Top Banner
!"##$ &'( )*))+ ,*- *.-/ !*-0$*0#) *- '12.#0 .1*$ "#$%&%'
199

0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

Aug 23, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!

!

!"##$%&'(%)*))+%%,*-%*.-/%!*-0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0

.1*$

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

"#$%&%'! !

Page 2: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

! !

Page 3: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!

!

!

!!

!

!

"#$%&'()!(*+!,$*,-./!+$0$'0&-*!-1!

2-(.!0(&*0!!

!

!

!

3(.$*!4$5($.0!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

6#$,&,!,72%&00$+!&*!0#$!17)1&))%$*0!-1!0#$!.$87&.$%$*0,!1-.!0#$!+$9.$$!-1!:-'0-.!

&*!;$0$.&*(./!<'&$*'$,!=>#:?@!A('7)0/!-1!;$0$.&*(./!B$+&'&*$@!C#$*0!D*&E$.,&0/!

! !

Page 4: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

(')*)&+',!

>.-1F!+.F!&.F!GF!;(*#($'5$!

A('7)0/!-1!;$0$.&*(./!B$+&'&*$@!C#$*0!D*&E$.,&0/!

>.-1F!+.F!AFHBF!67/00$*,!

H*&%()!<'&$*'$,!D*&0@!I*,0&070$!1-.!H9.&'7)07.()!(*+!A&,#$.&$,!J$,$(.'#!

AF!;(*+$*+.&$,,'#$!

I%K$.&()!B$(0!>.-+7'0,!

!

!

-+*.+',!)/!&0+!'+12%34!5)**%&&++!

+.F!LMF!N(79$*!

O-1&%(@!O-.P(/!

+.F!GF!N$.$,!

;&-*!A--+!C.-7K@!O$0#$.)(*+,!

>.-1F!+.F!:F!B($,!

A('7)0/!-1!;$0$.&*(./!B$+&'&*$@!C#$*0!D*&E$.,&0/!

!

!

-+*.+',!)/!&0+!+61*%31&%)3!5)**%&&++!

>.-1F!M%F!+.F!NF!:$!4.(2(*+$.!

J$K.$,$*0(0&E$!-1!0#$!+$(*!

>.-1F!+.F!&.F!OF!47/,!

A('7)0/!-1!4&-,'&$*'$!M*9&*$$.&*9@!G$7E$*!D*&E$.,&0/!

+.F!<F!B&))$0!

H*&%()!<'&$*'$,!D*&0@!I*,0&070$!1-.!H9.&'7)07.()!(*+!A&,#$.&$,!J$,$(.'#!

>.-1F!+.F!&.F!<F!:$!<%$0!

A('7)0/!-1!4&-,'&$*'$!M*9&*$$.&*9@!C#$*0!D*&E$.,&0/!

!

!

6#$!(70#-.!(*+!0#$!K.-%-0$.!9&E$!0#$!(70#-.&Q(0&-*!0-!'-*,7)0!(*+!0-!'-K/!K(.0,!-1!0#&,!P-.5!1-.!K$.,-*()!7,$!-*)/F!H*/!-0#$.!7,$!&,!)&%&0$+!2/!0#$!G(P,!-1!"-K/.&9#0F!>$.%&,,&-*!0-!.$K.-+7'$!(*/!%(0$.&()!'-*0(&*$+!&*!0#&,!P-.5!,#-7)+!2$!-20(&*$+!1.-%!0#$!(70#-.F!

Page 5: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

6H4GM!RA!"RO6MO6<!

!

!

!

E!

789:;!<=!><?7;?7@!!

"#$%&'(!)!A!*'+'($,!)+&(-./"&)-+!&-!0-$(!&$)+&!.'&'"&)-+!11111111111111!2!BC! 915D4')$32!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!E!

FC! G0%50!5)*H)$32,!1'+!51$,%34!.)1'!&1%3&I!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!J!

SFTF!H*+.-,0$*-*$!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!U!SFSF!<5(0-)$!(*+!&*+-)$!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!V!SFWF!R0#$.!'-*0.&270&*9!'-%K-7*+,!0-!2-(.!0(&*0!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TX!

EC! @&'1&+4%+,!&)!2+5'+1,+!.)1'!&1%3&!51$,%34!5)*H)$32,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!BK!

LC! 9)1'!&1%3&!2+&+5&%)3!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!BE!

YFTF!"#$%&'()!(*()/,&,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TY!YFTFTF! <(%K)$!K.$Z0.$(0%$*0!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TY!YFTFSF! <$K(.(0&-*!(*+!+$0$'0&-*!0$'#*&87$,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TU!

YFTFSFTF! "#.-%(0-9.(K#/!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!T[!YFTFSFSF! B(,,!,K$'0.-%$0./!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!T\!

YFSF!<$*,-./!(*()/,&,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!S]!YFSFTF! <$)$'0&-*!(*+!0.(&*&*9!-1!$^K$.0,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!SU!YFSFSF! B$0#-+,!(*+!,'()$,!7,$+!+7.&*9!$^K$.&%$*0,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!WX!

JC! >)35+H&$1M!/'1*+N)'D!)/!&0%,!,&$2O!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!EE!

PC! Q+/+'+35+,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!EL!

"#$%&'(!))!A!&#'!3'+3)&)4)&5!-6!6,'7)3#!")&)8'+3!&-!$+.(-3&'+-+'9!)+6,/'+"'!-6!*'+.'(:!$*':!,-"$&)-+!$+.!37-;)+*!#$0)&31!111111111111111!<=!

BC! R3&')2$5&%)3!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!LP!

FC! -1&+'%1M,!132!*+&0)2,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!LS!

EC! Q+,$M&,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!JK!

LC! T%,5$,,%)3!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!JF!

JC! 85D3)NM+24+*+3&,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!JP!

PC! Q+/+'+35+,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!JU!

Page 6: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

6H4GM!RA!"RO6MO6<!

!

!

!

E&!

"#$%&'(!)))!A!$!4$,).$&'.!/,&($>#)*#!%'(6-(7$+"'!,)?/).!"#(-7$&-*($%#5!"-/%,'.!&-!#)*#!('3-,/&)-+!7$33!3%'"&(-7'&(5!$+$,53)3!6-(!&#'!3)7/,&$+'-/3!?/$+&)6)"$&)-+!-6!&#'!&#(''!;+-@+!0-$(!&$)+&!"-7%-/+.3!111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111!AB!

BC! R3&')2$5&%)3!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!PF!

FC! -1&+'%1M,!132!*+&0)2,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!PL!

SFTF!J$(9$*0,!(*+!'#$%&'(),!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!UY!SFSF!<(%K)$,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!UY!SFWF!M^0.('0&-*!(*+!')$(*Z7K!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!U]!SFYF!I*,0.7%$*0(0&-*!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!U]!SF]F!_7()&0/!(,,7.(*'$!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!U[!SFUF!H*()/,&,!-1!1(0!,(%K)$,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!UV!

EC! Q+,$M&,!132!2%,5$,,%)3!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!PS!

WFTF!:$E$)-K%$*0!-1!,(%K)$!K.$Z0.$(0%$*0!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!UV!WFSF!DZN>G"!(*+!B<!K(.(%$0$.,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!U\!WFWF!B$0#-+!E()&+(0&-*!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF![T!

WFWFTF! <K$'&1&'&0/!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF![S!WFWFSF! <$)$'0&E&0/!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF![S!WFWFWF! G&*$(.&0/!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF![S!WFWFYF! H''7.('/!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF![Y!WFWF]F! >.$'&,&-*!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF![]!WFWFUF! G&%&0!-1!+$0$'0&-*!(*+!)&%&0!-1!87(*0&1&'(0&-*!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF![]!WFWF[F! <0(2&)&0/!-1!0#$!'-%K-7*+,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF![U!WFWFVF! H*()/,&,!-1!1(0!,(%K)$,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF![[!

LC! >)35M$,%)3!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!UV!

JC! 85D3)NM+24+*+3&,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!UV!

PC! Q+/+'+35+,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!SK!

"#$%&'(!)4!A!'4$,/$&)-+!-6!.)66'('+&!#'$&)+*!7'&#-.3!6-(!&#'!.'&'"&)-+!-6!0-$(!&$)+&!05!7'$+3!-6!&#'!#/7$+!+-3'!1111111111111111111!C=!

BC! R3&')2$5&%)3!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!SP!

FC! -1&+'%1M,!132!*+&0)2,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!SV!

SFTF!<(%K)$,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!V\!SFSF!"#$%&'()!(*()/,&,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!V\!

Page 7: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

6H4GM!RA!"RO6MO6<!

!

!

!

E&&!

SFWF!<$)$'0&-*!(*+!0.(&*&*9!-1!0#$!$^K$.0,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!\X!SFYF!N$(0&*9!%$0#-+,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!\Y!SF]F!M^K$.&%$*0()!,$0Z7K!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!\Y!

SF]FTF! "-%K(.&,-*!2$0P$$*!+&11$.$*0!#$(0&*9!%$0#-+,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!\]!SF]FSF! 6$'#*&'()!(,K$'0,!-1!0#$!,&*9$&*9!%$0#-+!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!\]!SF]FWF! ")$(*&*9!0#$!,-)+$.&*9!&.-*!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!\U!SF]FYF! <&*9$&*9!-*!0#$!,(%$!K)('$!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!\U!SF]F]F! N(2&07(0&-*!$11$'0!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!\[!

EC! Q+,$M&,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!VU!

WFTF!"-%K(.&,-*!2$0P$$*!+&11$.$*0!#$(0&*9!%$0#-+,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!\[!WFSF!6$'#*&'()!(,K$'0,!-1!0#$!,&*9$&*9!%$0#-+!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!\\!WFWF!M11$'0!-1!')$(*&*9!0#$!,-)+$.&*9!&.-*!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TXT!WFYF!<&*9$&*9!-*!0#$!,(%$!K)('$!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TXT!WF]F!N(2&07(0&-*!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TXW!

LC! T%,5$,,%)3!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!BKE!

JC! >)35M$,%)3!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!BKS!

PC! 85D3)NM+24+*+3&,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!BKV!

UC! Q+/+'+35+,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!BBK!

"#$%&'(!4!A!*$3!"#(-7$&-*($%#5!"-/%,'.!&-!3+)66!7$33!3%'"&(-7'&(5!$+.!/,&($!#)*#!%'(6-(7$+"'!,)?/).!"#(-7$&-*($%#5!"-/%,'.!&-!#)*#!('3-,/&)-+!7$33!3%'"&(-7'&(5!&-!/+($4',!0-$(!&$)+&!"-+&()0/&)+*!"-7%-/+.3!111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111!22=!

BC! R3&')2$5&%)3!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!BBP!

FC! -1&+'%1M!132!*+&0)2,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!BBS!

SFTF!D*0(.9$0$+!,'.$$*&*9!1-.!7*5*-P*,!7,&*9!C"Z<*&11ZB<!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TTV!SFTFTF! <(%K)$,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TTV!SFTFSF! C"Z<*&11!K(*$)!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TT\!SFTFWF! M^K$.&%$*0()!,$0Z7K!-1!0#$!+/*(%&'!#$(+,K('$!,(%K)&*9!=>7.9$!(*+!6.(K?!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TT\!SFTFYF! C"Z!R)1('0-%$0./!=C"Z<*&11!`!B<!&+$*0&1&'(0&-*?!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TSX!

SFSF!<'.$$*&*9!1-.!K.$+$1&*$+!(*+!7*5*-P*!2-(.!0(&*0!'-%K-7*+,!7,&*9!DN>G"ZNJB<!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TSX!SFSFTF! <(%K)$,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TST!SFSFSF! <$*,-./!(*()/,&,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TST!

Page 8: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

6H4GM!RA!"RO6MO6<!

!

!

!

E&&&!

SFSFWF! "#$%&'()!(*()/,&,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TST!SFSFYF! :(0(!&*0$.K.$0(0&-*!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TSS!

SFSFYFTF! 6(.9$0$+!,'.$$*&*9!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TSS!SFSFYFSF! D*0(.9$0$+!,'.$$*&*9!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TSY!

EC! Q+,$M&,!132!2%,5$,,%)3!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!BFP!

WFTF!D*0(.9$0$+!,'.$$*&*9!1-.!7*5*-P*,!7,&*9!C"Z<*&11!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TSU!WFSF!<'.$$*&*9!1-.!K.$+$1&*$+!(*+!7*5*-P*!2-(.!0(&*0!'-%K-7*+,!

7,&*9!DN>G"ZNJB<!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TSV!WFSFTF! 6(.9$0$+!,'.$$*&*9!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TS\!WFSFSF! D*0(.9$0$+!,'.$$*&*9!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TWT!

LC! >)35M$,%)3!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!BEU!

JC! 85D3)NM+24+*+3&,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!BES!

PC! Q+/+'+35+,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!BEV!

"#$%&'(!4)!A!*'+'($,!.)3"/33)-+!$+.!6/&/('!%(-3%'"&3!111111111111111!2<=!BC! W+3+'1M!'+,+1'50!)$&5)*+!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!BLJ!

TFTF!>-,&0&-*&*9!-1!0#$!0#$,&,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TY]!TFSF!B(&*!.$,$(.'#!1&*+&*9,!(*+!,'&$*0&1&'!'-*0.&270&-*,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!TYV!

TFSFTF! 6#$!,$*,&0&E&0/!-1!A)$%&,#!'&0&Q$*,!0-!(*+.-,0$*-*$!FFFFFFFFFFF!TY\!TFSFSF! DZN>G"ZNJZB<!(*()/,&,!1-.!0#$!,&%7)0(*$-7,!+$0$'0&-*!-1!2-(.!0(&*0!'-%K-7*+,!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!T]X!TFSFWF! 6#$!,&*9$&*9!%$0#-+!FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF!T]S!TFSFYF! I+$*0&1&'(0&-*!-1!*$P!2-(.!0(&*0!'-*0.&270&*9!'-%K-7*+,!FF!T]Y!

FC! =$&$'+!H+',H+5&%X+,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!BJP!

EC! Q+/+'+35+,!CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC!BPB!

!

$DDEFGHIEJKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK1112LM!

! @$**1'OYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYBPV!

! @1*+3X1&&%34YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYCBUE!

! T13DN))'2YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYCCBUU!

! >$''%5$M$*!Z%&1+YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYCCBSB!

!

Page 9: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

OR6H6IRO!IO:Ma!

!

!

!

E!

?<787R<?!R?T;[!!

SBI:! SZ%$0#/)&*+-)$!

WZHA"! WZ()0$.*(0&E$!1-.'$+!0$,0!

HH! (.$(!

H::! (*+.-,0(+&$*$+&-*$!

HC"! (70-%(0&'!9(&*!'-*0.-)!

H>"I! (0%-,K#$.&'!K.$,,7.$!'#$%&'()!&-*&,(0&-*!

H>I! (0%-,K#$.&'!K.$,,7.$!&-*&,(0&-*!! !

"I! '#$%&'()!&-*&,(0&-*!

"I! '-*1&+$*'$!&*0$.E()!

"I:! '-))&,&-*Z&*+7'$+!+&,,-'&(0&-*!

"b>! '/0-'#.-%$!>Y]X!!

MI! $)$'0.-*!&%K('0!&-*&,(0&-*!

M<! <K(&*!

M<I! $)$'0.-,K.(/!&-*&,(0&-*!

MD! M7.-K$(*!D*&-*!

AJ! A.(*'$!

AcNB! 17))!P&+0#!#()1!%(^&%7%!

C"! 9(,!'#.-%(0-9.(K#/!

C*JN! 9-*(+-0.-K&*$Z.$)$(,&*9!#-.%-*$!

N":! #&9#!$*$.9/!'-))&,&-*()!+&,,-'&(0&-*!

NJ! #&9#!.$,-)70&-*!

N>G"! #&9#!K$.1-.%(*'$!)&87&+!'#.-%(0-9.(K#/!

N<Z<>BM! #$(+,K('$!,-)&+ZK#(,$!%&'.-Z$^0.('0&-*!

I<R! &*0$.*(0&-*()!-.9(*&Q(0&-*!1-.!,0(*+(.+&Q(0&-*!

G"! )&87&+!'#.-%(0-9.(K#/!

GN! )70$&*&Q&*9!#-.%-*$!

GR:! )&%&0!-1!+$0$'0&-*!

Page 10: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

OR6H6IRO!IO:Ma!

!

!

!

E&!

GR_! )&%&0!-1!87(*0&1&'(0&-*!

G6_! )&*$(&.!0.(K!87(+.7K-)$!

BJAH! B$0ZH.9Z>#$ZH)(!('$0(0$!,()0!

B<! %(,,!,K$'0.-%$0./!

B<*! %7)0&K)$!,0(9$!%(,,!,K$'0.-%$0./!

Bc! %-)$'7)(.!P$&9#0!

!"#! %(,,Z0-Z'#(.9$!!

dBeNfe! K.-0-*(0$+!%-)$'7)(.!&-*!

O! 0-0()!(%-7*0!

ONW! (%-**&(!

>>B! K(.0,!K$.!%&))&-*!

>I<! K.-+7'0!&-*!,'(*!

J! >$(.,-*!K.-+7'0Z%-%$*0!'-..$)(0&-*!'-$11&'&$*0!

JS! '-$11&'&$*0!-1!+$0$.%&*(0&-*!

J<:! .$)(0&E$!,0(*+(.+!+$E&(0&-*!

J6! .$0$*0&-*!0&%$!

<:! ,0(*+(.+!+$E&(0&-*!

<O! ,&9*()Z0-Z*-&,$!.(0&-!

<IB! ,$)$'0$+!&-*!%-*&0-.&*9!

6<_! 0.&K)$!,0(9$!87(+.7K-)$!

6-A! 0&%$!-1!1)&9#0!

DZN>G"! 7)0.(Z#&9#!K$.1-.%(*'$!)&87&+!'#.-%(0-9.(K#/!

D3! D*&0$+!3&*9+-%!

D;! 7)0.(E&-)$0!

D<H! D*&0$+!<0(0$,!-1!H%$.&'(!

!!!!!!

Page 11: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

Chapter I

General introduction to boar taint detection

Page 12: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!

!

!

!

!

Page 13: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

W!

>\8(7;Q!R!

W;?;Q8:!R?7Q<T]>7R<?!7<!9<8Q!78R?7!T;7;>7R<?!

!

BC 915D4')$32!

!

RE$.! S]X!%&))&-*! K&9,! (.$! ,)(79#0$.$+! (**7())/! &*! 0#$! M7.-K$(*! D*&-*! 1-.! 0#$!

K7.K-,$! -1! %$(0! K.-+7'0&-*F! H2-70! 0P-Z0#&.+! -1! 0#$,$! K&9,! (.$! K.-+7'$+! &*! 1&E$!

'-7*0.&$,g!C$.%(*/!=SWh?@!<K(&*!=TUFTh?@!A.(*'$!=TXFh?@!>-)(*+!(*+!:$*%(.5!=(2-70!Vh!

$('#?F! I*!4$)9&7%@!%-.$! 0#$*!TT!%&))&-*!K&9,!(.$! ,)(79#0$.$+!K$.! /$(.@!P#&'#! &,! (2-70!

YF]h! -1! 0#$! 0-0()! (%-7*0! -1! K&9,! K.-+7'$+! &*! 0#$! MD! =6(2)$! IFT?=A(-,0(0@! SXTS?F!

I%K.-E$%$*0,! &*! +&$0,@! #-7,&*9! '-*+&0&-*,! (*+! 9$*$0&'! ,$)$'0&-*! &*! -.+$.! 0-! $*#(*'$!

'-%%$.'&()!$11&'&$*'&$,!(.$!0#$!.$(,-*!0#(0!%-+$.*!K&9!(*+!K&9!K.-+7'0&-*!,/,0$%,!(.$!

E$./!+&11$.$*0!1.-%!-.&9&*()!K&9!+-%$,0&'(0&-*!K.('0&'$,F!!

!

71.M+!RCB^!?$*.+'!)/!H%4,!,M1$40&+'+2!%3!&0+!;$')H+13!]3%)3!%3!FKBK!!_?$*.+',!1'+!*%MM%)3,!)/!0+12,`!!

!! >)$3&'O! -%MM%)3!

H%4,!

(+'5+3&14+!

H%4,!T! C$.%(*/! ]VFU! SWFX!S! <K(&*! YTFT! TUFT!W! A.(*'$! S]FY! TXFX!Y! >-)(*+! STFS! VFW!]! :$*%(.5! SXFT! [F\!U! O$0#$.)(*+,! TWFV! ]FY![! I0()/! TWFV! ]FY!V! 4$)9&7%! TTFY! YF]!\! D*&0$+!

3&*9+-%!

\F\! WF\!T

X!

>-.079()! ]F\! SFW!T

T!

H7,0.&(! ]F[! SFS!T

S!

J-%(*&(! ]FS! SFX!T

W!

N7*9(./! YF\! TF\!T

Y!

"Q$'#!

J$K72)&'!

WFW! TFW!T

]!

<P$+$*! WFX! TFS!T

U!

I.$)(*+! SF[! TFT!T

[!

A&*)(*+! SFS! XF\!T

V!

C.$$'$! TFV! XF[!T

\!

G&0#7(*&(! XF\! XFY!

Page 14: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

Y!

S

X!

47)9(.&(! XF\! XFY!S

T!

<)-E(5&(! XF[! XFW!S

S!

"/K.7,! XF[! XFW!S

W!

G(0E&(! XFY! XFS!S

Y!

M,0-*&(! XFY! XFS!S

]!

<)-E$*&(! XFY! XFS!S

U!

G7^$%2-7.9! XFT! XFXY!S

[!

B()0(! XFXV! XFXW!! 6-0()! S]YF]V! !

!

H*&%()! P$)1(.$! &,! (! 5$/! &,,7$! 1-.! K&9! K.-+7'$.,! &*! %-,0! K(.0,! -1! 0#$! P-.)+@!

$,K$'&())/!1-.!0#-,$!K.-+7'$.,!P#-!P(*0!0-!'-*0&*7$!$^K-.0&*9!K-.5!K.-+7'0,!P&0#-70!(!

.$,0.&'0&-*F!6#$!&*'.$(,$+!+$%(*+!1.-%!'-*,7%$.,!(*+!.$0(&)$.,!1-.!%-.$!iK&9!1.&$*+)/j!

K.-+7'0&-*! %$0#-+,@! &,! 1-.'&*9! 9-E$.*%$*0,! 0-! )$9&,)(0$! (*+! &%K-,$! (! K)$0#-.(! -1!

.$97)(0&-*,!-*!MD!)&E$,0-'5!(*+!K&9!K.-+7'$.,@!$F9F!9.-7K!#-7,&*9!-1!,-P,F!MD!)$9&,)(0&-*!

,0&K7)(0$,!0#(0!,-P,!,#-7)+!2$!5$K0!&*!9.-7K,!+7.&*9!(!K$.&-+!,0(.0&*9!1.-%!1-7.!P$$5,!

(10$.!,$.E&'$!0-!-*$!P$$5!2$1-.$!0#$!$^K$'0$+!0&%$!-1!1(..-P&*9!=SXXTkVVkM"?F!

<7.9&'()! '(,0.(0&-*! -1! %()$! (*&%(),! &*0$*+$+! 1-.! %$(0! K.-+7'0&-*! #(,! 2$$*!

P&+$)/!K.('0&,$+!1-.!'$*07.&$,F!6#$!%(&*!.$(,-*,!'-7)+!2$!1-7*+!&*!0#$!$(,&$.!#(*+)&*9!

-1!0#$!'(,0.(0$+!(*&%(),!(*+!0#$!1('0!0#(0!'(,0.(0$+!(*&%(),!+$K-,&0!%-.$!1(0@!P#&'#!P(,!

(0!0#(0!0&%$!.$87$,0$+!2/!'-*,7%$.,F!B-.$!.$'$*0)/@!'-*,7%$.,!0$*+!0-!+$%(*+!(!+&$0!

'-*,&,0&*9!-1!)$(*!%$(0F!6#&,!1('0@!'-%2&*$+!P&0#!0#$!)-P$.!K.-+7'0&-*!'-,0,!1-.!$*0&.$!

%()$,@!)$+!&*!%-,0!'-7*0.&$,!0-!0#$!(2(*+-*&*9!-1!'(,0.(0&-*!-1!'(00)$!(*+!,#$$KF!I*!K&9!

K.-+7'0&-*@! ,7.9&'()! '(,0.(0&-*! =P&0#-70! (*($,0#$,&(! -.! (*()9$,&(?! &,! ,0&))! K.('0&,$+! 0-!

.$%-E$!(*!7*K)$(,(*0!-+-7.!1.-%!K-.5!%$(0!7K-*!'--5&*9!(*+!0-!K.$E$*0!7*+$,&.(2)$!

,$^7()!(*+!(99.$,,&E$!2$#(E&-7.!-1!K&9,F!<-!1(.@!,7.9&'()!'(,0.(0&-*!-1!%()$!K&9,!P&0#-70!

(*($,0#$,&(! P(,! 0#$!%-,0! '-%%-*! K.('0&'$! &*! M7.-K$! 0-! (E-&+! 7*K)$(,(*0! -+-7.! -.!

0(,0$@! &*')7+&*9! (KK.-^&%(0$)/! \Y! %&))&-*! (*&%(),! K$.! /$(.! =A.$+.&5,$*! $0! ()F@! SXX\?F!

O$E$.0#$)$,,@! &0! #(,! 2$'-%$! (! ,&9*&1&'(*0! (*&%()! P$)1(.$! '-*'$.*! &*! .$'$*0! /$(.,F!

J$,$(.'#!#(,!K.-E$*!0#(0!0#&,!,7.9&'()!K.-'$+7.$!&*1)&'0,!K(&*@!$E$*!-*!E$./!/-7*9!K&9,!

=B(.^!$0!()F@!SXXW?F!I*!.$,K-*,$!0-!0#$,$!9.-P&*9!'-*'$.*,@!,$E$.()!%(&*!K)(/$.,!P&0#&*!

0#$! K&9! (*+! K-.5! &*+7,0./! &*! 0#$! MD! #(E$! (9.$$+! 0-! E-)7*0(.&)/! $*+! 0#$! K.('0&'$! -1!

,7.9&'()!K&9!'(,0.(0&-*!2/!L(*7(./!T,0!SXTVF!!

Page 15: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

]!

I*!.$'$*0!/$(.,!(!)-0!-1!.$,$(.'#!#(,!2$$*!'-*+7'0$+!-*!()0$.*(0&E$,!1-.!,7.9&'()!

'(,0.(0&-*! P&0#-70! (*($,0#$,&(@! (%-*9,0! P#&'#! '(,0.(0&-*! P&0#! (*($,0#$,&(@!

&%%7*-'(,0.(0&-*@!7,$!-1!(*()9$,&(!(*+!K.-+7'0&-*!-1!$*0&.$!%()$,!&*!'-%2&*(0&-*!P&0#!

%(*(9$%$*0!K.-'$+7.$,!(.$!0#$!%-,0!K-K7)(.F!I0!%(/!#-P$E$.!2$!$^K$'0$+!0#(0!-*!0#$!

)-*9! 0$.%@! '(,0.(0&-*!P&))! 2$! (E-&+$+! (*+!%-,0! )&5$)/! 0#$! '#-&'$!P&))! 2$!%(+$! 1-.! 0#$!

K.-+7'0&-*! -1! $*0&.$! %()$,F! N-P$E$.@! 0#$! K.-+7'0&-*! -1! $*0&.$! %()$,! +-$,! *-0!

97(.(*0$$! 0#$! '-%K)$0$! $)&%&*(0&-*! -1! 2-(.! 0(&*0F! 6#$.$1-.$@! 0#$! +$E$)-K%$*0! -1!

%$0#-+,!0-!(,,$,,!2-(.!0(&*0!(0!0#$!,)(79#0$.)&*$!0-!,-.0!-70!0(&*0$+!'(.'(,,$,!&,!7.9$*0)/!

*$$+$+F!4-(.! 0(&*0! &,! 0#$!7*K)$(,(*0!-+-7.! 0#(0!'(*!-''7.!P#$*! 1(0!-.!%$(0!-1!$*0&.$!

%()$,!&,!#$(0$+F!6#$!-+-7.!#(,!2$$*!+$,'.&2$+!(,!(*&%()@!7.&*$@!1($'()!(*+!,P$(0,Z)&5$!

=MA<H@!SXXY?@!(*+!0#$!&*'&+$*'$!-1!2-(.!0(&*0!(0!'-%%$.'&()!,)(79#0$.!P$&9#0!&*!4$)9&7%!

#(,!2$$*!$,0&%(0$+!2$0P$$*!Yh!,0.-*9)/!0(&*0$+!(*+!S]h!%-+$.(0$)/!0(&*0$+!=H)7Pl!$0!

()F@! SXX\?F!6#$!K.$,$*'$!-1!2-(.! 0(&*0! &*!K-.5!K.-+7'0,!#(,!-10$*!2$$*!$E()7(0$+!2/!(!

0.(&*$+!,$*,-./!K(*$)!=G7*+,0.-%!$0!()F@!SXX\?F!N-P$E$.@!0#$!7,$!-1!,$*,-./!0$,0,!,#-P,!

,$E$.()! +.(P2('5,! ,7'#! (,! #&9#! '-,0,@! #&9#! E(.&(2&)&0/! (*+! )-P! (''7.('/F! I*! (++&0&-*@!

0#$.$! &,! 0-! +(0$! ,0&))! *-! $,0(2)&,#$+! &*0$.*(0&-*())/! (KK.-E$+! +$1&*&0&-*! -1! 0#$! ,$*,-./!

K$.'$K0&-*! -1! 2-(.! 0(&*0@! $^'$K0! 0#(0! &0! .$)(0$,! 0-! 0#$! -+-7.! ,72,0(*'$,! ,5(0-)$! (*+!

(*+.-,0$*-*$F!J$9(.+)$,,!-1!0#$!K)$0#-.(!-1!(*()/0&'()!K.-0-'-),!0-!+$0$.%&*$!0#$!)$E$)!

-1!,5(0-)$!(*+!(*+.-,0$*-*$@! 17.0#$.!E()&+(0&-*! &,!*$$+$+!(*+!0#$.$!,0&))!$^&,0,!(!*$$+!

1-.!(!#(.%-*&,$+@!(KK.-E$+!%$0#-+! 1-.!+$0$'0&*9!2-(.! 0(&*0! &*! 0#$!MD! =N(79$*!$0!()F@!

SXTS?F!

!

FC G0%50!5)*H)$32,!1'+!51$,%34!.)1'!&1%3&I!

!

6#$! %(&*! '-%K-7*+,! (00.&270$+! 0-! 0#$! 2-(.! 0(&*0! -11Z-+-7.! (.$! ,5(0-)$! (*+!

(*+.-,0$*-*$F!I*+-)$!-*)/!'-*0.&270$,!0-!(!)$,,$.!+$9.$$!=>(00$.,-*@!T\UVm!;-)+@!T\[X?!

=A&9!IFT?F!6#$!)$E$)!-1!'-*0.&270&-*!0-!2-(.!0(&*0!(*+!&*0$.('0&-*,!2$0P$$*!0#$!'-%K-7*+,!

(.$!,0&))!(!,72n$'0!-1!+&,'7,,&-*F!!

Page 16: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

U!

!=%4!RCB^!>0+*%51M!,&'$5&$'+!)/!8`!132'),&+3)3+a!9)!,D1&)M+!132!>`!%32)M+!

SFTF 832'),&+3)3+!

H*+.-,0$*-*$! =]oZ(*+.-,0ZTUZ$*$ZWZ-*$?! &,! (! "T\ZpTUZ,0$.-&+! 0#(0! P(,!

&+$*0&1&$+! 1-.! 0#$! 1&.,0! 0&%$! (,! (! '-%K-7*+! -1! 2-(.! 0(&*0! 2/! >(00$.,-*! =T\UV?F! I0! &,!

,/*0#$,&Q$+! &*!0#$!G$/+&9!'$)),!-1!0#$!0$,0$,!(*+!'-*0.-))$+!2/!0#$!,(%$!%$'#(*&,%!(,!

0#$!-0#$.!0$,0&'7)(.!,0$.-&+,g!0#$!#/K-0#()(%&'ZK&07&0(./Z9-*(+()!(^&,!=C-P$.@!T\[S?F!6#$!

K.-+7'0&-*!-1!(*+.-,0$*-*$!9$*$.())/!-''7.,!&*!0P-!P(E$,!P&0#!K(.0&'7)(.)/!#&9#!)$E$),!

-1!(*+.-,0$*-*$!&*!0#$!,$'-*+!P(E$!,0(.0&*9!(.-7*+!P$$5!TYF!6#$!,$'-*+!P(E$!-''7.,!

0-9$0#$.!P&0#!0#$!K.-+7'0&-*!-1!0#$!-0#$.!0$,0&'7)(.!,0$.-&+,!(0!,$^7()!%(07.&0/!=")(7,!$0!

()F@!T\\Y?!=A&9!IFS?F!!

!=%4!RCF^!7%*+!5)$',+!)/!132'),&+3)3+!2$'%34!H$.+'&1M!2+X+M)H*+3&!%3!+3&%'+!*1M+!H%4,!

!_>M1$,!+&!1MCa!BVVL`!!

Page 17: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

[!

H!%(n-.!K(.0!-1!(*+.-,0$*-*$!&,!&%%$+&(0$)/!%$0(2-)&,$+!&*!0#$!0$,0$,!P#$.$!&0!

2$'-%$,! ,7)1('-*n79(0$+F! H! ,&%&)(.! K.-'$,,! -''7.,! &*! 0#$! )&E$.! P#$.$! "b>Z%$+&(0$+!

2&-0.(*,1-.%(0&-*!0(5$,!K)('$!=q(%(.(0,5(&(!`!<87&.$,@!SXX\?!=A&9!IFW?F!!

!

!!

=%4!RCEC!-+&1.)M%5!H1&0N1O,!)/!132'),&+3)3+!132!,D1&)M+!!

H*+.-,0$*-*$! &,! 0.(*,K-.0$+! 0#.-79#! 0#$! 2)--+! ,0.$(%! (*+! 0#$! 7*'-*n79(0$+!

1-.%! '(*@! (,! (! .$,7)0! -1! &0,! )&K-K#&)&'! '#(.('0$.&,0&',@! 2$! ,0-.$+! &*! 1(0F! 6#$! ,0-.(9$! &*!

(+&K-,$!0&,,7$!&,!.$E$.,&2)$@!#-P$E$.!0#$!.$)$(,$!&*0-!0#$!2)--+!,0.$(%!1.-%!0#$!(+&K-,$!

0&,,7$!&,!,)-P$.!0#(*!0#$!7K0(5$!=4.--5,!`!>$(.,-*@!T\VU?F!6#$!(%-7*0!-1!(*+.-,0$*-*$!

,0-.$+!&*!1(0!+$K$*+,!-1!0#$!&*0$*,&0/!-1!0#$!0$,0&'7)(.!,/*0#$,&,!(*+!0#$!)&E$.!(*+!0$,0$,!

%$0(2-)&,%!=J-2&'!$0!()F@!SXXV?F!>(.0!-1!0#$!(*+.-,0$*-*$!&,!0.(*,K-.0$+!1.-%!0#$!2)--+!

0-! 0#$! ,()&E(./! 9)(*+! P#$.$! &0! 2&*+,! 0-! (! ,K$'&1&'! K.-0$&*F! H*+.-,0$*-*$! ('0,! (,! (!

K#$.-%-*$! -*'$! .$)$(,$+! &*! 0#$! ,()&E(m! 0#&,! &,! .$87&.$+! 1-.! 0#$!%(0&*9! ,0(*'$! +7.&*9!

-$,0.-7,! -1! 0#$! 1$%()$! K&9! =4.--5,! `! >$(.,-*@! T\VU?F! <K$'&1&'! ,$)$'0&-*! (9(&*,0!

(*+.-,0$*-*$! .$,7)0,! %-,0)/! &*! (! +$'.$(,$+! K$.1-.%(*'$! (*+! ,$^7()! %(07.(0&-*!

=q(%(.(0,5(&(!`!<87&.$,@!SXX\?F!

!

<$*,&0&E&0/! -1! #7%(*,! 0-! (*+.-,0$*-*$! &,! 9$*$0&'())/! +$0$.%&*$+! =3$))$.! $0! ()F@!

SXX[?F! B-.$! ,K$'&1&'@! 9$*-0/K&'! E(.&(0&-*! &*! RJ[:Y! K.$+&'0,! 0#$! E(.&(0&-*! &*! 0#$!

Page 18: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

V!

K$.'$K0&-*! -1! (*+.-,0$*-*$F! 6P-! '-%%-*! ())$)$,! -1! 0#&,! .$'$K0-.! (.$!RJ[:Y! J6! (*+!

RJ[:Y!cBF!3$))$.!$0!()F! =SXX[?! &*E$,0&9(0$+!0#$!,$*,&0&E&0/!-1!(*+.-,0$*-*$!P&0#!K7.$!

(*+.-,0$*-*$! './,0(),! (*+! 1-7*+! 0#(0! &*+&E&+7(),! P&0#! RJ[:Y! J6kcB! (*+!cBkcB!

9$*-0/K$,! P$.$! )$,,! ,$*,&0&E$! 0-! (*+.-,0$*-*$! 0#(*! &*+&E&+7(),,! P&0#! 0#$! J6kJ6!

9$*-0/K$F!4$,&+$,@!0#$!RJ[:Y!9$*-0/K$!(),-!&*1)7$*'$,!0#$!$E()7(0&-*!-1!(*+.-,0$*-*$Z

0(&*0$+!'--5$+!%$(0!,(%K)$,!=G7*+$!$0!()F@!SXTS?F!I*+&E&+7(),!P&0#!0P-!'-K&$,!-1!0#$!J6!

E(.&(*0! 0$*+$+! 0-! .(0$! (*+.-,0$*-*$Z'-*0(&*&*9!%$(0! (,! )$,,! 1(E-7.(2)$! 0#(*!K$.,-*,!

'(../&*9!0#$!cB!E(.&(*0,F!>(.0!-1!0#$!K-K7)(0&-*!&,!(*-,%&'!0-!(*+.-,0$*-*$F!N-P$E$.@!

,-%$!(*-,%&'! &*+&E&+7(),! K-,,$,! 0#$! .$'$K0-.,! .$87&.$+!270! (0! ,72Z0#.$,#-)+! +$*,&0/F!

6#&,! (*-,%&(! '(*! 2$! '-*E$.0$+! 0-! -,%&'! (10$.! 1.$87$*0! $^K-,7.$! 0-! (*+.-,0$*-*$!

=c/,-'5&!`!4$(7'#(%K@!T\VYm!c/,-'5&!$0!()F@!T\V\?F!<$E$.()!,07+&$,!#(E$!.$E$()$+!0#(0!

,$*,&0&E&0/!0-!(*+.-,0$*-*$!E(.&$,!P&0#!9$*+$.@!(9$@!(*+!'-7*0./!(%-*9!-0#$.!E(.&(2)$,F!

A-.! $^(%K)$@! 0#$! K$.'$*0(9$! -1! (*-,%&'! P-%$*! E$.,7,! (*-,%&'! %$*! #(,! 2$$*!

$,0&%(0$+!0-!2$!T]FV!E,!SYFT!h!&*!M7.-K$!=$^')F!D3?@!S\F]!E,!W[FS!h!&*!D<H!(*+!T[FS!E,!

S]F]!h!&*!H,&(!=C&)2$.0!`!c/,-'5&@!T\V[?F!6#$!,$*,&0&E&0/!&*!A)(*+$.,!=0#$!*-.0#$.*!K(.0!-1!

4$)9&7%?!#(,!*-0!2$$*!0$,0$+!K.$E&-7,)/@!(*+!'(**-0!2$!+$.&E$+! 1.-%!,07+&$,! &*!-0#$.!

M7.-K$(*! '-7*0.&$,@! (,! ,$*,&0&E&0/! #(,! 2$$*! ,#-P*! 0-! +&11$.! 2$0P$$*! '-7*0.&$,F!

N-P$E$.@!5*-P)$+9$!-*!0#$!,$*,&0&E&0/!-1!'-*,7%$.,!0-!2-(.!0(&*0!&,!&%K-.0(*0@!0-!#$)K!

+$0$.%&*$! 0#$! &%K('0! -1! 2-(.! 0(&*0!P#$*! '(,0.(0&-*! -1!%()$! K&9)$0,! &,! 2(**$+! (*+! 0-!

$E()7(0$! P#$0#$.! 0#$! *7%2$.,! -1! '-*,7%$.,! 0$,0$+! &*! 0#$! .$,K$'0&E$! ,07+&$,@! (.$!

.$K.$,$*0(0&E$! P&0#! .$,K$'0! 0-! 0#$! *7%2$.! -1! '-*,7%$.,! 0#(0! &,! ,$*,&0&E$! 0-!

(*+.-,0$*-*$F!

SFSF @D1&)M+!132!%32)M+!

<5(0-)$! =WZ%$0#/)Z&*+-)$?! &,! 1-.%$+! &*! 0#$! #&*+970! 1.-%! 0#$! (%&*-! ('&+! GZ

0./K0-K#(*F!6#&,!1-.%(0&-*!-''7.,!&*!0P-!,0$K,g!0#$!K.-+7'0&-*!-1!WZ&*+-)$!('$0&'!('&+!2/!

M,'#$.&'#&(!"-)&!(*+!")-,0.&+&7%@!(*+!0#$!9$*$.(0&-*!-1!,5(0-)$!2/!(!,K$'&1&'!G('0-2('&))7,!

,0.(&*! =G('0-2('&))7,! ,KF! <0.(&*! TTSXT?! (*+! ")-,0.&+&7%! =L$*,$*! $0! ()F@! T\\](?F! 6#$!

1-.%(0&-*!-1!,5(0-)$!+$K$*+,!%(&*)/!-*!0#$!(E(&)(2&)&0/!-1!GZ0./K0-K#(*!0#(0! &,!+$.&E$+!

1.-%! '$))! +$2.&,! -1! 0#$! 970Z%7'-,(! (*+! 0#$! '-%K-,&0&-*! (*+! ('0&E&0/! -1! 0#$! &*0$,0&*()!

Page 19: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

\!

2('0$.&(! =q(%(.(0,5(&(! `! <87&.$,@! SXX\?F! 6#$! )$E$)! -1! &*0$,0&*())/! K.-+7'$+! ,5(0-)$! &,!

%(&*)/!+$K$*+$*0!-*!*70.&0&-*()!1('0-.,!(*+!*-!9$*$0&'!'-*0.-)!#(,!2$$*!+$%-*,0.(0$+!

,-!1(.F!H),-@!*-!K#/,&-)-9&'()!17*'0&-*!-1!,5(0-)$!#(,!2$$*!+$,'.&2$+!&*!K&9,!=J-2&'!$0!()F@!

SXXV?F!!

6./K0-K#(*! '(*! (),-! 2$! +$9.(+$+! 0-! &*+-)$@! 2/! (! E(.&$0/! -1! 2('0$.&()! ,K$'&$,F!

c&0#&*! 0#$! '-)-*@! &*+-)$! 1-.%(0&-*! K.$+-%&*(*0)/! -''7.,! &*! 0#$! '($'7%@! P#$.$(,!

,5(0-)$! '-*'$*0.(0&-*,! (.$! #&9#$,0! &*! 0#$! .$'07%F! <5(0-)$! (*+! &*+-)$! (.$! *-0! -*)/!

K.-+7'$+! &*! $*0&.$! %()$! K&9,@! 270! (),-! &*! 9&)0,! (*+! '(,0.(0$,@! &*! 0#$! '-)-*! -1! -0#$.!

%-*-9(,0.&'!,K$'&$,@!(,!P$))!(,!&*!0#$!.7%$*!-1!0#$!2-E&*$!(*+!'(K.&*$!,K$'&$,!=")(7,!$0!

()F@!T\\Y?F!

H!K(.0!-1!0#$!1-.%$+!,5(0-)$!&,!$^'.$0$+!&*!0#$!1($'$,!=A&9!IFW?F!6#$!)$E$),!1-7*+!&*!

1($'$,! '(**-0! 2$! +&,'.&%&*(0$+! 2$0P$$*! 9$*+$.,! =b-5-/(%(! `! "(.),-*@! T\[\?F! 6#$!

.$%(&*&*9! K(.0! -1! ,5(0-)$! &,! (2,-.2$+! &*0-! 0#$! 2)--+@! %$0(2-)&,$+! &*! 0#$! )&E$.! (*+!

$^'.$0$+! &*! 0#$! 7.&*$! =q(%(.(0,5(&(! `! <87&.$,@! SXX\?F! 4$'(7,$! -1! 0#$! )&K-K#&)&'!

'#(.('0$.&,0&',!-1!,5(0-)$!(*+!&*+-)$!(!K(.0!%(/!(),-!(''7%7)(0$!&*!(+&K-,$!0&,,7$!=4(2-)!

$0! ()F@! T\\]?F! 6#$! '-*'$*0.(0&-*,!-1! ,5(0-)$! (*+! &*+-)$! &*! 1(0! (.$!#-P$E$.! (11$'0$+!2/!

9$*+$.F!N&9#$.!'-*'$*0.(0&-*!)$E$),!(.$!1-7*+!&*!$*0&.$!%()$!K&9,!0#(*!&*!2(..-P,!-.!9&)0,!

=q(%(.(0,5(&(!`!<87&.$,@!SXX\?F!6#$!)$E$),!-1!,5(0-)$!&*!$*0&.$!%()$!K&9,!(),-!&*'.$(,$!(0!

K72$.0/! =4(2-)! $0! ()F@! SXXY?F! <$E$.()! #/K-0#$,$,! #(E$! 2$$*! K.-K-,$+! 1-.! 0#&,!

-2,$.E(0&-*F! :7.&*9! 0#$! /$(.,! $F9F! <&*9#! $0! ()F! =<&*9#! $0! ()F@! T\VV?! ,799$,0$+! 0#(0! (*!

(++7'0!P(,!1-.%$+!2$0P$$*!,5(0-)$!(*+!(*+.-,0$*-*$!+7.&*9!2)--+!0.(*,K-.0m!")(7,!$0!

()F! =T\\Y?! ,799$,0$+! 0#(0! (0! K72$.0/! 0#$! 07.*-E$.! -1! &*0$,0&*()! '$)),! &,! $*#(*'$+@!

K.-E&+&*9! (! ,-7.'$! -1! 0./K0-K#(*! 1-.! ,5(0-)$! K.-+7'0&-*F! N-P$E$.@! &0! #(,! (),-! 2$$*!

K.-K-,$+! 0#(0! 0#$! K72$.0()! &*'.$(,$! &*! ,5(0-)$! )$E$),! %(/! 2$! '(7,$+! 2/! &*'.$(,&*9!

(*+.-,0$*-*$!(*+!-$,0.-9$*!)$E$),!=2-0#!,/*0#$,&Q$+!&*!0#$!0$,0$,?!&*!K&9,!(0!0#(0!,0(9$F!

6#-,$!'-%K-7*+,!(.$!&+$*0&1&$+!(,!&*#&2&0-.,!-1!"b>SMT!(*+!"b>SH!$*Q/%$!$^K.$,,&-*@!

.$,K-*,&2)$! 1-.! 0#$! %$0(2-)&,%! -1! ,5(0-)$! &*! 0#$! )&E$.F! 6#.-79#! 0#&,! %$'#(*&,%@!

%$0(2-)&,%! &,! .$+7'$+! (*+! ,5(0-)$! %(/! (''7%7)(0$! &*! (+&K-,$! 0&,,7$! =:-.(*! $0! ()F@!

SXXS?F!4$,&+$,!&0!#(,!2$$*!,#-P*!0#(0!0$,0-,0$.-*$!&,!*-0!&*E-)E$+!&*!0#$!.$97)(0&-*!-1!

Page 20: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

TX!

,5(0-)$! )$E$),F! 6#$! .-)$! -1! -0#$.! 0$,0&'7)(.Z+$.&E$+! '-%K-7*+,! .$%(&*,! 0-! 2$!

&*E$,0&9(0$+!=q(%(.(0,5(&(!`!<87&.$,@!SXX\?F!

<5(0-)$!(*+!&*+-)$!'(*!2$!K$.'$&E$+!2/!\\h!-1!0#$!#7%(*!K-K7)(0&-*!(*+!0#$&.!

-+-7.! &,! -10$*! +$,'.&2$+! (,! 1($'$,Z)&5$! =c$&)$.! $0! ()F@! T\\[?F! 6#$! -+-7.! &,! %-.$!

K.-*-7*'$+!1-.!,5(0-)$!0#(*!1-.!&*+-)$@!1-.!0#(0!.$(,-*!,5(0-)$!&,!7,7())/!.$1$..$+!0-!(,!

0#$!5$/!,72,0(*'$!=")(7,!$0!()F@!T\\Y?F!!

SFWF <&0+'!5)3&'%.$&%34!5)*H)$32,!&)!.)1'!&1%3&!

6#$!'-%K-7*+,!+$,'.&2$+!(2-E$@!+-!*-0!'-%K)$0$)/!(''-7*0!1-.!0#$!-''7..$*'$!

-1!2-(.!0(&*0!(,!+$0$.%&*$+!2/!(!0.(&*$+!,$*,-./!K(*$)!=>(7)/!$0!()F@!SXTX?F!6#$.$1-.$!&*!

)&0$.(07.$!,$E$.()!(++&0&-*()!'-%K-7*+,!(.$!+$,'.&2$+!0#(0!%(/!'-*0.&270$!0-!2-(.!0(&*0!

$F9F! >(00$.,-*! =T\U[?! ! +$,'.&2$+! 0#$! K-,,&2)$! '-*0.&270&-*! -1! K#$*-)&'! '-%K-7*+,! 0-!

2-(.!-+-7.@!%(&*)/!KZ'.$,-)!(*+!YZ$0#/)K#$*-)F!H),-!0#$!K.$,$*'$!-1!-0#$.!pZTU!,0$.-&+,!

=MA<H@! SXXY?@! (*+.-,0$*-),! =4.--5,!`! >$(.,-*@! T\V\?@! YZK#$*/)ZWZ270$*ZSZ-*$! =J&7,!`!

C(.'&(ZJ$97$&.-@!SXXT?@! ,0/.$*$!(*+!T@YZ+&'#)-.-2$*Q$*$! =J&7,!$0!()F@!SXX]?!#(E$!2$$*!

%$*0&-*$+F! RE$.())! &0! '(*! 2$! ,0(0$+! 0#(0! (*+.-,0$*-*$! (*+! ,5(0-)$! (.$! E$./! ,0.-*9!

'-*0.&270-.,!0-!2-(.!0(&*0F!6#$!-0#$.!'-%K-7*+,!%(/!(),-!'-*0.&270$!0-!0#$!K$.'$K0&-*!

-1!2-(.!0(&*0!270!0#$!)$E$)!-1!'-*0.&270&-*!&,!,0&))!(!,72n$'0!-1!+&,'7,,&-*F!!

!

EC @&'1&+4%+,!&)!2+5'+1,+!.)1'!&1%3&!51$,%34!5)*H)$32,!

!

<7.9&'()! '(,0.(0&-*! P&0#-70! (*($,0#$,&(! -1! %()$! K&9,! &,! '-%%-*)/! 7,$+! 0-!

K.-+7'$!0(&*0Z1.$$!%$(0!2/!.$+7'0&-*!-1!0#$!'-*'$*0.(0&-*,!-1!,5(0-)$!(*+!(*+.-,0$*-*$!

&*! 1(0F! 4$'(7,$!-1! 0#$! ,-'&$0()! K.$,,7.$! 0-! ,0-K! ,7.9&'()! '(,0.(0&-*@! -0#$.! ,0.(0$9&$,! 0-!

+$'.$(,$!2-(.!0(&*0!#(E$!2$$*!$E()7(0$+F!

"(,0.(0&-*!P&0#! (*($,0#$,&(! #(,! 2$$*!%(*+(0-./! &*!O-.P(/! ,&*'$! SXXS! (*+! &*!

6#$!O$0#$.)(*+,! ,&*'$! SXX\@!P#$.$(,!C$.%(*/!7,$,! (*()9$,&(! ,&*'$! SXX\F! 6#$! 7,$! -1!

(*($,0#$,&(!-.!(*()9$,&(!P&))!.$+7'$!0#$!K(&*!(11)&'0$+!0-!K&9)$0,!+7.&*9!'(,0.(0&-*!=B(.^!

$0! ()F@! SXXW?F! I0,! K.-E&,&-*! %(/! 0#$.$1-.$! &%K.-E$! 0#$! P$)1(.$! ,0(07,! -1! K&9)$0,F!

Page 21: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

TT!

J$9(.+)$,,! 0#$! .$+7'0&-*!-1!K(&*@! 0#$!M7.-K$(*!+$')(.(0&-*!-*!()0$.*(0&E$,! 0-! ,7.9&'()!

'(,0.(0&-*!-1!K&9,!K7.,7&0,!0#$!(2(*+-*&*9!-1!())!5&*+,!-1!,7.9&'()!'(,0.(0&-*!2/!SXTVF!

I*! ,-%$! '-7*0.&$,@! $F9F! I.$)(*+! (*+! 0#$! D*&0$+! 3&*9+-%@! $*0&.$! %()$! K&9,! (.$!

K.-+7'$+!270!,)(79#0$.$+!(0!(!/-7*9$.!(9$F!6#$!$E-)70&-*!-1!0#$!2-(.!0(&*0!'-%K-7*+,@!

$,K$'&())/! -1! (*+.-,0$*-*$! #(,! &*+$$+! 2$$*! )&*5$+! 0-! (9$F! H,! +$,'.&2$+@! 0#$! )$E$)! -1!

(*+.-,0$*-*$!9$*$.())/!-''7.,!&*!0P-!P(E$,!P&0#!#&9#!)$E$),!-1!(*+.-,0$*-*$!+7.&*9!0#$!

,$'-*+!P(E$!,0(.0&*9!(0!P$$5!TY!=")(7,!$0!()F@!T\\Y?F!q(%(.(0,5(&(!$0!()F!=SXXY2?!1-7*+!

#&9#!)$E$),!-1!,5(0-)$!(0!(!/-7*9!(9$!(.-7*+!V!0-!TX!P$$5,@!1-))-P$+!2/!(!+$'.$(,$!1.-%!

TX!0-!TS!P$$5,!(*+!(!,$'-*+!&*'.$(,$!(0!P$$5!TV!=q(%(.(0,5(&(!$0!()F@!SXXY2?F!N-P$E$.@!

0#$!'-..$)(0&-*,!1-7*+!2$0P$$*!'-%K-7*+!'-*'$*0.(0&-*,!(*+!(9$@!(.$!.(0#$.!)-P!(*+!

2.$$+!+$K$*+$*0!=H)+()!$0!()F@!SXX]m!H)7Pl!$0!()F@!SXTT2m!4(2-)!$0!()F@!SXXS?F!6#$.$1-.$@!(!

'-%K)$0$! (2,$*'$! -1! -+-7.! +$1$'0,! &*! K&9! %$(0! '(**-0! 2$! 97(.(*0$$+! 7,&*9! 0#&,!

(KK.-('#!=6F!JF!MA<H@!SXTT?F!I*!(++&0&-*@!'(70&-*!%7,0!2$!0(5$*!P#$*!.$+7'&*9!,)(79#0$.!

P$&9#0@!*-0!0-!&%K('0!$'-*-%&'()!K.-1&0(2&)&0/F!

<&*'$! B(/! SXX\@! &%%7*-'(,0.(0&-*! #(,! 2$$*! (KK.-E$+! &*! 0#$! MDF! :7.&*9!

K72$.0/@! $*+-9$*-7,! 9-*(+-0.-K&*$Z.$)$(,&*9! #-.%-*$! =C*JN?! ,0&%7)(0$,! 0#$!

K&07&0(./Z9-*(+()! (^&,@! .$,7)0&*9! &*! 0#$! ,/*0#$,&,! -1! 0$,0&'7)(.! ,0$.-&+,@! &*')7+&*9!

0$,0-,0$.-*$! (*+! (*+.-,0$*-*$F! I%%7*-'(,0.(0&-*! &,! (! E(''&*(0&-*! P&0#! (! %-+&1&$+!

C*JN! K$K0&+$@! P#&'#! )$(+,! 0-! 0#$! K.-+7'0&-*! -1! (*0&2-+&$,! (9(&*,0! C*JNF! 6#$,$!

(*0&2-+&$,!2&*+!0-!$*+-9$*-7,!C*JN!(*+!K.$E$*0!0#$!,0&%7)7,!1-.!,$'.$0&-*!-1!K&07&0(./!

GN!(*+!0#$.$2/!(),-!&*#&2&0!0#$!0$,0&'7)(.!17*'0&-*!=B$0Q!`!")(7,@!SXXWm!q(%(.(0,5(&(!`!

<87&.$,@!SXX\?!=A&9F!IFYFH?F!6#$!K.&%&*9!+-,$!&,!9&E$*!(10$.!*&*$!P$$5,!-1!(9$@!0#$!,$'-*+!

+-,$!(0! )$(,0! 1-7.!P$$5,!(10$.! 0#$!K.&%&*9!+-,$!(*+!(),-! 0&%$+!2$0P$$*! 0#.$$! 0-! 0$*!

P$$5,! 2$1-.$! 0#$! K&9,! (.$! ,#&KK$+! -11! 0-! 0#$! ,)(79#0$.#-7,$F! 6#$! ,$'-*+! +-,$!

,0&%7)(0$,! 0#$! &%%7*$! ,/,0$%! 0-! K.-+7'$! ,K$'&1&'! (*0&2-+&$,! 0#(0! ,7KK.$,,! 0#$!

2&-)-9&'()! '(,'(+$! 0#(0! '-*0.-),! 0#$! 0$,0&'7)(.! 17*'0&-*! (*+! .$,7)0,! &*! 0$%K-.(./!

&%%7*-)-9&'()! '(,0.(0&-*! =<7KK.$,,&E$! (*0&2-+/! )$E$)?=A&9F! IFYF4?F! R*$! -1! 0#$! K-,&0&E$!

$11$'0,! -1! &%%7*-'(,0.(0&-*! &,! 0#$! 2$00$.! 1$$+! '-*E$.,&-*! .(0&-F! N-P$E$.@! 0#$! %(&*!

'-*'$.*! -1! 0#&,! ()0$.*(0&E$! &,! 0#$! (00&07+$! -1! '-*,7%$.,F! <07+&$,! &*! <P&,,! (*+!O-.P(/!

,#-P! 0#(0! '-*,7%$.,! (.$! .(0#$.! ,'$K0&'()! 0-P(.+,! &%%7*-'(,0.(0&-*@!P#&'#! &,!%(&*)/!

Page 22: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

TS!

2(,$+! -*! 0#$! 1$(.! 1-.! .$,&+7$,! &*! %$(0! (*+! 7*5*-P*! )-*9Z0$.%! '-*,$87$*'$,!

=A.$+.&5,$*!$0!()F@!SXTTm!N72$.ZM&'#$.!`!<K.&*9@!SXXV?F!I*!4$)9&7%!&%%7*-'(,0.(0&-*!P(,!

(),-!$E()7(0$+!%-.$!*$9(0&E$)/!0#(*!,7.9&'()!'(,0.(0&-*!P&0#!.$,K$'0!0-!1--+!,(1$0/m!0#&,!

&*! '-*0.(,0! P&0#! )(2-7.! 1-.! 0#$! 1(.%$.! (*+! (E-&+(*'$! -1! 2-(.! 0(&*0@! P#&'#! P$.$!

$E()7(0$+!%-.$!K-,&0&E$)/!=;(*#-*('5$.!$0!()F@!SXX\?F!

!

!!!! !H? 4?!!

=%4!RCL^!8`!@50+*1&%5!)/!%**$3)51,&'1&%)3!9`!@O3&0+&%5!W3Q\!M+X+M!132!.)1'!&1%3&!M+X+M!N%&0!%**$3)51,&'1&%)3!_(/%b+'a!FKKV`!

!

6#$! K.-+7'0&-*! -1! $*0&.$!%()$! K&9,! #(,! 9(&*$+! K-K7)(.&0/! &*! ,$E$.()! '-7*0.&$,F!

6#&,! %(&*)/! 2$'(7,$! -1! 0#$! +$%(*+! -1! ,7K$.%(.5$0,! 0#(0! (+n7,0$+! 0#$&.! %(.5$0&*9!

,0.(0$9/! 0-! ,$))!%$(0! -1! $*0&.$!%()$! K&9,@!P#&'#! &,! K.-%-0$+! (,! (!%-.$! iK&9! 1.&$*+)/j!

K.-+7'0&-*!%$0#-+!0#(*!,7.9&'()!'(,0.(0&-*F!I1!$*0&.$!%()$,!(.$!K.-+7'$+@!&0!&,!$,,$*0&()!

0-!%&*&%&,$!0#$!.&,5!-1!'-*,7%$.,!K7.'#(,&*9!K-.5!P&0#!K$.'$&E(2)$!)$E$),!-1!2-(.!0(&*0F!

H0!0#&,!%-%$*0@!0#$!%(&*!K(.(%$0$.,!0-!.$+7'$!2-(.!0(&*0!(.$!%(*(9$%$*0!,0.(0$9&$,F!

B(*(9$%$*0!,0.(0$9&$,!%(/!2$!1-'7,$+!-*!1$$+@!#/9&$*$!'-*+&0&-*,@!,$)$'0&-*!-1!2.$$+!

(*+!,)(79#0$.!P$&9#0F!A$$+!,0.(0$9&$,!'(*!.$+7'$!,5(0-)$!)$E$),!2/!(11$'0&*9!0#$!.(0$!-1!

,5(0-)$!K.-+7'0&-*@!0#$!&*0$,0&*()!0.(*,&0!0&%$!-.!0#$!&*0$,0&*()!(2,-.K0&-*!=L$*,$*!$0!()F@!

T\\]2m!;(*!R$'5$)!$0!()F@!T\\Vm!q(%(.(0,5(&(!`!<87&.$,@!SXX\?F!<$E$.()!,07+&$,!+$,'.&2$+!

0#$! ,7''$,,17)! .$+7'0&-*!-1! ,5(0-)$! )$E$),! 2/! &*')7,&-*!-1! *-*Z+&9$,0&2)$! '(.2-#/+.(0$,!

,7'#!(,!'#&'-./! =q(%%$.&*&!$0!()F@!SXTS?@! .(P!K-0(0-!,0(.'#! =q(%(.(0,5(&(!$0!()F@!SXX]?!

Page 23: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

TW!

(*+! &*7)&*! =3n-,! $0! ()F@! SXTX?F! R*)/! 1$P! ,07+&$,! .$K-.0! (*! &%K('0! -1! 1$$+! -*! 0#$!

'-*'$*0.(0&-*! -1! (*+.-,0$*-*$! =A.$+.&5,$*! `! O-1,0(+@! SXXU?F! N(*,$*! $0! ()F! =T\\Y?!

,799$,0$+! 0#(0! 5$$K&*9!K&9,! ')$(*! '-7)+! )-P$.! ,5(0-)$! )$E$),F! 6#$/!-2,$.E$+! 0#(0! K&9,!

5$K0! (0! #&9#! ,0-'5&*9! +$*,&0/! (*+! &*! +&.0/! K$*,! #(+! #&9#$.! 2('5! 1(0! ,5(0-)$! (,!P$))! (,!

&*+-)$! )$E$),! 0#(*! K&9,! 0#(0! P$.$! 5$K0! (0! )-P! ,0-'5&*9! +$*,&0/! &*! ')$(*! K$*,F! I0! P(,!

#/K-0#$,&Q$+! 0#(0! ,5(0-)$! %(/! 2$! (2,-.2$+! 0#.-79#! 0#$! ,5&*! (*+k-.! 0#$! )7*9,! (*+!

$E$*07())/! (''7%7)(0$,! &*! 1(0! =N(*,$*@! T\\V?F! H)7Pl! $0! ()F! =SXTT(?! 1-7*+! *-! ')$(.!

&*+&'(0&-*! -1! ,5(0-)$! .$+7'0&-*! 2/! &%K.-E&*9! 0#$! ')$(*)&*$,,! -1! $*0&.$! %()$! K&9,F! 6#$!

$11$'0,!+$0$'0$+!2/!N(*,$*!$0!()F!=N(*,$*@!T\\V?!P$.$!-2,$.E$+!+7.&*9!,7%%$.!(,!P$))!

(,! +7.&*9!P&*0$.@! 270! ,5(0-)$! '-*'$*0.(0&-*,!P$.$! ')$(.)/! #&9#$.! +7.&*9! ,7%%$.F! 6#&,!

+$%-*,0.(0$,!0#$!K-,,&2)$!&%K-.0(*'$!-1!,$(,-*()!$11$'0,F!N-P$E$.@!0#$!&%K-.0(*'$!-1!

,$(,-*()! $11$'0,! -*! ,5(0-)$! -.! (*+.-,0$*-*$! '-*'$*0.(0&-*,! E(.&$,! 2$0P$$*! ,07+&$,!

=A.$+.&5,$*! `! O-1,0(+@! SXXUm! q(%(.(0,5(&(! $0! ()F@! SXXY(?F 6#$! ,$)$'0&-*! -1! (! '$.0(&*!

2.$$+!-.! ,)(79#0$.!P$&9#0! '(*! )$(+! 0-! )-P$.! 2-(.! 0(&*0! )$E$),F! <87&.$,! =<87&.$,@! SXXU?!

.$K-.0$+!#&9#$.!(*+.-,0$*-*$!)$E$),!&*!:7.-'!2.$$+!(,!'-%K(.$+!0-!0#$!)(*+.('$!2.$$+F!

H)7Pl!$0!()F! =SXTT2?!+$0$'0$+! )-P$.!,5(0-)$! )$E$),! &*!>&$0.(&*! 0#(*! &*!G(.9$!c#&0$!(*+!

4$)9&(*!G(*+.('$F!6#$!(*+.-,0$*-*$!-+-7.!P(,!,0.-*9$.! &*!1(0!1.-%!2-(.,!,)(79#0$.$+!

(0!\X!-.!TTX!59!0#(*!1-.!2-(.,!,)(79#0$.$+!(0!]X!59F!6#.-79#!(KK)&'(0&-*!-1!%(*(9$%$*0!

,0.(0$9&$,! (*+! 0#$! ,$)$'0&-*! -1! 2.$$+! (*+! ,)(79#0$.! P$&9#0@! &0! &,@! #-P$E$.@! *-0! /$0!

K-,,&2)$!0-!.(&,$!$*0&.$!%()$!K&9,!P&0#!)-P!-.!*-!.&,5!-1!2-(.!0(&*0!P&0#-70!&*'.$(,&*9!0#$!

'-,0!-1!K.-+7'0&-*!=4()0#7,,$*!$0!()F@!SXXV?F!!

!

LC 9)1'!&1%3&!2+&+5&%)3!

!

H!P&+$!.(*9$!-1!+$0$'0&-*!%$0#-+,!#(,!2$$*!+$E$)-K$+!0-!+$0$'0!(*+.-,0$*-*$!

(*+!,5(0-)$!&*!K-.'&*$!0&,,7$F!6#$,$!+$0$'0&-*!%$0#-+,!'(*!2$!+&E&+$+!&*0-!0P-!9.-7K,g!

'#$%&'()! (*()/,&,! (*+! ,$*,-./! (*()/,&,F! 3*-P)$+9$! (2-70! '-*'$*0.(0&-*,! -1!

(*+.-,0$*-*$!(*+!,5(0-)$!&*!K&9!0&,,7$!&,!$,,$*0&()!1-.!0P-!.$(,-*,F!A&.,0@!0#$/!P&))!())-P!

+$0$'0&*9!0(&*0$+!%$(0!2$1-.$!&0!.$('#$,!'-*,7%$.,F!<$'-*+@!(''7.(0$!%$(,7.$%$*0,!-1!

2-(.! 0(&*0! '-%K-7*+,! (.$! *$$+$+! 1-.! .$,$(.'#! K7.K-,$,@! ,-! 0#(0! 1('0-.,! (11$'0&*9!

Page 24: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

TY!

E(.&(0&-*,!&*!(*+.-,0$*-*$!(*+!,5(0-)$!)$E$),!%(/!2$!&+$*0&1&$+!(*+!%$0#-+,!0-!.$+7'$!

2-(.!0(&*0!'(*!2$!+$E$)-K$+F!!

"#$%&'()! (*()/,&,!%-,0)/! &*E-)E$,! ,$E$.()! ,0$K,! =$F9F! ')$(*! 7K@! $^0.('0&-*?! 0#(0!

(.$!-10$*! )(2-7.Z&*0$*,&E$@!2$1-.$!+$0$'0&-*!-1! 0#$!'-%K-7*+,!2$'-%$,!K-,,&2)$F!6#&,!

.$*+$.,! %$0#-+,! *-0! ,7&0(2)$! 1-.! +$0$'0&-*! (0! 0#$! ,)(79#0$.)&*$F! R*! 0#$! -0#$.! #(*+!

'#$%&'()! (*()/,&,! K$.%&0! 87(*0&1&'(0&-*! -1! 2-(.! 0(&*0! '-%K-7*+,@! P#&'#! %(/! 2$!

+$,&.(2)$!1-.!.$,$(.'#!K7.K-,$,F!!

6#$! ,$*,-./! 0$,0,! (E(&)(2)$! '(*! 2$! +&E&+$+! &*0-! $^K$.0! (*+! '-*,7%$.! K(*$),F!

H*()/,&,!-1!2-(.!0(&*0!#(,!0.(+&0&-*())/!2$$*!K$.1-.%$+!2/!(!0.(&*$+!,$*,-./!K(*$)!(*+!

'-..$)(0$+! 0-! 0#$! )$E$),! -1! &*+-)$@! ,5(0-)$! (*+! (*+.-,0$*-*$! &*! 2-(.! (+&K-,$! 0&,,7$F!

"-*,7%$.! K(*$),! (.$! *$'$,,(./! 0-! $,0(2)&,#! (! ,$*,-./! 0#.$,#-)+! P&0#! .$9(.+! 0-!

'-*,7%$.!(''$K0(*'$!=N(79$*!$0!()F@!SXTS?F!

c#$*!'(,0.(0&-*!-1!%()$!K&9)$0,!P&))!2$!2(**$+!&*!0#$!*$(.!1707.$!+7$!0-!(*&%()!

P$)1(.$!'-*'$.*,@!(+$87(0$!,$*,-./!-+-7.! 0#.$,#-)+!E()7$,!(*+!'-*,7%$.!(''$K0(*'$!

)$E$),!1-.!,5(0-)$!(*+!(*+.-,0$*-*$!P&0#!.$9(.+!0-!,$*,-./!K$.'$K0&-*!-1!2-(.!0(&*0!P&))!

2$! *$'$,,(./F! :7$! 0-! 0#$! )('5! -1! #(.%-*&,$+! (*+! ,0(*+(.+&,$+!%$0#-+,! &*! 0#&,! 1&$)+@!

(KK)/&*9! 0-! 2-0#! ,$*,-./! (*+! '#$%&'()! %$0#-+,@! &0! #(,! 2$$*! +&11&'7)0! 0-! +$1&*$!

7*(%2&97-7,! ,$*,-./! 0#.$,#-)+! )$E$),! 1-.! 0#$! 2-(.! 0(&*0! '-%K-7*+,! =N(79$*! $0! ()F@!

SXTS?F!

YFTF >0+*%51M!131MO,%,!

I*!%-,0!-1!0#$!,07+&$,@!2('5!1(0!,(%K)$,!(.$!0(5$*!1.-%!0#$!*$'5!.$9&-*!270!0#$!

$^('0!,(%K)$!)-'(0&-*!&,!7,7())/!7*+$1&*$+F!I0!&,!#-P$E$.!)&5$)/!0#(0!0#$!'-*'$*0.(0&-*!-1!

2-(.! 0(&*0! '-%K-7*+,! &,! (11$'0$+! 2/! 0#$! ,(%K)&*9! )-'(0&-*@! ,0-.(9$! 0$%K$.(07.$! (*+!

,0-.(9$!0&%$!=N(79$*!$0!()F@!SXTS?F!

!

YFTFTF @1*HM+!H'+A&'+1&*+3&!

6#$!K7.K-,$!-1!'-*+7'0&*9!(!,(%K)$!K.$Z0.$(0%$*0!&,!0-!.$%-E$!*-*Z0(.9$0!27)5!

%(0.&^! &*0$.1$.$*'$F! 6#&,! K.-0$'0,! 0#$! )&1$0&%$! -1! 0#$! (*()/0&'()! ,/,0$%@! 270! %-,0!

Page 25: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

T]!

&%K-.0(*0)/! &*'.$(,$,! 0#$! ,&9*()! -E$.! *-&,$! (*+! 0#7,! 0#$! ,$*,&0&E&0/! -1! 0#$! 0(.9$0!

(*()/0$,F! :7$! 0-! 0#$! )&K-K#&)&'! K.-K$.0&$,! -1! 0#$! 2-(.! 0(&*0! '-%K-7*+,! +$E$)-K&*9! (*!

(+$87(0$! K.$Z0.$(0%$*0! %(/! 2$! '-*,&+$.$+! (,! (*! (*()/0&'()! '#())$*9$F! O$E$.0#$)$,,!

+&11$.$*0!')$(*!7K!(*+!$^0.('0&-*!%$0#-+,!#(E$!2$$*!+$,'.&2$+!1-.!'#$%&'()!(*()/,&,F!!

H*+.-,0$*-*$! &,! (! E$./! )&K-K#&)&'! %-)$'7)$@! P#&'#! %(5$,! &0! %-.$! +&11&'7)0! 0-!

$^0.('0!(*+.-,0$*-*$! 1.-%!0#$! 1(0!%(0.&^!(,!'-%K(.$+!0-! &*+-)$!(*+!,5(0-)$F!4$'(7,$!

(*+.-,0$*-*$!&,!(,,-'&(0$+!P&0#!0#$!*-*Z,(K-*&1&(2)$!1.('0&-*!-1!1(0@!,(K-*&1&'(0&-*!'(*!

2$!(++$+!(,!(*!(++&0&-*()!,0$K!&*!0#$!,(%K)$!K.$Z0.$(0%$*0!0-!$^0.('0!0#$!'-%K-7*+,F!

6#$! 1(0! '(*! 2$! ,(K-*&1&'(0$+! 0-! ,&%K)&1/! 0#$! ,$K(.(0&-*! 2/! $F9F! 7,&*9! K-0(,,&7%!

#/+.-^&+$!,-)70&-*!=:$!4.(2(*+$.!`!;$.2$5$@!T\VUm!6#-%K,-*!`!>$(.,-*@!T\[[?F!H10$.!

,(K-*&1&'(0&-*@!$^0.('0&-*!'(*!2$!$^$'70$+!P&0#!#$^(*$!=6#-%K,-*!`!>$(.,-*@!T\[[?!-.!

(! 87(0$.*(./! %&^07.$! -1! P(0$.Z%$0#(*-)Z0-)7$*$Z)&9#0! K$0.-)$7%! =:$! 4.(2(*+$.! `!

;$.2$5$@!T\VU?F!

:7.&*9! K.$Z0.$(0%$*0@! (! +$.&E(0&Q(0&-*! ,0$K! '(*! 2$! (++$+! 0-! $*#(*'$! 0#$!

+$0$'0&-*!-1!(*+.-,0$*-*$F!:$.&E(0&Q(0&-*! &,!(!'#$%&'()!%-+&1&'(0&-*!-1! 0#$!'-%K-7*+!

0#(0!.$*+$.,!0#$!'-%K-7*+!)$,,!K-)(.@!0#7,!%-.$!E-)(0&)$@!(*+!&,!%-,0)/!K$.1-.%$+!K.&-.!

0-!9(,!'#.-%(0-9.(K#&'!,$K(.(0&-*F!:$!4.(2(*+$.!`!;$.2$5$!=T\VU?!7,$+!A)-.-^!.$(9$*0!

0-!+$.&E(0&Q$!(*+.-,0$*-*$! &*!'-%2&*(0&-*!P&0#!C"ZM":F!6-!+$0$'0!(*+.-,0$*-*$!P&0#!

1)7-.$,'$*'$!+$0$'0&-*@!N(*,$*ZBr))$.! =T\\Y?!7,$+!+(*,/)#/+.(Q&*$F!N-P$E$.@! 0#$!7,$!

-1! (! +$.&E(0&-*! ,0$K!%(/! )$(+! 0-! K-,,&2)$! 1(),$ZK-,&0&E$! .$,7)0,! (*+! &,! )(2-7.Z&*0$*,&E$!

=;(*+$*!47,,'#$!$0!()F@!SXTX?F!

O-P(+(/,@! 0#$! %-,0! '-%%-*! $^0.('0&-*! K.-'$+7.$! &,! )&87&+! $^0.('0&-*! (*+!

)&87&+Z)&87&+!$^0.('0&-*!&,!K.-2(2)/!(KK)&$+!0#$!%-,0F!6-!0#&,!$*+!(+&K-,$!0&,,7$!&,!#$(0$+!

2$1-.$!$^0.('0&-*!(*+!(*!()&87-0!-1! )&87&+! 1(0! &,!%&^$+!P&0#!(!,-)E$*0! =:$#*#(.+!$0!()F@!

T\\Wm!A&,'#$.!$0!()F@!SXTTm!q(%(.(0,5(&(!`!L(,0.$2-E(@!SXXU?F!6#$!,$'-*+!K-,,&2)$!1-.%!

-1! )&87&+!$^0.('0&-*! &,!0#$!,-)&+Z)&87&+!$^0.('0&-*!+7.&*9!P#&'#!(+&K-,$!0&,,7$! &,!'70! &*0-!

K&$'$,! (*+!%&^$+!P&0#! (! ,-)E$*0! =C(.'&(ZJ$97$&.-!`!J&7,@! T\\Vm!N(*,$*ZBr))$.@! T\\Ym!

;$.#$/+$*! $0! ()F@! SXX[?F! <$E$.()! 0/K$,! -1! ,-)E$*0,! #(E$! 2$$*! 7,$+! 1-.! 2-0#! 0/K$,! -1!

)&87&+!$^0.('0&-*g!%$0#(*-)@!#$^(*$@!+&'#)-.-%$0#(*$@!('$0-*&0.&)$!-.! ,-)E$*0!%&^07.$,!

0-!$^0.('0!(*+.-,0$*-*$!(*+k-.!,5(0-)$F!R*)/!1$P!,07+&$,!#-P$E$.@!'-%K(.$+!$^0.('0&-*!

Page 26: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

TU!

$11&'&$*'&$,!7,&*9!+&11$.$*0!,-)E$*0,!-.!+&11$.$*0!'-%2&*(0&-*,!=N(79$*@!SXTS?F!B$0#(*-)!

#(,! 2$$*! ,#-P*! (,! 7,$17)! 1-.! 0#$! ,&%7)0(*$-7,! $^0.('0&-*! -1! (*+.-,0$*-*$! (*+! 0#$!

&*+-)&'! '-%K-7*+,! ,5(0-)$! (*+! &*+-)$! ="#$*! $0! ()F@! SXX[m! N(*,$*ZBr))$.@! T\\Ym!

;$.#$/+$*!$0!()F@!SXX[?F!O$E$.0#$)$,,@!%-,0!)(2-.(0-.&$,!K$.1-.%!$^0.('0&-*!-1!,0$.-&+,!

(*+!&*+-)&'!'-%K-7*+,!,$K(.(0$)/F!

<-)&+!K#(,$!$^0.('0&-*!&,!(!,(%K)$!')$(*!7K!0$'#*&87$!&*!P#&'#!'-%K-7*+,!0#(0!

(.$!+&,,-)E$+!&*!(!)&87&+!%&^07.$!'(*!2$!,$K(.(0$+!1.-%!-0#$.!'-%K-7*+,!&*!17*'0&-*!-1!

0#$&.! K#/,&'()! (*+! '#$%&'()! K.-K$.0&$,@! 0#-79#! &0! &,! %-.$! -10$*! 7,$+! (,! (! ')$(*Z7K!

K.-'$+7.$!(10$.!)&87&+Z)&87&+!$^0.('0&-*F!C(.'&(ZJ$97$&.-!$0!()F!=T\VU?!7,$+!*-.%()!K#(,$!

'-*+&0&-*,! &*! P#&'#! 0#$! '-%K-7*+,! P$.$! .$0(&*$+! -*! (! A)-.-,&)! '-)7%*! (*+! 0#$!

&*0$.1$.&*9! '-%K-7*+,! -1! &*0$.$,0!P$.$!P(,#$+! (P(/! 2$1-.$! $)70&*9F! 6#&,! &*! '-*0.(,0!

P&0#!N(*,$*ZBr))$.!=T\\S?!P#-!7,$+!.$E$.,$+!K#(,$!'-*+&0&-*,F!

R0#$.! ')$(*Z7K! K-,,&2&)&0&$,! (10$.! $^0.('0&-*! (.$! K.$'&K&0(0&-*! -1! 0#$! 1(0! (*+!

1&)0.(0&-*!-1!0#$!,(%K)$F!>.$'&K&0(0&-*!-1!0#$!1(0!'(*!2$!-20(&*$+!2/!'--)&*9!0#$!,(%K)$!&*!

(*! &'$!2(0#!(10$.!,(K-*&1&'(0&-*!(*+!2$1-.$!$^0.('0&-*! =6#-%K,-*!`!>$(.,-*@!T\[[?!-.!

(10$.!$^0.('0&-*!0-!')$(.!0#$!$^0.('0!2$1-.$!+$0$'0&-*!=N(*,$*ZBr))$.@!T\\Y?F!6#$!$^0.('0!

'(*! (),-! 2$! ')$(*$+! 2/! 1&)0.(0&-*@!P#$0#$.! -.! *-0! &*! '-%2&*(0&-*!P&0#! (! 1.$$Q&*9! ,0$K!

=C(.'&(ZJ$97$&.-!`!J&7,@!T\\Vm!;$.#$/+$*!$0!()F@!SXX[?F!

YFTFSF !@+H1'1&%)3!132!2+&+5&%)3!&+503%c$+,!

O7%$.-7,!(KK.-('#$,!#(E$!2$$*!+$E$)-K$+!0-!+$0$.%&*$!2-(.!0(&*0!'-%K-7*+,!

&*!K-.'&*$!(+&K-,$!0&,,7$@!,$K(.(0$)/!-.!0-9$0#$.F!O-.%()!(*+!.$E$.,$+!K#(,$!N>G"@!C"!

(*+! ,K$'0.-K#-0-%$0.&'! %$0#-+,! #(E$! 2$$*! 9$*$.())/! (KK)&$+! 0-! %$(,7.$! &*+-)&'!

'-%K-7*+,@!(*+!N>G"@!C"!(*+!(!*7%2$.!-1!&%%7*-)-9&'()!%$0#-+,!#(E$!2$$*!7,$+!0-!

%$(,7.$!(*+.-,0$*-*$!=N(79$*!$0!()F@!SXTS?F!

<K$'0.-K#-0-%$0.&'!%$0#-+,!(.$!2(,$+!-*!0#$!7,$!-1!,K$'&1&'!.$(9$*0,!1-.!'-)-7.!

+$E$)-K%$*0F!6#$!%$0#-+,!(.$!,&%K)$!(*+!#(E$!.$)(0&E$)/!,#-.0!(*()/,&,!0&%$,@!#-P$E$.!

0#$/! '(**-0! +&,'.&%&*(0$! 2$0P$$*! 0#$! &*+-)&'! '-%K-7*+,! -.! 2$0P$$*! 0#$! TUZ

(*+.-,0$*$!,0$.-&+,!=N(79$*!$0!()F@!SXTSm!B-.0$*,$*!`!<-.$*,$*@!T\VYm!<87&.$,@!T\\X?F!!

I%%7*-)-9&'()! %$0#-+,! (.$! %$0#-+,! &*! P#&'#! (*! (*()/0$! '-*'$*0.(0&-*! &,!

%$(,7.$+! 2/! .$('0&-*! 2$0P$$*! (*! (*()/0$! =('0&*9! (,! (*0&9$*?! (*+! (! '-%K)$%$*0(./!

Page 27: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

T[!

(*0&2-+/F!6#$!.$('0&-*! &,!%-*&0-.$+!2/!0#$!+$0$'0&-*!-1! )(2$))$+!7*&0,@!$F9F!.(+&-('0&E$!

&,-0-K$,@! $*Q/%$,!-1! 1)7-.$,'$*0! '-%K-7*+,@!P#&'#! (.$! '-*n79(0$+! 0-! 0#$! (*0&9$*!-.!

(*0&2-+/! =N(79$*!$0!()F@! SXTS?F!H! '-%%-*!+&,(+E(*0(9$!-1! &%%7*-)-9&'()!%$0#-+,! &,!

0#$&.! )-P! ,$)$'0&E&0/F! ".-,,Z.$('0&E&0/! %(/! +$'.$(,$! 0#$! (''7.('/! -1! (*+.-,0$*-*$!

%$(,7.$%$*0,!(0!)-P!'-*'$*0.(0&-*,F!HKK)&'(0&-*!-1!&%%7*-)-9&'()!%$0#-+,!1-.!,5(0-)$!

(*()/,$,!&,!)&%&0$+@!+7$!0-!0#$!)-P!%-)$'7)(.!P$&9#0!-1!0#$!(*0&9$*!(*+!0#$!7*(E(&)(2&)&0/!

-1!,K$'&1&'!(*0&2-+&$,F!=H*+.$,$*@!T\[]m!")(7,!$0!()F@!T\VVm!N(79$*!$0!()F@!SXTSm!67-%-)(!

$0!()F@!T\\[?F!!

"#.-%(0-9.(K#/! &,! (! K#/,&'()! ,$K(.(0&-*! %$0#-+! &*! P#&'#! '-%K-7*+,! (.$!

,$)$'0&E$)/!+&,0.&270$+!2$0P$$*!0P-!&%%&,'&2)$!K#(,$,@!(!%-2&)$!K#(,$!1)-P&*9!0#.-79#!

(! ,0(0&-*(./! K#(,$F! I*! 0#$! '-*0$^0! -1! 0#&,! >#:! 0#$,&,! -*)/! 0#-,$! 0$'#*&87$,! 7,$+!

0#.-79#-70!0#$!.$,$(.'#!P&))!2$!+&,'7,,$+!&*!+$0(&)F!!

YFTFSFTF >0')*1&)4'1H0O!

6#$!%-,0! &%K-.0(*0! '#.-%(0-9.(K#&'! 0$'#*&87$! &,! '-)7%*! '#.-%(0-9.(K#/! &*!

P#&'#! 0#$! ,0(0&-*(./!K#(,$! &,! K('5$+! &*! (! '-)7%*F! 6P-! 0/K$,!-1!%-2&)$!K#(,$! '(*!2$!

7,$+g!9(,!(*+!)&87&+!'#.-%(0-9.(K#/F!

*NJ!IOPQRNSQTPNDOU!

C(,! '#.-%(0-9.(K#/! =C"?! &,! (! '-%%-*! 0/K$! -1! '#.-%(0-9.(K#/! 7,$+! &*!

(*()/0&'()! '#$%&,0./! 1-.! ,$K(.(0&*9! (*+! (*()/,&*9! '-%K-7*+,! 0#(0! '(*! 2$! E(K-.&Q$+!

P&0#-70! +$'-%K-,&0&-*F! >(00$.,-*! =T\UV?! P(,! 0#$! 1&.,0! 0-! +$0$'0! 0#$! '-%K-7*+!

(*+.-,0$*-*$! (*+! 0#&,! P&0#! C"! '-7K)$+! 0-! 1)(%$! &-*&,(0&-*! +$0$'0&-*! (*+! -)1('0-./!

$^(%&*(0&-*F! H10$.P(.+,! ,$E$.()! -0#$.! C"! %$0#-+,! P$.$! +$E$)-K$+! 0-! +$0$'0!

(*+.-,0$*-*$! =6#-%K,-*!`! >$(.,-*@! T\[[?F! H)0#-79#! (*+.-,0$*-*$! '(*! 2$! +$0$'0$+!

P&0#-70!+$.&E(0&Q(0&-*@!,$E$.()!%$0#-+,!7,$!(!+$.&E(0&Q(0&-*!,0$K!0-!.$*+$.!0#$!%-)$'7)$!

%-.$!E-)(0&)$!=:$!4.(2(*+$.!`!;$.2$5$@!T\VUm!3(71%(**!$0!()F@!T\[U?F!;-)+!=T\[X?!P(,!

0#$! 1&.,0! 0-!+$E$)-K!(!C"Z!%$0#-+!0-!%$(,7.$!,5(0-)$F!O-P(+(/,@! ,$E$.()! )(2-.(0-.&$,!

%$(,7.$! ,5(0-)$! '-*'$*0.(0&-*,! &*! 1(0! 2/! C"Z%$0#-+,! =H**-.A.$%K-*9! $0! ()F@! T\\[m!

<'#.$7.,!$0!()F@!SXX[?F!

Page 28: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

TV!

J$'$*0)/@!(!C"!%$0#-+!#(,!2$'-%$!(E(&)(2)$!1-.!0#$!,&%7)0(*$-7,!87(*0&1&'(0&-*!

-1!(*+.-,0$*-*$!(*+!,5(0-)$!=A&,'#$.!$0!()F@!SXTT?F!G&87&+Z)&87&+!$^0.('0&-*!P(,!7,$+!1-.!

,(%K)$! K.$K(.(0&-*F! A7.0#$.! ')$(*! 7K! -1! 0#$! %$0#(*-)&'! 1(0! $^0.('0! '-*,&,0$+! -1! (!

1.$$Q&*9! ,0$KF! 6#$! %$0#(*-)&'! ,7K$.*(0(*0! P(,! 0.(*,1$..$+! &*0-! (! #$(+,K('$! E&()@!

(70-%(0$+!#$(+,K('$! ,-)&+ZK#(,$!%&'.-Z$^0.('0&-*!P(,! '(..&$+!-70!(*+!87(*0&1&'(0&-*!

#(KK$*$+!P&0#!C"ZB<!=&-*!0.(K?F!

,HVWHG!IOPQRNSQTPNDOU!

;(.&-7,! N>G"Z2(,$+! %$0#-+,! 0-! 87(*0&1/! ,5(0-)$! (*+! &*+-)$! #(E$! 2$$*!

K72)&,#$+F!C(.'&(ZJ$97$&.-!$0!()F!=C(.'&(ZJ$97$&.-!$0!()F@!T\VU?!P$.$!0#$!1&.,0!0-!+$,'.&2$!

(!N>G"!%$0#-+!'-7K)$+! 0-!D;!+$0$'0&-*! 1-.! ,5(0-)$!(*()/,&,F! I*! 0#&,!%$0#-+!(!*-.%()!

K#(,$! '-)7%*! P(,! 7,$+F! A.-%! 0#$*! -*P(.+,@! E(.&-7,! '#.-%(0-9.(K#&'! '-)7%*,! (*+!

+&11$.$*0! '-%K-,&0&-*,! -1! %-2&)$! K#(,$,! #(E$! 2$$*! (KK)&$+! 0-! ,$K(.(0$! 0#$! &*+-)&'!

'-%K-7*+,F!J$E$.,$+ZK#(,$!N>G"!7,&*9!,&)&'(Z2(,$+!"TV!%(0$.&()! &,!-10$*!0#$!%$0#-+!

-1! '#-&'$! ="#$*! $0! ()F@! SXX[m! :$#*#(.+! $0! ()F@! T\\Wm! N(79$*! $0! ()F@! SXTS?F! 6#$! &*+-)&'!

'-%K-7*+,! (.$! ,-)72)$! &*!%(*/! +&11$.$*0! -.9(*&'! ,-)E$*0,! 2$'(7,$! -1! 0#$&.! K-)(.! (*+!

*-*ZK-)(.! K.-K$.0&$,! (*+! '(*! 2$! ,$K(.(0$+! P&0#! *-.%()! (*+! .$E$.,$+! K#(,$!

'#.-%(0-9.(K#/! =N(79$*! $0! ()F@! SXTS?F! <&%7)0(*$-7,! '#.-%(0-9.(K#&'! (*()/,&,! -1! 0#$!

0#.$$!'-%K-7*+,!=,5(0-)$@!&*+-)$!(*+!+$.&E(0&Q$+!(*+.-,0$*-*$?!P&0#!N>G"!'-7K)$+!0-!

1)7-.$,'$*'$!+$0$'0&-*!P(,!1&.,0)/!+$,'.&2$+!&*!T\\Y!2/!N(*,$*ZBr))$.F!;$.#$/+$*!$0!()F!

=SXX[?! +$E$)-K$+! (! %$0#-+! 1-.! 0#$! ,&%7)0(*$-7,! +$0$'0&-*! -1! 0#$! 0#.$$! '-%K-7*+,!

P&0#-70!+$.&E(0&Q(0&-*!P&0#!G"ZB<*F!6#.-79#-70!0#$!)(,0!/$(.,!0#$.$!#(,!2$$*!(!0.$*+!&*!

)&87&+!'#.-%(0-9.(K#/!0-!,P&0'#!0-!7)0.(Z#&9#!K$.1-.%(*'$!)&87&+!'#.-%(0-9.(K#/F!6#&,!

(*()/0&'()!+$E$)-K%$*0! .$0(&*,! 0#$!K.&*'&K)$,!-1!N>G"!270!$*(2)$,! 1(,0$.! ,$K(.(0&-*!-1!

'-%K-7*+,! &*!'-%K(.&,-*!0-!'-*E$*0&-*()!G"@!+7$!0-! 0#$!7,$!-1!'-)7%*,!K('5$+!P&0#!

,72ZS!%&'.-*!K(.0&')$,F!DZN>G"!K.-E&+$,!&%K.-E$+!,K$$+!-1!(*()/,&,@!(,!P$))!(,!(!2$00$.!

.$,-)70&-*@!(*!&*'.$(,$+!,$*,&0&E&0/!(*+!(!.$+7'0&-*!-1!%(0.&^!$11$'0,!=c&))$!$0!()F@!SXTS?F!

6#$! 7*+$.)/&*9! K.&*'&K)$! -1! 0#&,! $E-)70&-*! &,! 9-E$.*$+! 2/! 0#$! E(*! :$$%0$.! $87(0&-*@!

P#&'#! &,! (*! $%K&.&'()! 1-.%7)(! 0#(0! +$,'.&2$,! 0#$! .$)(0&-*,#&K! 2$0P$$*! )&*$(.! E$)-'&0/!

=1)-P! .(0$?! (*+! K)(0$! #$&9#0! =NM>6! -.! '-)7%*! $11&'&$*'/?! =<P(.0Q@! SXX]?F! I*! 9$*$.()@!

Page 29: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

T\!

'-*,&+$.(2)/! &%K.-E$+!,$K(.(0&-*!-1!2-(.! 0(&*0!'-%K-7*+,! &*!'-%K)$^!%(0.&'$,!'-7)+!

2$!-20(&*$+!7,&*9!DZN>G"F!

YFTFSFSF -1,,!,H+5&')*+&'O!

:7.&*9! 0#$! )(,0! /$(.,@! %(,,! ,K$'0.-%$0./! #(,! 2$$*! %-.$! $^0$*,&E$)/! 7,$+! 0-!

+$0$'0! (*+.-,0$*-*$@! 0#$! &*+-)&'! '-%K-7*+,! =,5(0-)$! (*+! &*+-)$?! -.! ,&%7)0(*$-7,)/!

+$0$'0! 0#$! 0#.$$! '-%K-7*+,! =67-%-)(! $0! ()F@! T\\Vm! ;$.#$/+$*! $0! ()F@! SXX[m!

q(%(.(0,5(&(!`!L(,0.$2-E(@!SXXU?F!!

6#$!B<!K.&*'&K)$! '-*,&,0,!-1! &-*&,&*9! '#$%&'()! '-%K-7*+,! 0-!9$*$.(0$! '#(.9$+!

%-)$'7)$,! -.! %-)$'7)$! 1.(9%$*0,@! ,-.0&*9! (*+! &+$*0&1/&*9! 0#$! &-*,! (''-.+&*9! 0-! 0#$&.!

%(,,Z0-Z'#(.9$! =%kQ?! .(0&-!(*+!%$(,7.&*9! 0#$!(27*+(*'$!-1! 0#$! &-*,F!H,! ,7'#! 0#$!B<!

'-%K.&,$,!-1!(*!&-*!,-7.'$@!(!%(,,!(*()/,$.!(*+!(!+$0$'0-.!=;(*+$*!47,,'#$@!SXTT?F!!

6#$!%(&*!*$9(0&E$!(,K$'0!-1!G"ZB<!(*()/,&,! &,! 0#$!-''7..$*'$!-1!%(0.&^!$11$'0,F!

:7$! 0-! '-Z$^0.('0$+!%(0.&^! '-*,0&07$*0,@! 0#$!%(,,! ,K$'0.-%$0.&'! (*()/,$,!%(/! ,711$.!

1.-%! ,&9*()! ,7KK.$,,&-*! -.! $*#(*'$%$*0@! 0#$.$2/! +&,07.2&*9! (+$87(0$! 87(*0&1&'(0&-*!

=c&))$!$0!()F@!SXTS?F!

)QFHJNSHQF!JQWPIE!

M)$'0.-*! &%K('0! &-*&,(0&-*! =MI?! &,! (! P&+$)/! 7,$+! 0$'#*&87$! P#$*! '-7K)$+! 0-! 9(,!

'#.-%(0-9.(K#/F! I0! &,!(*!$*$.9$0&'!K.-'$,,! &*!P#&'#!(!#$(0$+! 1&)(%$*0!$%&0,!$)$'0.-*,!

0#(0! (.$! (''$)$.(0$+! 2/! (! ,K$'&1&'! K-0$*0&()! +&11$.$*'$! &*0-! 0#$! ,(%K)$! '#(%2$.F!

I-*&,(0&-*! -1! 0#$! ,(%K)$! -''7.,! &*! 0#$! 9(,! K#(,$! 2/! '-))&,&-*! -1! 0#$! *$70.()! ,(%K)$!

%-)$'7)$,!P&0#! $*$.9$0&'! $)$'0.-*,! (*+! &*+7'$,! &-*&,(0&-*! (*+! 1.(9%$*0(0&-*! =A&9! IF]?!

=c&))-79#2/! $0! ()F@! SXXS?F! I-*&,(0&-*! -1! 2-(.! 0(&*0! '-%K-7*+,! P&0#! C"ZB<! #(,!

0#.-79#-70!0#$!/$(.,!()P(/,!2$$*!K$.1-.%$+!P&0#!$)$'0.-*!&%K('0F!6#$!$)$'0.-*!&%K('0!

$*$.9/! &,!%-,0)/! ,$0! (0! [X! $;! (*+! K-,&0&E$! &-*,!P$.$!%-*&0-.$+! =A&,'#$.! $0! ()F@! SXTTm!

6#-%K,-*!`!>$(.,-*@!T\[[?F!

!

Page 30: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

SX!

!!

=%4!RCJ^!@50+*1&%5!)/!+M+5&')3!%*H15&!%)3%,1&%)3!_70+'*)!=%,0+'!@5%+3&%/%5a!FKBF`!!

O-P(+(/,@! G"ZB<! %$0#-+,! 7,$! '#$%&'()! &-*&,(0&-*! ="I?@! P#&'#! &,! (! ,-10$.!

&-*&,(0&-*!0$'#*&87$F!I0!&,!(!,&%&)(.!&-*&,(0&-*!0$'#*&87$!0-!MI@!$^'$K0!0#(0!(!.$(9$*0!9(,!

&,! &*0.-+7'$+! &*0-! 0#$! '#(%2$.! &*! $^'$,,! -1! 0#$! ,(%K)$F! 4/! %$(*,! -1! $)$'0.-*!

2-%2(.+%$*0@! 0#$! .$(9$*0! 9(,! &-*&,$,! (*+! K.-0-*(0$,! 0#$! ,(%K)$! %-)$'7)$,F! 6#&,!

K.-+7'$,!2-0#!K-,&0&E$!(*+!*$9(0&E$!&-*,!270!/&$)+,!)$,,!1.(9%$*0(0&-*!=A&9!IFU?F!!

!

!!

=%4!RCP^!@50+*1&%5!)/!50+*%51M!%)3%,1&%)3!_70+'*)!=%,0+'!@5%+3&%/%5a!FKBF`!!

c&0#! 0#$! &*0.-+7'0&-*!-1! (0%-,K#$.&'! K.$,,7.$! &-*&,(0&-*! =H>I?! 0$'#*&87$,@! 0#$!

*7%2$.!-1!'-%K-7*+,!,7''$,,17))/!(*()/,$+!2/!G"ZB<!$^K(*+$+F!c&0#!H>I!0#$!(*()/0$!

%-)$'7)$,!(.$!&-*&,$+!1&.,0!(0!(0%-,K#$.&'!K.$,,7.$@!*$^0!0#$!&-*,!(.$!%$'#(*&'())/!(*+!

Page 31: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

ST!

$)$'0.-,0(0&'())/! ,$K(.(0$+! 1-.%! *$70.()! %-)$'7)$,F! "-%%-*! (0%-,K#$.&'! K.$,,7.$!

&-*&,(0&-*! 0$'#*&87$,! (.$! $)$'0.-,K.(/! &-*&,(0&-*! =M<I?! (*+! (0%-,K#$.&'! K.$,,7.$!

'#$%&'()!&-*&,(0&-*!=H>"I?!=c&))-79#2/!$0!()F@!SXXS?F!

!

DK-*! (*()/,&,! -1! 2-(.! 0(&*0! '-%K-7*+,! P&0#! G"ZB<@! (0%-,K#$.&'! K.$,,7.$!

'#$%&'()!&-*&,(0&-*!=H>"I?!#(,!2$$*!%-,0)/!7,$+!=;$.#$/+$*!$0!()F@!SXX[m!q(%(.(0,5(&(!

`! L(,0.$2-E(@! SXXU?F! H>"I! &,! 9$*$.())/! 2$00$.! 1-.! ,%())! *-*ZK-)(.! (*+! %$+&7%! K-)(.!

%-)$'7)$,! P&0#! (! %-)$'7)(.! P$&9#0! =Bc?! .(*9$! 1.-%! TXX! 0-! TXXXF! <7'#! '-%K-7*+,!

&*')7+$! &*+-)$! =Bcg! TT[?@! ,5(0-)$! =Bcg! TWT?! =q(%(.(0,5(&(! `! L(,0.$2-E(@! SXXU?! (*+!

(*+.-,0$*-*$! =Bcg! S[S?F! H>"I! (),-! K.-E&+$,! #&9#$.! +$0$'0&-*! ,$*,&0&E&0&$,! 1-.! 0#$!

%(n-.&0/!-1!,0$.-&+()!'-%K-7*+,@!$F9F!(*+.-,0$*-*$!(,!'-%K(.$+!0-!M<I!=;(*#($'5$!$0!

()F@! SXTT?F! c&0#! H>"I@! 0#$! G"Z$)7$*,! &,! ,K.(/$+! 0#.-79#! (! #$(0$+! =0/K&'())/! S]Xs"! t!

YXXs"?!E(K-.&Q$.!(0!(0%-,K#$.&'!K.$,,7.$F!6#&,!E(K-.&,$.!0$%K$.(07.$!P(,!,$0!(0!WXXs"!

&*! 0#$! ,07+/! -1! q(%(.(0,5(&(! `! L(,0.$2-E(! =SXXU?! (*+! (0! YXXs"! 2/! ;$.#$/+$*! $0! ()F!

=SXX[?F!6#$!.$,7)0&*9!9(,!K#(,$!,-)E$*0!%-)$'7)$,!(.$!,72,$87$*0)/!&-*&,$+!2/!$)$'0.-*!

+&,'#(.9$+! 1.-%! (! '-.-*(! *$$+)$! (*+! 0.(*,1$.! 0#$&.! '#(.9$! 0-! 0#$! (*()/0$!%-)$'7)$,F!

>-,&0&E$! &-*,! (.$! 1-.%$+! 0#.-79#! K.-0-*! 0.(*,1$.@! P#&)$! *$9(0&E$! &-*,! (.$! 1-.%$+!

0#.-79#! $)$'0.-*! 0.(*,1$.! -.! K.-0-*! )-,,! =A&9! IF[?! =c&))-79#2/! $0! ()F@! SXXS?F! I*! 2-0#!

,07+&$,!0#(0!7,$!G"ZB<!(*()/,&,!1-.!0#$!+$0$'0&-*!-1!2-(.!0(&*0!'-%K-7*+,@!0#$!H>"I!P(,!

-K$.(0$+! -*)/! &*! 0#$! K-,&0&E$! &-*! %-+$! =;$.#$/+$*! $0! ()F@! SXX[m! q(%(.(0,5(&(! `!

L(,0.$2-E(@!SXXU?F!!

!

!

!

!

Page 32: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

SS!

!=%4!RCU^!@50+*1&%5!)/!1&*),H0+'%5!H'+,,$'+!50+*%51M!%)3%,1&%)3!_70+'*)!=%,0+'!@5%+3&%/%5a!FKBF`!

7NJJ!NFNXUJEP!

I*! )&0$.(07.$@! 0P-! +&11$.$*0! 0/K$,! -1! %(,,! (*()/,$.! #(E$! 2$$*! (KK)&$+! 1-.! 0#$!

+$0$'0&-*! -1! 2-(.! 0(&*0! '-%K-7*+,g! &-*! 0.(K! %(,,! (*()/,$.,! =A&,'#$.! $0! ()F@! SXTTm!

;$.#$/+$*! $0! ()F@! SXX[?! (*+! 87(+.7K-)$! %(,,! (*()/,$.,! =67-%-)(! $0! ()F@! T\\Vm!

q(%(.(0,5(&(!`!L(,0.$2-E(@!SXXU?F!

!

H*! &-*! 0.(K! %(,,! (*()/,$.! '-*,&,0,! -1! 0#.$$! #/K$.2-)&'! $)$'0.-+$,g! (! .&*9!

$)$'0.-+$@! (*! $*0.(*'$! (*+! (*! $^&0! $*+Z'(K! $)$'0.-+$! =A&9! IFV?F! :$K$*+&*9! -*! 0#$!

E-)0(9$,!(KK)&$+!-*!0#$!0#.$$!$)$'0.-+$,!(*+!0#$!&*+&E&+7()!%(,,Z0-Z'#(.9$!=%kQ?!.(0&-,@!

&-*,!P&))!2$!0.(KK$+!&*!0#$!'(E&0/!2$0P$$*!0#$!0#.$$!$)$'0.-+$,!-.!$^&0!0#$!0.(KF!D,&*9!(*!

&-*!0.(K!%(,,!(*()/,$.@!,$E$.()!%(,,Z,$)$'0&E$!-K$.(0&-*,!'(*!2$!'(..&$+!-70!(10$.!$('#!

-0#$.! =B<*?F! H10$.! 0.(KK&*9! 0#$! K.$'7.,-.! &-*,@! '-))&,&-*Z&*+7'$+! +&,,-'&(0&-*! ="I:?! &,!

(KK)&$+! 0-! 9$*$.(0$! ,0.7'07.()! &*1-.%(0&-*F! A-.! +$0$'0&*9! 0#$! &-*,@! 0#$! K-0$*0&(),! (.$!

()0$.$+!0-!+$,0(2&)&,$!0#$! &-*!%-0&-*,!.$,7)0&*9! &*!$n$'0&-*!-1!0#$! &-*,!0#.-79#!0#$!$^&0!

$*+Z'(K!=B(.'#@!T\\[m!c&))-79#2/!$0!()F@!SXXS?F!;$.#$/+$*!$0!()!=;$.#$/+$*!$0!()F@!SXX[?!

7,$+! 0#$! &-*! 0.(K! =G"ZB<?! 1-.! 0#$! ,&%7)0(*$-7,! +$0$'0&-*! -1! 0#$! 0#.$$! 2-(.! 0(&*0!

'-%K-7*+,F!:(0(!('87&,&0&-*!P(,!K$.1-.%$+!&*!17))!,'(*!%-+$!(*+!&*!K.-+7'0!&-*!,'(*!

=>I<?!%-+$@! 7,&*9! (,! K.$'7.,-.! &-*! 0#$! K.-0-*(0$+!%-)$'7)(.! &-*! dBeNfeF! O-.%()&,$+!

'-))&,&-*! $*$.9/!P(,! (KK)&$+! 2$0P$$*! YX! (*+! ]]hF! A&,'#$.! $0! ()F! =SXTT?! '-%2&*$+!C"!

P&0#!(*! &-*!0.(K!%(,,!(*()/,$.F!6#$!%(,,!,K$'0.(!P$.$!.$'-.+$+! &*! 17))!,'(*!%-+$!1-.!

Page 33: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

SW!

87(*0&1&'(0&-*F!<72,$87$*0)/@!(*()/0$,u!K$(5!(.$(!.(0&-,!P$.$!+$0$.%&*$+!2/!+&,K)(/&*9!

0#$!,K$'&1&'!%(,,!0.('$,!-1!$('#!(*()/0$!&*!,$)$'0$+!&-*!%-*&0-.&*9!=<IB?!%-+$F!

!=%4!RCS^!@50+*1&%5!)/!%)3!&'1H!*1,,!131MO,+'!_70+'*)!=%,0+'!@5%+3&%/%5a!FKBF`!

!H!87(+.7K-)$!%(,,!(*()/,$.!'-*,&,0,!-1!1-7.!K(.())$)!.-+,!=K-)$,?!$87())/!,K('$+!

(.-7*+! (! '$*0.()! (^&,! =A&9! IF\?F! 6#$! &-*,! (.$! &*0.-+7'$+! ()-*9! 0#$! (^&,! -1! 0#$! K-)$,F!

HKK)/&*9! E-)0(9$,! 0-! -KK-,&*9! ,$0,! -1! K-)$,! '(*! '.$(0$! (!%(,,! 1&)0$.F!R*)/! &-*,!P&0#! (!

K(.0&'7)(.!%(,,Z0-Z'#(.9$!.(0&-!P&))!K(,,!0#.-79#!0#$!1&)0$.!(*+!,72,$87$*0)/!2$!+$0$'0$+!

(0!(!K(.0&'7)(.!(KK)&$+!E-)0(9$F!H!i,&*9)$!87(+j!%(,,!(*()/,$.!%$(,7.$,! 0#$!$^0$.*())/!

9$*$.(0$+! 1.(9%$*0,F! H! 0.&K)$! 87(+.7K-)$! ())-P,! 1.(9%$*0(0&-*! P&0#&*! 0#$! %(,,!

(*()/,$.!=87(+.7K-)$!S?=c&))-79#2/!$0!()F@!SXXS?F!A-.!0#$!+$0$'0&-*!-1!(*+.-,0$*-*$!&*!

K&9! 1(0@! 67-%-)(! $0! ()F! =T\\V?! 7,$+! (! 0.&K)$! 87(+.7K-)$! %(,,! ,K$'0.-%$0$.F! H*! H>"I!

,-7.'$!P&0#!(!E(K-.&,$.! 0$%K$.(07.$!-1!YS]s"!P(,!7,$+F!6#$!B<!P(,!-K$.(0$+! &*!<IB!

%-+$!.$'-.+&*9!0#$!%-)$'7)(.!&-*,!dBeNfe!-1!0#$!0(.9$0!(*()/0$F!>-,&0&E$)/!'#(.9$+!&-*,!

P$.$!,'(**$+!P&0#!87(+.7K-)$!TF!6#$!1.(9%$*0(0&-*!-1!0#$!(*()/0$!P(,!-20(&*$+!2/!17))!

,'(*!%(,,! ,K$'0.(! -1! .$1$.$*'$! '-%K-7*+,F! A-.! 0#$! +$0$'0&-*! -1! &*+-)$! (*+! ,5(0-)$@!

q(%(.(0,5(&(! `! L(,0.$2-E(! =SXXU?! 70&)&Q$+! (! ,&*9)$! 87(+.7K-)$! %(,,! (*()/,$.F! 6-!

87(*0&1/! 0#$!'-%K-7*+,@! 0#$!<IB!%-+$!$^0.('0&*9! 0#$!K.-0-*(0$+!%-)$'7)(.! &-*,!P(,!

(KK)&$+F!

!

Page 34: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

SY!

!=%4!RCV^!@50+*1&%5!)/!c$12'$H)M+!*1,,!131MO,+'!_70+'*)!=%,0+'!@5%+3&%/%5a!FKBF`!!

6#$!%-,0!(KK)&$+!%(,,!,K$'0.-%$0.&'! 0$'#*&87$!,-! 1(.! &*!2-(.! 0(&*0!(*()/,&,!(,!

P$))!(,!&*!9$*$.()!&*!,%())!%-)$'7)$!(*()/,&,@!&,!0#$!87(+.7K-)$!%(,,!,K$'0.-%$0$.F!6#&,!

&*,0.7%$*0! #(,! #-P$E$.! '$.0(&*! )&%&0(0&-*,g! &0! +-$,! *-0! ())-P! K-,0Z('87&,&0&-*! .$Z

&*0$..-9(0&-*!-1!+(0(@!P#$*!1-.!$^(%K)$!(!*$P!0/K$!-1!2-(.!0(&*0!'-%K-7*+!#(,!2$$*!

+&,'-E$.$+m! -*)/! (! )&%&0$+! *7%2$.! -1! '-%K-7*+,! '(*! 2$!%$(,7.$+! K$.! .7*m! (*+! &0! &,!

&%K-,,&2)$! 0-! ,'.$$*! 1-.! 7*&+$*0&1&$+! 7*5*-P*! '-%K-7*+,F! 4$'(7,$! -1! 0#$,$!

)&%&0(0&-*,@! 0#$.$! &,! '7..$*0)/! (! 0.$*+! 0-P(.+,! 17))! ,'(*! B<! $^K$.&%$*0,F! "7..$*0!

,'.$$*&*9! (KK.-('#$,! (.$! K$.1-.%$+! 7,&*9! #&9#! K$.1-.%(*'$! 6-A! =0&%$! -1! 1)&9#0?!

&*,0.7%$*0,!P&0#!%(,,!(''7.('&$,!-1!v]!KK%!(*+!.$,-)70&-*,!-1!(2-70!T]@XXX!=O&$)$*!$0!

()F@!SXX[?F!6#&,!.$,-)70&-*!)$(+,!0-!&*(''7.(0$!%(,,!%$(,7.$%$*0,!&*!'-%K)$^!%(0.&'$,!

+7$!0-!7*.$,-)E$+!2('59.-7*+!%(0.&^!&*0$.1$.$*'$,F!M,K$'&())/!0#&,!%(,,!.$,-)70&-*!K)(/,!

(*! &%K-.0(*0! .-)$! &*! 0#$! ,7''$,,17)! &+$*0&1&'(0&-*!-1! '-%K-7*+,! &*! ,(%K)$,! '-*0(&*&*9!

#&9#!(%-7*0,!-1!'-%K)$^!%(0.&^!'-Z$^0.('0,!,7'#!(,!1-.!$^(%K)$!(+&K-,$!0&,,7$!=O&$)$*!

$0! ()F@! SXX[?F! I*! 0#&,! '-*0$^0@! 0#$! #&9#! .$,-)E&*9! K-P$.! =7K! 0-! TXX@XXX?! -1! 0#$! A-7.&$.!

6.(*,1-.%! R.2&0.(K! %(,,! ,K$'0.-%$0.&'! 0$'#*-)-9/! K.-E&+$,! K.$'&,$! %(,,! (''7.('/!

=2$)-P! S! KK%?! =O&$)$*! $0! ()F@! SXX[?@! ,$*,&0&E&0/@! )&*$(.&0/! (*+! ,$)$'0&E&0/! 1-.! '-%K)$^!

,(%K)$! (*()/,&,! (*+! &0,! 17))! ,'(*! ,K$$+! =TX! NQ?! &,! 17))/! '-%K(0&2)$! P&0#! 1(,0!

'#.-%(0-9.(K#/! %$0#-+,! =DZN>G"?@! 0#7,! ())-P&*9! 1(,0@! .$K.-+7'&2)$! (*+! .$)&(2)$!

(*()/0&'()!.$,7)0,!1-.!%7)0&K)$!'-%K-*$*0!(*()/,&,!=0#$-.$0&'())/!TSS]XX!'-%K-7*+,?F!!

Page 35: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

S]!

c#$*!&*n$'0$+!&*!0#$!R.2&0.(K!(*()/,$.@!&-*,!(.$!$)$'0.-,0(0&'())/!0.(KK$+!(.-7*+!

0#$! -70$.! '7.E$+! $)$'0.-+$! ,7,0(&*$+! (0! (! #&9#! E-)0(9$! =A&9! IFTX?F! 6#$! &-*,!P&))! .-0(0$!

(.-7*+! 0#$! '$*0.()! $)$'0.-+$! P#&)$! K$.1-.%&*9! (^&()! -,'&))(0&-*F! 6#$! -,'&))(0&*9! &-*,!

&*+7'$!(*!&%(9$!'7..$*0@!P#&'#!&,!+$0$'0$+!2/!(!2.-(+2(*+!+$0$'0&-*!(*+!1-))-P$+!2/!(!

A(,0!A-7.&$.!6.(*,1-.%(0&-*!0-!'-*E$.0!0#$!,&9*()! &*0-!(!1.$87$*'/F!A-.!'-*1&.%(0&-*!&*!

0(.9$0$+!(*()/,$,@! &,-0-K&'!K(00$.*,!-.!(!N&9#!M*$.9/!"-))&,&-*()!:&,,-'&(0&-*!=N":?!'$))!

P&0#-70! K.$'7.,-.! &-*! ,$)$'0&-*! '(*! 2$! 7,$+F! H*! N":! '$))! 9$*$.(0$,! 1.(9%$*0(0&-*!

&*1-.%(0&-*!&*!(!*-*Z!,$)$'0&E$!%(**$.!=B(5(.-E!`!<'&9$)-E(@!SXTX?F!

!

H?! ! 4?! !!

=%4!RCBK^!8`!@50+*1&%5!)X+'X%+N!)/!1!.+350A&)H!<'.%&'1H!*1,,!,H+5&')*+&+'a!9`!8!2+&1%M!)/!&0+!<'.%&'1H!*1,,!131MO,+'!_70+'*)!=%,0+'!@5%+3&%/%5a!FKBF`!

YFSF @+3,)'O!131MO,%,!

A.-%! 0#$! $E-)70&-*(./! K-&*0! -1! E&$P! -)1('0&-*! &,! -*$! -1! 0#$! -)+$,0! ,$*,$,@!

())-P&*9! 1-.! ,$$5&*9! 1--+@! .$'-9*&Q&*9!+(*9$.!-.! '-%%7*&'(0&-*g!#7%(*!-)1('0&-*! &,!(!

K.-0$'0&E$!,$*,$!(,! &0!())-P,!0#$!+$0$'0&-*!-1!K-0$*0&()! &))*$,,$,!-.! &*1$'0&-*,!2/!0(5&*9!

&*0-!(''-7*0!0#$!-+-7.!K)$(,(*0*$,,k7*K)$(,(*0*$,,F!R+-7.,!(.$!%&^07.$,!-1! )&9#0!(*+!

,%())!%-)$'7)$,!0#(0!'(*!(),-!2$!K.$,$*0!(0!E$./! )-P!'-*'$*0.(0&-*,! &*!0#$!&*#()$+!(&.F!

6#$,$!%-)$'7)$,!(.$!(2)$!0-!,0&%7)(0$!(*!(*(0-%&'()!.$,K-*,$@!P#&'#!&,!0#$!$^K$.&$*'$+!

K$.'$K0&-*! '())$+! 0#$! -+-7.F! :7$! 0-! &0,! *(07.$! -)1('0&-*! &,! 2$'-%&*9! (! 0--)! -1!

,0.(&9#01-.P(.+! &%K-.0(*'$! &*! E(.&-7,! 1&$)+,@! ,7'#! (,! 1--+! (*+! 2$E$.(9$! 87()&0/!

Page 36: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

SU!

(,,$,,%$*0! -.! &))*$,,! +$0$'0&-*! =4.(00-)&! $0! ()F@! SXTT?F! H*! &%K-.0(*0! 0--)!P&0#&*! 0#$,$!

87()&0/!(,,$,,%$*0,!2(,$+!-*!-)1('0&-*!&,!0#$!,$*,-./!K(*$)F!H!,$*,-./!K(*$)!&,!(!9.-7K!

-1!0$,0$.,!P&0#!$^'$K0&-*()!,$*,-./!1('7)0&$,!P#-!'(*!17))/!+$,'.&2$!K.-+7'0,!-*!0#$!2(,&,!

-1!0(,0$@!,%$))@!0-7'#!(*+!-0#$.!,$*,(0&-*,F!R*$!-1!0#$!(+E(*0(9$,!-1!,$*,-./!K(*$),!&,!

0#(0!0#$/!,%$))!0#$!i17))!K&'07.$j!-1!2-(.!0(&*0F!H,!%$*0&-*$+!(2-E$@!0#$!%(&*!2-(.!0(&*0!

'-%K-7*+,! (.$! ,5(0-)$! (*+! (*+.-,0$*-*$F! N-P$E$.@! 0#$,$! '-%K-7*+,! '(**-0!

'-%K)$0$)/!(''-7*0!1-.!0#$!-''7..$*'$!-1!2-(.!0(&*0!(,!+$0$.%&*$+!2/!(!0.(&*$+!,$*,-./!

K(*$)!=>(7)/!$0!()F@!SXTX?F!c#$*!7,&*9!,$*,-./!(*()/,$,@!())!'-%K-7*+,!(.$!&*')7+$+!&*!

0#$!-+-7.@!(),-!0#$!=(0!0#$!0&%$?!7*5*-P*!'-%K-7*+,F!:$K$*+&*9!-*!0#$!K7.K-,$!-1!(!

,$*,-./!0$,0@!0#$!K(*$)!0#(0!n7+9$,!0#$!K.-+7'0,!'-*,&,0,!-1!$^K$.0,!-.!'-*,7%$.,F!!I*!0#$!

K&9! K.-+7'0&-*! '#(&*@! K-.5! '-*,7%K0&-*! &,! 0#$! )(,0! ,0$K@! ,0.$,,&*9! 0#$! &%K-.0(*'$! 0-!

+$0$.%&*$! 0#$! ,$*,-./! (''$K0(2&)&0/! -1! K-.5! %$(0! 2/! '-*,7%$.,F! N-P$E$.@! (! )-0! -1!

.$,$(.'#! &*! 0#$!(.$(!-1!2-(.! 0(&*0!7,$,!$^K$.0!K(*$),! &*,0$(+!-1!'-*,7%$.!K(*$),F!6#$!

%(&*!+&11$.$*'$!&,!.$1)$'0$+!&*!0#$!('5*-P)$+9$+!,$*,-./!,$*,&0&E&0/!-1!0#$!$^K$.0,@!270!

(),-! &*! 0#$&.! '-*,&+$.(2)$! 0.(&*&*9! (*+! $^K$.&$*'$! &*! ,$*,-./! 0$,0&*9! P#&'#! )$(+,! 0-!

'-*,&,0$*0!(*+!.$K$(0(2)$!,$*,-./!(,,$,,%$*0,!=I<R!V]VU@!SXXV?F!6#$.$1-.$!$^K$.0,!(.$!

-10$*! '-*,&+$.$+! (,! 0#$! i%-,0! ,$*,&0&E$j! '-*,7%$.,F! c#$*! 1-'7,&*9! -*! 2-(.! 0(&*0!

,$*,-./! ,07+&$,@! +&11$.$*'$,! &*! 0#$! 7,$+! %$0#-+-)-9&$,! .$9(.+&*9! $F9F! 0#$! #$(0&*9!

K.-'$+7.$!-1!0#$!,(%K)$@!(*+!0#$!,'()$!7,$+!1-.!,'-.&*9!'(*!2$!-2,$.E$+@!0#&,!1-.!2-0#!

$^K$.0! (*+! '-*,7%$.! K(*$),F! 6#&,! #$0$.-9$*$&0/! &*!%$0#-+-)-9/! .$*+$.,! '-%K(.&,-*!

2$0P$$*!,07+&$,!+&11&'7)0F!H,!0#$!%(&*!1-'7,!&*!0#&,!>#:!0#$,&,!)&$,!-*!$^K$.0!K(*$),@!0#$!

+&11$.$*'$,! &*! ,$)$'0&-*! (*+! 0.(&*&*9! -1! 0#$! $^K$.0,! (*+! 0#$!%$0#-+-)-9&$,! (*+! ,'()$,!

7,$+!&*!0#$!+&11$.$*0!,07+&$,@!P&0#&*!$^K$.0!K(*$),@!P&))!2$!+&,'7,,$+!&*!0#&,!'#(K0$.F!!

!

YFSFTF @+M+5&%)3!132!&'1%3%34!)/!+6H+'&,!

H,! %$*0&-*$+@! $^K$.0,! 1-.! 2-(.! 0(&*0! (.$! '-*,7%$.,! ,K$'&1&'())/! ,$)$'0$+! (*+!

0.(&*$+!0-!+$0$'0!2-(.!0(&*0F!N-P$E$.@!(0!0#$!0&%$!*-!,K$'&1&'!97&+$)&*$,!(.$!(E(&)(2)$!-*!

#-P! 0-! ,$)$'0! (*+! 0.(&*! $^K$.0,! 1-.! 0#$! +$0$'0&-*! -1! 2-(.! 0(&*0F! 6#$.$1-.$! (! )-0! -1!

E(.&(0&-*! &,! 1-7*+! 2$0P$$*! 0#$! +&11$.$*0! ,07+&$,! 0#(0! 7,$! $^K$.0! K(*$),! (*+! &*! 0#$!

(%-7*0! -1! &*1-.%(0&-*! K.-E&+$+F! ! I*!%-,0! '(,$,! 0#$! &*1-.%(0&-*! &,! *-0! '-%K)$0$! $F9F!

Page 37: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

S[!

,K$'&1&'! +$1&*&0&-*,! -1! ,$*,&0&E$! E$.,7,! *-*Z,$*,&0&E$! (*+! 0#$! $^('0! )$E$)! -1! 0.(&*&*9!

(,,$,,-.,!.$'$&E$+@!(.$!)('5&*9F!A-.!$^(%K)$!<5.)$K!$0!()F!=SXTX?!K.-E&+$,!*-!&*1-.%(0&-*!

-*!#-P!K(*$))&,0,!(.$!,$)$'0$+!(*+!0.(&*$+F!R*)/!0#$!(%-7*0!-1!$^K$.0,!=]!1$%()$,!(*+!

-*$!%()$?!P(,!%$*0&-*$+F!H),-!>.7,(!$0!()F!=SXTT?!9&E$,!-*)/!)&%&0$+!&*1-.%(0&-*F!I*!0#&,!

,07+/@! 0#$! ,$*,-./! (.-%(! (*()/,$,!P$.$! ,K$*0! 0-! I-P(! <0(0$! D*&E$.,&0/F! ! 6#$! 0.(&*$+!

K(*$)! -1! 0#$! I-P(! <0(0$! D*&E$.,&0/! '-*,&,0$+! -1! 1-7.! &*+&E&+7(),! P#-!P$.$! 0.(&*$+! 0-!

$E()7(0$! 2-(.! 0(&*0F! O-! 17.0#$.! &*1-.%(0&-*! -*! #-P! 0#$! ,$)$'0&-*! (*+! 0.(&*&*9! P(,!

K$.1-.%$+@!&,!(E(&)(2)$F!<$E$.()!-0#$.!,07+&$,!=4/.*$!$0!()F@!SXXVm!>(.7*-E&'!$0!()F@!SXTX?!

.$1$.! 0-! I<R! V]VUZT! =9$*$.()! 97&+(*'$! 1-.! 0#$! ,$)$'0&-*@! 0.(&*&*9! (*+! %-*&0-.&*9! -1!

(,,$,,-.,?! P&0#-70! K.-E&+&*9! 17.0#$.! ,K$'&1&'! &*1-.%(0&-*! .$)(0$+! 0-! 0#$! ,$)$'0&-*! (*+!

0.(&*&*9!-1!$^K$.0,!0-!+$0$'0!2-(.!0(&*0F!!

A-.! 0#$! ,$)$'0&-*!-1!$^K$.0,! 1-.!87(*0&1/&*9!2-(.! 0(&*0@! &0! &,!K.&%(.&)/! &%K-.0(*0!

0#(0! 0#$! $^K$.0,! (.$! ,$*,&0&E$! 0-! (*+.-,0$*-*$F! I*! ())! ,$*,-./! ,07+&$,! ,-! 1(.! &*!P#&'#!

(*+.-,0$*-*$! -+-7.! P(,! -*$! -1! 0#$! (00.&270$,@! 0#&,! ,$*,&0&E&0/! 0-! (*+.-,0$*-*$! P(,!

0$,0$+F! 6#$,$! ,07+&$,! ,#-P@! #-P$E$.@! ,&9*&1&'(*0! E(.&(0&-*,! &*! #-P! (*+.-,0$*-*$!P(,!

K.$,$*0$+!$F9F!K7.$!1-.%!=c$&)$.!$0!()F@!SXXX?@!+&,,-)E$+!&*!%$0#(*-)!=>(7)/!$0!()F@!SXTX?@!

+&,,-)E$+!&*!-&)! =+$!3-'5!$0!()F@!SXXT?!(*+!+&,,-)E$+!&*!P(0$.!=H)7Pl!$0!()F@!SXX\?F!H),-@!

+&11$.$*0! 0$,0! ,$0Z7K,!P$.$! 7,$+!P#$*! ())-'(0&*9! K$-K)$! (,! ,$*,&0&E$! -.! *-*Z,$*,&0&E$F!

A-.!$^(%K)$@!c$&)$.!$0!()F!=SXXX?!K.$,$*0$+!-*$!E&()!P&0#!'./,0(),!-1!K7.$!,72,0(*'$!0-!

0$,0!,$*,&0&E&0/@!P#&)$!:&n5,0$.#7&,!$0!()F!=SXXX?!7,$+!(!0.&(*9)$!0$,0!=&*!P#&'#!0#$!'-..$'0!

2-00)$!*$$+$+!0-!2$!+$0$'0$+?F! I*!SXX\@!G7*+$!$0!()F!K72)&,#$+!(!,07+/! &*!P#&'#!(!*$P!

%$0#-+!P(,!+$,'.&2$+!1-.!+&11$.$*0&(0&*9!(*+.-,0$*-*$!,$*,&0&E&0/!2$0P$$*!'-*,7%$.,F!

H''-.+&*9! 0-! 0#&,! ,07+/@! 0#$! 2$,0! K.$,$*0(0&-*! 0-! K$.'$&E$! (*+.-,0$*-*$!P#&)$! (0! 0#$!

,(%$!0&%$!(E-&+&*9!(!+$0$'0(2)$!,%$))! 1.-%!$F9F!-&)@!P(,!(!+-72)$!WZ()0$.*(0&E$!1-.'$+!

0$,0! =WZHA"?! P&0#! (*+.-,0$*-*$! './,0(),! &*! +&,0&))$+! P(0$.@! '-*0(&*$+! &*! 1-&)$+! 9)(,,!

2-00)$,!&*!,0$(+!-1!(!0.&(*9)$!0$,0F!6#$.$1-.$!0#$!97&+$)&*$,!1-.!'-*,7%$.,!P$.$!'#(*9$+!

1.-%! #(E&*9! 0-! '#--,$! 0#$! 2-00)$! +&11$.$*0! 1.-%! 0#$! 0P-! -0#$.! 2-00)$,@! 0-! ,$)$'0! 0#$!

2-00)$!P&0#!0#$!,0.-*9$,0!-+-7.F!H),-@!(!)(2$))$+!%(9*&07+$!,'()$!P(,!&*0.-+7'$+!&*,0$(+!

-1!(!#$+-*&'!,'()$F!6-!.$+7'$!0#$!K-,,&2&)&0/!-1!97$,,&*9@!0#$!WZHA"!0$,0!P(,!K$.1-.%$+!

0P&'$!=,0$K!T!(*+!,0$K!S!&*!A&9!IFTT?F!6#&,!,$*,&0&E&0/!0$,0!())-P$+!0-!+&E&+$!0#$!'-*,7%$.,!

Page 38: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

SV!

&*0-!0P-!9.-7K,g!,$*,&0&E$!'-*,7%$.,@!P#&'#!P$.$!+$,'.&2$+!(,!'-*,7%$.,!P#-!K$.'$&E$!

0#$!-+-7.!-1!(*+.-,0$*-*$!(,!,P$(0@!,-7.k2&00$.@!7.&*$@!K7*9$*0!(*+!$0'#&*9kONW!(*+!

*-*Z,$*,&0&E$!'-*,7%$.,@!P#&'#!P$.$!+$,'.&2$+!(,!'-*,7%$.,!P#-!P&))!*-0!.$,K-*+!0-!

0#$!-+-7.!-.!7,$!(!K-,&0&E$!+$,'.&K0&-*!P#$*!$^K-,$+!0-!(*+.-,0$*-*$F!H!%-.$!.$'$*0!

,07+/!-1!G7*+$!$0!()F!=G7*+$!$0!()F@!SXTX?!+$%-*,0.(0$+!0#(0!(!)-*9ZP-.5&*9!$^K$.&$*'$!

(,! (,,$,,-.! +&+! *-0! ,$$%! 0-! ()0$.! (*+.-,0$*-*$! $E()7(0&-*! &*! 0(&*0$+! %$(0@! 270! 0#$!

%$0#-+!7,$+!0-!,'.$$*!0#$!(,,$,,-.,!1-.!0#$&.!(*+.-,0$*-*$!,$*,&0&E&0/!+&+F!H!+&11$.$*'$!

P(,!-2,$.E$+!2$0P$$*!0#$!(2&)&0/!-1!(,,$,,-.,!0-!+$0$'0!K7.$!(*+.-,0$*-*$!'./,0(),!(*+!

0#$&.! ,$*,&0&E&0/! 0-! 0#$! '-%K-*$*0! &*!%$(0F! I*+$$+@! ())! (,,$,,-.,!P$.$! (2)$! 0-! +$0$'0!

K7.$!'./,0(),!270!*-0!$E$./!(,,$,,-.!P(,!,$*,&0&E$!0-!(*+.-,0$*-*$!&*!%$(0F!6-!+&E&+$!(!

9.-7K!&*0-!,$*,&0&E$!-.!*-*Z,$*,&0&E$!1-.!(*+.-,0$*-*$!&*!%$(0@!0#$!%$0#-+!-1!G7*+$!$0!

()F! =SXX\?! ='./,0(),! +&,,-)E$+! &*! P(0$.! P&0#! (! WZHA"! 0$,0?! #(,! K.-E$*! &0,! 2$*$1&0,F!

H''-.+&*9! 0-! 0#&,! %$0#-+! 0#$! *-*Z,$*,&0&E$! (,,$,,-.,! +&+! *-0! +$0$'0! (*/! ,&9*&1&'(*0!

+&11$.$*'$,!2$0P$$*!(*/!-1!0#$!(*+.-,0$*-*$!,(%K)$,!$E()7(0$+m!0#&,!&*!'-*0.(,0!0-!0#$!

,$*,&0&E$!(,,$,,-.,!=G7*+$!$0!()F@!SXTX?F!!

!

!=%4!RCBB^!70+!c$+,&%)331%'+!$,+2!&)!2%X%2+!5)3,$*+',!%3!,+3,%&%X+!132!3)3A,+3,%&%X+!!

_:$32+!+&!1MCa!FKKV`C!!

Page 39: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

S\!

6#$! (2&)&0/! -1! '(*+&+(0$! $^K$.0,! 0-! +&,'.&%&*(0$! 2$0P$$*! +&11$.$*0! )$E$),! -1!

(*+.-,0$*-*$! -.! ,5(0-)$! &,! (*-0#$.! &%K-.0(*0! 1('0-.! 0#(0! %(/! 2$! $E()7(0$+! +7.&*9!

,$)$'0&-*F! H)7Pl! $0! ()F! =SXX\?! 7,$+! +&11$.$*0! +&)70&-*,! -1! ,5(0-)$! (*+! (*+.-,0$*-*$! &*!

P(0$.!1-.!0#&,!K7.K-,$!P#&)$!"-5$.!$0!()F!=SXX\?!7,$+!9.-7*+!K-.5!%&^$+!P&0#!+&11$.$*0!

'-*'$*0.(0&-*,!-1!2-(.!%$(0@!5*-P*!0-!'-*0(&*!(*+.-,0$*-*$F!A-.!$('#!0$,0@!+&11$.$*0!

&*0$*,&0&$,!-1! $('#! '-%K-7*+!P$.$!K.$,$*0$+! &*! (! .(*+-%!-.+$.! 0-! 0#$!$^K$.0,@!P#-!

P$.$!.$87&.$+!0-!K70!0#$%!&*!-.+$.!-1!&*'.$(,&*9!&*0$*,&0/F!!

O$^0! 0-! 0#$! +&11$.$*'$,! 0#(0! '(*! 2$! 1-7*+! +7.&*9! 0#$! ,$)$'0&-*! -1! $^K$.0,@!

E(.&(2&)&0/!&,!(),-!1-7*+!P&0#&*!0#$!0.(&*&*9!-1!$^K$.0,F!A&.,0)/@!+7.&*9!0.(&*&*9!&*!+$0$'0&-*!

(*+! .$'-9*&0&-*! -1! 0#$! -+-7.@! (,,$,,-.,! )$(.*! 0-! .$'-9*&Q$! (*+! +$,'.&2$! 0#$! -+-7.!

'-..$'0)/F!:&11$.$*0!0/K$,!-1!0.(&*&*9!'(*!2$!&+$*0&1&$+g!H)7Pl!$0!()F!=SXX\?!7,$+!+&11$.$*0!

'-*'$*0.(0&-*,!-1!0#$!'-%K-7*+,!+&)70$+!&*!P(0$.@!P#&)$!%-,0!-0#$.!,07+&$,!$^K-,$!0#$!

(,,$,,-.,! 0-! 0#$! ,(%K)$! %(0.&^! =(*+! 0#$! #$(0&*9! %$0#-+?! 0#(0! &,! 7,$+! +7.&*9! 0#$!

$^K$.&%$*0,F! 6#$!K7.K-,$!-1!2-0#! 0/K$,!-1! ,07+&$,! &,! 0-! )$(.*! 0#$!+&11$.$*'$!2$0P$$*!

,5(0-)$!(*+!(*+.-,0$*-*$!-+-7.,!(*+! 0-! .$'-9*&Q$!,$E$.()!'-*'$*0.(0&-*! )$E$),!-1! 0#$!

'-%K-7*+,F!B(0#7.!$0!()F! =SXTS?!+&+!*-0!0.(&*!0#$!$^K$.0,!-*!,5(0-)$!-.!(*+.-,0$*-*$!

270!-*!0#$!E(.&(2&)&0/!-1!-+-7.,! &*!1(0!,(%K)$,!(*+!2-(.!0(&*0! &*!9$*$.()F!<$'-*+)/@!0#$!

)$E$)! -1! 0.(&*&*9! 0#(0! (,,$,,-.,! .$'$&E$+! +&11$.,! ,&9*&1&'(*0)/! 2$0P$$*! ,07+&$,F!

:&n5,0$.#7&,! $0! ()F! =SXXX?@! ,$)$'0$+! [! K(*$),! 1.-%! [! +&11$.$*0! MD! '-7*0.&$,! =6#$!

O$0#$.)(*+,@!<K(&*@!<P$+$*@!C$.%(*/@!:$*%(.5@!A.(*'$!(*+!D*&0$+!3&*9+-%?@!270!$E$*!

P&0#&*! 0#&,! ,07+/! 0#$! )$E$)! -1! 0.(&*&*9! 07.*$+! -70! 0-! 2$! +&11&'7)0! 0-! #(.%-*&,$F! B-,0!

*-0(2)/! 0#$! 0.(&*&*9! K.-'$+7.$! %(/! #(E$! .$,7)0$+! &*! +&11$.$*'$,! 2$'(7,$! *-! 1&.%!

(9.$$%$*0,! P$.$! %(+$! '-*'$.*&*9! 0#$! %-%$*0! 0-! ,0-K! 0.(&*&*9F! I*! (++&0&-*@! 0#$!

'-**-0(0&-*!-1!0#$!P-.+,!-1!0#$!)&0$.())/!0.(*,)(0$+!(00.&270$,!)&,0@!P(,!+&11$.$*0!2$0P$$*!

0#$!'-7*0.&$,F!H,!%$*0&-*$+@!P#$*!'-%K(.&*9!+&11$.$*0!,07+&$,@!(! )(.9$!.(*9$!-1! )$E$),!

-1!0.(&*&*9!0#(0!(,,$,,-.,!.$'$&E$+!'(*!2$!1-7*+F!>(7)/!$0!()F!=SXTX?!,0(9$+!S!,$,,&-*,m!&*!

0#$! 1&.,0! ,$,,&-*@! 0#$! K.-1&)$,! -1! ,$*,-./! (00.&270$,! -1! 2-(.! 0(&*0! P$.$! 0(79#0! P&0#!

,7*1)-P$.!-&)@!,K&5$+!P&0#!0#$!,/*0#$0&'!'-%K-7*+,@!(*+!#$(0$+!&*!(!%&'.-P(E$!-E$*F!I*!

0#$!,$'-*+!,$,,&-*!0#$/!P$.$!&*,0.7'0$+!0-!$E()7(0$!2-(.!-+-7.@!2-(.!1)(E-7.@!n7&'&*$,,!

(*+! 0$*+$.*$,,F!:$!3-'5!$0!()F! =SXXT?!-.9(*&,$+!(! 0.(&*&*9!-1! 0P-!P$$5,! 0-! 1(%&)&(.&,$!

Page 40: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

WX!

0#$! $^K$.0,! P&0#! 9$*$.()! ,$*,-./! (*()/,&,! (*+! 0-! &+$*0&1/! 0#$! 0$.%,! 0-! +$,'.&2$! 2-(.!

0(&*0F! H*! $E$*!%-.$! &*0$*,&E$! 0.(&*&*9!P(,! K$.1-.%$+! 2/! :&n5,0$.#7&,! $0! ()F! =SXXX?! &*!

P#&'#! 0#$! $^K$.0,! P$.$! 0.(&*$+! -*! (! *7%2$.! -1! (00.&270$,! =6(2)$! IFS?! (*+! (! %-.$!

87(*0&0(0&E$!0.(&*&*9!&F$F!)$(.*&*9!#-P!0-!.(0$!0#$!&*0$*,&0/!-1!(00.&270$,F!6#$!$E()7(0&-*!

(*+! .(*5&*9! -1! 0.(&*&*9! %$0#-+,! &,! .(0#$.! +&11&'7)0@! ,&*'$! %-,0! ,07+&$,! +-! *-0! .$K-.0!

&*0.(Z!(*+!&*0$.Z+(/!E(.&(2&)&0/!-1!0#$!$^K$.0,!(10$.!0.(&*&*9F!

!71.M+!RCF^!@+3,)'O!1&&'%.$&+,!$,+2!%3!&0+!%3&+'31&%)31M!,&$2O!)/!T%dD,&+'0$%,!+&!1MC!_FKKK`!132!

&0+!5)$3&'%+,!%3!N0%50!&0+O!N+'+!3)&!1,,+,,+2!!

8&&'%.$&+,! <2)$'! ?)&!%3! =M1X)$'! ?)&!%3!

T! >&9! ! >&9! !

S! D.&*$! ! D.&*$! !

W! B(*7.$k<0(2)$! ! B(*7.$k<0(2)$! M<!

Y! O(K#0#()$*$k%-0#2()),! M<! O(K#0#()$*$k%-0#2()),! M<!

]! J(*'&+! ! J(*'&+! !

U! <P$$0! ! <P$$0! !

[! <P$(0! ! <P$(0! !

V! H2*-.%()!R+-7.! AJ! H2*-.%()!R+-7.! AJ!

"-7*0.&$,! &*E-)E$+!&*!0#$!,07+/g!:$*%(.5!=:3?@!A.(*'$!=AJ?@!C$.%(*/!=:M?@!O$0#$.)(*+,!=OM?@!<K(&*!=M<?@!

<P$+$*!=<M?!(*+!D*&0$+!3&*9+-%!=D3?@!!

YFSFSF -+&0)2,!132!,51M+,!$,+2!2$'%34!+6H+'%*+3&,!

A-.! 0#$! ,$*,-./! (*()/,&,!-1!2-(.! 0(&*0@! ,(%K)$,! (.$!%-,0)/!#$(0$+! 0-! ())-P! 0#$!

$^K$.0,! 0-!K$.'$&E$!0#$!2-(.!0(&*0!'-%K-7*+,F!H!P&+$!.(*9$!-1!#$(0&*9!%$0#-+,!#(E$!

2$$*! 7,$+! &*! +&11$.$*0! ,07+&$,! ,7'#! (,! ,&*9$&*9! P&0#! (! ,-)+$.&*9! &.-*! =B(0#7.! $0! ()F@!

SXTSm!c#&00&*90-*!$0!()F@!SXTT?@!'--5&*9! &*!(*!-E$*! =+$!3-'5!$0!()F@!SXXTm!>(.7*-E&'!$0!

()F@! SXTX?@! #$(0&*9! &*! (!%&'.-P(E$! =H)7Pl! $0! ()F@! SXX\m!c#&00&*90-*! $0! ()F@! SXTT?@! (*+!

9.&))&*9!=H)7Pl!$0!()F@!SXX\m!>(7)/!$0!()F@!SXTX?F!6#&,!.$*+$.,!'-%K(.&,-*!2$0P$$*!,07+&$,!

+&11&'7)0! 2$'(7,$! #$(0&*9! '-*+&0&-*,! #(E$! 2$$*! ,#-P*! 0-! &*1)7$*'$! 0#$! K$.'$K0&-*! -1!

2-(.!0(&*0!=A-*0!&!A7.*-),@!SXTS?F!ME$*!&1!0#$!0/K$!-1!#$(0&*9!0--)!7,$+!&,!&+$*0&'()@!0#$.$!

%(/! 2$!%(*/! ,K$'&1&'! +&11$.$*'$,F! A-.! $^(%K)$!B(0#7.! $0! ()F! =SXTS?! 7,$+! (! ,-)+$.&*9!

Page 41: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

WT!

&.-*!-1!TXX!c!=c$))$.w?!0#(0!P(,!#$(0$+!0-!(!0$%K$.(07.$!-1!W[Xs"@!P#&)$!&*!(*!$(.)&$.!

,07+/!-1!c#&00&*90-*!$0!()F!=SXTT?!*-!P(00(9$!-1!0#$!,-)+$.&*9!&.-*!P(,!K.-E&+$+!270!0#$!

,7.1('$!-1!0#$!#$(0$+!0&K!P(,!5$K0!(0!TV]s"F!6#&,!&*!'-*0.(,0!P&0#!0#$!,07+/!-1!H)7Pl!$0!

()F! =SXX\?!P#$.$!*-! ,7.1('$! 0$%K$.(07.$!P(,!%$(,7.$+m! -*)/! 0#$!P(00(9$! =WXc!t!*-!

2.(*+?! P(,! K.-E&+$+F! 6-! -7.! 5*-P)$+9$@! -*)/! -*$! $^K$.0! ,07+/! +$,'.&2$,! 0#$!

'-%K(.&,-*!-1!+&11$.$*0!#$(0&*9!%$0#-+,!=%&'.-P(E$@!,-)+$.&*9!&.-*@!2-&)&*9!(0!S]s"!(*+!

[]s"!(*+!%$)0&*9?!P&0#!.$,K$'0!0-!0#$!,$*,-./!(,,$,,%$*0!-1!2-(.!0(&*0!=c#&00&*90-*!$0!

()F@!SXTT?F!"-..$)(0&-*,!2$0P$$*!0#$!'-*'$*0.(0&-*,!-1!2-(.!0(&*0!'-%K-7*+,!(*+!0#$&.!

&*+&E&+7()! -+-7.,! &*! 2('51(0! P$.$! #&9#$.! 1-.! ,5(0-)$! 7,&*9! ())! 0#$! %$0#-+,F! A-.!

(*+.-,0$*-*$@!-*)/!,&9*&1&'(*0!'-..$)(0&-*,!P$.$!1-7*+!7,&*9!0#$!%&'.-P(E$!(*+!%$)0&*9!

%$0#-+,F! 4$,&+$,@! 0#$! (2*-.%()! -+-7.! P(,! %-.$! '-..$)(0$+! P&0#! ,5(0-)$! 0#(*! P&0#!

(*+.-,0$*-*$!=6(2)$!IFW?F!!

!

71.M+!RCE^!(+1',)3!5)''+M1&%)3!5)+//%5%+3&,!.+&N++3!)2)$'!,5)'+,!132!.)1'!&1%3&!5)*H)$32,!_G0%&&%34&)3!+&!1MCa!FKBB`!

!! -%5')N1X+! \)&N%'+! -+M&%34! 9)%M%34!

_UJe>`!

9)%M%34!

_FJe>`!

<5(0-)$!-+-7.!E,F!x9!,5(0-)$! XFYVY!yyy! XFY]\yyy! XFWYYyyy! XFYYXyyy! XFWSXyyy!

H2*-.%()!-+-7.!E,F!x9!,5(0-)$! XFYSTyyy! XFY]Tyyy! XFSSUyy! XFW\Syyy! XF]SXyyy!

H*+.-,0!-+-7.!E,F!x9!(*+.-,0! XFSY[yyy! XFX]\! XFTUTy! XFXW]! XFXSU!

H2*-.%()!-+-7.!E,F!x9!(*+.-,0! XFXUT! XFXSY! XFX[V! XFXVT! XFXYW!y>vXFX]@!yy>vXFXT@!yyy>vXFXXT!

!

4(,$+! -*! 0#$! ,&Q$! -1! +&11$.$*'$,! 2$0P$$*! 9.-7K,! -1! 2('51(0! (*+! '-%K-,&0$!

,(%K)$,! (*+! 0#$! '-..$)(0&-*,! 2$0P$$*! -+-7.! ,'-.$,! (*+! ,5(0-)$! (*+! (*+.-,0$*-*$!

'-*'$*0.(0&-*,@!0#$!%&'.-P(E$@!#-0P&.$!(*+!2-&)&*9!=[]s"?!%$0#-+,!P$.$!+$,'.&2$+!(,!

0#$!%-,0! ,7&0(2)$!%$0#-+,! 1-.!+$0$'0&-*!-1!2-(.! 0(&*0! &*!(2(00-&.,! =c#&00&*90-*!$0!()F@!

SXTT?F!

I*! ,$*,-./! (*()/,&,@! ,'()$,! (.$! 7,$+! 0-! +&,'.&%&*(0$! 2$0P$$*! ,(%K)$,! 2/!

%$(,7.&*9!,0&%7)&F!I*!0#$!'(,$!-1!2-(.!0(&*0@!0P-!0/K$,!-1!,'()$,!(.$!7,$+g!'(0$9-.&'()!(*+!

Page 42: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

WS!

'-*0&*7-7,! ,'()$,F! H2-70! 0P-Z0#&.+! -1! 0#$! $^K$.0! ,07+&$,! 7,$+! '(0$9-.&'()! ,'()$,! 0-!

$E()7(0$! $^K$.0,u! .$,K-*,$,F! N-P$E$.@! 2/! 7,&*9! (! '(0$9-.&'()! ,'()$@! ,-%$! &*1-.%(0&-*!

P&))!K-,,&2)/!2$! )-,0@! .$,7)0&*9! &*!(! .$+7'$+!,$*,&0&E&0/@! &*! ,7'#!(!P(/! 0#(0!%-.$! ,720)$!

'#(*9$,!&*!0#$!+(0(!'(**-0!2$!+$0$'0$+!=67/00$*,!$0!()F@!SXX\?F!A7.0#$.%-.$@!0#$.$!&,!(!

)-0!-1!E(.&(0&-*!&*!0#$!*7%2$.!-1!'(0$9-.&$,!7,$+@!.(*9&*9!1.-%!W!=<5.)$K!$0!()F@!SXTX?!0-!

TX!'(0$9-.&$,!=+$!3-'5!$0!()F@!SXXT?F!6#$!,'()$,!(.$!7,7())/!(*'#-.$+!P&0#!i*-!2-(.!0(&*0j!

&*!0#$! )-P$.!$*+!(*+!i,0.-*9!2-(.!0(&*0j! &*!0#$!#&9#$.!$*+F! I*!,-%$!,07+&$,!0#$!,'()$,!

7,$! -*)/!P-.+,! -.! *7%2$.,! =+$! 3-'5! $0! ()F@! SXXTm! <5.)$K! $0! ()F@! SXTX?! 0-! +$,'.&2$! 0#$!

'(0$9-.&$,@!P#&)$!-0#$.,!7,$!*7%2$.,!(*+!P-.+,!="-5$.!$0!()F@!SXX\?F!I*!0#$!7*,0.7'07.$+!

)&*$!,'()$@!0#$!)$*90#!-1!0#$!,'()$!E(.&$,!2$0P$$*!\!(*+!T]!'%!=4/.*$!$0!()F@!SXXVm!>(7)/!

$0!()F@!SXTX?@!(*+!0#$!,'-.$!%(/!2$!'-*E$.0$+!0-!(!E()7$!2$0P$$*!X!(*+!TXX!=:&n5,0$.#7&,!

$0! ()F@! SXXX?F! H)0#-79#! &0! '-7)+! 2$! K-,,&2)$! 0-! .$Z,'()$! -.! '-*,&+$.! 0#$! .$)(0&E$!

+&11$.$*'$,@!&0!.$*+$.,!'-%K(.&,-*!2$0P$$*!,07+&$,!+&11&'7)0!=A-*0!&!A7.*-),@!SXTS?F!

!

I*!9$*$.()@!%(*/!+&11$.$*0!#$(0&*9!%$0#-+,!$^&,0!0-!+$0$'0!2-(.!0(&*0@!270!*-*$!

-1!0#$%!#(E$!2$$*!,711&'&$*0)/!$E()7(0$+!(*+!E()&+(0$+!(*+!-*)/! 1$P!#$(0&*9!%$0#-+,!

(.$! (KK)&'(2)$! (0Z)&*$! &*! 0#$! ,)(79#0$.#-7,$F! 4$,&+$! 0#$! #$(0&*9! %$0#-+,@! (),-! 0#$!

,$)$'0&-*! (*+! 0.(&*&*9! -1! $^K$.0,! &,! *-0! ,711&'&$*0)/! #(.%-*&,$+@! (,! P$))! (,! 0#$! ,'()$,!

7,$+!0-!')(,,&1/!0#$!,(%K)$!&*!2-(.!0(&*0!(*+!*-!2-(.!0(&*0F!

! !

Page 43: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

WW!

JC >)35+H&$1M!/'1*+N)'D!)/!&0%,!,&$2O!

I*! 9$*$.()@! 0#$!+&11$.$*0!2-(.! 0(&*0!+$0$'0&-*!%$0#-+,! '(*!2$!+&E&+$+! &*0-! 0P-!

9.-7K,g! '#$%&'()! (*()/,$,! (*+! ,$*,-./! (*()/,$,F! B-,0! -1! 0#$! '7..$*0)/! (E(&)(2)$!

'#$%&'()!%$0#-+,!(.$!*-0!'(K(2)$!-1!+$0$'0&*9!0#$!0#.$$!5*-P*!2-(.!0(&*0!'-%K-7*+,!

,&%7)0(*$-7,)/@! P#&'#! )$(+,! 0-! (*()/,$,! 0#(0! (.$! -10$*! )(2-7.Z&*0$*,&E$! (*+! 0&%$!

'-*,7%&*9F! 4$'(7,$! '#$%&'()! (*()/,$,! '(**-0! 2$!7,$+! (0Z)&*$! &*! ,)(79#0$.#-7,$,@! 0#$!

,-)+$.&*9!&.-*!&,!-10$*!7,$+!(0Z)&*$!&*!4$)9&7%!(*+!6#$!O$0#$.)(*+,F!N-P$E$.@!0#&,!(0Z)&*$!

%$0#-+! #(,! *-0! 2$$*! ,'&$*0&1&'())/! $E()7(0$+F! 6#$.$1-.$@! &*! 0#&,! ,07+/! 0#$!%(&*! 9-(),!

P$.$! 0-! +$E$)-K! (! '#$%&'()! (*()/,&,! 1-.! ,&%7)0(*$-7,! +$0$'0&-*! -1! 0#$! 2-(.! 0(&*0!

'-%K-7*+,!(*+! 0-!$E()7(0$! 0#$!,-)+$.&*9! &.-*!(,!(!#7%(*!*-,$!,/,0$%!1-.!2-(.! 0(&*0!

+$0$'0&-*F!6#$!,K$'&1&'!9-(),!-1!0#&,!,07+/!(.$g!

!

! 6-!$E()7(0$!0#$!,$*,&0&E&0/!-1!0#$!A)$%&,#!'&0&Q$*,!(*+!0-!)--5!(0!0#$!$11$'0!

-1!9$*+$.@!(9$@!)-'(0&-*!(*+!,%-5&*9!#(2&0m!

! 6-!+$E$)-K!(!*-E$)!(*()/0&'()!(KK.-('#!0-!,&%7)0(*$-7,)/!+$0$'0!0#$!0#.$$!

5*-P*!2-(.!0(&*0!'-%K-7*+,m!

! 6-!$E()7(0$!+&11$.$*0!#$(0&*9!0--),!(*+!K$.1-.%(*'$!'#(.('0$.&,0&',!-1!0#$!

,&*9$&*9!%$0#-+!1-.!0#$!+$0$'0&-*!-1!2-(.!0(&*0!2/!%$(*,!-1!0#$!#7%(*!

*-,$m!

! 6-!+$0$.%&*$!P#$0#$.!0#$.$!(.$!-0#$.!'-%K-7*+,!&*E-)E$+!&*!2-(.!0(&*0!

2$,&+$,!0#$!0#.$$!5*-P*!2-(.!0(&*0!'-%K-7*+,F!

!

!

! !

Page 44: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

WY!

PC Q+/+'+35+,!

H)+()! IF@!H*+.$,$*!RF@!M9$)&!HF!3F@!N(79$*!LF!MF@!C.-+7%!HF@!An$0)(*+!RF!`!M&5((,!LF!GF!NF!=SXX]?F!G$E$),!-1!(*+.-,0$*-*$!(*+!,5(0-)$!(*+!0#$!-''7..$*'$!-1!2-(.! 0(&*0! &*!1(0!1.-%!/-7*9!2-(.,F!G&E$,0-'5!>.-+7'0&-*!<'&$*'$@!\]=TZS?@!TSTZTS\F!

H)7Pl!BF@!4$5($.0!3F!BF@!67/00$*,!AF!HF!BF@!;(*#($'5$!GF@!:$!<%$0!<F@!:$!4.(2(*+$.!NF!AF@!:$!4.(2(*+$.!:F! GF!`!B&))$0! <F! =SXTT(?F! I*1)7$*'$!-1! ,-&)&*9!-*!2-(.! 0(&*0! &*!2-(.,F!B$(0!<'&$*'$@!V[=W?@!T[]ZT[\F!

H)7Pl!BF@!B&))$0! <F@! 4$5($.0! 3F!BF@! 67/00$*,! AF!HF!BF@!;(*#($'5$! GF@!:$! <%$0! <F!`!:$!4.(2(*+$.!:F!GF! =SXTT2?F! I*1)7$*'$!-1!2.$$+!(*+!,)(79#0$.!P$&9#0!-*!2-(.!0(&*0!K.$E()$*'$!&*!$*0&.$!%()$!K&9,F!H*&%()@!]=V?@!TSVWZTSV\F!

H)7Pl!BF@!B&))$0! <F@! O&n,! CF@! 67/00$*,! AF! HF!BF@! ;$.#$/+$*! 3F@! :$! 4.(2(*+$.! NF! AF@! :$!4.(2(*+$.!:F!GF!`!;(*!R$'5$)!BF!LF!=SXX\?F!H2,$*'$!-1!(*!$11$'0!-1!+&$0(./!1&2.$!-.!')&*-K0&)-)&0$!-*!2-(.!0(&*0!&*!$*0&.$!%()$!K&9,!1$+!K.('0&'()!+&$0,F!B$(0!<'&$*'$@!VS=W?@!WYUZW]SF!

H*+.$,$*! RF! =T\[]?F! J(+&-&%%7*-(,,(/! 1-.! ]()K#(Z(*+.-,0ZTUZ$*ZWZ-*$! &*! K-.'&*$!(+&K-,$!0&,,7$F!H'0(!M*+-'.&*-)-9&'(@![\=W?@!UT\ZUSYF!

H**-.A.$%K-*9!IF!MF@!O70$!CF!JF@!c#&00&*90-*!AF!cF!`!c--+!LF!:F!=T\\[?F!6#$!K.-2)$%!-1!0(&*0! &*! K-.5! FSF! 6#$! &*1)7$*'$! -1! ,5(0-)$@! (*+.-,0$*-*$! (*+! &*+-)$@! K.$,$*0$+!&*+&E&+7())/!(*+!&*!'-%2&*(0&-*!&*!(!%-+$)!)&K&+!2(,$@!-*!-+-7.!K$.'$K0&-*F!B$(0!<'&$*'$@!Y[=TZS?@!Y\ZUTF!

4(2-)!LF@!<87&.$,!MF!LF!`!C7))$00!MF!HF!=T\\]?F!I*E$,0&9(0&-*!-1!1('0-.,!.$,K-*,&2)$!1-.!0#$!+$E$)-K%$*0!-1!2-(.!0(&*0F!A--+!J$,$(.'#!I*0$.*(0&-*()@!SV=U?@!][WZ]VTF!

4(2-)! LF@!<87&.$,!MF! LF!`!C7))$00!MF!HF! =SXXS?F!A('0-.,!(11$'0&*9!0#$! )$E$)!-1!2-(.!0(&*0! &*!$*0&.$!%()$!K&9,!(,!(,,$,,$+!2/!'-*,7%$.!,$*,-./!K(*$)F!B$(0!<'&$*'$@!UT=T?@!WWZYXF!

4(2-)! LF@! q(%(.(0,5(&(! CF@! L7*$n(! JF! 3F! `! G7*+,0.-%! 3F! =SXXY?F! 6#$! $11$'0! -1! (9$! -*!+&,0.&270&-*! -1! ,5(0-)$! (*+! &*+-)$! )$E$),! &*! $*0&.$! %()$! K&9,! &*! 1-7.! 2.$$+,g!b-.5,#&.$@!G(*+.('$@!N(%K,#&.$!(*+!:7.-'F!B$(0!<'&$*'$@!U[=S?@!W]TZW]VF!

4()0#7,,$*!cF!NF!BF@!4('57,!CF!4F!"F!`!N$**$*!cF!NF!CF!LF!=SXXV?F!M'-*-%&,'#$!$11$'0$*!E(*!#$0!K$.!+&.$'0!,0-KK$*!%$0!'(,0.(0&$!E(*!2$$.2&99$*!&*!O$+$.)(*+F!J(KK-.0!]FXVFXS@!GMI@!:$*!N((9F!

4.(00-)&!BF@!+$!C$**(.-!CF@!+$!>&*0-!;F@! G-&-0&)$!HF!:F@! G-E(,'&-! <F!`!>$*Q(!BF! =SXTT?F!R+-7.!:$0$'0&-*!B$0#-+,g!R)1('0-%$0./!(*+!"#$%&'()! <$*,-.,F! <$*,-.,@! TT=]?@!]S\XZ]WSSF!

4.--5,!JF!IF!`!>$(.,-*!HF!BF!=T\VU?F!<0$.-&+Z#-.%-*$!K(0#P(/,!&*!0#$!K&9@!P&0#!,K$'&()!$%K#(,&,!-*!2-(.!-+-.!Z!H!.$E&$PF!L-7.*()!-1!H*&%()!<'&$*'$@!US=W?@!UWSZUY]F!

4/.*$!:F!;F@!6#(%,2-.9!<F!BF!`!N(*,$*!GF!GF!=SXXV?F!H!,$*,-./!+$,'.&K0&-*!-1!2-(.!0(&*0!(*+!0#$!$11$'0,!-1!'.7+$!(*+!+.&$+!'#&'-./!.--0,!="&'#-.&7%!&*0/27,!GF?!(*+!&*7)&*!1$$+&*9!&*!%()$!(*+!1$%()$!K-.5F!B$(0!<'&$*'$@![\=S?@!S]SZSU\F!

Page 45: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

W]!

"#$*!CF@!q(%(.(0,5(&(!CF@!H*+$.,,-*!NF!3F!`!G7*+,0.-%!3F!=SXX[?F!M11$'0,!-1!.(P!K-0(0-!,0(.'#!(*+!)&E$!P$&9#0!-*!1(0!(*+!K)(,%(!,5(0-)$@!&*+-)$!(*+!(*+.-,0$*-*$!)$E$),!%$(,7.$+!2/!+&11$.$*0!%$0#-+,!&*!$*0&.$!%()$!K&9,F!A--+!"#$%&,0./@!TXT=S?@!YW\ZYYVF!

")(7,! JF@!B(#)$.!CF!`!B7*,0$.! MF! =T\VV?F! :$0$.%&*(0&-*! -1! 0#$! 2-(.! 0(&*0! ,0$.-&+! ]HZ(*+.-,0ZTUZ$*ZWZ-*$! &*! (+&K-,$! 0&,,7$! -1! K&9,! P&0#! (! .(K&+! %&'.-0&0.$! K)(0$!$*Q/%$Z&%%7*-(,,(/!=B6M?F!H.'#&E!A7.!G$2$*,%&00$)#/9&$*$@!W\=Y?@!V[Z\XF!

")(7,! JF@! c$&)$.! DF! `! N$.Q-9! HF! =T\\Y?F! >#/,&-)-9&'()Z(,K$'0,! -1! (*+.-,0$*-*$! (*+!,5(0-)$!1-.%(0&-*!&*!0#$!2-(.!Z!H!.$E&$P!P&0#!$^K$.&%$*0()Z+(0(F!B$(0!<'&$*'$@!WV=S?@!SV\ZWX]F!

"-5$.!BF!:F@!c$,0!JF!GF@!4.$*+$%7#)!LF!NF@!4.$*+$%7#)!:F!:F@!L-#*,-*!:F!:F!`!<0$)Q)$*&!HF!BF! =SXX\?F! M11$'0,! -1! )&E$! P$&9#0! (*+! K.-'$,,&*9! -*! 0#$! ,$*,-./! 0.(&0,@!(*+.-,0$*$+&-*$! '-*'$*0.(0&-*! (*+! ]Z()K#(Z(*+.-,0ZTUZ$*ZWZ-*$!=(*+.-,0$*-*$?!'-*'$*0.(0&-*!&*!2-(.!%$(0F!B$(0!<'&$*'$@!VS=W?@!W\\ZYXYF!

:$!4.(2(*+$.!NF!AF!`!;$.2$5$!JF!=T\VU?F!_7(*0&0(0&E$!+$0$.%&*(0&-*!-1!(*+.-,0$*-*$!&*!K&9!(+&K-,$!0&,,7$F!LRDJOHG!RA!"NJRBH6RCJH>Nb@!WUW@!S\WZWXSF!

+$! 3-'5! NF! GF@! N$&*Q$! >F! NF@! >-09&$0$.! "F! BF@! :&n5,0$.#7&,! CF! 4F! `!B&**((.! HF! =SXXT?F!6$%K-.()! (,K$'0,! .$)(0$+! 0-! 0#$! K$.'$K0&-*! -1! ,5(0-)$! (*+! (*+.-,0$*-*$@! 0#$!%(n-.!2-(.!-+-7.!'-%K-7*+,F!B$(0!<'&$*'$@!][=T?@!UTZ[XF!

:$#*#(.+!BF@! ")(7,! JF@! N&))$*2.(*+!BF! `! N$.Q-9! HF! =T\\W?F! N&9#ZK$.1-.%(*'$! )&87&+Z'#.-%(0-9.(K#&'!%$0#-+!1-.!0#$!+$0$.%&*(0&-*!-1!WZ%$0#/)&*+-)$!=,5(0-)$?!(*+!&*+-)$! &*! (+&K-,$Z0&,,7$! -1! K&9,F! L-7.*()! -1! "#.-%(0-9.(K#/Z4&-%$+&'()!HKK)&'(0&-*,@!UTU=S?@!SX]ZSX\F!

:&n5,0$.#7&,!CF!4F@!M*9$)!4F@!c(),0.(!>F@!A7.*-),!BF!AF!IF@!H9$.#$%!NF@!A&,'#$.!3F@!R)&E$.!BF!HF@! ")(7+&ZB(9*7,,$*! "F@! <&.$0! AF@! 4$(97$! BF! >F@! N-%$.! :F! 4F! `! 4-**$(7! BF!=SXXX?F!H*! &*0$.*(0&-*()! ,07+/!-*! 0#$! &%K-.0(*'$!-1! (*+.-,0$*-*$!(*+! ,5(0-)$!1-.! 2-(.! 0(&*0g! IIF! <$*,-./! $E()7(0&-*! 2/! 0.(&*$+! K(*$),! &*! ,$E$*! M7.-K$(*!'-7*0.&$,F!B$(0!<'&$*'$@!]Y=W?@!SUTZSU\F!

:-.(*!MF@!c#&00&*90-*!AF!cF@!c--+!LF!:F!`!B'C&E(*!LF!:F! =SXXS?F!"/0-'#.-%$!>Y]XIIMT!="b>SMT?!&,!&*+7'$+!2/!,5(0-)$!(*+!0#&,!&*+7'0&-*!&,!2)-'5$+!2/!(*+.-,0$*-*$!&*!&,-)(0$+!K&9!#$K(0-'/0$,F!"#$%&'-Z4&-)-9&'()!I*0$.('0&-*,@!TYX=T?@!VTZ\SF!

MA<HF! =SXXY?F! c$)1(.$! (,K$'0,! -1! 0#$! '(,0.(0&-*! -1! K&9)$0,g! <'&$*0&1&'! J$K-.0! -1! 0#$!<'&$*0&1&'! >(*$)! 1-.! H*&%()! N$)(0#! (*+!c$)1(.$! -*! (! .$87$,0! 1.-%! '-%%&,,&-*!.$)(0$+!0-!P$)1(.$!(,K$'0,!-1!0#$!'(,0.(0&-*!-1!>&9)$0,F!6#$!MA<H!L-7.*()@!\T@!TZTVF!

MA<H! 6F! JF! =SXTT?F! >.$K(.(0-./! P-.5! 1-.! 0#$! 1707.$! +$E$)-K%$*0! -1! (*&%()! 2(,$+!%$(,7.$,! 1-.! (,,$,,&*9! 0#$! P$)1(.$! -1! ,-P@! 2-(.! (*+! K&9)$0! &*')7+&*9! (,K$'0,!.$)(0$+!0-!K&9!'(,0.(0&-*F!M7.-K$(*!A--+!<(1$0/!H70#-.&0/F!

A(-,0(0F!=SXTS?F!J-%$@!I0()/@!#00Kgkk1(-,0(0F1(-F-.9k+$1(7)0F(,K^!!

Page 46: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

WU!

A&,'#$.! LF@! M),&*9#-.,0! >F! cF@! 47'5&*9! BF@! 6#-)$*! MF@! >$0$.,$*! 4F! `! c7,0! BF! =SXTT?F!:$E$)-K%$*0! -1! (! "(*+&+(0$! J$1$.$*'$! B$0#-+! 1-.! 0#$! <&%7)0(*$-7,!_7(*0&0(0&-*!-1!0#$!4-(.!6(&*0!"-%K-7*+,!H*+.-,0$*-*$@!W!()K#(ZH*+.-,0$*-)@!W! 2$0(ZH*+.-,0$*-)@! <5(0-)$@! (*+! I*+-)$! &*! >&9! A(0! 2/!B$(*,! -1! <0(2)$! I,-0-K$!:&)70&-*! H*()/,&,ZN$(+,K('$! <-)&+Z>#(,$! B&'.-$^0.('0&-*ZC(,!"#.-%(0-9.(K#/kB(,,!<K$'0.-%$0./F!H*()/0&'()!"#$%&,0./@!VW=T[?@!U[V]ZU[\TF!

A-*0! &! A7.*-),!BF! =SXTS?F! "-*,7%$.! ,07+&$,! -*! ,$*,-./! (''$K0(2&)&0/! -1! 2-(.! 0(&*0g! (!.$E&$PF!B$(0!<'&$*'$F!

A.$+.&5,$*!4F@!A-*0!&!A7.*-),!BF@!G7*+,0.-%!3F@!B&9+()!cF@!>.7*&$.!HF@!67/00$*,!AF!HF!BF!`!4-**$(7!BF! =SXX\?F! >.('0&'$! -*! '(,0.(0&-*! -1! K&9)$0,! &*! M7.-K$F! H*&%()@! W=TT?@!TYVXZTYV[F!

A.$+.&5,$*! 4F@! L-#*,$*! HF! BF! <F! `! <570$.7+! MF! =SXTT?F! "-*,7%$.! (00&07+$,! 0-P(.+,!'(,0.(0&-*! -1! K&9)$0,! (*+! ()0$.*(0&E$,! 0-! ,7.9&'()! '(,0.(0&-*F! J$,$(.'#! &*!;$0$.&*(./!<'&$*'$@!\X=S?@!W]SZW][F!

A.$+.&5,$*!4F!`!O-1,0(+!RF!=SXXU?F!6#$!O-.P$9&(*!J$,$(.'#!>.-9.(%%(!1-.!M*0&.$!%()$!>&9!>.-+7'0&-*F!H'0(!;$0$.&*(.&(!<'(*+&*(E&'(@!YV=<TU?F!

C(.'&(ZJ$97$&.-! LF! HF@! N-.0-,!BF@! H.*(7! "F! `!B-*1-.0! LF!BF! =T\VU?F! :$0$.%&*(0&-*! -1!,5(0-)$! (*+! &*+-)$! &*! 2('5! 1(0! -1! K&9,! 2/! N>G"F! L-7.*()! -1! N&9#! J$,-)70&-*!"#.-%(0-9.(K#/!`!"#.-%(0-9.(K#/!"-%%7*&'(0&-*,@!\=U?@!WUSZWUWF!

C(.'&(ZJ$97$&.-!LF!HF!`!J&7,!BF!HF!=T\\V?F!J(K&+!+$0$.%&*(0&-*!-1!,5(0-)$!(*+!&*+-)$!&*!K&9!2('5!1(0!2/!*-.%()ZK#(,$!)&87&+!'#.-%(0-9.(K#/F!L-7.*()!-1!"#.-%(0-9.(K#/!H@!VX\@!SYUZS]TF!

C&)2$.0! HF! OF! `!c/,-'5&! "F! LF! =T\V[?F! 6#$! ,%$))! .$,7)0,g! ,7.E$/F! O(0&-*()! C$-9.(K#&'@!-'0-2$.@!]TY!Z!]S]F!

C-P$.! :F! 4F! =T\[S?F! TUZ7*,(07.(0$+! "T\! ,0$.-&+,! Z! J$E&$P! -1! 0#$&.! '#$%&,0./@!2&-'#$%&,0./! (*+! K-,,&2)$! K#/,&-)-9&'()! .-)$F! L-7.*()! -1! <0$.-&+! 4&-'#$%&,0./@!W=T?@!Y]Z`F!

N(*,$*!GF!GF!=T\\V?F!I*1)7$*'$!-1!$*E&.-*%$*0()!1('0-.,!(*+!(*0&2&-0&',!-*!,5(0-)$!&*!K&9,F!I*! <5(0-)$! (*+! 2-(.! 0(&*0! =$+F! L$*,$*! c3?F! :(*&,#! B$(0! J$,$(.'#! I*,0&070$@!J-,5&)+$@!:$*%(.5@!TW[ZT]XF!

N(*,$*! GF! GF@! G(.,$*! HF! MF@! L$*,$*! 4F! 4F@! N(*,$*%-))$.! LF! `! 4(.0-*9(+$! >F! =T\\Y?F!I*1)7$*'$! -1! ,0-'5&*9! .(0$! (*+! 1$'$,! +$K-,&0&-*! &*! 0#$! K$*! (0! +&11$.$*0!0$%K$.(07.$,!-*!,5(0-)$!'-*'$*0.(0&-*!=2-(.!0(&*0?! &*!,72'70(*$-7,!1(0F!H*&%()!>.-+7'0&-*@!]\@!\\ZTTXF!

N(*,$*ZB-))$.! LF! =T\\S?F!:$0$.%&*(0&-*!-1! &*+-)&'! '-%K-7*+,! &*!K&9!2('5! 1(0!2/! ,-)&+ZK#(,$! $^0.('0&-*! (*+! 9.(+&$*0! #&9#ZK$.1-.%(*'$! )&87&! '#.-%(0-9.(K#/! P&0#!,K$'&()! $%K#(,&,! -*! 0n$! 2-(.! 0(&*0! '-%K-7*+! ,5(0-)$F! LRDJOHG! RA!"NJRBH6RCJH>Nb@!USY@!Y[\ZY\XF!

Page 47: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

W[!

N(*,$*ZBr))$.! LF! =T\\Y?F! J(K&+! #&9#ZK$.1-.%(*'$! )&87&+! '#.-%(0-9.(K#&'! %$0#-+! 1-.!,&%7)0(*$-7,! +$0$.%&*(0&-*! -1! (*+.-,0$*-*$@! ,5(0-)$! (*+! &*+-)$! &*! 2('5! 1(0!1.-%! K&9,F! L-7.*()! -1! "#.-%(0-9.(K#/! 4Z4&-%$+&'()! HKK)&'(0&-*,@! UUT=S?@! ST\ZSWXF!

N(79$*! LF! MF@! 4.7*&7,! "F! `! q(%(.(0,5(&(! CF! =SXTS?F! J$E&$P! -1! (*()/0&'()! %$0#-+,! 0-!%$(,7.$! 2-(.! 0(&*0! '-%K-7*+,! &*! K-.'&*$! (+&K-,$! 0&,,7$g! 6#$! *$$+! 1-.!#(.%-*&,$+!%$0#-+,F!B$(0!<'&$*'$@!\X=T?@!\ZT\F!

N72$.ZM&'#$.! 4F!`! <K.&*9! >F! =SXXV?F! H00&07+$,! -1! <P&,,! '-*,7%$.,! 0-P(.+,!%$(0! 1.-%!$*0&.$! -.! &%%7*-'(,0.(0$+! 2-(.,g! H! .$K.$,$*0(0&E$! ,7.E$/F! J$,$(.'#! &*!;$0$.&*(./!<'&$*'$@!V]=W?@!US]ZUS[F!

I<R! V]VUF! =SXXV?F! <$*,-./! (*()/,$,! Z! C$*$.()! C7&+(*'$! 1-.! 0#$! ,$)$'0&-*@! 0.(&*&*9! (*+!%-*&0-.&*9!-1!(,,$,,-.,F!K(.0!SF!

L$*,$*! BF! 6F@! "-^! JF! >F! `! L$*,$*! 4F! 4F! =T\\](?F! WZ%$0#/)&*+-)$! =<5(0-)$?! (*+! &*+-)$!K.-+7'0&-*! 2/! %&^$+! K-K7)(0&-*,! -1! K&9! 1$'()! 2('0$.&(F! HKK)&$+! (*+!M*E&.-*%$*0()!B&'.-2&-)-9/!UT@!WTVXZWTVYF!

L$*,$*!BF!6F@!"-^!JF!>F!`! L$*,$*!4F!4F! =T\\]2?F!B&'.-2&()ZK.-+7'0&-*!-1! ,5(0-)$! &*! 0#$!#&*+! 970! -1! K&9,! 9&E$*! +&11$.$*0! +&$0,! (*+! &0,! .$)(0&-*! 0-! ,5(0-)$! +$K-,&0&-*! &*!2('51(0F!H*&%()!<'&$*'$@!UT@!S\WZWXYF!

3(71%(**!CF@! J&00$.! AF!`! <'#72$.0! 3F! =T\[U?F!_7(*0&0(0&E$Z+$0$.%&*(0&-*!-1! 2-(.! 0(&*0!,72,0(*'$! ]()K#(Z(*+.-,0ZTUZ$*ZWZ-*$! &*! 1(0F! L-7.*()! -1! <0$.-&+! 4&-'#$%&,0./!(*+!B-)$'7)(.!4&-)-9/@![=V?@!]\WZ]\[F!

3$))$.!HF@!q#7(*9!NF!bF@!"#&!_F!bF@!;-,,#())!GF!4F!`!B(0,7*(%&!NF!=SXX[?F!C$*$0&'!E(.&(0&-*!&*! (!#7%(*!-+-.(*0! .$'$K0-.! ()0$.,!-+-7.!K$.'$K0&-*F!O(07.$@! YY\=[TUT?@! YUVZDYUUF!

3n-,!OF!>F@!RE$.)(*+!BF@!A(7,5$!HF!3F!`!<-.7%!NF!=SXTX?F!A$$+&*9!'#&'-./!&*7)&*!0-!$*0&.$!%()$!K&9,!+7.&*9!0#$!)(,0!K$.&-+!2$1-.$!,)(79#0$.!.$+7'$,!,5(0-)$!&*!+&9$,0(!(*+!2('51(0F!G&E$,0-'5!<'&$*'$@!TWY=TZW?@!TYWZTY]F!

G7*+$!3F@!M9$)(*+,+()!4F@!<570$.7+!MF@!B(&*)(*+!LF!:F@!G$(!6F@!N$.,)$0#!BF!`!B(0,7*(%&!NF! =SXTS?F! C$*$0&'! ;(.&(0&-*! -1! (*! R+-.(*0! J$'$K0-.! RJ[:Y! (*+! <$*,-./!>$.'$K0&-*!-1!"--5$+!B$(0!"-*0(&*&*9!H*+.-,0$*-*$F!>G-<!ROM@![=]?F!

G7*+$!3F@!<570$.7+!MF@!M9$)(*+,+()!4F@!A-*0!&!A7.*-),!BF@!O70$!CF!JF@!4$n$.#-)%!"F@!O&),$*!HF@! <0$*,0.-%! bF! NF! `! N$.,)$0#!BF! =SXTX?F! 6#$! &%K-.0(*'$! -1! 0#$! .$'.7&0%$*0!%$0#-+!1-.!(*+.-,0$*-*$!,$*,&0&E&0/!P&0#!.$,K$'0!0-!(''7.(0$!,$*,-./!$E()7(0&-*!-1!(*+.-,0$*-*$!0(&*0$+!%$(0F!A--+!_7()&0/!(*+!>.$1$.$*'$@!ST=U?@!UYVZU]YF!

G7*+$! 3F@! <570$.7+! MF@! O&),$*! HF! `! M9$)(*+,+()! 4F! =SXX\?F! H! *$P! %$0#-+! 1-.!+&11$.$*0&(0&*9!0#$!(*+.-,0$*-*$!,$*,&0&E&0/!(%-*9!'-*,7%$.,F!A--+!_7()&0/!(*+!>.$1$.$*'$@!SX=Y?@!WXYZWTTF!

G7*+,0.-%!3F@!B(00#$P,!3F!JF!`!N(79$*!LF!MF!=SXX\?F!>&9!%$(0!87()&0/!1.-%!$*0&.$!%()$,F!H*&%()@!W=TT?@!TY\[ZT]X[F!

Page 48: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

WV!

B(5(.-E! HF! `! <'&9$)-E(!BF! =SXTX?F! "-7K)&*9! )&87&+! '#.-%(0-9.(K#/! 0-! R.2&0.(K!%(,,!,K$'0.-%$0./F!L-7.*()!-1!"#.-%(0-9.(K#/!H@!TST[=S]?@!W\WVZW\Y]F!

B(.'#!JF!MF!=T\\[?F!H*!&*0.-+7'0&-*!0-!87(+.7K-)$!&-*!0.(K!%(,,!,K$'0.-%$0./F!L-7.*()!-1!B(,,!<K$'0.-%$0./@!WS=Y?@!W]TZWU\F!

B(.^!CF@!N-.*!6F@!6#&$)$2$&*!LF@!3*72$)!4F!`!E-*!4-.$))!MF!=SXXW?F!H*()/,&,!-1!K(&*Z.$)(0$+!E-'()&Q(0&-*!&*!/-7*9!K&9,F!L-7.*()!-1!<-7*+!(*+!;&2.(0&-*@!SUU=W?@!UV[ZU\VF!

B(0#7.!>F!3F@! 6$*!O(K$)! LF@!4)-$%#-1!<F@!N$.$,! GF@! 3*-)!MF! AF!`!B7)+$.!NF!HF! =SXTS?F!H!#7%(*!*-,$!,'-.&*9!,/,0$%!1-.!2-(.!0(&*0!(*+!&0,!.$)(0&-*,#&K!P&0#!(*+.-,0$*-*$!(*+!,5(0-)$F!B$(0!<'&$*'$@!\T@!YTYZYSSF!

B$0Q!"F!`!")(7,!JF! =SXXW?F!H'0&E$! &%%7*&Q(0&-*!-1!2-(.,!(9(&*,0!C*JN!+-$,!*-0!(11$'0!9.-P0#!#-.%-*$!270!)-P$.,!ICAZI!&*!K)(,%(F!G&E$,0-'5!>.-+7'0&-*!<'&$*'$@!VT=SZW?@!TS\ZTW[F!

B-.0$*,$*!HF!4F!`!<-.$*,$*!<F!MF! =T\VY?F!J$)(0&-*,#&K!2$0P$$*!2-(.! 0(&*0!(*+!,5(0-)$!+$0$.%&*$+! P&0#! (! *$P! (*()/,&,! %$0#-+F! WX! 0#! M7.-K$(*! B$$0&*9! -1! B$(0!J$,$(.'#!c-.5$.,@!4.&,0-)@!DF3F!

O&$)$*!BF!cF!AF@! E(*!M*9$)$*!BF!"F@! q7&+$.$*0!JF!`!J(%(5$.!JF! =SXX[?F! <'.$$*&*9!(*+!'-*1&.%(0&-*!'.&0$.&(! 1-.!#-.%-*$!.$,&+7$!(*()/,&,!7,&*9! )&87&+!'#.-%(0-9.(K#/!(''7.(0$! %(,,! 0&%$Z-1Z1)&9#0@! A-7.&$.! 0.(*,1-.%! &-*! '/')-0.-*! .$,-*(*'$! (*+!-.2&0.(K!%(,,! ,K$'0.-%$0./! 0$'#*&87$,F! H*()/0&'(! "#&%&'(! H'0(@! ]VU=TZS?@! TSSZTS\F!

>(.7*-E&'! OF@! >$0.-E&'! BF@! B(0$5()-Z<E$.(5! ;F@! >(.7*-E&'! LF! `! J(+-E&'! "F! =SXTX?F!J$)(0&-*,#&K!2$0P$$*!"(.'(,,!c$&9#0@!<5(0-)$!G$E$)!(*+!<$*,-./!H,,$,,%$*0! &*!A(0!-1!:&11$.$*0!4-(.,F!"Q$'#!L-7.*()!-1!A--+!<'&$*'$,@!SV=U?@!]SXZ]WXF!

>(00$.,-*!JF!GF!<F!=T\U[?F!H!K-,,&2)$!'-*0.&270&-*!-1!K#$*-)&'!'-%K-*$*0,!0-!2-(.!-+-7.F!L-7.*()!-1!0#$!<'&$*'$!-1!A--+!(*+!H9.&'7)07.$@!TV@!VZTXF!

>(00$.,-*! JF! GF! <F! =T\UV?F! ]oZ(*+.-,0ZTUZ$*$ZWZ-*$! '-%K-7*+! .$,K-*,&2)$! 1-.! 0(&*0! &*!2-(.!1(0F!L-7.*()!-1!0#$!<'&$*'$!-1!A--+!(*+!H9.&'7)07.$@!T\=T?@!WTF!

>(7)/!"F@!<K.&*9Z<0($#)&!>F@!Rz:-#$.0/!LF!;F@!3.(90$*!<F!HF@!:72-&,!<F@!B$,,(+$*$!LF!`!4$$!CF! =SXTX?F! 6#$! $11$'0,! -1! %$0#-+! -1! '(,0.(0&-*@! .$(.&*9! '-*+&0&-*! (*+! +&$0! -*!,$*,-./! 87()&0/! -1! K-.5! (,,$,,$+! 2/! (! 0.(&*$+! K(*$)F!B$(0! <'&$*'$@! VU=S?@! Y\VZ]XYF!

>.7,(!3F@!O$+$.E$)+!NF@!J7**$),!>F!GF@!G&!JF@!3&*9!;F!GF!`!".(*$!LF!>F!=SXTT?F!>.$E()$*'$!(*+!.$)(0&-*,#&K,!-1!,$*,-./!0(&*0@!]!()K#(Z(*+.-,0$*-*$!(*+!,5(0-)$!&*!1(0!(*+!)$(*!0&,,7$! 1.-%!0#$! )-&*! =G-*9&,,&%7,!+-.,&?!-1!2(..-P,@!9&)0,@! ,-P,@!(*+!2-(.,! 1.-%!,$)$'0$+!(2(00-&.,!&*!0#$!D*&0$+!<0(0$,F!B$(0!<'&$*'$@!VV=T?@!\UZTXTF!

J&7,!BF!HF!`!C(.'&(ZJ$97$&.-!LF!HF!=SXXT?F!J-)$!-1!YZK#$*/)ZWZ270$*ZSZ-*$!&*!2-(.!0(&*g!&+$*0&1&'(0&-*! -1! *$P! '-%K-7*+,! .$()0$+! 0-! ,$*,-.&()! +$,'.&K0-.,! &*! K&9! 1(0F!L-7.*()!-1!H9.&'7)07.()!(*+!A--+!"#$%&,0./@!Y\=TT?@!]WXWZ]WX\F!

Page 49: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

W\!

J&7,!BF!HF@!N-.0-,!BF!`!C(.'&(ZJ$97$&.-!LF!HF!=SXX]?F!I*1)7$*'$!-1!E-)(0&)$!'-%K-7*+,!-*!0#$!+$E$)-K%$*0!-1!-11Z1)(E-7.,!&*!K&9!2('5!1(0!,(%K)$,!')(,,&1&$+!P&0#!2-(.!0(&*0!2/!(!0$,0!K(*$)F!B$(0!<'&$*'$@![T=Y?@!]\]ZUXSF!

J-2&'! HF@! G(.Q7)! "F! `! 4-**$(7! BF! =SXXV?F! C$*$0&'! (*+! %$0(2-)&'! (,K$'0,! -1!(*+.-,0$*-*$! (*+! ,5(0-)$! +$K-,&0&-*! &*! K&9! (+&K-,$! 0&,,7$g! H! .$E&$PF! C$*$0&',!<$)$'0&-*!ME-)70&-*@!YX=T?@!TS\ZTYWF!

<'#.$7.,!OF!BF@!B'O(22!cF!"F@!6(E$*+()$!BF!NF@!G(*$!CF!HF@!4(../!6F!OF@!"7%%&*9,!6F@!A.(,$.!3F@!G-K$QZ;&))()-2-,!OF!`!J(%&.$QZJ$,0.$K-!"F!HF!=SXX[?F!<5(0-)$!(*+!&*+-)$!'-*'$*0.(0&-*! (*+! 0#$! -+-7.! -1! 1(0! 1.-%! )(%2,! 0#(0! #(+! 9.(Q$+! K$.$**&()!./$9.(,,kP#&0$! ')-E$.! K(,07.$! -.! G-07,! '-.*&'7)(07,F! H*&%()! A$$+! <'&$*'$! (*+!6$'#*-)-9/@!TWV=WZY?@!S]YZS[TF!

<&*9#!>F@!<#&*(!HF@!H1Q()!JF!`!4.-'5!6F!3F!=T\VV?F!H!>.('0&'()!$*Q/%$Z)&*5$+!&%%7*-(,,(/!1-.! 87(*0&1&'(0&-*! -1! ,5(0-)$F! I*g! >.-'F! WY0#! I*0F! "-*9.! B$(0! <'&F! 6$'#*-)F@!4.&,2(*$@!U\SZU\YF!

<5.)$K!BF@! <$97)(!4F@! >.$E-)*&5!BF@! 3&.2&,!HF@! A(Q(.&*'!CF!`!"(*+$5Z>-0-5(.!BF! =SXTX?F!M11$'0!-1! &%%7*-'(,0.(0&-*!=I%K.-E('!=J??! &*!1(00$*&*9!K&9,!IIg!'(.'(,,!0.(&0,!(*+!%$(0!87()&0/F!<)-E$*&(*!;$0$.&*(./!J$,$(.'#@!Y[=S?@!U]Z[SF!

<87&.$,!MF! LF! =T\\X?F!<07+&$,!-*!0#$!,7&0(2&)&0/!-1!(!'-)-.&%$0.&'! 0$,0! 1-.!(*+.-,0ZTUZ$*$!,0$.-&+,! &*! 0#$! ,72%(^&))(./Z9)(*+! (*+! 1(0! -1! K&9,! (,! (! ,&%K)$! '#$%&'()Z0$,0! 1-.!2-(.!0(&*0F!"(*(+&(*!L-7.*()!-1!H*&%()!<'&$*'$@![X=Y?@!TXS\ZTXYXF!

<87&.$,! MF! LF! =SXXU?F! >-,,&2&)&0&$,! 1-.! ,$)$'0&-*! (9(&*,0! 2-(.! 0(&*0F! H'0(! ;$0$.&*(.&(!<'(*+&*(E&'(@!YV=<V?F!

<P(.0Q!BF!MF!=SXX]?F!D)0.(!K$.1-.%(*'$!)&87&+!'#.-%(0-9.(K#/!=D>G"?g!H*!&*0.-+7'0&-*F!G'!C'!O-.0#!H%$.&'(@!VZTYF!

6#-%K,-*!JF!NF!`!>$(.,-*!HF!BF!=T\[[?F!_7(*0&0(0&E$Z+$0$.%&*(0&-*!-1!]()K#(Z(*+.-,0ZTUZ$*ZWZ-*$! 2/! 9(,! '#.-%(0-9.(K#/!%(,,! ,K$'0.-%$0./! (*+! &0,! .$)(0&-*,#&K! 0-!,$^! -+-.! &*0$*,&0/! -1! K-.5F! L-7.*()! -1! H9.&'7)07.()! (*+! A--+! "#$%&,0./@! S]=U?@!TSYTZTSY]F!

67-%-)(!BF@!N(5()(!BF!`!B(**&*$*!>F!=T\\V?F!:$0$.%&*(0&-*!-1!(*+.-,0$*-*$!&*!K&9!1(0!7,&*9! K('5$+! '-)7%*! ,7K$.'.&0&'()! 1)7&+! '#.-%(0-9.(K#/! %(,,! ,K$'0.-%$0./F!L-7.*()!-1!"#.-%(0-9.(K#/!4@![T\=TZS?@!S]ZWXF!

67-%-)(! BF@! N(.K&-! JF@! 3*7700&)(! >F@! B&5-)(! NF! `! G-E9.$*! 6F! =T\\[?F! 6&%$Z.$,-)E$+!1)7-.-&%%7*-(,,(/!1-.!0#$!%$(,7.$%$*0!-1!(*+.-,0$*-*$!&*!K-.'&*$!,$.7%!(*+!1(0!,(%K)$,F!L-7.*()!-1!H9.&'7)07.()!(*+!A--+!"#$%&,0./@!Y]=\?@!W]S\ZW]WYF!

67/00$*,! AF!HF!BF@! <K.$*9$.!BF@!;(*!O711$)!HF@!B($.0$*,!cF!`!;(*!:-*9$*! <F! =SXX\?F!J$)&(2&)&0/! -1! '(0$9-.&'()! E$.,7,! '-*0&*7-7,! ,'-.&*9! -1! P$)1(.$! &*+&'(0-.,g!)(%$*$,,!&*!'-P,!(,!(!'(,$!,07+/F!H*&%()!c$)1(.$@!TV=Y?@!W\\ZYX]F!

Page 50: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

CMOMJHG!IO6JR:D"6IRO!

!

!

YX!

;(*!R$'5$)!BF!LF@!c(.*(*0,!OF@!:$!>($K$!BF@!"(,0$$),!BF!`!4-7'87$!"F!;F!=T\\V?F!M11$'0!-1! 1&2.$Z.&'#!+&$0,!-*! 0#$!2('51(0! ,5(0-)$! '-*0$*0!-1! $*0&.$!%()$!K&9,F! G&E$,0-'5!>.-+7'0&-*!<'&$*'$@!]U=S?@!T[WZTVXF!

;(*+$*!47,,'#$!LF!=SXTT?F!H*()/0&'()!(KK.-('#$,!0-!7*.(E$)!0#$!,$%&Z$*+-9$*-7,!,0(07,!-1! 0#&-7.('&)F!"#(K0FT!C$*$.()! &*0.-+7'0&-*! 0-! 0#/.$-,0(0&'!+.79,F!>#:! 0#$,&,@!TZS\F!

;(*+$*!47,,'#$!LF@!;(*#($'5$!GF@!:$'$7*&*'5!bF@!;$.#$/+$*!3F@!c&))$!3F@!4$5($.0!3F@!G$!4&Q$'!4F!`!:$!4.(2(*+$.!NF! AF! =SXTX?F!:$E$)-K%$*0! (*+! E()&+(0&-*!-1! (*!7)0.(Z#&9#!K$.1-.%(*'$!)&87&+!'#.-%(0-9.(K#/!0(*+$%!%(,,!,K$'0.-%$0./!%$0#-+!1-.!87(*0&1/&*9! 0#/.$-,0(0,! &*! 7.&*$! P&0#-70! +$.&E(0&,(0&-*F! L-7.*()! -1!"#.-%(0-9.(K#/!H@!TST[=SU?@!YSV]ZYS\WF!

;(*#($'5$!GF@!;(*+$*!47,,'#$!LF@!c&))$!3F@!4$5($.0!3F!`!:$!4.(2(*+$.!NF!AF!=SXTT?F!D)0.(Z#&9#! K$.1-.%(*'$! )&87&+! '#.-%(0-9.(K#/Z0(*+$%! %(,,! ,K$'0.-%$0./! &*! #&9#Z0#.-79#K70! '-*1&.%(0&-*! (*+! 87(*0&1&'(0&-*! -1! WY! (*(2-)&'! ,0$.-&+,! &*! 2-E&*$!%7,')$F!H*()/0&'(!"#&%&'(!H'0(@![XX=TZS?@![XZ[[F!

;(*#-*('5$.! AF@! ;$.2$5$!cF!`! 67/00$*,! AF! HF!BF! =SXX\?F! 4$)9&(*! '-*,7%$.,z! (00&07+$!0-P(.+,! ,7.9&'()! '(,0.(0&-*! (*+! &%%7*-'(,0.(0&-*! -1! K&9)$0,F! H*&%()! c$)1(.$@!TV=Y?@!W[TZWVXF!

;$.#$/+$*!3F@!O-KK$!NF@!H)7P$!BF@!B&))$0!<F@!47,,'#$!LF!;F!`!:$!4.(2(*+$.!NF!AF!=SXX[?F!:$E$)-K%$*0!(*+!E()&+(0&-*!-1!(!%$0#-+! 1-.!,&%7)0(*$-7,!(*()/,&,!-1! 0#$!2-(.!0(&*0! '-%K-7*+,! &*+-)$@! ,5(0-)$! (*+! (*+.-,0$*-*$! &*! K&9! 1(0! 7,&*9! )&87&+!'#.-%(0-9.(K#/Z%7)0&K)$! %(,,! ,K$'0.-%$0./F! L-7.*()! -1! "#.-%(0-9.(K#/! H@!TT[Y=TZS?@!TWSZTW[F!

;-)+! MF! =T\[X?F! A)$&,#K.-+750&-*,$&9$*,'#(10$*! 2$&! M2$.*! 7*+! 3(,0.(0$*F! I;F!R.9(*-)$K0&,'#$! 7*+! 9(,'#.-%(0-9.(1&,'#$! D*0$.,7'#7*9$*!!c(,,$+(%K11){'#0&9$.! <0--11$! +$,! J{'5$*,K$'5$,! E-*! M2$.*F! B$)+&*9$.!O-.+(*+2.7'5#-$9,5-)$@!Y\@!T!Z!S]F!

c$&)$.! DF@! A&,'#$.! 3F@! 3$%%$.! NF@! :-2.-P-),5&! HF! `! ")(7,! JF! =T\\[?F! I*1)7$*'$! -1!(*+.-,0$*-*$!,$*,&0&E&0/!-*!'-*,7%$.!.$('0&-*,!0-!2-(.!%$(0F!I*!BF!4-**$(7@!3F!G7*+,0.-%!`! 4F!B()%1-.,! =M+,F?@! 4-(.! 6(&*0! &*! M*0&.$!B()$! >&9,! =KKF! TY[ZT]T?F!c(9$*&*9$*g!c(9$*&*9$*!H'(+$%&'!>72)&,#$.,F!

c$&)$.! DF@! A-*0! &! A7.*-),! BF@! A&,'#$.! 3F@! 3$%%$.! NF@! R)&E$.! BF! HF@! C&,K$.0! BF@!:-2.-P-),5&! HF! `! ")(7,! JF! =SXXX?F! I*1)7$*'$! -1! +&11$.$*'$,! &*! ,$*,&0&E&0/! -1!<K(*&,#!(*+!C$.%(*!'-*,7%$.,!0-!K$.'$&E$!(*+.-,0$*-*$!-*!0#$!(''$K0(*'$!-1!2-(.!%$(0!+&11$.&*9! &*!,5(0-)$!(*+!(*+.-,0$*-*$!'-*'$*0.(0&-*,F!B$(0!<'&$*'$@!]Y=W?@!S\[ZWXYF!

c#&00&*90-*!AF!BF@!q(%%$.&*&!:F@!O70$!CF!JF@!4(5$.!HF@!N79#$,!<F!IF!`!c--+!LF!:F!=SXTT?F!"-%K(.&,-*! -1! #$(0&*9! %$0#-+,! (*+! 0#$! 7,$! -1! +&11$.$*0! 0&,,7$,! 1-.! ,$*,-./!

Page 51: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!I!

!

!

YT!

(,,$,,%$*0! -1! (2*-.%()! -+-7.,! =2-(.! 0(&*0?! &*! K&9!%$(0F!B$(0! <'&$*'$@! VV=S?@!SY\ZS]]F!

c&))$!3F@!:$!4.(2(*+$.!NF! AF@!:$!c7)1! MF@!;(*!"($0$.!>F@! L(*,,$*!"F!JF!`!;(*#($'5$! GF!=SXTS?F! "-7K)$+! '#.-%(0-9.(K#&'! (*+! %(,,Z,K$'0.-%$0.&'! 0$'#*&87$,! 1-.! 0#$!(*()/,&,! -1! $%$.9&*9! K-))70(*0,! &*! 0#$! (87(0&'! $*E&.-*%$*0F! 6.('Z6.$*+,! &*!H*()/0&'()!"#$%&,0./@!W]@!V[ZTXVF!

c&))-79#2/!JF@! <#$$#(*! MF!`!B&0.-E&'#! <F! =SXXS?F! I,! G"ZB<! .&9#0! 1-.! /-7|! I*g! H!C)-2()!;&$P!-1!G"ZB<!S*+!$+&0&-*@!C)-2()!;&$P@!>&00,27.9#@!>$**,/)E(*&(@!D<HF!YYZV\F!

c/,-'5&! "F! LF!`! 4$(7'#(%K!CF! 3F! =T\VY?F! H2&)&0/! 0-! ,%$))! (*+.-,0$*-*$! &,! 9$*$0&'())/Z+$0$.%&*$+! >.-'$$+&*9,! -1! 0#$! O(0&-*()! H'(+$%/! -1! <'&$*'$,! -1! 0#$! D*&0$+!<0(0$,!-1!H%$.&'(Z4&-)-9&'()!<'&$*'$,@!VT=T]?@!YV\\ZY\XSF!

c/,-'5&!"F!LF@!:-..&$,!3F!BF!`!4$(7'#(%K!CF!3F!=T\V\?F!H2&)&0/!0-!K$.'$&E$!(*+.-,0$*-*$!'(*! 2$! ('87&.$+! 2/! -,0$*,&2)/! (*-,%&'! K$-K)$F! >.-'$$+&*9,! -1! 0#$! O(0&-*()!H'(+$%/!-1!<'&$*'$,!-1!0#$!D*&0$+!<0(0$,!-1!H%$.&'(@!VU=SX?@![\[UZ[\[VF!

b-5-/(%(! BF! 6F! `! "(.),-*! LF! JF! =T\[\?F! B&'.-2&()! %$0(2-)&0$,! -1! 0./K0-K#(*! &*! 0#$!&*0$,0&*()Z0.('0! P&0#! ,K$'&()! .$1$.$*'$! 0-! ,5(0-)$F! H%$.&'(*! L-7.*()! -1! ")&*&'()!O70.&0&-*@!WS=T?@!T[WZT[VF!

q(%(.(0,5(&(! CF@! 4(2-)! LF@! H*+$.,,-*! NF! `! G7*+,0.-%! 3F! =SXXY(?F! >)(,%(! ,5(0-)$! (*+!(*+.-,0$*-*$! )$E$),! &*! $*0&.$! %()$! K&9,! (*+! .$)(0&-*,#&K! 2$0P$$*! 2-(.! 0(&*0!'-%K-7*+,@! ,$^! ,0$.-&+,! (*+! 0#/.-^&*$! (0! E(.&-7,! (9$,F! G&E$,0-'5! >.-+7'0&-*!<'&$*'$@!V[=SZW?@!\TZ\VF!

q(%(.(0,5(&(!CF@!4(2-)!LF@!H*+$.,,-*!NF!3F@!H*+$.,,-*!3F!`!G7*+,0.-%!3F!=SXX]?F!M11$'0!-1! )&E$! P$&9#0! (*+! +&$0(./! ,7KK)$%$*0! -1! .(P! K-0(0-! ,0(.'#! -*! 0#$! )$E$),! -1!,5(0-)$@!(*+.-,0$*-*$@! 0$,0-,0$.-*$!(*+!-$,0.-*$!,7)K#(0$! &*!$*0&.$!%()$!K&9,F!G&E$,0-'5!>.-+7'0&-*!<'&$*'$@!\W=W?@!SW]ZSYWF!

q(%(.(0,5(&(!CF@!4(2-)! LF@!B(+$n!HF@!<87&.$,!MF! LF!`!G7*+,0.-%!3F! =SXXY2?F!H9$Z.$)(0$+!E(.&(0&-*! -1! K)(,%(! '-*'$*0.(0&-*,! -1! ,5(0-)$@! (*+.-,0$*-*$@! 0$,0-,0$.-*$@!-$,0.(+&-)ZT[! 2$0(@! -$,0.-*$! ,7)K#(0$@! +$#/+.-$K&(*+.-,0$.-*$! ,7)K#(0$@!0.&&-+-0#/.-*&*$! (*+! ICAZT! &*! ,&^! $*0&.$! %()$! K&9,F! J$K.-+7'0&-*! &*! :-%$,0&'!H*&%(),@!W\=W?@!TUVZT[SF!

q(%(.(0,5(&(!CF!`!L(,0.$2-E(!LF!=SXXU?F!HKK)&'(0&-*!-1!G"ZB<!1-.!+$0$.%&*(0&-*!-1!&*+-)$!(*+! WZ%$0#/)&*+-)$! &*! K-.'&*$! (+&K-,$! 0&,,7$F! "#.-%(0-9.(K#&(@! UY=[ZV?@! YW]ZYW\F!

q(%(.(0,5(&(!CF!`!<87&.$,!MF! LF! =SXX\?F!4&-'#$%&'()@!*70.&0&-*()! (*+!9$*$0&'!$11$'0,!-*!2-(.!0(&*0!&*!$*0&.$!%()$!K&9,F!H*&%()@!W=TT?@!T]XVZT]STF!

q(%%$.&*&!:F@!c--+!LF!:F@!c#&00&*90-*!AF!BF@!O70$!CF!JF@!N79#$,!<F!IF@!N(QQ)$+&*$!BF!`!B(00#$P,!3F!=SXTS?F!M11$'0!-1!+&$0(./!'#&'-./!-*!2-(.!0(&*0F!B$(0!<'&$*'$@!\T=Y?@!W\UZYXTF!!

! !

Page 52: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!

!

YS!

!

Page 53: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

Chapter II

The sensitivity of Flemish citizens to androstenone:

influence of gender, age, location and smoking habits

Page 54: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!

!

!

!

!

!

F!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!

J$+.(10$+!(10$.g!!

9+D1+'&!hC!-F@!67/00$*,!AF!HF!BF@!:7'#(0$(7!GF@!:$!4.(2(*+$.!NF!AF@!H)7P$!BF@!B&))$0!<F@!;(*+$*+.&$,,'#$!AF!`!;(*#($'5$!GF!=SXTT?F!6#$!,$*,&0&E&0/!-1!A)$%&,#!'&0&Q$*,!0-!(*+.-,0$*-*$g!I*1)7$*'$!-1!9$*+$.@!(9$@!)-'(0&-*!(*+!,%-5&*9!#(2&0,F!B$(0!<'&$*'$@!VV=W?@!]YVZ]]S! !

Page 55: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!II!

!

!

Y]!

>\8(7;Q!RR!

7\;!@;?@R7RZR7f!<=!=:;-R@\!>R7Rg;?@!7<!8?TQ<@7;?<?;^!R?=:];?>;!<=!W;?T;Qa!8W;a!:<>87R<?!8?T!

@-<hR?W!\89R7@C!

!

!

!

$YJSPNIS^!

<5(0-)$!(*+!(*+.-,0$*-*$!(.$!0#$!%(&*!2-(.!0(&*0!'-%K-7*+,F!c#$.$(,!*$(.)/!

$E$./2-+/! &,! ,$*,&0&E$! 0-! ,5(0-)$@! 0#$! ,$*,&0&E&0/! 0-! (*+.-,0$*-*$! &,! 9$*$0&'())/!

+$0$.%&*$+! (*+! +&11$.,! 2$0P$$*! '-7*0.&$,F! I*! 0#&,! ,07+/! 0#$!%$0#-+-)-9/! 1-.! 0$,0&*9!

(*+.-,0$*-*$! ,$*,&0&E&0/! P(,! .$1&*$+! (*+! (KK)&$+! 0-! T]U\! '-*,7%$.,! 0#(0! P$.$!

(KK.-('#$+! (0! ,&^! ,#-KK&*9! %()),! &*! A)(*+$.,F! >(.0&'&K(*0,! P$.$! (,5$+! 0-! ,%$))! 0#$!

'-*0$*0,!-1!1-7.!2-00)$,!=0#.$$!P$.$!1&))$+!P&0#!P(0$.!(*+!-*$!P&0#!(*+.-,0$*-*$!,-)E$+!

&*!P(0$.?!(*+!0-! &+$*0&1/!(*+!+$,'.&2$! 0#$!-+-7.!-1! 0#$!,0.-*9$,0!,%$))&*9!2-00)$F!6#&,!

0$,0! P(,! K$.1-.%$+! 0P&'$F! Y]FWh! -1! 0#$! .$,K-*+$*0,! P$.$! ')(,,&1&$+! (,! ,$*,&0&E$! 0-!

(*+.-,0$*-*$! =&F$F! 0#$! K$.'$*0(9$! -1! K(.0&'&K(*0,! 0#(0! &+$*0&1&$+! 0#$! '-..$'0! 2-00)$! &*!

2-0#!0$,0,!%&*7,!(!97$,,!'-..$'0&-*?F!<$*,&0&E&0/!+&11$.$+!2$0P$$*!,$^$,!=%$*g!WVFWh!Z!

P-%$*g!]TFTh@!>vXFXXT?@!(''-.+&*9!0-!(9$!=-)+$.!K$-K)$!P$.$!)$,,!,$*,&0&E$@!>vXFXXT?@!

(*+! 2$0P$$*! 0#$! 0$,0! )-'(0&-*,! =>vXFXXT?@! 270! *-0! 2$0P$$*! ,%-5$.,! E$.,7,! *-*Z

,%-5$.,F!

Page 56: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

<MO<I6I;I6b!6R!HO:JR<6MOROM!IO!AGHO:MJ<!

!

!

YU!

BC R3&')2$5&%)3!

4-(.!0(&*0! &,!(*!7*K)$(,(*0!-+-7.!0#(0!'(*!-''7.!P#$*!1(0!-.!%$(0! 1.-%!$*0&.$!

%()$!K&9,! &,! #$(0$+F! I*!%-,0! M7.-K$(*! '-7*0.&$,!K&9,! (.$! ,7.9&'())/! '(,0.(0$+! 0-! (E-&+!

2-(.! 0(&*0! =A.$+.&5,$*! $0! ()F@! SXX\?F! 4$'(7,$! -1! -*9-&*9! ,-'&$0()! K.$,,7.$@! '(,0.(0&-*!

P&0#-70!(*($,0#$,&(!#(,!2$$*!1-.2&++$*!&*!,$E$.()!'-7*0.&$,!-E$.!0#$!)(,0!+$'(+$!=$F9F@!

0#$! O$0#$.)(*+,! (*+! O-.P(/?F! H)0$.*(0&E$! %$0#-+,! %(/! 2$! 7,$+! &*,0$(+! ,7'#! (,!

'(,0.(0&-*!P&0#!(*($,0#$,&(!-.!(*($)9$,&(@!-.! &%%7*-'(,0.(0&-*F!H*-0#$.!()0$.*(0&E$! &,!

0#$!K.-+7'0&-*!-1!$*0&.$!%()$!K&9,F!I0!&,!5*-P*!0#(0!2-(.,!#(E$!(!2$00$.!1$$+!'-*E$.,&-*!

.(0&-!(*+!)$(*$.!%$(0!0#(*!2(..-P,!=H)7Pl!$0!()F@!SXX\?F!N-P$E$.@!&*!4$)9&7%!$F9F!1-7.!

K$.'$*0! -1! 0#$! %$(0! -1! $*0&.$! 2-(.,! &,! ')(,,&1&$+! (,! ,0.-*9)/! 0(&*0$+! (*+! 0P$*0/Z1&E$!

K$.'$*0! &,! ')(,,&1&$+! (,! %-+$.(0$)/! 0(&*0$+! (0! ,)(79#0$.! =H)7Pl! $0! ()F@! SXX\?F! A-.! 0#&,!

.$(,-*@! ())! '(.'(,,$,! -1! $*0&.$! %()$! K&9,! (.$! 0.$(0$+! (,! &*1$.&-.F! 6#&,! 0.$(0%$*0! P&))!

K$.,&,0!7*0&)!(!,)(79#0$.Z)&*$!+$0$'0&-*!%$0#-+!='7..$*0)/!7*+$.!+$E$)-K%$*0?!#(,!2$$*!

&%K)$%$*0$+F!!

6#$!%(&*! '-%K-7*+,! 5*-P*! 0-! 2$! .$,K-*,&2)$! 1-.! 2-(.! 0(&*0! (.$! ,5(0-)$! (*+!

(*+.-,0$*-*$! =>(00$.,-*@! T\UVm! ;-)+@! T\[X?F! H*+.-,0$*-*$! &,! (! K#$.-%-*$@! P#&'#! &,!

,/*0#$,&Q$+! &*! 0#$!2-(.! 0$,0$,! (*+! ,72,$87$*0)/! .$)$(,$+! &*0-! 0#$!2)--+,0.$(%F!R*'$!

(*+.-,0$*-*$! &,! .$)$(,$+! &0! '(*!2$! 0.(*,K-.0$+! 0-! 0#$! ,()&E(./! 9)(*+!-.! (''7%7)(0$! &*!

(+&K-,$!0&,,7$!=4-**$(7@!T\VS?F!<5(0-)$!&,!K.-+7'$+!1.-%!0./K0-K#(*!2/!%&'.-2$,!&*!0#$!

#&*+970!(*+!&,!K(.0)/!(2,-.2$+!&*0-!0#$!2)--+F!6#$!%(n-.&0/!&,!+$9.(+$+!&*!0#$!)&E$.@!270!

7*'#(*9$+!,5(0-)$!%(/!(),-!(''7%7)(0$!&*!(+&K-,$!0&,,7$!=L$*,$*!$0!()F@!T\\]2?F!<$E$.()!

,07+&$,! #(E$! ().$(+/! ,#-P*! 0#(0! ,5(0-)$! )$E$),! '(*! 2$! .$+7'$+! 0#.-79#!%(*(9$%$*0!

=$F9F@! +&$0! '-%K-,&0&-*! (*+! $*E&.-*%$*0()! 1('0-.,! =N(*,$*! $0! ()F! T\\Ym! N(*,$*! $0! ()F@!

SXXU??@! P#&)$! 0#$! -*)/! P(/! 0-! .$+7'$! (*+.-,0$*-*$! )$E$),! 5*-P*! ,-! 1(.! &,! 0#.-79#!

9$*$0&'!%(*&K7)(0&-*F!D*1-.07*(0$)/@!,$)$'0&-*!(9(&*,0!(*+.-,0$*-*$!&,!)&5$)/!0-!.$,7)0!&*!

*$9(0&E$!$11$'0,!-*!K$.1-.%(*'$!(*+!,$^7()!%(07.(0&-*!-1!%()$!K&9,! =4-**$(7@!T\\V?F!

B-.$-E$.@! ,K$'&1&'! (*-,%&(! =&*,$*,&0&E&0/?! 0-! (*+.-,0$*-*$! #(,! 2$$*! ,#-P*! 0-! +&11$.!

2$0P$$*!9$*+$.@!(9$!(*+!'-7*0./@!(%-*9!-0#$.,@!P#$.$(,!*$(.)/!$E$./!&*+&E&+7()!0$,0$+!

,-!1(.!#(,!K.-E$+!,$*,&0&E$!0-!,5(0-)$!=c$&)$.!$0!()F@!T\\[?F!I*!-.+$.!0-!0$,0!0#$!,$*,&0&E&0/!

-1!(!K-K7)(0&-*!0-!2-(.!0(&*0@!&0!&,!0#$.$1-.$!%-.$!.$)$E(*0!0-!1-'7,!-*!(*+.-,0$*-*$F!

Page 57: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!II!

!

!

Y[!

<$*,&0&E&0/! 0-! (*+.-,0$*-*$! &,! 9$*$0&'())/! +$0$.%&*$+! =3$))$.! $0! ()F@! SXX[m!

c/,-'5&! `! 4$(7'#(%K@! T\VY?! (*+! (! K(.0! -1! 0#$! '-*,7%$.,! #(,! 2$$*! ,#-P*! 0-! 2$!

(*-,%&'! 0-! (+.-,0$*-*$F! 6#&,! ,K$'&1&'! (*-,%&(! %(/! .$,7)0! 1.-%! +$1$'0&E$! -.! %&,,&*9!

%-)$'7)(.! .$'$K0-.,F! <-%$! (*-,%&'! &*+&E&+7(),! K-,,$,,! 0#$! .$'$K0-.,! .$87&.$+! 270! (0!

,72Z0#.$,#-)+! +$*,&0/F! N-P$E$.@! (*! -,%&'! '-*+&0&-*! %(/! (.&,$! P#$*! &*+&E&+7(),! (.$!

$^K-,$+!.$97)(.)/!0-!(*+.-,0$*-*$!=c/,-'5&!`!4$(7'#(%K@!T\VYm!c/,-'5&!$0!()F@!T\V\?F!

C&)2$.0!`!c/,-'5&! =T\V[?! $,0&%(0$+! 0#$! K$.'$*0(9$! -1! (*-,%&'!P-%$*! E$.,7,!

(*-,%&'!%$*!0-!2$!T]FV!E,F!SYFTh! &*!M7.-K$! =$^')7+&*9!0#$!D3?@!S\F]!E,F!W[FSh! &*! 0#$!

D<H!(*+!T[FS! E,F! S]F]h! &*!H,&(F!B-.$! .$'$*0)/@! 0#$!K.-K-.0&-*!-1! (*-,%&'!K$-K)$!#(,!

2$$*! $,0&%(0$+! 0-! 2$! %7'#! #&9#$.F! c$&)$.! $0! ()F! =SXXX?! .$K-.0$+! +&11$.$*'$,! &*!

(*+.-,0$*-*$!&*,$*,&0&E&0/!2$0P$$*!'-7*0.&$,!-1!U]F\h!1-.!P-%$*!(*+!U\F[h!1-.!%$*!&*!

C$.%(*/@!(*+!'-..$,K-*+&*9!K$.'$*0(9$,!-1!YVFTh!0-!]\F[h!&*!<K(&*F!I*!O-.P(/!]WFUh!

-1!0#$!P-%$*!(*+![WF[h!-1!0#$!%$*!#(E$!2$$*!.$K-.0$+!(,!&*,$*,&0&E$!0-!(*+.-,0$*-*$!

=G7*+$!$0!()F@!SXX\?F!!!

"-%K(.&,-*! -1! 0#$! (2,-)70$! K$.'$*0(9$,! -1! (*+.-,0$*-*$! ,$*,&0&E$! K$-K)$! &,!

K.-2)$%(0&'@! (,! 0#$! %$0#-+-)-9/! (*+! -K$.(0&-*()! +$1&*&0&-*! 7,$+! 1-.! '(0$9-.&Q&*9! (!

K$.,-*!(,!(*-,%&'!+&11$.,!'-*,&+$.(2)/!2$0P$$*!0#$,$!,07+&$,F!A-.!$^(%K)$@!&*!0#$!,07+/!

2/!c$&)$.!$0!()F!=SXXX?!-*$!2-00)$!P&0#!K7.$!'./,0(),!P(,!-11$.$+!0-!0#$!'-*,7%$.,F!H![Z

K-&*0! ,'()$! P(,! 7,$+! (*+! K$-K)$! 0#(0! %(.5$+! (! ,'-.$! -1! W! -.! )$,,! P$.$! '-*,&+$.$+!

&*,$*,&0&E$F! G7*+$!$0! ()F! =SXX\?! .$1&*$+! 0#&,!%$0#-+-)-9/!(*+!K.-E&+$+! 0#$! '-*,7%$.,!

P&0#!0#.$$!2-00)$,@!-*$!P&0#!(*+.-,0$*-*$!+&,,-)E$+!&*!P(0$.!(*+!0P-!P&0#!K7.$!P(0$.F!

6#&,! 0$,0! P(,! +-*$! 0P&'$! (*+! K$-K)$! P#-! '-..$'0)/! &+$*0&1&$+! 0#$! 2-00)$! P&0#!

(*+.-,0$*-*$!&*!2-0#!0$,0,!(*+!&*+&'(0$+!-*!0#$!)(2$)!%(9*&07+$!,'()$!0#(0!0#$!&*0$*,&0/!

-1!0#$!,%$))!P(,!(0!)$(,0!i,0.-*9j!P$.$!'-*,&+$.$+!,$*,&0&E$F!

I*! (*! &*0$.*(0&-*()! ,07+/! P&0#! ,$E$*! M7.-K$(*! '-7*0.&$,! =D*&0$+! 3&*9+-%@!

:$*%(.5@! A.(*'$@! <P$+$*@! C$.%(*/@! <K(&*! (*+! 0#$! O$0#$.)(*+,?! 0#$! -+-7.! -1!

(*+.-,0$*-*$! #(,! 2$$*! 9$*$.())/! +$,'.&2$+! (,! 7.&*$Z)&5$@! 270!%-.$! .$1&*$+! 0$.%,! )&5$!

*(K#0()$*$k%-0#2()),! #(E$! 2$$*! 7,$+! (,! P$))! =:&n5,0$.#7&,! $0! ()F@! SXXX?F! O-.P$9&(*!

'-*,7%$.,! +$,'.&2$+! 0#$! -+-7.! -1! (*+.-,0$*-*$! P&0#! 0$.%,! ,7'#! (,! (%%-*&(! (*+!

K7*9$*0!.(0#$.!0#(*!7.&*$!=G7*+$!$0!()F@!SXX\?F!N-P$E$.@!&0!'(**-0!2$!E$.&1&$+!P#$0#$.!

Page 58: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

<MO<I6I;I6b!6R!HO:JR<6MOROM!IO!AGHO:MJ<!

!

!

YV!

0#$!-+-7.!-1! (*+.-,0$*-*$! &,! .$())/! K$.'$&E$+!+&11$.$*0)/! 2/!+&11$.$*0! *(0&-*()&0&$,@! (,!

0#$!)&,0!-1!-+-7.!+$,'.&K0-.,!+&11$.$+!2$0P$$*!2-0#!,07+&$,F!!

6#$!,$*,&0&E&0/!0-!(*+.-,0$*-*$!&,!(),-!&*1)7$*'$+!2/!(9$F!B(00#$P,!$0!()F!=SXXX?!

.$K-.0$+!1.-%!(*!&*0$.*(0&-*()!,07+/!0#(0!0#$!-)+$,0!9.-7K!-1!'-*,7%$.,!#(+!0#$!)-P$,0!

K$.'$*0(9$!-1! +&,)&5$! ,'-.$,F! 6#$! $11$'0! -1! ,%-5&*9! 0-! 0#$! ,$*,&0&E&0/! -1! (*+.-,0$*-*$!

#(,!*$E$.!2$$*!0$,0$+!2$1-.$@!+$,K&0$!,%-5&*9!2$&*9!(,,-'&(0$+!P&0#!(!+$'.$(,$+!(2&)&0/!

0-!,%$))!=I,#&%(.7!`!A7n&&@!SXX[m!3(0-0-%&'#$)(5&,!$0!()F@!SXX[m!;$**$%(**!$0!()F@!SXXV?F!

6#$! K.$,$*0! ,07+/! (&%$+! 0-! $E()7(0$! 0#$! ,$*,&0&E&0/! -1! A)$%&,#! '&0&Q$*,! 0-!

(*+.-,0$*-*$F! 6#&,! #(,! *-0! 2$$*! 0$,0$+! K.$E&-7,)/! &*! A)(*+$.,! =0#$! *-.0#$.*! K(.0! -1!

4$)9&7%?@!(*+!'(**-0!2$!+$.&E$+!1.-%!,07+&$,!&*!-0#$.!M7.-K$(*!'-7*0.&$,@!(,!,$*,&0&E&0/!

#(,! 2$$*! ,#-P*! 0-! +&11$.! 2$0P$$*! '-7*0.&$,F! I*! (++&0&-*@! &0! P(,! (),-! &*E$,0&9(0$+!

P#$0#$.! (*+.-,0$*-*$Z,$*,&0&E&0/! (%-*9! A)$%&,#! '&0&Q$*,! &,! ,&%&)(.)/! (11$'0$+! 2/! (9$!

(*+!9$*+$.!(,!#(,!2$$*!+$,'.&2$+! 1-.!-0#$.!K-K7)(0&-*,@! (*+!P#$0#$.! &0! &,! (,,-'&(0$+!

P&0#!-0#$.!E(.&(2)$,!0#(0!#(E$!*$E$.!2$$*! &*E$,0&9(0$+!2$1-.$@!,7'#!(,!,%-5&*9!#(2&0,!

(*+!0$,0!)-'(0&-*F!

FC -1&+'%1M,!132!*+&0)2,!

H*+.-,0$*-*$! ,$*,&0&E&0/! (%-*9! T]U\! '-*,7%$.,! P(,! 0$,0$+! &*! ,&^! ,#-KK&*9!

%()),! &*!+&11$.$*0! '&0&$,! =R,0$*+@!3-.0.&n5@!B$.$)2$5$@!R-,0(55$.@!H*0P$.K!(*+!N(,,$)0?!

)-'(0$+! ('.-,,! A)(*+$.,! =6(2)$! IIFT?F! I*! 1&E$! -70! -1! ,&^! )-'(0&-*,@! 0$,0&*9! -''7..$+!

-70+--.,F!

6#$!%$0#-+-)-9/! 0-! 0$,0! ,$*,&0&E&0/! P(,! 2(,$+! -*! G7*+$! $0! ()F! =SXX\?F! >$-K)$!

P$.$! .(*+-%)/! (KK.-('#$+! (*+! &*E&0$+! 0-! K(.0&'&K(0$F! 6#$/! P$.$! (,5$+! 0-! ,%$))! 0#$!

'-*0$*0,!=TX!%)?!-1!1-7.!&+$*0&'()!0$,0!2-00)$,g!0#.$$!P$.$!1&))$+!P&0#!P(0$.@!(*+!-*$!P&0#!

(*+.-,0$*-*$! +&,,-)E$+! &*! P(0$.! (0! (! '-*'$*0.(0&-*! -1! XFT[! %9k%)! =0#$! 7*+&,,-)E$+!

'./,0(),!P$.$! *-0! .$%-E$+?F! 6#$! 2-00)$,!P$.$! '-E$.$+!P&0#! ()7%&*&7%! 1-&)@!%(5&*9! &0!

&%K-,,&2)$! 0-! ,$$! 0#$&.! '-*0$*0,F! I*! -.+$.! 0-! (E-&+! '-*0(%&*(0&-*! -1! 0#$! P(0$.Z-*)/!

2-00)$,!P&0#!0#$!,%$))!-1!(*+.-,0$*-*$@!())!P(0$.Z-*)/!2-00)$,!P$.$!.$K)('$+!P&0#!*$P!

2-00)$,!(10$.!(KK.-^&%(0$)/!SX!'-*,7%$.!0$,0,F!6#$!'-*,7%$.,!P$.$!(,5$+!0-!,%$))!0#$!

'-*0$*0,!-1!$('#!2-00)$!-*'$!(*+!0-!,$)$'0!0#$!2-00)$!P&0#!0#$!,0.-*9$,0!-+-7.F!6#&,!0$,0!

Page 59: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"NH>6MJ!II!

!

!

Y\!

P(,! .$K$(0$+! P&0#! (! *$P! ,$.&$,! -1! 1-7.! 2-00)$,! &*! -.+$.! 0-! .$+7'$! 0#$! )&5$)&#--+! -1!

K.-E&+&*9!(!'-..$'0!(*,P$.!2/!'#(*'$!=1.-%!TkY!0-!TkTU?F!!

!

71.M+!RRCBC!<X+'X%+N!)/!&0+!,%6!&+,&!M)51&%)3,!%3!=M132+',^!21&+!)/!5)3,$*+'!&+,&%34a!N+1&0+'!5)32%&%)3,a!1X+'14+!14+a!3$*.+'!)/!/+*1M+,!132!*1M+,!&+,&+2a!3$*.+'!)/!,*)D+',!132!3)3A

,*)D+',!N%&0%3!&0+!,1*HM+!&+,&+2!132!3$*.+'!)/!5)3,$*+',!N0)!012!.)&0!&+,&,a!)3MO!)3+!&+,&!132!3)!&+,&,!5)''+5&C!

!! -+'+M.+D+! <,&+32! h)'&'%dD! <),&1DD+'! 83&N+'H! \1,,+M&!:(0$! WZ\ZSXX\! VZ\ZSXX\! TXZ\ZSXX\! T]Z\ZSXX\! SYZ\ZSXX\! S\Z\ZSXX\!6$%K$.(07.$!=s"?! TU! TV! T[! T]! ST! TY!c&*+!=%k,?! [! S! [! W! ! W!")-7+&*$,,! U]! SX! UX! VX! ! VX!I*+--.k-7+--.! R70+--.! R70+--.! R70+--.! R70+--.! I*+--.! R70+--.!HE$.(9$!(9$!=/$(.,?! Y]! WV! Y[! YT! W]! WY!B()$,! [Y! TVX! \Y! TUY! TTV! VU!A$%()$,! TWX! TW\! TUW! TTX! TTU! T\]!<%-5$.,! ! V\! VW! U\! ]V! UT!O-*!,%-5$.,! ! SWX! T[Y! SX]! T[U! SSX!4-0#!0$,0,!'-..$'0! TSS! TWV! TX[! TYS! TT[! TYX!R*$!0$,0!'-..$'0! YX! YW! ]U! ]W! WY! UU!O-!0$,0!'-..$'0! YS! TWV! \Y! [\! VW! []!

!

6#$!'-*,7%$.,!P$.$!(,5$+!0-!$E()7(0$! 0#$!-+-7.! &*0$*,&0/!-1! 0#$!2-00)$!P#&'#!

0#$/!K$.'$&E$+!0-!,%$))!0#$!,0.-*9$,0!-*!(!)(2$)$+!%(9*&07+$!,'()$!=GB!,'()$?!=C.$$*!$0!

()F@!T\\U?F!I*!%(5&*9!#&,k#$.!n7+9%$*0!-1!&*0$*,&0/@!0#$!'-*,7%$.!P(,!&*,0.7'0$+!0-!.(0$!

0#$!-+-7.!-1! 0#$! ,-)70&-*! .$)(0&E$! 0-! 0#$! ,0.$*90#!-1! ,$*,(0&-*,!#$k,#$!$^K$.&$*'$,! &*!

$E$./+(/!)&1$F!6#7,@!i,0.-*9$,0!&%(9&*(2)$j!.$1$.,!0-!0#$!%-,0!&*0$*,$!,$*,(0&-*!#$k,#$!

#(+!$E$.!$^K$.&$*'$+F!6#$!&*0$*,&0/!P(,!,'-.$+!(10$.!$E$./!0$,0!,$.&$,!P&0#!1-7.!2-00)$,F!

6#$!&*0$*,&0/!,'()$!P(,!'-*E$.0$+!&*0-!(!,'-.$!1.-%!X!t!TXX!=C.$$*!$0!()F@!T\\U?!(*+!0#$!

%$(*! E()7$! -1! 2-0#! 0$,0! ,$.&$,! P(,! '()'7)(0$+! (*+! 7,$+! 1-.! 17.0#$.! ,0(0&,0&',F!

<72,$87$*0)/@!0#$!E-)7*0$$.,!P$.$!(,5$+!-*'$!0-!0&'5!0#$!0$.%!=-*)/!-*$!0$.%!'-7)+!2$!

0&'5$+?! P&0#&*! 0#$! )&,0! -1! -+-7.Z+$,'.&K0-.,! =i*-! -+-7.j@! i,-(KkK$.17%$j@! i,P$$0j@!

i,K&'/j@!i,P$(0j@!i7.&*$j@!iK7*9$*0j@!i,-7.k2&00$.j!(*+!i-0#$.j?!0#$/!(,,-'&(0$+!P&0#!0#$!

,%$))! -1! 0#$! 2-00)$F! 4$0P$$*! 0#$! 0P-! 0$,0! ,$.&$,@! '-*,7%$.,! P$.$! (,5$+! 0-! 1&))! -70!

&*1-.%(0&-*!.$9(.+&*9!0#$&.!9$*+$.@!(9$!(*+!,%-5&*9!#(2&0,!=,%-5$.!E$.,7,!*-*Z,%-5$.?!

-*!0#$!.$'-.+&*9!1-.%F!!

Page 60: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

<MO<I6I;I6b!6R!HO:JR<6MOROM!IO!AGHO:MJ<!

!

!

]X!

6#$! K.$E()$*'$! -1! '-*,7%$.,! ,$*,&0&E$! 0-! (*+.-,0$*-*$!P(,! $,0&%(0$+!P&0#! (!

97$,,!'-..$'0&-*!0-!'-..$'0!1-.!K$-K)$!P#-!#(+!2-0#!0$,0Z,$.&$,!'-..$'0!2/!'#(*'$g!

! !

$!&,!0#$!*7%2$.!-1!K$.,-*,!0#(0!'-..$'0)/!&+$*0&1&$+!0#$!2-00)$!P&0#!(*+.-,0$*-*$!

&*!2-0#!0$,0,!(*+!%! &,! 0#$!0-0()!*7%2$.!-1!K$.,-*,!0$,0$+F!6#$!$11$'0,!-1!,%-5&*9@!,$^!

(*+! (9$! -*! ,$*,&0&E&0/! P$.$! $E()7(0$+! 2/! (! 9$*$.()&Q$+! )&*$(.! %-+$)! P&0#! 2&*-%&())/!

+&,0.&270$+!$..-.!0$.%F!6#$!,&^!0$,0!)-'(0&-*,!P$.$!(),-!'-%K(.$+!P&0#!$('#!-0#$.!2/!(!

9$*$.()&Q$+!)&*$(.!%-+$)!P&0#!2&*-%&())/!+&,0.&270$+!$..-.!0$.%@!270!(*!(+n7,0%$*0!P(,!

%(+$!1-.!(9$!(*+!9$*+$.F!ME$./!-+-7.!0$.%!P(,!$E()7(0$+!2/!7,&*9!0#$!A&,#$.u,!$^('0!

0$,0! 0-! +$0$'0! -+-7.Z+$,'.&K0-.,! 0#(0! P$.$! ,$)$'0$+! ,&9*&1&'(*0)/! %-.$! -10$*! 2/!

'-*,7%$.,! ,$*,&0&E$! 0-! (*+.-,0$*-*$! 0#(*! 2/! *-*Z,$*,&0&E$! '-*,7%$.,! =B-,5-P&0Q@!

T\VV?F!

EC Q+,$M&,!

I*!0-0()![TU!%()$,!(*+!V]W!1$%()$,@!(9$+!2$0P$$*![!(*+!VV!/$(.,!=%$(*!}!W\F\[m!

<:!}!T[FV?!P$.$!0$,0$+F!R1!0#-,$!T]U\!E-)7*0$$.,@!Y]FWh!=\]h!"Ig!YSFUh!Z!Y[F\h?!P$.$!

')(,,&1&$+!(,!,$*,&0&E$!0-!(*+.-,0$*-*$F!!

6#$!K$.'$*0(9$!-1!0#$!,(%K)$!K-K7)(0&-*!,$*,&0&E$!0-!(*+.-,0$*-*$!P(,!,%())$.!

=>!v!XFXXT?!1-.!%()$,!=WVFWh@!P&0#!\]h!"Ig!WYF]h!Z!YSFSh?!0#(*!1-.!1$%()$,!=]TFTh@!P&0#!

\]h! "Ig! Y[F]h! Z! ]YF[h?@! P&0#! (*! -++,! .(0&-! -1! P-%$*! '-%K(.$+! 0-! %$*! 1-.!

(*+.-,0$*-*$!,$*,&0&E&0/!$87()!0-!TFU!=\]h!"Ig!TFWS!t!TF\[?F!H*+.-,0$*-*$!,$*,&0&E&0/!(),-!

+$K$*+$+! -*! 0#$! (9$! -1! 0#$! &*+&E&+7()! 0$,0$+F! 6#$! -++,! -1! (! ,72n$'0! 2$&*9! ,$*,&0&E$!

(%-7*0$+!0-!XF\V!=\]h!"Ig!XF\[!Z!XF\V?!-1!0#$!-++,!-1!(!,72n$'0!2$&*9!-*$!/$(.!/-7*9$.@!

%$(*&*9!0#(0!,$*,&0&E&0/!,&9*&1&'(*0)/!+$'.$(,$,!P&0#!(9$!=>!v!XFXXT?F!6#$!-)+$,0!9.-7K!-1!

K$.,-*,! (),-! 9(E$! 0#$! )-P$,0! -+-7.! &*0$*,&0/! ,'-.$! =6(2)$! IIFS?F! I*0$.$,0&*9)/@!

(*+.-,0$*-*$!,$*,&0&E&0/!P(,!*-0!,&9*&1&'(*0)/!(,,-'&(0$+!P&0#!,%-5&*9!#(2&0!=>!}!XF[SX?F!

4$0P$$*! 0#$! ,&^! 0$,0! )-'(0&-*,! ,&9*&1&'(*0! +&11$.$*'$,! P$.$! 1-7*+! &*! ,$*,&0&E&0/! 0-!

(*+.-,0$*-*$!=>!v!XFXXT?!=6(2)$!IIFW?F!!

16 1ˆ15 15XN

! = "

Page 61: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!

!

!

!

!

!"#$%&''()(&*+%,"-%&./0%/1.02&34&05%&"/6,310%/3/%&3637,&8%,9%.+%6&:193,%6&3/&"&19"$%&4,3;&<=><<&3/&05%&?@A&13,0%6&#2&"-%&-,378&&

*-%&:2%",1A& B& BC:DA& E%;"$%&:DA& @"$%&:DA& *+%,"-%&

./0%/1.02&"#$"! $$"! %&! ''! %(! %$)&!$"#("! *+*! ($! *&! (,! %%)*!("#'"! (&(! *&! '%! %-! %,),!'"#+"! $',! *%! *'! ((! $')(!+"#,""! &! ''! *"! *"! $()"!./0!1234256782!9:!6;2!<9<=>76?95!6;76!?@!@25@?6?A2!69!75B39@625952!!

!

!"#$%&''(F(&G%,9%/0"-%&34&93/17;%,1&1%/1.0.+%&03&"/6,310%/3/%&"/6&3661&,"0.31&34&"/6,310%/3/%&1%/1.0.+.02&#%0H%%/&0%10&$39"0.3/1&:6.44%,%/9%1&./&"-%&"/6&-%/6%,&H%,%&"9937/0%6&43,A&:I&<(<JK8K<(>L&I&<(<>K8K<(<JL&II&<(<<>K8K<(<>M&III&<(<<<>K8K<(<<>L&IIII&8K<(<<<>A(&!5%&3661&,"0.3&,%4%,&03&05%&

3661&34&#%./-&1%/1.0.+%&03&"/6,310%/3/%&34&"&$39"0.3/&./&05%&4.,10&93$3;/&+%,171&"&$39"0.3/&./&05%&4.,10&,3H(&&

!! N3,0,.OP& @%,%$#%P%& Q"11%$0& R10%/6& R310"PP%,& */0H%,8&C!@25@?6?A2! %-)-! *-),! (')*! %&)*! (+)'! (')'!D9363?EF! ,! #! #! #! #! #!G232>H2F2! $)$,IIII! ,! #! #! #! #!J7@@2>6! ,)-$I! ")-+! ,! #! #! #!K@625B! ,)%-LIM! ")'$I! ")+! ,! #! #!K9@67FF23! ,)+*III! ")+(! ,)"+! ,)%*LIM! ,! #!N56O23<! ,)&$III! ")+-! ,),$! ,)("LIM! ,)"(! ,!

Page 62: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#!$%$&$%'(%)(*#+,)!%"#)#"($#(-.*#+",!(

(

(

(

/0(

%12( 345546789( 4:4;<=:2>?<7@A748( A2<B>( 62<2( ;>2:( >798737?C8A5D( B4<2( 43A28( ED(

C8:<4>A28482=>28>7A7F2(?48>;B2<>(A1C8(ED(848=>28>7A7F2(?48>;B2<>G(H>@7?DI(JK(L(MNMM0OP(

H>62CAI(JK(Q(MNMMROP(H;<782I(JK(Q(MNMMROP(H@;8928AI(JK(Q(MNMMROP(HE7AA2<I(JK(Q(MNMMRO(C8:(

H>4;<I( JK( Q( MNMMRON( )3( A12>2( A2<B>P( H>62CAI( C8:( H;<782I(62<2( ;>2:(B4>A( J0RN/S( C8:(

0MNTS(43(A12(?4<<2?A(C8>62<>P(<2>@2?A7F25DOU(C3A2<(A17>(?CB2(H@;8928AI(JRVNWSOP(HE7AA2<I(

JR/NTSOP(H>4;<I(JR/NXSO(C8:(H>@7?DI(JTSON(

!" #$%&'%%$()*

$8(A17>(>28>4<D(>A;:D(?48:;?A2:(78(-5C8:2<>P(Y2597;BP(/RNRS(43(A12(32BC52>(C8:(

XZNXS(43(A12(BC52>(A2>A2:(62<2(?48>7:2<2:(A4(E2(>28>7A7F2(A4(A12(E4C<(AC78A(?4B@4828A(

C8:<4>A28482N(%12>2(@2<?28AC92>(?C8(485D(>;@2<37?7C55D(E2(?4B@C<2:(67A1(4A12<(>A;:72>P(

97F28(>798737?C8A(:7332<28?2>(78(A12(B2A14:4549D(34<(A2>A789(C8:<4>A28482=>28>7A7F7AD(C8:(

34<(:2378789(>4B2482(C>(@4>7A7F2N((

%12( B2A14:4549D( ;>2:( 78( A17>( >A;:D( 6C>( EC>2:( 48( A12( B2A14:( :2F254@2:( ED(

.;8:2( 2A( C5N( J0MMTON( .;8:2( 2A( C5N( J0MMTO( 78F2>A79CA2:( 617?1( @<2>28ACA748( 34<B( 43(

C8:<4>A28482( J@;<2( ?<D>AC5>P( ?<D>AC5>( :7>>45F2:( 78( 475( 4<( 6CA2<P( 4<( >45;A748>( 67A1(

;8:7>>45F2:( ?<D>AC5>( <2B4F2:( 4<( 84AO( 9CF2( A12( B4>A( 78A28>2( 4:4;<( C8:( A12( B4>A(

829CA7F2( <2>@48>2N( %12D( ;>2:( C8:<4>A28482( ?<D>AC5>( :7>>45F2:( 78( :7>A7552:(6CA2<P( 67A1(

;8:7>>45F2:(?<D>AC5>(84A( <2B4F2:P( 78( 3475=?4F2<2:(95C>>(E4AA52>N(*([;2>A7488C7<2(67A1(C(

A<7C8952( C@@<4C?1( ?4BE782:( 67A1( C( .\( >?C52( 6C>( >;E>2[;28A5D( :2F254@2:N( $8( A12(

@<2>28A( >A;:DP( .;8:2]>(B2A14:4549D(6C>( >5791A5D(B4:7372:N( $8>A2C:( 43( A64( A2>A( >2<72>(

67A1(A64(E4AA52>(37552:(67A1(6CA2<(C5482(C8:(482(67A1(C8:<4>A28482P(62(;>2:(A64(A2>A(

>2<72>( 43( A1<22( E4AA52>( 67A1( 6CA2<( C8:( 482( 67A1( C8:<4>A28482N( %17>( B4:737?CA748(

<2:;?2:( A12( @<4ECE757AD( 43( ?4<<2?A( C8>62<>( ED( ?1C8?2( 3<4B( R^T( A4( R^R_N( .;8:2( 2A( C5N(

J0MMTO( ?48>7:2<2:( ?48>;B2<>( A4( E2( >28>7A7F2( A4( C8:<4>A28482( 6128( E4AA52>( 62<2(

@2<?27F2:(?4<<2?A5D(78(E4A1(A2>A>(C8:(6128(A12(B2C8(FC5;2(43(78A28>7AD(6C>(78:7?CA2:(C>(

`>A<489](4<(17912<N(%17>(:23787A748(<CA12<(>2@C<CA2>(A12(F2<D(>28>7A7F2(?48>;B2<>(3<4B(A12(

848=>28>7A7F2( 4<( A12( >5791A5D( >28>7A7F2( ?48>;B2<>N( a462F2<P( >4B2( 848=>28>7A7F2( C8:(

>5791A5D( >28>7A7F2( ?48>;B2<>( ?C8P( C3A2<( 2b@4>;<2( A4( C8:<4>A28482( J34<( 2bCB@52P( 3<4B(

2b@4>;<2(A4(E4C<(B2CA(?48ACB78CA2:(67A1(E4C<(AC78AOP(E2?4B2(B4<2(>28>7A7F2(JcD>4?d7(

Page 63: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea*K%",($$(

(

(

/X(

2A( C5NP( RTZTON( %12( :23787A748( ;>2:( C8:( @<4@4>2:( 78( A12( @<2>28A( >A;:D( 7>( A12<234<2( 52>>(

?48>2<FCA7F2( A1C8( A12( 482( ;>2:( ED( .;8:2( 2A( C5N( J0MMTO( >78?2( @24@52(62<2( ?48>7:2<2:(

>28>7A7F2(6128(A12D(>?4<2:(E4A1(A2>A>(?4<<2?A5D(78:2@28:28A(43(146(>A<489(A12D(f;:92:(

A12( 78A28>7AD( 43( A12( 4:4;<( A4( E2N( %12( CE757AD( A4( :7>A789;7>1( C8:<4>A28482( 3<4B(6CA2<P(

1462F2<P(6C>(A2>A2:(B4<2(?48>2<FCA7F25D(78(A12(@<2>28A(>A;:D(C>(?4B@C<2:(A4(.;8:2(2A(

C5N( J0MMTON( %64( A2>A>( 67A1( 34;<( J78>A2C:( 43( A1<22O( E4AA52>( 62<2( ;>2:( C8:( C( 9;2>>(

?4<<2?A748(6C>(;>2:(A4(?4<<2?A( 34<(@24@52(614(1C:(E4A1(A2>A=>2<72>(?4<<2?A(ED(?1C8?2N(

c128( A12( ?<7A2<7C( 34<( ?CA294<7g789( C8( 78:7F7:;C5( C>( C8:<4>A28482=>28>7A7F2( C>( ;>2:( ED(

.;8:2(CA(C5N(J0MMTO(62<2(C@@572:(A4(A12(:CAC>2A(?4552?A2:(:;<789(A12(@<2>28A(>A;:DP(A12(

@<2FC528?2(43(-52B7>1(?48>;B2<>(>28>7A7F2( A4(C8:<4>A28482(6C>(<2:;?2:(?48>7:2<CE5D(

C8:( E2?CB2( ?4B@C<CE52( A4( A1CA( 43( #4<6297C8>( J%CE52( $$NWON( !A755P( A12(#4<6297C8>( 1C:(

E228(A2>A2:(67A1(0(b(X(E4AA52>(612<2C>(A12(-52B7>1(62<2(A2>A2:(67A1(0(b(W(E4AA52>N((

(

+,-./*00"!*12,34,4$()*4(*45/*6'/%%*&(77/&4$()*8/45(2*9&(77/&4$()*8,2/*:(7*3/(3./*;5(*5,2*

-(45*4/%4<%/7$/%*&(77/&4*-=*&5,)&/>?*/83.(=/2*:(7*/%4$8,4$)6*45/*3/7&/)4,6/*(:*,)27(%4/)()/<

%/)%$4$@/*8,./%*,)2*:/8,./%*$)*A.,)2/7%*4(*45/*8/45(2*'%/2*-=*B')2/*/4*,."*9CDDE>*

*

(

c2752<( 2A( C5N( J0MMMO( <2@4<A2:( C( >28>7A7F7AD( 43( X0NXS( 78( h2<BC8D( C8:( W_NWS( 78(

!@C78P( E;A( ?4B@C<789( A17>( >A;:D( 67A1( A12( @<2>28A( >A;:D( 7>( @<4E52BCA7?( 34<( >2F2<C5(

<2C>48>N(-7<>AP(A12(?48>;B2<>(78(h2<BC8D(C8:(!@C78(62<2(97F28(C(F7C5(37552:(67A1(?<D>AC5>(

43(@;<2(C8:<4>A28482(61752(A12(?48>;B2<>(78(#4<6CD(C8:(-5C8:2<>(<2?27F2:(C(E4AA52(43(

C8:<4>A28482(:7>>45F2:(78(6CA2<(J;8:7>>45F2:(?<D>AC5>(84A(<2B4F2:ON(c2(4@A2:(34<(A12(

5CAA2<(B2A14:(C>(.;8:2(2A(C5N( J0MMTO(2>ACE57>12:(A1CA(@;<2(?<D>AC5>(1CF2(C( 52>>( 78A28>2(

4:4;<(A1C8(?<D>AC5>(>45F2:(78(6CA2<N(!2?48:P(c2752<(2A(C5N(J0MMMO(;>2:(C(V=@478A(>?C52(34<(

<2?4<:789( A12( 78A28>7AD( 43( A12( 4:4;<( C8:( C( :7332<28A( ?;A=433( J>?4<2( i( XO( @<4?2:;<2( 34<(

?CA294<7g789( 78:7F7:;C5>( C>( >28>7A7F2( A4( C8:<4>A28482N( %12( >A;:D(43( .;8:2( 2A( C5( J0MMTO(

F/45(2G*H(3'.,4$()G*I(7;,=*

9B')2/*/4*,."*CDDE>*

A.,)2/7%*

9B')2/*/4*,."*CDDE>*

A.,)2/7%*

96'/%%*&(77/&4$()>!

\C52>( 0_(S( 0T(S! XZS(-2BC52>( W_(S( W0(S* /R(S(

Page 64: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#!$%$&$%'(%)(*#+,)!%"#)#"($#(-.*#+",!(

(

(

(

/W(

C8:( A12( @<2>28A( >A;:DP( 1462F2<P( ;>2:( C( .\=>?C52N( %17<:P(c2752<( 2A( C5N( J0MMMO( :7:( 84A(

<2@2CA( A12( C>>CD( C8:( A12( ?48>;B2<>(62<2(485D( C55462:( A4( >B255( C( F7C5( 48?2P(612<2C>(

:;<789( A12( >A;:D( 43( .;8:2( 2A( C5N( J0MMTO( C8:( A12( @<2>28A( >A;:DP( ?48>;B2<>( 1C:( A4(

?4<<2?A5D( 7:28A73D( A12( C8:<4>A28482=@4>7A7F2( E4AA52( 78( A64( A2>A( >2<72>N( h7F28( A1CA( C(

?48>;B2<(7>(>28>7A7F2(A4(C8:<4>A28482(C8:(A1CA(E4A1(A2>A>(C<2(:482(:7<2?A5D(C3A2<(2C?1(

4A12<P( A12( ?48>;B2<( 7>( 57d25D( A4( >B255( 78( A12( 37<>A( A2>A( A12( E4AA52( 67A1( C8:<4>A28482(

>A<4892<(A1C8(A12(E4AA52(67A1(C8:<4>A28482(78(A12(>2?48:(A2>AN(%12<234<2(A12(78A28>7AD(

6C>(>?4<2:(C3A2<(2F2<D(A2>A(C8:(A12(B2C8(FC5;2(43(E4A1(A2>A(<2>;5A>(?C5?;5CA2:(C3A2<(A12(

78A28>7AD(>?C52(6C>(?48F2<A2:(78A4(8;BE2<>(3<4B(M(j(RMM(J.;8:2(2A(C5NP(0MMTON((

*>(B28A7482:(CE4F2P(?4B@C<7>48(E2A6228(>A;:72>(7>(@<4E52BCA7?(E2?C;>2(43(A12(

;>2( 43( :7332<28A( B2A14:454972>( C8:( 4@2<CA748C5( :23787A748>( E2A6228( A12( >A;:72>N(

%12<234<2P(A12>2(AD@2>(43(>A;:72>(>14;5:(E2(1C<B487g2:N(%12(B4>A(4Ef2?A7F2(6CD(A4(A2>A(

A12( >28>7A7F7AD( A4( C8:<4>A28482( 7>( A4( 544d( 34<( A12( >@2?737?( <2?2@A4<( 78( 2C?1( ?48>;B2<(

>78?2(>28>7A7F7AD(7>(9282A7?C55D(:2A2<B782:(Jk2552<(2A(C5NP(0MMVON(a462F2<P(62(E2572F2(A1CA(

A12(?4>A(A4(A2>A(?48>;B2<>(ED(A17>(C@@<4C?1(6755(@<4ECE5D(E2(A44(1791N(*8(C5A2<8CA7F2(7>(

:2F254@789(C(>?<228789(A2>AN(.;8:2(2A(C5N(J0MMTO(1CF2(A2>A2:(:7332<28A(>D>A2B>(A4(@<2>28A(

C8:<4>A28482P( 78?5;:789( @;<2( ?<D>AC5>P( 617?1( 1CF2( C5>4( E228( ;>2:( 78( A12( >A;:72>( 43(

c2752<(2A(C5N(J0MMMO(C8:(-;<845>(2A(C5N(J0MM0ON(-4<(A12(A1<22(<2C>48>(B28A7482:(CE4F2(62(

E2572F2(A1CA(A12(>A;:D(43(.;8:2(2A(C5N(J0MMTO(E2AA2<(A2>A>(A12(>28>7A7F7AD(A4(C8:<4>A28482(

A1C8(c2752<( 2A( C5N( J0MMMON( a462F2<P( 7A( 7>( C:F7>CE52( A4( C@@5D( >4B2( >BC55( 2b@2<7B28AC5(

?1C892>( 57d2(62(:7:( 78( A12(@<2>28A( >A;:D(2N9NP(;>2( 34;<(E4AA52>( 78>A2C:(43( A1<22(>4( A12(

7835;28?2(48(9;2>>(?4<<2?A748(7>(5462<P(;>2(9;2>>(?4<<2?A748(78>A2C:(43(A12(?<7A2<748(A1CA(

A12(B2C8(FC5;2(43(78A28>7AD(1C>(A4(E2(H>A<489I(4<(17912<P(

*5A14;91(A12(C34<2B28A7482:(<2C>48>(2b@5C78(A4(C(5C<92(2bA28A(61D(A12(CE>45;A2(

@2<?28AC92>(C<2(84A(?4B@C<CE52(E2A6228(A12(:7332<28A(>A;:72>P(A12(<25CA7F2(:7332<28?2>(

78( C8:<4>A28482( >28>7A7F7AD( C8:( 78( @C<A7?;5C<( A12( 7B@C?A( 43( 928:2<( C8:( C92( ?4837<B(

@<2F74;>(378:789>N( $8:22:P(A12(17912<(>28>7A7F7AD(43(64B28(?4B@C<2:(A4(B28(1C>(E228(

<2@4<A2:( @<2F74;>5D( Jc2752<( 2A( C5NP( RTTVU( \CAA126>( 2A( C5NP( 0MMMON( %12( 829CA7F2(

C>>4?7CA748( E2A6228( C92( C8:( >28>7A7F7AD( 4E>2<F2:( 78( A12( @<2>28A( >A;:D( C9<22>( 67A1(

\CAA126>(2A(C5N(J0MMMON((

Page 65: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea*K%",($$(

(

(

//(

$8A<79;7895DP( 62( C5>4( 34;8:( :7332<28?2>( 78( >28>7A7F7AD( A4( C8:<4>A28482( E2A6228(

A12( FC<74;>( A2>A( 54?CA748>( 67A178( -5C8:2<>N( %12( 2b7>A28?2( 43( >798737?C8A( :7332<28?2>( 78(

C8:<4>A28482(>28>7A7F7AD(E2A6228(<29748>(67A178(C(?4;8A<D(1C>P(A4(4;<(d84652:92P(82F2<(

E228( <2@4<A2:( E234<2N( +7332<28?2>( E2A6228( k4<A<7fd( C8:( A12( 4A12<( 54?CA748>( C<2(B4>A(

@<484;8?2:(J%CE52($$NXON($A(7>(;857d25D(A1CA(A12>2(:7332<28?2>(62<2(<25CA2:(A4(A12(62CA12<(

?48:7A748>(6128( A12( A2>A>( 62<2( ?48:;?A2:P( C>( A12>2( ?48:7A748>(62<2( 84A( @C<A7?;5C<5D(

:7332<28A( 78(k4<A<7fd(?4B@C<2:(A4(A12(4A12<(37F2( 54?CA748>(J%CE52( $$NRON(%2B@2<CA;<2(C8:(

?54;:782>>(62<2(CE4;A(CF2<C92P(61752(A12(678:(F254?7AD(<2?4<:2:(6C>(48(CF2<C92(17912<(

A1C8(78(B4>A(?7A72>(E;A(A17>(6C>(C5>4(A<;2(34<(\2<25E2d2P(A12(54?CA748(612<2(A12(17912>A(

>28>7A7F7AD( 34<(C8:<4>A28482(6C>(B2C>;<2:N(*8A62<@(6C>( A12(485D( 54?CA748(612<2( A12(

A2>A(1C@@282:(78:44<>P(E;A(A12(<2>;5A>(C<2(?4B@C<CE52(A4(A12(4A12<(54?CA748>(C@C<A(3<4B(

k4<A<7fdN(%12(?4B@4>7A748(43(A12(>CB@52(43(@24@52(A2>A2:(CA(A12(:7332<28A(54?CA748>(62<2(

84A(7:28A7?C5(67A1(<29C<:(A4(928:2<(C8:(C92N(%12(2332?A(43(E4A1(FC<7CE52>P(1462F2<P(62<2(

C??4;8A2:( 34<( 78( A12( >ACA7>A7?>N( K4>>7E5D( A12(:7332<28?2(E2A6228(k4<A<7fd( C8:( A12(4A12<(

54?CA748>(BCD(E2(CAA<7E;A2:( A4(4A12<(:7332<28?2>( 78( A12(?4B@4>7A748(43( A12(>CB@52>(43(

@24@52( A2>A2:N( *5A14;91( >;?1( 7834<BCA748(6C>( 84A( ?4552?A2:P(62( 1CF2( A12( 7B@<2>>748(

A1CA( 78(k4<A<7fd( C( 5C<92<(@<4@4<A748(43( A12(@24@52( A2>A2:(62<2( 34<27982<>( C>( ?4B@C<2:(

67A1(A12(4A12<( 54?CA748>N(l857d2(@<2F74;>(>A;:72>P(C8:(;8A75( A12<2( 7>(B4<2(?5C<7AD(CE4;A(

A12( ;8:2<5D789( <2C>48( 34<( A12>2( :7332<28?2>( E2A6228( 54?CA748>P( 62( <2?4BB28:( A1CA(

@24@52( E2( A2>A2:( ;8:2<( C( <C892( 43( ?48:7A748>( C8:( 54?CA748>( 78( 4<:2<( A4( 2>A7BCA2( A12(

C8:<4>A28482(>28>7A7F7AD(43(C8(28A7<2(8CA748(4<(@4@;5CA748N(

k84652:92(48(A12(>28>7A7F7AD(43(?48>;B2<>(A4(E4C<(AC78A(7>(7B@4<AC8AP(@C<A7?;5C<5D(

73(?C>A<CA748(43(BC52(@79>(64;5:(E2(EC882:(C8:(A12(@<4:;?A748(43(28A7<2(BC52(@79>(64;5:(

E2( @<4@4>2:( C>( A12( C5A2<8CA7F2( >A<CA29DN( $8( A17>( ?48A2bAP( ?C<?C>>2>( ?48AC78789( 1791(

?48?28A<CA748>( 43( C8:<4>A28482( C8:( 546( ?48?28A<CA748>( 43( >dCA452( 6755( ?C;>2( 52>>(

@<4E52B>(A1C8(?C<?C>>2>(?48AC78789(1791(?48?28A<CA748>(43(>dCA452P(>78?2(C55(?48>;B2<>(

C<2(>28>7A7F2(A4(A12(@<2>28?2(43(>dCA452P(61752(485D(C(@C<A(43(A12(?48>;B2<>(7>(>28>7A7F2(

A4(C8:<4>A28482N(a462F2<P(CA(@<2>28A(7A(C@@2C<>(A4(E2(B4<2(32C>7E52(A4(<2:;?2(>dCA452(

52F25>(CB489(28A7<2(BC52(@79>(C>(?4B@C<2:(A4(C8:<4>A28482(52F25>P(617?1(64;5:(<2:;?2(

A12(7B@C?A(43(>dCA452(48(E4C<(AC78AN($8(9282<C5P(C(E2AA2<(1C<B487gCA748(43(C8:<4>A28482j

Page 66: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#!$%$&$%'(%)(*#+,)!%"#)#"($#(-.*#+",!(

(

(

(

/_(

>28>7A7F7AD( >A;:72>( 7>( 6C<<C8A2:N( )8?2( A12( >28>7A7F7AD( 43( C( @4@;5CA748( 7>( d8468( C8:( C(

:2A2?A748(B2A14:(7>(:2F254@2:P(7A(6755(E2(2C>72<(A4(:2A2<B782(A12(7B@C?A(43(E4C<(AC78AN(

J" 1&K)(;./26/8/)4%*

(

%17>( <2>2C<?1(6C>( 3;8:2:(ED(C(K1N+(9<C8A(43( A12( $8>A7A;A2( 34<( A12(K<4B4A748(43(

$884FCA748( A1<4;91( !?728?2( C8:( %2?184549D( 78( -5C8:2<>( J$c%=&5CC8:2<28ON( c2( C<2(

9<CA23;5( A4(\N( *;:28C2<AP( ,N( .7B@28>P( .N( e4;?d;DA( C8:( kN( +2( e<2B( 34<( A127<( 2b?25528A(

A2?187?C5(C>>7>AC8?2N(

(

( *

Page 67: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea*K%",($$(

(

(

/V(

L" M/:/7/)&/%*

(

*5;6m(\NP(\7552A( !NP( #7f>( hNP( %;DAA28>( -N( *N(\NP( &2<12D:28( kNP( +2( Y<CEC8:2<( aN( -NP( +2(

Y<CEC8:2<(+N(.N(n(&C8()2?d25(\N(oN(J0MMTON(*E>28?2(43(C8(2332?A(43(:72AC<D(37E<2(

4<(?5784@A75457A2(48(E4C<(AC78A(78(28A7<2(BC52(@79>(32:(@<C?A7?C5(:72A>N(\2CA(!?728?2P(

Z0JXOP(XW_=X/0N(

Y4882C;(\N( JRTZ0ON( e4B@4;8:>( <2>@48>7E52( 34<( E4C<( AC78AP( 67A1( >@2?7C5( 2B@1C>7>( 48(

C8:<4>A28482(=(*(<2F726(.7F2>A4?d(K<4:;?A748(!?728?2P(TJ_OP(_ZV=VM/N(

+7fd>A2<1;7>(hN(YNP("8925(YNP(cC5>A<C(KNP(-;<845>(\N(-N($NP(*92<12B(aNP(-7>?12<(kNP()57F2<(\N(

*NP( e5C;:7=\C98;>>28( eNP( !7<2A( -NP( Y2C9;2( \N( KNP( a4B2<( +N( YN( n( Y4882C;( \N(

J0MMMON(*8( 78A2<8CA748C5( >A;:D(48( A12( 7B@4<AC8?2(43( C8:<4>A28482(C8:( >dCA452(

34<( E4C<( AC78AG( $$N( !28>4<D( 2FC5;CA748( ED( A<C782:( @C825>( 78( >2F28( ";<4@2C8(

?4;8A<72>N(\2CA(!?728?2P(/WJXOP(0_R=0_TN(

-<2:<7d>28(YNP(-48A(7(-;<845>(\NP(.;8:>A<4B(kNP(\79:C5(cNP(K<;872<(*NP(%;DAA28>(-N(*N(\N(n(

Y4882C;(\N( J0MMTON( K<C?A7?2( 48( ?C>A<CA748( 43( @7952A>( 78( ";<4@2N( *87BC5P( XJRROP(

RWZM=RWZVN(

h<228(YN(hNP(+C5A48(KNP(e46C<A(YNP(!1C332<(hNP(,C8d78(kN(n(a79978>(oN(JRTT_ON("FC5;CA789(A12(

p5CE252:(BC987A;:2(>?C52p(34<(B2C>;<789(>28>CA748>(43(AC>A2(C8:(>B255N(e12B7?C5(

!28>2>P(0RJXOP(X0X=XXWN(

$>17BC<;( %N( n( -;f77(\N( J0MMVON( "332?A>( 43( >B4d789( 48( 4:4;<( 7:28A737?CA748( 78( oC@C82>2(

>;Ef2?A>N(,1784549DP(W/JXOP(00W=00ZN(

o28>28(\N(%NP(e4b(,N(KN(n(o28>28(YN(YN(JRTT/ON(\7?<4E7C5=@<4:;?A748(43(>dCA452(78(A12(178:(

9;A(43(@79>(97F28(:7332<28A(:72A>(C8:(7A>(<25CA748(A4(>dCA452(:2@4>7A748(78(EC?d3CAN(

*87BC5(!?728?2P(_RP(0TX=XMWN(

kCA4A4B7?125Cd7>(\NP(YC5CA>4;<C>(+NP(%<7@>7C87>(hNP(+CF<7>(!NP(\C<4;:7C>(#NP(+C87257:2>(&N(

n( !7B4@4;74>( eN( J0MMVON( %12( 2332?A( 43( >B4d789( 48( A12( 453C?A4<D( 3;8?A748N(

,1784549DP(W/JWOP(0VX=0ZMN(

k2552<(*NP(q1;C89(aN('NP(e17(rN('NP(&4>>1C55(.N(YN(n(\CA>;8CB7(aN(J0MMVON(h282A7?(FC<7CA748(

78( C(1;BC8(4:4<C8A( <2?2@A4<( C5A2<>(4:4;<(@2<?2@A748N(#CA;<2P( WWTJVR_ROP( W_Z=

lW__N(

.;8:2( kNP( !d;A2<;:( "NP( #75>28( *N( n( "925C8:>:C5( YN( J0MMTON( *( 826( B2A14:( 34<(

:7332<28A7CA789(A12(C8:<4>A28482(>28>7A7F7AD(CB489(?48>;B2<>N(-44:(r;C57AD(C8:(

K<232<28?2P(0MJWOP(XMW=XRRN(

KCAA2<>48( ,N( .N( !N( JRT_ZON( $:28A737?CA748( 43( Xs=1D:<4bD=/s=C8:<4>A=R_=282( C>( A12(B;>d(

4:4;<(?4B@4828A(43(E4C<(>;EBCb755C<D(>C57FC<D(95C8:(C8:(7A>(<25CA748>17@(A4(A12(

>2b(4:4;<(AC78A(78(@4<d(B2CAN(o4;<8C5(43(A12(!?728?2(43(-44:(C8:(*9<7?;5A;<2P(RTP(

WXW=WXZN(

Page 68: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#!$%$&$%'(%)(*#+,)!%"#)#"($#(-.*#+",!(

(

(

(

/Z(

&2882BC88(\N(\NP(a;BB25( %N(n(Y2<92<( kN( J0MMZON( %12( C>>4?7CA748( E2A6228( >B4d789(

C8:(>B255(C8:(AC>A2(7B@C7<B28A(78(A12(9282<C5(@4@;5CA748N(o4;<8C5(43(#2;<4549DP(

0//JZOP(RR0R=RR0_N(

&45:( "N( JRTVMON( -527>1@<4:;dA748>27928>?1C3A28( E27( "E2<8( ;8:( kC>A<CA28N( $&N(

)<9C8452@A7>?12( ;8:( 9C>?1<4BCA49<C37>?12( l8A2<>;?1;8928((

cC>>2:CB@335t?1A792<( !A44332( :2>( ,t?d28>@2?d2>( F48( "E2<8N( \25:7892<(

#4<:C8:E<;?d1429>d452P(WTP(R(=(0/N(

c2752<( lNP( -7>?12<( kNP( k2BB2<( aNP( +4E<4645>d7( *N( n( e5C;>( ,N( JRTTVON( $835;28?2( 43(

C8:<4>A28482(>28>7A7F7AD(48(?48>;B2<(<2C?A748>(A4(E4C<(B2CAN($8(\N(Y4882C;P(kN(

.;8:>A<4B(n( YN(\C5B34<>( J":>NOP( Y4C<( %C78A( 78( "8A7<2(\C52( K79>( J@@N( RWV=R/RON(

cC92878928G(cC92878928(*?C:2B7?(K;E57>12<>N(

cD>4?d7( eN( oN(n( Y2C;?1CB@(hN( kN( JRTZWON( *E757AD( A4( >B255( C8:<4>A28482( 7>( 9282A7?C55D=

:2A2<B782:( K<4?22:789>( 43( A12( #CA748C5( *?C:2BD( 43( !?728?2>( 43( A12( l87A2:(

!ACA2>(43(*B2<7?C=Y745497?C5(!?728?2>P(ZRJR/OP(WZTT=WTM0N(

cD>4?d7(eN(oNP(+4<<72>(kN(\N(n(Y2C;?1CB@(hN(kN(JRTZTON(*E757AD(A4(@2<?27F2(C8:<4>A28482(

?C8( E2( C?[;7<2:( ED( 4>A28>7E5D( C84>B7?( @24@52N( K<4?22:789>( 43( A12( #CA748C5(

*?C:2BD(43(!?728?2>(43(A12(l87A2:(!ACA2>(43(*B2<7?CP(Z_J0MOP(VTV_=VTVZN(

Page 69: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

Chapter iii

A validated ultra-high performance liquid chromatography coupled to high resolution mass spectrometry analysis for the simultaneous quantification of the three known boar taint componds

Page 70: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

,2:<C3A2:(C3A2<G((

Z/K,/74*X"*F"P(&C8:28(Y;>>?12(oNP(-<C8?47>(!NP(%;DAA28>(-N(*N(\NP(+2(Y<CEC8:2<(aN(

-NP(&C8:28:<72>>?12(-N(n(&C81C2?d2(.N(J0MR0ON(*(FC57:CA2:(;5A<C=1791(@2<34<BC8?2(57[;7:(

?1<4BCA49<C@1D( ?4;@52:( A4( 1791( <2>45;A748( BC>>( >@2?A<4B2A<D( C8C5D>7>( 34<( A12(

>7B;5AC824;>( [;C8A737?CA748( 43( A12( A1<22( d8468( E4C<( AC78A( ?4B@4;8:>N( o4;<8C5( 43(

e1<4BCA49<C@1D(*P(R0XTP(WT=//( (

Page 71: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea*K%",($$$(

(

(

(

(_R(

TQ1H+OM*000*

1*N1B0#1+O#*PB+M1<Q0RQ*HOMASMF1ITO*B0UP0#*TQMSF1+SRM1HQV*TSPHBO#*+S*Q0RQ*MOWSBP+0SI*

F1WW*WHOT+MSFO+MV*1I1BVW0W*ASM*+QO*W0FPB+1IOSPW*UP1I+0A0T1+0SI*SA*+QO*+QMOO*XISYI*ZS1M*

+10I+*TSFHSPI#W*

(

(

"#$%&'(%G(

(

Y4C<(AC78A(7>(C8(433=4:4;<(A1CA(?C8(4??;<(6128(B2CA(4<(3CA(3<4B(28A7<2(BC52(@79>(

7>( 12CA2:N( \4>A( 43( A12( ?;<<28A5D( CFC75CE52( C8C5DA7?C5( B2A14:>( C<2( 84A( ?C@CE52( 43(

:2A2?A789( A12( A1<22( d8468( E4C<( AC78A( ?4B@4;8:>( J78:452P( >dCA452( C8:( C8:<4>A28482O(

>7B;5AC824;>5DP(617?1(<28:2<>(A127<(C8C5D>7>(43A28(5CE4;<=78A28>7F2(C8:(A7B2=?48>;B789(

C>( >2@C<CA2( C8C5D>2>( C<2( <2[;7<2:N( $8( A17>( >A;:D( C( FC57:CA2:( l=aK.e=a,=)<E7A<C@=\!(

C8C5D>7>(B2A14:(7>(:2>?<7E2:(34<(A12([;C8A7ACA7F2(:2A2<B78CA748(43(A12(A1<22(E4C<(AC78A(

?4B@4;8:>( 78( 3CAN( %12( >CB@52( @<2=A<2CAB28A( 78F45F2>( C( B25A789( >A2@( 3455462:( ED(

2bA<C?A748( 67A1( B2A1C845( C8:( ?52C8=;@( ?48>7>A789( 43( C( 3<22g789( >A2@( C8:( >457:( @1C>2(

2bA<C?A748( Ja.Y( ?C<A<7:92>ON( %12( C8C5DA2>( C<2( A128( ?1<4BCA49<C@17?C55D( >2@C<CA2:( C8:(

:2A2?A2:(67A1(C8("bC?A7F2%\(1791=<2>45;A748(BC>>(>@2?A<4B2A2<N(+;2(A4(A12(CE>28?2(43(

9;7:25782>( 34<( A12( C8C5D>7>( 43( E4C<( AC78A( 78( 3CAP( A12( e4BB7>>748(+2?7>748( 0MM0^_/V^"e(

J";<4@2C8(e4BB;87ADP(0MM0O(C8:($!)(RVM0/(J$!)(RVM0/P(0MM/O(9;7:25782>(62<2(;>2:(C>(

9;7:25782( 34<( FC57:CA748( 43( A12( :2F254@2:( :2A2?A748(B2A14:N( %17>( <2>;5A2:( 78( 57B7A>( 43(

:2A2?A748(C8:(57B7A>(43([;C8A737?CA748(E2A6228(0N/(C8:(V(u9(d9=R(C8:(E2A6228(/(C8:(RM(

u9(d9=R( 34<(A12(A1<22(?4B@4;8:>P(<2>@2?A7F25DP(617?1( 7>( 3C<(E2546(A12(A1<2>145:(FC5;2>(

>2A(CA(RMM(u9(.=R(34<(78:452P(0MM(u9(.=R(34<(>dCA452(C8:(RMMM(u9(.=R(34<(C8:<4>A28482(78(@79(

3CA(>CB@52>N(%12(B2A14:(4EAC782:(34<(A12(A1<22(?4B@4;8:>(C(<2@2CACE757AD(J,!+O(5462<(

A128( R0NVS( C8:( C( 67A178=5CE4<CA4<D( <2@<4:;?7E757AD( J,!+O( 5462<( A1C8( R_NTSN( %12(

<2?4F2<D(43(A12(A1<22(?4B@4;8:>(<C892:(E2A6228(TT(C8:(RR0(C8:(C8(2b?25528A(5782C<7AD(

J,0( v( MNTTO( 6C>( 34;8:N( $8( A12( 3;A;<2P( A17>( B2A14:( BCD( E2( 2bA28:2:( 67A1( 4A12<(

?4B@4;8:>(A1CA(A;<8(4;A(A4(E2(?4<<25CA2:(67A1(E4C<(AC78AN(

Page 72: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea"\$e*.(*#*.'!$!G(l=aK.e=a,=\!(

(

(

_0(

[" 0)47(2'&4$()*

%12( ?C>A<CA748( 43(BC52( C87BC5>( 78A28:2:( 34<(B2CA( @<4:;?A748( 1C>( E228(67:25D(

@<C?A7>2:(34<(?28A;<72>N(%12(BC78(<2C>48>(62<2(2C>72<(1C8:5789(43(A12(?C>A<CA2:(C87BC5>(

C8:( A12( 3C?A( A1CA( A12>2( ?C>A<CA2:( C87BC5>( :2@4>7A( B4<2( 3CAP( 617?1( 6C>( CA( A1CA( A7B2(

<2[;2>A2:(ED(?48>;B2<>N($8(<2?28A(D2C<>P(C(A<28:(1C>(E228(4E>2<F2:(A46C<:>(?48>;B2<>(

:2BC8:789( C( :72A( ?48>7>A789(43(B4<2( 52C8(B2CAN( %17>( A<28:P( ?4BE782:(67A1( A12( 5462<(

@<4:;?A748(?4>A>(43(28A7<2(BC52>P(1C>(52:(A4(?2>>CA748(43(?C>A<CA748(43(?CAA52(C8:(>122@(78(

B4>A(?4;8A<72>(J"-!*P(0MMWON(%12(?C>A<CA748(43(BC52(@79>P(1462F2<P(<2BC78>(C(?4BB48(

@<C?A7?2( 78( B4>A( ?4;8A<72>( E2?C;>2( WS( A4( 0/S( J*5;6m( 2A( C5NP( 0MMTO( 43( 28A7<2( BC52>(

@<4:;?2(B4:2<CA2(A4(1791(CB4;8A>(43(E4C<(AC78AP(C8(433=4:4;<(<252C>2:(6128(12CA789(

A12(B2CA(43(>4B2(E4C<>N(

eC>A<CA748( 43( BC52( @7952A>( 7>( 9282<C55D( @2<34<B2:( 67A14;A( C8C2>A12>7C( 4<(

C8C592>7CN( %17>( @<C?A7?2( 1C>( 52:( A4( 2A17?C5( ?48>A<C78A>( J"-!*P( 0MMWO( C8:( >2F2<C5(

C5A2<8CA7F2>( C<2( 846( E2789( 2b@54<2:( J?C>A<CA748( 67A1( C8C2>A12>7CP( 7BB;84?C>A<CA748P(

;>2( 43( C8C592>7CP( 4<( @<4:;?A748( 43( 28A7<2( BC52>( 78( ?4BE78CA748( 67A1( BC8C92B28A(

@<4?2:;<2>O( JK<;872<( n( Y4882C;P( 0MM_ON( *A( A17>( A7B2( ";<4@2C8( 5297>5CA748( :42>( 84A(

34<E7:(?C>A<CA748(67A14;A(C8C2>A12>7C(4<(C8C592>7CN(#2F2<A1252>>P(>2F2<C5(?4;8A<72>(1CF2(

27A12<(C5<2C:D(34<EC:2(A12>2(AD@2>(43(?C>A<CA748(4<(1CF2(A12(78A28A748(A4(>A4@(C55(d78:>(43(

?C>A<CA748(?4B@52A25D(67A178(>2F2<C5(D2C<>(J7N2N(#4<6CDP(A12(#2A12<5C8:>P(!67Ag2<5C8:ON(*(

";<4@2C8( +2?5C<CA748( :2>?<7E2>( ACd789( A12( 37<>A( >A2@( A4( >A4@( ?C>A<CA748( 67A14;A(

C8C2>A12>7C(4<(C8C592>7C(ED(oC8;C<D(0MR0(C8:(78(A12(54892<(A2<BP(A4(CEC8:48(?C>A<CA748(

ED( 0MRZN( *:2[;CA2( :2A2?A748( B2A14:>( C<2( 2>>28A7C5( A4( :2A2<B782( 612A12<( A12(

C5A2<8CA7F2>(A4(?C>A<CA748(C<2(>;??2>>3;5(78(:2?<2C>789(E4C<(AC78AN((

%12( BC78( ?4B@4;8:>( CAA<7E;A2:( A4( A12( E4C<( AC78A( 433=4:4;<( C<2( >dCA452( C8:(

C8:<4>A28482U(78:452(485D(?48A<7E;A2>(A4(C(52>>2<(:29<22(JKCAA2<>48P(RT_ZU(&45:P(RTVMON(

Y2?C;>2( 43( A127<( 57@4@1757?( ?1C<C?A2<7>A7?>P( A12( ?4B@4;8:>( A28:( A4( C??;B;5CA2( 78( A12(

3CAAD( C<2C>( 43( A12( C87BC5N( %12( 2bA<C?A748( C8:( ?52C8=;@( 43( A12( 3CA( BCA<7b( 7>( A12<234<2(

?48>7:2<2:(A4(E2(A12(B4>A(?<7A7?C5(C8:(?1C55289789(>A2@(34<(A127<(C8C5DA7?C5(:2A2<B78CA748(

JaC;928( 2A( C5NP( 0MR0ON( !2F2<C5( C;A14<>( 1CF2( >ACA2:( A1CA( A12( 345546789( >CB@52(

Page 73: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea*K%",($$$(

(

(

_X(

@<2@C<CA748>( 43( A17>( 3CA( BCA<7b( 52C:( A4( C( @4>7A7F2( 7835;28?2( 48( A12( >28>7A7F7AD( 43( A12(

:2A2?A748(B2A14:G(57[;7:=57[;7:(2bA<C?A748(JhC<?7C=,29;27<4(n(,7;>P(RTTZOP(>C@48737?CA748(

J+2( Y<CEC8:2<( n( &2<E2d2P( RTZ_OP( >457:( @1C>2( 2bA<C?A748( J!78?5C7<( 2A( C5NP( 0MM/O( C8:(

57[;737?CA748(43(A12(3CA(J%;4B45C(2A(C5NP(RTTZON(

( $8(<2?28A(D2C<>P(>2F2<C5(B2A14:>(1CF2(E228(:2F254@2:(A4(:2A2<B782(A12(

E4C<( AC78A( ?4B@4;8:>N( a462F2<P( 485D( C( 57B7A2:( 8;BE2<( 43( C;A14<>( :2>?<7E2( C8C5D>7>(

B2A14:>( 34<( A12( 78:457?( ?4B@4;8:>( J78:452P( >dCA452O( C8:( A12( >A2<47:( ?4B@4;8:(

JC8:<4>A28482O( >7B;5AC824;>5DN( *8:<4>A28482( 7>( 43A28( :2A2<B782:( ED( ".$!*( Je5C;>( 2A(

C5NP(RTTVO(4<(9C>(?1<4BCA49<C@1D(?4;@52:(A4(252?A<48=?C@A;<2(:2A2?A748(J+2(Y<CEC8:2<(

n( &2<E2d2P( RTZ_OP( 35CB2( 7487>CA748( :2A2?A748( J,7;>( n( hC<?7C=,29;27<4P( 0MMRO( 4<(BC>>(

>@2?A<4B2A<D( JY2<:C9;m(2A(C5NP( RTTXOP(61752( A12( 78:457?( ?4B@4;8:>( >dCA452(C8:( 78:452(

C<2(:2A2<B782:(ED(?454<7B2A<7?(B2A14:>(JYCE45(2A(C5NP(0MMWO(4<( 57[;7:(?1<4BCA49<C@1D(

?4;@52:(A4(35;4<2>?28?2(:2A2?A748( JhC<?7C=,29;27<4(n(,7;>P(RTTZON(*8C5D>7>(43(C55( A1<22(

E4C<( AC78A( ?4B@4;8:>(BCD( A12<234<2( E2( ?48>7:2<2:( A4( E2( 5CE4;<=78A28>7F2( C8:( A7B2=

?48>;B789P(C>(>2@C<CA2(C8C5D>2>(B;>A(E2(@2<34<B2:N(

( aC8>28=\w552<( JRTTWO(6C>( A12( 37<>A( A4(:2>?<7E2(C( >7B@52(B2A14:( 34<( A12(

>7B;5AC824;>(:2A2<B78CA748(43(A12(A1<22(?4B@4;8:>(67A1(aK.e(?4;@52:(A4(35;4<2>?28?2(

:2A2?A748N( %12( 4EAC782:( 57B7A>( 43( :2A2?A748( J.)+>O( 34<( A12( 78:457?( ?4B@4;8:>( C8:(

C8:<4>A28482(62<2(QX(u9(d9=R(C8:(0M(u9(d9=RP(<2>@2?A7F25DN(*8:<4>A28482(6C>(:2A2?A2:(

;>789(:2<7FCA748(67A1(:C8>D51D:<Cg782N(a462F2<P(A12(;>2(43(C(:2<7FCA748(>A2@(BCD(52C:(

A4(@4>>7E52(3C5>2=@4>7A7F2(<2>;5A>(C8:(7>(5CE4;<=78A28>7F2(J&C8:28(Y;>>?12(2A(C5NP(0MRMON($8(

C::7A748P(A12(:2A2<B78CA748(43(A12(57B7A>(43(:2A2?A748(C8:([;C8A737?CA748(C<2(:2A2<B782:(

78(>AC8:C<:(>45;A748>(78>A2C:(43(78(C(BCA<7bN(%12(@4>>7E757AD(A12<234<2(2b7>A>(A1CA(A12(.)+>(

C8:(.)r>(64;5:(E2(17912<(78(C(BCA<7bN(\4<2(<2?28A5DP(C(>7B75C<(B2A14:(6C>(:2F254@2:(

617?1( <2572>(48(aK.e(?4;@52:( A4(BC>>( >@2?A<4B2A<D( J&2<12D:28(2A(C5NP( 0MMVON( $A(1C>(C(

57B7A(43([;C8A737?CA748(34<(A12(78:457?(?4B@4;8:>(43(/M(u9(d9=R(C8:(34<(C8:<4>A28482(43(

R0/(u9(d9=RN(-4<(<4;A782(@;<@4>2>P(1462F2<P(A17>(B2A14:(6C>(84A(<4E;>A(284;91(JBC785D(

34<(C8:<4>A28482ON(%12(2bA<C?A748(@<4?2:;<2(78(@C<A7?;5C<(822:2:(7B@<4F2B28AN(-7>?12<(

2A(C5N(J-7>?12<(2A(C5NP(0MRRO(:2F254@2:(C(B2A14:(67A1(57B7A>(43([;C8A737?CA748(43(MN/(C8:(R(

u9(d9=R( 34<(>dCA452(C8:( 78:452P( <2>@2?A7F25DP(C8:(_M(u9(d9=R( 34<(C8:<4>A28482(;>789(a!=

Page 74: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea"\$e*.(*#*.'!$!G(l=aK.e=a,=\!(

(

(

_W(

!K\"=he=\!N( K<74<( A4( A12( 2bA<C?A748P( A12( 3CA( 6C>(B25A2:( ED( C(B7?<46CF2( >A2@P( C3A2<(

617?1( B2A1C845( 6C>( C::2:N( %17>( 6C>( 3455462:( ED( C( 3<22g789( C8:( 2FC@4<CA748( >A2@N(

*3A2<6C<:>(a!=!K\"(6C>(;>2:(34<(2bA<C?A748P(61752(>2@C<CA748(C8:(:2A2?A748(4??;<<2:(

ED(he=\!N(

( %12(4Ef2?A7F2(43(A17>(>A;:D(6C>(A4(:2F254@(C([;C8A7ACA7F2P(C??;<CA2P(<4E;>A(

C8:(3C>A(l=aK.e=\!=EC>2:(B2A14:(A1CA(7>(?C@CE52(43([;C8A73D789(A12(A1<22(d8468(E4C<(

AC78A( ?4B@4;8:>( >7B;5AC824;>5D( 78( 3CAN( %12( B2A14:( 6C>( FC57:CA2:( C??4<:789( A4( A12(

9;7:25782>(43(0MM0^_/V^"e(J";<4@2C8(e4BB;87ADP(0MM0O(C8:^4<($!)(RVM0/(J$!)(RVM0/P(

0MM/O(617?1(BCd2>(A12(B2A14:(>;7ACE52(34<(;>2(6128(?4B@C<789(E4C<(AC78A(C5A2<8CA7F2>N((

(

C" F,4/7$,.%*,)2*8/45(2%*

0NRN M/,6/)4%*,)2*&5/8$&,.%*

%12(<232<28?2(>AC8:C<:>(78:452(J0PX=E28g4@D<<452OP(>dCA452(JX=B2A1D578:452O(C8:(

C8:<4>A28482( J/s=C8:<4>A=R_=282=X=482O( C8:( A12( 78A2<8C5( >AC8:C<:>( 0=B2A1D578:452(

J0\$+O( C8:( C8:<4>AC:7282:7482( JRPW=C8:<4>AC:7282=XPRV=:7482P( *++O( 62<2( 4EAC782:(

3<4B( !79BC( *5:<7?1( J!AN( .4;7>P( \)P( l!*ON( -4<( 2C?1( ?4B@4;8:( C( >A4?d( >45;A748( 6C>(

@<2@C<2:(78(B2A1C845(CA(C(?48?28A<CA748(43(R(B9(B.=RN(c4<d789(>45;A748>(62<2(BC:2(34<(

2C?1(?4B@4;8:(78(B2A1C845(CA(C(<C892(43(/(89(u.=R(A4(RMM(89(u.=RN(!45;A748>(62<2(>A4<2:(

78(:C<d(95C>>(E4AA52>(CA(=0M(xeN(

,2C928A>(62<2(43(C8C5DA7?C5(9<C:2(6128(;>2:(34<(2bA<C?A748(@;<@4>2>(C8:(43(\!=

9<C:2(34<(l=aK.e=\!(C@@57?CA748>N(%12D(62<2(4EAC782:(3<4B(&c,($8A2<8CA748C5(J\2<?dP(

+C<B>AC:AP(h2<BC8DO(C8:(-7>12<(!?728A737?(J.27?12>A2<>17<2P(l!*OP(<2>@2?A7F25DN((

0N0N W,83./%*

YC<<46>(C<2(84<BC55D(>5C;91A2<2:(CA(C(B2C8(?4BB2<?7C5(>5C;91A2<(62791A(43(RRM(

d9N(-4<(A12(?48A<45(>CB@52>P(82?d(3CA(43(EC<<46>(6C>(?4552?A2:(0W1(C3A2<(>5C;91A2<N(!d78(

C8:(B;>?52(62<2(>2@C<CA2:(3<4B(A12(3CA(E234<2(@C?dC9789(C8:(A12(>CB@52>(62<2(>A4<2:(

CA(=0M(xe(;8A75(C8C5D>7>N(

Page 75: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea*K%",($$$(

(

(

_/(

0NXN O\47,&4$()*,)2*&./,)<'3*

%64(9<CBB2>(43(3CA(62<2(>57?2:(78A4(@72?2>(C8:(>@7d2:(67A1(C(B7bA;<2(43(78A2<8C5(

>AC8:C<:>(J/MM(u9(.=R(0=\$+(C8:(RMMM(u9(.=R(*++ON(%12(3CA(6C>(B25A2:(78(C(B7?<46CF2(

4F28( 34<(X(B78(CA(00M(cCAA(C8:(C55462:(A4( <2>A( 34<(C84A12<(X(B78N(%17>(6C>( <2@2CA2:(

;8A75(CA(52C>A(XMM(u.(43(57[;7:(3CA(6C>(4EAC782:N(*8(C57[;4A(43(R/M(u.(6C>(ACd28(C8:(B7b2:(

67A1(V/M(u.(43(B2A1C845(ED(F4<A2b789N(%12(2@@28:4<3>(62<2(@;A(78A4(C(14A(6CA2<(ECA1(

J_M(xeO(34<(_M(B78(A4(281C8?2(A12(57[;7:=57[;7:(2bA<C?A748N(#2bAP(A12(>CB@52>(62<2(3<4g28(

J=0MxeO( 34<( _M( B78( A4( ?5C<73D( A12( >;@2<8CAC8AN( *3A2<6C<:>( A12( 2@@28:4<3>( 62<2(

?28A<73;92:(CA(RW(MMM(<@B(34<(/(B78;A2>(C8:(/MM(u.(43(A12(2bA<C?A(6C>(:75;A2:(67A1(T/MM(

u.(6CA2<(@<74<(A4(>457:(@1C>2(2bA<C?A748N(!457:(@1C>2(2bA<C?A748(J)C>7>(a.Y(X??(J_MB9OP(

JcCA2<>OO( 6C>( @2<34<B2:( 34<( 3;<A12<( ?52C8=;@N( %12( ?C<A<7:92( 6C>( ?48:7A7482:( C8:(

2[;757E<CA2:( 67A1( 0( B.( 43( RMMS( C8:( /S( B2A1C845P( <2>@2?A7F25DN( *3A2<( 54C:789( A12(

>CB@52P(A12(?C<A<7:92(6C>(6C>12:(67A1(0(B.(43(0MS(B2A1C845(C8:(25;A2:(67A1(R(B.(43(

RMMS( B2A1C845N( )3( A12( 4EAC782:( 2bA<C?AP( /MM( u.( 6C>( :75;A2:( 67A1( /MM( u.( 43( MNM/S(

34<B7?(C?7:P(C8:(RM(u.(6C>(78f2?A2:(:7<2?A5D(48A4(A12(?45;B8N(

0NWN 0)%47'8/)4,4$()*

%12(l=aK.e(>D>A2B(?48>7>A2:(43(C(%12<B4(-7>12<(!?728A737?( J!C8( o4>mP(e*P(l!*O(

*??25C( l=aK.e( @;B@789( >D>A2B( ?4;@52:( A4( C8( *??25C( *;A4>CB@52<( C8:( +29C>>2<N(

e1<4BCA49<C@17?( >2@C<CA748(6C>(C?172F2:(;>789( <2F2<>2:(@1C>2(?1<4BCA49<C@1D(67A1(

9<C:728A( 25;A748N( !2@C<CA748( 43( A12( ?4B@4;8:>( 6C>( ?C<<72:( 4;A( 48( C( aD@2<>75( h45:(

?45;B8( JRNT( uBP( /M( BB( b( 0NR( BB( $+O( J%12<B4( -7>12<( !?728A737?ON( %12( B4E752( @1C>2(

?48>7>A2:(43(C(B7bA;<2(43(B2A1C845(C8:(MNM/S(34<B7?(C?7:P(@;B@2:(CA(C(3546(<CA2(43(MNX(

B.(B78=RN()@A7B7g2:(>2@C<CA748(43(A12(?4B@4;8:>(6C>(4EAC782:(;>789(C(5782C<(9<C:728A(

J%CE52($$$NRON(

(

(

(

(

Page 76: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea"\$e*.(*#*.'!$!G(l=aK.e=a,=\!(

(

(

__(

+,-./*000"[G*B$)/,7*67,2$/)4*:(7*45/*%/3,7,4$()*(:*45/*-(,7*4,$)4*&(83(')2%*()*,*P<QHBT*%=4/8**

+$8/* ]*D"DJ*:(78$&*,&$2* ]*F/45,)(.*

MNMM* /M* /M*MNMR* /X* WV*0N/V* /M* /M*XNMM* /* T/*_NMM* M* RMM*ZNMM* M* RMM*ZNMR* /M* /M*RMNMM* /M* /M*

(

\C>>(>@2?A<4B2A<7?(C8C5D>7>(6C>(?C<<72:(4;A(;>789(C8("bC?A7F2%\(E28?1A4@(BC>>(

>@2?A<4B2A2<( J%12<B4( -7>12<( !?728A737?O( 37AA2:(67A1( C8( CAB4>@12<7?=@<2>>;<2( ?12B7?C5(

7487>CA748( >4;<?2( J*Ke$O( 4@2<CA2:( 78( A12( @4>7A7F2( 748( B4:2N( %12( 4@A7BC5( 7487>CA748(

>4;<?2(64<d789(@C<CB2A2<>(C<2(97F28(78(%CE52($$$N0N(*(>?C8(<C892(43(B^g(RMM(j(/MM(6C>(

?14>28(C8:(A12(<2>45;A748(6C>(>2A(CA(/M(MMM(3;55(67:A1(1C53(BCb7B;B(J-ca\O(CA(0ag(J0(

>?C8>( @2<( >2?48:ON( %12( C;A4BCA7?( 9C78( ?48A<45( J*heO( AC<92A( 6C>( >2A( CA( 1791( :D8CB7?(

<C892( JX( b( RM_O( C8:( A12( BCb7B;B( 78f2?A748( A7B2( 6C>( /MM( B>N( $87A7C5( 78>A<;B28A(

?C57E<CA748(6C>(:482(ED( 783;>789(?C57E<CA748(B7bA;<2>( 34<( A12(@4>7A7F2(C8:(829CA7F2( 748(

B4:2>( J%12<B4( -7>12<( !?728A737?ON( %12( @4>7A7F2( ?C57E<CA748( B7bA;<2( 78?5;:2:( ?C332782P(

\2A=*<9=K12=*5C( C?2ACA2( >C5A( J\,-*O( C8:( l5A<CBC<dy( R_0RP( 61752( A12( 829CA7F2(

?C57E<CA748( >45;A748( ?4B@<7>2:( 43( >4:7;B( :4:2?D5( >;53CA2P( >4:7;B( AC;<4?145CA2( C8:(

l5A<CBC<dy(R_0RN( %12>2( ?4B@4;8:>(62<2(:7>>45F2:( 78(C(B7bA;<2(43( C?2A487A<752P(6CA2<(

C8:(B2A1C845P(C8:(E4A1(B7bA;<2>(62<2(783;>2:(;>789(C(e12BDb(-;>748(RMM(>D<7892(@;B@(

J%12<B4(-7>12<(!?728A737?ON(%12(4@A748(43(HC55=748(3<C9B28ACA748I(;>789(A12(a791("82<9D(

e4557>748(+7>>4?7CA748(Jae+O(?255(6C>(A;<82:(433N(%12(34<2(FC?;;BP(1791(FC?;;B(C8:(;5A<C(

1791(FC?;;B(62<2(BC78AC782:(CA(C@@<4b7BCA25D(0(BEC<P(3<4B(RM=/(A4(X(b(RM=/(C8:(E2546(

Z(bRM=RM(BEC<P(<2>@2?A7F25DN($8>A<;B28A(?48A<45(C8:(:CAC(@<4?2>>789(62<2(?C<<72:(4;A(ED(

z?C57E;<(0NR(>43A6C<2(J%12<B4(-7>12<(!?728A737?ON(

(

(

*

Page 77: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea*K%",($$$(

(

(

_V(

+,-./*000"CG*1HT0*;(7K$)6*3,7,8/4/7%*:(7*$()$^,4$()*(:*45/*-(,7*4,$)4*&(83(')2%**

!@<CD(F45AC92(Jd&O( /NM(!12CA1( 9C>( 3546( <CA2( JC<E7A<C<D( ;87A>P(

C;O(

WM(

!622@(9C>(3546(<CA2(JC;O( 0(

*;b757C<D(9C>(3546(<CA2(JC;O( RM(

eC@755C<D(A2B@2<CA;<2(JxeO( 0VM(

a2CA2<(A2B@2<CA;<2(JxeO( 0/M(

eC@755C<D(F45AC92(J&O( VM(

%;E2(528>(F45AC92(J&O( TM(

!d7BB2<(F45AC92(J&O( 0M(

(

0N/N U',.$4=*,%%'7,)&/*

K<74<(A4(A12(>CB@52(C8C5D>7>P(C(>AC8:C<:(B7bA;<2(J0(89(48(?45;B8O(43(A12(AC<92A(

?4B@4;8:>(6C>(78f2?A2:(A4(A12(4@2<CA748C5(?48:7A748>(43(A12(?1<4BCA49<C@17?(:2F7?2>N(

%4( 2F2<D( >CB@52P( C( B7bA;<2( 43( 78A2<8C5( >AC8:C<:>( J0=\$+( C8:( *++O( 6C>( C::2:( CA( C(

?48?28A<CA748(43(/MM(u9(.=R(C8:(RMMM(u9(.=RP( <2>@2?A7F25DP(@<74<( A4(2bA<C?A748N(*8C5DA2>(

62<2( 7:28A7372:(EC>2:(48( A127<( <2A28A748( A7B2( <25CA7F2( A4( A1CA(43( A12( 78A2<8C5( >AC8:C<:(

C8:( A127<( C??;<CA2( BC>>( J%CE52( $$$NXON( -4<( [;C8A737?CA748( @;<@4>2>P( 2791A=@478A=EC>2:(

BCA<7b=BCA?12:(?C57E<CA748(?;<F2>(62<2(@<2@C<2:(ED(>@7d789(3CA(>CB@52>(67A1(C(>AC8:C<:(

B7bA;<2( 43( 78:452P( >dCA452( C8:( C8:<4>A28482( 4EAC78789( >2F28( ?48?28A<CA748>( 78( A12(

<C892(43(RMM(u9(.=R(A4(0MMM(u9(.=R(JRMMP(0/MP(/MMP(V/MP(RMMMP(R/MM(C8:(0MMM(u9(.=RON(%12(

78A2<8C5(>AC8:C<:>(0=\$+(C8:(*++(62<2(C::2:(CA(C(?48?28A<CA748(43(/MM(u9(.=R(C8:(RMMM(

u9(.=RP(<2>@2?A7F25DN(

e4BB7>>748( +2?7>748( 0MM0^_/V^"e( J";<4@2C8( e4BB;87ADP( 0MM0O( C8:( A12( $!)(

RVM0/(J$!)(RVM0/P(0MM/O(62<2(;>2:(C>(9;7:25782>(A4(>D>A2BCA7?C55D(?4F2<(A12(C8C5DA7?C5(

@2<34<BC8?2>(43(A12(B2A14:N(

(

(

(

(

Page 78: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea"\$e*.(*#*.'!$!G(l=aK.e=a,=\!(

(

(

_Z(

*+,-./*000"_G*T(83(')2*%3/&$:$&*FW*3,7,8/4/7%*:(7*45/*2$::/7/)4*-(,7*4,$)4*&(83(')2%*

*1),.=4/* 0()*

8(2/*

0)4/7),.*%4,)2,72* 4M* 1&&'7,4/* F/,)*8,%%** '%/2* * 8,%%* /77(7** * * 98$)>* 98`^>* 9338>*

$8:452* {* 0=B2A1D578:452* 0NRT* RRZNM_/M

M*

RNMR*!dCA452* {* 0=B2A1D578:452* XNT0* RX0NMZMW

X*

MNW/**8:<4>A28482* {* *8:<4>AC:7282:7482* /N_Z* 0VXN00MX

0*

MNVX*

0N_N 1),.=%$%*(:*:,4*%,83./%*

#2?d(C8:(5478(3CA(>CB@52>(43(T0(E4C<>(62<2(?4552?A2:(3<4B(A12(@<4f2?A(H)8(3C<B(

?4B@C<7>48( 43( :7332<28A( C5A2<8CA7F2>( 34<( >;<97?C5( ?C>A<CA748( 67A14;A( C8C2>A12>7CI(

J*9<7?;5A;<2( C8:( -7>12<72>( K457?D( *<2CP( Y25@4<?P( -52B7>1( e28A<2( 34<( *9<7?;5A;<C5( C8:(

-7>12<72>(\C<d2A789( J&.*\OON( %12(82?d3CA( >CB@52>(62<2( C8C5D>2:(ED(ee.(#;A<7?48A<45P(

&29125P(%12(#2A12<5C8:>P(61752(A12(5478(3CA(>CB@52>(62<2(C8C5Dg2:(CA(4;<(5CE4<CA4<DN()8(

A12>2( >CB@52>P( 4;<( 8265D( :2F254@2:( C8:( FC57:CA2:( l=aK.e=)<E7A<C@=\!( B2A14:( 6C>(

C@@572:N(%12(B2A14:(;>2:(ED(ee.(?48>7>A2:(43(A12(345546789(@<4?2:;<2N(Y<7235DP(MNR/(9(43(

57[;7:( 3CA(6C>( A<C8>32<<2:( A4( ?28A<73;92( A;E2>( J0(B5O( C8:(RNV/(B5(43(2bA<C?A748( >45F28A(

B2A1C845G12bC82( JTGRO( 6C>( C::2:N( *3A2<( ;5A<C>487?( A<2CAB28A( C8:( ?28A<73;9CA748P(

C@@<4b7BCA25D(RN/(B5(43(A12(2bA<C?A(6C>(A128(@5C?2:(78A4(C8(78f2?A748(F7C5(C8:(C55462:(A4(

92A(A4(<44B(A2B@2<CA;<2N(-78C55DP(0(|5(43(A12(2bA<C?A(6C>(78f2?A2:(78A4(C(he=\!P(67A1(A12(

:2A2?A748(@2<34<B2:(78(!$\(B4:2(67A1(B^g(0/V(JAC<92AOP(0/Z(C8:(0/T(C8:(C(:6255(A7B2(

43(RMM(B>N((

(

_" *M/%'.4%*,)2*2$%&'%%$()*

XNRN #/@/.(38/)4*(:*%,83./*37/<47/,48/)4*

,2@4<A>( 3<4B( 57A2<CA;<2( 78:7?CA2( A1CA(C(?<7A7?C5( >A2@( 78( A12(C8C5D>7>(43(E4C<( AC78A(

>;E>AC8?2>(7>(A12(>CB@52(@<2@C<CA748(43(A12(C:7@4>2(A7>>;2(JaC;928(2A(C5NP(0MR0O(E2?C;>2(

A12( ?4B@4;8:>( 43( 78A2<2>A( C<2( 57@4@1757?N( !2F2<C5( 2bA<C?A748( C8:( ?52C8=;@( >A2@>( 62<2(

Page 79: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea*K%",($$$(

(

(

_T(

A12<234<2( A2>A2:N( c7A1( <2>@2?A( A4( A12( 2bA<C?A748P( >C@48737?CA748( 67A1( @4AC>>7;B(

1D:<4b7:2(C8:(2bA<C?A748(67A1(2A12<(J*5:C7(2A(C5NP(0MM_U(+2(Y<CEC8:2<(n(&2<E2d2P(RTZ_U(

,7FC>(2A(C5NP(0MMZOP(B25A789(43(A12(3CA(C8:(2bA<C?A748(67A1(B2A1C845( Je128(2A(C5NP(0MM_U(

aC8>28=\w552<P(RTTWO(C8:(485D(2bA<C?A748(67A1(B2A1C845(J&2<12D:28(2A(C5NP(0MMVO(62<2(

A2>A2:N( *A( A17>( @1C>2P( 485D( C( 3<22g789( >A2@( 6C>( 78?5;:2:( C>( ?52C8=;@N( K<257B78C<D(

2b@2<7B28A>(>1462:(A1CA(B25A789(A12(3CA(3455462:(ED(2bA<C?A748(67A1(B2A1C845(@<4F7:2:(

A12( E2>A( <2>;5A>P( E;A( C( B4<2( 2bA28>7F2( ?52C8=;@( 6C>( 82?2>>C<D( A4( 257B78CA2( BCA<7b(

78A2<32<28?2>P( 2>@2?7C55D( 34<( A12( :2A2?A748( 43( C8:<4>A28482N( *5>4( 78A2<8C5( >AC8:C<:>(

62<2(C::2:(E234<2(B25A789(A12(3CA(A4(78?5;:2(A12(FC<7CE757AD(43(A12(B7?<46CF2N(

!2F2<C5(?52C8=;@(C8:(?48?28A<CA748(>A2@>(62<2(A128(A2>A2:(C8:(?4B@C<2:G(>457:(

@1C>2( 2bA<C?A748( JX??P( _MB9OP( ;5A<C375A<CA748( J*B7?48( RM( d+C( C8:( XM( d+COP( J@C<A7C5O(

87A<4928( 2FC@4<CA748( J67A1( <2:7>>45F789O( C8:( A12( ?4BE78CA748( 43( !K"( 67A1( 87A<4928(

2FC@4<CA748N(%12(E2>A(<2>;5A>(62<2(4EAC782:(C3A2<(>457:(@1C>2(2bA<C?A748(C8:(>457:(@1C>2(

2bA<C?A748(?4BE782:(67A1(2FC@4<CA748N(%12(@2Cd(C<2C>(C8:(>798C5=A4=847>2(<CA74>(43(A12(

?4BE78CA748( B2A14:( 62<2( >798737?C8A5D( 17912<N( -4<( E4A1( B2A14:>( 5782C<7AD( 6C>(

2FC5;CA2:( C>( 6255( C8:( A12( ;>2( 43( 485D( 482( !K"( 25;A748( >A2@( 4EAC782:( C( ?4<<25CA748(

?42337?728A( 43( MNTM( 34<( C8:<4>A28482P( 612<2C>( A12( ?4BE78CA748( B2A14:( 52:( A4( C(

<29<2>>748(?42337?728A(43(MN_RN(-4<(A12(?52C8=;@(67A1(*B7?48(375A2<>P( A12(C<2C(6C>(B4<2(

A1C8(3C?A4<(Z(5462<(A1C8(C3A2<(>457:(@1C>2(2bA<C?A748N(-;<A12<(4@A7B7>CA748(43(A12(?52C8=

;@(67A1(>457:(@1C>2(2bA<C?A748(6C>(4EAC782:(ED(?C<23;5(4@A7B7>CA748(43(A12(6C>1789(C8:(

25;A789(>A2@>N(%12(E2>A(<2>;5A>(62<2(<2C?12:(67A1(C(6C>1789(>A2@(43(0MS(B2A1C845(C8:(

C8(25;A748(>A2@(43(RMMS(B2A1C845(JR(B5ON((

XN0N P<QHBT*,)2*FW*3,7,8/4/7%*

$87A7C55DP( A12( C8C5DA7?C5( B2A14:( 6C>( :2F254@2:( 48( C( aK.e( >D>A2B( J-78879C8(

!;<F2D4<P( %12<B4( -7>12<( !?728A737?O( ?4;@52:( A4( C( .%r( 5782C<( 748( A<C@( BC>>( C8C5D>2<(

J%12<B4(-7>12<(!?728A737?ON(%12(aK.e(C8:(\!(?48:7A748>(62<2(ACd28(3<4B(&2<12D:28(2A(

C5N( J0MMVON( Y2?C;>2( A17>( aK.e=\!^\!( C@@57?CA748( 6C>( >;Ef2?A( A4( >;E>AC8A7C5( BCA<7b(

78A2<32<28?2>P( A12( B2A14:( 6C>( A<C8>32<<2:( A4( C( A<7@52( [;C:<;@452( C8C5D>2<( J%!r(

&C8AC92P(%12<B4(-7>12<(!?728A737?O(?4;@52:(A4(C(l=aK.e(>D>A2BN(%17>( A<C8>7A748(:7:(84A(

Page 80: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea"\$e*.(*#*.'!$!G(l=aK.e=a,=\!(

(

(

VM(

:2?<2C>2( A12( @<4E52BCA7?(BCA<7b( 2332?A>P( A1;>(62( >252?A2:( C8( )<E7A<C@(BC>>( C8C5D>2<(

J"bC?A7F2%\P(%12<B4(-7>12<(!?728A737?O(?4;@52:(A4(C8(l=aK.e(>D>A2BP(617?1(:7:(>45F2(A12(

@<4E52B(43(BCA<7b(2332?A>N(l=aK.e(4332<>(A12(C:FC8AC92(43(C(>798737?C8A5D(>14<A2<(C8C5D>7>(

A7B2( JRM( B78O( A1C8( 4A12<( B2A14:>( A1CA( >7B;5AC824;>5D( :2A2?A( A12( A1<22( E4C<( AC78A(

?4B@4;8:>P(2N9N(&2<12D:28(2A(C5N(J0MMVO(JXM(B78ON((

-4<( ?1<4BCA49<C@17?( >2@C<CA748P(:7332<28A( ?45;B8>(62<2( A2>A2:P( 7N2N(#;?524:;<(

!@178b( ,K( ?45;B8( JRNZ( uBP( RMM( BB( b( 0NR( BB( $+P( \C?12<2D=#C925OP( aD@2<>75( h45:(

?45;B8(JRNT(uBP(/M(BB(b(0NR(BB($+P(%12<B4(-7>12<(!?728A737?O(C8:(JRNT(uBP(RMM(BB(b(

0NR(BB($+P(%12<B4(-7>12<(!?728A737?O(C8:(#;?524:;<(eRZ($>7>(?45;B8(JRNZ(uBP(/M(BB(b(0(

BB($+P(\C212<2D=#C925ON(%12(?147?2(43(?45;B8(6C>(BC785D(:2A2<B782:(ED(A12(EC>25782(

>2@C<CA748(C8:( A12( <2A28A748( A7B2(43( A12( 37<>A(C8:( 5C>A(25;A789(C8C5DA2>N(h44:(EC>25782(

>2@C<CA748( E2A6228( >dCA452( C8:( 0=B2A1D578:452( 6C>( C?172F2:( 67A1( A12( aD@2<>75( h45:(

?45;B8( JRNT(uBP(/M(BB(b(0NR(BB( $+P(%12<B4(-7>12<(!?728A737?ON(*::7A748C5( >2@C<CA748(

C8:( 4@A7BC5( <2A28A748( A7B2>( 62<2( 4EAC782:( ED( ?C<23;5( >252?A748( 43( A12( 9<C:728A(

@<49<CBB2N(

Y234<2( :2A2<B78789( A12( 4@A7BC5( \!( ?48:7A748>P( A12( ?4B@4;8:>( 62<2( 783;>2:(

78A4( A12( CAB4>@12<7?=@<2>>;<2( ?12B7?C5( 7487>CA748( >4;<?2( J*Ke$O( C8:( A12( 4E>2<F2:(

BC>>2>( 62<2( ?4B@C<2:( 67A1( A12( A124<2A7?C5( BC>>2>N( "F2<D( ?4B@4;8:( 1C>( C( ;87[;2(

A124<2A7?C5(BC>>( :;2( A4( 7A>( >@2?737?( 252B28AC5( ?4B@4>7A748N( %12( A124<2A7?C5(BC>>(6C>(

?C5?;5CA2:(;>789(z?C57E2<(0NR(>43A6C<2(J%12<B4(-7>12<(!?728A737?ON(%12(BC>>(:2F7CA748(6C>(

2b@<2>>2:(78(@C<A>(@2<(B755748(J@@BO(C8:(:23782:(C>G(RM_(}(~JB2C>;<2:(BC>>(j(A124<2A7?C5(

BC>>O(^(A124<2A7?C5(BC>>�(J%CE52($$$NXON(%12(4EAC782:(BC>>(:2F7CA748>(62<2(E2546(/(@@BP(

78:7?CA789(C(1791(BC>>(C??;<C?DP(617?1(C55462:(7:28A737?CA748(43(A12(?4B@4;8:>N(

*Ke$( 6C>( ;>2:( E2?C;>2( 7A( 7>( 9282<C55D( E2AA2<( 34<( >BC55( 848=@45C<( C8:(B2:7;B(

@45C<( B452?;52>( 67A1( C( B452?;5C<( 62791A( J\cO( <C892( 3<4B( RMM( A4( RMMMN( !;?1(

?4B@4;8:>( 78?5;:2( 78:452( J\cG(RRVOP( >dCA452( J\cG(RXRO( JqCBC<CA>dC7C(n( oC>A<2E4FCP(

0MM_O(C8:(C8:<4>A28482(J\cG(0V0ON(*Ke$(C5>4(@<4F7:2>(17912<(:2A2?A748(>28>7A7F7A72>(34<(

A12(BCf4<7AD(43(>A2<47:C5(?4B@4;8:>P(2N9N(C8:<4>A28482(C>(?4B@C<2:(A4("!$(J&C81C2?d2(

2A(C5NP( 0MRRON(l@48(C8C5D>7>(43(E4C<( AC78A( ?4B@4;8:>P(*Ke$(1C>(E228(B4>A5D(;>2:N( -4<(

Page 81: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea*K%",($$$(

(

(

VR(

2bCB@52( &2<12D:28( 2A( C5N( J0MMVO( <2@4<A2:( A4( 4EAC78( 2332?A7F2( <2>;5A>( 485D( ;@48( *Ke$(

7487>CA748N(

%12(\!( ?48:7A748>( J%CE52( $$$N0O( 62<2( 4@A7B7>2:( EC>2:( 48( A12( @2Cd( 78A28>7A72>P(

@2Cd( C<2C>( C8:( >798C5=A4=847>2( <CA74>( 43( A12( 78:7F7:;C5( C8C5DA2>N( Y2?C;>2( A12( :7332<28A(

E4C<(AC78A(?4B@4;8:>(E25489(A4(A64(?5C>>2>P(8CB25D( 78:457?(C8:(>A2<47:C5(?4B@4;8:>P(

F2<D(43A28(:7332<28A(FC5;2>(62<2(4EAC782:(34<(E4A1(?5C>>2>N($8(9282<C5P(A14>2(?48:7A748>(

62<2(>252?A2:(617?1(<2>;5A2:( 78(A12(B4>A(4@A7BC5(:2A2?A748(43(C8:<4>A28482P(E2?C;>2(

@<2F74;>( :CAC( 1C:( >1468( A1CA( A17>( ?4B@4;8:( 6C>( >;Ef2?A2:( B4>A( A4( BCA<7b(

78A2<32<28?2>N( %12( B4>A( 4@A7BC5( *he( FC5;2( 6C>( :2A2<B782:( ED( C8C5D>789( >@7d2:( 3CA(

>CB@52>(EC>2:(48(C<2CP(@2Cd(>1C@2(C8:(>798C5=A4=847>2(<CA74N(%12(E2>A(*he(AC<92A(6C>(C(

1791(:D8CB7?(>?C8(<C892(JXbRM_ON(%12(B2C8(BC>>(<2>45;A748(6C>(C5>4(FC<72:(ED(C8C5D>789(

>@7d2:(3CA(>CB@52>(CA(/M(MMM(C8:(RMM(MMM(-ca\N(%12(E2>A(<2>;5A>(62<2(4EAC782:(67A1(C(

BC>>(<2>45;A748(43(/M(MMM(CA(0(ag(J0(>?C8>(@2<(>2?48:O(6128(544d789(A4(@2Cd(>1C@2(C8:(

@2Cd(C<2CP(CB489(4A12<>N((

XNXN F/45(2*@,.$2,4$()*

+;2(A4(A12(CE>28?2(43(9;7:25782>(34<(A12(C8C5D>7>(43(E4C<(AC78A(?4B@4;8:>(78(3CAP(

A12( e4BB7>>748( +7<2?A7F2( 0MM0^_/V^"e( J";<4@2C8( e4BB;87ADP( 0MM0O( C8:( $!)( RVM0/(

J$!)(RVM0/P(0MM/O(62<2(;>2:(C>(C(9;7:25782(34<(A12(FC57:CA748(43(A12(:2F254@2:(:2A2?A748(

B2A14:( 34<( 78:452P( >dCA452( C8:( C8:<4>A28482N( $8( 57A2<CA;<2P( A1<2>145:( FC5;2>( 34<( E4C<(

AC78A(?4B@4;8:>(78(@79(3CA(>CB@52>(C<2(>2A(CA(RMM(u9(.=R(34<(78:452P(0MM(u9(.=R(34<(>dCA452(

C8:(RMMM(u9(.=R( 34<(C8:<4>A28482( J*5;6m(2A(C5NP(0MMTON(*@@<4@<7CA2( 78A2<8C5( >AC8:C<:>(

62<2(>252?A2:P(?C@CE52(43(C8A7?7@CA789(35;?A;CA748>(78(>798C5(78A28>7AD(;@48(2bA<C?A748(43(

E4C<(AC78A(?4B@4;8:>(3<4B(3CA(>CB@52>N(&2<12D:28(2A(C5N(J0MMVO(;>2:(0=B2A1D578:452(C>(

78A2<8C5(>AC8:C<:(C8:(A17>(?4B@4;8:(6C>(34;8:(>CA7>3C?A4<D(78(A17>(>A;:D(34<(A12(78:457?(

?4B@4;8:>(C>(6255N(*8:<4>AC:7282:7482(6C>(C::2:(C>(C8(C::7A748C5( 78A2<8C5( >AC8:C<:(

34<(A12(>A2<47:(?4B@4;8:(C8:<4>A28482N(

Page 82: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea"\$e*.(*#*.'!$!G(l=aK.e=a,=\!(

(

(

V0(

XNXNRN W3/&$:$&$4=*

%12( >@2?737?7AD( 43( A12(B2A14:( ?4;5:( E2( :2B48>A<CA2:( ED( C8C5D>7>( 43( E5C8d( 3CA(

>CB@52>( C8:( >CB@52>( 34<A7372:( 67A1( 2C?1( C8C5DA2( >2@C<CA25D( CA( RMM( u9( .=RN( !78?2( A<;2(

E5C8d( 3CA( >CB@52>( C<2( 84A( CFC75CE52( JaC8>28=\w552<P( RTTWOP( 3CA( 3<4B( EC<<46>P( 617?1(

?48AC78>(F2<D(546(EC?d9<4;8:(?48?28A<CA748>(43(A12(C8C5DA2>(43(78A2<2>AP(6C>(>252?A2:(A4(

FC57:CA2(A12(B2A14:N(-4<(2C?1(C8C5DA2(>@7d2:P(A12(?1<4BCA49<CB>(>1462:(C(>798737?C8A(

78?<2C>2(78(@2Cd(C<2C(78A28>7AD(CA(A12(>@2?737?(<2A28A748(A7B2(43(A12(?4B@4;8:>P(ACd789(C(

>798C5=A4=847>2(<CA74(43(CA(52C>A(X(78A4(C??4;8AN(#4(4A12<(BCA<7b(>;E>AC8?2>(78A2<32<2:(CA(

A17>(<2A28A748(A7B2(J-79($$$NRON(*>(C(<2>;5AP(A12(:2F254@2:(B2A14:(6C>(34;8:(A4(E2(>@2?737?(

34<(78:452P(>dCA452(C8:(C8:<4>A28482(78(A12(@<2>28?2(43(BCA<7b(?4B@4;8:>N(

(

XNXN0N W/./&4$@$4=*

*8C5DA2>(62<2(7:28A7372:(48(A12(EC>7>(43(A127<(<25CA7F2(<2A28A748(A7B2P(617?1(7>(A12(

<CA74(43( A12(<2A28A748(A7B2(43( A12(C8C5DA2( A4( A1CA(43( A12( 78A2<8C5(>AC8:C<:N( $8(C::7A748P(

A12(C??;<CA2(BC>>(43(A12(748>(6C>(ACd28(78A4(C??4;8A(6128(A12(?1<4BCA49<C@17?(@2Cd(

43(78A2<2>A(1C:(C(>798C5=A4=847>2(<CA74(43(CA(52C>A(XN(*(BCb7B;B(BC>>(:2F7CA748(43(X(@@B(

6C>(C55462:(67A178(A17>(>A;:DN(

(

XNXNXN B$)/,7$4=*

%12( 5782C<7AD(43( A12(:2F254@2:(B2A14:(6C>(2FC5;CA2:(ED(@<2@C<789(2791A=@478A(

?C57E<CA748( ?;<F2>( 78( BCA<7b( 34<( A12( :7332<28A( ?4B@4;8:>N( %12( E5C8d( >CB@52>( 62<2(

34<A7372:(67A1(?48?28A<CA748>(<C89789(3<4B(RMM(A4(0MMM(u9(.=RN(.782C<(<29<2>>748(C8C5D>2>(

62<2( ?C<<72:( 4;A( ED( @54AA789( A12( @2Cd( C<2C( <CA74>( 43( A12( C8C5DA2( C9C78>A( A12( 78A2<8C5(

>AC8:C<:(F2<>;>(A12(C8C5DA2(?48?28A<CA748N(e4<<25CA748(?42337?728A>(J,0O(4EAC782:(34<(A12(

?4B@4;8:>(62<2(vMNTTN(

(

Page 83: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea*K%",($$$(

(

(

VX(

(

A$6*000"[G*T57(8,4(67,8*(:*,*-.,)K*:,4*%,83./*91>*,)2*,*%,83./*:(74$:$/2*;$45*[DD*a6*K6<b*$)2(./?*%K,4(./*,)2*,)27(%4/)()/*9Z>*,),.=%/2*()*45/*P<QHBT<O\,&4$@/c"**

9M+G*7/4/)4$()*4$8/d*11G*,7/,d*WIG*%$6),.<4(<)($%/*7,4$(>*

Page 84: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea"\$e*.(*#*.'!$!G(l=aK.e=a,=\!(

(

(

VW(

*

XNXNWN 1&&'7,&=*

*>(84( ?2<A7372:( <232<28?2(BCA2<7C5(6C>(CFC75CE52P( A12( <2?4F2<D(6C>(C>>2>>2:(ED(

>@7d789( 3CA( 43( EC<<46>P( ?48AC78789( 546( EC?d9<4;8:( ?48?28A<CA748>( 43( A12( C8C5DA2>( 43(

78A2<2>AN(!CB@52>(43(3CA(62<2(>@7d2:(CA(C(?48?28A<CA748(43(0MMP(/MM(C8:(RMMM(u9(.=R(34<(

C55( ?4B@4;8:>( 78( >7b( <2@57?CA2>N( %12( <2?4F2<72>( 4EAC782:( 67A1( A17>( C8C5DA7?C5( B2A14:(

62<2(>CA7>3C?A4<D(J%CE52($$$NWON(%4(A12(E2>A(43(4;<(d84652:92P(57AA52(JaC8>28=\w552<P(RTTWU(

&2<12D:28( 2A( C5NP( 0MMVO( 1C>( D2A( E228( <2@4<A2:( 78( 57A2<CA;<2( CE4;A( <2?4F2<72>( 43( E4C<(

AC78A(?4B@4;8:>(78(3CAN(

(

+,-./*000"!G*F/45(2*7/&(@/7=*,)2*37/&$%$()*(:*45/*2/@/.(3/2*8/45(2*:(7*45/*457//*-(,7*4,$)4*&(83(')2%?*$)*:,4"*

*

1),.=4/*

I(8$),.*

&()&/)47,4$()*

9e6*K6<[>*

F/,)*

7/&(@/7=*

H7/&$%$()*

M/3/,4,-$.$4=*Y$45$)*.,-(7,4(7=*

7/37(2'&$-$.$4=*

( ( \2C8Ä(!+( \2C8(Ä(!+( ,!+(JSO( ,!+(JSO(

( ( J8L(RZO( J8L/WO( J8L/WO( J8LV0O(

$8:452(

0MM( RM/ÄRR( 0RRÄ0X( RRN0( R_NW(

/MM( RMTÄRX( /W_Ä_/( RRNZ( R_NM(

RMMM( RR0ÄRX( RR0MÄRXX( RRNT( RXN/(

!dCA452(

0MM( RMZÄRX( 0R_Ä0V( R0N/( R_N0(

/MM( RM0ÄRR( /RXÄ/_( RMNT( R0NW(

RMMM( RM/ÄRM( RM/WÄRMZ( RMN0( RRNV(

*8:<4>A28482(

0MM( RRRÄRW( 000Ä0Z( R0N_( R_NZ(

/MM( RMMÄT( /MXÄW/( TNM( R0NW(

RMMM( TTÄV( TZ/ÄV_( VNV( R0NT(

(

Page 85: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea*K%",($$$(

(

(

V/(

XNXN/N H7/&$%$()*

%4( 2FC5;CA2( A12( @<2?7>748( 43( A12( B2A14:P( <2@2CACE757AD( C8:( 67A178=5CE4<CA4<D(

<2@<4:;?7E757AD( 62<2( :2A2<B782:N( Y4A1( FC57:CA748( @C<CB2A2<>( 62<2( 2FC5;CA2:( ED(

?C5?;5CA789( A12( <25CA7F2( >AC8:C<:( :2F7CA748>( JS,!+ON( -4<( 2FC5;CA789( A12( <2@2CACE757ADP(

A1<22(>2<72>(43(>7b( <2@57?CA2>(43(>CB@52>(62<2(C8C5D>2:P( A17>(CA(C(?48?28A<CA748(43(0MMP(

/MM(C8:(RMMM(u9(.=RN(%12>2(C8C5D>2>(62<2(?C<<72:(4;A(48(:7332<28A(4??C>748>(ED(A12(>CB2(

4@2<CA4<( ;8:2<( <2@2CACE52( ?48:7A748>N( *>( @<2>28A2:( 78( %CE52( $$$NWP( A12( ?C5?;5CA2:( ,!+(

FC5;2>(62<2(E2546(R/SP( 78:7?CA789(C(944:(<2@2CACE757AD(C??4<:789(A4(";<4@2C8(e<7A2<7C(

0MM0^_/V(J";<4@2C8(e4BB;87ADP(0MM0ON(

( %12(67A178(5CE4<CA4<D(<2@<4:;?7E757AD(6C>(2FC5;CA2:(67A1(34;<(>2<72>(43(>7b(

<2@57?CA2>( 43( >CB@52>( C8C5D>2:( CA( C( ?48?28A<CA748( 43( 0MMP( /MM( C8:( RMMM(u9( .=RN( %12>2(

>2<72>(62<2(C8C5D>2:(48(:7332<28A(:CD>(ED(:7332<28A(4@2<CA4<>N(*>(@<2>28A2:(78(%CE52($$$NWP(

A12( ?C5?;5CA2:( ,!+( FC5;2>( 62<2( E2546( 0MSP( 78:7?CA789( 944:( @<2?7>748( 43( A12(B2A14:(

C??4<:789(A4(";<4@2C8(e<7A2<7C(0MM0^_/V(J";<4@2C8(e4BB;87ADP(0MM0ON(

XNXN_N B$8$4*(:*2/4/&4$()*,)2*.$8$4*(:*f',)4$:$&,4$()*

.7B7A>(43(:2A2?A748(C8:([;C8A737?CA748(62<2(:2A2<B782:(EC>2:(48(A12(4;A?4B2(43(

>2F28=@478A(?C57E<CA748(?;<F2>(78(BCA<7b(78(C(<C892(43(R=RMM(u9(.=RN(%12(57B7A>(43(:2A2?A748(

C8:([;C8A737?CA748(C<2(2>A7BCA2:(ED(?C5?;5CA748(43(A12(>798C5(A4(847>2(<CA74N(%12(>798C5(A4(

847>2( <CA74( 1C>( A4( E2( CA( 52C>A( X( 34<( A12( 57B7A( 43( :2A2?A748( C8:( RM( 34<( A12( 57B7A( 43(

[;C8A737?CA748N( %CE52( $$$N/( >;BBC<7g2>( A12( ?C5?;5CA2:( 57B7A>( 43( :2A2?A748( C8:(

[;C8A737?CA748(34<(A12(:7332<28A(?4B@4;8:>(J-79($$$N0ON(

(

+,-./*000"JG*B$8$4%*(:*2/4/&4$()*9BS#>*9W`Ig_>*,)2*.$8$4%*(:*f',)4$:$&,4$()*9BSU>*9W`Ig[D>*:(7*45/*457//*-(,7*4,$)4*&(83(')2%?*$)*:,4"*

*

1),.=4/*BS#*

9e6*K6<[>*

BSU*

9e6*K6<[>*

$8:452( 0N/( /(

!dCA452( 0N/( /(

*8:<4>A28482( V( RM(

Page 86: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea"\$e*.(*#*.'!$!G(l=aK.e=a,=\!(

(

(

V_(

XNXNVN W4,-$.$4=*(:*45/*&(83(')2%*

%12( >ACE757AD( 43( >AC8:C<:( >A4?d( >45;A748>( 6C>( 2FC5;CA2:( ED( &2<12D:28( 2A( C5(

J&2<12D:28(2A(C5NP(0MMVON(,!+>(43(<2@2A7A7F2(78f2?A748>(4F2<(RM(622d>(62<2(9282<C55D(A12(

5462>A(6128(>A4<C92(4??;<<2:(CA(=0MxeN(

%12(>ACE757AD(43(A12(A1<22(E4C<(AC78A(?4B@4;8:>(78(BCA<7b(6C>(2FC5;CA2:(CA(=0Mxe(

C8:( =ZMxeN( !;??2>>7F2( 78f2?A748>( J8LR0O( 4F2<( /( 622d>( <2F2C52:( 84( :2?<2C>2( 78(

?48?28A<CA748(43(A12(?4B@4;8:>(E2A6228(A12(:7332<28A(>A4<C92(A2B@2<CA;<2>N((

(

(

A$6"*000"CG*T57(8,4(67,8*(:*,*-.,)K*:,4*%,83./*91>*,)2*,*%,83./*%3$K/2*,4*45/*.$8$4*(:*f',)4$:$&,4$()*9$)2(./*,)2*%K,4(./G*J*e6*K6<[d*,)27(%4/)()/G*[D*e6*K6<[*9Z>>*,),.=%/2*()*45/**

P<QHBT<O\,&4$@/c"**9M+G*7/4/)4$()*4$8/d*11G*,7/,d*WIG*%$6),.<4(<)($%/*7,4$(>*

Page 87: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea*K%",($$$(

(

(

VV(

XNXNZN 1),.=%$%*(:*:,4*%,83./%*

-4<( A12( ?4B@C<7>48(43( A12( >CB@52>(E2A6228( A12( A64( 5CE4<CA4<72>(43( 78A2<2>A( C(

!@2C<BC8]>(<C8d(?4<<25CA748(6C>(;>2:N(%17>(7>(C(848=@C<CB2A<7?(>ACA7>A7?(?4<<25CA748(A1CA(

B2C>;<2>( A12( >A<289A1(43( A12( C>>4?7CA748(E2A6228( A64(:CAC( >2A>N( -4<( A12( ?4B@4;8:>(

78:452P( >dCA452( C8:(C8:<4>A28482P( >798737?C8A( ?4<<25CA748>(43( MNWZP( MNV/( C8:(MNT0(62<2(

34;8:P(<2>@2?A7F25D(J-79($$$NXON(-4<(0R(>CB@52>P(A12(?48?28A<CA748>(43(>dCA452(62<2(E2546(

A12( 57B7A( 43( :2A2?A748( 34<( E4A1( C8C5D>7>U( A12>2( >CB@52>( 62<2( 84A( 78?5;:2:( 78( A12(

?4<<25CA748N(c128(A12(>CB@52>(62<2(:7F7:2:(78A4(A64(9<4;@>(67A1(C(?;A=433(52F25(43(RMM(

@@E( 34<( 78:452( C8:( /MM( @@E( 34<( C8:<4>A28482P( 5462<( ?4<<25CA748>(62<2( 34;8:( 34<( A12(

FC5;2>(E2546(A12(?;A=433(52F25(JMNXR(C8:(MNVVP(<2>@2?A7F25DO(C8:(17912<(?4<<25CA748>(JMNTV(

C8:(MNZTP(<2>@2?A7F25DO(62<2(34;8:(CE4F2(A12(?;A=433( 52F25N(-4<(>dCA452P(485D(482(FC5;2(

CE4F2(0MM(@@E(6C>(34;8:N(J-79($$$NXO(

%12( <CA12<( 546( ?4<<25CA748>( 34<( 78:452( C8:( >dCA452( BCD( E2( 2b@5C782:( ED( A12(

>CB@52>( 1CF789( E228( ACd28( 3<4B( :7332<28A( @C<A>( 43( A12( ?C<?C>>N( !2F2<C5( C;A14<>( 1CF2(

34;8:( A1CA( A12( ?48?28A<CA748(43( >dCA452( C8:( 78:452( FC<72>( >798737?C8A5D( A1<4;914;A( A12(

?C<?C>>(JaC;928(2A(C5NP(0MM/ON();<(<2>;5A>(?4837<B(A12>2(378:789>P(2B@1C>7g789(A12(822:(

A4(:2F254@(C8:(7B@52B28A(1C<B487>2:(9;7:25782>(48(A12(d78:(43(3CA(A4(E2(?48>7:2<2:(34<(

>CB@5789N(a462F2<P(>4B2(C;A14<>(JaC;928(2A(C5NP(0MM/O(C5>4(34;8:(78A<C?C<?C>>(FC<7CA748(

34<( C8:<4>A28482P(617?1(6C>( 84A( ?4837<B2:(67A178( A17>( >A;:DN( %12( 8;BE2<( 43( 3<22g2=

A1C6(?D?52>(A1CA(A12(>CB@52>(1CF2(;8:2<9482(BCD(A12<234<2(4332<(C(E2AA2<(2b@5C8CA748(

34<(A12(<CA12<(546(?4<<25CA748>(4EAC782:(34<(>dCA452(C8:(78:452P(C>(A12>2(?4B@4;8:>(C<2(

B4<2( <2C:75D( <252C>2:( 78A4( A12( 9C>24;>( @1C>2( E2?C;>2( 43( A127<( >5791A5D( 17912<(

1D:<4@1757?7AD(A1C8(A1CA(43(C8:<4>A28482N(

Page 88: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea"\$e*.(*#*.'!$!G(l=aK.e=a,=\!(

(

(

VZ(

(

A$6*000"_G*W&,44/73.(4*(:*EC*%,83./%*,),.=%/2*;$45*-(45*45/*)/;.=*2/@/.(3/2*8/45(2*Z/K,/74*/4*,."*9.($)*:,4?*h<,\$%>*,)2*45/*TT.*8/45(2*9)/&K*:,4?*V<,\$%>*:(7*45/*457//*-(,7*4,$)4*&(83(')2%"*

Page 89: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea*K%",($$$(

(

(

VT(

!" T()&.'%$()*

\4>A(5CE4<CA4<D(C8C5D>2>(<2@4<A2:(>4(3C<(:2A2?A(27A12<(A12(78:457?(?4B@4;8:>(4<(

A12(>A2<47:(?4B@4;8:N(e4BE78789(:7332<28A(:2A2?A748(A2?187[;2>( A4(C8C5D>2(C55(d8468(

?4B@4;8:>( 1C>( <2>;5A2:( 78( 5CE4<74;>( C8:( A7B2=?48>;B789( @<C?A7?2>( 617?1( C<2( B4>A(

43A28(84A(?1C<C?A2<7>2:(ED(A12(>CB2(C??;<C?DP(>@2?737?7AD(C8:(>28>7A7F7AD(C>(C8C5DA7?C5(l=

aK.e=a,=\!(B2A14:>N((

*::7A748C55DP( A12( ?;<<28A5D( CFC75CE52( B2A14:>( A4( :2A2?A( A12( A1<22( E4C<( AC78A(

?4B@4;8:>( >7B;5AC824;>5D( >146( >;E>AC8A7C5(BCA<7b( 78A2<32<28?2N( %17>( 27A12<( 1CB@2<>(

A12( <4E;>A82>>( C8:( <2@2CACE757AD( 43( A12( :CACP( 4<( 7984<2>( @<4@2<( FC57:CA748( :CACN(

%12<234<2P(62(4@A2:(34<(A12(;>2(43(C8(2bA28>7F25D(FC57:CA2:(C8:(<257CE52(l=aK.e=a,=\!(

C8C5D>7>(B2A14:N( %17>( C8C5D>7>P(6128(@<2?2:2:(ED(B787BC5( >CB@52(@<2@C<CA748P( 52:( A4(

A12( FC57:CA748( 43( C8( C??;<CA2( C8:( <4E;>A( B2A14:( A1CA( ?C8( :2A2?A( A12( A1<22( d8468(

?4B@4;8:>( >7B;5AC824;>5DN( c7A1( A17>( B2A14:P( A12( >252?A2:( A1<2>145:>( 34;8:( 78(

57A2<CA;<2P(RMM(u9(.=R(34<(78:452P(0MM(u9(.=R(34<(>dCA452(C8:(RMMM(u9(.=R(34<(C8:<4>A28482P(

C<2( 2C>75D( <2C?12:( C>( A12( 57B7A>( 43( [;C8A737?CA748(62<2( >2A( CA( /( u9( d9=R( 34<( A12( 78:457?(

?4B@4;8:>(C8:(RM(u9(d9=R(34<(A12(>A2<47:(?4B@4;8:N(%17>(B2A14:(6755(28CE52(<25CA7F25D(

3C>A( >?<228789( 43( A12( @<2FC528?2( 43( E4C<( AC78A( 78( 3CA( >CB@52>( C8:(BCD( E2( ;>2:( C>( C8(

4Ef2?A7F2(?4;8A2<B2C>;<2(34<(?48>;B2<(@2<?2@A748(C8:(>28>4<D(2FC5;CA748(@<C?A7?2>N(

(

J" 1&K)(;./26/8/)4%*

%17>(<2>2C<?1(6C>(34;8:2:(ED(C(K1+(9<C8A(43(A12($8>A7A;A2(34<(A12(K<4B4A748(43(

$884FCA748(A1<4;91(!?728?2(C8:(%2?184549D( 78(-5C8:2<>(J$c%=&5CC8:2<28ON(%12(C;A14<>(

64;5:(57d2(A4(A1C8d(oN(+2(&4>P(.N(+4>>?12P(\N(#C2>>28>P(+N(!A4?db(C8:(%N(&C812F25N(

(

( *

Page 90: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea"\$e*.(*#*.'!$!G(l=aK.e=a,=\!(

(

(

ZM(

L" M/:/7/)&/%*

*5:C7( #NP( )>4<4( kNP( YC<<48( .N( oN( ,N( n( #Cf2<C( *N( $N( J0MM_ON( hC>=57[;7:( ?1<4BCA49<C@17?(

B2A14:( 34<( C8C5D>789( ?4B@52b( B7bA;<2>( 43( 3CAAD( C?7:>( 78?5;:789( ?48f;9CA2:(

5784527?(C?7:>(J?7>TA<C8>RR(C8:(A<C8>RM?7>R0(7>4B2<>O(C8:(5489=?1C78(J8=X(4<(8=_O(

@45D;8>CA;<CA2:(3CAAD(C?7:>( =(*@@57?CA748(A4(A12( 78A<CB;>?;5C<( 3CA(43(E223(B2CAN(

o4;<8C5(43(e1<4BCA49<C@1D(*P(RRRMJR=0OP(RXX=RXTN(

*5;6m(\NP(\7552A( !NP( #7f>( hNP( %;DAA28>( -N( *N(\NP( &2<12D:28( kNP( +2( Y<CEC8:2<( aN( -NP( +2(

Y<CEC8:2<(+N(.N(n(&C8()2?d25(\N(oN(J0MMTON(*E>28?2(43(C8(2332?A(43(:72AC<D(37E<2(

4<(?5784@A75457A2(48(E4C<(AC78A(78(28A7<2(BC52(@79>(32:(@<C?A7?C5(:72A>N(\2CA(!?728?2P(

Z0JXOP(XW_=X/0N(

YCE45( oNP( qCBC<CA>dC7C( hNP( o;82fC( ,N( kN( n( .;8:>A<4B( kN( J0MMWON( %12( 2332?A( 43( C92( 48(

:7>A<7E;A748( 43( >dCA452( C8:( 78:452( 52F25>( 78( 28A7<2( BC52( @79>( 78( 34;<( E<22:>G(

'4<d>17<2P(.C8:<C?2P(aCB@>17<2(C8:(+;<4?N(\2CA(!?728?2P(_VJ0OP(X/R=X/ZN(

Y2<:C9;m(oN(.NP(&7C5548(eNP(Y4882C;(\N(n(.2:28BCA(\N(JRTTXON($8:7<2?A(2FC5;CA748(43(E4C<(

AC78A(67A1(9C>=?1<4BCA49<C@17?(BC>>=>@2?A<4B2A<7?(B2C>;<2B28A(43(12C:(>@C?2(

F45CA752>N( $8( \N( Y4882C;( J":NOP( \2C>;<2B28A( C8:( K<2F28A748( 43( Y4C<( %C78A( 78(

"8A7<2(\C52(K79>(J&45N(_MP(@@N(WT=/0ON(KC<7>G($8>A(#CA5(,2?12<?12(*9<484B7[;2N(

e128(hNP(qCBC<CA>dC7C(hNP(\C:2f(*N(n(.;8:>A<4B(kN(J0MM_ON("332?A(43(1eh(C:B787>A<CA748(

48(A12(<25CA748>17@(E2A6228(A2>A7?;5C<(>A2<47:>(C8:(78:457?(?4B@4;8:>(78(3CA(C8:(

@5C>BC(78(28A7<2(BC52(@79>N(\2CA(!?728?2P(V0J0OP(XXT=XWVN(

e5C;>(,NP(a2<E2<A("N(n(+2181C<:(\N(JRTTVON(e4B@C<CA7F2(:2A2<B78CA748(43(A12(E4C<(AC78A(

>A2<47:(C8:<4>A28482(78(@79(C:7@4>2(A7>>;2(ED(C(<C@7:(28gDB2(7BB;84C>>CD(C8:(

C8(aK.e=B2A14:N(*<?17F(-;<(.2E28>B7AA251D97282P(WZJ0OP(0V=XMN(

+2(Y<CEC8:2<(aN(-N(n(&2<E2d2(,N(JRTZ_ON(r;C8A7ACA7F2(:2A2<B78CA748(43(C8:<4>A28482(78(

@79(C:7@4>2(A7>>;2N(o)l,#*.()-(ea,)\*%)h,*Ka'P(X_XP(0TX=XM0N(

"-!*N( J0MMWON( c253C<2( C>@2?A>( 43( A12( ?C>A<CA748( 43( @7952A>G( !?728A737?( ,2@4<A( 43( A12(

!?728A737?( KC825( 34<( *87BC5( a25CA1( C8:(c253C<2( 48( C( <2[;2>A( 3<4B( ?4BB7>>748(

<25CA2:(A4(6253C<2(C>@2?A>(43(A12(?C>A<CA748(43(K7952A>N(%12("-!*(o4;<8C5P(TRP(R=RZN(

";<4@2C8( e4BB;87ADN( J0MM0ON( e4BB7>>748>( +2?7>748( 0MM0^_/V^"eN( )337?7C5( o4;<8C5( 43(

A12(";<4@2C8(e4BB;87ADP(00RP(Z=X_N(

-7>?12<( oNP( "5>78914<>A( KN( cNP( Y;?d789( \NP( %14528( "NP( K2A2<>28( YN( n( c;>A( \N( J0MRRON(

+2F254@B28A( 43( C( eC8:7:CA2( ,232<28?2( \2A14:( 34<( A12( !7B;5AC824;>(

r;C8A7ACA748(43(A12(Y4C<(%C78A(e4B@4;8:>(*8:<4>A28482P(X(C5@1C=*8:<4>A2845P(

X( E2AC=*8:<4>A2845P( !dCA452P( C8:( $8:452( 78( K79( -CA( ED(\2C8>( 43( !ACE52( $>4A4@2(

+75;A748( *8C5D>7>=a2C:>@C?2( !457:=K1C>2( \7?<42bA<C?A748=hC>(

e1<4BCA49<C@1D^\C>>(!@2?A<4B2A<DN(*8C5DA7?C5(e12B7>A<DP(ZXJRVOP(_VZ/=_VTRN(

hC<?7C=,29;27<4(oN(*N(n(,7;>(\N(*N(JRTTZON(,C@7:(:2A2<B78CA748(43(>dCA452(C8:(78:452(78(

@79(EC?d(3CA(ED(84<BC5=@1C>2(57[;7:(?1<4BCA49<C@1DN(o4;<8C5(43(e1<4BCA49<C@1D(

*P(ZMTP(0W_=0/RN(

Page 91: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea*K%",($$$(

(

(

ZR(

aC8>28=\w552<( oN( JRTTWON( ,C@7:( 1791=@2<34<BC8?2( 57[;7:( ?1<4BCA49<C@17?( B2A14:( 34<(

>7B;5AC824;>( :2A2<B78CA748( 43( C8:<4>A28482P( >dCA452( C8:( 78:452( 78( EC?d( 3CA(

3<4B( @79>N( o4;<8C5( 43( e1<4BCA49<C@1D( Y=Y74B2:7?C5( *@@57?CA748>P( __RJ0OP( 0RT=

0XMN(

aC;928( oN( "NP( Y<;87;>( eN( n( qCBC<CA>dC7C( hN( J0MR0ON( ,2F726( 43( C8C5DA7?C5( B2A14:>( A4(

B2C>;<2( E4C<( AC78A( ?4B@4;8:>( 78( @4<?782( C:7@4>2( A7>>;2G( %12( 822:( 34<(

1C<B487>2:(B2A14:>N(\2CA(!?728?2P(TMJROP(T=RTN(

aC;928( oN( "NP( -5CAA28(*N(n(*8:<2>28()N( J0MM/ON( $8A<C?C<?C>>( FC<CA748(43( C8:<4>A28482P(

>dCA452(C8:(78:452(3CA(52F25>(78(28A7<2(BC52(@79>N("**K(c4<d789(h<4;@("8A7<2(BC52(

@79>P(l@@>C5CP(!62:28N(

$!)(RVM0/N(J0MM/ON(h282<C5(<2[;7<2B28A>(34<(A12(?4B@2A28?2(43(A2>A789(C8:(?C57E<CA748(

5CE4<CA4<72>N(

KCAA2<>48( ,N( .N( !N( JRT_ZON( /s=C8:<4>A=R_=282=X=482( ?4B@4;8:( <2>@48>7E52( 34<( AC78A( 78(

E4C<(3CAN(o4;<8C5(43(A12(!?728?2(43(-44:(C8:(*9<7?;5A;<2P(RTJROP(XRN(

K<;872<(*N(n(Y4882C;(\N(J0MM_ON(*5A2<8CA7F2>(A4(@7952A(?C>A<CA748N(K<4:;?A748>(*87BC52>P(

RTJ/OP(XWV=X/_N(

,7;>( \N( *N( n( hC<?7C=,29;27<4( oN( *N( J0MMRON( !dCA452( C8:( 78:452( ?48?28A<CA748>( 78(

.4897>>7B;>(:4<>7(C8:(3CA(>CB@52>(43(@79>N(\2CA(!?728?2P(/TJXOP(0Z/=0TRN(

,7FC>(\N(#NP(,74>(oN(oNP(*<A2C9C(oN(-NP(r;752g(oN(-NP(YC<<2<4(*N(-N(n(.248=eCBC?14(\N(J0MMZON(

+2A2<B78CA748( 43( 28A=dC;<282( 78( >;E?;AC824;>( 3CA( 43( $E2<7C8( @79>( ED( 9C>(

?1<4BCA49<C@1D( B;5A7=>AC92( BC>>( >@2?A<4B2A<D( 67A1( A12( C7B( A4( :7332<28A7CA2(

E2A6228( 78A28>7F2( C8:( 2bA28>7F2( 3CAA28789( >D>A2B>N( *8C5DA7?C( e17B7?C( *?ACP(

_0WJROP(RMV=RR0N(

!78?5C7<( KN( *NP( ![;7<2>( "N( oNP( ,C2>7:2( oN( $N( n( ,28C;:( ,N( J0MM/ON( !D8A12>7>( 43( 3<22( C8:(

>;5@14?48f;9CA2:( R_=C8:<4>A282( >A2<47:>( ED( A12( .2D:79( ?255>( 43( A12( BCA;<2(

:4B2>A7?( E4C<N( o4;<8C5( 43( !A2<47:( Y74?12B7>A<D( C8:( \452?;5C<( Y74549DP( T_J0OP(

0RV=00ZN(

%;4B45C(\NP(aCdC5C(\N(n(\C887828(KN(JRTTZON(+2A2<B78CA748(43(C8:<4>A28482(78(@79(3CA(

;>789( @C?d2:( ?45;B8( >;@2<?<7A7?C5( 35;7:( ?1<4BCA49<C@1D( BC>>( >@2?A<4B2A<DN(

o4;<8C5(43(e1<4BCA49<C@1D(YP(VRTJR=0OP(0/=XMN(

&C8:28(Y;>>?12(oNP(&C81C2?d2(.NP(+2?2;878?d('NP(&2<12D:28(kNP(c7552(kNP(Y2dC2<A(kNP(.2(

Y7g2?(YN(n(+2(Y<CEC8:2<(aN( -N( J0MRMON(+2F254@B28A( C8:( FC57:CA748(43( C8(;5A<C=

1791(@2<34<BC8?2(57[;7:(?1<4BCA49<C@1D(AC8:2B(BC>>(>@2?A<4B2A<D(B2A14:(34<(

[;C8A73D789( A1D<24>ACA>( 78( ;<782( 67A14;A( :2<7FCA7>CA748N( o4;<8C5( 43(

e1<4BCA49<C@1D(*P(R0RVJ0_OP(W0Z/=W0TXN(

&2<12D:28(kNP(#4@@2(aNP(*5;62(\NP(\7552A(!NP(Y;>>?12(oN(&N(n(+2(Y<CEC8:2<(aN(-N(J0MMVON(

+2F254@B28A(C8:(FC57:CA748(43(C(B2A14:( 34<(>7B;5AC824;>(C8C5D>7>(43( A12(E4C<(

AC78A( ?4B@4;8:>( 78:452P( >dCA452( C8:( C8:<4>A28482( 78( @79( 3CA( ;>789( 57[;7:(

Page 92: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea"\$e*.(*#*.'!$!G(l=aK.e=a,=\!(

(

(

Z0(

?1<4BCA49<C@1D=B;5A7@52( BC>>( >@2?A<4B2A<DN( o4;<8C5( 43( e1<4BCA49<C@1D( *P(

RRVWJR=0OP(RX0=RXVN(

&45:( "N( JRTVMON( -527>1@<4:;dA748>27928>?1C3A28( E27( "E2<8( ;8:( kC>A<CA28N( $&N(

)<9C8452@A7>?12( ;8:( 9C>?1<4BCA49<C37>?12( l8A2<>;?1;8928((

cC>>2:CB@335t?1A792<( !A44332( :2>( ,t?d28>@2?d2>( F48( "E2<8N( \25:7892<(

#4<:C8:E<;?d1429>d452P(WTP(R(=(0/N((

(

Page 93: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

Chapter IV

Evaluation of different heating methods for the detection of boar taint by means

of the human nose

Page 94: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

,2:<C3A2:(C3A2<G(

(Z/K,/74*X"*F"?(*5;6m(\NP(&C81C2?d2(.NP(a2<2>(.NP(+;?1CA2C;(.NP(&C8:28:<72>>?12(

-N(n(%;DAA28>(-N(*N(\N(J0MR0ON("FC5;CA748(43(:7332<28A(12CA789(B2A14:>(34<(A12(:2A2?A748(

43(E4C<(AC78A(ED(B2C8>(43(A12(1;BC8(84>2N(\2CA(!?728?2(J>;EB7AA2:ON(

(

Page 95: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea*K%",($&(

(

(

Z/(

TQ1H+OM*0N*

O@,.',4$()*(:*2$::/7/)4*5/,4$)6*8/45(2%*:(7*45/*2/4/&4$()*(:*-(,7*4,$)4*-=*

8/,)%*(:*45/*5'8,)*)(%/*

*

AbstractG(

#4( C;A4BCA2:(:2A2?A748( >D>A2B( 34<( E4C<( AC78A( :2A2?A748( 7>( ?;<<28A5D( CFC75CE52P(

A1;>( E4C<( AC78A( CA( A12( >5C;91A2<5782( ?C8( ?;<<28A5D( 485D( E2( C>>2>>2:( ;>789( A12( >7892789(

B2A14:( J453C?A4<D(>?4<789ON(%17>( >A;:D(?4B@C<2>(>2F2<C5(12CA789(B2A14:>( JB7?<46CF2P(

>45:2<789( 7<48( C8:( @D<4@28O( C8:( 2FC5;CA2>( A12( 2332?A( 43( 1CE7A;CA748P( ?52C8789( A12(

>45:2<789( 7<48P(>7892789(A12(3CA(A67?2( 78(A12(>CB2(@5C?2P(C8:(FC<7CA748>( 78(A12(A2?187?C5(

@<4?2:;<2>N(*55(B2A14:>(>22B(A4(E2(>;7ACE52(34<(:2A2?A789(E4C<(AC78A(E;A(A12(?147?2(43(

12CA789(B2A14:(34<(>28>4<D(>?4<789(43(E4C<(AC78A(:2@28:>(48(1CE7A;CA748(43(A12(2b@2<A(

C8:(>@2?737?(?48:7A748>(C@@572:N(%12(@D<4@28(>22B>(A4(E2(B4>A(>;7ACE52(E2?C;>2(7A(:42>(

84A(?48AC?A(A12(3CA(C8:(7>(2C>D(A4(1C8:52(J67<252>>ON(-78C55DP(A12(78A28>7AD(>?4<2(BCD(C5>4(

E2( 7835;28?2:(EDG(?48ACB78CA748( 3<4B(84A(?52C8789( A12(>45:2<789( 7<48P( >7892789( A12( 3CA(

A67?2(78(A12(>CB2(@5C?2P(C8:(A12(2332?A(43(1CE7A;CA748N((

( (

Page 96: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#!),'(*#*.'!$!G(!$#h"$#h(\"%a)+(

(

(

Z_(

[" 0)47(2'&4$()*

$8(B4>A("l(?4;8A<72>P(ZM( A4(RMMS(43( A12(BC52(@79>(C<2(?C>A<CA2:( A4(CF47:(E4C<(

AC78A( J-<2:<7d>28P( 2A( C5NP( 0MMTON( !4?72AC5( @<2>>;<2( 7>( 78?<2C>789( A4( >22d( B4<2( 1;BC82(

C5A2<8CA7F2>( 34<( >;<97?C5( ?C>A<CA748N(%12(@<4:;?A748(43(28A7<2(BC52(@79>( 7>(9C78789(B4<2(

C8:( B4<2( C??2@AC8?2( 78( >2F2<C5( ?4;8A<72>( 78?5;:789( A12( #2A12<5C8:>( C8:( Y2597;BN(

\4<24F2<P(>4B2(>;@2<BC<d2A>(1CF2(C:f;>A2:(A127<(BC<d2A789(>A<CA29D(A4( 78?5;:2(>C52>(

43(@4<d(3<4B(28A7<2(BC52(@79>P(617?1(7>(@2<?27F2:(C>(C(1;BC82(C5A2<8CA7F2(34<(?C>A<CA748(

J&C8148C?d2<( 2A( C5NP( 0MMTON( c128( @<4:;?789( 28A7<2( BC52( @79>P( 1462F2<P( A12( <7>d( 43(

>255789(@4<d(67A1(E4C<(AC78A(B;>A(E2(B787B7>2:N(#4(B2A14:(1C>(D2A(E228(34;8:(A4(<C7>2(

28A7<2(BC52(@79>(67A1(C(>;337?728A5D( 546(@<2FC528?2(43(E4C<( AC78A( JaC;928(2A(C5NP(0MR0ON(

e48>2[;28A5DP( <C@7:( :2A2?A748( B2A14:>( 34<( ;>2( 78( >5C;91A2<14;>2>( C<2( 822:2:( A4(

7:28A73D(C8:(>4<A(4;A(?C<?C>>2>(67A1(;8C??2@ACE52(52F25>(43(E4C<(AC78AN((

*A( @<2>28AP( 84( 1C<B487>2:(B2A14:( 34<( :2A2?A789( E4C<( AC78A( 7>( CFC75CE52( C8:( C(

FC<72AD(43(:2A2?A748(B2A14:>(34<(;>2(C6CD(3<4B(A12(>5C;91A2<(5782(JH433=5782IO(C8:(CA(A12(

>5C;91A2<( 5782( JHCA=5782IO( C<2( ;>2:N( )33=5782( :2A2?A748( B2A14:>( ?C8( E2( ;>2:( 78( A12(

>5C;91A2<14;>2(E;A(84A(:7<2?A5D(48(A12(?C<?C>>N(*A=5782(B2A14:>(?C8(E2(C@@572:(:7<2?A5D(

48( A12( ?C<?C>>( CA( A12( >5C;91A2<( 5782N( $8( C( +C87>1( @79( >5C;91A2<14;>2P( C8( 433=5782(

?454<7B2A<7?(B2A14:(34<( A12(B2C>;<2B28A(43(>dCA452( 52F25>( 78(EC?d3CA( 7>(;>2:( J&C15;8P(

RTTXON( *( 3CA( >CB@52( 7>( @1D>7?C55D( <2B4F2:( 3<4B( 2C?1( ?C<?C>>( C8:( C8C5D>2:( 78( C(

5CE4<CA4<DN( !4B2( 43( A12( 57B7ACA748>( C<2( A1CA( C8:<4>A28482( 7>( 84A(B2C>;<2:P( C8:( A1CA(

BCb7B;B(RZM(>CB@52>(?C8(E2(A2>A2:(@2<(14;<(J"-!*P(0MMWON(*5>4(A12(5C?d(43(>@2?737?7AD(7>(

C( :7>C:FC8AC92( 43( A17>(B2A14:N( %12( ?454<( <2C928A( :42>( 84A( :7>?<7B78CA2( E2A6228( A12(

78:457?( ?4B@4;8:>N( %12( <2>;5A>( 43( A17>( B2A14:( C<2( A12<234<2( 2>A7BCA2:( 78( >dCA452(

2[;7FC528A>( JaC;928( 2A( C5NP( 0MR0ON( &C<74;>( 4A12<( @4A28A7C5( 252?A<487?(B2A14:>( 34<( A12(

<C@7:(433=(C8:(CA=5782(:2A2?A748(43(?C<?C>>2>(67A1(E4C<(AC78A(1CF2(E228(78F2>A79CA2:P(E;A(

822:( 3;<A12<(:2F254@B28A(E234<2(C@@57?CA748( 78(?4BB2<?7C5( >5C;91A2<14;>2>(E2?4B2>(

@4>>7E52(J.;8:>A<4B(2A(C5NP(0MMTON(

%12( 5C?d( 43( C( FC57:CA2:( :2A2?A748( >D>A2B( <2[;7<2>( B4>A( >5C;91A2<14;>2>( JC8:(

<2>2C<?12<>O(A4(;>2(>28>4<D(C>>2>>B28A(ED(1;BC8(2b@2<A>( 34<(A12(<C@7:(:2A2<B78CA748(

43( E4C<( AC78A( 78( ?C<?C>>2>N( %12>2( 453C?A4<D( >?4<789( >D>A2B>( <2[;7<2( A12( 12CA789( 4<(

Page 97: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

ea*K%",($&(

(

(

ZV(

>7892789(43(C(>CB@52(BCA<7b(J;>;C55D(3CAO(A4(<252C>2(E4C<(AC78A(4:4;<(73(@<2>28AP(617?1(7>(

A128( C>>2>>2:( ED( 482( 4<( B4<2( 2b@2<A>N( \;?1( FC<7CA748( 2b7>A>( 78( A12( B2A14:45497?C5(

C@@<4C?12>(43(A12>2(453C?A4<D(2FC5;CA748>G(A12(>252?A748(C8:(A<C78789(43(A12(2b@2<A>P(A12(

B2A14:( ;>2:( 34<( 12CA789( A12( >CB@52>( J2N9N( ?44d789P(B25A789P( E475789P( 4<( >7892789OP( A12(

>@2?737?CA748>( 43( A12( B2A14:( ;>2:( J2N9N( A2B@2<CA;<2( 43( A12( C@@C<CA;>P( :;<CA748( 43(

12CA789OP(C8:(A12(AD@2(43(>CB@52( J2N9N(@C<A(43( A12(?C<?C>>P( >7g2O( A1CA( 7>(C>>2>>2:( J%CE52(

$&NRON(

*5A14;91(A12(>7892789(B2A14:(?;<<28A5D(>22B>(A4(E2( A12(B4>A(?4BB485D(;>2:(

B2A14:(78(>5C;91A2<14;>2>P(A12(E2>A(6CD(A4(@2<34<B(A12(>7892789(B2A14:(1C>(84A(E228(

>;Ef2?A2:( A4( >?728A737?( >?<;A78DN( %12( 5C?d( 43( B2A14:45497?C5( 1C<B487>CA748( J2N9N(

?48?2<8789(A2B@2<CA;<2P(6CAAC92P(>252?A748(C8:(A<C78789(43(A12(2b@2<A>OP(A12(@C;?7AD(ED(

617?1(B2A14:45497?C5(:2AC75>(C<2(<2@4<A2:( 78(>4B2(>A;:72>P(C8:(A12( 5C?d(43(d84652:92(

48( A12( 2332?A>( 43( A12>2( B2A14:45497?C5( :7332<28?2>( BCd2( 7A( :7337?;5A( A4( ?4B@C<2( A12(

<2>;5A>(43(:7332<28A(>A;:72>N(Y4A1(<2>2C<?12<>(C8:(>5C;91A2<14;>2(C<2(78?<2C>7895D(?C55789(

34<( 3;<A12<( 4@A7B7>CA748( C8:( 1C<B487>CA748( 43( A12( >7892789( B2A14:N( K4A28A7C5(

7835;28?789(3C?A4<>(822:(A4(E2(78F2>A79CA2:P(A492A12<(67A1(2FC5;CA748(C8:(?4B@C<7>48(43(

:7332<28?2>(78(B2A14:4549DN((

$8(A17>(>A;:DP(C(>2<72>(43(2b@2<7B28A>(48(453C?A4<D(C>>2>>B28A(43(E4C<(AC78A(1CF2(

E228( ?48:;?A2:( 67A1( FC<74;>( 4Ef2?A7F2>P( 7N2N( A4( ?4B@C<2( :7332<28A( 433=5782( B2A14:>(

JB7?<46CF2P( >45:2<789( 7<48P( @D<4@28( C8:( @D<4@28( 67A1( @5CA2O( 34<( 12CA789( A12( 3CA(

>CB@52>U( A4( 78F2>A79CA2( A12( A2?187?C5( @2<34<BC8?2( JBCb7B;B( A2B@2<CA;<2( 43( A12(

>7892789(A445(C8:(A7B2(822:2:(@2<(>CB@52(C>>2>>B28AO(43(A12(@D<4@28(CA(A64(>2AA789>(

C8:(43(A1<22(>45:2<789(7<48>(43(:7332<28A(6CAAC92U(A4(?4B@C<2(A12(4:4;<(78A28>7AD(>?4<2>(

43(C(9<4;@(43(>CB@52>(67A1(C8:(67A14;A(?52C8789(A12(>45:2<789(7<48(C3A2<(2C?1(>CB@52U(A4(

A2>A(A12(2332?A(43(>7892789(A12(3CA(A67?2(CA(A12(>CB2(@5C?2U(C8:(A4(2FC5;CA2(A12(2332?A(43(

1CE7A;CA748(ED(>?4<789(A12(>CB2(9<4;@(43(XM(>CB@52>(A1<22(A7B2>(:;<789(482(:CDN((

(

(

Page 98: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!

!

!"#$%&'()*+&,-./0%1%2345%&$436&-7&0%3%"081&/"/%03&-2&1%"6429&.%61-:3&;3%:&#<&%=/%063&7-0&:%6%86429&#-"0&6"426&&>3428%&?@@A&B461&6-/48+&#-"0&6"426C&3%23-0<&%5"$;"64-2&"2:&%=/%06&/"2%$D)&

!

E%"6429&

.%61-:&

F%61-:&3/%84748"64-2& G"./$%&3/%84748"64-2&H%7%0%28%&

!%./%0"6;0%& !4.%& I61%0& !</%& G4J%&

"#$%$&'!(! )*!+$&! (! ,-./! (! 0123%-45!-/!.%65!7*)*8!

)9:;<! :!+$&! =#/!4%./-! >./!.&?!+-./! )@)@)!A+! 0BC$//$&'/#&5!-/!.%65!7*))8!

<##2$&'!

! D!+$&! )9**B!E!F3$%%!4%./-! ,-./! 76:!A+! 0G%HIJ5!-/!.%65!7**K8!

)9*!;<! 7@L+$&! (! ,-./! (! 0"M3&-5!NC.+OP#3'5!Q!=.&O-&5!7**98!

R*!;<! (! S&/-3&.%!/-+4! ,-./! )67R!A+D! 0<#2-35!-/!.%65!7**K8!

):*!;<! 7@D+$&! ! ,-./! )!A+! 0=.&O-&5!-/!.%65!7**98!

)K*!;<! L!+$&! F3$%%!4%./-! ,-./! )!A+! 0T.H%M5!-/!.%65!7*)*8!

)9*!;<! :!+$&! (! >./! :*!'!0T.3H&#U$A5!T-/3#U$A5!,./-2.%#E1U-3.25!T.3H&#U$A5!Q!V.?#U$A5!

7*)*8!

! (! 7@)!+$&! W3M$&'! ,-./! 7:'! 0XH&?-5!-/!.%65!7*)*8!

1#%?-3$&'!$3#&!(! (! D*B! >./! Y&!/C-!A.3A.OO! 0G%HIJ5!-/!.%65!7**K8!

)9*!;<! (! (! >./! L@L@L!A+! 0BC$//$&'/#&5!-/!.%65!7*))8!

,-%/$&'! )9:!;<! Z&/$%!+-%/-?! =#/!4%./-! >./! 7*!'! 0BC$//$&'/#&5!-/!.%65!7*))8!

,$A3#I.U-!

(! :*!O-A! R**B! >./! ! 0G%HIJ5!-/!.%65!7**K8!

(! 7@!7*O-A! =$'C!4#I-3! >./! )*!'! 0T3HO.5!-/!.%65!7*))8!

(! 7@):!O-A! =$'C!4#I-3! ,-./! )*!'! 0T3HO.5!-/!.%65!7*))8!

(! K*!O-A! R:*B! >./!.&?!+-./! 7*!'! 0BC$//$&'/#&5!-/!.%65!7*))8!

Page 99: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()*(

(

(

+,(

-./(0123(304567(8.4/(9:.9;:(<:/:(0/=2>:5(2>(01:(.;8=?0./6(=33:33@:>0(.8(A.=/(0=2>0(

.8(8=0(3=@9;:3(/:@.B:5(8/.@(01:(?=/?=33:3(.8(:>02/:(@=;:(92C3D(E:(9/:3:>0(5=0=(.>(01:(

:88:?0( .8( 01:( B=/2.43( :F9:/2@:>0=;( 0/:=0@:>03( 432>C( 01:( 3?./:3( C2B:>( A6( 01:3:( 8.4/(

:F9:/03D( )>( =55202.>7( 01:( ?.>?:>0/=02.>3( .8( 01:( @=2>( A.=/( 0=2>0( [email protected]>53(

G=>5/.30:>.>:7(3H=0.;:(=>5(2>5.;:I(.8(=;;(3=@9;:3(43:5(2>(:F9:/2@:>03(<:/:(5:0:/@2>:5(

B2=( ?1:@2?=;( =>=;6323D( %1:3:( ?.>?:>0/=02.>3( <:/:( ?.//:;=0:5( <201( 01:( 3:>3./6(

=33:33@:>03(.8(01:(8.4/(:F9:/03D(

!" #$%&'($)*+$,-+.&%/0-*+

JDKD 1$.2)&*++

L:?H( 8=0( GM( NOFKP( ?@I( 9=/03( .8( :>02/:( @=;:( 92C3( <:/:( ?.;;:?0:5( =0( =(

3;=4C10:/1.43:( .8( 01:( *)QL( -..5( R/.49( G&2>51.B:>7( 01:( L:01:/;=>53ID( %1:(

3;=4C10:/1.43:(:F9:/03(<:/:(3:;:?0:5(=>5(0/=2>:5(=3(5:3?/2A:5(A6(S=014/(:0(=;D(GJOKJI(

A6( =(@./:( :F9:/2:>?:5( 3;=4C10:/1.43:( :F9:/0D( %1:( >:?H( 8=0( .8( 01:( :>02/:(@=;:3( <=3(

32>C:5(432>C( =( C=3(A4/>:/( :T4299:5(<201( =(9;=0:( =>5( 3?./:5( 8./( 01:(9/:3:>?:(.8( A.=/(

0=2>0( A6( 01:( 3;=4C10:/1.43:( :F9:/0( =0( 01:( 3;=4C10:/( ;2>:( 432>C( =( 82B:U9.2>0( 3?=;:( GOV(

>./@=;( 9./H( 3@:;;( 0.( WV( 30/.>C( A.=/( 0=2>07( =3( 5:3?/2A:5( A6( S=014/( :0( =;D( GJOKJIID(

X:9:>52>C(.>(01:(:F9:/2@:>07(3=@9;:3(<:/:(43:5(8/.@(=;;(82B:(?=0:C./2:3(./(.>;6(8/.@(

?=0:C./2:3(O(=>5(W(G%=A;:()*DJID(#;;(B232A;:(@:=0(<=3(0/2@@:5(8/.@(01:(8=0(3=@9;:7(<12?1(

<=3(01:>(?40(2>0.(3@=;;:/(92:?:3(GM(YFJ(?@ID(%1:3:(3=@9;:3(<:/:(30./:5(=0(U(JOZ!(4>02;(

:F9:/2@:>03(<:/:(?.>54?0:5D(((

JDJD 3/&.(4$)+$,$)5*(*+

%1:( ?.>?:>0/=02.>( .8( =>5/.30:>.>:7( 3H=0.;:( =>5( 2>5.;:( <=3( 5:0:/@2>:5( A6(

?1:@2?=;( =>=;63:3( .>( .>:( 3=@9;:( G3H2>( /:@.B:5I( 9:/( >:?H( 8=0( 9=/0D( #>( [!US\( A=3:5(

5:0:?02.>( @:01.5( <=3( 43:5( =3( 5:3?/2A:5( A6( ]:H=:/0( :0( =;D( GJOKJID( )>( 31./07( 3=@9;:(

9/:9=/=02.>(?.>3230:5(.8(=(@:;02>C(30:9(8.;;.<:5(A6(:F0/=?02.>(<201(@:01=>.;7(?;:=>(49(

01/.4C1( 8/::^2>C( =>5( 3.;25( 91=3:( :F0/=?02.>D( \4A3:T4:>0;67( 01:( =>=;60:3( <:/:(

?1/.@=0.C/=912?=;;6(3:9=/=0:5(432>C(4;0/=(12C1(9:/8./@=>?:(;2T425(?1/.@=0.C/=916(G_U

Page 100: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

\&L\Q'`(#L#[`\)\V(\)LR&)LR(S&%"QX(

(

(

,O(

"$[!I( =>5( 5:0:?0:5( <201( =>( &F=?02B:%S( 12C1U/:3.;402.>( @=33( 39:?0/.@:0:/D(

a4=>0282?=02.>(<=3(9:/8./@:5(.>(01:(A=323(.8(?=;2A/=02.>(?4/B:3(8./(:=?1(=>=;60:(2>(01:(

8=0(@=0/2F(G%=A;:()*DNID(

(

JDND 1&)&4%(0,+$,-+%'$(,(,6+07+%/&+&82&'%*+

-./(01:(B=/2.43(:F9:/2@:>037(=(C/.49(.8(:F9:/03(<=3(3:;:?0:5(=>5(0/=2>:5(8./(01:(

3:>3./6( =33:33@:>0(.8(A.=/( 0=2>0( 2>( 8=0D( %1:3:(:F9:/03(<:/:(5288:/:>0( 2>52B254=;3( 01=>(

01:( 3;=4C10:/1.43:( :F9:/03( 9/:B2.43;6( @:>02.>:57( =>5( <:/:( 3:;:?0:5( =>5( 0/=2>:5( =3(

5:3?/2A:5(A:;.<D(%123(C/.49(.8(:F9:/03(<=3(43:5(8./(=;;(:F9:/2@:>03(/:9./0:5(1:/:D(%123(

C/.49( .8( :F9:/03(<=3( 43:5( 8./( =;;( :F9:/2@:>03( /:9./0:5( 1:/:D( -.4/( ?=>525=0:( :F9:/03(

<:/:( /:?/420:5V( .>:( <.@=>( 8/.@( 01:( [=A./=0./6( .8( !1:@2?=;( #>=;6323( GR1:>0(

_>2B:/3206I7(.>:(@=>(=>5(.>:(<.@=>( 8/.@( 01:( )>302040:( 8./(#C/2?4;04/=;( =>5(-231:/2:3(

':3:=/?1(G)[*QI(=>5(.>:(<.@=>(8/.@(=(92C(=>5(?=00;:(3;=4C10:/1.43:(G')S#7(S:?1:;:>7(

]:;C24@ID( %1:( 82/30( 30:9( 8./( 01:( 3:;:?02.>( .8( :F9:/03( ?.>3230:5( .8( =( 3:>3202B206( 0:30( 8./(

=>5/.30:>.>:( 432>C( 01:( @:01.5( 5:3?/2A:5( A6( ]:H=:/0( :0( =;D( G!1=90:/( )))ID( )>( A/2:8V( W(

A.00;:3(<:/:(82;;:5(<201(<=0:/D(%.(.>:(.8(01:(8.4/(A.00;:37(=(12C1(?.>?:>0/=02.>(.8(3.;25(

=>5/.30:>.>:(<=3(=55:5(GODKY(@C(@;UKID(%1:(?=>525=0:3(<:/:(=3H:5(0.(3:;:?0(01:(A.00;:(

<201(01:(30/.>C:30(.5.4/(=>5(0.(:B=;4=0:(01:(.5.4/(2>0:>3206(.8(01=0(A.00;:(.>(=(;=A:;:5(

@=C>2045:( 3?=;:D( %123( 0:30( <=3( /:9:=0:5( 01/::( 02@:3D( )>( ./5:/( 0.( A:( 3:;:?0:5( =3( =>(

:F9:/07( 01:( ?=>525=0:3( <:/:( /:T42/:5( 0.( ?.//:?0;6( 25:>0286( 01:( A.00;:( ?.>0=2>2>C(

=>5/.30:>.>:(=>5(0.(3?./:(01:(2>0:>3206(=3(=0(;:=30(b30/.>Cc(2>(=;;(01/::(0:303D(X4/2>C(01:(

3:?.>5(30:9(.8(01:(3:;:?02.>7(01:6(<:/:(9/:3:>0:5(01/::(A.00;:3(<201(<=0:/(=>5(.>:(<201(

=(12C1(GJ(@C([UKI(./(;.<(GODK(@C([UKI(?.>?:>0/=02.>(.8(=>5/.30:>.>:(./(=(12C1(GODP(@C([dKI(

./( ;.<( GODOK(@C( [UKI( ?.>?:>0/=02.>( .8( 3H=0.;:( 2>(<=0:/D( %1:( 8.4/( ?.>?:>0/=02.>3(<:/:(

.88:/:5( 01/::( 02@:3( =>5( 01:( ?=>525=0:3(<:/:( /:T42/:5( 0.( ?.//:?0;6( 25:>0286( 01:( A.00;:(

<201(01:(30/.>C:30(.5.4/(:B:/6(02@:D((

Page 101: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!

!

!

!

!"#$%&'()*&!+%&,-.#%/&012&34&4"5&6".7$%6&7%/&#3"/&5"8,5&9"5%:3/;&0"6&"66%66%<&#;&5+%&6$"-:+5%/+3-6%&%=7%/52&7%/&%=7%/5&7%/&<";&",<&5+%&+%"58,:&.%5+3<)&>?&6".7$%6&"/%&5"@%,&4/3.&43-/&<844%/%,5&9"/9"66%6A&>>?&6".7$%6&"/%&5"@%,&4/3.&6%B%,&<844%/%,5&9"/9"66%6)&

&!

1-.#%/&34&6".7$%6&7%/&#3"/&5"8,5&

9"5%:3/;&

01&34&6%6683,&7%/&<";&=&1&

34& 6".7$%6& 693/%<& 7%/&

6%6683,2&=&1&34&<";6&

C%"58,:&.%5+3<&

! D"5&E& D"5&F& D"5&*& D"5&G& D"5&H& ! I89/3J"B%& K3$<%/8,:&8/3,& L;/37%,& L;/37%,&J85+&7$"5%&

"#$%&%&'!(! )! *! ! ! *! ! ! *+,! -.//%&'!(! !

"#$%&%&'!0! )! ! *! *! ! ! ! *+,! -.//%&'!(! !

1234$#%52&!26!7.$/%&'!

3./7285!0+9! 0! *! 0! *! :0;*+<;)! =++,! *+,! -.//%&'!(! -.//%&'!(!

".>7&%>$?!$54.>/5! (@9! ! ! ! (@9! :(;*+<;=! !

*+,!

)+,!

A+,!

-.//%&'!(!

-.//%&'!*!!

1?.$&%&'!/7.!52?8.#%&'!%#2&! 0B99! ! ! ! )! :0;*+<;0! ! *+,! ! !

-%&'.%&'!2&!/7.!5$3.!542/! 0B99! ! ! ! )! :0;*+<;(! ! *+,! ! !

C66.>/!26!7$D%/E$/%2&! 0+9! 0! *! 0! *! :*;*+<;(! ! *+,! ! !

1$/!+F!&2#3$?!42#G!282E#H!1$/!(F!8.I%$&/!53.??J!DE/!&2!D2$#!/$%&/H!1$/!0F!?%//?.!D2$#!/$%&/!:DE/!&2/!K./!E&4?.$5$&/<H!1$/!*F!D2$#!/$%&/H!1$/!)F!5/#2&'!D2$#!

/$%&/! !

Page 102: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!

!

!

!

!"#$%&'()G?&MB%/":%&0N&KO2&",<&5+%&/",:%&7%/&9"5%:3/;&43/&%B%/;&#3"/&5"8,5&93.73-,<)&&

D"5%:3/;&1-.#%/&34&

6".7$%6&L"/".%5%/& ',<3$%&0.:&@:PF2& K@"53$%&0.:&@:PF2& M,</365%,3,%&0.:&@:PF2&

1$/.'2#K!+! LM@*!NI.#$'.!O!-P! +Q+*!R!+Q+*! +Q+@!R!+Q+*! +Q0B!R!+Q*+!

S$&'.! LP!T!+Q(@! LP!T!+Q()! LP!T!+QBU!

1$/.'2#K!(! LM@!NI.#$'.!O!-P! +Q+0!R!+Q+(! +Q+)!R!+Q+)! +Q(B!R!+Q+=!

S$&'.! LP!T!+Q+0! +Q+(!T!+Q(+! +Q+=!T!+Q0)!

1$/.'2#K!0! LMU!NI.#$'.!O!-P! +Q+U!R!+Q+A! +Q0+!R!+Q(A! (QBA!R!(QA+!

S$&'.! +Q+(!T!+Q0=! +Q+)!T!+Q@0! +Q(+!T!@Q)0!

1$/.'2#K!*! LM@!NI.#$'.!O!-P! +Q*B!R!+Q*(! (Q0@!R!(Q0A! (QU+!R!(Q0A!

S$&'.! +Q+U!T!+QAU! +Q00!T!*Q*U! +Q*B!T!*Q@+!

1$/.'2#K!)! LM((!NI.#$'.!O!-P! +Q0=!R!+Q(U! +Q=B!R!+QU+! 0Q00!R!(Q*B!

S$&'.! +Q+0!T!+Q@0! +Q+B!T!0QUB! +Q@(!T!@Q)+!

Page 103: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()*(

(

(

+,(

%-.(/0123(45.6(7/(5-.(4.3.85071(8714045.9(7/(5:7(62;54<(=>(5-;..(50?.4(/7@;(A7553.4(

:05-(2(90//.;.15(8718.15;25071(7/(219;745.171.(BCDEF(EDGF(ED=(219(EDE=(?H(IJ=( 01(:25.;>(

:.;.(7//.;.9(219(C>( 5-;..( 50?.4( /7@;(A7553.4(:05-(2(90//.;.15(8718.15;25071(7/( 4K2573.(

BEDGF( ED=F( EDE=( 219(EDEE=(?H( IJ=( 01(:25.;>(:.;.(6;.4.15.9D( %7(A.( 4.3.85.9F( 82190925.4(

-29(57(288@;25.3L(2;;21H.(5-.(A7553.4(2887;901H(57(018;.2401H(797@;(015.1405LD(

%-.( /7@;( 82190925.4( [email protected]/@33L( 6244.9( 5-.( 4.3.85071( 6;78.9@;.( 219( :.;.(

[email protected]@.153L(5;201.9(57(487;.(5-.(57523(A72;(52015(015.1405L(7/(/25(42?63.4(0145.29(7/(5-.(

015.14050L(7/( 4K2573.( 219(219;745.171.( 4.6.;25.3L( 219( 5-04(71(2( N04@23( 21237H@.( 4823.D(

O./7;.(452;501H(5-.(5;20101H(4.440714F(5-.(.P6.;54(:.;.(.P674.9(57(/25(42?63.4(:05-(219(

:05-7@5( A72;( 52015( 57(?2K.( 5-.?( /2?0302;( :05-( A72;( 52015( 219( 90//.;.15( 015.14050.4( 7/(

A72;(52015D(Q@;01H(2(5;20101H(4.44071F(5-.(.P6.;54(@4.9(2(4739.;01H(0;71(7;(2(6L;76.1(B01(

71.( 5;20101H( 4.44071(A75-(:.;.(@4.9>( /7;( 401H.01H( 5-.( /25( 42?63.4( 57( ;.3.24.( 5-.(A72;(

52015(797@;(B0/(6;.4.15>D R05-(.N.;L(?.5-79(B4739.;01H( 0;71(7;(6L;76.1>F(42?63.4(:.;.(

487;.9(5:7(7;(5-;..(50?.4(B9.6.1901H(71(5-.(;.4@354>(6.;(5;20101HD(&28-(5;20101H(4.44071(

235.;125.9(5-.(7;9.;(7/(5-.(?.5-79(B4739.;01H(0;71(7;(6L;76.1>(219(5-.(87?67405071(7/(

5-.(A258-(7/( 42?63.4( B01( 5;20101H(=( 219( 5;20101H(C( B%2A3.( )*DC>>(:.;.(235.;.9D(Q@;01H( 2(

5;20101H(4.44071(=E(42?63.4(4.3.85.9(/;7?(90//.;.15(825.H7;0.4(7/(A72;(52015(B%2A3.()*DC>(

:.;.( 6;.4.15.9( 5:08.( 57( 5-.( .P6.;54( 01( 2( ;2197?04.9( 7;9.;F( :05-( 2( GJ?01@5.( 62@4.(

A.5:..1(487;01H(.28-(42?63.D(S7;(.N.;L(42?63.(5-.L(:.;.(24K.9(57(487;.(5-.(015.1405L(

7/( A72;( 52015( 71( N04@23( 21237H@.( 4823.( :05-( 218-7;( 670154( /;7?( E( B17( 797@;>( 57( =EE(

B45;71H.45( 0?2H012A3.( 7//J797@;>( BS0H( )*D=>D( %-.( ;.4@354( 7/( 5-.( /0;45( 219( 4.8719( 487;01H(

:.;.(87?62;.9(219(42?63.4(5-25(-29(175(A..1(487;.9(09.1508233L(B0D.D(:05-01(2(;21H.(7/(

T( U(@1054(71( 5-.(=EE(67015( 4823.>(:.;.( 401H.9(219([email protected]( 4.62;25.3LD(#175-.;( /0N.J

?01@5.( 62@4.( :24( 52K.1( A./7;.( 487;01H( 5-.( 42?63.4( /7;( 2( 5-0;9( 219( /0123( 50?.D( %-.(

5;20101H(:24(871409.;.9([email protected]/@3(:-.1(5-.(;.4@354(7/(5-.(/0;45(219(4.8719(487;01H(909(

175(90//.;(:05-(?7;.(5-21(U(@1054(71(5-.(=EE(67015(4823.F(:-08-(;[email protected](01(2(V6.2;?21(

87;;.325071( 87.//080.15(7/( ;( W( EDXD( )1( 57523F( 5-.(.P6.;54( ;.M@0;.9(=Y( 5;20101H( 4.440714( 57(

28-0.N.(5-04(H723D(

Page 104: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

V&ZV['\(#Z#I\V)V<(V)Z]&)Z](^&%"[Q(

(

(

+U(

CDUD !"#$%&'()"$*+,-(

Q0//.;.15(?.5-794(/7;(-.2501H(5-.(/25(42?63.4(:.;.(@4.9(57(450?@325.(5-.(;.3.24.(

7/( A72;( 52015( 797@;( B0/( 6;.4.15>( 9@;01H( 4.147;L( 244.44?.15D( %2A3.( )*D( C( 6;.4.154( 21(

7N.;N0.:( 7/( 5-.( -.2501H( ?.5-794( B?08;7:2N.F( 4739.;01H( 0;71( 219( 6L;76.1( B:05-( 219(

:05-7@5(6325.>>( @4.9(6.;( .P6.;0?.15D( S7;( 5;20101H( 219(?745( .P6.;0?.154F( 5-.( 42?63.4(

:.;.( 401H.9(@401H(2(,ER255( 4739.;01H( 0;71( B&'V#_F(R.;5-.0?F(].;?21L>(7;( 2(6L;76.1(

BR&II&'_F(#6.P(%773(];7@6F(V62;K4F(`105.9(V525.4>D(%-.(-.25.9(506(7/(5-.(4739.;01H(0;71(

:24(6;.44.9(7157( 5-.( /25( 42?63.( 57( ;.3.24.( 5-.(797@;(24(9.48;0A.9(AL( a2;?73@K(.5(23D(

Ba2;?73@KF( .5( 23DF( =+YE>D( %-.( 6L;76.1( 821( A.( 4.5( 25( /0N.( 4.5501H4( ;21H01H( /;7?( ,GE( 57(

GEEb!D(#(452192;9(6L;76.1(:24(@4.9(25(4.5501H(=(/7;(5-.(.P6.;0?.15(71(5-.(87?62;0471(

7/( 5-.( 90//.;.15( -.2501H( ?.5-794F( 219( 25( 4.5501H( =( 219( ,( /7;( 5-.( .N23@25071( 7/( 5-.(

5.8-10823(246.854D(#(?790/0825071(57(5-.(6L;76.1(:24(5.45.9(24(:.33(/7;(5-.(87?62;0471(

7/(90//.;.15(-.2501H(?.5-794D(#(6325.( BC(8?(P(=DG(8?>(:24(25528-.9( 57( 5-.(.19(7/( 5-.(

6L;76.1F(:-08-(:24( 5-.1(-.25.9(AL( 5-.(H24( /32?.(219(6;.44.9(7157( 5-.( /25( 40?032;( 57(

@401H(5-.(506(7/(2(4739.;01H(0;71D(%-.(6.;/7;?218.(7/(5-.(,EJR255(4739.;01H(0;71(:24(2347(

87?62;.9(57(5-25(7/(2(UEJR255(219(XEJR255(4739.;01H( 0;71(7/(5-.(42?.(A;219D(S7;(5-.(

87?62;0471( 7/( 90//.;.15( -.2501H( ?.5-794F( 5-.( ?08;7:2N.( ?.5-79( :24( @4.9( 24( :.33D(

V2?63.4(:.;.(6328.9(01(8374.9(c2;4(219(U(c2;4(:.;.(-.25.9(01(2(?08;7:2N.(25(?2P0?@?(

67:.;( BYEE(R255>( /7;(GE4D(%-.( 4.147;L( 487;.4(:.;.(H0N.1( 0??.9025.3L(2/5.;( ;.?7N01H(

5-.(309D((

CDGD ./0"1%)"&$#2(-"$340(

S0N.( .P6.;0?.154( :05-( 90//.;.15( 7Ac.850N.4( :.;.( [email protected]( V2?63.4( :.;.(

23:2L4( 6;.4.15.9( 01( ;2197?04.9(7;9.;D( O.5:..1( .N.;L( 42?63.( 5-.( 4739.;01H( 0;71(:24(

83.21.9F(.P8.65(:-.1( 5-.(.//.85(7/( 83.2101H( 5-.( 4739.;01H( 0;71(:24([email protected](S7;( 5-.(

87?62;0471( 7/( 90//.;.15( -.2501H( ?.5-794( 219( 5-.( .N23@25071( 7/( 5-.( .//.85( 7/(

-2A05@25071F(5-.(.P6.;54(:.;.(.P674.9(57(5-.(42?.(/;[email protected](7/(A72;(52015(24(/7@19(01(2(

A72;(676@325071<(Ud(45;71H3L(52015.9(219(CGd(?79.;25.3L(52015.9(B#3@:eF(.5(23DF(CEE+>D(

%2A3.()*DC(6;7N09.4(21(7N.;N0.:(7/(5-.(1@?A.;(7/(42?63.4(5-25(:.;.(@4.9(6.;(A72;(52015(

825.H7;L(219( 5-.(-.2501H(?.5-79(5-25(:24(@4.9(6.;(.P6.;0?.15D( )1(233(.P6.;0?.154F(2(

Page 105: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()*(

(

(

+G(

N04@23(21237H@.( 4823.(:05-(218-7;(670154(:24(@4.9( /7;( 487;01H(A72;( 52015( 015.1405L( BS0H(

)*D=>D(

(5%'(67898(:*"(;%-4#2(#&#2+'4"(-<#2"(=%$*(#&<*+1(0+%&$-(4-",(>?($*"("/0"1$-(,41%&'($*"(

$1#%&%&'(#&,($*"(<+&-"<4$%;"("/0"1%)"&$-8((

CDGD=D @+)0#1%-+&(>"$=""&(,%AA"1"&$(*"#$%&'()"$*+,-(

)1(5-04(.P6.;0?.15F(5-.(4.147;L(487;.4(7A5201.9(2/5.;(@401H(/7@;(-.2501H(?.5-794(

:.;.(87?62;.9D(&N.;L(-.2501H(?.5-79(:24(@4.9(71(2(90//.;.15(5.4501H(92L(B4.62;25.9(

AL( =( :..K>( 57( ?010?04.( 2( 67440A3.( .//.85( 7/( -2A05@25071D( %7( 87?62;.( 5-.( 90//.;.15(

-.2501H( ?.5-794( 2( S;0.9?21( 5.45( :05-( 42?63.( 1.45.9( 01( .P6.;5( 24( A378K( /2857;( :24(

26630.9D( $20;:04.( 87?62;0471( A24.9( 71( 5-.( 40H1.9( ;21K( 5.45( :05-( 42?63.( 1.45.9( 01(

.P6.;5(24(A378K(/2857;(:24(2347(@4.9D()1(29905071F(f.19233g4(87;;.325071(87.//080.154(:.;.(

[email protected]( A.5:..1( 5-.( 8718.15;25071( 7/( 219;745.171.F( 4K2573.( 219( 01973.( 219( 5-.(

4.147;L( 487;.4( 7/( 233( 5-.( .P6.;54( 4.62;25.3L( 7;( 87?A01.9( /7;( 5-.( 90//.;.15( -.2501H(

?.5-794D(

CDGDCD :"<*&%<#2(#-0"<$-(+A($*"(-%&'"%&'()"$*+,(

)1( 5-04( .P6.;0?.15( 47?.( 5.8-10823( 246.854( 7/( 5-.( 401H.01H( ?.5-79( :.;.(

[email protected]( S0;45F( 5-.(?2P0?@?( 5.?6.;25@;.(7/( 5-.( 506(7/( 5-;..( 4739.;01H( 0;714( B,EF(UE(

219( XE( R255F( ;.46.850N.3L>( :.;.( ?.24@;.9( :05-( 5-.( 506( 7/( 2( %.457( UEEh( B%.457F(

I.1iK0;8-F( ].;?21Lj( 21( 2662;25@4( :05-( 2( 4@;/28.( 4.147;( :-08-( ?.24@;.4( 5-.(

5.?6.;25@;.( .N.;L( ,( 4.87194>( 219( 87?62;.9( :05-( 5-.( 5-.7;.50823( ?2P0?@?(

5.?6.;25@;.( B24( /7@19( 01( 5-.(?21@23>D( %.?6.;25@;.(:24( 871409.;.9(?2P0?23(:-.1( 05(

:24(452A3.(9@;01H(=E(4.87194(2887;901H(57(5-.(%.457(?.24@;.?.15D(^.24@;.?.154(:.;.(

6.;/7;?.9(25(;77?(5.?6.;25@;.(BCCb!>(219(01(2(:23KJ01(8773.;(BGb!>D(((

%-.(.P6.;54(:.;.(24K.9(57(487;.(5-.( 015.1405L(7/(A72;( 52015(7/(,E(42?63.4(:05-(

5-.( 4739.;01H( 0;71( B,EF( UE( 219( XE( R255>( 219( 5-.( 6L;76.1( B4.5501H( =( 219( ,>( 25( A75-(

!"#"$"%& '(&"!)*'(#+,-)+!-./*

,"$*&-(*0*-1 '(&"!)

Page 106: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

V&ZV['\(#Z#I\V)V<(V)Z]&)Z](^&%"[Q(

(

(

+k(

5.?6.;25@;.4( B%2A3.( )*DC>( 24( /245( 24( 67440A3.( A@5( :05-( 5-.( 1.8.442;L( 255.15071( /7;(

83.2101H(5-.(4739.;01H( 0;71D(%-.(?.24@;.?.154(82;;0.9(7@5(25( ;77?(5.?6.;25@;.(:.;.(

6.;/7;?.9( :05-( 42?63.4( 457;.9( .05-.;( 25( ;77?( 5.?6.;25@;.( BCEb!>( 7;( 25( ;./;0H.;257;(

5.?6.;25@;.( BUb!>D( %-.( 50?.( 1..9.9( 57( 487;.( 2( 42?63.( :24( ;.87;9.9( 219( [email protected](

A24.9(71(2(?0P.9(?79.3(:05-(.P6.;5(24(;2197?(.//.85(219(5-.(90//.;.15(5.?6.;25@;.4(

B7/(42?63.(219(;77?>(219(5-.(90//.;.15(401H.01H(?.5-794(24(/0P.9(.//.854D(

CDGD,D @2"#&%&'($*"(-+2,"1%&'(%1+&(

)1(5-04(.P6.;0?.15F(5-.(.//.85(7/(83.2101H(5-.(4739.;01H(0;71(B,E(R255>(2/5.;(.N.;L(

42?63.(244.44?.15(:24([email protected]([1(5-.(/0;45(92LF(233(/7@;(.P6.;54(487;.9(,E(42?63.4(

B%2A3.()*DC>(5:08.(:05-7@5(83.2101H(5-.(4739.;01H(0;71(2/5.;(.N.;L(@4.D(%-.(42?63.4(:.;.(

5-.1(457;.9(01(2(;./;0H.;257;(BUb!>(/7;(71.(92LD([1(5-.(/7337:01H(92LF(5-.(401H.9(/25(:24(

;.?7N.9(/;7?(.28-(/25(42?63.(219(42?63.4(:.;.(487;.9(2H201(2/5.;(83.2101H(5-.(506(7/(

5-.( 4739.;01H( 0;71( :05-( 626.;( 219( 90401/.8573( B!-.?JI2A( Z*F( l.9.3H.?F( O.3H0@?>(

A.5:..1( .28-( 42?63.D( %:7( 5L6.4( 7/( 42?63.4( :.;.( @4.9<( 42?63.4( :05-7@5( A72;( 52015(

B825.H7;L(E(7;(=>(219(42?63.4(:05-(A72;(52015(B825.H7;L(,(7;(U>D(%-.(.//.85(7/(83.2101H(71(

5-.(?.21( 015.1405L(797@;( 487;.(:24([email protected](AL(2( 40H1.9( ;21K( 5.45F( @401H( 5-.(:05-01(

42?63.J.P6.;5(90//.;.18.(219(5.4501H(:-.5-.;(5-04(90//.;.9(/;7?(i.;7D(&//.85(7/(83.2101H(

:24(2347([email protected](/7;(42?63.4(:05-(219(:05-7@5(A72;(52015(4.62;25.3LF(@401H(5-.(42?.(

5.45D( )1( 29905071F( f.19233g4( 87;;.325071( 87.//080.154( A.5:..1( 5-.( 8718.15;25071( 7/(

219;745.171.F( 4K2573.(219( 01973.(7/( 5-.( 42?.(42?63.4(219( 5-.( 015.1405L(7/(A72;( 52015(

A24.9(71(5-.(90//.;.15(.P6.;54(87?A01.9(7;(4.62;25.3L(:.;.([email protected](

CDGDUD B%&'"%&'(+&($*"(-#)"(02#<"(

%-.( .//.85( 7/( 401H.01H( 5-.( /25( 71( 2( 6328.( 5-25( -29( 23;.29L( A..1( 401H.9( 718.(

A./7;.( AL( 5-.( 4739.;01H( 0;71( B,E(R255>( :24( [email protected]( 9@;01H( 5-04( .P6.;0?.15D( %-0;5L(

;2197?0i.9( 42?63.4( :.;.( 401H.9( 219( 487;.9( /7;( A72;( 52015( 015.1405L( AL( /7@;( .P6.;54(

B%2A3.()*DC>D(#/5.;(2(,E(?01([email protected](5-.(42?.(,E(42?63.4(:.;.(401H.9(2H201(71(5-.(42?.F(

23;.29L(401H.9(6328.(219(487;.9(/7;(A72;(52015(2(4.8719(50?.D(%:7(5L6.4(7/(42?63.4(:.;.(

@4.9<(42?63.4(:05-7@5(A72;(52015(219(42?63.4(:05-(A72;(52015D(%7(.N23@25.(5-.(.//.85(7/(

;.6.25.9(401H.01HF(?.21(4.147;L(487;.4(7/(5-.(/0;45(219(4.8719(401H.01H(:.;.(87?62;.9(

Page 107: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()*(

(

(

+Y(

:05-(2(40H1.9(;21K(5.45F(@401H(5-.(:05-01(42?63.J5.45.;(90//.;.18.(219(5.4501H(:-.5-.;(

5-04(90//.;.9(/;7?(i.;7D(&//.85(7/(;.6.25.9(401H.01H(:24(2347([email protected](/7;(42?63.4(:05-(

219( :05-7@5( A72;( 52015( 4.62;25.3LF( @401H( 5-.( 42?.( 5.45D( )1( 29905071F( f.19233g4(

87;;.3250714(87.//080.154(A.5:..1(5-.(8718.15;25071(7/(219;745.171.F(4K2573.(219(01973.(

7/( 5-.( 42?.( 42?63.4( 219( 5-.( 015.1405L( 7/( A72;( 52015( A24.9( 71( 5-.( 90//.;.15( .P6.;54(

87?A01.9(7;(4.62;25.3L(:.;.([email protected](

CDGDGD !#>%$4#$%+&("AA"<$(

)1( 5-04(.P6.;0?.15(,E(42?63.4(:.;.(244.44.9(,( 50?.4( B@401H( 5-.(,ER(4739.;01H(

0;71>(:05-7@5(2([email protected]("2A05@25071(:24(9.5.;?01.9(AL(87?62;01H(5-.(?.21(A72;(52015(

015.1405L([email protected](7/( 5-.(,E(42?63.4(25( 5-.( /0;45F( 4.8719(N.;4@4(5-0;9(50?.(AL(2(620;(:04.(

87?62;0471( A24.9( 71( 5-.( 40H1.9( ;21K( 5.45D( )1( 29905071F( 5-.( 01/[email protected].( 7/( .N23@2501H( 2(

42?63.(:05-(7;(:05-7@5(A72;( 52015(71(5-.(4.147;L(244.44?.15(7/(2([email protected]@.15(42?63.(

:05-(7;(:05-7@5(A72;(52015(:24(01N.450H25.9(:05-(2(40H1.9(;21K(5.45D((

(

C8 D"-42$-(

)1( H.1.;23F( 5-.( 8718.15;250714( 7/( 5-.( /25( 42?63.4( 825.H7;04.9( 24( E( 7;( =( AL( 5-.(

432@H-5.;-7@4.(.P6.;5(:.;.(233(A.37:(5-.(8@5J7//(N23@.(7/(EDC(?H(KHJ=(/7;(4K2573.(219(=(

?H(KHJ=(/7;(219;745.171.(24(9.5.;?01.9(@671(`J"$I!J^V(2123L4.4D(S7;(825.H7;0.4(,(219(

UF(8718.15;25071(:24(2A7N.(8@5J7//(N23@.(/7;(25(3.245(71.(7/(5-.(87?67@194(B4K2573.(7;(

219;745.171.>(B%2A3.()*D,>D(

,D=D @+)0#1%-+&(>"$=""&(,%AA"1"&$(*"#$%&'()"$*+,-(

%-.( 4.147;L( 487;.4( 90//.;.9( A.5:..1( 5-.( /7@;( -.2501H(?.5-794( B$mEDEE=>D( %-.(

487;.4( 7A5201.9( :05-( 5-.( 6L;76.1( B:05-( 7;( :05-7@5( 6325.>( :.;.( 37:.;( 5-21( 5-74.(

7A5201.9(:05-(5-.(?08;7:2N.(7;(4739.;01H(0;71(B%2A3.()*DU>D((

Page 108: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!

!

Table IV.4: The mean value of sensory score given by the experts with the different heating methods and Kendall’s correlation!!"#$$%!%#&'(

)*#&*"+,(*!"+#("$('-#($".+(#/0#+'*('"1#'-#+(2&3(*#02+2'#4,5(6%'-('-#(!"&!#&'+2'%"&("$('-#(72%&(8"2+('2%&'(!"70".&3*!

"#$%!&'()!(*+,!-*../&/0+!)12/&)3&*2+)!"&/!)*40*.*3"0+56!-*../&/0+!"+!27898:!

! 9"702+%*"&("$(-#2'%&1(7#'-"3(:%!+"62;#( <"43#+%&1(%+"&( =,+"0#&( =,+"0#&(6%'-(042'#(

;/"0!<"51/!

'.!)3'&/!

=>2/&+!?! ?@9A!B!@C9A! D9D!B!@89:! E9F!B!?D98! C98!B!?@98!=>2/&+!@! ?89@!B!?F9F! ?89E!B!@G9?! :9?!B!?G9A! G9E!B!?E9E!=>2/&+!A! :9G!B!?G98! F9@!B!?F98! C9?!B!?@9@! G9C!B!@898!=>2/&+!C! @?9?!B!@G98! @A9?!B!@89E! ?C9:!B!@89:! ?@9?!B!@G9F!H55!/>2/&+)! ?@9A!B!@@9:"! ?@9F!B!@C9?"! E9:!B!?E9A#! E9F!B!?D9G#!

I0-'5/!

=>2/&+!?! 89GF$! 89:G$! 89F@$! 89GD$!

=>2/&+!@! 89:G! 89GD$! 89:C$! 898E!

=>2/&+!A! 89CG! 89GC$! 89CG! 89A@!

=>2/&+!C! 898A! 89:E$! 89C@! 89C@!

H55!/>2/&+)! 89@E$! 89C8$! 89AF$! 89@8!

JK"+'5/!

=>2/&+!?! 89GF$! 89E@$! 89D:$! 89GD$!

=>2/&+!@! 89A@! 89:G$! 89CE$! 898E!

=>2/&+!A! 89G?$! 89E?$! 89G?$! 89A@!=>2/&+!C! 89??! 89E?$! 89:E$! 89:E$!

H55!/>2/&+)! 89@G$! 89C?$! 89AG$! 89?G!

H0-&')+/0'0/!

=>2/&+!?! 89G?$! 89CF$! 89DC$! 89GD$!

=>2/&+!@! 89AC! 89:E$! 89CE$! 89?:!

=>2/&+!A! 89GF$! 89CA$! 89E@$! 89:C$!=>2/&+!C! 898A! 89AG$! 89@?! 89A:!H55!/>2/&+)! 89A:$! 89AE$! 89AC$! 89A:$!

!

Page 109: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()*(

(

(

++(

%,-( ./00-1234/56( 7-38--5( 3,-( 7/20( 32453( 6./0-6( 94:-5( 7;( 3,-( -<=-036( 25>( 3,-(

./5.-530234/5(/?(6@23/1-(25>(45>/1-(26(>-3-0A45->(7;(.,-A4.21(2521;646(8-0-(9-5-0211;(

,49,-0( ?/0( 3,-( 6/1>-0459( 40/5( 25>( =;0/=-5(843,/B3( =123-C( ?/11/8->( 7;( 3,-(A4.0/82:-C(

25>( ?45211;( 3,-( =;0/=-5( 843,( =123-( D%271-( )*EFGE( %,-( ./00-1234/56( 7-38--5( 3,-(

./5.-530234/5(/?(25>0/63-5/5-(25>(3,-(6-56/0;(6./0-6(8-0-(64A4120(?/0(211(?/B0(,-23459(

A-3,/>6E( )5( 9-5-021C( ./00-1234/56(843,( 3,-( ./A=/B5>( ./5.-530234/56(8-0-( 023,-0( 1/8(

D%271-( )*EFGE(%,-(7/20(32453(6./0-6(/73245->(7;(-<=-03(H(/?3-5(./00-123->(7-63(843,(3,-(

./A=/B5>( ./5.-530234/56C( 8,41-( 0-6B136( 8-0-( 023,-0( =//0( ?/0( -<=-03( I( B6459( 3,-(

=;0/=-5(843,(=123-(25>(?/0(-<=-03(F(B6459(3,-(A4.0/82:-E(%,-(./00-1234/56(7-38--5(3,-(

6./0-6(D?/0(3,-(?/B0(-<=-036G(/?(3,-(:204/B6(,-23459(A-3,/>6(8-0-(,49,-63(7-38--5(3,-(

=;0/=-5( 843,/B3( =123-( 25>( 3,-( A4.0/82:-( D'J( KELMGC( 25>( 1/8-63( 7-38--5( 3,-(

A4.0/82:-(25>(6/1>-0459(40/5(D'JKEFMG(D%271-()*ELGE(

!"#$%&!'()*+!,&-.#%%/0!1233&%#452-!12&66515&-4!$&47&&-!48&!.566&3&-4!8&#45-9!:&482.0!!

!

;&#45-9!:&482.! <2%.&35-9!532-! =>32?&-!=>32?&-!7548!

?%#4&!

N4.0/82:-( KEFMO( KELMO( KELKO(

P/1>-0459(40/5( ( KELKO( KELIO(

$;0/=-5( ( ( KEFQO(

O(=RKEKL(

MEIE "&18-51#%!#0?&140!26!48&!05-9&5-9!:&482.!

%,-( 3,-/0-34.21(A2<4ABA( 3-A=-023B0-( /?( 3,-( 6/1>-0459( 40/56( 826( ,49,-0( 3,25(

3,-( /76-0:->( A2<4ABA( 3-A=-023B0-( 8,-5( A-26B0->( 23( 0//A( 3-A=-023B0-C( 25>(

./564>-0271;( ,49,-0( 8,-5( A-26B0->( 23( 0-?049-023/0( 3-A=-023B0-E( #6( -<=-.3->C(

A2<4ABA( 3-A=-023B0-6(8-0-(,49,-0( ?/0( 3,-(,49,( :-06B6( 1/8-0(823329-( 6/1>-0459( 40/5(

D%271-()*ESGE((

%,-( 34A-( 5-->->( 3/( -:21B23-( 3,-( 62A=1-6( :204->( 2../0>459( 3/( 3,-( 6459-459(

A-3,/>(B6->C(3,-(62A=1-(25>(2A74-53(3-A=-023B0-C(25>(3,-(A-3,/>/1/9;(B6->E(TB0459(

3,-( -<=-04A-53C( 8-( 5/34.->( 3,23( 3,0--( -<=-036( 6459->( 3,-( ?23( 8,41-( 3,-;( 6A-11->C(

Page 110: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

P&UPV'W(#U#XWP)PY(P)UZ&)UZ(N&%"VT(

(

(

HKK(

8,-0-26( 3,-( ?/B03,(-<=-03( D-<=-03( MG(B6->(2(>4??-0-53( 0/B345-Y( 6,-( ?4063( 6459->( 3,-( ?23(

25>(3,-5(6A-11->(2?3-0820>6E(%,46(-<=-03(6./0->(3,-(?23(843,(25(2:-029-(/?(MEF(6-./5>6(

D[(KELG( =-0( 62A=1-( 45>-=-5>-53(/?( 3,-(823329-(/?( 3,-( 6/1>-0459( 40/5E( %,-( 3,0--(/3,-0(

-<=-036( 5-->->( 1-66( 34A-( =-0( 62A=1-( 843,( 45.0-26459( 823329-( /?( 3,-( 6/1>-0459( 40/5(

D$RKEKKHG(25>(843,( 45.0-26459( 3,-(6-33459(/?( 3,-(=;0/=-5( ?0/A(H( 3/(M( D$RKEKKHG( D%271-(

)*EQGE(N/0-(34A-(=-0(62A=1-(826(5-->->(?/0(62A=1-6(3,23(,2>(7--5(63/0->(/0(266-66->(

45(3,-(0-?049-023/0(26(./A=20->(3/(3,/6-(266-66->(23(0//A(3-A=-023B0-(D$RKEKKHGE(%,-(

B6-(/?(3,-(\K]^233(6/1>-0459(40/5(92:-(046-(3/(8,23(3,-(-<=-036(0-?-00->(3/(26(2(7B05->(

/>/B0E(%,-(62A-(826(30B-(?/0(3,-(=;0/=-5(23(6-33459(M(8,-5(3,-(62A=1-6(8-0-(266-66->(

23(0//A(3-A=-023B0-(D%271-()*EQGE((

(

"#$%&!'()@+!"8&23&451#%!#-.!:&#0A3&.!:#B5:A:!4&:?&3#4A3&!26!48&!02%.&35-9!532-0C!A0&.!#4!322:!4&:?&3#4A3&!#-.!3&6359&3#423!4&:?&3#4A3&!D&045:#4&!5-!EFG)!

!

;&#45-9!:&482.!

H#B5:A:!

48&23&451#%!

4&:?&3#4A3&!

H&#0A3&.!#4!322:!

4&:?&3#4A3&!DIIEFG!

H&#0A3&.!#4!

3&6359&3#423!

4&:?&3#4A3&!D*EFG!

P/1>-0459(40/5(MK^( M\K( I\H( IHI(

P/1>-0459(40/5(FK^( FIK( MI\( I\L(

P/1>-0459(40/5(\K^( FLK( FKL( MF\(

(

( (

Page 111: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()*(

(

(

HKH(

(

"#$%&!'()J+!KL&3#9&!45:&!48#4!48&!M!&B?&340!-&&.!42!0123&!#!0#:?%&!623!48&!.566&3&-4!02%.&35-9!532-0!#-.!?>32?&-!#4!.566&3&-4!4&:?&3#4A3&0!26!0423#9&!#-.!#00&00:&-4!DN!<OG!!

D&045:#4&!5-!0&1G!!

;&#45-9!:&482.!

H&#0A3&.!#4!322:!4&:?&3#4A3&!H&#0A3&.!#4!

3&6359&3#423!

4&:?&3#4A3&!

<#:?%&!#4!

322:!

4&:?&3#4A3&!

<#:?%&!#4!

3&6359&3#423!

4&:?&3#4A3&!

P/1>-0459(40/5(MK^( MES[KEL( ME+[KEL( FEM[KES(

P/1>-0459(40/5(FK^( IEH[KEF( IES[KEF( IEQ[KEL(

P/1>-0459(40/5(\K^( HE\[KEFO( IEH[KEMO( IEF[KELO(

$;0/=-5(D6-33459(HG( IEL[KEL( IEQ[KEL( FEH[KEL(

$;0/=-5(D6-33459(MG( HE\[KEFO( IEL[KEL( IE+[KEL(

O(7B05->(/>/B0(

MEME P66&14!26!1%&#-5-9!48&!02%.&35-9!532-!

!1-25459(3,-(6/1>-0459(40/5(64954?4.2531;(2??-.3->(3,-(6-56/0;(6./0-6(D$RKEKKHGE()5(

9-5-021( 3,-( A-25( 6-56/0;( 6./0-6( /73245->( 843,( .1-25459( 8-0-( 1/8-0( 3,25( 3,/6-(

/73245->( 843,/B3( .1-25459( D%271-( )*E\GE( %,46( 826( 3,-( .26-( ?/0( 7/3,( 62A=1-6( 843,(

D$RKEKKHG( 25>( 843,/B3( 7/20( 32453( D$JKEKMLGE( %,-( ./00-1234/56( 7-38--5( 3,-( 6-56/0;(

6./0-6(B6459(3,-(6/1>-0459(40/5(25>(3,-(./5.-530234/5(/?(45>/1-(25>(6@23/1-(./A=/B5>6(

26(>-3-0A45->(7;(.,-A4.21(2521;6-6(8-0-(./56463-531;(630/59-0(8,-5(3,-(6/1>-0459(40/5(

826(.1-25->(D%271-()*E\GE(%,-(./00-1234/5(843,(25>0/63-5/5-(826(5/3(2??-.3->E(

MEFE <5-9&5-9!2-!48&!0#:&!?%#1&!

%,-(A-25( 6-56/0;( 6./0-6( /73245->(8,-5( 3,-( ?23(826( 6459->( ?/0( 3,-( ?4063( 34A-(

8-0-(,49,-0(3,25(3,-(6-56/0;(6./0-6(/73245->(8,-5(3,-(?23(826(6459->(2(6-./5>(34A-(23(

3,-(62A-(=12.-(D$JKEKHMC(%271-()*E\GE((

Page 112: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!

!

!

!"#$%&!'()*+!",&!-&#.!/#%0&!12!3&.3145!3614&!78/&.!214!9,&!3#-:%&3!;89,!#.<!;89,109!$1#4!9#8.9!#.<!1/&4#%%=!>&.<#%%?3!6144&%#981.!61&22868&.9!@3&.3145!

3614&!78/&.!$5!9,&!2104!&A:&493!917&9,&4B!;89,!9,&!61.6&.94#981.!12!9,&!-#8.!$1#4!9#8.9!61-:10.<3!!!

"#$%$&!

!'()!*+,-./,!01/2!3144+*+5/!,-),6*1"/,!'*+!,1751416'5/.8!3144+*+5/!

! C%&#.8.7!9,&!31%<&48.7!841.! D8.7&8.7!1.!9,&!3#-&!3:19!

C%&#.8.7! E19F6%&#.8.7! GA!38.7&8.7! HA!38.7&8.7!

9+'5!:'.-+!

,6;*+!

<'=".+,!01/2!);'*!/'15/! &>%?!@!>&%A'! B?%C!@!>D%C)! EB%A!@!AA%?D! E>%F!@!A$%&!

<'=".+,!01/2;-/!);'*!/'15/! >%C!@!F%B'! D%$!@!A$%D)! C%E!@!F%F'! A%F!@!E%D)!

G..!,'=".+,! ?%>!!@!>A%>'! AC%$!@!>&%C)! AC%>!@!>&%?'! AA%A!@!>&%&)!

H;**+.'/1;5!

6;+44161+5/!

I53;.+! $%DFJ! $%CAJ! $%D?J! $%C$J!

<K'/;.+! $%D&J! $%>?J! $%DCJ! $%CAJ!

G53*;,/+5;5+! $%C$J! $%>EJ! $%>&J! $%>BJ!

Page 113: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()*(

(

(

+,-(

%./(/00/12(30(43567/(89:;/9:;(<=8(>/82>912/4(23(8=?@7/8(9:491=2/4(:32(23(13:2=9:(

63=>(2=9:2(A$B,C,DEF(A8=?@7/8(<92.(82>3:;(63=>(2=9:2G($H,C,IFC():(;/:/>=7J(2./(13>>/7=293:(

6/2<//:(2./(8/:83>K(813>/8(A03>(2./(035>(/L@/>28F(=:4(2./(13:1/:2>=293:8(30(8M=237/(=:4(

9:437/( A=8( 4/2/>?9:/4( 6K( 1./?91=7( =:=7K898F( </>/( 6/22/>( <92.( 2./( 09>82( 89:;/9:;(

13?@=>/4( 23( 2./( 8/13:4(89:;/9:;( A%=67/( )*CNFC(%./(13>>/7=293:(<92.(=:4>382/:3:/(<=8(

:32(=00/12/4C(

(

-CIC !"#$%&"%$'()

#( 89;:9091=:2( 4900/>/:1/( <=8( 035:4( 6/2<//:( 2./( 09>82( =:4( 2./( 8/13:4( 813>9:;(

A$O,C,,+F( =:4(6/2<//:( 2./( 09>82( =:4( 2./( 2.9>4( 813>9:;( A$B,C,,PF(45>9:;( 2./( 8=?/(4=KJ(

652(:32(6/2<//:( 2./( 8/13:4(=:4( 2.9>4( 813>9:;( A$H,C,IFC( ):( ;/:/>=7J( 2./(?/=:( 8/:83>K(

813>/8(362=9:/4(45>9:;(2./(8/13:4(A+PCIQDICRF(=:4(2.9>4(813>9:;(A+PCNQ-,C+F(</>/(.9;./>(

2.=:(2./(813>/8(362=9:/4(2./(09>82(29?/(A+-C+QDICRFC((

%./(/00/12(30(/S=75=29:;(=(8=?@7/(<92.(3>(<92.352(63=>(2=9:2(9??/49=2/7K(=02/>(=(

8=?@7/(<92.(3>(<92.352(63=>(2=9:2(<=8(=783(9:S/829;=2/4C(T/(368/>S/4(:3(4900/>/:1/8(03>(

8=?@7/8( <92.352( 63=>( 2=9:2( 813>/4( 9??/49=2/7K( =02/>( =( 8=?@7/( <92.( 3>( <92.352( 63=>(

2=9:2C( ):( ;/:/>=7J( 2./8/( 8=?@7/8( </>/( 813>/4( 9:( 2./( >=:;/( 30( :3( 3>( </=M( 63=>( 2=9:2C(

"3</S/>J( 8=?@7/8( <92.( 63=>( 2=9:2( </>/( ;9S/:( =( 73</>( 8/:83>K( 813>/( <./:( =88/88/4(

9??/49=2/7K(=02/>(=(8=?@7/(<92.(63=>(2=9:2(=8(13?@=>/4(23(<92.352(63=>(2=9:2(A$O,C,,+FC(

%.98(=00/12/4(2./(1=2/;3>98=293:(30(2./(8=?@7/8(=8(</77C(T./:(=(63=>U2=9:2/4(8=?@7/(<=8(

813>/4(49>/127K(=02/>(=(8=?@7/(<92.352(63=>(2=9:2J(=77(8=?@7/8(</>/(813>/4(9:(2./(>=:;/(30(

82>3:;C( "3</S/>J( <./:( =( 63=>( 2=9:2/4( 8=?@7/( <=8( 813>/4( 9??/49=2/7K( =02/>( =:32./>(

8=?@7/(13:2=9:9:;(63=>( 2=9:2J(3:7K(IDV(30( 2./(8=?@7/8(<92.(63=>( 2=9:2(</>/(813>/4(=8(

82>3:;(63=>( 2=9:2J(<.97/(-DV(30( 2./(8=?@7/8(@38929S/( 03>(63=>( 2=9:2(</>/(813>/4( 9:( 2./(

>=:;/( 30( ?34/>=2/( 9:82/=4( 30( 82>3:;J( =:4( +RV( 30( 2./( 8=?@7/8( <92.( 63=>( 2=9:2( </>/(

813>/4(=8(</=M(9:82/=4(30(82>3:;C(

*+ ,$-.&--$'()

):(2.98(8254K(4900/>/:2(@=>=?/2/>8(30(2./(370=123>K(813>9:;(8K82/?(</>/(/S=75=2/4(

9:17549:;( 2./( 13?@=>983:( 30( 4900/>/:2( ./=29:;( ?/2.348J( 2/1.:91=7( =8@/128( 30( 2./(

Page 114: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

W&XWY'Z(#X#[ZW)WG(W)X\&)X\(]&%"Y^(

(

(

+,_(

8374/>9:;( 9>3:J( 2./( /00/12( 30( 17/=:9:;( 2./( 8374/>9:;( 9>3:J( 89:;/9:;( 2./( 8=?/( @7=1/( =:4(

.=6925=293:C((

!3?@=>983:(30(2./(4900/>/:2(./=29:;(?/2.348(9:491=2/4(2.=2(2./(/L@/>28(>/@3>2/4(

73</>(63=>(2=9:2(813>/8(<./:(589:;(2./(@K>3@/:(A<92.(3>(<92.352(@7=2/F(13?@=>/4(23(2./(

?91>3<=S/(3>(8374/>9:;(9>3:C(#(@388967/(/L@7=:=293:(03>(2./(73</>(813>/8(362=9:/4(<92.(

2./( @K>3@/:( ?=K( 6/( 2.=2( 2./( ;=8( >/7/=8/4( 45>9:;( 58/( @=>27K( ?=8M8( 2./( 63=>( 3435>C(

"3</S/>J(13?@=>983:(30(2./(13>>/7=293:(13/00919/:28(6/2<//:(2./(./=29:;(?/2.348(=:4(

2./( 13:1/:2>=293:( 30( 2./( 63=>( 2=9:2( 13?@35:48( 494( :32( 9:491=2/( 73</>( 13>>/7=293:(

13/00919/:28( 03>( 2./( @K>3@/:C( `5>2./>?3>/J( 13>>/7=293:( 6/2<//:( 2./( 035>( 4/2/1293:(

?/2.348( <=8( 13?@=>=67/C( ):( 2./( 8254K( 6K( T.9229:;23:( /2( =7C( AD,++F( 2./( ?91>3<=S/J(

8374/>9:;( 9>3:J( 63979:;( =:4(?/729:;(?/2.348( </>/( 13?@=>/4( =:4( 2./(?91>3<=S/( <=8(

>/@3>2/4(23(6/(2./(@>/0/>=67/(?/2.34(6/1=58/(30(928(89?@79192K(=:4(8@//4C():(2./(@>/8/:2(

8254KJ(.3</S/>J(2./(?91>3<=S/(?/2.34(<=8(7/88(13>>/7=2/4(<92.(2./(13:1/:2>=293:8(30(

8M=237/(=:4(9:437/(9:(13?@=>983:(<92.(2./(8374/>9:;(9>3:(=:4(2./(@K>3@/:(<92.352(@7=2/C(

%./(13>>/7=293:8(6/2<//:(=:4>382/:3:/(=:4(2./(./=29:;(?/2.348(98(89?97=>(03>(2./(035>(

./=29:;( ?/2.348J( 83( 92( 8//?8( 2.=2( =:4>382/:3:/( 98( 7/88( 9:075/:1/4( 6K( 2./( ./=29:;(

?/2.34(58/4( 23( 813>/(63=>( 2=9:2( 9:2/:892KC( W3?/( 9:2>9;59:;(4900/>/:1/8(</>/(368/>S/4(

6/2<//:(2./(/L@/>28(=8(</77C(T./:(=885?9:;(2./(1./?91=7(=:=7K8/8(=8(2./(;374(82=:4=>4(

=:4(<./:(13?@=>9:;(/L@/>2(_(23(2./(32./>(/L@/>28J(/L@/>2(_(8.3</4(@33>(>/85728(589:;(

2./(?91>3<=S/(?/2.34C(&L@/>2(D(8.3</4(2./(6/82(>/85728(<92.(2./(8374/>9:;(9>3:(652(2./(

73</82(13>>/7=293:(<92.(2./(@K>3@/:(<92.(@7=2/C(a/1=58/(/L@/>2(-(.=4(2./(.=6925=293:(30(

09>82(89:;/9:;(2./(0=2(=:4(8?/779:;(=02/><=>48J(9:(13?@=>983:(<92.(2./(32./>(/L@/>28J(92(98(

@388967/(2.=2(83?/(63=>(2=9:2(85682=:1/8(=>/(=7>/=4K(/S=@3>=2/4(6/03>(8?/779:;J(<.91.(

?=K( 7/=4( 23(=( 73</>( 8/:83>K( 813>/C(X32/( 2.=2( 2./( 8374/>9:;( 9>3:(=:4(@K>3@/:(<92.352(

@7=2/(</>/(2./(./=29:;(?/2.348(58/4(23(2>=9:(2./(/L@/>28C(&L@/>2(+J(D(=:4(_(.=4(:/S/>(

58/4( 2./(?91>3<=S/( 6/03>/J( =:4( .=4( 58/4( 2./( 8374/>9:;( 9>3:( 23( =( 7/88/>( 4/;>//( 2./:(

/L@/>2(-C%.98(85;;/828(2.=2(2./(6/82(./=29:;(?/2.34(?=K(4900/>(6/2<//:(@/3@7/(=:4(1=:(

6/(9:075/:1/4(6K(2>=9:9:;C():(2/>?8(30(@>=1291=792KJ(2./(@K>3@/:(.=8(8/S/>=7(=4S=:2=;/8G((

92(98(=@@791=67/(3:(2./(1=>1=88(A9:(13:2>=82(23(2./(?91>3<=S/FJ(92(98(<9>/7/88J(=:4(b(90(58/4(

<92.352(=(@7=2/(b(2./>/(98(:3(>98M(30(3435>(13:2=?9:=293:(0>3?(3:/(8=?@7/(23(2./(:/L2C(

Page 115: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()*(

(

(

+,I(

):4//4J(:3(/S94/:1/(13574(6/(@>3S94/4(2.=2(=22=1.9:;(=(@7=2/(23(2./(@K>3@/:(9?@>3S/4(

928(@/>03>?=:1/(03>(2./(8/:83>K(/S=75=293:(30(63=>(2=9:2C((

%3(2./(6/82(30(35>(M:3<7/4;/J(2.98(98(2./(09>82(>/@3>2(2.=2(4/=78(<92.(2./(2/1.:91=7(

=8@/128( 30( 2./( 89:;/9:;( ?/2.34C( T./:( 589:;( 2./( 89:;/9:;( ?/2.34J( =:( =@@>3@>9=2/(

8374/>9:;( 9>3:( 3>( @K>3@/:( 8/229:;( ?582( 6/( 1.38/:C( ):( ?382( 1=8/8( 29?/( <977( 6/( =:(

9?@3>2=:2(0=123>(03>(2./(1.391/(30(4/S91/C(Y5>(>/85728(4/?3:82>=2/(2.=2(2./(.9;./>(2./(

<=22=;/(30(2./(8374/>9:;(9>3:J(2./(8.3>2/>(2./(29?/(://4/4(23(813>/(2./(8=?@7/8C(a52(=:(

5@@/>(79?92(.=8(6//:(/829?=2/4(6K(589:;(2./(8374/>9:;(9>3:(<92.(=(<=22=;/(=8(.9;.(=8(N,(

T=22(3>(6K(589:;(2./(@K>3@/:(=2(=(.9;.(8/229:;J(=8(92(65>:/4(2./(0=2(9:82/=4(30(?/729:;(92C(

%.98(@>3451/8(=(65>:/4(0=2(3435>J(<.91.(98(5:4/89>=67/(03>(4/2/129:;(63=>(2=9:2(6/1=58/(

2./(65>:/4(3435>(?=K(?=8M(=(@=>2(30(2./(63=>(2=9:2(3435>C(Y5>(>/85728(4/?3:82>=2/(=783(

2.=2( 2./( 2/?@/>=25>/( 30( 2./( 8=?@7/( =:4c3>( 2./( >33?( 9:075/:1/8( 2./( 29?/( ://4/4( 23(

813>/( =( 8=?@7/C( #( 73</>( >33?( =:4c3>( 8=?@7/( 2/?@/>=25>/( :/;=29S/7K( =00/12/4( 2./(

813>9:;( 29?/J( 2.58( 589:;( =( 8374/>9:;( 9>3:( <92.( =( .9;./>( <=22=;/( ?=K( 6/( =@@>3@>9=2/(

5:4/>(851.(13:49293:8C(`9:=77KJ( 2./(1.391/( 03>(=(1/>2=9:(2K@/(30(8374/>9:;( 9>3:(?=K(=783(

4/@/:4(3:(2./(/L@/>2C()2(98(@388967/(2.=2J(03>(2./(8=?/(13:49293:8J(3:/(/L@/>2(<977(58/(2./(

-,UT=22( 9>3:( =:4( =:32./>( <977( @>/0/>( 2./( _,UT=22( 9>3:( 4/@/:49:;( 3:( 2./9>( 3<:(

.=6925=293:C(%.98(?=K(6/(=S394/4(6K(589:;(2./(8=?/(4/S91/(5:4/>(2./(8=?/(13:49293:8(

<./:( 2>=9:9:;( 2./( /L@/>28C( %./(?/2.34( 58/4( 23( 813>/( =( 8=?@7/( =783( 4/@/:48( 3:( 2./(

.=6925=293:(30(2./(/L@/>2C(a32.(?/2.348(A89:;/9:;(2./(0=2(09>82(=:4(8?/779:;(=02/><=>48(

3>(89:;/9:;(2./(0=2(=:4(8?/779:;(=2(2./(8=?/(29?/F(.=S/(@>38(=:4(13:8C("3</S/>J(<./:(

2./(0=2(98(89:;/4(09>82J(2./(>/1/@23>8(9:(2./(:38/(=>/(@>36=67K(7/88(/L@38/4(23(2./(3435>J(

<.91.(?=K( 7/=4( 23( 7/88(.=6925=293:C( )2(<3574(6/( 9:2/>/829:;( 23(/S=75=2/(<.91.(30(632.(

2/1.:9d5/8(98(7/=82(8581/@2967/(23(0=29;5/C(

%<3(@=>=?/2/>8(30(2./(89:;/9:;(?/2.34(</>/(/S=75=2/4(?3>/(1738/7KG(2./(/00/12(

30(17/=:9:;(2./(8374/>9:;( 9>3:(=02/>(/S/>K(58/(3>(:32J(=:4(2./(/00/12(30(89:;/9:;(2./(0=2(

2<91/(=2(2./(94/:291=7(731=293:C(T./:(2./(8374/>9:;(9>3:(<=8(:32(17/=:/4J(/L@/>28(;=S/(=(

.9;./>( 813>/( 23( 8=?@7/8( <92.( 63=>( 2=9:2( =8( </77( =8( 23( 8=?@7/8( <92.352( 63=>( 2=9:2J(

=72.35;.(:5?/>91=7(4900/>/:1/8(</>/(73<C(!3>>/7=293:(13/00919/:28(30(2./(8/:83>K(813>/8(

<92.(2./(13:1/:2>=293:(30(8M=237/(=:4( 9:437/(=8(4/2/>?9:/4(6K(1./?91=7(=:=7K898(</>/(

Page 116: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

W&XWY'Z(#X#[ZW)WG(W)X\&)X\(]&%"Y^(

(

(

+,R(

>/451/4J(<.97/( 2./(13>>/7=293:(13/00919/:2(<92.(=:4>382/:3:/(<=8(:32(=00/12/4C(aK(:32(

17/=:9:;(2./(8374/>9:;(9>3:J(0=2(4>3@7/28(?=K(>/?=9:(3:(2./(85>0=1/(30(928(29@J(<.91.(?=K(

13:2=?9:=2/(=:4(9:075/:1/(2./(813>/8(30(2./(8568/d5/:2(8=?@7/8C(#:32./>(.K@32./898(23(

/L@7=9:( 2./( >/85728(?=K(6/( 2.=2( 2./( >/?=9:9:;( 0=2( 82=>28( 23(65>:C(%./(65>:/4U0=2( 8?/77(

?=K( ?=8M( 2./( 63=>( 2=9:2( 343>( 3>( 1=58/( =( 4/S9=:2( 8?/77( 03>( :3>?=7( 8=?@7/8C( T./:(

89:;/9:;(2./(0=2(2<91/(=2(=:(94/:291=7(8@32J(=(73</>(813>/(<=8(368/>S/4(03>(2./(8=?@7/8(

<92.352( 63=>( 2=9:2( 652( 2./( 813>/( 30( 2./( 8=?@7/8(<92.( 63=>( 2=9:2(<=8( :32( 89;:9091=:27K(

=00/12/4C(W9:;/9:;(=2(2./(8=?/(8@32(2<91/(494(:32(82>3:;7K(=00/12(8/:83>K(813>/8J(:3>(2./(

13>>/7=293:( 13/00919/:2( 6/2<//:( 2./( 813>/8( =:4( 2./( =:4>382/:3:/( 13:1/:2>=293:C(

"3</S/>J(13>>/7=293:(13/00919/:28(<92.(9:437/(=:4(8M=237/(</>/(=783(:/;=29S/7K(=00/12/4(

9:(2.98(/L@/>9?/:2C((

^/8@92/(=( 89?97=>( 13>>/7=293:(6/2<//:( 2./(=:4>382/:3:/(13:1/:2>=293:(=:4( 2./(

8/:83>K(813>/8(=?3:;(=77(30(2./(/L@/>9?/:28J(2./(13>>/7=293:(<92.(2./(13:1/:2>=293:(30(

9:437/(=:4(8M=237/(=:4(2./(8/:83>K(813>/(8//?8(23(6/(?3>/(=00/12/4C(WM=237/(=:4(9:437/(

=>/( ?3>/( >/=497K( >/7/=8/4( 9:23( 2./( ;=8/358( @.=8/( 6/1=58/( 30( 2./9>( 879;.27K( .9;./>(

.K4>[email protected]( =:4( =>/( 2./>/03>/( ?3>/( @37=>( 2.=:( =:4>382/:3:/C( #:4>382/:3:/( 98(

>/2=9:/4( 73:;/>( 9:( 2./( 0=2(?=2>9L( =:4(?=K( 2./>/03>/(/L/>2( =(?3>/( 79:;/>9:;( 9?@=12(3:(

2=9:2(=8(13?@=>/4(23(8M=237/(A[5:482>3?J(/2(=7CJ(D,,PFC(%./(4900/>/:2(1.=>=12/>(30(2./8/(

13?@35:48( 1=:( ;9S/( =( @>/79?9:=>K( /L@7=:=293:( 03>( 2./( 4900/>/:2( /00/128( 8//:( 9:( 2./8/(

/L@/>9?/:28C():(35>(/L@/>9?/:2=7(8/2U5@J(</(03158/4(3:(8=?@7/8(<92.(=:4(<92.352(63=>(

2=9:2( 23( 89?57=2/( 2./( 8925=293:( =2( 2./( 87=5;.2/>( 79:/C( %3( ;/2( ?3>/( 9:89;.28( 9:23( 2./(

4900/>/:2(:=25>/(=:4(/00/128(30(632.(2K@/(30(13?@35:48J(2.98(2K@/(30(/L@/>9?/:28(8.3574(

6/(>/@/=2/4(<92.(=(03158(3:(8=?@7/8(<92.(.9;.(3>(73<(9:437/J(8M=237/(3>(=:4>382/:3:/C((

):(632.(/L@/>9?/:28J(2./(4900/>/:1/8(035:4(3:(2./(?/=:(8/:83>K(813>/8(;9S/:(3:(

=( 81=7/( 0>3?( ,U+,,( @/>( @=>=?/2/>( </>/( >=2./>( 8?=77C( `3>( >/8/=>1.( @5>@38/8( </(

>/13??/:4(17/=:9:;(2./(8374/>9:;(=02/>(/S/>K(8=?@7/(=:4(/:85>9:;(2.=2(8=?@7/8(=>/(:32(

89:;/4( 3:( 2./( 8=?/( @7=1/C( ):( 13??/>19=7( 1=8/8J( 2./( 9?@=12( 30( 2./( /00/12( <977( 6/(

4/2/>?9:/4(6K(2./(152U300(7/S/78(58/4(23(83>2(2./(1=>1=88/8C(`3>(/L=?@7/J(<./:(=(73</>(

813>/(98(;9S/:(23(8=?@7/8(<92.(63=>(2=9:2(6/1=58/(2./(0=2(<=8(89:;/4(2<91/(=2(2./(8=?/(

@7=1/J(2./( 9?@=12(30(2./(/00/12(<977(6/( 79?92/4(<./:(2./(8/13:4(813>/( 98(82977(=63S/(2./(

Page 117: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()*(

(

(

+,E(

152U300( 7/S/7( 58/4( 23( 83>2( 2./( 1=>1=88/8C( a52(<./:( 2./( 813>/( 98( 73</>( 2.=:( 2./( 152U300(

58/4(23(83>2(2./(1=>1=88/8J(1=>1=88/8(<92.(63=>(2=9:2(<977(6/(@>31/88/4(=:4(?=K(7/=4(23(=(

:/;=29S/(13:85?/>(@/>1/@293:C(%.98(@39:28( 23( 2./(5>;/:2(://4( 03>(=(4/09:9293:(30(63=>(

2=9:2C(]3>/(8@/19091=77KJ(=(8/:83>K(2.>/8.374(<92.(>/;=>4(23(13:85?/>(=11/@2=:1/(?582(

6/(4/2/>?9:/4C((

]/9:/>2( AD,++F( S=794=2/4( =( .32( <=2/>( ?/2.34( =8( =( 89?@7/( ./=29:;(?/2.34( 23(

4/2/12(63=>( 2=9:2( =2( 2./( 87=5;.2/>( 79:/C(#8(@=>2(30( 2./(?/2.34(S=794=293:J( 2./(=88/883>(

8/:8929S92K(<=8(/L=?9:/4(=:4(:3(/00/12(30(.=6925=293:(<=8(035:4(=02/>(D,,(8=?@7/8C( ):(

2./(@>/8/:2(8254KJ(.3</S/>J(=:(9:1>/=8/(9:(3435>(9:2/:892K(<=8(035:4(=02/>(-,(8=?@7/8(

<92.( 2./( 8374/>9:;( 9>3:C( #( @388967/( /L@7=:=293:( 98( 2./( 6>/=M( 2=M/:(6/2<//:( 813>9:;( 30(

/=1.(03773<9:;(8=?@7/C():(]/9:/>2e8(8254K(AD,++F(2./(D,,(8=?@7/8(</>/(813>/4(9:(+(4=K(

A=6352(+_,(8/13:48(@/>(8=?@7/F(<.97/(2./(P,(8=?@7/8(30(2./(@>/8/:2(8254K(</>/(813>/4(

9:( =6352( _,( ?9:52/8( A=6352( DE( 8/13:48( @/>( 8=?@7/FC( %./( =88/883>( 9:( 2./( 8254K( 30(

]/9:/>2( AD,++F(.=4(?3>/( 29?/( 23( 17/=:8/( 2./(:38/J(<./>/6K(.=6925=293:(?=K(6/( 7/88(

@>3:35:1/4C(T./:(2./(89:;/9:;(?/2.34(98(58/4(9:(=(87=5;.2/>.358/(=2(=( 79:/U8@//4(30(

R,,(1=>1=88/8(@/>(.35>J(29?/(6/2<//:(2<3(=88/88?/:28(98(=@@>3L9?=2/7K(R(8/13:48C(%./(

@>/8/:2(8254K(8.3<8(2.=2(.=6925=293:(1=:(6/(=(@>367/?(=8(35>(/L@/>28(</>/(/L@38/4(23(

=6352( 2./( 8=?/(@>/S=7/:1/(30( 8=?@7/8(<92.(63=>( 2=9:2( =8( 035:4( 9:(35>(@9;(@3@57=293:(

A_V(82>3:;7K(2=9:2/4J(DIV(?34/>=2/7K(2=9:2/4(A#75<fJ(/2(=7CJ(D,,PFF(=:4(.=4(/S/:(?3>/(

29?/( 2.=:(]/9:/>2e8(/L@/>28C(#(@388967/( 8375293:(?=K(6/( 23(/L@38/( 2./(/L@/>2( 23(63=>(

2=9:2( 8=?@7/8(6/03>/( 8/:83>K( 813>9:;( 82=>28C( W51.(=(?/=85>/(?=K(3S/>13?/( 2./(/00/12(

035:4(9:(2./(09>82(-,(8=?@7/8C(T/(=783(8.3</4(2.=2(<./:(2<3(8=?@7/8(<92.(63=>(2=9:2(

</>/(813>/4(49>/127K(=02/>(/=1.(32./>J(2./(8/13:4(8=?@7/(>/1/9S/4(=(73</>(8/:83>K(813>/(

2.=:(=88/88?/:2(=02/>(=(8=?@7/(<92.352(63=>(2=9:2C(%3(/79?9:=2/(2./(/00/12(30(=(8=?@7/(

<92.(63=>(2=9:2(3:(2./(:/L2(8=?@7/(1=:(6/(362=9:/4(6K(;9S9:;(/L2>=(29?/(23(2./(/L@/>2(23(

17/=:8/(2./(:38/C(

%./8/( 09:49:;8J( <./:( 13?69:/4( <92.( =:( =88/88?/:2( 30( 83?/( 2/1.:91=7( =:4(

73;98291( =8@/128( 30( 89:;/9:;( ?/2.348J( =>/( 58/057( 03>( 4/2/>?9:9:;( 2./( ?382( @>/0/>=67/(

?/2.34(03>(=2U79:/(63=>(2=9:2(4/2/1293:(9:(87=5;.2/>.358/8C("3</S/>J(2./8/(/L@/>9?/:28(

.=S/( 6//:( 13:4512/4( 9:( =( 7=63>=23>K( /:S9>3:?/:2( =:4( 05>2./>( >/8/=>1.( <977( 6/(

Page 118: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

W&XWY'Z(#X#[ZW)WG(W)X\&)X\(]&%"Y^(

(

(

+,N(

:/1/88=>K( 6/03>/( /L2>=@37=29:;( 2./( >/85728( 23( =( 87=5;.2/>.358/( /:S9>3:?/:2C( W/13:4J(

9:2/>:=293:=7( >/8/=>1.( 98( :/1/88=>K( 23( 4/09:/( 2./( 4/09:9293:( 30( 63=>( 2=9:2( =:4( ?3>/(

9?@3>2=:2( 23( 4/2/>?9:/( 2./( 152U300( 23( 83>2( 6/2<//:( 1=>1=88/8( 5:=11/@2=67/( 03>(

13:85?@293:C( %./( 6/82( <=K( 23( ?9:9?98/( 2./( >98M( 30( .=6925=293:( =783( ://48( 05>2./>(

9:S/829;=293:C(

/+ 0'(.1&-$'()

%./( 7=1M( 30( =( S=794=2/4( /7/12>3:91( 4/2/1293:( 8K82/?( .=8( 03>1/4( ?382(

87=5;.2/>.358/8( =:4( >/8/=>1./>8( 23( 58/( =:( 370=123>K( 813>9:;( 8K82/?( 23( /S=75=2/( 63=>(

2=9:2(=2(2./(87=5;.2/>(79:/C():(a/7;95?J(\/>?=:K(=:4(2./(X/2./>7=:48J(=(8374/>9:;(9>3:(98(

?382(13??3:7K(58/4(23(./=2(2./(0=2(=:4(>/7/=8/(2./(63=>(2=9:2(3435>C(%./(@>/8/:2(8254K(

9:491=2/4(2.=2(3:/(8.3574(=S394(>/@/=2/47K(89:;/9:;(2./(0=2(3:(2./(8=?/(8@32C(]3>/3S/>J(

2./( 29@( 30( 2./( 8374/>9:;( 9>3:( 2.=2(?=M/8( 13:2=12(<92.( 2./( 0=2( 8.3574( 6/( 17/=:/4( =02/>(

/S/>K(8=?@7/(23(=S394(13:2=?9:=293:(30(63=>(2=9:2(3435>(6/2<//:(8=?@7/8C(`9:=77KJ(2./(

8@//4(=2(<.91.(8=?@7/8(1=:(6/(=88/88/4(4/@/:48(3:(2./(2/?@/>=25>/(30(2./(8374/>9:;(

9>3:(=:4(3:(2./(=?69/:2(=:4(8=?@7/(2/?@/>=25>/C("3</S/>J(<./:(2./(2/?@/>=25>/( 98(

233(.9;.(3>( 2./(./=29:;( 29?/( 233( 73:;J( 2./(3435>(30(63=>( 2=9:2(?=K(6/(?=8M/4(6K( 2./(

8?/77( 30( 65>:/4( 0=2C( ):( =449293:J( 2./( @K>3@/:( <=8( /S=75=2/4( 03>( 2./( 09>82( 29?/( 9:( 2./(

13:2/L2( 30( =2U79:/( 4/2/1293:( 30( 63=>( 2=9:2C( #72.35;.( 3:( =S/>=;/( 2./( 8/:83>K( 813>/8(

362=9:/4(<./:(589:;(2./(@K>3@/:(A<92.352(@7=2/F(</>/(73</>(A9:491=29:;(7/88(63=>(2=9:2F(

2.=:(<./:(589:;(2./(8374/>9:;(9>3:(3>(2./(?91>3<=S/(?/2.34J(2./(813>/8(13>>/8@3:4/4(

/d5=77K( </77( 23( 2./( 13:1/:2>=293:( 30( 2./( 63=>( 2=9:2( 13?@35:48( =8( 4/2/>?9:/4( 6K(

1./?91=7( =:=7K898C( %./( 8@//4( =2( <.91.( 8=?@7/8( 1=:( 6/( =88/88/4( <92.( 2./( @K>3@/:(

4/@/:48( 3:( 2./( 8/229:;( =:4( 98( 13?@=>=67/( 23( 2.=2( 30( 2./( 8374/>9:;( 9>3:C( %./( ?=9:(

=4S=:2=;/(30(2./(@K>3@/:(=8(13?@=>/4(23(2./(8374/>9:;(9>3:(=>/(2./(/=8/(30(.=:479:;(9:(

=(87=5;.2/>.358/(/:S9>3:?/:2(A6/1=58/(92(98(<9>/7/88F(=:4(2./(7=1M(30(49>/12(13:2=12(<92.(

2./(0=2J(<.91.(/79?9:=2/8(2./(>98M(30(3435>(13:2=?9:=293:C("3</S/>J(<92.(/S/>K(./=29:;(

?/2.34(58/4(03>(8/:83>K(=88/88?/:2(30(63=>(2=9:2(6K(.5?=:(/L@/>28J(3:/(8.3574(2=M/(

9:23( =1135:2( 5:<=:2/4( 9:075/:1/8( 30( 0=29;5/J( .=6925=293:( =:4( 7/S/7( 30( 63=>( 2=9:2( 9:(

@>/1/49:;(8=?@7/8C(

Page 119: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()*(

(

(

+,P(

2+ 3.4('51678696(%-)

%.98( >/8/=>1.(<=8( 05:4/4(6K(=($.^(;>=:2(30( 2./( ):829252/( 03>( 2./($>3?3293:(30(

)::3S=293:( 2.>35;.( W19/:1/( =:4( %/1.:373;K( 9:( `7=:4/>8( A)T%U*7==:4/>/:FC( T/( =>/(

;>=2/057( 23(]C(#54/:=/>2J(!C(a3/S/J(](a3/S/J(%C(^/1>338J('C( [9?@/:8J(WC(]/9>7=/:J(]C(

X=/88/:8J('C($37;=>(=:4(gC(%>5K/:(03>(2./9>(/L1/77/:2(2/1.:91=7(=88982=:1/C( )

Page 120: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

W&XWY'Z(#X#[ZW)WG(W)X\&)X\(]&%"Y^(

(

(

++,(

:+ ;6<6=6(.6-)

#75<fJ(]CJ(]977/2J(WCJ(X9h8J(\CJ(%5K22/:8J(`C(#C(]CJ(*/>./K4/:J(gCJ(^/(a>=6=:4/>J("C(`CJ(^/(

a>=6=:4/>J(^C([CJ(i(*=:(Y/1M/7J(]C(jC(AD,,PFC(#68/:1/(30(=:(/00/12(30(49/2=>K(096>/(

3>(179:3@2973792/(3:(63=>(2=9:2(9:(/:29>/(?=7/(@9;8(0/4(@>=1291=7(49/28C(!"#$%&'(")'"*%+,A-FJ(-_RU-IDC(

aK>:/J(^C( *CJ( %.=?863>;J( WC(]CJ(i("=:8/:J( [C( [C( AD,,NFC( #( 8/:83>K( 4/81>9@293:( 30( 63=>(

2=9:2(=:4(2./(/00/128(30(1>54/(=:4(4>9/4(1.913>K(>3328(A!91.3>95?(9:2K658([CF(=:4(

9:579:(0//49:;(9:(?=7/(=:4(0/?=7/(@3>MC(!"#$%&'(")'"*%-.ADFJ(DIDUDRPC(!3M/>J( ]C( ^CJ( T/82J( 'C( [CJ( a>/:4/?5.7J( jC( "CJ( a>/:4/?5.7J( ^C( ^CJ( j3.:83:J( ^C( ^CJ( i(

W2/7k7/:9J(#C(]C(AD,,PFC(&00/128(30(79S/(</9;.2(=:4(@>31/889:;(3:(2./(8/:83>K(2>=928J(

=:4>382/:/493:/( 13:1/:2>=293:( =:4( IU=7@.=U=:4>382U+RU/:U-U3:/(

A=:4>382/:3:/F(13:1/:2>=293:(9:(63=>(?/=2C(!"#$%&'(")'"*%+,A-FJ(-PPU_,_C(&`W#C( AD,,_FC( T/70=>/( =8@/128( 30( 2./( 1=82>=293:( 30( @9;7/28G( W19/:29091( '/@3>2( 30( 2./(

W19/:29091( $=:/7( 03>( #:9?=7( "/7=2.( =:4(T/70=>/( 3:( =( >/d5/82( 0>3?( 13??98893:(

>/7=2/4(23(</70=>/(=8@/128(30(2./(1=82>=293:(30($9;7/28C(/0"%12&3%4567)#8*%.9J(+U+NC(`>/4>9M8/:J(aCJ(`3:2(9(`5>:378J(]CJ([5:482>3?J(gCJ(]9;4=7J(TCJ($>5:9/>J(#CJ(%5K22/:8J(`C(#C(

]CJ(i(a3::/=5J(]C( AD,,PFC( $>=1291/(3:( 1=82>=293:(30( @9;7/28( 9:( &5>3@/C(3)(:#8*%;A++FJ(+_N,U+_NEC(

"=:8/:J([C([CJ(W237k/:6=1.J(WCJ(j/:8/:J(jC(#CJ("/:1M/7J($CJ("=:8/:U]377/>J(jCJ(WK>93@35738J(

gCJ(i(aK>:/J(^C(*C( AD,,NFC(&00/12(30( 0//49:;( 0/>?/:2=67/( 096>/U>91.( 0//4825008(3:(

?/=2(d5=792K(<92.( /?@.=898( 3:( 1./?91=7( =:4( 8/:83>K(63=>( 2=9:2( 9:( /:29>/(?=7/(

=:4(0/?=7/(@9;8C(!"#$%&'(")'"*%+<A_FJ(++RIU++E-C("=5;/:J( jC( &CJ( a>5:958J(!CJ(i(l=?=>=28M=9=J(\C( AD,+DFC('/S9/<(30( =:=7K291=7(?/2.348( 23(

?/=85>/( 63=>( 2=9:2( 13?@35:48( 9:( @3>19:/( =49@38/( 29885/G( %./( ://4( 03>(

.=>?3:98/4(?/2.348C(!"#$%&'(")'"*%.<A+FJ(PU+PC(j=>?375MJ([CJ(]=>29:J(#C("CJ(i(`>/4//:J("C(%C(A+PE,FC(^/2/1293:(30(2=9:2(A8/L(343>F(9:(@3>MC(

=#)#>(#)%4567)#8%5?%3)(:#8%&'(")'"*%@<A-FJ(EI,C([5:4/J(gCJ( WM52/>54J( &CJ( &;/7=:484=7J(aCJ( `3:2( 9( `5>:378J(]CJ(X52/J(\C('CJ(a/h/>.37?J(!CJ(

X978/:J( #CJ( W2/:82>3?J( ZC( "CJ( i( "/>87/2.J( ]C( AD,+,FC( %./( 9?@3>2=:1/( 30( 2./(

>/1>592?/:2( ?/2.34( 03>( =:4>382/:3:/( 8/:8929S92K( <92.( >/8@/12( 23( =115>=2/(

8/:83>K(/S=75=293:(30(=:4>382/:3:/(2=9:2/4(?/=2C(255>%A6#8($B%#)>%C7"?"7")'"*%,9ARFJ(R_NURI_C(

[5:482>3?J( gCJ(]=22./<8J( gC( 'CJ( i( "=5;/:J( jC( &C( AD,,PFC( $9;(?/=2( d5=792K( 0>3?( /:29>/(

?=7/8C(3)(:#8*%;A++FJ(+_PEU+I,EC(]=2.5>J($C(gCJ(%/:(X=@/7J(jCJ(a73/?.30J(WCJ("/>/8J([CJ(g:37J(&C(`CJ(i(]574/>J("C(#C(AD,+DFC(#(

.5?=:(:38/(813>9:;(8K82/?(03>(63=>(2=9:2(=:4(928(>/7=293:8.9@(<92.(=:4>382/:3:/(

=:4(8M=237/C(!"#$%&'(")'"*%.9J(_+_U_DDC(]/9:/>2J([C( AD,++FC(*=794=293:(30(m.5?=:(:38/m(?/2.34(03>(63=>(2=9:2(4/2/1293:C(D5#7E%

0"#>()F%?57%,<9+*%G"$0"78#)>*%3:E$"7>#:*%,%H"'":I"7J(PC(

Page 121: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()*(

(

(

+++(

$=>5:3S91J( XCJ( $/2>3S91J( ]CJ( ]=2/M=73UWS/>=MJ( *CJ( $=>5:3S91J( jCJ( i( '=43S91J( !C( AD,+,FC(

'/7=293:8.9@(6/2<//:(!=>1=88(T/9;.2J(WM=237/([/S/7(=:4(W/:83>K(#88/88?/:2( 9:(

`=2(30(^900/>/:2(a3=>8C(=J"'0%4567)#8%5?%255>%&'(")'"E*%,+ARFJ(ID,UI-,C($=57KJ(!CJ(W@>9:;UW2=/.79J($CJ(Yn^3./>2KJ(jC(*CJ(g>=;2/:J(WC(#CJ(^56398J(WCJ(]/88=4/:/J(jCJ(i(

a//J(\C(AD,+,FC(%./(/00/128(30(?/2.34(30(1=82>=293:J(>/=>9:;(13:49293:(=:4(49/2(3:(

8/:83>K( d5=792K( 30( @3>M( =88/88/4( 6K( =( 2>=9:/4( @=:/7C(!"#$% &'(")'"*% +KADFJ( _PNUI,_C(

$>58=J(gCJ(X/4/>S/74J("CJ('5::/78J($C([CJ([9J('CJ(g9:;J(*C([CJ(i(!>=:/J(jC($C(AD,++FC($>/S=7/:1/(

=:4(>/7=293:8.9@8(30(8/:83>K( 2=9:2J(I(=7@.=U=:4>382/:3:/(=:4(8M=237/( 9:( 0=2(=:4(

7/=:( 29885/( 0>3?( 2./( 739:( A[3:;9889?58(43>89F( 30( 6=>>3<8J( ;9728J( 83<8J( =:4(63=>8(

0>3?(8/7/12/4(=6=2239>8(9:(2./(o:92/4(W2=2/8C(!"#$%&'(")'"*%++A+FJ(PRU+,+C(WM>7/@J( ]CJ( W/;57=J( aCJ( $>/S37:9MJ( ]CJ( g9>698J( #CJ( `=k=>9:1J( \CJ( i( !=:4/MU$323M=>J( ]C(

AD,+,FC( &00/12( 30( 9??5:31=82>=293:( A)?@>3S=1( A'FF( 9:( 0=22/:9:;( @9;8( ))G( 1=>1=88(

2>=928(=:4(?/=2(d5=792KC(&85L")(#)%M"$"7()#7B%N"E"#7'0*%O-ADFJ(RIUEDC(*=.75:J(WC(A+PP-FC($'Y^o!%)YX(Y`(&X%)'&(]#[&($)\W()X(^&X]#'gC(28"(E'0P(7$E'0#?$*%

-;A_FJ(__IU__NC(*=:.3:=1M/>J(`CJ(*/>6/M/J(TCJ(i(%5K22/:8J(`C(#C(]C(AD,,PFC(a/7;9=:(13:85?/>8n(=229254/(

23<=>48( 85>;91=7( 1=82>=293:( =:4( 9??5:31=82>=293:( 30( @9;7/28C( 3)(:#8% Q"8?#7"*%9+A_FJ(-E+U-N,C(

T.9229:;23:J( `C(]CJ( l=??/>9:9J(^CJ(X52/J(\C('CJ( a=M/>J(#CJ("5;./8J( WC( )CJ(i(T334J( jC(^C(

AD,++FC( !3?@=>983:( 30( ./=29:;( ?/2.348( =:4( 2./( 58/( 30( 4900/>/:2( 29885/8( 03>(

8/:83>K(=88/88?/:2(30(=6:3>?=7(3435>8(A63=>(2=9:2F( 9:(@9;(?/=2C(!"#$%&'(")'"*%++ADFJ(D_PUDIIC(

Page 122: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

(

(

(

(

( (

Page 123: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

Chapter V

Gas chromatography coupled to sniff mass spectrometry and ultra high performance liquid chromatography coupled to high resolution mass spectrometry to unravel boar taint

contributing compounds

Page 124: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

(

'/4>=02/4(=02/>G(

(

M64"6=%) N+E+J( jC( *=:4/:(a5881./( jCJ( S=:(T=;/:6/>;( !C$C#CJ( 4/( j3:;( !CJ( *=:("/:4/( jCJ(

"/>/8( [CJ( %5K22/:8( `C#C]CJ( *=:4/:4>9/881./( `C( i( *=:.=/1M/( [C( AD,+DFC( \=8(

1.>3?=23;>[email protected](135@7/4(23(8:900(?=88(8@/12>3?/2>K(=:4(572>=(.9;.(@/>03>?=:1/(

79d594(1.>3?=23;>[email protected](135@7/4(23(.9;.(>/8375293:(?=88(8@/12>3?/2>K(23(5:>=S/7(

63=>(2=9:2(13:2>96529:;(13?@35:48C(#:=7K291=(!.9?91=(#12=(A856?922/4F(

(

Page 125: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'(*(

(

(

++I(

)

0!3>?@;)A)

B3C)0!;DE3?DB;3>!F)0DG>H@,)?D)CIJKK)E3CC)C>@0?;DE@?;F)3I,)GH?;3)!JB!)>@;KD;E3I0@)

HJLGJ,)0!;DE3?DB;3>!F)0DG>H@,)?D)!JB!);@CDHG?JDI)E3CC)C>@0?;DE@?;F)?D)GI;3A@H)MD3;)

?3JI?)0DI?;JMG?JIB)0DE>DGI,C)

(

!"#$%&'$()

a3=>(2=9:2(98(=:(300U3435>(=:4(300U07=S35>(2.=2(1=:(3115>(<./:(?/=2(3>(0=2(0>3?(

/:29>/(?=7/8(98(./=2/4C(%./(?=9:(13?@35:48(>/8@3:8967/(03>(2.98(3435>(=>/(8M=237/(=:4(

=:4>382/:3:/(=:4(23(=(7/88/>(4/;>//(9:437/C("3</S/>J(2./(13:1/:2>=293:(7/S/78(30(2./8/(

13?@35:48(43(:32(13?@7/2/7K(=1135:2(03>(2./(3115>>/:1/(30(63=>(2=9:2(=8(4/2/>?9:/4(

6K(8/:83>K(=:=7K8/8C(#(@7=58967/(/L@7=:=293:(03>(2.98(<3574(6/(2./(13:2>965293:(30(32./>(

p5:M:3<:e(13?@35:48(23(63=>(2=9:2C( ):(2.98(8254KJ(=(2<3U<=K(82>=2/;K(<=8(03773</4(23(

/L@73>/(2.98(.K@32./898C(`9>827KJ(=:(5:2=>;/2/4(=@@>3=1.(<=8(03773</4(589:;(\!UW:900U]WC(

%.98(>/8572/4(9:(2./(94/:29091=293:(30(/9;.2(:/<(13?@35:48(2.=2(?=K(13:2>9652/(23(63=>(

2=9:2C(W/13:47KJ(@382U=1d5989293:(>/U9:2/>>3;=293:(30(=(4=2=8/2(30(63=>(2=9:2(@38929S/(=:4(

:/;=29S/(8=?@7/8(<=8(@/>03>?/4(589:;(.9;.(>/8375293:(]WC(#(2=>;/2/4(81>//:9:;(30(2./(

13?@35:48(94/:2909/4(45>9:;(2./(09>82(@=>2(30(2./(8254K(=:4(@>/S9358(792/>=25>/(09:49:;8(

589:;(%3L)^(8302<=>/(94/:2909/4(2<3(=449293:=7(13?@35:48(2.=2(</>/(13>>/7=2/4(A'D(>/8@C(

,C+,I( =:4( ,C,EIF( 23( 63=>( 2=9:2J( :=?/7K( _J+RU=:4>382=49/U-U3:/( =:4( 983S=7/>91( =194C(

T92.9:(2.98(4=2=8/2(REV(30(4/(8/:83>K(813>/(98(/L@7=9:/4(6K(8M=237/(=:4(=:4>382/:3:/C(

%.98('(8d5=>/(43/8(.3</S/>(:32(9:1>/=8/(<./:(2./(32./>(13?@35:48(=>/(=44/4C(X/L2J(

=:( 5:2=>;/2/4( @382U=1d5989293:( 81>//:9:;( 30( 2./( 8=?/( 4=2=8/2J( 589:;( 4900/>/:29=7( =:4(

Y$[WU^#(=:=7K8/8(/:=67/4(2./(/75194=293:(30(/9;.2(63=>(2=9:2(13:2>96529:;(13?@35:48J(

9:17549:;(2./(2.>//(/82=6798./4(63=>(2=9:2(13?@35:48C():(232=7(89L(:/<(13?@35:48(</>/(

94/:2909/4(=8( 13>>/7=2/4( 23(63=>( 2=9:2J(<92.('D(>=:;9:;( 03>?(,C+_D( 23(,C_D_C( WM=237/J( RU

?/2.3LK9:437/(=:4(=(:/<7K(5:94/:2909/4(93:(1=:(/L@7=9:(INV(30(2./(8/:83>K(813>/(30(2.98(

4=2=6=8/C(

Page 126: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

W!'&&X)X\(`Y'(oXgXYTX(aY#'(%#)X%(!Y]$YoX^W(

(

(

++R(

O+ J(%='7&.%$'()

X3<=4=K8J(2./(58/(30(/:29>/(?=7/(@9;8(03>(@3>M(@>3451293:(98(79?92/4(6/1=58/(30(

2./( @32/:29=7( 3115>>/:1/( 30( 63=>( 2=9:2J( =:( 300U3435>( =:4( 300U07=S35>( 9:( ?/=2C( ):( 2.98(

13:2/L2J( 2<3( 13?@35:48J( 8M=237/( =:4( =:4>382/:3:/J( =>/( 13:894/>/4( =8( 2./( ?=9:(

13:2>96529:;(13?@35:48(23(63=>(2=9:2C():(+PRNJ($=22/>83:(A+PRNF(9837=2/4(=:4(94/:2909/4J(

589:;(?=88(8@/12>3?/2>KJ(IqU=:4>382U+RU/:/U-U3:/(=8(=(>/8@3:8967/(13?@35:4(03>(2./(

3435>( 30( ./=2/4( 8.3574/>J( 6=1M( =:4( >5?@( 0=2( 30( ?=25>/( 63=>8C( #:4>382/:3:/( 98( =(

82/>394=7(13?@35:4(@>9?=>97K(8K:2./89k/4(9:(63=>(2/82/8(Aa=637(i(Wd59>/8J(+PPIFC(W3?/(

K/=>8(7=2/>J(8M=237/J(09>82(9837=2/4(0>3?(63=>(0=2(6K(*374(A+PE,F(=:4(T=782>=(=:4(]==>8/(

A+PE,FJ(<=8(=783(>/7=2/4(23(2./(3115>>/:1/(30(63=>(2=9:2(Aa=637(i(Wd59>/8J(+PPIFC((

"3</S/>J(2./9>(7/S/7(30(13:2>965293:(23(63=>(2=9:2(98(=(856h/12(30(498158893:C(%./8/(

2<3( 13?@35:48( 43( :32( 13?@7/2/7K( =1135:2( 03>( 2./( 3115>>/:1/( 30( 63=>( 2=9:2( =8(

4/2/>?9:/4(6K( =( 2>=9:/4( 8/:83>K(@=:/7( A$=57K( /2( =7CJ( D,+,FC( !3/00919/:28( 30( 13>>/7=293:(

6/2<//:(=:4>382/:3:/(7/S/78(9:(0=2(=:4(63=>(2=9:2(9:2/:892K(=88/88/4(6K(2>=9:/4(/L@/>2(

@=:/78( >=:;/4( 0>3?( ,C_+( 23( ,CER( =:4( 03>( 8M=237/( 0>3?( ,CD,( 23( ,CI-( Aa3::/=5J( +PNDFC(

W/S/>=7( 0=123>8(?=K( /L@7=9:( 2./8/( >=2./>( 73<( 13>>/7=293:8( 362=9:/4( 83( 0=>C( `9>827KJ( 2./(

?=h3>92K(30(2./(S=>9=293:(9:(2./(8/:83>K(4/81>9@293:(30(63=>(2=9:2J(>/85728(0>3?(9:49S945=7(

S=>9=293:(368/>S/4( 9:(2>=9:/4(/L@/>28(=:4(2./9>(8/:8929S92K(23(2./( 9:49S945=7(13?@35:48(

1=589:;(63=>(2=9:2(AT/97/>(/2(=7CJ(+PPEFC(^900/>/:1/8(9:(?/2.34373;K(58/4(03>(2./(8/:83>K(

=88/88?/:2( 30( 3435>8( Aa3::/=5J( +PP-FJ( 9:17549:;( 8/7/1293:( =:4( 2>=9:9:;( 30( @=:/7(

?/?6/>8( =:4( @>/@=>=293:( =:4( @>/8/:2=293:( 30( 8=?@7/8J( ?=K( =783( 6/( 9?@3>2=:2C(

W/13:47KJ(2./>/(=>/(?=:K(1./?91=7(4/2/1293:(?/2.348(23(d5=:290K(63=>(2=9:2(=S=97=67/J(

652( <92.( S=>K9:;( S=79492KC( #( S=794( d5=:292=29S/( ?/2.34( 9?@79/8( =( >/@/=2=69792K( 30(

?=L9?5?( +IV( =:4( =( >/@>3451969792K( 30( ?=L9?5?( D,V( A&5>3@/=:( !3??5:92KJ(

D,,DFCY:7K( =( 0/<( ?/2.348( .=S/( 6//:( 8500919/:27K( 9:U.358/( S=794=2/4( <92.( >/;=>4( 23(

4315?/:2=293:(30(@/>03>?=:1/(1>92/>9=( A!.=@2/>( )))r( `981./>(/2(=7CJ( D,++r(*/>./K4/:(/2(

=7CJ(D,,EFC(]3>/3S/>J(?382(?/2.348(8500/>(0>3?(=(7=1M(30(>/0/>/:1/(23(300919=7(;594/79:/8(

A"=5;/:( /2( =7CJ( D,+DFC( %.9>47KJ( 2./( 7=1M( 30( 13:8982/:1K( 6/2<//:( >/85728( 362=9:/4( 0>3?(

S=>9358( 82549/8J( ?=K( =783( >/8572( 0>3?( 4900/>/:1/8( 9:( =:4>382/:3:/( =:4( 8M=237/(

Page 127: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'(*(

(

(

++E(

13:1/:2>=293:8( 30( 2./( =:9?=7( @3@57=293:8( 0>3?( <.91.( 2./( 8=?@7/8( </>/( 4/>9S/4( =:4(

0>3?( 2./( 9:49S945=7( S=>9=293:( 6/2<//:( @3>19:/( 1=>1=88/8( 9:( 2./( 7/S/7( 30( 63=>( 2=9:2(

13?@35:48(A&`W#J(D,,_FC(^/@/:49:;(30(2./(8254K(=783(9:2>=1=>1=88(S=>9=293:(?=K(@7=K(=(

>37/( 9:( 2./( 13>>/7=293:8( 4/2/>?9:/4( 03>( 8M=237/( =:4( =:4>382/:3:/C( !7=58( A+PEIF( =:4(

]=7?03>8(/2(=7C(A+PERF(368/>S/4(89?97=>(9:2>=1=>1=88(4982>965293:(30(=:4>382/:3:/(7/S/78(

9:(0=2C(%.98(9:(13:2>=82(<92.(#:4>/8/:(/2(=7C(A+PEIF(<.3(?/=85>/4(89;:9091=:2(4900/>/:1/8(

6/2<//:(2./(:/1M(=:(75?6=>(>/;93:8(A"=5;/:(/2(=7CJ(D,,IFC(T/97/>(/2(=7C(A+PPIF(>/@3>2/4(

:3(89;:9091=:2( 9:2>=1=>1=88(S=>9=293:(03>(8M=237/(=:4(9:437/C("=5;/:(/2(=7C( AD,,IF(3:(2./(

32./>(.=:4(4/2/12/4(S=>9=293:8(30(I(23(DIV(=:4(I(23(DDV(03>(=:4>382/:3:/(=:4(8M=237/J(

>/8@/129S/7KJ(2.>35;.352(2./(:/1M(0=2(1>388(8/1293:C(%./(13:1/:2>=293:8(4/1>/=8/4(0>3?(

2./( 9::/>(A?5817/(894/F(23(2./(352/>(A8M9:( 7=K/>F(0=2( 7=K/>8(=:4(1>388(8/1293:=7(S=>9=293:(

8//?/4(;>/=2/>(<92.(9:1>/=89:;(7/S/78(30(=:4>382/:3:/(=:4(8M=237/C(

):(8@92/(30(2./8/(@388967/(/L@7=:=293:8(<92.(>/8@/12(23(2./(4/2/1293:(2/1.:9d5/8(

=@@79/4J( 2./( @388969792K( 30( =449293:=7( 13?@35:48( 13:2>96529:;( 23( 63=>( 2=9:2( ?582( 6/(

2=M/:( 9:23(=1135:2C( ):(+PRNJ($=22/>83:( A+PRNF(=7>/=4K( >/13;:98/4( 2.=2( 2./>/(=>/(32./>(

3435>8(=88319=2/4(<92.(2./(?=25>/(63=>(=:4(2.=2(2./8/(?=K(=783(9:075/:1/(2./(;/:/>=7(

3435>( @/>1/@293:( 30( ./=2/4( 63=>( 07/8.C( $=22/>83:( A+PREF( 4/81>96/4( 2./( @388967/(

13:2>965293:(30(@./:3791(13?@35:48(23(63=>(3435>J(?=9:7K(@U1>/837(=:4(_U/2.K7@./:37C(

%.98( 343>358( @./:3791( 0>=1293:( 30( 63=>( @>/@529=7( 07594( <=8( =:=7K8/4( 6K( ;=8U79d594(

1.>3?=23;>[email protected](T=283:(/2(=7C( A+PNDF(=88319=2/4(2./(@>/8/:1/(30(+J_U491.73>36/:k/:/(

<92.(2./(4/S/73@?/:2(30(2=9:2(9:(@9;(0=2(8=?@7/8C(#:4>382/:3:/(6/73:;8(23(sU+R(82/>3948(

=:4( 32./>( 85682=:1/8( 9:( 2.98( ;>35@(?=K( =783( 13:2>9652/( 23( 63=>( 2=9:2( =8( >/S9/</4( 6K(

!7=58( A+PEPF( A&`W#J( D,,_FC( %./( 3435>( 30( 2./( =:4>382/:3:/8( 98( 4/81>96/4( =8( =( 5>9:=>K(

3435>( AItU=:4>382U+RU/:U-qU3:/( =:4( _J+RU=:4>382=49/:U-U3:/F( <./>/=8( 2./(

=:4>382/:378( =>/(?3>/( >/7=2/4( 23(?58MK( 3435>8( AIqU=:4>382U+RU/:U-qU37J( IqU=:4>382U

+RU/:U-tU37(=:4(IJ+RU=:4>382=49/:U-tU37F( Aa>33M8(i($/=>83:J(+PNPr(&`W#J(D,,_FC(]3>/(

>/1/:27KJ('958(=:4(\=>19=U'/;5/9>3(AD,,+F(94/:2909/4(2./(13?@35:4(_U@./:K7U-U652/:UDU

3:/(9:(@9;(0=2(8=?@7/8(17=88909/4(=8(2=9:2/4J(652(13:2=9:9:;(73<(13:1/:2>=293:8(30(8M=237/(

=:4(=:4>382/:3:/C(W/:83>K(=:=7K8/8(1=>>9/4(352(6K('958(/2(=7C(A'958(/2(=7CJ(D,,IF(>/S/=7/4(

2.=2( _U@./:K7U-U652/:UDU3:/( 13574( @>3?32/( 2./( :/;=29S/( @/>1/@293:( 30( 8M=237/( =:4(

Page 128: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

W!'&&X)X\(`Y'(oXgXYTX(aY#'(%#)X%(!Y]$YoX^W(

(

(

++N(

=:4>382/:3:/J(3>(13574(6/(>/8@3:8967/(03>(2./(4/S/73@?/:2(30(300U07=S35>8(<92.(89?97=>(

=22>9652/8(23(2.38/(58/4(23(4/81>96/(2./(@>/8/:1/(30(63=>(2=9:2( 9:(@3>M(8=?@7/8C( ):(2./(

8=?/(8254KJ( 2./(13:1/:2>=293:(30(32./>(S37=297/(13?@35:48( A=74/.K4/8J(=79@.=291(8.3>2(

1.=9:(0=22K(=1948(=:4(83?/(=713.378(=:4(M/23:/8F(9:(2./(9:S/829;=2/4(0=2(8=?@7/8(<=8(:32(

89;:9091=:27K(4900/>/:2(6/2<//:(2.38/(8=?@7/8(17=88909/4(=8(2=9:2/4(6K(2./(8/7/12/4(/L@/>2(

=:4( 2./( 13:2>378C( "3</S/>J( 82K>/:/( =:4( +J_U491.73>36/:k/:/J( 13?@35:48( 2.=2( ?=K(

3>9;9:=2/( 0>3?( /L2/>:=7( 13:2=?9:=293:J( 8.3</4( .9;./>( 13:1/:2>=293:8( 9:( 8=?@7/8(

17=88909/4( =8( 2=9:2/4( =8( 13?@=>/4( 23( 13:2>37( 8=?@7/8J( 9?@7K9:;( 2.=2( 2./8/( 13?@35:48(

13574( .=S/( 6//:( >/8@3:8967/( 03>( 2./( 4/S/73@?/:2( 30( 83?/( 300U07=S35>8( A'958( /2( =7CJ(

D,,IFC((

):(2./(@>/8/:2(8254K(=(2<3U<=K(82>=2/;K(<=8(03773</4(23(/L@73>/(2./(=885?@293:(

2.=2( 32./>( 13?@35:48(?=K( /L@7=9:( 03>( 2./( 73<( 13>>/7=293:8( 368/>S/4( 83( 0=>( 6/2<//:(

8/:83>K(63=>(2=9:2(=:=7K898(=:4(=:4>382/:3:/(=:4(8M=237/(13:1/:2>=293:8(362=9:/4(5@3:(

1./?91=7(=:=7K898C(%3(2.98(/L2/:2J(=:(5:2=>;/2/4(81>//:9:;(03>(5:M:3<:(13?@35:48(<=8(

@/>03>?/4(=2(X)lY(0334(>/8/=>1.(589:;(\!UW:900U]WC(X/L2J(13?@35:48(0>3?(2.98(8254K(

=:4(@>/S9358( 792/>=25>/(09:49:;8(</>/(13?69:/4(=:4(=(@382U=1d5989293:(>/U9:2/>>3;=293:(

30( 4=2=( 1377/12/4( 0>3?( =( S=82( 4=2=8/2( 30( 0=2( 8=?@7/8( 3:( "']W( <=8( /L/152/4( 23(

82=298291=77K( /S=75=2/( 2./( @32/:29=7( =449293:=7( 13>>/7=293:( 2.=2( 2./8/( @>/4/09:/4(

5:M:3<:8( ?=K( /L@7=9:( 03>C( `9:=77K( 2./( 8=?/( 4=2=8/2( <=8( =@@79/4( <92.9:( =( 81>//:9:;(

=@@>3=1.( 23( 8/=>1.( 03>( 5:M:3<:( 13?@35:48( 589:;( 2./("']W(4=2=8/2( =:4( 8@/19=79k/4(

8302<=>/C(

(

P+ E"%6=$"1)"(7)96%Q'7-)

DC+C G(%"=86%67)-.=66($(8)<'=)&(4('5(-)&-$(8)B0RC($<<REC)

DC+C+C C"9S16-)

`>3k/:(?/=2(8=?@7/8(<92.( 7=>4(30( 2/:(/:29>/(?=7/(@9;8(</>/(@>/8/7/12/4( 9:( 2./(

87=5;.2/>.358/( 30( 2./( *)YX( `334( \>35@( A&9:4.3S/:J( %./( X/2./>7=:48FC( %./( 8=?@7/8(

</>/( 813>/4( 03>( 2./(@>/8/:1/(30( 63=>( 2=9:2( =113>49:;( 23( 2./(?/2.34(30(]=2.5>( /2( =7C(

Page 129: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'(*(

(

(

++P(

AD,+DF( 6K( 09S/( /L@/>28( =:4( 49S94/4( 9:23( 2<3( ;>35@8G( =( 13:2>37( ;>35@( 30( 09S/( 8=?@7/8(

<92.352(63=>(2=9:2(3435>(=:4(=(;>35@(30(09S/(8=?@7/8(<92.(=(82>3:;(23(S/>K(82>3:;(63=>(

2=9:2(3435>C(

DC+CDC B0RC($<<)S"(61)

%.>//( /L@/>28( 1=>>9/4( 352( 2./( 8/:83>K( /S=75=293:( 45>9:;( 2./(\!UW:900( =:=7K8/8C(

%./K(</>/(>/1>592/4(0>3?(2./(X)lY(ADF(=:4(0>3?(*)YX(A+FC(%./(2<3(X)lY(/L@/>28(</>/(

8/7/12/4(0>3?(2./(X)lY(8/:83>K(@=:/7J(<.91.(13:89828(30(@>30/8893:=77KJ(2>=9:/4(=:4(@=94(

;>=4/>8J(8/7/12/4(13:03>?()WY(NINR(@>31/45>/C(%./(?/?6/>8(30(2./(@=:/7(</>/(9:(2./(

23@( 2/:( @/>1/:297/( 30( 6/82( 8M977/4( 9:49S945=78( 30( 2./( @3@57=293:( 9:( 2./( X/2./>7=:48J( 9:(

8?/779:;( =:4( 2=829:;C( %./K( 03773</4( >/;57=>( 2>=9:9:;( 3:( =( 8/2( 30( 0334( @>345128( =:4(

07=S35>(@>30979:;J( 9:( 3>4/>( 23( 7/=>:( 23( >/13;:9k/( =:4(:=?/(3435>8( 13:03>?(=( 13??3:(

07=S35>(7=:;5=;/C(a/894/8(2./9>(/L@/>298/(9:(>/13;:9k9:;(=:4(:=?9:;(3435>8J(2./(/L@/>28(

</>/(2/82/4(03>(2./9>(=69792K(23(8?/77(2./(3435>8(30(=:4>382/:3:/(=:4(8M=237/(2.>35;.(=(

8/:83>K(2>9=:;7/( 2/82C( ):( 2.98( 2/82( 2./(/L@/>28(.=4(23(6/(=67/( 23(13>>/127K( 94/:290K(=(S9=7(

<92.(8M=237/(AI(@@6F( 9:(<=2/>(=:4(=:4>382/:3:/(AI,(@@6F( 9:(/2.=:37C(`5>2./>?3>/J(2./(

/L@/>28( </>/(?=4/( 0=?979=>( <92.( 2./( 2K@91=7( 63=>( 2=9:2( 8?/77( =8( @/>1/9S/4( 0>3?( 0>9/4(

?/=2(8=?@7/8(<92.(63=>(2=9:2(@>3S94/4(6K(*)YXC(%./(*)YX(/L@/>2(<=8(2>=9:/4(6K(2/829:;(

3S/>( +,,( ,,,( 8=?@7/8( <92.( 4900/>/:2( ./=29:;( ?/2.348( =8( 4/81>96/4( 9:( ]=2.5>( /2( =7C(

A]=2.5>(/2(=7CJ(D,+DFC(#77(2.>//(/L@/>28(</>/(0/?=7/C(

DC+C-C @TS6=$96(%"1)-6%R&S)'<)%Q6)7U("9$.)Q6"7-S".6)-"9S1$(8))

) V>&=86)"(7)?="SW)

#( 09>82( /L@/>9?/:2( <=8( 8/2( 5@( 589:;( 3:/( 13:2>37( 8=?@7/( =:4( 3:/( 63=>( 2=9:2(

8=?@7/( 152( 9:23( @9/1/8C( #( 8/13:4( /L@/>9?/:2( <=8( @/>03>?/4( 3:( =( ?9L25>/( 30( @9/1/8(

3>9;9:=29:;( 0>3?( 035>( 8=?@7/8( <92.352( 63=>( 2=9:2( 3435>( =:4( =( ?9L25>/( 30( @9/1/8(

3>9;9:=29:;(0>3?(035>(8=?@7/8(<92.(=(82>3:;(23(S/>K(82>3:;(63=>(2=9:2(3435>C(#77(8=?@7/8(

</>/(0>9/4(9:(2./9>(3<:(>/:4/>/4(0=2(9:(=(0>K9:;(@=:C(%./(152(?/=2(8=?@7/8(=:4(0>9/4(0=2(

A7=>4F(</>/(58/4(03>(2./(4K:=?91(./=48@=1/(8=?@79:;(30(2./(\!U8:900(=:=7K8/8C(W=?@7/8(

</>/( 823>/4( =2( U+Nu!( 6/2<//:( 0>K9:;( =:4( 4K:=?91( ./=48@=1/( 8=?@79:;C( %./( 4K:=?91(

./=48@=1/( 8=?@79:;(.=@@/:/4(6K(@5>;9:;( =(./795?(;=8( 82>/=?( A+I,(?[c?9:F( 2.>35;.(

Page 130: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

W!'&&X)X\(`Y'(oXgXYTX(aY#'(%#)X%(!Y]$YoX^W(

(

(

+D,(

2/:(;>=?8(30(133M/4(?/=2(3>(+I(;>=?8(30(0=2(=2(+,,(u!(03>(P,(?9:C(%./(/L2>=12/4(S37=297/(

13?@35:48(</>/(2>=@@/4(3:(=683>@293:(256/8(13:2=9:9:;(!=>6389/S/(W)))( A+,?;J(R,UN,(

?/8.J(W5@/713J(oW#F(=:4(!=>632>=@(AN,?;J(D,U_,(?/8.J(W5@/713J(oW#F(=:4(8568/d5/:27K(

=:=7K8/4(6K(\!UW:900U]W(ADC+C_FC(

DC+C_C B0R)D1<".%'96%=U)VB0RC($<<)X)EC)$76(%$<$."%$'(W)

%./( /L2>=12/4( =>3?=( 13?@35:48( 1377/12/4( 3:( 2./( =683>@293:( 256/8( </>/(

2./>?=77K(4/83>6/4( Ao:92KvJ(]=>M/8J(ogF(=:4(8/@=>=2/4(3:(=(\!(1375?:(AR,(?(w(,C-D(

x?J(*=>9=:J(oW#F(<92.(*`U+?8(A40B+(x?F(=8(82=293:=>K(@.=8/(?35:2/4(9:(=(%./>?3(%>=1/(

\!(572>=(135@7/4(23(=(%./>?3(^Wy())(89:;7/(d5=4>5@37/(A%./>?3(`98./>(W19/:29091J(oW#FC(

%./(\!( 8/@=>=293:( 82=>2/4( =2( _,u!( 03>( 3:/(?9:( =:4( 2./:( 2./( 2/?@/>=25>/(<=8( >=98/4(

<92.(RCIu!c?9:(2977(DI,u!C(%.98(09:=7(2/?@/>=25>/(30(DI,(u!(<=8(M/@2(03>(=:32./>(89L(?9:C(

%./(\!(/0075/:2(<=8(8@792(23(=(8:900(@3>2(=:4(=:(]W(9:(=(>=293(30(09S/(23(3:/C(

%./( \!( W:900( <=8( 1=>>9/4( 352( S9=( =( ./=2/4( AD,,u!F( =:4( .5?94909/4( 8:900( @3>2J(

<./>/(2./(\!(/0075/:2(>/1/9S/4(2./(/L@/>28(9:23(2./(:=8=7(1=S92KC(%./(/L@/>28(</>/(=8M/4(

23(@58.(=(65223:(/S/>K( 29?/( 2./K(@/>1/9S/4(=:(3435>(=88319=2/4(<92.(63=>( 2=9:2C( %.98(

89;:=7(<=8(>/13>4/4(23;/2./>(<92.(2./(\!U]W(4=2=C(

%./( ]W( 3@/>=2/4( 9:( 81=:( ?34/( 3S/>( =( ?=88( >=:;/( 0>3?( DI( 23( -I,( =?5(

A+8c4/1=4/FJ(<92.(/7/12>3:( 9?@=12(=2(E,(/*C( ($32/:29=77K(13:2>96529:;(13?@35:48(</>/(

94/:2909/4( 45>9:;( 2./( 8/13:4( \!U8:900( /L@/>9?/:2( A?9L25>/( 8=?@7/8FC( %./( 13?@35:4(

82>5125>/8( </>/( =889;:/4( 6K( >/2/:293:( 29?/( 9:4/L( AX)lYFJ( 3435>( 4/81>9@293:(

A`7=S35>6=8/J( [/009:;</77( i( #88319=2/8J( oW#F( =:4( ]W( 8@/12>5?( 9:2/>@>/2=293:( =:4(

13?@=>983:( 30( 2./( 8@/12>=( <92.( 696793;>[email protected]( X)W%c&$#cX)"( ]=88( W@/12>=7( [96>ary

(%./>?3(`98./>(W19/:29091J(oW#F(=:4(T97/K(]=88(W@/12>=7([96>ary (j3.:(T97/K(i(W3:8J():1J(

oW#FC(

DCDC C.=66($(8) <'=) S=676<$(67) "(7) &(4('5() #'"=) %"$(%) .'9S'&(7-) &-$(8)G!>H0R!;EC)

W=?@7/( 8/7/1293:J( 8/:83>K( =:=7K8/8( =:4( 1./?91=7( =:=7K8/8( 58/4( 03>( 2./8/(

/L@/>9?/:28(</>/(>/@3>2/4(/=>79/>(A!.=@2/>()*FC(a/73<(=(8.3>2(4/81>9@293:(98(;9S/:C(

Page 131: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'(*(

(

(

+D+(

DCDC+C C"9S16-)

X/1M(0=2(30(N-(87=5;.2/>/4(/:29>/(?=7/(@9;8(<=8(1377/12/4(=2(2./(87=5;.2/>.358/(

30(2./(*)YX(`334(\>35@(A&9:4.3S/:J(%./(X/2./>7=:48FC(%./(:/1M(0=2(<=8(89:;/4(6K(=(;=8(

65>:/>(3:(<.91.(=(@7=2/(<=8(=88/?67/4(=:4(813>/4(03>(2./(@>/8/:1/(30(63=>(2=9:2(6K(2./(

87=5;.2/>.358/( /L@/>2( =2( 2./( 87=5;.2/>79:/( A]=2.5>( /2( =7CJ( D,+DFC( %./( 0=2(<=8( 17/=:/4(

0>3?(S98967/(>/?=9:8(30(?/=2(=:4(823>/4(=2(UD,u!(6/03>/(=:=7K898C((

DCDCDC C6(-'=U)"("1U-$-)

`35>(/L@/>28(</>/(8/7/12/4(=:4(2>=9:/4(23(@/>03>?(2./(8/:83>K(=:=7K8/8(A!.=@2/>(

)*FC(%./(8=?@7/8(</>/(89:;/4(589:;(=(-,UT=22(8374/>9:;(9>3:(A&'W#vFC(%./(./=2/4(29@(30(

2./(8374/>9:;(9>3:(<=8(@>/88/4(3:23(2./(0=2(8=?@7/(23(>/7/=8/(2./(=>3?=J(=8(4/81>96/4(

6K(j=>?375M(/2(=7C(A+PE,FC(a/2<//:(/S/>K(8=?@7/(2./(8374/>9:;(9>3:(<=8(17/=:/4(23(=S394(

13:2=?9:=293:C(`3>(/S/>K(8=?@7/J(/L@/>28(</>/(=8M/4(23(813>/(2./(9:2/:892K(30(63=>(2=9:2(

3:(=(S985=7(=:=73;5/(81=7/(<92.(=:1.3>(@39:28J( 0>3?(:3(3435>( 23( 82>3:;/82( 9?=;9:=67/(

300U3435>(A!.=@2/>()*FC((

DCDC-C 0Q69$."1)"("1U-$-)

%./(8=?@7/8(</>/(=:=7K8/4(<92.(=:([!U]W(6=8/4(4/2/1293:(?/2.34(=8(4/81>96/4(

9:(a/M=/>2(/2(=7C(A!.=@2/>()))FC( ):(8.3>2J(8=?@7/(@>/@=>=293:(13:8982/4(30(=(?/729:;(82/@J(

03773</4( 6K( =:( /L2>=1293:( <92.( ?/2.=:37( =:4( =( 17/=:( 5@( 2.>35;.( 0>//k9:;( =:4( 83794(

@.=8/(/L2>=1293:C(W568/d5/:27KJ(2./(=:=7K2/8(</>/(1.>3?=23;>[email protected]=77K(8/@=>=2/4(589:;(

572>=(.9;.(@/>03>?=:1/(79d594(1.>3?=23;>[email protected](Ao"$[!F(=:4(4/2/12/4(<92.(=:(&L=129S/%](

.9;.U>/8375293:( ?=88( 8@/12>3?/2/>( <92.( =2?38@./>91( @>/885>/( 1./?91=7( 93:9k=293:(

A#$!)F(9:(2./(@38929S/(93:(?34/C(#$!)(98(;/:/>=77K(6/22/>(03>(8?=77(:3:U@37=>(=:4(?/495?(

@37=>( ?37/157/8( <92.( =( ?37/157=>( </9;.2( A]TF( >=:;/( 0>3?( +,,( 23( +,,,C( W51.(

13?@35:48( 9:1754/( 9:437/( A]TG(++EFJ( 8M=237/( A]TG(+-+F( Al=?=>=28M=9=(i( j=82>/63S=J(

D,,RF(=:4(=:4>382/:3:/(A]TG(DEDFC(#$!)(=783(@>3S94/8(.9;./>(4/2/1293:(8/:8929S929/8(03>(

2./(?=h3>92K(30(82/>394=7(13?@35:48J(/C;C(=:4>382/:3:/(=8(13?@=>/4(23(&W)(A*=:.=/1M/(

/2(=7CJ(D,++FC(%./(&L=129S/%](.9;.U>/8375293:(?=88(8@/12>3?/2/>(=773<8(@382U=1d5989293:(

>/U9:2/>>3;=293:(30(4=2=C(

Page 132: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

W!'&&X)X\(`Y'(oXgXYTX(aY#'(%#)X%(!Y]$YoX^W(

(

(

+DD(

DCDC_C ,"%")$(%6=S=6%"%$'()

#72.35;.(2./(=:=7K291=7(?/2.34(<=8(4/S/73@/4(=:4(S=794=2/4(6K(031589:;(3:(2./(

2.>//(M:3<:(63=>(2=9:2(13?@35:48(A9:437/J(8M=237/(=:4(=:4>382/:3:/FJ(=(81>//:9:;(03>(

5:M:3<:( 13?@35:48( <=8( @>/?98/4C( %3( 2.98( /L2/:2J( 2<3( 4900/>/:2( 82>=2/;9/8( </>/(

/?@73K/4J( :=?/7K( =( 2=>;/2/4( =@@>3=1.( 589:;( %3L)^%]( 8302<=>/( =:4( =:( 5:2=>;/2/4(

=@@>3=1.(589:;(W9/S/%](8302<=>/C(

((

DCDC_C+C ?"=86%67)-.=66($(8)

#:( /L.=5829S/( 81>//:9:;( 30( 2./( 0577( 81=:( 4=2=( 03>( @>/8/7/12/4( 13?@35:48(

>/7/S=:2(23(63=>(2=9:2(=8(4/>9S/4(0>3?(792/>=25>/(A%=67/(*C+FJ(<=8(/L/152/4(589:;(%3L)^%](

DC+CD( 8302<=>/( A%./>?3( `98./>( W19/:29091J( W=:( j38/J( oW#FC( `3>( 2.98( @5>@38/J( =( %3L)^%](

4=2=6=8/( <=8( 13:82>512/4( 6K( 9?@7/?/:29:;( 2./( ?37/157=>( 03>?57=( 30( +_( >/7/S=:2(

13?@35:48( A%=67/( *C+FC( "3</S/>J( 9:03>?=293:( 3:( 2./( /7/?/:2=7( 13?@389293:( =:4(

?37/157=>(</9;.2(30(=(13?@35:4(=73:/(98(:32(8500919/:2(03>(=:(5:/d59S31=7(94/:29091=293:(

A\/>88/:(/2(=7CJ(D,++FC(%./>/03>/J(23(13:09>?(2./(@>/8/:1/(30(=(13?@35:4(<92.(=(8@/19091(

/7/?/:2=7(13?@389293:J(=(?9:9?5?(30(2<3(49=;:38291(93:8(9:17549:;(2./(z]{"|{(93:(=:4(

2./(98323@91(/d59S=7/:2(A+-!J(-E!7F(.=4(23(6/(@>/8/:2C(%./(98323@91(93:(A+-!J(-E!7F(<=8(3:7K(

035:4(8592=67/(=8(49=;:38291(93:(<./:(2./(13>>/8@3:49:;(z]{"|{(93:(<=8(=783(4/2/12/4(

=2( 2./( 8=?/( >/2/:293:( 29?/( =:4( 2./( 1=7157=2/4( >/7=29S/( 93:( 9:2/:8929/8( =;>//4( <92.(

!3??98893:( ^9>/129S/( D,,DcRIEc&!( A&5>3@/=:( !3??5:92KJ( D,,DF( >/d59>/?/:28G( 03>(

2./3>/291=77K(4/2/>?9:/4(>/7=29S/( 9:2/:8929/8(30(HD,(23(I,VJ(H+,(23(D,V(=:4(}+,VJ( 2./(

?=L9?5?( @/>?922/4( 237/>=:1/8( </>/J( >/8@/129S/7KJ( QDIVJ( Q-,V( =:4( QI,VC( ]=9:(

Page 133: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!

!

!"#$%&'()*&+,%-%$%./%0&.1231450-&,%$%6"5/&/1&#1",&/"75/&"-&0%,76%0&8,12&$7/%,"/4,%&"50&9:;-5788&"5"$<-7-(&="!#$%&'()!*!+,+-.&&

:1231450& :>%27."$&81,24$"& ?1$%.4$",&@%7A>/& B004./-& C-1/13%-& DE& D%8%,%5.%&

! /01231!

/0142531! 67

8!798'! !

-:$&;<=>?@$6A$);$7:$>'! 86B27++! C95,CCB66! 6++! ! C+,--! ! ! DE=>>F?!G!#)&=?>;H!6BIBJ!8'&(?H!6B9B.!

-:$&;<=>?@$6A$);$7K$>'! 86B27++! C95,CCB66! 6++! ! C+,--! ! ! DE=>>F?!G!#)&=?>;H!6BIBJ!8'&(?H!6B9B.!

5H6A$&;<=>?@&<L);$7$>;)! 86B2CA+! C9+,6B9I6! 6++! ! C+,--! ! +,6+-"!

DE=>>F?!G!#)&=?>;H!6BIB.!

5$)@MN'OM);>'! 8I26+P! 6CC,+9CA6! 6++! ! I,A-! ! +,+66! DQ,!R,!S,!#&@@)=?>;H!6BA9.!

O$T=)?>'! 892I+! 6+I,+-ABA! 6++! ! 9,-9! ! ! DQ,!R,!S,!#&@@)=?>;H!6BA9.!

S@N=);)! 8I2I! 6+5,+AC+-! 6++! ! I,A-! ! +,++I! D0,!U,!QL(?!)@!&',H!C++-.!

5$OM);N'$7$V(@);$C$>;)! 86+26+P! 65A,+9CA6! 6++! ! 6+,IC! ! ! D0,U,!QL(?!G!W&=TL&$Q)X()L=>H!C++6.!

-K$&;<=>?@$6A$);$7:$

>;)H!

86B2CIP! C9C,C675A! 6++! ! C+,--! ! ! D8'&(?H!6B9B.!

-H6A$&;<=>?@&<L);$7K$>'H! 86B2CIP! C9C,C675A! 6++! ! C+,--! ! ! DE=>>F?!G!#)&=?>;H!6BIB.!

6H5$<LTM'>=>V);Y);)! 8A258'C! 65-,BAI5-! 6++! ! ! A7,BC! ! D0,!U,!QL(?!)@!&',H!C++-.!

-$Z)@MN'$7$M)O@);)$C$

>;)!

8I265+! 6CA,6+7B6! 6++! ! I,A-! ! +,++C! 4[\P!]>><!Q)?)&=TM!

CH5$M)O@&<L);&'! 8926++! 66+,+9CA6! 6++! ! 9,-9! ! +,+67! 4[\P!]>><!Q)?)&=TM!

L?>%&')=LT!&TL<! 8-26+PC! 6+C,+A9-7! 6++! ! -,56! ! +,+9-"!

4[\P!]>><!Q)?)&=TM!

TL?$C$;>;);&'! 8B26AP! 65+,66B-A! ! 6++! B,97! ! +,+6C! 4[\P!]>><!Q)?)&=TM!

Page 134: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$$%&%'()*#(+%,%*-%(.*/#(0/&%0("*12*+%3!(

(

(

456(

078&301(9:;;<=>9(?7=?:@=:A(B(C<=<CDC(E:BF( <=;:=9<;G(7H(4III(B=A(B(CB8<CDC(

CB99(A:J<B;<7=(7H(K(EECL((

)<@9;M(B(9<CEN:(N<=:B@(@:>@:99<7=(O!2!!01(9;B;<9;<?9(5IP(QB9(?BN?DNB;:A(R:;Q::=(;S:(

9:=97@G( 9?7@:(B=A( ;S:( <7=( <=;:=9<;G(7H(:J:@G( ?7CE7D=A( <A:=;<H<:A(RG(078&3L( !:?7=AM(B(

CDN;<EN:(N<=:B@(@:>@:99<7=(O!2!!01(9;B;<9;<?9(5IP(QB9(D9:A(;7(B99<>=(;S:(?7CE7D=A9(;SB;(

:8ENB<=(R:9;(;S:(9:=97@G(9?7@:(B;;@<RD;:A(RG(:8E:@;9L((

5L5L6L5L !"#$%&'#'()*+%''","&)

)7@( ;S:( D=;B@>:;:A( 9?@::=<=>( 7H( E7;:=;<BN( R7B@( ;B<=;( ?7CE7D=A9( A<HH:@:=;<BN(

B=BNG9<9(Q<;S(!<:J:01(5LI(O0S:@C7()<9S:@(!?<:=;<H<?M(!B=(T79:M(+!/P(QB9(BEEN<:AL(0S:(AB;B(

E@7?:99<=>( H7NN7Q9( B( CDN;<EN:( 9;:E( 9;@B;:>GL( 0S:( H<@9;( 9;:E( <=J7NJ:9( 9:N:?;<=>( ;S:(

EB@BC:;:@9(;7(E:@H7@C(;S:(A<HH:@:=;<BN(B=BNG9<9(O0BRN:(UL5PL(0S:(9:?7=A(9;:E(?7=9<9;9(7H(

;S:( E:BF( BN<>=C:=;( E@7?:99M( AD@<=>( QS<?S( ;S:( E@7>@BC( ?BN?DNB;:9( ;S:( 7E;<CBN(

?7@@:NB;<7=9( R:;Q::=( 9E:?;@B( B=A( ?@:B;:9( B( CB;@<8( 7H( 9E:?;@BV;7V9E:?;@B( ?7@@:NB;<7=9(

;SB;( B@:( D9:A( ;7( BN<>=( ?S@7CB;7>@BC9L( 0S<9( :=9D@:9( ;SB;( :B?S( <7=( W!"#$"X( 7H( ;S:( 1!(

9E:?;@B(BEE:B@9(B;(<A:=;<?BN(@:;:=;<7=(;<C:(O@;<P(B?@799(;S:(B=BNG9:A(9BCEN:9L(&=(;S:(;S<@A(

9;:EM(!<:J:01(97H;QB@:(@:E7@;9(;S:(9<>=BN(BRD=AB=?:(7R9:@J:A(H7@(:B?S(<7=(W!#YM(@;X<( <=(

:B?S( 7H( ;S:( B=BNG9:A( 9BCEN:9L( 07( ;S<9( ED@E79:M( BNN( E:BF9( BR7J:( B( ><J:=( ;S@:9S7NA( B@:(

?7NN:?;:A( H@7C( @BQ( Z"[1!( AB;B( ;7( E@:J:=;( B=G( N799( 7H( <=H7@CB;<7=L( 3D@<=>( ;S:( H7D@;S(

9;:E( ;S:( BN>7@<;SC( A:;:@C<=:9M( H@BC:VRGVH@BC:M( QS:;S:@( B( 9;B;<9;<?BNNG( 9<>=<H<?B=;(

BRD=AB=?:( A<HH:@:=?:( :8<9;( R:;Q::=( ;S:( ?7=;@7N( B=A( ;@:B;C:=;( 9BCEN:9( H7@( <A:=;<?BN(

<7=9L()<=BNNGM(<A:=;<H<:A(E:BF9(B@:(97@;:A(7D;(;7(>:=:@B;:(B(;Q7VA<C:=9<7=BN(AB;B(;BRN:M(<=(

QS<?S(@7Q9(B=A(?7NDC=9(@:E@:9:=;(@:9E:?;<J:NG(;S:(9BCEN:(B=A(;S:(@:NB;<J:(E:BF(B@:B9L(

0S:( >:=:@B;:A( AB;BRB9:( ?7=;B<=9( B(QS7N:( @B=>:( 7H( BAA<;<7=BN( <=H7@CB;<7=( :L>L( ;S:( 2V

JBND:M(@B;<7M(@:?7=9;@D?;:A(<7=(?S@7CB;7>@BC9M(@:;:=;<7=(;<C:9(B=A(C[Y(JBND:9L((

( (

Page 135: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"\/20$#(U(

(

(

45K(

-$./')0123)4$%$5'#'%*)6*'()#7)8'%97%5)#:')(,99'%'"#,$/)$"$/;*,*),")<,'='->)21?1))

4$%$5'#'%) 0$/6')C[Y(@B=>:(O3BP( 4II(](KII(#0(@B=>:(OC<=P( 4(](^((27NB@<;G( 279<;<J:(1B8<CDC(BC7D=;(H@BC:9((

O::=S:<A_P(

4IIII(C[Y(Q<A;S(OEECP( K(#0(-<A;S(OC<=P( ILK(&=;:=9<;G(;S@:9S7NA(O/+P( 4IIII(

(

07(RD<NA(DE(B(E@:A<?;<7=(C7A:N(D9<=>(;S<9(F<=A(7H(AB;B9:;M(;S:(D9:(7H(CDN;<JB@<B;:(

;:?S=<`D:9( <9( :99:=;<BNL( ZB;:NGM( ;S:( *@;S7>7=BN( 2B@;<BN( Z:B9;( !`DB@:9V3<9?@<C<=B=;(

/=BNG9:9( O*2Z!V3/P(SB9(E@7J:=( <;9(D9:( O"7D@B=;(:;(BNLM( 5IIaPL(*2Z!V3/( <9( B( 9DE:@J<9:A(

C:;S7AM( E@7J:=( J:@G( :HH:?;<J:( H7@( E@7?:99<=>( NB@>:( AB;B9:;9( ;SB;( :=SB=?:9( ?NB99(

9:EB@B;<7=(O0S:7A7@<A<9(:;(BNLM(5I45PL(0S:(C7A:N(B;;:CE;9(;7(:8ENB<=(B=A(E@:A<?;(7=:(b(

JB@<BRN:(O<=(;S<9(9;DAGc(9BCEN:9(Q<;S(B=A(Q<;S7D;(R7B@(;B<=;P(H@7C(;S:(d(CB;@<8(OE799<RN:(

R7B@( ;B<=;( ?7=;@<RD;<=>( ?7CE7D=A9PL( &=( *2Z!V3/M( ;S:( 9G9;:CB;<?( JB@<B;<7=( <=( d( <9(

9:EB@B;:A(<=;7(;Q7(:N:C:=;9c(7=:(;SB;(<9(?7@@:NB;:A(;7(b(B=A(7=:(;SB;(<9(=7;(?7@@:NB;:A(

O7@;S7>7=BNP( ;7( be( ;S:(C7A:N( ;SD9( ?7CE@<9:9( ;Q7(C7A:N:A( JB@<B;<7=9M( <L:L( bVE@:A<?;<J:(

B=A(bV7@;S7>7=BNL(0S<9(E7@;<7=<=>(7H(;S:(dVAB;B(HB?<N<;B;:9(;S:(C7A:N(<=;:@E@:;B;<7=L()7@(

;S<9(@:B97=M(;S<9(9;DAG(SB9(7E;:A(;7(D9:(*2Z!V3/(B=BNG9<9(H7@(A:;:@C<=B;<7=(7H(E7;:=;<BN(

R7B@(;B<=;(?7CE7D=A9(Q<;S(!&1"/4f(O+C:;@<?9M(!Q:A:=PL(07(A:;:@C<=:(;S:(=DCR:@(7H(

9<>=<H<?B=;( ?7CE7=:=;9M( ;S:( C7A:N( D9:A( ?@799VJBN<AB;<7=( @DN:9( OBD;7H<;( E@7?:AD@:( <=(

!&1"/4fPL( )7@( BNN( 9BCEN:9M( AB;B( Q:@:( N7>5( ;@B=9H7@C:A( B=A( 9?BN:A( B??7@A<=>( ;7( ;S:(

2B@:;7(C:;S7AL(2B@:;7(9?BN<=>(7HH:@9(;S:(R:9;(@:9DN;9(Q<;S(1!(AB;B(B9( <;(A7Q=VQ:<>S;9(

;S:(NB@>:9;(B=A(DEVQ:<>S;9(;S:(C:A<DC(E:BF9(Q<;S7D;( <=HNB;<=>(RB9:N<=:(=7<9:L(UBN<A<;G(

7H( ;S:( *2Z!V3/( C7A:N( QB9( J:@<H<:A( RG( E:@H7@C<=>( "UV/=7JB( B=A( ;S@::( C7A:N(

?SB@B?;:@<9;<?9c(#5OdP(?7@@:9E7=A<=>(;7(;S:(E@:A<?;<J:(B=A(7@;S7>7=BN(JB@<B;<7=(<=(d(;SB;(

<9(:8ENB<=:A(RG(;S:(C7A:NM(#5ObP(A:H<=<=>(;S:(;7;BN(9DC(7H(JB@<B;<7=(<=(b(:8ENB<=:A(RG(;S:(

C7A:NM(g5ObP(>77A=:99(7H(E@:A<?;<7=(?BN?DNB;:A(RG(HDNN(?@799(JBN<AB;<7=L((

)<=BNNGM(B9(H7@(;S:(078&301(AB;B9:;M(9<CEN:(B=A(CDN;<EN:(N<=:B@(@:>@:99<7=(QB9(D9:A(

;7(<A:=;<HG(;S:(R:9;(C7A:N(;7(:8ENB<=(;S:(9:=97@G(9?7@:(><J:=(RG(;S:(:8E:@;9(

Page 136: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$$%&%'()*#(+%,%*-%(.*/#(0/&%0("*12*+%3!(

(

(

45^(

@1 ) A'*6/#*)$"()(,*+6**,7")

fL4L !"#$%&'#'()*+%''","&)97%)6"B"7C"*)6*,"&)DEF<",99)

0S:(9BCEN:9(D9:A(H7@(7NHB?;7C:;@<?(B=BNG9:9(Q:@:(9:N:?;:A(RB9:A(7=(;S:(9:=97@G(

:JBNDB;<7=(O9?BN:c(I(;7(6(](=7(R7B@(;B<=;(7A7D@(;7(9;@7=>(R7B@(;B<=;(7A7D@P(7H(H<J:(:8E:@;9(

7H(;S:(EB=:N(B9(A:9?@<R:A(<=(1B;SD@(:;(BNL(O5I45PL(/NN(9BCEN:9(Q:@:(@B;:A(7=?:M(RG(:B?S(

:8E:@;L( *H( ;S:( 9BCEN:9M( H<J:( SBA( B=( BJ:@B>:( 9:=97@G( 9?7@:( 7H( IL5( O68Ie484P( B=A(Q:@:(

?7=9<A:@:A(;7(R:(H@::(7H(;B<=;L(0S:(7;S:@(H<J:(9BCEN:9(B99<>=:A(B(9:=97@G(9?7@:(7H(f(7@(6(

RG(B;(N:B9;(H7D@(:8E:@;9(B=A(B(9?7@:(7H(IM(4(7@(5(RG(;S:(K;S(:8E:@;M(B=A(Q:@:(?7=9<A:@:A(

B9( S:BJ<NG( ;B<=;:AL( 0S:( SDCB=(=79:( SB9( R::=( D9:A( <=( 9:J:@BN( 9;DA<:9( ;7( <A:=;<HG( R7B@(

;B<=;(O.7==:BDM(4ah5e("7F:@(:;(BNLM(5IIae(1B;SD@(:;(BNLM(5I45PL((

0S:(@:9DN;9(7H(;S:('"V!=<HH(B=BNG9:9(7H(;S:(J7NB;<N:(?7CE7D=A9(7H(;S:(9<=>N:(O)<>(

UL4P( C:B;( 9BCEN:( A:C7=9;@B;:A( ;SB;( C7@:( ;B<=;:A( ?7CE7D=A9( Q:@:( E:@?:<J:A(

;S@7D>S7D;( ;S:( B=BNG9:9( 7H( R7B@( ;B<=;:A( C:B;( 9BCEN:9( ;SB=( <=( ?B9:( 7H( ;S:( ?7=;@7N(

9BCEN:L(0S:9:(@:9DN;9(Q:@:(?7=H<@C:A(Q<;S(;S:(C<8:A(9BCEN:9(OAB;B(=7;(9S7Q=PL(

0BRN:(ULf(E@:9:=;9(;S:(?S:C<?BN(=BC:9(7H(;S:(?7CE7D=A9(QS79:(C:@:(E@:9:=?:(

AD@<=>(9:=97@G('"(9=<HH(B=BNG9<9(<=(R7B@(;B<=;:A(B9(7EE79:A(;7(?7=;@7N(9BCEN:9M(<=A<?B;:A(

;S:<@( <=J7NJ:C:=;( <=(R7B@( ;B<=;(B=A(Q:@:( <A:=;<H<:A(B9(A:9?@<R:A(BR7J:L(0S:9:( <=?NDA:(

;S:(B?F=7QN:A>:A(R7B@(;B<=;(?7=;@<RD;<=>(?7CE7D=A9(9FB;7N:(B=A(<=A7N:L(/=A@79;:=7=:(

QB9(S7Q:J:@(=7;(<A:=;<H<:A(AD@<=>(;S:('"(9=<HHV1!(B=BNG9<9(<=(;S:(R7B@(;B<=;:A(9BCEN:9(

D=A:@(;S:(?7=A<;<7=9(7H(AG=BC<?(S:BA9EB?:(O2D@>:(i(0@BEP(B=A('"(B=BNG9<9(D9:A(H7@(;S<9(

9;DAGL(179;(7H( ;S:(7;S:@(?7CE7D=A9(R:N7=>(;7(;S:(?S:C<?BN(?NB99:9(7H( HB;;G(B?<A9(B=A(

BNA:SGA:9L(&;(SB9(R::=(@:E7@;:A(;SB;(;S:9:(?7CE7D=A9(CBG(?7=;@<RD;:(;7(7HHVHNBJ7D@9(<=(

E7@F(O.:@AB>D:(:;(BNLM(4aa4e(%B@JB:YV#<JB9(:;(BNLM(5I4Ie(1L(/L(#<D9(:;(BNLM(5IIKPL(/N97(#<D9(

:;( BNL( O5IIKP( <A:=;<H<:A( ;S:( CB<=( BAA<;<7=BN( R7B@( ;B<=;( ?7=;@<RD;<=>( ?7CE7D=A9( B9(

R:N7=><=>(;7(;S:(BNA:SGA:(B=A(9S7@;(?SB<=(HB;;G(B?<A(>@7DE9L(/N;S7D>S(;S:9:(?7CE7D=A9(

Q:@:(A:9<>=B;:A(B9(=7;(A<@:?;NG(@:9E7=9<RN:(H7@(R7B@(;B<=;M(;S:G(?7DNA(E799<RNG(:=SB=?:(

;S:( R7B@( ;B<=;( E:@?:E;<7=( 7H( ;S:( B?;DBN( @:9E7=9<RN:( ?7CE7D=A9( 9FB;7N:M( <=A7N:( B=A(

B=A@79;:=7=:(O#<D9(:;(BNLM(5IIKPL(/(9<C<NB@(@:CB@F(?B=(R:(CBA:(H7@(;S:('"V9=<HH(C:;S7A(

D9:A( <=( ;S<9( 9;DAGL( .:?BD9:( 7H( ;S:( ?7=A<;<7=9( D9:A( <=( ;S<9(C:;S7AM( <;( <9( E799<RN:( ;SB;(

Page 137: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"\/20$#(U(

(

(

45j(

BAA<;<7=BN( J7NB;<N:( ?7CE7D=A9( B@:( >:=:@B;:A( AD:( ;7( ;S:@CBN( A:>@BAB;<7=( 7H( NBR<N:(

?7CE7D=A9( <=(;S:(9BCEN:L(0S:9:(?7CE7D=A9(CBG(=7;(A<@:?;NG(R:(@:9E7=9<RN:( H7@(R7B@(

;B<=;e(S7Q:J:@M(;S:G(?B=(:=SB=?:(;S:(R7B@(;B<=;(E:@?:E;<7=(QS:=(9BCEN:9(B@:(S:B;:A(RG(

?7=9DC:@9L(179;(1!(9<>=BN9(7R9:@J:A(AD@<=>('"(9=<HH(B=BNG9<9(A<9ENBG:A(@B;S:@(N7Q(E:BF(

B@:B9(B=A(9<>=BNV;7V=7<9:(@B;<79M(QS<?S(?7CEN<?B;:A(;S:(9;@B<>S;H7@QB@A(<A:=;<H<?B;<7=(7H(

7;S:@(?7CE7D=A9L(

(

(G,&)01H3)DEF><)#7#$/),7")+:%75$#7&%$5)IJF$J,*K)#,5');F$J,*K%'/$#,=')$.6"($"+'L)C,#:)DEF*",99)%'*6/#*)79)$)*,"&/')%'9'%'"+')*$58/')I/'9#L)$"()$)*,"&/')*#%7"&)#$,"#'()*$58/')I%,&:#LM)9%;,"&)9$#)*$58/')'=$/6$#'().;)'J8'%#)E)I$.7='L)$"()'J8'%#)N)I.'/7CL1)-:')%'()(7#*)5$%B)#:')#,5')87,"#*)$#)C:,+:)$).7$%)#$,"#'()7(76%)

C$*)8'%+',='()(

( (

!"#"$"%&"'(%)'*)+$',+-%,. /)+$',+-%,

012"$,'3

012"$,'/

Page 138: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$$%&%'()*#(+%,%*-%(.*/#(0/&%0("*12*+%3!(

(

(

45h(

(

-$./')01@3)N7$%)#$,"#)$**7+,$#'()+75876"(*)$*),('"#,9,'()$9#'%)DEF<",99)$"$/;*,*)C,#:)7(76%)$+#,=')=$/6'*)IOP0L),")C$#'%1)

)E75876"(*)$**7+,$#'()C,#:)

.7$%)#$,"#)

OP0)IQ&)RFHL)5Mf(A<SGA@7VKVC:;SGNHD@B=( (

;7ND:=:( 56(

(<97JBN:@<?(B?<A( 45I(

KVC:;SGNVfVS:E;:=:V5V7=:( KI(?<9V5V=7=:=BN( IL4(

<=A7N:( 46I(9FB;7N:( IL5(

RD;G@<?(B?<A( 56I(5M6VS:E;BA<:=BN( 5(E@7E:=:(;S<7N( f(

fL5L <+%''","&) 97%) 8%'('9,"'() $"() 6"B"7C") .7$%) #$,"#) +75876"(*) 6*,"&)!S4REFSA><)

0S:( 9BCEN:9( D9:A( H7@( ;B@>:;:A( E79;VB?`D<9<;<7=( @:V<=;:@@7>B;<7=( 7H( AB;B( D9<=>(

078&301(Q:@:(9:N:?;:A(RB9:A(7=(9:=97@G(:JBNDB;<7=M(9<C<NB@(B9(A:9?@<R:A(D=A:@('"V!=<HH(

B=BNG9<9L( &=( >:=:@BNM( ;S:( ?7=?:=;@B;<7=9( 7H( HB;( 9BCEN:9( ?B;:>7@<9:A( B9( I( 7@( 4( RG( ;S:(

9NBD>S;:@S7D9:(:8E:@;(Q:@:(BNN(R:N7Q(;S:(?D;V7HH(JBND:(7H(IL5(C>(F>V4(H7@(9FB;7N:(B=A(ILK(

C>(F>V4(H7@(B=A@79;:=7=:(B9(A:;:@C<=:A(DE7=(+\2Z"V\#1!(B=BNG9:9L()7@(?B;:>7@<:9(f(

B=A( 6M( ;S:( ?7=?:=;@B;<7=9( Q:@:( BR7J:( ;S:( ?D;V7HH( JBND:( H7@( B;( N:B9;( 7=:( 7H( ;S:(

?7CE7D=A9(O9FB;7N:(7@(B=A@79;:=7=:PL((

0S:(9BCEN:9(D9:A(H7@(D=;B@>:;:A(E79;VB?`D<9<;<7=(@:V<=;:@@7>B;<7=(7H(AB;B(D9<=>(

!<:J:01M(Q:@:( 9:N:?;:A( H@7C( ;S:(hf( 9BCEN:9(7H( ;S:(078&301(AB;BRB9:L( 0Q7(RB;?S:9(7H(

9BCEN:9M( <L:L( 7=:( ?7=;B<=<=>( 9BCEN:9( ;SB;(Q:@:( @:>B@A:A(E79<;<J:( H7@(R7B@( ;B<=;( B=A(B(

?7=;@7N(RB;?S(NB?F<=>(R7B@(;B<=;M(Q:@:(H7@:9::=L(/9(;S:(BC7D=;(7H(9BCEN:9(E79<;<J:(H7@(

R7B@(;B<=;(QB9(N<C<;:A(;7(4KM(;S:(9BC:(BC7D=;(QB9(9:N:?;:A(H7@(;S:(?7=;@7N(9BCEN:9L()7@(

;S:( E79<;<J:( 9BCEN:9( O=k4KPM( B( C<=<CDC( ?7=?:=;@B;<7=( 7H( 9FB;7N:( 7@( B=A@79;:=7=:(

BR7J:(;S:(?D;V7HH(JBND:(O@:9E:?;<J:NG(IL5(C>(F>V4(B=A(ILK(C>(F>V4P(B=A(B(9:=97@G(9?7@:(7H(

B;(N:B9;(C7A:@B;:(7=(;S:(J<9DBN(B=BN7>D:(9?BN:(Q<;S(B=?S7@(E7<=;9M(Q:@:(E@:9DC:AL()7@(

;S:(9BCEN:9(Q<;S7D;(R7B@( ;B<=;M( ;S:(?7=?:=;@B;<7=9(7H( 9FB;7N:(B=A(B=A@79;:=7=:(Q:@:(

R:N7Q(;S:(?D;V7HH(JBND:9(B=A(;S:(9:=97@G(9?7@:9(Q:@:(IL((

Page 139: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"\/20$#(U(

(

(

45a(

fL5L4L -$%&'#'()*+%''","&)

)7@( ;S:( BEEN<?B;<7=(7H( 078&301M( 46( ?7CE7D=A9( O0BRN:(UL4P( 9:N:?;:A( <=( ;:@C9(7H(

@:N:JB=?:(;7(R7B@(;B<=;(B??7@A<=>(;7(N<;:@B;D@:(7@('"(9=<HH(@:9DN;9M(Q:@:(<CEN:C:=;:A(<=(B(

AB;BRB9:( B=A( :JBNDB;:A( 7=( ;S:<@( E@:9:=?:( <=( ;S:( hf( 9:N:?;:A( 9BCEN:9( H7@(QS<?S( AB;B(

Q:@:( BJB<NBRN:( H@7C( E@:J<7D9( +\2Z"V\#1!( B=BNG9:9L( 0S:( H7NN7Q<=>( ?7CE7D=A9( ?7DNA(

=7;( R:( A:;:?;:A( <=( ;S:( 9BCEN:9( D=A:@( <=J:9;<>B;<7=c( KlVB=A@79;V4^V:=VflV7NM( KlV

B=A@79;V4^V:=VfmV7NM( 4M6VA<?SN7@7R:=Y:=:M( 6VES:=GNVfVRD;:=V5V7=:( B=A( EV?@:97NL( 0S:(

?7CC:@?<BN( 9;B=AB@A9( 7H( ;S@::( 7H( ;S:9:( ?7CE7D=A9( O6VES:=GNVfVRD;:=V5V7=:M( 4M6V

A<?SN7@7R:=Y:=:(B=A(EV?@:97NP(Q:@:(ED@?SB9:A(B=A( <=n:?;:A( <=;7( ;S:(B=BNG;<?BN( 9G9;:C(

D=A:@(;S:(9BC:(?7=A<;<7=9L(\7Q:J:@M(=7=(7H(;S:9:(?7CE7D=A9(?7DNA(R:(A:;:?;:A(D=A:@(

;S:9:( ?<@?DC9;B=?:9M(QS<?S(:8ENB<=9( ;S:<@( BR9:=?:( <=( ;S:( 9BCEN:9(D=A:@( <=J:9;<>B;<7=L(

0S:(078&301(AB;BRB9:M(7=NG(?7=9<9;:A(7H(;S:(:N:C:=;BN(?7CE79<;<7=9(7H(;S:(?7CE7D=A9(

D=A:@( ?7=9<A:@B;<7=L( 0S:@:H7@:M( ?7CE7D=A9( Q<;S( B=( <A:=;<?BN( :N:C:=;BN( ?7CE79<;<7=(

CBG(R:(<CE799<RN:(;7(A<9;<=>D<9S(H@7C(:B?S(7;S:@(9<=?:(9?@::=<=>(RG(C:B=9(7H(078&301(

97H;QB@:( @:N<:9( 97N:NG( 7=( ;S<9( :N:C:=;BN( ?7CE79<;<7=( B=A( ;S:( B??D@B;:( !#$% A:@<J:A(

;S:@:7HL(&=(;S<9(9;DAGM(;S:(<7=(Q<;S(:N:C:=;BN(?7CE79<;<7=("4a\4h*(QB9(A:;:?;:A(<=(;S:(

9BCEN:9L(\7Q:J:@M( ;S<9( ?7CE79<;<7=(CBG(R:(BNN7?B;:A( ;7( ;S:(B?F=7QN:A>:A(R7B@( ;B<=;(

?7CE7D=A( KlVB=A@79;V4^V:=VflV7=:( B=A( ;7( KmVB=A@79;V4^V:=VflV7=:( B=A( KM4^V

B=A@79;BA<:=VfmV7NL( /;( ;S<9( E7<=;M( <;( QB9( =7;( E799<RN:( ;7( A<9;<=>D<9S( R:;Q::=( ;S:9:(

?7CE7D=A9M( 9<=?:( ;S:( @:;:=;<7=( ;<C:9( OKLf6( C<=D;:9P( B9?@<R:A( ;7( ;S:( ?7CE7D=A9( RG(

078&3(Q:@:( <A:=;<?BN( H7@(BNN(B=BNG9:A(9BCEN:9L(0S:@:H7@:M( <;(CBG(R:(E@:9DC:A(;SB;(;S:(

?7CE7D=A( A:;:?;:A( Q<;S( 078&301( ?7=?:@=9( B=A@79;:=7=:( B=A( =7;( ;S:( ;Q7( 7;S:@(

9;:@7<A9L(\7Q:J:@M(R:?BD9:(=7(?7@@:9E7=A<=>(?7CC:@?<BNNG(9;B=AB@A9(7H(KmVB=A@79;V4^V

:=VflV7=:( B=A( KM4^VB=A@79;BA<:=VfmV7N( B@:( BJB<NBRN:( B;( ;S:( ;<C:M( <;( <9( <CE799<RN:( ;7(

?7=H<@C(;S:(:8B?;(<A:=;<;G(7H(;S:(<7=L(

)7@( ;S:( 7;S:@( 9:J:=( ?7CE7D=A9M( 7=NG( ;Q7( ?7CE7D=A9( O?SB@B?;:@<Y:A( RG( B(

9E:?<H<?( :N:C:=;BN( ?7CE79<;<7=( B=A( Q<;S( S<>S( N<F:N<S77A( ?7@@:9E7=A<=>( ;7( 6M4^V

B=A@79;BA<:=:VfV7=:(B=A(<97JBN:@<?(B?<AP(?7DNA(R:(9<>=<H<?B=;NG(?7@@:NB;:A(Q<;S(R7B@(;B<=;(

O0BRN:( UL4PL( #:>@:99<7=( ?7:HH<?<:=;9( 7H( IL4IK( B=A( ILIjK( Q:@:( 7R;B<=:A( H7@( 6M4^V

B=A@79;BA<:=VfV7=:(B=A(<97JBN:@<?(B?<AM(@:9E:?;<J:NGL($B@N<:@M("NBD9(O4ajaP(SB9(A:9?@<R:A(

Page 140: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$$%&%'()*#(+%,%*-%(.*/#(0/&%0("*12*+%3!(

(

(

4fI(

;S:( E799<RN:( ?7=;@<RD;<7=( 7H( 6M4^VB=A@79;BA<:=:VfV7=:( ;7( ;S:( R7B@( ;B<=;( 7A7D@( O$)!/M(

5II6PL( 0S<9( 9;:@7<A( R:N7=>9( ;7( ;S:( 9BC:( >@7DE( B9( B=A@79;:=7=:M( =BC:NG( ;S:(

B=A@79;:=7=:9M(QS<?S(B@:(?SB@B?;:@<Y:A(RG(B(D@<=B@G(7A7D@L(/9( H7@( <97JBN:@<?(B?<AM( ;S<9(

?7CE7D=A( QB9( BN97( A:;:?;:A( RG( '"V!=<HH( B=BNG9<9( B=A( <9( ?SB@B?;:@<Y:A( RG( B( 9;@7=>(

ED=>:=;(?S::9G(7@(9Q:B;G(9C:NNL(+9<=>(CDN;<EN:(N<=:B@(@:>@:99<7=(7=(;S:(\#V1!(AB;B9:;M(

<;(QB9( A:C7=9;@B;:A( ;SB;( ^jo(7H( ;S:( 9:=97@G( 9?7@:(CBG( R:( :8ENB<=:A( RG( 9FB;7N:( B=A(

B=A@79;:=7=:L( 0S<9( E:@?:=;B>:( @:CB<=:A( ;S:( 9BC:( DE7=( <=?ND9<7=( 7H( <=A7N:M( 6M4^V

B=A@79;BA<:=:VfV7=:( B=A( <97JBN:@<?( B?<A( ;7( ;S:(C7A:NL( \7Q:J:@M( Q:( R:N<:J:( ;SB;( ;S:(

;S@::( ?7CE7D=A9(CBG( <CEB?;( R7B@( ;B<=;( <=( >:=:@BNM( B9( :J:@G( ?7CE7D=A( <9( E79<;<J:NG(

?7@@:NB;:A(Q<;S(;S:(7A7D@(9:EB@B;:NGL(0S:(<CE7@;B=?:(7H(<=A7N:(QB9(BN97(A:C7=9;@BA:A(

RG(B(9;DAG(7H(/NDQp(:;(BNL(O5I45PM(<=(QS<?S(7=NG(<=A7N:(O=7;(9FB;7N:(7@(B=A@79;:=7=:P(SBA(

B( E79<;<J:( ?7@@:NB;<7=( O@kIL4aM( 2qIL4P( Q<;S( ;S:( 7A7D@( 9?7@:A( RG( ;S:( ?77F( AD@<=>(

?7=9DC:@( E:@?:E;<7=( :8E:@<:=?:L( )7@( HD@;S:@( @:9:B@?S( <;( <9( <CE7@;B=;( ;7( :=NB@>:( ;S:(

AB;B9:;( B=A( =7;( 7=NG( N77F( B;( ;S:( ?7=;@<RD;<7=( 7H( :J:@G( ?7CE7D=A( RD;( BN97( B;( ;S:(

<=;:@B?;<7=9(R:;Q::=(;S:(?7CE7D=A9L(

0S:( ;B@>:;:A( 9:B@?S( H7@( E799<RN:( ?7=;@<RD;<=>( ?7CE7D=A9( 9;B@;:A( Q<;S( 46(

?7CE7D=A9( H7D=A( <=( N<;:@B;D@:( B=A( RG( '!V!=<HHV1!L( )@7C( ;S79:( 46( ?7CE7D=A9M( ;Q7(

?7CE7D=A9(B@:(<A:=;<H<:A(B9(E799<RN:(?7=;@<RD;<=>(?7CE7D=A9(H7@(R7B@(;B<=;(<=(9BCEN:9(

E@:J<7D9NG(B=BNG9:A(RG(+\2Z"V\#V1!(O)<>(UL5PL((

Page 141: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"\/20$#(U(

(

(

4f4(

(G,&)0123)!S4REFSA><)+:%75$#7&%$5)79)#:')B"7C")$"()"'C/;),('"#,9,'().7$%)#$,"#)

+7"#%,.6#,"&)+75876"(*)$*)('#'%5,"'().;)<,'='->)

fL5L5L !"#$%&'#'()*+%''","&)

)7@(;S:(D=;B@>:;:A(9?@::=<=>(7H(E7;:=;<BN(R7B@(;B<=;(?7=;@<RD;<=>(?7CE7D=A9M(fI(

9BCEN:9(Q:@:(9:N:?;:A(H@7C(;S:(NB@>:@(AB;B9:;(B9(A:?@<R:A(BR7J:M(;7(R:(E@7?:99:A(Q<;S(

!<:J:01(5LIL($8:?D;<=>(;S:(A<HH:@:=;<BN(B=BNG9<9(BNN7Q:A(;S:(A:;:?;<7=(7H(^ff6(<7=9M(:B?S(

! " # $ % &!'()*+,)(-.

!

"!

#!

$!

%!

&!!

!

"!

#!

$!

%!

&!!

!

"!

#!

$!

%!

&!!

/*012(3*+456-71-8*

!

"!

#!

$!

%!

&!!

!

"!

#!

$!

%!

&!!

/'9+&:;!449+$$;"<!=>9+"&??

/'9+":"%449+<"&%&"=>9+&<;%

/'9+?:;#449+???$;##=>9+&"?$$

/'9+?:&;449+#%@$&%=>9+%&?

/'9+&:!<449+?#<!#<=>9+&#%"

>A9+&:!$B?)CDE+&&%:!$##!F&&%:!$??%+G9+G'H=+I&J&K++L+M+4NOP+8QRQ-1+G600+)S+T&!!:!!F?!!:!!U++H=++POP=+

>A9+":;"B?)CDE+&;":!@<@&F&;":!%&!;+G9+G'H=+I&J&K++L+M+4NOP+8QRQ-1+G600+)S+T&!!:!!F?!!:!!U++H=++POP=+

>A9+&:"!B$)CDE+"@;:"&<!#F"@;:""&@%+G9+G'H=+I&J&K++L+M+4NOP+8QRQ-1+G600+)S+T&!!:!!F?!!:!!U++H=++POP=+

>A9+@:;<B#)CDE+"@&:"!#"%F"@&:"!@!!+G9+G'H=+I&J&K++L+M+4NOP+8QRQ-1+G600+)S+T&!!:!!F?!!:!!U++H=++POP=+

>A9+<:&?B#)CDE+&!;:!@#%;F&!;:!@?%@+G9+G'H=+I&J&K++L+M+4NOP+8QRQ-1+G600+)S+T&!!:!!F?!!:!!U++H=++POP=+

! " # $ % &!'()*+,)(-.

!

&!

"!

;!

#!

?!

$!

@!

%!

<!

&!!

!

&!

"!

;!

#!

?!

$!

@!

%!

<!

&!!

!

&!

"!

;!

#!

?!

$!

@!

%!

<!

&!!

/*012(3*+456-71-8*

!

&!

"!

;!

#!

?!

$!

@!

%!

<!

&!!

/'9+&:$<449+??&?&;=>9+"&?%

/'9+&:!"449+??#@!%=>9+&"!<

/'9+?:;#449+"<#$@%=>9+&&$;

>A9+@:&;B#)CDE+&&@:!%<<@F&&@:!<&&?+G9+G'H=+I&J&K++L+M+4NOP+8QRQ-1+G600+)S+T&!!:!!F?!!:!!U++H=++POP=+

>A9+#:;#B#)CDE+&#%:!@#?$F&#%:!@$!#+G9+G'H=+I&J&K++L+M+4NOP+8QRQ-1+G600+)S+T&!!:!!F?!!:!!U++H=++POP=+

>A9+":$@B?)CDE+&$&:!<#"%F&$&:!<?<!+G9+G'H=+I&J&K++L+M+4NOP+8QRQ-1+G600+)S+T&!!:!!F?!!:!!U++H=++POP=+

>A9+#:#;B#)CDE+"??:"!@%#F"??:"&!#!+G9+G'H=+I&J&K++L+M+4NOP+8QRQ-1+G600+)S+T&!!:!!F?!!:!!U++H=++POP=+

P-7Q0*

=V12Q0*

4-7RQS2*-Q-*

'QWPXY9

'QWPXY9

=(*3*Y9PX9+@#"

=(*3*Y9PX9+?&

=(*3*Y9PX9+&;"%

=(*3*Y9PX9+""";

Page 142: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$$%&%'()*#(+%,%*-%(.*/#(0/&%0("*12*+%3!(

(

(

4f5(

?SB@B?;:@<Y:A(RG(B(9E:?<H<?(CB99(;7(?SB@>:(@B;<7(B=A(@:;:=;<7=(;<C:L(%:8;M(;S:9:(A:;:?;:A(

<7=9(Q:@:(@B=F:A(B??7@A<=>(;7(B(9;B;<9;<?BN(?7=H<A:=?:(N:J:N(EB@BC:;:@(O2VUBND:(q(ILIKP(

<=(B??7@AB=?:(Q<;S(;S:(7R9:@J:A(A<HH:@:=?:(<=(<=;:=9<;G(7R;B<=:A(H7@(;S:(>@7DE9(Q<;S(B=A(

Q<;S7D;(R7B@(;B<=;L(/(9<C<NB@(?7=H<A:=?:(N:J:N(CBG(R:(BEEN<:A(H7@(;S:(@B;<7(7H(;S:(BJ:@B>:(

BRD=AB=?:(7H(:B?S( <7=(7R9:@J:A( <=(:B?S(>@7DEL( &;(QB9(A:?<A:A(;7(?7=9<A:@(B9(@:N:JB=;(

;S79:(<7=9(;SB;(Q:@:(B;(N:B9;(KIo(7@(C7@:(BRD=AB=;(<=(7=:(>@7DE(?7CEB@:A(;7(;S:(7;S:@(

O"7D@B=;( :;( BNLM( 5IIaPL( )<>D@:( ULf( E@:9:=;9( ;S:( J7N?B=7( EN7;( 7H( ;S:( ^ff6( <7=9M( BH;:@(

E@7?:99<=>(;S:(9BCEN:9(Q<;S(B=A(Q<;S7D;(R7B@(;B<=;L(0S:(<7=9(7H(E7;:=;<BN(<=;:@:9;(OQ<;S(

2VUBND:(R:N7Q(ILIK(B=A(@B;<7(7H(;S:(BJ:@B>:(BRD=AB=?:(7H(:B?S(<7=(S<>S:@(;S:=(4LK(7@(

R:N7Q( IL^P( B@:( N7?B;:A( <=( ;S:( QS<;:( B@:BL( /AA<;<7=BNNGM( 7=NG( ;S:( 45"( C7N:?DN:9( Q:@:(

@:;B<=:AL(0S<9(@:9DN;:A(<=(hf(<7=9(;SB;(Q:@:(?7=9<A:@:A(B9(E7;:=;<BNNG(@:N:JB=;(R7B@(;B<=;(

?7CE7D=A9L((

(G,&)01@3)07/+$"7)8/7#)79)#:')T@@U),7"*)7.#$,"'()$9#'%)+758$%,*7")79)+75876"(*)+7//'+#'()9%75)*$58/'*)C,#:)$"()C,#:76#).7$%)#$,"#)C,#:)#:')+7"9,('"+')/,5,#*)97%)4F0$/6')$"()%$#,7)79)#:')

$='%$&')$.6"($"+')79)'$+:),7")7.*'%='(),")'$+:)&%7681)(

&=( 7@A:@( ;7( <A:=;<HG( ;S:( <7=9( ;SB;( E799<RNG( ?7=;@<RD;:( ;7( R7B@( ;B<=;( *2Z!V3/(

B=BNG9:9( Q:@:( ?7=AD?;:AL( /9( 7D;ED;M( ;S:( R<EN7;M( ?N:B@NG( <=A<?B;:9( B( A<9;<=?;(

A<9?@<C<=B;<7=( R:;Q::=( ;S:( >@7DE( Q<;S( B=A( Q<;S7D;( R7B@( ;B<=;( BN7=>( ;S:( 8VB8<9( ON:H;(

9BCEN:9( Q<;S( R7B@( ;B<=;M( @<>S;( 9BCEN:9( Q<;S7D;( R7B@( ;B<=;P( B9( Q:NN( B9( ;S:( A<HH:@:=?:9(

Q<;S<=( ;S:( 9BC:( 9BCEN:( >@7DE( BN7=>( ;S:( GVB8<9( O)<>( UL6PL( 0S:( EN7;( A<9ENBG9( BN97(

9<C<NB@<;<:9( B=A( A<99<C<NB@<;<:9( R:;Q::=( 9BCEN:9( B=A( <7=9L( &7=9( =:B@RG( 9BCEN:9( B@:(

Page 143: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"\/20$#(U(

(

(

4ff(

E@:9:=;( B;( S<>S( ?7=?:=;@B;<7=( Q<;S<=( ;S:9:( 9BCEN:9( B=A( N7Q( <=( 9BCEN:9( 9<;DB;:A(

7EE79<;:L( &=( ;S<9( :8E:@<C:=;M( ;S:( H7?D9( NBG9( 7=( ;S79:( <7=9( ;SB;( B@:( 9<>=<H<?B=;NG(C7@:(

BJB<NBRN:(<=(9BCEN:9(Q<;S(R7B@(;B<=;L(&=(;7;BNM(;:=(<7=9(Q:@:(9<;DB;:A(=:B@RG(;S:(9BCEN:9(

Q<;S(R7B@(;B<=;M(QS<?S(<CEN<:9(;SB;(;S:9:(<7=9(B@:(E7;:=;<BN(?B=A<AB;:9(;7(?7=;@<RD;:(;7(

R7B@(;B<=;(O)<>(ULfPL(

(G,&)01U3)N,8/7#)79)#:')@?)*$58/'*)IC,#:)$"()C,#:76#).7$%)#$,"#L)$"()#:')V@),7"*)#:$#)$%')

87**,./;),58/,+$#'()$*).7$%)#$,"#'()+75876"(*1)(

07( @:J:BN( ;S:( 9<>=<H<?B=?:(7H( ;S:9:( <7=9( <=( @:NB;<7=( ;7(R7B@( ;B<=;M( B=( !VEN7;(QB9(

?7=9;@D?;:A( <=( QS<?S( :B?S( E7<=;( @:E@:9:=;9( B=( <7=( O)<>( ULKPL( &=( ;S<9( EN7;M( ;S:( 8VB8<9(

@:E@:9:=;9( ;S:( JB@<BRN:( ?7=;@<RD;<7=9L( 0S:( HD@;S:@( BQBG( B( AB;B( E7<=;( A:J<B;:9( H@7C(IM(

;S:(C7@:( <;( ?7=;@<RD;:9( ;7( ;S:( JB@<B=?:( 7H( ;S:( 9BCEN:( >@7DEL( 0S:( GVB8<9( A<9ENBG9( ;S:(

9BCEN:(?7@@:NB;<7=(Q<;S<=(;S:(9BC:(9BCEN:(>@7DEL(0S:(HD@;S:@(BQBG(B=(<7=(A:EB@;9(H@7C(

IM(;S:(R:;;:@(<;(?7@@:NB;:9(;7(7;S:@(9BCEN:9(Q<;S<=(;S:(9BCEN:(>@7DEL(/9(B(@:9DN;M(;S:(<7=9(

B;( ;S:( N:H;(:=A(7H( ;S:(!VEN7;( @:E@:9:=;( ;S:( N:BA<=>(?7=;@<RD;<=>( <7=9(Q<;S<=( ;S:(9BCEN:(

Page 144: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$$%&%'()*#(+%,%*-%(.*/#(0/&%0("*12*+%3!(

(

(

4f6(

>@7DE(E79<;<J:(H7@(R7B@(;B<=;M(Q<;S(;S:(S<>S:9;(?7=H<A:=?:L()7@(:8BCEN:M(<7=(K4(B=A(555f(

Q<NN(?7=;@<RD;:(Q<;S(B(S<>S:@(N<F:N<S77A(;7(;S:(R7B@(;B<=;(7A7D@(;SB=(<7=(KjKI(B=A(54hh(

O)<>( ULKPL( 0S:9:( @:9DN;9( B@:( ?7=H<@C:A( RG( ;S:( UB@<BRN:( &CE7@;B=?:( <=( 2@7n:?;<7=( OU&2P(

9?7@:9(O0BRN:(UL6PL(&7=9(Q<;S(B(U&2(!?7@:(>@:B;:@(;SB=(4(?B=(R:(?7=9<A:@:A(B9(<CE7@;B=;M(

QS<N:(<7=9(Q<;S(U&2(9?7@:9(N:99(;SB=(7=:(B@:(N:99(<CE7@;B=;(O0@:CB@7N<(:;(BNLM(5IIaP(O0BRN:(

UL6PL(&7=(KjKI(SB9(B(U&2(9?7@:(7H(7=NG(ILj^M(QS<?S(C:B=9(;SB;(;S:(?7=;@<RD;<7=(7H(;SB;(<7=(

;7( ;S:( R7B@( ;B<=;( 7A7D@( <9( N<C<;:AL( 0S:( 7;S:@( <7=9( SBJ:( U&2( 9?7@:9( S<>S:@( ;S:=( 7=:M(

<CEN<?B;<=>( ;S:<@( 9<>=<H<?B=;( ?7=;@<RD;<7=( ;7( R7B@( ;B<=;L( 0S:( S<>S:@( ;S:( U&2( 9?7@:9( ;S:(

S<>S:@(;S:(?7=;@<RD;<7=(;7(;S:(R7B@(;B<=;(7A7D@(O3<:;CB<@(:;(BNLM(5I45PL((

(G,&)01W3)<F8/7#)%'8%'*'"#,"&)#:')/'$(,"&)+7"#%,.6#,"&),7"*)9%75)#:')*$58/'*)C,#:)$"()C,#:76#)

.7$%)#$,"#X)%'='$/,"&)#:')*,&",9,+$"+')79)#:'*'),7"*1)(

0S:( `DBN<;G( 7H( ;S:(*2Z!V3/(C7A:N(QB9( J:@<H<:A(Q<;S( ?@799VJBN<AB;:A( E@:A<?;<J:(

@:9<ADBN9( O"UV/%*U/M( 2kILI4P( B=A( ;S@::( ?SB@B?;:@<9;<?9( 7H( ;S<9( CDN;<JB@<B;:( C7A:Nc(

#5OdPkILhK6M( #5ObPkILa5a( B=A(g5ObPk( IL^64L( 0S:( S<>S:@( #5OdP( ;S:( R:;;:@( ;S:( E@:A<?;<J:(

B=A(7@;S7>7=BN(JB@<B;<7=(<=(d(<9(:8ENB<=:A(RG(;S:(C7A:NL(17@:7J:@M(;S:(S<>S:@(#5ObP(B=A(

g5ObPM( ;S:( R:;;:@( B( 9:EB@B;<7=( R:;Q::=( 9BCEN:9( Q<;S( B=A(Q<;S7D;( R7B@( ;B<=;(CBG( R:(

!"#$"%&'()*+,#$%-,$*+./01 ./023 ./02 ./0/3 / /0/3 /02 /023.2

./04

./05

./06

./01

/

/01

/06

/05

/04

!"#$"%&'()*+7$8'+)'

Page 145: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

"\/20$#(U(

(

(

4fK(

7R;B<=:AL(0S:(A<HH:@:=?:(R:;Q::=(#5ObP(B=A(g5ObP(CBG(=7;(A<HH:@(C7@:(;S:=(ILf(O"7D@B=;(

:;(BNLM(5IIaPL(

/H;:@QB@A9M( <=A<J<ADBN( @:>@:99<7=( ?7:HH<?<:=;9( Q:@:( ?BN?DNB;:A( H7@( ;S:( ;:=( <7=9(

CB@F:A(B9(E7;:=;<BNNG(R7B@( ;B<=;( ?7=;@<RD;<=>( ?7CE7D=A9( O0BRN:(UL6PL( $<>S;(7H( ;S:( ;:=(

<7=9(A<9ENBG:A(B(9<>=<H<?B=;(O2qILIKP(#5M(QS<?S(<CEN<:9(;SB;(:<>S;(7H(;S:(;:=(?7CE7D=A9(

?7=;@<RD;:( ;7(R7B@( ;B<=;(QS:=( <=;:@E@:;<=>( :J:@G( ?7CE7D=A( <=A<J<ADBNNGL(-S:=( ;BF<=>(

9FB;7N:( B=A( B=A@79;:=7=:( ;7>:;S:@M( Kfo( 7H( ;S:( 9:=97@G( 9?7@:( CBG( R:( :8ENB<=:AL(

\7Q:J:@M(9FB;7N:(B=A(<7=9(4f5h(B=A(K4(;7>:;S:@(:8ENB<=(Kho(7H(;S:(9:=97@G(9?7@:L(0S<9(

QB9( ;S:( R:9;( C7A:N( H7D=A( H7@( ;S<9( AB;B9:;L( +N;<CB;:NGM( :<>S;( <7=9( Q:@:( @:;B<=:A( B9(

E7;:=;<BN(?B=A<AB;:(?7=;@<RD;7@9(;7(;S:(R7B@(;B<=;(7A7D@L()D@;S:@(@:9:B@?S(CD9;(?7=H<@C(

;S:9:(@:9DN;9(RG(<=?NDA<=>(;S:9:(?7CE7D=A9(<=(;S:(?S:C<?BN(B=BNG9:9(B=A(:8EB=A<=>(;S:(

=DCR:@( 7H( <=J:9;<>B;:A( 9BCEN:9L( )<=BNNG( BN97( ;S:( <=;:@B?;<7=( R:;Q::=( ;S:( ?7CE7D=A9(

CD9;(R:(;BF:=(<=;7(B??7D=;L(

( 0S:( H<=BN( 9;:E( 7H( ;S<9( Q7@F( ?7=9<9;:A( 7H( <A:=;<HG<=>( ;S:( <7=9( <=( `D:9;<7=( D9<=>(

@:N:JB=;(AB;BRB9:9L(0S@::(7H(;S:9:(<7=9(O&3c(4K4M(aK(B=A(^P(9S7Q:A(9<C<NB@(CB99:9(B9(;S:(

F=7Q( R7B@( ;B<=;( ?7CE7D=A9( <=A7N:M( 9FB;7N:( B=A( B=A@79;:=7=:L( 0S:@:H7@:M( ;S:( CB99(

A:J<B;<7=9( 7H( ;S:9:( <7=9( Q:@:( ?BN?DNB;:A( B=A( :8E@:99:A( <=( EB@;9( E:@( C<NN<7=( OEECPL(

"BN?DNB;<7=9( Q:@:( B9( H7NN7Q9c( 4I^( r( WOC:B9D@:A( CB99( s( ;S:7@:;<?BN( CB99P[;S:7@:;<?BN(

CB99XL(0S:(7R;B<=:A(CB99(A:J<B;<7=9(Q:@:(R:N7Q(K(EECM(<=A<?B;<=>(B(S<>S(CB99(B??D@B?G(

O0BRN:( UL6PL( /N97( ;S:( @:;:=;<7=( ;<C:( QB9( ;S:( 9BC:( B9( :8E:?;:A( B=A( ;S:( @:NB;<J:( <7=(

<=;:=9<;<:9(7H(;S:(?7@@:9E7=A<=>(<97;7E<?( <7=9(Q:@:(Q<;S<=(;S:(@B=>:(A:;:@C<=:A(RG("3(

55I[^Kj[$"L(0S:9:(;S@::(EB@BC:;:@9(BNN7Q:A(<A:=;<H<?B;<7=(7H(;S:(?7CE7D=A9(B9(<=A7N:M(

9FB;7N:(B=A(B=A@79;:=7=:L()7@(;S:(<A:=;<H<?B;<7=(7H(;S:(7;S:@(?7CE7D=A9M(;S:@:(B@:(9;<NN(

7=NG( H:Q( ;77N9( BJB<NBRN:( ;SB;( ?B=( BD;7CB;<?BNNG( >:=:@B;:( B( N<9;( 7H( E799<RN:( ?S:C<?BN(

9;@D?;D@:9(?7@@:9E7=A<=>(;7(B(><J:=(!#Y(JBND:(RB9:A(7=(AB;BRB9:9(9D?S(B9("S:C9E<A:@L(

Page 146: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!

!

!"#$%&'()*&+,-.&"$$,/"0%1&0,&02%&."34$%&56,74&4,.8089%&:,6&#,"6&0"8-0&;802&02%86&6%.4%/089%&81%-08:8/"08,-&-73#%6&<+=>?&3,$%/7$"6&;%8520&<@A>?&3"..&,9%6&/2"65%&6"08,&<3BC>?&6%0%-08,-&083%&<D!>?&6"08,&,:&02%&6%$"089%&"#7-1"-/%&,:&%"/2&8,-&,#.%69%1&8-&%"/2&56,74&<6"08,>?&EF9"$7%&,:&02%&18::%6%-08"$&

"-"$G.%.&<'"68"#$%&+34,60"-/%&8-&E6,H%/08,-&./,6%&<'+E>?&D%56%..8,-&/,%::8/8%-0&<DI>?&3"..&1%98"08,-&<J3>?&%$%3%-0"$&/,34,.808,-&"-1&/2%38/"$&-"3%(&&

+=& @A& 3BC& !& D"08,& EF'"$7%& '+E& DI& J3&&&<443>&

K$%3%-0"$&/,34,.808,-&

L2%38/"$&-"3%&

"#$%! #&"'&$(#

)!

#&%'&*)+

%!

#'%%! &'+$! &'&"! #'#(! &'#+",! &'*(! -).#&/"! 0123456789!498:!*+"! ##$'&(%"

(!

##*'&;&)

$!

#'(#! &');! &'&#! #'"%! &'#(+,! %'*$! -$.#"/"! .6<4=289!498:!#)#! ##*'&)**

">!##('&$)&

&!

#'"+! &'%#! &'&+! #'#)! &'%%*,! #'&"! -(.*?! 0=:256!;)! #%#'&*%#

(>!#%"'&(&+

)!

"'&$! &'+"! &'&"! #'#(! &'%(;,! &'$&! -;.;?! @A4B256!)#! #+*'&$(&

"!

#+('&*)%

&!

#'&#! &'#%! &'&+! #')#! &'#$%,! "'$%! -;.;?/! $CD6BE2<F!8=:256!)*)&! #)"'&)&"

%!

#)%'&)++

*!

+'&*! &'"&! &'&+! &'*$! &'&"+! ! ! !#%"(! #$&'&(($

+!

#$#'&;)&

;!

+'$"! &')*! &'&#! #'"&! &'"&%,! ! ! !"""%! ")+'"&#(

+!

"))'"&;#

"!

)'%$! &'+)! &'&#! #'%)! &'#(%,! ! ! !$! "*"'"#%$

#>!"*%'""&(

(!

)'%+! &'";! &'&"! #'#&! &'+"+,! "'&)! -#;."(/! G=:721B6=2=6!"#((! "*&'")))

)!

"*#'"$#%

(!

%'(;! &');! &'&%! #'&)! &'&#;! ! ! !>!02=1!H8BE!18D8547!D41161!41!BE6!A=2H=!I247!B48=B!92DJ2K=:1L!8=:256M!1A4B256!4=:!4=:721B6=2=6!,!NC345K6!2O!BE6!76P761182=!926OO8986=B!Q!&'&)!

!

!

!

! !

!

Page 147: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()(

(

(

(

*+,(

-./.0.12(3212.345(67/5(!528197:23(93;<7:2:(/2=/./7<2(7:2=/7>74./7;=(>;3(/5322(7;=1?(7;=(

@*A+( B71;<.C2374( .47:DE( ,F@( B52G.=;74( .47:E( ;:;H3( /5./( 71( >.//IE( 45221IE( 6.GIE( .=:(

321280C21( /5./(;>(J;./1(;3(;/523(0.3=I.3:(.=78.C1D(.=:(K*( BAL82/5;GI7=:;C2E(=;(:./.(

67/5( 321924/( /;(;:;H3(.<.7C.0C2DM(%52(8.11(:2<7./7;=1(;>( /5212( 7;=1(6232( 321924/7<2CI?(

NM,OE(+M,A(.=:(@MA+(998(B%.0C2()MFD(.=:(.C1;(/52(32C./7<2(7;=(7=/2=17/721(6232(67/57=(/52(

3.=J2(:2/2387=2:(0I(!-(@NN@PAK,P&!M(

";62<23E( .=.CI17=J( /52( 4;33219;=:7=J( 4;882347.CCI( .<.7C.0C2( 1/.=:.3:1( 7=( /52(

1.82( .=.CI/74.C( 1I1/28( H=:23( 7:2=/74.C( 4;=:7/7;=1( 71( 324;882=:2:( /;( 4;=>738( /52(

7:2=/7>74./7;=(;>( /52( 7;=1(0I(2MJM( 32/2=/7;=( /782M(#/( /52( /782E(=;(9;17/7<2( 7:2=/7>74./7;=(

4;HC:( 02( .4572<2:( >;3( /52( 328.7=7=J( /6;( 7;=1M( Q;3( 7;=( *+@O( 2<2=( 453;8./;J3.9574(

7:2=/7>74./7;=(93;<2:(H=1H44211>HC(BQ7J()M@DM(R24.H12(;>(7/1(57J5(4;332C./7;=(67/5(/52(0;.3(

/.7=/( ;:;H3( .=:( )S$( 14;32E( 7/( 71( 5;62<23( C7T2CI( /5./( /571( 7;=( 4;=/370H/21( /;( 0;.3( /.7=/M(

QH3/523(3212.345(67CC(02(=24211.3I(/;(.4572<2(.(J;;:(453;8./;J3.9574(7:2=/7>74./7;=(0I(

7893;<7=J( >;3( 2G.89C2( /52( 1.89C2( 4C2.=LH9E( 923>;387=J( 7/1( :2/24/7;=( ;>( /52( =2J./7<2(

8;:2E(2/4M(

(

!" #$%&'()*$%+

-H2(/;( /52( C;6(4;332C./7;=(02/622=(12=1;3I(.=.CI121(.=:(452874.C(.=.CI121E( 7/(

5.1( 022=( :7>>74HC/( /;( H=.807JH;H1CI( :2>7=2( 12=1;3I( /53215;C:( C2<2C1( >;3( 0;.3( /.7=/(

67/5;H/(=2J./7<2(923429/7;=(;>(/52(4;=1H823M(U=2(;>(/52(5I9;/52121(71(/5./(4;89;H=:1(

;/523( /5.=( /52( /5322( .4T=;6C2:J2:( ;=21( 4;=/370H/2( /;( 0;.3( /.7=/( .=:(8.I( /5232>;32(

7=432.12( /52( 4;332C./7;=M( V7/57=( /571( 1/H:IE( .( /6;L6.I( 1/3./2JI( 6.1( >;CC;62:?( .=(

H=/.3J2/2:( 14322=7=J( 67/5( W!LX=7>>LYX( .=:( .( /.3J2/2:( .=:( H=/.3J2/2:( 14322=7=J(

/53;HJ5( 9;1/L.4ZH717/7;=( 32L7=/233;J./7;=( ;>( :./.( 4;CC24/2:( >3;8( .( <.1/( :./.12/( ;>( >./(

1.89C21( .=.CI12:( 2.3C723( 0I( ["$\L"'LYXM( [17=J( /52( W!LX=7>>LYX( .993;.45E( 27J5/(

9;/2=/7.CCI( 4;=/370H/7=J( 4;89;H=:1( 6232( 7:2=/7>72:M( %5212( 4;89;H=:1( /;J2/523( 67/5(

4;89;H=:1(329;3/2:(7=( C7/23./H32(.1(9;1170CI(3219;=170C2(>;3(0;.3(/.7=/(6232(H12:(7=(.(

/.3J2/2:( 9;1/L.4ZH717/7;=( .993;.45M( Q3;8( /52( *F( 4;89;H=:1( C71/2:E( /6;( 4;89;H=:1E(

=.82CI(FE*AL.=:3;1/.:72=L+L;=2(.=:(71;<.C2374(.47:(6232(9;17/7<2CI(4;332C./2:(67/5(/52(

Page 148: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

X!'&&]S]W(QU'([]^]UV](RU#'(%#S]%(!UY$U[]-X(

(

(

(

*+O(

0;.3( /.7=/(;:;H3(:2/2387=2:( /53;HJ5(12=1;3I(.=.CI171M(V7/57=( /571(:./.12/(A,_(;>( /52(

12=1;3I(14;32(4.=(02(2G9C.7=2:(0I(1T./;C2(.=:(.=:3;1/2=;=2M(%571(92342=/.J2(:;21(=;/(

7=432.12(652=(7=:;C2E(FE*AL.=:3;1/.:72=L+L;=2(;3(71;<.C2374(.47:(.32(.::2:M(%5232>;32E(

7/( 71(93;0.0C2( /5./(.C1;( /52( 7=/23.4/7;=(02/622=(4;89;H=:1( 71( 7=<;C<2:M(#99C74./7;=(;>(

/52(H=/.3J2/2:( 14322=7=J(.993;.45(0I(H17=J(:7>>232=/7.C( .=:(U$\XL-#(.=.CI121(;=( /52(

1.82(:./.0.12E(.CC;62:(/;(32/.7=(.=;/523(12<2=(4;89;H=:1(;H/(;>(A++F( 7;=1M( S=( /;/.C(

B/.3J2/2:(.=:(H=/.3J2/2:(.993;.45D(=7=2(7;=1(6232(9;1/HC./2:(.1(9;1170C2(4;=/370H/7=J(

4;89;H=:1( /;( 0;.3( /.7=/( Q3;8( /5212( =7=2( 7;=1E( /5322( 6232( 7:2=/7>72:( .1( /52(

.4T=;6C2:J2:( 0;.3( /.7=/( 4;89;H=:1( 7=:;C2E( 1T./;C2( .=:( .=:3;1/2=;=2E( 657C2( >;H3(

;/5231(6232(7:2=/7>72:(.1(71;<.C2374(.47:E(52G.=;74(.47:(.=:(AL82/5;GI(7=:;C2(.=:(FE*AL

.=:3;1/.:72=L+L;=2M( #=;/523( /6;( 7;=1( 328.7=( H=7:2=/7>72:M(YHC/79C2( C7=2.3( 32J32117;=(

:28;=1/3./2:( /5./( KO_( ;>( /52( 12=1;3I( 14;32( 4.=( 02( 2G9C.7=2:( 0I( 1T./;C2E( AL

82/5;GI7=:;C2(.=:(7;=(*+@O(657C2(1T./;C2(.=:(.=:3;1/2=;=2(;=CI(2G9C.7=(>;3(K+_(;>(/52(

14;32M(

(

," -&.%$/'012030%4)+

%571( 3212.345(6.1( >H=:2:(0I( .($5-(J3.=/(;>( /52( S=1/7/H/2( >;3( /52($3;8;/7;=(;>(

S==;<./7;=( /53;HJ5( X472=42( .=:( %245=;C;JI( 7=( QC.=:231( BSV%LQC.=:231DM( %52( .H/5;31(

6;HC:( C7T2( /;( /5.=T( XM( -26HC>E(YM(].2112=1E(YM( #H:2=.23/E( ^M( %3HI2=E( 'M( \7892=1E( -M(

X/;4TGE(SM(U91/2I=(.=:(`M(W;2:J20H23(>;3(/5273(/245=74.C(4;=/370H/7;=(/;(/571(6;3TM(

( +

Page 149: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()(

(

(

(

*+a(

5" 607080%&0)+

(#CH6b(YME(\.=J2=:3721(^M(!M(YME(R2T.23/(^ME(%HI//2=1(QM(#M(YME(-2(R3.0.=:23(-ME(-2(X82/(

XM(c(Y7CC2/(XM(B@N*@DM(&>>24/(;>(1H3J74.C(4.1/3./7;=E(788H=;4.1/3./7;=(.=:(4574;3IL:72/(;=(/52(82./(ZH.C7/I(.=:(9.C./.07C7/I(;>(0;.31M(Y2./(X472=42E(1H087//2:M(

R.0;C( `M(c( XZH7321( &M( `M( B*aaKDM(dH.C7/I( ;>(82./( >3;8(2=/732(8.C2( 97J1M( Q;;:('212.345(S=/23=./7;=.CE(@OB+DE(@N*L@*@M(

R23:.JH2(`M(\ME(-2=;I23(!ME(\2ZH232(`M(\M(c(X28;=(&M(B*aa*DM();C./7C2(4;89;=2=/1(;>(:3IL4H32:(5.8M(`;H3=.C(;>(#J374HC/H3.C(.=:(Q;;:(!52871/3IE(+aB,DE(*@K,L*@A*M(

R;==2.H(YM( B*aO@DM( !;89;H=:1( 3219;=170C2( >;3( 0;.3( /.7=/E( 67/5( 19247.C( 2895.171( ;=(.=:3;1/2=;=2(L(#(32<726(\7<21/;4T($3;:H4/7;=(X472=42E(aBADE(AO,L,NKM(

R;==2.H(YM(B*aa+DM(&>>24/1(;>(:7>>232=/(4;89;H=:1(;=(0;.3(/.7=/M(FF/5(#==H.C(Y22/7=J(;>(/52(&##$E(#.35H1E(-2=8.3TE(*AL*a(#HJH1/E($@M+E(+@AL+@,M(

R3;;T1( 'M( SM( c( $2.31;=( #M( YM( B*aOaDM( U:;3( /53215;C:( ;>( /52( !*aL:2C/.L*AL1/23;7:1(

3219;=170C2(>;3(0;.3(;:;3(7=(9;3TM(Y2./(X472=42E(@KB*DE(**L*aM(!C.H1( 'M( B*a,aDM( $523;8;=2( 027( XeHJ2/7232=( H=:23( 021;=:232( R23f4T1745/7JH=J( :21(

&023J23H451/;>>21( H=:( 127=23( R2g725H=J( gH( .=:232=( ";:2=1/23;7:2=M(Q;3/14537//2( 7=( :2g( %72391I457;C;J72( H=:( %72323=e53H=JE( "2>/( *NE( )23C.J( $.HC($.32IE(".80H3J(H=:(R23C7=M(

!;T23(YM(-ME(V21/('M(\ME(R32=:28H5C(`M("ME(R32=:28H5C(-M(-ME(`;5=1;=(-M(-M(c(X/2CgC2=7(#M(YM( B@NNaDM( &>>24/1( ;>( C7<2( 627J5/( .=:( 93;42117=J( ;=( /52( 12=1;3I( /3.7/1E(.=:3;1/2=2:7;=2( 4;=42=/3./7;=( .=:( KL.C95.L.=:3;1/L*AL2=L+L;=2(B.=:3;1/2=;=2D(4;=42=/3./7;=(7=(0;.3(82./M(Y2./(X472=42E(O@B+DE(+aaLFNFM(

!;H3.=/( QME( $7=2C( WME( R745;=( &ME( Y;=/2.H( QME( #=/7J=.4( `M( $M( c( \2( R7g24( RM( B@NNaDM(

-2<2C;982=/(;>(.(82/.0;C;874(.993;.45(0.12:(;=(C7ZH7:(453;8./;J3.95IL57J5(321;CH/7;=(8.11(1924/3;82/3I(/;(14322=(>;3(4C2=0H/23;C(.0H12(7=(4.C<21M(#=.CI1/E(*+FBODE(*A+,L*AFAM(

-72/8.73(XME(";:1;=(YM($ME(dH2T(\M(&ME(%7887=1(]M(&ME(W3.I($M(c(]72C12=(\M(^M( B@N*@DM(#(YHC/7LU8741(#=.CI171( ;>( '24;807=.=/( $3;/27=( $3;:H4/7;=( 7=("2T@a+(!2CC1M( $\;X(U]&E(,BODE(2F++aFM(:;7?F++*NMF*+,*Ph;H3=.CM9;=2MNNF++aF((

&QX#M( B@NNFDM( V2C>.32( .1924/1( ;>( /52( 4.1/3./7;=( ;>( 97JC2/1?( X472=/7>74( '29;3/( ;>( /52(X472=/7>74( $.=2C( >;3( #=78.C( "2C./5( .=:(V2C>.32( ;=( .( 32ZH21/( >3;8( 4;887117;=(32C./2:(/;(62C>.32(.1924/1(;>(/52(4.1/3./7;=(;>($7JC2/1M(%52(&QX#(`;H3=.CE(a*E(*L*OM(

&H3;92.=( !;88H=7/IM( B@NN@DM( !;887117;=1( -24717;=( @NN@PAK,P&!M( U>>747.C( `;H3=.C( ;>(/52(&H3;92.=(!;88H=7/IE(@@*E(OL+AM(

Q714523( `ME( &C17=J5;31/( $M( VME( RH4T7=J( YME( %5;C2=( &ME( $2/2312=( RM( c( VH1/( YM( B@N**DM(-2<2C;982=/( ;>( .( !.=:7:./2( '2>232=42( Y2/5;:( >;3( /52( X78HC/.=2;H1(dH.=/7/./7;=(;>(/52(R;.3(%.7=/(!;89;H=:1(#=:3;1/2=;=2E(+(.C95.L#=:3;1/2=;CE(+( 02/.L#=:3;1/2=;CE( XT./;C2E( .=:( S=:;C2( 7=( $7J( Q./( 0I(Y2.=1( ;>( X/.0C2( S1;/;92(

Page 150: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

X!'&&]S]W(QU'([]^]UV](RU#'(%#S]%(!UY$U[]-X(

(

(

(

*FN(

-7CH/7;=( #=.CI171L"2.:19.42( X;C7:L$5.12( Y743;2G/3.4/7;=LW.1(!53;8./;J3.95IPY.11(X924/3;82/3IM(#=.CI/74.C(!52871/3IE(O+B*,DE(A,OKLA,a*M(

W23112=(#ME(YHC:23($M($M(`M(c(:2(R;23(`M(B@N**DM(X4322=7=J(;>( C79;957C74(8.37=2(/;G7=1(7=(152CC>715( .=:( .CJ.2?( -2<2C;982=/( ;>( .( C703.3I( H17=J( C7ZH7:( 453;8./;J3.95I(4;H9C2:(/;(;307/3.9(8.11(1924/3;82/3IM(#=.CI/74.(!57874.(#4/.E(AOKB@DE(*,AL*OKM(

".HJ2=( `M( &ME( R3H=7H1( !M( c( i.8.3./1T.7.( WM( B@N*@DM( '2<726( ;>( .=.CI/74.C( 82/5;:1( /;(82.1H32( 0;.3( /.7=/( 4;89;H=:1( 7=( 9;347=2( .:79;12( /711H2?( %52( =22:( >;3(5.38;=712:(82/5;:1M(Y2./(X472=42E(aNB*DE(aL*aM(

".HJ2=( `M( &ME( QC.//2=(#M(c(#=:3212=(UM( B@NNKDM( S=/3.4.34.11( <.3./7;=(;>( .=:3;1/2=;=2E(1T./;C2(.=:(7=:;C2(>./(C2<2C1(7=(2=/732(8.C2(97J1M(&##$(V;3T7=J(W3;H9(&=/732(8.C2(97J1E([991.C.E(X62:2=M(

`.38;CHT(\ME(Y.3/7=(#M("M(c(Q32:22=("M(%M(B*a,NDM(-2/24/7;=(;>(/.7=/(B12G(;:;3D( 7=(9;3TM(!.=.:7.=(`;H3=.C(;>(#=78.C(X472=42E(KNB+DE(,KNM(

Y./5H3($M(^ME( %2=(].92C( `ME(RC;285;>(XME("2321( \ME( ^=;C(&M( QM(c(YHC:23("M(#M( B@N*@DM(#(5H8.=(=;12(14;37=J(1I1/28(>;3(0;.3(/.7=/(.=:(7/1(32C./7;=1579(67/5(.=:3;1/2=;=2(.=:(1T./;C2M(Y2./(X472=42E(a*E(F*FLF@@M(

].3<.2gL'7<.1( YME( W.CC.3:;( &ME( '7;1( `M( `M( c( \2;=L!.8.45;( YM( B@N*NDM( #( /2=/./7<2(45.3.4/237g./7;=(;>(<;C./7C2(4;89;H=:1(>3;8(S0237.=(-3IL!H32:(".8(.44;3:7=J(/;(:7>>232=/(.=./;874.C(C;4./7;=1M(#(:2/.7C2:(1/H:IM(W3.1.1(j(#427/21E(A*BFDE(+AaL+,,M(

$.//231;=('M(\M(XM(B*aA,DM(#(9;1170C2(4;=/370H/7;=(;>(952=;C74(4;89;=2=/1(/;(0;.3(;:;H3M(`;H3=.C(;>(/52(X472=42(;>(Q;;:(.=:(#J374HC/H32E(*OE(OL*NM(

$.//231;=( 'M( \M( XM( B*aAODM( KkL.=:3;1/L*AL2=2L+L;=2( 4;89;H=:( 3219;=170C2( >;3( /.7=/( 7=(0;.3(>./M(`;H3=.C(;>(/52(X472=42(;>(Q;;:(.=:(#J374HC/H32E(*aB*DE(+*M(

$.HCI(!ME(X937=JLX/.25C7($ME(Ul-;523/I(`M()ME(^3.J/2=(XM(#ME(-H0;71(XME(Y211.:2=2(`M(c(R22(WM( B@N*NDM( %52( 2>>24/1( ;>( 82/5;:( ;>( 4.1/3./7;=E( 32.37=J( 4;=:7/7;=( .=:( :72/( ;=(12=1;3I( ZH.C7/I( ;>( 9;3T( .112112:( 0I( .( /3.7=2:( 9.=2CM(Y2./( X472=42E( OAB@DE( FaOL

KNFM('7H1(YM(#M(c(W.347.L'2JH273;(`M(#M(B@NN*DM(';C2(;>(FL952=ICL+L0H/2=L@L;=2(7=(0;.3(/.7=?(

7:2=/7>74./7;=( ;>( =26( 4;89;H=:1( 32.C/2:( /;( 12=1;37.C( :214379/;31( 7=( 97J( >./M(`;H3=.C(;>(#J374HC/H3.C(.=:(Q;;:(!52871/3IE(FaB**DE(K+N+LK+NaM(

'7H1(YM(#ME(";3/;1(YM(c(W.347.L'2JH273;(`M(#M(B@NNKDM(S=>CH2=42(;>(<;C./7C2(4;89;H=:1(;=(/52(:2<2C;982=/(;>(;>>L>C.<;H31(7=(97J(0.4T(>./(1.89C21(4C.117>72:(67/5(0;.3(/.7=/(

0I(.(/21/(9.=2CM(Y2./(X472=42E(,*BFDE(KaKLAN@M(%52;:;37:71(WM(#ME(W7T.("M(WME(V.=/(&M(`M(c(V7C1;=(SM(-M(B@N*@DM(\7ZH7:(453;8./;J3.95IL

8.11( 1924/3;82/3I( 0.12:( JC;0.C( 82/.0;C7/2( 93;>7C7=J?( #( 32<726M( #=.CI/74.(!57874.(#4/.E(,**E(,L*AM(

%328.3;C7()ME(V;3T2=/7=2(YM(\ME(V2Ch72(#M(YME();J2C("M(`ME(!237("ME()7/7(!ME(%.//7(&ME(i5.=J(

$ME("I=21(#M($ME(%H3=23('M( `M(c(i.==;=7(-M( B@NNaDM(Y2/.0;C;874( S=<21/7J./7;=(;>(

Page 151: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()(

(

(

(

*F*(

/52( R.4/237.C( '219;=12( /;( .( Y2/.C( !5.CC2=J2M( #99C72:( .=:( &=<73;=82=/.C(Y743;07;C;JIE(,KB+DE(,*aL,@OM(

)2352I:2=(^ME(];992("ME(#CH62(YME(Y7CC2/(XME(RH11452(`M()M(c(-2(R3.0.=:23("M(QM(B@NN,DM(-2<2C;982=/(.=:(<.C7:./7;=(;>(.(82/5;:( >;3(178HC/.=2;H1(.=.CI171(;>( /52(0;.3(/.7=/( 4;89;H=:1( 7=:;C2E( 1T./;C2( .=:( .=:3;1/2=;=2( 7=( 97J( >./( H17=J( C7ZH7:(

453;8./;J3.95IL8HC/79C2( 8.11( 1924/3;82/3IM( `;H3=.C( ;>( !53;8./;J3.95I( #E(**,FB*L@DE(*+@L*+,M(

V27C23([ME(-25=5.3:(YME("23023/(&M(c(!C.H1('M(B*aaKDM(&7=>CH1(<;=(W21457245/E(W2=;/I9(=:(Y.1/2=:J26745/(.H>(:72(#=:3;1/2=;=L(H=:(1T./;CT;=g2=/3./7;=2=(78(Q2//(<;=(8.1/145627=2=M(-72(&0238.1/E(*FL++M(

V27C23( [ME( Q714523( ^ME( ^28823( "ME( -;03;6;C1T7( #M( c( !C.H1( 'M( B*aa,DM( S=>CH2=42( ;>(

.=:3;1/2=;=2(12=17/7<7/I(;=(4;=1H823(32.4/7;=1(/;(0;.3(82./M(S=(YM(R;==2.HE(^M(\H=:1/3;8(c( RM(Y.C8>;31( B&:1MDE( R;.3( %.7=/( 7=( &=/732(Y.C2( $7J1( B99M( *F,L*K*DM(V.J2=7=J2=?(V.J2=7=J2=(#4.:2874($H0C715231M(

(((

(

(

(

(

Page 152: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

(

(

(

(

+

Page 153: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

Chapter VI

General discussion and future perspectives

Page 154: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

(

(

(

(

+

(

Page 155: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()S(

(

(

(

*FK(

#9-:;<6+=>+

?<@<6-A+B>C#DCC>E@+-@B+FD;D6<+:<6C:<#;>=<C+

G" ?0%08H'+80)0H8&I+$(4&$30+

*M*M :$)*4*$%*%2+$7+4I0+4I0)*)+

!.1/3./7;=(;>(8.C2(97J1(71(.(<23I(;C:(4H1/;8(/5./(6.1(4.3372:(;H/(/53;HJ5;H/(/52(

I2.31(/;(4;=/3;C(12GH.C(025.<7;H3(.=:(/;(;0/.7=(4.C823(.=:(>.//23(97J1E(0H/(.C1;(/;(.<;7:(

0;.3( /.7=/( 7=( :237<2:(82./( .=:(82./( 93;:H4/1M( R24.H12( ;>(62C>.32( 4;=423=1E( 1;472/.C(

93211H32( 5.1( 7=432.12:( :H37=J( /52( C.1/( I2.31( /;( 42.12( 1H3J74.C( 4.1/3./7;=( 67/5;H/(

.=.21/5217.( ;3P.=:( .=.CJ217.M( %5232>;32E( 3293212=/./7<21( ;>( &H3;92.=( >.38231E( 82./(

7=:H1/3IE( 32/.7C231E( 1472=/71/1E( <2/237=.37.=1( .=:( .=78.C( 62C>.32( ]WU1( 5.<2( <;CH=/.37CI(

17J=2:(/52(&H3;92.=(-24C.3./7;=(B@N*ND(;=(.C/23=./7<21(/;(1H3J74.C(4.1/3./7;=(;>(97J1M(RI(

17J=7=J(/571(:24C.3./7;=E(/52(:7>>232=/(9.3/721(4;887//2:(/;(9H/(.=(2=:(./(/52(93.4/742(;>(

1H3J74.C( 4.1/3./7;=(;>( 97J1(67/5;H/( 93;C;=J2:( .=.CJ217.( ;3P.=:( .=.21/5217.( 0I( `.=H.3I(

@N*@(.=:(/;(.0.=:;=(1H3J74.C(4.1/3./7;=(0I(`.=H.3I(@N*OM(S=(3242=/(I2.31E(.(<.1/(.8;H=/(

;>( 3212.345( 5.1( 022=( 4;=:H4/2:( ;=( .C/23=./7<21( >;3( 1H3J74.C( 4.1/3./7;=( 67/5;H/(

.=.21/5217.E(.8;=J1/(65745(4.1/3./7;=(67/5(.=.CJ217.(.=:P;3(.=.21/5217.( B&QX#E(@NNFm(

XH/523C.=:( 2/( .CME( @N*@DE( 788H=;4.1/3./7;=( BY2/g( c( !C.H1E( @NN+m( i.8.3./1T.7.( c(

XZH7321E( @NNaDE( ;3( /52( 93;:H4/7;=( ;>( 2=/732( 8.C21( 7=( 4;807=./7;=( 67/5( 8.=.J282=/(

1/3./2J721(B#CH6b(2/(.CME(@N**m(#CH6b(2/(.CME(@NNam(XZH7321E(@NNAD(.32(/52(8;1/(9;9HC.3M((

%52( 93;:H4/7;=( ;>( 2=/732( 8.C2( 97J1( 789C721( /5./( /.7=/2:( 82./( ;HJ5/( /;( 02(

932<2=/2:( >3;8(2=/237=J( /52(8.3T2/( 7=(;3:23( /;( .<;7:(=2J./7<2( 4;=1H823(923429/7;=M(

X7=42(3212.345(;=(0;.3(82./(02J.=E(7/(5.1(022=(1924HC./2:(/5./(/52(=2J./7<2(789.4/(;>(

93;42112:( /.7=/2:(82./(6;HC:( 02( C211( /5.=( /5./( ;>( >3215(82./( 024.H12( 93;42117=J( 7=(

<.37;H1( 6.I1( 8.I( 8.1T( ;3( :2432.12( /52( =2J./7<2( 923429/7;=( ;>( 1T./;C2( .=:(

.=:3;1/2=;=2( BY.//5261( 2/( .CME( @NNNDM( Q3;8( C7/23./H32( 7/( 71( T=;6=( /5./( aa_( ;>( /52(

4;=1H8231(.32(12=17/7<2(/;(1T./;C2(BV27C23(2/(.CME(*aa,DE(657C2(.=:3;1/2=;=2(12=17/7<7/I(71(

J2=2/74.CCI( :2/2387=2:( B^2CC23( 2/( .CME( @NN,D( .=:( :7>>231( 02/622=( 12G21E( .J21E( 2/4M(

";62<23E( 7=4CH:7=J( .=:3;1/2=;=2( 12=17/7<7/I( 7=( 4;=1H823( 1/H:721( ;>( /.7=/2:( ;3(

Page 156: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

-SX![XXSU](#]-(Q[%['&($&'X$&!%S)&X(

(

(

*FA(

9;/2=/7.CCI( /.7=/2:(82./(93;:H4/1E(6;HC:(.CC;6( /;(2<.CH./2(652/523( /52(4;=1H8231( 7=(

/5./(1/H:I(.32(3293212=/./7<2(>;3(/52(932:2>7=2:(4;=1H823(12=17/7<7/I(;>(/5./(9;9HC./7;=(

>;3(0;.3(/.7=/M(X7=42(/52(9;3T(7=:H1/3I(:2<.CH./21(2<23I(82./(93;:H4/(67/5(.=I(=2J./7<2(

923429/7;=E( 7/( 71(9.3/74HC.3CI( 789;3/.=/( /5./( /52(8;1/(12=17/7<2(4;=1H823( 71( 7=4CH:2:( 7=(

>H/H32(4;=1H823(.4429/.=42(2<.CH./7;=1M(S=(/571(4;=/2G/E(.=:3;1/2=;=2(12=17/7<7/I(8H1/(

02(:2/2387=2:(>;3(2<23I(4;H=/3I(.=:P;3(32J7;=(129.3./2CI(024.H12(/571(12=17/7<7/I(:7>>231(

02/622=(4;H=/3721(BW7C023/(c(VI1;4T7E(*aO,m(\H=:2(2/(.CME(@NNam(V27C23(2/(.CME(@NNNDM(

%;(.<;7:(82./(67/5(H=.4429/.0C2(57J5(0;.3(/.7=/(/;(32.45(/52(8.3T2/(.=:(C2.:(/;(

H=6.=/2:( =2J./7<2( 4;=1H823( 32.4/7;=1E( 0;.3( /.7=/( 8H1/( 02( :2/24/2:( ./( /52(

1C.HJ5/23C7=2M(!52874.C(.=:(12=1;3I(.=.CI121(5.<2(022=(:2<2C;92:(>;3(;<23(@N(I2.31(/;(

ZH.=/7>I( /52( 4;89;H=:1( 4;=/370H/7=J( /;( 0;.3( /.7=/( 7=( 2=/732( 8.C2( 97J1E( .=:( 8;32(

3242=/CI(/;(2<.CH./2(/52(:7>>232=/(.C/23=./7<21(>;3(4.1/3./7;=(67/5;H/(.=.21/5217.M(#(67:2(

3.=J2( ;>( .=.CI/74.C( 82/5;:1( 5.1( 022=( 93;9;12:( /;( :2/24/( /52( T=;6=( 0;.3( /.7=/(

4;89;H=:1( 7=(.:79;12(/711H2M(";62<23E( /52(8.h;37/I(;>( /5212(82/5;:1(.=.CI121(1;C2CI(

.=:3;1/2=;=2( B-2( R3.0.=:23( c( )2302T2E( *aOAm( ^.H>8.==( 2/( .CME( *a,Am( %5;891;=( c(

$2.31;=E( *a,,D( ;3( /52( 7=:;C74( 4;89;H=:1( Bi.8.3./1T.7.( c( `.1/320;<.E( @NNADE( 65745(

32=:231(/52(.=.CI121(/782(4;=1H87=J(n(.=:(52=42(4;1/CI(L(652=(0;/5(4;89;H=:1(8H1/(

02( ZH.=/7>72:M( R24.H12( ;>( /52( .012=42( ;>( JH7:2C7=21( >;3( /52( .=.CI171( ;>( ;:;3;H1(

4;89;H=:1E(8;1/(82/5;:1(.<.7C.0C2(1;(>.3(5.<2(=;/(022=(1H>>7472=/CI(7=L5;H12(<.C7:./2:(

67/5( 32J.3:( /;( :;4H82=/./7;=( ;>(82/5;:( 923>;38.=42( 45.3.4/2371/741( B".HJ2=( 2/( .CME(

@N*@DM(#/(93212=/E(/5212(452874.C(.=.CI121(4.==;/(02(H12:(./LC7=2(7=(/52(1C.HJ5/235;H12(

024.H12( ;>( 93.4/74.C( 4;=423=1( B2MJM( =;( ./LC7=2( :2/24/7;=( 82/5;:E( /782( 4;=1H87=JE(

4;89C74./2:(1.89C2(9329.3./7;=DE(0H/(.32(32ZH732:(/;(1H99;3/(/52(12=1;3I(.=.CI121(:./.(

024.H12(/52I(92387/(ZH.=/7>74./7;=(;>(0;.3(/.7=/(4;89;H=:1M(

S=:22:E( /52( C.4T( ;>( .( <.C7:./2:( 2C24/3;=74( :2/24/7;=( 1I1/28( 32ZH7321( 8;1/(

1C.HJ5/235;H121(B.=:(3212.345231D(/;(H12(12=1;3I(.1121182=/(0I(5H8.=(2G923/1(>;3(/52(

3.97:( :2/2387=./7;=( ;>( 0;.3( /.7=/( 7=( 4.34.1121( ./( /52( 1C.HJ5/23C7=2M( %5212( ;C>.4/;3I(

14;37=J( 1I1/281( 32ZH732( /52( 52./7=J( ;3( 17=J27=J( ;>( .( 1.89C2( 8./37G( BH1H.CCI( >./D( /;(

32C2.12(0;.3(/.7=/(;:;H3(7>(93212=/E(65745(71(/52=(.112112:(0I(;=2(;3(8;32(2G923/1M(#1(

82=/7;=2:(02>;32E(/5232(71(.(C;/(;>(<.37./7;=(7=(/52(82/5;:;C;J74.C(.993;.4521(;>(/5212(

Page 157: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()S(

(

(

(

*F,(

;C>.4/;3I(2<.CH./7;=1(B!5.9/23(S)DM(%5232>;32E(0;/5(3212.345231(.=:(1C.HJ5/235;H121(.32(

7=432.17=JCI( 4.CC7=J( >;3( >H3/523( ;9/7871./7;=( .=:( 5.38;=71./7;=( ;>( /5212( 12=1;3I(

.1121182=/1(B".HJ2=(2/(.CME(@N*@DM((

%52( 4;807=2:( H12( ;>( 452874.C( .=:( 12=1;3I( .=.CI121E( 0;/5( 9;;3CI( :2143702:(

.=:P;3( 5.3:CI( <.C7:./2:E( 5.1( C2.:( /;( 3./523( C;6( 4;332C./7;=1( 02/622=( 0;/5( /I921( ;>(

.=.CI121M( !;2>>7472=/1( ;>( 4;332C./7;=( 02/622=( 4;=42=/3./7;=1( ;>( .=:3;1/2=;=2( 7=( >./(

:2/2387=2:(452874.CCI(.=:(0;.3(/.7=/(7=/2=17/I(.112112:(0I(/3.7=2:(9.=2C1(3.=J2:(>3;8(

NMF*(/;(NM,AE(.=:(>;3(1T./;C2(>3;8(NM@N(/;(NMK+(BR;==2.HE(*aO@DM('242=/(3212.345(4.3372:(

;H/( 7=( R2CJ7H8( 32<2.C2:( 4;332C./7;=1( ;>( NM*,E( NM+A( .=:( NM+N( 321924/7<2CIE( >;3( 7=:;C2E(

1T./;C2( .=:( .=:3;1/2=;=2( B#CH6b( 2/( .CME( @N*@0DM( %52( 4;332C./7;=( 4;2>>7472=/1( 4;HC:(

9;1170CI(7=432.12(7>(0;/5(452874.C(.=:(12=1;3I(.=.CI121(6232(;9/787g2:(.=:(/5;3;HJ5CI(

<.C7:./2:( .=:( 1/.=:.3:7g2:M( R217:21E( 7/( 71( 93;0.0C2( /5./( /52( 4;=42=/3./7;=1( ;>( 1T./;C2(

.=:( .=:3;1/2=;=2( 4.==;/( 4;89C2/2CI( .44;H=/( >;3( /52( ;44H332=42( ;>( 0;.3( /.7=/( .1(

:2/2387=2:(0I(.(/3.7=2:(12=1;3I(9.=2C(B$.HCI(2/(.CME(@N*NDM(S=:22:E(/571(4;332C./7;=(8.I(

.C1;( 7893;<2( 7>( .::7/7;=.C( 4;89;H=:1( 4;=/370H/7=J( /;(0;.3( /.7=/(6232( /;(02( 7:2=/7>72:(

.=:(/.T2=(7=/;(.44;H=/M(

(

( +

Page 158: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

-SX![XXSU](#]-(Q[%['&($&'X$&!%S)&X(

(

(

*FO(

*M@M JH*%+80)0H8&I+7*%1*%2)+H%1+)&*0%4*7*&+&$%48*K(4*$%)+

%52(8.7=(.44;89C71582=/1(;>(/571(6;3T(.32(:2974/2:(7=(Q7JH32()SM*(

(

F*2+=>"G+C&I03H4*&+$L08L*0/+$7+4I0+3H*%+80)0H8&I+H&&$3M'*)I30%4)+$7+4I*)+/$8.++

Page 159: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()S(

(

(

(

*Fa(

*M@M*M +;I0+)0%)*4*L*4N+$7+F'03*)I+&*4*O0%)+4$+H%18$)40%$%0+

V52=(:2/2387=7=J(/52(12=17/7<7/I(;>(.(9;9HC./7;=(/;(0;.3(/.7=/(7/(71(8;32(32C2<.=/(

/;(>;4H1(;=(.=:3;1/2=;=2(17=42(=2.3CI(2<23I(7=:7<7:H.C(71(12=17/7<2(/;(1T./;C2(BV27C23(2/(

.CME(*aa,DE(65232.1(/52(12=17/7<7/I( /;(.=:3;1/2=;=2( 71(J2=2/74.CCI(:2/2387=2:( B^2CC23(2/(

.CME(@NN,DM(R24.H12(;>(/52(C.4T(;>(<.C7:./7;=E(:7>>232=/(82/5;:;C;J721(5.<2(022=(.99C72:(

/;( :2/2387=2( /52( 12=17/7<7/I( ;>( 4;=1H8231( /;( .=:3;1/2=;=2M( %5212( 7=4CH:2( /52( H12( ;>(

19247>74(8./237.C( B2MJM( 4;//;=(6;;CD( 932<7;H1CI( :7992:( 7=/;( .( 1;CH/7;=(;>( .=:3;1/2=;=2(

:711;C<2:( 7=( 2MJM( 2/5.=;C( ;3( 93;9IC2=2( JCI4;C( BQ;=/( 7( QH3=;C1E( @N*@DE( /52( 2G9;1H32( ;>(

4;=1H8231(/;(9H32(43I1/.C1( BV27C23(2/(.CME(@NNND(;3( /52(+L#Q!L/21/( B\H=:2(2/(.CME(@NNaDM(

%5212(:7>>232=/(82/5;:;C;J721(/;(82.1H32(.=:3;1/2=;=2(12=17/7<7/IE(32=:23(4;89.371;=(

;>( /52(.01;CH/2(92342=/.J21(;>(.=:3;1/2=;=2( 12=17/7<7/I(02/622=( 1/H:721(93;0C28./74M(

\H=:2(2/(.CM(B@N*ND(:28;=1/3./2:(/5./(.(9231;=(8.I(02(.0C2(/;(:2/24/(/52(9H32(43I1/.C1(

;>( .=:3;1/2=;=2( 67/5;H/( 027=J( .0C2( /;( 923427<2( .=:3;1/2=;=2( 7=( .( 82./( 8./37GM(

%5232>;32E(/52(+L#Q!(/21/(:2<2C;92:(0I(\H=:2(2/(.CM(B@NNaD(8.I(02(4;=17:232:(.1(.(J;C:(

1/.=:.3:( /;( 2<.CH./2( /52( 12=17/7<7/I( ;>( 4;=1H8231( /;( .=:3;1/2=;=2( 7=( .(82./(8./37GM(

R24.H12(12=17/7<7/I(:7>>231(02/622=(4;H=/3721(BV27C23(2/(.CME(@NNND(.=:(/;(.11H32(/5./( 7>(

2=/732( 8.C2( 97J1( 6232( /;( 02( 32.32:( ;=( .( C.3J2( 14.C2( 7=( QC.=:231E( /52( 12=17/7<7/I( ;>(

4;=1H8231(/;(.=:3;1/2=;=2(7=(QC.=:231(6.1(:2/2387=2:(:H37=J(/571(6;3T(B!5.9/23(SSDM(#/(

/5./( /782E(4;=1H823(923429/7;=(4;HC:(02(:7324/CI(4;89.32:(/;(/52(.44H3./2(12=17/7<7/I(

:71/370H/7;=(:./.M(

Q;3( /571( 9H39;12E( .( 8;:7>74./7;=( ;>( /52( +L#Q!( /21/( ;>( \H=:2( 2/( .CM( B@NNaD( 6.1(

7=/3;:H42:( /;( 32:H42( /52(93;0.07C7/I( ;>( 4;3324/( .=16231( 0I( 45.=42M( %571(82/5;:;C;JI(

8.I(.C1;( >;38(.(0.171( >;3( >H3/523(2G923/( /3.7=7=J( B2MJM(652=(;9/787g7=J(./( C7=2(12=1;3I(

2<.CH./7;=D( .=:( 4;=1H823( .4429/.=42( /21/7=J( 7=( >H/H32(6;3TM( S=( J2=23.C( F+MK_( ;>( /52(

3219;=:2=/1(7=(QC.=:231(93;<2:(12=17/7<2(/;(.=:3;1/2=;=2E(8;32(19247>74E(+OM+_(;>(/52(

8.C21( .=:( K*M*_( ;>( /52( >28.C21( 6232( 12=17/7<2( /;( .=:3;1/2=;=2M( R24.H12( ;>( /52(

:7>>232=/(82/5;:;C;J721(H12:( /;(82.1H32(.=:3;1/2=;=2(12=17/7<7/IE( 4;89.371;=(;>( /52(

;0/.7=2:(92342=/.J21(;>(.=:3;1/2=;=2(12=17/7<7/I(67/5(;/523(1/H:721(71(:7>>74HC/M(S=:22:E(

/52(82/5;:1(H12:(/;(:2/2387=2(.=:3;1/2=;=2(12=17/7<7/I(4.=(.>>24/(/52(4C.117>74./7;=(;>(

4;=1H8231( 7=/;( 12=17/7<2( .=:( =;=L12=17/7<2M( %52( 32C./7<2( :7>>232=421( ;0123<2:( 7=( /571(

Page 160: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

-SX![XXSU](#]-(Q[%['&($&'X$&!%S)&X(

(

(

*KN(

2G923782=/( 5;62<23( 4;=>738( 932<7;H1( >7=:7=J1( >3;8( C7/23./H32( 1H45( .1( /52( 789.4/( ;>(

J2=:23(B>28.C21(.32(8;32(12=17/7<2(/52=(8.C21D(.=:(.J2(B;C:23(92;9C2(.32(C211(12=17/7<2D(

;=( /52( 12=17/7<7/I( B\H=:2( 2/( .CME( @NNam( Y.//5261( 2/( .CME( @NNNm( V27C23( 2/( .CME( @NNNDM(

XH393717=JCIE( .C1;( .=( 789.4/( ;>( /21/( C;4./7;=( 6.1( >;H=:M( ";62<23E( >H3/523( 3212.345( 71(

6.33.=/2:( /;( 2CH47:./2( /52( H=:23CI7=J( 32.1;=1( >;3( /52( ;0123<2:( :7>>232=421( 02/622=(

/21/( C;4./7;=1M( !.H/7;=( 8H1/( 02( /.T2=( 652=( 923>;387=J( 4;=1H823( .4429/.=42(

2<.CH./7;=1( >;3( 9;/2=/7.CCI( /.7=/2:( 82./( 93;:H4/1( /;( 7=4CH:2( /5212( J2;J3.9574.C(

<.37./7;=1E( 17=42( /5212( 8.I( 17J=7>74.=/CI( 7=>CH2=42( .=:3;1/2=;=2( 12=17/7<7/I( .=:( /5H1(

4;=1H823(923429/7;=M(%5232>;32E( 7/( 71( 324;882=:2:(/5./(4;=1H823(1/H:721(923>;382:(

7=(QC.=:231(7=4CH:2(.(9;9HC./7;=(;>(FKM+_(4;=1H8231(12=17/7<2(/;(.=:3;1/2=;=2M(%571(67CC(

.CC;6(/;(:3.6(/52(93;923(4;=4CH17;=1(7=(/2381(;>(.4429/.=42(;>(82./(.=:(82./(93;:H4/1(

67/5( 0;.3( /.7=/( 7=( QC.=:231M( %571( 12=17/7<7/I( /21/( 71( 021/( 923>;382:( 67/5( /52( 82/5;:(

:2143702:(0I(R2T.23/(2/(.CM(B!5.9/23(SSD(.1(/52(12=17/7<7/I(92342=/.J2(;>(FKM+(6.1(:2>7=2:(

67/5(/571(82/5;:M(QH3/5238;32E(7/(8.I(.C1;(02(.:<712:(/;(923>;38(/52(1/H:I(./(:7>>232=/(

/21/(C;4./7;=1(.1(C;=J(.1(/52(H=:23CI7=J(32.1;=(>;3(/52(;0123<2:(:7>>232=421(02/622=(/52(

/21/(C;4./7;=1(5.1(=;/(022=(2CH47:./2:M(

(

*M@M@M DP9:A#P96PJC+H%H'N)*)+7$8+4I0+)*3('4H%0$()+1040&4*$%+$7+K$H8+4H*%4+

&$3M$(%1)+

%52(:2<2C;982=/(;>( .=(.=.CI/74.C( 93;42:H32( >;3( /52( 178HC/.=2;H1(:2/24/7;=(;>(

/52( /5322( T=;6=( 0;.3( /.7=/( 4;89;H=:1( 93;<2:( 45.CC2=J7=JE( :H2( /;( /52( 4;=17:23.0C2(

<.37.07C7/I( 7=( 452874.C( 93;923/721( ;>( /52( 4;89;H=:1M( %52( <;C./7C7/I( ;>( /52( 0;.3( /.7=/(

4;89;H=:1(4;807=2:(67/5(/52(:7>>232=/( C79;957C74(93;923/721(;>(/52(4;89;H=:1( 7=(>./E(

;=2( ;>( /52( 4;89;H=:1( 71( .( 1/23;7:( 67/5( .( 57J523( 5I:3;95;0747/I( /5.=( /52( ;/523( /6;(

7=:;C74(4;89;H=:1E(8.T21( /52(2G/3.4/7;=(.( /3H2(.=.CI/74.C(45.CC2=J2M(#1(.( 321HC/E(8;1/(

82/5;:1( .<.7C.0C2( 1;( >.3E( 1;C2CI( :2/24/( .=:3;1/2=;=2( ;3( 7=:;C2( .=:( 1T./;C2M( U=CI( .(

C787/2:( =H8023( ;>( .=.CI/74.C( 82/5;:1( .CC;6( /52( 178HC/.=2;H1( :2/24/7;=( ;>( /52( /5322(

4;89;H=:1( BQ714523(2/( .CME( @N**m(".=12=LYoCC23E( *aaFm()2352I:2=(2/( .CME( @NN,DM( X;82(

7=5232=/(>C.61(.32(5;62<23(932<.7C7=J(67/5(321924/(/;(/52(82/5;:1(.<.7C.0C2(1;(>.3E(/5./(

Page 161: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()S(

(

(

(

*K*(

.CC;6(178HC/.=2;H1(.=.CI171(;>(/52(/5322(4;89;H=:1E(1H45(.1(/52(H12(;>(.(:237<./7g./7;=(

1/29( >;3( :2/24/7=J( .=:3;1/2=;=2( B".=12=LYoCC23E( *aaFD( ;3( /52( C.4T( ;>( .( 1H>>7472=/CI(

3;0H1/(2G/3.4/7;=(93;42:H32(>;3(3;H/7=2(.99C74./7;=(B)2352I:2=(2/(.CME(@NN,DM(S=(/571($5-(

1/H:IE( /52( :2<2C;982=/( ;>( .( =;<2C( .=.CI/74.C( 93;42:H32E( 2=.0C7=J( /52( 178HC/.=2;H1(

2G/3.4/7;=(.=:(1H012ZH2=/(ZH.=/7>74./7;=(;>(/52(/5322(0;.3(/.7=/(4;89;H=:1(7=(.(3;0H1/(

.=:(J2=2374(8.==23E(6.1(32.C7g2:(B!5.9/23(SSSDM(

$37;3( /;( 3;H/7=2(H1.J2E( <.C7:./7;=(;>( .=( .=.CI/74.C( 93;42:H32( 71( 32ZH732:( .=:( 7=(

8.=I(.32.1(:28.=:2:(0I(32JHC./7;=E(/;(:28;=1/3./2(/52(1H7/.07C7/I(.=:(923>;38.=42(;>(

.(82/5;:( >;3( /52(:21732:(.99C74./7;=M(%52(4H332=/CI( 329;3/2:(82/5;:1( /5./(5.<2(022=(

.99C72:(>;3(/52(BZH.=/7/./7<2D(:2/2387=./7;=(;>(/52(0;.3(/.7=/(4;89;H=:1(32>C24/(<.3I7=J(

C2<2C1(;>(<.C7:./7;=(B".HJ2=(2/(.CME(@N*@DM(U=CI(>26(1/H:721(329;3/(.=(.4429/.0C2(C2<2C(;>(

7=L5;H12( <.C7:./7;=( BQ714523( 2/( .CME( @N**m( )2352I:2=( 2/( .CME( @NN,D( .=:( =;=2( ;>( /52(

82/5;:1( 329;3/2:( 1;( >.3( 5.<2( 022=( 93;923CI( 2G/23=.CCI( <.C7:./2:( /53;HJ5( 2MJM( 7=/23L

C.0;3./;3I(/37.C1(B".HJ2=(2/(.CME(@N*@DM(S=(/571(4;=/2G/E(7/(8H1/(02(1/./2:(/5./(=;(;>>747.C(

JH7:2C7=21(2G71/( /5./( 1I1/28./74.CCI( 4;<23( /52(.=.CI/74.C(923>;38.=421( 32ZH732:( >;3( /52(

.=.CI171(;>(;:;3;H1(4;89;H=:1M(Q;3(/571(32.1;=E(/52(<.C7:./7;=(;>(/52(=26CI(:2<2C;92:(

82/5;:E( 6.1( 923>;382:( .44;3:7=J( /;( /52( 437/237.( 19247>72:( 7=( !;887117;=( -24717;=(

@NN@PAK,P&!M( %52(923>;38.=42( 45.3.4/2371/741( /5./(6232(2<.CH./2:( 7=4CH:2( 12C24/7<7/IE(

19247>747/IE(C7=2.37/IE(.44H3.4IE(9324717;=E(3HJJ2:=211E(1/.07C7/I(.=:(C787/1(;>(:2/24/7;=(.=:(

ZH.=/7>74./7;=M( Q;3( .CC( /5322( 4;89;H=:1( 57J5CI( 1./71>I7=J( <.C7:./7;=( 321HC/1( 6232(

;0/.7=2:E( 7=( .44;3:.=42(67/5( /52( 923>;38.=42( 437/237.( 12/( ;H/( 7=( !-( @NN@PAK,P&!M( S=(

.::7/7;=E( a@(0;.3( .:79;12( 1.89C21( 4;CC24/2:( >3;8(.=;/523( 1/H:I( B#CH6b(2/( .CME( @N*@.D(

6232( 82.1H32:( 67/57=( .=( 7=/23LC.0;3./;3I( 4;89.371;=( H17=J( ;H3( =26CI( :2<2C;92:(

452874.C(82/5;:(.=:(/52(82/5;:(.99C72:(0I(!!\(]H/374;=/3;CE()2J52CE(%52(]2/523C.=:1M(

#C/5;HJ5( /5212( 1.89C21( 6232( 1/;32:( >;3( ;<23( A( 8;=/51( .=:( 2=:H32:( 12<23.C( >322g2L

/5.6(4I4C21(937;3(/;(.=.CI171E(/52(4;332C./7;=1(02/622=(/52(:7>>232=/(.=.CI/74.C(321HC/1(>;3(

7=:;C2E( 1T./;C2( .=:( .=:3;1/2=;=2( .8;H=/2:( 321924/7<2CI( NMFOE( NM,K( .=:( NMa@M( %52(

32C./7<2CI( C;6( 4;332C./7;=1( ;0123<2:( >;3( 1T./;C2( .=:( 7=:;C2( 8.I( 02( 2G9C.7=2:( 0I( /52(

:7>>232=/( ;37J7=( ;>( /52( .:79;12( 1.89C21( 67/57=( /52( 0;.3( 4.34.11( H12:( >;3( /52( 9.3.CC2C(

.=.CI121(.=:(/52(57J523(5I:3;957C747/I(;>(1T./;C2(.=:(7=:;C2(4;89.32:(/;(.=:3;1/2=;=2M(

Page 162: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

-SX![XXSU](#]-(Q[%['&($&'X$&!%S)&X(

(

(

*K@(

R24.H12(;>( /571( 1C7J5/CI(57J523(<;C.C7/I(.=:(57J523(5I:3;957C747/I( 1T./;C2(.=:( 7=:;C2(.32(

8;32( 32.:7CI( 32C2.12:( 7=/;( /52( J.12;H1( 95.12M( %571(8.I( 5.<2( 321HC/2:( 7=( .( :24C7=2( 7=(

4;=42=/3./7;=( /53;HJ5;H/( /52( >322g2L/5.6( 4I4C21M( ";62<23E( 7=( J2=23.C( /52( <.C7:./7;=(

:./.( ;0/.7=2:( :H37=J( /571( 6;3T( .=:( /52( 7=/23C.0;3./;3I( 4;89.371;=( :./.( 6232( 57J5CI(

1./71>.4/;3IE( :28;=1/3./7=J( /52( <.C7:7/I( .=:( .99C74.07C7/I( ;>( ;H3( =26CI( :2<2C;92:(

82/5;:M(%571(.=.CI/74.C(93;42:H32(6.1( >H3/523(H12:( 7=( /571($5-(1/H:I( >;3( 7=<21/7J./7=J(

12<23.C(.1924/1(;>(/52(17=J27=J(82/5;:(B!5.9/23(S)DM(

#3;H=:(/52(1.82(/782(/5./(.(=26(82/5;:(>;3(/52(178HC/.=2;H1(.=.CI171(;>( /52(

/5322(T=;6=(0;.3(/.7=/(4;89;H=:1(6.1(:2<2C;92:(:H37=J(/571($5-(/52171E(Q714523(2/(.CM(

B@N**D(329;3/2:(.(82/5;:(67/5(52.:19.42(1;C7:L95.12(8743;L2G/3.4/7;=(B"XLX$Y&D(.=:(

J.1( 453;8./;J3.95I( 4;H9C2:( /;( 8.11( 1924/3;82/3IM( %571( 82/5;:( .C1;( 4;=171/1( ;>( .(

32C./7<2( J2=2374( 1.89C2( 9329.3./7;=( 93;42:H32( 7=4CH:7=J( .( 52./7=J( .=:( >322g7=J( 1/29M(

R2>;32( /52( "XLX$Y&(6.1( 4;=:H4/2:E( /52( 2G/3.4/( 6.1( 2<.9;3./2:( /;( :3I=211M( Q;3( /52(

:2/24/7;=(;>(/52(4;89;H=:1E(.=(7;=(/3.9(8.11(1924/3;82/23(7=(12C24/2:(7;=(8;=7/;37=J(

8;:2(6.1(H12:M(

#1( ;99;12:( /;( /571(82/5;:E( /52( =;<2C/I( ;>( /52(82/5;:( :2<2C;92:( :H37=J( /571(

6;3T(4;=423=1(/52(H12(;>(/52(8.11(1924/3;82/374(U307/3.9(/245=;C;JIM(%571(/245=;C;JI(

93;<7:21( 57J5CI( 9324712(8.11( .44H3.4IE( 65745( C2.:1( /;( 1H44211>HC( 7:2=/7>74./7;=( ;>( /52(

0;.3( /.7=/( 4;89;H=:1( 7=( 1.89C21( 4;=/.7=7=J( 57J5( .8;H=/1( ;>( 4;89C2G( 8./37G( 4;L

2G/3.4/1(1H45(.1(.:79;12( /711H2( B]72C2=(2/(.CME(@NN,DM(R217:21E( /571(82/5;:(.CC;61(9;1/L

.4ZH717/7;=(32L7=/233;J./7;=(;>(:./.(7M2M(:./.(4.=(02(32L7=/23932/2:(./(.(C./23(/782(9;7=/(

/;( 14322=( >;3( ;/523( 4;89;H=:1( /5.=( /52( ;=21( 7=4CH:2:( 7=( /52( 82/5;:M( %571( 32L

7=/233;J./7;=(;>(:./.(5.1(022=(15;6=(H12>HC(7=(/52(12.345(>;3(H=T=;6=(4;89;H=:1(/5./(

4;=/370H/2( /;( 0;.3( /.7=/( B!5.9/23( )D( .=:(67CC( .CC;6( 7=4CH17;=( ;>( /5212( 4;89;H=:1( >;3(

>H3/523(.=.CI121M((

(

*M@M+M ;I0+)*%20*%2+304I$1+

%52( 17=J27=J(82/5;:( 71( .( >32ZH2=/CI( .99C72:( 12=1;3I( .=.CI171(82/5;:E( H12:( 0I(

3212.345231(.=:(1C.HJ5/235;H12(9231;==2C(.1(.(3.97:(./LC7=2(:2/24/7;=(82/5;:(>;3(0;.3(

Page 163: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()S(

(

(

(

*K+(

/.7=/E( 2<2=(8;32( 024.H12( .C/23=./7<2( <.C7:./2:( :2/24/7;=( 1I1/281( .99C74.0C2( ./LC7=2( 7=(

1C.HJ5/235;H121(.32(=;/(.<.7C.0C2(BI2/DM('212.345(;=(12=1;3I(.=.CI121(82/5;:1(1H45(.1(

/52( 17=J7=J( 82/5;:( >;3( 0;.3( /.7=/( 5.:E( /;( /52( 021/( ;>( ;H3( T=;6C2:J2E( =;/( 022=(

H=:23/.T2=( 1;( >.3E( 67/5( 321924/( /;( 2<.CH./7;=( .=:( <.C7:./7;=( ;>( 2G923/1( .=:(

82/5;:;C;JIM(V57//7=J/;=(2/(.CM( BV57//7=J/;=(2/(.CME(@N**D(4;89.32:(:7>>232=/(52./7=J(

82/5;:1( B8743;6.<2E( 1;C:237=J( 73;=E( 0;7C7=J( ./( @Kp!( .=:( ,Kp!( .=:(82C/7=JDM( %52( 021/(

321HC/1(6232(;0/.7=2:(67/5(/52(8743;6.<2(82/5;:E(/52(1;C:237=J(73;=(82/5;:(.=:(/52(

0;7C7=J( B,Kp!D( 82/5;:M( Y;32( 3242=/CIE( Y./5H3( 2/( .CM( B@N*@D( 7=<21/7J./2:( /52(

923>;38.=42( ;>( /52( 5H8.=( =;12( 14;37=J( 1I1/28M( %52( 3293;:H4707C7/I( 6.1( C;6E( 65745(

4;HC:(02(2G9C.7=2:(0I(/52(=./H3.C(<.37./7;=(.8;=J(5H8.=(027=J1(/;(:2/24/(0;.3(/.7=/M(

%5232>;32E(/52(H12(;>(8HC/79C2(9.=2CC71/1(6.1(324;882=:2:(652=(.44H3.4I(71(32ZH732:M(

S=(0;/5(1/H:721E(=;(7=<21/7J./7;=(6.1(923>;382:(;=(/52(/245=74.C(.1924/1(.=:(<.37./7;=1(

321HC/7=J(>3;8(/52(:7>>232=/(52./7=J(82/5;:1M(R24.H12(:2/.7C2:(T=;6C2:J2(;=(/52(H12(;>(

/52( 17=J27=J( 82/5;:( 71( C787/2:( .=:( H3J2=/CI( 32ZH732:( /;( .CC;6( 3212.345231( .=:(

1C.HJ5/235;H12( 9231;==2C( /;( .44H3./2CI( :2/2387=2( /52( 0;.3( /.7=/( 932<.C2=42( 7=( 7=/.4/(

4.34.121E(!5.9/23(S)(7=(/571(/52171(6.1(:2<;/2:(/;(/571(8.//23M(

V7/57=( /571(1/H:IE( >;H3(9.3.82/231(;>( /52(17=J27=J(82/5;:(6232(2<.CH./2:(.=:(

>;H3( :7>>232=/( 52./7=J(82/5;:1(6232( 4;89.32:M( %52( 4;332C./7;=( 4;2>>7472=/1( 02/622=(

/52(0;.3(/.7=/(14;321(0.12:(;=(/5212(12=1;3I(.1121182=/1(.=:(/52(4;=42=/3./7;=(;>(/52(

4;89;H=:1( 0.12:( ;=( /52( 452874.C( .=.CI121( 6232( 4;89.3.0C2( 02/622=( /52( <.37;H1(

52./7=J( 82/5;:1( /5./( 6232( 7=<21/7J./2:( B8743;6.<2E( 1;C:237=J( 73;=E( 9I3;92=( .=:(

9I3;92=(67/5(9C./2DM(%52(9I3;92=(6.1( >;H=:( /;(02( /52(8;1/(93.4/74.C( /;;C( >;3(52./7=J(

/52(>./(024.H12(;>(12<23.C(32.1;=1?(=;(371T(>;3(;:;H3(4;=/.87=./7;=E(.99C74.0C2(:7324/CI(

;=(/52(4.34.11(.=:(6732C211M(V7/5(321924/(/;(/52(/245=74.C(.1924/1E(7/(6.1(:28;=1/3./2:(

/5./(/52(3;;8(.=:(1.89C2(/28923./H32(.>>24/2:(/52(14;37=J(/782M(%52(932>2332:(52./7=J(

82/5;:(8.I( .C1;(:7>>23( 02/622=( 7=:7<7:H.C1( .=:( 4.=(02( 7=>CH2=42:(0I( /3.7=7=JM(V52=(

H17=J(/52(1;C:237=J(73;=E(;3(.=I(;/523(52./7=J(82/5;:(7=<;C<7=J(:7324/(4;=/.4/(67/5(/52(

>./E(4.H/7;=(71(32ZH732:(/;(.<;7:(4;=/.87=./7;=M(Q32ZH2=/(4C2.=7=J(;>(/52(1;C:237=J(73;=(71(

/5232>;32(.:<712:M(#C1;(C;623(.<23.J2(7=/2=17/I(14;321(67CC(02(.//370H/2:(652=(.(1.89C2(

71(14;32:(/6742(./(/52(1.82(19;/M(Q7=.CCIE(5.07/H./7;=(7=(/782(5.1(022=(;0123<2:(.>/23(+N(

Page 164: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

-SX![XXSU](#]-(Q[%['&($&'X$&!%S)&X(

(

(

*KF(

1.89C21(0H/(5.07/H./7;=(6.1(.C1;(=;/742:(H9;=(:2/24/7;=(;>(2<23I(1.89C2(9;17/7<2( >;3(

0;.3( /.7=/M( %5232>;32E( 7/( 71( 324;882=:2:( /;( 2G9;12( 2G923/1( /;( 0;.3( /.7=/( 02>;32( /52I(

1/.3/( 14;37=J( 1.89C21(;3( /;( 14;32( /52( >731/(+N( 1.89C21( /6742M(#C1;(652=(.( 1.89C2(67/5(

0;.3(/.7=/( 71(2<.CH./2:(.(9.H12(8H1/(02(/.T2=(/;(.<;7:(/52(2>>24/(;>(5.07/H./7;=M(R;/5(

5.07/H./7;=(2>>24/1(8.I(02(.<;7:2:(652=(8HC/79C2(9.=2CC71/1(.32(H12:(.1(324;882=:2:(

0I(Y./5H3(2/(.CM(B@N*@DM(

-2197/2( /52( >.4/( /5./( /5212( 2G923782=/1( 6232( 4;=:H4/2:( H=:23( C.0;3./;3I(

4734H81/.=421E(.(4C2.3( 7=:74./7;=(>;3(/52(H12(./(/52(1C.HJ5/23C7=2(71(93;<7:2:M(";62<23E(

>H3/523(3212.345(71(6.33.=/2:(/;(2<.CH./2(/52(4;3324/(789.4/(;>(/5212(9.3.82/231(./(/52(

1C.HJ5/23C7=2M( [=/7C( 8;32( 4C.37/I( 2G71/1( ;=( /52( 2>>24/( ;>( 2MJM( 5.07/H./7;=E( 7/( 71(

324;882=:2:( /;( >32ZH2=/CI( 167/45( 02/622=( 2G923/1( 219247.CCI( .>/23( 1.89C21( 9;17/7<2(

>;3( 0;.3( /.7=/( .=:( 7=( C7=2(67/5( /52( 324;882=:./7;=1( 0I(Y./5H3( 2/( .CM( B@N*@DE( /;( H12(

8HC/79C2(9.=2CC71/1(923(1.89C2(0./45M((

R217:2(/52(52./7=J(82/5;:E(.(C;/(;>(<.37./7;=(8.I(.C1;(2G71/(7=(/52(12C24/7;=(.=:(

/3.7=7=J(;>(2G923/1M(-7hT1/235H71(2/(.CM(B@NNND(4;=4CH:2:(/5./(7/(6.1(:7>>74HC/(/;(5.38;=7g2(

/52(82/5;:;C;JI(H12:(>;3(12<2=(12=1;3I(9.=2C1(/53;HJ5;H/(/52(&H3;92.=([=7;=M($.3/(;>(

/571( <.37./7;=( 4.=( 02( .//370H/2:( /;( :7>>232=421( 7=( 12=17/7<7/I( .=:( 923429/7;=( ;>( 5H8.=(

027=J1(/;6.3:1(0;.3(/.7=/(BY./5H3(2/(.CME(@N*@DM(RH/(2<2=(652=(.(J;;:(7=/23L<.37.07C7/I(71(

:7>>74HC/(/;(.4572<2E(/52(7=:7<7:H.C(<.37./7;=(;>(2<23I(9.=2CC71/(8H1/(02(1H>>7472=/CI(C;6(>;3(

/52( 7=:7<7:H.C( /;( 02( 32J.3:2:( .1( .=( 2G923/M( R24.H12( ;>( /52( .012=42( ;>( JH7:2C7=21( >;3(

12C24/7;=( .=:( /3.7=7=J( ;>( 2G923/1( ;=( 0;.3( /.7=/E( =;( 324;882=:./7;=1( .32( .<.7C.0C2(

32J.3:7=J( /5212( 7=/3.L( .=:( 7=/23L<.37.07C7/721M( V57/57=( /571( 3212.345E( /52( .78( 6.1( /;(

.4572<2( ./( C2.1/( .( 4;332C./7;=( ;>( NMO( 02/622=( /52( >731/( .=:( 124;=:( 14;37=J( 02>;32( /52(

7=/3.L<.37.07C7/I(;>(.=(2G923/(6.1(4;=17:232:(.1(J;;:M(((

*M@MFM >10%4*7*&H4*$%+$7+%0/+K$H8+4H*%4+&$%48*K(4*%2+&$3M$(%1)++

S=( *aAOE( .=:3;1/2=;=2( 6.1( :2/2387=2:( .1( /52( >731/( 0;.3( /.7=/( 4;=/370H/7=J(

4;89;H=:( B$.//231;=E( *aAODM( X2<23.C( I2.31( C./23E( .C1;( 1T./;C2( .=:E( /;( .( C21123(:2J322E(

7=:;C2(6232( 7:2=/7>72:(.1(0;.3( /.7=/( 4;89;H=:1( B);C:E( *a,NDM(";62<23E( /52(:2J322( /;(

65745( /5212( 4;89;H=:1( 7=/23.4/( .=:( 4;=/370H/2( /;( /52( ;:;H3( ;>( 0;.3( /.7=/( .32( 1/7CC( .(

Page 165: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()S(

(

(

(

*KK(

8.//23(;>(:714H117;=M(S=:22:E(/52(/5322(T=;6=(0;.3(/.7=/(4;89;H=:1(:;(=;/(4;89C2/2CI(

.44;H=/(>;3(/52(12=1;3I(2<.CH./7;=(;>(0;.3(/.7=/(.1(:2/2387=2:(0I(.(/3.7=2:(9.=2C(B$.HCI(

2/(.CME(@N*NDM(X2<23.C(>.4/;31(8.I(2G9C.7=(/52(3./523(C;6(4;332C./7;=1(;0/.7=2:(02/622=(

/52( 452874.C( .=:( 12=1;3I( .=.CI121?( /52( C.4T( ;>( 1H>>7472=/CI( <.C7:./2:( 452874.C( .=:(

12=1;3I(82/5;:1E(9;;3(12C24/7;=(.=:(/3.7=7=J(;>(/52(2G923/(9.=2CE(7=/3.4.34.11(<.37./7;=(

7=(0;.3(/.7=/(4;89;H=:1(;3(H=7:2=/7>72:(4;=/370H/7=J(4;89;H=:1(/;(0;.3(/.7=/M(S=(2.3C723(

45.9/231(;>(/571(/52171E(/52(452874.C(B!5.9/23(SSSD(.=:(12=1;3I(B!5.9/23(S)D(82/5;:1(6232(

;9/787g2:E(2<.CH./2:(.=:P;3(<.C7:./2:(.=:(.(X92.38.=(4;332C./7;=(q(NMO(B7=/3.L<.37.07C7/I(

;>( /52( 2G923/D( 6.1( 93;9;12:( 02>;32( /52( /3.7=7=J( ;>( /52( 2G923/1( 6.1( 4;=17:232:( .1(

1H>>7472=/M(S=(2.3C723(1/H:721(7=(R2CJ7H8E(.(4;332C./7;=(;>(NM*,E(NM+A(.=:(NM+NE(321924/7<2CIE(

>;3( 7=:;C2E( 1T./;C2( .=:( .=:3;1/2=;=2( 6.1( ;0123<2:( 02/622=( 452874.C( .=:( 12=1;3I(

.=.CI121( B#CH6b( 2/( .CME( @N*@0DM( QH3/523( ;9/7871./7;=( .=:( <.C7:./7;=( ;>( /52( 321924/7<2(

82/5;:1(7=(/52(93212=/(1/H:IE(.CC;62:(.=(7=432.12(7=(4;332C./7;=(/;(NMFNE(NMF@(.=:(NMK*E(

>;3( 7=:;C2E( 1T./;C2( .=:( .=:3;1/2=;=2E( 321924/7<2CI( B!5.9/23( )DM( S/( 8H1/( 5;62<23( 02(

=;/2:( /5./( /52( :./.12/( /5./( #CH6b( 2/( .CM( B@N*@0D( H12:( >;3( 4.C4HC./7=J( /52( 4;332C./7;=1(

6.1(17J=7>74.=/CI(C.3J23(/5.=(/52(;=2(H12:(7=(/571(/52171(BFFO(<231H1(O+(.:79;12(1.89C21DM(

#C/5;HJ5( 8;1/( 3212.345231( =;6( 4;CC24/( 1.89C21( >3;8( /52( =24T( 32J7;=( /;( 87=78712(

7=/3.4.34.11( <.37./7;=E( /52( .::7/7;=.C( 2G9C.=./;3I( 9;623( ;>( H=7:2=/7>72:( 4;=/370H/7=J(

4;89;H=:1(/;(/52(12=1;3I(923429/7;=(;>(0;.3(/.7=/(6.1(=2<23(9H31H2:(7=(.(1/./71/74.CCI(

32C7.0C2(8.==23M(%5232>;32E( /52( C.1/(!5.9/23( B!5.9/23()D(;>( /571( /52171(6.1(:2<;/2:( /;(

/52(12.345(;>(9;1170C2(.::7/7;=.C(0;.3(/.7=/(4;89;H=:1M((

%;( .4572<2( /571( J;.C( .( /6;L6.I( 1/3./2JI( 6.1( >;CC;62:?( >731/E( .=( H=/.3J2/2:(

14322=7=J( .993;.45( 6.1( >;CC;62:( H17=J( W!LX=7>>LYXE( 124;=:( 9;1/L.4ZH717/7;=( 32L

7=/233;J./7;=( ;>( .( <.1/( :./.12/( ;>( 57J5( 321;CH/7;=(8.11( 1924/3;82/374( :./.( ;>( 9;17/7<2(

0;.3(/.7=/(1.89C21(6.1(923>;382:(H17=J(.(/.3J2/2:(.=:(H=/.3J2/2:(.993;.45M(&G24H/7;=(

;>( /52( W!LX=7>>LYX( 14322=7=JE( .CC;62:( 7:2=/7>74./7;=( ;>( 27J5/( =26( 4;89;H=:1M( %52(

2C282=/.C(4;89;17/7;=(;>(/5212(452874.C1(/;J2/523(67/5(/5;12(;>(4;89;H=:1(932<7;H1CI(

329;3/2:(7=(C7/23./H32(.1(9;/2=/7.CCI(32C2<.=/(>;3(0;.3(/.7=/E(6232(7=4CH:2:(7=(.(:./.0.12(

.99C72:(/;(32/3;1924/7<2CI(/52(.=.CI171(:./.(;>(O+(.:79;12(2G/3.4/1M([17=J(/571(.993;.45E(

/6;( 4;89;H=:1( BFE*AL.=:3;1/.:72=L+L;=2( .=:( 71;<.C2374( .47:D( 6232( 7:2=/7>72:( .1(

Page 166: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

-SX![XXSU](#]-(Q[%['&($&'X$&!%S)&X(

(

(

*KA(

17J=7>74.=/CI(8;32( 932<.C2=/( 7=( 0;.3( /.7=/2:( 1.89C21( .1( 4;89.32:( /;( 4;=/3;C( 1.89C21M(

XT./;C2(.=:(.=:3;1/2=;=2(2G9C.7=2:(>;3(A,_(;>(/52(12=1;3I(14;32(;0/.7=2:(0I(2G923/1M(

RI( 7=4CH:7=J( /52( =26CI( 7:2=/7>72:( 4;89;H=:1E( =;( 7=432.12( 7=( 4;332C./7;=( 6.1( =;/2:M(

";62<23E(/52(8H/H.C(7=/23.4/7;=(;>(/52(4;89;H=:1(8.I(.>>24/(/52(0;.3(/.7=/(;:;H3(.1(

62CCM( X24;=:CIE( .=( H=/.3J2/2:( 14322=7=J( .993;.45( 0I( H17=J( :7>>232=/7.C( .=:( U$\XL-#(

.=.CI121E( .CC;62:( /;( 7:2=/7>I( .=;/523( 12<2=( 4;89;H=:1M( S=( /;/.C( B/.3J2/2:( .=:(

H=/.3J2/2:(.993;.45D(=7=2(7;=1(6232(9;1/HC./2:(.1(9;1170C2(4;=/370H/7=J(4;89;H=:1(/;(

0;.3( /.7=/M( Q3;8( /5212(=7=2( 7;=1E( /5322(6232( 7:2=/7>72:(.1( /52( /5322(T=;6=(0;.3( /.7=/(

4;89;H=:1( 7=:;C2E( 1T./;C2( .=:( .=:3;1/2=;=2E( 657C2( >;H3( ;/5231( 6232( 7:2=/7>72:( .1(

71;<.C2374(.47:E(52G.=;74(.47:E(AL82/5;GI7=:;C2(.=:(FE*AL.=:3;1/.:72=L+L;=2M(#=;/523(@(

7;=1( 328.7=2:( H=7:2=/7>72:M( %52( 021/( 1/./71/74.C( 8;:2C( /;( 2G9C.7=( /52( 12=1;3I( 14;32(

;0/.7=2:( 0I( 2G923/1( H12:( /52( 4;807=./7;=( ;>( 1T./;C2E( AL82/5;GI7=:;C2( .=:( /52( 7;=(

*+@OM(%571(8;:2C(2G9C.7=2:(>;3(KO_E(657C2(1T./;C2(.=:(.=:3;1/2=;=2(2G9C.7=2:(K+_(;>(

/52(14;32M((

(

Q" F(4(80+M08)M0&4*L0)+

(

#(95.12(;H/(;>(1H3J74.C(4.1/3./7;=(0I(@N*O(71(;=2(;>(/52(8.7=(J;.C1(67/57=(/52(97J(

7=:H1/3IM( %;( .4572<2( /571( J;.CE( 12<23.C( 8.7=( .4/;31( 7=( /52( 97J( 82./( 45.7=( <;CH=/.37CI(

17J=2:(/52(:24C.3./7;=(;>(R3H112C1M(";62<23E(7=(/571(:24C.3./7;=E(12<23.C(9;7=/1(;>(.4/7;=(

6232( 7:2=/7>72:( /;( 2=1H32( .( 1H1/.7=.0C2( .=:( 4;892/7/7<2(82./( 7=:H1/3IM( Q;3( 2G.89C2?(

32:H4/7;=( ;>( 0;.3( /.7=/( 4;89;H=:1( 0I( 97J( 0322:7=J( .=:P;3( 8.=.J282=/( >22:7=Jm(

8H/H.CCI( 324;J=7g2:( 82/5;:1( >;3( /52( .1121182=/( ;>( 0;.3( /.7=/( .=:( 3.97:( :2/24/7;=(

82/5;:1(>;3(0;.3(/.7=/(./(1C.HJ5/235;H121M(

V7/5(321924/( /;(0;.3(/.7=/(:2/24/7;=E(12<23.C(1/291(5.<2(022=(/.T2=(67/57=(/571(

$5-(/52171M(Y;32(19247>74.CCIE(.(452874.C(82/5;:(>;3(/52(178HC/.=2;H1(:2/24/7;=(;>(0;.3(

/.7=/(6.1(93;923CI(<.C7:./2:(.=:(12<23.C(;01/.4C21(6232(>;H=:(652=(H17=J(/52(17=J27=J(

82/5;:M( #( 02//23( 4;332C./7;=( 02/622=( 0;/5( .=.CI121( 6.1( .4572<2:( H9;=(

1/.=:.3:7g./7;=E(.=:(0I(7=4CH17;=(;>(9;1170C2(=26(0;.3(/.7=/(4;89;H=:1M(]2<23/52C211E(

Page 167: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()S(

(

(

(

*K,(

0.12:( ;=( /52( >7=:7=J1( ;>( /52( 93212=/( 1/H:IE( 1;82( 9;7=/1( >;3( >H3/523( 3212.345( 4.=( 02(

C71/2:?(

(

• <DP80&$2%*O01+2(*10'*%0)+7$8+&I03*&H'+H%1+)0%)$8N+304I$1)+

(

#( C;/( ;>( 3212.345( 5.1( 022=( :2:74./2:( /;( /52( :2/24/7;=( ;>( 0;.3( /.7=/E( 0;/5( 0I(

452874.C(.=:(12=1;3I(82/5;:1M(";62<23E(8.=I(;>(/52(452874.C(93;42:H321(.<.7C.0C2(1;(

>.3( 6232( /782( 4;=1H87=JE( =;/( 1H>>7472=/CI( 3;0H1/( .=:P;3( 9;;3CI( <.C7:./2:M( %52( =26(

82/5;:(:2<2C;92:(.1(9.3/(;>( /571($5-(/52171E(:;21(822/( /52(32ZH73282=/1( /;(02(H12:(

3;H/7=2CIE(H=:23( C.0;3./;3I(4;=:7/7;=1M(RH/(.C1;(.( C.4T(;>(<.C7:./7;=(:./.(6.1(;0123<2:(

67/5( 321924/( /;( /52( 12=1;3I( .=.CI121M( S=/23=./7;=.C( 82/5;:( 5.38;=71./7;=( >;3( 0;/5(

.=.CI121( 71( H3J2=/CI( =22:2:( .=:( /;( /571( 2G/2=/( JH7:2C7=21( .=:( 423/7>72:( 32>232=42(

8./237.C1(15;HC:(024;82(.<.7C.0C2(.=:(7=/23LC.0;3./;3I(/37.C1(15;HC:(02(;3J.=7g2:(;=(.(

32JHC.3(0.171M(U=CI( >H3/523(5.38;=71./7;=(67CC(.CC;6(4;89.371;=(02/622=(/52(:7>>232=/(

1/H:721(;=(0;.3(/.7=/M(%;(/52(021/(;>(;H3(T=;6C2:J2(;=CI(;=2(452874.C(<.C7:./7;=(1/H:IE(

7=( .J32282=/(67/5( 7=/23=./7;=.CCI( .993;<2:( 93;/;4;C1( ;>( 93;>7472=4I( /21/7=J( 5.1( 022=(

4;=:H4/2:( 7=( /571( >72C:( .=:(=;( 12=1;3I( <.C7:./7;=( 1/H:721M( %52(;0123<2:(:7>>232=421( 7=(

321HC/1(02/622=(82/5;:1(.=:(C.0;3./;3721E(4;=>738(/52(=22:(>;3(>H3/523(5.38;=71./7;=(

B".HJ2=(2/(.CME(@N*@DM(

(

• <DP80&$2%*O01+ )0%)$8N+ M08&0M4*$%+ 4I80)I$'1)+ /*4I+ 802H81+ 4$+ &$%)(308+

H&&0M4H%&0+

(

%;(.4572<2(3293212=/./7<2(4;=1H823(9.=2C1E(/52(12=17/7<7/I(;>(4;=1H8231(/;(0;.3(

/.7=/( .=:( 8;32( 19247>74.CCI( /;( .=:3;1/2=;=2( 71( ;>( H/8;1/( 789;3/.=42M( R24.H12( /571(

12=17/7<7/I( :7>>231( 02/622=( 4;H=/3721( BR;==2.H( 2/( .CME( @NNNDE( /52( 12=17/7<7/I( /;(

.=:3;1/2=;=2( 7=(QC.=:231(6.1(.112112:(:H37=J( /571($5-( /52171M(R24.H12(T=;6C2:J2(;=(

/571( 4;=1H823( 12=17/7<7/I( 67CC( >;38( /52( 0.171( >;3( >H3/523( 3212.345( ;=( 4;=1H823(

923429/7;=( .=:( .4429/.=42( ;>( 0;.3( /.7=/( 4;=/.7=7=J( 82./( .=:( 82./( 93;:H4/1E( 7/( 71(

Page 168: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

-SX![XXSU](#]-(Q[%['&($&'X$&!%S)&X(

(

(

*KO(

789;3/.=/( /;( 7=/23=./7;=.CCI( <.C7:./2( 12=1;3I(82/5;:1( >;3( 0;.3( /.7=/( 1;( 12=17/7<7/I( /;(

.=:3;1/2=;=2(02/622=(4;H=/3721(024;821(4;89.3.0C2M(

#=;/523( 789;3/.=/(>H/H32(9231924/7<2( 71(/;(:2>7=2(.:2ZH./2(12=1;3I(923429/7;=(

/53215;C:1(67/5(32J.3:(/;(4;=1H823(.4429/.=42M(X2<23.C(4H/L;>>(<.CH21(>;3(/52(452874.C(

.=.CI121(;>(1T./;C2(.=:(.=:3;1/2=;=2(5.<2(022=(1HJJ21/2:(BR;==2.H(c(!52<7CC;=E(@N*@m(

R3;;T1(c($2.31;=E(*aOam(-218;HC7=(2/(.CME(*aO@m(V.C1/3.(2/(.CME(*aaaDM(RH/E(:H2(/;(/52(

C.4T(;>(5.38;=712:(.=:(1/.=:.3:712:(82/5;:1(7=(/52(>72C:E(65745(.99CI(/;(0;/5(12=1;3I(

.1( 452874.C( 82/5;:1E( 7/( 5.1( 022=( :7>>74HC/( /;( :2>7=2( H=.807JH;H1( 12=1;3I( /53215;C:(

C2<2C1(>;3(0;.3(/.7=/(67/5;H/(=2J./7<2(923429/7;=(;>(/52(4;=1H823(B".HJ2=(2/(.CME(@N*@DM(

S=( /571( /52171E( 0;/5( 82/5;:1E( 12=1;3I( .1( 62CC( .1( 452874.CE( 6232( >H3/523( ;9/787g2:E(

32>7=2:( .=:( <.C7:./2:E( 65745( C2.:( /;( .( 4;332C./7;=( ;>( NMFNE( NMF@( .=:( NMK*E( >;3( 7=:;C2E(

1T./;C2( .=:( .=:3;1/2=;=2( 321924/7<2CI( 02/622=( 12=1;3I( .=:( 452874.C( .=.CI121M(

Y;32;<23E( /52( 7=4CH17;=( ;>( =26( 0;.3( /.7=/( 4;=/370H/7=J( 4;89;H=:1( 8.I( 52C9( 7=(

.4572<7=J(.(02//23( 4;332C./7;=M( S=( /571( 1/H:IE(.( >731/(.//289/(6.1(8.:2( /;( 7:2=/7>I(=26(

0;.3(/.7=/(4;=/370H/7=J(4;89;H=:1M(";62<23E(4;=>738./7;=(;>( /52( 7=<;C<282=/(;>(=26(

4;89;H=:1( /;( 0;.3( /.7=/( 923429/7;=( 71( 324;882=:2:(;=( .( C.3J23( :./.12/M([C/78./2CIE(

/52( 4;807=./7;=( ;>( /52( 32>7=2:( .=.CI171( /245=7ZH21E( /52( T=;6C2:J2( ;=( /52( 7=:7<7:H.C(

2G9C.=./;3I(9;623(;>(/52(3219;=170C2(4;89;H=:1(.=:(/52(7=/23.4/7;=(02/622=(/52(0;.3(

/.7=/(4;89;H=:1E(8H1/( C2.:( /;(J;;:( 7=/23=./7;=.C(.993;<2:( /53215;C:1(67/5( 32J.3:( /;(

4;=1H823(.4429/.=42M(

(

• 6HM*1+$KR0&4*L0+1040&4*$%+304I$1S)T+H4+4I0+)'H(2I408'*%0+

(

#/(93212=/(12=1;3I(.=.CI121(71(/52(8;1/(4;88;=CI(.99C72:(:2/24/7;=(82/5;:(>;3(

0;.3(/.7=/(7=(1C.HJ5/235;H121M(V52=(/.T7=J(/52(:7>>232=/(.<.7C.0C2(52./7=J(82/5;:1(7=/;(

.44;H=/E( .( C.3J2( 52/23;J2=7/I( 71( =;/742.0C2( 7=(82/5;:;C;JI( H12:( 02/622=( .=:(67/57=(

82/5;:1(B!5.9/23( S)DM(%571(<.37.07C7/I(8.T21(4;89.371;=(02/622=(1/H:721(:7>>74HC/M( S/( 71(

.:<71.0C2( /;( 12C24/( ;=2( 52./7=J(82/5;:( B/5./( 71( .C1;( /3.=1>23.0C2( /;( 1C.HJ5/235;H121D(

.=:(/;(<.C7:./2(/5./(82/5;:(1H>>7472=/CI(0I(2<.CH./7=J(/52(:7>>232=/(9.3.82/231(/5./(8.I(

Page 169: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()S(

(

(

(

*Ka(

7=>CH2=42( ;3( 4;=>;H=:( /52( 321HC/1( 1H45( .1( 4;=/.87=./7;=E( 52./7=J( /28923./H32E( .=:(

5.07/H./7;=M((

R217:21E( /52( :2<2C;982=/( ;>( =26( ;0h24/7<2( :2/24/7;=( 82/5;:1( :7324/CI(

.99C74.0C2( ./( /52( 1C.HJ5/23C7=2E( /5./( :;( =;/( 32CI( ;=( /52( 5H8.=( =;12E( .32( 6;3/5I( ;>(

>H3/523( 3212.345(.1(62CCM(&G.89C21(8.I(02( /52(:2<2C;982=/(;>(4;C;3782/374(.11.I1( >;3(

/52(0;.3(/.7=/(4;89;H=:1(;3(/52(>H3/523(2G9C;3./7;=(;>(2C24/3;=74(=;121M(

(

• :8$1(&4*$%+ $7+ 30H4+ H%1+30H4+ M8$1(&4)+ 78$3+ 4H*%401+30H4+ /*4I$(4+ %02H4*L0+

M08&0M4*$%+$7+&$%)(308)+

(

V52=(.:2ZH./2(12=1;3I(923429/7;=(/53215;C:1(.=:(3.97:(:2/24/7;=(82/5;:1(./(

/52(1C.HJ5/23C7=2(024;82(.<.7C.0C2E(3212.345(4;HC:(02(/.3J2/2:(./(93;:H47=J(82./(.=:(

82./( 93;:H4/1( 67/5( 0;.3( /.7=/( C2<2C1( 02C;6( /5212( /53215;C:1M( X7=42( 3212.345( ;=( 0;.3(

/.7=/( 02J.=E( 7/( 5.1( 022=( 1924HC./2:( /5./( /52( =2J./7<2( 789.4/( 7=( 93;42112:( 93;:H4/1(

6;HC:( 02( C211( /5.=( 7=( >3215(82./( 024.H12( 93;42117=J( 7=( <.37;H1( 6.I1( 8.I(8.1T( /52(

2>>24/1( ;>( 1T./;C2( .=:( .=:3;1/2=;=2( B&QX#E( @NNFDM( ";62<23E( ;=CI( .( >26( 1/H:721(

B-25=5.3:( 2/( .CME( *aaKm(Y.//5261( 2/( .CME( @NNNm(Y4!.HC2I( 2/( .CME( *aa,m(V.C1/3.E( *a,FD(

5.<2(7=<21/7J./2:(/52(9;11707C7/721(/;(93;4211(82./(67/5(0;.3(/.7=/M(#(9;17/7<2(2>>24/(6.1(

>;H=:( 652=( 82./( 93;:H4/1( 6232( 52./2:( :H37=J( 93;42117=J( .1( >;3( 2G.89C2( 5.992=1(

:H37=J(/52(93;:H4/7;=(;>(4H32:(4;;T2:(5.8(B#J23528(c(%;3=023JE(*aaKm(V;;:(2/(.CME(

*aaKDM(%571(4.=(02(2G9C.7=2:(0I( /52( >.4/( /5./(8;1/(0;.3( /.7=/(4;=/370H/7=J(4;89;H=:1(

.32( <;C./7C2E( 7=( 9.3/74HC.3( 652=( 52./2:M( ";62<23E( 17=42( 4;;T7=J( /;( .( 57J5( >7=.C(

/28923./H32(67CC(:2432.12(hH747=211(.=:(/2=:23=211(7=(9;3TE(/571(67CC(=;/(02(;9/78.C(>;3(

;0/.7=7=J( .( 57J5( 2./7=JLZH.C7/I( 9;3T( BV;;:( 2/( .CME( *aaKDM(U/523( 1/H:721( :28;=1/3./2:(

/5./( 0;.3( /.7=/( 4.=( .C1;( 02( 8.1T2:( >;3( 2G.89C2( 0I( H17=J( 197421E( 18;T7=J( ;3(

9;CI95;195./21( B-25=5.3:( 2/( .CME( *aaKm( \7=:.5C( 2/( .CME( @NN,m( X52.3:( 2/( .CME( *aaaDM(

]2<23/52C211( 1;82( 1/H:721( 32<2.C2:( /5./( 0;.3( /.7=/( 9;121( 93;0C281( 7=( .CC( 93;:H4/1(

32J.3:C211( ;>( /52( 93;42117=JM( $3;:H4/7;=( ;>( 0.4;=( 0I( 7=h24/7;=( ;3( 7882317=J( 7=( 1.C/(

1;CH/7;=1( 12282:( /;( 5.<2( ;=CI( .( 87=;3( 2>>24/( ;=( /52( 4;=42=/3./7;=( ;>( 0;.3( /.7=/(

BY;//3.8(2/(.CME(*aO@DM(#C1;(7=(X9.=715(1/H:721(7/(6.1(4;=4CH:2:(/5./(4H37=J(.=:(:3I7=J(

Page 170: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

-SX![XXSU](#]-(Q[%['&($&'X$&!%S)&X(

(

(

*AN(

:H37=J( 93;42117=J( 4;HC:( =;/(8.1T( 0;.3( /.7=/( B#3=.H( 2/( .CME( *aOAm( R.=;=( 2/( .CME( @NN+DM(

QH3/523(3212.345(71(5;62<23(=22:2:(/;(2<.CH./2(/52(789.4/(;>(/52(:7>>232=/(93;42117=J(

1/291(;=(82./(93;:H4/1( 7=(/2381(;>(0;.3(/.7=/(.=:(/;(:2/2387=2(/52(12=1;3I(/53215;C:(

>;3( 82./( .=:( 82./( 93;:H4/1( 7=( /52( :7>>232=/( 4;H=/3721( ;>( 7=/2321/( /;( .4572<2( .(

1H1/.7=.0C2(.=:(4;892/7/7<2(97J(82./(45.7=(7=(/52(&H3;92.=([=7;=M(

+

(

( +

Page 171: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()S(

(

(

(

*A*(

U" 607080%&0)+

#J23528("M(c(%;3=023J(&M(B*aaKDM(#(4;89.371;=(;>(/52(;>>L>C.<;H3(;>(82./(>3;8(2=/732(8.C21(4;;T2:(/;(/6;(:7>>232=/( 7=/23=.C(2=:L9;7=/( /28923./H321M($3;422:7=J1(;>(

/52( &##$( 6;3T15;9( ;=( 93;:H4/7;=( .=:( H/7C71./7;=( ;>( 82./( >3;8( 2=/732( 8.C21E(Y7C/;=(^2I=21E([^M(

#CH6b(YME(\.=J2=:3721(^M(!M(YME(R2T.23/(^ME(%HI//2=1(QM(#M(YME(-2(R3.0.=:23(-ME(-2(X82/(XM( c( Y7CC2/( XM( B@N*@.DM( &>>24/( ;>( 1H3J74.C( 4.1/3./7;=E( 788H=;4.1/3./7;=( .=:(4574;3IL:72/( ;=( /52( 82./( ZH.C7/I( .=:( 9.C./.07C7/I( ;>( 0;.31M( Y2./( X472=42E(1H087//2:M(

#CH6b(YME(Y7CC2/( XME( R2T.23/( ^M(YME( %HI//2=1( QM(#M(YME().=5.24T2( \ME(-2( X82/( XM(c(-2(R3.0.=:23( -M( \M( B@N**DM( S=>CH2=42( ;>( 0322:( .=:( 1C.HJ5/23(627J5/( ;=( 0;.3( /.7=/(932<.C2=42(7=(2=/732(8.C2(97J1M(#=78.CE(KBODE(*@O+L*@OaM(

#CH6b(YME(Y7CC2/( XME( ]7h1( WME( %HI//2=1( QM( #M(YME( )2352I:2=( ^ME( -2( R3.0.=:23( "M( QME( -2(R3.0.=:23(-M(\M(c().=(U24T2C(YM(`M(B@NNaDM(#012=42(;>(.=(2>>24/(;>(:72/.3I(>7032(

;3(4C7=;9/7C;C7/2(;=(0;.3(/.7=/(7=(2=/732(8.C2(97J1(>2:(93.4/74.C(:72/1M(Y2./(X472=42E(O@B+DE(+FAL+K@M(

#CH6b(YME( %HI//2=1( QM( #M(YME( R2T.23/( ^M(YME( -2( R3.0.=:23( -M( \M( c(Y7CC2/( XM( B@N*@0DM(&<.CH./7;=(;>(<.37;H1(0;.3(/.7=/(:2/24/7;=(82/5;:1M(#=78.CE(7=(93211M(

#3=.H(`ME(-7.g(SME(W.347.L'2JH273;(`M(#ME(";3/;1(YM(c(!.1.:28;=/(WM(B*aOADM(S=>CH2=42(;>(

0;.3( /.7=/( 7=(;3J.=;C29/74( 45.3.4/2371/741(;>( X9.=715( 4H32:(5.8M($3;422:7=J1(;>(+@=:(822/7=J(;>(Y2./('212.345(V;3T231E(W52=/E(R2CJ7H8E(+**L+*@M(

R.=;=(XME(W7C(YM(-M(c(W.337:;(YM(-M(B@NN+DM(%52(2>>24/1(;>(4.1/3./7;=(;=(/52(2./7=J(ZH.C7/I(;>(:3IL4H32:(5.8M(Y2./(X472=42E(AKB+DE(*N+*L*N+,M(

R;==2.H(YM( B*aO@DM( !;89;H=:1( 3219;=170C2( >;3( 0;.3( /.7=/E( 67/5( 19247.C( 2895.171( ;=(

.=:3;1/2=;=2(L(#(32<726(\7<21/;4T($3;:H4/7;=(X472=42E(aBADE(AO,L,NKM(R;==2.H(YM(c(!52<7CC;=($M(B@N*@DM(#4429/.07C7/I(;>(2=/732(8.C2(9;3T(67/5(<.37;H1(C2<2C1(

;>( .=:3;1/2=;=2( .=:( 1T./;C2( 0I( 4;=1H8231( .44;3:7=J( /;( /5273( 12=17/7<7/I( /;(.=:3;1/2=;=2M(Y2./(X472=42E(aNB@DE(++NL++,M(

R;==2.H( YME( ^2891/23( #M( `ME( !C.H1( 'ME( !C.H:7LY.J=H112=( !ME( -721/32( #ME( %;3=023J( &ME(V.C1/3.($ME(!52<7CC;=($ME(V27C23([M(c(!;;T(WM(\M(B@NNNDM(#=(7=/23=./7;=.C(1/H:I(;=(

/52(789;3/.=42(;>(.=:3;1/2=;=2(.=:(1T./;C2(>;3(0;.3(/.7=/?(SM($3212=/./7;=(;>(/52(93;J3.882(.=:(82.1H3282=/(;>(0;.3(/.7=/(4;89;H=:1(67/5(:7>>232=/(.=.CI/74.C(93;42:H321M(Y2./(X472=42E(KFB+DE(@K*L@KaM(

R3;;T1( 'M( SM( c( $2.31;=( #M( YM( B*aOaDM( U:;3( /53215;C:( ;>( /52( !*aL:2C/.L*AL1/23;7:1(3219;=170C2(>;3(0;.3(;:;3(7=(9;3TM(Y2./(X472=42E(@KB*DE(**L*aM(

-2(R3.0.=:23("M(QM(c()2302T2('M(B*aOADM(dH.=/7/./7<2(:2/2387=./7;=(;>(.=:3;1/2=;=2(7=(97J(.:79;12(/711H2M(`U[']#\(UQ(!"'UY#%UW'#$"jE(+A+E(@a+L+N@M(

Page 172: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

-SX![XXSU](#]-(Q[%['&($&'X$&!%S)&X(

(

(

*A@(

-25=5.3:( YME( !C.H1( 'ME( "23023/( &M( c( "7CC2=03.=:( YM( B*aaKDM( XT./;CLH=:(#=:3;1/2=;=T;=g2=/3./7;=2=( 7=( QC2714523g2HJ=7112=( .H1( &023145C.45/Tr3923=M(-72(&0238.1/E("2>/(FFaE(KKL,@M(

-218;HC7=(RME(R;==2.H(YME(Q3;H7=(#M(c(R7:.3:(`M($M(B*aO@DM(!;=1H823(/21/7=J(;>(9;3T(.=:(93;42112:(82./( >3;8(0;.31( L( /52( 7=>CH2=42(;>( >./(.=:3;1/2=;=2( C2<2CM( \7<21/;4T(

$3;:H4/7;=(X472=42E(aBADE(,N,L,*KM(-7hT1/235H71(WM(RME(&=J2C(RME(V.C1/3.($ME(QH3=;C1(YM(QM(SME(#J23528("ME(Q714523(^ME(UC7<23(YM(

#ME( !C.H:7LY.J=H112=( !ME( X732/( QME( R2.JH2( YM( $ME( ";823( -M( RM( c( R;==2.H( YM(B@NNNDM(#=( 7=/23=./7;=.C( 1/H:I(;=( /52( 789;3/.=42(;>( .=:3;1/2=;=2(.=:( 1T./;C2(>;3( 0;.3( /.7=/?( SSM( X2=1;3I( 2<.CH./7;=( 0I( /3.7=2:( 9.=2C1( 7=( 12<2=( &H3;92.=(4;H=/3721M(Y2./(X472=42E(KFB+DE(@A*L@AaM(

&QX#M( B@NNFDM( V2C>.32( .1924/1( ;>( /52( 4.1/3./7;=( ;>( 97JC2/1?( X472=/7>74( '29;3/( ;>( /52(X472=/7>74( $.=2C( >;3( #=78.C( "2C./5( .=:(V2C>.32( ;=( .( 32ZH21/( >3;8( 4;887117;=(32C./2:(/;(62C>.32(.1924/1(;>(/52(4.1/3./7;=(;>($7JC2/1M(%52(&QX#(`;H3=.CE(a*E(*L*OM(

Q714523( `ME( &C17=J5;31/( $M( VME( RH4T7=J( YME( %5;C2=( &ME( $2/2312=( RM( c( VH1/( YM( B@N**DM(-2<2C;982=/( ;>( .( !.=:7:./2( '2>232=42( Y2/5;:( >;3( /52( X78HC/.=2;H1(

dH.=/7/./7;=(;>(/52(R;.3(%.7=/(!;89;H=:1(#=:3;1/2=;=2E(+(.C95.L#=:3;1/2=;CE(+( 02/.L#=:3;1/2=;CE( XT./;C2E( .=:( S=:;C2( 7=( $7J( Q./( 0I(Y2.=1( ;>( X/.0C2( S1;/;92(-7CH/7;=( #=.CI171L"2.:19.42( X;C7:L$5.12( Y743;2G/3.4/7;=LW.1(!53;8./;J3.95IPY.11(X924/3;82/3IM(#=.CI/74.C(!52871/3IE(O+B*,DE(A,OKLA,a*M(

Q;=/( 7( QH3=;C1(YM( B@N*@DM( !;=1H823( 1/H:721( ;=( 12=1;3I( .4429/.07C7/I( ;>( 0;.3( /.7=/?( .(

32<726M(Y2./(X472=42M(W7C023/( #M( ]M( c(VI1;4T7( !M( `M( B*aO,DM( %52( 182CC( 321HC/1?( 1H3<2IM( ]./7;=.C( W2;J3.9574E(

;4/;023E(K*F(L(K@KM(".=12=LYoCC23( `M( B*aaFDM( '.97:( 57J5L923>;38.=42( C7ZH7:( 453;8./;J3.9574( 82/5;:( >;3(

178HC/.=2;H1( :2/2387=./7;=( ;>( .=:3;1/2=;=2E( 1T./;C2( .=:( 7=:;C2( 7=( 0.4T( >./(

>3;8( 97J1M( `;H3=.C( ;>( !53;8./;J3.95I( RLR7;82:74.C( #99C74./7;=1E( AA*B@DE( @*aL@+NM(

".HJ2=( `M( &ME( R3H=7H1( !M( c( i.8.3./1T.7.( WM( B@N*@DM( '2<726( ;>( .=.CI/74.C( 82/5;:1( /;(82.1H32( 0;.3( /.7=/( 4;89;H=:1( 7=( 9;347=2( .:79;12( /711H2?( %52( =22:( >;3(5.38;=712:(82/5;:1M(Y2./(X472=42E(aNB*DE(aL*aM(

^.H>8.==(WME( '7//23( QM(c( X45H023/( ^M( B*a,ADM(dH.=/7/./7<2L:2/2387=./7;=(;>( 0;.3( /.7=/(

1H01/.=42(K.C95.L.=:3;1/L*AL2=L+L;=2(7=(>./M(`;H3=.C(;>(X/23;7:(R7;452871/3I(.=:(Y;C24HC.3(R7;C;JIE(,BODE(Ka+LKa,M(

^2CC23(#ME(i5H.=J("M(jME(!57(dM(jME();115.CC(\M(RM(c(Y./1H=.87("M(B@NN,DM(W2=2/74(<.37./7;=(7=( .(5H8.=(;:;3.=/( 32429/;3( .C/231(;:;H3(923429/7;=M(]./H32E( FFaB,*A*DE( FAOL[FAAM(

\7=:.5C(WME(X/;Cg2=0.45(]72C12=(XME(!52=(WME(^.3C11;=(#M("ME(\H=:1/3;8(^M(c(RI3=2(-M()M(B@NN,DM(Y.1T7=J( ;>( 0;.3( /.7=/( 0I( 18;T7=J( .=:( >2382=/./7;=M( $3;422:7=J1( K+=:(

Page 173: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()S(

(

(

(

*A+(

S=/23=./7;=.C( !;=J3211( ;>( Y2./( X427=42( .=:( %245=;C;JIE( #HJH1/( AL,E( R27h7=JE(!57=.E(KN,LKNOM(

\H=:2(^ME(XTH/23H:(&ME(&J2C.=:1:.C(RME(Q;=/(7(QH3=;C1(YME(]H/2(WM('ME(R2h235;C8(!ME(]7C12=(#ME( X/2=1/3;8( jM( "M( c( "231C2/5(YM( B@N*NDM( %52( 789;3/.=42( ;>( /52( 3243H7/82=/(82/5;:(>;3(.=:3;1/2=;=2(12=17/7<7/I(67/5(321924/(/;(.44H3./2(12=1;3I(2<.CH./7;=(

;>(.=:3;1/2=;=2(/.7=/2:(82./M(Q;;:(dH.C7/I(.=:($32>232=42E(@*BADE(AFOLAKFM(\H=:2( ^ME( XTH/23H:( &ME( ]7C12=( #M( c( &J2C.=:1:.C( RM( B@NNaDM( #( =26( 82/5;:( >;3(

:7>>232=/7./7=J(/52(.=:3;1/2=;=2(12=17/7<7/I(.8;=J(4;=1H8231M(Q;;:(dH.C7/I(.=:($32>232=42E(@NBFDE(+NFL+**M(

Y./5H3($M(^ME( %2=(].92C( `ME(RC;285;>(XME("2321( \ME( ^=;C(&M( QM(c(YHC:23("M(#M( B@N*@DM(#(5H8.=(=;12(14;37=J(1I1/28(>;3(0;.3(/.7=/(.=:(7/1(32C./7;=1579(67/5(.=:3;1/2=;=2(

.=:(1T./;C2M(Y2./(X472=42E(a*E(F*FLF@@M(Y.//5261( ^M( 'ME( ";823( -M( RME( $H=/23( $ME( R2.JH2( YM( $ME( W71923/( YME( ^2891/23( #M( `ME(

#J23528("ME(!C.H:7LY.J=H112=(!ME(Q714523(^ME(X732/(QME(\2.1T("ME(QH3=;C1(YM(QM(SM(c(R;==2.H(YM( B@NNNDM(#=( 7=/23=./7;=.C(1/H:I(;=(/52( 789;3/.=42(;>(.=:3;1/2=;=2(.=:( 1T./;C2( >;3( 0;.3( /.7=/?( SSSM( !;=1H823( 1H3<2I( 7=( 12<2=( &H3;92.=( 4;H=/3721M(

Y2./(X472=42E(KFB+DE(@,*L@O+M(Y4!.HC2I(SME("2==211I(-M($ME(R;J5;117.=()ME(X.C7(\ME(X.C<./;32(\ME('2I=;C:1(`M(c(Y.61;=('M(

B*aa,DM(&>>24/(;>(82/5;:1(;>(4;;T7=J(.=:(93;42117=J(9;3T(;=( /52(923429/7;=(;>(0;.3( /.7=/M( S=( YM( R;==2.HE( ^M( \H=:1/3;8( c( RM( Y.C8>;31( B&:1MDE( R;.3( %.7=/( 7=(&=/732(Y.C2($7J1(B99M(*KAL*ANDM(V.J2=7=J2=?(V.J2=7=J2=(#4.:2874($H0C715231M(

Y2/g(!M(c(!C.H1('M( B@NN+DM(#4/7<2( 788H=7g./7;=(;>(0;.31(.J.7=1/(W='"(:;21(=;/(.>>24/(J3;6/5(5;38;=2(0H/(C;6231(SWQLS(7=(9C.18.M(\7<21/;4T($3;:H4/7;=(X472=42E(O*B@L+DE(*@aL*+,M(

Y;//3.8(-M(XME(V;;:(`M(-M(c($.//231;=('M(\M(XM(B*aO@DM(!;89.371;=(;>(0;.31(.=:(4.1/3./21(>;3( 0.4;=( 93;:H4/7;=( +M( !;89;17/7;=( .=:( 2./7=J( ZH.C7/I( ;>( 0.4;=M( #=78.C(

$3;:H4/7;=E(+KB#[WDE(,KLONM(]72C2=(YM(VM(QME( <.=(&=J2C2=(YM(!ME( iH7:232=/('M(c('.8.T23('M( B@NN,DM( X4322=7=J(.=:(

4;=>738./7;=(437/237.( >;3(5;38;=2(3217:H2(.=.CI171(H17=J( C7ZH7:(453;8./;J3.95I(.44H3./2( 8.11( /782L;>L>C7J5/E( Q;H3723( /3.=1>;38( 7;=( 4I4C;/3;=( 321;=.=42( .=:(;307/3.9(8.11( 1924/3;82/3I( /245=7ZH21M( #=.CI/74.( !57874.( #4/.E( KOAB*L@DE( *@@L*@aM(

$.//231;=( 'M( \M( XM( B*aAODM( S:2=/7>74./7;=( ;>( +kL5I:3;GILKkL.=:3;1/L*AL2=2( .1( /52(8H1T(;:;H3(4;89;=2=/(;>(0;.3(1H08.G7CC.3I(1.C7<.3I(JC.=:(.=:(7/1(32C./7;=1579(/;(/52(12G(;:;H3(/.7=/(7=(9;3T(82./M(`;H3=.C(;>(/52(X472=42(;>(Q;;:(.=:(#J374HC/H32E(*aE(F+FLF+OM(

$.HCI(!ME(X937=JLX/.25C7($ME(Ul-;523/I(`M()ME(^3.J/2=(XM(#ME(-H0;71(XME(Y211.:2=2(`M(c(R22(

WM( B@N*NDM( %52( 2>>24/1( ;>( 82/5;:( ;>( 4.1/3./7;=E( 32.37=J( 4;=:7/7;=( .=:( :72/( ;=(

Page 174: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

-SX![XXSU](#]-(Q[%['&($&'X$&!%S)&X(

(

(

*AF(

12=1;3I( ZH.C7/I( ;>( 9;3T( .112112:( 0I( .( /3.7=2:( 9.=2CM(Y2./( X472=42E( OAB@DE( FaOLKNFM(

X52.3:( $M( 'ME( ]H/2(WM( 'ME( '745.3:1;=( 'M( SME( $233I( #M(c( %.IC;3( #M( #M( B*aaaDM( S=h24/7;=( ;>(6./23( .=:( 9;CI95;195./2( 7=/;( 9;3T( /;( 7893;<2( hH747=211( .=:( /2=:23=211( .>/23(4;;T7=JM(Y2./(X472=42E(K*BFDE(+,*L+,AM(

XZH7321( &M( `M( B@NNADM( $;11707C7/721( >;3( 12C24/7;=( .J.7=1/( 0;.3( /.7=/M( #4/.( )2/237=.37.(X4.=:7=.<74.E(FOBXODM(

XH/523C.=:(YM(#ME(-.<71(RM(\ME(R3;;T1(%M(#M(c(!;2/g22(`M(QM(B@N*@DM(%52(95I17;C;J74.C(.=:(025.<7;3.C(3219;=12(;>(97J1(4.1/3./2:(67/5(.=:(67/5;H/(.=21/5217.(;3(.=.CJ217.M(`;H3=.C(;>(#=78.C(X472=42E(aNB,DE(@@**L@@@*M(

%5;891;=('M("M(c($2.31;=(#M(YM(B*a,,DM(dH.=/7/./7<2L:2/2387=./7;=(;>(K.C95.L.=:3;1/L

*AL2=L+L;=2( 0I( J.1( 453;8./;J3.95I(8.11( 1924/3;82/3I( .=:( 7/1( 32C./7;=1579( /;(12G( ;:;3( 7=/2=17/I( ;>( 9;3TM( `;H3=.C( ;>( #J374HC/H3.C( .=:( Q;;:( !52871/3IE( @KBADE(*@F*L*@FKM(

)2352I:2=(^ME(];992("ME(#CH62(YME(Y7CC2/(XME(RH11452(`M()M(c(-2(R3.0.=:23("M(QM(B@NN,DM(-2<2C;982=/(.=:(<.C7:./7;=(;>(.(82/5;:( >;3(178HC/.=2;H1(.=.CI171(;>( /52(0;.3(

/.7=/( 4;89;H=:1( 7=:;C2E( 1T./;C2( .=:( .=:3;1/2=;=2( 7=( 97J( >./( H17=J( C7ZH7:(453;8./;J3.95IL8HC/79C2( 8.11( 1924/3;82/3IM( `;H3=.C( ;>( !53;8./;J3.95I( #E(**,FB*L@DE(*+@L*+,M(

Vold E. (1970). Fleishproduktionseigenschaften bei Ebern und Kastraten. IV. Organoleptische und gaschromatografische Untersuchungen Wassedampfflüchtiger Stooffe des Rückenspeckes von Ebern. Meldinger Nordandbruckhoegskole, 49, 1 - 25.(

V.C1/3.( $M( B*a,FDM( Q.//2=7=J( ;>( I;H=J( 0;.31?( ZH.=/7>74./7;=( ;>( =2J./72<2( .=:( 9;17/7<2(.1924/1M(\7<21/;4T($3;:H4/7;=(X472=42E(*E(*O,L*aAM(

V.C1/3.($ME(!C.H:7LY.J=H112=(!ME(!52<7CC;=($ME(<;=(X2/5(WME(-721/32(#ME(Y.//5261(^M('ME(";823(-M(RM(c(R;==2.H(YM(B*aaaDM(#=(7=/23=./7;=.C(1/H:I(;=(/52(789;3/.=42(;>(.=:3;1/2=;=2(.=:(1T./;C2(>;3(0;.3(/.7=/?( C2<2C1(;>(.=:3;1/2=;=2(.=:(1T./;C2(0I(

4;H=/3I(.=:(12.1;=M(\7<21/;4T($3;:H4/7;=(X472=42E(A@B*DE(*KL@OM(V27C23( [ME( Q714523( ^ME( ^28823( "ME( -;03;6;C1T7( #M( c( !C.H1( 'M( B*aa,DM( S=>CH2=42( ;>(

.=:3;1/2=;=2(12=17/7<7/I(;=(4;=1H823(32.4/7;=1(/;(0;.3(82./M(S=(YM(R;==2.HE(^M(\H=:1/3;8(c( RM(Y.C8>;31( B&:1MDE( R;.3( %.7=/( 7=( &=/732(Y.C2( $7J1( B99M( *F,L*K*DM(V.J2=7=J2=?(V.J2=7=J2=(#4.:2874($H0C715231M(

V27C23( [ME( Q;=/( 7( QH3=;C1( YME( Q714523( ^ME( ^28823( "ME( UC7<23( YM( #ME( W71923/( YME(-;03;6;C1T7( #M( c( !C.H1( 'M( B@NNNDM( S=>CH2=42( ;>( :7>>232=421( 7=( 12=17/7<7/I( ;>(X9.=715(.=:(W238.=(4;=1H8231(/;(923427<2(.=:3;1/2=;=2(;=(/52(.4429/.=42(;>(0;.3(82./(:7>>237=J( 7=(1T./;C2(.=:(.=:3;1/2=;=2(4;=42=/3./7;=1M(Y2./(X472=42E(KFB+DE(@a,L+NFM(

V57//7=J/;=(QM(YME(i.88237=7(-ME(]H/2(WM('ME(R.T23(#ME("HJ521(XM(SM(c(V;;:(`M(-M(B@N**DM(!;89.371;=( ;>( 52./7=J( 82/5;:1( .=:( /52( H12( ;>( :7>>232=/( /711H21( >;3( 12=1;3I(

Page 175: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

!"#$%&'()S(

(

(

(

*AK(

.1121182=/( ;>( .0=;38.C( ;:;H31( B0;.3( /.7=/D( 7=( 97J(82./M(Y2./( X472=42E( OOB@DE(@FaL@KKM(

V;;:( `M(-ME(]H/2(WM('ME(QH312I(WM(#M( `M(c(!H/5023/1;=(#M( B*aaKDM(%52(2>>24/(;>(4;;T7=J(4;=:7/7;=1(;=(/52(2./7=J(ZH.C7/I(;>(9;3TM(Y2./(X472=42E(FNB@DE(*@,L*+KM(

i.8.3./1T.7.(WM(c(`.1/320;<.(`M(B@NNADM(#99C74./7;=(;>(\!LYX(>;3(:2/2387=./7;=(;>(7=:;C2(

.=:( +L82/5IC7=:;C2( 7=( 9;347=2( .:79;12( /711H2M( !53;8./;J3.957.E( AFB,LODE( F+KLF+aM(

i.8.3./1T.7.(WM(c(XZH7321(&M( `M( B@NNaDM(R7;452874.CE(=H/37/7;=.C( .=:(J2=2/74(2>>24/1(;=(0;.3(/.7=/(7=(2=/732(8.C2(97J1M(#=78.CE(+B**DE(*KNOL*K@*M(+

(

Page 176: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

(

(

(

( +

Page 177: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

Appendices

Page 178: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

(

(

(

(

Page 179: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

X[YY#'j(

(

(

(

*Aa(

CDJJ-6V+

R;.3(/.7=/( 71(.=(H=9C2.1.=/(;:;H3( /5./(4.=(;44H3(652=(82./(;3( >./( >3;8(2=/732(

8.C21( 71( 52./2:M( %52( 8.7=( 4;89;H=:1( 3219;=170C2( >;3( /571( ;:;H3( .32( 1T./;C2( .=:(

.=:3;1/2=;=2( .=:( /;( .( C21123( :2J322( 7=:;C2M( [=/7C( 3242=/CI( 97JC2/1( 6232( 4.1/3./2:( /;(

.<;7:( 0;.3( /.7=/M( %571( 93;42:H32( 71( =;6.:.I1( 4;=17:232:( .1( /;;( 9.7=>HC( 17=42( 7=(8;1/(

4.121(7/(6.1(923>;382:(67/5;H/(.=.21/5217.(;3(.=.CJ217.M(S=(3219;=12(/;(/5212(J3;67=J(

4;=423=1E(12<23.C(8.7=(9C.I231(67/57=(/52(97J(.=:(9;3T(7=:H1/3I(7=(/52(&[(5.<2(.J322:(/;(

<;CH=/.37CI( 2=:( /52( 93.4/742( ;>( 1H3J74.C( 97J( 4.1/3./7;=( 0I( `.=H.3I( *1/( @N*OM( #( 9;1170C2(

.C/23=./7<2(;=(/52(C;=J(/238(71(/52(93;:H4/7;=(;>(2=/732(8.C2(97J1M(%52(8.7=(4;=:7/7;=(/;(

.4572<2( /571( J;.C( 71( /52( 32:H4/7;=( ;3( 2C787=./7;=( ;>( 0;.3( /.7=/M( %;( /571( 2G/2=/(

8.=.J282=/(1/3./2J721(.32(.99C72:(0H/(67/5(<.3I7=J(:2J3221(;>(1H44211M(X7=42(0;.3(/.7=/(

5.1( =;/( 022=( >HCCI( 2C787=./2:E( /52( :2/24/7;=( ;>( /.7=/2:( 4.34.1121( ./( /52( 1C.HJ5/23C7=2(

328.7=1(32ZH732:M(QH3/5238;32E(/52(4.34.1121(67/5(0;.3(/.7=/(8H1/(02(93;42112:( 7=(.=(

24;=;874.CCI(>2.170C2(8.==23(.=:(67/5;H/(=2J./7<2(923429/7;=(;>(/52(4;=1H823M((

X7=42( 3212.345( ;=( 0;.3(82./( 02J.=E( 7/( 5.1( 022=( 1924HC./2:( /5./( /52( =2J./7<2(

789.4/( ;>( 93;42112:( /.7=/2:( 82./( 6;HC:( 02( C211( /5.=( /5./( ;>( >3215( 82./( 024.H12(

93;42117=J( 7=( <.37;H1(6.I1(8.I(8.1T(;3(:2432.12( /52(=2J./7<2(923429/7;=1(;>( 1T./;C2(

.=:( .=:3;1/2=;=2M( ";62<23( 7=( 8;1/( ;>( /5212( 4;=1H823( 9.=2C( 0.12:( 1/H:721E(

.=:3;1/2=;=2( 12=17/7<7/I( ;>( /52( 4;=1H8231( 6.1( =;/( 7=4CH:2:M( R24.H12( 12=17/7<7/I( /;(

.=:3;1/2=;=2(:7>>231(02/622=(4;H=/3721E( 7/( 71(324;882=:2:(/;(2<.CH./2(/52(12=17/7<7/I(

/;(.=:3;1/2=;=2(7=(2<23I(4;H=/3IM(%;(.<;7:(82./(67/5(H=.4429/.0C2(57J5(0;.3(/.7=/(/;(

32.45(/52(8.3T2/(.=:( C2.:(/;(H=6.=/2:(=2J./7<2(4;=1H823(32.4/7;=1E(0;.3(/.7=/(8H1/(

02( :2/24/2:( ./( /52( 1C.HJ5/23C7=2M( #(67:2( 3.=J2( ;>( 452874.C( .=:( 12=1;3I(82/5;:1( 5.1(

022=(93;9;12:(/;(:2/24/(/52(T=;6=(0;.3(/.7=/(4;89;H=:1( 7=(.:79;12(/711H2M(";62<23(

/52( 8.h;37/I( ;>( /5212( 82/5;:1( .32( 9;;3CI( <.C7:./2:E( 65745( 8.I( 9.3/7.CCI( 2G9C.7=( /52(

3./523(C;6(4;332C./7;=1(02/622=(452874.C(.=:(12=1;3I(.=.CI121(;0/.7=2:(1;(>.3M(#=;/523(

9;1170C2(2G9C.=./7;=(71(/52(4;=/370H/7;=(;>(.::7/7;=.C(4;89;H=:1(/;(0;.3(/.7=/(.=:(/52(

7=/23.4/7;=1( 02/622=( /5;12( 4;89;H=:1M( %52( 19247>74( ;0h24/7<21( ;>( /571( /52171( 6232(

/5232>;32?( /;( :2/2387=2( /52( 12=17/7<7/I( ;>( 4;=1H8231( /;( .=:3;1/2=;=2( 7=( QC.=:231(

Page 180: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

X[YY#'j(

(

(

*,N(

B!5.9/23(SSDm(/;(:2<2C;9(.=:(<.C7:./2(.(452874.C(.=.CI171(93;42:H32(>;3(/52(178HC/.=2;H1(

:2/24/7;=( ;>( /52( /5322( T=;6=( 0;.3( /.7=/( 4;89;H=:1( B!5.9/23( SSSDm( /;( 7=<21/7J./2( .=:(

;9/787g2(/52(12=1;3I(17=J27=J(82/5;:(>;3(0;.3(/.7=/(.1(.(3.97:(:2/24/7;=(82/5;:(./(/52(

1C.HJ5/23C7=2(B!5.9/23(S)Dm(/;(14322=(>;3(H=T=;6=(0;.3(/.7=/(4;=/370H/7=J(4;89;H=:1(/;(

.4572<2(.(02//23(4;332C./7;=(02/622=(452874.C(.=:(12=1;3I(.=.CI121(B!5.9/23()DM(

S=(/52(7=/3;:H4/7;=(B!5.9/23(SD(.=(;<23<726(71(J7<2=(;>(/52(/5322(T=;6=(0;.3(/.7=/(

4;89;H=:1( .=:( /5273( 19247>74( 95I174;452874.C( .=:( /;G74;C;J74.C( 93;923/721M(

XH012ZH2=/CIE( /52(:7>>232=/(.C/23=./7<21( >;3(1H3J74.C(4.1/3./7;=(.32(32<7262:(67/57=(/52(

>3.826;3T(;>( /52( /52171M(]2G/E( /52( 452874.C( .=.CI121( .=:( 12=1;3I( .=.CI121E( /5./(5.<2(

022=( :2<2C;92:( 1;( >.3( >;3( /52( :2/24/7;=( ;>( 0;.3( /.7=/E( .32( :714H112:M( Q7=.CCIE( /52(

4;=429/H.C(>3.826;3T(.=:(/52(:7>>232=/(3212.345(95.121(B!5.9/23(SSL)D(;>(/571($5-(/52171(

:2.C7=J(67/5(/52(:2/24/7;=(;>(0;.3(/.7=/(.32(>;38HC./2:M(

%52( 12=17/7<7/I( ;>( /52( QC28715( 4;=1H8231( /;( .=:3;1/2=;=2(6.1( 7=<21/7J./2:( 7=(

!5.9/23(SSM(S=(J2=23.CE(FKM+_(;>(/52(/21/2:(4;=1H8231(93;<2:(12=17/7<2(/;(.=:3;1/2=;=2M(

S/(71(T=;6=(/5./(6;82=(.32(8;32(12=17/7<2(/5.=(8.=E(65745(6.1(4;=>7382:(7=(;H3(1/H:I?(

+OM+_(;>( /52(8.C2(9.3/7479.=/1(.1(4;89.32:(/;(K*M*_(;>( /52( >28.C2(9.3/7479.=/1(6232(

12=17/7<2( /;( .=:3;1/2=;=2M( #C1;( .=( 2>>24/( ;>( .J2(6.1( =;/742:E( ;C:23( 92;9C2(6232( C211(

12=17/7<2E(.=:(.=(2>>24/(;>(/21/(C;4./7;=M(%52(H=:23CI7=J(32.1;=(>;3(/52(:7>>232=421(7=(/21/(

C;4./7;=( 6.1( =;/( 2CH47:./2:( 1;( >.3( .=:( 71( .=( 7=/37JH7=J( .1924/( >;3( >H3/523( 3212.345M(

Q7=.CCIE(=;(2>>24/(;>(18;T7=J(5.07/1(6.1(=;/2:M((

S=(!5.9/23(SSS(/52(:2<2C;982=/(.=:(<.C7:./7;=(;>(.=(HC/3.L57J5(923>;38.=42(C7ZH7:(

453;8./;J3.95I(4;H9C2:(/;(57J5(321;CH/7;=(8.11(1924/3;82/3I(.=.CI171(/5./(2=.0C21(/52(

:2/24/7;=( ;>( /52( /5322( T=;6=( 0;.3( /.7=/( 4;89;H=:1( 178HC/.=2;H1CI( .=:( .CC;61( 9;1/L

.4ZH717/7;=(32L7=/233;J./7;=(;>(:./.(71(93212=/2:M(%571(.=.CI/74.C(93;42:H32(6.1(<.C7:./2:(

.44;3:7=J( /;( !;887117;=( -7324/7<2( @NN@PAK,P&!E( 321HC/7=J( 7=( C787/1( ;>( :2/24/7;=( .=:(

C787/1(;>(ZH.=/7>74./7;=(;>(321924/7<2CI(@MK(.=:(K(sJ(TJL*(>;3(/52(7=:;C74(4;89;H=:1(.=:(,(

.=:( *N( sJ( TJL*( >;3( .=:3;1/2=;=2M( %571( [L"$\!L"'LYX( 82/5;:( ;0/.7=2:( .=( ;<23.CC(

9324717;=( ;>( *AM@_( B32C./7<2( 1/.=:.3:( :2<7./7;=DM( U/523( 82/5;:( 923>;38.=42(

45.3.4/2371/741(7=4CH:7=J(C7=2.37/IE(324;<23IE(12C24/7<7/I(.=:(19247>747/I(.32(.C1;(93212=/2:(

Page 181: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

X[YY#'j(

(

(

(

*,*(

7=:7<7:H.CCI(>;3(2.45(/.3J2/2:(4;89;H=:(.=:(6232(62CC(67/57=(/52(923>;38.=42(437/237.(

93;9;12:(7=(!-(@NN@PAK,P&!M(

R24.H12(=;(.H/;8./2:(:2/24/7;=(1I1/28(>;3(0;.3(/.7=/( 71(.<.7C.0C2(./( /52(/782E(

0;.3(/.7=/( 71(4H332=/CI(.112112:(./(/52(1C.HJ5/23C7=2(0I(12=1;3I(.=.CI121M( S=(!5.9/23(S)E(

>;H3(52./7=J(82/5;:1(6232(4;89.32:(.=:(:7>>232=/(9.3.82/231(;>(/52(17=J27=J(82/5;:(

6232(2<.CH./2:M(#CC(>;H3(/21/2:(82/5;:1(93;<2:(1H7/.0C2(>;3(:2/24/7=J(0;.3(/.7=/(0H/(7=(

/2381( ;>( 93.4/74.C7/IE( /52( 9I3;92=( :719C.I2:( 12<23.C( .:<.=/.J21M( V52=( H17=J( /52(

17=J27=J(82/5;:E( /52( 7=/2=17/I( 14;32(8.I( 02( 7=>CH2=42:(0I( 4;=/.87=./7;=( 7=( 4.12( /52(

1;C:237=J(73;=(71(=;/(4C2.=2:(;=(.(32JHC.3(0.171(;3(0I(17=J27=J(/52(>./(/6742(./(/52(1.82(

19;/M(Y;32;<23E( .=( 2>>24/( ;>( 5.07/H./7;=(6.1(;0123<2:E( 7=( /782( B.>/23( +N( 1.89C21( /52(

7=/2=17/I( 14;32( 71( 57J523D( .=:( 2<23I( /782( .>/23( .( 1.89C2( 9;17/7<2( >;3( 0;.3( /.7=/( 6.1(

:2/24/2:E( /52( 1.89C2( :7324/CI( .>/23( :719C.I2:( .( C;623( 7=/2=17/I( 14;32M( %;( 2G/3.9;C./2(

/5212(321HC/1(/;(.(1C.HJ5/235;H12(2=<73;=82=/E(>H3/523(3212.345(67CC(02(=24211.3IM(

S=(8;1/( 1/H:721E( ;=CI( /6;( 4;89;H=:1( .32( 4;=17:232:( /;( :2/2387=2( 0;.3( /.7=/E(

=.82CI(1T./;C2(.=:(.=:3;1/2=;=2M(";62<23E( /5212(/6;(4;89;H=:1(:;(=;/(4;89C2/2CI(

.44;H=/( >;3( /52( ;44H332=42( ;>( 0;.3( /.7=/( .1( :2/2387=2:( 0I( .( /3.7=2:( 12=1;3I( 9.=2CM(

!;2>>7472=/1(;>(4;332C./7;=(02/622=(.=:3;1/2=;=2( C2<2C1( 7=( >./(.=:(0;.3( /.7=/( 7=/2=17/I(

.112112:(0I(/3.7=2:(9.=2C1(3.=J2:(>3;8(NMF*(/;(NM,AE(.=:(>;3(1T./;C2(>3;8(NM@N(/;(NMK+M(

X2<23.C( >.4/;31( 8.I( 2G9C.7=( /5212( 3./523( C;6( 4;332C./7;=1( 329;3/2:( 1;( >.3?( <.37./7;=(

67/57=( 452874.C( .=:( 12=1;3I( .=.CI121( 0H/( .C1;( ;/523E( H=T=;6=( 4;89;H=:1E( /5./(

4;=/370H/2( /;( 0;.3( /.7=/M( %5232>;32E( 45.9/23( )( >;4H12:( ;=( /52( 14322=7=J( >;3( H=T=;6=(

4;89;H=:1(9;1170CI(4;=/370H/7=J(/;(0;.3(/.7=/M(S=(/571(45.9/23(4;332C./7;=1(;>(NMFNE(NF@(

.=:(NMK*(>;3(321924/7<2CI(7=:;C2E(1T./;C2(.=:(.=:3;1/2=;=2(6232(329;3/2:E(02/622=(/52(

452874.C( .=:( 12=1;3I( .=.CI121M( Q731/CIE( >;3( /52( 14322=7=J( ;>( H=T=;6=( 4;89;H=:1E( 32L

7=/23932/./7;=( ;>( 932<7;H1CI( 3H=( 1.89C21( 5.992=2:( 67/5( 4;89;H=:1( 7:2=/7>72:( >3;8(

C7/23./H32( .=:( :./.( ;0/.7=2:( >3;8( W!L1=7>>( .=.CI171M( V7/5( /571( .993;.45E( @( =26(

4;89;H=:1(4;HC:(02(4;332C./2:( /;( /52(0;.3( /.7=/(;:;H3( BFE*AL.=:3;1/.:72=L+L;=2(.=:(

71;<.C2374( .47:DM( -2197/2( /52( >7=:7=JE( /5./( /5212( 4;89;H=:1( :7:( =;/( 7=432.12( /52(

4;332C./7;=(02/622=(12=1;3I(.=:(452874.C(.=.CI171E(/5273(7=/23.4/7;=(67/5(/52(;/523(0;.3(

/.7=/( 4;=1/7/H2=/1( 8.I( 02( ;>( 789;3/.=42( /;( /52( J2=23.C( 923429/7;=( ;>( 0;.3( /.7=/M(

Page 182: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

X[YY#'j(

(

(

*,@(

X24;=:CIE(>;3(/52(14322=7=J(;>(H=T=;6=(4;89;H=:1E(.(:7>>232=/7.C(.=.CI171(6.1(H12:(;=(

.(9.3/(;>(/52(:./.12/(/;(:2/24/(4;89;H=:1(/5./(8.I(4;=/370H/2(/;(0;.3(/.7=/M(V7/5(/571(

.993;.45E(.=;/523(F(4;89;H=:1(6232(7:2=/7>72:(/5./(4;HC:(02(4;332C./2:(/;(0;.3(/.7=/M(

S=( /571( 4.12( /52( 021/( 8;:2C( /;( 2G9C.7=( /52( 12=1;3I( 14;32( 6.1( J7<2=( 0I( 1T./;C2E( AL

82/5;GI7=:;C2(.=:(.(=26CI(>;H=:(H=7:2=/7>72:(4;89;H=:M(

S=( !5.9/23( )S( /52( J2=23.C( :714H117;=( .=:( >H/H32( 3212.345( 9231924/7<21( ;>( /571(

:;4/;3.C(6;3T(6232(3293212=/2:M(S=(15;3/E(/571(:;4/;3.C(/52171(:21437021(.(=26([L"$\!L

"'LYX(82/5;:(.=:(.=(;9/787g2:(17=J27=J(82/5;:(>;3(/52(.=.CI171(;>(0;.3(/.7=/E(65745(

6232( 0;/5( <.C7:./2:( 321HC/7=J( 7=( 8;32( 32C7.0C2( 321HC/1E( 7=432.17=J( /52( 4;332C./7;=1(

02/622=(0;/5(82/5;:1M(S/(6.1(15;6=(/5./(1T./;C2(.=:(.=:3;1/2=;=2(2G9C.7=(A,_(;>(/52(

12=1;3I( 14;32( ;0/.7=2:( 0I( 2G923/1( ;=( .( :./.12/( ;>( O+( .:79;12( 1.89C21( .=:( /5./( =26(

4;89;H=:1(8.I(.C1;(4;=/370H/2(/;(12=1;3I(14;32(.1(J7<2=(0I(2G923/1M(";62<23(.(C.3J23(

:./.12/( 71( .:<712:( /;( 4;=>738( /5212( 321HC/1( .=:( /;( 7=<21/7J./2( ;=( .( 1/./71/74.C( 32C7.0C2(

8.==23( .=I( 9;1170C2( 7=/23.4/7;=1( 02/622=( /52( 4;89;H=:1M( Q7=.CCIE( >H3/523( 3212.345(

8H1/( 02( /.3J2/2:( ./( 93;:H47=J(82./( .=:(82./( 93;:H4/1(67/5( 0;.3( /.7=/( C2<2C1( 02C;6(

.:2ZH./2(12=1;3I(923429/7;=(/53215;C:1(/;(.<;7:(.=(24;=;874.C(C;11(652=(2=/732(8.C21(

.32(32.32:M+

(

Page 183: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

X#Y&])#%%S]W(

(

(

*,+(

C-J<@=-;;>@?+

(

R232=J2H3(71(22=(;=..=J2=.82(J2H3(:72(<37hJ21/2C:(6;3:/(6.==223(<C221(;>(<2/(

<.=( 0232=( B=72/LJ24.1/3223:2( 8.==2C7hT2( <.3T2=1D( 6;3:/( <236.38:M( -2( 02C.=J37hT1/2(

4;89;=2=/2=(:72(<23.=/6;;3:2C7hT(g7h=(<;;3(:2g2(J2H3(g7h=(!"#$%&(2=(#'()%!$*'%'(2=(7=(

87=:232(8./2(+'(%&M(%;/(<;;3(T;3/(623:2=(07JJ2=(4573H3J7145(J24.1/3223:(;8(0232=J2H3(

/2( <2387h:2=M( -2g2( 93;42:H32( 6;3:/( .C1( /2( 97h=C7hT( 02145;H6:E( ..=J2g72=( g2( g;=:23(

<23:;<7=J(;>(97h=021/37h:7=J(6;3:/(H7/J2<;23:M(#C1(.=/6;;3:(;9(:2(/;2=282=:2(1;47.C2(

:3HT(52002=(:2(8221/2(145.T2C1(7=(:2(<.3T2=1L(2=(<C2217=:H1/372(<37h67CC7J(:2(<23TC.37=J(

;=:23/2T2=:( ;8( /2J2=( H7/23C7hT( *( h.=H.37( @N*O(82/( 4573H3J71452( 4.1/3./72( /2( 1/;992=M(

&2=( 8;J2C7hT( .C/23=./72>( ;9( C.=J2( /2387h=( 71( :2( .>821/7=J( <.=( =72/LJ24.1/3223:2(

8.==2C7hT2( 07JJ2=M( -2( 02C.=J37hT1/2( <;;36..3:2( ;8(:7/( /2( 02327T2=E( 71( :2( 32:H4/72( ;>(

2C787=./72(<.=(0232=J2H3(82/(025HC9(<.=(8.=.J282=/1/3./2J72t=M(U8:./(/;/(;9(52:2=(

0232=J2H3( =72/( J2tC787=223:( T.=(6;3:2=( 71( :2( :2/24/72( <.=( T.3T.112=(82/( 0232=J2H3(

..=( :2( 1C.45/C7h=( <.=( 52/( 5;;J1/2( 02C.=JM( -2g2( T.3T.112=( 82/( 0232=J2H3( 8;2/2=(

<23623T/(TH==2=(6;3:2=(/;/(<C221(2=(<C22193;:H4/2=(g;=:23(=2J./72<2(923429/72(<;;3(

:2(4;=1H82=/M((

X7=:1(:2(1/.3/(<.=(52/(;=:23g;2T(=..3(0232=J2H3(6;3:/(23(<23;=:231/2C:(:./(:2(

=2J./72<2(789.4/(<.=(0232=J2H3(07h(<C22193;:H4/2=(87=:23(J3;;/(71(07h(<231(<C221E(2=(:7/(

;8:./( :2( <23623T7=J( ;9( <231457CC2=:2( 8.=7232=( /;/( 22=( 32:H4/72( <.=( :2( J2H3( T.=(

C27:2=E( 82/( 22=( :.C7=J( <.=( :2( =2J./72<2( 923429/72( /;/( J2<;CJM( S=( :2( 8221/2(

4;=1H82=/2=1/H:721( 623:( :2( J2<;2C7J527:( <;;3( #'()%!$*'%'( 245/23( =72/( ;=:23g;45/M(

#.=J2g72=( :2( J2<;2C7J527:( <;;3( #'()%!$*'%'( /H112=( C.=:2=( <231457C/E( 6;3:/( 23(

..=J23.:2=(;8(:2g2( 7=( 2CT( C.=:(.>g;=:23C7hT( /2( 2<.CH232=M(U8( /2( <2387h:2=(:./( <C221(

82/(;=..=<..3:0..3(5;J2(0232=J2H3(:2(8.3T/(02327T/(2=(g;(C27:/(/;/(=2J./72<2(32.4/721(

<.=(:2(4;=1H82=/E(8;2/(0232=J2H3(..=(:2(1C.45/C7h=(J2:2/24/223:(TH==2=(6;3:2=M(&2=(

J3;;/( ..=/.C( 452871452( 2=( 12=1;371452( 82/5;:21( g7h=( <;;35.=:2=( ;8( :2(

0232=J2H34;89;=2=/2=( /2( :2/24/232=( 7=( <2/M( -2(8221/2( <.=( :2g2(82/5;:21(623:2=(

245/23( ;=<;C:;2=:2( J2<.C7:223:E(6./( 22=( <23TC.37=J( g;H( TH==2=( 072:2=( <;;3( :2( C.J2(

Page 184: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

X#Y&])#%%S]W(

(

(

*,F(

4;332C./721(:72(/;/(;9(52:2=(623:2=(6..3J2=;82=(/H112=(:2(452871452(2=(12=1;371452(

.=.CI121M( &2=( .=:232( 8;J2C7hT2( <23TC.37=J( 71( :2( ..=62g7J527:( <.=( 07hT;82=:2(

0232=J2H34;89;=2=/2=( 2=( :2( 7=/23.4/72( /H112=( :2g2( 4;89;=2=/2=M( -2( 19247>72T2(

:;2C1/2CC7=J2=( <.=( :7/( 93;2>14537>/( 021/..=( 23( :.=( ;;T( 7=( ;8?( :2( J2<;2C7J527:( <;;3(

0232=J2H3( /2( 029.C2=( 07h( :2( )C..812( 4;=1H82=/( B";;>:1/HT( SSDm( 22=( 452871452(

.=.CI1282/5;:2( /2(;=/67TT2C2=(2=(<.C7:232=(<;;3(:2(J2C7hT/7h:7J2(:2/24/72(<.=(:2(:372(

02T2=:2( 0232=J2H34;89;=2=/2=?( +'(%&E( !"#$%&( 2=( #'()%!$*'%'( B";;>:1/HT( SSSDm( 22=(

:729J..=:2(2<.CH./72(<.=(:2(12=1;371452(1453;2782/5;:2(H7/(/2(<;232=E(/;29.10..3(.C1(

1=2CC2( :2/24/7282/5;:2( ..=( :2( 1C.45/C7h=( B";;>:1/HT( S)Dm( /2( g;2T2=( =..3( ;=02T2=:2(

0232=J2H34;89;=2=/2=(82/(.C1(27=::;2C(22=(02/232(4;332C./72( /2(02T;82=(/H112=(:2(

452871452(2=(:2(12=1;371452(.=.CI1282/5;:21(B";;>:1/HT()DM(

S=(:2( 7=C27:7=J( B";;>:1/HT( SD(6;3:/(22=(;<23g745/(J2J2<2=(<.=(:2(:372(02T2=:2(

0232=J2H34;89;=2=/2=( 2=( 5H=( >I174;L452871452( 2=( /;G74;C;J71452( 27J2=145.992=M(

-..3=..1/(6;3:2=(:2(<231457CC2=:2(.C/23=./72<2=(<;;3(4573H3J71452(4.1/3./72(07==2=(:2(

:;2C1/2CC7=J2=( <.=( :7/( 623T( J2T.:23:M( )23<;CJ2=1( 6;3:2=( :2( 452871452( 2=( :2(

12=1;371452( .=.CI121E( :72( /;/( ;9( 52:2=( ;=/67TT2C:( 623:2=( <;;3( :2( :2/24/72( <.=(

0232=J2H3E( 02193;T2=M( %2=1C;//2( 6;3:2=( 52/( 4;=429/H22C( T.:23( 2=( :2( <231457CC2=:2(

;=:23g;2T11/.:7.( B";;>:1/HT( SSL)D( <.=( :2g2( :;4/;3../1/52171( 7=( <230.=:(82/( :2/24/72(

<.=(0232=J2H3(J2>;38HC223:M(

-2(J2<;2C7J527:(<.=(:2()C..812(4;=1H82=/(<;;3(#'()%!$*'%'(623:(;=:23g;45/(

7=(";;>:1/HT( SSM( S=(52/(.CJ2822=(6;3:2=(FKM+_(<.=(:2(J2/21/2( 4;=1H82=/2=(J2<;2C7J(

02<;=:2=(<;;3(#'()%!$*'%'M(#CJ2822=( 71(02T2=:(:./(<3;H62=(8223(J2<;2C7J(g7h=(:.=(

8.==2=E(6./( 7=(;=g2(1/H:72(02<21/7J:(623:?(+OM+_(<.=(:2(8.==2=(7=(<23J2C7hT7=J(82/(

K*E*_( <.=( :2( <3;H62=M( U;T( 623:( 22=( C22>/7h:1J20;=:2=( 2>>24/( <.1/J21/2C:?( ;H:232(

9231;=2=( 0C7hT2=( 87=:23( J2<;2C7JM( U;T( =..3J2C.=J( :2( 32J7;( 623:( 22=( <231457C(

6..3J2=;82=M( &45/23E( <2387/1( 23( J22=( <23:232( 7=>;38./72( ;<23( :2( ;=:23g;45/2(

7=:7<7:H2=( <23g.82C:( 623:E( T;=( :2( ;=:23C7JJ2=:2( ;;3g..T( <.=( :7/( >2=;822=( =72/(

<.1/J21/2C:( 6;3:2=M( %2=1C;//2( 623:( 23( J22=( <231457C( ( /H112=( 3;T231( ;>( =72/L3;T231(

<.1/J21/2C:M(

Page 185: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

X#Y&])#%%S]W(

(

(

*,K(

S=( ";;>:1/HT( SSS( 6;3:/( :2( ;=/67TT2C7=J( 2=( <.C7:./72( J23.99;3/223:( <.=( 22=(

HC/3.923>;38.=/2( 5;J2:3HTL<C;271/;>453;8./;J3.>72( B["$\!DE( J2T;992C:( ..=( 5;J2(

321;CH/72(8.11.1924/3;82/372( B"'LYXD( .=.CI1282/5;:2E( :72( :2(:2/24/72( 32.C71223/( <.=(

:2( :372( 02T2=:2( 0232=J2H34;89;=2=/2=( 2=( /;2C../( ;8( L( 9;1/L.4ZH717/72( L( :2( :./.(

;9=72H6( 7=( <3..J( /2( 1/2CC2=M( -2g2( .=.CI/71452( 93;42:H32( 623:( J2<.C7:223:( 7=(

;<2322=1/2887=J(82/( :2( u!;887117;=( -7324/7<2( @NN@PAK,P&!vE(82/( .C1( 321HC/../( 22=(

:2/24/72C7872/( 2=( T6.=/7>74./72C7872/( <.=( 321924/72<2C7hT( @MK( 2=( K( wJ( TJ( L*( <;;3( :2(

+'(%&+!,-*. ,%/0%'*'$*'( 2=( ,( 2=( *N( wJ( TJ( L*( <;;3( #'()%!$*'%'M( -2g2( [L"$\!L"'LYX(

82/5;:2( 321HC/223:2( 7=( 22=( JC;0.C2( =.H6T2H37J527:( <.=( *AM@_( B32C./72<2(

1/.=:..3::2<7./72DM( #=:232( 9321/./72T.3.T/2371/72T2=( <.=( :2( 82/5;:2( 6..3;=:23(

C7=2.37/27/E(12C24/7<7/27/E(19247>747/27/(2=(/23HJ<7=:7=J(6;3:2=(<;;3(2CT(<.=(:2(0214532<2=(

4;89;=2=/2=( ;;T( 7=:7<7:H22C( J23.99;3/223:( 2=( <.CC2=( 07==2=( :2(

9321/./72T.3.T/2371/72T2=(<;;3J21/2C:(7=(!-(@NN@PAK,P&!M(

)2387/1( 23( J22=( J2.H/;8./71223:( 1I1/228( <;;35.=:2=( 71( ;8( 0232=J2H3( /2(

:2/24/232=E(6;3:/(:2g2( /;/(;9(52:2=(..=(:2(1C.45/C7h=(029..C:(2=(:7/(82/(025HC9(<.=(

22=(12=1;371452(.=.CI12M(S=(";;>:1/HT(S)(6;3:2=(<723(<236.387=J182/5;:21(<23J2C2T2=(

2=(<231457CC2=:2(9.3.82/231(<.=(:2(1453;2782/5;:2(J2t<.CH223:M(#CC2(<723(:2(82/5;:21(

0C7hT2=( J21457T/( <;;3( 0232=J2H3:2/24/72(8..3( <.=H7/( 22=( 93.T/7145( 1/.=:9H=/( T2=/( :2(

9I3;92=( 8223:232( <;;3:2C2=M( ( V.==223( :2( 1453;2782/5;:2( J203H7T/( 6;3:/E( T.=( :2(

7=/2=17/27/(<.=(:2(14;32(02x=<C;2:(6;3:2=(:;;3(4;=/.87=./72(6.==223(07h<;;3022C:(:2(

1;C:2230;H/(=72/(<;C:;2=:2(J2327=7J:(623:(;>(6.==223(52/(<2/( /6228..C(;9(:2g2C>:2(

9C../1( <231453;27:(623:M(U;T(623:(22=(J262==7=J12>>24/( <.1/J21/2C:E( 2=23g7h:1( 7=( /7h:(

B=.(+N(1/.C2=(71(:2(7=/2=17/27/114;32(5;J23D(2=(.=:23g7h:1(;=87::2CC7hT(=.(22=(1/..C(82/(

0232=J2H3( B52/( 1/..C( :./( :..3;9( <;CJ/( T37hJ/( 22=( C.J232( 14;32DM(U8(:2g2( 321HC/./2=( /2(

2G/3.9;C232=(=..3(22=(1C.45/5H71;8J2<7=J(71(<23:23(;=:23g;2T(=;;:g.T2C7hTM(

R7h(:2(8221/2(1/H:721(6;3:2=(8221/.C(1C245/1(/622(4;89;=2=/2=(;=:23g;45/(/23(

029.C7=J(<.=(0232=J2H3E(=.82C7hT(!"#$%&(2=(#'()%!$*'%'M(-2g2(/622(4;89;=2=/2=(g7h=(

=;45/.=1( =72/( <;CC2:7J( <23.=/6;;3:2C7hT( <;;3( 52/( <;;3T;82=( <.=( 0232=J2H3E( g;.C1(

<.1/J21/2C:( :;;3( 22=( 12=1;37145( 9.=2CM( !;332C./724;t>>747t=/2=( /H112=( 52/(

#'()%!$*'%'J25.C/2( 7=( <2/( 2=( :2( 7=/2=17/27/( <.=( 0232=J2H3( L( J2145./( :;;3( J2/3.7=:2(

Page 186: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

X#Y&])#%%S]W(

(

(

*,A(

9.=2C1( L( <.37223:2=( /H112=( NMF*( 2=( NM,A( 2=( <;;3( !"#$%&( /H112=( NM@N( 2=( NMK+M(

)231457CC2=:2(>.4/;32=(TH==2=(:2g2(223:23(C.J2(4;332C./72(<23TC.32=E(6..3;=:23(<.37./72(

07==2=( :2( 452871452( 2=( 12=1;37tC2( .=.CI121(8..3( ;;T( :2( 02/3;TT2=527:( <.=( .=:232E(

;=02T2=:2(4;89;=2=/2=(:72(8;J2C7hT(07h:3.J2=(/;/(0232=J2H3M(S=(5;;>:1/HT()(6;3:/(:2(

5I9;/5212(:./(;;T(;=02T2=:2(4;89;=2=/2=(02/3;TT2=(g7h=E(;=:23g;45/M("723(623:(22=(

4;332C./72( J2<;=:2=( <.=( NMFNE( NMF@( 2=( NMK*( <;;3( 321924/72<2C7hT( +'(%&E( !"#$%&( 2=(

#'()%!$*'%'( /H112=( :2( 12=1;371452( 14;32E( 029..C:( :;;3( 2G923/2=( 2=( :2( 452871452(

.=.CI12M(-..3=..1/(623:(23(J23745/(J2g;45/(=..3(*F( 4;89;=2=/2=E(:72( /23HJJ2<;=:2=(

623:2=(7=(:2(C7/23./HH3(2=(:;;3(]SiU(;=:23g;2TM().=(:2(*F(4;89;=2=/2=(TH==2=(23(@(

4;89;=2=/2=( J232C./223:( 6;3:2=( ..=( 0232=J2H3( BFE*AL.=:3;1/.:72=L+L;=( 2=(

71;<.C237..=gHH3DM( -21;=:.=T1( <235;J2=( :2g2( 4;89;=2=/2=( 52/( 92342=/.J2( <.=( :2(

12=1;371452(14;32(=72/E(:(322:1(<23TC..3:(6;3:/(:;;3(!"#$%&(2=(#'()%!$*'%'M()23<;CJ2=1(

623:(23(;9(22=(:22C(<.=(:2(:./.12/(n(<7.(:7>>232=/7.C(.=.CI12(L(22=(;=J23745/2(14322=7=J(

H7/J2<;23:M("72307h(623:2=(<723(2G/3.(4;89;=2=/2=(82/(0232=J2H3(J232C./223:M(R7h(:2g2(

:./.12/( 6;3:/( :2( 12=1;371452( 14;32( 52/( 021/( <23TC..3:( :;;3( !"#$%&E( 1.82=( 82/( 12

/*$-%34+'(%&.*'.7;=(*+@OM(

S=( ";;>:1/HT( )S( 6;3:2=( :2( .CJ282=2( :714H1172( 2=( :2( 8;J2C7hT2( /;2T;81/7J2(

;=:23g;2T19231924/72<2=(<;;3J21/2C:M(%7h:2=1(:2g2(:;4/;3../1/52171(623:(22=([L"$\!L

"'LYX(82/5;:2(J2<.C7:223:(2=(:2(1453;2782/5;:2(<23>7h=:E(6./(7=(8223(02/3;H60.32(

321HC/./2=( 2=( 22=( 02/232( 4;332C./72( /H112=( 027:2( 82/5;:21( 321HC/223:2M( &3( 6;3:/(

..=J2/;;=:(:./(!"#$%&(2=(#'()%!$*'%'(A,_(<.=(:2(12=1;371452(14;32(<23TC.32=( 7=(22=(

:./.12/( <.=( O+( 1/.C2=M( -..3=..1/( 6;3:/( KO_( <.=( :2( 12=1;371452( 14;32( 029..C:( :;;3(

!"#$%&( 2=( /622( =72H6( J2<;=:2=( 7;=2=E( =;J( 22=( ;=J2x:2=/7>74223:2( 7;=( 2=( AL

82/5;GI7=:;CE( 7=( 9C../1( <.=( K+_( :;;3( !"#$%&( 2=(#'()%!$*'%'E( ;9( 22=( :./.12/( <.=( +N(

1/.C2=M( -7/( /;;=/( ..=( :./( .=:232( 4;89;=2=/2=( 7=:23:..:( 22=( 3;C( TH==2=( 192C2=( 7=(

0232=J2H3M()23:23(;=:23g;2T( 71( 245/23(=;;:g.T2C7hT(;8(:2g2( 321HC/./2=( /2(02<21/7J2=(

2=(2<2=/H2C2(7=/23.4/721(/H112=(:2(4;89;=2=/2=(/2(021/H:232=M(-..3=..1/(8;2/(<23:23(

;=:23g;2T(g745(;;T(3745/2=(;9(:2(93;:H4/72(<.=(<C221(2=(<C22193;:H4/2=(82/(0232=J2H3E(

g;=:23(=2J./72<2(923429/72(<.=62J2(:2(4;=1H82=/M((

Page 187: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

-#]^VUU'-(

(

(

(*,,(

W>X+Y<@+<<@C+E:+6<>C+?<Z<<C;"[+

(

ST(02=(;9(3271(<23/3;TT2=(g;=:23(245/(/2(62/2=(6..3522=M(UTE( 7T(6.1(.C(;9(3271(

J26221/(2=( 7T(5.:(;;T(.C(22=(1/HTh2(<.=(:2(6232C:(J2g72=M(Y..3(/;45E(:7/(6.1(.=:231M(

);;3(:2g2(3271(8;21/( 7T(245/(J3;/2(<;;302327:7=J2=(/32>>2=(2=(<;;3.C?(:2( hH71/2(J7:12=(

<7=:2=E(02/3;H60..3(2=(23<.32=M();;3(:2g2(3271(5.:( 7T(n(;=:.=T1(52/( >27/(:./(52/(22=(

3.g2=:( 0;272=:( 93;J3.88.( 02C;;>:2( /2( 6;3:2=( 2=( 7T( ;=/g2//2=:( <22C( 19.==2=:2(

.<;=/H32=(g;H(J..=(02C2<2=(L(021/(62C(14537T(<;;3(6./(T;82=(g;HM(

(

S=( 129/28023( @NNO( 021C;;/( 7T( 82( 7=( /2( 14537h<2=( <;;3( 22=( <723( h..3( :H32=:2(

.<;=/HH3C7hT2(/32T/;45/(<7.(:2(;3J.=71./72(SV%M(%;2=(7T(7=(-2428023(@NNO(;9(22=(.=:232(

3271(6.1(L(87h=(5H62C7hT13271(=;/.(02=2(L(T322J(7T(;=:23(22=(1/3.C2=:2(g;=(;9(52/(1/3.=:(

<.=(Y7.87(/2(5;32=(:./( 7T(J212C24/223:(6.1(<;;3(:2(/379(82/( SV%M([7/23..3:(193;=J( 7T(

22=( J./( 7=( :2( CH45/(8..3( /23g2C>:23/7h:( 02J;=(87h=( 5.3/( ;;T(6./( 1=2CC23( /2( 1C..=M( "2/(

<23/32T(6.1(788231(.C(<;;3g72=(<;;3(:2(8..=:(=.:72=E(=.82C7hT(h.=H.37(@NNa(MMM(ST(520(

22=1(:729(7=J2.:28:(2=(520(;9=72H6(87h=(T;>>231(J29.T/M(

(

]./HH3C7hT(T3H71/2=(<2C2=(87h=(9.:(J2:H32=:2(:2g2(/;45/E(T322J(7T(<22C(5HC9C7h=2=(

<;;3(.:<721E(T;=(7T(0;J2=(;9(3271<235.C2=(<.=(.=:232(.<;=/H37231(2=(T;=(7T(J2:H32=:2(

2=T2C2( >2CC2(;=62:231(145H7C2=(07h(<2C2=(<.=( hHCC72M( ST(02=( hHCC72(:..3(;93245/(:.=T0..3(

<;;3(2=(520(5723..=(:.=(;;T(87h=(025;H:2=(/5H71T;81/(/2(:.=T2=M(

(

S=(52/(07hg;=:23(67C(7T(<;CJ2=:2(y3271J2=;/2=z(:.=T2=(?(

(

&2=( g223( 19247.C2(:.=T(J../(H7/(=..3(:2(8.=(:72(52/(8;J2C7hT(8..T/2(;8(87h=(

6232C:3271(..=(/2(<.=J2=?($3;>M(-2(R3.0.=:23M(U;T(g;=:23(:2(C;T.C2(:.J2C7hT12(3271J7:1(

\I==(B;=:23/H112=($3;>M().=5.24T2D(5.:(:2g2(871172(=72/(TH==2=(1C.J2=M(R2:.=T/(<;;3(

52/( H7/g2//2=( <.=( :2( T;231E( 52/( C2JJ2=( <.=( 4;=/.4/2=( 82/( H7/522812( 1/.882=E( 52/(

J2:HC:7J2( ;9C27:2=( <.=( ;=:23J2/2T2=:2( 7=( .CC23C27( ;<23C2<7=J1/245=72T2=E( 52/( C232=(

Page 188: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

-#]^VUU'-(

(

(

(*,O(

:;1232=(<.=(T3.45/(2=(93;<7.=:(2=(52/(..=032=J2=(<.=(B3245/<..3:7J2D(4;3324/721M(U;T(

:2(J7:12=(Q3.=T(%(2=(Q3.=T()--( ?(02:.=T/( <;;3(52/(07h1/H32=(6..3(=;:7JM( %2<2=1(22=(

62CJ2822=:2( 02:.=T7=J( ..=( :2( 4;88711.37112=( :72( 87h=( :;4/;3../( ..=( 22=( J3;=:7J(

=.g745/(52002=(;=:236;392=M(

#.=J2g72=( 22=( J3;;/( :22C( <.=( :2( 3271( :;;3J7=J( ;9( ;=02T2=:( 45287145( 2=(

12=1;37145( J2072:E( J../( 22=( J3;/2( :.=T( H7/( =..3( :2( =.<7J./;31( <.=( :72=1/( ?( \H472E(

Y.3/7=2E( -73TE( `;T2E( S=2( 2=( Y72T2E( <;;3( 52/( 67hg2=( ;9( :2( 4;3324/2( 2=( ;;T( 87=:23(

4;3324/2( C.0;3./;37H8T;2312=M( -.=Tg7h( 5H=( 7=1/3H4/721( 02=( 7T( C.=J1522=( J2<..3C7hT2(

62J2=(J23271:(2=(520(7T(452871452(.>J3;=:2=(62/2=(/2(87h:2=M(U;T(:2(=.<7J./;31(<.=(

52/(S\)UE(7=(52/(07hg;=:23(Y.37hT2(L(y52/(71(:.=(;;T(0232=J2H3(6..3;9(h2(623T/z(n(:.=T(

7T(<;;3(:2(<2C2(5HC9(2=(:2(0;272=:2(32>C24/72L(2=(:714H11728;82=/2=M(

-;;3522=(:2( 3271(6.32=(23( ;9( <231457CC2=:2( /7h:1/7992=(9231;=2=(:72( 22=( 27=:(

82/(87h(8223271:2=M(Y72T2E(^.3;C72=E(YI37.8(2=(';C.=:(.C1(2G923/(<;;3(0232=J2H3(2=(

:2({:.J/379h21(=..3(52/(1C.45/5H71{E(1;81(<;;3(:.J(2=(:.H6M(%.=/2(Y.3/7=2(2=(8.8.(.C1(

{457=212(<37h67CC7J23({<;;3(87h=(0232=J2H393;2>E(8.8.(<;;3(:2(5HC9(07h(52/(<231=7h:2=(2=(

<239.TT2=( <.=( :2( 1/.C2=( <;;3( :2( 93;2<2=( 7=( :2( .>J2C;92=( h.32=M( '20244.( 2=( \;H32=1(

B)7;=D( <;;3( :2( 5HC9( 7=( 52/( 1C.45/5H71E( 52/( H7/1;3/232=( 2=( 14;32=( <.=( 1/.C2=M( W223/( 2=(

^.3;C72=( B'78.D( <;;3( :2( 1/.C2=( <.=( 0.3J2=<2/( 2=( 123H8( 2=( :2( T2==718.T7=J(82/( 52/(

1C.45/5H71M( `;3=( 2=( X;9572( <;;3( :2( 5HC9( 7=( :2( ;=/67TT2C7=J( <.=( :2( 82/5;:2( 2=( 52/(

J2:HC:(<;;3(6.==223(7T(52/(g2C>(2<2=(=72/(8223(J;2:(671/M(X.3.5(<;;3(52/(52C92=(g;2T2=(

=..3( ;=02T2=:2( 4;89;=2=/2=( 82/( y%;GLS-zM( "2/( J.( hHCC72( .CC28..C( J;2:( ;9( hHCC72(

<23:232(3271|(

U9(87h=( 3271( :;;3T3H71/2( 87h=( 9.:( /2<2=1( :./( <.=( .=:232( .<;=/H37231( :72( 22=(

1;;3/J2C7hT2(3271(;=:23=.82=M(Y2/(`HC72()-RE(^C..1E(`HC72(^E(\72<2=()YE(]./5.C72E(W.0372CE(

\7212C;/(2=(#==2C22=(5.:(7T(22=(..=/.C(82/J2g2CC2=(:72(=2/(g;.C1(7T(J3..J(4.T2(2/2=(2=(

6..3<.=(1;887J2=(:.=(;;T(22=(T;;T0;2T(g7h=(02J;==2=E(y-H9h21(R.T0;2Tz(g2J(8..3M(

);;3( :2( =;:7J2( ;=/19.==7=J( J2:H32=:2( :2( 3271( 623:( J2g;3J:( :;;3( :2(

.=78./;32=( <.=( :72=1/?( :3( #==2C;21E( :3( Q3;2E(83( #3h.4( 2=( :3( i.//2( i62H3/5( <;;3( 52/(

..=032=J2=( <.=( J221/37hT2( 2=( :;31/C2112=:2( J;2:232=( 7=( 4;807=./72( 82/( :2(

;=/19.==2=:2( 2=( :2HJ::;2=:2( .4/7<7/27/2=( 2=( >7h=2( J21932TT2=M( ^./372=E( #3=2E( j.==E(

Page 189: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

-#]^VUU'-(

(

(

(*,a(

X78;=E(Y.:;E($72/(2=(\7=:.(<;;3( >7h=2(8;82=/2=(<.=(;=/19.==7=JM(W3;;/( C.6..7(Rb=b(

<;;3(57C.37/27/(2=(52/(J2g.82=C7hT(<23;30232=(<.=(03;;:h21(;<23(:2(87::.JM(-2(<.TJ3;29(

452871452( .=.CI12( <;;3( :2( ..=J2=.82( T;>>72L( 2=( CH=459.Hg21M( #.=( hHCC72( 2=( .CC2(

.=:232=(:72(7T(;=J2/67h>2C:(02=(<23J2/2=(?(22=(:7TT2(82347(|(

W2:H32=:2(:2g2(<723(h..3(:H32=:2(3271(J7=J(7T(32J2C8./7J(;<23(2=(6223(=..3(5H71(

;8(2<2=(;9(.:28(/2(T;82=M(R2:.=T/('7T(2=(R2.(<;;3(52/(J3;/2(J2:HC:(.C1(52/(2<2=(=72/(

8223(J7=J(2=(H7/23..3:(<;;3(:2(J2g2CC7J2(.923;v1(2=(2/2=/h21(2=(<;;3(:2(5HC9(07h(;=g2(

.=:232( 3271E( =.82C7hT( y:2( <230;H67=JzM(V;H/23E(]./5.C72E( `23;2=( 2=(#==2C721( <;;3( :2(

028;2:7J2=:2( 6;;3:2=( <;;3( :2( TC27=2( B145;;=DgH1( 2=( <;;3( :2( J2g2CC7J2( 2=(

;=/19.==2=:2( >.87C728;82=/2=M( X2==2E(YI3/52E( QC2H3E( `.4T(c( !5.3C72( ;8( 145.//7J( /2(

g7h=( 2=(82(87h=( J2:.45/2=( B.>( 2=( /;2( =;;:J2:6;=J2=D( /2( :;2=( <23g2//2=M(Y.8.( 2=(

9.9.E( <;;3( :2( ;=0214537h>2C7hT2( h.32=C.=J2( 1H99;3/( :72( 7T( <.=( hHCC72( 520( J2T32J2=M(

&7J2=C7hT(g7h=(:..3(J22=(6;;3:2=(<;;3M(

&2=(19247.C2(:.=T(J../(H7/(=..3(`HHC/h2(B:2(T./D((;8(g745(/2(C./2=(T=H>>2C2=(.C1(7T(

52/(=;:7J(5.:(B.C(6.1(52/(1;81(82/(/2J2=g7=DM(Y..3(<;;3.C(=..3(%5;8.1M("2/(02J7=(<.=(

:2g2(3271(<72C(1.82=(82/(52/(02J7=(<.=(;=1(5H62C7hTM(W22=(C72<232(8.=(T.=(7T(62=12=(2=(

22=(5;;>:1/HT(g;H(TH==2=(J214532<2=(6;3:2=(;<23(.CC21(6..3<;;3(7T(h2(8;2/(02:.=T2=M(

Y..3( 5723( .C<.1/( 22=( TC27=2( ;91;887=J( ?( 02:.=T/( <;;3( 52/( <2C2( J2:HC:E( 0.002C1E(

T=H>>2C1E(2/2=/h21E(}(U=:.=T1(:./(62(:2(C../1/2(h.32=(2=T2C2(/2J2=1C.J2=(1.82=(52002=(

8;2/2=(:;;31/..=E(TH==2=(62(=H(H7/T7hT2=(=..3(:2(J2g7=1H7/0327:7=J(5.C>(827M(`2(g.C(22=(

;=J2C;;>C7hT(C2HT2(9.9.(g7h=|(

(

-2(3271(27=:7J/(=72/(5723M(-2(32718743;02(522>/(82(/2(9.TT2=(2=(:2(.<;=/H3723(7=(

87h(71(6.TT23(J28..T/M(-2(3;H/2(71(=;J(=72/(H7/J21/7992C:(8..3(bb=(:7=J(1/../(62C(322:1(

<.1/( ?(87h=(<;CJ2=:2(3271(g.C(87h(;9=72H6(=..3(;=02T2=:2(5;37g;=/2=(032=J2=M(-.=Tg7h(

hHCC72(6;3:/(52/(;=J2/67h>2C:(62:23;8(22=(025;H:2=(3271(|(

(

X-6<@"+

(

Page 190: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

-#]^VUU'-(

(

(

(*ON(

+

( +

Page 191: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

![''S![\[Y()S%#&(

(

(

*O*(

#D66>#DADJ+=>;-<+

:08)$%H'*H+

(

].82?( R2T.23/(^.32=(

Y;07C2?( ~+@(F,K(FO(O@(F*(

&L8.7C?( ^.32=R2T.23/�J8.7CM4;8(

$C.42(;>(073/5?( W52=/(

-./2(;>(073/5?( #HJH1/(@F/5E(*aO+(

]./7;=.C7/I?( R2CJ7.=(

(

<1(&H4*$%+

(

*aaA(n(@NN@?( X472=421(L(Y./528./741(

( X7=/LR.<;("H8.=7;3.E(W52=/(

@NN@(n(@NN,?( Y.1/23(;>(R7;C;JIE(Q.4HC/I(;>(X472=421E(W52=/([=7<2317/I(

( Y.1/23(/52171?(#=./;874.C(1/H:I(;>(.=(2G/3282(>22:7=J(.99.3./H1(

7=(54'6'#$-7!.)%!$*&&#$7!8#,7!(BXI=J=./57:.2D(

@NNa(n(@N*@?( $5-( 7=( )2/237=.3I( Y2:747=2( ./( /52( \.0;3./;3I( ;>( !52874.C(

#=.CI171E( Q.4HC/I( ;>( )2/237=.3I( Y2:747=2E( W52=/( [=7<2317/IE(

-29.3/82=/(;>()2/237=.3I($H0C74("2.C/5(.=:(Q;;:(X.>2/I(

(

:8$70))*$%H'+H&4*L*4*0)+

(

@NN,(n(@NNO?( '212.345( 1472=/71/( ./( /52( S=1/7/H/2( >;3( #J374HC/H3.C( .=:( Q71523721(

'212.345E(#=78.C(X472=42(H=7/(

QU-L93;h24/?( y&.3CI( .=:( 32C7.0C2( :2/24/7;=( ;>( 0;.3( /.7=/( .=:( 7/1(

J2=2/74(932:719;17/7;=Mz(

Page 192: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

![''S![\[Y()S%#&(

(

(

*O@(

X29/28023(@NNa?( F/5( S=/23=./7;=.C( V;3T15;9( ;=( /52( #1121182=/( ;>( #=78.C(

V2C>.32( ./( Q.38( .=:( W3;H9( \2<2C( BV#Q\D?( U3J.=717=J(

!;887//22(BW52=/D(

@NNO(n(@NNa?(( Y2=/;3( ;>( /6;( 0.452C;3( 1/H:2=/1( .J3;( L( .=:( 07;/245=;C;JIE(

^#"U(X7=/L\72<2=E(W52=/(

#937C(@NNa?( ( %Xd().=/.J2(/3.7=7=J(4;H312(

U4/;023(@NNa?( X#'#Q(!;H312?(X45;;C(Q;3(#:<.=42:('217:H2(#=.CI171(7=(Q;;:(

BQ3.=42D(

@NNa(n(@N*N?( Y2=/;3( ;>( .( 8.1/23( 1/H:2=/( 7=( $5.38.42H/74.C( X472=421E(

W52=/([=7<2317/I(

@NNa(n(@N*N?( %H/;3(.1171/.=/(>;3(/52(93.4/74.C(/52;3I(.=:(2G234712(12117;=(;=(

/52( 9378.3I( 4;89;=2=/1( ;>( /52( 4;H312( uQ;;:( .=:(

&=<73;=82=/.C( !52871/3Iv( ./( /52( Q.4HC/I( ;>( )2/237=.3I(

Y2:747=2E(W52=/([=7<2317/I(

X29/28023(@NNa?( !;H312?(#:<.=42:(.4.:2874(2=JC715?(V37/7=J(1T7CC1(

@N*N(n(@N**?( Y2=/;3( ;>( .( 8.1/23( 1/H:2=/( 7=( $5.38.42H/74.C( X472=421E(

W52=/([=7<2317/I(

#HJH1/(@N**?( $5-(!;H312?(#:<.=42:(Y2./(X472=42(

@N**(n(@N*@?( Y2=/;3( ;>( .( 8.1/23( 1/H:2=/( 7=( $5.38.42H/74.C( X472=421E(

W52=/([=7<2317/I(

(

C&*0%4*7*&+:(K'*&H4*$%)+

+

:008+80L*0/01+H)+7*8)4+$8+&$PH(4I$8+

+

)2352I:2=( ^E( ];992( "E( ).=5.24T2( \E(V7CC2( ^E( ).=:2=( RH11452( `E( Y0.H084+ XE( %5.1( UE(

`.=112=( !'( .=:(-2( R3.0.=:23("Q( B@NNaDM( &G432/7;=( ;>( 2=:;J2=;H1( 0;C:7;=2( 7=(

5H8.=( H37=2?( 7=>CH2=42( ;>( 95I/;1/23;C( 4;=1H89/7;=M( `;H3=.C( ;>( X/23;7:(

R7;452871/3I(.=:(Y;C24HC.3(R7;C;JI(**,?(OL*F(

Page 193: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

![''S![\[Y()S%#&(

(

(

*O+(

-2(R3.0.=:23("QE().=:2=(RH11452( `E(V7CC2(^E(Y0.H084+ X( .=:().=5.24T2( \( B@N*NDM( %52(

1/./2(;>(/52(.3/(;>(3217:H2(.=.CI171?(/52(A/5()-'#(1I89;17H8(@N*NM(-3HJ(%21/7=J(

.=:(#=.CI1719.@?(F@*LF@+(

).=:2=(RH11452(`E().=5.24T2(\E(-242H=7=4T(jE()2352I:2=(^E(V7CC2(^E(Y0.H084+XE(\2(R7g24(

R( .=:( -2( R3.0.=:23( "Q( B@N*NDM( -2<2C;982=/( .=:( <.C7:./7;=( ;>( .=( HC/3.L57J5(

923>;38.=42( C7ZH7:( 453;8./;J3.95I( /.=:28( 8.11( 1924/3;82/3I( 82/5;:( >;3(

ZH.=/7>I7=J( /5I32;1/./1( 7=( H37=2( 67/5;H/( :237<./71./7;=M( `;H3=.C( ;>(

!53;8./;J3.95I(#E(*@*,?(F@OKLF@a+(

)2352I:2=(^E(];992("E(i;3=("E().=(S8823122C(QE().=:2=(RH11452(`E(V7CC2(^E(Y0.H084+XE(

`.=112=(!'E(-2(R3.0.=:23("Q(.=:().=5.24T2(\( B@N*NDM(&=:;J2=;H1(0;C:2=;=2L

>;38./7;=( 7=( 4.//C2?( #C/23=./7<2( 7=<23/203./2( ;3J.=7181( /;( 2CH47:./2( /52(

2=gI8./74(9./56.I(.=:(/52(9;/2=/7.C(3;C2(;>(2:70C2(>H=J7(;=(4.//C2v1(>22:M(`;H3=.C(

;>(X/23;7:(R7;452871/3I(.=:(Y;C24HC.3(R7;C;JI(**a?(*A*L*,N(

)2352I:2=(^E(];992("E().=:2=(RH11452(`E(V7CC2(^E(Y0.H084+XE(-2(R;2<23(\E().=(#4T23(`E(

`.=112=( !'E( -2( R3.0.=:23( "Q( .=:( ).=5.24T2( \( B@N*NDM( !5.3.4/2371./7;=( ;>(

1/23;7:1(7=(6;;:2=(43./21(;>(<2.C(4.C<21(0I(.442C23./2:(1;C<2=/(2G/3.4/7;=(B#X&ÄD(

.=:(HC/3.(57J5(923>;38.=42(C7ZH7:(453;8./;J3.95I(4;H9C2:(/;(/379C2(ZH.:3H9;C2(

8.11(1924/3;82/3I(B[L"$\!LdZdLYXLYXDM(#=.CI/74.C(.=:(R7;.=.CI/74.C(!52871/3I(

+a,?(+FKL+KK(

#CH6b( YE( Y7CC2/( XE( Y0.H084+ XJE( %HI//2=1( Q#YE( ).=5.24T2( \E( -2( X82/( X( .=:( -2(

R3.0.=:23( -\( B@N**DM( S=>CH2=42( ;>( 0322:( .=:( 1C.HJ5/23( 627J5/( ;=( 0;.3( /.7=/(

932<.C2=42(7=(2=/732(8.C2(97J1M(#=78.C(K?(*@O+L*@Oa(

#CH6b(YE(Y0.H084+ XJE( %HI//2=1( Q#YE().=5.24T2( \E(-2( X82/( XE(-2(R3.0.=:23("QE(-2(

R3.0.=:23( -\( .=:(Y7CC2/( X( B@N**DM( S=>CH2=42( ;>( 1;7C7=J( ;=( 0;.3( /.7=/( 7=( 0;.31M(

Y2./(X472=42(O,?(*,KL*,a(

Y0.H084+ XJE( %HI//2=1( Q#YE( -H45./2.H( \E( -2( R3.0.=:23( "QE( #CH6b( YE( Y7CC2/( XE(

).=:2=:37211452(Q(.=:().=5.24T2(\(B@N**DM(%52(12=17/7<7/I(;>(QC28715(47/7g2=1(/;(

.=:3;1/2=;=2?( 7=>CH2=42( ;>( J2=:23E( .J2E( C;4./7;=( .=:( 18;T7=J( 5.07/1M( Y2./(

X472=42(OO?(KFOLKK@(

Page 194: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

![''S![\[Y()S%#&(

(

(

*OF(

%HI//2=1(Q#YE().=5;=.4T23(QE(\.=J2=:3721(^E(#CH6b(YE(Y7CC2/(XE(Y0.H084+X(.=:()2302T2(

V( B@N**DM( &>>24/( ;>( 7=>;38./7;=( 93;<717;=7=J( ;=( .//7/H:2( /;6.3:( 1H3J74.C(

4.1/3./7;=( ;>( 8.C2( 97JC2/1( .=:( .C/23=./7<2( 1/3./2J721( >;3( .<;7:7=J( 0;.3( /.7=/M(

'212.345(7=()2/237=.3I(X472=42(a*?(+@,L++@(

).=:2=(RH11452( `E( ).=5.24T2( \E(-242H=7=4T( jE(V7CC2( ^E(Y0.H084+ XE( \2( R7g24( R( .=:(-2(

R3.0.=:23("Q(B@N**DM([C/3.L57J5(923>;38.=42(C7ZH7:(453;8./;J3.95I(4;H9C2:(/;(

/379C2(ZH.:3H9;C2(8.11(1924/3;82/3I(:2/24/7;=(;>(=./H3.CCI(;44H337=J( /57;H3.47C(

7=( H37=2( ;>( H=/32./2:( C7<21/;4TE( :;821/74./2:( .=78.C1( .=:( 5H8.=1M( Q;;:(

.::7/7<21(.=:(4;=/.87=.=/1(9.3/(#L452871/3I(.=.CI171(4;=/3;C(2G9;1H32(.=:(371T(

.1121182=/(@O?(*AAL*,@(

).=5.24T2(\E().=:2=(RH11452(`E(V7CC2(^E(Y0.H084+X(.=:(-2(R3.0.=:23("Q(B@N**DM([C/3.L

57J5( 923>;38.=42( C7ZH7:( 453;8./;J3.95IL/.=:28( 8.11( 1924/3;82/3I( 7=( 57J5L

/53;HJ59H/( 4;=>738./7;=( .=:( ZH.=/7>74./7;=( ;>( +F( .=.0;C74( 1/23;7:1( 7=( 0;<7=2(

8H14C2M(#=.CI/74.(!57874.(#4/.(,NN?(,NL,,(

Y0.H084+ XJ\( ).=:2=( RH11452( `E( Q3.=Å;71( XE( %HI//2=1( QE( -2( R3.0.=:23( "QE(

).=:2=:37211452(Q(.=:().=5.24T2(\(B@N*@DM(#(<.C7:./2:(HC/3.L57J5(923>;38.=42(

C7ZH7:(453;8./;J3.95I(4;H9C2:(/;(57J5(321;CH/7;=(8.11(1924/3;82/3I(.=.CI171(>;3(

/52( 178HC/.=2;H1( ZH.=/7>74./7;=( ;>( /52( /5322( T=;6=( 0;.3( /.7=/( 4;89;H=:1M(

`;H3=.C(;>(!53;8./;J3.95I(#(*@+a?(FaLKK(

#CH6b(YE(%HI//2=1(Q#YE(Y0.H084+XJE(-2(X82/(XE(-2(R3.0.=:23(-\(.=:(Y7CC2/(X(B@N*@DM(

&<.CH./7;=( ;>( <.37;H1( 0;.3( /.7=/( :2/24/7;=( 82/5;:1M( #=78.C( B7=( 93211?(

5//9?PP:GM:;7M;3JP*NM*N*,PX*,K*,+***@NNNO@*D(

Y0.H084+ XJE( #CH6b( YE( Y7CC2/( XE( W;2/5.C1( ^E( S120.23/( XE( ]7h1( WE( -2( R3.0.=:23( -\E(

)2352I:2=( ^E( -2( R3.0.=:23( "QE( ).=5.24T2( \( .=:( %HI//2=1( Q#Y( B@N*@DM(

$32:74/7=J( /52( C7T2C75;;:( ;>( :2<2C;97=J( 0;.3( /.7=/?( 2.3CI( 95I174.C( 7=:74./;31( 7=(

2=/732( 8.C2( 97J1M( Y2./( X472=42( B7=( 93211?(

5//9?PP:GM:;7M;3JP*NM*N*APhM82./147M@N*@MNFMNNKD(

(

+

C(K3*4401++

Page 195: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

![''S![\[Y()S%#&(

(

(

*OK(

+

Y0.H084+ XJ\( #CH6b( YE( ).=5.24T2( \E( "2321( \E( -H45./2.H( \E( ).=:2=:37211452( Q( .=:(

%HI//2=1(Q#Y(B@N*@DM(-2/24/7;=(;>(0;.3(/.7=/(0I(82.=1(;>(/52(5H8.=(=;12M(Y2./(

X472=42(B1H087//2:D(

#CH6b(YE( \.=J2=:3721(^!YE(Y0.H084+ XE( %HI//2=1(Q#YME(-2(R3.0.=:23(-E(-2(X82/(X(c(

Y7CC2/(X( B@N*@DM(&>>24/(;>( 1H3J74.C(4.1/3./7;=E( 788H=;4.1/3./7;=(.=:(4574;3IL:72/(

;=(/52(82./(ZH.C7/I(.=:(9.C./.07C7/I(;>(0;.31M(Y2./(X472=42(B1H087//2:D+

Y0.H084+XJE(`M().=:2=(RH11452(`E(<.=(V.J2=023J(!$#E(:2(`;=J(!E(-H45./2.H(\E("2321(\E(

%HI//2=1( Q#YE( ).=:2=:37211452( Q( .=:( ).=5.24T2( \( B@N*@DM( W!LX]SQQLYX( .=:(

["$\!L"'YX( /;( H=3.<2C( 0;.3( /.7=/( 4;=/370H/7=J( 4;89;H=:1M( #=.CI/74.( !57874.(

#4/.(B1H087//2:D(

(

-K)48H&4)+

+

#:37.2=1(-E(Y0.H084+XE(W2=03HJJ2(#E(Y.202(-E("HI12=/3HI/(Q(.=:(W2237=4TG(%(B@NNADM(

!;=<23J2=/( 2<;CH/7;=( ;>( .=( 2324/7C2( 197=2( .99.3./H1( 7=( C;374.37;7:( >71521M( #==H.C(

822/7=J( ;>( /52( #82374.=( X;472/I( ;>( S45/5I;C;J71/1( .=:( "2392/;C;J71/1M( ]26(

U3C2.=1E([X#(

#:37.2=1(-E(Y0.H084+XE(W2=03HJJ2(#E(Y.202(-E("HI12=/3HI/(Q(.=:(W2237=4TG(%(B@NNADM(

).=:2CC7.( L( .( 8I1/237;H1( >715( 2ZH7992:( /;( 5;C:( ;=M( *+/5( R2=2CHG( !;=J3211( ;>(

i;;C;JIM(\2H<2=E(R2CJ7H8(

#:37.2=1(-(.=:(Y0.H084+ X( B@NNADM(Y;395;C;JI(.=:(8245.=718(;>( /52(;9234HC.3( 197=2(

C;4T7=J( .99.3./H1( 7=( 5.23=./;95.J;H1( 4.=:73H( 4./>715M( S=/2J3./7<2( .=:(

!;89.3./7<2(R7;C;JI(FAE(&@L&@(

#:37.2=1(-(.=:(Y0.H084+ X+ B@NN,DM(Y;395;C;JI(.=:(8245.=718(;>( /52(;9234HC.3( 197=2(

C;4T7=J(.99.3./H1( 7=(5.28./;95.J;H1(4.=:73H(4./>715M(#==H.C(822/7=J(X;472/I(;>(

S=/2J3./7<2(.=:(!;89.3./7<2(R7;C;JIM($5;2=7GE([X#(

Y0.H084+XJE(%HI//2=1(Q#YE(]7h1(WE(#CH6b(YE(Y7CC2/(XE().=(U24T2C(Y`E().=J2I/2(`E(R.23/(

`E()2352I:2=(^E(-2(R3.0.=:23("Q(.=:(-2(R3.0.=:23(-\(B@NNODM(&.3CI(:2/24/7;=(;>(

Page 196: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

![''S![\[Y()S%#&(

(

(

*OA(

0;.3(/.7=/(0I(82.=1(;>(025.<7;H3.C(.=:(95I174.C(932:74/;31M( S'%#E(Y;=2CC1E(X9.7=E(

9M*AL*,(

Y0.H084+XJE(%HI//2=1(Q#YE(]7h1(WE(#CH6b(YE(Y7CC2/(XE().=(U24T2C(YE().=J2I/2(`E(R.23/(`E(

)2352I:2=(^(.=:(-2(R3.0.=:23(-\(B@NNODM(&.3CI(:2/24/7;=(;>(0;.3(/.7=/(0I(82.=1(

;>(025.<7;H3.C(.=:(95I174.C(932:74/;31M(&##$E()7C=7H1E(\7/5H.=7.E(9Maa(

%HI//2=1( %E( )2357CC2( RE( ).=5;=.4T23( QE( ).=(U24T2C(YE(Y0.H084+ X( .=:(-2(R3.0.=:23(-(

B@NNODM( #//7/H:2( ;>( >.38231( 4;=423=7=J( .C/23=./7<21( >;3( 97JC2/1M( &##$E( )7C=7H1E(

\7/5H.=7.E(9MaO(

%HI//2=1(%E(-2(W3;;/( `E().=('22=2=(^E(Y0.H084+ XJE( X/3H2C2=1(&E(-2(R;H3:2.H:v"HI(#(

B@NNODM(X;47.C(025.<7;H3(;>(2=/732(8.C2(97J1(<231H1(0.33;61M(R;;T(;>(#01/3.4/1(;>(

/52(Ka/5(#==H.C(Y22/7=J(;>(/52(&H3;92.=(#11;47./7;=(>;3(#=78.C($3;:H4/7;=M(&##$E(

)7C=7H1E(\7/5H.=7.E(9Maa(

#CH6b(YE(Y7CC2/(XE(Y0.H084+XE(%HI//2=1(QE(-2(R3.0.=:23(-\(.=:().=(U24T2C(Y`(B@NNODM(

%2=:23=211(;>(82./(>3;8(2=/732(8.C2(97J1?(2>>24/1(;>(0322:E(1C.HJ5/23(627J5/(.=:(

82.1H37=J( 82/5;:M( $3;422:7=J1( ;>( /52( KF/5( S=/23=./7;=.C( !;=J3211( ;>( Y2./(

X472=42(.=:(%245=;C;JIE(!.92(%;6=E(X;H/5(#>374.E(9M*+*(

Y0.H084+XJE(%HI//2=1(Q#YE(]7h1(WE(#CH6b(YE(Y7CC2/(XE().=(U24T2C(YE().=J2I/2(`E(R.23/(`E(

)2352I:2=(^(.=:(-2(R3.0.=:23(-\(B@NNaDM(&.3CI(:2/24/7;=(;>(0;.3(/.7=/(0I(82.=1(

;>( 025.<7;H3.C( .=:( 95I174.C( 932:74/;31M( Q;;:( @( ^=;6( '212.345( X287=.3E( W52=/E(

R2CJ7H8M(

#CH6b(YE(Y0.H084+XJE(%HI//2=1(Q#YE().=5.24T2(\E(-2(R3.0.=:23(-\E(Y7CC2/(X( B@NNaDM(

S=>CH2=42(;>(1;7C7=J(;=(0;.3(/.7=/(7=(2=/732(8.C2(97J1M(R#YX%E(Y2CC2E(R2CJ7H8M(

Y0.H084+ XJ\+ %HI//2=1( Q#YE( ).=5.24T2( \E( ).=:2=:37211452( QE( -H45./2.H( \E( -2(

R3.0.=:23("Q(B@N*NDM+%52(12=17/7<7/I(;>(QC28715(47/7g2=1(/;(.=:3;1/2=;=2?(7=>CH2=42(

;>(J2=:23E(.J2E(32J7;=(.=:(18;T7=J(5.07/1M(&##$(;=(/52(93;:H4/7;=(.=:(H/7C7g./7;=(

;>(82./(>3;8(2=/732(8.C2(97J1(R371/2CE([^E(9M*a(

Y0.H084+ XJE( -2( R3.0.=:23( "QE( ).=:2=( RH11452( `E( V7CC2( ^E( %HI/2=1( Q#YE(

).=:2=:37211452( Q( .=:( ).=5.24T2( \( B@N*NDM( U9/78.C71./7;=( ;>( .( 82/5;:( >;3(

178HC/.=2;H1(.=.CI171(;>(0;.3(/.7=/(4;89;H=:1M(X7G/5(S=/23=./7;=.C(XI89;17H8(;=(

";38;=2(.=:()2/237=.3I(-3HJ('217:H2(#=.CI171E(W52=/E(R2CJ7H8(

Page 197: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

![''S![\[Y()S%#&(

(

(

*O,(

#CH6b(YE(Y0.H084+XJE(%HI//2=1(Q#YE(-2(X82/(XE(-2(R3.0.=:23(-\(.=:(Y7CC2/(X(B@N*NDM(

BY7117=JD( C7=T( 02/622=( :7>>232=/( 0;.3( /.7=/( :2/24/7;=( 82/5;:1M( &##$E( !32/2E(

W32242(

Y0.H084+ XJ\( %HI/2=1( Q#YE( -2( R3.0.=:23( "QE( ).=:2=:37211452( QE( -H45./2.H( \( .=:(

).=5.24T2(\(B@N*NDM(%21/7=J(/52(12=17/7<7/I(;>(QC28715(4;=1H8231(/;(.=:3;1/2=;=2?(

1;47;L:28;J3.9574( 7=>CH2=421M( Q;H3/5( &H3;92.=( !;=>232=42( ;=( X2=1;3I( .=:(

!;=1H823('212.345E()7/;37.LW.1/27gE(X9.7=(

Y0.H084+ XJE( %HI//2=1( Q#YE( -2( R3.0.=:23( "QE( ).=:2=:37211452( QE( -H45./2.H( \( .=:(

).=5.24T2( \( B@N**DM( %52( 12=17/7<7/I( ;>( QC28715( 47/7g2=1( /;( .=:3;1/2=;=2?( >7=2L

/H=7=J( /52( 82/5;:;:C;JI( .=:( /21/7=J( /52( 7=>CH2=42( ;>( J2=:23E( .J2E( 32J7;=( .=:(

18;T7=J( 5.07/1M( S=/23=./7;=.C( !;=>232=42( >;3( Y2./( X472=42( .=:( %245=;C;JIE(

W52=/E(R2CJ7H8E(9M*,@(

Y0.H084+ XJE( %HI//2=1( Q#YE( -2( R3.0.=:23( "QE( ).=:2=:37211452( QE( -H45./2.H( \( .=:(

).=5.24T2(\(B@N**DM(%52(H12(;>(/52(5;/(73;=(82/5;:(.=:([L"$\!LYXPYX(.=.CI171(

>;3( /52( :2/24/7;=( ;>( 0;.3( /.7=/M( S=/23=./7;=.C( !;=>232=42( >;3( Y2./( X472=42( .=:(

%245=;C;JIE(W52=/E(R2CJ7H8E(9M**A(

#CH6b(YE(Y7CC2/(XE(\.=J2=:3721(^!YE(Y0.H084+XJE(%HI//2=1(Q#Y(.=:(-2(R3.0.=:23(-\(

B@N**DM(!574;3I( 7=(0223( >22:?(2>>24/(;=(0;.3( /.7=/(.=:(82./(ZH.C7/IM( S=/23=./7;=.C(

!;=>232=42(>;3(Y2./(X472=42(.=:(%245=;C;JIE(W52=/E(R2CJ7H8E(9M@+O(

).=5.24T2(\E().=:2=(RH11452(`E(V7CC2(^E(Y0.H084+X(.=:(-2(R3.0.=:23("Q(B@N**DM([C/3.L

57J5( 923>;38.=42( C7ZH7:( 453;8./;J3.95I( /.=:28( 8.11( 1924/3;82/3I( 7=( 57J5L

/53;HJ59H/( 4;=>738./7;=( .=:( ZH.=/7>74./7;=( ;>( +F( .=.0;C74( 1/23;7:1( 7=( 0;<7=2(

8H14C2M( S=/23=./7;=.C( !;=>232=42( >;3( Y2./( X472=42( .=:( %245=;C;JIE( W52=/E(

R2CJ7H8E(9M+N,M(

#CH6b(YE(Y7CC2/(XE(\.=J2=:3721(^!YE(Y0.H084+XJE(%HI//2=1(Q#Y(.=:(-2(R3.0.=:23(-\(

B@N**DM(!;89.371;=(;>(82./(ZH.C7/I(02/622=(0.33;61E(0;.31(.=:(0;.31(<.447=./2:(

.J.7=1/( J;=.:;/3;97=L32C2.17=J( 5;38;=2M( S=/23=./7;=.C( !;=>232=42( >;3( Y2./(

X472=42(.=:(%245=;C;JIE(W52=/E(R2CJ7H8E(9M**A(

Y0.H084+ XJE( %HI//2=1( Q#YE( -2( R3.0.=:23( "QE( ).=:2=:37211452( Q( .=:( ).=5.24T2( \(

B@N**DM([L"$\!L"'LYX( .=.CI171( >;3( 178HC/.=2;H1( ZH.=/7>74./7;=(;>( /52( 0;.3( /.7=/(

Page 198: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

![''S![\[Y()S%#&(

(

(

*OO(

4;89;H=:1M(R;.31(52.:7=J(>;3(@N*OE(#81/23:.8E(]2/523C.=:1(

Y0.H084+ XJE( %HI//2=1( Q#YE( #CH6b( YE( -2( R3.0.=:23( "QE( ).=:2=:37211452( Q( .=:(

).=5.24T2( \( B@N**DM( %52( 5;/L73;=(82/5;:( >;3( .112117=J( 0;.3( /.7=/?( 923>;38.=42(

45.3.4/2371/741( .=:( /245=74.C( 93;42:H321M( R;.31( 52.:7=J( >;3( @N*OE( #81/23:.8E(

]2/523C.=:1(

(

#$%7080%&0\+/$8.)I$M)+H%1+)03*%H8)+

(

! Y22/7=J(;>( /52(&H3;92.=(#11;47./7;=( >;3(#=78.C(93;:H4/7;=(V;3T7=J(W3;H9(;=(

$3;:H4/7;=(.=:([/7C71./7;=(;>(Y2./(>3;8(&=/732(8.C2(97J1E(Y;=2CC1E(X9.7=E(@NNO(

B;3.C(93212=/./7;=D(

! Ka/5(&H3;92.=(#11;47./7;=(>;3(#=78.C(93;:H4/7;=E()7C=7H1E(\7/5H.=7.E(@NNO(

B9;1/23(93212=/./7;=D(

! Q;;:(@(^=;6('212.345(X287=.3E(W52=/E(R2CJ7H8E(@NNa(

B9;1/23(93212=/./7;=D(

! V./231(.99C74./7;=(X287=.3L[$\!E(W52=/E(R2CJ7H8E(@NNa(

! X/H:72:.J( R2CJ7.=( #11;47./7;=( >;3( Y2./( X472=42( .=:( %245=;C;JIE( &=23J72L( 2=(

g;H/32:H4/72(7=(<C221(2=(<C22193;:H4/2=E(Y232C02T2E(R2CJ7H8E(@N*N(

! Y22/7=J(;>( /52(&H3;92.=(#11;47./7;=( >;3(#=78.C(93;:H4/7;=(V;3T7=J(W3;H9(;=(

$3;:H4/7;=(.=:([/7C71./7;=(;>(Y2./(>3;8(&=/732(8.C2(97J1E(R371/;CE([^E(@N*N(

B;3.C(93212=/./7;=D(

! A/5(S=/23=./7;=.C(XI89;17H8(;=(";38;=2(.=:()2/237=.3I(-3HJ('217:H2(#=.CI171E(

W52=/E(R2CJ7H8E(@N*N(

B9;1/23(93212=/./7;=D(

! Q;H3/5( &H3;92.=( !;=>232=42( ;=( X2=1;3I( .=:( !;=1H823( '212.345E( )7/;37.L

W.1/27gE(X9.7=E(@N*N(

B9;1/23(93212=/./7;=D(

! K,/5(S=/23=./7;=.C(!;=>232=42(>;3(Y2./(X472=42(.=:(%245=;C;JIE(W52=/E(R2CJ7H8E(

@N**(

B9;1/23(.=:(;3.C(93212=/./7;=D(

Page 199: 0$*0#)%*-%'12.#0 .1*$ Doct_KB.pdf · 6h4gm!ra!"ro6mo6

![''S![\[Y()S%#&(

(

(

*Oa(

! !;=>232=42?(R;.31(52.:7=J(>;3(@N*OE(#81/23:.8E(]2/523C.=:1E(@N**(

B;3.C(93212=/./7;=D(

(