BETTER DIRECTBETTER DIRECT AND CROSS EXAMINATIONS · 2018. 5. 29. · BETTER DIRECTBETTER DIRECT AND CROSS EXAMINATIONS Andrea Roberts Pierson Indianapolis Bar Association M 28 2010May

BETTER DIRECTBETTER DIRECT ANDANDBETTER DIRECT BETTER DIRECT AND AND CROSSCROSS EXAMINATIONSEXAMINATIONSCROSS CROSS EXAMINATIONSEXAMINATIONS

Andrea Roberts PiersonIndianapolis Bar AssociationM 28 2010May 28, 2010

4640268

PRESENTATION OVERVIEWPRESENTATION OVERVIEW

• How and whyHow and why

• Determining the scope of direct/cross

• Developing themes

• Eliciting helpful admissions g p

• Techniques for handling the difficult witness

• Witness presentation and impact on jury

2

3

WHAT ARE MY OBJECTIVES?WHAT ARE MY OBJECTIVES?

4

TECHNIQUES FORTECHNIQUES FORQQBETTER DIRECT BETTER DIRECT EXAMINATIONEXAMINATION

DIRECT EXAMINATIONDIRECT EXAMINATION

• Be PreparedBe Prepared– Know your witness and his/her secrets– Review publications and prior depositionsReview publications and prior depositions– Investigate the witness – even fact witnesses– Seek assistance from your expertsSeek assistance from your experts– Analyze a witness’s demeanor and style well in

advance– Develop outline– Work from a complete medical chronology

6

p gy

DIRECT EXAMINATIONDIRECT EXAMINATION

• Have A Clear PurposeHave A Clear Purpose

• Be BriefBe Brief

• Identify The Tone• Identify The Tone

8

DIRECT EXAMINATION

DIRECT EXAMINATIONDIRECT EXAMINATION

• With experts and company witnesses askWith experts and company witnesses, ask about qualifications and experience that mattermatter

• Offer CV after testimony on qualifications, if i d ff iif you intend to offer it

10

DIRECT EXAMINATION

• Develop Themes

DIRECT EXAMINATION

Develop Themes

• Use Looping / Speak in ThreesUse oop g / Spea ees

• Listen for Gems

11

DIRECT EXAMINATION

DIRECT EXAMINATION

• Anticipate• Anticipate the warts/bulletproofbulletproof your client

13

DIRECT EXAMINATION

• Get answers in layman’s terms and ask

DIRECT EXAMINATION

Get answers in layman s terms and ask for clarification

• Ask questions regarding medical records• Ask questions regarding medical records, x-rays, and related documentsE d hi h t• End on a high note

14

TECHNIQUES FORTECHNIQUES FORC QU S OC QU S OBETTER CROSS BETTER CROSS EXAMINATIONEXAMINATION

15

CROSS EXAMINATION

• Three Golden Rules:

CROSS EXAMINATION

Three Golden Rules: Close ended questions One fact per question One fact per question Only ask questions to which you know the

answeranswer

16

CROSS EXAMINATION

CROSS EXAMINATIONCROSS EXAMINATION

• Reinforce three mainthree main facts/points –not all pointsnot all points are knock outs

18

CROSS EXAMINATION

• Highlight missing credentials/qualifications

CROSS EXAMINATION

Highlight missing credentials/qualifications

• Challenge bias or prejudices Ties to the profession, industry, party,

etc. $$$$$$$$$$

B h t d d Beware: what goes around, comes around

19

CROSS EXAMINATION

• Know the rules of impeachment – Rule

CROSS EXAMINATION

p803(18)

Three “C’s” – confirm, commit, contradict• Little Mistakes, Dent the Armor – but

don’t get lost in the forest Identify them and move on Identify them and move on

“Begin With The End In Mind”

20

LESSONS LEARNED FROM LESSONS LEARNED FROM JURY RESEARCHJURY RESEARCH

21

LESSONS LEARNED FROM JURY RESEARCH

22

LESSONS LEARNED FROM JURY RESEARCH

23

LESSONS LEARNED FROM JURY RESEARCH

24

LESSONS LEARNED FROM JURY RESEARCH

25

THE ENDTHE END

26