Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 ......Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 25.02.2019 22 Storyline: ‘FLR should remain
Post on 06-Oct-2020
6 Views
Preview:
Transcript
http
s://de.w
ikiped
ia.org/w
iki/Ham
let#/m
edia/File:D
avid_G
arrick_in
_Ham
let,_A
ct_I,_Scene_4
.JPG
http
s://de.w
ikiped
ia.org/w
iki/Ham
let#/m
edia/File:D
avid_G
arrick_in
_Ham
let,_A
ct_I,_Scene_4
.JPG
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 3
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 4
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 5
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 6
STANDARD
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 7
STANDARD
http
s://ww
w.d
esignb
oo
m.co
m/d
esign/d
esign-in
dab
a-20
12
-po
rky-hefer-o
f-anim
al-farm/
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 8
How did youdo it?
http
s://de.w
ikiped
ia.org/w
iki/Ham
let#/m
edia/File:D
avid_G
arrick_in
_Ham
let,_A
ct_I,_Scene_4
.JPG
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 9
ConceptualLiterature
Existent Standards & Commentary
Expert Interviews
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 10
ConceptualLiterature
Existent Standards & Commentary
Expert Interviews
Argumentative DiscourseAnalysis
Hajer, 2006 & Nielsen, 2016
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 11
ConceptualLiterature
Existent Standards & Commentary
Expert Interviews
Argumentative DiscourseAnalysis
Standard/GuidanceTypologies
Hajer, 2006 & Nielsen, 2016
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 12
What was the result?
http
s://de.w
ikiped
ia.org/w
iki/Ham
let#/m
edia/File:D
avid_G
arrick_in
_Ham
let,_A
ct_I,_Scene_4
.JPG
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 13
Sou
rce:
htt
ps:
//p
ort
als.
iucn
.org
/lib
rary
/sit
es/l
ibra
ry/f
iles/
do
cum
ents
/20
14
-03
0.p
dfSo
urc
e: h
ttp
://w
ww
.bo
nn
chal
len
ge.o
rg/c
on
ten
t/ch
alle
nge
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 14
Sou
rce:
htt
ps:
//p
ort
als.
iucn
.org
/lib
rary
/sit
es/l
ibra
ry/f
iles/
do
cum
ents
/20
14
-03
0.p
dfSo
urc
e: h
ttp
://w
ww
.bo
nn
chal
len
ge.o
rg/c
on
ten
t/ch
alle
nge
htt
ps:
//w
ww
.wri
.org
/pu
blic
atio
n/r
esto
rati
on
-dia
gno
stic
Sou
rce: http
s://po
rtals.iucn
.org/lib
rary/sites/library/files/d
ocu
me
nts/2
01
8-0
22
-En.p
df
http://genderandenvironment.org/resource/paving-the-way-for-gender-responsive-flr-enhancing-cultural-identity-livelihoods-and-ecosystems/
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 15
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 16
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 17
http
s://imgflip
.com
/mem
egene
rator/Fu
turam
a-Fry
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 18
Based on: Hajer, 2006 & Nielsen, 2016
Storyline:
Problem (agenda
setting)
Solution (policy tool)
Vision (improved
outcome)
Storyline: ‘Business as usual in FLR must be improved or is unsound.’
Problem
Solution
Vision
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 19
Storyline: ‘Business as usual in FLR must be improved or is unsound.’
Problem • Unbalanced objectives• (Ab)use of FLR label
Solution • Standards/guidance sound FLR
Vision • Integrity of FLR label• Enhanced FLR quality
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 20
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 21
Storyline: ‘FLR should remain inclusive and also open to more private and
financial involvement to reach upscaling.’
Problem
Solution
Vision
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 22
Storyline: ‘FLR should remain inclusive and also open to more private and
financial involvement to reach upscaling.’
Problem • Exclusion could hamper uptake• Notorious lack of funding
Solution • Inclusive guidance
Vision • Conceptual inclusivity• Increased funding
De
cen
tral
ize
d
vs.
C
en
tral
ize
d a
dm
inis
trat
ion
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 23
Global level
Global w/ national
interpretations
Global w/ landscape
interpretations
National level
Landscape level
Forest biome level
De
cen
tral
ize
d
vs.
C
en
tral
ize
d a
dm
inis
trat
ion
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 24
Global level
Global w/ national
interpretations
Global w/ landscape
interpretations
National level
Landscape level
Forest biome level
De
cen
tral
ize
d
vs.
C
en
tral
ize
d a
dm
inis
trat
ion
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 25
http
s://de.w
ikiped
ia.org/w
iki/Ham
let#/m
edia/File:D
avid_G
arrick_in
_Ham
let,_A
ct_I,_Scene_4
.JPG
Can youmanage
this?
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 26
Complementingtypologies
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 27
Complementingtypologies
• Principle-basedguidance
• Definition-basedguidance
• Policy integrationstandard
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 28
Complementingtypologies
• Principle-basedguidance
• Definition-basedguidance
• Policy integrationstandard
Normative typologies
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 29
Complementingtypologies
• Principle-basedguidance
• Definition-basedguidance
• Policy integrationstandard
Normative typologies
• Safeguard type ofguidance
• Qualityguidance/ standard
• Inclusiveguidance
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 30
Content-specifictypologies
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 31
Content-specifictypologies
• Carbon focusedstandard
• Forest certification-based guidance
• Ecological standards
• Conciliatory guidance
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 32
Content-specifictypologies
• Carbon focusedstandard
• Forest certification-based guidance
• Ecological standards
• Conciliatory guidance
Other typologies
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 33
Content-specifictypologies
• Carbon focusedstandard
• Forest certification-based guidance
• Ecological standards
• Conciliatory guidance
Other typologies
• Decentralized guidance
• Non-guidance/ nostandard
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 34
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 35
http
s://de.w
ikiped
ia.org/w
iki/Ham
let#/med
ia/File:David
_Garrick_
in_H
amlet,_A
ct_I,_Scene_4
.JPG
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 36
25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 37
top related