Revolution, Constitutionalism, and Democracy

Revolution, Constitutionalism, and Democracy

The German Weimar Republic

Peter Caldwell [“Carl”]Rice University, Houston, Texas, USA

The Revolutionary United States

"When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another...":

"When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another...":

“The unanimous Declaration of the united States of America…”

“We the People of the United States of America…”

Representation in the U.S. Constitution

Abbé Sieyès, “What Is the Third Estate?”

Abbé Sieyès

“The Third Estate is the Nation.”

Abbé Sieyès

“The Third Estate is the Nation.”“In every free nation (and every nation ought to be free) there is only one way to put an end to differences about the constitution. If we lack a constitution, then a constitution must be made, and the Nation alone has the right to do so.”

King Louis XVI

Abbé Sieyès

“…the privileged orders have shown themselves to be…an enemy of the common order.”

Robespierre

“Louis must die, that the nation may live.”

French Revolution:Committee of Public Safety

trumps constitution; Terror deemed necessaryto suppress the enemy.

The Russian Revolution

• Disastrous war• Tsar impedes organization for the war,

alienates most of the nation• February Revolution replaces Tsar with a new

Provisional Government• Task: to complete the war, and then to devise

a new constitution

Dual Power

Lenin, State and Revolution

Lenin, State and Revolution

Revolution carried out by classes—in this case, “the proletariat organized as the ruling class,” to suppress “the exploiting class, the bourgeoisie.”

Lenin, State and Revolution

“Marxism educates the vanguard of the proletariat, which is capable of assuming power and of leading the whole people to socialism…”

Trotsky on the Red Terror

The Red Terror is a weapon utilized against a class, doomed to destruction, which does not wish to perish.

American Revolution

French Revolution Bolshevik Revolution

Revolution 1776: directed against British in name of national liberation; acts of terror against British sympathizers during Revolutionary War

1789: starts with aristocratic revolt; spreads to revolt of commoners against aristocrats; spreads to revolt against King and enemies; 1793-94, turns against many revolutionaries, during the Terror

1917: breaks with the February Revolution in the name of direct rule by the Proletariat; exclusion of other parties; civil war and Red Terror; consolidation of institutions of direct rule and Red Terror over the 1920s

Constitution First constitution too weak; second constitution (1787) stabilizes authority by creating new power—but states remain

Multiple attempts to create constitution from 1790 on; constitutions trumped by emergency action against enemy, the “terror”

Party claims position above law, as motive force of revolution; constitution can be suspended by Party in interest of the revolution

Representation (who is the people? Or: What is democracy?)

Complex form of representation at federal level; tension between states and federal government

National Assembly at first; Committee of Public Safety, speaking in the name of the entire Nation

Party, speaking in the name of the Proletariat, which claims to embody the entire Nation

Monarch------------------------Army and Bureaucracy

Assembly-----------------------------Budget/Taxes

“Kommandogewalt”

“Budgetrecht”

Unified Germany

“The Proclamation of the German Empire on January 18, 1871, in the Hall of Mirrors at Versailles”

The political system of the Empire

Individual states’ monarchs or assemblies

Bundesrat

Reichstag

All German men 25 years or older

Kaiser

ChancellorPrussian Minister-President

Legislation, budget, information

Army

=

Otto von Bismarck

“If it has to be revolution, then we would rather make it ourselves than suffer it.”

The political system of the Empire

Individual states’ monarchs or assemblies

Bundesrat

Reichstag

All German men 25 years or older

Kaiser

ChancellorPrussian Minister-President

Legislation, budget, information

Army

=

The Kulturkampf

German Reichstag Elections, 1871-1893