2016-04-25 - E2 Task 2 4 D2 10 - Recommended on-board ... · Task 2.3 S on-board Exchange The repor and infras Service P Based on The meth 2 Intro Integration element in report is
Post on 12-Oct-2020
0 Views
Preview:
Transcript
D2.1netw Project no.Project acr sea Funding sc Start date End date oDuration: Due date oActual subRevised suOrganisatio
10 Rework
. ronym:
cheme:
of project: of project:
of deliverabbmission datubmission don in charg
ecomArch
le: te:
date: e of deliver
mmenhitec
6363EfficEFF
Inno
1 Ma30 A36 m
25 A
able: Part
ndedcture
329 cienSea2 ICIENSEA2
ovation Actio
ay 2015 April 2018 months
April 2016
-ner 21, DAN
“This project the Europeanresearch andunder grant a
on-b
2 – efficient
on (IA)
NELEC
has received fun Union’s Horizod innovation progagreement No 6
boar
, safe and s
unding from on 2020 gramme
636329”.
rd
sustainable traffic at
DOCUM
Authors Name Henrik BeErik Styhr Anders RyTimo Kosti
Peter Ande
DocumeVersion 0.1 0.2 0.7 0.9 0.91 1.0
RevieweName Andy WinbHannu PeiKrzysztof BJens Kristi
MENT S
and cont
ech HelnæsPetersen
ydlinger iainen
ersen
nt HistoryDate 2015-2015-2015-2016-2016-2016-
rs
bow ponen
Bronk an Jensen
STATUS
ributors
s (editor)
y
09-09 10-01 12-01 03-18 04-20 04-25
S
InitialsHBH HBH HBH HBH HBH HBH
Page 2 of
OrganisDanelecWärtsiläTransasFuruno
Cobham
DescripFirst DrSecondUpdateFinal DFinal DFinal R
OrganisCIRM FurunoNIT DMA
“This pthe Euresearunder
f 91
sation c Marine ä s
m
ption raft d Draft ed with 10%Draft for reviDraft for reviReport
sation
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
% review chaew ew meeting
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
anges
g
om
Contents
1 Su
2 Int
3 De
4 Me
5 Sc5.1 Intr5.2 Ba
5.2.1 5.2.2 5.2.3
5.3 The5.4 Arc
6 Vie6.1 Co6.2 Fun6.3 Info6.4 Co6.5 De6.6 De6.7 Op
7 Vie7.1 Inte
7.1.1 7.1.2 7.1.3
7.2 Cy7.3 Lin7.4 Pri7.5 Ca7.6 Ba
7.6.1 7.6.2 7.6.3
7.7 Da7.8 Vie
8 Sta
9 Pe
s
mmary ....
roduction
efinitions a
ethodology
ope and Croduction .ckground .The HeritSOLAS, CType App
e MC and chitectural
ewpoints .ontext Viewnctional Viormational
oncurrency evelopmenteployment Vperational V
ews ..........eraction TyPoint to PMulticast Broadcas
ber Securink Requiremority .........
andidate Casic CommGeneric WData ServBroadcas
ata Formatsewpoints fo
akeholder
rspectives
................
n ...............
and Acron
y ..............
Context ....................................age ..........Carriage Rproved ‘clusMCC in CoElements
................wpoint .......
ewpoint ... ViewpointViewpoint
t ViewpoinViewpoint Viewpoint .
................ype ..........
Point (P2P)................
st ..............ity ............ments ......................arriers ......unication S
Web Servicvice ..........st Messages ..............or the differ
r Identifica
s ..............
................
................
nyms ........
................
................
................
................
................Requiremensters’ .......ontext ......(AE) ........
................
................
................t ...............t ...............t ..............................................
................
................) ...............................................................................................................Services ...ce.............................
e Service ..................rent servic
ation ........
................
Page 3 of
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................nts and IM................................................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................ces ............
................
................
“This pthe Euresearunder
f 91
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................O Type Ap................................................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................pproval .....................................................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
om
.............. 5
.............. 5
.............. 6
.............. 7
.............. 9
.............. 9
.............. 9
.............. 9
............ 12
............ 14
............ 16
............ 17
............ 19
............ 19
............ 19
............ 19
............ 19
............ 19
............ 20
............ 20
............ 21
............ 25
............ 25
............ 25
............ 25
............ 25
............ 27
............ 27
............ 29
............ 30
............ 32
............ 32
............ 33
............ 33
............ 34
............ 34
............ 35
5
5
6
7
9 9 9 9
4 6 7
9 9 9 9 9 9 0 0
5 5 5 5 5 7 7 9 0
3 3 4
4
5
9.1 Low9.2 Re9.3 Cy
9.3.1 9.3.2 9.3.3 9.3.4 9.3.5 9.3.6
10 Sta10.1 WP10.2 Re
10.2.1 10.2.2 10.2.3 10.2.4 10.2.5
10.3 De10.3.1 10.3.2
11 Arc11.1 Sim11.2 Ne11.3 Inte11.4 Inte11.5 Qu
12 Arc
13 Ide
14 Co
Bibliogra
15 Ap
16 Ap
w impact Inequirementber SecuriUser NeeUsing theCyber SeMitigationDetect anCyber Se
akeholderP3 User Neequirement
Traffic SControlShip OpAdminisAccomm
educed, AsConcurOpenin
chitecturamplest Impetwork Topoegrated Coegrated Ga
uality of Se
chitectura
entification
onclusion
aphy .........
ppendix A
ppendix B
ntegration t of an “opeity Conside
eds describe NIST Fracurity Risk
n of Cyber nd Respondcurity Con
r Concernseed analysts deducedSegmentat of Qualityperation nestrative Nemodation (sumed and
rrency .......g discussio
al Candidaplementatioology .......ommunicatateways ...rvice ........
al Candida
n of poten
................
................
– Consoli
– Final Re
with existien” and haerations ....bed by E2, mework fok IdentificatSecurity Rd to Cyberclusion ....
s (Requiresis ............d from Anation ..........
y of Serviceetworks ....etworks .....(Infotainmed/or obviou................on on how
ates ..........on .............................tion System................................
ate Test Re
ntial Areas
................
................
idated Use
eview Rep
Page 4 of
ng infrastrarmonized ................WP3 .......
or Improvintion ..........
Risks usingr Security B................
ements) ...................lysis of typ................
e ...............................................
ent, Passeus Require................
w AIS functi
................
................
................m .............................................
esults .....
s for stand
................
................
er Needs .
port ..........
“This pthe Euresearunder
f 91
ucture andarchitectur................................g Critical I................ 460-GateBreaches .................
................
................pical netwo................................................................nger and C
ements .....................ionality is i
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
dardizatio
................
................
................
................
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
d architecture .............................................nfrastructu................ways .......................................
................
................ork topolog................................................................
Crew netwo................................mplemente
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
n .............
................
................
................
................
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
ure ...........................................................
ure Cybers................................................................
................
................gy .............................................................................ork) ..........................................ed ............
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
................
om
............ 35
............ 35
............ 36
............ 38security . 38............ 39............ 40............ 41............ 42
............ 43
............ 43
............ 44
............ 45
............ 46
............ 47
............ 48
............ 49
............ 49
............ 50
............ 50
............ 53
............ 53
............ 55
............ 56
............ 58
............ 59
............ 60
............ 60
............ 60
............ 61
............ 63
............ 66
5 5 6 8 8 9 0
3 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 9 0 0
3 3 5 6 8 9
0
0
0
3
6
1 SumThis reporboard sysTask 2.3 Son-board ExchangeThe reporand infrasService PBased on The meth
2 IntroIntegrationelement inreport is tonetwork sarchitectu In collaboharmonizeregime, winteroperasystems, and safe m
mmary rt constitut
stem integrSeamless part of the
e System (Vrt use the ustructure, 2
Portfolio andthe propoodology us
oduction of equipmn providingo provide t
standards, ure to be us
oration withed on-boar
whether by able radio cautomationmanner, us
tes deliveraration archRoaming f
e Maritime VDES). user needs2015) combd proposessed requirsed, is the
on ment in ong the shipbthe first steand installsed.
h Work Pacrd architecIMO and Icommunicn systems sing intellig
able D2.10itecture. Tfunction, thCloud (MC
s describedbined with s a set of rements, th(ISO/IEC4
-board netboard compep in analyation trend
ckage 3, incture, whichEC instrumation devicand other
gent netwo
Page 5 of
0 in the Effhe architeche MaritimeC), and the
d in (E2-T3analysis o
requiremenhe report s42010, 201
tworks takiponent of tysing the avds, to form
nput is provh, while re
ments, or bces with toelectronic
ork controll
“This pthe Euresearunder
f 91
ficienSea2 cture is intee Cloud Cl EfficienSe
3.1, Analysof the servints for the uggests an11)
ing cyber sthe maritimvailable ona recomm
vided towaspecting th
by Class, wday's and
c data proclers to sep
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
project. It egrating thient Comp
ea2 Task 2
sis report oces specifiarchitecturn on-board
security intme cloud. Tn-board commendation o
rds the defhe current
will promotetomorrow'sessing sysarate the n
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
describes he EfficienSponent (MC2.1 VHF Da
on communfied in the Mre.
d architectu
to account The scope mponents,on the netw
finition of atype appro
e the integs navigatiostems in a networks.
om
the on-Sea2 CC), the ata
nication Maritime
ure.
is a key of this , existing work
a oval ration of
on reliable
3 Defi AE AIS ASM DMZ DOS E2 ECDIS FW GPS GW ICS LOS MC MCC MMS MSP QoS RADAR
SOLAS
VDE VDES VDR VTS
Wi-Fi
initions
ArchitectAutomatiApplicatioDemilitarDenial OfEfficienSElectroniFirewall Global PoGatewayIntegrateLoss of SMaritime Maritime Maritime Maritime Quality oRAdio DeSafety ofamendmVHF DataVHF DataVoyage DVessel Ta trademNetwork)
s and Ac
ural Elemec Identificaon Specificrised Zone f Service ea2 c Chart Dis
ositioning Sy d Commun
Service Cloud Cloud ClieMessaginService Pf Service etection Anf Life at Seents) a Exchanga ExchangData Recoraffic Servark of the
)
cronym
ent ation Systec Messagin
splay and
System
nication Sy
ent Compog Service ortfolio
nd Ranginga (SOLAS
ge ge Systemrder (IEC 6ice Wi-Fi allian
Page 6 of
ms
em (IEC 62ng
Informatio
ystem
onent
g (IEC 623S Conventio
61996:201
nce (WLAN
“This pthe Euresearunder
f 91
2320:2008
n System
388:2013)on, 1974, w
3)
N or Wirele
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
)
(IEC 61174
with
ess Local A
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
4:2015)
Area
om
4 MetDue to thethe entire kind of thiwhich bindsystems. the architemaritime c To suppora recognizhas used Architectu Literature GroundedStakeholdThe proceillustrated
thodoloe rules andelectronicnking is reds the MarThis beingecture mucloud and
rt future vazed way tothe standa
ure Descrip
supporting
d in this staders, Concess to follo in Figure
ogy d regulationc infrastructequired to britime Clou
g stated, houst be provas such su
alidation ofo describe ard: (ISO/IEption.
g the stand
andard, thecerns, Vieww and the 1.
ns in the mture of a shbe limited tud Client Cowever, it iven (testedupport fulfil
f the on-bothe on-boaEC42010,
dard is (Ro
e descriptiowpoints and
steps take
Page 7 of
maritime dohip to be ato the nove
Componentis reasona) to be a vlment of re
oard MCC aard archite2011) Sys
ozanski & W
ons in this d Perspecten to provid
“This pthe Euresearunder
f 91
omain, onea subsystemel part of tht (MCC) to ble to suggalid part of
equirement
and to provcture. This
stems and
Woods, 20
documenttives. de a recom
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
e cannot imm of the mhe shipboathe existin
gest that thf the architts to the m
vide a descs work prodSoftware e
013).
make use
mmended a
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
mmediatelymaritime cloard architecng type apphe novel patecture of t
maritime clo
cription thaducing thisengineerin
e of the con
architectur
om
y consider oud; this cture proved arts of the oud.
at is using s report g –
ncepts:
e is
FFigure 1 Proccess to follow
Page 8 of
w to produce r
“This pthe Euresearunder
f 91
recommende
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
ed architectur
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
re
om
5 Sco
5.1 IntrBy today (global fleeannum. Ayear to baare small perhaps 2MC shoulthe MC im‘critical masafety andpractical tfulfil its po This real-whence notComponeexisting ruoperationsit could beLack of suimplemenof the MC The approthe fundamnecessariin full resprules. Whpositive siand integrwith the Mdescribe tequipmenincomplet
5.2 Bac
5.2.1 ThFrom the particular
pe and
oduction (2015), in et. Comme
Assuming aalance scraand intend
2.000 per yd not be so
mplementatass’ wouldd efficiencyterms, the otential.
world impat be undere
ent (MCC), ules, regulas and marie. uch compantation beyoC even befo
oach chosemental thely must bepect of theile this maide-effectsrated ship
MCC. Indeethe MCC wnt – if not, tte.
kground
e Heritageearly 1990focused o
Contex
rough numercial expe
a service lifapping andded for locayear – is a omething wtion rate w
d be too lony would imMC must a
act on the estimated:from every
ations, equitime equip
atibility couond limitedore it goes
en in the wesis being te an add-onir present fy seem as
s, one beincontrol sys
ed, as a dirwithin the frthen the co
e 0s, to the mn on-board
xt
mbers, thererts in the mfe of, say, 3d to provideal trading, potential ta
which just would be tong, unneceprove becalso apply
MC, its fun unless they relevant uipment anpment man
uld even turd testing inbeyond an
work reportthat the MCn to existinfunction an
s a constrag that prevstem archirect result ramework ompatibility
middle of thd infrastruc
Page 9 of
re are apprmaritime d30 years, se the expeeach of tharget for thnew ships o low, and
essarily pocause of the
to the exis
nction, chae MC, andvantage p
nd culture onufacturing
rn out to bn isolated gn embryon
ted in this dCC, as a reng ship sysnd entirely int from sovious work tectures isof this lineof existing
y of the MC
he first decctures and
“This pthe Euresearunder
f 91
roximately domain expsome 3.00cted growte remaininhe Maritimewill benef
d, correspostponing the MC. Thusting fleet a
racteristicsespeciallyoint is fundof commer
g, it is less
e an unsurgeographicnic state.
document esult of thestems and
aligned toome perspe
on ship sys suitable ae of thinkingg referenceCC to the p
cade of 200control sy
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
63.000 SOpect a grow0 ships areth. While sng part of the Cloud (Mit from; if thndingly, thhe day whes, both con
and future
s and archy its on-boadamentallyrcial shipbulikely to be
rmountablecal areas, c
reflects thie argumeninstrument the preseectives, it hystems, shas a foundag, it must b
e models ofpresent wo
00, two resystems, one
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
OLAS shipswth rate of e being bu
some of thehese new
MC). Howehat was thehe timespaere the manceptuallybuilds in o
itecture, shard Maritimy compatibuilding, shiecome the
e barrier tocausing the
is understats presentetation infrant set of rehowever a
hip infrastruation for thbe possiblef ships and
orld is prob
search proje being the
om
s in the 2% per
uilt every ese ships ships – ver, the e case, n to reach
aritime and in
order to
hould me Cloud le with thep success
o e demise
anding, ed,
astructure, elevant lso has uctures e work e to d ships ably
jects in e
e
ATOMOSother one cooperateinfrastruct2001; DISDISC projsystems –(ISO/IEC4One suchgrouping pcomponen1997)): • The
positetc.,prop
• The genethe abst
• At thdescinto stan
The thinkiand perhaControl sythe three
S Consortiubeing the
ed on bringtures and i
SC II). Direject aimed – or, in oth42010, 201 AD is shophysical shnts and a g
‘Generic’ tion, speed but the g
pulsion con‘Compon
eralise, i.e.correspondtraction pyrhe lowest lcribed with5 to 10 gdardized m
F
ing expresaps more rystems. Onoriginal DI
um (ATOMMiTS Foru
ging forwarintegrationctly applicaat providiner words, A11). own in Figuhipboard dgeneric gro
level cond, headinggeneric layntrol etc. nent’ level . informatioding impleramid. level, whic
h a relativeroups. The
modelling is
Figure 2 - Abs
sed in the refined andne such exSC layers
OS, 1994;um (The Mrd a comm mechanisable to theng a commArchitectur
ure 2, whicevices into
oup, each b
tains inforg, destinatioyer also co
contains on that is dementation
ch is the ‘Lely low nuerefore, sims possible
straction of t
original DId evolved Axample comare expan
Page 10 o
ATOMOSMiTS Forum
on suggessms, joininge matter at mon undersral Descrip
ch introduceo (from botbeing defin
rmation peon, name ontains ge
ship spedefined by n of the sy
Level of Sember of vmilarly to wat this lev
the DISC ISC-
ISC ISC abArchitecturmes from (nded to five
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
S II, 2000; Am, 2015). Tsted standag forces in hand, part
standing ofptions (AD)
es a three-ttom to topned as follo
ertaining toof the ship
eneric func
ecific detathe specifi
ystems be
ensors andariants, e.what was el.
-System, from
bstraction ral DescripRødseth, C
e. While the
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
ATOMOS These two gard for Intethe two D
t of the wof integrated), as this te
-layer abstp) sensors ows (edited
o the shipp, general ctions such
ails that aic configuring consid
d Actuatorsg., valves the case
m (DISC, 1997
pyramid istions of IntChristensee two conc
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
IV, 2002), groups mo
egrated ShISC projec
ork in the od ship conterm is used
traction pyand actuatd from (DIS
p as an emachineryh as navig
are not poration of thedered as p
rs’, such decan be g
at the gen
7)
s reflected tegrated Sen, & Lee),cepts are q
om
and the oreover ip Control cts (DISC, riginal trol d by
ramid, tors, SC,
ntity, e.g.,y conditiongation and
ossible toe ship andpart of the
evices areeneralised
neric level,
in later, hip where
quite
, n d
o d e
e d
similar in interconneinterconne‘Layer’ is interconneelectrical With the dfrom ‘botto • ‘Inst
highcomseemActu
• ‘Proc(199dive
• ‘Intethe D
• ‘Genwhicpres
• ‘Off-wousupp
EspeciallyLee) is se
many respectivity; in ection betwbroader inections. Thconnection
definition aom’ to ‘top
rument Laer-level apmands de
ms to be cuators’; cess Laye
97) abstracrgence betgrated ShDISC (199neral Ship ch are irrelsent work, ship Layeld come toplemented
Figure 3 -
y the moreeen as usef
pects, it shothe (Røds
ween devic its definitihe horizontns between
above in mip’, as follow
ayer’ – whpplications
evices at thclose to, or
r’ – which ction pyratween the ip Control 7) ‘GenericLayer’ –
levant to ISlike infotainr’ – which
o consider with the fa
Schematic S
evolved ISful in the c
ould howeveth, Christces, rather on, and dotal lines in n the three
ind, (Rødsws:
hich defines that utilizhe bottom r even iden
appears tomid, but wtwo mentio(ISC) Lay
c Layer’; which comSC, but whnment netw, for all pras part of
acilities and
hip Network
SC Ship Ncontext of t
Page 11 o
ver be nottensen, & Lr than the Does not expthe DISC
e layers.
seth, Christ
es the intezes the infof the ‘Ins
ntical with,
o be similawhere a coned mode
yer’ – whic
mbines tophich are sworks and ractical purthe ship-sd services
Architecture
etwork Archis docum
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
ed that theLee) terminDISC (1997plicitly diffeAD howev
tensen, & L
erconnectiformation strument L the DISC
ar to the ‘Ccloser scruels with resh is seen
p-level, shensible to shipboard
rposes, enshore comm
offered by
from (Rødse
chitecture fent since i
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
e latter AD nology, ‘La7) model der betweenver imply th
Lee) descr
on betweeprovided,
Layer’, Con (1997) ‘La
Componenutiny probaspect to layas being s
ip-wide fuconsider i
d administrancompassemunicationy the MC.
eth, Christens
from (Rødst has its fo
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
focuses oayer’ thus mdefinition, wn devices ahat there a
ribes five la
en sensorand in so
nceptually,ayer of Se
nt Layer’ inably wouldyers 2 andsimilar in p
nctions wiin the con
ration; es the funcns solutions
sen, & Lee)
seth, Chrisocus on
om
n means the where and re
ayers,
s and theome cases this layer
ensors and
n the DISCd reveal ad 3; purpose to
ith entitiestext of the
ctions ones of today,
stensen, &
e s r d
C a
o
s e
e
interconneproviding as their tyarchitectuthe extenstunnels, tocritical dev In way of the (Røds
5.2.2 SO
5.2.2.1 NThe SOLAequipmeneach entitrequiremeconformanInternationStandards As an illusrequires thaccordingindependeand charaMSC.192(in practicehave theircites a nuensures imdocumentrequired tEquipmenpassing th One issueequipmenseen as adevice is a
ection, rathan overvie
ypical, immure could resive usageo segregatvices and
topology dseth, Christ
OLAS, Car
Navigation AS convennt that a shty of such eents, knownce againsnal Electros’.
stration of hat all ship
g to Sectionent 3 GHz acteristics o(79):2004,e, that equr equipmenmber of otmplicit fulfits and proco use only
nt Directivehe relevant
e is in partint is Type Aan indepenapproved a
her than onew of the b
mediate relaelate to she of securitte network type appro
descriptiontensen, &
riage Req
and Comntion dictatehip must caequipment
wn as ‘Perfost the Perfoo-technical
this chain ps above 3n 2.7.1 of tRADAR if
of these on upon whicipment supnt ‘Type Apther IEC stlment of alcesses, Eu
y equipmene (MED), fot tests.
icular relevApproved adent islandas a RADA
n devices. basic functiationships,ip – off-shity devices segments
oved entitie
, the work Lee) five-la
uirements
mmunicatioes the min
arry to fulfil t, the IMO ormance Sormance SCommissi
of requirem300 gross tthe same rthe ship is
ne or two Rch the test ppliers whopproved’ intandards also the latturopean shnt which haor which eq
vant for theaccording td – so in thAR device
Page 12 o
As such, tions and/o including ip integratiin the form
s and to proes.
being repoayer AD, in
s and IMO
ons Equipnimum set o the Convehas moreo
Standards’,Standards oion (IEC) p
ments, SOtons are to regulation, s above 3.0RADARs aspecificat
o wishes ton accordans being ma
ter. In addithips – i.e. sas been apquipment i
e present wto its basiche case de- only.
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
the (Rødser devices ialso – impon. It is als
m of firewalovide cybe
orted on inncluding th
O Type App
pment of navigatiention – thover publis and to maoperationapublishes a
LAS Ch. Vcarry a 9 Gmust be s000 gross
are describion IEC 62o manufac
nce with IEandatory; ftion to thisships whichpproved acs rewarded
work: navigc function, escribed in
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
eth, Christen an ISC a
portantly – so seen asls, gatewa
er-security
the presehe defined
proval
on and come carriage hed a high
ake assessal and reproa correspon
V, Reg. 19,GHz RADAupplementtons. In tued in IMO
2388:2013 cture marinC 62388:2fulfilment o complex oh flies a Euccording to d the ‘Whe
gation and and is, as the forego
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
ensen, & Larchitecturehow an IS
s worthwhilays and VPisolation fo
ent documemeaning o
mmunicatirequireme
her-level sesment of oducible, tnding set o
, Section 2AR, which,ted with anrn, the proResolutionbuilds. Th
ne RADARs2013 – whicof the formeof approvauropean fla
o the EC Meelmark’ up
communica starting
oing, a RAD
om
Lee) is e, as well C le to note
PN or mission
ent adopts of ‘Layer’.
on ents. For et of
he of ‘Test
.3.2 , n operties n is means, s have to ch in turn er
al ag – are aritime pon
cations point, DAR
To ensurestandardsthe correscommunicunderstoorugged – communic As toucherequiremecommunicthe realm overall rulspawned navigationdevices likmembers RADAR, Ethe correcwell as mo
5.2.2.2 EThe Classregime whsystems, and segre Where shrequiremedifferent psystems –of an examfeatures a From an adescribedand actuastandardiz
• Bin• An
volmA
e the integrs often pressponding incations staod in the mand, as a bcations.
ed upon brents and thcation equof navigat
les set forta set of Pen functionske VHF, Mof the GM
ECDIS, Hect function ore genera
Equipmentsification Shen it comeand publis
egation of f
ips are quents, they hpropulsion – the list is mple, whileand automa
architecturad above, in ators, and tzed within
nary sensoalogue sentage or a c
A outputs b
rity of naviscribes dirnterface standards aremaritime do
benefit to c
iefly in the he IMO typipment. Retion: any seth by SOLAerformances. This mea
MF, HF, FleMDSS clan,eading Conof navigati
al-purpose
t for Alert,Societies ares to equip
sh rules forfunction.
ite generichowever dplants, auxvery long,
e all ships ation level
al vantagethe sense
the ‘Instrumthree area
ors which cnsors, whiccurrent is pbeing the m
gation sysect interfacandards. Ine almost umain, and cyber secu
foregoinge approva
eferring to eagoing shAS Ch. IV ‘e Standardans that theeet broadba from a rul
ntrol (autopion systemsensors li
Monitorinre to a greapment for sr their desig
c when it coiffer muchxiliary engi and the nhave geneof individu
e point, AMe that at thement Layeras:
conceptuallch usually proportionamost comm
Page 13 o
tems and sces between the latterniversally are chara
urity, they d
, the main l regime fathe latter,
hip above 3‘Radiocomds and Tese primary fand, Watchles-based pilot), to th
ms (Gyro, Gke wind sp
ng and Coat extent reship-boardgn, perform
omes to thmore in thines, valve
number of veric systemual instanc
MC systemse lowest ler’ interface
ly are contprovide an
al with the monplace),
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
subsystemen systemr context, tused. Thescterized asdo not allow
functions/dall in the spthe rules b300 gross
mmunicatiost Standardfunctions oh Receivervantage poe sensor p
GNSS, echpeed and d
ontrol (AMeplicating t
d Alert, Monmance, res
e navigatiohe AMC spe systems, variations v
ms like a ‘Bes are, aga
s however vel they us
es to such c
tacts whichn industrialmeasured
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
ms, the IMOs, and almthe family ose interfacs being staw extraneo
devices gopheres of nbase is verytons has tons’, which ds, similarlyof voice/dars, and theoint are co
packages ro sounder
direction, N
MC) the IMO Tynitoring ansponse tim
on and comhere: Shipswitchboa
very large.Ballast Watain, varied
follow the se relativelcomponen
h can be ei-standard value (0-1
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
O Type Appmost alwaysof IEC 611
ces are weable, effectous
overned bynavigation ry similar too comply win turn hasy to the wo
ata commue other variomparable required tor(s), speedNAVTEX an
ype Apprond Control es, interco
mmunicatiops are outfiards, tank g. Moreoverter Systemd in many r
ideas in thly standard
nts tend to
ither closedinterface w
10 VDC an
om
proval s dictates 62 serial ll tive and
y carriage and o that in with the s orld of nications ous to ensure log(s)) as nd AIS.
val (AMC)
onnections
ons tted with gauging r, in way ’, the
respects.
he AD d sensors be
d or open, where a nd 4-20
• Fiefor or athis
Irrespectivinstrumencomply wiIf the equiinstead; m The consulower levewhich canthan not ainstallationalmost exproprietarsmall-pacone protorequireme AMC systdescribedone descrAMC systof AMC syship-specthe Classiprocess, iapproved particular question, interconne
5.2.3 TypIrrespectivin the IMOignored, hthan implyand the deindividual ships are or be able
eld-buses, informatio
analogue is level.
vely, it shont level, is rith the envipment is a
more often
umers of dels of the An be either are interconns this cou
xclusively Ery, since mcket, near-rcol concur
ents from s
tems are gd for navigaribed abovtems are mystems is b
cific configuification Sot is validat‘building bship and pand, of paections and
pe Approvvely of the O type apphowever rey, the SOLemands incomponenfree to be
e to mainta
most oftenon more coinformation
ould be notrequired tovironmentaalso be usethan not, s
data (and thAD) connec
PLC-typesnnected atuld include Ethernet. P
many supplireal-time crrently, prospecific ser
oing throuation and cve, driven bmuch more based on turations, anociety chosted that theblocks’, andplant are aarticular reld infrastruc
ved ‘clustrule and rroval or th
estrictive anLAS convenn SOLAS ants, do notmore lavis
ain the man
n using IEComplex thann, but also
ted that all o be ‘Type l standardsed in the ssuppliers c
he correspcted to the s or PC-typt the ‘ProceHDLC, Ar
Protocols vaers believeommunicaviding datarvices and
gh an apprcommunicaby the natu
varied thathe submisnd of testssen by the e systems d that the rdhered to, evance in ctures.
ers’ egulation be Class typnd rigid thention is conre set fortht exceed a shly equippndatory tra
Page 14 o
C 61162-tyn what it isCanbus a
hardware Approved’s describehip’s bridg
choose to c
ponding pro ‘Instrumepes of hardess Level’ rcnet and Eary at the ‘e that certa
ations. Soma transmispurposes,
roval proceations equiure of the ban the lattession of dras of the ind
ship owneunder scrurelevant ru including this contex
base, i.e. wpe approvaese procesncerned wh to ensuregiven max
ped than stading perm
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
ype sentencs possible tnd Profibu
involved a’. This mead in IACS e, it has tocertify agai
oviders of cnt Layer’ isdware – prusing som
Ethernet, in‘Process Lain propert
me suppliersion which, rather tha
ess which ipment, bubeast: as der two domawings andividual syser for a parutiny are coules and rethe performxt, the seg
whether theal domainssses may s
with the safee that a shximum levetated by thits without
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
ces or Modto convey ws are relat
and/or connans that haE10 (IACS
o fulfil (IEC inst both st
commandss usually processors w
me kind of nn newer insLevel’, but aties of TCPrs are also
h is optimizan one-size
is comparat it is moreescribed inains. In prad functionastems, undrticular shipomposed egulations imance of tregation an
e approvals, the rationseem to beety of the cip as a whoel of accephe Convent
being in c
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
dbus RTU with simpletively often
nected to tardware is S).
C 60945, 20tandards.
s to devicerocess comwhich morenetwork. Installations are very ofP/IP are ill-o using mozed to the e-fits-all.
able to thee individuan the foregactice, the
al descriptioer the ausp. During tentirely of tin force forthe systemnd isolatio
l regime is nale shoul
e. As the nacrew/passeole, as we
ptable risk. tion, they w
compliance
om
telegramse binary in use at
the tested to
002)
es in the mputers, e often
n older this is ften -suited for re than
e one l than the
going, approval
ons of pices of his type r the
m in n of
grounded d not be ame more engers, ll as its While
will not gete with
s
t
SOLAS, aPerformanensure thato the mar Within theexactly thintegrity, dsafety andvaluablesan internausually is financing words, anClass rulewith a lon One practboard sysboard systime limite‘meant’ toboard syssystem re(AMC) syswill also bbeing ‘closystem thfunctions both.
and the assnce Standaat capabilitriner.
e scope of e same midependabid wellbeing. The cons
ationally reunable to for building
ny recognizes – also cog list of int
tical result stem is govstems are ced to integro work togestems like iepresents ostems are
be clear thased worldsat is not tywhich com
AutomatioSystem
Commu
Di
Figure 4 – C
sociated seards and thties which
machineryission as IMlity and resg of the cresequence ocognized Cbe insuredg or acquirzed ship owonsideringternational
of the typeverned by tcreated ourate deviceether. For tit has beenone such ctwo other
at these sys’: one canype approvmpromise th
NaS
on
unications Devic
irect links
Conventional
et of presche correspare deeme
y and automMO, and thsilience of ew, the proof not meeClassificatid by a recoring a non-wner does that Classrules and
e approval the IMO ort of type a
es and to pthis reasonn done alsocluster, the archetypic
ystems essnnot directlved for the he type ap
avigation System
e
Type-aDirec
(2016) topolo
Page 15 o
cribed safeponding IECed to be cr
mation sysheir rules aa ship and
otection of eting and reion Societyognized un-conformannot have a
s rule comregulation
regime, irr by Class,pproved ‘b
provide funn, it is in mo in the for communic
cal clusterssentially arey add compurpose a
pproved fun
GMDSSystem
Firew
approvedct links
ogy showing
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
ty standardC Test Staritical to life
stems, the are formulad the ship sthe enviro
emaining iny is that suderwriter. nt ship will a choice bupliance ims besides
respective is what co
building blonctions whiany cases regoing (secations syss. Followinge meant to
mponents oas approprinctionality
Sm
wall/Router
clusters of t
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
ds. Indeedandards aree at sea ar
Classificatated to enssystems wnment andn complianch a ship, This meannot be ava
ut to be in plicitly ensIMO.
ly of whethould be calocks’, but thch, througmeaningfu
ee Figure 4stem and tg the argumo be kept ar devices tate, and oof such an
Public Address
In
ype approved
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
d, the IMO e formulatere always a
tion Societsure the sa
which influed the presence with theand its ca
ns, in practailable; in ocomplianc
sures comp
her a particlled ‘clustehey are at h the Ruleul to subdi4): The navthe automaments pres
apart, as weto either ty
one cannot n entity, clu
nfotainmentSystem
d equipment
om
ed to available
ties have afety, nces the
ervation of e rules of rgo, tice, that other ce with pliance
cular ship-ers’: On-
the same e base, arevide ship-vigation ation sented, it ell as
ype of add
uster, or
e
The excepadditionaldevice or rule and ralso seembut also bdedicatedworkstatiocontrol, onhere is sethe risk of
P
5.3 TheThe argumbut also ohowever aco-exist wthe upcom
• Thca
• Thsy
• ThM
ption for th devices aapplication
regulationsm to involvebetween end for particuons can cone network
egregation f corruption
AutomationSystem
Communic
Direc
Performance daSuppliers Re
Figure 5
e MC and Mment that iton the existalso clear f
with type apming MC se
he on-boaran be provhe on-boarystems andhe on-boar
MC/MCC do
his practiceand/or funcn, while ob
s in force. We the extenntities at eaular purpos
onceivably k for adminand the enn of essent
NavSy
cations Device
ct links
ata (could be offemote Diagnosti
5 - State-of-th
MCC in Cot is necessting fleet isfrom the fopproved cluervices to t
rd architecvided to therd architecd clusters ord architecoes not vio
e is usuallyctions do nobserving thWhen it consive use oach layer, ases (see Fbe connec
nistration, ansuring thatial service
vigation ystem
f-line)cs
ChS
Type-aDirec
he-art topolog
ontext sary for thes a primaryoregoing thusters, thethe marine
cture must e mariner;cture has toof systems
cture has toolate mand
Page 16 o
y tied to beot violate tat the addmes to netof gatewayas well as igure 5). A
cted to oneand one neat no data fes.
GMDSSystem
art Updating (coSuppliers Remot
Firew
approvedct links
gy (2016) sho
e MC and My dimensiohat it is insue architectuer:
support th
o be so thas; o ensure thatory funct
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
ing able tohe type ap-ons are totworked sy
ys and firewthe usage
As an exame network fetwork for flows from
SSm
ould be off-line)te Diagnostics
wall/Router
owing a highe
MCC to ben of the coufficient thaure must be
at eNaviga
at it does n
hat the losstions;
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
o demonstrpproved nao be complystems, bewalls, not oof multiple
mple of thisor alert, mCCTV; theone doma
Public Address
)
er level of inte
e fitted not ontext. Withat the MCCe so that th
ation functi
not compro
s of conne
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
rate that suature of theliant to anyst practice
only betwee networkss, operator onitoring a
e importantain to the n
InfotainmentSystem
tegration
only on nehin that, it C is simplyhe MCC ca
ions and s
omise type-
ctivity to th
om
uch e host y relevant e does en layers,
s
and t issue next, with
ew ships is
y able to an provide
ervices
-approved
he
• Thbe
5.4 ArchTo be ablehave a nedescribedOne suchanother, wapproved IMO Perfothey nevearchitect. Figure 6 selements
• e-N• Aut• Na• GM• Info• IEC• Pu• T2
The MCCVSAT, T2 Elements Figure 3, each repr
he topologest practice
hitecturae to produ
eed for comd from a nu view, whic
which is monavigation
ormance Sertheless ha
show a potare clearly
Navigation tomation S
avigation SyMDSS Systotainment C61162-46blic Addres.3 Roamin
C as well as2.1 VDES a
that can bsuch as EC
resent a ce
gy of the one for secur
l Elementce candida
mmunicatioumber of arch is well rore implicitn and commStandards aave to be k
tential concy visible:
Services System ystem tem system
60 ss g
s the elemeare clearly
be identifiedCDIS, RAD
ertain funct
n-board arcrity, protec
ts (AE) ate architecon with the rchitecturarepresentet, is the funmunicationand the IECknown to, a
ceptual mo
ents providalso an AE
d from e.gDAR, AIS mtion within
Page 17 o
chitecture ction and se
ctures, the MC throug
al views, ased in the abnctional viens devices C Test Staappreciate
odel of the
ding the vaE
. may not nethe Naviga
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
has to be iegregation
e essential gh the MCs set forth bbove, is theew: becausand comp
andards, thed and und
architectu
arious com
eed to be itation Syste
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
in compliann of infrastr
elements, C, are to bby (ISO/IEe physical –se the funcponents arehese are seerstood by
re. Some a
munication
tems in theem.
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
nce with thructure.
i.e. elemebe identifieC42010, 2– topologicctionality oe inherent eldom exply the syste
architectur
n services,
e architect
om
he industry
ents that ed and 2011). cal – view;f type in the licit, but
ems
ral
such as
ure, since
y
e
For claritythe lower Figure 6 nstandardsE10 or IECphysical pcommunicreason, thexample, and certaitechnolog
AutS
eNavigationServices
F
y, it should half of
not necesss and test sC 60945 fo
proximity tocations reqhere may nwould be tin kinds of
gy.
tomationSystem
Commun
Commun
Commun
Direct links
Figure 6 – Po
be noted t
sarily are tystandards. or shipboao the ship’squirement wnot be a relthe case foterrestrial
Navigation System
Onboard Ext
IEC 611
nications Device
nications Device
nications Device
TypD
otential/conce
that the thr
ype approvIndeed, w
rd use, thes navigatiowhich is nolevant set or a WiFi dcommunic
Page 18 o
GMSys
ternal-enabled Ne
162-460
Roam
FW
pe-approvedDirect links
eptual ship-b
ree individ
ved accordwhile such de relevant son bridge, tot mandateof perform
device, certcations net
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
DSSstem
etwork
ming Device (cost-o
oard eNaviga
ual commu
ding to an Idevices hastandard bthey are seed by rules
mance standtain kinds otworks, suc
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
Public Address
optimized routing)
Typ
ation topolog
unications’
MO/IEC seave to confbeing depeeen here as and reguldards avaiof satellite ch as mob
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
)
InfotainmentSystem
ype Approval Dom
gy
’ devices s
et of perforform to eithndent on ts fulfilling alations. Foilable, whiccommunicile phone
om
ain
shown in
rmance her IACS he a
or this ch, for cations
6 ViewThis chapdefined scExperiencviewpoints
• Co• Fun• Info• Co• De• De• Op
In WP2, T
6.1 ConThe contethe on-boThe conteinvolved infrom the sConcerns
6.2 FunThe functiresponsib
6.3 InfoThe informmanages
6.4 ConThe concuoperating/Since the and functiviewpoint However, prioritizati
6.5 DevThe develprocess. The architeasy deve
wpointspter identifiecope for Tace from uses are recom
ontext nctional ormational
oncurrency evelopmenteployment perational
Task 2.4 we
ntext Viewext viewpoiard system
ext viewpoin various sship. s/requireme
ctional Vional viewp
bilities, inte
ormationamational viand distrib
ncurrency urrency vie/servicing architectu
ionality relyis a given the viewpon and the
velopmenlopment vi
tecture andelopment o
s es the viewask 2.4. e of the (ISmmended
t
e have not
wpoint int describ
ms and theint is consiservice con
ents seen f
iewpoint point descrrfaces and
al Viewpoewpoint debutes inform
Viewpoinewpoint bain multiple
ure in scopeying on thito consideoint may be architectu
nt Viewpoewpoint de
d the data of services
wpoints im
SO/IEC420for consid
t identified
es the relair environmdered to bntexts i.e. a
from all rel
ribes the s
d primary in
oint escribes thmation.
nt asically des
contexts.e is centras communer. be simplifieure behavi
oint escribes th
communic.
Page 19 o
portant for
010, 2011)eration:
further vie
ationships, ment. be fully releall services
levant type
system’s runteractions
he way the
scribes the
al in communication nee
ed to requiriour in spe
he architec
cation proto
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
r the on-bo
methodolo
ewpoints.
dependen
evant sinces that invol
es/classes
untime funcs.
architectu
e architectu
unication toeds to ope
rements recial situatio
cture that s
ocols and
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
oard archite
ogy is that
ncies and in
e the architlve commu
of services
ctional elem
re stores,
ural behavi
o/from the erate concu
elated to coons e.g. in
upports the
data struct
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
ecture with
the follow
nteractions
tecture in sunication to
s must be
ments, the
manipulate
iour when
ship and surrently, th
ommunicat distress.
e developm
tures shou
om
hin the
ing
s between
scope is o and
included.
ir
es,
services e
tion
ment
uld support
t
6.6 DepThe deplodeployed.Since we takes the recommenbe defined
6.7 OpeThe operaand suppo
ployment oyment vie. have the oexisting inndation and.
erational Vational vieworted when
Viewpoinwpoint des
overall goafrastructur
nd the exist
Viewpoinwpoint desn active.
nt scribes the
al of recomre into consting infrast
nt scribes how
Page 20 o
e environm
mmending asideration tructure, a
w the archi
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
ment into wh
architectureand identifperspectiv
tecture wil
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
hich the sy
e in our defies the gave dealing w
l be opera
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
ystem will b
efined scopap betweenwith deplo
ated, admin
om
be
pe that n the oyment will
nistered
7 ViewThis chaprerequisiintegrated Efficient cdifferent soperation share, stomatrix outtime aspeThe table The e-Nafrom memorganizatiInternationAuthoritieInternationCommissiIn defininservices hVarious ohave furth The TaskviewpointsAt this timsince this MSP show
ws apter descites and /d ships net
communicsystems pand monit
ore and tratlining the
ect. does not i
avigation smber stateions, inclunal Radios (IALA), nal Marition (IEC).
ng the curhas been dther works
her refined
k 2.4 analys describe
me of writiis work on
wn in Figur
cribes theor requiretwork.
cation solurovides netoring to rensfer data user need
include wh
strategy has of IMO uding the o-Maritime
the Inteime Cou
rrent and defined, nas, MarNIS,the servic
ysis work d in chapteng (April 2
ngoing. E2re 7. This n
e operatioments for
utions andew way ofeporting oris the key
d, services
hat is requir
as been deand a num
Internatioe (CIRM)ernational ncil (BIM
future maamely: The
Flagship, ces defined
to produceer 6, and b2016), the Task 2.2 numbering
Page 21 o
onal needsr the desig
d enhancef doing “olr analytics to succes
s in use, d
red by and
eveloped mber of Inonal Hydr),the Inte
ChamberMCO) and
aritime com Maritime SEfficienSe
d by MSP.
e Views hbasing the ere is a bithas produ
g is also us
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
s/views thgn of the
ed ability td stuff” -of historics. In the ta
data type a
d fulfilled by
by IMO (Nntergovernmrographic rnational r of Shipd the Int
mmunicatioService Poea, Monalis
as resulteviews on tt of confusced the ov
sed in the w
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
hat shall on-board
to integratall the wa
cal data. Thable below and data n
y the insta
NSCR-1/28mental andOrganizatAssociatio
pping (ICSternational
on needs,ortfolio (MSsa, ACCSE
d in combhe MSP. sing numbverview of work of Tas
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
be consarchitectu
te informaay from plahe possibiwe have p
needed inc
alled GMDS
8) with cod non-govtion (IHOon of LS), the B Electro
, a set ofSP). EAS and M
bining seve
bering of thcurrent desk 2.4.
om
idered asure for the
ation fromanning viality to use,prepared acluding the
SS.
ntributionsvernmental), Comité
LighthouseBaltic and
technical
f maritime
MonaLisa2
eral of the
he MSP’s,efinitions of
s e
m a ,
a e
s l
é e d l
e
2
e
, f
MSP reference
MSP 1MSP 2MSP 3MSP 4MSP 5MSP 6MSP 7
MSP 8
MSP 9MSP 10MSP 11MSP 12MSP 13MSP 14
MSP 15
MSP 16-----
Fig
Maritim
VTS IVTS NavigatVTS Traffic
LocMaritime Sa
Ves
Telemedical MaMaritime
NaNautic
IceMeteoro
real-time hydrogra
Search aRemote m
C
gure 7 Maritim
me Service (IALA W
Information Service tion Assistance Serc Organization Servcal Port Service (LPafety Information (MS
Pilotage ServiceTugs Service
ssel Shore Reportin
aritime Assistance Se Assistance Serviceautical Chart Serviccal Publications Sere Navigation Service
ological information saphic and environm
servicesand Rescue (SAR) monitoring of ships sOffshore activitiesFishing activitiesLeisure boating
Coastal surveillance
me Service P
WG3) S
(IS);rvice (NAS)vice (TOS)PS)SI) service
ng
Service (TMAS)e (MAS)erviceeserviceental information
Servicesystems
e
Page 22 o
Portfolio (MSP
EfficienSea 2Selected & ref Use C
MSP 1MSP 2MSP 3MSP 4MSP 5MSP 6MSP 7
MSP 8
MSP 9MSP 10MSP 11MSP 12MSP 13MSP 14
MSP 15
MSP 16MSP 17MSP 18MSP 19MSP 20MSP 21
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
P) as defined
Cases
Ic
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
by IALA and
EfficienSea 2 M(WP
VTS (tatasktask
Port informatMSI & NM
Port reportiSRS reportin
Self‐organising emSea charts
ce Cat Service ‐ chartMETOC (
Self‐organising em
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
E2
MSP use casesP2.2)
ask 6.2)k 6.2k 6.2tion (task 5.2)
M (task 4.2)
ng (task 5.2) ng (task 6.2)mergency (task 6.1)s (task 4.4)
ts & forecast (task 4.7task 4.3)
mergency (task 6.1)
om
7)
Category
Task 4.5 M
Task 4.5 3
Task 4.6
Task 4.6Task 6.1 1
Task 4.6
Task 5.3
Task 6.2
Task 6.2
Task 6.3
Task 5.2
Task 4.7
Task 4.2
Task 4.4
Task 4.3
Task 5.1
Figur
MSP
MSP 5/14/15/18
MSP 3/18/(others?)
MSP 1/8
MSP /2/3/4/6/13/14
MSP 1/2/3
MSP 1
MSP 8
MSP1
MSP8
MSP 10/16
MSP 4
VTS &
Port Infor
MSP 13 Ice ChServic
MSP 5
MSP 11
MSP 14
Route
Smart b
Sea Ch
Weat
Port Rep
MSI &
MSP 8
re 8 MSP Use
Po(prio
Po(prior t
MSI &
Real t
Sea C
Sea Char
Smart buo
Smart Buoy
A
RRoute info'Route optim
(Ex. Arctic na
Route informatiinc
Ro
Ice Cha
Ice Cha
Ice Chart
Ice Chart
Po
PoComm
VT(see also
SR
SRS
Self-organizing e(Arctic are
rmation
Emission Mon
harts ces
UseCas
data
buoys
harts
ther
porting
NM
Page 23 o
cases and re
ort Reporting or to port entry)
ort Reporting to port departure)
MSI & NM
NM (Hydro data)
time Metoc Data
METOC
harts (authorities)
rts (commercial serv.)
oy Broadcast Service
y Management Service (AtoN)
Route planActive route
Route checks - suggestion - alertsmisation & negocationav: ice + shallow waters)
ion (optimization, revisioncident, hazard)
oute exchange
art Service - charts
art Service - charts
t Service - forecasts
t Service - forecasts
ort Information
ort Informationmercial services
TS Reportingo Route info task 4.6)
RS Reporting
emergency ea)
nitoring
se
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
elation to E2
Data Source
on-board adm
on-board adm
Shore Authoriti
Shore Authoriti
Shore Authoriti
Commercial en
Shore Authoriti
Commercial en
Smart Buoy
Off-shore installa
Ship
Shore AuthoritiVTS services
Commercial ProvPilot
, VTS services
Ship
Shore Authoriti
Commercial Prov
Shore Authoriti
Commercial Prov
Port authorities (not iPort organisatio
Commercial entPort organisatio
Ships sensors/deSmart Buoys sensors
Shore control sta
Shore Authorit
Ships
Ships
Data to
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
Tasks
eUs
(what eq(what e
min Shore A
min Shore A
ies Sh
ies Sh
ies Sh
ntity Sh
ies Sh
ntity Sh
y SOff-shore
ations A
Shore AVTS
S
iessvider S
s S
S
ies Sh
vider Sh
ies Sh
vider Sh
n Effic.2)ons Sh
titiesons Sh
evicess/devicesations
Shore AShipping
ies S
Sh
ShSh
be available electronica
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
sagequipment)endpoint)
Authorities
Authorities
hips
hips
hips
hips
hips
hips
hipsinstallations
AtoN
Authoritiescenters
Ship
Ship
Ship
Ship
hips
hips
hips
hips
hips
hips
AuthoritiesCompanies
hips
hore
hipshore
ally
om
Task 2.2 and relatioSince thcommunicFigure 9.
For each of charactsub-chaptIn the tabdenote thpossible a
and Task on to workhe on-bocation/serv
of the use-teristics ofters)
bles in the hat further at this time
2.4 have k on-going oard arcvices, Task
Figure 9
-cases in tf the comm
following cinvestigat
e of writing
in co-operin various
chitecture k 2.4 have
E2 Task 2.4 a
his larger tmunication
chapters thtion has to(April 2016
Page 24 o
ration workE2 tasks.
also hproduced
added Servic
table, E2 Tinvolved i
here are qo be made6).
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
ked out a This list is ave to an additio
es and their u
Task 2.2 ann the serv
question me to achie
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
list of MSshow in Fisupport
nal set of
use cases
nd Task 2.vice (descr
arks severeve better
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
P’s, their igure 8.
other use cases
4 have defribed in the
ral places.guess tha
om
use cases
types of, shown in
fined a sete following
This is toan what is
s
f n
t g
o s
7.1 InteThere are
• Po• Mu• Bro
The table and the fo
7.1.1 PoWe have the sourceproviding communic
7.1.2 MuMulticast known andestinatio
7.1.3 BroBroadcastare not kThereforeThere aremessagesGeocasts known or Since broreport will
7.2 CybTo indicatare used.
• Aut• Co• Clie
The table Note that
eraction Te three inte
int to Pointulticast oadcast
in Figure ollowing su
oint to Poindefined the of commacknowle
cation.
ulticast is defined
nd the souon is provid
oadcast t is defineknown by e there are e several sus distribute
can be bnot. adcasts ca use the te
ber Securitte the leve
thenticatioonfidentialitent Authen
in Figure MSP desig
Type eraction/com
t (P2P)
10 shows tub-chapters
nt (P2P) he P2P co
munication iedgement
as a “one rce of com
ding acknow
ed as “onethe sourcnot guaran
ubsets of bed to a geobased on m
an be “filteerm broadc
ty el of cyber
on of informty (Encryptntication
10 shows cgn is still w
mmunicati
the interacs describes
mmunicatiis sure thaof recepti
to many” cmmunicatiowledgeme
e to many”ce and arntee that inbroadcastsographical multicasts
red” by vacast.
r security i
mation, incltion)
cyber secuwork on-go
Page 25 o
on types:
ction types s the intera
on so thatat informatiion. TCP
communicaon is sure nt of recep
” communire not pronformations. E.g. geolimited areor broadc
rious cons
n the com
luding data
urity characing and he
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
involved inaction type
t the destinon is transis one ty
ation, wherthat inform
ption
ication, whoviding acn is transfecasts used
ea. casts, all d
straints, wh
mmunication
a integrity (
cteristics foence inform
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
n the varioes in more
nation endsferred, sinype of pro
re all destimation is tr
here the dcknowledgerred. d in literatu
depending
here geogra
n, the follo
(Digital sig
or the variomation is su
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
ous MSP usdetail.
d-point is knce the desotocol use
nation endransferred,
estination ement of
ure for MSP
if the rec
aphy is jus
owing char
ning)
ous MSP uubject to c
om
se cases
known andstination ised in P2P
dpoints are, since the
endpointsreception.
P denoting
ceivers are
st one, this
racteristics
use cases.hange.
d s P
e e
s .
g
e
s
s
VTS & SRS
Port Informatio
Ice Charts Services
Route data
Smart buoys
Sea Charts
Weather
Port Reporting
MSI & NM
Figure 10
Port Re(prior to
Port Re(prior to po
MSI
MSI & NM (
Real time
ME
Sea Charts
Sea Charts (co
Smart buoy Bro
Smart Buoy Man(At
RoutActive
RouteRoute info's - suRoute optimisat
(Ex. Arctic nav: ice
Route information (oincident
Route e
Ice Chart Se
Ice Chart Se
Ice Chart Serv
Ice Chart Serv
Port Info
Port InfoCommerc
VTS R(see also Rout
SRS R
Self-organizing emerg(Arctic area)
on
Emission Monitorin
UseCase
g
0 Use Case In
eporting port entry)
eporting rt departure)
& NM
(Hydro data)
Metoc Data
TOC
s (authorities)
ommercial serv.)
oadcast Service
nagement Service toN)
e plane route
e checkuggestion - alertstion & negocatione + shallow waters)
optimization, revision, t, hazard)
exchange
ervice - charts
ervice - charts
vice - forecasts
vice - forecasts
ormation
ormationcial services
eportingte info task 4.6)
Reporting
gency
ng
Page 26 o
nteraction Ty
P2P
MulticasPoint to
many, witack.
X
X
X
X
X
X
X X
X
X
X
X
X
X X
X X
X
X
X
X
Interaction
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
pe and Cybe
t,o th
Broadcast,Point to
many, No ack.
Auth
(dsig
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Type
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
r Security
enticationigital
gning)
Confidential(Encrypted)
X X
X X
X X
X X
X
X X
X
X X
X
X X (?)
X
X X
X X
X
X
X X
X X
X
X X
X X
X X
X X
Cyber Securit
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
l Client Authenticati
on
X
X
(X)
X
X
X
X
ty
om
7.3 LinkThe Link r
• Tra• Info• Tra• Lat
This is bathe commThe link reE2 Task 2options foThe table Note that
7.4 PrioFor use wcalling.
• Dis• Urg• Saf• Ro• Ge
The tablecases.
k Requirerequiremen
ansaction Formation sansfer per tency
asically to pmunication.
equiremen2.2, evaluaor commun
in Figure MSP desig
ority when prior
stress gent fety
outine eneral
e in Figure
ments nts are spl
Frequencysize per traday, per si
provide som
nts are not ating commnication in v11 shows tgn is still w
ritizing traff
11 shows
it into the f
y nsaction ite
me estima
as importamunication various scethe Link re
work on-go
fic, we hav
s the priori
Page 27 o
following:
ates on req
ant in relattechnolog
enarios. equirementing and he
ve used th
ity for the
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
uired band
tion to devgies, but w
ts for the vence inform
he same d
communic
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
dwidth and
veloping arill provide
arious MSmation is su
definitions
cation in th
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
d accepted
rchitecture an unders
P use caseubject to c
as in GM
he various
om
latency in
as it is forstanding of
es. hange.
DSS DSC
MSP use
n
r f
C
e
VTS & S
Port Inform
Ice ChaServic
Route d
Smart b
Sea Ch
Weath
Port Repo
MSI & N
Figure
Po(prio
Po(prior t
MSI &
Real t
Sea C
Sea Char
Smart buo
Smart Buoy
A
RRoute info'Route optim
(Ex. Arctic na
Route informatinc
Ro
Ice Cha
Ice Cha
Ice Chart
Ice Chart
Po
PoCom
VT(see also
SR
SRS
Self-organizing e(Arctic are
mation
Emission Mon
arts ces
UseCas
data
uoys
harts
her
orting
NM
e 11 Use Case
ort Reporting or to port entry)
ort Reporting to port departure)
MSI & NM
NM (Hydro data)
time Metoc Data
METOC
Charts (authorities)
rts (commercial serv.)
oy Broadcast Service
y Management Service (AtoN)
Route planActive route
Route check's - suggestion - alertsmisation & negocationav: ice + shallow waters)
ion (optimization, revisioncident, hazard)
oute exchange
art Service - charts
art Service - charts
t Service - forecasts
t Service - forecasts
ort Information
ort Informationmercial services
TS Reportingo Route info task 4.6)
RS Reporting
emergency ea)
nitoring
se
Page 28 o
e Link Requir
Transaction Frequency
I(p
Depend of Type of Operation1 per day ?
Depend of Type of Operation1 per day ?
Depend on info type & priority
Depend on info type & priority
Depend on info type & priority
On request
On requestOn event (change)
On requestOn event (change)
1 hOn event (alert)
On event
before leave berthon changeon demand
n, On eventOn request
1h
1h
1h
1h
On request
On request
On eventOn request
Depend on type of operation 1 per day?
On eventOn request
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
rements and
nformation Sizeper transaction)
(maximum)
Traper d
sk
32 x 1 K Byte 32 x 1
32 x 1 K Byte 32 x 1
1‐10 kByte
High data volumes> 1 Mb
?
< 1‐10 kBytes(images ?)
< 1‐10
<150 MB ? <20
?
< 1 kbytes < 1
< 10 Kbytes 10 K
250 bytes 1
1 Kbytes(may be more,
images ?)
1 KBytes 4
1 Kbytes(may be more,
images ?)
?
?
< 10 Kbytes 10 K
32x 1K Byte 32x 1
< 1 kByte < 1
Link Requirements
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
Priority
nsfer day per sitekB
Latency
1 K Byte
1 K Byte
?
1‐4 hours (?)
0 kBytesfew hrs to
several weeks
0 MBfew hrs to
several weeks
1 hS
Days
10 kB
KbytesFew mn to few
hours
1200
?
4800
?
?
?
KbytesFew mn to few
hours
1K Byte
kByteFew mn to few
hours
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
Priority(Distress,Urgent,Safety,RoutineGeneral)
Routine
Routine
Safety
Safety
Routine
RoutineUrgent (on event)
RoutineUrgent (on event)
RoutineUrgent (on event)
RoutineSafety (alert)
Safety
Routine
RoutineUrgent (on event)
Routine
Routine
Routine
Routine
Routine
Routine
RoutineUrgent (on event)
Routine
Urgent
Priority
om
7.5 CanThe candE2 Task 2
• Wi-• WiM• Ce• AIS• VD• MF• MF• Inm• Irid• VS• VD
For descremerging Figure 12larger exc
Smart buoys
Sea Charts
Weather
Port Reporting
MSI & NM
ndidate Caidate carrie2.2 are:
-Fi Max
ellular netwS/ASM
DE-TERR F/HF NBDPF/HF digitamarsat dium SAT DE-SAT
ription of thcommunic
2 show cancel sheet n
Port Reportin(prior to port en
Port Reportin(prior to port dep
MSI & NM
MSI & NM (Hydro
Real time Metoc
METOC
Sea Charts (autho
Sea Charts (commer
Smart buoy Broadca
Smart Buoy Managem(AtoN)
UseCase
arriers ers for the
works (2G,
P l data serv
hese, pleascations tec
ndidate carot suitable
Figure 12 Ex
W
ng ntry)ng arture)
o data)
c Data
orities)
rcial serv.)
st Service
ment Service
communic
3G, LTE)
vice (NAVD
se refer tochnologies.
rriers for se to include
ample Candid
Wi-Fi WiMAX
X X
X X
X X
X X
X X
X X
X X
Page 29 o
cation to s
DAT)
o (E2-T2.2,.
some MSPe in this rep
date Carriers
Cellular networks(2G, 3G,
LTE)
AIS/ASM
X
X
X ASM
X
ASM
X
X
X
ASM
ASM
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
upport the
2016) An
P use caseport.
s for some MS
M VDE-TERR MN
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
Candidate C
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
various se
nalysis rep
s. The full
SP Use Cases
MF/HF NBDP
MF/HF digitadata service(NAVDAT)
Carriers
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
ervices, id
port on ava
list is ava
s
al e Inmarsat
(also C) Iridiu
X X
X X
X X
X X
X X
X X
X X
om
entified by
ailable and
ailable in a
um VSAT VDE-SAT
X X
X
X X
X X
X X
X X
X
X
X
y
d
a
7.6 BasThis chapenvisionecombinati The actuathis report
• (ACMa
• (AC• (E2• (E2
show a se
• Ma• Alm• Loc• Loc
It is judgeservice elthat cannoIn some oMCC and With a fewtop of the Figure 13 make useservices.
ic Commupter makesd serviceson can be
al design ot, however
CCSEAS, ariners SerCCSEAS, 2-T3.1, Ana2-T3.1, D3
et of basic
aritime Mesmanac cal Data Scal Lookup
ed that the ements of ot be standof the use-c
tailored cow exceptioIP layer (R
and Figure of the bas
unication an attemp by T2.4 inused to cr
f the variour, analysis
Service Dervice, 2015Service Dealysis repo.2 Concep
elements
ssaging
ervice p Service
on-board cthe MCC.
dardized incases, the omponentsns (AIS thrRFC1122,
re 14 showsic service
n Services pt to break n to basic create the c
us servicesof various
escription: 5) escription: ort on commptual Mode
in the MCC
componenOthers wil
n a similar specific se
s. rough VHF1989).
w how the vs, partly of
Page 30 o
down the
communicacomplete se
s obviouslyservice de
Maritime S
Maritime Cmunicationl, 2015)
C:
ts for manll require fumanner aservices ma
F), it is ass
various serffered by th
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
services fration servicervice in th
y cannot bescriptions
Safety Info
Cloud, 201n and infra
y of the usurther tailos done for ay be imple
umed that
rvices in thhe MCC an
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
rom the MSces, that sihe Maritime
e predicted, such as:
ormation an
5) structure, 2
se cases caored web sethe MC an
emented as
all of the s
e MSP arend partly b
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
SP and theingle hande Cloud (M
d in the sc
nd Notice t
2015),
an be baseervice com
nd MCC. s a combin
services ar
e anticipateby tailored W
om
e future ded or in MC).
cope of
to
ed on the mponents
nation of
re built on
ed to Web
Sea Charts
Weather
Port Reporti
MSI & NM
Ice ChartsServices
Route data
Smart buoy
VTS & SRS
Port Informat
Port (prior t
Port (prior to p
MS
MSI & NM
Real tim
M
Se
Sea Charts (
Smart buoy B
Smart Buoy M(
RoAct
RouRoute info's - Route optimis
(Ex. Arctic nav:
Route informationincide
Route
Ice Chart S
Ice Chart S
Ice Chart Se
Ice Chart Se
Port I
Port IComme
VTS (see also Ro
SRS
s
ng
UseCase
a
ys
S
Self-organizing eme(Arctic area)
ion
Emission Monito
Figure 1
Reporting to port entry)Reporting
port departure)
SI & NM
M (Hydro data)
me Metoc Data
METOC
a Charts
(commercial serv.)
Broadcast Service
Management Service (AtoN)
oute plantive route
ute checksuggestion - alerts
sation & negocationice + shallow waters)
n (optimization, revision, ent, hazard)
e exchange
Service - charts
Service - charts
ervice - forecasts
ervice - forecasts
Information
Informationercial services
Reportingoute info task 4.6)
Reporting
ergency )
oring
13 Basic Com
Data Source
on-board adm
on-board adm
Shore Authoriti
Shore Authoriti
Shore Authoriti
Commercial en
Shore Authoriti
Commercial en
Smart Buoy
Off-shore installa
Ship
Shore AuthoritiVTS services
Commercial ProvPilot
VTS services
Ship
Shore Authoriti
Commercial Prov
Shore Authoriti
Commercial Prov
Port authorities (not iPort organisatio
Commercial entPort organisatio
Ships sensors/deSmart Buoys sensors
Shore control sta
Shore Authoriti
Ships
Ships
Data to
Page 31 o
mmunication
eU
(what e(what
min Shore
min Shore
es S
es S
es S
ntity S
es S
ntity S
SOff-shore
tions A
Shore VTS
essvider
s
es S
vider S
es S
vider S
n Effic.2)ons S
itiesons S
evicess/devicestions
Shore Shipping
ies S
S
SS
be available electronic
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
Services for
Usageequipment)endpoint)
MM
Authorities X
Authorities X
Ships X
Ships X
Ships X
Ships X
Ships
Ships
Shipse installations X
AtoN X
AuthoritiesS centersShip
X
Ship X
Ship X
Ship X
Ships X
Ships X
Ships X
Ships X
Ships
Ships
Authoritiesg Companies
Ships X
Shore X
ShipsShore
cally
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
the MSP
MS Almanac LLS
X X X
X X X
X
X
X X X
X X X
X X
X X
X
X
X X X
X X X
X X X
X
X X X
X X X
X X X
X X X
X X
X X
X X X
X X X
?
Base Com
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
S LDS WEB
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
munication Service
om
B AIS
7.6.1 GeA web sertherefore JSON. ThThe term integratingstandardsto transferwhat serv
7.6.2 DaThe Data/shore or fsimply mehandled bthe qualityThe Data/data/file trdestinatio
Vessel tracking
Voyage Safety monitoring
Ro
Voyage efficiency monitoring
Vessel Performance
analysis
Ship’s system performance
M
Ship’s system performance
and maintenance
analysis
an
Cargo monitoring
V
Ship’s spares and logistics
Text Communication
eneric Webrvice is as a basic se
he service c"Web servg Web-bass over an Inr the data,
vices are av
ata Service/File Servicfrom shoreeans that thby a basic ry of service/File servicransport ca
on endpoint
Ship to S
Ship to Shore S
AIS
oute + Tracking + Safeconditions and
Tracking + Nav Data +dynamic ves
Consolidated data pacshore based performa
plannin
Monitoring of vessel syand alar
Consolidated data pacnalysis of vessels syste
maintenance
Volumes/weight, enviroetc.
UseCase
Figure
b Service defined by
ervice implecan be RE
vice" as gesed applicanternet proWSDL is u
vailable.
e ce is a bas to ship. Thhe size of request/rese providedce is envisian be initiats as well a
Ship
Ship to Ship
ety alarms + loading d stability
+ Fuel + static and ssel data
ckage needed for ance analysis and ng
ystem performance rms
ckage needed for em performance and
planning
onmental conditions
e 14 Basic Co
y W3C Weemented u
EST complinerally undations usinotocol backused for de
sic service he term larthe data tosponse we by e.g. VSoned to be
ated by speas other re
Data Source
Ships
Ship/Shore
Ship
Ship
Ship
Ship
Ship
Ship
Ship
Shore
Data to b
Page 32 o
ommunicatio
eb Service using standiant or not.derstood, d
ng the XMLkbone. XMescribing t
that is ablerger conteno be transpeb service SAT, VDESe of a “bacecification equirement
U(what (wha
Sh
be available electroni
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
n Services fo
Architectudards such . describes aL, SOAP, WL is used the service
e to transpnt is a semported is ofin a robustS.
ckground” nof content ts to the pa
Usageequipment)t endpoint)
Ships
hip/Shore
Shore
Shore
Shore
Shore
Shore
Shore
Shore
Ship
ically
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
or MSP
re Workingas HTTP,
a standardWSDL and to tag the ds available
port larger cmi-undefinef a size that manner d
nature in thidentificati
articular tra
MMS Almanac
X
X
Base C
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
g Group, a HTML, XM
dized way oUDDI ope
data, SOAe and UDD
content froed measureat is too bigdue to the
he sense thion, sourceansport in a
LLS LDS
Communication Serv
om
nd ML and
of en P is used
DI lists
om ship to e. It g to be nature of
hat a e and a request
WEB AIS
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
vice
to the Datclient wheBoth sourcertain amcontent. The simplclient plusto the FTPthe client Several Sfor transpprovide arouts whenservices tSimilar meis to work
7.6.3 BroWe have acknowledstation trabroadcastIt is envisito “subscrchannel. For inspiraa referencthe Really In (ACCS(MMS) is a certain gfiltering ap
7.7 DatSince the MSP menhave provlanguage JPEG200Other worNotice to
ta/File Serven the transrce and desmount of st
lest implems a serviceP server anof complet
SATCOM porting largere that the n transportypically maethods shoacross VD
oadcast Mdefined brodgement o
ansmitting vt of data inioned that ribe” to the
ation to arcce to similay Simple S
EAS, Servdescribed geographicpplied on m
a Formatfirst versio
ntioned in cvided seveand allows0. rks, such aMariners S
vice, and tsport has cstination etorage cap
mentation o that enabnd the FTPtion and lo
providers aer data ammethods u
ting larger ake use ofould be conDES.
Message Soadcasting
of receptionvoiced fore
nformation for receive
e broadcas
chitectural ar broadcayndication
vice Descriusing geo
cal area. Tmessages
ts on of the (Ichapter 7.6ral additions for encod
as (ACCSEService, 20
hen the secompletedndpoints thacity, enou
of such a sles clients
P client to “cation of th
re offering mounts to/frused are odata amou
f advancednsidered w
Service g as a distrn. The servecasts via via availab
ers to be at stations,
design of st services (RSS), als
ption: Mar-casting, a
The basic Bbroadcast
HO, 2009)6 and the wns/extensioding langua
EAS, Servic015) and (A
Page 33 o
ervice will t. hat supporugh to sup
service couto request
“get” the filhe transpo
file transprom the sh
overcomingunts, especd TCP spoowith respec
ribution of vice type isVHF radio
ble data exble to recesimilar to t
a Broadcas that haveso called W
ritime Cloua broadcasBroadcast
could also
) S100 stanwork in e-Nons to S10ages such
ce DescripACCSEAS
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
take care o
rt this servpport the pr
uld containt files to bele from theorted file.
port/synchrhip. The vag the problecially in areofing and vct to the MC
informatios similar to
o. The new xchange coeive broadctuning into
ast Message been devWeb Feeds
d, 2015), asting methoMessage So be a solu
ndard wasNavigation 00. S100 d as XML, G
ption: Marit, S-100 Pr
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
of the trans
ice must ofroviders an
a FTP sere transferree server an
ronisation slue added ems with laeas of poovarious typC data serv
n to multipo an autom
element hommunicatcast inform the specif
ge Serviceveloped fors.
a Maritime od addressService wittion here.
publishedprojects lik
defines a cGML, HDF
time Safetyroduct Des
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
sport and n
of course cond consum
rver and a ed from thend when do
services asthat these
atency andorer link quapes of comrvice, espe
ple clients wmated weathere is thattions chan
mation, theyfic VHF rad
, it is worthr the W3C,
Messaginsing receivth geograp
d, several wke the Monconceptual F-5, ISO 82
y Informatiscription: M
om
notify the
ontain a mers of the
FTP e source one, notify
s means e services d drop-ality. The pression.cially if it
without her t it is the nels. y will havedio
h to make namely
g Service ers within
phic
works on nalisa 1&2 schema
211 and
on and Maritime
Safety Infon the S1In generasuch as JenhancedIt is not inthat the arservices.
7.8 ViewTo be suranalysed
• • • • • • •
With the cthat analystakehold
8 StakThe Efficiecommunica sub-comrequiremeboard arc
formation / 00 standal, the XMLSON and B
d efficiency the scoperchitecture
wpoints fre that all afrom the v
Context FunctionaInformatioConcurrenDevelopmDeploymeOperation
current statysis. Thereer concern
keholdeenSea2 prcation frammponent suents for thehitecture.
Notice to rd. schemas BISON are
y. e of this doe must sup
for the difaspects areviewpoints
al onal ncy
ment ent nal
te of the defore a mor
ns as given
er Identroject has bmework for upporting te framewor
Mariners S
are the doe becoming
cument to port any of
fferent see considereas set out
efinitions ore intuitive n in chapte
tificatiobeen setupthe maritim
that framewrk, the wor
Page 34 o
Service, 20
ominant weg increasin
define datf the data f
rvices ed for the sin chapter
of the varioapproach
er 10.
on p in such ame cloud, work. Sincerk of WP3 w
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
015) base t
eb service ngly used o
ta formats formats us
services der 6.
ous serviceneeds to b
a way, that and as suce WP3 muwill also pr
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
the data fo
data formaon the basi
further. It csed in the d
efined in M
es, it is too be applied
WP3 devech the on-bust collect irovide requ
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
ormats dev
ats althougis of claime
can be condefinition o
MSP, they h
early to cowhen ded
elops the board archnput and d
uirements f
om
veloped,
gh formats ed
ncluded of web-
have to be
onduct ucing
hitecture is develop for the on-
e
9 PersAn architethat are uthat requir The follow
• Low• Re• Cy
9.1 LowPresentlyas navigabased comand AIS. Within botsolutions Furthermosubstantiashould bewhich hassafe data With the elittle standarchitectuTo validatmap of theoverview.
9.2 ReqMany discarchitectu An Open
• Thefun
• Thedef
spectiveectural perssed to ensre conside
wing perspe
w impact Inequirementber Securi
w impact I, the stand
ation sensommunicatio
th the naviare still do
ore, it is noally, conside possible ts been put platforms.
existing madardizationures and thte the cande existing
quirementcussions caure means.
architectur
e architectnctionality e architectfined and p
es spective is
sure that a eration acro
ectives hav
ntegration t of an “opeity Conside
Integratiodardization ors in the IEon betwee
igation, autominant.
ot expecteddering bothto integrateinto estab
agnitude ofn, it is impohe existing didate archinstalled b
t of an “oan be initia This chap
re means:
ture suppo
ture is basepreferably
s a collectiosystem ex
oss a numb
ve been id
with existien” and haerations.
on with exof the on-
EC61162 sn sensors
tomation a
d that the ah the magne into the Mlishing and
f the instalortant to uninstalled b
hitectures uase to at le
pen” andated on whpter describ
rts easy ex
ed on funchave open
Page 35 o
on of archixhibits a paber of the s
dentified to
ng infrastrarmonized
xisting infboard data
series of stand data u
and commu
advent of tnitude of thMaritime Cd maintaini
led base onderstand tbase. using this peast a top
harmonihat the requbes the as
xpansion w
ctional elemn source im
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
tectural acarticular sesystems a
be relevan
ucture andarchitectur
frastructua infrastructandards, tusers, suc
unication d
he Maritimhe installedCloud, but aing the pre
of on-boardthe gap be
perspectivelevel topol
zed archiuirement osumptions
with and im
ments with mplementa
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
ctivities, tacet of relatedrchitectura
nt for E2 T
d architecture
ure and arcture is mothat cover sh as RADA
domains on
me Cloud w base, whi
also the veesent effec
d data infraetween sug
e, it is impoogy and da
tecture of an open made in T
mplementat
interfacestion examp
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
ctics and gd quality pral views.
Task 2.4:
ure
rchitectuostly in areaserial and AR, ECDIS
n ships, pro
will change ich it in any
ery substanctive, efficie
astructuresggested ca
ortant to pata commu
and harmoTask 2.4.
tion of add
s that are pples.
om
guidelines roperties
re as such network
S, VDR
oprietary
this y case ntial effort ent and
s with very andidate
roduce a unications
onized
ditional
publicly
Harmonizproperties Context pHarmonizFunctionaHarmonizInformatioelements.HarmonizOperation Note, thatbe standa
9.3 CybThe Cybedo so, as of securitysociety on The only s(IEC6116 Europeananalysis opolicies an Currently,on the are BIMCO ha(BIMCO, 2Intercargo American applicatioThis note Both BIMCsecurity, a The originElectrotec
zed architecs are define
properties dzed contextal propertiezed functiononal proper.
zed informanal properti
t the aboveardised.
ber Securiter Security
the world oy breachesn land, sea
standards 2-450, 201
n Network aof cyber send recomm
, there are ea.
as in Janua2016). Theo and Inter
Bureau ofn of cyber is indicate
CO and ABas well as t
nal and ongchnical Com
cture meaned by exist
describe hot properties
es describenal propertrties descr
ational propies describ
e does not
ty Considstandardsof intercons and their a, air and s
found, tha11) and (IE
and Informecurity aspemendations
suggestio
ary 2016 pe guidelinertanko, and
f Shipping security p
ed to be the
BS are refethe ISO/IE
going workmmission i
ns that its ting and / o
ow architecs then mea
e the functities then mribe what in
perties thebe how the
mean that
derations area is co
nnected IT effects arepace.
t relate dirEC61162-4
mation Secuects in the s in the Ma
ns to IMO
published Ges are prodd several o
(ABS) hasrinciples toe first in a s
erencing thEC 27000 s
k of the ISAin producin
Page 36 o
context, fuor upcomin
ctural eleman: use of ion of arch
mean: requnformation
en mean: se architectu
t e.g. all fu
omplex andsystems a
e continuin
rectly to cy460, 2015).
urity Agencmaritime s
aritime Sec
and work
Guidelines duced and other organ
s February o marine aseries.
he NIST sestandards.
A99 commng the mult
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
unctional, inng areas fo
ments interstandardisitectural el
uirement of is exchan
tandardiseure will be o
nctionality
d growing, and devicesng to provid
ber securit.
cy (ENISAsector, cleactor. (ENIS
initiated fo
on Cyber supported
nisations an
2016 pubnd offshore
eries of sta
ittee is beiti-standard
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
nformationor standard
act. sed protocoements.
f standardisged betwe
ed data formoperated w
of the arch
and will prs are devede a sourc
ty on-board
) has prodarly identify
SA, 2011)
r producin
Security Oby BIMCO
nd compan
lished a gue operation
andards rel
ng utilizedd IEC 6244
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
nal and opedisation.
ols.
sed functioeen archite
rmats. when active
hitecture n
robably coeloping. Thce of risks t
d are the
uced a repfying the ne
g recomm
On-board SO, CLIA, ICnies.
uidance nons (ABS, 2
lated to cy
d by the Int43 series. A
om
erational
onality. ectural
e.
needs to
ntinue to e history to our
port on eed for
endations
Ships CS,
ote on the 2016).
ber
ernational Although
not a specAutomatio– Informasystems –security th IHO has cbe the basDPSWG) for 2018 pto include Since the strategy fostandardssystems acontrols, lcommunic The requi
In Figure have diffestakehold In (MARINdiscussedcarriers an
cific maritimon and Contion techno– Requiremhreats in th
created andseline for aare draftin
publishing.e placehold
work on cor Task 2.4s and recomareas alongike use of cation.
red securit
Figur
15 the threerent requirers.
NTECH, 20d. Partly asnd partly a
me standantrol Systeology – Se
ments, bothhe maritime
d maintainall IMO e-Nng cyber se The S-100
ders for dig
cyber secur4 is to basemmendatiog with comfirewalls, g
ty levels de
re 15 Three a
ee areas, Srements fo
009) securs a summaa discussio
rd, the ISAems (IACS)ecurity techh of which e context.
ns the baseNavigation.ecurity to b0 metadata
gital signatu
rity will bee the cybeons, as we
mmon IT prgateways,
epend on t
reas with diff
Safety relaor control o
rity issues rary classificn of some
Page 37 o
A/IEC 6244) Security ahniques – Iare releva
eline S-100. Within IHbe includeda will alreaures.
on-going ier security cell as standractices forauthentica
the on-boa
ferent Securit
ted, Commof cyber sec
related to scation of diremedial a
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
43 series aand complnformationnt to the re
0 standard HO two wod into the Sady amend
n the timefconsiderat
dards applier implemenation, autho
ard function
ty requireme
mercial/Buscurity and
ship to shoifferent typactions tha
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
addresses ements IS
n security mesponse to
which is srkgroups (
S-100 baseed for edit
frame of Eftions on theed in the IT
ntation of riorization a
nal areas.
nts (SINTEF,
siness andsimilarly d
ore commue of satelli
at can be ta
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
Industrial SO/IEC 270managemeo potential
selected by(S100WG aeline most tion 2.1.0 p
fficienSea2e above mT and Conisk mitigatind encrypt
2005)
d Entertainifferent
unication isite commuaken.
om
001:2013 ent cyber
y IMO to and probably
publishing
2, the mentioned
trol ion ted
ment
s nication
In Figure different lestandard tthe (IEC6functional
9.3.1 UsThe directcommunic
• Discouaga
• Thereq
However, communic
• Ro• Sta
info• The• Ow
ma
9.3.2 UsBoth ABSmanagemThe frame
16 a typicaevels of sethat specif1162-460,ity and is t
er Needs t requiremecation and
sruption of uld affect aainst Cybee level of pquired for t
the consocation and
ole based aandardizedormation ae infrastruc
wnership ofanaged
ing the NIS and BIMCment. ework amo
Figure 16 Ty
al security ecurity requfies a firew 2015) whethen called
describedents extracinfrastruct
infrastructa large poper Security protection shose syste
olidated listinfrastruct
access cond function(sare neededcture mustf informatio
IST FrameCO discuss
ongst other
ypical Securit
implementuirements
wall to use fere the fire
d a 460-Ga
d by E2, Wcted from tture, 2015)
ture functiopulation of risks should be ems that de
t of user neture, 2015)
ntrol (authes) for valida
t provide ston element
ework for Is the use o
rs contains
Page 38 o
ty Implement
tation is share separafor on-boarewall functiateway.
WP3 the conclus) are the fo
ons due to users, and
at least eqepend on t
eeds in (E2) has the fo
entication aation of au
tandardizets, and aut
Improvingof the NIST
s the four e
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
tation (MARIN
hown. The ated using rd securityionality is c
sion in (E2ollowing:
hacking od thus such
quivalent tothe infrastr
2-T3.1, Anollowing cy
and authoruthenticity a
ed means tthorization
g Critical IT framewor
elements:
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
NTECH, 2009)
different sfirewalls. S
y control hacombined w
2-T3.1, Ana
r other typh services
o the level ructural fun
alysis repoyber securi
isation) and integri
to support to pass it
nfrastructrk for cybe
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
)
sections wiSince 2009as emergedwith a gate
alysis repo
pes of cybeshould be
of protectinctions.
ort on ity related
ity of trans
encryptionon must b
ture Cyber security r
om
th 9, a new d, namely eway
ort on
er-attacks protected
on
needs:
ferred
n of data e
rsecurityrisk
• Ideasseeffecritprioof oGov
• Proinfra poAccPro
• DetcybExaCon
• Rescyb
9.3.3 CyRisk identoperationsIt is imporunderstan Many diffeon-board
• Ba• De• Dir• Eav• Sp• Tam• Info• Priv• Exp• So• Ma• Ide• Pa
entify – Devets, data, anective use oftical functionoritize its effoutcome Catvernance; Rotect – Deverastructure sotential cybecess Control
ocedures; Matect – Develbersecurity eamples of ountinuous Mospond – Devbersecurity e
yber Securtification iss and datartant to addnd what thr
erent Cybearchitectur
ckdoors enial-of-Serrect-accessvesdroppinoofing mpering ormation Dvilege Escploits cial Engine
alware entity Theftssword Att
velop the orgd capabilitief the Framewns and the re
fforts, consistegories with
Risk Assessmelop and impservices. Theersecurity evl; Awarenesaintenance; lop and impevent. The Dutcome Cateonitoring; anvelop and im
event.
rity Risk Ids the procea and the pd that the preats that i
er Security re are liste
rvice s ng
Disclosure calation
eering
t tacks
ganizational es. The activwork. Underelated cyberstent with itshin this Fun
ment; and Riplement the e Protect Funvent. Examps and Trainiand Protectilement the a
Detect Functiegories withind Detectionmplement th
dentificatiss of deter
possible ouprocess incs relevant.
threats exed here.
Page 39 o
understandivities in the Irstanding thersecurity risks risk managnction includisk Managemappropriate
unction suppples of outcoing; Data Seive Technolappropriate aion enables in this Func
n Processes. he appropriat
ion rmining ris
utcomes cludes und.
xist and ne
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
ing to managIdentify Fune business cks enables angement stratede: Asset Mament Strateg safeguards orts the abilome Categorecurity; Inforogy. activities to timely discotion include
te activities
ks that cou
derstanding
w are appe
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
ge cybersecunction are foontext, the rn organizatiegy and busianagement; Bgy.
to ensure deity to limit ories within thrmation Pro
identify the overy of cybe: Anomalies
to take actio
uld potentia
g vulnerab
earing. A f
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
urity risk to oundational fresources thion to focus iness needs.Business En
elivery of cror contain ththis Functionotection Proc
occurrence bersecurity es and Events
on regarding
ally impact
ilities and
few relevan
om
systems, for at support and . Examples nvironment;
ritical he impact ofn include: cesses and
of a events. s; Security
g a detected
t system
to
nt to an
f
It is advisasources o
• UnThr
• http• ii) U• http• http• iii)
ConSP
• http• iv)
Lan• http
env201
9.3.4 Mit
9.3.4.1 MSome equprovided bcommunic Here we c
• 611equpub
• “Lethestacon
9.3.4.2 UThe 460 nbe preferacloud. Theaccessed uncontroll
able to useof threat inf
ited States Nreat Informap://csrc.nistUnited Statep://www.dhp://www.dhUnited Stat
ntrolled Un800-171, Ju
p://nvlpubs.European Undscape 201ps://www.evironment/14/at_dow
tigation of
Mission criuipment wiby the Marcating with
can identify
162-460 couipment is blished recegacy” eque Maritime atus of safenfigured fo
Uncontrollenetwork proable to alloe Maritimefrom an u
led networ
e Threat Information:
National Insation Sharin.gov/publices Departm
hs.gov/topichs.gov/topictes Nationa
nclassified Inun 2015. .nist.gov/nisUnion Agen14, Jan 201enisa.europ/enisa-thre
wnload/fullR
f Cyber Se
itical equipithin the naritime Clou such equi
y two extre
ompliant every rare t
cently. uipment coCloud ava
ety and secor this purp
ed equipmovides sec
ow the conne Cloud is sncontrolled
rks include
ntelligence
stitute of Stng, SP 800-ations/draft
ment of Hom/informatio/cybersecurl Institute o
Information
stpubs/Specncy for Netw5. pa.eu/activat-landsca
Report
ecurity Ris
pment avigation syd. IEC-611ipment.
emes in the
quipment itoday due
nnected inailable for thcurity. A fiose.
ment curity but anection ofsupposed td network.
Page 40 o
(ABS, 201
tandards and-150, Draft,ts/800-150/s
meland Secuon-sharing rity-informaof Standards
in Nonfede
cialPublicatwork and In
vities/risk-mape/enisa-t
sks using
ystem, for 162-460 de
e range of
inside a futo the fact
n legacy nehis equipmrewall dev
also placessome nonto provide Examples
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
16) by cons
d Technolog Oct 2014. sp800_150_
urity, “Inform
ation-sharins and Techneral Informa
ions/NIST.Snformation S
managemethreat-land
460-Gate
example, efines a sta
available e
lly compliat that the -4
etworks. It ment withouvice like the
many rest-critical eqcybersecu
s of applica
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
sulting and
gy (NIST),
_draft.pdf mation Shar
ng nology (NISation System
SP.800-171Security (EN
ent/evolvinscape-
ways
will requireandardized
equipment
ant 460-net460 standa
should be ut degradine 460-Gate
trictions. Inuipment di
urity, so it cations that
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
d monitor t
Guide to Cy
ring,” curre
ST), Protectms and Orga
1.pdf NISA), ENI
g-threat-
e access tod solution f
t:
twork. Sucard has be
possible tong their cueway could
n some casirectly withcan be safecould be u
om
he various
Cyber
ent.
ting anizations,
ISA Threat
o data for
ch en
o make rrent
d be
ses it may h the ely used in
s
• e-N• Ap• Ap
Uncontroldirect con From the ConnectioGateway, (DMZ) to The use cdata (e.g. equipmen Two ways
• Mofromeveof t
• SetDeeasnet
The latter defined inhand, the
9.3.5 DeThe on-boThe only a2015) stansystem lothe mentio The architpredict thetemporary
Navigation plication foplication fo
led equipmnnections s
point of vieon between
by settingtransfer da
cases are b automated
nt in uncon
s to use the
ove files recm equipmeen by meathe marinet up autom
efine a metsily (or auttworks.
r method isn advance.
former me
etect and Roard architavailable bndards. Thg informatoned stand
tecture mue nature ofy isolation
prototype or browsingor managin
ment may usuch as HT
ew of 6116n such a n
g up an appata files.
basically red reports).trolled netw
e files insid
ceived froment inside tns of remo
er comparematic transfhod or contomatically
s preferableIt is more
ethod will a
Respond ttecture neebuilding blohese, amonion. To supdards.
ust providef the requirof safety c
display terg Maritimeng subscrip
use the DMTTPS.
62-460, theetwork andplication se
eception of Interactivworks.
de 460-net
m the Clouthe 460 neovable meded with currfer of data nvention to) found an
e, and not difficult to
always be a
to Cyber Seds to enabocks are thngst otherspport detec
means forred responcritical netw
Page 41 o
rminal e Service Pptions to se
MZ inside 4
e maritime d 460 netwerver within
f data (e.gve commun
twork:
ud manualletwork. Thidia. It will wrent practicfrom the C
o organize d accesse
difficult to make it exavailable a
Security Bble functio
he (IEC611s, contain rcting breac
r respondinnses. Shortworks.
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
Portfolio Reervices of t
460-gatewa
cloud is aworks is pon the gatew
. chart updnication ne
y into the Ds can be d
work, but itces.
Cloud to thedata in thed from the
do if the dxtensible foas a fall-ba
Breaches ns to detec62-450, 20requiremeches, the a
ng to secut term resp
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
egistry the Maritim
ay, but the
n uncontrossible throway's dem
dates, MSI)eeds can p
DMZ, and done by net will not re
e DMZ throe DMZ such equipmen
ata to be tor new servack.
ct cyber se011) and thnts for equ
architecture
rity breachponses wou
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
me Cloud
ey could als
olled netwoough the 46ilitarized z
) and sendperhaps be
then accesetwork acceeduce the w
ough netwh that it ca
nt inside 46
transferredrvices. On t
ecurity breahe (IEC61uipment to e must the
hes. One culd e.g. inc
om
so use
ork. 60-one
ding of left to
ss them ess or workload
work. an be 60
d is well the other
aches. 162-460, provide n support
cannot clude
In many ccomponenrequired t In summaconfigurat
9.3.6 CyGiven, theneeds idethe availaThe Archimust cont This could
• Pla• De• De
elema
Making us
cases, the nts and eso update t
ary, the arction and so
yber Secure perspectentified in (able standatectural Catain sufficie
d be achiev
acing (IEC6escribing Gescribing stements andaritime clou
se of the N
long term rpecially thhe softwar
chitecture moftware/firm
rity Concluive “RequiE2-T3.1, A
ards for secandidates ent Securit
ved by:
61162-460Gateway funtandardized between ud.
NIST appro
responsese Firewall/re/firmware
must allow mware.
usion rement of
Analysis recurity risk mneeds to bty control m
0, 2015) Firnctionality d methodsarchitectu
oached des
Page 42 o
s require co/Gateway ce of the co
w for efficien
an “open” port on comitigation, be validatemechanism
rewall/Gatethat enabl
s to encrypral elemen
scribed in c
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
onfiguratiocomponenmponents.
nt and safe
and harmommunicatisuch as (Id against C
ms to enab
eways at ses use of r
pt communnts and the
chapter 9.3
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
n updates ts. In other
e update of
onized archon and infrEC61162-Cyber Secle mitigatio
strategic plrole basedication bet
e off-board
3.2 in the v
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
of the netwr cases, it
of compone
hitecture” frastructure-460, 2015curity threaon of the ris
aces in thed access cotween archelements
validation.
om
work is
ent
, the user e, 2015), 5), ts and sks.
e topologyontrol hitectural in the
10 StaThis chaprequireme
10.1 WPAnalysingthat it con
keholdpter describents for the
P3 User Neg (E2-T3.1,ntains a set
er Concbes the rese recomme
eed analy Analysis rt of consol
cerns (Rsult of analended on-b
ysis report on cidated list
Page 43 o
Requirelysis of Staboard arch
communicaof user ne
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
ments)akeholder iitecture.
ation and ineds. See
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
nput to dev
nfrastructu
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
velop a se
ure, 2015)
om
et of
reveals
Appendix The follow
• The• MC• T2• Arc
Se• Me
Me• Me
(Lo• Me• Arc
(sin• Arc
com
10.2 ReqThis chaprequiremeimplemenPlease nonot mean mark a re The segm
• • • •
In (Rødse17). The fdescriptioand the sesegmenta
A.
wing list is t
e ArchitectCC must be.3 Roaminchitecture mrvice
essage Traessaging Sessage Traoss of Servessage Trachitecture tngle point ochitecture mmmunicatio
quiremenpter analyseents that wntation of thote that thro
requiremequirement
mentation o
PrioritisatAvoidanceCyber SecAllowing d
eth, Christefollowing c
on of the layegmentatio
ation requir
the set of d
ture must be present ag must be must supp
ansport ProService) ansport Provice) ansport Protopology mof failure) amust suppon must no
ts deducees a typica
will enable phe requiredoughout th
ent originatfor the rec
of the on-bo
ion of traffie of congecurity risk different lev
ensen, & Lhapters anyered abston on eachrements.
deduced re
be able to as AE present asort distribu
otocol mus
otocol mus
otocol musmust not byareas. ort offline oot be affec
ed from Aal network proper cybd classes ohis chapterting from acommende
oard netwo
ic accordinestion (overmitigationsvels of sec
ee) layerednd networktraction. Hoh layer are
Page 44 o
equiremen
support st
s AE ution of bro
st support r
st support c
st support ey method o
or "silent mcted by on-
Analysis ostructure o
ber securityof servicesr, when thea resolutioned architec
ork is steer
ng to imporrloading) s curity
d network k segmentaowever, thbeing disr
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
nts for the o
andardized
oadcasts m
reception o
compressio
encryptionor impleme
mode" requline/off-line
of typical non-board ay risk mitiga from the m
e term REQn or standacture to be
red by requ
rtance
architectuation, doeshe specific regarded d
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
on-board a
d encryptio
made by Ma
of acknowle
on and con
ntation cha
uired functie state
network ta ship, and ations as wmaritime seQUIREMENard, but a nproposed
uirements
re is beings not contrause of VPNue to abov
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
architecture
on protoco
aritime Me
edge (Mar
ntinue afte
ange state
ionality. I.e
topology proposes
well as alloervice portNT is notednotation usby this rep
for:
g presentedadict the geN and Gatve mention
om
e:
ls
essaging
ritime
r LOS
e of SPOF
e. Inter AE
ow for tfolio. d, it does
sed to port.
d (Figure eneral eways
ned
In this ana
• Acc• Ad• Sh
In (SINTEnot found The Navigcontrol of ensure thenavigationGateways
10.2.1 TraControllinthat e.g. sadministraAttacks. For the paable to disdecisionsas mitigatDenial of
Fig
alysis, the
commodatministratioip Operatio
EF, 2005), d.)
gation and each dome networksn system as – or by de
affic Segmg segment
safety relatative traffic
art of the trstinguish th. Separatintion. If VLAService At
gure 17 Layer
following d
tion (Crewon on
Security re
Automatiomain’s intern
s are not cand automaedicated s
mentation tation of trated traffic isc – or pass
raffic that ishe origin/dng the netwAN’s are usttacks with
red network a
domains w
, Passenge
equirement
on systemsnal networongested. ation systeerial lines
affic to/froms not suffe
senger traff
s to be rouestination
work domasing the saorigin from
Page 45 o
architecture (
will be used
er and Info
ts are bein
s are requirk is cruciaTypically t
em (engine62162-1 a
m the diffeering from nfic and to r
uted to/fromof the traff
ains by usiname physicm e.g. Pas
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
(Rødset, Chri
d:
otainment)
ng discusse
red to be sl - both for there are in
e) sometimnd -2
rent domanetwork coreduce sec
m shore, thfic to be abng VLAN iscal connectsenger net
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
istensen, & L
ed (Error!
separate dsecurity re
nterconneces by usin
ins is vital ongestion dcurity risk o
he T2.3 roable to makes often mistion, it will t.
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
Lee)
Reference
omains wheasons anctions betwg -450 and
– both to edue to loweof Denial o
aming neede the right stakenly benot mitigat
om
e source
here full d to
ween e.g. d -460
ensure er priority f Service
ds to be roaming
eing used te risk of
Due to thiseparate p
• Acc• Ad• Sh
10.2.2 CoQuality of controlledChapter 7service reservices, quality of Today, theaccountinquotas forcommunicavailable transfer ofspecific ac To be ablescenariosVSAT covbandwidthT2.3 RoamService apgiven time An idea oService atcould be uIt could pausers). It might alimplemen It can be ccontrol of
s, there is physical po
commodatministrativip operatio
ontrol of Qf Service (Qd. 7.3 Link Reequirementin the domservice tha
e SatCom g, where mr users andcation linksquota, banf data and ccount in t
e to contros varying froverage andh constrainming functpplicationse, to be ab
riginating fttributes cautilized. artly be im
lso be anticntation in m
concluded Quality of
a REQUIRorts and ne
tion (Crewe networks
on network
Quality of SQoS) for co
equirements to the co
main of vesat can be p
providers managemed for M2M s, if we focndwidth anthen just g
the given c
ol and provom poor q
d all the wants with Witionality thas need to hle to make
from SatCoan be assig
plemented
cipated thamany of the
that it is RService.
REMENT tetwork seg
, Passenges
ks (Safety
Service ommunicat
nts and 7.4ommunicatsel monitoprovided by
offer servient can concommunic
cus on M2Md priority. Tget the actcommunica
vide the apuality in thay to excel-Fi and GSat can implhave knowle the right d
om providegned, acco
d by T2.3 R
at the MC/e MSP app
REQUIRED
Page 46 o
that the Effgments for
er and Info
related)
tion to/from
4 Priority prtion links fooring and Vy the comm
ces that hantrol allocacations. In M accountsThe M2M tual qualityation scena
propriate qe arctic arelent quality
SM 3G/LTElement thisledge of thdecisions w
ers, havingompanied w
Roaming an
MCC couldplications in
D that the a
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
ficienSea2:
otainment)
m the MSP
rovide an ior the varioVTS servicemunication
ave user aation of banthis scena
s, are not pclients nee
y of serviceario.
quality of seas to highy with veryE, it is envis on its owhe availablewhen comm
g M2M accwith a QoS
nd partly b
d centralizen the M2M
architecture
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
Task 2.3 r
P services n
ndication oous servicees, adaption links, will
nd machinndwidth, prario, the clieprovided wed to atteme that can b
ervice in thh quality ary low latencsioned than. The eleme quality ofmunication
counts to wS managem
by the appli
e functionamode
e supports
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
roaming m
needs to b
of the quales. For somon to the acbe require
ne2machinriority and ents (users
with informampt connecbe provided
he commureas with gcy and lowat it is not oments of thf service an is require
which Qualiment funct
ications (M
ality that co
s implemen
om
must have
be
ity of me of the ctual
ed.
e data s) of the ation of ction and d for the
nication good
w only the he t any
ed.
ity of ionality,
M2M
ould ease
ntation of
10.2.3 ShThe ship o
• Aut• Na• Saf
10.2.3.1 There ma
• En• En• Ca
In many csuppliers connectedother systfollows (IE The operaGateway/Denial of Further it functional It is REQUIEC61162automatioThis is durequire all
10.2.3.2 The navigRevised P(MSC.86(and the IE Most navithe (IEC6Integrated The (MSC
ip Operatoperation n
tomation Navigation fety, Secu
Automatay be multip
gine Automergy Autom
argo Autom
cases, e.g. of the systd to that netems as thEC61162-4
ation netwoFirewalls, Service Atis REQUIRity specifie
UIRED tha2-460 Gateon networke to the pelowing end
Navigagation netwPerformanc(70), 1998)EC standar
gation netw1162-450,d Navigatio
C.252(83),
ion netwonetworks c
Networks
rity and Su
tion Netwople Automa
mation mation
mation
these autotems only getwork. The means o450, 2011)
orks are Rthus protettacks. RED to imped by the s
at the architeway, to avk. erspective dpoints for
tion Netwwork is govce Standar) rds coverin
works are 2011) form
on Systems
2007) requ
orks can be divid
upervision
orks ation Netw
omation neguarantee e supplier
of commun.
EQUIREDcting each
plement intstandard.
tecture allovoid direct
of easy intcommunic
work verned by trds for Inte
ng the Integ
proprietaryms the bass.
uire interfa
Page 47 o
ded into cl
works on-bo
etworks arefunctionalmay speci
nicating wit
D to be seph network fr
terface to t
ows for usecommunic
tegration ocation to be
the IMO Reegrated Na
grated Nav
y solutionsse and dire
acing to the
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
asses, suc
oard a ves
e part of a ity with theify and delh the syste
arated usinrom unwan
the networ
e of proxy cation to en
of the recome inside the
esolution (avigation S
vigation Sy
s, normally ection for th
e Central A
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
ch as:
sel, such a
closed syse supplier diver Interfaem. Somet
ng IEC611nted acces
rk functions
services andpoints at
mmended e protected
MSC.252(8ystem, the
ystem.
based on he network
Alert Manag
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
as:
stem wherdelivered eaces (Gatetimes the n
62-460 ss and aga
s via the G
as part of tht entities in
architectud network.
83), 2007)e original
Ethernet. k used in n
gement sy
om
re the equipment eways) to network
ainst
Gateway
he nside the
re that will
) The
However, new
ystem.
To protecSecurity TREQUIRE
10.2.3.3 Safety, Seobtain SafThese netlevel. Thisleading toThese netAccess to460, 2015(MSC.147
10.2.3.4 For type aUsually upthe appro For other It is REQUand firmwable to deallow for fOf courseencryption It is REQUautomated
10.2.4 AdThe ship aand passetypically husing dedremote off It is REQUinternet viThis prevecompany
t the NavigThreats, anED that the
Safety,ecurity andfety and Stworks ares means tho a very lowtworks are
o and from 5) Gateway7(77), 2003
Firmwaapproved epdate on thpriate verif
types of eUIRED tha
ware/softwaeploy Gatewfast reactioe, the connn, authoris
UIRED thad deploym
dministratiadministraenger interhas ability tdicated VPNffice to the
UIRED thaia VPN to sents need network.
gation Netwnd to ensure network i
Security d Supervisiecurity on-
e assumed hat any riskw level of re REQUIRE
these are y/Firewalls3) Revised
are/Softwaequipment,his type of fication of f
quipment, at the architare on certway/Firew
on to securections, anation and a
at the architment of conf
ive Netwotive networnet and froto connect N connectishore bas
at the on-boshore and to manage
work and thre conforms protected
and Supeion Networ-board the to be prote
k assessmisk for thesED to be keREQUIRE ensuring c Performa
are update, the standequipmenfunctionalit
various mtecture supain types oall configurity threatsnd the itemauthentica
tecture mufiguration/f
rks rk is REQUom Safety to shore o
ion and thaed networ
oard adminthrough sh
e a multitud
Page 48 o
he Integramance to thd by (IEC6
ervision Nerks are impvessel.
ected froment of the se networkept separa
ED to be keconformannce Stand
e of equipdards definnt cannot bty after up
ethods of fpports easof equipmerations rap.
ms providedation using
ust allow fofirmware a
UIRED to brelated do
office netwat on-boardk.
nistrative nhore basedde of mobi
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
ted Navigahe performa61162-460,
etworks plementing
m cyber secship netwo
ks. ate from allept under snce to the Iards for a
ment on te the procee done witdate.
firmware/ssy and rapient. Especpidly and in
d in the updigital sign
or implemeand softwar
be a separomains. Thork. It is Rd administ
network ond companyile (on-boa
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
ation Systeance stand, 2015) Ga
g communi
curity threaork should
other netwstrict controMO ResolShip Secu
the operatedures andthout huma
oftware ded deploymially an orgn a comple
date must natures.
entation of re.
rate domaie administEQUIREDrative netw
ly has cony firewall. ard) firewal
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
em from Cydards, it is ateway(s).
ication nee
ats on the hresult in m
works. ol using (IElution urity System
tive netwod methodsan interact
eployment ment of conganisation etely safe m
be secure
services fo
n – both frtration netw
D that this bwork consid
nection to
l entries to
om
yber
eded to
highest mitigations
EC61162-
m.
orks s to follow. ion and
exist. figuration should be
manner, to
e using
or
rom crew work be done dered as
the public
o the
Few gatewmaintain a One can ton one veothers. In this casdedicated In cases wcollect infoIEC61162administra
10.2.5 AcInfotainmeprovide onnetworks priority. Since the network aon the vesSeen fromdomain of To protecAttacks orroaming dPassengestandard sAttacks. The Passoften therBYOD req450 netwo The Pass
10.3 DedFor compobvious re
ways/firewand contro
think of exaessel and e
se, the samd VPN conn
where it is ormation fr
2-460 Gateative netwo
ccommodaent, Passen-board seon a vesse
type of traare not conssel.
m other netf the public
t the T2.3 riginated frdevice imper network specifies th
enger/Crewre is a needquires DHCorks.
enger/Crew
duced, Asleteness oequiremen
walls betweol and thus
amples of each requir
me principlnections to
needed throm the Sheway/Firework.
ation (Infoenger and cervices sucel, the traff
affic that is ntrolled, it is
tworks on tc internet.
roaming arom the Palements deis isolatedhe requirem
w network d to allow fCP (Dynam
w network
ssumed aof the set ofnts.
en the secless prone
multiple opring an adm
e of separao respectiv
at equipmehip operatio
walls config
otainment,crew netwoch as e-mafic to/from
generateds REQUIR
the vessel
nd the restassenger/Cetection an using a IEments nee
cannot befor BYOD (
mic IP Addr
may be im
nd/or obvf requirem
Page 49 o
cure and noe to risks d
perators (cministrative
ation and rve shore ne
ent on the on network
gured to all
, Passengork provide
ail and medthis netwo
d by the eqRED to be c
, the passe
t of the shiCrew netwond protectioEC 61162-4eded for pro
e implemen(Bring Youress alloca
mplemente
vious Reqents, this c
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
on-secure due to mist
companiese network
remote offietworks are
administrak. It is REQlow for con
er and Crees connectdia streamirk are requ
quipment ccompletely
enger netw
ip network ork, it is REon against 460 Gatewotection ag
nted as anur Own Devation) – wh
d as wirele
quirementchapter sta
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
domains aakes.
) with sepaon-board s
ice is requie required.
ative netwoQUIRED thntrolled con
ew networtion to the ng. Compauired to be
onnected ty separate f
work is to b
from DeniEQUIRED such attac
way / Firewgainst Den
IEC61162vice). ich is not a
ess 802.11
ts ates a set o
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
are easier
arate resposeparated
ired. I.e. m.
ork has abhat this is dnnections f
rk) internet anared to the
e given the
to the passfrom other
be conside
ial of Servithat eithercks, or the
wall. The -4nial of Serv
2-450 netw
allowed in
1 networks
of assume
om
to
onsibilities from the
multiple
ility to done usingfrom the
nd may e other lowest
senger r networks
red as the
ce r, the
460 vice
work, since
61162-
.
d and/or
• E2 • SA• E2
10.3.1 CoArchitectuconfiguredship.
10.3.2 OpRegulatiosystems aaccordingoperationa The functiand a com Imagine ifin place. today. The AIS fuservice) a Since the and data fAIS functiIt would ahappen vi With the cAIS would With the cexchangeand implerisks. It shuncertain Since the unit wouldWith connsystem wo
Task 2.1 VAT Broadba
Task 2.3 R
oncurrencyure must sud prioritisa
pening disn 19 of SOand equipmg to ship typal use of s
ion of the Ammunicatio
f the architThen imple
unction woand the oth
(RFC1122formats aronality wit
also very quia VHF cha
current sugd very quic
current suge on some ementing bhould be noand clarific
IP data exd be pronenections onould be in
VDES Comand must bRoaming m
y upport contion and al
scussion oOLAS Chapment - setspe. Resoluhipborne a
AIS can beon of AIS d
tecture andementation
ould quicklyher would b
2, 1989) is e being sph the standuickly becoannels, but
ggestions ockly be func
ggestions iVHF chanoth parts inoted that, acation cou
xchange pa to cyber s
n the AIS prisk.
mmunicatiobe present must be pre
ncurrent prollocated ba
on how AIpter V - Cas out navigaution A.917automatic i
e split in sedata part. T
d network in AIS func
y be split inbe the func
already inpecified as dards, toolome obviout also via b
of the MC actionality im
n the standnels and An one physat this timeld change
art would hsecurity thrpart, directl
Page 50 o
on Functioas AE esent as A
ovision of sandwidth fo
IS functioarriage reqational equ7(22) providentificatio
everal partsThis chapte
infrastructuctionality wo
n two partsction of com
n place andWEB servls and metus that combroadband
and the MCmplemente
dardisationAIS and ASsical unit lee of writingabove sta
have somereats originly into the
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
nality mus
AE
services acor the asso
nality is imuirements uipment tovide guidelion systems
s. One wayer provides
ure, as purould be dif
s. One the mmunicatio
d most of thvices, it wohods availmmunicatiosatellite c
CC messaed using M
n work of VSM data exeads to a c (April 201tement.
e connectionating fromBridge nav
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
t be presen
ccording toociated com
mplementfor shipbobe carriednes for thes (AIS)
y is to haves the ration
rely TCP/Ufferent from
transpondon of AIS d
he worlds iuld be natuable in thaon of AIS dhannels.
ging servicCC messa
VDES, comxchange onconcern for6), the role
on to the pum the internvigation sy
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
nt as AE
o SLA givemmunicatio
ted orne navigad on boarde on-board
e a transponale for doi
UDP/IP basm what we
der functiondata.
internet seural to defi
at domain. data could
ce, the ASaging servi
mbining IP n other char cyber sece of VDES
ublic internnet domainystem, the
om
en by on to/from
ational ships,
d
onder parting that.
sed, was see
nality (or
ervices ine the
not only
M part of ices.
data annels, curity is
net, the . navigation
t
Thereforehandled th In the sugand the TAIS traffic This discuAIS/ASM available tVDES mo The E2 T2Figure 18
Figure 18
With the dService, thFigure 19 Hence, th
e one wouldhe same w
ggested arc2.3 roamin
c.
ussion andfunction istoday and
odem.
2.3 has de.
The E2 T2.3 a
discussion he NetworNetwork Pis model h
d implemeway as othe
chitecture, ng is expec
the archits kept the w
then imple
eveloped a
architecture
opened herk protocol Protocol Mhas no “No
nt the AIS er traffic, e
the AIS fucted to han
ecture proway that leementing th
model as
of the Maritim
ere and themodel simodel. n TCP/UD
Page 51 o
function sensuring se
unction hasndle the ap
posal, doeegacy provhe VHF da
shown in
me Cloud clie
e suggestimplifies as s
DP/IP” path
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
o that AIS ecurity usin
s been splippropriate r
es not prevides – namata exchan
ent connected
ons in 7.6.shown in
.
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
data woulng -460 gat
t in the aborouting and
vent implemmely using nge (of IP b
d with the com
3 Broadca
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
d be routeteways.
ove mentiod prioritisa
mentationsthe produc
based data
mponents of
ast Messag
om
ed and
oned partstion of
where cts a) using a
f the hybrid
ge
s
AIS Transpon
der
T2.1 V
ECDISECDISECDIS A
VDESSA
(InmaIrridium
Figure 19 N
Page 52 o
TCP/IP/UD
Application
Roaming
ATarsat, m, VSAT)
WW
Network Prot
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
P
s
2GWiFi,WiMax
tocol Model
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
MCC
G, 3G, LTE
ECDISECDISOther
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
C
om
11 ArcThis chapwork of T2To ease thbefore impnetwork to
11.1 Sim Figure 20 Figure 21 with respeship, befoelements The automthe same IEC61162 In this exaimplemenECDIS an
hitectupter describ2.4 until thhe readingplementatiopology.
mplest Imp
and illustrate b
ect to on-bore implemlike ECDIS
mation sysnetwork se
2-1 and -2.
ample, it isnt e-navigand VDR.
ural Canbes one aris moment
g, the chapion and aft
plementa
before andoard netwoentation haS attached
tems are cegment. T
s imagined tion and V
ndidateschitecturalt of writing
pter starts tter impleme
ation
after implork and shas one Eth
d to it.
connected he rest of o
that the arVessel mon
Page 53 o
s l candidate. to describeentation ex
ementationhip/shore dhernet netw
to bridge con-board c
rgumentatnitoring, he
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
e that has b
e the most xample an
n done e.gata comm
work segm
control pancommunica
ion for doinnce IEC61
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
been deve
simple impd then a de
g. on a shipunication. ent that m
nels via eithation is don
ng the insta162-450 c
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
eloped duri
plementatiescription
p with low In this exaay not eve
her serial lne via seri
allation is tconnectivity
om
ng the
on as a of the full
maturity ample, the en have
lines or onal lines
to y to
B
S
Automation Syste
Bridge and Navigation
GMDSS
Safety, Security & Sup
ECDIS RADA
VDR
Figure 2
ems
System
AIS
ervision
AR
20 Simplest S
Page 54 o
Situation – Be
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
Switch / F
(InIrridi
A
efore Implem
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
Firewall / VPN
SATmarsat, um, VSAT)
dministration
entation
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
om
B
S
11.2 Net Figure 22 architectu The MCCthat it is sgateway. work togecommunic It is uncerThereforeonly.
Bridge and Navigation Syst
Automation Systems
AISTransp
der
afety, Security & Supervis
GMDSS
ECDISRADAR
VDR
twork Top
Network Ture. The re
C is in the fitill a discusIt is, at this
ether and hcation chan
rtain, at thise the VDES
tem
Sponr
sion
Figure
pology
Topology squired arch
igure, placssion if MCs point in ti
how to avoinnels.
s point in tS, as used
T2.1 VDModem
21 Simplest
shows the thitectural e
ed as a paCC exist onime (April 2id duplicate
time (2016in the arch
Page 55 o
DESm
T2.3 Roaming
SAT(Inmarsat,
Irridium, VSA
‐460 Gateway
Situation – A
top level nelements a
art of the mn-board in 2016), unce informat
-04), what hitecture, is
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
AT)
DMZ
‐460GW
After Impleme
etwork topare include
main -460 Gmultiple in
clear how mion to be c
VDES is gs assumed
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
Administration Network
Public Netw
MCC
Maritime Messaging
Local Data Service
entation
pology of thd in the dr
Gateway. Itstances. I.
multiple MCcommunica
going to prd to provide
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
k VPN
work
C
Almanac
Local Lookup Service
he suggestrawing.
t should be.e. in everyCC instancated over th
rovide on IPe IP conne
om
ted
e noted y -460 ces would he sparse
P side. ectivity
Automatio
Bridge and Navig
Novel E‐Na
GMDSS
Safety, Security
11.3 InteThe shipbexternal cfunctions The desigIMO perforelevant IMsolution is450. The ICS isare used ato and accEach subssubsystemsubsystem
n Systems
gation System
avigation
AISTranspon
der
& Supervision
egrated Cborne integcommunicaof onboard
gn requiremormance stMO resolus based on
s a systemas subsystcepting inpsystem is im where apms.
T2.1 VD
‐460 Gateway
‐460 Gateway
‐460 Gateway
‐460 Gateway‐460
Gateway
‐460 Gateway
Communicgrated comation and dd routeing ments to antandards fotions and c
n applicable
m in which items, i.e. wputs from ain complianpplicable, A
DES
T2.3
SAT(Inmarsat,
Irridium, VSAT)
Ga
Figure 2
cation Symmunicationdistress andof this comn Integrateor integratecirculars. Fe requirem
individual rwithout thea communince with thAn ICS con
Page 56 o
3 Roaming
WiFi,WiMax
‐460 ateway DMZ
Secu
re Network
‐460 Gateway
22 Network T
ystem n system (d safety co
mmunicatioed Commued RadiocoFor interco
ments for E
radiocomme need for tications huhe IMO typnsists of a
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
2G, 3G, LTE
Maritime Messaging
Local Data Service
Adminy
‐460GW
Topology
(ICS) is desommunicaton. nication Syommunicannection othernet inte
munication their own c
uman machpe approvat least two
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
MCC
Alm
LoLoSe
nistration Network
Public Net
signed to ptions (GMD
ystem are tion System
of the elemerconnecti
equipmencontrol unithine interfal requiremindividual
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
Accom(Infotaiment ,
manac
Local ookup ervice
VPN
twork
perform shDSS) and t
based on ms, and otents of theion in IEC
nt and instats, providinace (COM ents for thGMDSS
om
mmodation, Passenger & Crew)
hip the
the of the ther e ICS, the 61162-
allations ng outputs HMI). at
The COMdedicated Figure 23 Communi The domashows howThe “yellorisk, the im
M-HMI is ded to commu
illustratescation Sys
ain of the ICw the gate
ow” integramplementa
Bridge and Navigatio
Automation Sys
Safety, Security & Su
Novel E‐Naviga
GMDSS
T
esigned so unications
the relatiostem (IEC6
CS has beeway and Mation needsation shoul
on System
‐460 Gatewastems‐460
Gatewa
‐460 Gatewaupervision‐460
Gatewa
‐460 Gatew
ation
AISTranspon
der
‐460 Gatewa
Figur
that it canor as part
on to this u62940-ICS
een markedMCC can bs to be amed be done
T2.1 VDES
ay
S(Inm
Irridiu
ay
ayay
ay
ay
re 23 The inte
Page 57 o
n be made of a multi-f
up-coming , 2016).
d with red abe includedended with on separa
T2.3 Roaming
SATmarsat, um, VSAT)
WiFi,WiMax
‐460 Gateway DMZ
Secu
re Network
‐460Gatew
egrated Comm
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
available ofunction di
IEC standa
and yellowd in the ICSh a note thaate autono
2G, 3G, LTE
Maritime Messaging
Local Data Service
Administr
Z
0 way
‐460GW
munication S
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
on a bridgesplay.
ard on Inte
w dashed linS. at to mitigamous units
MCC
Almanac
Local Lookup Service
ration Network V
Public Network
ystem
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
e workstati
egrated
nes. The y
ate cyber ss.
Accommodation(Infotaiment, Passenger & Crew)
VPN
om
ion either
yellow one
security
11.4 InteIn case wconforms Gateway needed. HFigure 24
egrated Ghere the Ato the Seris simplifie
Hence the .
GatewaysAutomationrvice standed by the fgateways
System aards offerefact that nocan be inte
Figure 24
Page 58 o
nd the Brided by the Mo translatioegrated int
4 Integrated G
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
dge and NaMC and MCon betweento one. Se
Gateways
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
avigation SCC, the roln proprietaree
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
System cole of the -4ry protoco
om
mponents 460 ls is
11.5 QuaTo allow tquality of that servicQoS serve Figure 25
QoClie
ality of Sethe serviceservice thace clients her impleme
illustrates
T2.1 VDES
S
Service ClientService ClientService Client
oS ent
ervice e clients to at the comhave the oented in th
suggested
T2
SAT(Inmarsat
Irridium, VS
QoS Server
Applications
F
make intemunicationption of ime T2.3 roa
d architect
2.3 Roaming
, AT)
WiFi ,WiMax
Maritime Messaging
QoS Client
Figure 25 QoS
Page 59 o
lligent decn links allo
mplementinaming.
ture for Qo
2G, 3G, LTx
MCC
Almanac
S Client/Serve
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
cisions on hw in certaig a QoS c
S impleme
TE
C
Local Data Service
(Q‐460GW
er Architectu
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
how to usen situationlient that c
entation.
Local Lookup Service
Public NetworQuota based Acco
re
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
e the availans, it is sugcan interfac
Accomm(Infotaiment, Pas
rkounts)
om
able ggested ce with a
modationssenger & Crew)
12 ArcIt is suggechapter 9
13 IdenThis chap During thepotential a
• Inc201
• Dacan
• Qu
14 ConProposedSince the proposed stakeholdphase of t Based on is believedmitigationuse of (IECyber Secchoices of Considerabeen discfor graduacan be do The perspit is suggeOne of theship (excebased on
hitectuested that tPerspectiv
ntificatpter is inclu
e work of Tareas for s
clusion and16)
ata formatsn be extenuality of Se
nclusion architectustakeholdarchitectuers, the arthe E2 Tas
Cyber Secd that the p, partly in t
EC61162-46curity Persf communi
ations on thcussed andal implemeone with ins
pective of pested that te consequept GMDSstandardiz
ural Canthe proposves and ch
tion of puded to pro
T2.4 produstandardiza
d standardi
and protosions in thrvice Cont
n ure is believer input is
ure is not brchitecture sk 2.4 work
curity Persproposed athe structu60, 2015) spective neication pro
he impact d it is suggeentation. Astallation o
providing athe proposences is thS), is centrzed networ
ndidate sed architehapter 10
potentiaovide input
cing this dation.
isation of M
cols used e S100 fra
trol for the
ved to fulfidescribed ased on a is, therefo
k.
spectives, aarchitectur
ure and suggateways.
eeds to be tocols to b
when implested that
Also it is suof few com
an open ansed architehe fact thatralized thrork, using st
Page 60 o
Test Reecture fulfilsStakehold
al Areasto E2 WP
document,
MCC as ex
for the defamework.ship/ship a
il the user as user nefull and re
ore, likely to
a set of reqre providesggestions f included in
be used are
lementing tthe archite
uggested thponents in
nd harmonecture is det it is propoough the Ttandardize
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
esults s the requier Concern
s for sta1.
the followi
xtension/ad
fined servic
and ship/sh
needs as deeds on a
eviewed seo be modif
quirementss sufficient for network
n the furthee to be don
the recomecture provhat “transfon existing o
ized architelivering thosed that a
T2.3 Roamed protocol
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
irements ans (Requir
andardi
ng have be
ddition to th
ces in MSP
hore comm
described brather hight of require
fied or exte
s have beemeans for
k separatio
er work forne there.
mended arvides a framormation” ton-board in
ecture hase basis forall communing functios and data
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
as describerements).
ization
een identif
he (IEC629
P, several
munication
by WP3. h level, theements froended in th
en developr security ron, and pa
r T2.4, sinc
rchitecturemework thto the archnfrastructur
s been defir exactly thnication to/
on and thata formats.
om
ed in
fied as
940-ICS,
of these
e om the he next
ped and it risk rtly by the
ce the
e have at allows itecture res.
ined, and hat. /from the t it is to be
BibliogABS. (201
ope
ACCSEASMa
ACCSEAS
ACCSEASMa
ATOMOShttp
ATOMOShttp
ATOMOShttp
BIMCO. (2INT
DISC. (19The
DISC. (20http
DISC II. (nPopra
E2-T2.2. (tec
E2-T3.1. (DM
E2-T3.1. (
ENISA. (2SE
IACS. (n.dhttp_E_
graphy 16). The Aperations. H
S. (2015). ariners Ser
S. (2015).
S. (2015). ariners Ser
S. (1994). Rp://cordis.e
S II. (2000).p://cordis.e
S IV. (2002p://cordis.e
2016). TheTERCARG
997). Brief e DISC Co
001). Retriep://cordis.e
n.d.). Retrirtal: http://w
actical-dem
(2016). E2chnologies.
(2015). AnMA - Peter
(2015). D3
2011). ANAECTOR. Eu
d.). IACS. p://www.ia_pdf150.P
pplication
Houston: A
S-100 Prorvice. ACC
Service De
Service Dervice. ACC
Retrieved 0europa.eu/
. Retrievedeuropa.eu/
). Retrieveeuropa.eu/
e GuidelineGO, INTER
Summary onsortium.
eved 01 16europa.eu/
ieved 01 1www.trans
monstration
2 Task 2.2 A. EfficienSe
nalysis repoPetersen,
3.2 Concep
ALYSIS OFuropean Ne
Retrieved cs.org.uk/d
of Cybersemerican B
oduct DescSEAS.
escription:
escription: SEAS.
01 22, 2016/project/rcn
d 01 16, 20/result/rcn/2
ed 01 16, 2/project/rcn
es on CybeTANKO.
of Final Re
6, 2016, fro/project/rcn
6, 2016, frsport-resean
Analysis reea2.
ort on comGateHous
ptual Mode
F CYBER Setwork and
01 29, 201document/
Page 61 o
ecurity prinureau of S
cription: Ma
Maritime
Maritime S
6, from COn/17378_en
016, from C23723_en
2016, from n/52030_en
er Security
eport, DIS
om CORDIn/44674_en
rom TRIP -arch.info/pr
eport on av
mmunicationse.
el. EfficienS
SECURITYd Informati
16, from IA/public/Pub
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
nciples to mShipping.
aritime Saf
Cloud. AC
Safety Info
ORDIS: n.html
CORDIS: .html
CORDIS: n.html
y Onboard
C Docume
IS: n.html
- Transportroject/integ
vailable an
n and infra
Sea2.
Y ASPECTon Securit
ACS: blications/U
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
marine and
fety Informa
CSEAS.
ormation an
Ships. BIM
ent ID D10
t Researchgrated-ship
nd emergin
astructure.
TS IN THE y Agency (
Unified_req
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
d offshore
ation / Not
nd Notice
MCO, CLIA
1.00.01.04
h and Innovp-control-sy
ng commun
Jens K. Je
E MARITIM(ENISA).
quirements
om
tice to
to
A, ICS,
47.005B.
vation ystem-
nications
ensen,
ME
s/PDF/UR
IEC 60945andRe
IEC61162
IEC61162Sa
IEC62940
IHO. (200AN
ISO/IEC4
MARINTEfrie
MSC.147(SE
MSC.252(ST
MSC.86(7nav
NSCR-1/2
RFC1122
Rødseth, new
Rozanski,Sta
SINTEF. (
The MiTSforu
5. (2002). d Systems
eaults. Gen
2-450. (201
2-460. (201fety and S
0-ICS. (201
09). S100 -ND INFORM
2010. (201
ECH. (2009endly, D-D1
(77), I. (20ECURITY A
(83), I. R. (TANDARDS
70), I. (199vigation eq
28. (n.d.). E
. (1989). R
Ø. J., Chriw ship data
, N., & Wooakeholders
(2005). Ma
S Forum. (2um.org/
IEC 60945s - Generalneva: IEC.
11). Multipl
15). MultiplSecurity.
16). IEC62
- HYDROGMATION. I
11). System
9). Europe1.3 Ship-sh
003). REVISALERT SY
(2007). ADS FOR INT
98). Adoptioquipment. I
E-NAVIGA
Requireme
istensen, Ma network.
ods, E. (20s Using Vie
arnis, WP2
2015). Retr
5 - Maritimel Requirem
le talkers a
le talkers a
2940 - Integ
GRAPHIC Gnternation
ms and So
an Framewhore comm
SED PERFYSTEM. IMO
DOPTION OTEGRATED
on of new IMO.
ATION STR
nts for Inte
M. J., & Le
013). Softwewpoints an
2.2 Broadba
rieved 01 1
Page 62 o
e Navigatioments - Met
and multipl
and multipl
grated Com
GEOSPATal Hydrogr
oftware Eng
work for Samunication.
FORMANCO.
OF THE RD NAVIGA
and amen
RATEGY IM
ernet Hosts
e, K. (n.d.)
ware Systend Perspe
and Comm
16, 2016, f
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
on and Rathods of Te
le listeners
le listeners
mmunicatio
TIAL STANraphic Bure
gineering -
afe, Efficie. FLAGSH
CE STAND
REVISED PATION SYS
ded perfor
MPLEMEN
s -- Comm
). Design C
ems Architeectives. ISB
munication
from The M
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
diocommuesting and
s - Etherne
s - Etherne
on System
NDARD FOeau.
- Architectu
nt and EnvIP.
DARDS FO
PERFORMSTEMS (IN
rmance sta
NTATION P
unication L
Challenges
ecture, WoBN-13> 987
- State of
MiTS Forum
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
unication Ed Required
et interconn
et interconn
m. IEC.
OR MARINE
ural Descri
vironmenta
OR A SHIP
MANCE NS). IMO.
andards for
PLAN. IMO
Layers. IET
s and decis
orking with 7-0-321-71
the Art.
m: http://ww
om
Equipment Test
nection.
nection -
E DATA
iption.
ally-
P
r
O.
TF.
sions for a
1833-4.
ww.mits-
15 App This chapcommunicthe deducThe user
• ID • SD• SR• MS
pendix A
pter list the cation and ced requireneed “No”
is about IdD is about SR is about SS is Miscell
A – Con
consolidatinfrastruct
ements to tcolumn ta
dentity manService defSeamless rlaneous
solidate
ted user neture, 2015)the T2.4 on
ags are sho
nagement finition androaming
Page 63 o
ed User
eeds, extra). The list in-board arortcuts:
and role bd discovera
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
r Needs
acted froms amendedchitecture.
ased acceability
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
s
m (E2-T3.1,d with an e
ss control
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
, Analysis rextra colum
om
report on mn stating
No. Need
It must be
The role cocompatibleresponsibil
ID#8The infrastrencryption
ID#10Vetting of iand facilitatrelationship
ID#3A UID regisand facilitat
ID#4
ID#1All types ofShore entitinteracting
ID#2
A digital UIthe Maritimforward comactors.
ID#5Unique Idenobjects) areconsidered
ID#6 Standardizneeded
ID#7Standardizintegrity of
ID#9 Ownership on must be
possible to associate
oncept should be flexie, allowing unique roleity domains
ructure must provide sof data
dentities would increate a higher degree of ps or sharing of inform
stry is needed, which te lookup of seconda
f Ships as well as a mties must be able to inactors must be mana
ID (Universal Identifierme Domain, which is fmpatible, yet provide
ntifiers for virtual objee paramount for some
d in relation to develop
ed function(s) for Aut
ed function(s) for validtransferred informatio
of information elemene managed
e identities with roles
ble, decentralized ane definitions for differe
standardized means
ase the credibility of itrust in online busine
mation within the indu
can uniquely identifyry identifying attribute
multitude of shore basnteract, and Digital Idageable
r) concept must be deflexible, decentralizedunique identifiers for d
cts (such as informate use cases and shouping a maritime UID c
hentication of identitie
dation of authenticity on are needed
nts, and authorization
NotesSee Wikdigital Id
https://
In the mauthoritieoperatorships’ caidentifiabAn IdentidentifierThe ideof the Uhttps://ntifier
Not all anumbersand ded
In other mail addThe UID existing It must bassigninAs suchlookup opossibleStandardgroups tcertain raccess
nd forward nt
In using to a respbelongs ‘Flagstatauthorityassign sthose re
EU couldto inform
An actorExamplea particuAid to N
IdentitiesauthenticIdentity
The abiliaccess tby manyCommonavoid all function,systemsIt must bway, thainformat
Certifica
to support In order
The infraunauthoPrivacy oaddresserequiremA digitalbe explicauthorizaStandardcollaborato accesmany inf
identities ess stry
Vetting: digital idrelationsidentity (etc.)
y an actor, es
sed or Off dentity of
efined for d and different
tion uld be
concept
es is
and
n to pass it
Page 64 o
kipedia for an overviewdentity Management.
/en.wikipedia.org/w
aritime domain entitiees, ports, ships as wrs with assigned rolesaptain, VTS operator ble. tity concept that can r that can cover the Mntifier concept coulURI (Universal Resou/en.wikipedia.org/w
actors have MMSI nums play a significant roicated maritime comm
cases identifiers sucdresses could be used
registry must enableidentifiers and a uniq
be possible to decentng identitiesh, the UID registry maof identities and assoce across the Maritimedized roles may be deo manage which iden
responsibilities and en
role based access mponsibility domain, whto one role, eg. IMO te’, ‘Coaststate’ or ‘Py to competent authosuch roles to identitiesesponsibilities
d most likely reuse romation sharing within t
r/identity may be asse: A Voyage_IDs idenular ship, or a Persistavigation
s related to objects thcation may belong toregister related to act
ity to validate the idento restricted informatiy use cases to facilitan authentication functservices implementin
, requiring actors to ms they need to accessbe possible to ‘sign’ aat the recipient can vaion and detect if it ha
tes may need to be p
to support transfer of
astructure must not parized parties of confidential informaed – technically as w
ments for legal interce service provided bascit about ownership oation to pass on infordized functions suppoators (roles or specificss my information) coformation servicesValidation of relations
dentity – for instance aship between a ship a(identified by UID, IM
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
w of definitions related
wiki/Identity_manag
es such as companiewell as employees or s/responsibilities (sucor harbour master) m
provide one binding, uMaritime Domain mustd be a maritime adource Identifier) wiki/Uniform_Resou
mbers, however MMSle in several existing munication systems
h as terminal numberd to identify an actor
e binding (lookup) betwque UIDtralize the process of
ay be decentralized, bciated identifiers mus
e Domain.efined by certain stak
ntities are associated ntitled to which level o
management, a role behere a specific responcould define the roles
Portstate’, and delegatrities of its member ss executing tasks rel
oles already defined rthe e-maritime conce
igned more than one ntifying a particular voent Universal Identifie
hat are not actors ando other registers, thantors that need authen
ntity of an actor requeion or a resource is nate access controltion(s) is(are) neededng their own authenticmaintain password lists.a digital document in alidate the origin of thas been modified
part of some data tran
f confidential informati
ass on information to
ation transfer must bewell as legally, includineption (law enforcemeed on this infrastructu
of information and rmationorting Nomination of c identities who are e
ould ease implementa
ship between legal ena flag state validating
and an associated digO number or MMSI n
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
Task 2.4 Red to
gement
es,
ch as must be
unique t be option
rce_Ide
SI GMDSS
rs, or e-
ween
but st be
keholder with
of
elongs nsibility s of a te
states to ated to
relevant ept
roleoyage of er for an
d need the
ntication.
esting eeded
, to cation ts for all
such a e
nsfers.
ionThe Architestandardiz
o
e ng nt).ure must
entitled ation of
ntity and the
gital umber,
N/A
N/A
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
equirement
ecture must be ableed encryption proto
om
e to support ocols
No. NeedSD#1
The infrastrfunction
SD#2A standardfunctional doperational
SD#3A standardservice imp
SD#4A standardhow privacyis exchang
SD#6Standardizshould be d
SR#3Support forinformationrequested
SR#4
Although nbe designeGMDSS (Dqueues of i
SR#5A Messagiinformation
SR#6Legal implimust be cointernationa
SR#7A Messagimessages
SR#9A Messagitransfer of dA MessagistandardiseThe text-chstandardisechanged tim
MS#1 Introductionmodificatio
MS#2Introductionpoints of famaritime st
MS#3A businessshould be i
MS#4Legal implishould be a
MS#5
The roadmashould inclwhere techfor agile ad
MS#6The level ofdefined
SR#10
SR#2A Messagiinformationinformation
SR#8 A Messagiefficient tra
SR#1Actors shopoint radio roaming)
ructure should provide
dized description of a description, user pres context and definitio
dized service descriptiplementation dized description of a y of information is ens
ged with the serviceed methods for settindeveloped
r setting up dynamic mn only to actors relate
ot part of the GMDSSed to support the operDistress, Urgency, Sanformation transfer
ng Service should sun delivery
cations of the compoonsidered – including al law related to lawfu
ng Service should su to ships outside ran
ng Service should sudatang Service should sued contenthat function could be ed information exchanme of arrival
n of the infrastructure ns of existing system
n of the infrastructure ailure, which may prevtakeholders due to d
s case for operating thdentifiedcations of establishinanalysed and addressap towards establishiude establishing test
hnologies can be testedaptation of technologf criticality of the infra
ng Service should sun to actors inside an an in an area or along a
ng Service should suansfer of data
ould be able to interaclink or the same sate
e a Service Registry /
digital service shouldsentation issues (wheon of data formatsion language could fa
digital service must dsured, if confidential i
ng up subscriptions to
multicast groups for md to a particular opera
S, any roaming capabrational priorities definafety, Routine) in exec
pport requesting ackn
onents of a Messagingrequirements in natio
ul interception.
pport the ability to disge of stable connecti
pport encryption for c
pport text messages
used to clarify other nge e.g. explain reaso
should not require mms
should not introducevent interactions betwdisrupted operation
he infrastructure funct
ng the infrastructure fusedng infrastructure funcbeds and developer f
ed and validated, andgy developmentsastructure functions m
pport the capability toarea (or actors subscra route)
pport methods for ban
ct without using the saellite system (seamle
Notes/ lookup
d include a ere relevant), Geograp
could be
acilitate
describe nformation
Technicaincludingregime c
o a service
SeamlescommunproposedThis will can offershore baswitchinlinks, baGeocastroaming the ‘liste
Precisiolocation
multicasting ation is (like sub
operatio
bility should ned for cuting
Based oinfrastrucsupportidesign sat a latebecome
nowledge of Acknowa commdelivery,received
g Service onal or
stribute vity
May reqability tostatusesacknowlEfficient should bIn case otransfer to contintransfer
confidential
with non-
on for
major
The infratransitioimprovedenablingattention
e single ween
Infrastrucrequire obe able tdecentra
tions Supporte
unctions Supporte
ctions forums, allow room HLUG a
must be
StandardPhrases
o broadcast ribing to
ndwidth
ame point-2-ess
Page 65 o
phic context and levele part of the operation
al as well as legal asg stating which nationcover the provider of th
ss roaming - i.e. a canication service - shoud Maritime Messaginrequire a shipboard m
r other shipboard appased messaging servig between a number
ased on availability, cating (broadcasting to service to be aware o
ening area’ of fixed ac
on and timing requiremof mobile actors has
bscribing to a chat roonal information related
on advice from the Higcture functions shouldng safety critical app
should not prevent upger stage, if the function
widely used. ledge mechanisms counication link level ac an application level a at a relevant applicat
uire store-and-forwardo provide ‘delivery delas in relation to requireedge. methods for encodin
be appliedof a temporarily lost cof a large data block,
nue after a reconnect,over.
astructure functions sn towards better servd and unified access g automation of interacn
cture functions shouldonline access to centto be replicated and falized manner
ed by comments from
ed by comments from
lso requested a roadm
dized expressions, sus, could be supported
“This pthe Euresearunder
of 91
of criticality of a servnal context
pects must be coverenal (or international) lehe service
arrier agnostic or crossuld be available (The g Service)messaging applicatio
plications a connectioice, while automaticaof different communicapacity, cost or otheran area) will require tof mobile actors locat
ctors
ments for updating thenot been determined
om for sharing certaind to an operation)
gh Level User Group, d not initially aim for lications, but its inhegrading the operationns prove successful a
ould exist at different cknowledge of informaacknowledge of informtion, or a user acknow
d queuing capabilitiesayed’ or ‘not connecteement for delivery
g or compression of d
connection during an the process should , rather than starting t
hould rather allow a gvice designs, providingcontrol mechanisms,ctions with minimal u
d as far as possible nralized systems, but function offline or in a
m HLUG
m HLUG
map
uch as Maritime Stan.
project has receuropean Union’srch and innovatigrant agreemen
Task 2.4 Re
MCC must
vice
ed egislative
MCC must s carrier
n, which n to a
ally cation rthe tion or
e d
n
MCC must the
rent al status and Covered by
Perspectivlevels -
ation mation wledge
Message Treception a
s, and ed’
data
ongoing be able the
Message Tencryption
gradual g , user Covered by
existing in
not should
ArchitectuimplementArchitectumode" reqcommunicline/off‐lin
Roaming m
ndard
MCC must Architectubroacasts
Message TcompressioService)
eived funding fros Horizon 2020 ion programme nt No 636329”.
equirement
be present as AE
be present as AE
be present as AE
y the Open and Harmve
ransport Protocol macknowledge
ransport Protocol mn
y the Low Impact Intfrastructure perspecre topology must notation change state re must support offquired functionality.ation must not be afne state
must be present as A
be present as AEre must support dist
ransport Protocol mon and continue afte
om
monized
must support
must support
tegration with ctiveot by method or of SPOF areas.line or "silent I.e. Inter AE ffected by on‐
AE
tribution of
must support er LOS (Loss of
16 AppeThis chapter
N° Re- viewer Initials
1 NIT
2 NIT
ndix B – Filist the review
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
page 42, par.10.2.1
form
page 42, Par. 10.2.2
form
inal Reviewcomments rec
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
mulation The seEfficienand neoutcom The roawith seNetwor
mulation Commapplicaany givcommu The sewhere EfficientransmThe infbe logimodifieMaritim
w Report ceived and acti
wer's Comments
entence: „Due to thnSea2 Task 2.3 roetwork segments fme of Task 2.3.
aming device fromeveral separate phrk segments will bent refers to the s
ations need to havven time, to be abunication is requir
ervices are performthe required QoS
nSea 2 Task 2.3 rmission link which w
formation about thcally distributed toed by them – sucme Cloud.
D2.10 O
Page 66 of 91
on on commen
s, Question and P
his, there is a REoaming device mufor (…)” is not com
m the EfficienSea hysical ports – thebe separated logicsentence: „The eleve knowledge of thble to make the rigred.”
med via Maritime S and necessary eroaming device wiwill depend on thehe QoS that is curo relevant network
ch a modification c
Onboard system
nts from the fina
Proposals
QUIREMENT thatust have separatempliant with the re
2 Task 2.3 will noere will be only oncally. ements of the Serhe available quali
ght decisions when
Cloud and it is in ndpoints are deteill select the most e required QoS anrrently available ink components butcan only be perfor
m integration a
“This project hathe European research and under grant agre
al review of thi
t the e physical ports esults and
ot be equipped e physical port.
rvice ity of service at n
Maritime Cloud ermined. The
suitable nd endpoint. n the link may t cannot be rmed by the
rchitecture – F
as received funding froUnion’s Horizon 20innovation programm
eement No 636329”.
s report.
Editor’s action comment.
After correspondinput from review16, editor has derequirement for the report. The mis achieved are decided in the nT2.4 and T2.3 … stick to QoS w
Final review re
om 020 me
on review
dence with NIT anw meeting 2016-0ecided to stick wittwo physical portsmeans of witch thto be discussed aext phase of E2
way of drawing
eport
nd 04-th s in is
and
N° Re- viewer Initials
3 NIT
4 NIT
5 NIT
6 NIT
7 NIT
8 NIT
8a NIT
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
page 45, par. 10.2.5
form
Fig. 22/23/24/25/26
form
Fig. 26 form
Par. 7.1.3 struc
General edito
General edito
Page 49 edito
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
mulation Commrest of PassenimplemPassen To clarequippthem. PGatewaSo, outthe sec
mulation The EfseparaGatewa
mulation The Efinformaequipp
ctural In par. docum“broadcobservconfus7.1.3 a
orial To meninstead‘QOS’ http://w
orial There few exa
orial It is: “F
Page 67 of 91
wer's Comments
ent refers to the sthe ship network nger/Crew networ
ments detection annger network is is
rify the matter: theped with ANY modPassenger netwoay / Firewall. t of the two possibcond one is true.
fficienSea2 Task 2ate physical ports.ay / Firewall. fficienSea2 Task 2ation logically to re
ped with the QoS S
7.1.3 a definition ents regarding thecast” are used int
ved by the authorsion, we believe a
as well. ntion Quality of Sed of the most comusually refers to „
www.acronymfindeis a relatively big amples below:
Figure 22 and Figu
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
sentence: „ To profrom Denial of Serk, it is REQUIREDnd protection agaisolated using a IEC
e EfficienSea2 Tasdules detecting attrk must be isolate
bilities included in
2.3 roaming devic Public Network s
2.3 roaming devicelevant network cServer.
of broadcast come Maritime Cloud,terchangeably. Wes later in paragrapsimilar statement
ervice, the authormmon form – ‘QoS„Quality Operatinger.com/Quality-Opnumber of spellin
ure 22 illustrates…
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
otect the T2.3 roamervice Attacks origD that either, the rinst such attacks, C 61162-460 Gate
sk 2.3 roaming detacks and/or proteed using a IEC 61
the cited sentenc
ce will not be equipshould be separat
ce might send the components, but it
mmunication is giv, the terms “geocae acknowledge, th
ph 7.6.3, but to avot should be include
s use the acronym’. It should be cor
g System” - perating-System-(g and punctuation
…”
ming and the ginated from the roaming device or the eway / Firewall.”
evice will not be ecting against 162-460
ce from D.2.10,
pped with ted using the
QoS t will not be
en. In many ast” and hat this fact was oid possible ed in paragraph
m ‘QOS’, rrected, since
(QOS).html n mistakes. A
Editor’s action comment.
The sentence hanote that -460 grequired in E2.
Figures updated
Definition of the T2.3 roaming anare to be discusthe next phase oFormulation of dGeocast can bebroadcast. Geocdistributed using
Fixed.
Fixed (I hope)
Fixed
on review
as been extendedateway/firewall is
d to show GW
QoS functionalitynd the service cliessed and decided of E2 definition expande a special case ofcast could also beg multicast.
d to
y in ents in
ed. f e
N° Re- viewer Initials
8b NIT
8c NIT
8d NIT
8e NIT
8f NIT
8g NIT
8h KB (NIT)
9 AW
10 AW 11 AW
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
Par. 11.1 Fig. 8 edito
Fig. 8 edito
Fig. 9 edito
Fig. 13 edito
Fig. 13 edito
Page 40, 1st sent. in par. 10.2
edito
Page 43, Par. 10.2.2
edito
Ch 2 para 1 sentence 2
Edit
Ch 3 DittoCh 4 para 1
…
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
It shouorial It is: “S
It shouorial It is: “S
It shouorial It is: “T
It shouorial It is: “S
It shouorial It is: “S
It shouorial It is: “T
and proIt shoua ship,
orial It is: “The idQualityIt shou“The idQuality
orial The sc
o … DefinitiPossibinfrastrpossibmaritim
Page 68 of 91
wer's Comments
ld be: “Figure 21 Shios”
ld be: “Ships” Shpis” (x2)
ld be: “Ships” Tasl 2.4”
ld be: “Task 2.4”Shios”
ld be: “Ships” Shpis” (x2)
ld be: “Ships” This chapter analyopose requiremenld be “This chapte and proposes req
dea from the SatCy of Service attribuld be:
dea from the SatCy of Service attribucope of …[not for]
ion of MCC – Marble redraft: the conructure of a ship ale due to the rules
me domain. Howe
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
and Figure 22 illu
yse a typical netwonts(…)” er analyses a typiquirements(…)”
Com providers, of hutes (…)”
Com providers, of hutes (…)”
ritime Cloud Clienncept of considerinas a sub-system os and regulations ever, a limited app
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
ustrate…”
ork structures on-
ical network struct
having M2M acco
having M2M acco
t Component? ng the entire elect
of the maritime clothat apply to equi
plication of the con
board a ship,
tures on-board
ounts to witch
ounts to which
tronic oud is not pment in the ncept is
Editor’s action comment.
Fixed (I hope)
Fixed (I hope)
Fixed (I hope)
Fixed (I hope)
Fixed (I hope)
Fixed
The paragraph wIt has been Refo
Fixed
Fixed Found both formread, so stayed
on review
was confusing. ormulated.
mulations hard to on existing one.
N° Re- viewer Initials
12 AW
13 AW
14 AW
15 AW 16 AW
17 AW 18 AW 19 AW
20 AW
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
Ch 4 para 2
…
Ch 4 para 4
…
Ch 4 para 5.1
Form
Ch 5.1 EditCh 5.1 para 1 last sentence
…
Para 2 … … Ch 5.2.1 …
After Fig. 2, 3rd
…
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
possibbind thsystemRedrafboard ain this The proarchite
mulation Reviewfleet (oone frothose oships oMaritimICS weinterna The texis therealtogetthe fac
orial ….pote….and builds
On boaSugges….200infrastr While
Page 69 of 91
wer's Comments
le on novel parts oe maritime cloud
ms. ft? ....on board Marchitecture a recreport. ocess to follow an
ecture is illustratedwer Comment: EQover 100 GT) of wom the other the nof over 500 GT noof over 300 GT) isme Transport 2015ebsite quotes a figationally.
xt referring to SOLefore a bit confusither and just makict that it will be 20 ential improveme in practical termsin order to fulfil its
ard [not on ship]st delete text: ….a0, two research pructure…. the two concepts
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
of those parts of tclient component
CC and to identifycognized standard
nd the steps takend in Figure 1. QUASIS 2014 figuhich 31,240 were
number of SOLASotwithstanding thes 53,854 in 2014. 5 has a higher figugure of approx. 50
LAS ships and sming so I suggest ding a comment onto 30 years befor
ents… s the NC must apps potential.
and which it is conprojects in particula
….
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
the shipboard arch(MCC) to existing
y and describe a s has been used (t
n to provide a reco
res are 85,094 shless than 500 GT ships (generally
e fact that some prThe UNCTAD Re
ure for the total of0,000 ships trading
mall ships and repeleting the secon
n the size of the cure the majority are
ply to the existing
nsidered to deservar focused on on-
hitecture that g type approved
suitable on-the ISO/IEC…)
ommended
hips in world T – so taking taken to be rovisions are for eview of f 89,464. The g
lacement rates d sentence urrent fleet and e replaced.
fleet and future
ve. -board
Editor’s action comment.
Paragraph refor
Suggested form Reformulated a “rough numbersof the text the sato make clear thon-board architeintended for new
Could not find, aUsed suggestionformulation.
Fixed Deleted. Used suggestion
Fixed
on review
rmulated.
ulation used.
bit and added a s” attribute. Left mame, since point i
hat the MC and theecture is not only w builds.
assume fixed n and simplified
n.
ost s e
N° Re- viewer Initials
21 AW 22 AW
23 AW
24 AW
25 AW
26 AW 27 AW 28 AW
29 AW
30 AW
31 AW 32 AW 33 AW
34 AW
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
sentence Last para … 5.2.2.1 First sentence
…
Para 4, 2nd sentence
…
3rd sentence
…
Ch 5.2.2.2 para 1
…
Para 2 … Para 3 … …
Ch 5.2.3 para 2 2nd sentence
…
Ch 5.2.3 para 3
…
StruPara 4 EditCh 5.3 …
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
…adopCommmodel,I suggeSOLAS…are a
…to be
…publ
…balla…tendThe firsor split The corules…
..comp
ucture There aorial …also
…..argon new…arch.1 supp.2 does
Page 70 of 91
wer's Comments
pts the (…) five-laent: Actually owne spec, etc) so theest delete the firstS Convention estaalmost universally
e discussed below
ish… [not publish
ast water system…… [not tends] st sentence is verinto shorter sente
onsequence of not….
ponents… (s adde
are no referencesseem to involve…ument that it is ne
w ships but also thitecture must be sports… s not compromise
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
yer AD, including ers do have a cho
e text is a bit odd, t 1.5 sentences anablishes the minimy used.
w, they do not allo
es]
….
ry long and complences. t meeting and rem
ed) …compromise
s in the text to figu… ecessary for the Mhe existing fleet…such that the MCC
e…
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
the definition of ‘loice of equipment particularly the Cond start the rest wmum set of…….
w extraneous com
icated and might
maining in complia
…(s deleted)
ures 4 or 5
MC and MCC to be
C:
layer’ (manufacturer,
onversely bit so with: The
mmunications.
be better edited
ance with the
e fitted not only
Editor’s action comment.
Fixed Used suggestion
Used suggestion
Used suggestion
Fixed
Fixed Fixed Edited and split…
Used suggestion
Fixed
Fixed Fixed Used suggestion
Kept existing for
on review
n.
n
n
…
n.
n.
rmulation.
N° Re- viewer Initials
35 AW
36 AW
37 AW
38 AW 39 AW 40 AW
41 AW 42 AW 43 AW
44 AW 45 AW
46 AW
47 AW 48 AW 49 AW
50 AW
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
Ch 5.4 Gen
Ch 5.4 near end
Edit
Para 1 …
Para 3 … Para 4 … Ch 6 Gen
EditCh 6.1 … 2nd sentence
...
Ch 6.3 … Ch 7 1st sentence
…
2nd sentence
…
Para 2 … Para 2 2nd sentence
Edit
Para 2 3rd sentence
…
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
.3 ensu
.4 is in neral The lis
same iorial ..never
The MCbefore …VSA…..ma
neral Althougand its Font in
orial Experie…and ….cont
…infor…requ
….com
…via o….stra
orial ….mar
…othe
Page 71 of 91
wer's Comments
ures that… compliance… t of items is in a dn other lists – thertheless have to b
CC….. [no need tin text]
AT, T2.1 VDES arey not need to be sgh Viewpoints is a concepts do not
n list is as in previoence… [no s]…fotheir environmentext viewpoint is c
rmational…[al addirements …[s add
mmunication soluti
operation and montegy has been de
ritime communicat
r projects and res
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
different font to the font might be thebe known, ….
to spell out as abb
e clearly also AE.separate items…a part of the ISO/Iseem to add mucous general commr consideration…
nt considered to be f
ded] ded]
ons and enhance
nitoring to reportineveloped by IMO…tion needs, a set o
search including: [
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
e rest of the text ae same throughou
breviation used ma
EC 42010 standach (for me at least)ment
fully relevant since
ed ability to integra
ng…. … of…
[list..] have further
and this is the t the text
any times
ard this chapter ).
e the….
ate…
r refined…
Editor’s action comment.
Fixed fonts
fixed
fixed
fixed fixed Kept chapter. Imwork. Font fixed. Fixed, used fixed Used suggestion
fixed fixed
Used suggestion
Used Used Fixed
Fixed
on review
mportant for furthe
n
n
er
N° Re- viewer Initials
51 AW
52 AW
53 AW
54 AW
55 AW
56 AW
57 AW
58 AW
59 AW
60 AW
61 AW
62 AW
63 AW
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
Para 3 …
Figure 8 …
Last sentence
…
Ch 7.1 …
…
Ch 7.1.1 …
Ch 7.1.2 …
Ch 7.1.3 …
Ch 7.2 …
…
Figure 10 Erro
Figures 8,10 & 11
Edit
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
….in p
At the t
This taTask 5….to bwriting Font in
There a
….destthat……Definedcommu…is alspoint…that theFont in
…..the
or??? Aren’t
orial The wo
Page 72 of 91
wer's Comments
revious chapters
time of writing [en
able is basically or5.1 should be move made to make a[ enter a date]
n list as before…
are three interacti
tination end point ….providing acknod as a one-to-manunication is sure tso a one-to-many
….., no acknowledge information is tran list as before….
level of….
MSI and NM gene
ord chart has bee
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
[ s added]
nter a date] the nu
rdered according tved accordingly a better estimate t
ion/comms types
is known and theowledgement of reny communicationhat acknowledgem
y communication bgement is given thansferred.
erally broadcast ra
en misspelt as car
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
umbering of MSPs
to Task number s
than is possible a
[delete types of]
e source of commueception. n…..and the sourcment… but where the desherefore there is n
ather than P2P?
rt in the tables
s is confusing….
o on that basis
at the time of
unication is sure
ce of
tination end no guaranteed
Editor’s action comment.
Reference to theadded fixed
Table is orderedof use cases. KeFixed
fixed
fixed
fixed
fixed
reformulated
fixed
fixed
Good question. and came to theservice would be“client request aNM’s and serveHence P2P. This might chanof the service deFor now, no chaFixed
on review
e specific chapter
d from an original ept it that way.
We discussed thie conclusion that te implemented as
available MSI and r will send to clien
ge with completioescription. ange made.
r
list
s the s a
nt”.
on
N° Re- viewer Initials
64 AW
65 AW
66 AW
67 AW
68 AW
69 AW
70 AW
71 AW
72 AW
73 AW
74 AW
75 AW
76 AW
77 AW
78 AW
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
Ch 7.3 …
…
Ch 7.4, 7.5, 7.6
…
Ch 7.6 para 3
…
Ch 7.6 para 4
Edit
Ch 7.6.1 …
Ch 7.6.2 …
Final para second sentence
…
Final para last sentence
…
Ch 7.6.3 …
…
…
…
2nd para …
Ch 7.7 …
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
Font in
….estim
Font in
…..it is
orial Figure make uA web
Both so
The va
Similarservice
…ackn
The neavailab…..the
With rebroadcRSS (W….also
…have
Page 73 of 91
wer's Comments
n list as before…
mation of the…[no
n list….
s assumed that all
14 shows how thuse of the basic…service is the sta
ource and destina
alue-added that th
r methods should e, especially if it is
nowledgement…
ew element here isble data exchangey will have to ‘sub
espect to architectcast services that Web feeds) are a o be a solution her
e provided severa
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
ot guesstimate]
l of the services a
e various services….
ndard defined by
ation end points th
ese…
be considered wis to work across V
s that it is the broae communicationsbscribe’….
tural design of a Bhave been developossible examplere.
al additions….
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
re built on top of…
s in the MSP are a
the W3C….
hat support [s dele
th respect to the MVDES
adcast of data infos channels
Broadcast Messagoped for the W3Ce to follow.
….
anticipated to
eted] the….
MC data
ormation via
ge Service, the , particularly the
Editor’s action comment.
Fixed
Changed. However, we reathan estimated…Fixed
Used suggestion
fixed
Reformulated.
fixed
fixed
Used suggestion
fixed
Used suggestion
fixed
Reformulated.
fixed
fixed
on review
ally guessed more…
n
n
n
e
N° Re- viewer Initials
79 AW
80 AW
81 AW
82 AW
83 AW
84 AW
85 AW
86 AW
87 AW
88 AW
89 AW
90 AW
91 AW
92 AW
93 AW
94 AW
95 AW
96 AW
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
…
Ch 7.8 …
…
…
Ch 8 …
…
…
Ch 9 …
C 9.1 1st para
Edit
…
…
Ch 9.2 …
…
Para 2 …
Functional sub heading
…
Ch 9.3 Erro
Figure 15 Edit
…
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
In genealthougused o…set o
Font in
….as g
…..set in WP3Since W
…..will
Font in
orial …..sta
….serie
Delete
….mea
Font in
Delete
…requ
or??? ShouldComm
orial No refe
ENISA
Page 74 of 91
wer's Comments
eral, the XML schgh formats such a
on the basis of claout in chapter 6
n list as before
given in chapter 10
up in such a way3 and the on-boarWP3…[delete: in
also provide requ
n list…s
ndardization of th
es of standards th
the ‘’ at the end
ans
n list…
it’s and replace w
irement for [ not o
d reference also bittee and the IEC erence in the text
A and ABS might b
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
emas are the domas JSON and BISOimed enhanced e
0.
y that the communrd architecture… [the work]
uirements forming
e on-board data i
hat cover serial an
with its
of] standardization
e made to ETSI C62443 series to this figure
be better in ( ) and
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
minant web servicON are becoming fficiency.
nication frameworkdelete: of..]
g the basis…
nfrastructure is…
nd network-based
n
Cyber Security Te
d the full name in
e data formats increasingly
k is developed
…
chnical
text – and the
Editor’s action comment.
Used suggestion
Fixed
fixed
fixed
reformulated
fixed
reformulated
fixed
fixed
fixed
fixed
Fixed
fixed
Fixed
fixed
Reference and d
fixed
Fixed
on review
n.
description made
N° Re- viewer Initials
97 AW
98 AW
99 AW
100 AW
101 AW
102 AW
103 AW
104 AW
105 AW
106 AW
107 AW
108 AW
109 AW
110 AW
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
Ch 9.1 and 9.2
Stru
Ch 9.3 2nd para
Edit
…
Last para …
General …
Ch 9.3.1 …
Ch 9.3.3 …
Ch 9.3.4 …
2) …
Penultimate para
…
Edit
…
Ch 9.3.5 …
Ch 9.3.6 …
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
same fucture These
apprecbe give
orial …types
…actio
…has
As a geformatsstandaFont in
Risk idimpact Such e
….it ma
…the 4
orial … resp
… reco
…to en
Given tthe usemitigatvalidate.1 plac
Page 75 of 91
wer's Comments
format used throutwo chapters are
ciate that cyber seen (if possible) to
s..
on that can be take
emerged..
eneral comment…s: bullet points, nu
ardized. n list…
entification is the system operation
equipment is very
ay be preferable t
460 gateway is..
ponsibility for [not
ommendations for
nable [delete for] f
the perspective reer needs identifieding security risks ed…… of the risking…
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
ghout (i.e. acronyvery brief compa
ecurity is a hot issuintegration and op
en.
…the various lists umbering, use of a
process of determns and data and thrare today…
to allow the conne
of]
r [not of]
functions that
equirement (para d in (E2-T3.1…etc(IEC…), any candks. This might be
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
ym in ( ) to follow fred to 9.3 on cybeue but should morpen, harmonized a
in the report are ia), b) etc… they m
mining risks that che possible outco
ection of some…
9.2 above) for an c) and the availabdidate architecture achieved by:
full text) er security – I re elaboration architecture???
n various might be
could potentially mes.
open…… and ble standards for e needs to be
Editor’s action comment.
Input from review21: The level of and 9.2 is acceptime Could not find –fixed fixed
fixed
Fixed … only onnumbering.
fixed
Reformulated.
fixed
fixed
fixed
Fixed
fixed
fixed
Reformulated ansuggestion.
on review
w meeting 2016-0information in 9.1
pted at this point i
– hence assume
ne required
nd used part of
04- n
N° Re- viewer Initials
111 AW
112 AW
113 AW
114 AW
115 AW
116 AW
117 AW
118 AW
119 AW
120 AW
121 AW
122 AW
123 AW
124 AW
125 AW
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
Ch 10.1 …
Gen
Edit
Ch 10.2 …
…
…
Ch 10.2.1 …
Ch 10.2.2 …
…
…
Ch 10.2.3.1
…
Ch 10.2.4 …
…
Ch 10.3.2 …
Ch 11 …
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
.2 desc
.3 descMakingduplicaSome e(email
neral Is the l
orial Font in
…. anaclassesFont in
In (SIN
….is vVLAN ….7.4
Which
The texanticipaimplem…supp
Examp
In this
Delete
…up u
Page 76 of 91
wer's Comments
cribing… cribing… g full use of the NIates 9.2.3] explanation of ID,exchange of 7 Apist here a summa
n list…
alyses a typical nes of services
n list…
NTEF)… each dom
ital…traffic is…adis… priority provide an
h at the top of pag
xt starting One coated that the MC/
mentation in manypliers of the system
ples can be envisa
case the same pr
: …one would ve
ntil the date of thi
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
IST approach (pa
, SD, SR and MS pril refers) ary? If so it might
etwork structure…
main’s internal….t
dministrative or pa
n indication of..
e 43 ..not witch!
ould also imagine…/MCC could centray of the MSP applims….implement i
aged of multiple o
rinciple…. In case
ery quickly…
s report [date to a
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
ra 9.3.2) [and dele
in the table in Ap
say so…
….and proposes…
there are intercon
assenger traffic an
…could say: It mialize functionality cations in the M2nterfaces…
perations
es…..
add]
ete the list as it
pendix required
. required
nections….
nd to reduce….
ght also be that could ease M mode.
Editor’s action comment.
Added into desc
Added descriptio
fixed
fixed
fixed
fixed
fixed
fixed
Used suggestion
fixed
Not changed, suchange meaningfixed
reformulated
Date on front pa
on review
cription in Append
on for list
n
uggestion would g.
age.
ix.
N° Re- viewer Initials
126 AW 127 AW 128 AW
129 AW
130 AW
131 AW
132 PAN
133 PAN
134 PAN
135 PAN
136 PAN
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
Ch 11 EditCh 11.3 … Ch 12 … Ch 14 …
…
Page 10 edit
Figure 6 struc
7-1-1 and 7.1.2
edit
10.2.3 struc
Figure 20 struc
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
orial Figures….illusIt is sugWP3. [
….is, th
While tChang
ctural With rethe inteshown Either aor adopAnd the And the
ctural Descrip Consid
ctural Figure In figur
Page 77 of 91
wer's Comments
s should be 21 anstrates the relationggested that… [full stop to add]
herefore, likely….
to two concepts ae to to the
eference to the listelligent roaming din figure 19
add some text expt it into the drawie source of comm
e source of commption of the comm
der adding a desc
20 is in contradic
re 19 VDES is a n
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
nd 22 n….
re quite similar in
ting on the previoevice described in
plaining the impleing.
munication are sur
munication is sure munication network
ription in this chap
ction to figure 19 in
non LAN item, in fi
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
many respects
us page I miss ann T2.3. the parts I
ementation of intel
re that
that k based on IEC 62
pter
n relation to placin
igure 20 it is a LA
n indication of I miss are
lligent roaming,
2940
ng the VDES.
N item
Editor’s action comment.
fixed fixed Changed. fixed
fixed
fixed
List show the rofigure 6 does shdevice.
fixed
Rejected. The 6seen as a ship oTraditionally thecomponents arethe navigation asay that ICS is pNavigation netwhowever – it is sis binding it all toI think you hit thproblem in our wAs it looks, VDEAIS/ASM as non
on review
aming device andhow the roaming
62940 network is noperation networke communication e considered part and hence one coupart of the
work. Later in doc, shown how the ICogether. e spot of the main
work. ES is offering bothn lan and data
d
not k.
of uld
S
n
N° Re- viewer Initials
137 PAN
138 PAN
139 JKJ
140 JKJ 141 JKJ
142 JKJ 143 JKJ
144 JKJ 145 JKJ
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
11.3 edit
Figure 24 edit
P12,40 form
P13,5 formP13, 5.2.2.2
form
P14,13 editoP14,20 form
P14,37 editoFig. 4 struc
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
The lat I think It is noUpdate
mulation Unclea
mulation Replacmulation Should
orial Passenmulation ‘Never’
We fretake in
orial Proposctural I miss t
Page 78 of 91
wer's Comments
tter “yellow” integr
the sentence shot possible to followe the figure to makar. I don’t see how
ce GPS-type with d BAM not be men
ngers are relevan’ is a strong wordquently need to sto account creativ
se to delete “entitithe administration
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
ration needs to be
uld be, the latter “w the yellow line ake both yellow an
w this is discussed
GNSS ntioned in this con
t for Safety of Life… end test standardve solution which es and”
n (office) network
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
e amended with a
“red” integration nall the way on the d red lines fully vi
d in the section be
ntext?
e At Sea as well…
ds into a maintenano one had imagi
– which is mentio
note
needs…. figure sible.
elow.
…
ance cycle, to ned.
oned in the text
Editor’s action comment.
exchange via thBy nature, VDESbetween VHF (nboard networks.As noted later, itmove away fromand move the coIP based. In the proposed assumed that Vnothing but IP coA note of that hachapter 11.2. Reformulated.
Fixed
Reformulated, resecurity fixed BAM is part of Ctype approval refixed Deleted last sen
fixed The figure showapproved equipm
on review
e IP network. S is an interface non-lan) and the o. t is suggested to
m the non-lan areaommunication to a
architecture, it is DES is providing onnectivity. as been added to
efer to cyber
CAM and part of IMegime
ntence.
w clusters of type ment.. .that is not
on-
a an
MO
in
N° Re- viewer Initials
146 JKJ 147 JKJ 148 JKJ
149 JKJ
150 JKJ
151 JKJ
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
P15,7 editoP15,8 strucFigure 5 struc
P16 form
Figure 6
Figure 10
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
orial Add ‘toctural Don’t uctural Miss th
associa
mulation I’m notthe serNAVIG
What isadmini
*Why a What isdata)? RE MSMulti- oConfidetypicall RE the‘route s
Page 79 of 91
wer's Comments
o’ understand “betwehe admin networkated communicati
t sure what is mearvices (MSP’s) dis
GATION system?
s meant by the sestrative network?
are several Use C
s the difference be
SI&NM, I think theor broadcast are tentiality/encryptioly publicly availab
e broadcast of ROsegment’. It is unl
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
een entities betwe. Administrative reion needs play a s
ant here. Is it admscussed in e-Navig
eparate network f
Cases duplicated –
etween MSI&NM
P2P interaction wthe typical – and I on for this use casble .
OUTE PLAN / activikely that the entir
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
een layers”… eporting formalitiesignificant role
ministrative systemgation are related
for e-Navigation?
– Port Reporting fo
and the version w
would be an excepsee no need for e. These informat
ve route – I think ire route plan will b
es and
ms? Many of d to the
Where is the
or instance?
with (hydro
ption, while the
tions are
t should read be broadcast.
Editor’s action comment.
the office netwofixed Reformulated The figure showapproved equipmthe office/adminNo .. it is not adsystems. It is theidentifying architthat must presenarchitecture. Why e-navigatioincluded separanew. Separate netwobecause it is newAre reverting to administrative nreport. All very good ancomments. Will not change changes will notarchitecture. The list/overviewservice communrequirements nemuch more work
on review
rk.
w clusters of type ment.. .that is not network. ministrative e process of tectural elements nt in the proposed
on services are ately is because it
rk for e-navigationw. definition and useetwork later in
nd relevant
for this report sinct influence propos
w of MSP and nication eeds to undergo k during E2.
in
d
is
n is
e of
ce sed
N° Re- viewer Initials
152 JKJ
153 JKJ
154 JKJ
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
Figure 11
Figure 12
Page 28,
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
RE ROplan seor mult RE ICErequirinpublic RE Embe P2PMSI&N SeaCHoverlayexperie SMARTROUTI ICE CH EMISSto be ‘RI wouldwould dservicefunctio Re SnaCellulaMany AmanagVDES,
Page 80 of 91
wer's Comments
OUTE EXCHANGEegment broadcastticast operation w
E CHARTS – I dong client authenticinformation just lik
mission monitoringP requiring encrypNM: I would expec
HARTS: The indicays only. Base chaence.
T BOUY MANAGINE (SAFETY on
HART service: I w
SION MONITORINROUTINE’. (No idd consider it unlikedisapprove of utilie. That would oven of AIS.
art bouy Managemar or even commeAtoN are today eqgement. NAVDAT, NBDP
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
E I think the ‘broat. The EXCHANG
which would requir
n’t understand whcation is not mentke weather foreca
g I think the typicaption and client auct Priority to be ‘SA
ated information srt ENC data magn
EMENT SERVICEevent)
would expect Prior
NG: I would expecdea of the magnituely to fit much Seaization of AIS/ASMrload the AIS with
ment Service I seercial satellite serv
quipped with 3G o
P…?
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
adcast’ is coveredE of route will type authentication a
hy a broadcast inteioned. ICE charts
asts.
l communication iuthentication AFETY (URGENT
sizes must be updnitudes are larger
E: I would conside
ity to be ‘SAFETY
ct latency to be ‘Dude or frequency).aChart data into AM for a commerciah data transfers irr
e no reason why Wvices are not candor similar for remo
d by the Route ically be a P2P
and encryption.
eraction without s are likely to be
interaction will
T on event)
dates or in my
er Priority to be
Y’
ays’ and priority .
AIS/ASM – and I al sea chart relevant to the
Wi-fi, WiMax, idate carriers. ve
Editor’s action comment.
All very good ancomments. Will not change changes will notarchitecture. The list/overviewservice communrequirements nemuch more work
All very good ancomments. Will not change changes will notarchitecture. The list/overviewservice communrequirements nemuch more workVDES not a serv
on review
nd relevant
for this report sinct influence propos
w of MSP and nication eeds to undergo k during E2.
nd relevant
for this report sinct influence propos
w of MSP and nication eeds to undergo k during E2. vice.
ce sed
ce sed
N° Re- viewer Initials
155 JKJ
156 JKJ
157 JKJ 158 JKJ 159 JKJ
160 JKJ
161 JKJ
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
27
Page 28, 13
9.1 2nd para
Figure 15 Page 36,5 P38,36
P39,7
Figure 17
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
I think figure 1Introduhaul. Ieasily, capabiuse ca Delete
IdenticAlso?Is it thesegregcontainstorageA foresisolatioor manobservIdentic An alteGMDSisolatioas an iwith IC
Page 81 of 91
wer's Comments
Web services can13/14 seem to inducing a MCC with n the mean time, although not benlities provided by ses.
”
al to figure 18. Is
e primary role? I tgation of controlledn a DMZ area, ande of data made acseeable emergencon of safety criticanually disconnectinved anomaly from al to figure 3. Pro
ernative would be SS network. Althouon, this could be insolated network c
CS Workstations o
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
n and will play a sdicate, for several MMS capabilitiesa lot of web serviefitting from the ethe MCC. I think
it needed twice?
thought the role od networks from ud functionality in tccessible by sevecy response proce
al networks – i.e. cng gateways to coaffecting safety c
opose to delete he
to extend the figuugh probably not indicated explicitlyconnecting radio con the process lay
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
ignificant role – mreasons:
s, almanac, etc. wces may be expo
ease of authenticathe ‘web’ is a can
of the 460-gatewayuncontrolled. The hat zone could beral networks? edure might includconsider the effectontrolled networkscritical functions. ere and refer to fig
ure. In this figure I ncluded due to coby adding the GM
comms on the Inster.
much more than
ill be a long sed more
ation and other ndidate for most
y was Gateway may
e related to
de temporary ts of disabling s, to prevent an
gure 3.
lack the omplete MDSS network trument layer
Editor’s action comment.
NAVDAT and Nare … They are to be rservices in the MDon’t understanDoes this not unwork and idea bNo change madat next E2 conf.
fixed
It is included twiDeleted. Deleted paragra
Reformulated, hshort term respopart of gateway
Kept the figure t
on review
BDP stay as they
replaced by new MSP. d.
ndermine the whobehind MC ?
e .. to be discusse
ce for readability.
aph.
however I think theonse: isolation is re-configuration.
to ease readability
y
le
ed
e
y.
N° Re- viewer Initials
162 JKJ
163 JKJ 164 JKJ
165 JKJ
166 JKJ
167 JKJ
168 JKJ
169 HP
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
Figure 18
P45,27 P46,22
P46,39
P49,5
P49,10
11.3
Figure 3 struc
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
Identic reformInteresreal timRADARIP or oQoS anWould mean yto the p But agit is an networ VDES remain(shore MessaconneccapabiMMS oNOT GBefore Figure Don’t q
ctural The fig
Page 82 of 91
wer's Comments
al to figure 15. Pr
ulate sting discussion. I me need of the AISR, which results inther protocol. Round a well known lait necessarily? J
you cannot createpublic internet.
reed – the VDES open radio netwo
rk, but it only allow
could be designen a strictly maritim
stations) could beging Service) – wctions via internetlity, based on prio
only allow traffic wGeneral.
and after what?
21
quite understand t
gure 3 might be a
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
ropose to delete a
think this chapterS service in order n a requirement fouting via different atency would not ust because IP is
e a maritime radio
network must be ork – a bit like the ws certain data str
d to utilize the IP e professional rade allowed to conn
which in turn would, providing the croority. VDES stationwith priority Routin
this – please expla
"copy-paste" from
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
and refer to figure
r should however to correlate well w
or Point-2-point cocommercial SATCbe useful. chosen as a protnetwork which is
treated as ‘dangeAIS is a door into
ructures to pass…
protocol, but I thindio network. VDESect to the MMS (M
d also be allowed oss network messns should howevee, Safety, Urgenc
ain.
m the declared sou
15 instead.
touch upon the with e.g. ommunication – COM without
ocol, it doesn’t not connected
erous’ because o the IEC 61162
…
nk VDES should S gateways Maritime to accept
saging er just like the cy or Distress –
urce (Rödseth,
Editor’s action comment.
Figure 18 deletefigure 15. Fixed. Uncertainty of Vhas been added
Uncertainty of Vhas been added
reformulated
fixed
Added descriptiowork. The figure is not
on review
ed and reference t
VDES role statemed to chapter.
VDES role statemed to chapter.
on of ICS standar
t supposed to
to
ent
ent
rd
N° Re- viewer Initials
170 HP
171 HP
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
Figure 3 struc
Clause 5.2.2.1 3rd para
struc
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
ChristeFor maNavigaarrangecharts ECHOthen a additiodocumUse cafor oveUse caroutingchart ause ca
ctural The figthe Effimplemused ashould IMO e-an admMSPs The boclear.See als
ctural The 3rd
living ininstalla Howev
Page 83 of 91
wer's Comments
ensen & Lee), but any years there haation services. Maement, although tand updates was. I propose that thnew alternative final figure is in "pient).
ase "a)" in the picter 5 years by compase "b)" in the pictg, Ice-breaker assand updates. Thisse "a)".
gure 3 should be cicienSea2. The E
ment infrastructurealso for other purp be distinguished -Navigation includministrative task toare related to Nav
ody text and/or Fig
so picture 2 providd paragraph talks n isolation. I fully ation.
ver the wording giv
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
it gives wrong imas been online deany of them are ofthere was a time w available by methhe figure 3 is modgure is added. Thcture 1" (see end
ture 1 has been ppanies such as Future 1 has been pistance, Route ex
s use case has ev
clearer about whaEfficienSea2 has fe for IMO e-Navigaoses than IMO e-clearly from the m
de 16 MSPs. MSPo fill and submit IMvigation. gure 3 should mak
ded in the end of about navigation agree this for the
ves reader wrong
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
pression of the reelivery of many of ff course today bywhen online delivehods established
dified or if that is nhe new key pointsof this review com
rovided ENC charuruno, Transas, Nrovided weather, w
xchange, etc. in adven longer history
t is the scope or ffocus to provide pation. The platfor-Navigation, but sumain focus. P8 (Vessel Shore MO FAL-forms. A
ke the focus of the
this review documand communicatio most of the curre
impression abou
eality onboard. the IMO e-y private ery of ENC by EU-project
not acceptable, s of the new or mment
rt and updates Navtor, etc. weather ddition to ENC of use than the
focus area of latform to
rm might be uch things
Reporting) is ll other IMO
e EfficienSea2
ment on equipment
ent existing
t the real
Editor’s action comment.
illustrate reality oa view of how warchitecture intoFurther into the architecture modespecially arounEnd of report sudifferent topologlooking as you hpicture 1 and usEven though usehistory and will pquite some timewell, the purpospropose architecand connected sthat manual tranincluded. Figure 3 is not sscope of E2. It isand discussion, which illustrate tThe objective ofadvice infrastrucnavigation. Thatobjective.
3rd para deleted
on review
onboard, but merewe could organize o a layered model.document, this del is challenged,nd cyber security. uggest a slightly gy, much more have shown on secase a) ecase b) has a loprobably be used
e into the future ase of this project iscture for the on-linship. This means nsport of data is n
supposed to illustrs part of backgrouleading to figure 6
the scope. f E2 is not only to cture for e-t is only part of the
ely
.
ng
s s to ne
ot
rate und 6
e
N° Re- viewer Initials
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
situatioIMO - aintegraCommStandaneitherrequireslow to AnyhowNavigaNavigamandaFor IMOinteresmake ehand IMvoluntatype apimplem The 3rd
true thalimited strong PerformRadar meansThe resand IN About tcarriagvessel
Page 84 of 91
wer's Comments
on. as rule setting orgation. IMO publishunication System
ard for Integrated r of these integrateement. We can clo understand bene
w IMO still strongation. One part ofation is to specify aatory integration beO the whole e-Na
sted parties to adoe-Navigation as mMO has a clear ruary instrument, thepproved. Conclus
ment the navigatio
d paragraph is talkat today such devand it is already lopinion about the
mance Standard oand ECDIS functi
s that such combinsult of this would S.
the legal side of uge requirement is c
+ ECDIS and his
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
ganization - has behed Performance (IRCS) already inNavigation Systemed solution is partaim both manufacefits and proceedi
ly believes in the f the SIP (Strategyadditional moduleetween communic
avigation is a volunopt. IMO has cleamandatory carriageule that if an IMO Pen, if installed onbsion is that the INSn side of the IMO
king about combinvices exist, but thelooking like that their use. The basicof the INS, one unions is actually coned devices shoulbe that there can
use of "non-INS" cclear: 1 or 2 radarbackup arrangem
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
een pro-active in sStandard for Integ
n 1995 and Perform (INS) in 1998. t of mandatory cacturers and ship ong into this direct
integration as pary Implementation es to the IMO INS cation and navigantary arrangemen
arly stated that thee requirement. OPerformance Stanboard, such instruS is seen to be thee-Navigation.
nation of Radar aneir legal use caseshe class societies c issue is that by rnderstand that a covered by the INSld be type approveexist "only Radar
combined Radar+rs depending of th
ment. A combined
specifying grated Radio rmance However rriage
owners being ion.
rt of IMO e-Plan) of IMO e-to provide
ation. nt available for ere is no plan to n the other ndard exist for a ment must be e instrument to
nd ECDIS. It is s are extremely will have a very
reading IMO combination of . Therefore this ed of being INS. r", "only ECDIS"
ECDIS. IMO he size of the d unit without
Editor’s action comment.
on review
N° Re- viewer Initials
172 HP
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
Clause 5.2.2.2
struc
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
being abe legarequiretougheapprov The pramanufaINS forin the mavailabprocestightenalreadyRadar+
ctural This clatheir "ArelevanIMO haand NaNavigaObviouoften thhas noBridgeSocietihas pu(BAM).My opiAMC. and thefor bridfor beloBasic i
Page 85 of 91
wer's Comments
an INS does not fually used only as aement (although reer toward a directioved as INS).
actical reason for acturers have hadr the market. In pmarket before 201ble. But as insidess to type approveing of the followiny foreseen that wi+ECDIS will disapause explain that
Alert, Monitoring ant for the EfficienSas published Perfoavigation instrumeation instruments iusly vessels have hese outside the b
ot implemented sim. Below deck is mes. The AMC is fblished a Perform. nion is that for theMy opinion is thae text within it shodge this is specifieow deck this is spdea of BAM is tha
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
ulfill the carriage ran additional deviecently interpretaton that any comb
still today existingd not enough interpractice there were12 and still today vr I know that all m
e their combined ung of the rules by tithin the project timppear as being leg
Classification Soand Control (ACMSea2 project? ormance Standardents. Typical for Ris that they are insa lot of system in
bridge devices aremilar type approvamainly controlled afor below deck pu
mance Standard c
e scope of Efficient the title of 5.2.2.
ould explain that ed by IMO BAM pecified largely indat either all alerts
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
requirement. Thece in addition to ction of the authoriined equipment sh
g combined units rest to provide reae no type approvevery few manufac
major manufactureunits as a consequthe authorities. Tme of the EfficienSgal for SOLAS vescieties go beyond)" system. That is
d only for Radio CRadio Communicastalled in the bridgstalled outside thee called as "belowal regime to belowand polices by therposes. For bridgalled Bridge Alert
nSea2 the issue is2 should be "Aler
dividual Class Socare by individual e
erefore they can carriage ties are getting hall be type
is the fact that al type approved ed INS available cturer has it ers are now in a uence of
Therefore it is Sea2 combined ssels. d IMO rules for s true, but it that
Communication ation and ge of the vessel. e bridge. Very
w deck". IMO w deck than for e Classification ge purpose IMO Management
s BAM and not rt management"
ciety rules equipment only
Editor’s action comment.
Text updated to between IMO tyClassification ty
on review
clarify difference pe approval and pe approval.
N° Re- viewer Initials
173 HP
174 HP
175 HP
176 HP
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
Clause 5.2.3 Figure 4 Figure 5
struc
Clause 5.4
edito
Clause 5.4 Figure 6
struc
Clause struc
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
or all aConseqfrom beIEC ha61924-Furthein addi(IEC 61propriefor 201
ctural See pic
orial Typo.
ctural For Effwithin Ireplacedetail.Anotheapprovsimilar Last coFigure be trueInmarsnot par(enviroSee Pi
ctural Basic c
Page 86 of 91
wer's Comments
alert are centralizequence is that maelow deck source
as already specifie-2 INS) r IEC is working otion to standardiz1162-450) explainetary, etc. and the8 publishing. ctures 3 and 4 in t
Change "IEC 621
ficienSea2 "eNaviIMO type approvae current paper ba
er confusion is aroval. They are subj
to the type approonfusing detail is t6 out of type app
e for the future. Ssat, very soon alsort of type approva
onmental rules, escture 5 in the end
component of cyb
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
ed - partial implemany vessel have IMs
ed how to impleme
on a new standarded serial line (IECn a converter betw standardized inte
the end of this rev
162-460" as "IEC
gation" is IMO e-Nal. Otherwise e-Nased solution. Th
ound Automation Sject to class socie
oval required for ththe fact that all coroval domain. Thatellite terminal bo Iridium) are partl regime although
specially EMC ruled of this review co
ber security are: au
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
mentation is not acMO BAM which al
ent the Alert comm
d for BAM (IEC 62C 61162-1) and staween historical legerfaces. The stan
view document
61162-460"
Navigation. IMO eavigation solutione figure 6 is not c
System being parety approvals, whihe rest. ommunication devhat is not true todaeing part of GMDSt type approved re it is covered part
es) by IMO resolutmment document
uthentication, inte
cceptable. lso show alerts
munication (IEC
2923), which will andardized LAN
gacy, ndard is planned
e-Navigation is ns cannot legally correct for this
rt of type ch are not
ices are in the ay and will not SS (today
egime - VSAT is tly tion A.694(17). t
egrity and
Editor’s action comment.
Agree to the profigures updated.
fixed
E2 is not only eNeNavigation is nbecome mandatWill it then be wapproved doma It should be noteusing the term Tequipment that irules. It will howhighlight that in report. Text updated to between IMO tyClassification tyHave tried to ma
on review
oposed changes, .
Navigation. not planned to tory. ithin the type in?
ed that Class is alType Approved foris fulfilling their
wever be useful to the text of the
clarify difference pe approval and pe approval. ake it more clear
lso r
N° Re- viewer Initials
177 HP
178 HP
179 HP
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
7.2 Figure 10
Clause 7.4 Figure 11
struc
Clause 7.5 Figure 12
struc
Clause 7.6 Figure 13
struc
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
confideToday Guidelbasic aAnotheIntegritSee Pi
ctural Some BiggesundereSee Pi
ctural Some cshould See Pi
ctural SeveraUse of as a mbut theact shaAlso onfulfill eqapplica
Page 87 of 91
wer's Comments
entiality. in the second yeaine it is unrealistic
authentication. er detail which is tty check shall be acture 6 in the end
priority classificatst finding is that daestimated cture 7 in the end
classification shou be added. cture 8 in the end
al issues MMS for MSI. Maritime chat. I do
e use of MMS for mall be arranged to ne cannot use a cquipment rule to pable in addition to
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
ar of establishing c to assume that a
totally missing in Fadded to every se
d of this review co
ion should be chaata volumes for S
d of this review co
uld be changed a
d of this review co
MMS is not very weo not say that use mandatory items fbe clearly disting
common history lopreserve history loMSI for all servic
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
of the IMO Cyber any new service c
Figure 10 is "integervice. mment document
anged. ea Charts is totall
mment document
nd a column for In
mment document
ell defined. Someof MMS for MSI isfor which user hasuishable for nice t
og with all the otheog of MSI. This coes which have ide
Security could be without
grity". Obviously
t
y
t
nmarsat C
t
e understand it s impossible, s obligation to to know, etc. er MMS chat to omment is entified legal
Editor’s action comment.
that integrity is pauthentication.We see the two authentication ..(clients/servers/authentication osupposed to inc MSP tables reviAgree to commemore work on thand the MSP deused there. Howtime, it is not seehave effect on tharchitecture. MSP tables hasthe received inp Disclaimer of nutables added to Same action as
Same action as
on review
part of data
types of one is entities
/users) … anotherof data. The latter lude integrity.
ewed and updateents, we need to dhe MSP use-casesesign. Input will bewever, at this poinen that changes whe proposed
been updated wiput.
umbers in MSP report. HP-9
HP-9
r is is
ed. do s e t in will
th
N° Re- viewer Initials
180 HP
181 HP
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
Clause 7.7 1st para
struc
Clause 9.3
struc
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
status Route the Momandasee hoespeciabased unders"monkethe coo
ctural The listheir upcharts)
ctural Basicaalreadybe addadded) IHO haselectetwo wosecuritpublishpublishcyber sAuthensectionPublic Integritmethodis both Confideencryp
Page 88 of 91
wer's Comments
and end user oblidata. IEC has sta
onalisa-project (avatory to implementow other formats oally as such formaon international s
stand how MMS coey interface" (= a ordinates into his t of data formats mpdates (both curre)
ally the existing coy going on in the ided at the end of e)
as created and maed by IMO to be thorkgroups (S100Wy to be included in
hing. The S-100 mhing to include plasecurity can be suntication: Will use n of dataset(s). RKey ty: Will share PKI d is such that he d authentication ofentiality: This is th
ption (note depend
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
igation to act. andardized the Rovailable in IEC 611t for all new ECDI
or methods could ats should go throstandard. Therefoould be used for Rhuman operator rECDIS) miss ISO 8211, went S-57 ENC cha
ontent is good, butnternational stand
existing clause 9.3
aintains the baselhe baseline for all
WG and DPSWG) nto the S-100 bas
metadata will alreaaceholders for digiummarized PKI, digital signateceiver check dig
and digital signatdigital signature isf the source and inhe encryption. S-ding of service the
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
oute Exchange for174 Ed4). This foS equipment. It ispenetrate to the m
ough the type appore it is difficult for Route data unlessread text of MMS
which is used by Earts and future S-1
t it miss one impodardization. This 3 (Below is propos
ine S-100 standarIMO e-Navigationare already drafti
seline most probaady amended for eital signatures. Ba
ture(s) are embedgital signature aga
ure used for authes calculated over tntegrity check of t100 will not requir
e data is either con
rmat used by ormat is s very difficult to
market roval process me to
s the idea is a and then enter
NC charts and 101 ENC
rtant element element could sal for text to be
rd which is n. Within IHO ng cyber bly for 2018 edition 2.1.0 asic concept of
dded in header ainst delivered
entication. The the data. Result he data. re mandatory nfidential or
Editor’s action comment.
Added.
Have added theparagraph. The chapter purmention ongoingdetail.
on review
e first suggested
rpose is here to g work, but not in
N° Re- viewer Initials
182 HP
183 HP
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
Clause 9.3.4
struc
Clause 9.3.4
Stru
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
intendemethodexampspecifyin use ISO 82Distribudistribumethodcertificaend of long laofferingand unin mari
cture The 2 fwritten equipmwhite v First is2015) aproducpassed Second460-Swcommucard slmemorBased -460 ba
ucture Within Basica
Page 89 of 91
wer's Comments
ed for public availads and it is a task
ple S-101 for ENCy if encryption is u(Note: similar arra
211, S-102 use HDution of keys. IHOuted Public keys. d used by HTTPSates are checked chain). The pre-dtency times and dg file transfer to ovnder IHO S-63 it htime domain. first paragraphs a that there are 2 s
ment and b) unconview.
sue to note is thaand therefore man
cts available in thed type approval te
d issue is that onewitch(es) and 460unication devices ots, etc. for whichry/device/etc.. on what I said abased system. 9.3.4 there is "su
ally I agree. Mariti
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
ability). S-100 wiof the S-100 bas chart, S-102 for Bsed and, if used,
angement as for eDF-5, etc.) O has already in uThis is different a
S (HTTPS use chauntil a Certificate
distributed public dropouts (see 7.6.vercome problemas a successful s
are about "Missionsubcategories: a) ntrolled legacy. I s
t IEC 61162-460 nufacturers have e market. Furtherest in Apr 2016.
e can build -460 c-Gateway(s), if thdo not include op
h user could insert
bove it is already p
b-section" "2) uncime Cloud itself w
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
ll include multiple ed Product SpecifBathymetric chartwhich method of
encoding: for exam
use a PKI method arrangement than ain of trust in whic Authority (CA) is key method is not.2 and SATCOM ps with latency andervice history clos
n critical equipmenvery rare 61162-4strongly disagree
is just recently punot had enough tiI know that first e
compliant network e connected navig
pen UBS-ports, opt an uncontrolled
possible to build a
controlled equipmewill be seen as an "
encryption fication (for s, etc.) to the available is mple S-101 use
based on pre-the certificate h linked found in the
t vulnerable to providers d drop-outs) se to 20 years
nt" in which it is 460 compliant so black and
blished (Aug ime to make equipment has
by just utilizing gation or
pen SD-memory
a type approved
ent" "uncontrolled
Editor’s action comment.
Reformulated tois a range from conforming at al
Will use this inpservice design la
on review
o illustrate that thelegacy not ll, to full conformin
ut when we get toater in E2.
ere
ng.
o
N° Re- viewer Initials
184 ESP
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
Figure 20 Edit
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
networwithin tFurthecontrolMy firsSimplethe DMexampmethodexamploadingby manyou ca460 is historiealso unNetworThe cubetweeboth arprincipCloud have thincludemethodservicepull meansweside). etc. of securitinside t
orial no connaviga
Page 90 of 91
wer's Comments
rk". Nice to know the "uncontrolled r I agree with the led Navigation net comment start fr
est method to makMZ of the 460-Gateple M:). This is ved to load ENC cha
ple drive D:), interng a mapped netwony companies althll it", etc. have nota new standard fr
es up to 5-10 yearnnecessary to sperk side.
urrent wording proen Maritime Cloudre possible. For aally different solut(push-method) orheir pros and conse an automatic loads of the Cloud toe(s) which the useethod is that the 4r to any external rIn the push methoevery 460-Gatewy con is that throuthe secure 460-Nnection between tion
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
features like the 3part". idea that the Mar
etwork through 46rom "How to use tke files available ineway visible as mry handy as in praarts and updates. nal USB-port (for eork drive in DMZ. hough their "servict yet been type aprom Aug 2015 andrs already). This ecify/recommend
opose 1) manual od and DMZ. Off coautomatic transfertions. Automatic tr by the 460-Gatews. In case of the pading robot who iso find ports, URL aer have requested460-Gateway can request from the uod the Cloud need
way for which he nugh this path also etwork side. automation and n
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
3 bullet points cou
itime Cloud is con0-Gateway. the files inside 460nside the 460-Net
mapped network dractice every ECDI Loading from intexample E:) is no This method is ace boxes", "gatewpproved as -460 (td the services hasmapped network port number, etc.
or 2) automatic traourse at this levelr there exists howetransfer could be way (pull method)pull method the 46s able to use the daddresses, etc. of . The big cyber sbe made stealth (uncontrolled netwod to know port nueed to push data.the cyber attacke
navigation and no
uld stay forever
nnected to a
0-network" twork is to make rive (for IS include a ernal DVD (for
ot different from lso field proven
ways", "what do this because -s operational drive makes at the 460-
ansfer of data l I agree that ever two initiated by the ). Both methods 60-gateway
discovery the available
security pro for (i.e. it do not ork / Internet mber, address . The big cyber er can penetrate
connection to
Editor’s action comment.
Changed
on review
N° Re- viewer Initials
185 ESP 186 ESP
187 ESP
188 ESP
Reference in doc. (General or Paragraph, Figure …)
Typ(editostrucformuerror
Figure 21 EditFigure 22 Stru
Figure 22,23 and 24
Stru
Chapter 11
Gen
pe orial,
ctural, ulation )
Review
orial no conuctural “-450 s
uctural Novel E
-460 ga
neral MCC togatewa
Page 91 of 91
wer's Comments
nection between secure network” to
E-navigation to beateway
o exist as multipleay
“This project has recethe European Union’sresearch and innovatunder grant agreeme
s, Question and P
automation and no be changed to “S
e separate entity o
e instances on-boa
eived funding from s Horizon 2020 tion programme nt No 636329”.
Proposals
navigation Secure Network”
outside navigation
ard … i.e. one in e
n, and with own
each -460
Editor’s action comment.
Changed Changed
Changed
Notes on this disadded to report.discussed in theMSP design.
on review
scussion has bee This topic to be
e further work on
n
top related