LISA CHAVARRIA STAHL, BERNAL & DAVIES, LLP AUSTIN, TEXAS LISA@SBAUSTINLAW.COM PRESENTED AT: THE UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF LAW 2008 WIND ENERGY INSTITUTE Wind.

LISA CHAVARRIASTAHL, BERNAL & DAVIES, LLP

AUSTIN, TEXAS LISA@SBAUSTINLAW.COM

PRESENTED AT: THE UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF LAW 2008

WIND ENERGY INSTITUTE

Wind Leases: Emerging Issues

Initial considerations

Client counseling considerations. Option lengths Developer Considerations?

Financial Aspects of Wind Lease

Gross Revenues - What is typically included? Excluded?

Emerging Requests : Future created state and federal green credits ,

pollution credits, offsetting credits Construction claim amounts Others ???

Are “Most Favored Nations” Clauses a good thing?

Project Build Out

Landowners want to maximize number of turbines installed on property. Small landowner considerations

Landowners want contractual assurances of build out; developers need to be conservative. How do you strike the right balance?

“Shrink Wrapped Projects”

Some leases allow a developer to release acreage x number of years after the project is built.

The Pros and Cons of releasing acreage: Landowner Perspective

Small tract issues Less money Fewer burdens?

Developer Perspective Provides a project buffer Future development

Related Issue - Easement rights – in perpetuity v. coterminous.

Hunting Rights

Landowner and developer perspectives.

Oil and Gas Exploration

Texas Accommodation Doctrine Conflicts with non-executive rights holders

What should be included in accommodation agreement?

Distances from turbines; other facilities Realistic provisions

Pitfalls to avoid Can’t we all just get along?

WIND LEASE TERM

Length of term varies for Texas wind leases Some are as long as 150 years. Most are 30 years with an option to extend for

additional periods. Lock in royalty now? Negotiate royalty later? How?

WIND LEASE TERM

Minnesota, North Dakota and South Dakota have statutory limitations on length of a wind lease term and severance rights.

Option lengths

North Dakota § 17-04-04

Wind energy leases — Termination.

A lease for wind energy purposes is void and terminates if development to produce energy from wind power has not occurred on the leasehold within five years after the lease commences. ND Cent Code § 17-04-04.

North Dakota, § 17-04-03

Wind easements — Creation — Term — Development required.

A property owner may grant a wind easement in the same manner and with the same effect as the conveyance of an interest in real property. The easement runs with the land benefited and burdened and terminates upon the conditions stated in the easement. However, the easement is void if no development to produce energy from wind power associated with the easement has occurred within five years after the easement is created. ND Cent Code § 17-04-03

Minnesota Statute

THIS LEGISLATION HAS BEEN PASSED: Amendment to Minn Stat § 500.30(2) …subdivision 2, is

amended to read: …A wind easement, easement to install wind turbines on real property, option, or lease of wind rights shall also terminate after seven years from the date the easement is created or lease is entered into, if a wind energy project on the property to which the easement or lease applies does not begin commercial operation within the seven-year period.   EFFECTIVE DATE. This section is effective the day following final enactment, and applies to wind easements created and wind rights leases entered into on and after the effective date of this section....  

-2007 Minn. Laws ch. 136, Art. 4, § 15 (S.F. No. 145).

South Dakota

Re development period:

Any property owner may grant a wind easement in the same manner and with the same effect as a conveyance of an interest in real property. The easement shall be created in writing and shall be filed, duly recorded, and indexed in the office of the register of deeds of the county in which the easement is granted. Any such easement runs with the land or lands benefited and burdened and terminates upon the conditions stated in the easement, except that the term of any such easement may not exceed fifty years. Any such easement is void if no development of the potential to produce energy from wind power associated with the easement has occurred within five years after the easement began. Any payments associated with the granting or continuance of any such easement shall be made on an annual basis to the owner of record of the real property at the time the payment is made. SD Codified Laws § 43-13-17.

Severance of Wind Rights In Texas

What do we mean by that? Is this a good idea?Sever with caution! Legislation has been discussed in Texas.Suggested legislative considerations:

Don’t impede development –understand what the industry needs to continue growth;

Understand what property owners need for protection; Transferable property rights should encourage

maximizing energy output . Understand severing wind rights can be abused – one

person can control energy development.

Severance of Wind Rights (North Dakota)

Severance of wind energy rights limited.

Except for a wind easement created under section 17-04-03 and as otherwise provided in this section, an interest in a resource located on a tract of land and associated with the production of energy for wind power on the tract of land may not be severed from the surface estate.

However, nothing in this section may be construed to prohibit

or limit the right of a seller of real estate to retain any payments associated with an existing wind energy project. ND Cent Code § 17-04-04

Severance of Wind Rights (South Dakota)

Re severance of wind rights from land:

No interest in any resource located on a tract of land and associated with the production or potential production of energy from wind power on the tract of land may be severed from the surface estate as defined in § 45-5A-3, except that such rights may be leased for a period not to exceed fifty years. Any such lease is void if no development of the potential to produce energy from wind power has occurred on the land within five years after the lease began. The payment of any such lease shall be on an annual basis. SD Codified Laws § 43-13-19.

QUESTIONS?