Transcript
7/31/2019 Howto Government Contracts
1/17
7/31/2019 Howto Government Contracts
2/17
Hw d governmental contracts i Bzi laW
ai chb c Bzi amcHam
Ii ai Dp
Bzi, 2010
ACKNOWL
EDGMENTS
Lima & Curvello Rocha Lawyers is a law irm headquartered in Brasilia, the capital city o
Brazil, and specialized in providing legal advice on national and international govern-
ment procurement procedures and government contracts in Brazil, in addition to carrying
out strategic planning and representing Brazilian and oreign companies in the country.
Our team o lawyers has extensive experience in government entities, the Superior
Courts, and Government Accounting Courts, and is ully prepared to provide you with
all the necessary guidance to take part in procurement procedures carried out by Brazil-
ian government entities.
We hope that our contribution to the AMCHAMs How To series is able to illustratesome o the market opportunities and provide you with a strategic view o the market o
government contracts in Brazil, in addition to demonstrating how the irm is able and
available to assist oreign companies in the country.
Jonas Lima,PartnerLima & Curvello Rocha Lawyers
Delza Curvello Rocha,Partner -Lima & Curvello Rocha Lawyers
Gabriel Rico, Executive Director AMCHAM Brazil
The American Chamber o Commerce or Brazil, being the largest Amcham outside the
United States is constantly serving its members by building bridges or Brazilian businesses
worldwide. Our oreign investment attraction eorts have also been a key leading point or
Amcham. The How To Series is part o this initiative; with the support o some o our corpo-
rate members we are putting together strategic inormation on the most various aspects o
doing business in Brazil. Over the last year the Brazilian economy has clearly demonstrated
an outstanding economic perormance. The countrys business environment as well as or-
eign investment numbers are also very positive. The International Monetary Fund estimates
that crisis apart; the Brazilian economy should grow on a 3.5% basis. It is now more than
ever, a strategic time or businesses opportunities in Brazil, we welcome you and hope that
the inormation you are about to read serves you best.
7/31/2019 Howto Government Contracts
3/17
Hw d governmental contracts i Bzi laW
CONTENTS
BRAZIL: A COUNTRY OF OPPORTUNITIES ....................................................................6
RULES AND REGULATIONS ON GOVERNMENT CONTRACTS IN BRAZIL ....................9
NATIONAL BIDDING X INTERNATIONAL BIDDING ....................................................12
PRICE REGISTRATION SYSTEM ......................................................................................13
DIRECT PURCHASES AND HIRES ..................................................................................14
SPECIAL ATTENTION TO IMPORTS ...............................................................................15
FOREIGN COMPANIES AND INTERNATIONAL GOVERNMENT PROCUREMENT ........16
QUALIFICATION............................................................................................................17
PROPOSALS...................................................................................................................20
ADMINISTRATIVE SANCTIONS .....................................................................................21
INTERNATIONAL PROCUREMENT PROCEDURES WITH FOREIGN RULES ..................21
REVOCATION AND ANNULMENT OF THE BIDDING ..................................................22
OVERSIGHT ROLES .......................................................................................................22
GOVERNMENT CONTRACTS ........................................................................................25
ABOUT OUR SPONSOR................................................................................................30
td by tdJui lw, lu & cuu
7/31/2019 Howto Government Contracts
4/17
6 Hw d governmental contracts i Bzi 7laW
BRAZIL: A COUNTRY OF OPPORTUNITIES
large construction and public works in inrastructure
or logistics, roads, urban transportation, telephone ser-
vices, sewage and water supply, and power supply;
advertising services; supply o air tickets; in addition to
equipment and works or large government-owned
companies, such as Petrobras.
Moreover, when the Government is the importing party,
specic tax exemptions apply, which may result in sav-
ings o up to 40% in terms o pricing in some cases.
Among other examples o the gures involved in public
procurement procedures, one can mention the Health
Ministry, which alone is responsible or over 58% o all
imports to the Brazilian Federal District although most
products are then distributed across the Country to
several States.
Ports
Approximately 80% o Brazilian imports and exports
go through the ports, which currently require a large
amount o investments, considering the change in the
export routes, regional developments, and the size o
the countrys coast. To date, the ederal governments
investments orecast (according to the PAC) totals ap-
proximately USD 4 billion, and requires private public
partnerships to meet the USD 18 billion needed in re-
sources or the sector.
Brazil has a large and growing market or government
procurement and government contracts. This market
accounts or USD 160 billion a year considering busi-
nesses carried out with all the spheres o government.
Thereore, this gure includes domestic and interna-
tional bidding processes in over 20,000 government
entities, agencies, and government-owned companies.
Currently, Brazil is oering unprecedented opportuni-
ties or oreign companies to engage in government
procurement procedures.
According to statutory provisions, companies not based
in the Brazil are also allowed to take part in government
procurement carried out in the country. However, it is
the eld o international public procurement, in other
words, procuring aimed at companies based abroad,
where the most interesting opportunities can be ound.
And, in this particular, case the notices o procurement
are especially drated to invite oreign bidders.
The Market Today
The most signicant sources o government contracts
today are: medical and hospital products and equip-
ment; drugs and medication; pharmaceutical products
and equipment; research oundations; special equip-
ment and vehicles or public saety, law enorcement,
re departments, ports, and airports; IT equipment;
Airports
INFRAERO, the government-owned company that
manages Brazilian airport operations, is expected to in-
vest more than USD 3 billion between 2010 and 2014
in order to increase and renovate several airports. As a
result, the passenger and cargo capacity o the Brasliaairport, or instance, will increase two-old and three-
old, respectively. As a result, there will be an increas-
ing volume o government procurement procedures.
Land Transportation
Brazil is undergoing a revolution in terms o land trans-
portation among and within cities. This is illustrated by
the recent notices o government procurement proce-
dures or the city o Rio de Janeiro, with investments to-
taling USD 1.02 billion, and or the competitive bidding
process or the high-speed train between Rio and So
Paulo, with investments estimated at USD 18.8 billion.
Growth Acceleration Program (PAC 1)
Investments orecast or inrastructure projects under
the PAC are constantly updated. During the rst stage
o the PAC, between 2007 and 2010, they were esti-
mated at USD 337.95 billion. Currently, most o the
projects have been implemented (approximately 60%)
and 40% o the projects have been concluded. PAC 1
also included projects in roadways, logistics, and en-
ergy, and social and urban investments.
Growth Acceleration Program (PAC 2)
Launched in 2010, investments orecast or the second
stage o the PAC total USD 544 billion or the period
between 2011 and 2014. In the post-2014 period, ad-ditional investments o USD 358 billion have been
orecast. Thus, total investments should achieve over
USD 900 billion.
Investments in cities, water and sewage, paving and
suracing, urban mobility, and prevention works in
risk areas, total USD 31 billion or the 2011-2014
period. Building new schools, sports acilities, com-
munity police stations, and healthcare units will re-
ceive USD 13 billion. Low-income housing mortgage
plans shall receive investments o USD 158 billion.
For universalizing access to water and power supply,
USD 17.3 billion have been allocated. For transpor-
tation, roadways, railways, ports, waterways, airports,
and equipment or smaller roadways investments will
total USD 59.3 billion by 2014 and, ater that year,
additional USD 2.5 billion have been orecast. Fi-
nally, in terms o generation and transmission o elec-
tricity, oil (including the Pre-Salt layer), and natural
gas, naval industry, and mineral research, the invest-
ments orecast amounts to USD 262.2 billion and,
ater 2014, are estimated in USD 356.1 billion.
7/31/2019 Howto Government Contracts
5/17
8 Hw d governmental contracts i Bzi 9laW
2014 FIFA World Cupand 2016 Olympics
The budget or the 2014 FIFA World Cup, one o the
biggest sporting events in the world, has been esti-
mated in USD 56.8 billion, and or the 2016 Olym-
pic Games, taking place in Rio de Janeiro, USD 19.3
billion in investments have been orecast.
Furthermore, Brazil is hosting the Conederations
Cup in 2013, the Para-Olympic Games in 2016, and
the Games o Peace, all o which will present in-
creased business opportunities between Brazilian
and oreign companies. It is also worth mentioning
that because o these events, Brazil has already es-
tablished various tax incentive programs at the ed-
eral, state, and municipal levels, in addition to spe-
cial nancing conditions.
Oil and Gas
Taking part in competitive bidding processes and sign-
ing contracts with Petrobas, the most well-known Bra-
zilian company, which is controlled by the Federal
Government, can mean good business opportunities,
seeing that the company has announced investments
totaling USD 224 billion between 2010 and 2014.
Moreover, or the uture exploration and development
o the Pre-Salt layer a number o companies may come
together or compete or certain business activities with
Petrobras. It is worth mentioning that total long-term
investments may reach USD 600 billion, 28% o
which, by mid-2010, had already undergone procure-
ment procedures.
Energy Supply
Brazil has an enormous demand or energy supply.
For the coming years construction works will be car-
ried out or 54 hydroelectric plants, 71 wind energy
plants, and three power plants, and 22,765 km in
transmission systems.
Broadband
Aimed at increasing internet broadband access three-
old by 2014, the Brazilian Federal Government will
invest in the ormer Telebras (mixed-capital compa-
ny) USD 1.83 billion to oster competition and pro-
mote market growth. As a result, there will be much
opportunity or service providers taking part in gov-
ernment procurement procedures in the sector.
National Defense Strategy
Due to this program, which among other goals aims at
renovating the national deense industry, through ac-
quiring products and equipment, technology transer,
and capacity building procurement and contracts in
the eld are dierentiated and, thereore, chiefy re-
terprises, which are avored by Law 123/2006 (simi-
lar to the American Small Business Act). Under this
system, although small or medium enterprises are
not allowed to join with large companies in order to
take part in the procurement process, there is no le-
gal provision prohibiting a small Brazilian enterprise
selling oreign products rom taking part in the pro-curement process in its own name.
* th fu b-id h b xpd i
UsD bd h xh 1UsD = Brl1.76.
quire that oreign companies be engaged in order to
ulll the specic goals or technology transer and
technology-related partnerships.
Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs)
Today, in Brazil, ordinary contracts with public enti-
ties (everyday needs), which represent more than hal
o all government procurement procedures carried
out, are being won by small and medium-sized en-
RULES AND REGULATIONS ON GOVERNMENT CONTRACTS IN BRAZIL
In Brazil, there are many ederal, state and local laws
governing government procurement procedures and
contracts. These laws usually address the ollowing
aspects:
I - Procuring entity;
II - Scope o procurement; and
III - Procurement method.
Procuring Entities
In regard to this rst aspect, it is worth noting that the
main norms governing government procurement pro-
cedures in Brazil stem rom article, 22, XXVII o the
Brazilian Constitution, pursuant to which the Union isthe sole entity with authority to issue legislation estab-
lishing general rules or all methods o procurement
and contracting processes involving direct and indi-
rect government entities, including oundations and
autarchies under Federal, State, Federal District, and
Municipal governments. This authority is exercised
based on the principles set orth in article 37, XXI o
7/31/2019 Howto Government Contracts
6/17
10 Hw d governmental contracts i Bzi 11laW
The Government Procurement Act also governs direct-
government agencies, special unds, autarchies, gov-
ernment oundations, government-owned companies,
mixed-capital companies, and any and all entities di-
rectly or indirectly controlled by the Union (Federal
Government), States, Federal District, Municipalities.
The Act also establishes under article 118 that: The
States, the Federal District, Municipalities and the in-
direct-government entities shall adapt their procure-
ment and contract rules to the provisions o this Act.
It is also important to stress that article 119 o the Gov-
ernment Procurement Act provides that mixed-capital
corporations, government-owned companies, govern-
ment oundations, and entities directly or indirectly
controlled by the Union and by the other spheres o
government will issue their own regulations.
This is the reason why government-owned compa-
nies and mixed-capital corporations have their own
specic norms, as is the case o the Petrobras Simpli-fedProcurementProcessRules, a requirement under
article 67 o Law 9 478/97 (the Oil and Gas Act), ap-
proved by Decree 2 745/98.
Scope of Procurement
There is a second category o laws, which is made up
o legislation addressing the scope o procurement
the Constitution; and according to the provisions un-
der article 173, paragraph 1, subsection III, in the case
o government-owned companies and mixed-capital
companies.
In turn, article 37, heading and subsection XXI o the
Brazilian Constitution establishes that direct and in-
direct government entities under any o the Branches
o Power within the Union, States, Federal District,
and Municipalities, shall be governed by the princi-
ples o legality, impersonality, morality, transparency,
and eciency, and exception made to specic cases
set out in statute, government works, services, pur-
chases, and disposals, shall be contracted according
to government procurement procedures ostering
equal treatment to competitors, and establishing
terms o payment based on the terms and conditions
o the proposal, as provided by law, which [procure-
ment procedures] shall only require technical exper-
tise and economic qualications essential to secure
the accomplishment o the obligations.
The above-mentioned provision was regulated by Law
8.666 o 1993 (Government Procurement Act), which
sets orth the general rules o government procure-
ment and government contracts concerning works,
services including advertising, sales, purchases, and
leases involving the Union (Federal Government),
States, Federal District, and Municipalities.
procedures, and they usually apply to more complex
procurement procedures, such as the ones adopted
to select and hire advertising agencies, which in this
case are governed by Law 12 232/2010.
Another example o special government procurement
procedures is the case o highly-regulated sectors. Law
9 472/1997 (Telecom Act), or instance, applies to any
and all procurement procedures carried out by the
National Telecommunications Agency (ANATEL).
It is also worth stressing that in the event the scope o
the procurement process or public service conces-
sions at the ederal level the applicable statute is Law
8.987/95. Concession periods vary. For instance, high-
way concession terms may be 20 years long, depend-
ing on the case.
When the scope o procurement is a public-private
partnership (PPP), Law 11 079/2004 applies. This law
was enacted to provide an alternative or government
debt and lack o government resources or imple-menting public interest projects. Thereore, it estab-
lishes general terms and conditions or procuring and
entering into PPS at the Federal, State, Federal Dis-
trict, and Municipal levels. The scope o the rst PPP
in Brazil was or the concession o Line 4 o the So
Paulo Subway System.
Lastly, or certain situations many other norms may ap-
ply. For instance, medication procurement procedures
must comply with ANVISA (National Health Surveil-
lance Agency) regulations; and procurement proce-
dures or outsourcing in general or or outsourcing IT
services must comply with the regulations issued by
the Ministry o Planning, Budget and Management.
When the resources originate rom nancing and do-
nations rom abroad, the norms o the international
cooperation agency apply, in addition to the general
norms in the Brazilian legislation concerning the
principles governing public activities, such as article
37 o the Brazilian Constitution and article 3 o Law
8666 (which also sets out principles).
Procurement Methods
The third and last aspect that procurement legislation
usually addresses is the procurement method to be
adopted. It should be highlighted that Law 8666/93 (the
Government Procurement Act), only sets orth the so-
called traditional procurement methods: competitive
bidding, price survey, invitation, contest, and auction.
Competitive bidding can be briefy dened as the
procurement method adopted or making purchases
or contracting services over BRL 650,000.00; and
contracting public works or engineering services
over BRL 1,500,000.00.
7/31/2019 Howto Government Contracts
7/17
12 Hw d governmental contracts i Bzi 13laW
NATIONAL BIDDING X INTERNATIONAL BIDDING
PRICE REGISTRATION SYSTEM
entic or artistic work; and auction is held to sell mov-
able property, which are no longer used by the procur-
ing public entity, or goods lawully oreited or seized;
and/or to sell real estate or purposes o land titling.
Lastly, in addition to the procurement methods de-
ned under the Brazilian Government Procurement
Act (Law 8666), Federal Law 10520/2002 establishes
the reverse auctionmethod, which is adopted when
the public entity is procuring common goods and
services, regardless o price. Common goods and ser-
vices are dened as those whose perormance and
quality standards are capable o being objectively
dened by the procurement notice, based on com-
monly available market specications.
Price survey is the method adopted or making pur-
chases or contracting services rom BRL 80,000.00 to
BRL 650,000.00; and or contracting public works or
engineering services rom BRL150,000.00 to BRL
1,500,000.00.
Invitation is a procurement method limited to short-
listed companies and applied to acquiring goods and
services rom BRL 8,000.00 to BRL 80,000.00; and
or contracting public works or engineering services
rom BRL 15.000,00 to BRL 150,000.00.
In addition to the procurement methods described
above, which are categorized according to the costs
involved, there are two other methods: contest and
auction. Contest is organized to select technical, sci-
An international bidding is required when, due to do-
mestic market limitations or conditions, the procuring
government entity needs to open and expressly an-
nounce its procuring eorts both inside and outside
Brazil so oreign tenderers are able to participate. In
addition, the announcement is especially prepared or
the participation o oreign tenderers.
On many occasions, international procurement e-
orts are the only means to attain certain goals o
Government and, on the other hand, they also poten-
tially avoid a considerable amount o direct hires
based on cases in which procurement procedures are
not mandatory or can be waived.
In short, there are many situations in which interna-
tional procurement eorts bring more advantages
than procurement carried out locally.
There is no ban on oreign companies taking part in
national bidding. However, in practice, this may some-
times prove to be impractical or unavorable to both
the procuring entity and to the oreign company, de-
pending on the scope o the bidding and the general
terms o agreement.
Nevertheless, it should be stressed that article 37, sub-
section XXI, o the Brazilian Constitution establishes
as a general rule that procurement procedures must
ensure equal treatment to all bidders and tenderers,
and the heading o article o Law 8 666/93, establishes
equal and air treatment as basic principles in govern-
ment procurement, and paragraph 1, subsection II, o
the same provision expressly prohibits Brazilian and
oreign companies be treated dierently.
The price registration system (xed pricing), is a tool
or optimizing government purchases o goods and
services, which was conceived to save government
money and promote eciency, in addition to over-
coming problems deriving rom variation in demand
and budget limitations.
In this system, according to statutory provisions, the
rst step is to carry out procurement procedures, u su-
ally through competitive biddings or reverse auctions
(see article 3 o Decree 3931/2001), during which
bidders agree to supply goods and services under to
certain terms and conditions which are recorded in
the minutes o the procedure, and are valid or up to
a maximum 12-month period, including any exten-
sions o term which may eventually be granted.
There is no obligation on the part o the procuring
entity to contract any supply o goods and services.
Moreover, there may be no actual demand or need
on the part o the procuring entity or any or all o
amount o goods and services priced under the scope
o the procurement procedures.
It is worth noting that xed pricing can also be car-
ried out at the same time by several procuring gov-
ernment entities. In this case, the names o these enti-
ties will appear in the procurement notice. By doing
7/31/2019 Howto Government Contracts
8/17
14 Hw d governmental contracts i Bzi 15laW
DIRECT PURCHASES AND HIRESSPECIAL ATTENTION TO IMPORTS
procedures that have already taken place and would
potentially meet the entities needs (without having to
carry out the same procedure again).
this, Government is able to obtain economy o scale.
And, lastly, there is also the possibility o other gov-
ernment entities benetting rom, or catching a ride
with or acceding (technical term) to, xed pricing
is the case, or example, when a government entity
has to acquire certain medical equipment which is
only available rom one single manuacturer or dis-
tributor. In this case, opening procurement procedures
would be pointless and could even delay the render-
ing o certain public interest services. The situations
article 25 provides or are non-exhaustive. The main
text o the article suces to justiy there being an in-
surmountable obstacle to the carrying out o bidding.
In Brazil, article 37, XXI o the Constitution provides
the general rule that government entities comply with
procuring methods in order to make purchases or
hire services, exception made to the situations ex-
pressly mentioned under statute. Law 8666/1993
(Government Procurement Act), came to regulate the
constitutional provision and, thereore, established
three situations in which government entities may
carry out direct purchases and hires without having
to adopt general procurement procedures.
The rst situation is when, according to article 17 o
the Government Procurement Act, the bidding is
waived. In this case, the waiver o bidding operates
automatically as a result o the statutory provision ac-
cording to which Government Authorities may di-
rectly dispose o government assets due to public
interest (justied accordingly) and based on previ-
ously carried out appraisal o market value. This takes
place in the case o government entities selling real
estate (or the purposes o land titling) or stock (which
can be traded pursuant to special legislation), among
other situations.
The second case is when the bidding is dispensable,
under article 24 o the Procurement Act, even when
there could have been a price competition due to a
competitive market. The law establishes certain situa-
tions where the bidding it is not mandatory. Examples
o this situation are: small purchases, works or services
(any purchase or hire that does not exceed 10% o the
aggregate amount o the invitation procurement
method) or purchases carried out in the event o emer-
gencies, public calamities, among other situations.
Finally, the third case o direct contracting is when the
bidding is not required pursuant to the terms o arti-
cle 25 o the Procurement Act. In this case, procure-
ment procedures cannot and shall not be carried out
because competitive bidding cannot be achieved. This
Decree 6759/2009 (Customs Regulation), in article 550,
establishes that imported goods are, according to spe-
cic statutory provisions, subject to licensing procedures
through SISCOMEX (the Integrated System o Foreign
Trade). In the event imported goods are subject to the
control o other government entities, the latter will also
express their approval through SISCOMEX.
Ordinance 25/2008, which regulates oreign trade
operations, provides under article 6, that government
entities required to act as approving authorities in
oreign trade situations must be SISCOMEX accred-
ited in order to give their approval in connection to
the products under their jurisdiction.
Currently, there are 16 (sixteen) approving entities
that are SISCOMEX accredited. In some cases, there
may be the need or the approval o more than one o
them or the same situation or a certain product to
be imported to Brazil.
7/31/2019 Howto Government Contracts
9/17
16 Hw d governmental contracts i Bzi 17laW
FOREIGN COMPANIES AND INTERNATIONALGOVERNMENT PROCUREMENT
QUALIFICATION
sortia can take part in the procurement procedures
depends on assessing the advantages in terms o costs
and increased competitiveness.
In the event o consortium among Brazilian and or-
eign companies, a B razilian company shall necessar-ily be the leader o the enterprise.
There are similar provisions under articles 16 and 17 o
Annex I to Decree 3555/2000 (Reverse Auction Regu-
lation), and articles 15 and 16 o Decree 5450/2005
(Electronic Reverse Auction Regulation), respectively,
which address the participation o oreign companies
and consortium.
Lastly, the broad denition o joint venture means
that oreign companies can also acquire, in whole or
in part, shares o capital or equity interest in Brazilian
companies participating in procurement procedures.
This is one way o investing in companies which al-
ready have the necessary conditions to and know-
how on taking part in Brazilian government procur-
ing. This kind o association among Brazilian and
oreign companies could also include opening a new
company or subsidiary in Brazil only or the purposes
o taking part in government procurement.
Foreign companies not based in Brazil are allowed to
take part in international government procurement
procedures alone and in their own name. However,
bidders must provide a proxy in the country to re-
ceive communications and summons, and eventually
answer court or administrative proceedings.
Foreign bidders can also take part in government pro-
curing together with Brazilian bidders through joint
ventures.
An example o the rst case is a oreign company taking
part in procurement procedures through an agent in the
country, as provided by article 710 o the Civil Code.
The kind o legal bond resulting rom this relationship is
weaker than one created by a consortium among bid-
ders, because in the latter situation, article 33, subsec-
tion V, o the Government Procurement Act provides
that there will be joint and several liability among the
parties to the joint venture both during the procuremen t
stage and the perormance o the agreement.
An example o the second case is article 33 o the
Government Procurement Act, which authorizes the
consortium. Thereore, the decision whether consor-
tia shall be admitted in the procuring procedures is
made by the procuring entity at the time o drating
the notice o procurement. Deciding whether con-
The aim o the qualication stage is to veriy whether
potential bidders ulll the necessary criteria to take
part in the procurement procedures.
Both Brazilian and oreign bidders must comply with
the requirements under articles 28 to 31 o the Pro-
curement Act.
Firstly, article 28 provides that, during the qualica-
tion process, potential bidders must provide the ol-
lowing supporting documents when applicable:
I Personal identifcation document;
II Trade registration, or one-person busi-
nesses;
III Duly registered articles o incorporation,
articles o association, partnership agreement,
articles o organization or bylaws, and, in the
case o business partnerships and corpora-
tions the documents supporting the election
o management;
IV Proo o registration o the articles o
partnership, in the case o civil partnerships,
with inormation on current management;
V Decree authorizing the oreign company
or oreign partnership to do business in Bra-
zil, an registration or operation license issued
by the competent authority, when the scope
o the operations o said company or partner-
ship so requires.
Article 29 provides that concerning their tax standing,
potential bidders must submit, when applicable:
I Proo o enrollment at the National Taxpay-
ers Registry o the Ministry o Finance (CPF/
CNPJ);
II Proo o enrollment at the state or munici-
pal taxpayers registry, i any, concerning the
bidders place o business/residence or main
ofces, bidders industry, and/or scope o bid-
ders articles o organization/association;
III Proo o good standing with the Federal,
State and Municipal Revenue Services at the
place o business/residence or main ofces o
the bidder, or other similar document required
by law;
IV Proo o good standing with the Brazilian
Social Security System (INSS) and with the
Workers Compensation Fund (FGTS).
7/31/2019 Howto Government Contracts
10/17
20 Hw d governmental contracts i Bzi 21laW
7/31/2019 Howto Government Contracts
11/17
20 Hw d governmental contracts i Bzi 21laW
PROPOSALS ADMINISTRATIVE SANCTIONS
INTERNATIONAL PROCUREMENT PROCEDURES WITH FOREIGN RULES
It must be stressed that, when the Government is the
importer (when the winning bidder is a oreign com-
pany), at the time o payment o the invoices the
products are exempt rom import taxes.
Another requirement o the notice o procurement is
that all bids and proposals must be submitted in Bra-
zilian Portuguese.
The Government Procurement Act also requires bid-
ders to provide a bid bond under article 31, subsection
III, in the modalities o article 56 o the same law.
Lastly, oreign bidders must be aware that their pro-
posals and estimates made in connection with inter-
national procurement processes carried out by Bra-
zilian government entities must speciy all the correct
price o their imported goods, including customs du-
ties, costs o loading, unloading, carrying, and insur-
ance to place o destination.
Article 42 o the Government Procurement Act sets out
the general rules concerning proposals made during
international procurement processes, and provides that
in international competitive bidding, the invitation to
bid must be adapted to directives o monetary policies
and oreign trade and meet the requirements o the
competent authorities. The latter phrase illustrates theimportance o Brazilian inspection entities in regard to
certain oreign documents which have no similarity.
The prices in international government procurement
can be expressed in BRL or in oreign currencies.
However, when oreign bidders are allowed to pro-
vide prices in oreign currencies, Brazilian bidders
can also do the same.
Payments to Brazilian bidders shall be made in BRL,
based on the exchange rate o the day immediately
beore the date o payment.
Payment guarantees given to Brazilian and Foreign
bidders shall be the same.
For the purposes o bid assessment, the amount o the
taxes levied on sales made by Brazilian bidders shall
also be added to the bids submitted by oreign bid-
ders. Thereore, procurement rules aim at bringing
parity among bids made Brazilians and oreigners, and
at respecting equal treatment provided or under arti-
cle 3 o the Government Procurement Act.
According to the Brazilian legal system, administrative
sanctions may be applied to potential bidders and not
only to contracted parties. Although article 87 o the
Government Procurement Act establishes that the
sanctions are applicable to bidders which were hired
or contracted, Brazilian case law understands that any
bidder may be punished administratively as a result oillegal conduct during the bidding process, such as,
the case o a bidder submitting ake supporting docu-
ments during the qualication stage.
Receiving a warning, suering a ne, or being given
a suspension rom taking part in government pro-
curement procedures and contracting with the gov-
ernment or a period o up to 2 (two) years, are sanc-
tions which can be imposed by the procuring
government entity. On the other hand, the declara-
tion o ineligibility to take part in bidding or contract-
ing with the government is a sanction which can only
be given by a Ministry o State, a State Secretary, or a
Municipal Secretary, depending on the case.
The choice o sanction depends on the seriousness o
the oense committed by the legal entity during the
procurement procedures or during the perormance
o the agreement. The sanctioned party shall have the
right to due process and to le an administrative ap-
peal against the sanction.
The Brazilian Government needs the infow o or-
eign resources to implement large projects in many
areas, such as inrastructure or sanitation and trans-
portation, environmental protection, public saety,
among others. These resources are usually grants or
loans made by international nancial institutions,
such as the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB),
which have their own rules or carrying out projects
and procurement procedures.
The understanding in Brazil is that these institutions pol-
icies are to be complied with, according to article 42,
paragraph 5 o the Government Procurement Act; how-
ever, Brazilian statutory provisions, constitutional prin-
ciples and a number o specic provisions o the Gov-
ernment Procurement Act such as the one providing
bids be assessed objectively and according to preestab-
lished criteria under the notice o procurement, and the
one granting the right to le administrative appeals.
22 Hw d governmental contracts i Bzi 23laW
7/31/2019 Howto Government Contracts
12/17
22 Hw d governmental contracts i Bzi 23laW
REVOCATION AND ANNULMENT OF THE BIDDING
OVERSIGHT ROLES
to support such revocation. The same article also es-
tablishes that government procurement processes can
be annulled due to lack o compliance with legal pro-
visions, by operation o law, or by third-party requests
based on a written and well-grounded opinion.
Article 49 o the Government Procurement Act sets
orth that the government entity with authority to give
approval to procurement procedures can only revoke
them or reasons o public interest resulting rom su-
pervening events, considered relevant and sucient
annulment o procurement procedures; denial o request
or bidder registration; unilateral termination o agree-
ments; administrative sanctions (warnings, suspensions,
or other penalties).
Additionally, at the Federal Executive level, corruption
practices and crimes against the treasury can be re-
ported to the Oce o the Comptroller General (CGU),
pursuant to article 17 o Law 10683/2003, which is an
oce that assists the President. There are similar o-
ces at State, Federal District, and Local levels.
Outside Oversight or Control byGovernment Accounting Courts
Article 71 o the C onstitution establishes that the Bra-
zilian Congress shall be responsible or outside over-
sight through the Federal Government Accounting
Court (TCU), which have authority to oversee and su-
pervise procurement procedures.
The decisions o Federal Government AccountingCourt are administrative in nature, since the TCU
does not belong to the Judiciary Branch. However,
the decisions are binding and can only be challenged
administratively within the TCU. Nevertheless, as a
last resort, a legal suit may be led at the Brazilian
Supreme Court (however, statistically, this has only
taken place in a very small number o cases).
Accounting Courts at State, Federal District and Lo-
cal levels have similar roles to the TCU.
Article 113 o the Government Procurement Act ex-
pressly provides that the control o expenses resulting
rom contracts and other instruments governed by the
Act shall be carried out by the Accounting Courts, in ad-
dition to the inside oversight mechanisms o control.
Any bidder, individual, or legal entity can le com-
plaints to the Accounting Courts and to inside over-
sight entities against violations in applying the Law.
Control by Anti-Trust andAnti-Cartel Authorities
In the event o practices harmul to a competitive
market are ound during international competitive
biddings, such as predatory pricing or cartelization
to x prices or exclusion o competitors, Law 8884/94
applies. This Law contains provisions to prevent and
deter crimes against the economy and the market.
Preliminary investigations or other proceedings brought
by the Secretariat or Economic Law (SDE) o the Min-
istry o Justice are not brought against the government
procuring entity, but against the companies taking part
in the bid and engaging in anti-competition practices.
The order in this case shall be given by the Brazilian
Council or Economic Deense (CADE).
In the Brazilian legal system, there are several protec-
tion mechanisms to secure the rights o entities, both
in administrative and court proceedings. But having
certain rights does not suce; one must know how to
protect them.
Inside Oversight or Controlby the Procuring Entity
Article 41, paragraph 1 o the Government Procure-
ment Act establishes that any citizen shall have the
right to challenge the invitation to bid up to ve (5)working days beore the date xed or the opening o
envelopes or the qualication. On the other hand,
paragraph 2 provides that bidders have a preemptive
period o two business days beore the opening o the
envelopes during the qualication stage o a com-
petitive bidding procedure to challenge the respec-
tive notice o procurement.
In the event o reverse auctions, it is worthy o note
that Decree 3555/2000, article 12 o Annex I, pro-
vides that up to two days beore the date o submis-
sion o bids, any individual can le requests or inor-
mation or challenge the de invitation to bid o a
reverse auction. In the case o electronic reverse auc-
tions, article 19 o Decree 5450/2005 establishes
that requests or inormation concerning the bidding
procedures should be sent to the auctioneer, up to
three days beore the date o the public session, elec-
tronically to the e-mail address inormed in the no-tice o procurement.
The right to le administrative appeals against the ac-
tions taken during the procurement process is enshrined
in article 109. The appeal deadline is ve (5) business
days ater bidder notication or ater the minutes are
published. Appeals can be led against bidder qualica-
tion or disqualication; bid assessment; revocation or
24 Hw d governmental contracts i Bzi 25laW
7/31/2019 Howto Government Contracts
13/17
GOVERNMENT CONTRACTS
sectors. As in the case o the entities with authority to
oversee competitive bidding procedures, the actions
o regulators are aimed at bidders and n ot at govern-
ment authorities.
Control by the Courts
According to article 5, subsection XXXV, o the Brazil-
ian Constitution, the law shall not exclude any injury
or threat to a right rom being submitted to the Judicial
Branch. However, one needs to choose the appropri-
ate strategy and know which legal suit to le depend-
ing on the situation.
In the eld o government procurement and govern-
ment contracts, the most common legal action eld
with the courts is the petition or writ o mandamus
enshrined in article 5, subsection LXIX, o the Consti-
tution and regulated by Law 12016/2009. This writ is
granted to protect the so-called undisputable rights
(rights upon which there is no shadow o doubt)
when the party in violation is a government entity or
legal entity acting in violation o the law or in abuse
o authority. This legal action is speedier than any
other, and the court has the authority to grant a pre-
liminary injunction suspending all administrative ac-
tions in the course o the procurement process.
Another alternative, or cases involving more complex
Control by Regulators
Article 175 o the Brazilian Constitution provides that
the Government is responsible or providing public
utility services, through procurement procedures to
award concessions or permissions. As a result o ar-
ticle 175, there are a number o regulators in Brazil.
Among them are:
I - The Amazon Development Agency;
II - The National Waters Agency (ANA);
III - The National Electric Power Agency (ANEEL);
IV - The National Petroleum Agency (ANP);
V - The National Agency o Supplemental
Health (ANS);
VI - The National Telecommunications Agency
(ANATEL);
VII - The National Land Transportation Agency
(ANTT); and
VIII - The National Health Surveillance Agency
(ANVISA).
Regulators may take action concerning international
procurement procedures carried out in their specic
matters o law, which depend o discovery procedures
or expert opinions, or instance, bidders may le regu-
lar-track lawsuits (ordinary proceedings) based on arti-
cle 282 o the Code o Civil Procedure. The complaint
may contain a request or provisional remedy to prevent
the nal court decision rom becoming ineective.
In addition to the two above-mentioned actions, there
are two others, which are also among the most com-
mon lawsuits involving government procuring, that
can be led by third-parties.
The rst one is the public civil action based on article
129, subsection III o the Constitution and on Law
7347/85. The goal o this class action is to protect so-
ciety and the public interest. Thereore, a private busi-
ness can report illegal practices taking place during or
in connection with government procurement proce-
dures in order or the Public Ministry le the class ac-
tion lawsuit.
Secondly, according to article 5, subsection LXXIII o the
Constitution and Law 4717/65, any citizen (only indi-
viduals) may le a peoples legal action against any vio-
lation or injury to government assets or entity held, in
whole or in part, by the Government. This lawsuit aims
at ghting violations and injury to the public interest.
Government contracts entered into by government
entities in Brazil are subject to Public Law. Thereore,
they are regulated by Law 8666/1993 [the Govern-
ment Procurement Act] and by p rinciples o Admin-
istrative Law, such as the ones listed under article 37
o the Brazilian Constitution.
Characteristics of
Government ContractsGovernment contracts have the ollowing character-
istics:
I The Government entity party to the agree-
ment holds a privileged position in regard to
the other contracting parties;
26 Hw d governmental contracts i Bzi 27laW
7/31/2019 Howto Government Contracts
14/17
VIII The Government entity may unilaterally
amend contractual provisions, as is the case
o reducing or increasing the number o units
o products purchased (maximum 25% varia-
tion), or amount o services (maximum 25%
variation), or engineering works contracted
(up to 50%);
IX The parties may agree to amend the agree-
ment when, or instance, they intend to change
the payment schedule;
X The Government entity may terminate the
agreement due to public interest, non-peror-
mance o contractual obligation on the part o
the other party, unauthorized assignment o
agreement, among others;
XI Contractors may terminate the agree-
ment in the event o delay in payment o in-
voices by government entities o more than
90 (ninety) days.
Term of Agreement and Extensionof Term of Agreement
Article 57 o the Government Procurement Act estab-
lishes that the term o agreements entered into with
the government shall be limited to the period o the
budget allocated (this has been interpreted as a peri-
II The public goals prevail, although the par-
ties contracting with the government are enti-
tled to receive just payment;
III To be deemed valid, contracts must com-
ply with the orm prescribed in law;
IV Procurement processes must be compliedwith, and procurement methods must be im-
plemented, except when the law provides oth-
erwise;
V Government contracts are standard orm
agreements, thereore the terms and condi-
tions are written by the Government entity,
thereore, terms and conditions can only be
challenged by the parties to the agreement or
by third-parties in the courts (judicial or ad-
ministrative);
VI The agreement is intuitu personae, that is,
it is signed based on the technical qualifca-
tions o the contracting party proved during
the procurement process;
VII Government contracts contain special
provisions, which are not common in agree-
ments in general, such as the duty o oversight,
requirements o guarantees, and the possibility
o administrative sanctions being applied;
od o 12 consecutive months), exception made to:
I Project contemplated in the Pluriannual
Plan, which may have their term extended pur-
suant to the interest o the Government and as
long as this possibility has been written in the
notice o procurement;
II Services provided on a continuous basis,
which may have their period o services re-
newed or equal and consecutive period aimed
at obtaining more avorable prices and condi-
tions, but limited to a 60-month period;
III Equipment lease and using sotware, cases
in which the term o agreement may be re-
newed to a maximum 48-month period ater
the date o execution o the agreement.
Essential Terms and
Conditions of ContractArticle 55 o the Government Procurement Act pro-
vide that the ollowing are considered mandatory
contractual provisions in every agreement entered
into with a Government entity:
I Scope o the agreement and description o
special eature;
II Perormance schedule or supply schedule;
III Price and conditions o payment, pricing
criteria; deadlines, and requency o price ad-
justments, criteria or monetary adjustments
between date o perormance and date o
payment;
IV Schedule containing the starting dates o
stages o perormance, deadlines, delivery
dates, inspection period, date o fnal delivery,
as applicable;
V Origin o government resources which
will meet the price o the agreement, with in-
ormation on the government program and
economic category;
VI Guarantee o perormance, when required;
VII Rights and duties o the parties, sanctions
applied, and the amount o the penalties;
VIII Cause o termination;
IX Acknowledgement o the rights o the
Government entity, in case o termination
caused by non-perormance o the agreement
by contractor;
X Terms and conditions o importing goods;
28 Hw d governmental contracts i Bzi 29laW
7/31/2019 Howto Government Contracts
15/17
In the case o engineering works and large-scale sup-
plies involving highly complex technical services
and signicant nancial risks, established in expert
opinions approved by the competent authority, the
party may be required to provide guarantee o up to
10% o the total price o the agreement.
Pursuant to article 56 o the Government Procurement
law, at the discretion o the competent authority, a
guarantee may be required in the notice o procure-
ment and the bidder may oer one o the ollowing
types o guaranty:
I Certifcate o money deposit or govern-
ment titles;
II Bid bonds; and
III Bank guaranty.
Right to Economic and Financial
Balance of the ContractArticle 37, XXI o the Constitution establishes, among
other things, that in the course o government con-
tracts the terms and conditions contained in the bid
submitted during the procurement procedures shall
be preserved.
In addition, article 57, paragraph 1 o the Govern-
the date and the exchange rate applicable, i
appropriate;
XI Binding eect o the notice o procure-
ment or to the document waiving or dismiss-
ing said notice to the proposal o the winning
bidder;
XII Legislation applied to perormance o
the agreement and especially to the cases
when the law is silent;
XIII The duty o the party contracting with
Government to preserve, maintain and keep,
throughout the entire perormance o the
agreement, its obligations, all the conditions
o qualifcation and eligibility required during
the procurement procedures.
Guarantees
When engaging in government procurement proce-
dures, according to article 31, subsection III o the
Procurement Act, the law requires a standard guaran-
tee totaling 1% o the estimated price o the scope o
the procurement.
However, when actually entering into an agreement
with the Government, the required guarantee may
escalate to 5% o the total agreement price.
ment Procurement Act provides that the Government
has the right to economic and nancial equilibrium
in government contracts in the event o one o the
ollowing situations which must be documented in
the proceedings:
I Changes to the original project or to proj-
ect specifcations by the Government entity;
II Supervening or unoreseeable events be-
yond the parties reasonable control, which
signifcantly alters the conditions o peror-
mance o the agreement;
III Suspension o the agreement or changes
in the working schedule resulting rom the re-
quest o the Government Entity or due to
public interest;
IV Increase in the amounts purchased, re-
specting the maximum limits provided or in
statute;
V Impossibility o perorming the agreement
due to an action or situation caused by a third-
party, but acknowledged by the Government
entity pursuant to a document produced at
the time o said action or situation;
VI Omission or delay caused by the Govern-
ment, including in regard to payment sched-
ule, which may result in interruption o or de-
lay in perormance, notwithstanding any legal
sanctions that may apply to the persons re-
sponsible or said interruption or delay.
30 Hw d governmental contracts i Bzi 31laW
7/31/2019 Howto Government Contracts
16/17
ABOUT OUR SPONSOR
and cargo transportation services, travel services, event
organization, capacity building, and others.
In all our cases, our lawyers address all the necessary
legal guidance concerning qualiying or government
procurement procedures, submitting proposals, pre-
venting risk, in addition to providing the necessary
legal representation or the clients and their businesspartners, on administrative, civil and criminal issues.
In summary, our rm is open to oreign companies
needing legal guidance on how to operate wisely
and saely in the government procurement market
in Brazil.
Bi
SAUS Quadra 4, Lotes 9 e 10Ed. Victoria Oce Tower, Salas 803/804 Asa SulCEP 70070-938Braslia - DF - Brazil
Telephone: +55 61 3223-0015
Email: @iuh.
Website: www.iuh.
Lima & Curvello Rocha, LLP is a law rm headquar-
tered in Brasilia, the capital city o Brazil, and spe-
cialized in providing legal advice on national and
international bidding and government contracts in
Brazil, in addition to carrying out strategic planning
and representing Brazilian and oreign companies.
Their lawyers have extensive experience in Public
Law, in representing clients beore Brazilian Superior
Courts and Government Accounting Courts.
In the eld o Administrative Law and in connection
to government procurement procedures and govern-
ment contracts, the legal team draws upon deep ex-
perience to guide clients about all the issues on con-
sortium and other joint venture among Brazilian and
oreign companies.
Lima & Curvello Rocha provide legal services across
several areas o business, among which: government
procurement procedures or the supply o hospital
products and equipment, medication, catering, servic-es, and engineering works (including inrastructure or
logistics at ports and airports and other constructions),
communications, media, clipping, advertising, graphic
printing, inormation technology (hardware, sotware,
storage, and networks), call center, telecommunica-
tions, sale o real state, security equipment, uniorms,
and weapons, outsourcing services, car rental, people
7/31/2019 Howto Government Contracts
17/17
top related