Zeberio Amwona, A096 129 849 (BIA Nov. 10, 2014)
Post on 13-Apr-2018
218 Views
Preview:
Transcript
7/26/2019 Zeberio Amwona, A096 129 849 (BIA Nov. 10, 2014)
1/12
Pritschet, R. Leo, EsqR Leo Prische Law Oice105 5h Avenue South, Suie 105Minneapolis, MN 55401-0000
ame: AMWOMA, ZEBERIO
Executive Oce r Imigration Revew
Board of Imigration AppalsQc oh k
507 Leeb Pke Ste 2000Falls Churc, Vgi 030
HSICE Oice of Chie Counsel B(SP)1 Fedea Drive, Suie 1800 Snelling MN 55111
096129849
Date o his noice 11/102014
Ecosed s a copy of the Board' decso nd order n he above-reerenced case.
nclosure
b
Sincere,
Doa Ca
Chie erk
For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished
Cite as: Zeberio Amwona, A096 129 849 (BIA Nov. 10, 2014)
7/26/2019 Zeberio Amwona, A096 129 849 (BIA Nov. 10, 2014)
2/12
Dpm f scExecutive Oce aon Reiew
Decsn of e Board o Immaon Appeals
Fas Chc, Vgna 5
Fle: A096 129 849 - Blomngton, Date
In e ZEERIO AMWOMA
RMOVL PROCDNGS
AEAL
ON BEHLF OF PONDENT R. Leo Pritschet, sque
ON BHALF OF DHS
CHAR:
Lu W. Tosenssistt Chief Cousel
tc ec 37(a)()(A) &N Act 8 USC 22(a)()(A)]
NOV 1 O 2014,
ndmisble at tme of eny o adjstment of tatus der sectona)(C)(i), &N ct [8 USC 82(a)(6)C)(i) Faud o wil msepesentatn f mtel ct
'
The espondent hs ld ppea f the Immigaton Judge's Apl 12, 2013, dcsonndng e espondent movable ude section 2()()() of th Imigratin d Ntonalict having ben nadmssible at the tme of his stment of status uder section22(a)()(C)(i) o e Act by eason of aud or wll msepesentaton f materia ctThe Depment f Homed ecuity (DS") h ed bef n oppostion to eespondents appea he recod wll be rmded
The spondent chlenges the Immigaton Jdges eterminatn t he msepeseted amateria ct n hs applcaton r adjusmet f status d thus was namssble psunt tosectin 212)(6)(C)() f he Act t the tme ajtment of status was grted He also gusht the Immatn udge ws prdsposd to nd m emabe as charged
We evew ndng o ct, ncludng the determnatin of cdiblity, mde by themmiaton udge und cley eoneus" tdd. 8 C
1003(d)(3)(i); Mae of
R-S-H-, 3 &N Dec 9 ( 2003) Mae of SH 2 I&N Dec. 46 (B 002)We evew all he sss, ncludng whthe he pies he met the elevt uden of poof,d e o dsceo, de e noo d di o-B4 IN Dec. 49 BIA 2008).
The ecod shws that e epnent in e peent case dd t scose on hs applcatnsr dustmet of sts ed July 0 Juy 05 the chilen that he theedn Keya w gret Kemuto mwom T t 9 x 5 ectn B f the pliction
to egst ement esence or dut Status, Fo 85 sates Lst you presenthbfe, ll of y sons d aughtes f you hae none, te non" (Exh )he espondent rote nn" n the led 20 Exh 2) On e m ed n 2005 w
Cite as: Zeberio Amwona, A096 129 849 (BIA Nov. 10, 2014)
7/26/2019 Zeberio Amwona, A096 129 849 (BIA Nov. 10, 2014)
3/12
7/26/2019 Zeberio Amwona, A096 129 849 (BIA Nov. 10, 2014)
4/12
096 19 849
W nd it ncssy o rmnd rcod o Immiraion Jud r considaiond nalysis. Th Immiaton ud dos not app o hav shid urdn of proof o thrspondnt upon h DHSs showin of matrality of th misrpsnaion. See Maer ofBosuego, upra Addtionally, th rspondnt rus in his appa if hat th Imiation
ud mischracrzd d faid to onsid th numous afavits nd documns hsubmitd in suppor of his rmoval hn (Rspondn's Bf at 8 Durin h iniia masrnd hin in 202, th rspondnts aoy tod th Imaion u a had dsva doumns in Api 20 wth h DS rlain o th h of movabiity issudaaist th sponnt {T. a 3, 9-10). T spondnts attoy cld ht th DHS omidth doumnt om roup xhiit tha th DS sumitd o th cour (Tr at 3, 9-0.
Thr, on rmn Immiation Jud should consid and vaut al vidnc ofrcod to drmin whth rspondnt had mt is budn of showin a no popnd of inamissibii coud b mad. Th pis so shoud povidd oppounity opsnt any additiona vt vidnc.
As to h rspondnts n ha th Immiraion ud ws pdisposd to dny himrif, in ordr o stabish that his rih o du procss was violatd, h spondn musdmonsat both a ndntal procdual o and a h ror rsultd prudi. Seeoroge v Holde 753 F.3d 809 (8h C. 14; Doe Holder 65 F.3d 824 (8th Cir. 201(o staish a du procss vioaion in rmova podins ain us dmonsra boh andnta procdural or d pudic as a su of t rror Braic v Hoder 603 F.3d107 (8th Cir. 010). sponnt in s mar has no provn pjudi.
Accordiny, th lown ord ill b ntrd.
OER rord is rmdd r r procdins nd ny of a nw dcision
1 Th rspondn has aso d additiona vidnc on appa rain o h armonial aws ins oy. W do no considr vidnc prsntd th rs tim on app 8 C..R. 003.(d)(3( Mae of S-H 3 &N D. 46 (BIA 2003. owvr, n it of odcision to rmnd h as, th rspondn may prsn th vidnc o h Immiraion udon rmnd.
3Cite as: Zeberio Amwona, A096 129 849 (BIA Nov. 10, 2014)
7/26/2019 Zeberio Amwona, A096 129 849 (BIA Nov. 10, 2014)
5/12
(
NED SATES DEPRTMENT OF JUSCE
EXCTVE FICE O IMMGAO RIWNED STATES MMIGRAION COBLOMINGON, MNNESOA
e A096-129-849
te aer o
April 2 203
ZERO MWM
)
)))
IN RMVAL POCEDINS
RESPNDT
CHARE Secton 237(a)(1)() - a e tme o e of adusme o sausnadmissibe de Secon 22(a)(6)(C)(i) raud o illisrepreseatio o a ateral ac.
APPICANS: eiato of proceedigs ad voay depaure
N HALF F SPONDN: E RSCE, Atorey a aw
N BEF OF S AA TRZAN
RAL DCSN OF E IGRATON UDGE
he respoden is a iize of Kenya ho was paed remova poceedgs o
Jne 202, y te flig th te mgrao Cou o he Noce to Appear Exit
e respodet as charged it beig sbject to eoval der Seco 23(a)(1){A)
of the Imigraon ad Naoality Ac (Act) o beig iadssile a e ie o e o
aduse of saus de Secto 22(a)(6)(C)() o te At raud or illfu
misepeseao o a matera act
1
..- . . .. . . . . . .wk. .
.
6.W
..A
...}.. ;:
. . . . .WE>.....f
,_
-
7/26/2019 Zeberio Amwona, A096 129 849 (BIA Nov. 10, 2014)
6/12
Te espodet ou cosel adited te fst ou actu alleations
coaied in te Noce to ppear it te aedme o aegto o. 3 beg a B1
visa rathe an Te espodet deied alleato o 5 elat o te fad o
illu epreseato ad deed a e as sject to eov caged
e Govee sbitted docuets n sppo o e aegaio ad te
cae Exibit 2. e respode ubitted documets sppot o is dea o te
aca alegato ad te care Exbt 3 d te ou as aso cosdered e
repodens itte brie regad o aerait Exibi 4 e respoet aso
testfed ths case
e docuear evidece and the reodet's tesmo refect tat te isue
in tis case relates to te espodet are to iden fve biologica clde n i
applicaton fo permaen resdet satu Fom -485 Exiit 2 staig o page 53
e espode suseuetl filed a For N00 appicato o atazatio
Setebe 011 Exibit 2 pge 1 ich e cude ese cde
Te Goveent are tat the repodets aue to cude i boloca
clde at te e of is appcatio or peranet esdet satus s a willl
srepresenato o a materal fact Te respodet agues at te alue o detif
tese clde s ot maeal to te espodets appcato o adjutet o s
iatio statu
Te ourt oe fst o a as far as e evidece goes tt te Goveret
evdence cotaed i Exit elecs te hsto o e espodets cae ela ohis acusio of peaet esdet tus ad ssequet appcao for
naazaton ncdes a swo taee ake of te esode at e time o
tevie o is ataizato appco Ehibit , aes 11 tou 14 I icde
copies of te b ceficae o e ive cden beoni o e espodet Exb
09612984 2 Apl 013
z _;
L (@l
7/26/2019 Zeberio Amwona, A096 129 849 (BIA Nov. 10, 2014)
7/12
ges 15 hgh 19 nd i ins e 485 ws arved in e resde's
se nd wh refles n enion f he ve hldren xibi 2 ges 53 hrogh 57
onras, e esndens evidene aned in xhib 3 s, her ha e
brh efes of he resens hildren nd hs dve eree om s Ued
Ses zen we nd hs wn bh eiie domes h ear o have been
sefly eaed r he rpse sbissn o s C n s eng Te
Cor des n gve he sme wegh hse dues s gives he esondes
wn saemens relaing his adjusmen o sas nd naurazan nevews
he resnde hs summarzed, vey wel s he ase law ha eaes
he ssue wheher a f s meria r o fo uroses f exdbiliy under Sen
22a)(6(C) of he he resonde sas w he ases f Maer of S- and
B-C- a 6 rney enel Deson n whih es ws se frad inlde
nlyss irs f all, f whehe he rerd esblishes he esnden s exludble
n he rue fs and f he e fas wod reder e esnden exdable, en he
seresena s maera f des o, hen he send ad hd qesns s
be nsdered The deisn goes on sae seond, dd e msreresenin end
o sh e f inquy whh s eleva he le's egibliy d, f relev ie
f inqiy has been f migh ha nqry ve resled in a er deerminan h
he alien be exded
In he frs nsne des e rerd esblish h s resnden wld be
exldable n he re fas? n ohe wods f he resden d dslsed hs fveldren, wud h have endee hm exludable he Cu fds a d n
Seo e r oks weher e seresen wd en s a ne
of nqy reevan he resondens eigby The Cur fnds h i des d n
a e Cr finds loglly fwing he lne qiry a wuld have reeded
096129-849 3 ri 2 23
'Mf 3
7/26/2019 Zeberio Amwona, A096 129 849 (BIA Nov. 10, 2014)
8/12
.I
from discose o hs fe childe he wold a ikeliood hae bee deed
dset o stat he Cootes i is regard tha he espod msel
testfe, nd the bth certifctes o e cire sblish, ta are e poct o
oe oher naed Margret d the reoet ee Ehb pags 5 roug 9
The esodet imself tes a taed i a reos sor staemet tat h wa
arrie o argaet i csomr mrrge rese testid, a the swon
tatemen eflect! tat when e responde cae te Un tates o his sto
is e ma hae icd ha me ta h was mred I the swor statementcotae xibit age 1 th qeso fom e teieer posed was drig the
N- itew toay, ecber 8, 01 o tesd tat o wer marie
customr to gat, bt that yor family d ot aproe" Te aswer ge b e
responde ws e" T iteewer ase whee ws the cusom arrge?
he resons ge b te eponde was i Ks Ka. Te ect ace is
kara, a mrketplace, m oeto
he respod goes o tate tat wor tatee tat tere ws o
cereo, o dge o goemet ose I was ot cl e js cae a
sa w e here is o eidece to estabish wheher he espoet ha a
cstor mrriage b cobtao d the brt of chdre bsd po this statement
owee e Co aso otes ta te so statem e respodet was so
sked the esto g te 0 teew yo estfied t o biee that o
caed to be mared whe yo apled or yo , isa Wo di o cm o beor e at t tme i 999 e epode sre Mrgaret Camto Swenta
r ccte ded y the respoe Et 3 ad the Goemet
xibi re etical excet or cces rond cert formatio o t esodet's
copies o se bir ceriictes Th bth cetificates were l obtae 0 a
A0969-89 4 Apri 1,
-&
w
7/26/2019 Zeberio Amwona, A096 129 849 (BIA Nov. 10, 2014)
9/12
iniae a ae o reisrain Fera 01 see xhii paes 15 houh 19.
he rh erifaes lis he name an surname o he aher as Zeero mwoma
Amwoma. f he ith eraes lst the name a aien name of mother as
Margae amo mwma. The espne entie her s Magaet wenta he
respones sumssio of he rh eriaes earg he name o he moher as
Margaet amuo mwoma sugess a mara relaionship ewee he ahe a
mter f these hilren
While he asee of he ames aes an ples o irh of five hilre in an
of se woul o ae he espens eliiiliy r ajusten of saus is lear
ha he failure o isose ha informion uo a ne o nqi ha leas to he
qesion of wheher or he respnent ha a prior unisove marriage hose
hilrens mher l the lren have he esponets last ame All o he irth
eriiaes reet hat thei mhe eas he same last ame. The esponet has o
moe han e oasin iiae ha he was marrie o a wman ame Margare
n al o hs evene wol ea to a ine f nqry ernng he responents prior
mara stas I he responen ha an unisve marrage he o ot have ee
eligle for ausmen o saus o he 85 whih ha een approve ha ine of
nqui was o an onsequel has n reahe an onlso eause he
nqui has never ee onue. Logial when someoe has five hren wth he
same woman who eas his name an he has laime to e marre to it woul e
e o nvesgae wheher suh eionsp is onsere a ega maige in he
oun i whih t ourre a woul seek o eterme weher ay marrage reors
r ssli ors xis a unr eause e Goermen was unale to
lok nto hose maes eause he were n awae at he esponent ha ve
hlre wih he same woman in Kena elilty ou no e eermne eause tha
A99-89 5 prl 1 1
7/26/2019 Zeberio Amwona, A096 129 849 (BIA Nov. 10, 2014)
10/12
le of quiry was cuo
,\
ased upo a cosideratio o the evidece i the record this case te Co
fids a te carge agais e resodet is sstaed he respode
misrepreseted a aeral ac wic cto a ie of iquiry eadig to a issue ta
relaes directly o eigbiity for adjstme of tats ad it apeas i is case at
adjustmet of staus may wel ave bee deed
e respode seeks i te aterative, outay departre ad the
Goveret is ot opose to tha reqest Accordgly he Cort wil grat voutarydeparure i e repodes case to te maim 60 days aoed by law po th
osti o a oltary deartre bod wch te Court wil se at the mimm amout
o $500
Accordgly, the oowig order shal be etered
ORDER:
e carge der Secto 23(a)(1)(A) iadmssble uder Secto 22(a)(6)(C)(i) of
the Act i sstaied
he resode s grated e prvlege of voluarly deatig the ed States o or
before Je 11 o ostig a bod i te amou of 500 thi ive bsiess days
it a aerate order o removal o eya
3 Attached ad icorporated erei s te Noice o Respodets Grated Vouay
Deartre, whic cotais the addtioal adisas to persos grated ostcoclsio
volua deparre
Plee ee he ex p ge f elei
sin ture
A0912949 6 Arl 1 03
7/26/2019 Zeberio Amwona, A096 129 849 (BIA Nov. 10, 2014)
11/12
68
SUSN COImigraton Judge
7 Aprl 3
7/26/2019 Zeberio Amwona, A096 129 849 (BIA Nov. 10, 2014)
12/12
.
.
//s//
Iigration Judge SUSAN E. CARO
castros on July , 2013 at 2:48 PM GT
A096-129849 8 Aprl , 203
top related