04.05.2015ORDERS(SP)

STATE INFORMATION COMMISSION, PUNJAB

SCO NO. 84-85, SECTOR 17-C, CHANDIGARH

Tele No. 0172-4630062, FAX No. 0172-4630888

Visit us @ www.infocommpunjab.comShri Gurdev Singh, (9465948752)

S/o Shri Gaga Singh,

Village Kothe Sapoora Singh wale,

P.O Mehma swai, District Bathinda. - 151201

Appellant

Versus

Public Information Officer

O/o Sub Divisional Magistrate,

Bathinda.-151001

First Appellate Authority,

O/o Deputy Commissioner, Bathinda.-151001

RespondentsAPPEAL CASE NO. 748 /2015

Present:Sh. Gurdev Singh, (9465948752) Appellant in person.

Sh. Avtar Singh, Naib Tehsildar (94172-01292) on behalf of Respondents.ORDER

RTI Application filed on

:23.06.2014

PIO Replied

:Nil

First Appeal Filed

:08.08.2014Complaint/ Second Appeal Received :29.12.2014

in State Information Commission on

Information Sought

:

Action taken on my appeal etc. as mentioned in his RTI application. Grounds for Complaint/Appeal

:No information was supplied. Contd..2

-2-

APPEAL CASE NO. 748 /2015

Relevant Facts Emerging during :

Hearing

The respondent has given detailed reply signed by the SDM, Bathinda today to the Commission a copy of the same was handed over to the appellant before the bench. In case the appellant wants to get more information, he may appear before the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Bathinda on 19.06.2015 at 11.0 AM.

DECISION :

The case is, therefore, closed and disposed off.

Announced in open Court,

The copies of order be sent to the parties.

Sd/-Chandigarh

(Satinder Pal Singh)

May 04, 2015

State Information Commissioner



Tele No. 0172-4630062, FAX No. 0172-4630888

Visit us @ www.infocommpunjab.comShri Amarjit Singh, (0946711923)

S/o Shri Gurdit Singh, 36,

The Mall, Ambala Cantt.-133001 AppellantVersus

Public Information Officer,

O/o Director Local Govt. Pb.

Juneja Building, Sector -17-C,Chandigarh-160017


O/o Director Local Govt. Pb.

Juneja Building, Sector -17-C, Chandigarh-160017

Respondents


Present:Shri Amarjit Singh, (0946711923) Appellant in person.

1. Sh. Sanjeev Kumar Sr. Asstt. (99888083722) and

2. Paramjit Singh, Supdt. (99889-98986) on behalf of Respondents.

ORDER

After hearing both the parties, it emerges that the requisite information was to be supplied by the PIO, office of Secretary, Local Government, Punjab ( Local Govt. I Br.) Sector-9,Chandigarh to whom the RTI application has since been transferred in December, 2014, but the appellant has not received any intimation pertaining to the same. On the next date of hearing, PIO, office of Secretary, Local government Punjab, (L.G.-I, Br.) Sector-9, Chandigarh will appear personally along with the information.

To come up on 12.06.2015 at 10.30 AM.

Sd/-Chandigarh


May 04, 2015


Copy to:


O/o Secreary, Local Govt. Pb. (Local Govt. I Br.) Setor-9, Chd.

---- You are directed to appear personally on the above mentioned date and time in the Commission along with information.

Sd/-Chandigarh


May 04, 2015

State Information CommissionerSTATE INFORMATION COMMISSION, PUNJAB


Tele No. 0172-4630062, FAX No. 0172-4630888

Visit us @ www.infocommpunjab.comShri Tarsem Jindal ,Neeli Chattri Wala (9855151985)

S/o Shri Kastoor Chand,

R/o Kothi No. 306, Aastha Enclave,

Barnala -148101

Complainant

Versus


O/o Additional Deputy Commissioner

Mansa

RespondentCOMPLAINT CASE NO. 674 /2015 Present:None on behalf of the Complainant.

Sh. Harwinder Singh, Clerk (94634-92241) on behalf of RespondentORDER


:24.01.2015

PIO Replied

:Nil

First Appeal Filed

:Nil

Complaint/ Second Appeal Received :02.03.2015


Information Sought

:

On fourteen points, regarding action taken on my dated 26.12.2014 etc. as mentioned in his RTI application. Grounds for Complaint/Appeal

:No information was supplied. Contd..2-2-

COMPLAINT CASE NO. 674 /2015


Hearing

The complainant is not present and sought exemption in writing vide diary no.8852 dated 08.04.2015. The perusal of the file shows that he has not availed the provisions of filing the first appeal before the First Appellate Authority. The respondent has submitted his reply -- a copy of which has been sent to the complainant on 18.02.2015. The complainant is directed to appear before the First Appellate Authority, i.e. Additional Deputy Commissioner, Mansa on 22.06.2015 at 11.00 AM.

DECISION :




Sd/-Chandigarh


May 04, 2015




Tele No. 0172-4630062, FAX No. 0172-4630888

Visit us @ www.infocommpunjab.com Dr. Sandeep Kumar Gupta (09992931181)#1722 Sector 14 Hissar,

Haryana-125001 Complainant

Versus


O/o Estate Officer PWD (B&R)

Nirman Bhawan

DAC, Nabha Road Patiala

Respondent


Present:None on behalf of the Complainant.

Sh. Pawan Sharma, Supdt. (98729-73049) on behalf of the Respondent

ORDER

The complainant is absent today but he has sent an intimation dated 02.05.2015 received in the Commission vide diary no.11062 dated 04.05.2015 regarding his objections to the reply sent by the respondent to him dated 24.04.2015. A copy of the objections received from the complainant was handed over to the respondent today. The case shall he heard again on 22.06.2015

To come up on 22.06.2015 at 10.30 AM.

Sd/-Chandigarh


May 04, 2015




Tele No. 0172-4630062, FAX No. 0172-4630888

Visit us @ www.infocommpunjab.comShri Ravinder Pal Singh (9888557750)

#332 Preet Colony

ChandigarhAmbala Road

Zirakpur Complainant

Versus


O/o Chief Engineer, Local Govt. Pb.

SCO 131-132, Sector -17-C Chandigarh Respondent


Present:Shri Ravinder Pal Singh (9888557750) complainant in person.

Sh. Neeraj Bhatti, A.T.P. (99888-00345) on behalf of Respondent. ORDER


:02.01.2015

PIO Replied

:Nil

First Appeal Filed

:Nil



Information Sought

:

Regarding copy of Inquiry Report on the application submitted by Nagar Council Employees Union, Zirakpur etc. as mentioned in his RTI application. Grounds for Complaint/Appeal

:No information was supplied.Contd..2

-2-



Hearing

The complainant has stated before the bench that the requisite information has since been received by him. The case is, therefore, closed.

DECISION :




Sd/-Chandigarh


May 04, 2015




Tele No. 0172-4630062, FAX No. 0172-4630888

Visit us @ www.infocommpunjab.comShri Tarsem Lal Sharma (09914224404)

8 Young Dwellers Society,

Sector 49 A Chandigarh Complainant

Versus


O/o Principal Secretary, Local Govt. Pb.

Mini Secretariat, Sector -9 Chandigarh RespondentCOMPLAINT CASE NO. 710 /2015

Present:Sh. Tarsem Lal Sharma (09914224404) Complainant in person.

Sh. Taranjeet Singh Asstt. (94652-23582) on behalf of the RespondentORDER


:01.01.2015

PIO Replied

:Nil

First Appeal Filed

:Nil



Information Sought

:

On five points regarding complaint against Sh. Varinder jain, Executive Officer, Nagar Council, Dera Bassi, etc. as mentioned in his RTI application. Grounds for Complaint/Appeal


-2-



Hearing

The requisite information has since been supplied a copy of which has been taken on record of the Commission. However, the complainant has pointed out that actual Inquiry Report which is mentioned at flag ( T ) in the noting portion has not been supplied. A copy of the same which is available with the respondent in the record, which he has brought, is ordered to be supplied to the complainant today itself. Apart from the documents which have been supplied, there are no other documents pertaining to the RTI application available in the record. Since the needful has been done, the case is closed.

DECISION :




Sd/-Chandigarh


May 04, 2015




Tele No. 0172-4630062, FAX No. 0172-4630888

Visit us @ www.infocommpunjab.comSh. N.K. Sayal,

Accounts Officer (Retd.),

Member RTI Federation, Punjab,

Sayal Street, Sirhind - 140406

Complainant

Versus


O/o Principal Secretary, Local Govt. Pb.

Mini Secretariat, Sector -9, Chandigarh Respondent


Present:Sh. N.K. Sayal,(01763-222700) Complainant in person.

Sh. Taranjit Singh, Asstt. (94652-23582) on behalf of the Respondent.

ORDER

After hearing both the parties, it emerges that the respondent present today has stated that the requisite information is to be supplied by the office of Director, Local Government, Punjab, although as stated by the complainant, both the offices are shifting responsibility of supplying the information to each other. On the next date of hearing, PIO, office of Director, Local Govt. Punjab along with the information.

To come up on 12.06.2015 at 10.30 AM.

Sd/-Chandigarh


May 04, 2015


Copy to:Public Information Officer,

O/o Director, Local Govt. Pb. Juneja Building,

Sector-17,Chandigarh

--- You are directed to ensure presence on the above date and time in the Commission

Sd/-Chandigarh


May 04, 2015




Tele No. 0172-4630062, FAX No. 0172-4630888

Visit us @ www.infocommpunjab.comShri Amar Nath, (9780362953)

House No. 33159, St. No. 1,

Partap Nagar, Bathinda-151005 Complainant

Versus


O/o Tehsildar,

Bathinda. -151001

Respondent


Present:None on behalf of the parties.ORDER

Both the parties are absent today without any intimation to the Commission. The case shall be heard again on 12.06.2015.

To come up on 12.06.2015 at 10.30 AM.

Sd/-Chandigarh


May 04, 2015




Tele No. 0172-4630062, FAX No. 0172-4630888

Visit us @ www.infocommpunjab.comSh. Rohit Sharma Adv. (98722-00918)

Chamber No. 320, Lawyers Chambers,

Second Floor, District Courts, Bathinda. - 151001 Complainant

Versus


O/o Deputy Commissioner, Bathinda.

Respondent

REMENADED TO First Appellate Authority

O/o Deputy Commissioner, Bathinda.


Present:None on behalf of the Complainant.Sh. Parmod Chander Kanoongo (98728-94331) on behalf of the RespondentORDER


:13.11.2014

PIO Replied

:Nil

First Appeal Filed

:Nil



Information Sought

:

On four points regarding Paying Guests accommodation in Bathinda City etc. as mentioned in his RTI application. Grounds for Complaint/Appeal

:No information was supplied.Contd..2-2-



Hearing

The complainant has informed in writing vide diary no.10140 dated 23.04.2015 that he has recently suffered from Head Injury and IS not in a position to travel to Chandigarh. He has requested that the complainant submitted by him be transferred to the First Appellate Authority for adjudication. Otherwise also the perusal of the file shows that the complainant has not availed the provisions of filing the first appeal before the First Appellate Authority. However, keeping in view his request this case is remanded to the First Appellate Authority, office of Deputy Commissioner, Bathinda , where the complainant is directed to appear on 15.06.2015 at 11.00 AM. DECISION :




Sd/-Chandigarh


May 04, 2015




Tele No. 0172-4630062, FAX No. 0172-4630888

Visit us @ www.infocommpunjab.comShri Prem Singh, (8146565200)

S/o Shri Harbhajan Singh,

1133/B- New Partap Nagar, G.T. Road, Amritsar-143001. Appellant Versus


o/o Director, Technical Education & Industrial Training, Pb.

Sector- 36 A, Chandigarh.


o/o Director Technical Education & Industrial Training, Pb.

Sector - 36 A, Chandigarh.

Respondent


Present:None on behalf of the Appellant

Sh. Rachhpal Singh, Sr. Asstt. (88720-10744) on behalf of Respondents.

ORDER


:28.02.2015

PIO Replied

:Nil

First Appeal Filed

:Nil



Information Sought

:

On four points regarding recruitment of wireman Instructor during July, 2013 etc. as mentioned in his RTI application.Grounds for Complaint/Appeal


-2-



Hearing

The appellant is absent today without any intimation to the Commission, However, the respondent has informed in writing that there is a Civil Writ Petition No.22757/2011 titled Sham Lal Bishnoi versus Central Government and other pending in the Hon'ble Punjab & Haryana High Court, Chandigarh pertaining to recruitment of 216 posts mentioned in the RTI application. The Hon'ble Punjab & Haryana High Court has stayed the process of recruitment of 216 posts. Since the case is sub-judice, therefore, the information sought by the appellant cannot be provided. The appellant has been informed accordingly by the respondent.

DECISION :




Sd/-Chandigarh


May 04, 2015




Tele No. 0172-4630062, FAX No. 0172-4630888

Visit us @ www.infocommpunjab.comShri Prem Kumar Rattan, (9872220039)

House No. 78/8, Park Road,

New Mandi Dhuri, District Sangrur. AppellantVersus


O/o Director, Local Govt. Pb.

Juneja Building Sector -17-C,Chandigarh.


O/o Director, Local Govt. Pb.

Juneja Building Sector -17-C,Chandigarh Respondents

APPEAL CASE NO. 845 /2015 Present:None on behalf of the Appellant.

Sh. Taranjit Singh, Asstt. (94652-23582) on behalf of Respondents.

ORDER

The appellant has intimated in writing vide diary no.11069 dated 04.05.2015 that having to appear in Judicial Court, Patiala today, therefore, he would not be able to appear before the Commission today and sought another date. However, the respondent has informed the appellant regarding the action taken. The case shall be heard again on 12.06.2015.

To come up on 12.06.2015 at 10.30 AM.

Sd/-Chandigarh


May 04, 2015




Tele No. 0172-4630062, FAX No. 0172-4630888

Visit us @ www.infocommpunjab.comShri Prem Kumar Rattan, (9872220039)

House No. 78/8, Park Road,

New Mandi Dhuri, District Sangrur.

Appellant

Versus


O/o Inspector General of Police,

Bathinda.


O/o Director General of Police, Pb.

Chandigarh.

Respondents


Present:None on behalf of the Appellant.

1.Sh. Dinesh Kumar Insp. (85588-00551),.

2. Sikander Singh ASI (85588-73812) and

3. Sh. Lachhman Singh, H.C.(99150-21754) n behalf of the Respondents.

The appellant has intimated in writing vide diary no.11069 dated 04.05.2015 that having to appear in Judicial Court, Patiala today, therefore, he would not be able to appear before the Commission today and sought another date. The case shall be heard again on 12.06.2015.

To come up on 12.06.2015 at 10.30 AM.

Sd/-Chandigarh


May 04, 2015




Tele No. 0172-4630062, FAX No. 0172-4630888

Visit us @ www.infocommpunjab.comSh. Parbodh Chander Bali (94170-10035)

16-Shiv Nagar, Batala Road,

Amritsar 143001

Appellant

Versus


O/o Municipal Corporation,

Town Hall, Amritsar

First Appellate Authority

O/o Municipal Corporation,

Town Hall, Amritsar

RespondentAPPEAL CASE NO. 2342/2014

Present:None on behalf of the Appellant

1. Sh. Jasbir Singh Addl. Commissioner-cum Nodal Officer and

2.Sh. Narinder Sharma (98728-89985), Jr. Asstt. on behalf of Respondents.ORDER

The appellant has requested in writing vide diary no.11074 dated 04.05.2015 to exempt his appearance today and sought adjournment. A copy of the written submissions filed by the appellant today was handed over to the Nodal Officer. The respondent has assured that the consolidated information would be supplied at his level by the next date of hearing to the appellant.

To come up on 22.06.2015 at 10.30 AM.

Sd/-Chandigarh


May 04, 2015


04.05.2015ORDERS(SP)

Documents

requisite information

gurdev singh

avtar singh

paramjit singh

chandigarh tele

punjab local

shri amarjit singh

shri gaga singh