!"#$%& ()**%")+, - .%)/0 12+3") 4%&)0)/),56% 7/89"9:)% ; 1<39$ =</5%$ >??+/9"9:@ - A)9"9:@ &BC7 CDE F<""%/ ; GHEIGJEKKLGM !"#"$%&%#' )%* +%,%#-.*/0#$%# 12# 34%5/62.#'78#4.,.'2*%#
!"#$%&'()**%")+,'-'.%)/0'12+3")'4%&)0)/),56%'7/89"9:)%';'1<39$'=</5%$'>??+/9"9:@'-'A)9"9:@'
'
&BC7'CDE'F<""%/';'GHEIGJEKKLGM'
!"#"$%&%#'()%*(+%,%#-.*/0#$%#(12#(34%5/62.#'78#4.,.'2*%#(
!"#$%&''#%%$()$*++&,(-"#./01$
=6%/-4%""?</N'>??+/)D@'KLGO'
2,,(3/43#$*++&,(-"#./0*#%$$/%%6.#$(5"#5%*(.&&0#.'9(59:%('0*#.#$("#)(;0,;%<0%#':9(.#5*%";.#$(*%;62#;%(*"'%;(
5#6&7/4(,$()$!$'#77$/'43/4(,$8$9/7/,'*,6$/'43/4,6$/,:$*,"*9*-(.1$%*6,/7%$
4%""?</N'P<D+$%'KLGG'
!"#$#%&'#%(')**&+,#%-&'*#-$%./'%-)0/'%100)2/-"#'&34%
8#4.,.'2*9(*%5%6'2*;=(.%>(.&&0#%(54%5/62.#';(6:"9("(/%9(*2:%(.#(")"6?1%(.&&0#.'9@(•! 5&12-#2&26#%/.%3#'13"#'&,%%%%%%%$#,.%-/,#'&26#%•! 7'#8#29/2%/.%&)-/:100)21-4%
A*"#;.%#'(%B6*%;;.2#(2#(C0#5?2#":(%D%5'2*(A(5%::;(%E0;'".#%)(%B6*%;;.2#(2#()9;C0#5?2#=(.%(>%B4"0;'%)(A(5%::;(
Q'
;#'"/,*%+$()$<!=>?@$/,:$AB?C$*,"*9*4(,$8$$:*D#.#,-$(.$%477$E&*-#$%*+*7/.$F$
R@)N'SBAC'1%T'KLGU'
CTLA-4deficientmicedeveloplympho-prolifera4vedisease
6 Waterhouseetal,Science1995
PD-1deficiencypredisposestoautoimmunediseases
Nishimuraetal,Science2001andImmunity1999
<!=>?@H$AB?C$/,:$AB?=C$6#,#%$/.#$7*,I#:$-($%#7)?-(7#./,'#$/,:$/.#$*,3(73#:$*,$/&-(*++&,#$:*%#/%#$
4)569DN'B+$'W'=</5%$'KLGM'
!"#$:#7*'/-#$9/7/,'#$()$*++&,(-"#./01$8$/&-(*++&,#$*,J/++/4(,$
=6<?*)<DN'!//'7/59"'KLGQ'
K1%-#+*'$*,J/++/4(,$*,$/$+#7/,(+/$0/4#,-$-.#/-#:$L*-"$*++&,#$'"#'I0(*,-$2,"*9*-(.%$?$/,$/&-(0%1$%-&:1$
W>X=N'<55%*D%&'
K1%-#+*'$*,J/++/4(,$*,$/$+#7/,(+/$0/4#,-$-.#/-#:$L*-"$*++&,#$'"#'I0(*,-$2,"*9*-(.%$?$/,$/&-(0%1$%-&:1$
W>X=N'<55%*D%&'
K1%-#+*'$*,J/++/4(,$*,$/$+#7/,(+/$0/4#,-$-.#/-#:$L*-"$*++&,#$'"#'I0(*,-$2,"*9*-(.%$?$/,$/&-(0%1$%-&:1$
W>X=N'<55%*D%&'
K1%-#+*'$*,J/++/4(,$*,$/$+#7/,(+/$0/4#,-$-.#/-#:$L*-"$*++&,#$'"#'I0(*,-$2,"*9*-(.%$?$/,$/&-(0%1$%-&:1$
W>X=N'<55%*D%&'
2++&,#$.#7/-#:$/:3#.%#$#3#,-%$
/%%('*/-#:$L*-"$/,4?<!=>?@$/,49(:*#%$
R<%6"%$N'C%?'7/59"'KLGL'.9$Y<DN'W=7'KLGQ'
2++&,#$.#7/-#:$/:3#.%#$#3#,-%$/%%('*/-#:$L*-"$/,4?<!=>?@$/,49(:*#%$
A%$D$</&N'A4='4%&)5)/%'KLGQ'
2,'*:#,'#$
5*%I$./4($M+6NI6$
O%P$CQ$+6NI6$
2++&,#$.#7/-#:$/:3#.%#$#3#,-%$/%%('*/-#:$L*-"$/,4?<!=>?@$/,49(:*#%$
V9"5698N'KLGLZ'V%3%$N'KLGQ'
5/:*(6./0"*'$0.(G7*,6$()$*++&,#$.#7/-#:$/:3#.%#$#3#,-%$/%%('*/-#:$L*-"$/,4?<!=>?@$/,49(:*#%$
[/*+3"),6%&N'X)$+?</)N'=</5%$'>??+/9"'\%,'KLGQ'
A7/'#,-/$R$-&+(.%$&47*S#$AB?CNAB?=CNAB?=T$$*,-#./'4(,$-($#3/:#$*++&,#$.#'(6,*4(,$
B*%-.*9&4(,$()$*.>U%$L*-"$/,4?<!=>?@H$/,4?ABC$(.$/,4?AB?=C$/,49(:*#%$
4)569DN'B+$'W'=</5%$'KLGQ'
!*+#$-($(,%#-$()$%#7#'-$-.#/-+#,-?.#7/-#:$>U%$)(.$,*3(7&+/9$V/,1$6./:#W$X$Y$@Z@[$
V%3%$N'!C=7'KLGQ'
X#L$-.#/-+#,-?.#7/-#:$%#7#'-$>U%$(3#.$4+#$L*-"$,*3(7&+/9$V/,1$6./:#W$,$Y$\Z][$
V%3%$N'!C=7'KLGQ'
X*3(7&+/9$>:3#.%#$U3#,-%$V+#7/,(+/[$
X9*<")</N'KLGUZ'V%3%$N'KLGQ'
X*3(7&+/9$>:3#.%#$U3#,-%$VXK<=<[$
F%]/:%$N'KLGU'
A#+9.(7*S&+/9$>:3#.%#$U3#,-%$V+#7/,(+/[$
\93%$DN'KLGUZ'V%3%$N'KLGQ''
Generalrules:managementofimmune-relatedadverseevents
Grade Management Con4nuethedrug?
Low DelaythedoseResume
whenAEsresolvetograde≤1orbaseline
Moderate∼High
AdministerCoracosteroids±Immunosuppressants
(ana-TNF,mycophenolate,etc)
Disconanuedrugpermanently(Delayinsomesituaaons)
KI*,$!(`*'*-1$
SkinToxicity
GradeofRash
(NCICTCAEv4)Management Follow-up
Grade1-2• Erymthaousand/
ormaculopapular(10-30%BSA)• Dryskin
• Pruritus,localizedordiffuse
intermident• Vi4ligo(nointerven4onindicated)
IfimprovestoGrade1:• Tapersteroidsoveratleast1monthandaddprophylac4can4bio4csforopportunis4cinfec4ons
• Resumetherapy
Grade3-4• Erythematourrash(>30%BSA))
• Pruritus,diffuseandconstant• Blisters,ulcera4on,
bullae,necro4corhemorrhagic
lesions• Toxicepidermal
necrolysis
Ifpersists>1-2weeksorrecurs:• Considerskinbiopsy• Delaytherapy• Consider0.5-1.0mg/kg/daymethylprednisoloneIVororalequivalent.Onceimproving,tapersteroidsoveratleast1month,considerprophylac4can4bio4csforopportunis4cinfec4ons,andresumetherapy
Ifworsens:• TreatasGrade3-4
• Symptomytherapy(e.g.an4histamines,topicalsteroids)
• Con4nuetherapy
• Delayordiscon4nuetherapy• Considerskinbiopsy• Dermatologyconsult• 1.0-2.0mg/kg/dayIVmethylprednisoloneIVorIVequivalent
B*/.."(#$/,:$'(7*4%$
20*7*+&+/9H$X$Y$C@gh$ >,1$6./:#H$,Vb[ ^./:#$M?@$Vb[ ^./:#$\$Vb[ _)<$$6%< QQU'cOfe GLU'cMEJe L
=9")a,' GKL'cHELe fU'cUEJe G'cgLEGe X*3(7&+/9H$X$Y$MQ@$ >,1$6./:#H$,Vb[ ^./:#$M?@$Vb[ ^./:#$\$Vb[ _)<$$6%< OM'cGKe O'cGe L =9")a,' L L K'cgGe
Diarrhoeandcoli4s
GradeofDiarrhea/Coli4s
(NCICTCAEv4)
Grade1Diarrhea:<4stools/day;Coli4s:asymptoma4c
Grade2Diarrhea:4-6stoolsperday
IVfluidsindicated<24hrs
Coli4s:abdominalpain;bloodinstool
Grade3-4Diarrhea(G3):≥7stoolsperday
incon4nence;IVfluidsindicated≥24hrs;
Coli4s(G3):severeabdominalpain,medicalinterven4onindicated,
peritonealsignsG4:life-threatening,perfora4on
• Con4nuetherapy• Symptoma4ctreatment
Management
• Delaytherapy• Symptoma4ctreatment
• Discon4nuetherapy• 1.0to2.0mg/kg/daymethylprednisoloneIVorIVequivalent
• Addprophylac4can4bio4csforopportunis4cinfec4ons
• Considerlowerendoscopy
Follow-up
• Closemonitoringforworseningsymptoms.• Educatepa4enttoreportworseningimmediatelyIfworsens:• Treatasgrade2or3/4
Ifimprovestograde1:• Resumetherapy• Ifpersists>5-7daysorrecur:• 0.5-1.0mg/kg/daymethylprednisoloneororalequivalent• Whensymptomsimprovetograde1,tapersteroidsoveratleast1month,considerprophylac4can4bio4csforopportunis4cinfec4ons,andresumetherapy
Ifworsensorpersists>305dayswithoralsteroids:• Treatasgrade3/4
Ifimproves:• Con4nuesteroidsun4lgrade1,thentaperoveratleast1month
Ifpersists>3-5days,orrecursalerimprovement:• Addinfliximab5mg/kg(ifnocontraindica4on).Note:Infliximabshouldnotbeusedincasesofperfora4onorsepsis
19.12.2014 • Diarrhea,nausea,andemesisbegan
22.12.2014 Work-upiniaated:• CTscanofabd/pelvis:milddistensionofsmallbowelbutnoevidenceofmechanicalobstrucaon,freeair,masslesion,orcolonicthickness/edema
• Stool:Fecalleukocytespresent• TreatedwithIVfluidsandanaemeacbutsymptomsworsened
25.12.2014
GIToxicityCaseStudy:71yroldfemale,melanoma,stageIV
• Hospitalizedwithseverenausea,vomiang,intractablediarrhea(grade3),anddehydraaon‒ RepeatCTscan:subtledilataaonoftheduodenum;noevidenceof
mechanicalbowelobstrucaon‒ Labtests:Stoolhemoccultmildlyposiave,stoolcxnegaave‒ Colonoscopy:abnormalmucosa‒ Colonbiopsy:benigncolonicmucosa
• Beganhighdosedexamethasoneandmetronidazoleforpresumedcolias‒ Alsoreceivedomeprazole,ondansetronandIVfluids
• Received7dosesipilimumab(3mg/kg)9/14–12/14
TPCPTQC\$ C@?*D9?,'$%D+$/%&'&+$)/:',D%$9)&'D<*%$'^)D69+D'$%56<""%/:%'9#'/)Y9"+?<3'>/5"+&%&'Y9?)a/:N'^<D%$@',D99",'c+*'D9'GLI&<@eN')/D%$?)T%/D'+**%$'<3&9?)/<"'*<)/'•! 5#0#/-$'(7(,(%'(01h''<3/9$?<"'59"9/'</&'59")a,'•! 5#0#/-$'(7(,$9*(0%1h'')/j<??<a9/'c/%^'l/&)/:e'•! m*6"$:(%#$%-#.(*:%$.#?%-/.-#:H$C`$5#+*'/:#$V2,J*`*+/9[$\$+6NI6$
\PTPTQC@$
^2$!(`*'*-1$</%#$K-&:1_$ZC$1.$(7:$)#+/7#H$$+#7/,(+/H$%-/6#$2O$
•! m<a%/D'&),56<$:%&'69?%'^)D6'$%,9"Y%&'/<+,%<N'&)<$$6%<N'</&'Y9?)a/:N'D9'59?*"%D%',D%$9)&'D<*%$''
•! CD+&@'&$+:'*%$?</%/D"@'&),59/a/+%&'
>?*$9Y%?%/D'D9':$<&%'KN'&%k<?%D6<,9/N',D<$D'D<*%$)/:'MCPCTPTQC@$
Whatarethelessonslearned?
§ Iniaatetreatmentearly
§ Useresultsofdiagnosacevaluaaontoguidemanagement
§ Anegaavediagnosacevaluaaonmayneedtoberepeated
§ Ifsteroidsarebegun,taperslowly
GIToxicityCaseStudy:71yroldfemale,melanoma,stageIV
Pneumoni4s
Incidence
InfrequentAllgrades:3%Grades3-4:1%,deathsassociatedwithpulmonarytoxicity
Riskfactor
§ Nounderlyingfactoridenafiedtodate§ Noapparentrelaaonshiptotumourtype
→ Casesobservedinmulapletumourtypes(Melanoma,RCC,NSCLC,etc)
Symptom § Cough,SOB/dyspnea(restorexeraon),fever§ Asymptomaacradiographicchanges
Assessment § Pulseoximetry(restandexeraon)§ CT§ Indoubtorfordifferenaaaonperformbronchoscopy
Management
§ Delaydosing§ Coracosteroids
→ ifnotimproving48hrsorworsening,addimmunosuppressants§ Bronchoscopy/BAL
Pneumoni4s
GradeofPneumoni4s
(NCICTCAEv4)
Management Follow-up
• Re-imageatleastevery3weeksIfworsens:• TreatasGrade2or3-4
Grade1Radiographicchangesonly
• Considerdelayoftherapy• Monitorforsymptomsevery2-3days• ConsiderPulmonaryandInfec4ousDisease(ID)consults
Grade2Mildtomoderatenew
symptoms
• Re-imageevery1-3daysIfimproves:• Whensymptomsreturntonearbaseline,tapersteroidsoveratleast1monthandthenresumetherapyandconsiderprophylac4can4bio4cs
Ifnotimprovingaler2weeksorworsening:• TreatasGrade3-4
• Delaytherapy• PulmonaryandIDconsults• Monitorsymptomsdaily,considerhospitaliza4on
• 1.0mg/kg/daymethyl-prednisoloneIVororalequivalent
• Considerbronchoscopy,lungbiopsy
Grade3-4Severenewsymptoms;New/worseninghypoxia;
Life-threatening
Ifimprovestobaseline:• Tapersteroidsoveratleast6weeksIfnotimprovingaler48hoursorworsening:• Addaddi4onalimmunosuppression(e.g.infliximab,cyclophosphamide,intravenousimmunoglobulin(IVIG),ormycophenolatemofe4l)
• Delaytherapy• Hospitalize• PulmonaryandIDconsults• 2-4mg/kg/daymethylprednisoloneIVorIVequivalent
• Addprophylac4can4bio4csforopportunis4cinfec4ons
• Considerbronchoscopy,lungbiopsy
PulmonaryToxicityCaseStudy#1
• 66yofemalewithmetastaacNSCLC,4priorsystemictherapies• Pasthxofasthma,pulmonaryembolism,25packyeartobaccouse(quitin1990)§ medicaaon:salmeterol/fluacasoneandsalbutamolinhaler
2.2015-8.2015 Received14dosesNivolumab(3mg/kg)
2.9.2015 • Serialrestagingrevealedparaalremission• Radiographicappearanceofgroundglassopaciaesnotconsistentwithmetsorinfecaon
• Subjectwasasymptomaac,deniedcoughorworseneddyspnea
• O2sat95%(92%withprolongedambulaaon)
5.9.2015 Bronchoscopy:noinfecaouseaology,reacavechangesandinflammaaononBAL
7.9.2015 • Steroidtherapywasiniaatedon8/17/10,withsubsequentslowtaper(6wks)• Scansimproved• Subjectrechallengedoncesteroidstapered,withnorecurrenceofpneumonias
!! QJ'@9'?<"%'^)D6'?%"</9?<'!! 7/,%Dh'_<@'HJ'cO'&<@,'<r%$'fD6'&9,%'9#'m_G'
<3e'!! =6%,D'*<)/I,69$D/%,,'9#'3$%<D6'!! X$%<D%&'^)D6',D%$9)&,'9/'_<@'JJ''!! >/j)k)?<3'c&<@'GLUe'</&'?@59*6%/9"<D%'c_<@'
GLJe'^%$%'<&&%&E'!! _%Y%"9*%&':$<&%'U'!\_C'!! _%<D6'&+%'D9',%*,),'9/'_<@'GGM'
A&7+(,/.1$!(`*'*-1$</%#$K-&:1$nT$
Pneumoni4s
Whatarethelessonslearned?
• Pulmonarytoxicitymaypresentwithclinicalsymptomsormaybeanincidentalfindingonscans
• Subjectshavebeensuccessfullytreatedwithsteroids• Subjectswithlow-gradepnemoniasmaybere-challenged
withstudydrugoffofsteroids
Endocrinopathies
Incidence • Allgrades:6%• Grade3/4:1%
Involvedorgans• Hypothyroidism/hyperthyroidism• Hypophysias• Adrenalinsufficiency,secondaryadrenocoracalinsufficiency
‒Morethanoneendocrineorganmaybeinvolved
Onset• Withinweeks∼mayoccurmanymonths
‒ Typicallyidenafiedthroughrouaneperiodicmonitoringor‒ Partofworkupofassociatedsymptoms
Symptom• Non-specificsymptoms
‒ Headache,faague,weakness,memoryloss,impotence,personalitychanges,andvisual-fieldimpairment
• Whenencounteringnon-specificsymptoms,thinkofendocrinopathies
Management• Nivolumabmaybeconanuedonceappropriatehormonereplacementiniaated
• Subjectswithendocrinopathymayrequirereplacementdosesteroidsratherthanhigh-dosesteroids
EndocrinopathyCaseStudy
• 72yomalewithmalignantmelanomawithmulaplesites,1stlinechemotherapy• Pasthistoryofhypertension,insulin-dependentdiabetesmellitustype2,
hypercholesterolemia,andbenignprostatehypertrophy• Conmeds:glyburide/meuormin,atenolol,hydrochlorothiazide,aspirin,rosuvastaan,insulin,
finasteride,lisinopril,lorazepam,prochlorperazine,andamlodipine4-7.2014 Received4cyclesofipilimumab(3mg/kg)
3.8.2014 Presentedtoclinicwithprofoundfaague,bodyaches,andlegweakness• Labs:undetectableserumcorasollevel,elevatedLH13.6mIU/mL(ref1.7-8.6),otherwiseWNL
• BrainMRI:Nosignsofanymasslesions;CXR:mildlyenlargedheart
8.8.2014Admidedtohospitalon8.8.2014• OrthostaacwithSBPin60’suponstanding• ACTH:<5pg/ml(RR7-50)• ACTHsamtest:pre-samcorasol0.9ug/dL,post-samcorasol8.6ug/dL@30min,10.8ug/dL@60min
• Endocrineconsult:primaryhypophysias• HypoadrenalstateduetoprimaryACTHdeficiency• TreatedwithIVFandreplacementdosesteroids
U,:('.*,(0/-"1$</%#$K-&:1$
C\PhPTQC@$ _),56<$:%&'#$9?'69,*)D<"''TQPhPTQC@$ C%%/')/'5")/)5'^)D6')?*$9Y%?%/D'9#'6@*9D%/,)9/N'#<a:+%N'</&'&)00)/%,,'ThPhPTQC@$ CD%$9)&'$%*"<5%?%/D'56</:%&'#$9?'.='D9'*$%&/),9/%'cQ'?:'n)&e'
Endocrinopathies
Asymptoma4cTSHeleva4on
• Con4nuetherapy• IfTSH<0.5xLLN,orTSH>2xULN,orconsistentlyoutofrangein2subsequentmeasurements:includefT4aatsubsequentcyclesasclinicallyindicated;considerendocrinologyconsult
• Evaluateendocrinefunc4on• ConsiderpituitaryscanSymptoma4cwithabnormallab/pituitaryscan:• Delaytherapy• 1-2mg/kg/daymethylprednisoloneIVorPOequivalent• Ini4ateappropriatehormonetherapy
Noabnormallab/pituitaryMRIscanbutsymptomspersist:• Repeatlabsin1-3weeks/MRIin1month
Ifimproves(withorwithouthormonereplacement):• Tapersteroidsoveratleast1monthandconsiderprophylac4can4bio4csforopportunis4cinfec4ons
• Resumetherapy• Pa4entswithadrenalinsufficiencymayneedtocon4nuesteriodswithmineralocor4coidcomponent
• Delayordiscon4nuetherapy• Ruleoutsepsis• StressdoseofIVsteroidswithmineralocor4coidac4vity• IVfluids• Consultendocrinologist• Ifadrenalcrisisruledout,thentreatasaboveforsymptoma4cendocrinopathy
Symptoma4cendocrinopathy
Suspicionofadrenalcrisis(e.g.severedehydra4on,
hypotension,shockoutofpropor4onto
currentillness
Endocrinopathies
Whatarethelessonslearned?
• Whenencounteringnon-specificsymptoms(faague,weakness),thinkofendocrinopathies
• Considerendocrineconsulttointerpretlabresultsandguidemanagement
• Subjectwithendocrinopathymayrequirereplacementdosesteroidsratherthanhigh-dosesteroids
Renaltoxici4es
Incidence
• <1%ofsubjectstreatedwithnivolumabmonotherapyhaveexperiencedarelatedSAEofacuterenalfailure‒ 2Grade2,3Grade3‒ 2inmonotherapystudies(Mel,RCC),3incombinaaon
(Mel,NSCLC)
Onset • Median43days(6-505days)• Mostcommonlypresentwithelevaaonsinserumcreaanine
Management Steroidsgenerallyleadtoclinicalimprovement/resoluaon
Renalbiopsy Mayhelpdisanguishinflammatoryversusnon-inflammatoryeaologies
RenalToxicityCaseStudy
§ 70yomalewithmetastaacmelanoma,1stlineBRAFinhibitor,2ndlineipilimumab§ Pasthxofhypothyroidism,asthma,dvt§ Conmeds:thyroidhormonereplacement,lowmolecularweightheparin(LMWH)§ Baselinelabs:nitrogen-N6.4mmol/l,Creaanine–114micromol/l
12.2013-4.2014 Receivedpembrolizumab(3mg/kg,2doseswithprogressionofdisease,palliaaveradiotherapy,conanuaaonbeyondprogression,6dosespembrolizumab
3.5.2014 • Labs:Creaanine–increasedto273micromol/l• Presumedcontrastinducednephropathy–ReceivedIVFluids• Labs:Creaanine–decreasedto251micromol/l
26.4.2014 • Rou4neLabs:Slightlyelevatedcreaanine–150micromol/l
27.4.2014 • ScheduledCTTumorAssessmentwithIVContrast:Decreaseinmetastaacdisease(abdominalmass)
RenalToxicityCaseStudy
13.5.2014 • Labs:Creaanine–increasedto334micromol/l• HospitalizedforManagementofelevatedCr
‒ Symptoms–Drymouth,nose,throat‒ Labs-Auto-anabodiesnegaave
-Urinalysis–noproteinuriaorhematuria‒ Renalultrasound–normalsizekidneys,witholdnon-occlusivetumorthrombusintheinferiorvenacavaandrightrenalvein.
9.6.2014 • Labs:Creaanine–nadiredtobaselineat123miromol/l
15.5.2014 • KidneyBiopsy:AcuteIntersaaalNephrias• Labs:Creaanine–308miromol/l• Treatment:Oral70mgBIDprednisone• wasstarted,creaaninedecreasedTreatment:Prednisonetaperedover3weeks
anddisconanuedon6/9/2012.
14.6.2014to18.6.2014
• Labs:Creaanine–increasedto141micromol/lthen159micromol/l
18.6.2014 • Treatment:10mgPODailyPrednisonestarted
21.6.2014 • Labs:Creaanine–decreasedto130micromol/l
Renaltoxici4es
Grade1Crea4nine>ULNand>thanbaselinebut≤1.5x
baseline
GradeofCrea4nineEleva4on
(NCICTCAEv4)
Grade2-3Crea4nine>1.5xbaseline
to≤6xULN
Grade4Crea4nine>6xULN
Management
• Con4nuetherapy• Monitorcrea4nineweekly
• Delaytherapy• Monitorcrea4nineevery2-3days• 0.5to1.0mg/kg/daymethylprednisoloneIVororalequivalent
• Considerrenalbiopsy
• Discon4nuetherapy• Monitorcrea4ninedaily• 1.0-2.0mg/kg/daymethylprednisoloneIVorIVequivalent
• Consultnephrologist• Considerrenalbiopsy
Follow-up
Ifreturnstobaseline:• Resumerou4necrea4ninemonitoringperprotocolIfworsens:• TreatasGrade2or3/4
IfreturnstoGrade1:• Tapersteroidsoveratleast1month,considerprophylac4can4bio4csforopportunis4cinfec4ons,andresumetherapyandrou4necrea4ninemonitoringperprotocol
Ifeleva4onspersist>7daysorworsen:• TreatasGrade4
IfreturnstoGrade1:Tapersteroidsoveratleast1monthandaddprophylac4can4bio4csforopportunis4cinfec4ons
Renaltoxici4es
WhatAreTheLessonsLearned?
• Steroidsgenerallyledtoclinicalimprovement
• Renalbiopsygenerallyshowesevidenceofkidneyinflammaaon
• Noclearassociaaonwithtumortype,noincreasedriskapparentinRCC
Hepatotoxici4es
Incidence Hepaaasisrare
DiagnosisConsiderimmune-relatedcauseevenifconfoundingfactors(conmeds;relevantmedicalhx)arepresent
Onset Median89days(range:13-140days)
Management Longsteroidtaperisindicated,evenifimprovementoccursrapidly
Outcomes• Nofatalcase• Mostcasesweremanagedwithcoracosteroidswitheventresoluaon
HepatotoxicityCaseStudy
§ 60yomalewithstageIVNSCLCmetastaac,severalpalliaaveradiotherapiesand4priorsystemicregimens
§ Pasthistoryofalcoholuse(4-6beers/day),GERD§ Nopasthxofliverdisease§ Conmeds:atenolol,alprazolam,andpantoprazole
1.15-7.2015 • Received16dosesNivolumab(3mg/kg)
24.8.2015 Rou4nelabs:• AST(38)andALT(38)• Tbili(0.5)• AlkPhos(74)• LDH(221)
27.7.2015 • Iniaatedatovaquone/proguanilforMalariaprophylaxis
31.8.2015 • CTscan:nolivermasses
C@PgPTQC\$ \%D+$/%&'D9'5")/)5'#9$'&9,%'xGf'•! \%*9$D%&'&<$8'+$)/%'#9$'G'^%%8'•! AUh'C5"%$<"')5D%$+,N'/9'6%*<D9?%:<"@'•! =*3#.$pNKh'/9'3)")<$@'93,D$+5a9/N'*<D%/D'6%*<a5'Y<,5+"<D+$%'^)D6'/9$?<"'j9^N'
/9'#95<"'")Y%$'?<,,'•! _),59/a/+%&'<D9Y<n+9/%'#9$'m=m'**k'
m#0/-(-(`*'*-1$</%#$K-&:1$$
$m(%0*-/7*S#:$)(.$-.#/-+#,-$•! .%*<aa,'</&'=4i'/%:<aY%'•! 1)Y%$'3)9*,@h'?9&%$<D%'*<D56@'?)k%&'•! *9$D<"')/j<??<a9/'^)D6'?)"&'*<D56@'•! "93+"<$'6%*<aa,'
C\PgPTQC\$
CZPgPTQC\$ •! >i'?%D6@"*$%&/),9/%',D<$D%&''•! X9D<"'3)")h'MEM'"'KEL'"GEf'"GEK'?:I&1'•! !CXh'UMH'"'GGL'"'UJ'"'KU'[I1'•! !1Xh'MQM'"'OGK'"'GOQ'"'UJ'[I1'•! !"8'*69,h'MMJ''"'UUL''"'Kff''"'GfQ'[I1'$•! C^)D56%&'D9'9$<"'*$%&/),9/%'D<*%$'D9'59?*"%D%'OL'&<@'59+$,%'9#',D%$9)&,''
^)D6'D<*%$'
Hepatotoxici4es
GradeofLiverTestEleva4on
(NCICTCAEv4)
Grade1ASTorALT>ULNto3.0orULNand/
orT.bili>-1.5XULN
Grade2ASTorALT>3.0to≤5xULNand/orT.bili>1.5to≤3xULN
Grade3-4ASTorALT>5xULN
and/orT.bili>3xULN
• Con4nuetherapy
Management
• Delaytherapy• Increasefrequencyofmonitoringtoevery3days
• Discon4nuetherapy*• Increasefrequencyofmonitoringtoevery1-2days
• 1.0to2.0mg/kg/daymethylprednisoloneIVorIVequivalent**
• Addprophylac4can4bio4csforopportunis4cinfec4ons
• Consultgastroenterologist
Follow-up
• Con4nueLFTmonitoringperprotocolIfworsens:• Treatasgrade2or3-4
Ifreturnstobaseline:• Resumerou4nemonitoring,resumeI-OtherapyperprotocolIfeleva4onspersist>5-7daysorworsen:• 0.5-1mg/kg/daymethylprednisoloneororalequivalentandwhenLFTreturnstograde1orbaseline,ortapersteroidsoveratleast1month,considerprophylac4can4bio4csforopportunis4cinfec4ons,andresumeI-Otherapyperprotocol
Ifreturnstograde2:• Tapersteroidsoveratleast1month
Ifdoesnotimprovein>3-5days,worsensorrebounds• Addmycophenolatemofe4l1gBID• Ifnoresponsewithinanaddi4onal3-5days,considerotherimmunosuppressantsperlocalguidelines
>:3#.%#$U3#,-$;/,/6#+#,-$
=6<?*)<DN'!//'7/59"'KLGQ'
A.#3#,-$
>,4?$'*0/-#$
'
B#-#'-$'
!.#/-$'
;(,*-(.$
>:3#.%#$U3#,-$;/,/6#+#,-$
=6<?*)<DN'!//'7/59"'KLGQ'
A.#3#,-$
>,4?$'*0/-#$
'
B#-#'-$'
!.#/-$'
;(,*-(.$
Prevent-1
• Knowtheimmune-toxicityspectrum->considerrareirAE:• Nervoussystem(e.gPN,meningites/encepahalias,Guillan-Barresyndrome)• Hematology(e.g.hemolyacanemia,thrombocyto-,neutro-,pancytopenia)• Musculo-aracularsystem(e.g.arthrias,myopathies)• Heart(e.g.pericardias,myocardias)• Eyes(e.g.uveias,conjuncavias,blepharias,reanias,orbitalmyosias)
• Tumoralinfiltra4on->pulmonarylymphangias,carcinomatousmeningiasé
• Opportunis4cpathogens
->considerhistoryofpreviousinfecaonsandriskforviralinfecaons(e.g.HIV,viralhepaaas)
• Co-medica4ons
->anaarrhythmics,anahypertensives,anabioacs,anaconvulsantsoranapsychoacs
Prevent-2
• Iden4fydys-immunityriskfactors->personalandfamiliarhistoryofautoimmunediseases• digesave(Crohn’sdisease,ulceraavecolias,celiacdisease)• skin(psoriasis)• rheumaac(spondyloarthraas,rheumatoidarthrias,lupus)• endocrine(diabetes,thyroidias)• respiratory(intersaaalpneumonias,sarcoidosis)• pancreaac(pancreaaas)• kidney(nephrias)• hematological(hemolyacanemia,immunologicthrombocytopenicpurpura)• neurological(myasthenia,mulaplesclerosis)• eye(uveias,sclerias,reanias)• cardiovascular(heartfailure,lerventricularsystolicdysfuncaon,myocardias)
Prevent-3
• Informpa4entsandtheirhealthcareproviders->avoidself-management->newsymptomshouldberapidlyreportedwithoutdelay->reacaonsmayoccuratanyame•Digesave:diarrhea,bloodormucusinthestool,severeabdominalpain•Endocrine:faague,weightloss,nausea,vomiang,thirstorappeateincrease,polyuria•Skin:extensiverash,severepruritus•Respiratory:shortnessofbreath,coughing•Neurological:headache,confusion,muscleweakness,numbness•Arthralgiaorswellingjoints•Myalgia•Unexplainedfever•Hemorrhagicsyndrome•Severelossofvisioninoneorbotheyes
Prevent-4
• Pa4entswithspecificcondi4ons• Elderly
->nodifferenceinsafety(>65yrs,nodoseadjustment)• Renalandhepa9cimpairment
->nodata,nodoseadjustment(ie.>30ml/min,bilirubin>ULNto1.5N)• Pregnancyandbreast-feeding
->maycausefetalharmincludingaboraon,sallbirthorprematuredelivery• Paaentswithhistoryofchronicinfecaon
->limiteddata,hepaactoxicityincreased• Pa9entswithhistoryofauto-immunediseases
->limiteddata,monitorcloselyandwithinaninterdisciplinaryteam
20*7*+&+/9$*,$0/4#,-%$L*-"$0.##`*%4,6$/&-(*++&,#$:*%(.:#.%$
W96/,9/N'W!4!'7/59"'KLGQ'
20*7*+&+/9$*,$0/4#,-%$L*-"$0.##`*%4,6$/&-(*++&,#$:*%(.:#.%$
W96/,9/N'W!4!'7/59"'KLGQ'
>:3#.%#$U3#,-$;/,/6#+#,-$
=6<?*)<DN'!//'7/59"'KLGQ'
A.#3#,-$
>,4?$'*0/-#$
'
B#-#'-$'
!.#/-$'
;(,*-(.$
An4cipate
• ImmunotherapybaselinechecklistPhysicalexamina4on:•performancestatus,weight,size,BMI•heartrate&bloodpressure•generalsymptoms•pre-exisangsymptoms:intesanaltransit,dyspnea/coughing,rash,nausea,headaches,signsofmotororsensoryneuropathyandarthralgia•historyoffeverorrecentinfecaon•baselineelectrocardiogram
Laboratorytest:•CompleteCBC,Serumelectrolytes•Totalbilirubin,AST,ALT,GGT,PAL•Albuminemia,CRP•TSH,T4•(Corasol,ACTH,LH,FSH,estradioltestosterone)•(Proteinuria,Urinarysediment)•(Virology,Auto-anabodies)Imaging:• CTscan(e.g.thorax)
• Duringtreatment• CBC,renal/liverfuncaon,serumelectrolytes,glycaemia,CRP• TSH/proteinuriaevery2months• No“rouane”imaging
>:3#.%#$U3#,-$;/,/6#+#,-$
A.#3#,-$
>,4?$'*0/-#$
'
B#-#'-$'
!.#/-$'
;(,*-(.$
Detect-1
• Ruleoutdiseaseprogression• Orenmostlikelycauseforsymptoms
• Ruleoutotherevents• e.g.infecton,paraneoplasacthrombosis
• AlwaysconsiderirAE:• Earlytoxiciaes(e.g.skin5weeks,gastrointesanal7.3weeks,hepaac7.7weeks)• Latetoxiciaes(e.g.pulmonary8.9weeks,endocrine10.4weeks,renal15.1weeks)• However:largeconfidenceintervals!!
• Considerbaselinevaluesasreference
B#-#'-$?T$
•! <(,%*:#.$:*D#.#,4/7$:*/6,(%*%'
B#-#'-$?$M$
MM'
KL##-u%$%1,:.(+#$*,$/$0/4#,-$L*-"$+#-/%-/4'$+#7/,(+/$/l#.$*0*7*+&+/9$-"#./01$
>:3#.%#$U3#,-$;/,/6#+#,-$
A.#3#,-$
>,4?$'*0/-#$
'
B#-#'-$'
!.#/-$'
;(,*-(.$
Treat
• Cor4costeroidmodality->ruleoutanyinfecaon->consideranabioacprophylaxisandtesangfortuberculosis->generallyapplycoracosteroidsoveraperiodofatleastonemonth,slowtapering
• Resume/terminateimmunotherapy->generallyconsiderdelayingtherapyforproperdiagnosis->definitelydisconanueincaseofadverseimmunedysfuncaon -life-threatening(Grade4) -severe(Grade3)andrecurring -moderate(Grade2)butnotresolvedinthreemonthsdespitetreatment->endocrinopathiescontrolledbyhormonereplacementtherapydonotrequireterminaaonofimmunotherapy->resumeimmunotherapy: -ifthesideeffectisstabilized≤Grade1AND -ifthesteroiddoseisreducedto≤10mg/dprednisonorequivalentAND -intheabsenceofotherimmunosuppressivedrugs
• Considerorganspecialistreferral
R@)N'W>X='KLGU''
A(%%*9*7*-1$()$(00(.-&,*%4'$*,)#'4(,$
>:3#.%#$U3#,-$;/,/6#+#,-$
A.#3#,-$
>,4?$'*0/-#$
'
B#-#'-$'
!.#/-$'
;(,*-(.$
;(,*-(.$
•! 5#%(7&4(,$I*,#4'%$()$:1%*++&,#$-(`*'*4#%$
X6%'3%:)//)/:'</&'%/&'9#'%<56'5+$Y%'$%*$%,%/D'D6%'?%&)</'a?%'D9'9/,%D'</&'?%&)</'a?%'X9'$%,9"+a9/N'$%,*%5aY%"@E'B<56'*%<8'$%j%5D,'D6%')/5)&%/5%E'
V%3%$N'!C=7'KLGQ'
!*+#$-($*.>U%$V/,4?AB?C[$
S$%%?</dR%""%$'#-%&,A%B,12%B&26#'%<#$#&'6"%KLGQ'
;(,*-(.$
•! 2+0/'-$()$*++&,(%&00.#%%/,-%$(,$(&-'(+#$
C&2(0&'D%/.%6/''#,&-#$%/.%/8#'&,,%$)'818&,%12%3&9#2-$%-'#&-#(%=1-"%131,10)0&+%
.9$Y<DN'W=7'KLGQ'1%):6"N'V=1='KLGQ'
'
E;F?G!;:HHI%J%K-#'/1(%L$#%&2(%G)-6/0#%
_9^/%@'A%B,12%B&26#'%<#$#&'6"%KLLf'
*.>U%$&,:#.$*0*7*+&+/9$/,:$'(..#7/4(,$L*-"$%&.3*3/7$
S$%%?</dR%""%$'#-%&,A%B,12%B&26#'%<#$#&'6"%KLGQ'
*.>U%$&,:#.$,*3(7&+/9$/,:$'(..#7/4(,$L*-"$%&.3*3/7$
S$%%?</dR%""%$'#-%&,A%B,12%B&26#'%<#$#&'6"%KLGQ'
<&-/,#(&%$*.>U%$/,:$'(..#7/4(,$L*-"$%&.3*3/7$
Toxici4esofemergingcombina4onimmunotherapies
77
fH'
U3(73*,6$%1,#.6*%4'$'(+9*,/4(,%$()$$*++&,(-"#./0*#%$
fH' Chapman, NEJM 2015
\<*)&'B$<&)5<a9/'9#'<'A+"8@'4%"</9?<'4<,,'^)D6'7/%'_9,%'9#'=X1!dUIm_dG'59?3)/<a9/'
Slide 14
Jedd Wolchok at 2015 ASCO Annual Meeting
<"#'I;/-#$Q]Z?$20*$v$X*3($)(.$+#7/,(+/$
Slide 10
Michael Postow at 2015 ASCO Annual Meeting
K/)#-1$
Treatment-Related Select AEs Reported in <br />!10% of Patients
!.#/-+#,-?.#7/-#:$%#7#'-$>U%$.#0(.-#:$*,$eCQb$
Michael Postow at 2015 ASCO Annual Meeting
Time to Onset of Grade 3/4 Treatment-related Select AEs<br />Patients receiving nivolumab + ipilimumab or ipilimumab alone
Presented By Michael Postow at 2015 ASCO Annual Meeting
HO'
20*7*+&+/9$07&%$%/.6./+(%4,#$3%$*0*7*+&+/9$/7(,#$)(.$-.#/-+#,-$()$+#-/%-/4'$+#7/,(+/$
Hodi, JAMA 2014
A$Y$QPQMh$
HU'
X$%<D?%/Dd$%"<D%&':$<&%,'OdQ'D9k)5)D@'3@'D9k)5)D@'5<D%:9$@%
A$Y$QPQ@Z$
20*7*+&+/9$07&%$%/.6./+(%4+$3%$*0*7*+&+/9$/7(,#$)(.$-.#/-+#,-$()$+#-/%-/4'$+#7/,(+/_$/$0"/%#$22$%-&:1'
.9&)N'W!4!'KLGU'
A$Y$QPQMQ$
Melanoma NSCLC RCC
Schedule
CheckMate0674xI3N1Q3W,thenN3Q2W
CheckMate012I1Q6W,N3Q2W
CheckMate0164xI1N3Q3W,thenN3Q2W
ResponseRate
57.6%
39%
43%
Toxicity,AEGrade3/4
68.7%
28%
23.8%
Ipilimumab(I)Nivolumab(N)combinaaons
Ipilimumab(I)Nivolumab(N)combinaaonRCC
Hammersetal,ASCO2014
Toxici4esofcombina4onsofimmunotherapieswithtargetedtherapies
87
HH'
U3(73*,6$%1,#.6*%4'$'(+9*,/4(,%$()$-/.6#-#:$*++&,(-"#./0*#%$
!/.6#-#:$-"#./0*#%$
2++&,#$'"#'I0(*,-$97('I/:#$X(3#7$-"#./0*#%$N$'(+9*,/4(,%$
K&.3*3/7$
!*+#$
<(,-.(7$
4%"%$9'#-%&,E'N'P<D'\%Y'=</5%$'KLGQ'
HJ'
20*7*+&+/9$07&%$:/'/.9/S*,#$)(.$0.#3*(&%71$&,-.#/-#:$+#-/%-/4'$+#7/,(+/P$
.9&)N'PBW4'KLGL'
Ribasetal.,NEJM2013
Hepatotoxicitywithcombina9onofvemurafenibundipilimumab
Evolvingsynergis4ccombina4onsoftargetedimmunotherapies
A"/%#$C$-.*/7_$/,4?AB?=C$V:&.3/7&+/9[$:/9./)#,*9$/,:$-./+#4,*9$
JG' m$%,%/D%&'3@'!/D9/)'\)3<,'!C=7'KLGQ'
Response
92 PresentedbyAntoniRibasASCO2015
Select drug-related adverse events of interest
Antoni Ribas at 2015 ASCO Annual Meeting
Safety
94
Bevacizumabplusipilimumabinpa4entswithmetasta4cmelanoma
Hodi, Cancer Immunol. Research 2014
JQ'
c#3/'*S&+/9$07&%$*0*7*+&+/9$*,$0/4#,-%$L*-"$+#-/%-/4'$+#7/,(+/$
Hodi, Cancer Immunol. Research 2014
C1.#:-"'#&-#212*%O*'&(#%PQ%&2(%$#8#'#%O*'&(#%RQ%-'#&-0#2-:'#,&-#(%&(8#'$#%
#8#2-$%
Summary-combina4ontherapies
- Highresponserates- Unexpectedtoxiciaes- Combinaaonshavetobetestedinearlyphasetrials
- Guidelinesandmanagementoftreatmentshavetobeadaptedtoeachcombinaaon
96