Cosco Busan 11 years on: Restoration - CA State Lands ...Pollution Case Settlement •response and assessment costs •penalties ... Restoration Planning (CCSF & EBRPD) • Public

Cosco Busan 11 years on:

Restoration

Steve HamptonAssistant Deputy Administrator

Prevention FirstSeptember 25, 2018

Potential Components of a

Pollution Case Settlement

• response and assessment costs

• penalties

• natural resource damages

• other claims • public entities (lost tax revenue, lost parking fees, extra

staff time, etc.)

• private claims (lost income, injury to property, etc.)

$32.3 million

What are Natural Resource Damages?

• Compensation for natural resource injuries

• Compensation for loss of use and enjoyment

• Damages are based upon the amount of

restoration needed to make the environment

and the public whole (OPA, Lempert-Keene)

Trustees and Coordination

• Trustees – DOI (USFWS, NPS), NOAA, CDFG, CSLC

• Local Agencies – Assessment Coordination &

Restoration Planning (CCSF & EBRPD)

• Public – Restoration Planning

The Process

1) Oil Spill

2) Data Collection

3) Public Information Meeting

4) Injury and Damage Quantification

5) Draft Restoration Plan

6) Public Comment Period

7) Final Restoration Plan

8) Implement Restoration Projects WE ARE HERE

Methods

• Multi-disciplinary, multi-agency team

• Collecting data and planning NRDA tasks since Nov 7

• Assessed injuries by resource category:

birds, mammals, fish, shoreline habitats, eelgrass, rec use

Value of

Habitat

Initial

Level

Time

Project

Benefits

Compensatory

RestorationSpill

(Baseline)

Resource Equivalency Analysis

Injury

Berkeley Pier

RFP for scoter project

Corvid Management

Farallon Nest Site

Improvements

Large Diving Birds(scoters, large diving ducks, loons)

Large Grebes

Salt Pond Divers(small diving ducks, small grebes)

Alcids and Procellarids(murres, auklets, fulmar)

Cormorants, Gulls, Pelicans

Marbled Murrelets

Snowy Plovers

Shorebirds

Marsh and Land Birds(coots, geese, herons, others)

South Bay Salt Ponds

Tule Lake Grebe Habitat

Eelgrass Restoration

Native Oyster & Rockweed Restoration

Various Local Projects

To Be Determined

Fish

Eelgrass

Sandy Beaches

Salt Marsh and Flats

Rocky Intertidal

Human Recreational Uses

Aramburu Island

Muir Beach Dunes

Albany Beach

Injury Summary

Birds

Collected Live and Dead: 2,940

Total Estimated Mortality: 6,849

Primary Species Impacted

Surf Scoter

Western Grebe

Eared Grebe

Common Murre

Marbled Murrelet

Shoreline Habitats (acres impacted)

Rocky Intertidal: 384

Sandy Beach: 648

Saltmarsh and Mudflats: 1,395

Eelgrass Beds: 940

Note: Most acres were lightly or very lightly oiled.

Fish

Herring Larvae inside spill zone:

Herring Larvae outside spill zone:

Estimated 14-29% of herring spawn lost in 2007-8.

No impacts detected: salmon, tidewater goby, Dungeness crab.

Recreational Use

Lost User-Days:

• fishing: 69,500

• boating: 26,600

• general shoreline use: 983,800

Value of a Lost User-Day:

• varied across time and activity, but averaged $17.41

Total lost value: $18.8 million

Settlement

Birds

Habitat

Fish/Eelgrass

Recreational Use

administration

$5M

$4M

$2.5M

$18.8M

$2M

$32.3M

Restoration Summary

Derelict Net Removal,

Salish Sea

Eden Landing Salt Pond MgmtMarbled Murrelet Restoration,

Humboldt Redwoods State Park

Egg Aversion Project, Santa Cruz Mtns

Bird Projects

Berkeley Pier Bird Platforms

Habitat Projects

Bird and Habitat Projects

Eelgrass Restoration,

Marin County and East Bay

Muir Beach Dune Restoration

Aramburu Island Restoration

Recreation Projects

East Bay, $4,806,000

Marin County, $3,231,000

SF County, $8,398,000

San Mateo County,

$2,106,000

Other Areas, $260,000

Oakland Estuary cleanup

Miller Knox Regional Park Restoration

South Rodeo Beach Access

Recreation Projects

BEFORE AFTER

Recreation Projects

Junior Lifeguard Program, Stinson Beach

Ocean Beach Seawall Repairs, SF

Youth Fishing Program, Hayward Shoreline

Small Boat Docks,

Lake Merritt, Oakland

http://www.dfg.ca.gov/ospr/Science/cosco_busan_spill.aspx