Top Banner
- Sudipta Dassupta Chamber Advocate Ifigh Court, Cafcutta. Residence Bar Association Room No. 16 To I The Government Pleader High Court, Calcutta 2. The Secretary, West Bengal Board of Primary Education, Acharya Profulla Chandra Bhavan, DK-7/1, Sector-II, Salt Lake, Kolkata- 700 091 3. National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) Service through its Chairporson, Hans Bhawan, Wing-II, 1 Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg New Delhi- 110002 10, K.S.Roy Road, rd Floor, Room no. 35, (Mezzanine) Kolkata- 700 001 65/5,Jyotish Roy Road, New Alipore, Kolkata- 700 053, Mobile : 9432977913 Date: January 14, 2021 I Re: W.P.A No./ 5,3 gof 2020 Sweta Mahanta & Ors State of West Bengal & Ors Dear Sir, Enclosed please find a copy of the Writ Petition along with all annexure in the above matter. Please note that the above matter has been filed before this Hon'ble Court for being listed before the Hon'ble Justice Rajarshi Bharadwaj on lif h January 2021; or so soon thereafter as and when the business of the Hon'ble Court may permit. Kindly make it convenient to be present at the time of hearing. Yours truly, Advocate Enclo: as above
76

- Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

Jan 15, 2023

Download

Documents

Khang Minh
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

- Sudipta Dassupta

Chamber

Advocate Ifigh Court, Cafcutta. Residence Bar Association Room No. 16

To I The Government Pleader

High Court, Calcutta 2. The Secretary,

West Bengal Board of Primary Education, Acharya Profulla Chandra Bhavan, DK-7/1, Sector-II, Salt Lake, Kolkata- 700 091

3. National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) Service through its Chairporson, Hans Bhawan, Wing-II, 1 Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg New Delhi- 110002

10, K.S.Roy Road, rd Floor, Room no. 35, (Mezzanine) Kolkata- 700 001 65/5,Jyotish Roy Road, New Alipore, Kolkata- 700 053, Mobile : 9432977913

Date: January 14, 2021

I Re: W.P.A No./ 5,3 gof 2020 Sweta Mahanta & Ors

State of West Bengal & Ors Dear Sir,

Enclosed please find a copy of the Writ Petition along with all annexure in the above matter. Please note that the above matter has been filed before this Hon'ble Court for being listed before the Hon'ble Justice Rajarshi Bharadwaj on lifh January 2021; or so soon thereafter as and when the business of the Hon'ble Court may permit.

Kindly make it convenient to be present at the time of hearing.

Yours truly,

Advocate Enclo: as above

Page 2: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

DISTRICT: 24 PARGANAS (NORTH)

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA

CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION

APPELLATE SIDE

W.P.A No. /538 of 2021;

Subject matter relating to:

Under Group- II ; Head -

of the classification List kbe)t 4211^-Ntril Cekojit-A P(4-61 157g

Ca se - tle

SWETA MAI-IANTA & ORS

PETITIONERS

VS

STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS

RESPONDENTS

[IL

Advocate on record

MR. SUDIPTA DASGUPTA, Advocate

10, Kira Sankar Roy Road, Room no.35 (Mezzanine Floor) Kolkata- 700 001. Mob: 9432977913. [email protected]

Page 3: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

DISTRICT 24 PARGANAS (NORTH)

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA

CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION

APPELLATE SIDE

W.P.A No. 1538 of 2021;

In the matter of:

An application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,

And

In the matter of;

SWETA MAHANTA & ORS PETITIONERS

VS STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS

RESPONDENTS INDEX

Si. No. Particulars of Document Annexure Pages

1. Writ petition

1-18 2. True mark sheet the petitioners p-i

13-5_5 3. True copy of the said notification. P-2

54-53 4. True copy of the said order. P-3 Ko 5. True copy of the said notification. P-4 61 6. True copy of the said guideline and notification P-5

62 -it dated 23rd August 2010

Page 4: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

DISTRICT: 24 PARGANAS (NORTH)

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA

CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION

APPELLATE SIDE

W.P.A No. /538 of 2021 In The Matter Of: -

An application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India;

-And- IN THE MATTER OF SWETA MAHANTA & ORS

PETITIONERS

VS

STATE OF WEST BENGAL & ORS

RESPONDENTS

LIST OF DATES

23.08.2010 NCTE laid down minimum qualification

11.02.2011 NCTE issued guideline for conducting TET.

12.05.2017 West Bengal Board of Primary Education published advertisement for conducting TET 2017

30.06.2017 Petitioners have been released from two years diploma in elementary education course, the same being over.

09.10.2017 West Bengal Board of Primary Education published on line application for conducting TET 2017

14.11.2017 Respondent authorities modified earlier notification allowing all pursuing students to sit for TET 2017

31.01.2021 TET 2017 to be held .

Page 5: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

POINTS OF LAW

WHETHER THE ACTION ON THE PART OF THE RESPONDENT AUTHORITIES IN NOT ALLOWING THE PETITIONERS TO APPLY FOR TET 2017 IN VIOLATION OF NCTE GUIDELINE IS JUSTICIABLE IN THE EYE OF LAW?

Page 6: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

DISTRICT: NORTH 24 PARGANAS

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA

CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION

APPELLATE SIDE

W.P.A. NO. / 5 3 8 OF 2021;

In the matter of:

An application under Article 226 of the

Constitution of India;

-And-

In the matter of:

1. SWETA MAHANTA daughter of

Subhas Mohanta, residing at

Rajganj Bakercihar, District- Purba

Burdwan, Pin- 713102.

2. ANTARA BHUL daughter of

Baidyanath Bhul, residing at Village

and Post office- Bamunari, Police

Station- Dankuni, District- Hooghly,

Pin- 712250.

3. BONASHREE ADAK daughter of

Mahadev Adak, residing at Village

and Post Office- Ramnagar, District-

Hooghly, Pin- 712410.

Page 7: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

2

4. SOUMEN GHOSH son of Akhil

Bandhu Ghosh, residing at Village-

Moheshpur, Post office-Jagalgori,

Police Station- Jangipara, District-

Hooghly, Pin- 712403.

5. ANKITA DAS daughter of Samir Das,

residing at 9/3, Naskar Para 1st Bye

Lane, Howrah, Post office-

Santragachi Police Station- Shibpur,

Pin- 711104.

6. BAPPA SARKAR son of late Gopal

Chandra Sarkar, residing at Village

and Post office- Sankari, Police

Station-IChandaghosh, District-

Purba Bardhaman, Pin-713424.

7. BIBEK SARKAR son of Haripada

Sarkar, residing at No. 064, Barua,

Sijgram, Rajganj, Uttar Dinajpur,

Pin- 733134.

8. POULOMI SARKAR HALDER wife of

Udayan Haider, residing at 38,

Sonargaon Busing Cooperating

Society, Teghoria, Sonarpur,

Narendrapur Station Road, Post

office- R.K. Pally, Police Station-

Narendrapur, District- South 24

Parganas, Pin- 700 150.

9. SUBIR KUMAR MANDAL son of

Madhusudhan Mandal, residing at

Page 8: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

3

Birkhat, Mahisbathan, West Bengal,

Pin- 733123.

10. MONIDEEPA KUNDU, daughter of

Sailendranath Kundu, residing at

Mirzanagar, Boso, Daniakhali,

District- Hooghly, Pin-712302.

11. RAKESH PANJA son of Amarendra

Nath Panja, residing at Village and

Post office- Bajekumarpur, District-

Purba Bardhaman, Pin- 713427. pt/xi

12. PAPAYA GHOSH daughter of Subal

Chandra Ghosh, residing at A11/1

Anandangar, Dakshin Behala Road,

Sarsuna, District- South 24

Parganas, pin- 700 061.

13. PRIYA BOXI daughter of Tapas

Boxi, residing at Naya Basat,

Nayabasat, District- Paschim

Medinipur, Pin- 721257.

... PETITIONERS

-VERSUS-

1. THE STATE OF WEST BENGAL,

Department of Education, Service

through its Secretary, 9th Floor,

Bikash Bhavan, Salt Lake,

Kolkata- 700 091.

2. WEST BENGAL BOARD OF

PRIMARY Education, service

through the Secretary, having its

Page 9: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

4

office at Acharya Profulla

Chandra Bhavan, DK-7 / 1,

Sector-II, Salt Lake, Kolkata- 700

091.

3. THE SECRETARY, West Bengal

Board of Primary Education,

having its office at Acharya

Profulla Chandra Bhavan, DK-

7/ 1, Sector-II, Salt Lake, Kolkata-

700 091.

4. THE PRESIDENT, West Bengal

Board of Primary Education,

having its office at Acharya

Profulla Chandra Bhavan, DK-

7/1, Sector-II, Salt Lake, Kolkata-

700 091.

5. NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR

TEACHER EDUCATION (NCTE),

service through its Chairperson,

Hans Bhawan, Wing-II, 1,

Bahadur Shah Zafar, Marg New

Delhi- 110002.

6. EASTERN REGIONAL

COMMITTEE, National Council

for Teacher Education (NCTE)

service through the Regional

Director, having its office 15,

Neelkanth Nagar, Nayapally,

Bhubhanswar,- 751012.

7. THE REGIONAL DIRECTOR,

Eastern Regional Committee,

Page 10: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

5

National Council for Teacher

Education (NCTE)having its office

15, Neelkanth Nagar Nayapally,

Bhubhanswar,- 751012.

RESPONDENTS To,

The Hon'ble Thottathil B Radhakrishnan, Chief Justice and His

Companion Justices of The said Hon'ble Court.

The humble petition on behalf of the

petitioners above named most

respectfully -

SHEWETH:

1. Your petitioners are citizen of India and residing at the address

given in the cause title above.

2. Your petitioners state that your petitioners have passed out

Higher Secondary Education with 50% and above marks and/or

Graduation and also have passed 2 years Diploma in Elementary

Education from Colleges recognized by National Council for Teacher

Education (hereinafter referred to as NCTE) and affiliated to the West

Bengal Board of Primary Education and are eligible for appearing in

Teacher Eligibility Test (hereinafter referred to as TET 2017.

True mark sheet of the petitioners are annexed hereto and

collectively marked with letter "P-1".

3. Your petitioners state that all of the petitioners have completed

the 2 years Diploma in Elementary Education Courses for the sessions

2018 -2020.

4. Your petitioners state that respondent no.3 vide a notification no.

1167/BPE/2017 have notified for conducting Teacher Eligibility Test

(TET) 2017 for classes I to V in terms of order of the Department of

School Education, Government West Bengal vide its memo no. 287-

Page 11: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

6

SE/(EE)/10M-6/2009 Pt-I(TET) dated 17.04.2017 read with no. 343-

SE/EE/10M-6/2009 Pt-I(TET) dated 12.05.2017

True copy of the said notification is annexed hereto and marked with

letter "P-2".

5. Your petitioners state that in the said notification it was interalia

specified that only those persons who have acquired the academic and

professional qualifications specified in the NCTE-Notification dated

23.08.2010 are eligible to apply for the TET, 2017. In the said

notification it was further interalia provided that only students who

have appeared in the final examination of two years training course will

only be eligible to appear as pursuing students.

6. Your petitioners state that under the facts and circumstances of

the case a writ petition was filed before this Hon'ble High Court, praying

interalia for a direction upon the respondents pursuing students of

training course who have taken admission to allow them to sit for TET

2017.

The aforesaid writ petition was taken up for hearing when by an order

dated October 27, 2017 His Lordship the Hon'ble Justice Arijit Banerjee

was interalia pleased to pass following order:

Accordingly, without prejudice to the rights and

contentions of the parties in these writ petitions, the

petitioners are permitted to apply for participating in TET,

2017. The respondent authorities shall accept such

applications if made within the prescribed date. This will not

create any equity or right in favour of the petitioners and

this interim order is subject to the final result of the writ

petition. If the petitioners participate in TET, 2017, their

result will not be published without the leave of the Court.

Further, the benefit of this interim order shall be available

Page 12: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

7

only to the petitioners who are before me by way of the

present writ petitions and to nobody else.

Subsequently the respondent authorities issued a notification

being Memo no. 2744/BPE/2017 dated 14.11.2017 modifying the

earlier notification to the effect of allowing all pursuing students of

training course to sit for TET 2017 and in view thereof, the

aforesaid writ petition was disposed off.

True copy of the order is annexed hereto and marked with letter

"P-3"

7. Your petitioners states that petitioners approached the

respondent authorities to allow them to sit for TET 2017 as they have

completed their training and since examination will be held on January

31, 2021, but the respondent authorities refused the prayer of the petitioners.

8. Your petitioners states that the respondent authorities has issued

a notification declaring that TET 2017 will be conducted on January 31,

2021 but surprisingly have not allowed the petitioners to participate in

TET 2017, although they are eligible.

True copy of the notification is annexed hereto and marked with letter "P-4"

9. Your petitioners state that eligibility criteria for appearing in TET

as stated in notification no. 1167/BPE/2017 dated 12th May 2017 in

terms of the order of the Department of School Education Government

of West Bengal vide a memo no. 287-SE(EE)/10M-6/2009 Pt-I(TET)

dated. 17th April 2017 read with memo no. 343-SE/EE/10M-6/2009 Pt-I(TET) dated 12th May 2017 and Memo No. 2552/BPE/ dated 9th

October 2017 is in absolute violation of the National Council for Teacher

Education (NCTE) guidelines dated 11th February 2011 being no. 76- 4/2010/NCTE/Acad and also in complete violation of notification dated 23rd August 2010 issued by the NCTE.

Page 13: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

8

True copy of the said guideline and notification dated 23rd August 2010

are annexed herewith and collectively marked with letter "P-51).

10. Your petitioners state that notification no. 1167/BPE/2017 dated

12th May 2017 in terms of the Order of the Department of School

Education Government of West Bengal vide a memo no. 287-

SE(EE)/10M-6/2009 Pt-I(TET) dated 17th April 2017 read with memo

no. 343-SE/EE/10M-6/2009 Pt.-I(TET) dated 12th May 2017 and Memo

No. 2552/BPE/ dated 9th October 2017 issued by the West Bengal

Board of Primary Education has violated clause 5(ii) of the guideline

dated 11th February 2011 in as much notification no. 1167/BPE/2017

dated 12th May 2017 and notification dated October 9, 2017 have

interalia debarred the pursuing students of 2 years D.El.ed or 2 years

B.Ed. Special Education, for appearing in TET 2017.

11. Your petitioners state that eligibility criteria according to the

NCTE guideline dated 11th February 2011 is as follows:

i. A person who has acquired the academic and professional

qualifications specified in the NCTE Notification dated 23rd

August 2010.

ii. A persons who is pursuing any of the teacher education

courses (recognized by the NCTE or the RCI, as the case may

be) specified in the NCTE Notification dated 23rd August 2010. iii. The eligibility condition for appearing in TET may be relaxed in

respect of a State/UT which has been granted relaxation under

sub-section(2) of section 23 of the RTE Act. The relaxation will

be specified in the Notification issued by the Central

Government under that sub-section.

12. Your petitioners state that debarring the candidates for appearing

in TET 2017 who are pursuing any of the Teacher education courses

(recognized by NCTE or RCI as the case may be) specified in the NCTE

notification dated 23rd August 2010 is violative of Article 14, 19, 21 and

Page 14: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

9

21A of the Constitution of India and is also violative of Principle of

Natural justice.

13. Your petitioners states that any notification issued by the

respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 in violation of notification dated 23rd August

2010 and NCTE guideline dated 1191 February 2011 while conducting

Teacher Eligibility Test 2017 is liable to be set aside.

14. Your petitioners states that clause 11 of TET guideline interalia

provides that the appropriate Government should conduct a TET at

least once every year. The respondent authorities last conducted TET

2014 on October 11, 2015 and issued notification for conducting TET

2017 on January 31, 2021. It is clear from the aforesaid fact that the

respondent authorities have acted in violation of TET guideline and by

doing so have debarred the petitioners for applying to appear in TET

2017.

15. Your petitioners states that petitioners are not seeking to consider

of appointing them, they are merely praying for an opportunity to

participating in TET 2017 which is qualifying examination by nature.

Qualifying TET make a candidates eligible to appear for recruitment

process and the respondent authorities by not allowing the petitioners

to participate in TET 2017 are acting malafide inasmuch as the

respondent authorities are curtailing the rights of the petitioners to

appear recruitment process.

Be it mentioned here that TET has to be conducted at least once every

year but the respondent authorities have acted whimsically and in

violation of TET Guideline thereby prejudicing the right of the

petitioners.

It is further stated in this regard that the respondent authorities issued

a notification dated December 23, 2020 have interalia notified that TET

2014 candidates will be eligible apply for recruitment of Primary

Teacher. Since the respondent authorities did not conducted TET in

every year, petitioners could not participate in the recruitment process

Page 15: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

10

and as such the respondent authorities by acting in a nature which is

malafide as aforesaid has taken away the legitimate vested rights of the

petitioners and as such petitioner cannot be made to suffer for the

wrong committed by the respondent.

16. Your petitioners states that notification dated 12th May 2017 being no. 1167/BPE/2017 and Memo No. 2552/BPE/ dated 9th October

2017 is itself self contradictory in as much it has been interalia stated

that Teacher Eligibility Test (TET) 2017 for classes I to V, to be

conducted by the West Bengal Board of Primary Education as per the

NCTE guideline but in the instant case the respondent authorities are

acting in complete violation of TET guideline by not allowing the

petitioners to participate in TET 2017.

17. Your petitioner states that the West Bengal Board of primary

Education have deliberately failed to conduct TET every year and the

same has caused the petitioners to suffer irreparable loss and injury. 18. Your petitioners submit that according to NCTE Rules regulation

guideline Teacher Eligibility Test is a qualifying exam and it is not a

selection procedure. It is also submitted that qualifying TET shall not

confer right on the petitioners for getting appointment as primary Teachers.

19. Your petitioners state that unless the Hon'ble High Court allows

the petitioners to appear for Teacher Eligibility Test 2017 your

petitioners shall suffer irreparable loss and injury.

20. Your petitioners states that the respondent board is bound to

follow NCTE guideline for conducting TET inasmuch as the respondent

board has got no separate guideline for conducting TET and also they

have declared that TET will be conducted in terms of NCTE guideline. 21. Your petitioners state that your petitioners have a strong prima

fade case and balance of convenience and in convenience is in favour of

the petitioners and therefore if orders prayed in this writ petition is not

allowed your petitioners shall suffer irreparable loss and injury and the

Page 16: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

matter is extremely urgent as because the date of examination of TET

2017 is on 31st January 2021.

22. Being highly aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the impugned act

of the respondent authorities, your petitioners begs to move this

instant petition on the following :

GROUNDS I. FOR THAT the respondents authorities particularly the

respondents no. 1, 2 and 3 has miserably failed to perform the

statuary duties and discharge their bounded obligation as per as

the instant case concerned.

II. FOR THAT in the instant case the relevant Rules, Notification and

Guidelines for TET 2017 for Class Ito V have not been complied

with.

III. FOR THAT in the presence of specific guideline issued by the

National Council for Teacher Education for conduction the

Teacher Eligibility Test, the respondents concerned ought to have

followed the said guideline in as much as the respondents

concerned cannot bypass the said guideline and as such it is

incumbent upon the respondent concerned to abide by such

guideline prescribed by the National Council for Teacher Education.

IV. FOR THAT, petitioners have passed out Higher Secondary

Education with 50% and above marks and/or Graduation and

also have passed 2 years Diploma in Elementary Education from

Colleges recognized by National Council for Teacher Education

(hereinafter referred to as NCTE) and affiliated to the West Bengal

Board of Primary Education and are eligible for appearing in

Teacher Eligibility Test (hereinafter referred to as TET 2017 V. FOR THAT recently the secretary West Bengal board of primary

education have interalia published notification for on line

application for TET 2017 being Memo No. 2552/BPE/ dated 9th

Page 17: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

12

October 2017 wherein the pursuing students of 2015-2017 Batch

have been completely debarred from appearing in the said Exam.

VI. FOR THAT eligibility criteria for appearing in TET as stated in

notification no. 1167/BPE/2017 dated 12th May 2017 and Memo

No. 2552/BPE/ dated gth October 2017 is in absolute violation of

the National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) guidelines

dated 11th February 2011 being no. 76-4/ 2010/NCTE/Acad and also in violation of notification dated 23rd August 2010 issued by the NCTE.

VII. FOR THAT, respondent authorities issued a notification being

Memo no. 2744/BPE/ 2017 dated 14.11.2017 modifying the

earlier notification to the effect of allowing all pursuing

students of training course to sit for TET 2017.

VIII. FOR THAT, when your petitioners approach the respondent

authorities for filing up the application form they were told that as

and when notification for date of conducting TET 2017 will be

published, they will be allowed to fill the application form for

appearing in TET 2017 prior to the date of examination.

IX. FOR THAT, the respondent authorities has issued a notification

declaring that TET 2017 will be conducted on January 31, 2021

but surprisingly have not allowed the petitioners to participate in

TET 2017, although they are eligible.

X. FOR THAT, since the respondent authorities did not conducted

TET in every year, petitioners could not participate in the

recruitment process and as such the respondent authorities by

acting in a nature which is malafide as aforesaid, has taken away

the legitimate vested rights of the petitioners and as such

petitioner cannot be made to suffer for the wrong committed by the respondent.

iv

Page 18: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

13

XI. FOR THAT in terms of clause 5(ii) of the guidelines of the National

Council for Teacher Education dated February 11, 2011, the

petitioners are eligible and entitled to appear in Teacher Eligibility

Test (TET) 2017.

XII. FOR THAT any notification issued by the respondents no.1,2 and

3 in violation of notification dated 23rd August 2010 and NCTE guideline dated 11th February 2011 while conducting Teacher

Eligibility Test 2017 is liable to be set aside.

XIII. FOR THAT in the instant case the respondent authorities by not

allowing the petitioners to appear in TET 2017 are taking away

the vested right of the petitioners.

XIV. FOR THAT the action of the respondent authorities are illegal,

arbitrary and violative of Article 14, 19, 21 and 21A of the

Constitution of India.

XV. FOR THAT the acts impugned are otherwise bad in law and liable

to be interfered with by this Hon'ble Court.

23. That, your petitioner has not moved any other application on the

self same grounds and /or self same cause of action before this Hon'ble Court.

24. That your petitioner has demanded justice before the respondents

and further demand of justice will be a futile formality.

25. Your petitioner states that there are no other effective efficaous

alternative remedy other than to move before this Hon'ble Court under

Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

26. Your petitioners state that the instant writ petition is made

bonafide for the ends of justice.

In the circumstances stated above your

Petitioners most humbly pray that Your

Lordship would graciously be pleased to issue:-

Page 19: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

14

a. Leave dispensing with Rule 26 of The

Rules of High Court Calcutta relating

to Applications under Article 226 of

The Constitution of India;

b. A Writ in the nature of Mandamus

commanding the respondents and

each of them particularly the

respondents no.1, 2 and 3 to allow

the petitioners to appear in the

Teacher Eligibility Test (TET) 2017

examinations conducted by the

respondent no.3 in accordance with

the NCTE guideline dated 11th

February 2011 since the instant

petitioners have completed Teacher

Education courses (Recognized by

the NCTE or the RCI, as the case

may be);

c. A Writ in the nature of Mandamus

commanding the respondents and

each of them particularly the

respondents no.1, 2 and 3 to

cancel/quash/ rescind/ set aside

the Order of the Department of

School Education Government of

West Bengal vide a memo no. 287-

SE(EE)/10M-6/2009 Pt-I(TET) dated

17th April 2017 read with memo no.

343-SE/EE/ 10M-6 / 2009 Pt-I(TET)

Page 20: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

15

dated 12th May 2017 dated 12th May

2017 and Memo No. 2552/BPE/

dated 9th October 2017.

d. A Writ in the nature of Mandamus

commanding the respondents and

each one of them particularly the

respondents no. 1, 2 and 3 to

withdraw/cancel/quash/ rescind/

set aside the advertisement and/or

public notice dated May 12, 2017

and Memo No. 2552/BPE/ dated 9th

October 2017 and issue a fresh

notice strictly in accordance with the

Rules and Notification and guideline

prescribed by the National Council

for the Teacher Education.

e. A Writ in the nature of Mandamus

commanding the respondents and

each of them particularly the

respondents no.3 to declare that

petitioners are eligible to appear in

TET 2017 in accordance with NCTE

guideline dated 11th February 2011

being no. 76-4/2010/NCTE/Acad.

f. A writ in the nature of Certiorari

directing the respondents, to certify

and transmit the entire records

relating to the case so that

Page 21: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

16

conscionable justice may be

administered to your petitioner;

g. Rule NISI in terms of prayers (a), (b),

(c), (d), (e) and (I)

h. An order directing the respondents

authorities, particularly the

respondents no.3 to allow the

petitioners to appear in the Teacher

Eligibility Test (TET) 2017 pursuant

to memo no. 1167/BPE/2017 dated

12th May 2017 and Memo No.

2552/BPE/ dated 9th October 2017

and in terms of Order of the

Department of School Education

Government of West Bengal vide a

memo no. 287-SE(EE)/10M-6/2009

Pt-I(TET) dated 17th April 2017.

i. An order restraining the respondents

authorities, particularly the

respondents no.3 from giving any

effect and/or further effect to the

public Notice dated May 12, 2017

dated 12th May 2017 and Memo No.

2552/BPE/ dated 9th October 2017.

j. Ad-interim order in terms of prayer

(h), and (i).

k. Costs of and incidental to this

application be paid by the

respondent.

Page 22: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

17

1. And any other further order or

orders as Your Lordship may deem

fit and proper for the ends of justice.

And for this act of kindness your Petitioner as in duty bound shall ever

pray.

I, certify that petitioner no. `is duly authorized to sign and affirm this affidavit for self and on behalf of the others petitioners.

Advocate

0,

H-0 ° 1 . mat

Page 23: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

rtii Advocate

I, ANKITA DAS daughter of Samir Das, aged abourt-P.. years by faith-

Hindu, by occupation- unemployed, residing at 9/3, Naskar Para 1st

Bye Lane, Howrah, Post office- Santragachi Police Station- Shibpur, Pin-

711104, do hereby solemnly affum and say as follows:-

1. That I am the petitioner no. 5 herein, as such I am fully

acquainted with the facts and circumstances of the case. I

have been duly authorized to sign and affirm this affidavit on

behalf of the others respondents. I am competent to sign this

affidavit.

2. That the statements made in paragraphs 1, to 11 are

true to my knowledge and the rest are my respectful

submissions before this Hon'ble Court.

Otglra. Prepared in my office The deponent is known to me

Certified that all annexure are legible

(+1 Advocate

Solemnly affirmed before me on

this the day of January, 2021.

C MMISSIONER

f AiSclavit aissiorer Side Com— Appf,fate, -

15# eflanctia'

Page 24: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

f ---19-

DIPLOMA-IN-ELEMENTARY EDUCATION COURSE PRi

ce;--vvfr7

r?„,,e-z.,•::: h

)1 y .. • n

on tht.,. 4./e 11—• • •

( I Amone

f

Session: 2018-2020 index No, : 030238

of the

Name of the

cite: DISTRICT INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION AND TRAINING, BURDWAN

SWETA MOHANTA ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ,,, ,,,,,,,,,,, ndiat tle : .......... .....

SUBHAS MOHANTA 3ThEiri Daughter of :

18032910238 Registration No. 2018

fiz• 4.14; SECRETARY

Page 25: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

DK 7/1! Sector II, f Salt Lake, kolkata -

Reset

18032910238 20032211 0184 PASSED

•-•

Candidate's Registration Number *:

18' :1._ '1 ;

Candiciate's Roll *:

20032211

Candidate's No.*:

Page 26: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

SWETA

164153441014 ; 154153441017 201S

RATHTALA NANOHARDAS VI DYANI KETAN

4153

HOME - SCIENCE HSCH

BEN? ' 43/B 20 20/0 A-7/3+

ENG2 00 34/C 20 20/0 54/2

COW 0 10 10/0 80/A+

HPMG SO 32/A 40 37/0 10 10/0 25/A+

6I OH 70 25/P 30 27/0 521E

DTC2 70 64/0 30 27/0 91/0

PHFA 50 47/0 1 40 35/A+ 10 10/0 92/0

ENST BO 47/B 20 20/0 67/B+

226

500

rya

411

82.20 /

Nag, 2017'

Page 27: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC
Page 28: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

Candidate's Registration Number

18072511478

Page 29: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

REF.11irr PASSED

ot.TRALL GRADE 8+

COMPULSOR

fiNGA LOG 60713-t.

ENO i3 100 41/e+

.

• COMPULSORY ELECTIVE i ____

I;EQD . cr 20 ,1 24 6 r: SUB+

I

PHIL ; 100 30 I 64/2 1

SNSK 0

74/A r

oPTIoN AL ELECTIA

HIST LOG

ENVE 130 ( Tq TA E_)36

I---

4U

49 es

(EIGHTY FIVE)

GRAND TOTAL 30E

74

(SEVENTY FOUR

(SIXTY SIX) ______ _____

, 64

XTY

r;r:rr r__

TY THREE.11

FOURiI 2.1-

60

SIXTti 2-1.

i

-

INS' JR FION

WEST

BENGAL COUNCIL OF flIGHER SECONDARY EDUCATION 1)1

COOL

MARK-SHEET 11709;7

2012 THE FOLLOWING IS THE STATEMENT OF MARKS AND GRADE OBTAINED BY

• ANTARA

ROLL 211721 No. Cre66 AT THE HIGHER SECONDARY F.XA MINATION 2012.

FL L L MARKS I PASS MARKS MARKS/GRADE TOTAL SUBJECTS ;THEORY; PRACTICAL 1 THEORY I /ORAL/ I

PRACTICAL I THEORY

PRACTICAL IN FIGURES /ORAL/ r

SUBJECT l ' I PROJECT GRADE it-, I

'PROJECT —COMPULSORY LANGUAGE PROJECT IN WORDS

1323-9395 Higher Secondary ExEmination

/114/1 koC(11

DEPUTY SFCR TT A g Y icY NA TNT A Minx 7%

PL EASF SEE REVERSE

Page 30: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

STITUTION CODE

1171SS

No.

THE FOLLOWING IS THE STATEMENT OF MARKS AND GRADE OBTAINED BY

BONASHREE An.h.;

OF FiVaINEF NGAL

MARK-SHEET 7 Higher Secondary aamirat to!'

2014

ROLL 211221 No. 0 7 61 AT THE HIGHER SECONDARY EXAMINATION 2014

FULL MARKS PASS MA MARKS/GRADE TOTAL SUBJECTS

zr THEORY PRACTICAL

/ORAL/ THEORY PRACTICAL

/ORAL) /ORAL/ THEORY PRACTICAL IN FIGURES

GRADE SUBJECT

PROJECT PROJECT PROJECT IN WORDS COMPULSORY LANGUAGE

N

ENGA 100 70/A L 7° I

LSE

vENTY) )

ENGE 100 C 48 -

(FORTY EIGHT) I

= COMPULSORY ELECTIVE

is FiC4R 30 20 7 S2/13+ 19/0 71

(SEVENTY ONE)

HIST 100 30 70/A 70

C SEVENTY ) A

SNSK 100 64/E+ I 64

(SIXTY FOUR)

OPTIONAL ELECTIVE

FOLS 100 8/C 48

(FORTY EIGHT) C.

COMPULSORY

ETIVE 10 ..v-7-

40 64

(SIXTY FOUR`

GRAND TOTAL 323 I

Page 31: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

ion: 201s-2020 indeS

• •••••' •••• ••'••••••:

e of the Candidate 11°SH

ARBIL BANDHU GHOST SOD WU*" of :

Registration No la 9,71111487

- - Bengal Board of Primary Education Acharya ?tallith Chandra Bhavan, DK 7/1, Sector - II,

Bidhannagar, Koikata 700 091

DIPLOMA-IN-ELEMENTARY EDUCATION COURSE

I Registration Certificate::

Page 32: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

40 1111•1

4G 1§10:15 •

RESULT OF D.EL.ED PART -EXAMINATION OF THE SESSION - 2018-

Candidate's Registration Number*:

18071111487

Candidate's Roil *:

18071111

Candidate's No. *:

1349

Submit

Reset

18071111487

18071111 1349

PASSED

Risci.Jaitirr• S FULLY

LTE2

Page 33: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

1o17 2018-2020 071517

SUPTENDU MEMORIAL D.ED. COLLEGE,HOOGHLY

ANKITA DAS

SAMIll DAS / 0;04,

18072111517 2018 Fr „ . ,

Page 34: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

RESULT

Ci

Q A .bbprimaryeducation.org

Candidate's Registration Number

18072111517

Candidate's Roll *:

2007

Candidate's No.*:

0525

18072111517 20072211 0525 PASSED

Page 35: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

WEST BENGAL COUNCIL OF HIGHER SECONDARY EDUCATION I,

mARK-sHEET 2_ Higher Secondary gxaminatioa 1 1

2011 THE FOLLOWING IS THE STATEMENT OF MARKS AND GRADE OBTAINED BY

ANB I TA DAS

ROLL 420921

No. 0472 AT THE HIGHER SECONDARY EXAMINATION

FULL MARKS PASS MARKS MARKS/GRADE i iyDy,,,L,..

St..IBJECTS THEORY pRACTICAL /ORAI/

THEORY PRACTICAL /ORAL/

THEORY PRACTICAL! IN HytJREe

PROJECT PROJECT PROJECT INIAipitttS;! COMPULSORY

i iL iANGUAGE !I

ll '"OMOA 100 30 69/A :!ili di jib

TR'. p';;;:, ;; 4 Ep -p:P:PIRIllp.RIP ih in ffillIP.dlif b. ..phi, iplh1,01,

RIRohl :1; ( E 1 x-Eyl;

Rh REihfRERilh';;;Ph.hh'0;;E;:hr

i„; h hip . ' HI hull ,,,,i h ;; 1 h

IY

TJ,Hh.;!;*MOD '

, 100

it II

30 52/D+ !!

.' ! IPihrhPhiP.;PRPIRHP!!- PhPpl!EIR !:111 ! 54!P!!!!!Phl

II

h;!11Ph li ihihhly R ; il;;;;:ih

h 1 . ( F I Ftylacwiiii

.„ ,,,,,, .1pfr: - ,i; i:(0,1i;,0 n '.1: 1 ,1,:lhqd

111,, ,I , J !

, k4pOMPOLS ORY

i rittiVE II

„1 110)E1 i j.1,U ,11j)1;

11;11

i INE 91.

MiH!:. TIP10e. 80 20 24 6 31/C

1:,irill:Iii - oh 11 1 11 iii hh o, 11,h0;(

it phT E.E.; ;;;Irip

H111111411 ;;EI ,

:11

111( !; i ;!'

P.

hi ], , Iiii (!lfill:Plfthh;h1P;OkIP#;1101

; hliphhhimhph

'PriP

ph: ol Er hiRpho h'PP1

LPH ., C BO 20 24 6 52/A 16/A+HI!

II REI - !y;

,4111;;PhPlihOPi

11111 1E

!!!!

-

" IP !

!(01XTYhEil4ii* IP11441iPi. i

hp .

P

i

Ph.pliT

1 111

111

1h h lib

11 l t 70 30 21 9 63/AA

4; I ; ;;;I.4; 30/AA i

L1H;Oni41: il!

,„

p

l

p

'!

I

,

I1!

.pR

i1

.

i,

!

r

, X11 Ili

-

h

!il

I

l

;I

0],

:

,,FhI.

,

:1

,,E

1R

'1

h

,L[i1

ii

h

,1

i.;i

l hlahri E

1lkliA

1 IF1#1ili; (NIVEI14

A *1.

1 ~II‘ fi11'II1

"1ll

d; ;[11111 0Y11111'111

;fiitIr11(1 iF1017pNAL

l0:' 11i0J47

h 1 1 t 1 Ii i l

II0 011111111 ,1!

r 11 SO 20 24 6 13/D

.. , I,III' ,,11HI,i; 17/A+ h; , ; iliODEPEIR hl

;(hAph,Rilhp RiPlop!Popilill

'' II/ir iinii/J! pihhho'11111riji

'Phhr111

rp

( I 1H .E: ..;

Ripprh,,;:j; Rhihh1111411;;I;h1l'ihP4h ('1$ i ;;;P ; 1 , ic:1!dp !;ph1..liri

p;hi.lop7lhiR4111 !RH hi l'''

II PORPiROLHORy R. ' (I:h;;;;;P:PIRPRIPTO; hilEhhhiph

hi .E 40 60 30( TOTAL.) 30 SO R" 118 911;Phrulp

IRII h hIllh

I I I P PR111ElPhh;;;P,

Ph ph poll; (1 iphiP p [ 1,11., IP

iP814i9 l i:;i; :11Tr '1Iii 11 Ilic:'511!:1!1!I

111 11;i111-1 111:111:idli:lidlii

hchh!uh,;_Riih 1. lli5:'PlirTi4l1:111 ql iiMP1,11)Alli5,1;1111;:i

INSTITUTION NO. CODE

106076 B398513

Page 36: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

West Bell -al Board of Primary Ed cation Actasr a. Prafulla Chandra Bhavan, 7 I, Sector -

Bidhannagar, Xolkata 700 094

DIPLOMA-IN-ELEMENTARY EDUCATION COURSE

Page 37: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

RESULT OF D.EL.ED PART - II EXAMINATION OF THE SESSION - 2018-2020

Candidate's Registration Number *

18011111461

Candidate's Roll *:

20012111

Candidate's No.

1264

Submit Reset

Registration No. Roll No

Result Remarks

18011111461

20012111 1264

PASSED

(DISCLAIMER: THIS RESULT IS FULLY PREPARED AND GENERATED ELECTRONICALLY. THE ERRORS AND

OMISSIONS ARE EXCUSED.)

©West Bengal Board Of Primary Education-2020

Page 38: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

WEST BENGAL COUNCIL OF HIGHER SECONDARY EDUCATION

INSTITUTION NO. MARK-SHEET , CODE Higher Secondary Examination

04045 0051478 2007

THE FOLLOWING IS THE STATEMENT OF MARKS OBTAINED BY

KAPPA SARKAR

ROLL 207141 Na 0368 AT THE HIGHER SECONDARY EXAMINATION 2007.

SUBJECTS MARKS OBTAINED

THEORY PRACTICAL

/ORAL/ PROJECT

TOTAL GRADE'

LANGUAGE

Bengali (A)

Eng 1 i sh (B )

65

51

55

52

58

42

34

19

17

,51

65

51 •

74

52

58

59

85

A

5

A

B

B

13

A+

COMPULSORY ELECTIVE

Geography

Philosophy

Sanskrit

OPTIONAL ELECTIVE

Biological Sciences

COMPULSORY

Environmental Education

RESULT: PASSED

(X-doovr.r dil cal... PLEASE SEE REVERSE -,‘ 'r SECRETARY

Page 39: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

West Bengal Board of Primary Education 0 Arharya Praculla Chandra pha‘an. DK 7/ 1,, actor -

Bidhannsex, Kothata 700 091+;

Page 40: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

18191211522 20192111 001 5 PASSED

-37 Candidate's Registration Number :

18191211522

Candidate's Roll :

20192111

Candidate's No:

0015

Page 41: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

'OUNDIL il WEST BENGA

Fri ION LODE

THE FOLLOWING IS

BIBEti, SASMA..

ROI,t

CHER SECONDARY EDUCATION

MARK-SHEET Higher Sc ondazyExant nation

E STAT ENT OF MARKS AND4iyiiy.9aT74*

1827'

PASS :BARKS

SUBJECTS' HE PRACTICAL /ORAL/

, PRoria RY ACJ

SEVENT,

OVERALL GRADE: Bic-

PLEASE SEE REVERSE DEPUTY SECRETARY (EXAMINATION)

Page 42: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

'tit 1'r l'[1,.', Li I;( / 4i i ( I ()1

'lull I) I i I h I I:II I; t

( 1 111i1111111$:.11. Rt.!' 11 I

111 I 1 I MI I I/1 1 Uri 'if II .4

RI,1;itiirt1111111 (c! if h I

Index No. 180445

Name ofthe Institute : SONARGAON VIVERANANDA INSTITUTE FOR PRIMAR2 TEACHERS' TRAINING,SOUTH 24 PARGANAS

e of the Candidate : POULOMI SARKAR BALDER

XXX: Daughter of : BABLU KUMAR SARKAR

Registration No. 18182510445 of 2018

SECRETARY

Page 43: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

tandRiate Dumber " '.

r_t 11: etthi

Cm:5d No_+-

8182510435 29782211 0491 PASSED

Page 44: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

- in-

Page 45: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

1

Bhavan, DR Bidhannagar, Kolkata 700091

DIPLOMA-IN-ELEMENTARY EDUCATION COURSE

Registration Certificate }

2018-2020 Index No.: 191556

Name of the Institute - RAIGANJ EDUCARE TEACHERS TRAINING COLLEGE,UTTAR

Name of the Candidate ; . . . .......

Registration Aro. : - • - • • • • -

Page 46: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

Candidate's No.

0040

18191511556 20192111 0040 PASSED

Candidate's Roll*:

20192111

;.; West Bengal Board Of Primary Education

Candidate's Registration Number*:

18191511556

Page 47: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

(FIFTY ONE)

( FORTY )

( FORTY SEVEN)

00 13E13M

(SIXTY FIVE)

( THIRTY SEVEN) .

( SEVENTY FIVE)

T: PASSED

;>1.E.L.S!"..SEE E.EVEftS.F. DEPUTY SECRETARY (EXAMINATION)

TOTAL FULL MARKS PASS MARKS

SUBJECTS THEORY PRACTICAL THEORY PRACTICAL /ORAIJ /ORAIJ

PROJECT I PROJECT H__________i__-.--___ COMPULSORY I ANGUAC I

EINGA 100 30

IN FIGURES .

IN WORDS

THEORY PRACTICAL /ORAL/

PROJECT

30

EC OG 100 30

[ .

: I- oPTIONAL ; ELECTIVE

COMA 70 30 21

I ENVE 40 60 30 ( TOTAL )

(NINETY ONE)

k- • • - THE STA i EAL ENT OF MARKS AND GRADE OBTAINED BY

AT THE HIGHER SECONDARY EXAMINATION 2010.

NGD 100

cOmPuLSOEI I. Li VE

30

30

L COMPULSORY

29014 2050534

E Eel

SUB IR KUMAR MANDAL

'B OLL 159141 N°- 0013

MY EDUCATION

MARK-SHEET

2010

it

ACCT 100

Page 48: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

Index No, 030225 Session : 2018-2020

DISTRICT INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION AND TRAINING, EUPDWAN

Name of t he a

MONIDEEPA ICUNDU

SAILENDPANATH KUNDU

Name of the Candidate

UN/ Daughter of :

2018

421 AlitCA SrmRPTARy

18032110225 Registration No. •

DIPLOMA-1N-ELEMENTARY EDUCATION COURSE

Rerr: rsrvtion t t7

Page 49: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

Candidate's Registration Number *:

18032110225

Candidate's Roll *:

20032211

Candidate's No

0117

Submit

Reset

18032110225 20032211 0117 PASSED

Page 50: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

it,t7.<KS AND CliAl ;; NE! THE rouovvINc

• 201.1 2104,i THE HIGHER SECONDARY EXAMINATION

c4/13 ;nil( I BO

/ yi

N NETY ONE)

2018

] FULL MARKS : PASS MARRS M ARKS/GRAD[ ! TOTAL

! SUBJECTS IIHEORYi PRACTICAL . THEORY PRACTICAL' THE( 2S ' PRAC1 IC AL ' IN FIGURES IORAU

t` I . ! 1

1 I /ORAL/ /OR A L/ ___ _ _

C

R.i.DE

PROJECT PROWCI PI:nlE.Ci" ! IN 1VORDS

COMPULSORY LANGUAGE

NI WET N IWO )

70/A+ 20/D !

9 COMPULSORY ELECTIVE

:LF PUT":SE IU"1 AR).

(NINETY)

H.L. 80

OPTIONAL ELrCTIVE

POLE I 80

COMPULSORY

47_

3

SE1'.2ENTY

Page 51: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

Sessto 2018-2'02

aradex N 070208

• . r

2018

Nam

Son

Reg stration No.

RAJ1:RAMMORAN ROY GOVERNMENT PRIMARY T ACH RS'a e institute : TRAINING IlISTITUTE , HOOGHLY

• "”.

rumi.E. 511 PANJA of the. Candidate ..

18071.1.10208. . .

DIPLOMA-1N-ELEMENTARY EDL

( Registration

Page 52: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

18071110208 20072111 0131 PASSED

ti? Bengal Bcard Of Primary Education C}

/70

,_SULT OF DILED PA lT - II EXA1riNATION OF THE SESSION - 2018-

2020

Candidate's Registration Number *:

18071110203

Candidate's Roll *:

20072111 •

Candidate's No.

0131

Submit

Reset

Page 53: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

No. AT THE HIGHER SECONDARY EXAMINATION 2015.

THE FOLLOWING IS THE STATEMENT 01 MARKS AND GRADS OBTAINED BY

RAF; ESK PANjA

ROLL

AnYr 4 — FELE M IN

:DOE MARK-SHEET H W55' Secondary [Omnia cd ion

2015 jy1r7;CCC5 -7 3

IJ

DEPUTY SECRETARY (EXAMINATION) 5

FULL MARKS PASS MARKS MARKS/GRADE 1 TOTAL

SUBJECTS THEORIWACTICAL /ORM/

THEORY PRACTICAL i THEORY /ORAE/

PRACTICAL IN FIGURES I SUBJECT . GRADE

E I PROJECT

i PROJECT

/ORAL/ FRC/TEC!

COMPULSORY

IN WORDS

gqqq~

LANGUAGE

El 80 24 1 c:,..,

1

1

24 i_...

647 Ai

E

20 in ,

li Gill)/ F0)17, _..._

S4. .

)

COMPULSORY ELECTIVE J GEGP. 7C' 1T, I E6

): E I Gfr )TY ST II I

I PHIL. efi '20 6 72/0

,

12..0 ) 92 I 0 I

III . I NET ), TWO) i

c 80 20 24 Is/ ;I- 70 10 SF

;El GHTY FIVE)

OPTIONAL ELECTIVE

i ; ; J 1

COMPULSORY

I

L ,

BEsuLr )7" .

- — ,

1 GRAND TOTAL I 077 1

t_

1-50

Page 54: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC
Page 55: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

Tatat Ivtarks Obtained : 575

RESULT PASSED

h.area Prafuka Chandra Bh

16TH MARCH , 2020

lARK SHEET Session : 2018-2020 INDEX- 152081

The following is the statement marks obtained by PAPIA GROSE( BOAT DAUGHTER of

SUBAL CHANDRA GHOSH who appeared front SAX PRIMARY TEACHERS TRAINING INSTITUTE, PASCHIM MEDINIPUR

with Roll 18151211 No. 2285 as REGULAR candidate at the Diploma-In-Elementary-Education Part I Examination held

he NOVEMBER f 2019 month of

AREA COURSE PAPER AkKS FULL

AlMIT ARKS

mARRs PASS NARKS

HARKS OBTAINED B D

--' 1L 141

[- oME—

Core CC-0l Child Studies 00 Imetpal Ainng 0 , , , 28

78 Tit ii End T ry 70 . 2850

Compulsory Pedagogic

Studies (CPS)

CPS-01 Langci2 ge (Li)

/UN 0 Internal A g 1 9 12 29

78 ,8 4. 49 70

CPS-02 100 a l

I 30 71 a

End oryi7

CPS-03 Mathematics I00 Inteuial Assigmarent30 12 28

80 TentEndEh 70 28. 52

C vi ta Science

100 , 0 7 30

82 7 8, 52

-...

Pn-lntcrisk p w,es ed

Teaching Ledllittig Slall Enhz-IiLemen.)

;internal 47 91

'x 50 25 44

P- ( EC311‘ c D a-r:

fir- ts. Pr.,..-;w1 R P Edn.-40 20 38

95 eathe Drama et; bducation-30 15 29

Music Educarion-30 15 28

Page 56: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

VN

IOld

Ia

II

r A

- 0

• FRtir

Page 57: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

Education, it i Exammat 2018

.rya Prafulla Chandra Bhavan, idhannagar, Koikata-700 091

16TH MARCH ,2020 Aisci

SECRETARY

Total Marks Obtained : 566

RESULT : PASSED

Pass Alo,

MARK SHEET Session : 2018-2020

INDEx - 152071

The following he statemen marks obtained by PRIYA BORT

DAUGHTER af TAPAS BOXI who appeared from SAR PRIMARY TEACHERS TRAIN/NG INSTITUTE PASCHIM MEDINIPUR

with Roll 18151211 No. 2282 as REGULAR candidate at the Diploma-In-Elementary-Education Part I Examination held in the month of NOVEMBER 2019

AREA COURSE CODE PAPER mARKs MARKS ALLOTTED PASS

. . MARKS MA RKS

OBTAINED -

TOTAL IMARKS

OBTAINED

Core CC-01 Child Srudies 100 n al As ment-30 12 28

nd The 70 18 49 7'7

Compulsory Pedagogic

Stuchet (cps)

CPS-01 Page ( Ll )

( df/U/N)

0 12 28

T ti 2 46 74

CPS-0'5 Lang uag° 2) (English)

Ass 28 70

/1 Oo 0 , 42

cps-0 a cs , Interna A si en 0 29 si

tOtin od Tithry-70 2 52

Ci3s4).4 m ironmemal Se&nce

', inte4114 ASSi,ffil i 29 so

end Thient-70 ,, .. , a 51

Practic

.., '

Pz c-internship (Pnress Bawd

laclung Ltanung Skil! Ezthanc,mient)

00 90 ernat - ... 45

P- 3tn, e DiLma,

FA; Ar.s Pm ‘icai k, -,,,,e li- Fouc: nun

0

Int. P & H Edn,-40 20 39

• 94 Int. Creative Drama & An Education-30 15 27

Int. Music Education-30 1 28

Page 58: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

it

PLEASE SEE REVERSE DEPUTY SECRETARY (EXAMINATION)

RESULT: PASSED

fC.Mtre III II II II:.ass 1,,, -

it

WEST BENGAL COUNCIL OF HIGHER SECONDARY EDUCATION

INSTITUTION NO. CODE

205125 8502442

MARK-SHEET Higher Secondary Examination

2015

-

THE FOLLOWING IS THE STATEMENT OF MARKS AND GRADE OBTAINED BY

PR I YA BOX I

ROLL 321621 No. 1080 AT THE HIGHER SECONDARY EXAMINATION 2015.

1

I

FULL MARKS PASSMARKS MARKS/GRADE TOTAL

SUBJECT GRADE

h. SUBJECTS THEORY PRACIACAL /ORAL/

THEORY PRACTICAL

- /010sli THEORY PRACTICAL IN FIGURES

PROJECT Eitojitr /ORAL/

PROJECT N WORDS

COMPULSORY LANGUAGE --11

eNoA 80 20 24 50/B+ T-20/0 70

:

A (SEVENTY)

ENGB 1 80 20 24 48/B+ 20/0

1 68

B+ (SIXTY EIGHT)

COMPULSORY ELECT VE

, NI

HIST 80 20 24 6 31/P 20/0 51 B -I

(FIFTY ONE)

PHIL 80 20 24 6 52/B+ 20/0 : 72 1 A

(SEVENTY TWO)

SNSK • 80 20 24 6 57/A 20/0 I 77 I A

:

(SEVENTY SEVEN)

OPTIONAL ELECTIVE

p

R

POLS 80 20 24 4 4I/B 19/0 60 2+

(SIXTY)

COMPULSORY

GRAND TOTAL 347

Page 59: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

West Bengal Board of Primary Education Acliarya PrafttlIa Chandra Bhavan, DIC 7/I, Sector II, BliThannagar, Folk to 700091

"39E. (033) 2321 1201/1202, 23 59 8099/8135. 2334 8983. 2 secrelarv.whImerri,..90211.88.8 www.wbbpe.org

No. 1167/B /2017 Date: 12/05/2017

NOTIFICATION FOR TEACHER ELIGIBILITY TEST (TED 2017 FOR CLASSES I-V TO BE CONDUCTED BY WEST BENGAL BOARD OF PRIMARY EDUCATION AS PER

THE NCTE GUIDELINES

All concerned are hereby notified that.the Teacher Eligibility Test (TET), 2017 for classes I-V will be conducted in terms of the order of the Department of School Education, Govt. of West Bengai vide its memo No. 287-SE(EE)/IOM-6/2009 Pt-1(TET) dated 17-04-2017 read with No. 343-SE/EE/IOM-6/2009 Pt-I(TET) dated 12-05-2017 for the purpose of recruitment of primary school

teachers.

The Teacher Eligibility Test (TET) will be conducted by this Board, on a single day throughout

West Bengal.

Only those persons who have acquired the academic and professional qualifications specified in the NCTE-Notification dated 23-08-2010 are eligible to apply for the TET, 2017 (set out below):

(i) Classes I-V

Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 50% marks and 2 year Diploma in Elementary Education (by whatever name known)

OR

Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 50% marks and 4 year Bachelor of Elementary Education (B.ELEd.)

OR Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 50% marks and having Diploma in Education (Special Education), a course recognized by the Rehabilitation Council of India (R.C.I.), shall also be considered.

5% relaxation of marks in Senior Secondary or its equivalent examination (i.e. 45%) will be allowed for the SC, ST, OBC-A, 011C-B, PH, EC, Ex-Serviceman and DH (Death-in-harness) category candidates.

Page 60: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

(ii) As per the Govt. order No. 287-SE(EE)/10M-6/2009 Pt-I(TET) dated 17-04-2017 read with No. 343-SWEE/10M-612.009 Pt-I(TET) dated 12-05-2017 persons who have appeared final examination of Two Year D.E.Ed. Course from NCTE recognized institutions on the date of this Notification and the result is not yet published

And

Persons who have appeared final examination of Two Year D.Ed. (Special Education) Course from RCI recognized institutions on the date of this Notification and the result is not yet published shall also be eligible to sit for the TET, 2017.

Minimum academic qualifications mentioned above obtained after the date of this notification, shall not be accepted. Any such applications submitted shall be rejected.

First Language : Applicants will have to choose any one of the following languages as first language : Bengali, Hindi, Urdu, Nepali, Santhali, Oriya and Telugu. The choice will be on the basis of the medium of instruction in the school.

Second Language :English (for all)

Qualifying Marks : A candidate who will score 60% and above of the full marks (150) in the TET will be considered as TET 2017 passed candidate. A relaxation by 5% (i.e. 55%) will

be the qualifying mark for SC, ST, OBC-A, OBC-B, PH, EC, Ex-Serviceman and DH (Death-in-harness).

However, qualifying the TET would not confer a right on any person for recruitment employment as it is only one of the eligibility criteria for appointment.

• The details regarding the submission of online application forms,. deposit of fees (Rs, 100/- only and Rs. 25/- only for SC, ST and PH candidates), date, time and venue of the TET examination etc. shall be notified in due course.

(Dr. R. C. Bagchi ) Secretary

Page 61: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

58 - op

ctOL/T7:07+e— r 3v

TEACHER ELIGIBILITY TEST (TET)H214P,

LaFOR CLASSES ITV

iwesr4;§tg.bat rate issued by

Ctlif9R 'ur

OTIFICA ON 0

. Crl netlEtpaApflcfpE/EE/1006/2000(Pt-1)(TET) es9Filticati9v,ovtheepowpcmio:trour canierndlifIcation dated l,( is frunhjeljo4ecgrytqatdqqhaqpearThg at TET 2017 to be

alqahao(lnriaryEcluotabol'ipy(-,,T.,

following;minimurn eligibilitkconpillbns prescribed by NCTE from time to

'4,4erSbnior Secondary (or its enuivalenth0+2) with at least 50% marks and 2 ahtElementary Education (D.EI.Ed.).

Or et.S econdary ;Senior Secondary (or its equivalent 10+2) with at least 50% marks and 4

Yearst3achelotofElpmentary Education (B.EI.Ed.). Or

Ift9bef Secondary/ Senior Secondary (or its equivalent 10+2) with at least 50% marks and 'frIling DiplomatEs/motion (Special Education), recognised by the Rehabilitation Council of

India (RCp. Or

graduatjonqpd,TwoYear Diploma in Elementary Education (D.ELEd.). -NOte:5Wrelaiptjob of Marks In Higher Secondary I Senior or its equivalent

.-examinaticrt 19+2 (i.e. 45%) will be allowed for the SC, ST, OBC-4, 013C-B, PH, Exempted Category, Ex-serviceman and DH (Death-in-harness) category candidates.

Minirnum.ocademic.qualifications mentioned above obtained after the date of this notification, .2017bhallnotbeacc pted.

Nay; Two Year D.ELEd. Course passed from an institution recognised by the NCTE and 'catfiliatedto the examining bodynotifiedbytheNCTE.

Det6ikotomission pfsuchapplications will be availableon thefellowingwebsites: i?pe.org

.ctigevsin ,Oggested,.to follow the procedures=,ghen below for successful log-in and

wbsed N AMIC/NTW.OF9R3TEAFISIEKE(.15.1151LITYJEST (TET)-2017 (Primary)

. . ttertcprinitiusopu,

.409.1(

ir.cisfaintstsportito Ipporelpinkoodgmthot

pagpooregvad ?pi lg

the Webeitesleill Open for:subjrussiim of limb i•nliaeapig iatiolitk-fronriorio;2017aliopts* cm,29.10-zo;t7 . L. rc.r,

Page 62: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

_ j r - F-9

WEST BENGAL BOARD OF PRIMARY EDUCATION A.P.C. Shawn, DK-7/1, Sector-II, Salt Lake City, Koikata — 700 091

No. 2552/13PE/2017 Date: 09.10.2017 NOTIFICATION FOR

ONLINE APPLICATION FOR TEACHER ELIGIBILITY TEST (7E7)-2017 (Primary) FOR CLASSES I-V

In Weis of the order of the Department of School Education no. 343-SWEE/10M-6/2009(Pe 1)(TET) dated 12.05.2017 and in partial modification of the eligibility criteria in our earlier notification dated 12.052017, online applications are invited from eligible candidates for @pairing at TET 2017 to be conducted by the West Bengal Board of Primary Education. The applicants must fWfil the following minimum eligibility conditions, prescribed by NCTE from time to lime I. Higher Secondary/ Senior Secondary (or its equivalent 10+2) with at least 50% marks and 2 Year Diploma in Elementary Education (D.ELEd.).

Or 2. Nigher Secondary/ Senior Secondary (or its equivalent 10+2? with at least 50% marks and 4 Years Bachelor of Elementary Education (B El F4.).

Or 3. Iligher Secondary/ Senior Secondary Or its equivalent 10+2) with at least 50% marks and having Diploma in EdWation (Special Education), recognised by the Rehabilitation Council of

Or 4. Graduation and Two Year Diploma in Elementary Education (D.ELEd.). Note: 5% rekaation of Markt in Higher Seamdaryl Senior Secondary or its equivalent examination 10+2 (re. 45%) will be allowed for the SC, ST OBC-A, OBC-B, PH, Exempted Category, Ex-serviceman and DH (Death-in-harness) category candidates. Minimum academic qualifications mentioned above obtained after the date of this notification, i.e. 09.10.2017 shall not be accepted. NA: Two Year Orli Fa. Caine passed from an institution recogniled by the NUT and affiliated to the examining body notified by the NCTE Details of submission of such applications will be available on the following websites:

wwwwbbPaorgliDwviat41Weed.gov.in Eligible applicants are requested to follow the procedures given below for successful log-in and submission of online application.

1. Visit the websites wwwwbbpe.org/ www.wbsed.govin 2. Click on "ONLINE APPLICATIONFOR TEACHER ELIGIBILITY TEST (TET)-2017

(Primary) FOR CLASSES kr; 3. Gaunt Login ID and password after putting inputs in the given fields; 4. Use the Login ID imd password as itrected on the link; 5. PPrails will appear before you one after one; 6. The required documents such as Photograph, Sigaature, 1D-Card, Caste Certificate issued

by the Govt of West Bengal em are to be uploaded as directed; 7. Get a print-out of the application before final submission; 8. Pay fees as required in the directed mode; 9. Download the Application Form with c-paid stamp;

The websites will open for submission of sach online applications from 10-10-2017 and close on 29-10-2017

Details of the procedure for online pay/neat of the exam fees @Rs. 100/- (12.s. 25/-fee SC, ST and PH candidates) and for submission of applications are available in the above mentioned websites.

For any gutty dial 033-2337-9313 (Monday to Friday between 11 am it 04 p.m.)

SP/-Secretary

Page 63: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

tillc w c c-c-trm

AST 388 of 2017

Reshab Sarkar & Ors. Vs

State of West Bengal & Ors.

Mr. S. Dasgupta .....For the Petitioners.

Mr. B.P. Vaisya, Mr. S. Chatterjee For the State.

Mr. Subir Sanyal, Mr. Ratul Biswas For the Board.

Mr. S. Ghosh For NCTE

Since the state has already issued a notification being Memo No.

2744/BPE/2017 dated 14.11.2017 modifying the earlier notification in regard to

TET., 2017 ( Classes I-V) , therefore the writ petition has become infructuous.

Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed as being Infructuous'.

The notification dated 14.11.2017 filed in court today be kept with the

record.

( Samapti Chatterjee, J )

Page 64: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

A211 e'We

g

WEST BENGAL BOAR; OF PRIMARY EDUCATION ARC. Bhavan, DK-711, Sector-II, Salt takeCily, Kolkata 700 Si

NOTICE FOR HOLDING THE PRIMARY TET-EXAMINATION-2017

In continuation of the notification for holding Teacher Eligibility Test Examination (TET-2017) No.

:1167/BPE/2017, dated — 12/05/2017, read with the subsequent notifications in this regard, all concerned art

i'hereby notified thatthe Teacher Eligibility Test (TET-2017) Examination

wilt be conducted by this Board on a single day all over the state onlyforthose candidates who have already submitted online applications in response to the aforesaid notificatibne

; as perthefollowing schedule, 4 - - •

D te• anuarta toll° P.

Page 65: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

iLv\i"A/1-2

scurrrai itPan 14nrel T(TEEIV za tofilitrTh Mira)

N1\1.101'11 COUTICti for StultOuT • IWO"' of the

c .1

No, 76-4/2010/NCTE/Acad

Dated : 11 February 2011

To All Secretaries/Commissioners of Education of State Government:Nis

Subject: Guidelines for conducting Teacher Eligibility Test (7E7) under the Right or Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act (RTE), 2009

Sir/Madam,

In accordance with the provisions of sub-section (1) of Section 23 of the RTE Act, the National Coundl for Teacher Education (NCTE) had vide Notification

dated 231I1 August, 2010 laid down the minimum qualifications for a person to be

eligible for appointment. as a teacher in classes I to VIII. It had been Inter alia

provided that one of the essential qualifications for a person to be eligible for appointment as a teacher In any of the schools referred to In clause UU of section 2 or the RTE Act is that he/she should pass the Teacher Eligibility Test (TE-1)

which will be conducted by the appropriate Government in accordance with the

Guidelines farmed by the NOTE.

In this regard, please find enclosed the Guidelines for conducting the Teacher Eligibility Test (TET) for necessary action at your end.

This may be brought to the knowledge of all concerned.

Yoursi f

ully It t '

2411

csays.42 afw Copy to:-

(i) PS to HRM/MOS(HRD) (ii) PPS to Secretary (SE&L)

(iii) Commissioner, Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan

(iv) Commissioner, Navodaya Vidyalaya Sande

(v) Chairman, Central Board of Secondary Education

(vi) Chairman, Council for the Indian School Certificate Examination

Wing - 11, Hans Ilhavvan. 1, Dabsdur Shah Zular ISlurg,Thrvy Delhi - 110002

Olt -23.7-010.S- Tel : Fax : 23370128

E-mail: [email protected] Website : http://www.ricte-iodiadirg

(Vikra ahoy Member Secretary

Page 66: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

Guidelines for conducting Teacher Eligibility Test (TET)

Background and Rationale

The implementation of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education (RYE) Act, 2009 requires the recruitment of a large number of teachers across the country in a time bound manner. Inspite of the enormity of the task, it is desirable to ensure that quality requirement for recruitment of teachers are not diluted at any cost. It is therefore necessary to ensure that persons recruited as teachers possess the essential aptitude and ability to meet the challenges of teaching at the primary and upper primary level.

2 In accordance with the provisions of sub-section (1) of section 23 of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education (RTE) Act, 2009, the National Council for Teacher Education (NOTE) has laid down the minimum qualifications for a person to be eligible for appointment as a teacher in class Ito VIII, vide Its Notification dated August 23, 2010. A copy of the Notification is attached at Annexure 1. One of the essential qualifications for a person to be eligible for appointment as a teacher in any of the schools referred to in clause (n) of section 2 of the RTE Act is that he/she should pass the Teacher Eligibility Test (TET) which will be conducted by the appropriate Government.

3 The rationale for including the TET as a minimum qualification for a person to be eligible for appointment as a teacher is as under:

i. It would bring national standards and benchmark of teacher quality in the recruitment process;

It would induce teacher education institutions and students from these institutions to further improve their performance standards; It would send a positive signal to all stakeholders that the Government lays special emphasis on teacher quality

4 The TET examination may be conducted by a suitable professional body designated by the appropriate Government for the purpose. it will be conducted in accordance with the Guidelines hereunder.

Eligibility

5 The following persons shall be eligible for appearing in the TET:

i. A person who- has acquired the academic and professional qualifications specified in the NOTE Nonfication dated 231d August 2010.

ii. A person who is pursuing any of the teacher education courses (recognized by the NCTE or the RCI, as the case may be) specified in the NCTE Notification dated 23rd August 2010.

iii. The eligibility condition for appearing in TET may be relaxed in respect of a

2

Page 67: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

-

State/UT which has been granted relaxation under sub-section (2) of section 23 of the RTE Act. The relaxation will be specified in the Notification issued by the Central Government under that sub-section.

Structure and Content of TET

6 The structure and content of the TET is given in the following paragraphs. All questions will be Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs), each carrying one mark, with four alternatives out of which one answer will be correct. There will be no negative marking. The examining body should strictly adhere to the structure and content of the TET specified below.

There will be two papers of the TET. Paper I will be for a person who intends to be a teacher for classes Ito V. Paper II will be for a person who intends to be a teacher for classes VI to VIII. A person who intends to be a teacher either for classes I to V or for classes VI to VIII will have.to appear In both papers (Paper 1 and Paper II).

Paper I (for classes Ito V); No. of MCQs —150; Duration of examination: one-and-a-half hours

Structure and Content (All Compulsory)

(i) Child Development and Pedagogy 30 MCQs 30 Marks (ii) Language I 30 30 " (iii) Language II 30 30 " (iv) Mathematics 30 ' 30 (v) Environmental Studies 30 - 30 "

Nature and standard of Questions

While designing and preparing the questions for Paper I, the examining body shall take the following factors into consideration:

• The test items on Child Development and Pedagogy wilt focus on educational psychology of teaching and learning relevant to the age group of 6-11 years. They will focus on understanding the characteristics and needs of diverse learners, interaction with learners and the attributes and qualities of a good facilitator of learning.

• The Test items for Language I will focus on the proficiencies related to the medium of Instruction, (as chosen from list of prescribed language options in the application form).

The Language II will be from among the prescribed options other than Language I. A candidate may choose any one language from the available language options and will be required to specify the same in the application form. The test items in Language II will also focus on the elements of language, communication and comprehension abilities.

3

Page 68: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

(:5

• The test items In Mathematics and Environmental Studies will focus on the concepts, problem solving abilities and pedagogical understanding of the subjects. In all these subject areas, the test items shall be evenly distributed over different divisions of the syllabus of that subject proscribed for classes kV by the appropriate Government

• The questions in the tests for Paper I will be based on the topics of the prescribed syllabus of the State for classes I—V. but their difficulty standard, as well as linkages. could be upto the secondary stage.

Paper II (for classes VI to VIII); No. of MCQs —150; Duration of examination : one-and-a-half hours

Structure and Content

(I) Child Development & Pedagogy (compulsory) 30 MCQs 30 Marks (ii) Language I (compulsory) 30 30 " (iii) Language II(compulsory) 30 30 " (iv) (a) For Mathematics and Science teacher: Mathematics and Science — 60 MCQs of 1 mark each

(b) For Social studies teacher: Social Studies - 60 MCQs of 1 mark each (c) for any other teacher — either 4(a) or 4(b)

While designing and preparing the questions for Paper 11, the examining body shall take the following factors into consideration:

The test items on Child Development and Pedagogy will focus on educational. psychology of teaching and learning, relevant to the age group 11-14 years. They will focus on understanding the characteristics. needs and psychology of diverse learners, interaction with learners and the attributes and qualities of a good facilitator of learning.

• The test items for Language I will focus on the proficiency related to the medium of Instruction, as chosen from list of prescribed options in the application form.

The Language II will be a language other than Language I. The person may choose any one language from among the available options and as in the specified list In the application form and attempt questions in the one indicated by the candidate in the application form by him. The Test items in Language II will also focus on the elements of language. communication and comprehension abilities.

The test items in Mathematics and Science, and Social Studies will focus on the concepts, problem solving abilities and pedagogical understanding of these subjects. The test items of Mathematics and Science will be of

4

Page 69: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

30 marks each. The test items shall be evenly distributed over different divisions of the syllabus of that subject as prescribed for classes by the appropriate government.

• The questions in the tests for Paper II will be based on the topics of the prescribed syllabus of the State for classes VI-VIII but their difficulty standard as well as linkages could be upto the senior secondary stage.

6 The question paper shall be bilingual — (i) in language(s) as decided by the appropriate Government; and (ii) English language.

Qualifying marks

9 A person who scores 60% or more in the TET exam will be considered as TET pass. School managements (Government, local bodies, government aided and unaided)

(a) may consider giving concessions to persons belonging to SC/ST, OBC. differently abled persons. etc., in accordance with their extant reservation policy;

(b) should give weightage to the TET scores in the recruitment process; however, qualifying the TET would not confer a right on any person for recruitment/employment as it is only one of the eligibility criteria for appointment.

Applicability

10

(a) TET conducted by the Central Government shall apply to all schools referred to in sub-clause (i) of clause (a) of section 2 of the RTE Act.

(b) YET conducted by a State Government/UT with legislature shall apply to

(i) a school of the State GovernmenVUT with legislature and local authority referred to in sub-clause (i) of clause (n) of section 2 of the RTE Act; and

(ii) a school referred to In sub-clause (ii) of clause (n) of section 2 of the RTE Act in that State/UT.

A school at (I) and (ii) may also consider eligibility of a candidate who has obtained TET Certificate awarded by another State/UT with legislature. In case a State Government/UT with legislature decides not to conduct a TET, a school at (i) and (ii) In that State/UT would consider the TET conducted by the Central Government.

(c) A school referred to in sub-clause (iv) of clause (n) of section 2 of the RTE Act may exercise the option of considering either the TET conducted by the Central Government or the TET conducted by the State GovemmenVUT with legislature.

5

Page 70: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

6 - -

Frequency of conduct of TET and validity period of TET certificate

11 The appropriate Government should conduct a TET at least once every year. The Validity Period of TET qualifying certificate for appointment will be decided by the appropriate Government subject to a maximum of seven years for all categories. But there will be no restriction on the number of attempts a person can take for acquiring a TET Certificate. A person who has qualified TET may also appear again for improving his/her score.

Procedure for conduct of the Test

12 The examining body shall formulate a detailed procedure and lay down instructions for conduct of the TET. Candidates should be informed that a very serious view will be taken of any malpractice or Impersonation.

Legal Disputes

13 All legal disputes with regard to conduct of TET shall be subject to the jurisdiction of the appropriate Government.

Award of TET Certificate

14 The appropriate Government conducting the Test shall award a TET Certificate to all successful candidates. The certificate should contain the name and address of the candidate, date of birth, Registration No. year/month of award of Certificate, marks obtained in each Paper, class level of its validity (Class Ito V, class VI to VIII or both), and, in case of classes VI to VIII, the subject area (Science and Mathematics, Social Studies, etc.). The certificate may be electronically generated with adequate security features. Appropriate may consider utilizing the services of specialized agencies for issuing de-materialized (demat) TET certificates as a security feature to avoid any kind of malpractice.

Monitoring

15 Following measures would be taken for monitoring the quality and administration of the TEL

(a) The appropriate Government shall appoint a Nodal Officer for the purpose of TET.

(b) The NCTE would organize meetings of the Nodal Officers at least once every year.

(c) Every appropriate Government will forward a report of each TET to the NCTE in a format to be prescribed by the NOTE.

(d) The NOTE shall maintain data base and be the repository of experts and resources, including the technological tools for conduct of the TET, and shall share it with the appropriate Government.

6

Page 71: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

‘1Tri Ill—ate 43

+1R7 Th7 (IA94. : affilbffei

(ii) .174 3ITTR 3 f 2001 *I treA fur 31WIITIW I

5. alto erw- 4 of arfitioeritft 4r< 124Effie arazettw — re aiRreq-er

th-14 t qk Nworil 3TuT4T Q.Tr-AtzT telt qe.noqi IIiCi fecurrie wrer

alarm-4 mnr fkzfrt aR rdter rezT t, l Relf

ftrarr trfer- (mil at: a t f rr ‘-eue ti Taff, a Atli-RI

RPa4{, 2001 (TTTRI— X111 Zia) ZIglif Trt—ef Vi

NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACI LER EDUCATION

NOTIFICATION

New Delhi, the 23rd August, 2010 F. No. 61-03/20/2010/NCTE/(N&S).—In exercise of the powers conferred by Sub-section (I) of Section 23 of the

Right of Children to Free and Compulsory EducationAct, 2009 (35 of 2009), and in pursuance of Notification No. S.O. 750 (E) dated 31st March, 2010 issued by the Departrnent of School Education and Literacy, Ministty ofFiuman Resource Development, Government of India, the National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE)hereby lays down the followingminimum.sualifications for a person to be eligfitie for appointment as a teaeher in class I to VIII in a school referred to in clause (n) of Section 2 of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009, with effect from the date ofthis Notification :-

1 Minimum Qualifications.-

(i) Classes IN

(a)

Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 50% marks and 2 - year Diploma in Elementary Education (by whatever name known)

OR

Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 45% marks and 2 - year Diploma in Elementary Education (by

whatever name known), in accordance with the NOTE (Recognition Norms and Procedure), Regulations 2002

OR

Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at bast 50% marks and 4-year Bachelor of Elementary Education (B.

El. Ed.)

argcre ITW -Tan Cfnitta III/4/131 /10-41in

OR

Page 72: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

6

CA' -.I -

THE GAZELLE OF INDIA : EXTRAORDINARY [Pm 4)

Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 50% marks and 2 - year Diploma in Education (Special

Education)

AND

Pass in the Teacher Eligibility Test (TED, to be conducted by the appropriate Government in accordance with

the Guidelines framed by the NCTE for the purpose..

Classes VI VIII

B.A/B.Sc and 2 - year Diploma in Elementary Education (by whatever name known)

OR

BA/B.Sc. with at least 50% marks and 1- year Bachelor in Education (B. Ed)

OR

BA/B.Sc. with at least 45% marks and 1 - year Bachelor in Education (8. Ed), in accordance with the NCTE

(Recognition Norms and Procedure) Regulations issued from time to time in this regard

OR

Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 50% marks and 4-year Bachelor in Elementary Education (B.

EL Ed) -

OR

Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 50% marks and 4-year BA/B.Sc. Ed or B.A. Ea/6So. Ed.

OR

BA .Sc. with at least 50% marks and 1 year B.Ed. (Special Education)

AND (b) Pass in the Teacher Eligibility Test (TED, to be conducted by the appropriate Government in accordance with

the Guidelines framed by the NCTE for the purpose.

2 DiplomalDegree Course in Teacher Education.- For the purposes of this Notification, a diploma/degree

course in teacher education recognized by the National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) only shalt be considered.

However, in case of Diploma in Education (Special Education) and B. Ed (Special EdUcation), a course recognized by

the Rehabilitation Council of India (RCI) only shall be considered.

Page 73: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

[VIII-541 Sart Wr MitirtRuf 7

Training to be undergone.- A person -

a) with BA/B.Sc. with at least 50% marks and B. Ed qualification shall also be eligible for appointment for Class Ito V

pto 1st January, 2012, provided he undergoes, after appointment, an NCTE recognized 6-month special programme in

lementary Education.

a) with D. Ed (Special Education) or B. Ed (Special Education) qualification shall undergo, after appointment, an NCTE

:cognized 6-month special programme in Elementary Education.

Teacher appointed before the date of this Notification.- The following categories of teachers appointed for

lasses I to VIII prior to date of this Notification need not acquire the minimum qualifications specified in Para (1) above,:

0 A teacher appointed on or after the 3rd September, 2001 i.e. the date on which the NCTE (Determination of

linimum Qualifications for Recruitment of Teachers in Schools) Regulations, 2001 (as amended from time to time)

ame into force, in accordance with that Regulation.

rovided that a teacher of class Ito V possessing B. Ed qualification, or a teacher possessing B. Ed (Special Education)

D Ed (Special Education) qualification shall undergo an NCTE recognized 6 — month special programme on

ementary education.

0 A teacher of class I to V with B. Ed qualification who 'has completed a 6-month Special Basic Teacher Course

>pedal BM) approved by the NCTE;

A teacher appointed before the V September, 2001, in accordance with the prevalent Recruitment Rules.

Teacher appointed after the date of this Notification in certain cases.- Where an appropriate Government

local authority or a school has issued an advertisement to initiate the process of appointment of teachers prior to the

Ile of this Notification, such appointments may be made in accordance with the NCTE (Determination of Minimum

ualifications for Recruitment of Teachers in Schools) Regulations, 2001 (as amended from time to time).

HASIBAHMAD, Member-Secy. [ADVT III/4/13 1/10-Exty.)

Printed by the Rfenager, Government of India Press, Ring Road, Mayapuri, New Delhi-I10064 and Published by rhu funitaitr-r nonu_i mutt

Page 74: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

rUNC-11, R

NCYIIMCATtON

New 1)e/hi. the 29thiuly, 2011 F. No. 61-1/2011 /NCTE(N&S).-111 exercise °MC potivers confened by su h-section (1) ofthe Section23ot' Bight

of Ch ildren to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009(35 of2009) and in pursuance oftheNotifkationNO. 75t,ktl dated 31st March, 2010 issued by the Departntent of School •Edueatiem and Litcrags Ministry of Human itesource Development, Government of India, the National. Council forTeacher Education (NCFE) hereby Makes* Slowing amen dmentsto the Notification No. 215 dated 25th August, 2010 pubilsbed in the Gazette ofindia, Extraordiant3sPart - Sezt ion - 4, vide ENO. 61-1 /2011-NCTE(N8cS). dated theardAugust, 2010, laying downthe MinthintincittitWeations fora person to be eligible for appointment as a teacher(hereby retentdio as thePrintipal Notification) namely:—

CUFor stth-para (i)ofpara I of the Principal Notitication,the following shall besubstituted, namely :-1. Minimum Qualifscatious:—

(i) Classes X—V

(a) Senior Secondary (or its cquivalent)wilit at kart 50% znarks and 2-year Diplotna in Element Education whatever name known)

at

Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 45% marks and 2-year Diploma in Elementaty Education (by 'hate name known), in accotdance with dreNCTE (RecognitionNorms arid ProcedUre),-Regulatipns, 2002.

SeniorSceondary(or.itsequivalmn)wititat least,50%tilarks and 4-yea.rBachelorofEtenientary EducattonaliEl

OR Senior Secondary (or its tquivalent)with atic st 50% marks and 2.y&tr Diploma incation(S

pecialrh4tiation)

ttq:z,' (b)Pass in the TachtrEligibitity Test it to be obutlutied by theapproptiate GovtmmentinaxordanceWith

Guidelines named bythe NCTE for the PulimSL

) For su b-para (ii) of pan 1 of the PritelparNotintattion, the (ollowingshal/ besubstituted,namely )1) Classes VI—V111

(a) Graduation and2-year Diploma in ElementaryEducation(by whatevername known)

CR Graduation with atleast 5094 marksand 1-year Bachelor in Education (B.Ecl )

OR

Graduation with at least 45% marks and 1-year Bachelor in Education (B.Ed.), in accordance with theNCTE zoo Won Norms and Procedure) Regulations issued from time to time in this regard.

OR

Senior Secondary (or its equivalent) with at least 50% marks and 4-year Bachelor in Elementary Education (a.m.ea.)

OR Senior Seconaary (or its cgvivalenp with at least 50% marks and4,-ye A .Sc.Ed. or B,A. Ed

rwn (3raduauon with at leas/ 50% maths and 1 ;ea ilEd. (Special Education)

AND (b) Pass in 1-cather Eligibility Test (`27 to be conducted by the appropriate Government in accardanccw

th clings framed by the NCTE for the purpose.

Cft GradUatiOn and two year Diploma in EletnentaryEdueation (by whatev n

Page 75: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

WKRAMSAHAY, eonvener

MONITiii/41131/2011/Egv."

Station 4,VideNuinber Note :-Ihe Principalliotaicafiort E.61-120114,1CM(MtS),

i "FRA NA I Pt L.;

(0 frailliflf, to tie undergone. A penien--

(L) with eiredintion with at least Soi4 111214AS and atd, qua? dice orwith at least 45% marks and 1-yeai 13,-Aelor in Felucanor MEd.), inamen:len with the NOM (Recognition Norms an tics:dine) Regulations issued from tirne zo tent in this regal" aisohe forappoinuneat to Class I to V vp to 1st Janny.,.2, 2012, providaditersheworgoe4 afk, appoint/lien., an NCTE recocpkzed 6-month Special Peogranune manna./ Lducation;

(b) witlin.Eci:(SpqciAlEducation) or-II.Ed, (Special &Nation) qualifieaticin shall uttgeOtterViOintmegall NCTErecognizedb-tuoirth SpecialTrograttnne in Elernentar; Education..

(ii)ResanatIon Policy :

Relaxation up to-5% in the qualifyingtnarks shall be nllowed to the candidates belonging to res ed ca as SCST/OBC/Pit

ov) For Oa ra 5 of the PrinelpalNotification, the f011owing shall betubstituted, na meIy:-

5. (a) Teacher appointed After thulateof this notiftcation in certain cases :--Wher eanapiaopriateGORtnment oi- local authority or aschoothas issued atadvettisement0 initiate thepr4ce,ss,of appoirrtmentOteacherspriortothedare ofthis NollIkation such appointractdsmaybernacteumeeordanccwatbtheht.it.(Dcteninnation ofivhninnaln Qualifications for Recruitment ofteachers inSchooh) Re‘,ulations, 2001 (asamcnded from timeto -tithe).

(b) The minimum gnardieltial 11°MtS retr0 to in thfr 1\14 Q4 IY incliests erlaWizagcs S(*ial Studies, Mathenlatict Seienoe, f Physical Education-warners Mkt:Indio-in be applicable. Forzeachern4fArt Edocarloa.Cailt norms PresFribed bYd..t.e&a,ie,G*vetranElaaPly down thetifutimuni (pit iffettiOns in vespeetaiticittc;chets.

Page 76: - Sudipta Dassupta Advocate - SARTHAC

DISTRICT 24 PARGANAS (NORTH) IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA

CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION

APPELLATE SIDE

W.P.A No. /53g of 2021

In The Matter Of: -

An application under Article

226 of the Constitution of

India;

-And-

IN THE MATTER OF

SWETA MAHANTA & ORS.

PETITIONERS

VERSUS

STATE OF WEST BENGAL &

ORS

RESPONDENTS

PETITION

SUDIPTA DASGUPTA Advocate

10, Kiran Sankar Roy Road, Room no. 35, (Mezzanine Floor), Kolkata- 700 001. Mob: 9432977913.

Email: [email protected]