rejectingfreedomandprogress.comrejectingfreedomandprogress.com/wp-content/uploads/...Third Worldism ...

/

Third Worldism

(substitute)

(complementarity)

(three dimensional)

(state within the state)

(Facticity)

(state within the state) loyal

disobedience

self-defeating

Loyal disobedience

(value-neutral)

voluntary

Governance process

Scottish enlightenment

Dynamic

2 1

Ultimate end (Freedom) (Capita)

Contribution

(Principal of

Capital accumlation)

Capitalist socialisation Capitalist Socialization

Intellectual

(Heroes)

impartiality

armed forces

(Imperial oversight agents)

non national citizens

capital market

circle of capital

(Rating)

legislature

processes

Authoritarian

Authoritarian

Personnel

Representation Mediation

1

mediation2

mediation

proceses Interest Groups

Heroes Political Parties

Administration and courts

1

2

3

similarities

4 5

NGOs

Mediation Mediation

Mediation

Co-option

co.option

co.optco.option Const i tuency Const i tuency

legitimacy

:Exclusion

Mediation

Mediation Mediat ion

Mediation

processes

Tolerance:

Tolerance Tolerance T o l e ra nc e

Tolerance

Relative Nature Tolerance

Tolerance

Choice of Choice

Tolerance Tolerance

Process

Tolerance

Sc o t t i s h Commerce Enlightenment

Commerce

Right of self determination

Ontological ontological Liberalism Liberalism

De

Good ontological Liberalism Ontological Liberalism

ontological John Mill ontological Good Liberal ism

Good Liberalism

''In all the states of created being capable of laws, where

there are no laws there is no freedom.''

Private property

Good ontological Liberalism

Good ontological Liberalism Scottish Enlightenment Utilitarianism

Utilitarianism J.S.Mill

Pleasure Good ontological Liberalism

[Right] Pleasure

Right-based liberalism De-ontological Liberalism

R a w l s M e t a p h y s i c a l Utilitarianism

self-interested

Primary Goods Basic primary Goods

Wealth Power

Income Authority

Primary Goods Primary Goods

Content Contents

Basic primary goods Content Content

Content

''I am not ready to argue with any one who is not liberal,

I am not going to argue with him, I am going to shoot him.''

End

Puritan Protestant

Revisionist

PuritanShariah

Constraint

Glorious Revolution

William Marry Puritan Movement

Enclosure Movement

Enclosure Movement

Individualism Marketize

Human Civil Society

Violence

17921774

165

/

1784

17 1789

Hugenot

Hugenot

/

Terror , Violence

General Will

Third Estate Allies

1 2 3

Declaration of Independence Federalist Papers

1492

Red Indians

Indians

The Civilization

Dark side of the demo cracy

1776

Slavery American Civil War

''We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created

equal,and they are endowed by their creator with certain

unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the

pursuit of happiness.''

Right of Life 1

Red Indians Red Indian

Right of Property 2

Property Accumulation of Capital

Red Indians

Right of Consciousness 3

Labour Market

Slave Labour

1

(Negroes) Slavery

2

Wage Labour

3

Lincoln Confederation Union

1861-1865

Maximizition of

Pleasure/ Happiness

Human Rights

Red Indians

1

2

3

4

Mob

Secular Intellectuals

Trade Unions

"The state should not have any thing to do with telling people what to

wear, what to eat and drink, what they should believe in"

"He has no plans to ban bikinis on the beach or the sale of

alcohol, for example, I would prefer it if people didn't do this, but it

is up to them "He says"

(empirical)

(Enlightenment)

Humanity

(fuedalism) (mode of production)

progressive

progressive

division of labor (antagonism)

(Paris Commune)

(armed people) (armed force)

(Working conditions)

(Voucher)

(Consumption)

Specie being

(scarcity)

(division of labor)

(Consumption)

(Specie being)

(wither away)

(Humanity as being part of himself)

(Wither away)

(Human agency)

.

State and Revolution

(Neutralize)

Kautsky

(State is

an organ to reconcile class-antagonism)

super structure

(state is an organ to promote irreconcilable class-antagonism)

(i)

(ii)

(Revolutionary situation)

(Class for itself)

(Wither away)

(abundance)

Revolutionary

Situation

(Material and objective necessity)

Centralized organization Organization of violence

Democratic centralism (i

Freedom of discussion, unity of action

Over-development (ii

:Professionalism (iii

:Violence (iv

(i

Capitalist Development in Russia

ii

(Base camp)

(Class for itself) (class in itself)

Vanguard .

Four Essays on Philosophy

On Correct Handling of Contradictions among the People

(The people)

Non-antagonistic Antagonistic

non (antagonistic) Antagonistic

Universality of contradiction

Particularity of contradiction

(Co-operatives) (Consumption)

(Accumulation)

democratic centralism

'unity, criticism, unity'

Han Chauvinism

Han Chauvinism

unity, criticism, unity

(Koutsky)

(Paris Commune)

(humanity) Specie being

Specie being

(Ideology)

(Autonomus and self-determinent)

(Human Being) (self-determination)

Human Being (Human Being)

(Equal Freedom)

(Progress) (Will) (Human Being)

(Ideologies)

(Sc ient if ic

(Engels) (Marx) Socialism)

(Techniques of Production)

(Relations of Production)

(Techniques (Relations of Production)

(Relation of of Production)

Production)

18 (Feudal) 19

(Bourgeois

class)

19

(Techniques of Production)

Plan (Nationalize)

(Market)

(Bourgeois)

Human being

Plan

1917

(Lenin)

(Revo l ut ionary - Conciousness)

(Trade - Union)

Vanguard (Representative) Vanguard

(Dictatorship of the Proletariat)

(Full Time Revolutionist) (Democratic Centralization)

(Voluntary)

Vanguard

(Dictatorship of the Proletariat)

1860

1860

(Peasants)

Narodnik

Narodnik 1880 1870

Narodnik Saska Saska 14

Narodnik

Russia Social Democrate and Labour Pleknonoe 1883(RSDLP)Party 1883

RSDLP 1883 (Marxism)

RSDLP 1898

RSDLP

RSDLP

RSDLP

RSDPL 21

Development of Capitalism in Russia

RSDLP

Narodnik RSDLP

RSDLP1902 RSDLP RSDLP

(Memshevik) (Bolshevik)

Murtov RSDLP

(Czar) 1905

St. Petersbourgh

Soviet

- St. Petersbourgh

1905-

- Soviets

Soviets

Orthodox church

1917 1905

(Duma)

Stopin

Socialist Revolutiounary Narodvik

1914 party

Bolshevik

Sovie t 1917 1905

Soviet Soviet

,So c ia l i s t RSD LP Soviet Bolshevik Revolutionary Memshevik

Bolshevik

1917 1906 Supreme Soviet

Supreme Soviet Soviet

Socialist Revolutiounary Memshevik

1906-1917

1914 1917

1917

Social ist Revolut ionar ies

Sup re m e So vie t (Dum en)

Kerenskey 1917 Kerenskey

Kerenskey 1917 The April Thesis

Lenin Kerenskey

(Soviet)

Bolshevik Supreme Soveit

1917 Kremline Kremline 4

54 1924 (Civil war) 1921 1918 1917

74 (Empire)

( V a n g u a r d )

(Specie being) (Humanity)

Humanity Specie being

Specie

(Will) (Human being)

Specie being

Human being

(Self Conciousness existence) Humanity Specie being

Specie being

Dictatorship of Humanity Specie being

Specie being the Proletariat

Dictatorship of the Proletariat

Dictatorship of the Proletariat

1923-24 1906 Specie being

1921 1918

( E conom ic boycott)

1924 1906

Socialist Revolutionary 1921 1918

(Leon Trotsky) Memshevik Trotsky

(Trotsky) (Civil war)

Stalin

Specie being

Specie

being

KGB (Torture)

(Soviet) KGB

Civil war

Civil war

1953 1925 Stalin Building Socialism in one country

Civil war

Soveitman

Stalin

(Planing)

Civil war (New Economic Policy)

1927

Stalin (Capital Market) (Money Market)

Brezhnev

Dictatorship of the Proletariat

1995

Human

Yanan

Well to do Middle Peasant

(Armed Uprising)

(Costal Cities)

(Peasent Army) -

Socialist

Ideals Ideals

/

Potentially

Class

(Sick Man of Europe)

/

/ (Planned Mass Action

Strategy)

Enlightenment

17 15

(pan)

1857

G8

[Third world nationalism]

[Diasposa Nationalism] [Stateless Nationalism]

19

[Will of people]

18 10

(Hindu tiva)

Hunduness Hinduness Hindu Way of Life

1980

8

/

RSS RSS

(National Volunteer Organization)

Complete India

Tolerance

1967 VHP

VHP Revive

BJP RSS

1980 1951 1996

1998 13

2001

Central Concept

Land Father (Holy land)

(S) (H)

Father Land

Holy land

Holy land Father

/

/

land

19

1857

/ /

/ / /

Berington Moore

(Strategy)

(Peasants) Feudals

(Surplus)

(Financial)

1857 1947 1857

25 800

(Renaissance) 13 16

(surplus)

(cast system)

(commercial)

Permanent Settlement

Parasitic

(Train)

34

Lord Macaullay said the following about India in 1835 in

British Parliament.

"I have traveled across the length and breadth of India

and I have not seen one person who is a beggar, who is a thief.

Such wealth I have seen in this country, such high moral values,

people of such calibre, that I do not think we would ever conquer

this country, unless we break the very backbone of this nation,

which is her spiritual and cultural heritage, and, therefore, I

propose that we replace her old and ancient education system,

her culture, for if the Indians think that all that is foreign and

English is good and greater than their own, they will lose their

self-esteem, their native self-culture and they will become what

we want them, a truly dominated nation."

"We must do our best to form a class who may be

interpreter between us and the millions whom we govern, a class

of persons Indian in blood and colour but English in taste, in

openions, words and intellect."

30,000

Reformist Society

(Development)

1857

(Symbols)

(Goal)

(Symbol)

16

50

25 800

1868

1895 (Jose Marti)

(Castro)

Platt. Amendment

1934

Grav San Martin 1952 Batista

"In 1959 US nationals owned 90% of the country electricity light and power service, 50% of

public railways, the telephone industry and a vast majority of the

country's transportation, mining import, manufacturing and

tourist industries". (Haddad, 2003, p.74)

1959

Ideologue 1959

Fidelity Fidelity

Fidelity

Fidelity is a Star of the mind that equates uncompromising loyalty

to the nation, socialism and Castro with true revolutionary

Consciousness (Medin, 1990)

Fidelity

Idealized

Third Worldism

(anti-globalization)

Frantz Fanon, Ahmed Ben Bella, Gamal Abdel

Nasser, Andre Gunder Frank, Samir Amin and Simon Malley

(national liberation movements)

(vertical or herarchical)

(growth)

(uniting factor)

(epistemological)

(Reformation) (Reconstruction)

(cultural symbol)

(motivating and binding force)

:

(Presume)

Over throw

Revisionist

Revisionist Thought

Litmus Test

Revisionist

Revisionist

Substance Form

(Substance)

(Form) Substance Form

Revisionists Modernists

Form

Form, Substance

Human

Human

(rationality)

(ill-liberal democracy)

pluralistic

Enlightened

(general (will of all) will)

.

...

-

.

(pre-suppose)

.

.

...

.

.

pragmatism

.

(universal conception of peace)

(the truth)

.

(structure and discipline)

(facticity)

.

(facticity)

.

(spontaneous)

.

(substitute) (complementarity)

(three dimensional)

(state within state)

( p r oc es s )

(institutions)

(specialize)

(grassroot level)

Future of Freedom

Tolerant

tolerant

dogmatic intolerant

(matured)

Practice

1

2

3

Pluralism

Justice & Development

20 19

1905 Peters burgh 1862 1871

2007 2002

2007 2002

Human Tolerance Pluralism Rights

APDM

Tolerance, Pluralism APDM

(Advisor)

(Financial (Capital Market) Market)

Caspian Sea

%10 %40

11

%98 1501

12

12

[Equality]

Freedom

1921

1925 /

/

/

1941

1953 1974 1951

M-16 CIA

1954

1963 (White Revolution)

1

2

3

4

5

6

(Life with Political Power) 1

(Life without Political Power) 2

Restructure Principles

Accommodate

Imperfect

Bad Government is better than no Government

Moral Law

Moral Law

Social Network

(Epistemological Weakness)

(Islamic epistemology)

(Spontaneous)

Mudetergitimise

Reconciliation

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1861 20

50

48

(Handesson)

(currency)

Suara-al-Islam

Montesqieu Locke

(option)

option

Vanguard Vanguard

Vanguard

Vanguard

Vanguard 0.01

Vanguard

Vanguard (Superman)

Vanguard Supermen

Vanguard

Vanguard

Vanguard

Vanguard

Democratic Vanguard

Centralism

party line Forum

party line Vanguard Democratic Centralism

p a r t y l i n e

Vanguard

party party line line

party line Vanguard

party line party line

Vanguard Democratic Centralism

Democratic Centralist party line

party line

party line

Vanguard

Bernstein Lenin Entryism

1970 Weimer 1970

Entrysim (Historic Compromise)

Union

Entryism

Entryism

1940

1948-1949

1957 1948

1953 1957

1959/1958

1978-79 1969 (2004-2008)

Gangsu Xinjiang

(Persecution)

World Bank I.M.F ADB World Bank I.M.F

Certificates

Social democrat

Strategy