Wal-Mart A dirty word?
Jan 12, 2016
Wal-Mart
A dirty word?
Founded by Sam Walton Headquarters in Bentonville, Arkansas WMT – Stock letters on NYSE Revenue - $378,799,000,000.00 Profit - $12,731,000,000.00 Stock Price – 10-20-10 - $53.28 High - $63.85 Low - $42.50 Market Cap - $277 billion Shares – 3.9 billion CEO – Mike Duke
Wal-Mart
Wal-Mart – The Bully from Bentonville – How Wal-Mart is destroying the world
The Wal-Mart Revolution
The Wal-Mart Triumph
If Wal-Mart were to open in your town, how would you feel?
Books About Wal-Mart
1.8 million employees $7 billion in weekly revenue $378 billion in annual revenue 3,400 stores 550 Sam’s Clubs Larger then the next 5 largest retailers combined
◦ Home Depot◦ Sears◦ Kroger◦ Costco◦ Target
Facts and Figures
120 million shoppers each week
84% of Americans drive by a Wal-Mart each week
15% of Chinese imports go to WM
China’s 8th largest trading partner
Facts & Figures
Estimated 8% to 39% price reductions due to WM groceries
Only soda sold for less at other stores
WM pushes down prices an avg. of 13%
WM has greater effect in smaller cities
Price Advantages
$40,000 - $45,000 – avg. income for WM shoppers
$60,000 for Target $74,000 for Costco Save $782 per family per year buying
groceries at WM 1.5% of income Country would save $87 billion if everyone
bought groceries at WM
Wal-Mart Shoppers
Closer you live to a WM, the more you save
46% of Americans live within 5miles of a WM or Sam’s Club
67% of stores in U.S. within 5 miles of WM
Wal-Mart Locations
Sells more DVDs than anyone
Largest customer for Disney, P & G, Kraft, Hershey, Revlon & Gilette
Biggest seller of – groceries, guns, toys, diamonds, jewelry, cds, apparel, dogfood, detergents, sporting goods, video games, socks, bedding and toothpaste
Largest film developer and optician
Sales
2-5 businesses close within 5 years of a WM opening
Avg. county in U.S. has over 200 stores Accused of predatory pricing Occasionally uses loss leaders-lose money
on certain items to attract customers Practice legal or illegal? Chain grocery stores were already hurting
mom & pop stores Very low margins in the grocery business
Economic Effects
Keeping WM at bay hurts the consumer
WM expanded into groceries because it was profitable
WM has been sued for its business practices
Most suits settled out of court
Economic Effects
All stores connected by computer, bar codes, and the largest private satellite system
Suppliers are connected as well Items are now being radio tagged to track
them anywhere WM’s size allows them to spread costs and
bargain for cheaper prices WM can modify space to have more toys
than Toys-R-Us at Christmas and reduce toys after holidays
Wal-Mart Productivity
Economies of density – training, distribution and advertising are cheaper when one store opens near another
WM is 40% more productive per worker than competition
Productivity expands the economy WM responsible for 10% of countries
productivity growth in the 90s Key losers are competitors not customers
Wal-Mart Productivity
New stores hire 400 workers or associates Net effect on jobs is hard to calculate People leave competitors to work at WM so
net gain would not be 400 jobs Complaints and lawsuits over wages Despite wages, 8,000 people applied for
500 jobs at new store in Glendale – better odds for a Harvard applicant
Wal-Mart Labor
Employees typically are poorer with less education and few job skills
Median wage in 2001 was $9.00 vs. $8.34 for the country
Labor market is competitive for workers in the WM labor pool
WM typically draws employees from lower income areas
Wal-Mart Labor
No WM is unionized vs. 6% of the competition Stiff anti-union tactics Switched to prepackaged meats when
meatpackers tried to unionize 2005 closed a store in Quebec that voted in a
union In both cases courts ruled against WM Sued in 30 states for off the clock work 2006 PA workers awarded $78 million Sued for no break and subcontracting with illegals Competitors have been sued as well
Wal-Mart Labor
WM benefits are considered stingy WM benefits are higher than the rest of the
industry Many employees are poor and have govt.
health plans
Wal-Mart Labor
Traffic congestion Too much development Tax incentives for development Refuses to sell some products
◦ Magazines◦ Recordings◦ Morning after pill
Wal-Mart Concerns
http://walmartstores.com/Sustainability http://investing.businessweek.com/research
/stocks/people/people.asp?symbol=WMT http://investing.businessweek.com/business
week/research/stocks/people/person.asp?personId=313059&capId=313055&previousCapId=313055&previousTitle=Wal-Mart%20Stores%20Inc.
Links
1,000’s of lawsuits Most are class action suits for unpaid wages Other examples
◦ Detained for shoplifting◦ Bathroom mess◦ Slip and falls◦ Wrongful termination◦ Sexual harassment◦ Disability not accommodated◦ Fell off break chair
Wal-Mart Lawsuits
Sam Walton worked at J.C. Penny Bought a Ben Franklin – lost his lease Bought a 5 & 10 Opened 1st store in 1950 Sought better terms from suppliers and
passed savings to customers 1962 – 11 stores
Wal-Mart Founding
Must be efficient to supply Wal-Mart Just in time inventory WM is cutting suppliers by developing their
own brands (Sam’s Choice)◦ Sell detergent for ½ price of Tide◦ Old Roy now outsells Purina◦ WM can cut out middleman and negotiate directly
with China and others
Wal-Mart Suppliers
Economists as a whole say savings to consumers outweigh costs
Most complaints are by competitors and about low wages and poor benefits
Americans have a love/hate relationship with Wal-Mart
Conclusion