Русский сборник том 5

14 . " *

n f l #

\VA

, , r t O C ^ - ' 0 'K , v y c a * A

V t f ' JJ t. ***

o\V

t>T1

> *i

f t C V

1 - ^ ^ f t o V 4 ' u ^ v v v e v v i

y * v \ V ^

^ \ \ ;

f t *-

'JI0

w I

u 1 ,

v\ \V

\

,4> W 3 ^ eCX

\ \ *

? e j

v w

\ \ . V vx

\ \ o ^

^

$ v

4

\

O ' nW

n\W J^VV b ** * * * *

\eo # t b . wv^c 'tU

K N W V. e w v v ' " "t ' V ' . . , - ;

' "

, ^

^ >..

0 % ^ \

-:

. . , , . . , ,

V

2 0 0 8

V IK I| I (< til) 1.1.1. It I ll 11

II.,

. /. .

: /.-. . . , , . . , , . V. .: , 8

i s b n 9 78 - 5 - 9 1 50 - 2 4 - 5

. . ,

/. / . . 1495-1497 . ........................................ 7

/ . . XVII : -- .......................................................................................... 37

- -. : , .............................67

. . . - 1907 ..........................................................................................93

. . . - : - (1914 1917) . . . . 125

. . . : 19 16 - 19 17 . ........................................................................................................................... 1 5 2

. (1866-1944), : , . . 2 1 5

. : (1943-1946).............241

li'ampuona . : - 95- 975 ............. 52

'.). It. . ( 2006 ).......................................................................................293

. : ................304

/>\ /}. : . . , 2006. . . 3 2 6

.. . . . XIX XX ( . . ). , 2 0 0 4 ............................................3 3 8

I I / ' \ i i i n t n r i u o n It li I Iimiiim lihn "Mu " I |i io la l'i m < hi I l\t |t* I |i I in miiih >11 lu Httilii ( .1 ll I , /I m i ( ) ....................................................................I 3 4 2

\ l M It II . /(emeu. ItiK iiiiiHii : 170 0 191B it. .,'200 .| .............. I > 3 6 ^

\ I : . . Siehcrhcitspolizci in Estland 1941-1944,..- Sindic /in' Kollaboraiion O sten. Paderborn, M iinchcn, W ien,

/,lli'ich, 1 0 0 6 .............................................................................................................................. m 3 6 6

//. : H erbert J . Ellison. B oris Yeltsin and K g g fe S D em ocratic Transform ation/Jackson School Publications in International Studies.

Seattle: University of' W ashington P rc s i, 8 0 0 6 ..................... .... g f fp

/'. '.ht/ : R obert F. Baum ann, G eo rg e W. Gavn-ych, W alter

E. K rctch ik. A rm ed > : B osnia. Fo rt i

. . h 'o .ic/x x i:

. ,. , ... . , .. i . f 1 t 3 8 9

. l i . : Paul Chaist|i Legislative PolitidMknd Eeon mie Power in

Russia. O xford . 2 0 0 6 ................. .... , _ , , , a *, * j

I I . : Byron . IS S etio n s% J 3eSign: P arB K & n d Patronage in

R ussia s R egions. D eK alb : N orthern Illinois University * 1 a jg8

I L 3 {>m oe: . . .

(19 89 -U 0 0 51T .). ^>6 i n n m i n

. : >|> ? - $ |> *t o / . . - . ., s ftd j* . , , . .............................................. 4 0 ^

................................................................ , , . , 4J P

. .

1495-1497 .1

1495-1497 . . - , . 11 (1493 .) .

( ) 323 . 2.

1495-1497 . . 3.

I - .

7004 ( 1518 .) : , , -

1 ( / 1 N 0 4 .0 1.0 0 39 2

- . . .

X V . ., 1952. . 3 8 5 - 3 8 7 ; . . - X V X V I . ., 1884. . 13 7 - 15 3 ; . .

- - . X I V X V I . ., 1975, . 2 6 1- 2 8 2 ; . . X V X V I . ., 1980. . 140145.

3 I Scrip io rcs Rerum Svecicarum Mcdii ( ) . , 1818.

. . .

7

11,11 ' I I ( '.( . .(| < )hi /, |. '. , iif 11in. I .

( ,

, [. . - . ). .] . , , , ) .

7000 :

. 6 , 15 .

, , , 8.

, ( ) , .

() 7003 : ... . . .

.

.

: . []

. . .

- . .

.

. . 6 ; ; 6 jp - .

11 . T g / i . . 8 1- 8 2 .

9

I I < 11 III .111 I I I I I ' I >11 'I I.IIK I I I ) I I d ll, 11, 1)1 n p i i l l I I I 11II >1 < > I I I M o t 'K H U ,

\ ill iMiiinu I in I I,'1, ( (H im ,I III . . ,|% . - I >1 h i , in I I , .'1, It 1493 . 10. , >". , . , .

. , . , . 12.

, , , 1477 ., 1:\

, 1487 .,

, , 05*4

, 16. , , . 1487 . 1493 .

, , , , . , . , , -

/ 1(7 5 - 15 9 !! . ., 1966. .2 1. (: 98)

10 P K - 9 8 . . 3 3 .

1 1 . T j R . 3 2 3 .

12 . . XV XVI . ., 1980. .7 5 . (: ).

13 . . .

PK 98. . 2 1.

15 - 0 5 . . 4 2 .

16 . .2 6 1-2 6 2 .

10

, . 15 - . : , , .

. . 1481 . ( ) , -, . 80-90- . 17, . . , . , , . - .

( ), ( XV . ).

, 18.

. 50- ., 1467 . .

- . i486 . ( )19. 20. , , 1493 . 21, . 1495 . - , .

17 . . - .. I. ., 19/(7.

.287. (: ).

111 . . 29 2 .

14 98. . 2 0 .

20 , .2 9 2 ; . .66.

21 98. . 23.

,mn I f e U M i , . , , . 1 . , , , X V I . . , 1480 , ... #^, . . , 1495 . ( ) ^ . & , 1480 . , 1495 . * . - () , , .

, (6 ) (15 ). , 20 . . - , , 24 . , , .

1495 . . .

.23 , (, )24.

20 17 25. . : , , , , , , , ,

. .337. . .26. . 290.

, .**

12

, I . I ...

(, ). ( ). (6 ). 120 .

, , , . - , .

1495 . . 1475 . : ( ), (2 ), ( ), (6 ), (2 ). 22 .

1479 . 5 , , , .

15 . 1495 . , , .

15 475 1479 . , -, , . . .

495 . .( '. 7 , 3 ,

, 6 . . , , .

, 1495 . , ) , , , , () .

() - . , ( . 26.

*(> Scripiores rcgum Svcciarum Medii g ev i. Upsacige. 1818.

13

( ,

Mill i Ajg \ 400 , , . U IB H B H f 1 ' .

" I if, \ ... ,, . 1 . , .

. , , .

I . , t . j l 19 , . . I ... . 500 , . , . , * , .

, . ( ) . , , - . , . 400 .

, . ' . - , , . .

. . . . 30 . - , , , . , !. , , . , 34 .

4 . ,

'. , ,

14

((So .)21, , , .

I 1293 . , . 1477 . , - 24. .

. . , .

. , . , . .

I . , , , .

( / : > , .

( '. , , . , , , .

.

.

, .

, , ..

, , .I 1796-1797 . .

< > . , . 1799 . ( . 1 1 .

> . :>. . V I I . . , 1912. C .JO I-IQ 2.

. . .

15

II Mm I,hi.I I in h i I 11 hi I in I >111 it * < n a -in ini ncpi I ( )(>o | m h i.i ii (' .

, , . 7004- 25 30.

4 , 20 , . . 15-20 .

- :

, - , .

:

.

. . .

, 1731.

. 20-25 , ( 20 ). , . .

. , ( , ), .

30 -9 8 . ;.2.

31 . . 27.

16

I (), - , .

70 . , [. . !,--10. . ] , , ; , [ ].

... - ... ... , ... []... , , .

, , , -, .

. ... ... . . ( '. .

I . , . . . , , , ' .

900 , , , 2 ... .

.I 24 . ...

. , ,

, . .

1 . , , . . .

I? , 500 . , . , - .1 1 , , , - .

Scri|>tor 193.

17

In , ,| III lll l I ,

, - - , , . ; ( ), , ( , , ) I ( ) . , 34 .

, - .

, -, : .

-...

, .

. I . .1 1 1 , , , . - 37.

: 3".

, . , , .

, , , , : ) () ( ); 2) ; 3) , , ; 4) ( ).

- i t , . !^ , ... ; () () ; #,

, , ( , I !< - I); , , , , ; , - , : - .

1496 . , . , . . ( ) . -

17 . .3 7 . .9 8 .

1,1 14 7 5-16 0 5 . ., 1977. ( : 05).

, .1 (. . 8 9 ).

19

(. I/ >1 -111 . , -

| ' < I )| 1111II > 1IIVIO . . |>\1'./|0|00

, :* ,

, ( . .

- , . - , 411.I , ? . 1349 . . .. 1349 . , 41.

1411 . (. ). ) , , . 42. - , . . , ; , .

. 1419 . , 500 , , , . (. . ) : , 4, 1445 , , , , , . , , , (, ). ,) , ... , , , . , 41.

^ :?>( , .

* . . . XIV ,

W 4,! . . 411 -

44

20

, , , , .

I . 1493 . ( >), , I . 1494 . 45. .' , - , , , (. . , ) . . - ... 46. 7005-1496/97 . , " . , 5 1494 ., / 1495 . , - 494 ., .I .

' 1496 . - . I , : , () , ... ( 8 . .) . ( . ..) ... , - ; ... - mvn , ( ). .), , ... , , , I ;, - , ... ... : ... , -, ..., , ... ...

1,1 . .28. . 158, .

. .37. . 98.

21

I >\< > : I 11 m i 1111 , Mil ) li . I. . Ilol Ml, lUHTOlbKO , ... ... ... ... 47.

. , -, , 48. .

, , (, ), , , , . , , , . , , -, , -, . , . , , . - , , , . , .

-. , - - 1496 . . ( 1496 .), . ( ), , , , , , , , .

1496 .44

47 . . ., 1988. .2 0 1 -3 0 2 .

48 . . . ( )//

X I V - X I X . ., 1965. .7 -2 9 .

44 . . ... .2 5 -26 .

22

- , , , (. , -,

58*

. 1311 . ... , ... ... ... - I -, #*. , ^ - ()%

gjfl . , , , cywbSRoro %. . . fififlM U S H L " I III , , , , -, 51.

131 1318 . , % .I - 0 1496 . - .

, , . , >82 . rioxtp : , () . , - \ , . , , - - . , , . & 1 . 1 ( )

( - ( I, X V I . ). . . .,

) {. ( 1 .8 , , 10 3 .)

' & !; . . ... . 72-79 .

.. O .gg , 337.

' 1 . . . ... .79.

I '< ) I IK' I fill , >. * ( | I.VIl) II ;i |>11>1 ( 150 ), / 11>, ' . -, .. . , , , , . , , , . , , . : 1471 . , . , , X V . , , 53.

. , , , , .

, , . , . , 1489 . ( . , ) . , , , , - , , ( ). 1496 . .

. , , , , X V . . , , .

- , , ( ) , , .

,

, , -, ; . 1375 .

(, . . . 102).

24

, .. 56. < ' .

. () () XIIXIII . ( , .). , - , - . ( ).( (XI .) , () 2 60-70 . (XII-XI1I .) , , , . , . () 37.

() . , >( >\ , . ., , . . , .

( 70-80- X V . . , . - ., , I , . - - .

I , , , . -. , ; ( ). , , . ' - .

, , , . , , , ,

, . . . ., 1967. . 195.

. 0 . 16 6 -19 5 .

25

Il;l < ', \ ' ; II upon loin , I 1 1)1.

yi I it. 111 ( . ) ,; 1 11. (mii.

> I>i(>|>c . I , , .

; .

- - , , . , , . ( . , -, , , , .

. , I ( . , .

1349 , . . , 1496 . : ' .^

, 7005 .

19, , , , -

BHHtflHL . 1 in i ^^ ,

.

26

, , , - . , , , . , . - , . , , , .1 1 60.

'.') ., 7004. .-.

. [7004] . > , , 61.

I ( ) /|

. 11 , . , , . , , , . , , .

, , , . . . . (5 ).

, , . .

, . , , . , , .

19 . (26 ) , . - 2-3 , , 23 . , , .

. , - - , . 70 4-5 (, 60-70 )63. , , -, . . , . , .

... ...

28

I It) . - I . |)>).

.I .

, . () , - , , , 64. , , .

. , , . . . - . , - , .

( . , 11165, , mu. , .

< ) . , . , ( , , , .

I I , - . , I . .] , : , , 66.

1 1 . , , 12 . -

1.1 . .36.

1.1 . . III. //

. . 70- . . . ., 2 0 0 3 . ( 1 0 8 - 1 2 6 .

' . . 158.

29

25 , , . . . , , -.

, . , . . -, . -, .

. ... , , . . . . .

. , [7004=1496] :

;

.

. . ,

) 67. .

-, , .

.

, , , , , .

, .

, . - , .

67 -9 8 . . 27.

30

, , , - , - < > . .

() . :

... - , , , , . ... , : , , , .

, .

I , , , . , 1487 . . 1-) , , - .

I , , .

(1 . /) , , .

- ... , .

, , . -, , .

() . -1: , - > , I -, . . -... , , 7005 .

I .

31

$3 , .

( :I? ; 1

, , .

. . ,

, .

.

, .

, .

- .

, , . : , . ( ).

, . . []

[] . []

; ; ; 68. , . 1487 .,

. , . .

- . -.

, , 1496 ., . , , . , , -

6 8 - 9 8 . . 8 .

32

, ; . , ( .

I I : - , .

I , . It - ... , , . 111 , - . , , -.

, .

15 1497 . - - . , , -- , .

..) , , . , , , , , 111 i .

, 1496 . - , )', . . , | ( .

111 I. h i . . .39 3 ; . .

33

, -, , - . , . , .

, .

. .

.

, .

, .

- , , , , .

, 6-8- . , . .

- .

, . , .

. , ( ?) - . . , . 70.

70 .. III... . 10 8 - 12 5 .

34

- . . , - . . (., -, .

. , 4 .! - - . I ., ,

() , .

* . , -- , . - in 11111 . , . , . .

. - . , . , , , , -, .

. Bf/f >< - ('- , , - unit . , .

I . ( - 111> 11 ), - - 11 , ( U H H -.

35

, . , , .

.

XVII :

- - 1

, , . , . , ( ) X V II , . , , , - . , , * . , 2.

( . : Nikolaos A. C hrissidis. A Jesuit in Scven im u h Russia: Cosm ology and the Planotary System in the Slavo-Creeo-Latin Academ y//

Marshall and Ja r mo Kotilaine, eds. M odernizing Muscovy: Reform and Social Change

in Seventeenth-Century Russia. London and New York: RoutledgeCurzon, 20 0 4 .

( , ) .

2 ., : . . -

ro //S lav ia . 1987. 3 . .2 4 3 -2 5 2 ( . : - . //

. 1995. 3 . . 4 6 -6 ] , - -

37

, , X V II 3. , , , , , (, , ) . , . , , , .

, , , , , * --- 68- 1690- . -

(|)-, -

); / . . (.). ., 1982; . .

X V I I . ., 1973; . . X V I I . ., 1990 ; . .

X V I I . ., 1974; . . 1670- / / . 1972. 27 . .2 7 3 - 2 8 3 ; Jam es C arcraft. The Peirine Revolution in Russian

A rchitecture (Chicago and London: University o f Chicago Press, 1988), , Paul Bushkovitch. Religion and Soeicty in Russia: The Sixteenth and Seventeenth C enturies.

New Y o rk O xford: Oxford University Press, 1992; Cathy J . Potter. The Russian Church and the Politics o f Reform in the Second H alf o f the Seventeenth Century. Ph. D. diss. Yale

University, *993-

3

X V I I ,

,

.

: . .

X V 1X V 11 . 2- . : . . . , 19 14 ;

. . 6 - 8 - XVII . . //

X I 11X V I I I . / . . . . .: - A l l , 1986. . 17 7 -2 0 9 .

4 , , . ,

, ( 16 8 8 -16 9 1 ., ) .

38

- , , -- . * , XVII 5. ) (.. , ), (, ) . ,

, ,

; , -

, ,

. .: Paul-Richard Blum, D cr

Standardkurs dcr kaiholischcn Schulphilosopie im Jahrh und eri, : A risioielism us and Renaissance: In mcmoriam Charles B. Sch m iu, eds. Eckhard Kessler, Charles H. Lohr,

and Walter Spam [ WoMcnbiitteler Forschungcn, vol. 4oj (Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz, 1988),

127-48 . . *

(. .X III. . 2; . . II. . 2), , ( ,

) , , . , X V I ,

: . Jam es . Lau is, Between Copernicus and Galileo: Christoph Clavius

and the C ollapse o f Ptolemaic Cosm ology (C hicago and London: University o f Chicago Press, >99/)), 3 2 3 8 ; Peter D ear, Jesuit M athematical Science and the Reconstitution

o f E xperien ce in the Early Seventeenth C en tury, Studies in H istory and Philosophy o f Science, 18: 2 (1987), 13 3 -7 5 . ,

, X V I X V I I . ,

.

, , ,

, ,

: . S .K . H eninger, Jr .T h e C osm ographical C lass: Renaissance

Diagram s o f the Universe (San Marino, CA: Huntington Library, 1977), 7.

.: Eugenio Garin, A strology in the Renaissance: T he Zodiac o f Life, trans.

C arolyn Jack son and Ju n e A llen , trans. revised in cojunciion with the author by C lare

Robertson (London, Boston, Melbourne and Henley: Rout ledge and R egan Paul, 1983). .: W illiam F. Ryan, The Bathhouse at M idnight: An H istorical Su rvey o f M agic and D ivination in Russia (University Park: Pennsylvania Stale University Press, 1999), . 15. , -, X V I I I .

. ( , 385).

39

7, . , , , , . , . : , . , ( , ) . , , 8.

7

. , ,

, ,

1687 . , : . Patricia R cif, The Textbook Tradition in Natural Philosophy, 16 0 0 -16 5 0 , Journal

o f the H istory o f Ideas 30 : 1 (1969), 1 7 - 3 2 ; Edward G ran t, In D efense o f the E arth 's G en erality and Im mobility: Sch olastic Reaction to G opcrnicanism in the Seventeenth C entury, : Transactions o f the A m erican Philosophical So ciety 74: 4 (1984), . 3

passim; Gabriele Baroncini, L inscgnam ento della filosofia naturalc nei collcgi Italiani

dei C csu ili (16 10 -70 ): un esem pio di nuovo A ristotelism o, : L a Ratio studiorum . Modclli culturali practichc educative dci Gcsuiti in Italia tra C inque e Seicento, ed. Gian

Paolo Brizzi (Rome: Bulzoni, 1981), 16 3 - 2 1 5 (. 19 2 -2 0 2 2 0 2 - 2 14 0 ); .

: John L . Russell, S j, Catholic A stronom ers and the Copernican

System after the Condemnation o f G alileo, Annals o f Science 46 (1989), 36 5-38 6 .

8

.: . . . 2-

. .: , 186 2 , . . , . .

. .-.: - ,

1937; 2 - ., . .-.: - , 1947, , 1 - 9 ( ); !'. XI X V 11 .

.-.: - , 19 40 ; A lexander V ucin ich , Science in Russian

Culture: A H istory to i86 0 , 2 . (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1963),

; Loren R. Graham, Science in Russia and the Soviet Union (Cambridge and New York: Cam bridge University Press, 1993),

X I X X X . .: - . .

. .: . - -. - , 1956; W illiam F. Ryan. Astronomical and A strological Term inology in Old Russian Literature,

D. P hil.Th esis (Oxford University, 1969) ( -

40

, . - , , . , . X V II , (1073 1076 .), ( ) 9. ' ,

).

.: . . .

: / /

/ . . (.). .: , 19 88. . 2 9 0 - 3 1 0 . . :

Max Okenfuss, The Jesuit Origins o f Peirine Education, : The Eighteenth Century in

Russia, cd. John Cordon Garrard (Oxford: O xford University Press, 19 73), 1 0 6 - 3 0 .

, ,

( 17 0 0 . --

, ),

. ,

.

, ,

, ,

( ,

). : ,

, , ,

, .

- - X V I I I .

.: . .

. - - / /

/ . . (.). .: , 19 9 2. . 1 0 9 - 1 3 0 .

' ' ( ) .: : X I

X I V ./ . . (.). . . .: , 19 8 7 . -

; . , 1 0 7 3 . 10 7 6 .;

. ,

. ,

,

, : ) -

, , , . , . , , , , . ., . , , , -

]|?! ^ , , , ,

X V I I (.:

: - ./ . (.). . 2 . . 2. .: , 1989.

); 2) ( 1551 .),

X V I I . (. , ); 3)

( - , , ), .

: . 2 . . . ; 4) (1647), 1670- . (.: . X I X V I I . .4 3 8 -4 4 8 ; .: . .

/, 40 [1985]. . 181).

X V I I . , , (.

:

. . 19 -20). ,

:

,

, ,

.

: ,

. , -

. ,

( , ), , ,

, , . . : -

42

. X V I I - (), , 10.

, . , . - ( ) 11. -

, .1 .3 Ryan, T he Bathhouse ai M idnight, 1 .1 .15

, ,

(.

: X I X I V ./ . (.). . . .: , 1987.

), , -

, X I I I .,

(. Ihor Sevccn k o , Rem arks 011 the D iffu sio n o f Byzantine

Scicn tific and P seu do-Scicn tific L iteratu re am ong the O rthodox Slavs, T h e Slavonic and

East E u ro pean rev iew 59 : 3 (1981), 3 2 7 - 4 5 , . 7); (

) ,

: . . .

. / . . N 50 . 1996. ( ' .6 7 7 - 6 8 3 . (

, ,

). ,

. ,

.

10 ., : A lex an d er , From the C lo sed W orld to the In fin ite U niverse (B al

tim ore and L o n d o n : Jo h n s H opkins P ress , J9 57 ); Edw ard G ran t, P lan ets, S ta rs , and O rbs:

the M edieval C o s m o s , 1 2 0 0 - 1 6 8 7 (C a m b rid g e and New Y o rk : C a m b rid g e U n iversity

P ress, 19.94).

11 To,

, (

( ) . . 17 3 ( , ).

. . 3 0 3 (., 186). . - .), ,

, - , -

, ,

. ,

( ),

(16 6 9 -17 0 7 ), .

I! 16 94 , ,

, , ,

[,

/ / , 111: . . : XVII XVIII . .:

43

, , . - Eiq ( , ")12; - De Mundo. In Libros Aristoielis Stagintae de Mundo, et ( . [] , In Libras)13. . . , 1690 .14, -

. . , 1899. & 8 6 ./, , . ( ),

. . : . . 8 /(-88 .

, 169] (

)

'5. , , ! In Libros , , ; , , .

, .

, , ; XVII XVI I I 2.

( . . 173. . . 319 (. 3 14 4 ) ) , &, : ) , %) , ) . , . . , ( ) . , , , - , , , , , , , ,

1652

. , , , , ( - ) , 25. : , , , In Libros, (, cursus philosophicus), .

, . , .: Lohr, Laiin Aristotle Commentaries: II. Renaissance Authors, 105; Za\ap{aq TaipriavAi]c;, Oi 66.53 . In Libros Almagcstum Novum (1651) ( ), , 1663 : , , In Libros, 16 5 1-16 6 3 . , In Libros , . , In Libros , - , , (. ). , ( ; ;, 14 6 -4 7 154-55), -- , , , . : In Libros -< , ( , :., , Antonio Poppi, Iniroduzionc alParisioielismo padovano, and. cd. (Padova: Aiiienorc, 1991).

47

, *4;.

, In Libros^-, ?5 . . ( ) . ( ) . , :, , , , .. : , , .

In Libros . g. * , ( - i w f i , , , : ( -) ( - )37. , .

. 1 !, ( ) ( ,

: .); . Lohr, Latin A risto ilc Com m entaries II:

Renaissance A m hors, passim.

2:5

(, ...

,

... (Grant, Jn Defense o f ihe E a rth s Ccntraliiy, 3 -4 ). He

, . . : C harles

. Schmitt, Aristotle and the Renaissance (CambridgeLondon: Harvard University Press,

1903), . . l , ; Reif, TheTextbook Tradition in Natural Philosophy, 17 -3 2 . J9 -2 0 .

26

: . ;, |) nccpafioorj, 15 3 -5 4 .

27 ) .: Lattis, Between C opernicus and G alileo; ,

.: G ran t, In D efense o f the E a rth s Centrality, ( . , ); : . Planets, Stars, and Orbs.

48

- , , , 28. , - In LibroSi ( : , , , , ). , ( , . , ). , - , .

, In Libras, , , , , . , : -

/ 1 : , - , , ,

.

,

( ) , (), (0] (, 1|).

,

: ,

, ( ,

); ,

, . . . , , X V I I , (

\ VI .) : ., \ Kapdq, O i0tHKEc;nioirjpec;oiovAAqviK6 xwpo

(|->

, , 29.

. , , , , ( . : , 31 , , , - ; , . ; , 31. , d i Libros , ( -), - , | diuumia experientia): ( ' ; )3^ .

? , , , . . . , , : , (, afi-jg?) , ;;

& > , -

, .

: . ;, ^]

], 15 4 - 5 5 , - , .

30 . . 173 . 3 0 3 ( .186). . 9 9 - 10 3 ; . . 173. 3 19 (. 3144). . 3 3 - 3 5 . , (

) (. 9 .3 9 - 4 0 ); In L ibros , , ( [], [], ||), ,

-: . /to.

31 . . 173. 3 0 3 (. 186). . 104-10406.

32 . . 173 . 3 19 (. 3144). .4 3 -4 5 .

.

50

, , ( , ). , ,- 33. In Libros . 34.

, Libros , , . (novae) 35. , , . ? , , , . , , , . (. . 36), . , . : , , ; , (, ) 37.

33 . . 173. 3 0 3 (. 186). . 105-10506.

34 ) .: Edw ard G ram , W ere T h ere S ign ifican t D ifferences betw een M edieval and Early M odern Scholastic N atural Philosophy? T heC ase for C osm ology , Nous 18: 1 (1984), 5 - 1 4 ; : on , Celestial

In corru p tib ility in M edieval C o sm ology (12 0 0 -16 8 7 ) , : Physics, C osm ology and

Astronomy, 1 3 0 0 - 17 0 0 : Tension and Accommodation (Boston Studies in the Philosophy

o f Science, vol. 126), ed. Sabetai Unguru (D ordrecht, Boston, London: K luw er Academic

Publishers, 1991), 10 1-2 7 .

: ( . , 71)

1572 . 1577 .

. .: G rant, Celestial Incorruptibility,* 10 8 -0 9 .

,

X V ! X V I I ., .: Lohr, Latin Aristotle Com m entaries: I I . Renaissance Authors, 9 8 -9 9 ; W. C . L . Randles, Lc cicl chez

les jesuitos espagnols et portugais (1590-1651), : Lcs jesuites a la Renaissance. Systeme

cducalif et production du savoir, ed. Luce C iard (Paris: Presses universitaircs de France,

*9 9 5 )12 9 -4 4 . , In Libros . ,

, , .

51

, - , , : , 38. , , : , , . , , , 39.

, Libros 40, , , . , . , , , , () . ?*, , , . , (, ,

, ,

, , : . . 173. N -319

(. 4 -4

* . 0 .4 6 -4 8 . : , , , ,

. .: Grant, Celestial Incorruptibility, 1 13 - 14 .

. . J 7 3 . 3 1 9 (. 3 / 4 4 ) . . 4 9 - 5 1 . -

X V I I . .: . . X V I I ./ /

. 5 0 . 1 9 9 6 . . 6 8 / j - 6 8 8 .

.

40 . , 71.

11 (probabilius)

.: R e if, The Textbook Tradition, 3 0 . X V I I , ,

, - X V I : . L attis , Between C opernicus and G alileo , 76 ,

W illiam W allace, Galileos Early Argum ents for Gcoccntrism and His Later Rejection o f Them , Novita celesti e crisi del sapcrc. Atti del Convcngo Im ernazionale di S lu d i G alile ian i, ed. Paolo Galluzzi (Florence: G iunti B arbcra, 198/1), 3 1 - 4 0 . Libros, .

52

)4?. , , . , , ()43. (, , ) , . , : , 44. , , . , , - 45. , In Libros , , , : , . , 46,

In Libros, , . In Libros, , , , , ; , 47. , ( ), (), . , , . , (alogos pos), . , , , , . , : , ; ; , , , (2 ., 12, 2). , , ,

12 BTBL . 173. 3 19 (. 3144)- .5 J -5 3 .

.

'. . 173. N 319 (. 3144). . 5 3-54 -

. ;.3 4 -5 8 .

. O . ig - t e t

. , 173, N "3 0 3 (. 186). . 99- .

53

, 48. , 1 Libros &, 44.

. , , , . , In Libros , . , () : , , . , , %. , , - , . , , . , , , , ( ]6) , , (). ( ) , , , , . , , , . (^) , , , . , , ,, . , : ... (anthroparion). , , , , . , (semeia), (aitia) , ". In Librogp

48 ' , . ] 0906.-110.

44 . *> .

0 . , .

54

( ) , : * & , , - , , , **,.

, , , ! , ; (, , ): . , , (, , ), , , , ( )92 - , , - , ; . ( , : , . . , ; , .

, . , , . .' . ( ), . * - , -

. . - .: W illiam F .R y a n , M agic and D ivination. Old Russian Sources, The O ccult in Russian and Soviet C ulture, ed. Bernicac G latzer Rosenthal (Ithaca and London: Cornell

University Press, 1997), 3 5 -5 8 , ; .: Ryan, The Bathhouse at Midnight.

55

, . , , . , , . . , : . * , . , : , . , , . , In Libros , , , .

, , 53. , . , , , , , , . , , . , , .

, . -, . , , , , , 54. -

53 .: S ir D avid R oss, A r is io ilc , 6ih ed. (London New York: Routlcdge, 1995), . 3 ; Jonathan Barnes, ed., The Cam bridge Companion to AristoUe (Cam bridge, Eng.: Cam bridge University Press, 1995), . .. 4 - 5 ,

.

1 . : . . . .:

56

. , . 33. , , , , , , , 56. , , , , , 57.

- , 1963; [. : , - - , , , ,

*934 . 6 4 2-6 4 7 , , .

]; W illiam F. Ryan, Aristotle and Pseudo- ris-

Lotle in K ievan and M uscovite Russia, : Pseudo-Aristotle in the M iddle A ges. The T heol

ogy and O ther Texts (W arburg Institute Surveys and Texts, vol. 11), ed. Jill rave,4 W illiamF. Ryan, and C harles B . Schmitt (London: W arburg Institute, University o f London, 1986),

9 7 - 10 9 , , ...

,

, , ...

- (103); Ihor bevccnko, Rem arks on t h e Diffusion.

.: O xford Dictionary o f Byzantium , ed. A lexander P. Kazhdan, 3 . (N ew York: O xford U niversity Press, 1991), v o l .3 , s -v- Philosopher;

K . L n n o i e p r j q , ; ]) elc; ];, E m o x r jp o v t K r j E n e t q p i c ; ir jq ]; L)(oAj](; io v n a v m i o t q p i o u AOqvwv 1 4 ( 19 6 3 -6 4 ) , 3 8 6 - 4 5 8 ; -

oeuq (];, oupBoArj etc; ; ; apxmtov Etc; ;,

44 (1973), 3 5 1 - 5 4 . .: . .

. - . ., , 1909. .43. (

); : . .

X V 1 X V 11 . / / . 1 . 17 . 1961. .3 5 8 -3 6 8 ,

, - .

.: C h riss id is , C reatin g the New Educated E lite, .4 ,

2 2 8 -3 2 .

, . .:

C hrissidis, C reatin g the New Educated Elite, .2. .: Potter, The Russian Church,

, , 11 11 .

Bushkov itch, R eligion and Society, 16 3 -7 5 ; . .

/ / . . 2 2 8 - 2 4 6 ; . . Poesia docta // .

. 2 4 6 -2 6 0 . ,

57

, . , In Libros, , , , 38. , XVII . In Libros ( ) , . . . , , , 59. , 60. 61. , 62. , , . , , , 63. , In Libros . , , ( )61.

,

, , : . .

. .77 -7 8 .

8 . . 173 . 3 19 (. 3 14 4 ). . 6 5 - 7 0 ; >. . 173. 3 0 3 (. j86). . .- .

9 . . 173. 3 0 3 (.186). . 114-11406 .

60 . . 120 0 6 .-12 1.

61 . . J1406 .

62 . . 11406 .-116 .

Gi , .

. . 173. 3 19 (. 3144). . 6 5 7 0 . , In Libros , ( ) , : . 3 0 - 3 1 . In Libros -

58

, XVII . -, , . , , , , - . . 65.

. , : . - , In Libros : , , , [ ..] . [ . .\ , [~ . .\ 66.

, , XVII , - . , , - . , , -- : [. . - ..], , , , , 67.

(,

), , ,

: ,

, lam veritatis qiram novitatis scciaiores

(. 28-29).

.: G ran t, In Defense o f the E a rth s Centrality,

3 2 - 3 3 ; - .: C iard , ed., Les jesuites a la Renaissance. Systemc

cducatif et production du savoir, IV .

(>,> . . 173. 3 0 3 (.186). . 1280 6 .-134 ; . . 173. 3 19 (. 3144). .7 0 -7 8 . ,

, In Libros. :

. . //

. . 1964. .9 1-9 3 .

systcmma |!] pro caeteris m agis nobis arridct, dum Celum Planetarium liquidum esse defendimus. Plura de his pertinent ad Astronomos, quorum est ea fusius et enucliatius

explicanda ( . . 173. 3 19 (11. 3144). C .72-73).

1,7 to ifio ou o iq p a | . . - //. .\(" & iwv Koivfj [ !I ;

donaZopfBa (. . 173 . N- 3 0 3 (. 186). . 12906.)

59

, ? , , , , : , , , , . , , , ( X V II , )6". - , , - , , , , , . , , . , , , , ,

68 1/ 15 3 -18 2 1 . .:

Dimitrios Dialetis and Eflhym ios Nicolaidis, Issues in the H istoriography o f Post-

Byzantine Science, in Trends in the Historiography o f Science (Boston Studies in the

Philosophy o f Science, . 151), cds. Kostas Cavroglu, Jean Christianidis, and Efthymios Nicolaidis (Dodrecht, Boston, London: Kluwer Academ ic Publishers, 1994), 12 1- 2 7 . .:

KovfiuAqq, ]6 ) ] ]

64. , , - - ( )70.

, , . , , , XVII , . , - , , , , . ( , In Libros ). , , XVII . - : , , 71. ,

(>'J pi lj. . ly j . 3 0 3 (. 186). . 10 9 . -

, , . ,

: Russell, Catholic Astronomers and ihe Copernican System , 36 8, . 8.

70 , .

, - , -, . -,

(;, OiEm oxqpeqotrjv, .2 ,

a n 15) , .

, - -

?

, .

( )

.: Lattis , Between C o p ern icu s and G alileo , 2 0 5 - 1 6 ; M ichcl-Picrrc

Lerncr, L en trec dc Tycho Brahe chcz les jcsu ites ou Ic chant du cygne de Clavius, :

Les jesuites a la Renaissance. Systeme cd u eaiif ct production du savoir, ed. Giard, 14 5 -8 5 ;

Barone ini, L insegnam ento della f'ilosofia naiurale nci co llcg i Ita lian ! dci G e su iii, 17 6 -79 ; C hrisiin e Jon es Schofield, The Tychonic and seml-Tychonic World Systems, : Planetary A stronom y from Lhc R enaissance to the Rise o f A strophysics: Part A : Tycho

Brahe to Newton, ed. Rene Taton and C u rtis W ilson | Michael A . H oskin, ed., The General

History o f Astronom y, . 2|, 3 3 -4 4 , , , 16 33 . [ /1.\

- ,

XVII . (41); R usse ll, Catholic A stronom ers and the

6i

, - .

, X V II ., : , - , . , , , , I , -72. , . . -, , , X V I - . -, - , . , , , 73. , , , , .

-, , -

Copcrnican System. .: John Louis Em il D reycr, Tycho Brahe: A Picture

o f Scien tific L ife and Work in the Sixteenth Century (Edinburgh: A . & C . Black, 189 0 ; repr. New York: D over Publications, 1963).

72 . . 18 . ., , 19 88 -19 9 5 . . 7. . 46 9 -470 ; -

. . .2 5 - 3 2 ; - . . X V I1X V 1 1 1 . .: , 19 9 0 . .2 1 0 - 2 2 8 [

XX .]; . . //

XVII 2 / . . (.). .: - , 1979. 4 .2 .. 14 2 -15 4 .

73 ., : A . Rupert Hall, The Revolution in Science, 1 5 0 0 - 1 7 5 0 ,311 ed. (London and New Y ork : L o ngm an , 1983), 1 17 - 4 6 ; : C ra m , In D efen se o f the E a rth s Centrality.

62

, ( , ) 74, 75, , , . , . , , , . , : . Ike , , , . , , , . , , , 76. , , : , 77. , , . . , 78. , , 74.

, - - , .

.: C hrissidis, C reatin g ihc New Educated Elite, . 2.

7 . e. , .

,(> .: Ihor Sevcenko, The

Definition ofPhilosophy in the Life o f St. Constantine' : For Roman Jakobson: Essays on the Occasion o f his Sixtieth Birthday, O ctober 1956, ed. Morris H ale et al. (The Hague:

Mouton, 1956), 44 9 57 ; .: . . - ( -

- ) //

/ . . (.). .: , 1992. . 4 4 -7 8 .

' .: .

. .3.

.: Ryan, M agic and Divination. Old Russian Sources;

idem. The Bathhouse at Midnight, chap. 14 .

9 , - ,

: . . 173. 3 0 3 (. 186). . 13 5 - 13 8 .

63

, - . , , - - . , , , 8, 81. , , , , .

, , . . , , X V II . , . 1

, 1650-1660- .

80 ( . 5), , -

16 50 - . Theatrum O rbis Tcrrarum sive Atlas Novus (Joan Blaeu) (Amsterdam, 1645). -,

,

( ), , X V II . , (.

. . 84 3). ,

. , ,

;

. .

(Abraham O rielius) Theairum O rbis Terra rum ( 1595 .): Peier Kofi,a, E inc Russischc Kosm ographic aus diem 17. Jahrhundert:

Sprachvvisscnsehafiliche A nalyse mil Tcxtedition und Faksim ile (Spceim ina Philologiac Slavicae, vol. 40) (Miinchen: O .Sagner, 1982).

81 . ( 64), In Libros 16 33 . , , , , .

64

, , . , , , . , . , . , , , , 82. )', , , 83.

In Libros : , - , , , [] 84. : , , . , , ( ) . , , . , 8. , : , , . . , , , , ,

.: -

. .

. , 1992. .4 - 5 ; .:( chrissidis, C reatin g the New Erlucaicd Elite, r.1. 2.

.: Bushkovitch, Religion and Society,

163-75-Atque haccde M undo, e l C elo sinl satis, in quibus vix ccrli aliquod potest haberi. et sacpe saepius divinarc cogim ur, cum vera ratione non suppctat, nee ecrtus cffectiis: 1. . 173. N- 319 (. ;>/|). .78.

. .73. 7 3 -7 8 . , , .

.< 5 3 9 6 5

(, ) . , . -- 86.

.

!!f

XVII

. , ,

: . Valentin B oss, Newton and Russia. Ihc Early Influence,

16 9 8 -17 9 6 (Cam bridge, Mass.: G arvard University Press, 1972), 234 . ,

- - 1685 . . -

.: ibid., 7 9 - 8 0 .

- -

:

,

, 1754 -

, . , , -, . , - . . , , , : ... ... , . , : , ? , , . , , 1.

, XIX ., . . , , , ... 2. , , , .

1 . . , , . ., .: Academia, 1931. X 1. .24 4 -24 6 .

1 . . . 2. IV.

67

, , , , - : . . , , , , , . , , - , , : , , , 3. , , ; , 4.

, , . , , XVIII . , , 1 . , , . , , - , , , . , ) -

3 . X X I X - X X X I V .

'* ]8 6 ., . ,

. : , , .

: , .

: , : // . . I (-). . , 1806. . 1 134 ; [sicj/ . . II (-). . , 1 8 0 9 . .7 9 5 . . : //

X V I I I . . 5 ( ). .: , 1 9 8 9 . . 1 3 6 ;

// . . 8 (- ). . : , 1 9 9 5 . . 1 3 3 ^ 1 3 4 .

68

.

I X I X , , . ,, , , - , , , , . . , , H 5 .

1750- -. . , , , . , {, II . , I I . , , , , , . , , , , - . .

, , , , -

, , .

X V I I I ,

, . . .

, , , . , ,

, , , , , : . 3 9 .17 6 9 . . 3 0 5 -3 0 7 .

69

, , . , . : , , . , . , , , , , , , 6.

, XVIII . , , , . , III 1762 ., -, , , , 7. ,

: . . : 17 19 - 17 2 7 .

.: 19 0 2 . : The H ague: M oulon, 1970; . . 1 II. . I. 1727 .

1727--1775 . .: .

. , 1913- X X

.

., : G eorge Yancy. T he Systematization o f R ussian Governm ent: Social

Evolution in the Adm inistration ol'Im perial Russia. 17 11- 19 0 5 . Urbana, III.: University o f

Illinois Press, 1973. . . (W. Bruce Lincoln)110 .

' : . X V I I I . . :

B .C . , 1889. ). .: .

: .

X I X . . : -, 199/j. . : . . X V I I I . .: , 1999.

/',

70

?. - , . H H R B B 1 , S XVI1 8 , ^ II8 . , , , . , , | - , , , , . 3FBRJ 10.

- ^ .

;

, -

.

8 ., : Valerie A .K ivelson . Autocracy in the Provinces: The Muscovite Gentry

and Political C u lture in the Seventeenth Century. Stanford C A : Stanford University Press,

1996. .

, . 8, 14, 32.

9 . . 17 6 0 - ., ill .

. . . . noblesse russe C ahiers du

monde russe et sovietique. V o l.X X X I V (1-2,) : 1 7 - 1 8 . ,

. .: . W. Cavendcr.

'K in d A ngel o f the Soul and H eart': D om esticity and Fam ily C orresponden ce am ong the Pre-Em ancipation Russian G e n try / / The R u ssian R eview . J u l y 2 0 0 2 : 3 9 1- 4 0 8 .

John W. Randolph. That Historical Family: The Bakunin Archive

and the Intim ate T heater o f History in Im perial Russia, 17 8 0 - 19 2 5 //R u ss ia n Review.

O d o b cr, 2 0 0 4 : 574, note 2, . . . .: . . //

. . . . . , 1902.

10 . . .

71

, XVIII , , . , , , , . , 11. , 1762 . , - . , 1762 . , , . , . . , , , 12.

, , 13. , , , - .

, -

11 Racfl . O rigins ol'the Russian intelligentsia. New York, 1966; Michael Confino. A propos

dc la notion de service dans la noblesse russc aux X V I I l c et X I X c s icc lc s//C a h ic rs du

m o n d c russc ct sovieti(|ue. X X X I V ( 1 - 2 ) : Janvicr-juin 1 9 9 3 : 4 7 - 5 8 ; . . .

12 . . . 16 8 -173 .

, : ,, , ,

1762 , , .

15 ., : Thomas Nevvlin. A Voicc in the Carden: Andrei Bolotov and the A nxieties

o f Russian Pastoral, 17 38 -18 33 . Evanston, Illinois: Northwestern University Press, 2 0 0 1. , ,

, ,

X V I I I .

72

, I . , - , , , , , 14.

. - , , , . , : , . }' , , , , - 15. , , , , , 16.

, , 1711 ., . , XVII , , .

11 Marc RaelT. T h e W ell Ordered Ptt/tte State: Social and Insiiiuiional C hange through Law

in the Germ anics and Russia, 16 0 0 - 18 0 0 . New Haven: Yale University Press, 1983.

2 6 17 15 . : hup://w w w . hisi. msu. ru /K R /E tcxt/articu l. him

,f> . 11.10 .17 15 : Weber, Friedrich Christian. Thepresent state o f Russia. Volume 2. London, 1723, p. 97. .: H. .

. .: , 1994. .388.

73

, , XVII , , Polizeiwissenschaft , , , . , - , XVII 17. XVII , , , , 18.

, , . , raison d'etat, , , , , , , 19. , . ,

.

, . .

.

: Richard H cllic. Enscrfm cnt and M ilitary C hange in Muscovy. Chicago: University o f Chicago Press, 1971.

| V .A . K ivelson. C artography, A utocracy and State Povvcrlcssncss: The Uses o f Maps in

Early Modern R ussia//Im ago M undiVol. 1.1 (1999), p. 8 3 - 10 5 .

19 ., : Valerie A. Kivelson. Autocracy in the Provinces: The Muscovite Gentry and Political C ulture in the Seventeenth Century. Stanford : Stanford University Press,

'9 9 6 .

74

. . . . , . 1710- 1720- ., 1720- . , 20.

, 21; 22. , , , , . , , : , , . , , , . , , , . , , , , .

II. . -

. .: . . . , 1.905; . . .

21 ., : J . P. Som m ervillc. A bsolutism and Royalism / / J . H. B urns, ed. T he

C am bridge h istory o f political thought, 14 5 0 - 17 0 0 . New York: C am bridge University Press, 1991.

22 . , I - : . . : R. . Haywood. Russia Engers the Railway A ge, 18 4 2 -18 55 . Boulder, Colo.: East European Monographs, 1998.

Shifra Sharlin, University o f W isconsin-Madison.

75

23.

, 1750- . , , , , , , 1727 .'24 , , : , , 25.

1750- . , , 26, , , , 27.

23 . . . VI.

24 . . 495.

, , ,

. . : .4 0 4 -4 10 .

2 17 30 - .

,

. ( . . :. ,

1956. .75). : W. Gleason. Moral

Idealists. Bureaucracy, and Catherine the CrcaL. Rutgers NJ: R utgers University Press, 1981; N. Riasanovsky. The Image ol Peter the Great in Russian H istory and Thought. New

York: O xford University Press, 1985.

27 -

1750 - 1760- . X V III . . . , ., ,

76

, , 2. , , raison dfttai .

, , , , , , - 29. I , , , ,

1759 / . 1759.

, , ,

, .

, ,

, , , , . .

1759 . ,

, : 2 5 .9 .17 5 9 .71. 2 19 -2 2 0 . ,

: W alter J . G leason, Moral Idealists and Catherine the

Great.

.

: D ouglas . Smith. W orkin g the Rough Stone:

Freem asonry and Society in Eightccnth-C cniury Russia. D eK alb , III.: Northern Illinois

University Press, 1999.

29 ,

,

. .: Brenda Mechan-W aters. A utocracy and A ristocracy: the Russian Ser

vice Elite o f 1730 . New Brunswick, N .J.: Rutgers University Press, 1982; Robert Crummey. A ristocrats and Servitors: the Boyar E lite in Russia, 16 13 -16 8 9 . Princeton, N .J.: Princc-

ton University P ress, 1983; John P. LeD onne. Absolutism and the R u lin g C lass: the Formation o f the R ussian Political Order, 17 0 0 - 18 2 5 . New Hork: O xford University Press,

1991; David Ransel. The Politics o f Cathcrinian Russia: the Panin Party. New Haven: Yale University P ress, 1975; Valerie Kivclson. K in sh ip Politics/A utocratic Politics: A Recon

sideration o f Early EighlccnLh-Century Political C u ltu re//Jan e Burbank and David Ransel, eds. Im perial Russia: New Histories for the Em pire. Bloom ington, Ind.: Indiana University Press, 1998 , p. 5 3 1.

. . . . .

7 7

, . ; , , 30.

, , . , , , , , . , , , , , , , 31. , , ,

. : . . X V I I I X I X // ). .

. . I V . .: , 1996. . 10 2 - 1 10 . ,

, , 1780 - ., , . .

, ... ,

. . , , . .

31 ,

. , , ,

. X V I I . . , , , ,

. . : K ivelson. A utocracy in the Provinces; H cllie. Enscrfinent and Military Change.

78

m I : . , , : in5 , , , , , , - : , -I >, 33.

, - , - - .

, , . . , , , 34. , - .

, , ,

,

, , , .: . . .; . . . . , , , .

33 K ivelson. A u io eraey in ih e Provinces and Kin sh ip; H ellic, E n serlm eni and M ilitary Change.

* * .: . ... i.

79

. , . , , , , . , , -.

, , . , , , , 35. , , (. . , . , . ), II36.

, , , , , , , 37. ,

' . 11 . / / -

. .: , 1755 . .2 ,-16 , . . 1 3 - 16 ,

,

. .: M ariens. D ie Botschafi dcr Tugend: D ie A u fk laru n g ini Sp iegel der dciuschcn M oralischen W ochcnschriftcn. Stultgart: J . B. M ctzlcrschc Vcrlagsbuchhand lung, 1971.

36 Gleason. Moral Idealists; Ransel. C aihcrin ian Politics.

iT ., : // . 1759. .36 3.

: . 17 6 9 ,23- |sicj. .3 ; , ,

, 5 0 0 , , -

80

ii . - 38.

, , . ,

, . , , , .

, X V II , . . - , , , 39. , 40, 1760- 1770- ., , , , 41. -

,

: . X X I I I . 2 9 .9 .17 6 9 / / ... . 1 3 0 - 1 3 1 .

. .

.1769.

39 ., : // - . . (.). XVII . .: , 1977, 2 - .

-3 J-3 3 -40 . . .

41 ., : // . 1760 . . 8. XVI

, 1769 ., -

, , 3 0 0 0 , , . , , . ,

, , - , , : . . (.).

. . . .-.: , 1951. . 10 5 -10 6 .

81

, .

, , of JfVI 11 . XVIII , , , , , , , . , $ , , tpt , , . , . , - , 43. 44.

' >.. pro -

.

, , , . , ? ^, , : , , , , , , .. ; , , % , 1785 , .

, . 27-

( 1769 .) - /

..., ,

. , , ,

. , ,

,

.

4 ., , ,

, 1759 .,

,

,

.

. ... .

,

,

. ,

(Dcgcntiilezza) ( ),

, , , ,

, , .

(. ).

: a la B ourgeois// . 1759* . 177179; // . .36 3 . .

: . 2 0 .17 6 9 . . 15 4 -15 5 , .

8 3

, , , . , ; , , -46. , , , - , 47. . - , .

48. , , , , - , - *9. , , 50. , , , , , , . , , I , . , , , , 51. -

46 . . . .3 3 4 -3 5 4 .

47 . . . . 14 9 -16 5 .

48 : . . (). . . .: , 1974.

; . , *

. , .

.

5() . IV. V II.

| . : ' . IV. I. .

84

I , , - . , , , . , 1 1 , I I I 1762 , ^ - . .

, ,

51. , . , . , , .

, , , , , . . , X V III 55. , . . 1775 1785 . .

, , , . , , , . , - , . - , , 56, , .

54 . . , . 8 ,3 2 .

55 . R . Roosevcli. L ife on the Russian G ouiury Estate: A S o c ia l and C ultural History. Nevy Haven: Yale University Press, 1995; . : . . .

. .: , 1798. . 1-7 .

86

, , , XVIII , III1762 57. , -- , 511, , , , . - - 1762 , . , , , , , .

, , , , XVIII XIX . . , , , , , 59. , -, , XVIII .

- , XVIII . , , . ,

. . .; . . .; . ;Raeff. O rigins; . . .

8 I , ,

, - , , .

Ncwlin. Voice in the Carden.

87

*, , . , , , . , , , , , , . .

, : ? ? , *- -, , , , , , 6 , , , , , . -, , , . , , XVIII , . . , . , , , . , 86 . , , , .6**

, XIX ., , , ^-

* .: Field;, T h e End ofSterfdom: N obilityan d Burcaueracy in Russia, uS6i. Cam bridge, M ass.: Harvard University Press, 1976,

.

89

, . , , , , , , 1762 . . , 1720- . , , 1762 ; - . , , , . . , , , .

1762-1825 ., , , II 1785 . , , , , , . , , , , , , , , , . , , 64. -

, : . . - X V I I I .: . .: , 1 9 7 4 ; -

90

, , , , raison detat, , , I , 6!

,

, . , , , , X V I I I X I X . , , , .

II.

. .

- 1907

I J X IX

, , , , , . - . , 1 9 0 5 . . , , .1

, 8 (31) 1907 , , , , . . , 2.

1 1906 .

2 1894 . ; 1904 .

93

d , , 1907 . , , , , , . - 1907 1914 .3 , .

, , , . . -, -. - XX . , .4

-, . . : , , , . : XX . (, , ).

, , 18 (31) 1907 . , , .

; 19 0 7 - , .

3 .

4 : N 133: . . 470; 13 7 : , 18 3 0 - 19 16 . . 475; 13 8 : . . 467; N 144 : . . 488 ,489 ; 154:

. . 7 1 0 / 1 ,7 1 0 / 2 ; 19 4 : . . 5 2 8 / 1 , 5 2 8 /2 .

94

I (>\ . , , , . I . , , , .

, , , .5 , , .

. - I, , . , ; , , , -6,. .

, , - . () . , , , .

.

- ( ) , . , ^, , , .

> , .. 7, , , , ,

(1856-1917). ., 1952. . 387.

6 . . 388.

7 . . (19 0 7-19 .). ., 1962. . 59.

95

, , , . .

-, , ; . . -, , , , 1828 , .8

, , , .

, , . - 1907 , . . , . . . , , 1876 883 -- , 1883 189 : , , . II. 9. : , , , , , , , , , , , , , ) 10 11.

. . (1907-1914 .). ., 1962. . 59.

4 . . , . .-., 1912. .43.

19 0 5 - 19 1 1 19 0 5 . : - , , , , ().

, 5 19 0 6 -

96

12 , , 1912 ., . , , , : , , , , : , , , , , , , .13

, , , , , , . - , , , , . 1907 ., , , , , , . , , . 1907 : , , 1 *,

; 7 . 8 19 0 7

-- , - . . 19 0 8 ,

. 1909 .

, . , -- .

.

.: . . 19 0 5 -19 11 . ., 1957.

11 ( .96) . . . . (1 50.

12

^ I, . 144 ,. 4 8 8 ,19 0 7 ., . 22,92, . 33.

14 2 British documents on foreign affairs. Scr. A , Russia. W ashington, 1983. Vol. 5 , p. 89.

4 5 3 9 9 7

, , ^ ^, ,^ - , .

. , JH M H . 1907 .

, , - . * . . , . . , . . , . \{ 11. . , , 1', * , , ; , . , , .,7^

, ; XIX #. , status quo. . . ,18

_ .- ., . . rifJP , . ! * ( " , . 4 8 8 , 1 9 0 7 . 6 ,

17 "^ . . , .

98

, , .

, , . , , : ; ( 1873 40 . 19); ; ! 1881 20, ; .

, . . , , 21.

- , . -, I , , , . , . . 1907 ., . , , , - . (...) , .22 , , , . , , -

19 . ., 1997. .4 , . 8.

20 , . 1 2 2 - 13 4 .

21 . . . . .4 3 .

22 , .14 4 , 0 1 1 .4 8 8 ,^ 2 2 9 2 - , 1907 ., .-. 6 5 -6 5 .

4* 99

, , .

. . , , , .23

, , . . . . . . , . , , , , .

2 3 , , 72 . , . . . , , , , .24

. . : ) , , 2) , , . . 25.

, 26. . , , , , . , . .

2: , 0 1 1 . 4 8 8 , 4 . 2 2 9 2 , . 1 . - 5 9 .

24 , . 144 , . 488, . 229 2 , 19 0 7 ., . 68.

2- , . 6.

26 .

100

, ,3

(. . , . . , JL . ) : , , . - , , , , . (...) . , , , , . **.

. ^! , . , . , , , - .30

.

. . : ( , , , ,, X . . , , : , , , , ,

37 , . . . )!!8. : , 19 0 7 ., . 6 .

2{ , .-. 6]-6 j .

29 Briiish documents on foreign affairs. W ashington, 1983. Ser. A , Russia, vol. 5 , p. 89.

30 , . 144 , .488 , .2 2 9 2

, J9 0 7 ., . 6906.

101

. : , , , , , , , , , .#*

, ( ), , . , , I ; - , , , , .

, 1908 . . . EL . S #; , : . . : , , , VBP> , , - , , , . , . , , , ,

* , 44 . - . 2292 - , 1907 . - .

. . . ., 1952; . . 19 0 5 -J9 11. ., 1957.

102

, .33

, , , 15 1908 34, , ,, . , , )' , . ; , , , .33

, . , , 36, , . 1908 ; 37, . , , , , , , , . , , , . . , .38 , . .34

411. )' . . : , ,

33 . . . . .3 7 -2 8 .

34 ... .- ., 19 11. . , . j 19.

35 . . . . .- .74-75.

36 ... .- ., 1911. . , . 8 1-8 2 , , 1 15 ,12 3 ,12 8 .

37 . . 13 1 - 13 2 .

. . . . .- .77 -78 .

; ... .- ., 19 . . , . 242.

40 , (j44 . . 488 , . 229 3 . .

17 19 19 0 8 . . 88.

103

, , , . , , , -, , 41.

: , . . , , . , --- . , .43

, , , , , . . 43, - , 4 - -, , , , . . , , , , ( ..), .44

- , 45 , 46.

!* , , .47'

1^1 . . 8.

, . 1 4 4 . * 4 & 8 , . . ^ ) ( ) I .

i t ) . . 8 9 .

* . A. ^ .

4 4 , . 1 4 4 t p f o jp . . 20$ . -8 9

^ - . (>)). . ] , . - -

. .4| ( )* . . 1908 . British documents on foreign affairs. W ashington, 1983.

Set;. A , Russia, vol. 5, p .a i.j.

104

, , 17-19 1908 , : , ?

. . , , : , , . 1906 1907 , ; . ?.48 . . , ,49 . . . - , , .50

. , - , , , - , . . . : , , . , , ; , ; .31

, , . ,

18 , . / | . . 4 8 8 , .2 2 9 3 , 8 . 71. 9 2 .

. . , . ., 19 12 . . 51.

3 0 , . /j , .,1 8 9 , . 5 9 9 6 . .1.306.

, . 1 4 4 , 0 1 1 . 4 8 8 . . 2 2 9 3 . .-. 9 3 0 6 . - 9 4 .

105

0 , . - , . , . . , , . , , , . , . , , ; , .32

, . . , , ' 17 19 1908 , , .

, , -, , , , , --, , --, ( ), , -, , , , .

, , .33 , ,

, . i/j/j ., 011.488, .2293. . 94.

, .14 4 , 011.488, .2 2 9 3 , .97.

106

. , , 5 . , .54

, , , . - .55 , - , - . -, . , 56

21 1909 , , , . , .57 , , , . , , .511

, . , . , . 2 1907 . : ,

54 ,-1-97 .

55 , . 1 44 , 0 11.4 88 , . 2 29 4 , g 1909 . .

5 .36 , . 144 , 0 11.488 , .2 2 9 4 , .7406.

16

1909 .

57 , . 144 , 489, . 5996. . 4 .

5 8 ' , . 1 4 4 , ./(88, . 2 2 9 4 , .75.

107

.'9 . . , , , , . , .60

, , , . , . . , . ?

, , , . . , - - .

. . , . , , , , . , , , .

( . .) . - ,

39 . . . . .- .6 3 -6 4 .

60 . . 45

108

, 61.

1909 , . . . , , , , . , , - .62 63 6'1 . , , , , , , .63 , , , , .66 . ; . , , .

21 , , - . - . - .67

. . . .48.

62 ... .- ., 19 . . , . 12 0 . -

. . .

.

f)3 , . F/j4, 0 11.4 88 , .2 2 9 4 , .. 143. . 21 1909 .

64 , . 175. 25 1909 .

65 ' .

66 ' .

67 British docum ents on foreign affairs. W ashington, 1983. Ser. A , Russia, vol. 5 , p .354 .

109

, 25 , , -- - . , .61*

, , . .69

22, 1909 . -- , , .70 . .71 . .72

-- . , , )' , . , , . , . , . . .73 3 1909 , . , }' -, -, . --.

6 , . i/j4 , .488 , . 2294, . 177 .

69 British documents on foreign affairs. W ashington, 1983. Scr. A , Russia, vol. 5 , p .355 .

70 ... .- ., 19 . . 2 , . 158.

71 , . 172, 2 4 0 -2 4 2 .

72 , . 257262.

... .- ., 19 . . 2 , . 224 .

110

, - , , . , . . , .

. . , , , . , , , , . .74 , , . . . : , , , . , , , , . , .75 . , . 2,5 . 4-5 . , .

, 1909 ., , , . .

74 ... .- ., . . 3. . 8 -8 8 .

75 , . ]/|/|, , 0 11.488 , .22 9 5 , .217. , 17 1909 .

111

76, . . . - , , 77.

, () 1910 , 1910 78. , . . . . -74, , , . 80, 1911- .81

1910 . . , , , ,82 . 1910 500 , , 2500 .83 . . . . - , , 1909 ; , , ,- 84.

76 British (lociimetils on foreign affairs. Washingtoij, 1983. Ser. A , Russia, vol.5 , p. 358.

77 \ ... . 11.. ign. . 3 , t'.gjg. 31 (i.

78 . ... --6., BHL . i J U H

79 .

80 116.. IM L H H L & JH JB IL

81 , . 4 4 ! . ,|8g. - 5 ) .. .1. yfd.

82 M L 4 * .

83 - .84 . , 1 4 4 , ^ [

j .

112

, , . - .85

. , .86 , .

- . , . . , . , , , . , , . . , , , , , , , . 87. , , . , , , , , , , , , 88.

, - 1907 , ,

83 , . 14 4 , . 488, . 2296, .'-. 19-1906.

5 19 10 .

86 British documents on foreign affairs. W ashington, 1983. Ser. A , Russia , vol. 6, p. 112 .

87 , . 144 , 0 11.488 , . 229 6 , . 2406.-25.

88 .

113

, , . 1910 , , .

& . . . . , . . -, - - , . . - -, , , , , , ; .90 - , , . .91

, -, 8 ?, , - . , , , , , .42

, 1910 .,, . , . , , .9

1,9 i l l 'l l . . !>*

9

, , , . , , .

, . . 1911 . , 94. 7000 ... ... ... ( ..), . . - .95 , 1907 . , , .96

, , , . . . 5 1911 , , ... , ( . .) ... , }' ,

94 19 10

.

1911 .

5 . , .

. , .

9 ... .- ., 1913. . 7, .75.

96 1, . 14/j, . /jiig, . 5996., . .

115

, , , .97 20 , - , , .98

, . .99 ign . , (. . .) , , , .100 , , 1907 .

. , , . --. : . , , , , . , .

, --, . , , .

97 , 2 , . 8 , . , N 295.

98 11, . 1

' , -- , , . , , 101. , , .

, , , , , , , , . . . - -. , , 102.

. . , , , . - . , , }' , . , , - . , 103.

. . : ... , . , . , . 101.

10 1 , . 1 4 4 , 0 1 1 . 4 8 9 , . 2 8 0 6 . , . 1 . - 1 . 4 1 2 - 4 1 3 .10 2 -|' . 3 9 9 .

|

. () - (, ); ; .1(8 .106

1911 ., & , - 1907 , 107. , .108 , , , . II .

. . , , ... .: 104 , , , , - , ,*10

- 1907 . , .

19071 , (. Nfii 111). 1909 . ( - ) . , , , .

10 ... .- ., 1913. . 7 ,0 .2 5 9 .

106 , .372.

107 , . 8 .

108 . ., 19 52 , 64 .

109 . . , 1:9** 19** .

110 . . ., J99J. .83.

111 . ., 1952 , . 38 7 -38 8 .

118

, , 4% , , , .

, . ^ . igj 1912 ^ , , , # 1907 .1

1913 . - . 1913 . -^ . , , , . - * | # . , , . 1911 , .114

, 1908 1913 , , , 1907 . ., 50 1913 " , , , . , , , ( //.//.) , *, I , , , , ^

& . ., 90.

11 3 . 2 , . 1 9 ; $ , K J p , . . I , -

119

, , , , 1907 , ,

- ; , , , , , , . , , , , , , 115. , , 1907 , .

, . - , 1914 . .

. 1914 , - , . , , - , ^ ^ , . , 1 , .118 , , , , 114.

- , . 0 , 0 1 1 .4 J B 9 , . . . 7 0 6 .

, g , U l F b K .

117 , . B U L _>9 * 118 : - \ , . 1 4 4 , , .4 8 9 , . 5 9 S - .- . 9 - 9 0 # . .

120

. - . , , , , , , - , .120

, , , , , . . , - .

1914 , , 20 . - , , . , , . , , , , , , , - , . ., , .

( ) - , , - , . , , , , .121

, , ,

120 , . 144, , 011.489,4.5996. .-. 12-1206.

121 , . 144, , 011.489, . 5996. . .

121

1914 . . , : , , .

122. , , .

- . 1914 . , , , - , 123.

, , , , , .

. 1914 , -- . -- , , -- , -, , , . --.

, , . . , , -

122 , . 144, , 011.489, .5996. . 1206.123 . . .

122

, , , . , , , . --- , , . , ,-- --- , , , , , , . : --, , --, , 124. , - ( - ) -, , .125 . ., , 1907 . .

, 126. , - , , , , - , 1907 127.

, , . , 1907 . , , ,

124 ,