REVITALIZE 2018...4/10/18 1 Dry Needling Paul Thomas, PT, DPT, OCS, FAAOMPT 2018 CONFERENCE & EXPO Material presented at IPTA 2018 REVITALIZE Conference “Myofascial pain is arguably

Post on 18-Apr-2020

3 Views

Category:

Documents

0 Downloads

Preview:

Click to see full reader

Transcript

4/10/18

1

DryNeedlingPaulThomas,PT,DPT,OCS,

FAAOMPT

2018CONFERENCE&EXPO

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2018REVITALIZEConference

“Myofascialpainisarguablythemostcommoncauseofpaintoafflicthumankind”

-Gerwin,2011

Title

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2018REVITALIZEConference

•  JanetTravelrediscoveredtriggerpointsintheearly1940’sanddevelopedtheideaoftriggerpointinjecZons

•  By1944theideathattheneedlemaybepartlyresponsibleforthetherapeuZceffectshadalreadybeenmenZoned

4/10/18

2

•  Atfirstmanagementofmyofascialpainwithinvasivetechniqueswasreservedforphysicians

•  MostMD’spreferredinjecZonsoverdryneedling

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

Theneedleeffect

•  In1979,KarlLewitpublishedontheneedleeffect§  Achievedsuccessfuloutcomesin86%ofpaZentstreated§  Successdefinedasimmediateanesthesia

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

Acupuncturists

•  Inthe1980’ssomeacupuncturistsawareofTravellandSimons’workanddevelopedaninterestinthetriggerpointconcepts§  Seem2007

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

3

PhysicalTherapists

•  PT’sthathadstudiedwithDr.JanetTravelldevelopedaninterestindryneedling

•  1984MarylandBoardofPhysicalTherapyExaminerswasthefirstintheUStoapproveddryneedlingaswithinthescopeofPTpracZce

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

MyofascialTriggerpoint

•  TrP’scanbepresentasaprimaryproblemandindependentcauseofpain

•  Ortheycanbeaco-morbiditysecondarytoamedicalissue§  OAorotherjointproblems(e.g.,knee,hip,etc)§  Systemicdiseases§  NutriZonaldisorders(e.g.,vitamindeficiencies)§  VisceraldysfuncZons(e.g.,endometriosis,intersZtalcysZZs,IBS,prostaZZs)

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

MTrP

•  TriggerpointscanpersistbeyondtheduraZonoftheiniZaZngcondiZon

•  MusclehavevarietyofnocioceptorsthatcanbeacZvatedbymechanicalorchemical

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

4

TrPDefined

•  Atriggerpointisahyperirritablespotinatautbandofaskeletalmusclethatispainfuloncompression,stretch,overload,orcontracZonoftheZssuewhichusuallyrespondswithareferredpainthatisperceiveddistantfromthespot§  Simonsetal.1999

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

AcZveorLatent

•  LocalandreferredpainfromacZvetriggerpointsreproducessymptomsreportedbypaZents

•  BothacZveandlatenttriggerpointscauseallodyniaattheTrPandhyperalgesiaawayfromtheTrP

•  LatenttriggerpointsthelocalandreferredpainarenotrecognizedasbeingusualpainthatpaZentexperiences

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

Latenttriggerpoints

•  AlthoughlatenttriggerpointsarenotproducingacZvepain,theyprovidenociocepZveinputtothedorsalhorn(Geetal.2008,2009,Ge&Arendt-Nielson2011)

•  LatentTrPcanbecomeacZvetriggerpointswithcentralsensiZzaZonandincreasedefficacyinthedorsalhorn

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

5

AcZveTrP’s

•  AcZvetriggerpointsinducelargerreferredpainareasandhigherpainintensiZes(Hongetal2000)

•  OverlyingcutaneousandsubcutaneousZssuesmoresensiZvetopressureandelectricalsZmulaZonthanlatentTrP’s.(Vecchietetal.1990)

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

•  BothacZveandlatenttriggerpointscanprovokemuscledysfuncZons§  Muscleweakness§  InhibiZon§  Increasedmotorirritability§  Spasm§  Muscleimbalance§  Alteredmotorrecruitment

•  ChangesoccurintheeffectedmuscleorfuncZonallyrelatedmuscles

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

MotoracZvaZonlatentTrP

•  Lucasetal2010demonstratedimpairedmotoracZvaZonpamernsinlatenttriggerpoints

•  CorrecZonoftheTrPnormalizedthemotoracZvaZon

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

6

Referredpain

•  Mensedescribedreferredpaincomingfromdeepstructures(muscles,joint,tendons,viscera)asdeep,diffuse,anddifficulttolocalize

•  Referredpaincanbeexperiencedanywhereinthebody

•  Sizeofthereferredareaisvariableandrelatedtothepaininducedchangesinthecentralsomatosensorymaps

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

Referredpain

•  Characterizedby:§  DuraZonofreferredpaincanlastafewsecondstohours,weeks,or

indefinitely.§  Deep,diffuse,burning,Zghtening,orpressingpain(completely

differentfromneuropathicorcutaneouspain)§  SimilarreferralofpainfrommuscleZssuesasreferralfromjoints§  Referredpaincanspreadsuperior/inferiororventral/dorsal§  IntensityofpainandsizeofreferredareaareposiZvelycorrelatedto

thedegreeofirritabilityofthecentralnervoussystem(sensiZzaZon)§  FrequentlyfollowsdistribuZonofscleratomes,notdermatomes§  Maybeaccompaniedbynumbness,coldness,sZffness,weakness,

faZgue,ormotordysfuncZon

§  Arendt-Nielsen&Ge2009,Fernandez-de-las-Penasetal2011

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

BasisofReferredPain

•  Convergent-projecZontheory(1961)§  AfferentsfromdifferentZssuesincludingskin,viscera,muscles,andjointsconvergeontocommonspinalneuronswhichleadstomisinterpretaZonofthesourceofthenociocepZveacZvityfromthespinalcord

§  Doesn’texplainthedelayinonsetofsymptoms

•  Covergence-facilitaZontheory§  SomatosensorychangesinthereferredareaduetosensaZzaZonmechanismsinthedorsalhornandbrainstemneurons

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

7

BasisofReferredPain

•  Thalamic-convergencetheory(1949)§  SummaZonofinputfrominjuredareaandfromreferredareawithin

neuronsinthebrain,butnotinthespinalcord§  EvidenceofpainreducZonwithanestheZzingthereferredarea

suggesZngaperipheralprocesscontributes§  Centralprocessarebelievedtobedominant

•  Central-Hyper-excitabilitytheory§  FollowingnoxioussZmulus,dorsalhornneuronsthatwerepreviously

responsivetoonlyoneareawithinamusclebegantorespondtonociocepZonfromareasthatdidnotpreviouslytriggeraresponse

§  LatentconvergentafferentsonthedorsalhornneuronareopenedbynoxioussZmulifrommuscleZssues

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

NatureofTrPs

•  Tautbandscanbepalpatedwithflatorpincergrip•  TautbandsignifiescontracZonwithinacertainnumber

ofmusclefibersindependentofelectromyogenicacZvityanddoesnotinvolvetheenZremuscle

•  Localtwitchresponseusuallyoccurswithmanualstrummingorneedling

•  Canbeobservedvisually,recordedonEMG,orvisualizedwithdiagnosZcUS

•  NumberofLTR’smayberelatedtotheirritabilityofthemusclewithmayberelatedtothedegreeofsensiZzaZonofnocioceptors(Biochemicalchanges)

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

LTR’s

•  EliciZngtheLTRhasbeenadvocatedforneedling(Hong1994,Shah2005)

•  Shah2005observedimmediatedropinconcentraZonsofbiochemicalsintheextracellularfluidoflocalTrP’s

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

8

TrPDevelopment

•  MayresultfromrepiZZvemuscleoveruse,acuteorsustainedoverload,psychologicalstress,orotherprimaryTrP

•  FollowingintenseconcentriccontracZonoreccentriccontracZons

•  Muscletrauma,repeZZvelowintensitymuscleoverloadmaycreatedamageinthesacroplasmicreZculumorcellmembrane,shortageofATP,andimpairedcalciumconcentraZon,shorteningofacZn/myosin

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

MTrPDevelopment

•  MTrPmaydevelopintheabsenceofmedicalproblemsorasaco-morbiditywithothercondiZons

•  MTrPcanbeassociatedwithsystemicdiseases,arthriZccondiZons;metabolic,parasiZc,ornutriZonaldisorders;secondarytoinjuries

•  PainfromMTrPcancauseseparateandindependentcauseofacuteandespeciallychronicpainthatmaycompoundthesymptomsoftheothercondiZonandmaypersistaqertheoriginaliniZalizingcondiZonhasresolved

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

Integratedmodel

•  ProposesthatabnormaldepolorizaZonofpost-juncZonalmembraneofmotorendplatescauseslocalhypoxiaacZvaZngreflexarcsthensustainedbysensaZzaZonmechanisms

•  Musclespindlesalsoinvolved.H-reflexesassociatedhavegreateramplitudesandlowerthresholds

•  Believedtoberelatedtogreaterexcitabilityofmusclespindleafferents(Geetal2009)

•  IncreasedchemicalmediatorsmaycontributetoincreasedspindlesensiZvity(Shahetal2005)

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

9

ProposedmechanismsforTDN

•  MechanicallyitmaydisruptcontracZonknots,stretchcontracturedsacromeres,reduceoverlapofacZn/myosin

•  MaydestroymotorendplatesandcausedistalaxondenervaZonandchangesintheendplatecholinesteraseandacetylcholinereceptorsimilartonormalmuscleregeneraZonprocess

•  ReducedendplatenoisefollowingLTRfromTDN

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

AcetylcholineresponsetoTDN

•  DecreasedSpontaneousElectricalAcZvityandAcetylocholineatMyofascialTriggerSpotsaqerDryNeedlingTreatment§  Ratstudy,dividedinto2groupsreceivingTDNtotriggerpointornon-triggerpoints

§  Dryneedlingtreatmentlast2weeks,onceperweek§  SEAs,Ach,AChR,AChElevelsmeasuredaqeroneweekresyofdryneedling

§  ResultsAmplitudeandfrequenciesofendplatenoiseandendplatespikessignificantlydecreasedaqerTDNingroupreceivingtreatmenttoMTrP

§  AchandAChRlevelssignificantlydecreasedandAChEsignificantlyincreasedintreamentgroup

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

Mechanisms

•  LTRreducesconcentraZonsofbiochemicalsintheimmediateareaofTrP’sincludingCGRP,substanceP,serotonin,interleukins,epinepherine

•  DropinsubstancePandCGRPlikelycorrespondwiththedecreasedpainfollowingTDN

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

10

Mechanisms

•  Effectonthecentralnervoussystem§  hasbeensuggestedthatneedlinghaseffectsonlimbicsystemanddescendinginhibitorysystem

•  StudiesonTDNoffibromyalgiapaZentsdemonstratesthatneedlingafewpointsonpaZentsreducespainnotonlyinthetreatedareasbutreducesoverallsensiZvityandwidespreadpain.

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

Mechanisms

•  ReducessegmentalnociocepZveinput

•  ExperimentallyinducedmusclepainimpairsnoxiousinhibitorycontrolmechanismsandTDNseemstoeffectcentralsensiZzaZonbyalteringthenociocepZveprocessing

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

ConnecZveZssueresponse

•  Langevinetal.mulZplestudies•  Whenneedlesrotatedcollagenbundleadheretotheneedleand

winditselfaroundtheshaqinimmediatevicinity•  StretchismaintainedaqertherotaZngtheneedleifleqinplace•  Sustainedstretchcausesvisco-elasZcrelaxaZon,Zssuetension

dropsandsemlesatequilibriumduetomolecularreorganizaZonwithinthecollagenmatrix

•  ConnecZveZssuefibroblastsrespondbychangingshape,formaZonofnewcytoplasmicextensions.

•  Remodelingofcell’scytoskeleton•  ChangecausesfurtherreducZoninZssuetensionthenthat

achievedbyviscoelasZcrelaxaZon•  Fibroblastsresponduptoseveralcmawayfromtheneedle•  Needlesrequiredtostayinforlongperiod(10’)

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

11

SuperficialTDNMechanisms

•  AmributedtothesZmulaZonofA𝛿fiberswhichmayoutlastthesZmulusforupto72hours(Baldry2005)

•  TypeIhighthresholdfibersacZvatedbynociocepZvemechanicalsZmulaZon

•  SZmulaZonofA𝛿fibersmayacZvateenkephalinergic,seratonergic,andnoradrenergicinhibitorysystems

•  MayacZvatemechanoreceptorscoupledtoslowconducZngunmyelinatedCfiberafferents

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

SuperficialDryNeedling

•  PeterBaldrybeganemployingthetechniqueinthe1980’s§  .3mmneedle,30mmlength§  Insertfor30secondsabovetheMTrPtobeinacZvated§  Iffailstorespondthenwillleaveforupto2-3minutes§  IfveryweakresponderthenmayintermimentlytwirltheneedletosZmulate

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

Gunn-IMS

•  GunnIntramuscularSZmulaZon•  Developedinthe1970’sbyChanGunn,MD•  Cannon’s“SupersensiZvityofDenervatedStructures,aLawofDenervaZon”

•  Believedinradiculo-neuropathic-myofascialpain(RNMP)

•  Leadtolookingforsegmentalmyotomalinvolvement

•  PredictstriggerpointsinmyotomaldistribuZonincludingtheposteriorramus

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

12

Gunn

•  Increasedmuscletone•  Neurogenicedema–matchsZcktest,peaud’orange•  Vasomotordisturbanceswithhypothermia–coolertopalpaZon

•  Exaggeratedpilomotorandsudomotorreflexes–goosebumps,increasedsweat

•  Dermatomalhairloss

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

CannonandRosenbluth’sLaw

•  Whenaunitisdestroyedinaseriesofefferentneurons,anincreasedirritabilitytochemicalagentsdevelopsintheisolatedstructureorstructures,theeffectbeingmaximalinthepartdirectlydenervated

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

BiomedicalAcupuncture

•  WMAisatherapeuZcmodalityinvolvingtheinserZonoffineneedles;itisanadaptaZonofChineseacupunctureusingcurrentknowledgeofanatomy,physiologyandpathology,andtheprinciplesofevidencebasedmedicine

•  Characterizedbydryneedlingoftriggerpointsandsegmentalacupuncture(needlingofanareainnnervatedbythesamespinalsegment

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

13

Biomedicalacupuncture

•  Localeffects•  Segmentalanalgesia

§  SZmulatestheA𝛿fibersinskinandmuscle§  TheseacZvatesmallintermediatecellsinthedorsalhorn§  IntermediatecellsreleaseneuromodulatorenkephalinwhichblocksthetransmissionofpaininthesubstanZagletainosacells,partofthenociocepZvepathway(fromtheunmyelinatedC-fibers

•  Extrasegmentalanalgesia

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

BiomedicalAcupuncture

•  ExtrasegmentalAnalgesia§  OpioidpepZdes(neuromodulators):

•  β-endorphin(midbrain,PAG)•  Enkaphalin(dorsalhornofspinalcord)•  Dynorphin(brainandspinalcord)•  Orphanin–akaendomorphinornocicepZn(widespread)

§  HaveeffectontargetcellforsustainedperiodofZme•  Descendinginhibitorypaincontrol

§  PAGacZvatedbyβ-endorphin,releasedfromfibersdescendingfromthehypothalamusspecificallythearcuatenucleuswheresomeafferentpathwaysoftheA𝛿terminate

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

Extrasegmentaleffects

•  Descendingpaincontrolreleasesserotonin,sZmulaZngtheintermediatecelltoreleasemet-enkephalinwhichinhibitsthesubstanZagelaZnosacells(addiZonaltothesegmentalinhibiZonalreadyacZvated)

•  Alsocausesreleaseornoradrenalinediffuselythroughoutthedorsalhornwhichhasadirectinhibitoryeffectonpost-synapZcmembraneoftransmissioncellsfurthercontrollingnociocepZon

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

14

E-sZm

•  2Hz–releasesβ-endorphin,enkephalin,andorphanin

•  80-100Hz–releasesdynorphin•  15Hz–limitedreleaseofenkephalinandβ-endorphin

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

AdverseEventsreportedin7629treatmentswithTDN

Event CasesReported Numberper100treatments

Number(%)ofPT’srepor<ngnone

Extremevaluesbyindividualprac<onersper100treatments

Bleeding 576 7.55 4(10.25) 32.23,30

Bruising 355 4.65 3(7.69) 26.09,21.84

Painduringtreatment

230 3.01 9(23.08) 20.75,20.69

Painaqertreatment

167 2.19 14(35.9) 20.69,18.4

AggravaZon 67 0.88 22(56.41) 10.99,5.75

Drowsiness 20 0.26 32(82.05) 4.44,3.26

Feelingfaint 17 0.22 28(71.79) 4.17,2.5

Headache 11 0.14 31(79.49) 1.15,1.1

Nausea 10 0.13 31(79.49) 1.15,1.1

FaZgue 3 0.04 37(94.87) 1.77,0.27

EmoZonal 3 0.04 37(94.87) 1.59,0.27

Shaky 1 0.01 38(97.44) 3.03

Itching 1 0.01 38(97.44) 0.47

Claustophobia 1 0.01 38(97.44) 0.16

Numbness 1 0.01 38(97.44) 0.47

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

AdverseEvents

VeryCommon Common Uncommon Rare VeryRare

>10%/>1-10 >1-10%/1-10/100

>0.1%-1%1-10/1000

>0.01%-0.1%1-10/10,000

<0.01%<1/10,000

BleedingHematomaNeedlesitepain

InflammaZonSwellingStrongpainduringNerveirritaZonNerveinjuryHeadacheFaZgueVerZgoNausea

LocalinfecZonRednessItchingSweaZngBloodpressurechangesUnconsciousnessTachycardiaBreathingdifficulZesVomiZng

PneumothoraxBrokenneedleForgomenneedleSystemicinfecZonAffectedspeechDisorientaZon

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

15

Guidelines

•  Handhygiene§  washhandswithsoap/waterorusehandsaniZzersifnotvisiblysoiled

•  Gloves§  UseisinlinewithOSHAguidelines,likelycontactwithblood

•  Skinprep§  NotusuallyrequiredforTDNperWorldHealthOrganizaZonforintradermal,subcutaneous,orintramuscularinjecZons

§  Ifskinisvisiblysoiledshouldbecleanedwithsoap/waterfirst§  Mayuse70%alcoholleqonskinforatleast2minutesespeciallyifpaZentisimmunocompromisedyetsuitableforTDN

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

AbsoluteContra-indicaZons

•  PaZenthasneedlephobia•  PaZentisunwilling–fear,belief•  Unabletogiveconsent•  AcutemedicalcondiZon•  OveranareaorlimbwithlymphodemaasitmayincreaseriskofcelluliZs/infecZon

•  Inappropriateforanyotherreason

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

RelaZvecontra-indicaZons

•  Abnormalbleeding•  Compromisedimmunesystem•  Vasculardisease•  Diabetes•  Pregnancy•  Children•  FrailpaZents•  PaZentwithepilepsy•  Psychologicalstatus•  PaZentallergies•  PaZentmedicaZon•  UnsuitablepaZentforanyotherreason

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

16

AnatomicalconsideraZons

•  Lungsandpleura•  Bloodvessels•  Nerves•  Organs•  Joints•  ProstheZcimplants/fixaZondevises•  Implanteddevices

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

MuscleCramps

•  Geetal2008demonstratedlatenttriggerpointscouldbeatleastparZallyinvolvedinmusclecrampsbyinducingcrampswithglutamateinjecZonsin92.86%ofsubjectstested

•  NocrampswereobservedwheninjecZonoccurredinnon-TrP’s

•  IncreasednociocepZvesensiZvityattheTrPisbelievedtobeonemechanismforthedevelopmentofmusclecramps

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

EffectsofTDNonPower/ForceProducZon

•  40malesseparatedin4groups§  RectusfemorisTDN§  MedialgastrocTDN§  RectusfemorisandmedialgastrocTDN§  Control(noneedles)

•  Peformedjumpsquatsatincrementalloadsandmeasuredforjumpheight,poweroutput,opZmalforce,andopZmalvelocity

•  Results:§  Immediateincreaseinjumpheightforgroup2(gastroconly)andat48

hourspostintervenZon§  From48hoursonwardatrendwasobservedforjumpheight,power,and

velocity§  AuthorsconclusionthatTDNcausesiniZaldecreasedperformancewith

levelsimprovingabovebaselineaqer48hours

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

17

LTR

•  TheassociaZonbetweendryneedling-inducedtwitchresponseandchangeinpainandmusclefuncZoninpaZentswithlowbackpain:aquasi-experimentalstudy.

•  66paZentwithmechanicalLBP•  TDNtoL3andL5bilaterally•  NumericpainraZng,modifiedOswestry,pressurealgometry,ultrasound

imagingbeforeandaqertreatment•  Results:parZcipantswithLTRexhibitedgreaterimprovementinmulZfidus

funcZon12.6%changevs5.7%)•  Howeverdifferencewasnotpresentatoneweek•  Nobetweengroupdifferencesindisability,painintensity,ornociocepZve

sensiZvity.•  ConclusionsthatLTRmaynotbenecessaryforsuccessfultreatment•  ResultsmayhavelastedlongeriffollowedbystrengtheningoracZvaZon

exercises

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

CosteffecZveness

•  CosteffecZvenessoftheinclusionofTDNintoanExerciseProgramforSubacromialPainSyndrome:EvidencefromaRCT§  50paZentsrandomizedintoexerciseorexerciseplusTDN§  BothgroupsaskedtoperformRCexercises2x/dayfor5weeks§  AllparZcipantssawPTforsupervisedexercisesonceperweekfor5weeks§  PaZentsintheneedlinggroupalsoreceivedTDNon2ndand4thsessions§  SocietalcostsandhealthrelatedQOLovera1yearfollowupwereusedto

generatecostperquality-adjustedlife-year(QALY)raZosforeachintervenZon

§  Exercisegroupmademoredoctorvisitsandreceivedgreaternumberofothertreatments

§  Majorcontributertothesocietalcostswasabsenteeism(lostproducZvity)

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

TrA/MulZfidus

•  ImmediateChangesinResZngandContractedThicknessofTransversusAbdominisAqerDryNeedlingofLumbarMulZfidusinHealthyParZcipants:ARandomizedControlledCrossoverTrial§  47healthyindividualswithoutLBPinprevious6monthsassignedTDNtomulZfidusorsham-TDN(usedtubeonly).

§  ParZcipantsreceivedbothintervenZonsatleast7daysapart.§  InstructedhowtocontractTrAandmeasuredwithultrasoundatrestandcontractedbeforeandimmediatelyaqereachintervenZonbyevaluatorblindedtotheintervenZonreceived

§  ResultsdemonstratedTDNtothemulZfidus(L4)wasaccompaniedbydecreasedresZngthicknessandincreasedcontracZonthicknessoftheTrA

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

18

MulZfiduschangeswithTDN

•  66volunteerswithmechanicalLBP•  Ultrasoundmeasurementsandpainalgometry(PPT)ofthe

mulZfidustakenatbaseline,immediatelyaqerTDN,and1week.

•  PercentagechangeinmusclethicknessfromresttocontracZonwascalculatedtodeterminemusclefuncZon.

•  ParZcipantdeterminedtoberespondersornon-respondersbasedonimprovementmeasuredwithmodifiedOswestryatoneweek.

•  RespondersexhibitedlargerimprovementsinmulyiduscontracZonandnociocepZvesensiZvityat1week,butnotimmediatelyaqerintervenZonthannon-responders

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

TDNforLBP

•  Evidencefordryneedlinginthemanagementofmyofascialtriggerpointsassociatedwithlowbackpain:asystemaZcreviewandmeta-analysis§  11RCTinvolving802paZentsincludedinmeta-analysiswithresultssuggesZngthatcomparedtoothertreatements,dryneedlingofMTrPswasmoreeffecZveinallevaiZngintesityofLBPandfuncZonaldisability

§  However,significanteffectsofdryneedlingplusotherintervenZonscouldbesuperiortodryneedlingalonepostintervenZon

§  ConclusionthatTDNofMTrPcanberecommendedespeciallyifassociatedwithotherintervenZonstorelieveintensityofLBP

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

Heelpain

•  EffecZvenessoftriggerpointdryneedlingforplantarheelpain:ameta-analysisofsevenrandomizedcontrolledtrials

•  Extensiveliteraturereviewfoundonly7RCT’smeeZnginclusioncriteria.

•  PooledresultsshowedMTrPneedlingsignificantlyreducedVASscorecomparedwithcontrol

•  TDNhadsimilaradverseeventincidenceascontrols•  ConclusionTDNeffecZveforreducingheelpainduetoplantarfasciZs

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

19

CervicalPain

•  Beneficialeffectsofdryneedlingfortreatmentofchronicmyofascialpainpersistfor6weeksaqertreatmentcompleZon§  45paZentswith>3monthscervicalpainandMTrP’scompleted3sessionTDNand

evaluated6weeksaqerwards§  VAS,BriefPainInventory(BPI),andMTrPstatus§  RespondersdefinedasthosewhereMTrPchangedfromacZvetolatentornon-palpable

nodule§  SecondaryoutcomesPPT,ProfileofMoodStates,OswestryDisabilityIndex(ODI),MOS

36ItemShortFormHealthSurvey,andcervicalROM§  Results:Painmeasuresremainedsignificantlyimproved6weeksposttreatment,asdid

theSF-36physicalfuncZoningscoreandODI.SidebendingandPPTforsubjectswithunilateralMTrPhadsustainedimprovement.

§  Respondersandnon-responders,changesinVASandBPIwerestaZsZcallysignificant,butchangeinPPTwasnot

§  HigherbaselineVASwasassociatedwithhigherlikelihoodofnotrespondingtoTDN§  GreaterdropofVASfrombaselinewasassociatedwithhigherlikelihoodofsustained

improvement

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

KneePain

•  EffecZvenessofinclusionofdryneedlinginamulZmodaltherapyprogramforpatellofemoralpain:arandomizedparallel-grouptrial§  60paZentsrandomizedintomanualtherapyandexerciseormanualtherapy,exercise,plusdry

needling§  Bothgroupreceivedthesamemanualtherapyandstrengtheningprogramfor3sessions(1x/wkfor

3wks)§  TDNgroupalsoreceivedTDNtovastusmedialisandlateralis§  PaZentsassessedatbaseline,15dayposttreatmentand3months§  Nosignificantdifferencesbetweengroupsforanyoutcomemeasure(KneeInjuryandOsteoparthriZs

Outcomescale,InternaZonalKneeDocumentaZonCommimeeSubjecZveKneeEvaluaZonForm,painraZng

§  Bothgroupsimprovedoutcomescores§  Conclusion:AddiZonofTDNdidnotresultinanyaddiZonalimprovedoutcomesforpainordisability

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

TDNvsOMT

•  ComparisonofdryneedlingversusorthopedicmanualtherapyinpaZentswithmyofascialchronicneckpain:asingle-blind,randomizedpilotstudy§  36paZentsplacedintooneof3groups:manualtherapy,TDNandstretching,orsoqZssuetechniques

§  Allgroupsreceived2sessionwith48hoursbetween§  AssessedforNDI,paincatastrophizingscale,VAS,cervicalROM,PPTformechanicalhyperalgesia

§  Results:all3groupsreporteddecreasedpainintensity§  TDNandOMTgroupshadreduceddisability§  TDNandOMTgrouphadincreasedcervicalROM§  ReducedmechanicalhyperalgesiaandpaincatastrophizinginOMTgrouponly

4/10/18

20

TDNforshoulderpain

•  Exercisesanddryneedlingforsubacromialpainsyndrome:arandomizedparallel-grouptrial§  50subjectswithsubacromialpainrandomizedtoexercisegroupor

exerciseplusTDN§  ParZcipantsaskedtoperformexercises2x/dayfor5weeks§  Supervisedexerciseonceperweekfor5weeks§  TDNgroupalsoreceivedneedlingtoMTrPsessions2and4§  Assessedatbaseline,1week,3wk,6wk,and12monthsaqer

treatment§  Results:largerimprovementsfortheexerciseplusTDNgroupin

shoulderdisabilityatallf/uperiods§  Bothgroupshadsimilarimprovementsinshoulderpainoutcomesat

allpoints§  Conclusion:TDNeffecZveforimprovingdisabilityinsubacromialpain

syndrome

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

Flexibility

•  ClinicaleffectsofdryneedlingamongasymptomaZcindividualswithhamstringZghtness:arandomizedcontrolledtrial§  27subjectswithhamstringextensibilitydeficitsrandomizedintoside

oftreatment(non-dominant/dominant)andgroup(bluntneedling/dryneedling)

§  FirstsessionmeasuredHSextensibilityandperformanceon4unilateralhoptests,HEPinstrucZoninHSstretching,andneedlingdistaltoischealtuberosityandmidbelliesofmedial/lateralHS

§  2ndsession3-5daysaqerre-measuredandneedling§  3rdsession4-6weeksforoutcomesonly§  Results:HSextensibilityimprovedinbothgroups,triplehopshowed

improvementforTDN§  Conclusion:Dryneedlingdoesnotresultinincreasedextensibility

beyondthatofstretchingaloneinasymptomaZcgroups

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

TDNforsportsimprovement

•  Comparisonofdryneedlingvs.shamontheperformanceofverZcaljump§  35parZcipantsdividedintoshamorTDNgroup§  TDNgroupreceivedneedlingto4sitsin(B)gastrocnemiusmuscles,2eachformedial/lateralhead

§  TwoleggedverZcaljumpheightwasrecordedpre-andpost-forbothgroups

§  Results:TDNgroupincreaseverZcalsignificantly(1.2”)overshamgroup

§  Conclusion:singlesessionofTDNcancauseimmediateeffectonincreasingverZcaljumpheight

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

21

TDNforTMD

•  Short-termeffectsofdryneedlingforacZvemyofascialtriggerpointsinthemassetermuscleinpaZentswithtemporomandibulardisorders§  12femaleseachamendedtwosessionsandreceiveddryneedlingorsham,randomizedontwoseparatedays

§  PPTovermasseterandmandibularcondyle,pain-freeacZvejawopeningwereassessedpre-and5minutespostintervenZonbyblindedexaminer

§  Results:subjectsshowedgreaterimprovementinallmeasureswithTDNcomparedtosham

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

TDNvssteroidforplantarfasciZs

•  ComparisonofdryneedlingandsteroidinjecZoninthetreatementofplantarfasciZs:asingle-blindrandomizedclinicaltrial§  66paZentswithrandomizedtoreceiveddryneedlingor1mlDepo-Medrol

§  F/ufor12monthsandmonitoredforVASatbaseline,3wk,6wk,3month,6months,1year

§  Results:steroidinjecZongroupsignificantlyreducedVASscoresunZl3weeksposttreatmentcomparedtoTDN

§  PaZentsintheTDNgroupreportedlowerVASatendofstudycomparedtosteroidintervenZon

§  Conclusion:steroidcandecreaseheelpainrapidlybutdryneedlingcanprovidemoresaZsfactoryresultsforpaZentswithplantarfasciZslongterm

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

Deepvssuperficialdryneedling

•  ComparisonofacuteeffectsofsuperficialanddeepdryneedlingintotriggerpointsofthesuboccipitalanduppertrapeziusmusclesinpaZentswithcervicogenicheadache§  30parZcipantswithdiagnosisofcervicogenicHAdividedrandomlyintodeepandsuperficialgroups

§  HeadacheIndex,triggerpointtenderness,cervicalROM,funcZonalraZngindexassessedatbaseline,immediate,and1weekaqertreatment

§  Results:bothgroupsshowedreduucZoninheadacheindexandtriggerpointtenderness.

§  DeepdryneedlinggroupshowedgreaterimprovementincervicalROMandfuncZonalraZngindex

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

22

LateralepicondyliZs

•  DryneedlinginlateralepicondyliZs:aprospecZvecontrolledstudy§  PaZentsselectediftheyhadpainatlateralepicondylefor>3months,painduringresistedsupinaZon,andresisted3rdfingerextension

§  PaZentevaluatedwiththePaZent-ratedTennisElbowEvaluaZon(PRTEE)atbaseline,3weeks,and6months

§  110paZentsrandomizedtoreceivedryneedlingoribuprofen100mg2x/dayandforearmbrace

§  TDNtoMTrParoundthelateralepicondyle2x/wkfor5sessions§  Results:bothgroupsimprovedat3weeks,butdryneedlingsignificantlymoreeffecZveat6months

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

Wryneck

•  ImmediateeffectsofparaspinaldryneedlinginpaZentswithacutefacetjointlockinducedwryneck§  21paZentswithacutefacet

lockedwryneckweretreatedwithsinglesessionofdryneedlingfor12-15minutes.

§  VASandcervicalROMimmediate,24hours,and1week

§  Results:reducedVASandcervicalROMincreasedimmediatelypostintervenZonandwasmaintainedatthe1weekfollowup.

Measure

Baseline

Immediate

24hour 1week

VAS 73.47 18.80 5.85 2.12

Flex/ext 30.38° 95.33°

115.04°

122°

SB 13.76°

91.90°

117.42°

125°

Rot 15.42°

88.28°

107.66°

115°

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

DiscogenicLBP

•  TheeffectofdryneedlingontheradiaZngpaininsubjectswithdiscogeniclowbackpain:arandomizedcontroltrial§  58paZentswithdiscogenicradicularLBPrandomizedtocontrolgroupand

experimentalgroup§  VAS,OswestryDisabilityIndexatbaseline,endoftreatment,2months

postintervenZon§  ReceivedthermalmodaliZes,US,TENS,exercise(McKenzieand

stabilizaZon).§  Experimentalgroupreceived5sessionsTDNparaspinals,mulZfidus,QL,

glutemax/med/min,piriformis,psoas,HS,gastrocneedledaccordingtopresenceofMTrP’s.

§  SignificantimprovementinVASandOswestryforbothgroupsfollowingintervenZonatduringf/uperiod

§  PainanddisabilityimprovementgreaterintheexperimentalgrouppostintervenZonVAS25.17,ODI22.17vsVAS42.41,ODI30.27)andmaintainedduringf/u

§  ConclusionthatdryneedlingmayenhanceeffectofstandardintervenZon

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

4/10/18

23

RRefer

•  References:–  TriggerPointDryNeedling:AnEvidenceandClinicalBasedApproach.DommerholtJ.Churchill

LivingstonElsevier.2013.–  Steinbrocker,O.1944.TherapeuZcinjecZonsinpainfulmusculoskeletaldisorders,JAMA.125,

397-401.–  Lewit,K.1979.Theneedleeffectinthereliefofmyofascialpain.Pain.6,83-90.–  SeemM.2007.AnewAmericanacupuncture;acupunctureosteopathy.BluePoppyPress,

Boulder.–  Jarrell,J.2004.MyofascialdysfuncZoninthepelvis.Curr.PainHeadacheRep.8,452-456.–  SimonsDG,TravellJG,SimonsLS.1999.MyofascialPainandDysfuncZon:thetriggerpoint

manual.Vol1.LippincomWilliam&Wilkins,Philadelphia.–  Hongetal.1997.ReferredpainelicitedbypalpaZonandbyneedlingofmyofascialtrigger

points:acomparison.Arch.Phys.MedRehabil.78,957-960.–  Vecchietetal.Latentmyofascialtriggerpoints:changesinmuscularandsubcutaneouspain

thresholdsattriggerpointandtargetlevel.J.ManMed.5,151-154.–  Geetal.InducedmusclecrampsbynociocepZvesZmulaZonofmyofascialtriggerpoints.Exp.

BrainRes.187,623-629.

MaterialpresentedatIPTA2016REVITALIZEConference

•  References–  Geetal.IncresaedH-ReflexresponseinducedbyintramuscularelectricalsZmulaZonoflatent

myofascialtriggerpoints.Acupunct.Med27,150-154.–  GeHY,Arendt-NielsenL.2011.Latenttriggerpoints.Curr.PainHeadReports15,386-392.–  LucasKR,RichPA,PolusBI.2010.MuscleacZvaZonpamernsinthescapularposiZoning

musclesduringloadedscapularplaneelevaZon:theeffectsoflatenttriggerpoints.ClinBiomechanics.25,765-770.

–  Arendt-Nielsen&Ge2009.PathophysiologyofreferredmusclepaininFernandezdelasPenasetal.TensionTypeandCervicogenicHeadache:Pathophysiology,diagnosis,andtreatment.Jones&BartlemPublishers,Boston,pp51-59.

–  Fernandez-de-las-Penasetal.2011.Manualtreatmentofmyofascialtriggerpoints.NeckandArmPainSyndromes:AnEvidenceInformedscreening,diagnosis,andconservaZvemanagement.ChurchillLivingstonElsevier,London,pp451-461.

–  Shahetal.2005.Anin-vivomicroanalyZcaltechniqueformeasuringthelocalbiochemcialmilieuofhumanskeletalmuscle.J.Appl.Physiol.99,1997-1984.

–  HongCZ,TorigoeY.1994.ElectrophysiologiccharacterisZcsoflocalizedtwitchresponsesinresponsivebandsofrabbitskeletalmusclefibers.J.MusculoskeletalPain2,17-43.

–  HongCZ.1994.ConsideraZonsandrecommendaZonofmyofascialtriggerpointinjecZon.J.MusculoskeletalPain2,29-59.

•  References–  BradyS,McEvoyJ,DommerholtJ,DoodyC.Adverseeventsfollowingtriggerpointdry

needling:aprospecZvesurveyofcharterphysiotherapists.JManManipTher.2014Aug;22(3):134-40.

–  LangevinHM,BouffardNA,BadgerGJ.2006.SubcutaneousZssuefibroblastcytoskeletalremodelinginducedbyacupuncture:evidenceforamechanotransducZonbasedmechanism.J.Cell.Physiol.207,767-774.

–  LangevinHM,BoffardNA,ChurchillDL,BadgerGJ.2007.ConnecZveZssuefibroblastresponsetoacupuncture:dosedependenteffectofbi-direcZonalneedlerotaZon.J.Alt.Compliment.Med.13,355-360.

–  Langevinetal.2011.FibroblastcytoskeletalremodelingcontributestoconnecZveZssuetension.J.Cell.Physiol.226,1166-1175.

–  Langevinetal.2001.MechanicalsignalingthroughconnecZveZssue:amechanismforthetherapeuZceffectofacupuncture.FASEBJ.15,2275-2282.

–  Langevinetal.2001.Biomechanicalresponsetoacupunctureneedlinginhumans.J.Appl.Physiol.91,2471-2478.

–  Langevinetal.2004.Tissuedisplacementsduringacupunctureusingultrasoundelastographytechniques.UltrasoundMed.Biol.30,1173-1183.

–  Langevinetal.2005.DynamicfibroblastcytoskeletalresposetosubcutaneousZssuestretchexvivoandinvivo.Am.J.Physiol.CellPhysiol.288,C747-C756.

4/10/18

24

•  References–  GunnCC.TheGunnapproachforthetreatmentofchronicpain:intramuscularsZmulaZonfor

myofascialpainofradiculopathicorigin.ChurchillLivingstonElsevier,NewYork.1989.–  WhiteA,CummingsM,FilshieJ.AnIntroducZontowesternmedicalacupuncture.Churchill

LivingstonElsevier.NewYork.2008.–  DeveruxF,O’RourkeB,ByrnePJ,ByrneD,KinsellaS.Theeffectsofmyofascialtriggerpoint

releaseonthepowerandforceproducZoninthelowerlimbkineZcchain.JStrengthCondRes.2018Feb22.

–  Arias-BuriaJL,MarZn-SaboridoC,ClelandJ,KoppenhaverSL,Plaza-ManzanoG,Fernandez-de-Las-PenasC.CosteffecZvenessevaluaZonoftheinclusionofdryneedlingintoanexerciseprogramforsubacromialpainsyndrome:evidencefromarandomizedclinicaltrail.PainMed.2018Feb22.

–  PuenteduraEJ,BuckinghamSJ,MortonD,MontoyaC,FernandezdeLasPenasC.ImmediatechangesinresZngandcontractedthicknessoftransversusabdominisaqerdryneedlingoflumbarmulZfidusinhealthyparZcipants:arandomizedcontrolledcrossovertrial.JManipulaZvePhysiolTher.2017Oct;40(8):615-623.

–  LiuL,HuangQM,LiuQG,ThithamN,LiLH,MaYT,ZhaoJM.Evidencefordryneedlinginthemanagementofmyofascialtriggerpointsassociatedwithlowbackpain:asystemaZcreviewandmeta-analysis.ArchPhysMedRehabil.2018Jan;99(1):144-152.

•  References–  KoppenhaverSL,WalkerMJ,McGowenJM,UmlaufL,HarrisKD,RossMD.Changesinlumbar

mulZfidusfuncZonandnociocepZvesensiZvityinlowbackpainpaZentrespondersversusnon-respondersaqerdryneedlingtreatment.ManTher.2015Dec;20(6):769-76.

–  KoppenhaverSL,WalkerMJ,Re{gC,DavisJ,NelsonC,SuJ,FernandezdeLasPenasC,HebertJJ.TheassociaZonbetweendryneedling-inducedtwitchresponseandchangeinpainandmusclefuncZoninpaZentswithlowbackpain:aquasi-experimentalstudy.Physiotherapy.2017Jun;103(2):131-137.

–  HeC,MaH.EffecZvenessoftriggerpointdryneedlingforplantarheelpain:ameta-analysisofsevenrandomizedcontrolledtrials.JPainRes.2017Aug18;10:1933-1942.

–  GerberLH,SikdarS,AredoJV,ArmstringK,RosenbergerWF,ShaoH,ShahJP.Beneficialeffectsofdryneedlingfortreatmentofchronicmyofascialpainpersistfor6weeksaqertreatmentcompleZon.PMR.2017Feb;9(2):105-112.

–  LiuQG,LiuL,HuangQM,NgyenTT,MaYT,ZhaoJM.DecreasedspontaneouselectricalacZvityandacetylcholineatmyofascialtriggerpointspotsaqerdryneedlingtreatment:apilotstudy.EvidBasedComplementMed.2017;2017:3938191.

–  Espi-Lopezetal.EffecZvenessofinclusionofdryneedlinginamulZmodaltherapyprogramforpatellofemoralpain:arandomizedparallel-grouptrial.JOrthopSportsPhysTher.2017Jun;47(6):392-401.

•  References–  Arias-NuriaJL,Fernandez-de-las-PenaC,Palacios-CenaM,KoppenhaverSL,Salom-

MorenoJ.2017.Exercisesanddryneedlingforsubacromialpainsyndrome:arandomizedparallel-grouptrial,18(1):11-18.

–  Campa-MoranIetal.ComparisonofdryneedlingversusorthopedicmanualtherapyinpaZentswithmyofascialchronicneckpain:asingle-blind,randomizedpilotstudy.PainResTreat.2015;2015:327307.

–  GeistKetal.ClinicaleffectsofdryneedlingamongasymptomaZcindividualswithhamstringZghtness:arandomizedcontrolledtrial.JSportRehabil.2017Nov;26(6):507-517.

–  BandyWD,NelsonR,BeamerL.Comparisonofdryneedlingvs.shamontheperformanceofverZcaljump.IntJSportsPhysTher.2017Oct;12(5):747-751.

–  Fernandez-CarneroJetal.ShorttermeffectsofdryneedlingofacZvemyofascialtriggerpointsinthemassetermuscleinpaZentswithtemporomandibulardisorders.JOrofacPain.2010Winter;24(1):106-12.

–  RastegarS,BaradaranMahdaviS,HoseinzadehB,BadieiS.ComparisonofdryneedlingandsteroidinjecZoninthetreatementofplantarfasciZs:asingle-blindrandomizedclinicaltrial.IntOrthop.2018Jan;42(1):109-116.

4/10/18

25

•  References:–  SedighiA,NakhosZnAnsariN,NaghdiS.Comparisonofacuteeffectsof

superficialanddeepdryneedlingintotriggerpointsofthesuboccipitalanduppertrapeziusmusclesinpaZentswithcervicogenicheadache.JBodywMovTher.2017Oct;21(4):810-814.

–  UygerE,AktasB,OzkutA,ErincS,YilmazogluEG.DryneedlinginlateralepicondyliZs:aprospecZvecontrolledstudy.IntOrthop.2017Nov;41(11):2321-2325.

–  ShanmugamS,MathiasL.ImmediateeffectsofparaspinaldryneedlinginpaZentswithacutefacetjointlockinducedwryneck.JClinDiagnRes.2017Jun;11(6):YM01-YM03.

–  MahmoudzadehA,RezaeianZS,KarimiA,DommerholtJ.TheeffectofdryneedlingontheradiaZngpaininsubjectswithdiscogeniclowbackpain:arandomizedcontroltrial.JResMedSci.2016Oct18;21:86.

top related