Electric Space Heating Innovations - MemberClicks...Integrating Carbon Footprint and Demand Response with Energy Efficiency October 21-23, 2009 3rd Annual Colorado Utility Efficiency

Integrating Carbon Footprint andDemand Response with Energy Efficiency

October 21-23, 2009

3rd Annual Colorado Utility Efficiency Exchange

Focus on Residential Energy Efficiency

Electric Space Heating Innovations

Jean-Marie Falquetjmf@convectair.com

Focus on Residential Energy Efficiency

Electric Space Heating Innovations

Marie Falquetjmf@convectair.com

(or why don't I just stick to extreme skiing ?)

(or why don't I just stick to extreme skiing ?)

Carbon footprint, demand response, energy efficiencyvs

Electric resistance heating ??

• What should we know ?

• What should we tell ?

• What should we do ?

• Why should we even care ?

3rd Colorado Util3

Carbon footprint, demand response, energy efficiencyvs

Electric resistance heating ??

Why should we even care ?

Utility Efficiency Exchange : Focus on Residential Energy EfficiencyAspen Meadows Resort, Aspen, CO, October 22, 2009

Carbon footprint, demand response, energy efficiencyvs

Electric resistance heating ??

1) Affordable install, no maintenance, reliable

2) Well-suited to specific needs

3) Cleaner at point of use

4) "Part of the mix" (generation vs use)

3rd Colorado Util4

Carbon footprint, demand response, energy efficiencyvs

Electric resistance heating ??

1) Affordable install, no maintenance, reliable

suited to specific needs

4) "Part of the mix" (generation vs use)

Utility Efficiency Exchange : Focus on Residential Energy EfficiencyAspen Meadows Resort, Aspen, CO, October 22, 2009

Electric resistance heating ??

It is out there...

− Legacy systems (older existing buildings)

− Commercial buildings, condos, low income housing− Commercial buildings, condos, low income housing

− Supplementary heat, additions

3rd Colorado Util5

... Generate winter Kwh revenues

Electric resistance heating ??

Legacy systems (older existing buildings)

Commercial buildings, condos, low income housingCommercial buildings, condos, low income housing

Supplementary heat, additions

Utility Efficiency Exchange : Focus on Residential Energy EfficiencyAspen Meadows Resort, Aspen, CO, October 22, 2009

revenues,

and peaking loads

Electric resistance heating ??

It keeps coming...

− "Amish" heaters

− Paul Harvey / Bob Vila

− Co-op state ads...

3rd Colorado Util6

Electric resistance heating ??

Utility Efficiency Exchange : Focus on Residential Energy EfficiencyAspen Meadows Resort, Aspen, CO, October 22, 2009

Residential fuel price trends2000 –

(2000 = 100)The image cannot be displayed. Your computer may not have enough memory to open the image, or the image may have been corrupted. Restart your computer, and then open the file again. If the red x still appears, you may have to delete the image and then insert it again.

Source : EIA short term energy outlook, Oct.6, 2009for West / Mountain regions

3rd Colorado Util7

Residential fuel price trends– 2010

(2000 = 100)

10-YEAR CHANGE

Oil : +96%

Propane : +63%Nat. Gas : +54%

Electricity : +35%

: EIA short term energy outlook, Oct.6, 2009for West / Mountain regions

Utility Efficiency Exchange : Focus on Residential Energy EfficiencyAspen Meadows Resort, Aspen, CO, October 22, 2009

Electricity : +35%

Worthwhile application # 1

� Supplementary comfort / spot heat

− Easy install, low cost, instant comfort, individual control

− Efficient ("why heat the whole house when only one room feels cold")

− Safer and more efficient than a "kick

− No "cured copper" or other magic involved... just solid, up to date, proven technologyup to date, proven technology

vs.

3rd Colorado Util8

Worthwhile application # 1

Supplementary comfort / spot heat

Easy install, low cost, instant comfort, individual control

Efficient ("why heat the whole house when only one

Safer and more efficient than a "kick-over heater"

No "cured copper" or other magic involved... just solid, up to date, proven technologyup to date, proven technology

vs.

Utility Efficiency Exchange : Focus on Residential Energy EfficiencyAspen Meadows Resort, Aspen, CO, October 22, 2009

Worthwhile application # 2� Replacement of older existing electric

heating equipment

Example : Old baseboards, unsafe "Register" heaters, noisy fan heaters, failing ceiling cable installations, low rental housing rehabs...

− Maintains revenue base for utility.− Maintains revenue base for utility.

− Reduce peak load (less installedwatts, better control).

− Little or no new wiring involved, no ducts or plumbing.

− Safety, comfort, lower bills.

3rd Colorado Util9

Worthwhile application # 2Replacement of older existing electric

Example : Old baseboards, unsafe "Register" heaters, noisy fan heaters, failing ceiling cable installations, low

Maintains revenue base for utility.Maintains revenue base for utility.

Reduce peak load (less installed

Little or no new wiring involved, no

Utility Efficiency Exchange : Focus on Residential Energy EfficiencyAspen Meadows Resort, Aspen, CO, October 22, 2009

Worthwhile application # 3

� Complete home heating

Examples : buildings in remote location (on grid) ; intermittent use ; perimeter heating as a supplement to central heat/cool system.

− Low installation cost.− Low installation cost.

− Highly reliable.

− Little or no maintenance.

− Fast heat.

− Easy programming, simple integration into home automation system, remote activation, etc.

3rd Colorado Util10

Worthwhile application # 3

Complete home heating

Examples : buildings in remote location (on grid) ; intermittent use ; perimeter heating as a supplement to

Easy programming, simple integration into home automation system, remote activation, etc.

Utility Efficiency Exchange : Focus on Residential Energy EfficiencyAspen Meadows Resort, Aspen, CO, October 22, 2009

How to choose a heater # 1

� Baseboards

− Least expensive to purchase (<$100), moderate installation cost.

− Uneven heat and fluctuating temperature.− Uneven heat and fluctuating temperature.

− Energy hog (increases wall & ceiling heat loss).

− Wall space, streaking, noise, etc.

Applications : utility basements, crawl spaces, frost protection with low thermostat setting.

3rd Colorado Util11

How to choose a heater # 1

Least expensive to purchase (<$100), moderate

Uneven heat and fluctuating temperature.Uneven heat and fluctuating temperature.

Energy hog (increases wall & ceiling heat loss).

Wall space, streaking, noise, etc.

utility basements, crawl spaces, frost protection with low thermostat setting.

Utility Efficiency Exchange : Focus on Residential Energy EfficiencyAspen Meadows Resort, Aspen, CO, October 22, 2009

How to choose a heater # 2

� Cove heaters

− Medium to high equipment cost ($100installation costs.

− Located out of the way, discreet.

− Some radiant comfort, depending on type of control used, room layout and location.used, room layout and location.

− Uncontrolled convection heat (>50%) along ceiling.

− Increases cold air convection current along windows and heat loss along the ceiling.

Applications : kitchens with no wall space.

3rd Colorado Util12

How to choose a heater # 2

Medium to high equipment cost ($100-200), higher

Located out of the way, discreet.

Some radiant comfort, depending on type of control used, room layout and location.used, room layout and location.

Uncontrolled convection heat (>50%) along ceiling.

Increases cold air convection current along windows and heat loss along the ceiling.

kitchens with no wall space.

Utility Efficiency Exchange : Focus on Residential Energy EfficiencyAspen Meadows Resort, Aspen, CO, October 22, 2009

How to choose a heater # 3

� Convectair convection heater.

− Medium to high equipment cost ($200 and up) but lowest installation cost.

− Flexible installation (many possible locations).

− Even heat distribution, extremely stable temperature control, better comfort, especially in cold floor areas.cold floor areas.

− Designed to minimize room heat loss (proven to lower energy costs in many applications).

− Energy Star programmable feature.

Applications : anywhere except high dust areas.

3rd Colorado Util13

How to choose a heater # 3

Convectair convection heater.

Medium to high equipment cost ($200 and up) but

Flexible installation (many possible locations).

Even heat distribution, extremely stable temperature control, better comfort, especially in

Designed to minimize room heat loss (proven to lower energy costs in many applications).

Energy Star programmable feature.

anywhere except high dust areas.

Utility Efficiency Exchange : Focus on Residential Energy EfficiencyAspen Meadows Resort, Aspen, CO, October 22, 2009

How to choose a heater # 4

� Convectair radiant + convection heater.

− High equipment cost ($600 and up model and required features), low to medium installation cost.

− Same advantages as Convectair convection systems plus :systems plus :

� Instant radiant comfort at a lower temperature setting.

� Smart heating control (radiant vs convection heating optimization).

� Many design and installation choices

Applications : rooms with high ceilings and/or large windows ; designer choice.

3rd Colorado Util14

How to choose a heater # 4

Convectair radiant + convection heater.

High equipment cost ($600 and up - depending on model and required features), low to medium

Same advantages as Convectair convection

Instant radiant comfort at a lower temperature setting.

Smart heating control (radiant vs convection heating

Many design and installation choices

rooms with high ceilings and/or large windows ; designer choice.

Utility Efficiency Exchange : Focus on Residential Energy EfficiencyAspen Meadows Resort, Aspen, CO, October 22, 2009

Performance standard :

3rd Colorado Util15

Source : h

Performance standard : CSA 828-2006

Utility Efficiency Exchange : Focus on Residential Energy EfficiencyAspen Meadows Resort, Aspen, CO, October 22, 2009

http://www.hydroquebec.com/residential/thermostats/index.html

Wright Hennepin field testWright Hennepin field test

Wright-Hennepin Cooperative Electric AssociationAnnandale, MN

Winter Kwh used Heating Degree Day (HDD)

2004-2005 17340 6015

2005-2006 16300 5711

2006-2007 16851 5986

2007-2008 19024 73332007-2008 19024 7333

2008-2009 (Convectair) 15088 6705Average Kwh/HDD 2004 to 2008

Average Kwh per HDD2008 – 2009 Winter

Difference

2nd Colorado Util17

Hennepin Cooperative Electric AssociationAnnandale, MN Test House

Heating Degree Day (HDD)

Average KwhPer Heating Degree Day

6015 2.88

5711 2.85

5986 2.82

7333 2.597333 2.59

6705 2.252.79

2.25

-19%

Utility Efficiency Exchange : Focus on Residential Energy EfficiencyAspen Meadows Resort, Aspen, CO, October 16, 2008

A "smart" load management tool

• Cascading, cyclical, load shedding.

• ETS, Convectair heaters, water heater.water heater.

• Utility triggered, individually managed.

2nd Colorado Util18

A "smart" load management tool

Utility Efficiency Exchange : Focus on Residential Energy EfficiencyAspen Meadows Resort, Aspen, CO, October 16, 2008

Carbon footprint, demand response, energy efficiencyvs

Electric resistance heating ??

1) Be aware

2) Be informed

3) Offer affordable, appropriate solutions

4) Manage it (good revenues, good margins)

3rd Colorado Util19

Carbon footprint, demand response, energy efficiencyvs

Electric resistance heating ??

3) Offer affordable, appropriate solutions

4) Manage it (good revenues, good margins)

Utility Efficiency Exchange : Focus on Residential Energy EfficiencyAspen Meadows Resort, Aspen, CO, October 22, 2009

Thank you

Jean-Marie Falquetjmf@convectair.cajmf@convectair.ca

Lon Garrisonlon.garrison@convectair.com

719-338

www.convectair.com

2nd Colorado Util20

Thank you

Marie Falquetjmf@convectair.cajmf@convectair.ca

Lon Garrisonlon.garrison@convectair.com

338-0242

www.convectair.com

Utility Efficiency Exchange : Focus on Residential Energy EfficiencyAspen Meadows Resort, Aspen, CO, October 16, 2008