По результатам рассмотрения докторской ...test.ssla.ru/dissertation/solutions/23-08-2016-1sol1.pdf · 2016-08-23 · perxeHl4e AI{ccepraIII4oHHoro

По результатам рассмотрения докторской диссертации направленной на

дополнительное заключение Абдуджалилова Абдуджабара на тему:

«Теоретические проблемы гражданских правоотношений в Интернете» по

специальности 12.00.03 – гражданское право; предпринимательское право;

семейное право; международное частное право (юридические науки)

диссертационный совет Д-212.239.03 при федеральном государственном

бюджетном образовательном учреждении высшего образования «Саратовская

государственная юридическая академия» принял решение не присуждать

соискателю Абдуджалилову А. ученую степень доктора юридических наук.

На заседании диссертационного совета при рассмотрении докторской

диссертации направленной на дополнительное заключение Абдуджалилова А.

присутствовали:

Ф.И.О. Уч. степень Шифр специальности

Исаенкова О.В. Д.ю.н. 12.00.15

Шестерякова И.В. Д.ю.н. 12.00.03

Колодуб Г.В. К.ю.н. 12.00.03

Афанасьев С.Ф. Д.ю.н. 12.00.15

Барков А.В. Д.ю.н. 12.00.03

Вавилин Е.В. Д.ю.н. 12.00.03

Валеев Д.Х. Д.ю.н. 12.00.15

Григорьева Т.А. Д.ю.н. 12.00.15

Кузбагаров А.Н. Д.ю.н. 12.00.15

Морозов С.Ю. Д.ю.н. 12.00.03

Попов В.В. Д.ю.н. 12.00.03

Сенякин И.Н. Д.ю.н. 12.00.15

Соловьева Т.В. Д.ю.н. 12.00.15

Цыбуленко З.И. Д.ю.н. 12.00.03

Председатель диссертационного совета, доктор юридических наук, профессор

О.В. Исаенкова

AOIOnHI4IEJIbHOE 3AKJIIOTIEFIIaE A,ICCEPTAI_U4OHHO| O COBETA

A 212.239.03 HA BA3E OETPAnbHO|O |OCyAAPCTBEFIHO|O EFOIpI(ET-

HO|O OEPA3OBATEJIbHO|O YIIPEXrcHI4.fl BbICIIIE|O OEPA3OBAHI4fl

TAPATOBCKAjI |OCyIAPCTBEHFIA.fl IOPIIN,I9F,CKATI AKArcMI{rI>

I\/fril*ICTEPCTBA OEPA3OB AIil4fl'I4 HAyKI'I PO

NO WTCCEPTAIU4I,I IIA COI{CKAHI4E YTIEHOIZ CTEIIEHI4

AOKTOPAHAYK

arrecrarruoHHoe relo J\b

perxeHl4e AI{ccepraIII4oHHoro coBera or 18 aBrycra 2016 r. Ns 17

O nprE cyx Aenrlv A64y4xaru4 Jr o By ,4.6 ayaxa 6 upy, rp axA aH I4ny P e c ny 6 nurcu

TaANurncraH, yteuofi crerlenn AoKTopa rcpI'IALIqecKI4x HayK.

3aqnra Ar4cceprarlzu A6ay.qxanr{JroBa A6ayaxa6apa <<TeoperuqecKl,Ie

upo6leuu rpax{AaHcKr4x rrpaBoorHoruettuit s Znrepuere)> cocrotJlacb 02 ot<rn6pt'

2015 r. e O6reAr{HeHHoM Ar4cceprarluoHHoM coBere nlI 737.004.08 npz Ta4-

xr{KcKoM HarILroHzrJrbHoM yHrrBepczrere, I4ncruryre QznocoQ^^, rronl4ToJlorvrkr vr

rrpaBa HMeHrl A.M. EaxosaAALrHoBa AH Pecny6turcw TaAxurzcraH, MOy BIIO

<<Pocczfi cro-TaAxurcrufi (claeancr ufi) y uuaepcl4Ter)>.

HayrHrrfi KoHcynbraHT - AoKTop ropkrAl4rrecKLIx HayK, npoSeccop, 3acJly-

xennrrfi Aerrenb HayKr4 r.r rexHr4Ku Pecny6iII4KtI TaAxurzcraH III.M. Zctr{auroe.

Orsrrnn, nocryrrr{Brrrrae Ha Arrcceprarlruo (oQnquaJlbHbx orIrIoHeHToB - AoK-

ropa topr{AuqecKlrx HoyK, upoSeccopa A.f. ,{u4enr<o, AoKTopa rcpuAl{llecKl,rx HayK,

lpo$eccopa B.lI. KausrurancKoro, Aorilopa rcpLIALIqecKI{x HayK, npo$eccopa JI.A.

rleroea4se; BeAyrqefi opranvlaar\vrv - (DIEOy BIIO <PocczficKat rocyAapcrBeHH€ul

aKa1evrur r{HrenneKTyamsofi co6crnenHocrrD) (P|AI4C) u anropeQepar Al4ccepra-

quz A. A6.4y4xalr4rroBa, rBJrrrorcr noJroxrr{TeJIbHbIMIa I,I coAepx(ar BbIBoAbI o roM,

rrro AkrcceprarlrloHHan pa6ora coorBercrByer rpe6onaHvIflM) IrpeAbsBJUIeMbIM K Ha-

frHbrM LrccneAoBaHuflM AoKropcKoro ypoBrul ) a ee aBTop - A6ayax€LTII4JIoB A6nya-

xa6ap - 3acJryx(LrBaer npr4cynqeHLrs. yreHofi creIreHLI AoKTopa rcpllAtauecKax HayK

lro cnequarrbHocTtr 12.00.03 - rpax,4allcKoe npaBo; IIpeAIIpI4HLTMaTeJIbcKoe rrpaBo;

ceMeftHoe rlpaBo ; MexAyHapoAHoe qacrHoe rlpaBo.

llo p$ynbraraM 3arrltrrbr O6rcAunennsrfi Allccepralluounnfi coBer ,[\4

737.004"08 mrxe cAenaJr BbrBo,{ o roM, qro Auccepralluq A. A6ryAXarII4JIoBa rIPeA-

craBJyrer co6ofi Ha)rr{Ho-KBann$uraqr4oHrrylo pa6ory, coorBercrByroqylo KpLITepr{-

rM, ycraHoBJreHHbrM lloloxeHrleM o noptAKe npucylxAeHzrl freHbIX creneHeu, yrB.

flocranosreHlreM flpanarenbcrBa P@ or 24 ceurs6ps.2013 r. N0842, 14 rlpuruIn pe-

rrreHr4e nplrcyAlrrr A. A6gy,{xarrzJroBy }ryeHylo crerleHb AoKTopa rcpl4AlrqecKlfx Ha-

yr. Peeynbrarbr rrpoBeAeHHoro B coorBercrrivrvr c pernaMeHToM rafinoro roJlocoBa-

Hr{t cneAyarque: uz lg rIeJroBeK, BXoA{Iqax B cocraB coBera, B KoJILIqecree 15 qero-

BeK, Lr3 srry.7 AoKTopoB HayK no crrerll{€ulbHocrl{ 3alrlI4lrlaerraofi Auccepral{lau, rrporo-

JrocoBztrln: 3a - 1 3, nponE B - 2, neAeficrsuTeJlbHbrx 6rornerenefi - ner.

,{anee orKpbrrbrM roJrocoBaHr4eM eAvHornacHo rlpl4Htro 3aKJlroqeHue AEc-

ceprarluoHHoro coBera rro Alrcceprapu A. A6ay.QK€trILIJIoBa, Koropoe rro orpa-

xeHHbIM B efo COAep)KaHI4U aCIIeKTaM tBnteTcg llonoxtl{TeJlbHblM.

B coorsercrBr{u c [paBr4JraMr4, npeAycMorpeHHbIMI4 n. S2lloloxenurfl, o co'

Bere rro 3arrlare Ar4ccepra\uit sa co[cKaHue yrenofi creneHl4 KaHAI{Aara HayK, Ha

cor{cKaHr4e yuenofi crereHlr AoKropa HayK or 13 fl:nBaps' 20L4 r. Nb 7, I.trr. o3Ha-

KoMneHr4r c HarrpaBJreHHbrMLr Bucurefi arrecralll{onHofi KoMl{ccuefi upu Mu-

no6pHaynu P(D B Ar{cceprarluoHHbrfi coser [ 212.239.03 ua 6a:e Se4epanbHoro

rocyAapcrBeHHoro 6rogxeruoro o6pa:oBareJlbHoro f{pex{AeHl4-l Bblcllrero o6pa-

3oBaHrir{ <<CaparoncKar rocyAapcrBeHHa{ ropllALTrlecKat aKaAeMIlD) Allccepra\r4evr

v1aurepvraJraM6r arrecrarluoHHoro Aeila A. A6AyA)I{aJII{JIoBa, orIeHKI{ Kpurl4qecKl4x

3aMeqaHr4fi, nrrcrasaHubrx Kounccuefi. na grarle paccMorperlvrfl. arrecralll4oHHoro

AeJIa, U npeAcTaBIrelc.ufl, upoeKTa AouonHuTeJlbHofo 3aKJIIOqeHVIfl, VI3 IIJIeHOB AI{C-

ceprarluoHHoro coBera 1212.239.03 6ula co3AaHa KoMLIcct4t. PeneuueM coBera

or 24 prroHrr 2016 r. Jtlb 12 s cocraB KoMLrccr4I4 BorrrJII,I: AoKTop ropl{Al4qecKkIx HayK,

AorIeHr VI.B. [lecrepaKoBa, AoKrop IopLIALITIecKLIX HayK, npoQeccop A.B.Eapron,

AoKrop rcpuAI4qecKl/tx HayK, nposeccop c.Io. Moposon.

B o6cyxAeHlrr4 Arrccepraqnu A.A 6 ly lxatmJloBa Ha 3aceA aEr4r4 Al4ccepra-

rILToHHoro coBera L212.239.03 nzrro r{3 rrJreHoB coBera yqacrue npvr]F'fl.n. flocle

o6cyx4enprr BorrpocoB, orHocflrr\vxcs, K coAepxaHwo ALIccepraIII4oHHoro llccile-

AoBaHu.n A. A6aylxairr4rroBa, AL4ccepraIIrIoHHbIfi coser [212.239.03 npulxeJl K

cJreAyrcIquM BbIBOAaM:

xoAr I{3 LI3rreHHbIX MaTepLI€UIOB AeIra,

Hur rpaxAaHcKl{x npaBoorHourenuft s

L. flpe4rvreroM AlrcceprarlLToHHoro I4ccneAoBanus. A. A6ryAxta[]IJIoBa, vQ'

sBrrfler c fl rIccJIeAoB anvre SynrquoHLIpoBa-

l4nrepHere c yqeroM I4x Bo3MoxHofi eso-

Jrrorlr4lr. llo ceoeNdy 3aMbrcny ALIccepraIILIoHHas pa6ora BbITntALIT AocraroqHo

LrHHoBarIkroHHo, rrocKonbKy e Hefi rlpoBo3rJlarraercs. nepexoA or KJlaccl4qecrofi x

rrocrHeKJraccnqecKoft reopurd rpaxAaHcKoro npaBa (nocruerJlaccl4rlecrofi reopuu

fpaxAaHcKrix rrpaBoorHorrresufi n reopLTLI o6.asarerbcrBeHHoro upana) B ycnoBLT-

rx Ar4HaMr{rrHoro pa3Br4Ttrfl. qusponofi cpe,4u ZHrepuera. I'Iueer Mecro rIorIbITKa

BBeCTH HOBbIe fIOlF^flTVrfl.- TaK B qacTHocTkI, (3JIeKTpOHHbIe rpaxAaHcKLIe [paBooT-

HorueHurr), B ToM qucJre rronbrrKa cog4alrrr4s. e4uuofi Teopvu SJIeKTpoHHbIX rlpaBo-

orHorxeHuit s qenoM r{ co3AaHr{r HoBoro Kareropl4€ulbHoro anilapara (c. 8), 'no

coorBercrByer 3arBJreHHofi rleln - I43f{eHI{{ TeoperI4rIecKLIX upo6neru rpaxAaH-

cKrlx npaBoorHourenrafi e I4nrepnere.

OAuarco rleJrb (nrnro.rax LTccJreAoBaHue cocraBa rpaxAaHcKltx rlpaBoorHolue-

]g{uit u o6sgarelrcrBeHHbrx rrpaBoorHorueurafi) ne 6ula [ocJIeAoBareJIbHo peanl{3o-

BaHa B nu6panuoM MeroAoJrorr{qecKoM I{ TeoperruecKoM acneKTe. B peylrrare,

Her ocHoBasuit rnanzQraqr4poBarb Araccepralll4lo B KaqecrBe HalnrHoro AocrLDKeHI4f,,

{BJurroqeroc.rr KpynHbrM BKJTaAOM B TILTBI4JII4CTLIKy, B TOM CMbICJIe, KOTOpOM TpeOyeT

u. 9 par4ena II lloloxeHr{rr o [pucyxAenkrvrfreHbrx creueHefi, yrBepxAennoro flo-

craHoBneHzeru llpanr4rerrbcrBa P@ or 24 cenu6px 2013 r. J\b 842 (Y pe4ar<quz flo-

craHoBrreHux flparureJlbcrBa P(D or 2l anpenn20l6 r. J\b 335).

B carraofi ALrcceprar\Lrv\ B ToM rrr4cJle, B ee eeoAHofi .taQTLL. ocHoBHoe BHI{-

MaHr.re yAeJrrercq o6qereoperr4qecKzM BonpocaM coIILIo-ryMaHuITapHoro xapaK-

Tepa orHocr{TeJrbHo rrpr4poAbr n SynrqnoHl4poBaHuxlrTarepHera c [pI'IBJIeTIeHI{eM

6olruroro MacckrBa gJIeMeHToB Karefopl4€ulbHoro aTrnapara, He orHoc{uleroct K

3

roprrAr4rrecKofi HayKe. B cyrUuocTu, fiepBrrfi pas,qen (c. 25 - 99), zaYurvrato1qnfi

K cne[Lr€lJrbHocrr4 12.00.03 -ceMeftHoe rpaBo; MexAyHa-

B rIeJIoM. B o6utereoperLTqe-

qerBepryro qacrb AkrcceprarllroHHofi pa6oru lr nocB.alqeunrrfi alnurvr3y coBpeMeH-

Hbrx MoAelefi Irlurepuera, He I'IMeer orHorueHns' Hvr

fpaxAaHcKoe npaBo; npeAnpl{HI4MaTeJIbCKOe rlpaBo;

poAHoe rlacrHoe rrpaBo, Ho lI K IopuAuqecrofi HayKe

cKr,rx paccyxAeHnflx, Koropbre uMeror Mecro n pa6ore A. A6ny.qxcalruJloBa u Ko-

Topbre, cJro)KHo oTHeCTLT K TeopnII fpax{AaHcKOfO npaBa, coAepx{uTcs Macca He-

ToqHocrefi, a raxxe [p?rcyrcrByror MoMeHTbI TepMl4HoJlon{qecKofi rryrauwlbl I4

uonsrufi Hofi ueonpeAeneHHocrl{.

Tax, ua c. 6 Aucceprarluu yKa3brBaerct, rrro elrle He co3AaHa I{enocrH€ul

rrpaBoBar AoKTpuHa Anr r{31nre:ar4fl, Teoperl{qecKl4x upo6leu lpDKAaHcKI4x rlpaBo-

orHorxeHuit s Llnrepnere. Tarzu o6pasovt, aBrop 6eper Ha ce6fl' cMeJlocrb co3Aa-

Hr4_rr (Teopupr reoperr.rqecKr4x npo6reM), xorr c MeroAororuqecKofr roqKu 3peHLIs

3Ta TepMUHOJrOfrrtIecKoe flocrpoeHlle He Hecer s ce6e KaKoro-Jlra6o sHa'rllMoro

cMbrcna. flpe4cran ilflercs' rrro B paMKax AllccepraIlraonnofi pa6oru zMeHHo rlo

creqraJrbHocrr4 12.00.03 co3Aarb rrpaBoByro reoprlro llnrepuera B coBoKyrlHocrl4

c pa:pa6orKaMlr reoperuqecKrax npo6levr rpaxAaHcKl4x rlpaBoorHolllenufi n nup-

ryalrHofi cpeAe Znrepnera, He npeAcraBIrflercfl Bo3Mox{HbIM, KaK MLIH?IMyM, nPV

coBpeMeHHoM cocroflHnkrkr cro.rrrlux nepeA oreqecrBennofi qLIBLIJILIcrIaroft 3aila-

qax. B qacrHocru, rrepBas. 3a1aqa orHocl{Tcfl K Kpyry npo6leu o6qefi reopl4l{

ilpaBa, B paMKax roropofi;rBJrrrorcr yMecrHbIMI{ paccyxAeHl{s o Kraccllqecrofi n

HeKJraccrr.{ecroft HayKe, o6 apxLrreKToHLIKe reopl4li I'Inrepnera, o cneqzQure

npaBoorHourenufi B cerr4 I,Inrepner vrr.A. CuequalbHocrb 12.00.03 I4ccneAoBaHLIe

lepeqr4cneHHbrx npo6nevr, Koropbre HapsAy c ApyrrIMI4 BorlpocaMrl 3arpoHyrbl B

A1rcceprarlura A. A64yaxanvrrroBa, rpe6yerraoro KoMrIJreKcHoro (<.uorropcroro>>)

ypoBHr, ucxoAr us rpa1wJvrr4 vr oSuqzanbHbrx rIpaBlIJI, He rlpeAnoJlaraer. Kpoue

TO|O, Ha3BaHHbre TeopeTLTrrecKr4e Borrpocbl, oqeBI{AHO He COOTBeTCTByIOqUe CIIe-

qI,I€UIbHOCTH, TIOAHI/IMaIOTC.rI aBTOpOM B pa3Aene (aKTytulbHocTb TeMbI), a He B

pa3Aene ((reoperl{qecKat 6aza Auccepralluz>.

Cnegyer yKa3aTb vI Ha rpoTIIBopeIII4e n pa6ore. C oAuofi cropoubl, roBo-

pvrTcfl. o neo6xoAr4Mocrr4 rrepeocMbrcJrLlTb cylqecTByroqylo upaBoBylo AoKTppIHy

IrlHrepnera c f{eroM oco6eHHocrefi $yurqzoHt4poBaHl{5. cerlr, Korop€u BbI3bIBaer

Maccy BorrpocoB ropuAr{qecKoro xapaKTepa) a) c Apyrofi cropoHbl, oTMeqaerc-f, He-

Aocraroqnaa o6opMJreHHoorb caMLrx fpaxqaHcKLIX rpaBoorHoruenuite quSponofi

cpeAe r.r o ToM, rrTo gTrr rrpaBooTHorrreHklt c TpyAoM noAAaloTct HopMaTI4BHOMy

peryJrr{poBaHr4to, TaK KaK pefynr4poBaHLIe aHaJILl3VIpyeMbIX IpaXAaHCKO-IIpaBOBbIX

orHoIIreHUit, no oAHo3HaqHOMy BbIBOAy AHCCepraHTa JILITeHO CTICTeMHO|O xapaK-

Tepa. Cle4yer c-qtrrurb, qro rtoAo6nufi rIoAXoA rlopox(Aaer coMHeH.ufl' B SMrIupu-

irecKofi o6ocHoeaHHocrLI pa6orbl.

BogHI,IrcaIor coMHeHLI.f, B Teoperl4llecKol4

TeM, qro I43r{eHI4IO SneKTpOHHbIX rpax(AaHcKI4X

o6ocHosaHHocrlr, cBt3aHHbIe c

rrpaBoorHoruenurfi AonxHa rlpeA-

o6ourosaHHbrM 6y4er yuorpe6mrb raKl{e SopvrynupoBKll, KaK (c0opMLIpoBarb

KoHrIenIII4Io (qelOcruOe HayrlHoe [peAcTaBJIeHue o peIueHuII

<<o6ocnoearb IIpaBoByIo MoAenr (roucrpyKlll'Ito)> " r.l. Vlcxoyx uz

IuecrBoBarb ?IX III4BHnLIcrvrLrecKafl. paspa6oraHHocrb, Ho oHa HeBo3Mo)KHa BHe

o6ulenpasoeofi AoKTpLtHbr rpaBoorHourenufi e I4ntepnere (c.6). Bn'recte c reM'

co3AaHr4e nocJreAHefi ne nxoAlrr B KoMrIereHIIurc HayKLT I'paxAaHcKoro [paBa, xo-

Tr rr HecoMHeHHo, HeBo3Moxno 6es eeyqacrvrfl.

1.2. @opMyJrr4poBalue rleJru Haf{Horo plccJleAoBalvrfl, - He ipoprraalrustfi

MoMeHr. I{em Alrcceprarlrrrd AonxHa 6rrrr KoHKperHoir. w HarlpaBnennofi Ha pe-

[reHr4e npo6lerrau, cQoprr,rynLrpoBaHHofi e Ha3sanvlvr Arlcceprallzu. I{elrrc ALTQ-

ceprarluoHHofi pa6omr A. A64yaxalrrJroBa flBrflercfl. KoMrrJIeKcHoe I{3f{eH}Ie

reoperLrrrecKux npo6neu lpaxAaHcKlIX npaBoorHollrenuir s ?Inrepuere, Qopn'ry-

Jrr4poBaHr{e [peAJroxeuufi ilo coBeprrreHcrBoB anrrro reoperllqecKl4x I{ MeroAoJIo-

rurrecK?rx noAXoAoB K rr3f{eHrdro reopr4ul4mepuera u ero [paBoBoMy perynnpo-

BaHLrro (c. 13 Aucceprarluu). O4naKo Ilerrb He Aonx{Ha npeAcraBJltrb co6ofi rpo-

qecc (analu3 - Irkrurb oALrH rr3 MeroAoB IzccJreAoeanzx). I{enr AoJIx{Ha o6ecue'ru-

Barb rron) reHr{e KoHKperHoro HaflHoro pe3ynbrara uccneAoBaHkrfl. floerouy

upo6neuu)>,

IIOIIOOHOI{ JIO.

rLrKlr orIeHKr{ cqkrraeM, rrro rleJrb, yKa3aHHafl. A. A6ayaxalI{JIoBbIM, He coorBercr-

Byer npeAbrBJrreMbrM K Haf{Ho-zccneAoBareJlbcrofi 4emeJrbHocrrl rpe6onauvflM-

1.3. Pa6o.ta uzo6uJryer MHo)KecrBoM HeyAarrubrx, He KoppeKTHbrx, B Haytl-

HoM nJraHe SopuynprpoBoK, Koropsre Bcrpeqalorct, B ToM qI4cJIe I4 Bo BBeAOHLII'I

LrccneAoBa1vrfl.. Haupnrvrep, B pffiAeJIe HoBLI3HrI, aBTop uclonb3yer cneAyloque

QoprraynnpoBKrr - (HafrHar HoBr{3Ha l4ccJleiloBaur4s,, BbIHoclIMafl. Ha 3aIrII{Ty),

(rrpaBoBoe rroJro)KeHr4e gTofi o6lacrx Ae.lrenbHocrll n l4urepuere) i4 T.A.

Tar xe ocraerc.fl He rcHbrM, K qeMy crpeMl,ITct aBTop - K co3AaHI{Io reopun

DJreKTpoHHbIx fpaxAaHcKLrx [paBoorHouleuufi, I{JII4 xte Bcero JILIIUr K ocMbIcJIe-

Hlrro I4X TeOpeTLITIeCKAX aCTIeKTOB.

1.4. flonoBr{Ha r.r3 rrpeAcraBJreHHbrx 3aAarl, perreHl4e Koropblx, Iro MHeHLITO

aBTopa Heo6xoAlrMo Anf, Aocrr4x(eH ufl. r\eilu AI{ccepraIII4oHHoro I{ccneAoB auut' (c.

1.3-14), He roJrbKo He orHocf,Tcr K rrpeAMery r\vrBvfnucrzqecxofi :flrayKkr, Ho LI

rrpeAMergoMy nonro rcplrAlr.recrofi HayKLl KaK TaKoeofr, n qacrHocru: vr3Yrvrrb

o6qenayqHbre reoperr{qecKlre r4 npaBoBble [oAXoAbI K Senorr,reny ZHrepHera'

rrpoaHaJrLt3lrpoBarb coBpeMeHHbre Ha1nrHble MoAenI{ LI3fr eilvts. I4urepuera, c$op-

Mr{poBarb rIoH{TLre Irlurepuera; o6ocHoBarb I43MeHeHI/te reoperI4rlecKl'Ix I4 Mero-

,{ororr{qecKr,rx uoAxoAoB K cyrqecrByroqefi rrapaAlarMe hurepnera' cMeHbI I{H-

QopuaqzoHnofi napaAurMbr Ha o6qenpaBoBylo, B Koropofi Hayrnofi AotuunaHrofi

AoJrxHa 6116 lpaxAaHcKo-npaBoB€Lrr MoAerrb; vrcyqvrb npaBoBble xapaKTepLIcrlIKI{

co3.rlaHHofi c nouorrlbro rexHnrrecKl4x cpeAcrB Brlpry€lJlbHoro rlpocrpaHcrBa -

iunuuofi TexHoJroru'recrofi cpeAbr, Koropaf, Iro3BoJlfler cy6rercraM Bcryrlarb Brryr-

pu uee B peaJrbHbre orHorueEr4fl; Bbr.sBr4Tb o cHoBHbre npLI HIIansr SyHTIILIoHLIpoBa-

rrus,VlwrepHeravBurpryanbHorotlpocrpaHcrBa.

2. floloxeHvrfl., BbrHocr4Mbre Ha 3arrllrry, c roqKI,I 3peHLIfl nrr6pauuoro crI{JIs

r4x r{3Jroxe[r4fl. HarroMr{HaroT He TpaAI..IIII4OHHbIe IIOJIOXeHWS, a QOpMyJIIIpOBKI4

nyHKToB HoBr.r3nbr, Koropbre lporlcreKaror H3 peIIreHHt rIocraBJIeHHbIX sa4au. llpu

groM, rrro I4Meer 6o6ruee [prlHuurrrr€ulbHoe 3HarleHue, Sopnrzpylorcfl o6lerrzs-

Hbre npereH3rrr{ K coAepxaHlrro 6olrnuncrBa LI3 npeAcraBneHHblx IroJIo)KeHI4I'I.

2.1. flonomeHpre, BbrHocrdMoe Ha 3aIIILITy Ne 1, He I{Meer orHoIrIeHLrA K 3aAB-

lennofi cuequaJrbHocTlr, XoTfl 3Aecb lI BbIcK€BaHbI LIHTepecHbIe 3aMerIaHI'It, Ho oH?I

LrMeror rJraBHbrM o6pa:orvr reoperr4Ko-rlpaBoBoit, a He lparAaHcKo-[pasoeofi xa-

paKrep. CrpauunM Br4Alrrcr na Sone npl{3Hatrus Heo6xoAl{Mocua $opl,rupoBaHllJl

o6qenpaeonofi [apaAr{rMu IrlnrepHera rlpoBo3fnalueHl4e orKa3a or upLIHtroLI Ha

ceroArurrrluafi Aenr znsopuaqwonnofi MoAenI{ IrlntepHera. 3ro nporllBopeql{T

r.r3Haq6t[bHo BbrcKa3aHHbrM Opr4eHTarIr{tM aBTOpA HA [OCTH9KJIaCCI4qeCKyIO HayKy,

KoTopatr, KaK LI3BecTHo, I43f{aer cJIoxHbIe cl4creMbl I4 B paMKax roropofi HaAo ro-

B Opt4 Tb o 83 aI{M OAO nOnH eH VII4 VICC JI9AO B aTeiIbC KI4X nO AXO AO B.

BUeCre C TeM, CaMa vl4efl, o CMeHe [paBOBbIX [apaAurM B no.{XOAe K pery-

nrrpoBaHlrro [paBoorHorrreHr{it s VIkrrepHere, a LTMeHHo nepexoA or AoMLIHI4poBa-

nux unQopMar{uoHHo-rrpaBoeofi MoAenu noHI{MaHI{t K rpaxAaucKo-rlpaBoeofi,

KorAa Znrepner paccMarptrBaera . KaK cpeAa, B Koropofi Sopunpylorct o6qecr-

BeHHbre oTHorueHrn{ no [oBoAy LrMynIecTBeHHbIX LI IUqHbIX HekIMyIqecTBeHHbIX

6nar, flBlrflerafl, gnaquuofi, Ho HeBepHo rIp?IMeHLITeJIbHo K KoHTeKcry coBpeMeH-

Hofi HayKH, B ToM rrucre rcpr{AlrqecKofi, roBopl{Tb o roM, rITo AoJIXHa rlpola3ofiru

cMeHa AoMtrHlrp oBalufl, Teoperr4rrecKl{x rIoAXoAoB. ,,{ocrarorlHo rIepcrIeKTLIBHofi

flBqrflercg. flocraHoBra npo6leMbl, Kacanqeficg roro, rrro rreMy AonxHo ttoAql4-

HflTbcs: Znrepner - lpaxAaHcKoMy npaBy, utru uao6opor.

2. lloloxeHrre, BbrHocLrMoe Ha 3arrlrlry Nl 2, Hocllr o6Iquft xapaKrep I4 He

I4Meer orHollreHvrfl, K rJuBkrJILIcrr4Ke. 06 IrlnrepHere roBopllTct, B ToM tIIrIcJIe, KaK o

KOMTIJIEKCE TEXHLITICCKI4X CLICTEM, HA OCHOBAH'VTLI KOTOPbIX CO3AAETC' BHPTY€IJIbHOE

[pocrpagcrBo npaBoorHourenzfi. Taroe BuAeHue flBnrflercfl, ropa3Ao 6olee y3KlIM,

verr,r raHSopMarlr{oHnsrfi noAxoA, K orKtt3y or Koroporo npl43blBaer Al4cceprasr.14

ToJrbKo e lloroxgeivLr J\b 16 MoxHo BI{Aerb pa3btcHeHl4e, Kacaroqeect roro, qro

Heo6xo.{uMo pa3nl{qar6 Irlurepuet, c oAHofi cropoHbl, KaK TexHI4qecKyIo cllcreMy,

Lr KaK Bupry€lJrbHoe [pocrpaHcrBo o6qecrseHHblx orHorlreHuit, c,4pyrofi cropo-

Hbr.VI B rrepBoM, r,r Bo BTopoM cnyrae [peAMer rlpaBoBoro perynnpoBaHHfl flBIrfl-

ercf pa3nLIqHbIM. OrMe.reHHoe o6cro{TeJlbcrBo cBla,qerenbcrByer o He B3aLIMo-

o6ycloueHHoM Lr rrporrrBopeqlrBoM xapaKTepe aHuwr3vrpyeMblx noJloxeHuit, YFlt-

HOCI{MbIX Ha 3aIqI,ITy.

2.3. llonox(eHlre, BbrHoclrMoe Ha 3arrlt4Ty No 3, AeMoHcrpl4pyer rIoHtrI'I[Hyto

ABycMbrcJreHHocrb B onpeAeJrenrruZurepuera, Koropblfi on[cHgaerct yxe He KaK

((MHLTMag T9XHSJIO;LIII9CKa{ CpeAa>, a KaK Cpe.qa, O6UIeCrseHHbIe OTHOIUSHVIS B

Koropofi Hocrr Bce xre peaJrbHbrfi xapaKrep. Palree o6 I4nrepHere roBopl{nocb KaK

o Br{pryaJ6sofi cpeAe r4Jrr4 KaK o ne$uauqecKoM rlpocrpaHcrBe. B qelovt, o6utrue

coqr{n;rbHo-Suloco$cxoft TepMlrHoJrorr{u rpl4Beno K coKpaIrIeHI{Io HafIHo-

ropuAr{qecroft cocraBJr*oulefi pa6oru, reu 6oree - K HeBblcoKofr creueru4 cBfl3kr

prccJreAoBa1vrfl. c Hayrofi rpax(AaHcKoro npaBa. Brrcrasannrrfi s flonoxenuu Jt 3

Te3uc o roM, qro ropuAlrqecKue Qarru B Bllpry€ulurofi cpeAe tBJltlorct He KoH-

rlerrTy€uILI3I{pOBaHHbIMI4, CneAyeT oAHo3HaqHo npI43HaTb npeyBeIHqeHLIeM'

2.4.Ilo1ox(eHrre, BbrHoctrMoe Ha 3arrllrry Jllb 4, BIITJIIAIIT KaK AoTIoJIHeHI{e K

floroxenzro }lb 2 u uy1eer o6qereoperrlqecKoe coAepxaHlle. B Hetur I'Iurepner

onpeAenserc-s KaK HeMarepzaJrbHas, TexHoJlorurqecKas. cpeAa Als o6uIecrBeHHbIX

orHorrreHufi uo rroBoAy LrMyrrIecrBeHHbIx I{ JII{.IHbIX HeI4MyIrIecrBeHHbIX 6lar.

2.5. YrcasaHHbre s lloroxe1Lrkr, BbIHocI{MoM Ha 3aIqLIry JS 5, TpLIHIIIITIbI

llnrepHera paccMaTpr{BaroTcr oAHoBpeMeHHo KaK orlpeAentrcIrlkIe ero [paBoByro

nprdpoAy Lr rcpvALrqecKyro cyrrlHocTb Bo3HvKaIorII{x B HeM rlpaBoorHollrelFluir.

oAgaro He yAaJrocb ycraHoBr{Tb, KaK 9TLI IpLIHIII,IIbI, Hanpl4Mep, AeMoKparI4rI-

HOCTb, 3aMKHyTOCTb Lr T.A. OTpaxaroTct B coAepxaHvrvr T.H. lpaxAaHcKl4x 9JIeK-

TpoHHbrx npaBoorHoruenzfi .

2.6. llotrox{eHr4e, BbrHoclrMoe Ha 3alrltlry J\b 6 (C. 18), o Heo6xoAltMocrll

r4crroJrb3oBa1u[ coqlroJroflrqecKofo IIOAXOAa B paMKax Teopul4 lpalKAaHcKoro

rrpaBa K 3aKoHoMepHocrrM gBoirrcqvr npaBoorHollrenufi upIEvreHuTenbHo r Zn-

TepHery r{Meer KoHcrarr{pyroqefi xapaKrep. lloerouy rocJle alnalrkrsa Aauuofi

u1efi;eoit ycraHoBKlr AlrcceprarTa, He yA€trlocb BbItBIlTb HayrrHylo IIeHHocrb AaH-

HO|O nOJIOXteHI4t, BbIHeCeHHOfO Ha 3aIqI4Ty.

2.7 . f1onoxreHlre, BbrHocr{Moe Ha 3arrII{Ty Jt{b 7, B KoropoM Aaercf orlpeAene-

rrlre rpax{AaHcKlrx orHorueuuit s Brrpry€ulbHoM npocrpaHcrBe I'Inrepnera, B cylq-

rrocrrr, He coAepxur QopnnynupoBoK KaKr4x-To rrpr4HIII4[I{aJIbHo HoBbIX 3HaHI4I{.

2.8. B lloloxelrur{, Bbrgocr{MoM Ha 3aIqLITy J\b 8, npI.{BoAIlTcsKIraccrrSuraqrar

fpax(AaHcKr4x rrpaBoorHorrreHuit s c$epe Irhrrepnera, oAHaKo He rrpotcHeHHblMll c

MeroAoJroru.recKofi TorrKr{ 3peHilr oKa3arrr4cb ocHoBaHu{ noAo6noro PoAa KJIaccv-

Snraqzu. Teru 6olee Bo3Hr4Kaer Bonpoc, KaK B Btlpryanblryro cpeAy I'Inrepuera Bo3-

Mo)I(Ho BKrroqurb orHorueHnn, Bo3ntrKarcIque n SusruecKoM IrpocrpaHcrBe.

2.9. SneueHTbr HoBr{3Hbr e llonoxenvIn) BbIHocLIMoM Ha 3aIrII4Ty Nl 9, ne

lpocne)KLIBalorct, TaK KaK 3atBneHHoe I4crIoJIb3oBaHue nnloparlkrcrllrlecKofi ron-

qe[quu o6rerra rrpaBoorHoruenuft HMeer Mecro I4 rIprIMeHIlTeJIbHo K rlpaBoor-

HorxeHutu, SynrqrIoHrIpyIoUILIM BHe Bl4pryalrnofi cpeAbl I4urepuera.

2.I0. Co,qepxarquftcs, e flonoxeHLrL\ BbIHocLIMoM Ha 3anlllry }lb 10, BbIBoA

o KoHBeHrIrr€rJrbHoM xapaKTepe orHorlrenufi s Znrepuere c rrocJIeAyIoqI'IMu yrorl-

HeHr{rMr4 r4Meer Bcero Jlrirrlb KoHKperI43HpyIouII4fi xaparrep I4 nI4IIreH SJIeMeHToB

rrpraHrlu[ualrnofi HoBr43Hbr. Crolr xe yroqHxtott\uit xapaKTep l4Meer u floloxe-

sue J\b 11, nocerrleHHoe o6sgarerbcrBeHHblM rIpaBoorHorueHLIrIM' Koropbre aBTop

Bcero Jrprrrrb XapaKTepr,r3yeT KaK BLIpTytlJIbHbIe. AualOra'{Hrrfi BbIBoA MoxtHo CAe-

Jrarb raKlce Lr3 aH€urHsa floroxreHLrf, J\b 12, B KoropoM AeJlaercfl rIorIbITKa onpeAe-

Irelc.Idfl, SJIeKTpOHHO| O .4Of OBOpa.

Z.Il. Co4epxauue lloloNeHvrs. J\e 15 (c. 18 .4rlccepralllll4) JII,IIUr KoHcrarI4'

pyer $axr oTcyrcTBlrr B HarILroHaJrbHoM 3aKoHoAaTenbcrBe HopMaTITBHbIX aKToB,

Koropbre peryJrLrpoBaJrvr 6rr rpax4aHcKo-[paBoBble orHolueHpll B paMrax I'Iurep-

Hera, rrogroMy AaHHoe lloloxeHze soo6qe He Moxer 6uru [pI{3HaHo B KaqecrBe

TI0JIO)I(eHI4'I, KOTOpOe BbIHOCVTTC fl. Ha 3 aIrII4Ty.

Ha ocHosaHvru cKa3aHHofo crILITaeu ueoOxoAI{MbIM cAeJlarb BbIBoA o roM'

qro 3asBJreHnsrfi ypoBeHb HoBLr3Hbr pa6oru Herb3-[ npll3Harb yAoBJIerBopLITenb-

HbrM. TeoperuvecKrre rroJroxreHlr{, BbIHoctIMbIe Ha 3aIrIIlTy, He coorBercrBylor

rpe6onanurrM rr. 9, n. 14lloloxenur o [opf,AKe rlpl4cyxc.4eHrll{ freHbIX crelreHelI,

yrBepxAeHHoro llocranosJreHlleM lparnrelbcrBa P@ or 24 cerns6px 2013 r. l\b

g42, ype4. flocraHoBJreHur.flpayureJrbcrBa P@ or 2L anpetrs' 2016 r. Ns335, a ee

aBrop He 3acJryx{nBaer npr,rcyxAenuTs,Iacrouofi yreuofi crerleHrr AoKTopa rcpl{At4-

rrecKlrx HayK ro cnequ€UIbHocTII 12.00.03 - lpaxAaHcKoe IIpaBo; IIpeAnpLIHvIMa'

reJrbcKoe npaBo; ceMefiHoe rpaBo; MeXAyHapOAHOe qaCTHOe npaBo.

flpz upoBeAeHlru rafiHoro roJrocoBaHr4s, AkrccepraIILIoHHHfi coser B KOJII4-

qecrBe 14 .reroseK, r43 rnx 6 AoKTopoB HayK rro cleIIIr€uIbHocrLI 3alquqaeMofi

Al{ccepTarln;f^, yqacTBoBaBIrII4x B 3aceAa1r4Lr, nz 2I qeJIoBeKa' BXoAf,IrII4x B cocraB

coBera, rrporoJrocoB€urr{: za - 4, [porl{B - 9, ne4eficrsllrerbHblx 6ronlereHefi - 1.

Ilpe,qcelareJrb

AIICCepTaIITIOHHoTO caeHKoBa Oncana B.uaAuvrupoBHa

Vqenrtfi ceKperapl'

ArrccepTaIIrIOHHOrO Koro4y6 lpuropufi BqqecraBoBrlrl

(18>) aBrycra 2016 roAa

10