zrr t, 1 arrtaa a1Tietza

er, 3T1c,crf crfesa• tir a-rttu irmena. #r+# 5 fariI

~Ir El aztr Tfr art artd-w aft Trft# <moil arranr- t

3. 33-FRI 33 i f Tk-vm .31ferWIT 31 Ts1, 2005 * th-471

.th(c1 rattrftF *r art,* I

: IPO No. 42F 57806

(Dail a

3r r#

Sh. A.K. Mallik. US(M-IV) 4,r ch #5aT

Sh. A.K. Mallik, usim-VII: IRr Act, klydi antmt

tit31Tt .117/131 Cell U.O. No. 2/10/2018-P1 itt i-WiDated 26.11.2018

FEDERATION OF INDIAN PLACER MINERAL INDUSTRIES A movement to protect pacer rninerats & Industnes

Registered Office :

Phone : 044-22772133, 22772: '1: Door No. 12;62 . 7th Street, Veerabathmn !lager Mobile 9444400113 Isriambakkam M in Road. E-mail presidentiiprnigigrnat;.ccril Medavakkam, C.hennai - 600100

The Almighty, The Creator of the Universe is Continuously watching over us. We are answerable to Him. Praise to the Almighty.

REF RTI/F-101.9/703/2018-19

From

Dr. D. Dhaya Devadas, President,

TO

Date : 13.11.2018

The C.entrai Public information Officer, (Under Secretary) Ministry of Mines, Govermnent of India,

.tihnstri Uhawan. Dr. Rajendra Prasad Road, New Delhi - 110 001.

Dear Sir,

Sub: Request to furnish information under RTI Act, 2005 - reg. k 121 Ito(

Ref : 1. Sec. 19 of MM(Il&R) Act, 1957 2. Your letter No. 7/4/2018-M.IV dated 30.08.2017. :i. The Sun Mono 11. in WP.Nu.1592/2015.

1.1. With reference to tip: above said letter cited, we bring to your kind attention that Govt. of Tamil Nadu have gra:ited 68 Nos. Garnet, etc. mining leases out of 77 Nos. to M/s. V.V. Minerals and their Associates and 2 Nos. to others without complying the statutory preconditions prescribe-I in the Environment Protection Act, 1988 and the Water (Prevention ant: (amtn,: of Pollution) Act 1974 and Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act. 1981, etc . 'total violation of law in Tamil Nadu.

1.2. Moreover, file dovt. of Iamb Nadu have directly granted 5 phis. Garnet Mining leases an 27.09.2010, 27.12.20 (I, 29.12.2010 and 03.11.2010. without granting the Precise Areas as per Rule 22 of MCR 1960 70 ::n extent of area 23.9.5.5 Heels. covering one S.F. No. 3901131 in Kottiinnir T.:nk of 1 :or ,;e, Musiri Taltik, Trichy District to M/s. Rivenvays Garnet Pvt. 1.,:d mid '4Inera;s that too without prior approval of mining plans. linvironineat Cleo-ince t.: H 1 iromuent Protection Act, 1986, consent to establish anti operate in compliance of the (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act 1974 and Air (Prevention Con' ml of Polk t...m) Act, 1981, etc prescribed in the relevant Acts and

rr • nudes pplicablv 0! mining !eases.

C\c" 2.. The Distnct GAL...dor, Trichy have executed the 5 lease deeds covering the 5 Nus. Garnet MMing leaseS is April 2(118 in total violation of the law.

Name of the Lessees No. of mining leases No. of

in Tamil Nadu leases in Andhra mining I

__

I

I.V.V. Minerals _....... 36

I Beach Mown! Sand_ Co. 10 I

Beach Mineral Co. Andhra P. Ltd Nil

'l'ransworld Garno India Pvt. Ltd 16

Industrial Mineral India Pvt. Ltd 1 Nil

Raines!' _M. 1 N il

li: Tkaagitya [ 1 I Nil

Mai3tp; Minerals 1 Nil

1 I Nil Cauvery Carnet P,:t..1.0.1

- Nexus Lipo-ratl --- — 1 Nil

I Riverways Garnet India Pvt. Ltd 4 . Nil

12.S.S. Minerals 1 • Nil

TO TAI 175 I 2

5. 6.

4, L . 1_ r li

No.

:3:I'he Govt. of Tamil Nadu have included the banned Monazite along with Zircon, Leucoxene and Sillimanite in the existing 18 Nos. invalid Garnet, Ilmenite and Rutile mining leases granted in total violation of the Sec. 19 of MM(D&R) Act, 1957 that too without obtaining twiur approval from the Ministry of Mines under Section 5(1) of MM (D&R) Act, 1957, without prior approval of the Mining Plan, Environment Clearances, etc

4. The•Govt. of Tamil Nadu have granted over 30 Nos, Precise areas for the Associated.

Minerals Garnet and Silimanite in the Coastal Areas omitting the other 5 Nos. Associated Minerals like Ilmenite, Rutile, Zircon, Leucoxene and Monazite existing in the precise are granted areas that too within 3 to 6 months in total violation of law.

5. We furnish below the details of lessee wise Garnet, Ihnenite, etc mining leases covering M./s. V. V. Minerals and their Associates in Tamil Nadu and Andhra for your kind perusal.

b.1. ltte 6'1v...trim:ea of Tamil Nadu have granted said 75Nos. mining leases \l/s. VA'. Minerals their ..!•.:tociatas and others without complying said statetory p.v.aaklitions

mentioned :move.

6.2. They have operated their over 55 Nos. Large Mineral Processing Industries in

total violation ',flaw.

6.3. 'they have illegally mined over 14 Crores MT of Run of Mine:: in total t 'dot ion id

law covering over 8,000 lied. of non-leases land.'

7.1. The Government of Tamil Nadu have constituted S Nos. Special Teams to conduct detailed enquiries and inspections based on the 3 PILs filed by our Federation of Indian Placer Minerals Industries and its 2 members in W.P. (M.D) No. 5549/2007. 1233/2012 and 1592/2015 to avoid CBI and SIT enquiry based on our request and the details are

furnished below

Report Special Teams Headed and purpose of the Government

The Revenue Secretary- Mr. Gagandeep Singh Hedi. LAS to conduct Inspection and enquiri--:

. and totally banning the mining and transport.

No. G.O.Ms.No am! date

L • 156p3.3.2013 _ _ _ . 2 173/17.9.2013

L

date • I.

17.09.2013 19.06.201,1-

14. We

1. Cop.:.•: Govt.:

12. You are aware that the Income Tax Department have conducted raids recently

about 5 days in 100 phi es of M/s. V.V. Minerals.and their Associates and also ireezed bank accounts and lockers based on the detailed complaints submitted to them.

13. M/s. V.V. Minerals and their Associates have no valid mining leases in Tamil Nadu

and Andhra and they have illegally mined and exported and locally st.' a I sand minerals

in rota! violation of the law and hence they have to pay the entire :titt . :::t of the illegtily

mimic!. processed, tramported and exported and locally sold mineral:: penally as ;ter

the relevant Act wid Rules and also the Supreme Court Order dared I/Li-Cr.) IT

No. 114/2014.

in to kindly furnish the following information under Act. 2005,

to files anti the Ministry of Mines letters addresses tt ti::. St..1 ••

• Mg the actions to be taken by the Govt. of Twilit etc mining lenses to Mls. V.V. Minerals and their

.invironment Clearances, Site Specific Consent to Estdr.kr

. -.Eon of the Sec. 19 of the MM(D&R) Act, 1957. :des and the Ministry of Mines letters addressed

..ing the actions to be taken by the Govt. of Tamil N.alt. t, only for Garnet, Ilmenite and Rutile without CUD, Leucoxene and Sillimanite and also :Tech sia iii.tte accrued during the process of Garnet, [linen :•,,.

• :de and letters of Ministry of Mines add re,:st•ti :,•

the actions to be taken by the Govt. of Tamil ::-included minerals in the existing 63 Nos. mining lease':

:heir Associates. • t•

tiles and letters of Ministry of Mine, the actions Co be. taken by the Govt. u:

ils to the tune of over 14 Crones MTs of Run tti Mines . .

hj; ; •kt on our repeated complaints. and letters of Ministry of Mines addressed tt, t:. •

.:-.• actions to be taken by the Govt. of Tamil Nadi: : t• along with Zircon, Leucoxene and

Ilmenite and MAUL'

.jHt; approval from Ministry of Mines wider S.M.

:77, without environment clearance, consent to est;

()line law. •: and letters of Ministry of Mines addressed

.:.‘• actions to be taken by the Govt. el 1': ;iw Nati!. MTS of run of mines, processed and

by the Special Team head Mr. . ti• . ..

.• ides of Ministry of Mines showing the actions taken based on tat:

Ely 5 Special Teams, the Comprehensive Reptirts ot tae

• ...tovernment reports CO file the Cuinva::: in the

. I.-02/2015, : Ministry of Mires ShOWing the V•ilffi 1.,:lStrnf d Suo-Mottu NIL related to the world

;- I::: .1 of over Rs. One Lakh Crores and also illegal storage u!

179/27.07.2015

Taluk level & District level Committees, etc. to curb the illegal mining , To quantify the illegally stored entities wise, mineral wise stocks including the Monazite.

09.11.2016 & 22.02.2017 9.7.2018

29/25.03.2017

41/07.04.2017

fl

r-

F45

7.2. The Horeble High Court has converted the Public Interest Litigation in W.P. No, 1592/2015 as Stio-Motto PII, and appointed the Senior Advocate Dr. V. Suresh, as Amicus Curiae in their Interim Order dated 28.01.2016 in the said Writ Petition.

7.3The Hon'hle High Court has directed all the concerned State and Central Government Departments to furnish the required information to the Amicus Curiae

8.1. The Special Team headed by Mr. Gagandeep Singh Bedi, IAS., has submitted their detailed reports dated 19.06.2014 containing 790 Nos. pages engaging over 185 staffs of various concerned departments for several months related to Thirunelveli and Kanyakumarl Districts to the Government confirmed the illegal mining as stated in the Affidavits filed in W.P.(MD)Nos.5549/2007 and 3233/2012.

8.2. The above said Special Team headed by Mr. Satyabrata Sahoo, IAS has submitted .his reports have confirmed that M/s. V.V. Minerals and their Assocaites have illegally mined, transported, processed, exported and locally sold minerals to the tune of over Rs. One Lidch Crams and illegally stored 1,49,96,224 M.Ts of Run of Mines, processed and semi-processed minerals including Monazite and in addition, 1,35,135 MT of Monazite tailing containing 23,608 MT of Monazite, as per the Atomic Mineral Directorate Test Report.

8.3. The Amicus Curiae has also submitted his Comprehensive Reports dated 20.06.2017 09.07.2018 Wil it a request to cancel the entire mining leases granted to M/s. V.V. Minerals.

9. The State Government have recently filed their counters in the pending Sue Mottu PH. and the W.A. Nos. 1168/2015 and 1169/ 2015 admitting the entire facts, based UN the undisputable Reports of the said 5 Nos. Special 'reams and the Amicus Curiae's Reports, after 25 years of continuous denial in the courts and also submitting false Remarks/ Information to Government of India.

10.1. M/s. V.V. Minerals and their Associates have illegally controlled the entire 'beach sand minerals business in Tamil Nadu with their illegally amassed wealth.

10.2. Moreover, they have not allowed the other Beach Sand Mineral Companies in Tamil Nadu including the Indian Rare Earths Ltd, a Department of Atomic Energy Govt. of India owned company so as to get 100% monopoly in the beach sand mineral business.

11. We bring to your kind notice that the undersigned is Partner of Southern Enterprises, Chairman cum Managing Director of M/s. Indian Garnet Sand Cu. (P) Lid, president of Federation of Indian Placer Mineral Industries and the undersigned has only exposed the looting of over Rupees One lakh Crores worth of minerals and illegal storage of 1.5 Crores MTh of run-of-mines, processed and semi-processed minerals with rich Monazite only to protect the interest of several millions of people, businessmen, officials, teachers, Industries, companies, Schools, colleges churches and temples , Diocese , Nadar Sangam , Tatnilnadu Mercantile Bank Ltd, etc.

Pits of 1.11:1 of miles, processed and semi-processed minerals as the report •

submitted by the S: ecial Team head Mr. Satyabrata Sahoo, IAS on 18.04 20I II

9. Copies of the Nutt files of Minisu•y of Mines showing the valid reasons not ink' ng

actions against the IBM officials for approving the mining plans and Scheme M Mining with him: Unary insitu reserve, replenishable reserve, bulk density, mineralogy totally contrary to the already published prospecting report covering the mining plan areas and also the minerals available covering the yearly permitt ad

areas sin wing in r different colours for five years in the mining plan ''e ' subsequenily for Citierent 5 colours for each five years in the Scheme of M Ming.

10. Copies of the Note showing the valid reason for not taking appropriate rernedmi

actions covering tl--• recommendations of M.S. Nagar Committee Report submitted

to Ministry of ;cline.. to protect the National Mineral Wealth.

We have enclosed herewith an Indian Posta! Order bearing No. 42F 5781)62 dame.:

2.1.09.201H bir iIs. ..ivotir of Pay and Accounts Officer, Ministry of Mint-:;. Nev.- lied::

towards the prescribed It...' under Rule 3 of the Right to Infornimion ,. Izegid•.t:in, ea' tee

cast; Riffle s, for the same.

Thanking you

(Dr. R. D1IAYIt DI.:VADAS)

No. 16/02/2018-M-VI arRw /Government of India

44,uti q /Ministry of Mines ******


To Dr. D. Dhaya Devadas President Federation of Indian Placer Mineral Industries Door No. 12/627, 7th Street Veerabbathran Nagar Mambakkam Main Road, Medava.klcam Chennai — 600 100





The information sought by you is not specific. Moreover, this information relates to State Government. Therefore, you are requested to approach the State Government concerned in this regard.


This information pertains to State Government.


You have not mentioned the details of the representation. Moreover, this information pertains to State Government.


The CPIO has not issued any such letter to State Government.


The Ministry of Mines has requested the TA. CGSC to inform us the status of Writ Pending pending before Horeble High Court.

2. In case, you are not satisfied with the information provided, you may prefer an appeal before First Appellate Authority Dr. Veena Kumari Dermal, Director, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi within the stipulated period under the provisions of the said Act.

End: As above.

Yours faithfully,


Phone No. 2338 4743

Copy to: ''PIO, PI Cell w.r.t. U.O. No. 2/140/2018-PI dated 26.11.2018








26.11.2018.

Sir, I am directed to refer to your RTI application, PI Cell, U.O. No. 2/140/2018-PI dated

26.11.2018 and say that the information may be treated as NIL with respect to Mines-IV

Section.

2. If you are not satisfied with reply / information. you may prefer an appeal to Dr.

Veena Kumari Cermal, Director and Appellate Authority, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Shawan,


Yours faithfully,

(A K



y to: PI Cell U.O. No. 2/140/2018-PI dated 26.11.2018.

tkr-I0-11 c17 3d13" 3iftfit4zrxr, 2005

fa‘ici raiit/Due date 25.12.2018


3.1Rct oichN

.1..410-1 411101.4

.33-ftr+-7- arferiWzraq.,2oos srrca- 3rra-4w I

Dr. D. Dhaya Devadas, Rio Chennai 3Tra-c-- f4-- iw 13.11.2018 act TrrzT Sizta. wit 1kt-cid 1,.qI un TAT tl

2. 0:401 I WI 3al-W 3ftfA-433, 2005 *I' tiru 6(3) * 31 1 zit *aft Trt 0, a r faq44 337-z- f chlqicazI F1 ;sd FratZ t at a-- • 31ftwtr,FA--43--t-1 31T-4'eW 3-tar Tarr tr4 N`“44,1 3ritMtIchl4eie4 aritCW gifesa. *t Frtzg. F1 mm irth-a fta- 5 PA k graT nrmtanw <moil aztr pr aft a aire-cwa,1 gtTrp-a- 3fird-Mn I

3. 31714# 39#t./ f +1T4di arib-*-R .31-11:11ARLP:1; 2005 Limo c,( F fAttrita- Tram ir a

tieidoll WO No. 421 578436

.111 150

3ffair3r aritiWtt

Sh. A.K. Mallik. US(M-IV) . 1-7 of eh T-VT afftrthit Sh. A.K. Mallik. US(M-V1). .31ft.Miff titat tail Cell 1.1.0. No. 2/1 39/2018-pl 'it-a*/ I )ated 26.11.2018

...•••••••

tync.its

vi\ sib ,

Ap_t\

FEDERATION OF INDIAN PLACER MINERAL INDUSTRIES

The Almighty, The Creator of the Universe is Continuously watching over us. We are answerable to Him. Praise to the Almighty.

A movement to *(oteet pacer miner?is &Intiostres

Registered 011ie* • Phone . 044-227721.33. 2277i

Licor No. 12.'6.7. 7th Street. Veerabalhan Nagar. Mobile 9444400113

Mambakkam I am Road. riesittent.flomiie:nmot!

Medavakkam. :Therinai 600100.

REF : RTI/F-1.020/704/.' 018-19 : 3.11.?Wpd

Pram

1)r. D. t)haya Devadas, President,

The Genteel Public Infurma boa Onkel (Under Secretary) Ministry of \1 ii Govt. :intent of India,

Bh.imin, 11:-. Rai, ndra Prasad Road, IP:T

• Ncya: Delhi - 110 :WI. -.11tt•I

Dear Sir, "\O7

Request :o furni•di information under RTI Act, 2005 — reg.

I. Sec. 19 of M :1&11.) Act, 3957

2. Votir ter N 77-1/2018-M.IV dated 30.08.2017.

3. me Sm, Pik. in iAT.No.1592/201.5.

• Move, we draw the Ministry of Mines letter No. 7/-11:tiii1-:.i.11.

.rotary to Govt. of Maharashtra, Mumbai in respect of M/s. Indian ,ad M/s. Southern Enterprises and M/s. Rare Minerals (P) Ltd on

covering their 11 Nos. Ilmenite, Garnet, Zircon and Niagnedte

• :I: introduction MM(L)&R) Amendment Act. 2015 on 11.01.2ti ;5

that Gov:. ('I Tamil Nadu have :',ranted lit 1. M/s. V.V. Minerals and their Associates and 2 No::. to

: • st.tcutory preconditions prescribed in the FriVi:h ;11,er (Prevention and Control of Pollution) .1c: :

of IN.11:0. ion) Act, 192 1. etc in total violation of Lox InT . 'N..idi..

of Taniil Nadu have directly granted 5 Nos. a )1O, 29.12.2010 and 03.11.7:;i:''...vit 0.I:•0

ic s

Cl2 1.960 to an o:tont

,"tink KORatliti. • Il !''..•

\ /S• 'Air.elab; Lid'

ace wider Environment Pridt&'' k$ Of the Water (Prevention anti Contr.::

.tvci Polititain) Act, 1981. etc presti:!:••. •: lenses.

P5- •.: :17 :

R

Sub:

Ref:

• • 47• .5":

•ec

Em• 3:. The District Collector, Trichy have executed the 5 lease deeds covering the 5 Nos. Garnet

Mining leases in April 2018 in total violation of the law.

4.The Govt. of Tamil Nadu have included the banned Monazite along with Zircon. Lein:oxen,: and Sillimanitc in the existing 18 Nos. invalid Garnet, Ilmenite and Rat it mining leases

granted in total violation of the Sec. 19 of MM(1.-)8zR) Act, 1957 in Thouthilkodi,Thiru Delve!'

anti Kanyakumari Districts of Tamil Nadu that too without obtaining prior approval Irma the Ministry of Mines under Section 5(1) of MM (D&R) Act, 1957. without prior approva!

ite Mihing Plan, linvirolanent Clearances, etc

S. I he t. of 'l aid! have granted over 30 Nos. Precise areas that :no '...'.]ill 3 to n

months tor tiw ed Minerals Garnet and Silimanite in the tuastdi ir, the same

•taiti 3 districts. timittilt,..; the other 5 Nos. Associated Minerals like llinet•ae,

Leucoxene and NI:mazite existing in total violation of law.

o. W.. tcr:Iis:t ..kw: the details of lessee wise Garnet, Ilmenite, etc mining letnit. cove!

Ntis. ‘'. \ . . rats and their Associates in Tamil Nadu and Andhra for your kind perusal.

I. Let; eeN No. of inining'leases in Nii. ot milling leases

1. Tamil Nadu in Andltrii

... 36 . Nil

C:: :‘1 SAM' CO. 1tl ! Nil

c.,). Andhra P. Ltd Nil 1

..1:;typid Gar itg India Pvt. Ltd 16

al puha i'vt• Ltd 1 Nit

I 1 Ni;

Ill.

inanitarm . . :.• .1:th; i.1.::eray; 1

.1‘l

N.1

•••Ci

.:01.••• Coroorat

•;i1

11 t—ra India Pvt. Ltd

_.14. _

III..............i iirl'ami1 Nadu have granted said 75Nu5. M/s.

I ale. .7rAl others without con.:ilyinif, salt. : ...

prescribed in the releyant is and Rules.

7.2. The State Government have allowed the said markt groups to operate thin: 55 Nos. Large •I i neva; Processing Industries in total violation of law without complying :aid

3taturory prescribed in the relevant Acts and Rules.

7.3. have (.legally mined over 14 Crores MT Of Run of Mina; in total of

Iow covering L-ent' i/,0011 lied. of non leases land during the past S )oals mspite

repeated complaints and tiling Public Interest Litigations.

8.1. The Guvorinnem it Tamil Nadu Lave constituted 5 Nos. Spec:a. Teams to cooltio

detailed enquiries . inspections based un the 3 Pli.s riled by our Federation of Indian

Placer Minerals Industries and its 2 members in W.P. AD) No. 5S 1(1/2;)07, 12113,12C; 12

I

and 1592/2013 to :ivcl CBI and SIT enquiry based on our request and We details. are furnished below.

No. G.O.Ms.No and Special Teams Headed and purpose of the I Report date date

1 156/8.8.20.13._ Government

Ihe Revenue Secretaiy- Mr. Gagande.ep Singh 17.09.2013 173/17.9.2013 !kW. L11.$ to conduct Inspection and enquiries t 19.06.2014

and totally banning the mining and transport. 3 179/27.07.2015 raluk level 8: District level Committees, etc. to 09.11.2011, Y

turh the illegal mining 22.02,2017 __29/2:; quantify the illegally stored entities wise, 9.7,4it

5 -11 /07.0.1.2017 ntneral wise stocks lad tiding the Monazite.

8.2. The I lontbit II g!! Court has converted the Public Interest Litigation in W.P. No. 1502 '201S as Suo-\!c,:: 11 PP, and appointed the Senior Advocate Dr. V. Suresh, Amiens cariae in their littitrim I :.ter dated a3.01.2016 in the said Writ Petition.

'J.,. 1: 'n is digki Coart has directed all the concerned State .:.1 tienty.t1 Cower: men: I tepartme. s to furnish tile required information to the Anucus

9.1. Thy Si: ...:l can headed by Mr. Gagandeep Singh Bali, 1AS., has t-aihni oast I detailed reports ed 0.06.2014 containing 790 Nos. pages engaging over 1::5 l;i ...ara):K • • -Allten;:i for several months related to Thin:next:it Kai:ca:an . die Government confirmed the illegal mining a.. stateti in :L. Ardt:y:1s :Led ta iNos.55.9/2007 anti 1233/2012.

5.2. tr. o alityte s t Special 'ream headed by Mr. Satvabrata . < submitted kis report.. tia-a ,tticat 7 .; -d M/s.11.V. Minerals and tit* Assoc„.' tt, :to... • inure, ?an:sported. .•:,:ported and locally sold niinerws ta the • Dint ....kit

i:ttores att.a tLe ttilly .! I, 19.06224 M.Ts of Pain tit mineri.k izite an:: in addition, 1,35,1.-ttI t.: onto:

nitt MI int Mot tazit e. .s per the Atomic Nlineral Director tt•

Amicu has also suatnitted his Comps,. 20.0G.2017 ops.7.201 v ith a request to caned the entire mining, le tdinerattc ;atd Heir t.sso t. , '' s.

10. The Stare Ctit . ttroment halve recently filed their counters in the pundint; I 11. mkt the V.A. Nos. 68/2015 and 1169/ 2015 admitting die entire ;acts, based on the undisputable Reports the said 5 Nos. Special Teams and the amirus Curiae's Rep t4 after 25 year; o:' con' :mous denial in the courts and also submitting lalse Ri ma:. Imo:Ana:ion yin of India,

11 i. \.V linerais and their Associates have illegally cantotileti ....tn.: - beach sand minerots 'wt.:nest:: in Tamil Nadu ;Aid' their illegally amassed wr.t.ittti.

112. Moretivor, they hive not allowed the other Beach Sand Mmeral Companies in Tamil Nada int:lading Lie Milian Rare Earths Ltd, a Department to Atomic Encrg).• i;oyt.

otatnen t.ompunt Sc; as to get 100% monopoly in the bead: :;and 1:: ICU 'Mill concerned officials.

' 12. We bring to your kind notice that the undersigned is Partner of Southern Enterprises. Chairman cum Managing Director .of M/s. Indian Garnet Sand Co. (P) Ltd, president of Federation of Indian Placer Mineral Industries and the undersigned has only exposed the looting of over Rupees One Latch Crores worth of minerals anu illegal storage of

1.5 Crores MTs of run-of-mines, processed and semi-processed minerals with rich Monazite only to protect the interest of several millions of people, businessmen, officials, teachers, Industries, companies, Schools, colleges temples churches , Schools, colleges, etc .

13. You are :Awl: e that the Income Tax Department have recently conducted raids about 5 clays in 100 places of M/s. V.V. Minerals and their Associates and also Ifeczed theft hank accounts and lockers based on the detailed complaints submitted to them.

14. M/s. V.V. Minerals and their Associates have no valid mining leases in Tamil Nadu and Andhra and they have illegally mined and exported and locally sold beach sand minerals in total violation of the law and hence they have to pay the entire 100% cast of illegady

mined, processed, lrans;u,rted and exported and locally sold minerals vita penalty as r:er

the relevant Act and Ruses and also the Supreme Court Order dated 02.08.2017 in W.P.(Cl

No. 114/2014.

6. We also extracted below the relevant portion of the para 1.3 and 1.4 of the Ly the Mmistry of Mines, Government of India vide their Notification No.

(P..it 11) kited :40.10.2014 for your ready reference :

"1.:5. 'ibese pronoiacerients require the State action to he unbiased, ‘vithota Ixva.•itista or nepotism, and to be in pursuit of promotion of healthy competition and equitable ntattnent; and that it should conform to the norms which are rational, informed with reasons and guided by public interest. It has also been held by the Apex Court that if a

policy or is patently unfair to the extent tha: it falls foul t:f the fairnei:s requirement of Al :tele 14 of the Constitution, the Court would not hesitate a: st:•iiiin:;

it down.

1.4.Thu details of the judicial pronouncements need to be understood by al! co: i•erilA For

quick reference, certain portions of these judicial pronounceinci.t:: :..:.. :,:•en extracted :.e:iarately and annexed to these guidelines in •

ar,• ti :lie purpose of emphasizing the issue so 1...it Cite

is lair, reasonable, non-discriminattny capricious, inhiami•ii without favouritism or nepotism, in pt: . - .is r,it.n of

healthy competitiii: and equitable treatment. If these objectit ei; aot met, then

such action by the Government (State of Central) can been called in q .iestion as being violative of the letter and intent of the Article 14 of the constitution".

15. In this connection, we request you to kindly furnish the following o:

Act, 2005.

1. Details' of State wise, lessee wise, minerals wise lease 11.01.2015 in compliance of the MM(D&R) Amendment Act, 2C I :;.

2. Details or State wise and mineral wise Ministry of Mines. :ie..... i,

Secretaries of Industries Department or the State Governments Lilco taking appropriate actions, as instructed in the said letter dated 3::.: the 11 Nos. mining leases granted to the said 2 lessees.

t,• d. the lOr

17Cf :Vering

3. Details of rhv ichons taken against the State Government tor not implementing My Act atn! Rules co% ering the 6 precise area granted on 14.10.20C:11M the graot o: mining lease on 11.01.2017.

Copies of the note file showing the Ministry of Mines taken action or our Fed'. itt..in Complaints for not disposing the pending mining leases over 2:1 years in spite of the specific 'rdne Boancl orders of the I•1igh Court and also the guidelines given by the Government of Raclin as per the relevant Acts and Rules in compliance of the Art of He list Itutil tl of hunt

S. C..piys of the :•eleyani. Act and Rules under which mining lease applic uns ..ri responsible tor tilt: State Governments officials willfully kept pending and without dispo ;big trin:ng lease applications as per the law, Supreme Court Orders and the

•,,,isiitition of India.

ii. Det.ifis of the site government wise High Court Orders covered Mini:a: Le::St` Apnli.-atoao; he; ; pending without disposal covering the various :nine:ais

...phallic of the above said Ministries of Minvs guide imes ;loth:. anti tat. Court Orders.

7. Do:ails of tot• .it ion Lamm against the State Government ofticiais tor not the mining lease 'indication as per the Ministries of Minos guide lines, Act and • and Time Room, High Coart Orders in spite of repeated reminders particukirly the Nlinistvy of Government of India vide your Notification No. 21.11"11111-'.'.1'.- (Purl II) dated .10.2014.

We Live enC:us. ,1 herewith an Indian Postal Order bearing No. 42.: 1lti.!0/- Il fa1'01.:1" of Pay inn] Accounts Officer, Ministry of Minoi., .1.i

.ci-m•ds Lae ph:scrims. :,•e tinder Rule 3 of the Right to Information Wegalati.in Of E..'e V.1-; .;',1 10r* .

No 16/02/2018-M-VI

t /Government of India

ist Id d-ipuei Li /Ministry of Mines


To Dr. D. Dhaya Devadas President Federation of Indian Placer Mineral Industries Door No. 12/627, 7th Street Veerabbathran Nagar Mambakkam Main Road, Medavakkam Chennai — 600 100




With regard to point no-(i)

Ececution of lease deeds are done by the State Government. No such information is maintained in the Ministry of Mines.

With regard to point no-(ii and

The information is denied under Section 8 (h) of RTI Act, 2005.

With regard to point no-(iv)

Taking a decision on the application for PL/ML comes under purview of State Government. You have not mentioned the details of your representation.

With regard to point no-(v)

The Mines and Mineral (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 and the Rules framed thereunder are in public domain.

With regard to point no-(vi)

No such information is available/maintained.

With regard to point no-(vii)

The information sought at this point relates to State Government.

2. In case, you are not satisfied with the information provided, you may prefer an appeal before First Appellate Authority Dr. Veena ICumari Dermal, Director, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi within the stipulated period under the provisions of the said Act.

End: As above.

Yours faithfully,


Phone No. 2338 4743

Copy to: TO, PI Cell w.r.t. U.O. No. 2/139/2018-PI dated 26.11.2018

Sir, With reference to your. RTI application, PI Cell, U.O. No. 2/139/2.018-PI dated . .

26.11.2018, replyto the RTI application is as under with respect to Mines-IV Section:

Reply

The State Governments grant mineral concessions for the minerals located within their respective boundaries under the provisions of the Mines and Minerals (Developinent and Regulation) (MMDR) Act, 1957 and the rules made them under. Therefore, the information pertains to respective State Governments.

2 &•3 . 'The information is denied under Section 8 (h) of the RTI Act, 2005.

4 to 7 t The information may be treated as NIL with respect to Mines-IV Section.

Information sought in point no

F. No. 9/1./2018-M.IV GOVERNMENT OF INDIA







26.11.2018.

2. • If you are not satisfied with reply / information, you may prefer an appeal to Dr.

Veena Kuinari Dermal, birector and Appellate Authority, Ministry of Mines. Shastri Bhawan,

New Delhi within 30 days of receipt of information

Yours faithfully,

K CPIO/Under Secretary to the Govt. of india

Telephone No. 011-23384743 E-mail address: [email protected]

L.$01511;: PI Cell U.O. No. 2/139/2018-PI dated 26.11.2018.

7' 3TitIW alitfMRDT, 2005

gel fa /Due date 25.12.2018


3476 tRchli

fk1517. it4011 asr 3r rT .3f1437, 2005 4T TAT Alta- 31T4-Ci I

risch trit-C6W 3-t{ t T 1%—d* 14.11.2018 c,zirif 111Lts aft-CC ff, c1M•Llirli 31T-a-CR' it-Ri'W 08.11.2018 ail TFT a * ITYI 3i 'a• W1441*

Sitild 141.41 reT tI

2. ti,T.40-1T Tir

tttfrii

TrraCZ t 4't

3arthitich1e.lic14

1:2114-dita. 4itc1J

.311bWJT 311110-n7127, 2005 *I' CI1 r1 6(3) 3i irl e TR* alt t rzt 311 tRchl1t chN41 m4.4 1:1

siltmlt,fatichl 3i-rta wzrr t-,## mr-d-c-# Rtetra- titm111 ar-d-cw *t crfPa- a-rtra zrerrera- #1%-# 5 RA i aft&

01t.11 #2# nr aft er air -d-cw sit Trft# =mot 3.1T42 , t I

3 .3TPT# 3117tCT t"f tkcicif ar 3iit-th-rt 3ift(ffizraT, 2005 TT chic) §(1- 6eI4R falirr{F #24-4 Wi4ar5 r %AN

End: MoRTH's letter No. MORTH/R/2018/01203 dated 14.11.2018.

(Heil ;ftl)

.39a## srftrwrft

Sh. Yogesh R. Patel. USIAdmin) / 3arthlti

Sh. R.R. Mandal, SO(Mines II) / *IttImo' At. 31-ftitt

Sh. A.K. Mallik. US(Mines111)/ *Felt,' each :fpaT

Tft.31It .r4 /PI Cell U.O. No. 2/138/2018-PI it-diVDated 26.11.2018

0701bigeRM/317/2018/01203

trftan 3117 k (3irreBirt 374, n 1. c&vra 110001

1tRiV. 14 Mnit, 2018 /tat 4,

atnarrfa-ai- (YR° to rfo)

NrCatitchut,Allfte;Aucia

fates:- vat *r 3rRmt altrfAvrg, 2005 3frafra 4 aNi ftt 355, .ri'.1 Ua Ttg, *pc 4,744, Vitt.nr • 141008 wr ?TOFF

SIC

1:ft•- at. -714'ma

ai0414.4.

' . _ irdn

MaT fatrzr vei atn 3.1111Writ (3rrter3u4)

3M-11ST Lira.r11.4.- 1. 311:11r*Fr siiretrad 3111t4W hs FiraS at lit • 355, al .4•1 Okr4 WIRra 51tU1a1 - 141008 gratzt

FY 31M-717,7 174- 71" PIR-t ••% oit•Thc.;igrici afa-TItFY *I-. ff41

.5cvel a yrrabrit siidAvr FA

a' r 3M-ern .3113011-atief, ma

p,, 311acA natarfa WAT

WE, k ...en i 05.11.2018

.2018 *I' 11Rt13llt 34111;1,frs, 2005

after:Tut .3,1 cm Sr tedeJer 3, a r fcror 3rf t at n 4.; an Sri Fin zjawr FAT crriv prr tit I

7it T-5 trnr aura tuomi eismerfraitra t- 137: 57 2005 tr EMT 6(3) t 3crWar Teryar p-47

i35-5

!

aa C tam-n- A . t.tr* 0-eV. isiter4 Saco

crtinkst o‘-r ic\es3- 63.

se

oct &g 2))4c-t ckciA\ \

7AZt %\s"" Caw& ‘30

.an--a-vx__ vitycoi

V\

k* w1/2 A0-45 SA-)

aca :MCA ca %41.,,A) a-ok `--1511 --;\ \\MV,C,-4 e;;•

k4e.. Laisa- AcLos

Lrs:::: . Nc\-543Y6AZWt,4, -h-cth c\r evccs&-kced (r\vi \-71-,'s‘A 71c1( Mv‘\ ; -Z1V aft--147aVSZ, vaw

.M% 1 , ‘n-&‘S *a- -ot.\ WcUctak_ 6 'hkra?; Z-4:4QA --à NC-4_4 -t-tc:k C5-V a\ri` s-Vc"W:c-

cCulatvit6m ) VARINDER SINGH At:t Friends Colony, Ldh-141-101

355, Jzssian Road,'

'tics tk16.146.)&a.

I (sikuks- Q4,

-1,AerisT: 1)d-P11/8- t &ta-- \`.s.

s

0 Z n o

<

"I

gig(at aa.

No.31/13i2018-M.111

WZ? titortt / Government of India

urra'a-imicva / Ministry of Mines *****

44-- New Delhi, Dated 2- 0 November, 2018

CPIO-Co-ord (Hqrs.) (Shri A.D. Selokar) Dy. Mineral Economist, Indian Bureau of Mines, Nagpur.


Sir, Please find enclosed herewith a copy of RT1 application received from Shri Varinder

Singh, Ludhiana with Registration No. 2/138/2018-P1 dated 26.11.2018. The information sought by the applicant relates to IBM. Therefore, the application is transferred to IBM under sub-section (3) of Section 6 of RTI Act 2005 for further necessary action.

End: As above Yours faithfully,

ik1/4 (Adhir Kumar Mallik)

Under Secretary & CP10 Tele No. 23384743


Copy to:

1. Sh. Varinder Singh, 355, Jassian Road, Friends Colony, Ludhiana-141008 1?ZCP10, PI Cell w.r.t. their Registration No. 2/138/2018-P1 dated 26.11.2018

te•

To

RD MATTER BY SPEED POST

No. 31/2/2016-M.II Government of India

e^N Ministry of Mines

New Delhi,21 November, 2018

Shri S.C. Bose, Admin. Officer & Nodal Officer RTI Geological Survey of India, Central Headquarters (CH9), 27-J.L. Nehru Marg, • Kolkata-700016

Subject: RTI Request through. P.I, Cell vide U.O. No. 2/138/2018-PI dated 26.11.2018 under RTI Aq, 2005 — Reg.

• Sir, Please find enclosed a copy of RTI application transferred by Ministry

of Road Transport and Highways vide O.M. No. MORTH/R/2018/01203 dated 14.11.2018 under the subject reference.

2. The information sought by the applicant pertains to GSI being an attached office of this Ministry. Therefore, a copy of the application is hereby transferred to you under Section .6(3) of RTI Act, 2005 for furnishing the reply within stipulated period under RTI Act 2005 to the applicant directly under intimation to this Ministry.' ;

Encl: As stated Yours faithfully,

(M. R. Sathy narayanan) Section Officer/CPIO [email protected]

Tele: 23389211

Copy to:

1. Shri Varinder Singh, 355; Jassian Road, Friends Colony, Ludhiana-141008 for information. A copy of your application has been forwarded as stated above. For any fuither query, concerned PIO of the GSI may be contacted directly. If you are not satisfied with the information furnished by PIO of tht GSI, you may appeal to the Appellate Authority in GSI under the provision of RTI Act, 2005.

Cell w.r.t. their U.O. No. 2/138/2018-PI dated 26.11.2018

•-krto-I1 T 3TitMT .3.TMThzPT, 2005

4-4d ifMtc/Due date 25.12.2018 TIME BOUND/RTI MATTER

3-11Ta.

4.910 c1-1,11e1 4.4

fdtizr: Fly a- TT 3Tfer*Ti 3Titeag, 2005 .3taira. 3iTtCaI I

+IS* Ceita-0 3rk Baia; 14.11.2018 crFa sir

vi arra-c-F Itaiw 01.11.2018 W' r 1:19. * T T317t6 W4-41$

t7, fen•241 fT t T ti

2. Tarn W 31ThWr 31*1:AziFf, 2005 *t tim- 6(3)317071TT Tref 71$

tlic.101 fatizi chleaeizi 1/47.15/

nt..T t as fa 3fra-cw atar arzrr 1 3TT 'er +lc' ci riich141

siftwrtritreneizi ardcri T crereia. *r alit 41 zrtiveru Afth-F 5 facrlI * afidit

T2Tmtaita. cmcii ,y141 t 5-41- it * 311-a-CW "1 aft Tfta- =toll 3Tmzrw t I

3. .31i4a 3TVI2 t 3TitIWT 3ar ofrz11 TT, 2005 14-4.A40 Lnehrs

chici rmi-4-6wts 7 ER- fAtinka Tra:m. wrdart rrrr

End: MoRTH's letter No. MORTH/R/2018/01194 dated 14.11.2018.

Sh. M.R. Sathvanaravanan, SO(Mines I) / ct4R ou ch ÷17.4011 aritirtt

Sh. Yogesh R. Patel, US(Acimin) / RI ell,* titled alitrthlt

431.3$ .'mac /PI Cell U.O. No. 2/137/2018-PI itFIWDated 26.11.2018

(tpm. arTirir sfferwrer

1. stitarr .4414.4 a zie4 •ti et 40 ruT i%1111T, ZITRZIct titt 14113. - Tata*, • , FiTiNut - 829123 *Pamir 3rranrdr trs-4 trT 8X34 4/714 RT 34444 ifitcar, 3titr9lr4 444* *-{ .4-64 1.;

C3

vgairairekrulariti2015/01194 444 Fear

01,336 46.4 Mk(arrreraut nu.°

grid-Pr aiaa. 1. ark iac.01.-110501

F7174 qtr,

4-4r 4, 0192. 14 *TAM, 7018

rilsg.34*-47(317To tto ant .) 3117-ai.nii, FSft.44.c1V I

farq:- (u.:13T 3011"+"IT anirftziri, 2005 t 3i*** 45. rarrett, ;Jura wit ;Rh- - =twat, ft-gr. 4.14, 829123 WI' erria* I

Paw,

RS 41 cfkci f fta 01.10.2018 * aurerant 3rrara. crfarnfir adrftra *14 wr faati t f.".4 sip a1 feu* 08.11.2018 Wr 347931x# 303:e4**, 2005 k /1- .4(1 /var * air ur I

2. Stweit .5;011ad 3T1M3Tft au-4-44 4 4-4 titstii 7 *nit arttivr9 41r{ff t tmela *tic t 31*: wer .4ra 4 pi atirazr iipc, *TA r argerarrt 3rfirmrwr, 2005 *r um 6(3)* 4-64 TTMET 4r0 31111-49 si* °Tit* t luer 31re3nt- 3503.* %-zrr 3rar t

11 erich: zru1-4vr

aa~lu , •

VIA Itar)

3.3-at 4f0-0 tr* sim aritirr4T, (3rrer3rrt)

lactu- ki°

AThrJ1( -1'wmig.-:0=f acii

14's -mil-i1

jtiftcii-q A a 1M-7--'Weli tietticirp:ral(C

ZP-gi tb-T .&QN-B1<a{filtaffi 7-00 5- s ctn.

V2R7f Wait

-137- 014/21 tc7-1-1 1 & L5-1124

(..\\ 2_01 (.4 .27- - rrefi kprEc,-T1 fraWit?,aicralirirc-ArZ

avc. -.6HcerCu‘ 9Qz-i-RiSiji &PIT

C24 4 2014 ).0)g i 45-`4) k\

Zek--- der •ri-R.

4--.4-4 Ai sztrii-0-45i

C.41 CrreCr 41. .297-I) €i 44 ikk

Cifb “ripf

sd

arr 4-4--11,

ea .111T4 etc crn fir1.4.1-1

0 t, rarri ter. •

cc evrewq.k 13,4„2-011- le

k €-Thri‘ liccg - fit) .341 3)144

ki-15 4R-419.1 nce211 krg

.sra\--0-1 A7-1 <41)* cwr &l L1 tai

. talcv fxr ztk---R

It/ rfl '49 -T-P-o--Acui•toil 3€f 0 31 el-1-

s 0 gAlch 10. 2-°

IBfloi 018 143\C:&

Oic C. R. Section CRT ) Dairy bte.f.'49.9 . 51.1.Y ol

_r - .1111:3

a\ThrWririg

cc, (-friT

i2r-cc o. 14,3-1 11" k ofi -2-1)<-4'"1-‘?1 eb) 15119-G1 4-6 orr) ?0,-9 rallfir

(11(41 ) cciR R tleArtf. Cci3 t-7 crich—c3-9

<r' P-1:5--; &Ft

3c. f. 0.31' 2-1

) I•s-W) c

.\-ictc A' .31.1 ajTrieiraFFF-10, (Rev,"

-h3 q, LTAcRdi (ifffce--7-2_•*Tr4 <itetn

1- ..etc -11611Trirc !Aim -7-11D r— .-c:k te ,reki sj.g4, ci sf. I ;

ors

cc: d'Itt, . z

0 o

R:r '71

tgt1

Co x #00

..e•g7

31?1-1) zj -314 0 I 14 /2 1-2_1 2-0)

R TT a 2stiatileb cbl

41(bk- 04111,2_,<$1


No. 4435)/2015-M.1 New Delhi, the 27.11.2018 To

Shri S.C. Bose, Admin. Officer & Nodal Officer RTI, Geological Survey of India, 27, J.L. Nehru Road, Kolkata-700 016

Subject: Application seeking information under RTI Act, 2005 by Shri Krishna Kishore, Village and Post Cha4i, Prakand- Petarwar, District Bokaro, Jharkhand-829123 seeking information about GSI.

Sir, I am directed to transfer under. Section 6(3) of the RTI Act 2005, an RTI

application dated 1.10.2018 of Shri Krishna Kishore, Village and Post Champi, Prakand-Petarwar, District Bokaro, Jharkhand-829123 received on transfer from Ministry of Road Transport and Highways on 26.11.2018 on the subject mentioned above.

2. You are requested to provide the applicant, the information sought by him at pars 7 of the RTI application dated 1.10.2018 directly within the stipulated time limit under intimation to this Ministry.

Yours faithfully,

(ma. Sa anarayan)

Copy for information to: CPIO Mines.'

1. Shri Shri Krishna Kishore, Village and Post Champi, Prakand- Petarwar, District Bokaro, Jharkhand-829123. A copy of your RTI application has been forwarded to Geological Survey of India (GSI) as stated above. For any further query, concerned P10 of the G5I may be contacted directly. If you are not satisfied with the information furnished by PIO of the GSI, you may appeal to the Appellate

Z2. Authority in GSI under the provision of RTI Act, 2005. PI Cell, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi w.r.t their U.O.No.2/137/2018-PI dated 26.11.2018.

(M.R. Sathyanarayanan) CPIO Mines.I

tkr-hrif 3.1-ftMT 3-Tftf%7171, 2005

P4-ici Thalit/Due date 15.12.2018


49101 41,116.4.1

tcloi I W. 31ita,TT 31'fbi:n171, 2005 3taira. ‘4 I k.ci 3iia I

Ministry of Heavy Industries and Public Enterprises t lzfq

01.11.2018 col“ Air trfr. 1t 6, enla t SRI-0 3.11a-Ca• ?drift 21.09.2018

TIM c.17, cr+-T6 I

2. ÷i:4011 r 3Tt‘Tft Sr, 2005 tir tiRT 6(3) t 3iTTR .la gitt Tit

tiz-krii 5 410..1 3 +Rchitl eni4c,“.4 a161/

7rJrCZ t aF .3iThRFrft, fatt arra-cF 3-tal MIT t tra .arra tici1c d t1,(1-41

3Tftwrtifrbicilerei tr yea. *r artru trurercr .41%-R- 5 faril grd7

T211-46ita choiT ..71(41 FITT '174 •11" 310-C" aft Ttit-a- co(eil 3Trallit t I

3. 311N 3.9111.1* .311%91t Sr, 2005 * Pck-1) aiT 1-11H0-1

§cr 5+l' fattfta. #34-4 # wriartt a-rcr

End: OPE's letter No. 2 r(1)/2009-6M(Pt.) dated 01.11.18

Sh. M.R. Sathvanaravanan, SO(Mines n /*Tt- Rf each •z-u<rir 31 Tit

Sh. Singh. SO(Metai / teal- Ach t1yo11 3111Mitl.

Smt. Lakshmi Subramanian. US(Metal 111) / 3achi

11.31* AF/PI Cell U.O. No. 2/136/2018-PI Marc/Dated 16.11.2018

.7\c'cc (as-I1

393Trir 3ar+-rtt

F. No. 27(1)/2009-GM(Pt.) Government of India

Ministry of Heavy Industries and Public Enterprises Department of Public Enterprises

Block 19, CGO Complex. Lodhi Road, New Delhi-n0003.

To, Dated, the 1h: November, 2018 Shri SP Singh, A 401, Aashirte/d Anneal], Indra Vihar. Keta. Pin - 324 009.

Subject: Information required under current 'Right to Information Act, 2005'. Sir,

I-5i Provide the total list of directors of all PSUs with their 3.,4. and 5. As Directors on thCboarcis of Name, Designation, category and company in which the CPSEs are appointed by their concerned hold the post.

administrative Minche:is/Depart merits. a copy of your RTI application is being — — — 4. RR-WM the number 0: independent directors in Polls 1 forwarded to all administrative

belonging to 11,1 inistries/Departments under Section Scheduled Tribes Category and OBC.

general category, Scheduled caste category, 6(3) of RTI Act, 2005 with a request to

5. J furnish relevant information relating to r'rovide the number of government nominee directors Directors of CPSEs under their in PSUs belonging to general category, Scheduled caste administrative control to you directly. eateeon,- Scheduled Tribes Catenary and OBC

An appeal against this letter can be preferred to the Appellate Authority in this Department, within thirty days from the receipt of this letter at the following address.

Dr. Madhukar Gupta, Additional Secretary, Room No. 401, Department of Public Enterprises Block No. 14, CGO Complex, Lodi Road, New Delhi - 130 003.

Yours faithfully,

okesh Bajpai) Director & CPIO Tel : 2436-o736

Copy to :- CPIOs of al! achninistrative Ministries/Departments With a request to send the information regarding Directors of CPSEs under their administrative rontrol as requested in point no. 3,4 and 5 of R77 application (copy enclosed) to RT7 applicant directly under intimation to this Department. (

Please refer to your RD application (DPENT/R/2018/50503) received in DPE on 21.9.2018. The R11 application was transferred by other CPIO in DPE on 16.1o.2018. The information in respect /if Your R'll application is as under. Information Sought

____T_. _____, r1. Provide the total numberof sanctioned Information

posts of 1. and 2. There are no CPSEs under thel I director to be impolitic.] on regular basis in all PSUs administrative control of DPE and there . Wider DPE. 1.......____

is no information to furnish in this I 2. Provide the total number of directors in PSU belonging regard. to general category, Scheduled caste category, Scheduled ,

'Tribes Catecory and OBC.

https://rtionline.gov.in/RTIMISCPHYRTIDetails.phpfreg---+ViA:

RTI REQUEST DETAILS @irritant afTlE(idcHuI) Registration Number DPENT/R

(thiljerur *kg/0 /2018/50503

Type of Receipt Th-r Online Receipt Bell) :

Date of Receipt 21/09/2018 OH ThchlitC4) :

Language of Request English (rdtir t mica) :

I of

Name (.M) : SP SINGH Gender Male

Address (TM) : A 401, Aashirvad Aangan, Indra Vihar, KOTA, Pin:324009

State (t l) : Rajasthan

Country : India

Mobile Number +91-9161044777 01-orfu ricm :

+91-9161044777 Phone Number OP -I 4i) :

Email-ID [email protected]

Status (Pit)(RuraUUrban) : Urban Education Status : Above Graduate

Is Requester Below Poverty No Line ? elltZeg 4t4cn wT

31414 t?) :

Citizenship Status Indian (-114 iDcPc11)

Amount Paid (.211T TIBR) 10) (original : recipient)

Request Pertains to ( Lokesh Bajpai Avfalla ticigicrt :

Mode of Payment Payment Gateway ( TUT4W wrote)

Information Sought (vll-tcpl

Sir, It is requested to kindly provide the following latest information related to number of directors appointed in the board of Public Sector Undertaking (PSUs) governed by Department of Public Enterprises.. 1. Provide the total number of sanctioned posts of director to be appointed on regular basis in all PSUs under DPE. 2. Provide the total number of directors in PSI) belonging to general category, Scheduled caste category, Scheduled Tribes Category and OBC. 3. Provide the total list of directors of all PSUs with their Name, Designation, category and company in which the hold the post. 4. Provide the number of independent directors in PSUs belonging to general category, Scheduled caste category, Scheduled Tribes Category and OBC. 5. Provide the number of government nominee directors in PSUs belonging to general category, Schedtiled caste category, Scheduled Tribes Category and OBC

Print Save Close

10/18/2018 11:08 A

MOST IMMEDIATE/RTI ACT FAX/SPEED POST


No.5/4/2017-Met.III New Delhi, the November, 2018

To

Shri SP Singh, A 401, Ashirvad Aangan, indra Vihar, Kota' Pin- 324009.

Sub: - Information sought under RTI Act 2005.

Sir, I am directed to refer to your RTI application dated 21.09.2018 received

in Ministry of Mines, which was transferred by CPIO in DPE vide his letter dated 01.11.2018 and to provide you the information sought in your RTI application as under:-

kvou.sti. HAka

Points 3, 4 & 5: - The instructions vide DOPT's O.M. No. 13(15)E0/2007(ACC) dated 01.09.2010ifor appointment of Non-Official Directors do not speak about reservation in appointment of Directors in CPSEs. As such Ministry does not keep the category details of the Directors. For other information sought in your RTI application on the said points you may visit the website of Hindustan Copper Limited i.e. https://hindustancopper.com.

2. In case, you are not satisfied with this information, you may file an appeal before the Appellate Authority, i.e. Smt. Farida Naik, Director, Ministry of Mines, Room No. 312D, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi, Ph. :- 011- 23384593 within 30 days from the receipt of this letter.

Yours faithfully

It

(Lakshmi Subramanian) CPIO & Under secretary to Govt. of India

\../opy to: PI cell w.r.t. their UO No. 2/136/2018-PI dated 16.11.2018

I);: .r.11aiTilY 0 Mines-I S'ection

No.4.0/35/2015.0 New Delhi, the -1 53.11.2010

To,

Shri S.P. Singh, A 401, Aastiirvad Amgen, Indra Vihar, KOTA-324009

Subject-Information sought under RTI Act, 2005 regarding information relatexl to number of directors appointed in the board of Public Sector Undertaking (PSUs) governed by•Department of Public Enterprises.

Sir, This has reference to your RTI application dated 21.9.2018 received by this

Section on 16.11.2018 on transfer from Department of Public Enterprises vide their letter F.No.27(1)/2009-GM(Pt) dated 1.11.2018 on the above mentioned subject.

2. Mines-i Section of Ministry of Mines is concerned with the matters of iViinera! Exploration Corporation (MECL) and the information sought by you about the above PSU is as follows:-

(1) The total number of sanctioned post of directors to be appointed on regular basis in MECL is 12.

(2) Total number of directors in MECL belonging to general category, scheduled caste category, scheduled tribe category and OBC is 7.

(3) The total list df Directors of MECL with their name, designation, category is as given below:-

(a) Dr. Ranjit Rath, CMD, General (b) Shri R.N. Jha, Director(Technical), General (c) Shri Ghanashyam Sharma, Director(Finance), General (d) Shri Bipul Pathak, Part Time Official Director (e) Shri Peeyush Kumar, Part Time Official Director

Ms. Ranjana Sinha, Part Time Non-Official Director, General

(g) Shri Akhilesh Jain, Part Time Non-Official Director, General

(4) The number of Independent Directors in MECL belonging to general category. scheduled caste category, scheduled tribe category and OBC is 2.

(5) The number of government nominee directors in MECL belonging to general category, scheduled caste category, scheduled tribe category and OBC is 2.

3 information about category of Shri Bipul Pathak, and Shri Peeyush Kumar, Part Time Official Directors of MECL in Point 3 of the RTI application is not available with this Section' "therefore, the above part of the RTI application is transferred to

.it•:t• • :

4, If yciu • with the reply of this Ministry, you may file an app:i•if.. the AppeNate Ad!ti-prity i.e Dr. Joyesh Bagchi, Directorriech.), Ministry of Mines, Roc,::: No. 305, D-Wing, Shashi Shawan, New Delhi within the stipuiated time period as per provisions o the. RYI Act, 2005.

Yours faithirtiliy.

5.3:-athyanaray9nag) C7-10( Mines it

Copy for information to:-

1. Shri Yogesh R. Patel, Under Secretary (CM); Ministry of Mines, Shastri T3hEiwar,, New Deihl.

9. Shti Sae) Shattacharya, Under Secretary(CP10), MInistry 01: Shaslri Shaw,Tn, Room No.351-A, New Delhi.

3. PI C'li: Ministry of Mines, New Delhi.w.r.t Their J.0.Mo:4/I 36/761P-1-'1 cla(ed 16.11.2018.

(M.R. Sathyariarayanan) CP10(iViinsis-1)

No. 25/1/2017-Met-I

To,

Shri S P Singh, A-401, Aashirvad Aangan, Indra Vihar. Kota Rajasthan, Pin-324009


RTI MATTER/SPEED POST

Shastri Bhawan,New Delhi, the 28th, November, 2018

Subject: Seeking Information under RTI Act, 2005.

Sir,

With reference to your RTI application Regn No. DPENT/R/2018/50503 dated 21/09/2018 to Department of Public Enterprises (DPE), Mk Heavy Industries & Public Enterprises duly transferred

to this Ministry regarding appointment of Directors in the Board of Public Sector Undertakings (PSUs)

2. The information (for the point No. 3, 4 and 5 of your application) relating to National

Aluminium Co. Ltd (NALCO) a PSU under the administrative control of this Ministry is given below:

"Since, there is no reservation in the post of Directors appointed in NALCO. a PSU of Mk Mines therefore, no record is maintained by this office.. The list and the details of Board of Directors including independent directors and Government Nominee directors relating to NALCO is available on the official website of the company i.e. trim. MikOillditt.a»11"

3. In case you are not satisfied with the reply you may prefer an appeal before the Appellate

Authority Smt. Athira S Babu, Appellate Authority and Director, Room No.311 "D", 3rd Floor, M/o Mines, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi within the stipulated period as per the provisions of RTI Act, 2005.

Yours faithfully,

(Vinay &tapSingh) CPIO & Section Officer

e-mail rnet Copy to :

I. Shri Lokesh Bajpai, Director & CPIO, D/o Public Enterprises, Block No. 14 CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003 with reference to your communication No. 27/1/2009-0M(N) dated.1/1 1/2018.

2. PI Cell, Mk Mines with reference to U.0 No. 2/1 36/2018-PI dated 16/11/2018

aiftwR- aiftlf4z7azi, 2005

/Due date 14.12.2018 TIME 80UND/RTI MATTER

474 4R7t

rifra- 4--arRzr F. No. 2/1.35/2018-Pi

sriFt (fls. - tar 4, 24* 15.11.2018

CPIO-Co-ord (hiqrs.) (Sh. A.D. Se!akar) Dy. Mineral Economist, Indian Bureau of Mines, Nagpur.

Faurzr: 2:1:4M aTite0-7a, 2005 * „3-t-e4a- CTIER 3.11 -CR- I

3:1-et-C7,

gr-4U t U, StaTT-47, * 3174-47 iza-97-* 05.11.2018 *)- air r1-7 4rer 3-F3a- wrir-art cr-ffa- fkar r6r

2. Taar 31t(*IT ar, 2005 *t txr-4 6(3) * 31.7rr-4- zrlt- artraft 44- Ta4r fitrzr 4.-wr-tr -rzfrazr afiv trat.. affemirtr, f4-+-t .31-rd-cif t #1- .3Trk-c-a- ffrwrfir arltr-rtrIzr irr-d-4-R-

crft'a• ‘'t arttEr zrvrettr 41t4 5 It* * grer nrraiaftF wz4r 7.Lt a147 art 317-4-W *t aft T7faa- m-R-4r arrlizT*" t I 3. .341-cr# ar:dtti e-

f 4y4r r 33Iftazpq, 2005 * 1*-43:4 recr-{ f4E4ft--- 44zr a1 wraart aRr

IPO No. 81G 545111

Copy to:

t st•A'sr qs C Zfd Bircarr, Tr.riTrw art atu,

• tcff "aT" (ft 1Hr @ 4160

?)(

Atit 7-4grret-a-1' atfIr-t-rt-alartra of R rd

R TI-MT

rair (aTrarizr) at-{irr

(z- ) Tatterwr Mira C<14) f WM5Talefra tara

tegM 3-T4 Wre-Ma

(dt4) '2'411 (airazr47) arcr -arr mitata ciu

*T ;T .qtriT vi!T t i94 •

•Frtl if:I-en 1 3-(T4t7 ww-47t.1

*31

<r -r F-A-m zre -H- Ftr-I

irsc ei Si 71-1-47T fe T. 37T? 9c fe)77 411F)

3,

RI

ttfW cir tip: tier

/Rtmrq 3T Fff i fz TrErr el At a•Hccit 'Ecru"

TT': 1-7 13.7 . 9, Fi r -4" TO *IT %-; "11 -1 ci:1

C€rrt) 'Mit ,. ZCITMK1-16cn 31-It c4-1-

owva. zErr-5 m7-i" zttir

I an

Ff70-qm• (14T) T-4t arwQIP;r

(7344.49r.ut if-errit,1 'ff.T !RN)

ai.Ji<N, AT. fiV-Er 3Trerftwd.

r:T.F-zrft urcrift-7 (-3-1317:74M

'4Ptaccr 79 irgTM)

si • ic 0 0 02,

-r%It-57 kisrcnw-4 itrfIF

ZT..reff Mt, -aiT, c% a(1.

1:t

— V“-vt.F.,30R 0

-71' ,RTIT ajitT, N. any' T4T.:T

H f("9" . 6u<4 ThTfi*

Root a' Rote.

4 0 INt..ss

T,R71w. -17:l4

prftwiVi atftWR ai-S_ Rook 31"--"4 SfireavziRTrataTT 3:1-al‘- tti

wed,

witact aTftr-*--Ri Th-r-9-Jt afrq. trig-R7 vrr-4;fr 11--o7 tf. r*--;

• .4 1

ek/Ui -09.6 • rT)iniP A75

17.71.:-. st. • ., ar 1••••

3Titr+-TT 3iftra7:P:1, 2005

go fail/Due date 12.12.2018 TIME 80UND/RTI MATTER

3TITa. +Hctiv(

4.910

F. No. 21134/2018-PI

21111 , far-A

eit9fT 13.11.2018

CPIO-Co-ord (I-Iqrs.) (Sh. A.D. Selokar) Dy. Mineral Economist, Indian Bureau of Mines, Nagpur.

qei. tat WT 31RYThzia:r, 2005 Matra P-ct arra-C"

Sh. Varinder Singh, R/o Ludhiana taiw 05.11.2018 WY Tfr cifl #rtr 3fi 1wr-zi-ar-3 srfda fdw.41 T trr ti

2. tkr-I0-11 Th-T

.4cloir air

Trrift - t at at

31-ftrwrticni III M11

nTrat-dtj cbtril

alWzrpr, 2005 *r C.IRT 6(3) S 317ITT 44 *aft 7* WrreT ti ichi•D cf1R6 Mel .7.151/

arttrwre-, arra-c-# gar zr-44-r t t4:1 31Taf *r tR4)111 331 r crriRt'a 1 artrur zrtrrsitcr Afth-F 5 ftal S afra--t-

a-ar t a-zrr vrt A- air-The-w,R9- 4I toi l mr-dszt“

3. Strc1-4 3TT1tr f ektaciT a7 arttrw arftrizr#, 2005 k L1ai1 r 4iciai r 1Atirfra #-#zr * wp5a-rt tir :siii

rivort. IPO No. 46F 226762

Copy to:

Sh. Varinder Singh, 355, Jassian Road, Friends Colony, Ludhiana-141008

9..rcri, laGq.ct

ck:--c--e—Cekectss in. .d

\---1c-5.

Virtinfilhe%ot nma-siNsie, 12-1044.

---MH? ,,IJA:: ;/1 ci:4.. '

1 Wcz-A -s-z--,\:-.1--n neke‘ c3)62_ aksa(;0:,,,s-n,c ..•:„

nAn \\+`kz-v.i, 3.4a:46-o,s• %\e„Rsa •WcIs• , 41:c.,7:-,-.- --:::,\-J (...MQ.,

--*-.--a-&fttc r'c')tt9lbn ka `1\44=1%-k th

•-•%-kvaavti

a enetA9A-

-k\*IcS\4Ft

Cok-koc\CA, ‘;k:z%. tile-tolh,r4-i?J

\3*-6%-3-A.C\ \'AcaWk41c-I-N-1 _

aai gcW- *\\ - sk‘ OAS tevi.\\ a;NA

rez:V `VOgenako. c_disrilDn)

Ice\ Rt.)1c 53\ S • 1 \- NS> ,,ate .4.

L-Vsksc 034„Na

RV-1 G 94 r6Q, r,scv

VARINDER SINGH 355, Jassian Road,

Friends Colony, Ldh-141008.

LAixost_ta.. .

41:40-11 air 3TRITT 3114fiW4PT, 2005

Ci far4/oue date 12.12.2018


INF

+ke40-il 3iftMIT 3f F, 2005 3fail7 atra-co.

Sh. Varinder Singh, R/o Ludhiana mr-d-c-F ftRi' 05.11.2018 T1 VT!"

PVT UffiF reT

2. 3arwr arftrftzraT, 2005 *t Eurr 6(3) * 39-4Tr-4- rtaft 3-rt idoki ar;--zr +keni enne.i ete4 T1 151/

at at stftwrft, ft:Wr 3tr--4-4-F aka-r Trio. HO -4w F tio • 3iftWthi4 lq1c,ler 41, arr#a-a• Sr ',111Th Sr zrzmitr -12'+-7-r 5 fariI afta-{ 7wftt atir Tfr a1 aft a cfrtcril 31-Mzin I

3. arrqu t +koini r arftr+-R- Sr, 2005 t W.! Lilese

r 34141 fAtinta ."1.4104 b -1-frdit aTZ I

rfrpri. IPO No. 46F 226761

pp—\'b ki

)

sTTrr-ir .3TitiTift

Sh. A.K. Mallik, US(M-III) / t*z1' ei en kly#T 31tIWt1 Sh. Yogesh R. Patel, USIAdrnin) / *-4R1- each Kr.:4W 3ifeWitt

Lft.34 (.4111 Cell U.U. No. 2/133/2018-PI itFtW/Dated 13.11.2018

103,x-n

Okk. %Ns- -Selac;T GUS 3~ W

W Cekki & VC; ‘ • Cik \'''• •

net .\\ fh W,1/4.S.(S\Ok‘ cle \ ria S,C4-‘ab.

3I 1 :,

c•• 1•14g nft

0 tb-IC1/27)t_bil M.- 'II If\

_t14"-am e1 /4Q.k, -aubs- %\e_c-K----a-v N,;:r

1 'tA- i. --R%-.t. s‘Try,ax, -,Niala le-iA8-04Y‘ Gat,

.akEttAc, ,,,it.s..4stx,

\\ 0

IGI?,?' &bg\i\ bnka.\k;n\

a

C'f\:‘-ktY t:\SS-Tkk-a CfCnft‘ "a \

AA'‘-- `-• p t-og\ .4.‘titAX c-\\ sa.\-%\. c.. 4-0A-4 V:t

---3"- N tr-Ser N -I L-13 \-C\k .\t\A

C'.4 1.i.n a , Vftift‘961kON 4 newp,), utka (LY44.;a6c -ArAvy a,\s.. ,\ ,

.... \:.,_e :0cw ik_a... a_to\wEcc \1\*„..,4

ae* I_N:-••4- 7-cal w_ \\,;:-&--aa.\ 1V.: ----, ,3\\- \

1,ita ‘

A e ?C -- ICW-ac-1 tk-CICNCI Mitte-1/4t

‘ Ccic‘ -.41\t‘ \

cuait pla.15.3-wro c‘raik_.\\.ca Q Xt-V\ ;-\\.‘)/ velath..015%

VARINDER SINGH 355, Jassian Road, 41\33 ste 6,4 znyFriends T:olo Ldh-141008.

€14 bail-COM:k

No.31/13/2018-M.111 Mire / Government of India

UM'4ir t i / Ministry of Mines an*

New Delhi, Dated 30 7 11120 1 8

To CPIO-Co-ord (Hqrs.) (Shri A.D. Selokar) Dy. Mineral Economist, Indian Bureau of Mines, Nagpur.


Sir, Please find enclosed herewith a copy of RTI application received from Shri

Varinder Singh, Ludhiana with Registration No. 2/133/2018-PI dated 13.11.2018. The information sought by the applicant relates to IBM. Therefore, the application is transferred to IBM under sub-section (3) of Section 6 of RTI Act 2005 for further necessary action.

End: As above

Copy to:

Yours faithfully,


Tele No. 23384943 Email: ak.mallikritnic.in

1. Sh. Varinder Singh, 355, Jassian Road, Friends Colony, Ludhiana-141008 9./ePIO, PI Cell w.r.t. their Registration No. 2/133/2018-PI dated 13.11.2018

0 tloi I 9r 31ftmltWzr#, 2005

faeid J.-aril/Due date 12.12.2018


Aga- filet .<

4.9101 J-1,11c1.4

fter4: +1,,t4011 3fit1-4,R" arit(r4-4-g, 2005 i aide ci silucr 347-4

Sh. Manoj Kumar, Rio Delhi 3Tra-Ca• ftei-.a, nil Tht cri* TIM 5I Th7zfriti g7, \Hid f ur IT TF

2. tkcierlI TT .3TibW7 3ifeardzPI, 2005 *1 EMT 6(3) 3i1AR An* ,q RtieI 31- 1" tftchil) chieneiq .).1$1/

1:1- ft•Z t a. a-E afferAft, ftzr-41- 31- CF-CF A7r rmi-r trA- titan tig,14 ailtrAftiw,Iclei a0-a-4-A. mird ter Frtru trarem if+-A- 5 fad-II * afrai- nn*afta. chtMI oiti• Ftrr T4:1- ari at areit AT arra- zrw

3. 311 attl" r Irk Th7 3TitrThiT 3ifteiWzrg, 2005 * zbki Thi 91"-a =hi r- tiLli fatifita- bait wRtart *f 'AP: I

#-437. IPO No. 44F 163.5 73

Sh. Yoaesh R. Patel, USiestt /

111.311t #ei/PI Cell ILO No. 2/1 32,2018-P1 13.11.2018

•"'"

A°5

21 09 Fr

rr

•1/4 to i

The Public Information Officer • Personnel Department / EWA \-......tat.rngervh

Ministry of Mines Govt. of India Shashri Shawan New Delhi

Sub Seeking infnrnation under RTI Act

The following iffinfrnation are required under RTI Act from your Department

1. Provide the copy of letter received from New Delhi Municipal Council (NDMC). Palika Kendra, New Delhi where it has been mentioned that ND1VIC wants den Itatcon of Shri Ashish Aggrawal, Assistant/ ASO.

2 Provide the copies of entire noting and correspondence portion of We deal' for deputation of of Shri Ashish Aggrawal, Assistant/ ASO presently or. deputatlor as a Deputy Director (Vigilance)/Smart City

3 The period of deputation in Rio of Shri Ashish Aggrawal, Assistant/ ASO is

already been expired on 20th October. 2018 and next steps taken to repratatiof of of Shri Ashisn Aggrawal Assistant/ ASO back to ministry of

Mines, Govt. of India. 4 Prov ide e Rules& Regulation which inform the procedure adopted for

reguliZation of excess period which has already expired 5 Provide te rules & regulation for getting the consent /willingness and time

period rec Aired

Yours i• -51 Cl/

caftre,;7.e-PS IS" Manoj Kumar,

House no E:16 Block-A, ShasholiNaget•

Delhi 1100752

tick 92_11 78'it

No.11(3)/2014-Estt. GOVERNMENT OF INDIA

MINISTRY OF MINES

icV1) New Delhi, the Dec., 2018

To Shri Manoj Kumar H.No.916 Block-A, Shashtri Nagar Delhi-110052

Sub: Application under Right to Information Act, 2005

Sir,

Please refer to your letter dated Nil under RTI Act, 2005 which has been received in Establishment Section of Ministry of Mines from P.I. Cell of this Ministry vide U.O. No.2/132/2018-PI dated 13.11.2018.

2 In so far as Establishment Section of Ministry of Mines (Sectt. Proper) is concerned the

information is as under-

01) A copy of NDMC letter No. SO(E)/1229/SA-I(R) dated 14.10.2015 is enclosed .

2) For providing requisite information, please deposit a fee of Rs.281-@ Rs. 2/- per page for 14 pages [(copies of noting (4 pages) and copies of correspondence (10 pages) of file No. P-11/852/2011-Estt.j, as per section 7(3) of RTI Acf, 2005.

3) to 05): NDMC has requested for granting extension of deputation of Shri Ashish Agrawal , ASO(CSS), Ministry of Mines as Deputy Director (Vigilance) in NDMC for two years beyond 20.10.2018 vide their letter No.A-19012/149/2017-Secy.Estt. dated 28.09.2018. Cadre clearance was granted vide this Ministry's letter No.P-II/852/2011-Estt. dated 18.10.2018 in terms of DoPT OM No.6/8/2009-Estt.(Pay-II) dated 17.06.2010 after approval of the Competent Authority .

3. In case you are not satisfied with the above reply, you may file an appeal before the Appellate Authority (Shri Shersha, Director, Ministry of Mines, Room No.309, Wing, Shastri Bhavan, New Delhi) within a period of 30 days from the date of receipt of this letter.

Yours faithfully,

(Yogesh-R.Patel / Under Secretary to the Govt. of India

Tel: No. 011-23383946 [email protected]

Copy to: PI Cell, Ministry of Mines w.r.t. Registration Number cited above.

)

Yogesh R.Pala ) Under Secretary to the Govt. of India

tkci erf I WI aritrWR afferfkr3T, 2005

cra" f*Iir/Due date 11.12.2018


ainw .4-s1ch12

uira- #-A-wzr

3ifern7 31ittfAzig, 2005 t 3fcT <i vita- 3-3-rd-

J3fr End ETW TraR--/Tra. 3TraTa it-4w nil 1-4:r Eg- * Rmr cl WItIt Sr+TH-6, fstrr off ?Kr 11

SIT 34ftthzr-g, 2005 ETRI 6(3) * .34"9-4tR e *aft art faisrzr -TzItr-zr t TsT/

301M1t, f tTh 3ir-4-4-F gar arr-d-cr, tdira. trim( "1, 311-4CW *r strRrr arttur trzinfru M.'it-F 5 faoi alfidt

airr art at .3frE-c-w *Rwr arranr*

3. 31Tcr1 39-4-114- +ktiol 3ar-+-TT 3TitriOzp:1 2005 tuoiri -Tftrr3-ficr-{ Ei ffatzr wrirart irir .71 Elf I

tlaaPi: IPO No. 41F 341271

"'"\\

(frgi cor(r) 31933T-JT

Sit ALMa11ik iS(M_Inl1_ o*rePT 431.31*.41/131 Cell U.O. No. 2/131/2018-P1 ar•--e*/1)ated 12.11.2018

Inn 0 0 5 6 ( 3) r:cie-c: iq;r< 2- 4- 6 0) -i-F-?-17-1-1 --E

'3\4-9 3-1frr ;; Oc ii‘.4

0 4-

, ,A

:: ' eic k“; *•1/4( ,

3cA1 0 • r•- ‘12_001.•C‘

• li ' "'

r-,44'<r OR: :Z c

egril-i

cl.t:frif 'Ca-171 "j-- ertrt

FeE24- RI I act 200 S t TT-a- *k SAac

stk-TR -ate‘r--072:- small

->sa .4) GF—rreA"

. e \--4" Jam} escreri aln -44--6-sTk (-64-Freg7-1.

Qw

9.• `41 re-4"(4 Cfn-e450

sazi --1 t "r"4-atil sctri-k

til '2340.--11 eCril afar -;-'S tl

FETS'n rari •Crl 3_fia-c-4-val,crtiC\c„—r24

Gvvecisni* Tigi-Eir--.-Ti,s2_00s-- a ---c4

4, CI) in--err! carg INTO 3411-4-C-1 ;1\4'

51-NI-679 Mc a Tr-Fr241-741e.-r-c-A G-Trakel

-cfurA, •-kM rirr-si elem./ siki ;it 4

4171-1 crgl 13-ien5-1 I

-Xer%str

st-IW OTR (341:AZ-

.37Th ccrel4

elf

No.31/13/2018-M.III

3111-ff Government of India

/ Ministry of Mines *****

New Delhi, Dated November, 2018

To CPIO-Co-ord (Hqrs.) (Slui A.D. Selokar) Dy. Mineral Economist, Indian Bureau of Mines, Nagpur.

Sub: Information asked under RT1 Act, 2005

Sir, Please find enclosed herewith a copy of RTI application received from Sh. Dhruv Pal,

Sikar (Rajasthan) with Registration No. 2/131/2018-PI dated 12.11.2018, The information sought by the applicant relates to IBM. Therefore, the application is transferred to IBM under sub-section (3) of Section 6 of RTI Act 2005 for further necessary action.

End: As above

Yours faithfully,

(Adhir Kumar Mallik) Under Secretary & CP10

Tele No.-23384743 Email: ak.mallik(6nic.in

Copy to:

1. Sh. Dhruv Pal, R/o Nethwa Tehsil- Ramgarh Shekhawati, Sikar (Rajasthan) -331024 with the request that the further correspondence may be made with IBM.

L....Z.-CPI°, PI Cell w.r.t. their Registration No. 2/131/2018-PI dated 12.11.2018

Tarn r 3-TitWIT 3TftIft1P4, 2005

fliici 11/Due date 01.12.2018


3irla tit~t It

4-1,110144

fag-4: 41:4011 .T'n Sr, 2005 * kaira ‘41'-c-1 3.17tC I

air 1, I Wet, ,iitcaus 311- it #11W 25.10.2018 ti9'* 172;

3±46 wrira-rt 14,241 ar ti

"ThThT{ Sr, 2005 *r UM 6(3) * 3lt1Ti Kira Hidfl Tit

fdWtr 31rz- I tit la 404 eit4

.3TR- 411)ft, +ice)) 31lt87 #71 artrrt #1" arlaco tiQStrl ti(4)11)

er, 3Tra-CF r srffezr *r a-rtm # trMv AitR- 5 RA

aTracch 3tt crioit 3Traqzrt t-

BSI

3. 3ircra 337@tt7 t• Ntr-ieff SIT siftrFAzmr, 2005 * cilaa

ACT 34-14i fAtitta 1:171z1 "liraft °Hy I

*twirl. 'PO No. 36F 03 814

(arm 50

3T -D3.1-r# 3artrtr

Sh. A.K. Mallik, USIM-I11) / *al" (44) 41:4crii .3.1114#

Sh. A.K. Mallik. US(M-IV) —411Z11 614) 3litnitt

11.3TT3 .t1F/PI Cell 110. No. 2/130/2018-P1 t#*/Dated 02.11.2018

re;:n7;-ri 2 b

tribud jtts:2-T ardif,ii

F el It r

"td - `1.11- cili 3 tle-ciii;Y.,g1thrizin .2_005-, f41.?,---,-) 11-;-'

sir) rJ 41--,

czw-ni. -}11-4 1,

- cet

1.7,

<21 -ccl‘ri R,1 4

0-RH

cbr\ 11,374). g_nr

\L- Zczt 1Th• 4 164:11 tfet

Cd 7 -171)4-T1 2.ci ,-jic?i

. (1/4). tv

T-1 1(4TJ 4CIL <ci-sA"4it Po-1(3A 9

141 it\ -2.1 2.- 7 i -kk "q(-1,1,5=1 Ptbie-ZY t

kle?Kg • - ; 7 • •

04) 2 2_

) rteri. -€1,-Ererri - 1 9761 k kepi ;jab

T-r- . k el .c-tt 2.71AECA 1r" a-I ACC-tr( e)-ril I as

-J51 451 .

I Zcil* Lcr 'err (i;r-- (CY‘ arr-C -2drriAlt ; ;

NcIer -ft (ZTR-Ii T r4145

41 irk INT -6); ca-aet 0-1 7t- Fl zl kizi lYk ,i401-11(1).-t

rift- -ST-(F27.i Li-77.41A2

o( 0-tai IF% r-fa 0 •atiFfirs; Zi4.2.11- F"" b (3) s cs k'as

';;; .4•11 1 t

tiri I. - - cicaL—crIR -211611 d**112-k*TS 82J 12.3

'Olt) 411- .11.1TITC1cari tr Ce-7 •••\ 4\410; i .

.;•'-',4s &Cr ;•• • L; •s, J

IA! Fer .V.;\‘‘ 00-4.1i1

er• No.31/13/2018-M.III

3Tria" twori / Government of India

R3w4iiimq / Ministry of Mines *****

"PI New Delhi, Dated id November, 2018

To CPIO-Co-ord (Hqrs.) (Shri A.D. Selokar) Dy. Mineral Economist, Indian Bureau of Mines, Nagpur.


Ref: RTI application under Registration No. 2/130/2018-Pi dated 02.11.2018 of Shri Krishan Kishore, Jharkhand

Sir,

Please find enclosed herewith a copy of an RTI application received from Sluff Krishan Kishore, Jharkhand with Registration No. 2/130/2018-PI dated 02.11.2018. The information sought by the applicant relates to IBM. Therefore, the application' is transferred to IBM under sub-section (3) of Section 6 of RTI Act 2005 for further necessary action.


Alf (Adhir Kumar Malik)

Under Secretary & CPIO to the Govt. of India Tele No.-23384743, Email: attnallikenic.in

Copy to:

1. Sbri Krishan Kishor, Gram and Post Champi, Block Peterwar, District Bokaro, Jharkhand-829123 with the request that the further correspondence may be made with IBM.

CPIO, PI Cell w.r.t. their Registration No. 2/130/2018-PI dated 02.011.2018


MINISTRY OF MINES Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi

Dated: 26th November, 2018

To Shri Krishna Kishore,

Village and Post Champi,

Prakhand Petarwar, District Bokaro,

Jharkhand — 829123

Subject: Information sought under RTI Act, 2005. PI Cell, U.O. No. 2/130/2018-PI dated 02.11.2018.

With reference to your RTI application, PI Cell U.O. No. 2/130/2018-PI dated 02.11.2018, the

pVIIII-VVI)C icidly w kl*S.• 44. • ..."..--......._ ._

Information sought in point no

Reply

1, 5, 6 & 7 Pertains to IBM

2 The State Governments grant mineral concessions for the minerals located within their respective boundaries under the provisions of the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) (MMDR) Act, 1957 and the rules made there under

which may be accessed online at

https://ibm.gov.in/index.phOc=Pages&m=index&id=492

The details of auction of major mineral blocks may be accessed online at

https://mines.gov.in/ and also at 3

https://minesgov.in/writereaddata/Content/Successful%20Auction%20Details.pdf

So far 50 major mineral blocks have been auctioned in the country.

4 The MMDR Amendment Act, 2015 instituted the system of auctions for grant of mineral concessions for major minerals. This was aimed at bringing in transparency

and removing discretion in the grant of mineral concessions.

2. If you are not satisfied with reply / information, you may prefer an appeal to Shri Prithul

Kumar, Director and Appellate Authority, Ministry of Mines, Room No. 315 'D' Wing, Shastri Bhawan,


Yours faithfully,



Copy to:

i. Indian Bureau of Mines, with a request to provide information with respect to point no. 1, 5,

6 & 7 of the application to the applicant directly.

\A( PI Cell, U.O. No. 2/130/2018-PI dated 02.11.2018.

N .3iitr*T4- 3-Ttrffa, 2005 1:49'6iWfit/lOtie date 01.12.2018


aTRF 79 77

4.9101 34-4TRZT

i5sRT: Rzr:u-R-r 31ftr*R- .3-iftrftnr 2005 5 kaira Alta' 3fT I

arch LT* a-1W- -x`r r+-rt 3-47fra1 1WairaRr, rea-trzsrcrg * 25.10.2018 cam WP-ci aza-cm Ittg, * 3TT-4-CR- it4W 09.10.2018 51- cr7 Brzi 3-fta" Wr441-3" 9i-cp f*zrr ti

2. riz.40-ri .3ift(57-4- 311t1 rirtzirr 2005 e tIRT 6(3) 5 Wirt zit z a at kv-H-r fawn TR-wit wrzir-mT --s-r/ Te- 3111chi, 347T anrr #1. 31 T *). *Attu a:rzwrtr aritThth-triwrzfr-gzr arr- *r Frtrur zrzinfrcr aw 5 ft-A. S aftaz mr-araita• cfrial 1 retr mrr vrt al arc* *r aft aip-a- =Not arranc* g.

3. 3419-4:1 3171E7 t 1'5* tix4.1( .3-fitimif arittfp:i, 2005 5 ft -trait Wr .4 !CT 3Tra-CP: rT,T oi ITT fAttfta- Tratzr a wrzl-at art* I

1724/724k513iiti.-05/2018-19 f'-45 25.10.2018

1, (tra:rr

39w-dr .3rf4rwrti

Sh. A.K. MalliM.v. . 1r* tfrart .Ac /P1 Cell V.0 No. 2/129/2018-PI Dated 02.1 I.20 I 8

. •

'{AG /72-W.31ft.-05/ 2018-19

Rik) src,_ 2018

TIZTIT4 T491 3iftehltilr4 fl ufAct> X4114 trg, r4t,

611reil

*al A, Vfff 31tirT1t 2. S 7F-11 ST A.

Uri 71t1rg4 21TO. 11 CNC 1044 En Ukt

7.4 74 I 100-3f1 4”) $011,

5"Clerf I

leiir TJ 31ftTN-2005 TT 6TRI 6(3) S 3MIt'ff TOT 44064 4"(I q1A S 11974 41

he; 44. Virl; - C Ltd o Lit) A YI I ZATrt. 33rR10, =pm 74 0.1'4w:hi rat gtitor

7'1777-Jo? a =71655 ft9i-a- 17 3187Z, 2018 (nit tics TT IT-21 Tz4 TT Tie.: RATA

7-€ 31817 cfnit, IRE t PAI vimgivr 31 cnvil tZ. az.nri * 31-11t1 Trg Rik, 09-16-2018 T

ft3 tits4.0 01 *1 WIT 319 -kictfl. 1-1PTI totov. M<R4d $1

8Firairdl ,..T0t1 WS' 1:M MC1410( 'Ad 3TRifeczn. I sIRT 6(3) Ti 3M-47 ii3 C41717:rr 2.112I

tiferg 1:wzg n1 Tg t R-p arett-wgi igr 044i0 fir' 31.5*1 17 Rik) 09 376c4r, 2018 T ft3 ttall CI i•-1

316*-1 .qttrel aritiwt, Wr gAW 13471 IP) crn A7 0:ra-r4 tit w‘g wRigrel ardingrei

3170MTilt, TTC

rift tr-

3r17-)Th A-g urgwrfai

flWn ,trf I /..^ sf

M ,t1F1T ant ::,t.t4RTZT

#436T: /72-11011331R703110-2005/2018-19 oiraniR)d tifeeft1 : AirifAcr 704 74 &rum vital& tg erdi

1. ;Irciltu 7,74 76 Si'..Igik4)4 6TO, ‘3racd 46,81:11

2. 3n knClkikri NT 31 WW1 tt, Wt‘rtc:1. T1.3 9T affra WA twit(' 08 8mtien, 20-18 $ .4%7

trim i

tieRt, 1166-1

C11a> ntilf 31tRet. t«1.1;14

1 2 Tffireva rilsti MMDR A 4 It rif e Ammendm vt4 amfen Procl Free wm-Erft g-4R m-f4 aril* ms• Fit g-a,r- 4z4Eim mairiPr amt

Ct /957 aga ent qi

a---SW arjwrw-1 alktfrART W0 1328/V11-

1/2017/8 W1/16 Izt9j* 11-10-20t7 7'; allTRicam 174

WO 182s/V11-1 ' 2Ct 7 8 4r- 17-11-2017 SIM Pr-gm

mrt ik-arrazr, 9--wmg0.3

*pre. , n* T44, aTtgra41). year km ef*-4 mss.z-rft4 F447troa ummitow trevr

arm- 4-41w1‘55 /oero-ouito-loadtaargto os/llowf4oto/zom-19 Amiw nal-4w 2018

974417. 41 ir4w1 *I 3ifiROM Sart-2005 * ar--- 3K fe W-IT 3cre821" *

dpi W1-4 TOW-k7

3.1791M fittaj7w 3174 OW vrsta 1614/72- laWfOxit0-05/2018-19 ih

rm 09 SOW 2018 .318WWW *A Fr *kr *t 1kwth

gm 37/1)-amf 44 maim ftrem r-44 rla Ors-4 M 944 cm. Ft-re fiem 'RA gl

RTI/OCT//8,05 /NM i0-10-2018 4' Bit 7t4/ 1:4-1 Tro 01 V 05 ea ra-qy 317Raa WiT4

i 2018

t g-g Prefon,

'wpm 45-D-41 ft arytEamf 31ght OW tit*

09 3Z 2018 il BStW 1:4-tar 4 4/ arc 01 crl 02 a4 irtri/ y41 al arri 4 E413a la4r 34682 wee re) g , urr *OW la ai aNt

Itl pa a 311111

efkri t liecra ,t # f4-1 ?la at ati 02 0 i-497 77-/ #- 1 Willi VW

2009-1-31: %/boor & Mineral Regulation Act 1957 Trt97

rirrafkiff (MMDR Act IQ57)

Otithnrilifl erk *8 14•82/1 4 tr -,974-ct at* Teo tra ra* IW ia4 0 twm;r tiFzer m1r

cn

(5 ng1/2A at TM

—1715.7"

c?i t 017-frtd

A7--T4 ,240:r oh can' 21 cfri (-171

1 — WI t o

4/_ 2kq

4ktir-°. tvcsrat. 1-7 S° re :"eif

11213 -1- Ate

;TO

eldf . Off c.De

r_ cglcuptio75-- es,

al— for IP

--__, e a 1 41 i• C---

&Ph rp-JiretfoiTIG c, •

Pt° i- t'77,3d<1 Or ,3---,U1S-1

jig

obT>7 1 Otgi ni5i or tirciilowe (4 , r _r, t ---, -....„

5 *--wir 44,(0, 2R07c-c( friburre4 Nato/4.A oscs

• .i: yti OA M 0--. kef•

Fkrear it Warr L4_0410(1 4

.. tn-W-4157 chi, cpr)-i re, •tact- ovc

@ - 0,-)041 02m1 3W-- 3 are- go—WC TO" Millsbio-Ad- 1€717 * cY4A

cr-- P 6Th cas4 1-. uoi- to n - dri I A-nitchtutd" Z)-1- -3-i girtit--; cit•cil

eitieL isiTiVro (---__S op FP Iliite k-- ri---- ---F ::(6 iiwil al

t 04 I gitChn Piff i UN tr-R: ITC iferst PVIA pktkth fit_ l ia- te(Ti6sc al, HI ),---)

— PhorCiCkft;t:

PIC20^ PaPir4.- -i / ivi-eitel MatPlt

rei

er

.1)e nAtui-tini 1,211. a -)-/- )1 -e-za 4fri dito—RD

3ifer

„\11 I Vi Pk-0-94 et ci-c-tir) .51-6-ck Peiett,

t

fi=t k 0.i,d2tNi NH )t, j -• i4

Q v4-0 ?tics—Tirru...../141L, 4 .

a-, fir-cut tjetio.„-- dire, 0 it, or cm — e

f;?iii

stif lay

-76- ±1(C V

7 I tar TriLnglr tr,Th--- 77/Th 0,qcnicta— Ortr31:1(4:):17

14 t (1$3- orfr 'elr ci) ) f )

i+ 1;11 9(1

4.40 crriWIT2)-Cli TH

T.(7.1 _ q 1 I ef0

?TIT:mire/74m f

ire itc,r;.1

1 tor -din etiTT 0 ow-

a! 014- Su TM! 47 ) __.._

No. 16/02/2018-M-V1 31-Ica titctiii /Government of India

;MIMI* /Ministry of Mines ******

Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi Dated the December, 2018

To

Shri Jaipal Singh 31, Karzan Road Dehrailun Uttarakhand — 248 001

Subject: Seeking information under RTI Act, 2005. Sir,

I am to refer to your application dated 09.10.2018 received under transfer from Mining and Geology Unit, Govt. of Uttarakhand on the subject mentioned above and to inform you that the MMDR Act and the Rules made thereunder are in public domain. Necessary information regarding the amendments carried out in MMDR Act and Rules made thereunder may be obtained after going through them. These are also available in the website of Ministry of Mines i.e. mines.nic.in. 2.

In case, you are not satisfied with the information provided, you may prefer an appeal before First Appellate Authority Dr. Veena Kumari Dermal, Director, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi within the stipulated period under the provisions of the said Act.

Yours faithfully,


Phone No. 2338 4743

Copy for information to: CPIO, (21 Cell) IVI/o Mines, w.r.t U.O. No. 2/129/2018-pI dated 02.11.2018

tij.10-8 SeitiWIT 3ireci1*d:1, 2005

ratici faitylDue date 28.11.2018


aTTra"

&Hirt cH 41(444

014 arttrwrz 3iftrfk2m 2005 * ataah- crrca 311-1-4W

egra sfrt-da it-a* nil "1" T cry Trrzr 3 c wrzfrart SH-col t-gr

arftrwrt 33-ftrirxr, 2005 DIRT 6(3) th 3 o1gr-{ .ql 4idfl ark faqei 3-rni

at7r Trzrr h,erlt 3174-4w Tt-Ekra• titmlfl 3traeoi *r sr'Ra r Fitru zruretcr c 5 farii atra-t

0-1•00 t Ftrr FTwt 24 anaca, gar Tip-a- cmirn 3Tra3Z7w

3. 3iicr-A- 39tU f 4ty.401 3itrwR 34trfAtraT, 2005 *c cliii• Tr Erma q+tcl PT 4-P-1 rntnfta. Trni. W14-01$ tr

IPO No. 45F 77305)

Sh. A.K. Mallik, uson-voi t-4 ch c 11 311tiThlt

111311' taill Cell 13.0. No. 2/128/2018-PI %a/Dated 30.10.2018

F iti4INE.

ziprz 'rt \\c‘c\-5

4

' - -

fdaTallet

47/Eig

-<77267C (fent

fit,T2111,- {eta :Mfr.. "et .<--TrotrZej 7}>:

' rogre Trita-05VCC21)5) re.)-4E1

f--R4-51- 15 843-Z477( 71e9)-1 -Qv< -rtr-q-f-T

--i&i Z 34-Tiel/Azeirf wty

ze k9F-K

.7-77;-gqua :f90 ;33-1

zci,FT fee); 117- ( sq-99-- P315-

9

V/ -65e/

t)._ r-firre4R- CM;1-1 arber 77-4-4-gr

fiRccri • err-4

X4 FT

.Pv-PM -45?

r rv-Cfs, .Threircicr zet

--7)2„-

&270

94011

ilra -(7 car

3477P5 cr--09-C ) 342-

cb ,14

p5 S2 04 rvu) - gg Li 2 2-4,0 2

TlyaT TT 3TitteT 3litliWtp:T, 2005

fair'`car/Due date 23.11.2018


aiIra tlictifi

tglei

rargr: trail arTr*--R- arft)M-zrzr, 2005 * at-eata" Circa 3174-4W I

Sh. T. Velayudhan, R/o New Delhi * mr-E-cw fa-a* 23.10.2018 *t T4i tri *TM wrzt-ar. t-q icrf7.6, fd,err R-Er

2. +I:40-11 *r aarfA-tp:r, 2005 tr c-IRT 6(3) * .3i717 *aft /it tkr.roi +1.(441.1 74- op/ 117-4- tZ t a-6 .3.1Th-WrAft-g-4 3Trica" alter gnu U71 31T4-47 apt tied +Non' 31Th*Tel4h1 lielq mt, arraem *t CTIfeZziSr FT1lif ZaTTelIT #f5F 5 RA *2-fl-a7 r2r-mtafta- choir ,art.11 Ftrr fl aft a1 31"rd-cw1 aft Rp-64,tai, 317-a2iw t

3. .331-971 t t1:401 31t1W-17 3-litTi*zfacr, 2005 5 w-1 jr ylcrai r 5+14.( *1-4:1-dit Sr 7TCT I

rieidet: IRO No. 5 06 270249, 1B 507958 and 2 09 462850.

2.,A)0 ref)

.3T-Tswer 3rftrt1

Sh. A.K. Mallik. 1.151M-IV)/05reRT KTFT .4c 7P1 Cell (1.0. No. 2/127/2018-P1 fd-- */*Dated 29.10.2018

11-Zici'

a3 ./0.a48.

TA, at/ tarezi &Ire, in-qa-irrictiks, e{- -ries

A2a,tisby 4 M s tC4 C 152 vo\t" -

&At.) .4-p• 6 kepec a".4/ c fiar ,

)1(cyc -5\1\t

t.e.17 br.)qcrynast,p7-4) ma, R77 no-avg

Prer r /tray 4,1c • WnSidelt -,9"

02 • Covf r e4,7tararkai,614-- ltlo . to cox-- alb g •;1. le -9

iclec4-eatiel 4 cctLaeNte. .ate;) as Imoce) ylipphopt)

Act it Petal 4 Aue:3/4 /Cechy Dee-ca-wi Eopicoodeet) rittito

elm- ;yin/ etht-c? 4 Wacuzz a(p.C1 f4; eretie..frci /Ur

. udc, neat ( owe/ ofts42- e6 9c,. a ptcyow obs-c

2 oC39 •

t : )-

a) frula ckc r,c,..o Jeff 6 - door) not 4,44.Ati, a /127a,/iti.4

ka,m/aicitc I20v6A hadetn axicti 2A $r, a ricfry

14,23/ 4 MD l AC-t fraj CC/J.06-d ern9 SOCI tv lm tote-/') (4c

ariaiti; ecoar gar 66'1-/fre-tevt Zio PetWank, z1/03 cred2valtit,

to 507 75'9 9t, laateuvi acb 4 . /07( Vasa&

ILVe-5 61-7 (6 ileys:14i /Cale:WS eej crAt taPS-4-r-A •

IAna, Acceetv a ta cadv &pew e

raw -g (09Lcce• L" mit kyr-L.Y/4e nntaij ey?.vtze,%cbti •

t-- ti

Y6c4.36 it-evr/6- 1-12

ut, cam" -•

y ye' fiVii Dfrl AA/ nochvrgicel E44.14vC# I 1Ect-, DztA9 neje h

G1 /4)64/6 9 g7/e^ d7S-2 •


MINISTRY OF MINES

To, New Delhi, Date 8th November, 2018

Shri T. Velayudhan,

14 Munirka Enclave,

New Delhi — 110067

Subject: Information sought under RTI Act, 2005. PI Cell, U.O. No. 2/127/2018-PI dated 29.10.2018.

Sir,

I am directed to refer to your RTI application, PI Cell, U.O. No. 2/127/2018-PI dated 29.10.2018 and say that the information sought in the application is enclosed.

2. If you are not satisfied with reply / information, you may prefer an appeal to Shri

Prithul Kumar, Director and Appellate Authority, Ministry of Mines, Room No. 315 'D' Wing,

Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi within 30 days of receipt of information.

End: As above

Yours faithfully,

(A K Mall) CPIO/Under Secretary to the Govt. of India

Telephone No. 011-23384743 E-mail address: alc.na< Rich)

.94y to: PI Cell U.O. No. 2/127/2018-PI dated 29.10.2018.

3aFt-R 3a 41T, 2005

sizafr/Due date 23.11.2018 TIME BOUND/RTI MATTER

RR?

451101 61,11e1

3ftWit 3T N, 2005 *34-dilia' 31ra-CW

Department of Personnel and Training O.M. ita 15.10.2018 colii

Sh. Satish R Kate, Rio Mumbai c 3ria-CF fa-R* 04.10.2018 tr trq

472.T 31%7 aii4eits 1.41.41 1T W t

2. Nitta-if W• 3iftliWEP4, 2005 *T URI 6(3) t 3177 3:(Ptr Trt

70W rdwzr 3 orzr MThTel *RA ei4.4

Tr- Am' t at ag 3T91-s-rer,1 -474- 31-ra Trzrr 3.1t7 tEf4F. ÷Itchlti

3a1Welichktlei4i *t vfta artry zmnitu *%i 5 atrd-r

TP.Trarafta- mien 71t t Fur nr eft 4 341 W 31-rmzr t

3. 3Trcitf 317-Tott ektirir 31firt-R. aftWzrxr, 2005 11eri1 5TT Lucid

wrA llT 3+11/4“ iTS-Rd TMI wrzi-a-rt

dodo. O.M. No. 2/2/2018-RTIC/04550 dated 15.10.2018

Sh. A.K. Mallik. / t-471. cilcbTrp-dT

tif.30$ Am/PI Cell L; 0. No. 2i 126.1201 itFiWDated 25.10.2018

;cv 0411 tsto

ypirer 3rMwit1

•

No. 21.2:2018 RTIC,t4553.

Government of India

Ministry of Personnel. Public Grievances and Pensions

Department of Personnel and Training

IfiUdEDIATERTLMATTER

North Block. New Dell • ; •

OFFIQF MFMORANMJNI

Subject: Transfer of ?; T1 application uncer RTI Act, 2006

An RI I application of Satish R. Kate. dated 04.10.2018 Keg No. DOP8.17121.2016104550), received from Depadment of Pensions & Pensioners Welfare vide their fetter No. 4041FC12018.

09 10.2018. is being •rildsterreC to Ministry of Mines under Section 613) of the RTI Act, 2005. as the subject

matter of inform-Won its° pertains to the aforesaid public authority. The RTI Application has also been !my:aided

to the CPIO concemet of this Department to whom the information sought closely pertains.

End • as above yrol

(Er, Mohan: Under Sec:mien: m too Gott n,

Tel el' 2115:V14

To

( he CPIO. RTI COI Ministry. of Mines

Shastri Bhawan. Dr. R .iendra Prasad Road. New Delhi - 110 301.

oki sot: Shukdeo San. 1./.! DOPT

Copy toe intoonattot, to.-

Shn Satish R. Kate,

903. Bhakti Resident:

Plot No.6, Sector 11. Sommer: Nevi

LT Frit viciad Boar ziTazyi =dre Pt; e: • 3troer, zinTer*- 31treh 3en. e.11744. 311T ..TRIeTtl firm 3nt ?.nt, nefez 7.1'.T ertre iinty ;cm' irRartra. n t Dm. e., ftm Jr .1.

rata hT 1 ?to- irtrat enjeta far. ; •-•.‘ -. Flta irter d RfleviNevIT$ttrrenrc 3crya mI ena, 7ara taitTele = RT ;Pm 3eltg .ver ,•••:.1. ,:.;:- Im•c•ITT•r `bill grti 4 "- • .77e es; 3.144.1 cc;17Pirc;

etra sen(21... 3Tferazeit. aB-ai i.eYnerry t air en e .fic Mr4" 4 TF - tt000t - cors - 23092338 taw 3filtr r•••• ;

•

511% 404 /3Titt/_IYm3 ITT-fd t vet- 1(

IfW, t P14n4c1 1131ff tWq 3t1Z eivr9Thrft *Fr

cc

IPT6 1:14ff, Zififf cjcaw ftM1-110003, It9Ta 09.102018

plO, irn Cell DOPT North Block New Delhi-110001

Qn56° 5 gififi gitv:00 '

@Otielti \CCarCk\Cilcz)2°\ j. itilw

FORT : titis M-1 ZIRMR 4+1, 2005 * a6n dira cti ht77-1,

Rile* 09.10.2018 MI 3114WR a 2005 06c1 wir 1111?f Th-T4 Satish R. Kate t1 Tr) 31-*7 gair trqw et .s4 l T 15T SR. 31 ?q4, 2005 $1. EMT 6 (3) arrqng. 3TIEWf c-H-11 WI Vet tl 31TER1 3T ETt f iFM' tpill 3ftR 31ffift49, 2005 .7 1;10W-4.3M 31I7 Mc* 3,1t Wf:e475 airri 711Eft airt<9 gild utrareT wiz wt

2. steoPin ltzfl qTal t f 31Tkff 10/— •C=IIR 311#9' Tr ?OFT t i arldv aTlitot atiR c* m-r u-Mer -NAN nifa) aft 3114-49' eclo.) 31kitt4 rdV Thtisetet*Tintn-ni*i

Af 1. Sh. Satish R. Kate, Mumbai-400705, Maharashtra 31ftitf if* Tit14 Mt I

a ltc

W ej17-.7 x 19-XJ:

tits() 3TV a/

tc411 nITR 3afititt, 2005 reOef arfrWe

903, Bhakti Residency, Plot No.6, Sector-11, Sanpada, Navi Th) "RT 310E7 * ZIRT f41ireff utter StRi 3F9T

g?, se&e,D PosT

fro

Date. 4.10.2018 Ref: 04102018RTI

To, The Information Officer under RTI Act 2005 Ministry of Personnel, P msion and Pensioners Welfare,

Department of Pension ?.‘ Training, Khan Market,

New Delhi -110003

Subject: Re uest for followin Information Under RTI Act 2005

Dear Sir,

This is to request you to provide me following information:

The GOI has introduced a new Post/Pay Scale in Class -I, A, Category as Entry Grade/Scale though the Class-I A Posts were existing. Thus there became two Post/Scales Class-I (A) Entry Post/Scale and thence next post/Scale was named by Prefixing Sr. before name of that post. For example in Ministry pjISnes.the Class-I (A) Gazetted Post of Assistant Controller of Mines (ACOM) was traditionally existing since many years and was then an Entry Level Post. The next promotion Post was Dy. Controller of Mines. But then a post in between ACOM and

Dy.COM was created and named as Sr. Assistant Controller of Mines while the already existing

Class-I (A) Post/Scale of ACOM became an Entry Grade Class-I (A) Post/Scale. c.-.,1,08-4./bes•C .V‘i*C

1) Please let me know the Departmentslin which suchklevj Sr. Class -1 (A) Posts/ Scale have been introduced & then existing Class-I (A) Posts/Scales became Entry Grade

Class-I Posts/Scales.

2) The rationale, justification behind introduction of such new Sr. Post/Scale & terming the then existing Class-I Posts/Scales as Entry Grade Class-1 Posts/Scales.

3) While accepting and approving this new introduction and changes, a copy of GOI

Approval note for such changes be supplied. t '35-035-4 SC

As required, RTI Act fee of Rs.101- by Crossed ipti N ofi Dated 2o• )-19-is enclosed. €70,..cli, 4z S--/—

Thanking you and regards,

-S-Utish R. Kate 903 Bhakti Residency, Plot No.6, Sector 11,

Sanpada, Navi Mumbai - 400705 (Maharashtra) Mob: +91.7506511140

Email ID: sriSALTSliffmail.com

en^ avc fo 4 • /of-

LO1 C- g 3 3--035-4 43C-S 1$1716

Cr01 & c rc s Qrt

urnytizi Tec1.3-6

ebo C). st,Sz. -Pr treirfrivv -14.e.»,)

0\ 1-10.-) ) PepCoge. ini-rodwfd

Claas-T /A GAletkel eosi4;6-4 s A.-.1" Cs

44 ?b l.-(1 96- Cro 1 i .1C4 es SG •

No .31/13/2018-M.III gITTJ Nttehlt I Government of India

a1A' dittiwt / Ministry of Mines *****

New Delhi, Dated 2-‘ October, 2018

To CPIO-Co-ord (Hqrs.) (Ski A.D. Selokar) Dy. Mineral Economist, Indian Bureau of Mines, Nagpur.


Sir, Please find enclosed herewith a copy of RTI application received from Sh.

Satish R. Kate, Mumbai dated 04.10.2018 received at Ministry on 25.10.2018. The information sought by the applicant relates to IBM. Therefore, the application is

.-.4.A.:iratidetiSe-tanirr-nitibt;Vgaitkiiadc.S§ctiaaltffi7,4159frartattM?-:;:t• •%•:‘,:jf,n:.-?';,

necessary action. •


Ats,

(Adhir Kurnaraaallik) Under Secretarylc-CPIO txt""m'cr--- -413

Tele No. 23384743 Email: ak.mallik®nic.in

Copy to:

1. Sh. Satish It Kate, 903, Bhakti Residency, Plot No. 6, Sector 11, Sanpada, Navi Mumbai-400705 with the request that the further coxrespondence may be made with IBM.

CPIO, PI Cell w.r.t. their Registration No. 2/126/2018-PI dated 25.10.2018

I F.31414WIT 3TibMtp:r, 2005

facci ti/Due date 21.11.2018 TIME BOUND/RTI MATTER

3TR9 +1.(chk

gel: +kg .3fitTh-R 3nzir3T 2005 * afraira Mit'a" I

Ufa" cri 3W 1:4-347r tr-4-f 11.10.2018 saw iLd eft airy tt6- * .3•TftCR' flak 10.12.2016 mar TA- * TIM Tftd. Wrialt Cr9a' f~rr ar tI

2. twir 3.11twz .31M1=43437, 2005 T EMT 6(3) 3919-R- wit- 4-lid art rd-N--zr anr- <chi .F1 wrzliwzr Tsri Ram t at 4F 3rftsmfir, l'a#Tfer 33I T a-tal 77:rr t41 arrtr, tic:ad ÷lichirr 31ltrthttichigivi44 crftFr ITT zrzrrem #1t# 5 RA *Ft Ftn—Htafti chid' oittl azrr Tfr ITt a1 3Tra-CW -41 3ft #In'a arramw g-

3. aircr# 3TRttI t f wail Wr 31f 7 aritiWzr-F, 2005 k IW-zrait Liteirr cMc/ 6+11+4 atir" TITIZT 4 *.1 ar(T

74...-08-ij1aii-o4/2017/2567/trg.,ft, clich 11.10.2018

cfrxrr 34-1347-r 3rItrwrtr

Sh. A.K. Mallik, US(M-V0 / *-41-4 cilah4:7RT rf1.341t .2 R7P1 Cell O.O. No. 2/125/2018-PI itatW/Datecl 23.10.2018

znraug zizca-a gam faluai

sfagazI

0/54 tarcF-telo1'-i'o--08- yea-04 / 2017

*FRN, 7g9.9 IrCiftTWA

731T3 r ITCTRKWEli.

•1171

#4T 11. vfT ovir *T 1t ttttp-1 4‘311-all, %TRU tr.-N-411•Z • - .1:11-feter

Ti Feral t

faisni : wi-a41 air VitMR afar', 2005 Thni QTRT-6(3) irera TrIT

3nA4rr nutaf3u 4R4 41 IN'tx 41

WITT %Fix ?awl cNich-2700, fazli45-30.12.2016 7.1RT TiVni

PA1 Tin Piz 1.14.1 wt 70.9T 0S-1 et9t45-10.12.2016

17MTZI,

31444ii falsRWO q'CrJ 1 3T011;1 i tvgintitt earg

tR4t t ratrant-et ;WIZ% 3TR-011tr's ctr-1 31ritn attifa 0r4

Vf6EIT-757/ 2017 gTsi frifirett NITA rit it-qt.-03-02.04.2019 raf t I

:1111 11 TIMIug VP4 afldr71 ;171 7091. 31.0.q 45 3ffira

Ttarkt WiA i5r f1k4I itLIT rm t

3.1117 -1-Frat1 ; vrt 31T1it4 mat trttt-o4 trr Mtn;ebi T1;17

era mmt-:41 1:1-4.4ticttr -a AI 44 *tt wcti 4( -am

1

faralli1“1-7M.

1,0 r\‘' 'quirt zrFT Sit

TSPI ffraVITEILI

:4~re. e;:reznrrinor wOne

/ cfno,41-41.fra- (1 110 (( 1

12 (493 r

1W

'1

tr

24 8o 05/ RTI-05-87:16 307.4101 4 9020

31-47 TART tRTPUWIft ‘3e4)+1, WIN 74 lidN ffiNTIT

Wff tRift1it, PaYIRR. 4, 31R-113T, '441-834002

*iitsivt tp<cbk zi9-9- 7: taw Thing

/#4, R-1 I ch o . 19-- I /

ifrinr n-4-4rferwry afrezPi-2005 V16c1 ‘14e1&1 t4sr -41

34 t1 144tict) ftit lift <PI tiell fC4TW 10.112016 S

EiRT 6 (3) c 3ITTRIM Slci4 6toiciRcr cp,(a• arftET t gag! rait 3Tra-C 11t94 \i4Mt7 cbfla ...) Sr-emit ThIrt amm Th-v-4 Thjrr wrq

1,t7 1 V*0 10/ Off( g

390—zretrou

t „ni ;my- - .2"tel

al-cr( qTra-4-7W- •Ririr tr-4-erwrql

xes l rev Nenwort Mn

3TeR 11-4<4 et. -a? .V;TI gat

weifii, 0M cr4 1LevM LiTri

Atrra ZYZ174, t411,

fariP 9T ii a$ 5R au 2005 * c <r vr91 -atiroq 4771-4

TIZP!4,

cOW KiciiFRI 1-44?-1 LIR R-0.4* IRRi ;

"TM WTF4-1- 457Izi W1 W:cit VtiNI •

14-4ff Wit? Nftrch-r-41 -4314 .. TI;:14;.: Irrttf-. ,r

1 T[•ZSte Si &KC 4 -1WRA' .

it sit f-A-c:Rif '47-,M01

T

::1-1 •

str-40m -4 4it-,4-.Tr4 irrifari 7i5

Ki11-4 I

JA ft 2. 311Telt-

Wire.° iti)R.itipTA

11 t4 75702 t4 I

ti 3. MITK ,f141;:t4 1:%14314) 1901 airEliKt-Fit cFV.-) 1/4-4 octo

-is 3 -nitht -61{1. WIFF91 Wgilt T imegricar T 0.

16 I -0D-r

flZlT Wz.4

.scri prvisic,e3 wiaccur cr4 Ftwre f4IFIT4-(41 1988 31-F1Errnibre1 stai ;14

tik0 AI G3wwiNT 3 zel.STIF4t1 Vlid 1041 Writ

n112511hR4Z 181MCji W11;14-FT

f-1;17:.±R.P,

/ Cififtriliacci 3TIcr leaf 3Ta I

6 ngNAZ UltRTIFi tf*!: 1986 C ccitiwiTiam.

TATICERT TM WWI 77111191 Thz1 tri-474

WIZ' I

7 ltrai Itc:-fREpi-t, 7iwt-zrt1-41144/1,?1, PI.F11-1 ..ViY

411, taT4 T 7,11)(74ThW

tretTafq9 W-4:7 :3101 * rtct 1:141q1e1 RiN1 1116-a.:1 %.14. :Sit I i

R-62-1.1REIFI t 1114-41i9 Wit WRS.4 1:41:q I

(S2

;;. 'acid ifkr (441fiteit 311*-0 31R1-41.4 WI ark 1, 4)4 , „ 1-4511 loNvf 11-4T171Thl4' m ( tr4114-I, EFATRTR LEO ifffire cv;••\ Sirdtri7 tiR 4-11446-1 TA .gtar 31PT I

3ffi: *ihii 31-OLT 311;f1Tk,I -44tif>1413” vr-T. Trrft 12 "R aftrelartS fkzFrrgrisi e1Nr.4E5 tra! wciiT

ant titsn .3612 0t3293 ft,fiTh.. lop*? t irth 3T-4-r ctrmi 'g I

fta min-loll; allo rico : IIRtzt erFk

.0"1,10•••

41,t1 err I 7 31f d+'R adtfazar, 2005

<id fat/I/Due date 15.11.2018


3T1Ta- (itchit

4.9101 fl-1,11c-4e1

faqen T-1011 Wr 3a1-th-TT ST, 2005 3ta-41W 31*R" I

Director, M/s Central News Agency Pvt. Ltd., Delhi * .3.11'4a7 ItF*

12.10.2018 --r ti TIM 31%a. WltaTt t7) Ut cici 441 a-r tl

2. +I:401i Wr 31MT77 aP7, 2005 *r Urn 6(3) * 317TT 3:1i2ft Tit

+1U o11 W" 411 .71$1

R:Pft.“at r6 areitrwt , 31-rtd7 air arra' t 3ltia7 +lead 2-NchlA)

3ffeWittichl Ic44 suckg grita tt Frtrur zrzl-Nitu elPori 5 fk-KI j attar

rinraftachtPIIaFft 'tt art afra-cw aft .31-ra3zr- t-

3. 3111M 3i 1g7 t f tiz-1011 31MW-{ Si, 2005 44d-i 41 Mel

mtcl fi atitit %aft ##zr wRkrt r.7rcr

IPO No. 18G 289747 WiNe

yOF fs,

6 r' tk° ey IS . \

*Th e) \I •

Sh. Yogesh R. Patel. US(Admin /

111311$ .t1R7P1 Cell U.O. No. 2/124/2018-P1 ittWIDated 17.10.2018

•_ •-,-

3T,a-Tra-r arftrwth

Central News Agency Private Limited

Lk 2r...in. cre:::81 JP: N t: I I 6(/5!, I •Ir tr• " ; I ; 41'4 I F.:- .:3C200:16

October 12, 2018

CPIO Ministry of Mines R.No.D-303 Shastri Shawar New Delhi - 110001

Request for Information under RTI Act-2005 with respect to purchase of newspapers & Magazines

Dear Sir,

We have been supplying newspapers and magazines to the Library and Officers of M/o Mines at Shastri Bhawan since the last few years.

An amount of Rs 14789.00 was sanctioned against our outstanding bills for the supply of newspapers/magazines in 2014 (letter enclosed) but no payment was received against this sanction.

Despite repeated reminders in the form of letters (listed below) as well as verbal communication and personal visit by our representative, we have not received the payment of these bills till date.

1. Reminder dated 10/08/2014 2. Letter no.N/1433 dated 03/12/2015 3. Reminder dated 09/06/2016 4. Letter no, N/921 dated 25/09/2017 5. Reminder dated 08/02/2018 6. Letter dated 12/06/2028

"'; : !TOE)! I'•i

ni IND? GROU

1936-2011

Central News Agency Private Limited entt-cription Department tEllcx.fhancletvalan F.:mermen. Now Delhi 110055 Meet. .91 11 41541111 Fax *91 I I .3626036 L matt: substiettuicoin Website. rna.co in

In view of the fact that no response has been received from the concerned officials in the Department, We would like to seek the following information:

1. If the above bills have been paid, the complete details for the payment made including cheque number, cheque date, drawee bank and the date of encashment of cheque from your bank or if transferred directly to our account, then the NEFT details.

2. If the above bills have not been paid, the reason for the same.

A'postal order no. 186 289747 for Rupees Twenty is enclosed towards the requisite RTI fee.

Thanking you,

Yours sincerely, for Central News Agency Pvt Ltd

( Director )

fiegutextxt Office : P 20. Connaught Cocos. New Delhi 110 001 CIN No : U741400L1971PT0005499

C---)-4

n -r,

, Qo i4,:arc Q014

er244-5

3°°P1 41.2oci-To WA'.

:TRW iitcmi

ZITR" 4421144

ne•JA - atnc. ki en I Lb

Y 11 ceinz h nil?, C-40 er I :gad Joel ,v

Sif

aar kM r' (R1 . a .., 46„. g..n) Li 4 • 1 in -17 atogii

Rim Pt' snitch! Fchti? °urn it I fa/P47: 'W/ (r.1 al fanicm wat

1 C ) (1 s

PI rig

1A-1-.N..(7.t.(\

_ IL .-o\\ A- "Ai •yk le•I V I Si eri / /.2.. .qr— oh In -1.---

iV. 111.

Q.-k. XI -....0 1......_,— lei. on cc i el &1 w, e ej 6' V.

VI. _ -- .H----__(k-____

c-i ?A e VII. aff t 21 • yl VII. )x. - X. XL

XII. 1

XIII.

XIV.

XV.

XVI.

Gr',Fi .2 , .

Er.4 TA 4-15 WTI 41. 67 et, 2irzwr ergs '3451v-I el44 a n (VW qit*)-00.090- a•;TRq(.fiuT sl'ilk)-13 WA. ifi-gZ1- 13.01.13 16 1FF MR' WV I

n11-1613 (17.k. SW)

, gRa 2144tili stFntd(k;:-

1. I)i-Fer fl eir-dr a um dilevizi, el)q, atict) acad.. .7*W-it 1

1....

..., --------12. tars' 3.33744

CA11E01.1(7 SYRIAN HANK 1.1) a3t, CONNAUGIrr CIRCUS, NMI' 010.1 /1-

011-23328747 YES

wit:CATHOLIC SYRIAN HANK I TO

For The Ca yrian Bank Ltd. : ?Vt. Lib.

p lank's Suunp) • Date:

°I IC) /11 'fled Office P - 20, Connaught Circus, New De!h: 110 001

°gran r t......

sierglioniorvuswificr.

r ••-

-,:ehtranNitiAisylnited--- ubsaiptionE.1/21eartment

4€,/15, Jhandewalan Extension, New Delhi - 11005$ hone: +91 /1 41541111 Fax: +9] 11 23626036 -mail: subsOcna.co.m, eresointesecna coin WebsIte: hltp://ttame.cna.

coln . • •

Deptt of Mines & Metals

The Under Secretary

101-17' Wing, Shashi Ethawan New Delhi-I 10001

Dear Sir,

. • Our bank detail are as follows : .

A ottrrAil, OFACCOUNT HOLDER: I-NAF.140E Ai:COI:NI HOLDER • COF4131 I 11 aismer Aouttr:BS

TE/ .EP I roNENUMBER/VA &MAIL

-.7 NAL MA.141t/1 A CCOUNI NU1141110a____

11, BANK ACCOUNT' DETAILS:

HANK NAME

DRANCI NAME WITH COMPLETE ADDRESS -. •••• •

110001 L2EallofeE NUMBITANI) EMAIL

wrii:Tri Wit '11,11; BRANCH Iii•OMPIJT-IIRISED? WI IETI II/12 "1/ 111 BR:VA:II IS 12,11./S !NAM lift IF 1111:14 MIA 1 IS WE 13RNCLFS

t!.S Y71E IIRAN.211 ALSO NEXT ENAISI,ED? " .—___... _ F

. , sifitraist

c- s AL-1611

CSI3K0000205 1 YES

;ANTRAL NI:WS AGINCY ,_ P-20 CONNAtkiPT CiReCis.NI 1-3-1T/Irl 104:1 1 0 I-41541111. h

AA/V.04233C arc 011-23626WIE,SW..12.3

•• i MICR CODE OF

//NEE OE p.prEcr. • . fiStt Code

020500566721195001 11004700?. . . IMMEDIATELY

60702H ! hen:tri *ChM: that thy, pa:tit:tikes. Ids.

un'nbuvr we wheat and complele If thy iransaction Beim or nal

---- r effected at for reason of iniximpkt: or incorrect inlOrmation would nor hold the user instruciimi responsible. I

sditint. hove Fend the option invitation letter 214 agree in discharge revonsibili!y r.":,!X•eled of mum a roniei punt Int Pr- .r*

• Fcr CENTRAL NEV.12 AC:ENCY ?VT. LTD.

• , • . .. • ............................ ' bah:: 3W0 149013

S g131.4acioltthielpiCrattal. Cot filled th at the

particular furnished above arc cnribi as per our mcards.

1`16 -6o

184 ----cr0

120 --cro

NO-0- CO

144 - cr-0

S4 --cry

124 --di)

140--cr0

--Oia

1411---0-0

132--0-0

138 2.0,

11*---r-ro

--se, 12

at- co

11 -et 12- ci

1,24 i 1 -.•--c•P-c;$

t2.0

132---fro

z• 1.3 •

1/4: 5

I •

.

! a •

- rt. . II •

12 •

I RI. rc'

. •

,a,

i 2.e, Let - !

22-

12.5. 21.7 •

2.6 •

!Pa- •

-

It21'

tap -

0 I • 3 2

'.33'

$.3),

14S5-• 1,36.

PI%

;zei.

Vi• 1

o (-1

42 ,

L11.

19 11•

SC

QC. 6.S!.319 E'1- 2o12_

9134V-I - -244. 5•31 Mai -

1/4 -8-2061 53 1164 - 4--1-20.11 face") --€-1-loll PCS • 61`1190 - -8 -201

6205-(6 .

62321-K 1-ro-20/1

6275-461-i - -2611

4628641-1 eS1361 6-1-2012_ _

6311082 - M 22012 trz - 3C4 3-3-2011 <4 •

43'4513 -31-3-241 •

GC 1153 - 4-5"-1442- 5.3188cf 4-1-2pc,9 sc, •

534c3G C • niicq 531814

542448 - r*:0

51-1 50-12

5653.) -4-2-20to 5vi 0183- S-3-201 Sq 31-3- Si 'ass" -14-‘-2a

6q-9.31 - 5"-

Satc1,51- 6-04651 (rums - 6 -1-2o1

St( 0029 -- 107.e1

512425 - .6-11-200

5c1 ,361 - -12- -.24

5-9 6.6 59"o - 2011

Gool - 5-2:2011

603953-T-1-2ot

60 G 1 Li 9 -0 -1 -2mi

6016E6

C oaa - 4-G toll

6 iciogl

611-168 - c-8-acIr

6 40 148 - 6-5-701

6?-32-114- 1-10-20

c • c •

62:5-`114 it

(2 -12.2"11130 ---era

- r ci-

A \ t•PrzelSkT an (7-; 4 21.47-1 too'

7,

'GI'S Pi

2rEct(÷F,- 566 toti 2009 trit 2001

2009 c-Vei 2041 Ette 2.011 qtr 2.0ti (2e 11

If1'4--a< 20 I I

2.•:•

14-c-fr1/4"Kr 201 I 61-full'

2.42. rer 2-o 12.-

elelY 2-oi

Cr„ a .7-oay

Elterirth2,20 5.t "FT 2089

cej

ificit.gZ 2099 diro-ca .2•2; a ci

IZe e--z 2.0.1 cm-rtaq. Zeno wiCor•f4 2010

•a-f I .2-010

-61Yer 2-etc

.9-ow CarT

ts-I 2010 cITE 2010 K-ET Zoi a

R 1d 2olo

7,1°1-49,47, 2010

ct.}47e .2.o I

0.51-10,4 zott

-‘ve-ciQ 3.0 Li alici 2.) I -26b-il 4 1° f

oars 20 I I

c•cl:E.2.0

7.otet-c7 20 t

a-Icy-Tao It

levNT,2.€7? I

0-10‘)-e-K 2 a t t

I,

I'

1

11

111 1k-pR.eincLE

71

.1 )

• •

I •

1 1

7,

17

,1

I)

1,/

I)

1,

'I

.4 - aiew•a • er cnitcr

.cI

41- "Zino -1-200 a- "

1/49‘ 334511- k-S-2o09 a •

tit. 5311So ---11-1-2co9 • io • 53411'1 — 1-10-.2frG 4: •

51. gLi 243 I --S.-II-260'i 4‘.7

52- • 4aS1-1 (•-12.-2007 -a •

ca • fitl-Cq't -I-2o / 0 a •

5k- 569311 1t-1-24go

cc • 57090- — C. •

613641 31-3 2010 a •

544 • 516620 i1-C-2b/a ' 58• 1,303 --4-6-200

59 58140 2 --- 4cl2de a.

Go • 134436 6-8-201 • A -

Cl. 1333 C-41-2-00 •

62,• 1-Int10 a •

63 2419 --&--11-240 44-

ar-t• 93531/46 —4-12-- 2s/la

65". thss' q- 1 -2A5 I

4C. 6132. i

03458 ----I's-2o

68. 60143( -- 31-3.2011

Gel • 065.2. ---5-0?-2 11 90. 6123514 —4 -6-2011

'II' 615045 1-2011 12- C...9 -20 I 61-nin 12 • 620110 4-1-201i 14. 6232-0o io

9S-• 6.24- 110 II 2o11

16- 246 ---'c7•-12-t.11 631324—•6-1 -2011

use'

2.2c— fp e0

2-Cg— ca c— co

230— cro

264---CO

284"--an Vto — 2,80.—eo

366— GM

31-10—cr0

2-00—CO

2.9 59.--41:0 cro

2.010 —n)

2no — co 2.cfo —cc

300—n 240—00 380 8,10—•01, at:S..-- CD

324 —at 23o— c0

320 ""'00

36e15-0

'a-' Zwai 41-.J. -cinC(..-Arna) crlIk 2.009

riru Wei 2-co9 Pcie18-47 .2009

1,14-LC,R 2005

--IdlYGR 2 cogs

itatiritg 2001

CA--tcla -tato

"•,4-9Z4 2010

-.142-oLe

2-1.%%raT 24,10 frE 2010

tg-rf. 2at o

je:s7ri .22 obiloo

4king-2410

letoe-S.OR aolo

—fete-1Z 2010

(4-1).-crt.

0-1-vvell .2611

ti.0 0R9 2e II

5-11-4 20 it

2/1.5-c-1-_1001

4-4 2-o ht .2.0 I i

tiank 2011

R-E7 3011

12161-62. A o 'Z'Ine_ciZ -14%)-0R 2.13 11

0 z1Kir Zo 1 I

‘c •

.; • a •

11

,7

'I

I.

1,

It

II 111

11

÷1,T.I 011 W. 3iitfTR 31 di, 2005

Pqmiti fait/Due date 15.11.2018

TIME BOLINO/RTI MATTER

iitchR

(gIcel <1-1,11e141

tioll 31itiWR 3rftriAzIR,2005 .3.174a' AFFT 331 e1 I

Department of Personnel & Training 31Tt7 fa-Ft* 10.10.2018

crria• Dr. A.K. Chatterjee, Rio Nagpur 331-4-C7 sitt* 15.09.2018

TEM 3-fta" *faart f-4,411 71 r Si

2. t1:4011 ST 311bWr{ 3arrA7P4, 2005 *t tiRr 6(3) ** 3T-TITT #Rft rrt

*T ibrzr araf TRThltf *

TIVOZ t at a Sr, fA-4:r+-t 3U t ear Trar t ttr 3rr-a-4eT*r ÷isiMd TRrer

31ThWItichicileiO4 I, 3TtaR" crrfeFr Fitful # zrumircr`i%-R* 5 fad) * grat

Turatafta mto11 0.1(41 S azir nr art gr 317 *t Str i.Sa crioil 3T1-d3r* S I

3. 3Trcr# 3911T t f*' tizair 3Titrth-17 3ritrFazrxr, 2005 q+.44-1 lama

eni(1 Itftse{F 1:17:RT 77-frirt 71 I

rieldd: Copy of DoPT's Order No. A8-14017/6/2018-Estt. (RR)/00377/Appeal/2018

dated 10.10.2018

Ar, (m-1t Ito 3T-Trir Sr

Sit R.R. Mandal, SO(M-111/ kcrt- fzr eik' #71' 3at*T#

rit.strt .#F1P1 Cell U.O. No. 2/123/2018-P1 fc-A1-- /Dated 17.10.2018

RTI MATTER By Registered Post

. AB-14017/6/2018-Esft. (RR)/00377/Appeal/2018 Government of India

stry of Personnel Public Grievances and Pensions Department of Personnel & Training

AM

Room No. 278-B North. Block New Delhi Dated: October [0, 2018

f. : TrArW:7R-Ti

I rtiqi.: "-WI. wit itat

4 r PIPT f

200 Lt ?-4-7 rztyar

ORDER

Subject: Appeal under Right to Information Act, 2005. Appellant: Dr. A.K. Chatterjee, Ex. Addl. DO, GSI, Uttarayan, 8 C, Tilak Nagar, Nagpur-

4400010

Appeal against Reply of CPIO & US Estt. (RR), dated 30.08.2018.

I have perused your R11 query dated 6-8-2018 soliciting information on following

points:

In the context of DoPT's OMs of 24-3-2009 and reminder dated 17-3-2016 on the subject of "Sixth Central Pay Canimission's recommendations - revision of pay scales -amendment of Service Rules/Recruitment Rules",

(i) Correspondence 'with DoPT by 051 and Mk Mines regarding the post of ADG (HAG) -

(ii) Whether GP of Rs. 12000/- is applicable to above post in the context of above OMs of DoPT;

(iii) Any reminders by DoPT after 17-3-2016; (iv) Action by DoPT against ministries for non-complance; (v) Copy of sample RR for any post with Rs. 12000/

i GP HAG level.

2. It is noted that CPIO (US(RR), DoPT vide letter dated 30-8-2018 replied as under:

Point No. 1 & 5: Since single file system is followed in Estt. (RR) DoPT by which comments/views of DoPT are written on the file of referral ministry itself and the file is returned to the Administrative Ministries; copies of correspondence is not retained in DoPT and hence desired information is not available. DoPT (Estt. (RR) does not keep copies of any.

RRs for any post in the ministries/departments and hence the desired information is not

available with the CPIO.

Point No.2: Query is clarificatory in nature and in the RTI Act CPIO is required to furnish only material information available in his custody and clarifications on hypothetical case is not covered under the BM Act. The CPIO has no information as sought in his custody.

Point No. 3 & 4: DoPT as nodal department frames/lay down guidelines/instructions on personal matters. These are implemented by ministries/departments with whom the facts of the case/details are available. CPIO has provided copies of OMs issued by DoPT after 17-3-2016 i.e. OM dated 9-8-16, 18-1-2017, 22-12-2017, 29-1-2018 and 25-7-2018 requesting

ri r 150 W

5°

administrative ministries to amend/update RRs/SRs etc. CPIO has further conveyed to you that it is the responsibility of ministries/department to carry out the process of amendments as requested by DoPT.

3. In your First Appeal dated 15-9-2018, you have raised the following points:

Point No. 1: You have stated that 051 is supposed to revise RRs after issue of OMs and reminders by DoPT and you have sought copies of correspondence by GSI and Ministry of Mines with DoPT. Point No. 2 you have appealed that you have only sought "whether GP of Rs. 12000/- was applicable to HAG grade of ADG in the GSI. Point No. 3 you have sought copies of reminders sent by DoPT but CPIO's reply is non- committal. Point No. 4 You have sought whether any action was initiated by DoPT against ministries for non-Compliance. Reply of CPIO is not satisfactory. Point No. 5 CPIO did not reply at all.

4. After perusal of your RTI Query, CPIO's reply and your First Appeal, the following order, point-wise, is issued:

A) The applicant has enclosed a postal order of Rs. 10/- with First Appeal, which is not required under the RTI Act. Hence,, the .postal order is returned herewith to the Applicant.

Point No. 1:

CPIO has clearly informed that in view of the Single File System followed in Estt. (RR), copies of Correspondence are not available in his record. Under the RTI Act, CPIO is required to provide material information available with him and he is not expected to provide any information on the non-existing material. Since the Ministry of Mines is administratively concerned with GS! and is repository of all information in this regard, a copy each of RTI query and Appeal are forwarded hereby to the CPIO, Ministry of Mines to provide information, if any, directly to the Applicant, in this regard.

Point No. 2:

To provide information on this point, the CPIO is required to study the relevant OMs of DoPT, RRs of the post of ADO (Geology), GSI (Which is not with the CPIO), analyze the record, form a opinion and then convey the answer to the Applicant. Under the RTI Act, CPIO is required to provide material information available with him and he is not required to provide any answer/reply/opinion on the non-existing material. Since the Ministry of Mines is administratively concerned with GSI and is repository of all information in this regard, a copy each of the RTI query and Appeal are forwarded to CPIO, Ministry of Mines to provide information, if any, directly to the Applicant, in this regard.

Point No. 3:

CPIO has already provided to the Applicant, copies of OMs issued by DoPT after 17-3-2016 as available in the relevant file on the subject. 3 OMs on the subject of

2

No. AB.14017/61/2008-Estt. (RR)/Pt. Government of India

Ministry of Personnel, Publip Grievances and Pensions Department of Personnel and Training

Dated 8th July, 2011 New Delhi

OFFICE NiEMORANDUttli.

Subject:- Sixth Central Pay Commission's recommendations amendment of Service Rules ** - regarding

• This Department in dm No.A131401//6112008-Estt(RR) dated

24.3.2009 issued the guidelines for amendment, of Service

Rules/Ftecruitrnent Rules for incorporating the changes arising out of 6th

CPC recommendations. Separately the revised eligibility conditions for SAG & HAG level for members of Organized Group A Services have been

issued in this. Department OMs dated(Non-Technical) and

18.01.2011 (Engineering Services). The. provisions with regard to grant of functional scale of Rs. 14300-18300 (pre-revised) to the SEs and equivalent in respect of Engineering Services prescribed in OM dated 29.12.2010 also refers. Instructions for grant of NFU as per e

h CPC

recommendations have been issued in OM dated 24.4.09

2. As the Recruitment Rules/Service Rules are required to be

amended after incorporating the above instructions, all the

• Ministries/Departments/Cadre Controlling Authorities of Organized Group

'A' Services may take immediate necessary *action for notification of

Service Rules positively by 31.3.2012 in consultation with DOPT/UPSC &

Ministry of Law.

3. Hindi version will follow. (Smithumar) '-

Director (Estt. I) Tel. 2309 2479

To All cadre controlling authorities of Organized Group 'A' Services • •

No 'S.

.. --I

. . . .. . • .1.-,. ....: 14

1.11(tt*C•t.t.t, • • -0? ,..... '. .

ilLoy I Olaf, r 4'

li

'I

IIPS-tfl'air•-•••••••••

•

•

-2-

OM No. AB.14017/61/2008-Estt. (RR)/Pt. dated 8th July, 2011

Copy to:-

1. All Ministries/Departments of Government of India 2. The President's Secretariat, New Delhi. 3. The Vice-President's Secretariat, New Delhi 4. The Prime Minister's Office, New Delhi. 5. The Cabinet Secretariat, New Deihl. 6. The ComPtrollerand Auditor General of India, New Delhi. 7. The Union Public Service Commission, New Delhi. • 8. The Rajya Sabha Secretariat, New Delhi. 9. The Lok Sabha Secretariat, New Delhi. 10.All Attached Offices under the Ministry of Personnel,

Public Grievances and Pensions. 11. Establishment Officer and Secretary, ACC (10 copies). 12.All Officers and Sections in the Department of Personnel

& Training. 13.Secretary, Staff Side, National Council (JCM), 13-C,

Ferozeshah Road, New Delhi 14.All Staff Members of National Council (JCM) 15,All Staff Members of the Departmental Council (JCM),

Ministry of Personnel, PG and Pensions 16. Establishment (RR Division) (100 copies) 17. MC, North Brock for posting on the website.

• (Smita umar)

Director (Estt. I)

No. AB.14.017/61/2008-Estt. (RR) Government of India

Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions Department of Personnel and Training

New Delhi

• Dated 12th March 2010

,OFFICE MEMORANDUM

Subject:- Sixth Central-Pay Commission's recommendations - revision of pay scales- amendment of Service Rules/Recruitment Rules

The undersigned is directed to invite reference to this Department's OM of even number dated 24th March, 2009 on the above subject. 2. In the Annexure to the said OM, following grades may be revised..as under-

aCo. From I 6

To

1900

Minimum qualifying service

3 years 1. 1800 25. 10000 HAG 3 years 26. HAG •HAG t scale 1 year 27. HAG Apex scale 2 years

3. Hindi version will follow.

aidyanathan) Deputy Secretary to the Gov nment of India

23092112 To

•,---at.-;:1 Ministries/Departments of Government of India

Ar.'''

1L-5,, i, The President's Secretariat, New Delhi. . 3AThe Vice-President's Secretariat, New Delhi

. The Prime •Minister's Office, New Delhi. •:,-0, C..--5". , The Cabinet Secretariat, New Delhi. • •••;, ..

5

g. (SO •\":- Tie Comptroller and Auditor General of India, New Delhi. I,

7 t .: t. ck \ k s , al _ 070.::- j<c:Ffil Union Public Service Commission, New Delhi. •!.. e .-: - ,•• •• '1/4

• 14, --...:e7-- ..,--

the entries pertaining to the •

-2-

No. AB.14017/61/2008-Esti (RR) dated 12th March, 2010

Copy 4.41-7 The Rajya Sabha Secretariat, New Delhi. he Lok Sabha Secretariat, New Delhi.

All Attached Offices under the Ministry of Personnel, public Grievances and Pensions.

Establishment Officer and Secretary, ACC (10 copies). 5. All Officers and Sections in the Department of Personnel

& Training . 6. Secretary, Staff Side, National Council (JCM), 13-C,

roaeshah Road, New Delhi II Staff Members of National Council (JCM)

Ail Staff Members of the Departmental Council (JCM), Ministry of Personnel, PG and Pensions

. ,Fstablishment (RR Division) (50 copies) NIC, North Block for posting on the virebsite

3/4 /

(J.A. lyanathan) Deputy Secretary to the Gove I ent of India

23092112

.1. •• '11- \

No. AB.14017761 /2008-Estt. (RR)/Pt. Government of India

Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions Department of Personnel and Training

New Delhi

Dated 15th December, 2009

OFFICE MEMORANDUM

Subject:- Sixth Central Pay Commission's recommendations —amendment of Service Rules - regarding

***

This Department in OM No.AB14017/61/2008-Estt(RR) dated 24.3.2009 issued the guidelines for amendment of Service Rules/Recruitment Rules for incorporating the changes arising out of 6th CPC recommendations.

2. The 61h CPC have also recommended for bringing uniformity in eligibility criteria across various organized Group A Services for promotions. The issue has been examined and in the light of these, it has been decided that the following steps to amend the existing Service Rules shall be undertaken on priority basis:

(i) For promotion to SAG level, the eligibility requirement shall be

" Officers in the JAG with 8 years' regular service in the grade including NFSG OR Officers with 17 years' regular service in Group 'A' posts in the service out of which at/east 4 years' regular service should be in the JAG (including service rendered in the NFSG of the JAG."

(ii) For promotion to HAG level, the eligibility requirement shall be

" Officers in the SAG with 3 years' regular service in the grade OR Officers with 25 years' regular service in Group A' posts in the service out of which atleast 1 year: regular service should be in the SAG."

-2-

3. The cadre controlling authorities of the various Organized Group A

Services may initiate action for appropriate amendments in the Service

Rules.

4. Hindi version will follow.

To

44114-rY- (A I o k Ranj ) Director (E I)

Tel. 2309 2479

cadre controlling authorities of Organized Group 'A'

Services

Copy to:-

All Ministries/Departments of Government of India he President's Secretariat, New Delhi.

.-k, The Vice-President's Secretariat, New Delhi

- .-< .,he Prime Ministers Office, New Delhi. „...-The Cabinet Secretariat, New Delhi.

•b,\--(6. The Comptroller and Auditor General of India, New Delhi.

-. The Union Public Service Commission, New Delhi. 8. he Rajya Sabha Secretariat, New Delhi.

ee. The Lok Sabha Secretariat, New Delhi.

v4)1-0.All Attached Offices under the Ministry of Personnel, • ,

bblic Grievances and Pensions. Establishment Officer and Secretary, copies).

12.All Offiders and Sections in the Department of Personnel & Training.

Vf3. Secretary, Staff Side, National Council (JCM), 13-C, Ferozeshah Road, New Delhi

.AII Staff Members of National Council (JCM)

✓15 All Staff Members of the Departmental Council (JCM),

Ministry of Personnel,. PG and Pensions / Establishment (RR Division) (100 copies)

17. NIC, North Block for posting on the website.

(A ok Rani n) Director (E I)

Tel. 2309 2479

0

dder-

ficerceler'egrs;

From

Dr A.K. Chatterjee

Ex Addl Director General, GSI, Uttarayan, 8 C, Tilak Nagar, Nagpur 440 010

e1 /4-rect 14144V0

" RTI MATTER TIME LIMIT

No 136dd. / AKC / 2018

Reference:- Letter no. AB-1.4017 3 2018. Estt Prakasam Under Secreta Sir/ Madam,

I am to kindly refer to (a) DoPT OM No. AB.14017/61/2008-Estt. (RR) dated • 24.03.2009 and (b) DoPT Reminder vide OM No. AB.14017/61/2008-Estt. (RR) dated 17.03.2016 and my RTI application no. 136d/ AKC / 2018 dated 06/08/2018 (copy enclosed).

I had in my RTI O.A. dated 6.08.2018 requested for information solely regarding the VI Pay Commission OM's of the DoPT

assigning the Grade Pay of Rs 10,000=00 for the HAG Grade in GSI, under the Ministry of Mines. The requisite information was not provided and hence this first appeal.

(1) VReferring

Commission,tothe a above

whereincited theDoPT

RR's . Mw.

were e ' s( as) uapnpdos( be )d above,

tobe revisedrelated byto

thethe

Geological Survey of India under the silpeaterjilen e of e Ministry of

Miswith new Grade Pays for the posts, including that of Additional Director General (Geology) (HAG) (PB-5), it was requested to please provide information with copies of letters on any such correspondence initiated by the GS' /Ministry of Mines with the DoPT for revision of RR's for the post of ADG (Geology)

Sub'ect.- first A eal under the RTI Act 2005

RR and CPIO DoPT New Delhi

dtd 30.08.18 from Mr K

vs(1) 0244,40An7 ace °

To A91 No; o3135 .

Ms G.Jayanthi, FAA „icy: Joint Secretary(E.I) intazninia pc, aid

D/o.Personnel & Training yip fri North Block New Delhi 110001 #fli

Dated 15th September 2018

Copies of RR's were not asked for but only copies of correspondence were sought.

(2) Please inform as per DoPT extant pM's whether the Grade Pay of Rs 12,000/- per month is applicable to the post of Additional Director General (Geology) of the Geological Survey of India, as per the DoPT O.M.'s cited above in sl.nos. (a) and (b)?

This question is not clarificatory, but an answer was sought as to based on the

OM's of the DoPT cited above,: whether the GP of Rs 12,000 was applicable to the HAG Grade of ADG (Geology) in the 651.

b\(3) It was asked as to after the I IM. No. B.14017/61/2008-Estt. (RR)--) dated 17.03.2016, relating to the VI Fiay Commission, has the DoPT issued• any further reminders to the indiiidual Ministries/ Attached Offices/ Subordinate Departments for necessary compliance. If so, copies/ copy of such letters/correspondence may please be sent. But the reply by the CPIO is non committal.

(4) It was sought to know as to whether any action been initiated by the DoPT against the individual Ministries/ Attached Offices/ Subordinate Departments including the GSI/ Ministry of Mines for not complying with the DoPT O.M.'s (a) and (b) (VI Pay thmniission only) cited above ? Copies/ copy of such letters were requested but the reply is again not satisfactory.

(5) A request was made to provide a sample copy of any such revised RR for the post of HAG with Grade Pay of Rs 12,000/- in any Ministry/ Attached Office/ Subordinate Office vide the DoPT 0.M.'s as cited above in (a) and (b) (VI Pay Commission). No reply was given to this query no. 5 by theCP10.

is This is for your kind further necessary action.

Yours faithfully,

sirb if Dr A.K. Chatterjee

Ex Additional Director General (GS!)

Enclosure: (1) RTI First Appeal format duly filled in (2) Crossed IPO No. 0 S G .3 24 8-03,

C-V &MT BO Aec /10 eg Ocis72.0

4-1111118

No 136d / AKC / 2018

From

Dr A.K. Chatterjee

Ex Addl Director General, GSI, Uttarayan, 8 C, Tilak Nagar, Nagpur 440 010

Subject:- Information under the RTI Act 2005 Reference : - a DoPT OM No. AB.14017 61

fbl DoPT Reminder vide OM dated 17 03.2016 Sir,

RTI MATTER TIME LIMIT

To

Shukdeo Sah, (RR-II), CPJO and Under Secretary(RR-II) RoomNo.215-A/11

D/o.Personnel & Training North Block New Delhi 110001 Dated 6 th

August 2018

2008-Estt. RR dated 24.03.2009 No. AB.14017 61 2008-Estt (RR

This is to request you to please provide the following information to the undersigned:-

(1) Referring to the above cited DoPT O.M.'s (a) and (b) above, related to the VI Pay Commission, wherein the RR's were supposed to be revised by the Geological Survey of India under the superintendence of the Ministry of Mines, with new Grade Pays for the posts including that of Additional Director General (Geology) (HAG) (PB-5) , you are requested to please provide information with copies of letters on • any such correspondence initiated by the GSI and Ministry of Mines with the DoPT for this post of ADG (Geology).

(2) Please state whether the Grade Pay of Rs 12,000/- per month is applicable to the post of Additional Director General (Geology) of the Geological Survey of India, as per the DoPT O.M.'s cited above in sl.nos. (a) and (b)?

(3) After the issue O.M. No. AB.14017/61/2008-Estt. (RR) dated 17.03.2016, has the DoPT issued any further reminders to the individual Ministries/ Attached Offices/ Subordinate Departments for necessary compliance. If so, copies/ copy of such letters/correspondence may please be sent.

(4) Has any action been initiated by the DoPT against the individual Ministries/

Attached Offices/ Subordinate Departments including the GSI/ Ministry of Mines for not complying with the DoPT O.M.'s (a) and (b) cited above ? If so, copies/ copy of such letters may please be sent.

(5) A sample copy of any such revised RR for the.post of HAG with Grade Pay of Rs 12,000/- in any Ministry/ Attached Office/ Subordinate Office vide the DoPT 0.M.'s as cited above in (a) and (b) may please be provided.

This is for your further necessary action.

Yours faithfully,

Dr A.K. Chatterjee Ex Additional Director General (G5I)

Enclosure: Crossed IRO Nos. (1) 21 F 196620 dated 8/12/2017 of Rs 10=00

7.A No ............. Tor official ue)

: be- • 1,C. aft 21-7-ra Jere e re--A-A, v R. A-su,

MAGAA ptli-6/9 4.4 o 0 r .

tirk: Pn4a€14...‘, tcpio 10 PT; Niece ob-e.64,617t9 6-8-7_0 IS

C:ri • 2 (g

r

To, PIS

eiwrfit . ..

............ . . ;St' senior

ame and address of the officer acting as first appellate authority)

2. Addr . Name of the Applicant ess

3. PartiCidats of the Centrai/State Public Information Ofncer (a) Name (b) Address

4. Date of submission of application for

seeking information 5. Date on which 30/35/40 days

from submission of application

6. Reasons for appeal are over

(a) No response received within the specified tiroe-titrat Aggrieved

by the response received within the specified period (c)

Grounds for appeal

7. Last date for Ming the appeal 8--cal. P

articulars of information tonna tion

(b) Subject requested

(c) Period

No .0 ...... .......for appea112a been de Date.. .. . ................

24)4; • dated. Am . ... postre-d in 0

vide Receipt

Reek/Ate /2-04 eafir(Vit- s v2

SiSignature tureof Applicant gnal address,

if any

Tel. No. (office)._ (Residence) .... ..

. ....

9

Right to information: One SPECIMEN OP P Should K110141 IRST AEPEALER UNDO

SECTION 19(1) OF THE A-NNEXURE 9.1 RICET

TO INFORfrunON ACT, 2005

q to .2_0 (24 /0A4

0,70pILLa-, wfriblpfre4-1,"slig

Annexure 9.1: Specimen of First

Appeal

Acknowledgement Received an appeal from Shri.b ..........

...... of. ..... .... . .............. . .................

section I 9(1) of the Right to thfOrrnatiOn ACti 2005.

Dare: ........ ..........

Signature of Receipt Clerk, .... ...... ...

...... (Name and address of appellate authority) Tel. No ........................

mail:.... Website: .....................

I Delaik

• r RTI REQUEST DETAILS (aintbirt arghr(dtem)

Registration Number (Li CinUi #4gri) :

DOP&T/R/2018/03639 • Date of 13/08/2018 Receipt (sit

wrflz4) :

Local Receipt Type of Receipt (i irk VT •

Sictik) :

Language of English Request

090111i IBTTIT) :

A K CHATTERJEE Name CITA) :

UTARAYAN, 8.TICAE. NAGAR, NAGPITR, wl

• Address (EraT) : Pirr4.40010

Details not provided Country Details not

provided

Mobile Details not Number provided

. Email-ID aild-arr" Details not provided

Status On) Urban (Rural/Urban) :

Education Graduate Status :

Requester Letter Details notprovided Number( t4 WW1)

Details not Letter Date : provided

Is Requester Below Poverty No Line ? ozrr arrawTrfte •

kart4t4wran :

Citizenship Indian Status

(71111 Sol)

10) (original recipient) • Amount Paid (ZIP! m-r

:

Mode of Postal Order Payment

(TIM' WT WtR)

Does it concern the life or No(Normal) Liberty of a Person?

ozartruf4741.aratrk 4114 Atm ci t?) :

Request K.Prakasham, Pertains to US (RR)

(allay faAlad 'ittftrat :

Information Sought Information. Under RTI Act,2005 of -mil 41141):

Nips ifroonlino.gov.in:RTIMISICP10/RTIDetails.phplreg=NVCZTaR8unVsJi9ap2%2FIZy9xFhhmVIvedebt%2BelllaU%30 111

Gender Male

State et 'wet) :

Details not provided

Phone Number (09-4-47):

No 136d . / AKC / 2018

RR

Subject:- Information under the RTI Act 2005 Refererae : - (a) Don OM No. AB.14017/61/2008-Estt. (RR) dated 24;03.2009

Lb) Don Reminder vide OM No. 18.140/7/61/2008-Estt. fRft) dated 11112016 Sir,

This is to request you to please provide the fcillowing information to the undersigned:-

(1) Referring to the above cited DoPT 0.M.'s (a) and (b) above, related to the VI Pay Commission, wherein the RR's were supposed to be revised by the Geological Survey of India under the superintendence of the Ministry of Mines, with new Grade Pays for the posts including that of Additional v •-) Director General (Geology) (HAG) (PB-5) , you are requested to please provide information with copies of letters on any .such 'correspondence initiated by the GSI and Ministry of Mines with the DoPT for this post of ADG (Geology).

(2) Please state whether the Grade Pay of Rs 12,000/- per month is applicable to the post of Additional Director General (Geology) of the Geological

CSurvey of India, as per the DoPT.O.M.'s cited above in sl.nos. (a) and (b)?

(3) After the issue O.M. No. AB.140/7/61/2008-Estt. (RR) dated 17.03.2016, has the DoPT issued any further reminders to the individual Ministries/. Attached Offices/ Subordinate Departments for necessary compliance. If so, copies/ copy of such letters/correspondence may please be sent.

(4) Has any action been initiated by the Don against the indivIdual Ministries/

• Attached Offices/ Subordinate Departments including the 651/ Ministry of Mines for not complying with the Don O.M.'s (a) and (b) cited above ? If so, copies/copy of such letters may please be sent.

(S) A sample copy any such revised RR, for the. post of I-lAG with_ Grade Pam of Rs 12;000/- in any Ministry/ AttaChed Office/ Subordinate Office' vide the Don 0.M.'s as cited above in (a) and (b) may please be provided.

— :W•hwtl,” your further necessor • a

RTI MATTER TIME LIMIT

To

Shukdeo Sah, (RR-11), CPIO and Under Secretary(RR-111 RoomNo.215-A/II 0/o.Personnel & Training

North BlockNey gek)4,9R01 Dated 6 m Auguit2618 '

i A1.1: i

...

Enclosure: tEro;sed0i0. Nos. (1) 21 F 196620 dated 8/12,17.017 of Rs 10=00

A3 11/ 1 /61../0/k) get/ C Government m India e

Minisny of Personnel Public Grievances and Pensions Department 6f Personnel & Training

*40

T Room 215A111 North Block, New Delhi

Dated: August 30, 2018 To

Shri A. K. Cliatedee Utarayan. 8 C Tilak Nagar Napur 440010

• Sub: - Application for information under RTI Act 2005 — Registration no. DOP&T/R/2018/03639 dated 13.08.2018.

Sir.

Please refer to your request for information under RTI Ac 2005.1t is informed that the point wise reply is as under:

Point No.1 and 5: As per established procedure/practice. the proposals received from Administative Ministries are processed in this branch of DOPT under Single File System why the file of the referring Ministry/Department is returned to that Ministry/ Department with the views of the DOPT. DOPT does not keep copies of RRs of Miniseries/Dept, and, therefore, the desired information is not available with the undersigned.

Point No.2: The information sought is clarificatory in nature. In the R11 Act a CPIO is required to furnish only the material information available in its custody. Clarification on hypothetical case is not covered under the scope of RTI Ack-This CPIO has no information as sought.

Point No.3 & 4: This Department as nodal Department frames/lay down guidelines/instructions on personnel matters. These are implemented by various Ministries/Departments with whom the facts of the case/details of officers are available. It may interest you to know that after the implementation of 7* CPC, DoPT has issued OM no.AB-14017/13/2016-Estt (RR) dated 09.08.2016, dt.18.01.2017, dt.22.12.2017, dt.29.01.2018. and dt.25.07.2018 requesting Ministries/Departments to amend the RRs/SRs to bring them in conformity with 7th CPC recommendations ( copy each enclose). You may kindly appreciate that it is the responsibility of the Ministry/Department to carry out the process of amendment as requested/suggested by DoPT:

2. In case you want to go for an appeal in connection with the .information provided, you may appeal to the Appellate Authority indicated below within thirty days from the date of receipt of ibis letter.

Smt. G. Jayanthi, FAA & Joint Secretary (El). D/o Personnel & Training North Block. New Delhi.

Yours faithfully

(K. Prakasham) CP10 84 Under Secretary to the Govt. of India

Enci: as above

t

;Th Kr..fib,33./2/L.;‘,026-M.1:4

Ministry of Mines Government of India

ItTI MATTER 3? SPEED POST

To

3rd Floor, D Wing, Shastri Bhawan NeycDelhi-110001

Dated: OlVovember, 2018

Dr. A.K. Chatterjee, Ex. Addl. DG, GSI, Uttarayan, 8 C, Tilalc Nagar, Nagpur - 440014.

Subject: Information under RTI Act 2005-Re

Sir,

Please refer to your RTI request dated 06.08.2018 forwarded by DoPT vide order No. AB-14017/6/2018-Estt. (RR)/00377/Appeal/2018 dated 10.10.2018. So far

as Ministry of Mines is concerned, the point wise reply to the relevant points on the basis of available records is as under.

2. Point 1, "As per the established procedure, the proposal for amendment

of RR is submitted to DoPT under Single file System (Online). After the clearance of DoPT, the draft goes to UPSC, after their concurrence/approval it goes to Department of Legal Affairs and finally for notification. Therefore, no single letter/correspondence was made with DoPT, UPSC or DoLA and complete draft proposal was sent to all the concerned departments. In case you are not satisfied with the reply, you may inspect the concerned files by visiting Ministry of Mines".

3. Point 2, "The DoPT has correctly informed you that the information

sought is clarificatory in nature. The present ADG (the then Senior DDG) is placed at Level 15 of Pay matrix.

4. Point 4, "Firstly, the query was related to DoPT and has been replied.

Secondly, as far as amendment/ modification of RR for the post of ADG(G) in GSI is concerned, it is informed that it has been done as per the established procedure/practice and guidelines of Don";

5. If you are not satisfied with the information provided above, you may

appeal to the First Appellate Authority, Ms. Farida M Naik, Director, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhavan, New Delhi - 110001 under the provisions of the RTI Act, 2005.

Yours faithfully,

(Ram Rashflc Mandal) Section Officer/CPIO


Cell w.r.t. their U.O. No. 2/123/2018-PI dated 17.10.2018

TIVRT a5TT 311t r+72 a, 2005

fAqct Mit/Due date 13.11.2018 TIME BOUND/RTI MATTER

&TRW &tem-4

(gm

fati=4: tktien a r 3TitIVIT .iritrf*zpT,2005 3.Wra• wca arr4-4wI

Dr. D. Dhaya Devadas, Rio Chennai *311-d-CF raw* 06.10.2018 i1 it

c17 urzr and m-rzlart t7, u9 . id,441 ti

2. art rth-n 3r m, 2005 *t ta-Rr 6(3) * 3171"44R- c Fri* 4

Htlo1I *-1" fa044 chti4Se141

Trgat“ a--6" 31-ItrwrIsr, flrich 310-C7 atriTi mit t,## arr-4-47 *•r ricad tit -1 Sitrkwaietei *t sirfd *t ant& # zretreta- #ft# 5 Cara afta-r

cr”frii 0141 t- attr T art' * Nita* *1 aft Itita" ch.(di 3-rmzrw t

3. 3rn:R4 3Mttl• t"f tr-wn 31ft1WI2 a, 2005 *crti

*R#lT .5tp4R ittrfta Trarzr wrztart *r I

titlarf. Copy of IPO No. 42F 578057

it '

(1;1 ( corit)

.31,31-PT

Sh. A.K. Mallik. US(M-IV) / c.a.* :1:47-11 3iftrnit

11.34 .ft7P1 Cell 1.3.0. No. 2/122/2018-PI FCFIWDated 15.10.2018

1Q)'.;, 5.0.1J Si ISO 90e1:2008 Certified ,,:tc

Phone : +91 44 32572050 Mobile : +91 9444400113, 9444392454 Email . [email protected]

purchase©indiangametsand.com Website : www.indiangametsand.com

Registered Office : 11580. 7th Street, Veerabathran Nagar. Mambakkam Main Road, Medavakkam, Chennai - 600 100. INDIA.

lelet S

7-`Tr.T.f7

f i

INDIAN GARNET SAND CO. (P) LTD.

The e• 1: • • the Universe is continuously watching over us. Praise to the aimignry

REF : RTI/DI-74/682/2018-19

From

Dr. D. Dhaya Devadas, Chairman cum Managing Director,

To

The Central Public Information Officer/ Under Secretary (Mines- V), Ministry of Mines, Gover invent of India, Shastri Bhawan, Dr. Raje id ra Prasad Road, New Delhi -110 001.

Date : 06.10.2018

Dear Sir,

Sub : Request to furnish :ertain information under RTI Act, 2005 - reg.

We request you to kindly furnish the following information under the RT1Act,2005 :

1. Copies of the letters sent to the Secretary, Industries, Energy and Labour DepartmeAt. Govt. of Maharashtra or any directions or Notifications or office memo during the period between 01.01.2018 and 01.09.2018 covering the mining leases granted, Lease Deed executed and register •cl for ilmenite, Magnetite, Garnet, etc related to the following 2 lessees covering the in ning leases granted Government Orders :

M/s. Indian Garret Sand Co. (P) Ltd. in Ratnagiri District, Maharashtra vide Government Orr.crs No. MMN-1820/ 8091/Ind-9, MMN-1820/C.R.8052/lnd-9, MMN-1820/ C.R.;•;066/ Ind-9, MMN-1820/ C.R.8051/Ind-9, MMN-1820/ C.R.8117/ Ind-9, MMN-1820 /C.R.8044/ Ind-9 dated 11.01.2017.

(ii) M/s. Rare Minerals in Ratnagiri District, Maharashtra vide Government Orders No. 1004/ CR.722/Ind.9 dated 11.01.2017.

2. Copies of the Note file related to the letters sent to the Secretary, Industries, Energy and Labour Department, Govt. of Maharashtra or any directions or Notifications or office memo during the period between 01.01.2018 and 01.09.2018 in respect of the above said mining leases granted ro the said 2 lessees.

We have enclosed herewith an Indian Postai Order bearing- No. 42F 578057 dated 24.09.2018 for Rs.10/- in favour of Pay and Accounts Officer, Mibistry of Mines, New Delhi towards the prescribed fee under Rule 3 Of thetRighrtb pegulation of fee and cost) Rules, 2005 for the sane.

Thanking you,

yours fait

HAYA DEyAthts


MINISTRY OF MINES

New Delhi, Date 8th November, 2018 To,

Dr. D. Dhaya Devadas,

1/580, 7th Street, Veerabathran Nagar,

Mambakkam Maid Road, Medavakkam,

Chennai — 600100


15.10.2018.

Sir,

I am directed to refer to your•RTI application, PI Cell, U.O. No. 2/122/2018-PI dated

15.10.2018 and say that the matter related to the information sought in the application is

under process. Consequently, the information is denied under Section 8 (h) of the RTI Act,

2005. You may seek the information under fresh RTI application, after the matter is

processed.




Yours faithfully,



dpy to: PI Cell U.O. No. 2/122/2018-PI dated 15.10.2018.

tiuoil SR Sr, 2005

fatici faiit/Due date 10.11.2018 TIME BOUND/RTI MATTER

aITTF ti tct,1(

tMG-1- 061,nciel

ItCR: 4i:A 011 Wr +1e1,2005 ¶1T'?1 iii I

Sh. Mohit Choubey, Rio New Delhi i 3-174-47 faWh 08.10.2018

ci7* Fru 3 wrirart ;14-c y-1 fd-rgi IT Tri t I

31 F, 2005 a Um 6(3) -e-n 3r7rrt 73-rer 7-3

3WZTeitqa 4,146(.H4 # 711

aritrwrt ird--4T-4" 331-a-CF 3t7T zr-zrr t, t4 ar1k-4-R- R cT ti .bi

3i-1-a-d - a surd FlitEf zfZITeR7f M+-R. 5 farii grgc R.

aFtt t alTr 5ti ark- 81t a chidl arranw t I

3. 3.171# 3iTott t.T t f itcroi T arffm-rT arilrn--41-F, 2005 * sil T ITraW

chic; I

• tiodri. Copy of WO No. 44F 065473

(tr#r tortr)

317111-4 arit-+-rtr

Sh. Prakash 5. Mundharikar SO(RC1 I ..doll 3iftWft

11".3irt .mac iPI Cell U.O. No. 2/n1/2018-PI sit*WiDated 12.10.2(118

To,

The Ppblic yet S kn'sq a

Mining Triblanal.

Info atisn Officer,

"•!-• • • H

i••:•:1; • its Pm; ft or

•

1 t

nt2k Shashtri Bhawan, 7:Y5-117- t net

New Delhi

Sub: - Application of Seeking Information under Right to

information Act 2005

Dear Sir/Madam,

I. The Applicant wish to seek the information related to the Revision Applications pending before the Revisional authority.

Please provide the following information under Right to

Information Act:

1. A copy of the Note-sheets/Order-sheets related to the Revision Applications mentioned below: -

MINISTRY OF MINES REVISION APPLICATIONS

*****:i*****

STATE: MADHYA PRADESH

SI.No. FiteNo./Receipt

Date Petitioner

-Name/Address Village/Tehsil/District/State

. - Minerals Type/Area

1 16/(44)/2013/RC-CIVIL II 22/08/2013

SHRI TRILOK NATH AGARWAL

LINES,GANESH CHOWK,KATNI MADHYA PRADESH

PADREHI VDAYRAGHAVGARH KATNI MADHYA PRADESH

DOLOMITE, LIMESTONE

ML 7.579 HECTARE

2 16/(52)/2013/RC-

6,

II 07/10/2013

M/S DOLBY MINING AND POWER PVT LTD

DWARKA SADAN, PRESS COMPLEX, ZONE I, M P NAGAR, BHOPAL- 462011 MADHYAPRADESH

GUDDA PAGRA PAVAI PANNA MADHYA PRADESH

.

PL

LIMESTONE 251.980 HECTARE

3 16/(62)/2013/RC-STONE II 09/12/2013

MIS MISWAL LIME

COMPANY CIVIL LINE

BAMFLORE NAGOD SATNA MADHYA PRADESH

' LIMESTONE

ML 13.290 HECTARE

16/(01)/2015/RC-AT-POST II 05/01/2015

483222

SHRI SHRIKANT PANDEY

VILLAGE GANDHIGRAM, DISTT. JABALPUR, MADHYA PRADESH-

• HRIDYANAGAR SIHORA JABALPUR MADHYA PRADESH

IRON ORE, LATERITE, MANGANESE ORE

ML 4.67 HECTARE

16/(05)/2017/RC-NEAR II 11/12/2017

MADHYA PRAESH

M/S S.N.S (MINERALS) LTD.

RAILWAY, CROSSING N.H.7. REWA ROAD, MAIHAR, SATNA,

JAMUWANI KALA VDARAVGARH KATNI MADHYA PRADESH

DOLOMITE, LIMESTONE

ML 8.584 HECTARE

16/(01)/2018/RC-MINERALS II 03/01/2018

MIS K.G.N

MISSION CHOWK, KATNI483501, MADHYA PRADESH

NIL NIL

• KATNI MADHYA PRADESH

DOLOMITE, LIMESTONE

PENALTY UNDER SECTION 21 (5) OF MMDR ACT 00 HECTARE

16/(02)/2018/RC-COMMERCIAL II 03/01/2018

M/S

MINERALS MISSION CHOWK, KATNI-483501

NIL NIL KATNI MADHYA PRADESH

DOLOMITE, LIMESTONE

PENALTY UNDER SECTION 21 (5) OF MMDR ACT 00 HECTARE

II. The information sought is required in printed form.

III. The application fee Rs. 10/- (Rupees ten only) has been paid by postal Order.

IV. You are humbly requested to provide information within a five days time as the same is required urgently by the applicant.

Declaration of the Applicant

I am the counsel in all the Revision Applications mentioned in the aforesaid chart. I am a bonafied citizen of India and allow allegiance to the sovereignty, unity and integrity of Indian and have not voluntarily acquired the citizenship of another country.

MOHIT CHOUBEY (ADVOCATE) ADDRESS: 23, FF, BAZAR LANE BENGALI MARKET, NEW DELHI-110001.

4.

5

6

7

Place: - New Delhi Date: - 08.10.2018

•dli PI ki.71. , . •

",./1;1t 4.3 %it. •,•1::

• • • 1 10 WA,tit

• ti • 1•1• 1 a , 1. .0

e

' • io,,•!' 4 1.1101/M bI I 1 tit h. •

tirelk,il •••!..! ! :

C I I • •

Pirt \ I t' k • I •

111,`,/1/

4 At\

•

..404141

I •

Yei . Dtg. I

I

p V' It 1

( .1

01

. t .

4 v,ztizirossissirt.:17,...

rt,',5;ithr ilril a 4 Iv: •:„...,,, ‘,> •

' et. 4 • , 1

kri

r A I

s, :! . .

1 tri. 41, t ..'i

.n.- iisic.4

tkInft1 .e •7 11..:

RTI Ivlatter/SPeed Post

No.01/02/2018/RC-18611 Government of India

Ministry of Mines

Dated the W November, 2018 ShastriOsman, New Delhi

To

Shri Mohit Choubey (Advocate) 23, FF, Bazar Lane Bengali Market New Delhi - 110001

Subject: Application of Shri Mohit Choubey for seeking information

under RTI Act, 2005.

Sir

Please refer to your RTI application dated 08.10.2018 on the subject mentioned above and to say that copy of desired information

contains 27 pages.

2. As per Act, copy of the requisite information can be provided on depositing charges ® Rs.2/ - per page copied. You are, accordingly, requested to deposit amounting to Rs. 54/- (Rupees fifty four only) in the form of Cash/Demand Draft/Banker Cheque in favour of Pay and Accounts Officer, Ministry of Mines or deposit at Information Facilitation Counter, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan, Dr. Rajendra Prasad Road, New Delhi-110001.

Yours faithfu y

5 (Prakash S. kvlundharikar)

Section Officer & CPIO Tel No. 011-23384070

ocy to CPIO, PI Cell, Ministry of Mines, w.r.t. their UO No.

02/121/2018-PI dated 12.10.2018.

Yours faithfu y

‘-t (Prakas S. Mundharikar)

Section Officer & CPIO

RTI Matter/Speed Post No.01/02/2018/RC-1&Il Government of India

Ministry of Mines Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi

Dated the 19th November, 2018

To

Shri Mohit Choubey (Advocate) 23, FF, Bazar Lane Bengali Market New Delhi - 110001

Subject: Application of Shri Mohit Choubey for seeking information under RTI Act, 2005.

Sir

Please refer to your RTI application dated 08.10.2018 and Challan Receipt No. 4014 dated 14.11.2018 on the subject mentioned above to enclose herewith desired copies of information sought by you related to the following Revision Applications:

SI. No. File No. Revisionist's Name 1 No. 16/44/2013/RC-II Shri Trilok Nath Agarwal 2 No. 16/52/2013/RC-II M/s Dolby Mining and Power Pvt. Ltd. 3 No.16/62/2013/RC-II Ws Jaiswal Stone Lime Company 4 No.16/01/2015/RC-II Shri Shrikant Pandey 5 No.16/05/2017/RC-II M/s S.N.S. (Minerals) Ltd. 6 No.16101/2018/RC-11 M/s K.G.N. Minerals 7 No.16/02/2018/RC-I1 MIs Commercial Minerals

2. In case, you are not satisfied with the reply, you may prefer an appeal before the Appellate Authority Smt. Athira Babu, Director, Ministry of Mines, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi within the stipulated period under the provisions of the said Act.

End: As above

y to CPIO, PI Cell, Ministry of Mines, w.r.t. their UO No. 02/121/2018-PI dated 12.10.2018.

21 01 I TT .3IThTTT 3littr4zP7, 2005

facici faill/Due date 01.11.2018


• 3T179- +RchR

•

+.9101 4141W-I

41z4cr0 WT 3iitrITh 3iferrazf3r, 2005 3frdira' ClIta 31Ta-CR I

Ms. Sabyasachi Bhaduri, R/o New Delhi 3-cra•-CW se4-RiW 25.08.2018

Tire' 3n-a- AF a; 141411 Trr tI

3TIT(1:44x1, 2005 tir CAM 6(3) 37147{ zifk

Ca tit e4 3W721 tHerii.b eink&Ici # .7011

31 a~IF1, DNI-Ict4 arra-c# 3-tyr arzrr r arra-ca.

31*A7 *r tAirea Sr artrer F1 znirera- A%-# 5 12,0

a-Ftr t anr 5ei ark a1 3fraT' air +pci q to11 3rrd2z t

3. 3117#orittT IT TOW WI 3.TRITT 31ft*L171, 2005 t TA4.44-1.1 TT 41Mei

cfri 3 > V 3t)-t WPM* Sr °1i2 I

4-leido. copy of IPO No. 44F 067948

(Rima Puri)

.31-rfrir 3fitiTlt

Sh. A.K. Mallik. US(Mines IV) / *-4171. ei VFaT 3fierTItt

11131* ARV! Cell Us). No. 2/120/2018-PI itRiT/Dated 03.10.2018

Right to Information Act- 2005

Application for Information

To,

Public Information Officer, Anistry of Mines, Government of India, Shastri l3hawan, Dr. Rajendra Prasad Road, New Delhi — 110 001.

Subject: Application under Section 6(1) of the Right to

Information Act - 2005.

Particulars of information required:

1. Whether the Government Of India has sent any

communication/letter to the Indian Bureau of Mines, Nagpur

regarding the mineral blocks that are situated in the village of

Chachiyawas and Kayad, Dist. Ajmer Rajasthan? If yes, then

kindly provide me a copy of the same.

2. Further, if the Indian Bureau of Mines, Nagpur has sent any

communication/letter to the Government of India regarding

the said mineral blocks, kindly provide me a copy of the same

as well.

3. Any other information that you may find relevant to the

queries raised above.

: 1

•

TOV,c,;: k1/4.210

v51-ine "I

Applicant Name: Sabyasachi Bhaduri

Citizenship: Indian

Father's Name: Mr. Kishore Bhaduri

Postal Address: A-165, Lgf, Defence Colony, New Delhi 110024.

Telephone number (with STD Code): 011 - 41686821

Mobile No: +91-95841-50000

E-mail Id: [email protected]

I state that the information sought does not fall within the

restrictions imposed under the Right to Information Act, 2005.

Further, I submit that the information sought, to the best of my

information/understanding, pertains to your office.

A fee of Rs. 10/- is being enclosed with the present application.

Signature of Applicant Date: :< 0 g 20 Wsc..

Encl: Indian Postal Order bearing no.



Dated 4th October, 2018

To Shri Sabyasachi Bhaduri,

A-165 (LGF), Defence Colony,

New Delhi-110024

Subject: Information sought under RTI Act, 2005. PI Cell U.O. No. 2/120/2018-PI dated

03.10.203.8.

Sir, I am directed to refer to your RTI application, PI Cell U.O. No. 2/120/2018-PI dated

03.10.2018 and say that:

ii. No response has been received from IBM so far on the letter sent by the Ministry.

i. The information sought in point no. 1 of the RTI application is enclosed.






Telephone No. 011-23384743


to: PI Cell, U.O. No. 2/120/2018-PI dated 03.10.2018.

iturn a5r3-ritIW2 .3iitliWZra, 2005

c1go falit/Due date 01.11.2018


31Teff SIT •

tali gtirn-zr

fatrzr: +1t.Io1I 1 31M 1T 3ftrA-4-sr, 2005 t 31T-d-cA- I

Sh. D. Venkata Ramana, R/o Andhra Pradesh * 3T14-C4 IRW 25.09.2018 Wr c1-9- * TIM 3fta. 7.4aTt t7, 14'411 3T TAT

2. Tsar .3111.7-{ 31tfizr-F, 2005 *r ETT4 6(3) * 411-a a** 7 'Iy41. a r itsizi TRM-14 chI4eiq Tr/ AM-Z t qr arttr-+-rtr,r, aird-CA 4-ar wrzrr (),,4 arr-4-c4 ticad 4-4-th-rtr arftr-+rtrichieliem, I, 31T WTf rartu4 zrzneru a-A- 5 faritt gra-4- cfv(all a-Ttr atir wt 4 ,317-d-dt t1 air TIP-a• 3Tra.mw g- I

3. 31P* 39tEr t f tkuoil wr 3-ftw13- 3arPH--crar 2005 t PticH1 tr qua ch.(c1 r 3t1" l*frita. R:144 W4-4* 1 I

Copy of IPO No. 25F 860023 and 25F 860024

(Rims Puri)

393TraT 311trwrtr

Sh. A.K. Mallik. USiMines IV) /*-4R1 jon_211 Titr-thn Er1311$ 4W/P1 Celli.' O. No. 2/1 19/2018-P1 itFiW/Dated 03.10.2018

d) Whether information is required

by post/in person/E-mail

e) In case by post (Ordinarv/Reaistered or Speed)

6 Address / E-mail :0 to



available by the public required 9 Do you agree to pay the required


(if yes, please inc.icate details of such

deposit) Whether belongs to BPL category Have you furnished the proof of the

same 7 Place : Srikakulam Date :25.09.2018

11



: D.Venkata Ramona

14-9-9, Dhandi Street, C.B.Road, Srikakulam - 532 001 Andhra Pradesh

: Aadhaar No.: 6506 9314 0887

: Letter No.7/26/2012-M.IV dt 03.10.2012 from Ministry of Mines, Gol to l&C, GoAP

-do-

: October, 2012

: Mines & Minerals - inclusion of other heavy minerals like limonite, Rutile, Zircon, Leucoxene and Silimanite in the existing mining lease for Garnet

over an extent of 95.0851-Ia. From the confluence f

Nagavali river upto Sy.No.1042 of Srikurmam village, Srikakulam District held by M/s Transworld Garnet India Pvt Ltd - prior permission of GoI under Section 5(1) of MM(D&R) Act, 1957.

: by post & E-mail


1 Full name of the ai- plicant

2 Name of the FathE

3 %Permanent Addres

4 Particulars in resp•:ct of identity of the applicant

5 Particulars of info: nation solicited




required

: Speed post

14-9-9, Dhandi Street, C.B.Road, Srikakulam - 532 001 Andhra Pradesh verilsoldonnali n

: No

: No

: Yes

Yes. IPO No.25F 860024 & 25F 860023. Rs.10/-

towards application fee and Rs.10/- cost e the

photostat copies.

No

fr.jefitint .ti.t

Full signature of the applicant Address : 14-9-9, Dhandi Street,

C.B.Road, Srikakulam - 532 001.

Office of the Public Information Officer


Address

Seeking information


on Place : Date :

2=1-



Dated 10th October, 2018 To

Shri D Venkata Ramana

14-9-9, Dhandi Street,

C.B. Road, Srikakulam-532001,

Andhra Pradesh

Subject: Information sought under RTI Act, 2005. PI Cell U.O. No. 2/117/2018-PI dated

03.10.2018 and PI Cell U.O. No. 2/119/2018-PI dated 03.10.2018.

Sir,

I am directed to refer to your RTI application, PI Cell U.O. No. 2/117/2018-PI dated

03.10.2018 and PI Cell U.O. No. 2/119/2018-PI dated 03.10.2018 and say that the

information sought in the applications in enclosed.

End: As above

Yours faithfully,



Copy to: PI Cell U.O. No. 2/117/2018-PI dated 03.10.2018 and PI Cell U.O. No. 2/119/2018-PI

dated 03.10.2018.

mar 3rd.3fite4-zp:f, 2005

Ikzra Mit'/Due date 01.11.2018

TIME 80UND/RTI MATTER

•

T R R*17 urrF at-A-r-gzr

ittrzf: ThWT 31"itWZ arffazazr 2005 k .34-dirF Alta' .311-4-4W I

Sh. D. Venkata Ramana, R/o Andhra Pradesh * 25.09.2018 farmsfarms *t r* TIM 3rna Tizhdrt t--q" Tfga- Weir 7T 71'

2. 237Fr .31triffizrg, 2005 *t ZHU 6(3) art ratrzi- 3» TReer wzt-zr tisti Arotz tat at artr+-r-tr,14:re- 3rr-a-4-a- rar arur l 3Tr -CW tEltra FITWth arittetrie-41#4 a t, 31-0-Ca- e artrur zrzuarre- 12'th-A- 5 it- {} * aftaT T-tr ati-r rfr 413- arr-E-cw e air a X037 3fia217n I 3. ancrt 31-71-#1- */' 3Titiifo-rn=r 2005 MtraRt tfl- r zr-, wrzha-rt- aRr I

1*67F: Copy of I PO No. 08G 388864

(Rime Puri)

.3iTori3i 3-1it-Wref

SA, A K A a H U Min IV / RIW 27-. 0r ottarrt .fig/P1 Cell I !.0. No. 2/118/2018-P1 it -"i,/Dated 03.10.2018

•



To The Information Counter, Ministry of Mines, Government of India Shastri Shaven, New Delhi.



the applicant 5 Particulars of information solicited

a) Sub)ect matter of information



required

d) Whether information is required

by post/in perso. /E-mail

e) In case by post (Ordinary/Registered or Speed)

6 Address / E-mail ID to

D.Venkata RaMarla

• : 14-9-9, Dhandi Street,

C.B.Road, Srikakulam - 532 001 Andhra Pradesh

Aadhaar No.: 6506 9314 0887

: Letter No.4/17/2011-MIV dt 20.01.2012 from Ministry of Mines, GoI to I&C, GoAP

-do-

: 3anuary, 2012

: Mines & Minerals - inclusion of other heavy minerals like Ilmenite, Rutile, Zircon, Leucoxe and arnet Silimanite in the existing mining leas

ne e for G

over an extent of 95.0851-Ia. From the confluence f Nagavali river upto Sy.No.1042 of Srikurmam village, Srikakulam District held by M/s Transworld Garnet India Pvt Ltd - prior permission of GoI under Section

Cf 11 of IsAMf rift.ln Art- 10c1

: by post & E-mail



available by the publicaured 9 Do you agree to pay the required


(if yes, please indicate details of such

deposit) 11 Whether belongs to BPL category

Have you furnished the proof of the

same Place : 5rikakulam Date :25.09.2018

: Speed post

14-9-9, Dhandi Street, C.B.Road, SrIkakulam - 532 001 Andhra Pradesh 1/4s()SgatilSI

No

: No

: Yes

Yes. IPO No.08G 388864 for Rs.20/-. Rs.10/- towards application fee and Rs.10/- cost of the

photostat copies.

No

ots .Vip it. A PP— kh..•"--11

Full signature of the applicant

Address :-9 14-9, Dhandi Street, C.B.Road, Srikakulam - 532 001.

Pi Office of the Public Information Officer

Received the application from ................ ........ ..................................................

........ ................................

Address......... . ..................... ........... .............

.......................................................................

on ....... ....... ........... ........ ........... Seeking information

place :

Full name of Pub information

Date

Officer

Designationlic

& Seal :


MINISTRY OF MINES

Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi To




C.B. Road, Srikakulam-532001, Andhra Pradesh

Subject: Information sought under RTI Act, 2005. PI Cell U.O. No.

2/118/2018-PI dated 03.10.2018.

Sir,

I am directed to refer your RTI application, PI Cell U.O. No. 2/118/2018-PI dated

03.10.2018 and say that the file related to the information sought in the application is under

investigation by the Ministry. Consequently, the information is denied under Section 8 (h) of

the RTI Act, 2005. You may seek the information under fresh RTI application, after the investigation is concluded.


Prithul Kumar, Director and Appellate Authority, Ministry of Mines, Room No. 315 'D' Wing, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi within 30 days of receipt of information.

Yours fairully,

(A K MaMk) CPIO/Under Secretary to the Govt. of India

Telephone No. 011-23384743 E-mail address: alura

C y to: PI Cell, U.O. No. 2/118/2018-pl dated 03.10.2018.

3a 5 7 3ari:A7.12:1, 2005

faqci faR/Due date 01.11.2018


TRW

491tri .1-1,11vie1

aiftwTT 3if 3r, 2005 *3i7-116 31raCF I

Sh. D. Venkata Ramana, R/o Andhra Pradesh * 3T1-44# ?CR* 25.09.2018 aft zR"* TIT2T 3W6 W14-dTP t7 1;f9R- r4-)Q41 IT PI

2. i1tlo1I T .3f R .3ftiWzr# 2005 *I' t1TU 6(3) * 317(rt csild dje rkrait fd4.14 337-4- • tlicniti chiciiefer zap - aF 3a1Thlti, la+ich) 3tra-Ca" a 1T Trzrr kelt 3tra-Cd' Th-sf ÷icncl tItch 3ritWrtchRaei+-1 Tht, 3ird-CW *t Imrd atur zrzinftu Af+-F 5 1?,OI1 gra-{ Ftimitincl cbtril 0141 t rT47 aft # 3rrd t afr kita- choli 3T1q3fl P I

3. 3114 31V1.1 E ft rkurti 3fit-wri- .311111*-4# 2005 * MR-4 chic? r 3+1LN fAtfrfri- Trepa at wrtrart we-

8-garl. Copy of 1PO No. 08G 388863.

Sh. A.K. Mallik. USiMines IVI / r Act. fibril alit1w# tfrant .mac Cell 1.1.0 No. 2/117/2018-11 1a7tWIDated 03.10.2018

trim

(Rima Puri)

3ITTPT aritrwiit

•

: D.Venkata Ramana

14-9-9, Dhandi Street, C.B.Road, Srikakulam - 532 001 Andhra Pradesh

: Aadhaar No.: 6506 9314 0887

: Letter No.7/26/2012-M.IV dt 10.07.2012 from Ministry of Mines, GoI to I&C, GoAP

-do-

: )uly, 2012

Mines & Minerals - inclusion of other heavy minerals like Ilmenite, Rutile, Zircon, Leucoxene and Silimanite in the existing mining lease for Garnet over an extent of 95.085Ha. From the confluence f

Nagavali river upto Sy.No.1042 of Srikurmam village,

Srikakulam District held by Mts..T;ansiesioild Garnet India Pvt Ltd - prior perrniFfoo .91..dol under Section

5(1) of MM(D&R) Act, -- by post & E-mail '

C17.10A • t Speed post

14-9-9, Dhandi Stree C.B.Road, Srikakula Andhra Pradesh veukahriondapaii8309fP No

1

tit\

3 4.tii111171-'

• ' I.

\‘q Tr. i"C.1 1

Yes. IPO No.08G 388863_for Rs-r

towards application fee and P.s.10/- cost of the

photostat copies.

No

D vv.-ea ./ft_ 12.9\)---0 LAR. Full signature of the applicant

Address : 14-9-9, Dhandi Street, C.B.Road, Srikakulam - 532 001.

No

Yes



7 Has the informatior been provided earlier

8 Is this information of made available by the Dunk reouired

9 Do you agree to pay the required fees ?

10 Have you deposited application fee (if yes, please indicate details of such

deposit) 11 Whether belongs to BPL category

Have you furnished the proof of the same ?

Place : 5rikakulam Date :25.09.2018

V Office of the Public Information Officer


Address Seeking information


on

Mace : Date :



4 Particular, in respect of identity of

the applicant 5 Particulars of informetion solicited

a) Subject matter of 'nformation


c) Specific details of nformation required

d) Whether informr.ion is required by post/in person/E-mail

e) In case by post (Ordinary/Reoistred or Speed)

6 Address / E-mail ID to


MINISTRY OF MINES

Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi To




C.B. Road, Srikakulam-532001, Andhra Pradesh

Subject: Information sought under RTI Act, 2005. PI Cell 1/.0. No. 2/117/2018-PI dated 03.10.2018 and PI Cell U.O. No. 2/119/2018-PI dated 03.10.2018.

Sir,

I am directed to refer to your RTI application, PI Cell 0.0. No. 2/117/2018-PI dated 03.10.2018 and PI Cell 11.0, No. 2/119/2018-pl dated 03.10.2018 and say that the information sought in the applications in enclosed.

End: As above

Yours faithfully,

(A K Mallij CPIO/Under Secretary to the Govt. of India

Telephone No. 011-23384743 E-mail address: alt)

to: PI Cell U.O. No. 2/117/2018-PI dated 03.10.2018 and PI Cell U.O. No. 2/119/2018-PI

dated 03.10.2018.

.0\ip (4)aii tit) - Ministry of Mines

Documents