© ABSL Power Solutions © STM Quality Limited STM Quality Limited Failure Mode and Efect Analysis TOTAL QUALITY MANAGEMENT F.M.E.A.
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
STM Quality Limited
TOTAL QUALITY MANAGEMENT
What do we do when it"s #nished!
Introduction
Failure Mode and Efect Analysis?
F.M..A. is a sim$le way o% $redi&tin' what mi'ht 'o wron'.
By usin' a stru&tured method( results
&an )e *uanti#ed and hen&e &om$ared.
+denti#es &riti&al and si'ni#&ant &hara&teristi&s
,el$s en'ineers $rioritise and %o&us on
tilise indi-iduals" /nowled'e and s/ills within a team en-ironment
Failure Mode and Efect Analysis
F.M..A.s &an )e done %or any desi'n( manu%a&turin' or in1ser-i&e a&ti-ity
F.M..A.s are modular and &an )e
&arried out %or sin'le $arts or lar'e assem)lies
!ene"ts # Desi$n F.M.E. A.
Aids in e-aluatin' re*uirements and alternati-es Aids in initial esi'n %or Manu%a&ture +n&reases $ro)a)ility o% dete&tin' %ailure
modes and their e3e&ts Pro-ides additional in%ormation %or
testin' re*uirements ,el$s identi%y &riti&al and si'ni#&ant
&hara&teristi&s ,el$s -alidate test methods
!ene"ts # Process F.M.E. A.
+denti#es $otential $ro&ess related %ailure modes whi&h will e3e&t internale4ternal &ustomers 5edu&es &osts o% re$airs due to %aulty
$ro&ess methodolo'y +n&reases e6&ien&y sta)lishes a $riority system %or
&onsiderin' &orre&ti-e a&tions +denti#es &on#rmed &riti&al and
si'ni#&ant &hara&teristi&s
F.M..A +denti#es 5is/s
$esi%n &esponsibility
To /ee$ u$ with &om$etition
To retain &urrent )usiness
,el$ o)tain new )usiness
FM..A.s are li-in' do&uments and are u$dated when9
Modi#&ation to a &om$onent( $ro&ess or system is $lanned:
om$onent is to )e used in new en-ironment:
ustomer &on&ern arises.
Then identi%y )oundary %or analysis
<e4t( &reate a ;ow &hart %or one o$eration
Process Flow %hart
=$.>0 Pre$aration
=$.?0 Weld
=$.@0 assem)le
=$.C0 +ns$e&t D Pa&/StorePa&/
=$.20 Mould
!oundary For Analysis
Press EStart" )utton
=$.0 Trim
$esi%n &esponsibility
From Pro&ess ;ow9
nter a sim$le des&ri$tion o% the $ro&ess )ein' analysed i.e. Pla&e $art on trim ma&hine #4ture:
+ndi&ate the $ur$ose o% the $ro&ess )ein' analysed i.e. Fully seat $art in &orre&t orientation:
List se$arately other o$erations in-ol-ed with that $ro&ess:
Pro&ess %un&tion &ontains )oth $rodu&t and $ro&ess &hara&teristi&s.
Process)Function *e+uire,ents
What is the $ro&ess $ur$ose!
What is its %un&tion!
De"ne the Process Purpose
Process Purpose
=$.0 Trim
$esi%n &esponsibility
e#nition9
Potential %ailure mode is the manner in whi&h the $ro&ess &ould $otentially %ail to meet the $ro&ess re*uirements andor desi'n intent.
+t is a des&ri$tion o% the non1 &on%orman&e at that s$e&i#& o$eration.
Failure Mode
<o %un&tion
Partial %un&tion
+ntermittent %un&tion
$esi%n &esponsibility
e#nition9
The e3e&ts o% the %ailure mode on the &ustomer. The &ustomer &ould )e the ne4t o$eration( su)se*uent o$erations or the #nal &ustomer user.
Efects o' Failure Mode
ne4t user
downstream user
ultimate &ustomer
ma&hines e*ui$ment
Efects o' Failure Mode
'ncorrect to
$esi%n &esponsibility
e#nition9
An assessment o% the seriousness o% the e3e&t o% the $otential %ailure mode on the &ustomer.
eerity
with
warnin'
H
<one <o 3e&t >
$esi%n &esponsibility
© STM Quality Limited
STM Quality Limited
Identi'y pecial %haracteristics
5+T+AL9 5e*uirements that a3e&t &om$lian&e with 'o-ernment re'ulations or sa%e -ehi&le $rodu&t %un&tion and re*uire s$e&ial &ontrols KS&ore H or >0
$esi%n &esponsibility
e#nition9
Potential &ause o% a %ailure is de#ned as how the %ailure &ould o&&ur in terms o% somethin' that &an )e &orre&ted or &ontrolled.
%ause
© STM Quality Limited
STM Quality Limited
=nly s$e&i#& errors or mal%un&tions Ke'. =$erator %ails to remo-e waste should )e listed.
Am)i'uous $hrases Ke.'. =$erator error( ma&hine mal%un&tion should not )e used.
%ause
$esi%n &esponsibility
© STM Quality Limited
STM Quality Limited
,ow %re*uently the &ause is $roOe&ted to o&&ur. Based on9
8 ,istori&al manu%a&turin'assem)ly %ailure rates with similar $arts
8 Statisti&al data %rom similar $ro&ess
84istin' $ro&ess &ontrols
8ustomer &on&ern data
8 5eOe&ts( PPM( Warranty data
(ccurrence
About 1 in 2
About 1 in 80
About 1 in 400
About 1 in 2000 @
$esi%n &esponsibility
© STM Quality Limited
STM Quality Limited
+n&reasin' ins$e&tion is only a tem$orary measure. Permanent orre&ti-e A&tion is re*uired.
m$hasis must )e $la&ed on $re-entin' de%e&ts rather than dete&tin' them Ke.'. S.P..
%ontrols
Pre-ention ontrols
8 Pla&e a EP" )e%ore ea&h $re-ention &ontrol listed
ete&tion ontrols
8 Pla&e a E" )e%ore ea&h dete&tion &ontrol listed
%ontrols
Pre-ention9 KPre%erred o$tion
Pre-ent the &ause me&hanism o% %ailure or the %ailure mode o&&urrin'( or redu&e their rate o% o&&urren&e
Preention %ontrols
ete&tion9
ete&t the &ause me&hanism o% %ailure or the %ailure mode and lead to &orre&ti-e a&tions
Detection %ontrols
Audi)le or -isual warnin' de-i&es
+n Pro&ess Final ins$e&tion
S.P..
$esi%n &esponsibility
ete&tion is an assessment o% the $ro)a)ility that9
The $ro&ess &ontrols listed will dete&t a $otential &ause me&hanism K$ro&ess wea/ness ( or
The $ro&ess &ontrols listed will dete&t a su)se*uent %ailure mode.
Detection
Almost &ertain
>
Pro&ess &ontrol will not andor &annot dete&t a $otential &ause J or there is no $ro&ess &ontrol
o&&urren&e
ete&tion Add to or im$ro-e the &ontrol methods
han'e the desi'n ... or the $ro&ess i% o$erator sa%ety is in-ol-ed
han'e the desi'n or $ro&ess
+m$ro-e a)ility to dete&t a %ailure mode
$esi%n &esponsibility
We ha-e seen that the F.M..A. as/s three *uestions9
What mi'ht 'o wron'!
What &aused the $ro)lem!
Failure Mode and Efect Analysis
From the answers to the three *uestions we &an wor/ out a ris/ $riority num)er9
*is/ Priority 0um)er
,ow do we &al&ulate the 5.P.<.!
We sim$ly use the s&orin' &riteria easily remem)ered )y9
Se-erity o% the $ro)lem
a&h is 'i-en a -alue %rom > to >0
Let"s try this out %or S( = D
For 4am$le(
=&&urren&e > 2 ? @ C 7 N H >0
ete&tion > 2 ? @ C 7 N H >0
Failure Mode and Efect Analysis
,ow &an we use these -alues to 'i-e an o-erall ris/!
We multi$ly the three #'ures to'ether9
e.'. 7 4 @ 4 ? N@.
So the 5.P.<. is N@.
Failure Mode and Efect Analysis
From the 5.P.<. we &an now see the areas o% 'reatest &on&ern
i.e. Those %ailures with the hi'hest ris/ $riority num)ers
Failure Mode and Efect Analysis
We &an now %o&us our attention on the worst $ro)lems 8 those with the hi'hest 5.P.<.
With limited resour&es( this must )e a 'ood idea
We &an now eliminate or
redu&e the $otential %ailure
$esi%n &esponsibility
*eco,,ended Actions
The intent o% any 5e&ommended A&tion is to redu&e ran/in's in the %ollowin' order9
Se-erity
$esi%n &esponsibility
*esponsi1ility
a&h a&tion must )e assi'ned to a s$e&i#& indi-idual and not a de$t. or'anisation
$esi%n &esponsibility
Actions aken
Actions aken
Ad-anta'es o% F.M..A.s
+m$ro-ed $arti&i$ation a&ross traditional )oundaries
More ad-anta'es o% F.M..A.s
ses e4tensi-e D unta$$ed $ersonnel$ro&ess /nowled'e to im$ro-e new D e4istin' wor/
Pro-ides a -ehi&le %or &ontinuous im$ro-ement
Su$$orts $rodu&t lia)ility
There are draw)a&/s %or F.M..A.s9
Must )e ade*uate time D resour&es %or F.M..A.s
Produ&t Lia)ility
Failure Mode and Efect Analysis
ee$ the meetin's short and the tem$o shar$
esi'n F.M..A. team 1 hairman( Produ&tion( Ser-i&e( Quality Personnel
Pro&ess F.M..A. team 1 R= ,==S
TOTAL QUALITY MANAGEMENT
What do we do when it"s #nished!
Introduction
Failure Mode and Efect Analysis?
F.M..A. is a sim$le way o% $redi&tin' what mi'ht 'o wron'.
By usin' a stru&tured method( results
&an )e *uanti#ed and hen&e &om$ared.
+denti#es &riti&al and si'ni#&ant &hara&teristi&s
,el$s en'ineers $rioritise and %o&us on
tilise indi-iduals" /nowled'e and s/ills within a team en-ironment
Failure Mode and Efect Analysis
F.M..A.s &an )e done %or any desi'n( manu%a&turin' or in1ser-i&e a&ti-ity
F.M..A.s are modular and &an )e
&arried out %or sin'le $arts or lar'e assem)lies
!ene"ts # Desi$n F.M.E. A.
Aids in e-aluatin' re*uirements and alternati-es Aids in initial esi'n %or Manu%a&ture +n&reases $ro)a)ility o% dete&tin' %ailure
modes and their e3e&ts Pro-ides additional in%ormation %or
testin' re*uirements ,el$s identi%y &riti&al and si'ni#&ant
&hara&teristi&s ,el$s -alidate test methods
!ene"ts # Process F.M.E. A.
+denti#es $otential $ro&ess related %ailure modes whi&h will e3e&t internale4ternal &ustomers 5edu&es &osts o% re$airs due to %aulty
$ro&ess methodolo'y +n&reases e6&ien&y sta)lishes a $riority system %or
&onsiderin' &orre&ti-e a&tions +denti#es &on#rmed &riti&al and
si'ni#&ant &hara&teristi&s
F.M..A +denti#es 5is/s
$esi%n &esponsibility
To /ee$ u$ with &om$etition
To retain &urrent )usiness
,el$ o)tain new )usiness
FM..A.s are li-in' do&uments and are u$dated when9
Modi#&ation to a &om$onent( $ro&ess or system is $lanned:
om$onent is to )e used in new en-ironment:
ustomer &on&ern arises.
Then identi%y )oundary %or analysis
<e4t( &reate a ;ow &hart %or one o$eration
Process Flow %hart
=$.>0 Pre$aration
=$.?0 Weld
=$.@0 assem)le
=$.C0 +ns$e&t D Pa&/StorePa&/
=$.20 Mould
!oundary For Analysis
Press EStart" )utton
=$.0 Trim
$esi%n &esponsibility
From Pro&ess ;ow9
nter a sim$le des&ri$tion o% the $ro&ess )ein' analysed i.e. Pla&e $art on trim ma&hine #4ture:
+ndi&ate the $ur$ose o% the $ro&ess )ein' analysed i.e. Fully seat $art in &orre&t orientation:
List se$arately other o$erations in-ol-ed with that $ro&ess:
Pro&ess %un&tion &ontains )oth $rodu&t and $ro&ess &hara&teristi&s.
Process)Function *e+uire,ents
What is the $ro&ess $ur$ose!
What is its %un&tion!
De"ne the Process Purpose
Process Purpose
=$.0 Trim
$esi%n &esponsibility
e#nition9
Potential %ailure mode is the manner in whi&h the $ro&ess &ould $otentially %ail to meet the $ro&ess re*uirements andor desi'n intent.
+t is a des&ri$tion o% the non1 &on%orman&e at that s$e&i#& o$eration.
Failure Mode
<o %un&tion
Partial %un&tion
+ntermittent %un&tion
$esi%n &esponsibility
e#nition9
The e3e&ts o% the %ailure mode on the &ustomer. The &ustomer &ould )e the ne4t o$eration( su)se*uent o$erations or the #nal &ustomer user.
Efects o' Failure Mode
ne4t user
downstream user
ultimate &ustomer
ma&hines e*ui$ment
Efects o' Failure Mode
'ncorrect to
$esi%n &esponsibility
e#nition9
An assessment o% the seriousness o% the e3e&t o% the $otential %ailure mode on the &ustomer.
eerity
with
warnin'
H
<one <o 3e&t >
$esi%n &esponsibility
© STM Quality Limited
STM Quality Limited
Identi'y pecial %haracteristics
5+T+AL9 5e*uirements that a3e&t &om$lian&e with 'o-ernment re'ulations or sa%e -ehi&le $rodu&t %un&tion and re*uire s$e&ial &ontrols KS&ore H or >0
$esi%n &esponsibility
e#nition9
Potential &ause o% a %ailure is de#ned as how the %ailure &ould o&&ur in terms o% somethin' that &an )e &orre&ted or &ontrolled.
%ause
© STM Quality Limited
STM Quality Limited
=nly s$e&i#& errors or mal%un&tions Ke'. =$erator %ails to remo-e waste should )e listed.
Am)i'uous $hrases Ke.'. =$erator error( ma&hine mal%un&tion should not )e used.
%ause
$esi%n &esponsibility
© STM Quality Limited
STM Quality Limited
,ow %re*uently the &ause is $roOe&ted to o&&ur. Based on9
8 ,istori&al manu%a&turin'assem)ly %ailure rates with similar $arts
8 Statisti&al data %rom similar $ro&ess
84istin' $ro&ess &ontrols
8ustomer &on&ern data
8 5eOe&ts( PPM( Warranty data
(ccurrence
About 1 in 2
About 1 in 80
About 1 in 400
About 1 in 2000 @
$esi%n &esponsibility
© STM Quality Limited
STM Quality Limited
+n&reasin' ins$e&tion is only a tem$orary measure. Permanent orre&ti-e A&tion is re*uired.
m$hasis must )e $la&ed on $re-entin' de%e&ts rather than dete&tin' them Ke.'. S.P..
%ontrols
Pre-ention ontrols
8 Pla&e a EP" )e%ore ea&h $re-ention &ontrol listed
ete&tion ontrols
8 Pla&e a E" )e%ore ea&h dete&tion &ontrol listed
%ontrols
Pre-ention9 KPre%erred o$tion
Pre-ent the &ause me&hanism o% %ailure or the %ailure mode o&&urrin'( or redu&e their rate o% o&&urren&e
Preention %ontrols
ete&tion9
ete&t the &ause me&hanism o% %ailure or the %ailure mode and lead to &orre&ti-e a&tions
Detection %ontrols
Audi)le or -isual warnin' de-i&es
+n Pro&ess Final ins$e&tion
S.P..
$esi%n &esponsibility
ete&tion is an assessment o% the $ro)a)ility that9
The $ro&ess &ontrols listed will dete&t a $otential &ause me&hanism K$ro&ess wea/ness ( or
The $ro&ess &ontrols listed will dete&t a su)se*uent %ailure mode.
Detection
Almost &ertain
>
Pro&ess &ontrol will not andor &annot dete&t a $otential &ause J or there is no $ro&ess &ontrol
o&&urren&e
ete&tion Add to or im$ro-e the &ontrol methods
han'e the desi'n ... or the $ro&ess i% o$erator sa%ety is in-ol-ed
han'e the desi'n or $ro&ess
+m$ro-e a)ility to dete&t a %ailure mode
$esi%n &esponsibility
We ha-e seen that the F.M..A. as/s three *uestions9
What mi'ht 'o wron'!
What &aused the $ro)lem!
Failure Mode and Efect Analysis
From the answers to the three *uestions we &an wor/ out a ris/ $riority num)er9
*is/ Priority 0um)er
,ow do we &al&ulate the 5.P.<.!
We sim$ly use the s&orin' &riteria easily remem)ered )y9
Se-erity o% the $ro)lem
a&h is 'i-en a -alue %rom > to >0
Let"s try this out %or S( = D
For 4am$le(
=&&urren&e > 2 ? @ C 7 N H >0
ete&tion > 2 ? @ C 7 N H >0
Failure Mode and Efect Analysis
,ow &an we use these -alues to 'i-e an o-erall ris/!
We multi$ly the three #'ures to'ether9
e.'. 7 4 @ 4 ? N@.
So the 5.P.<. is N@.
Failure Mode and Efect Analysis
From the 5.P.<. we &an now see the areas o% 'reatest &on&ern
i.e. Those %ailures with the hi'hest ris/ $riority num)ers
Failure Mode and Efect Analysis
We &an now %o&us our attention on the worst $ro)lems 8 those with the hi'hest 5.P.<.
With limited resour&es( this must )e a 'ood idea
We &an now eliminate or
redu&e the $otential %ailure
$esi%n &esponsibility
*eco,,ended Actions
The intent o% any 5e&ommended A&tion is to redu&e ran/in's in the %ollowin' order9
Se-erity
$esi%n &esponsibility
*esponsi1ility
a&h a&tion must )e assi'ned to a s$e&i#& indi-idual and not a de$t. or'anisation
$esi%n &esponsibility
Actions aken
Actions aken
Ad-anta'es o% F.M..A.s
+m$ro-ed $arti&i$ation a&ross traditional )oundaries
More ad-anta'es o% F.M..A.s
ses e4tensi-e D unta$$ed $ersonnel$ro&ess /nowled'e to im$ro-e new D e4istin' wor/
Pro-ides a -ehi&le %or &ontinuous im$ro-ement
Su$$orts $rodu&t lia)ility
There are draw)a&/s %or F.M..A.s9
Must )e ade*uate time D resour&es %or F.M..A.s
Produ&t Lia)ility
Failure Mode and Efect Analysis
ee$ the meetin's short and the tem$o shar$
esi'n F.M..A. team 1 hairman( Produ&tion( Ser-i&e( Quality Personnel
Pro&ess F.M..A. team 1 R= ,==S
Related Documents
