WIPO 2nd Global Symposium 17 Sep 2010 IP5 Foundation Projects – why are they necessary and what are the challenges? Jan Modin, FICPI CET Special Reporter,

WIPO 2nd Global WIPO 2nd Global Symposium 17 Sep 2010Symposium 17 Sep 2010

IP5 Foundation Projects – why IP5 Foundation Projects – why are they necessary and what are they necessary and what

are the challenges?are the challenges?

Jan Modin, FICPI CET Special Jan Modin, FICPI CET Special Reporter, International Patents Reporter, International Patents

jan.modin@ficpi.orgjan.modin@ficpi.org

FICPI view on the patent systemFICPI view on the patent system

• Balance of interestsBalance of interests

• Increased transparency – Increased transparency – publication of patent applications publication of patent applications at 18 monthsat 18 months

jan.modin@ficpi.orgjan.modin@ficpi.org 22

• Transparency - benefits to:Transparency - benefits to:

• Third partiesThird parties

• OfficesOffices

• The PublicThe Public

• ApplicantsApplicants

jan.modin@ficpi.orgjan.modin@ficpi.org 33

Make search reports more complete:Make search reports more complete:

• Data bases searchedData bases searched

• Search strategies usedSearch strategies used

• Claims searchedClaims searched

• ICC proposalICC proposal

jan.modin@ficpi.orgjan.modin@ficpi.org 44

• Timing of searches at different officesTiming of searches at different offices

• Early grant in some countriesEarly grant in some countries

• Later searches in other officesLater searches in other offices

• invalidityinvalidity

jan.modin@ficpi.orgjan.modin@ficpi.org 55

• Supplementary searchesSupplementary searches

• Concurrent, sequentialConcurrent, sequential

• Present system not usedPresent system not used

• EPO SISA – development?EPO SISA – development?

jan.modin@ficpi.orgjan.modin@ficpi.org 66

• Why are IP5 Foundations Why are IP5 Foundations Necessary?Necessary?

• Single search not enoughSingle search not enough

• Collaborative, joint effort ???Collaborative, joint effort ???

• FICPI Resolution: FICPI Resolution: truly supplemental truly supplemental searchessearches

• Reasonable time frame Reasonable time frame

jan.modin@ficpi.orgjan.modin@ficpi.org 77

• What are the challenges?What are the challenges?

• CoordinationCoordination

• First and second filingsFirst and second filings

• Competent OfficesCompetent Offices

• Backlogs costlyBacklogs costly

jan.modin@ficpi.orgjan.modin@ficpi.org 88

• FICPI Proposal: PCT LINK systemFICPI Proposal: PCT LINK system

• Central data base for PCT Central data base for PCT applications (international phase)applications (international phase)

• Links to Office websites (national Links to Office websites (national and regional phases, incl OFF)and regional phases, incl OFF)

• Uniformly structuredUniformly structured

• Search results, strategies, Search results, strategies, parameters, claims searchedparameters, claims searched

jan.modin@ficpi.orgjan.modin@ficpi.org 99

Spread the work!Spread the work!

• IP5IP5

• Other PCT authoritiesOther PCT authorities

• GB, DEGB, DE

• 15 competent offices15 competent offices

jan.modin@ficpi.orgjan.modin@ficpi.org 1010

• How to cope with the workload?How to cope with the workload?

• Reduce effort by truly Reduce effort by truly supplementary searchessupplementary searches

• Increased transparency Increased transparency

• Better coordination Better coordination

• Utilize all resourcesUtilize all resources

jan.modin@ficpi.orgjan.modin@ficpi.org 1111

Thank youThank you

jan.modin@ficpi.orgjan.modin@ficpi.org