Top Banner
An introduction to WORD OF MOUTH MARKETING What it is and how to use it. A primer for software company CEOs and CMOs who need to drive sales with more credible marketing. The goal of this white paper is to help you understand the process well enough to know where to turn for help. Awareness of word of mouth (WOM) is growing exponentially in the press and in the marketplace…and yet its application is often poorly understood. There are currently several versions in vogue. The major word of mouth trade associations (www.womma.org and www.vbma.net ) are still struggling to define the ground rules for its deployment. This document offers the author’s views shaped over the past four years by many of the major resources impacting this powerful approach to new business. It provides solid case studies and shows how to get started. Many marketers refer to word of mouth as the world’s greatest sales force. It could be! By Keith W. Bates [email protected] April 24, 2005, Version 1.7 www.illinoistech.org COMPILED BY SPONSORED BY
35
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Word of Mouth White Paper

An introduction to WORD OF MOUTH

MARKETING

What it is and how to use it. A primer for software company CEOs and CMOs who need to

drive sales with more credible marketing.

COMPIL

The goal of this white paper is to help you understand the process well enough to know where to turn for help. Awareness of word of mouth (WOM) is growing exponentially in the press and in the marketplace…and yet its application is often poorly understood. There are currently several versions in vogue. The major word of mouth trade associations (www.womma.org and www.vbma.net) are still struggling to define the ground rules for its deployment. This document offers the author’s views shaped over the past four years by many of the major resources impacting this powerful approach to new business. It provides solid case studies and shows how to get started. Many marketers refer to word of mouth as the world’s greatest sales force. It could be!

By

Keith W. Bates [email protected]

April 24, 2005, Version 1.7

www.illinoistech.org

ED BY

SPONSORED BY

Page 2: Word of Mouth White Paper

About the Illinois Technology Association THE ITA MISSION: The Illinois Information Technology Association exists to be a leading change agent that drives

growth, development and retention of IT-focused businesses and talent in Illinois by providing networking, advocacy,

resources and leadership. They serve members in Chicago-land and throughout the State and exist to help grow the

number of successful businesses that create, deploy and utilize information technology as a core part of their

organization. www.illinoistech.org

We represent the interests of our diverse membership at a local and national level, and work to connect member

companies with each other and the resources they need to succeed. The ITA continues on a more than twenty year

tradition of service to the technology community, and in 2005 was renamed from the Chicago Software Association

(CSA). The CSA had a solid program and had been recognized as one of the most important technology

organizations in the Midwest. ITA remains committed to continuing the good programs we began as the CSA.

About Keith Bates The MISSION of this Keith Bates effort is to offer the members of the Illinois Technology Association a resource

where they can benefit from the past four years of Bates’ research into Word of Mouth marketing. That research was

preceded by 30 years as CEO/Creative Director of Keith Bates & Associates Inc., a high tech ad agency Bates

founded in 1970 to serve exclusively the software industry. He also founded Walker-Bates, a high tech PR firm that

he managed concurrently with the ad agency. Over those years his agency and PR firm supported the sales and

marketing communications needs of more than 150 software/services vendors. www.kbates.com

What is the inspiration behind this seemingly altruistic effort? Bates was inspired by Peter Drucker, the great

management writer and thought leader, who has a goal of learning something completely new, in depth, every

decade. This decade’s learning for Bates (which began in 2001) has been word of mouth marketing and its

application to the software industry. Today the technology industry is being challenged to improve both marketing’s

efficiency and credibility while reducing costs. Word of mouth offers these solutions and Bates wants to share what

he’s learned in hopes of shortening someone else’s learning curve.

2

Page 3: Word of Mouth White Paper

EXECUTIVE OVERVIEW ………………………………………………… EVERYTHING YOU ALWAYS WANTED TO KNOW ABOUT WOM Word of mouth marketing defined ………………………………… Viral marketing explained …………………………………………… Benefits to marketers and buyers ………………………………… Word of mouth stories and case studies ………………………… Choose your approach: ……………………………………………… Influencer Relations ………………………………………… The Ideavirus ………………………………………………… The Shockvirus ……………………………………………… Costs overview ……………………………………………………… Challenges to implementation ……………………………………… The deliverables from WOM marketing …………………………… Launching a WOM program ………………………………………… Understanding network hubs ……………………………………… Warning: Failure to explore all three could be hazardous……… Random comments from practitioners, authors, WOMMA, and V Report on the first ever WOMMA Summit ................................. WOMMA Code of Ethics …………………………………………… WOM’S NATURE AS PRESCRIBED BY ITS AUTHORS/PRACTITIO Regis McKenna, Word of Mouth …………………………………… Malcolm Gladwell, The Tipping Point ……………………………… Seth Godin, Unleashing the Ideavirus …………………………… Emanuel Rosen, The Anatomy of Buzz …………………………… George Silverman, The Secrets of Word of Mouth Marketing … Jackie Huba and Ben McConnell, Creating Customer Evangelis Ed Keller and Jon Berry, The Influentials ………………………… Paul Rand, Ketchum ………………………………………………… VBMA Global………………………………………………………… Andy Sernovitz, WOMMA …………………………………………… CONCLUSION: A ONE PAGE CALL TO ACTION If you found this white paper provocative enough to study its de APPENDIX: A ONE PAGE LAUNCH OUTLINE A KBA Communications Support Plan focused on WOMM ……

3

Table of Contents

………………………………………..

………………………………………… ……………………………………….. ……………………………………....

…………………………..…………… ………………………………………. ………………………………………

………………………………………. …………………………………….… …………………….…………………. ………………………..……………… ……………………..……………….. …………………………..………….. ……………………………..………..

…………………………..………….… …………………………………..……. BMA …………………………..…….

........................................................ ……………………………………..…

NERS ............................................ ……………………………………….. ………………………………………

………………………………………… ………………………………….……

………………………………………... ts .……………………………………. …………………………………..…… …………………………………….…

…………………………………….… ………………………………………

tails…then do something! ……..….

………………………………………..

4

6 6 6 6 7

11 11 12 13 13 14 14 14 14 16 16 19 22

23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33

34

35

Page 4: Word of Mouth White Paper

…to add wings to your marketing, spurs to your sales

Executive Overview Awareness of word of mouth marketing (WOMM) is

growing exponentially in the press and in the

marketplace…and yet its application is often poorly

understood. The goal of this article is to help you

understand the process well enough to know where to

turn for help, or how to launch your own program.

WOMM Defined

For the purpose of this white paper I am dividing word

of mouth into several categories although in reality,

according to Dr. Paul Marsden, WOMM/Viral/Buzz are

all same thing, namely network enhanced Word of

Mouth. For those who want nuances: viral marketing

leverages digital networks; buzz leverages media

networks; and WOMM leverages social networks. Viral

marketing can employ either an ideavirus or shockvirus

approach, while social networking is typically managed

as influencer relations. Keep in mind that pure word of

mouth has no limits on distribution vehicles.

Viral Marketing Explained

And from Justin Kirby, Managing Director of DMC Ltd.,

“In fact the most successful use of online viral

marketing is not as a standalone tactic but as an

integrated part of a brand's overall marketing strategy.

One of the big mistakes brands make is thinking that an

online viral campaign is an end in itself rather than

recognizing that it's a means to an end. Viral marketing,

like PR, is a process not an event. Its point is to create

a buzz in order to help build brand and shift product, not

just to create a buzz full stop. There is no point in 'going

viral' without fulfilling a wider or longer-term strategic

purpose.

Metcalfe’s law, the power behind viral marketing

Metcalfe’s law tells us that the value of a network

increases with the square of the number of people

using it. So when you have 10 users in the world, that’s

25 times better than when there were two. And at 100

users your network is 1000 times better than at 10. With

100 user hubs your network has a reach of 10,000

people. 100 hubs seems to be the magic number.

Twenty five years after Regis McKenna published a

brochure touting the value of word of mouth the term

viral marketing was created by the VC firm Draper

Fisher Jurvetson. It was used to describe the

phenomenon of Hotmail, which grew with the rapidity of

a cold virus, from 0 to 12 million subscribers in eighteen

months. Viral marketing was pronounced marketing

buzzword of the year for 1998.

And then not much happened until 2001 when the July

30 issue of BusinessWeek carried Buzz Marketing as

their cover story. That’s also the year when four major

books came into being expanding on the concept of

word of mouth marketing. Those four books are

identified with stars on the Authors/Practitioners page.

Benefits of employing WOMM

Perhaps the first issue to resolve, because of the nature

of the audience for this white paper, is whether WOM

lends itself better to consumer marketing or business to

business. The answer is “both” equally well. In the B2B

world it is particularly well suited to the pharmaceutical

and technology industries because of the need for one

on one conversation about technical aspects.

From the customers point of view word of mouth

emanates from a trusted source, is credible, friendly,

and tuned to the listener’s personal interests. It also

overcomes the four most feared words in advertising,

“I don’t believe you”.

4

Page 5: Word of Mouth White Paper

Stories and Case Studies

From Stanley Arnold’s Tale of a Blue Horse to the

incredible stories of Hotmail, Post-it Notes and a dozen

others you’ll find inspiring success stories. Netscape,

Napster, Trivial Pursuit, and BullGuard software

security all offer exciting examples of WOM.

Choose the approach that best fits your needs.

There are three, and they range from Ideaviruses to

Shockviruses to Influentials.

Ideaviruses are predicated on spreading the word

based on a superior product. Shockviruses are

predicated on spreading the word based on superior

advertising. And Influentials are predicated on

spreading the word based on either evangelists, or the

mavens and connectors that populate network hubs

who are persuaded to spread the word based on either

the user’s enthusiasm for the product or corporate

sponsored relationships.

A point of clarification contributed by Justin Kirby,

“What’s the difference between Viral Advertising and

Viral Marketing? Well any viral advertising campaign is

doing viral marketing but what is specific about viral

advertising is the use of creative agents rather than the

amplification and acceleration of product

recommendations”. And referencing a recent Marketing

Sherpa report, “The reason you focus on the creative

agents is because the product normally doesn’t have a

uniqueness that can be leveraged to amplify and

accelerate word of mouth. So you make the creative

agent/communications sticky because the product isn’t

necessarily.”

Costs Overview You will encounter two sets of costs if you pursue a

WOM program. First will be an ongoing monthly fee to

design and manage the process. These monthly fees

can range from $5,000 to $20,000 and will probably be

based on a one year commitment. Second will be your

out of pocket costs for production services which need

to be estimated before a commitment is made … but

this cannot be accomplished until the planning is done.

Challenges to implementation

Both WOM and viral marketing can be a tough sell to

management because they reflect a major change in

the typical approach to marketing communications.

However they solve some big sales and marketing

problems … like qualified leads, shorter selling cycles,

and often an overall reduction in the cost of sales.

Deliverables from your WOM marcom group

Marketing’s deliverables include development of a

virusworthy product or story, databases of power

influencers, messaging and assistance with accelerated

contagion or seeding.

Launching a WOM program

I mentioned earlier that WOM is not a standalone tactic,

but rather a component in your overall marketing

strategy. So before putting all your eggs in the WOM

basket be sure you develop a comprehensive

Communications Support Plan.

Understanding network hubs

Network hubs are individuals who communicate with

more people about a certain product than the average

person does. Researchers have traditionally referred to

them as “opinion leaders.” In industry they’re called

”influencers,” “lead users,” or sometimes “power users.”

They are the 10% who influence the 90%.

To wrap this up read seven pages of random comments from practitioners, pioneering WOM authors, and my friends from both WOMMA and VBMA.

Where to turn then? Help can be found via word of

mouth consultants, ad agencies, and PR firms.

5

Page 6: Word of Mouth White Paper

…to add wings to your marketing, spurs to your sales

Everything you ever wanted to know about WOM WORD OF MOUTH DEFINED

Regis McKenna’s explains the difference between word

of mouth and all other forms of communications with the

following. “It is an experienced process, rather than an

observed one. The message is tuned to the individual

listener. The credibility of the speaker carries over to

the message immediately. Experts can be used in this

medium without the negative effect of commercializing

his or her position and message. Efficiency… while

taking time to disseminate the message is delivered

directly to those who must use the information and act

on it. Feedback is instantaneous.”

To quote Emanuel Rosen’s The Anatomy of Buzz, “To

create buzz and use it effectively, you should have a

realistic view of the phenomenon, not glorify it. For

example, some word-of-mouth enthusiasts argue that if

you get good buzz, you don’t need to do any marketing.

This can be a major mistake. Distribution, advertising,

promotions and other traditional marketing activities can

translate the goodwill surrounding your product into

sales. Good buzz is the best thing you could wish for,

but it’s just one component of your marketing mix.”

VIRAL MARKETING EXPLAINED

Conceived in 1996. Born in 2001. It’s the management

of an “ideavirus”, or a “shockvirus” through word of

mouth online. It’s word of mouth on steroids.

It’s marketing’s response to the educated consumer

and the Internet. As the ability (speed) of customers to

communicate with customers grows stronger, the

credibility of marketers communicating with customers

grows weaker. If charging people for exposure to your

virus is going to slow down its spread give it away!

Apple cut the price of WebObjects from $50,000 to

$699 recognizing that unless a lot of people used their

software no one would use it!

WHY GO VIRAL? WHY CHOOSE WORD OF MOUTH?

BECAUSE TRADITIONAL ADVERTISING IS COSTLY

AND SERIOUSLY LACKING IN CREDIBILITY! And

because viral marketing has become the latest

stealth strategy for “qualified” lead generation.

What’s this viral marketing thing all about? Viral

marketing (VM) is defined as managing digitally-

augmented word of mouth, or buzz. “Digitally-

augmented” simply means using the Internet to deploy

your VM program and email is the primary tool of

choice. Word of mouth has been around since the

beginning of time but the spreading, without electronic

support, is typically both tedious and slow from a

marketing standpoint. The Internet has changed all that.

To quote Seth Godin from his Unleashing the

Ideavirus,”Stop marketing at people. Turn your ideas

into epidemics by helping your customers do the

marketing for you!”

BENEFITS TO MARKETERS AND BUYERS

The simplest reason for choosing word of mouth

marketing over traditional advertising is that it can be

FASTER, CHEAPER, BETTER! But no guarantees! A

recent study by advertising giant Euro RSCG

Worldwide states that for generating excitement about

products, word of mouth is 10 times more effective than

TV or print ads. If you can achieve focus on your

product’s virus-worthiness viral marketing will deliver

10X the market impact at 1/10th the cost. VM turns your

ideas into epidemics by helping your customers do the

marketing for you. It also overcomes the four most

feared words in advertising, “I don’t believe you”.

6

Page 7: Word of Mouth White Paper

Why the viral marketing approach to word of mouth? In

a nutshell it’s the speed and low cost distribution

enabled by the Internet. And because traditional

advertising is costly, not terribly productive anymore,

and lacking in credibility word of mouth marketing is

becoming the best way to launch a brand. Today the

speed of information diffusion enable by the Internet is

weakening the ability of marketers to communicate with

customers and strengthening the ability of customers to

communicate with customers.

From the customers point of view word of mouth

emanates from a trusted source, is credible, friendly,

tuned to the listener’s personal interests, very efficient,

and offers instant feedback. In other words, dialogue,

rather than monologue.

WORD OF MOUTH STORIES AND CASE STUDIES

From Stanley Arnold’s Tale of the Blue Horse, 1968

comes the story of United Airlines and how they used

word of mouth to inspire executive secretaries to

choose United over competitors when charged by their

bosses to book a flight. At that time United’s public

image seemed to lack something. Arnold’s suggestion:

send a freshly cut, long-stemmed rose every Monday of

every week for a year to the executive secretaries of the

top 1000 CEOs (fifty-two thousand roses). Plus a bud

vase with the first mailing. The result: doors closed

previously to United salesmen were suddenly open.

Within six months dramatic increases in ticketing

occurred.

Before General Foods could sell (new products) they

first had to announce this new line of products to their

salesmen—the men who would sit down with the buying

committees of the retails stores and try to persuade

them that a demand for (their new products) would be

sweeping the nation (via word of mouth). Young &

Rubicam, their ad agency, was therefore asked to

develop an imaginative idea that would help General

Foods introduce (the new products) to its sales force

with flair and confidence. Y&R turned to Stanley who

dreamed up the idea of a blue horse consistent with

General Foods promise that the new product line would

definitely be “a horse of a different color.”

On meeting day the blue horse had been tethered

to a tree about forty feet from the bar. After the first

round of drinks the salesmen of General Foods could

not believe their eyes. "These drinks are so damn

good," one of the regional sales managers said to me,

"I believe I see a blue horse out there." All the others

said the same thing, but none could believe what their

eyes told them.

Finally the meeting began as General Foods

announced to its salesmen that their company was

going to give them the most exciting line of products in

their company's glorious history. General Foods finally

revealed it was going into gourmet foods. Everyone

quickly had a second drink. The applause was

perfunctory. Some of the applause even sounded like

hissing.

"This is new territory for General Foods," the

speaker went on. You might even say that compared to

what you’ve been selling until now, this is a horse of a

different color.”

At that point they responded. They had seen a

blue horse out there. Now they knew what it was all

about. The meeting finally picked up momentum, and to

the extent that experienced food salesmen can

summon up enthusiasm for gourmet foods, these

salesmen were close to a level of exuberance. The

introduction of the gourmet line was dispatched beyond

anyone's expectations.

In Search of Excellence by Tom Peters and Robert

Waterman. In 1980 Peters and his coauthor Bob

Waterman, (McKinsey consultants) put together a 125-

page summary of what later became the classic

management book In Search of Excellence. They gave

it to just a few executives they knew, but very quickly

these individuals started discussing with others what

they had read. Tom Peters attributes part of the

success of his first book to an extensive seeding

campaign.

7

Page 8: Word of Mouth White Paper

VIRAL MARKETING STRATEGY: Successful

seeding is an active process. It goes well beyond the

Field of Dreams cliché "If you build it, they will come."

Rather than waiting passively for people to come to

you, you go out and plant seeds all around the forest.

Here are a few guidelines:

VIRAL MARKETING TACTICS: As word about the

coming book started to spread, demand soared, and

the authors decided to seed the market with 15,000

copies of this preliminary report. Their publisher was

worried that Peters and Waterman were giving too

many. Edward Burlingame, who commissioned the

book for Harper & Row, said that the company

expected to sell around 60,000 copies in the first year,

meaning that the 15,000 copies represented 25 percent

of that amount. But Peters believes that these copies

were important in generating word of mouth and sales.

"Within days of the book's launching, supportive

reviews appeared, and the network of 15,000 (plus at

least an equal number of photocopied knockoffs)

hurried to buy the real thing, often in bulk for their

subordinates," Peter recalls in Thriving on Chaos.

RESULTS: In Search of Excellence sold 1.5

million copies in hardcover alone.

The game of Trivial Pursuit sold 20 million copies in

1984 but word about the product didn’t spread by

contagion alone. Buzz was accelerated by a seeding

campaign. Samples were sent to celebrities mentioned

in the game. The helped start trivia parties which in tern

were encourage by more than 100 radio stations asking

trivia questions. They also sent teaser mailings to toy

buyers just before a major industry toy fair. Emanuel

Rosen calls this type of acceleration leapfrogging.

In 1993 people didn’t really understand online services.

AOL had formed alliances with major media but the

masses weren’t responding. Comprehension and

credibility were low. So Jan Brandt mailed 250 million

CDs to seed the market. The program cost $300 for a

new user worth only $124. It worked. After reaching

their tipping point costs dropped to less than $100 per

new user.

THEN THE INTERNET ARRIVED

The Hotmail story started in 1995 with two young men

from Silicon Valley, each working for a different

company, but needing to collaborate on a common

project without using their company’s email. Suddenly

they had a bright idea…a free email service that could

be accessed through the web. With only $300,000 in

VC seed money they launched the company. A word of

mouth program launched both electronically and face-

to-face started to spread the word. It was good old word

of mouth marketing at Internet speed. Within two

months they had 100,000 users, and by eighteen

months they had 12 million subscribers. The term viral

marketing evolved from this success story. Microsoft

bought Hotmail for $400 million and as of 2001 was

signing up a hundred thousand people a day.

Napster, a way of networking people’s hard drives so

that they can share music, spread so fast in only a few

months that it threatened the entire recording industry

and appeared on the cover of Newsweek!

The story of Post-It notes is so good it ought to be

apocryphal but it’s actually true. Nobody was buying

the. 3M was going to cancel the whole program. Then

the brand manager of the product persuaded the

secretary of the chairman of 3M to send a case of Post-

Its to the secretaries of the chairmen of the other 499

Fortune 500 Companies. Suddenly, the most powerful

sneezers in the most powerful companies in the country

were sending around memos, all containing comments

scrawled on Post-Its. It took just a few months after that

for it to become yet another successful business

communication device. A classic ideavirus.

From a recent Wall St. Journal article, “Airlines in

bankruptcy usually don’t have the luxury of grinding

through precious dollars with fancy image campaigns to

reassure nervous travelers. United spent some $30

8

Page 9: Word of Mouth White Paper

million on advertising in the first half of the year,

according to CMR/TNS Media Intelligence. But airlines

do have an army of messengers in flight attendants,

gate agents, and ticket-counter people, and the key is

to get them plugged in and on board quickly with

positive spin on a financial restructuring, crisis specialist

say. United’s ad agency, Publicis Groupe’s Fallon

Worldwide is managing the marketing plans.

While Starbucks and those offering Wi-Fi at hotels and

airports advertise their services online and through local

promotions, in the majority of cases word about free Wi-

Fi “hot spots” spreads by word-of-mouth—and fast.

From iMedia Communications, Inc.

Following the Sept 11 events, travel fell drastically in

the United States and the Travel Industry Association of

America (TIA) determined that there was a need for

some immediate action to encourage Americans to

travel again. The association conceived a "See America

Day" -- which coincided with Veterans' Day - - and

asked Ripple Effects Interactive (REI) to propose a

cost-effective Internet-based campaign.

REI determined that a grassroots e-mail campaign

leveraging the association's members was by far the

most cost-effective and impactful means of reaching

Americans interested in travel. As such, TIA forwarded

to each of its 2,200 members the flash creative and

encouraged them to forward it to their own e-mail lists --

thereby hundreds of thousands of would-be travelers.

Participants included Hotel Operators such as Ramada

and Travelodge, transporters like Amtrak, and Visitors'

Bureaus such as the Las Vegas CVB.

Now, of course this all needed to be done with a

very little budget. Hence, the viral e-mail (although we

like to call it "video e-mail). We asked two things of our

members:

1. Submit a special deal to be posted on

SeeAmerica.org

2. Take the viral e-mail and forward it on to their e-

mail lists (vendors, employees, customers, etc.)

The e-mail included a link back to the SeeAmerica.org

deals section.

Campaign Insights: The campaign won a gold

medal at the Hospitality Sales and Marketing

Association International (HSMAI) annual awards

ceremony held in New York in January. This is the most

prestigious Tourism Communication Competition.

Word of mouth makes the front page of the Wall Street

Journal: On Jan. 13, Shannon Syfrett, a 15-year- old

ninth-grader at Central Academy in Macon, Miss.,

launched a chain letter over the Internet. E-mail chains

that seek responses from around the world are the

latest rage in science-fair projects, as kids set out to

learn where and how fast information travels. Shannon

called her project "[email protected]," and

she expected that in six weeks she "might get 2,000 or

3,000" replies to her note asking people to write back

and then pass her message along. That was her first

miscalculation.

The next day, Jan. 14, the request she had sent to

23 people generated 200 e-mail replies, an average of

one every 7.2 minutes. By Jan. 16, messages had

arrived from 47 states and 25 countries, including

Australia and Zimbabwe. There were 8,768 e-mails on

Jan. 24, and another 12,013 three days later. They

were now arriving one every 7.2 seconds.

Overwhelmed and sick with the flu, Shannon shut

down her screen name for 2 1/2 days, but 9,455 e-mails

flooded in when she reopened it on Jan. 31, her log

shows. Messages from Libya and Iran popped up on

Feb. 2. On Feb. 4. Shannon and her parents emptied

the electronic mailbox 35 times--it holds 1,000 incoming

messages--but stilI, a man telephoned from France to

complain that he couldn't get his e-mail through. On

Feb. 5, there were another 37,854 e-mails, one every

2.3 seconds. Shannon pulled the plug, 17 days early.

Altogether, she had received 160,478 e-mails from 189

countries and 50 states.

From George Silverman: A complicated piece of

machinery required extensive research to buy, usually

9

Page 10: Word of Mouth White Paper

taking about six months. It then needed to be com-

pared to the alternatives, which also took months. Then

it had to be tried, which took about a year. Then it had

to be rolled out gradually, with training. Another year.

The whole thing was compressed into about eight

weeks by holding a seminar/training program, then

following it up by audio teleconferences. The decision

makers were given the material that would have taken

them months to find, shown how to evaluate it, given

extensive (and flattering) competitive materials, and

encouraged to try one against the other-all in a carefully

structured trial that kept several prospects in touch with

each other and with customers, with a hotline to third-

party experts. This word of mouth, applied to several

critical bottlenecks in the decision process, cut the

decision time by multiples, while at the same time

showing that the company had nothing to hide.

Netscape Navigator: Built entirely upon word of mouth,

Netscape captured about 90 percent of the Web

browser market before it placed its first ad. The

company did it by giving away the first versions of its

product, and by word of mouth, primarily on the

Internet. Netscape has now been overtaken by

Microsoft’s Internet Explorer (which stole a process

patented by Eolas Technologies Inc. to achieve this

feat).

BullGuard develops security software for the home user

The following case study is presented by fellow VBMA

member Claus Moseholm of GoViral.com for a

Denmark client of his www.bullguard.com/movies

Background

. BullGuard is a small company operating in a battle of

the giants (Norton & McAfee)

. BullGuard's marketing budget non-existent

. Viral is inexpensive compared to other consumer

advertising

Objectives

. To build awareness and interest towards a global

target group of home Internet users

. To brand BullGuard as "the young rebel" in the

security industry

. To generate trial downloads of the BullGuard security

software package

Solution

. Videos communicating overall USP . "Real life" web-,

surveillance- or video-cam shot, making the videos

appear very realistic

. Integrated into BullGuards corporate website

enhancing trial downloads.

. Daily surveillance - clips adjusted and optimized

during the first weeks after launch

Results . More than 10 million views

. Significant percentage of trial software downloads

. Growth in search engine traffic

. 317% growth in revenue in year one after launch

. Access to retail distribution side by side with main

competitors due to increased brand awareness.

. Plenty of PR and funnier company presentations

WHO ELSE IS DOING THIS? RECOGNIZE ANY OF THESE NAMES?

From "The Anatomy of Buzz" the listed companies include: Amazon.com, AOL, Amway, Apple Computer, Armani, AT&T, Avon, Barnes & Noble, Blair Witch Project, BMW, Budweiser, Car & Driver Magazine, Charles Schwab, Cisco Systems, CNN, Coca Cola, Compuserve, Crisco Oil, DaimlerChrysler, Dell Computer, EBay, Edison, FedEx, Ford Mustang, General Motors, Harper & Row, Hewlett Packard, Honda, Intel, Intuit, Kodak, Lotus, Macy's, McDonald's, MCI, Microsoft, Miller Brewing, Neiman Marcus, Nike, Nintendo, Palm Computing, Pepsi, Polaroid, Proctor & Gamble, Saks Fifth Avenue, Star Wars, Sun Microsystems, Taco Bell, 3COM, Twentieth Century Fox, Union Bank of California, Warner Brothers, Yahoo, Ziff Davis.

From "The Secrets of Word of Mouth Marketing": Adobe, AOL, Apple, Avon, Campbell Soup, Citigroup, Dell, Disney, Eudora, First USA, Google, Hotmail, McKinsey & Company, Microsoft, Napster, Roche Laboratories, United States Postal Service, Verizon DSL, Wall Street Journal, Xerox Parco

From "The Tipping Point"; ABC News, Airwalk Company, Audi Automobile, CBS, Centers for Disease Control, Century Wilshire Hotel, Coca Cola, Columbia Record Club, Glaxo Wellcome, Gore-Tex, Hush Puppies Shoes, New York City, Prozac, R.J. Reynolds, Sesame Street, TV Guide, Winston Cigarettes.

10

Page 11: Word of Mouth White Paper

From "Unleashing the ldeavirus"; Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, Amazon, com, American Airlines, American Express, American Greeting, Amway, AOL, Apple, Atkins Diet, Audi, Barnes & Noble, Budweiser, Burger King, Cisco, Clairol, Coke, eToys, FedEx, Google, Hallmark, Harry Potter, Herman Miller, Hotmail, Intel, Kodak, Lycos, Marlboro, Mary Kay Cosmetics, McDonalds, MCI, McKinsey, Microsoft, Napster, Nike, Palm, PC Magazine, Polaroid, Post-it- Notes, Priceline, Reebok, Rexall, Schick, Sports Illustrated, Starbucks, Star Wars, Martha Stewart, 3M, Time Warner, Tommy Hilfiger, Toyota, ToysRUs, Tupperware, Twentieth Century Fox, VW Beetle, Yahoo.

The companies in the foregoing list were referenced in

the four books published on the topic of word of

mouth/viral marketing in 2001. I cannot verify that these

are all case studies of viral marketing, only that they

touched the concept in some manner deemed

worthwhile by the various authors.

Hotmail, Yahoo!, eBay, Amazon, GeoCities,

Broadcast.com, Google—all of them succeeded

because an ideavirus was unleashed and spread.

To reach 10 million users it took radio 40 years, TV 15

years, Netscape 3 years, and both Hotmail and Napster

less than a year. Hotmail and Napster got the hang of

viral marketing.

CHOOSE YOUR APPROACH

There are several approaches for launching word of

mouth marketing and they vary substantially so it

seems worthwhile to study them separately. Variations

on the public relations industry concept of Influencer

Relations seems to be one of the more popular but

equally powerful in a slightly different fashion are two

flavors of viral marketing, which I have arbitrarily divided

into the Ideavirus approach and the Shockvirus

approach.

• INFLUENCER RELATIONS

From my friend Patrick Rooney of Expand

Communications come the following thoughts:

“What is Influencer Relations? Influencer Relations is a

program to help ensure clients benefit from the lasting

value of their relationships with elite industry

influencers. The buying decisions of your customers are

influenced by a far broader base than media and

industry analysts, although each is vital to the overall

communications mix. Today, the purchasing process is

influenced by a broad array of friends, colleagues and

peers, pundits, academics, authors, researchers, and

many others. What’s more, each market has its own set

of influencers, making it necessary to understand how

to identify, and then to reach, these new influencers.

Simply put, the mantle of thought leadership and

influence has fragmented, resulting in the need to

expand your communications.”

Many years ago I managed the high tech public

relations firm that I founded with Rich Walker. I wish I

had understood influencer relations at that time.

Regis McKenna summed it up well in his 1982 brochure

on Word of Mouth which states, “Regarding the 90-10

Rule – by now one might be saying, ‘Okay, by talking to

everyone in the world we can better communicate our

message. That's not practical or possible, Right!’ But

the 90-10 rule states that 90 percent of the world is

influenced by the other 10 percent. There are probably

no more than 20 or 30 people in any one industry who

have a major impact on trends, standards, opinion and

a company's image or character.

Certainly we know this is true in the media and financial

community. While there may be dozens of magazines

and mountains of analysis covering an industry, only

several have real influence and impact. This is true

within companies as well. A relatively few people hold

the key to power in any organization. This is not to say

that these key influences are easy to reach. A memo

may reach them easier, but credible word-of-mouth

approach will be far more influential and effective.”

LAUNCHING INFLUENCER RELATIONS:

Start by getting management’s acceptance of the

principles of the seminal Ed Keller/Jon Berry book on

influencer relations titled The Influentials.

11

Page 12: Word of Mouth White Paper

The following outline is presented to you courtesy of

Ketchum’s recently introduced, proprietary IRM

(Influencer Relationship Management) program. It uses

a highly targeted approach rather than traditional mass

media to identify, target and connect with individuals

and groups that can directly affect buyer’s perceptions

and behaviors.

1. Start the process of market segmentation and

identification of “key three” most critical proponents;

initial influencers, ultimate influencers, buyers and

decision makers.

2. Ecosystem and mapping is based on clearly

determining desired mindset, actions and impact of Key

Three and Initial Influencers

3. Prioritization and Benchmarking.

4. Strategic Alignment (program development)

5. Engagement

6. Measure: With priorities, benchmarks and programs

formalized IRM measures specific agreed upon values.

7. Manage

• THE IDEAVIRUS

An Ideaviruses is about the concept of the product while

a Shockvirus is about the presentation of the product.

One is about good ideas and the other about good

presentations. Traditionally great ideas last longer than

great presentations.

Depending on where you live, although the lines are

blurring today, you may be exposed to either

ideaviruses or shockviruses. Viral marketing in the UK

is a little different than the early efforts of viral marketing

in the US. Their leading practitioners depend more on

powerful graphics than unique product attributes to

convey the power of the product. They focus more on

“shockviruses” than “ideaviruses”, simply two schools of

thought. Both are effective.

The Ideavirus was really the pioneering viral marketing

catalyst and traces the concept of its origin back to

Geoffrey Moore’s Crossing the Chasm where he

discusses technology adoption, "…any time we are

introduced to products that require us to change our

current mode of behavior or to modify other products

and services we rely on … such change-sensitive

products are called discontinuous innovations. The

contrasting term, continuous innovations, refers to the

normal upgrading of products that do not require us to

change behavior."

Ideaviruses represent discontinuous product

innovations. I like Geoffrey Nicholson’s (VP Technical

Planning/Technical Ops for 3M) statement from some

years back that I saved. “If an idea doesn’t stop people

in their tracks, then maybe it’s just an incremental

change and not an innovation at all.” Ideaviruses have

nothing at all to do with incremental change. You must

think long and hard about which approach is best.

So if you don’t have a unique idea perhaps you should

explore a shocking presentation…which is what many

companies in the United States and the rest of the

world are doing these days…

LAUNCHING AN IDEAVIRUS:

To quote Seth Godin, “…to embrace ideavirus

marketing techniques you also have to accept a change

from the status quo. And many of the executives who

are now in charge made their way to the top by

embracing the status quo, not fighting it.”

First, and often the biggest challenge is to get

management acceptance of Metcalfe’s law that tells us

that the value of a network increases with the square of

the number of people using it. So when you have 10

users in the world, that's 25 times better than when

there were two. And at 100 users your network is 1000

times better than at 10. With 100 user hubs your

network has a reach of 10,000 people. For success a

large user base is imperative. 100 Network Hubs

seeming to be the magic number.

The challenge I’ve encountered is with startup

companies who don’t have a hundred users and are

reluctant to give product away, or with established

companies who get a lot of money for their product and

12

Page 13: Word of Mouth White Paper

are reluctant to give up any income. These giveaways

should be considered beta sites.

• THE SHOCKVIRUS

Shockviruses are typified by shocking graphics and

tend to rely more on entertainment and visual

excitement for their distribution. DMC and The Viral

Factory were early proponents of this approach.

Ideaviruses traditionally have relied more on unique

product attributes although that is changing rapidly as I

write this. Other issues to contend with have to do with

augmenting your viral marketing. Shockviruses tend to

have a shorter life than ideaviruses. But ideaviruses are

dependent on powerful product discontinuous

innovations while any brilliant creative director can

come up with a shockvirus. Because either approach

will wear out its welcome once the newness and

excitement grow old you must explore ways to

augment, or maintain or reinforce your message.

Augmentation typically uses traditional integrated direct

marketing programs, whether ongoing or of the 90-Day

Blitz variety, and are often supported by public

relations. Viral augmentation tactics also will be heavily

dependent also on the Internet.

What’s a 90-Day Blitz? Simply a deluge of marketing

materials that acts as a quick fix for inadequate lead

flow. Pioneered by Ernan Roman it’s a multimedia, lead

generation activity based on response compression

techniques. It is a fully integrated 3 month program that

combines traditional media with interactive media to

create a sense of event, which in turn produces a

substantial flow of leads in a very short time with

minimal commitment of financial resources. For 20

years it’s been a hot seller at the Bates agency.

LAUNCHING A SHOCKVIRUS:

The first challenge to getting started with the Shockvirus

approach is locate a production firm with the creative

expertise, and experience to build a virus so

provocative that it spreads to epidemic proportions …

like the recent Subservient Chicken from Burger King.

And the second challenge is then to assign a viral

marketing / creative consultant to work with the

production company who understands the product and

market well enough to keep the viral creatives on track.

This person could come from the ranks of creative

consultants or ad agency creative directors.

Then you follow these next few steps which have much

in common with the Ideavirus approach.

1. Identify Regular and Mega level hubs within

your Network Hubs databases.

2. Develop virus-worthiness concept/strategy

around which the Shockvirus will be developed.

3. Write copy /design storyboards to support the

Shockvirus and generate buzz

4. Expose the virus through regular/mega hubs.

5. Support the epidemic with accelerated

contagion which can be ongoing ad and PR work or a

blitz tactic.

NOTE: Before considering a viral marketing program

please take a moment for introspection:

What is the buzz that your company wishes to spread,

hopefully to epidemic proportions? In ten words or less,

what makes your product virusworthy? If you can’t

come up with an answer fix the product, or reposition

your marketing differentiation message.

COSTS OVERVIEW

To use the Marcom Engine model I developed many

years ago is to use a six step process that is common

knowledge among marketers. First there’s a Planning

Module that delivers an audit of the market followed by

strategy development which is in turn followed by the

creative process. Second is the Execution Module

which develops the arsenal of marcom tools, the actual

deployment of the strategy/tactics, and finally the

tracking and maintenance of the program.

For the PLANNING MODULE and its three components

typical monthly fees of a marketing consultant, whether

independent, or attached to an ad agency or PR firm

13

Page 14: Word of Mouth White Paper

can range from a low of $5,000 to $20,000 or more for

large companies in big markets.

For the EXECUTION MODULE and its three

components costs cannot be estimated until the

planning stages, complete with media strategy, are

completed and are more inclined to represent out of

pocket expenses. They can vary dramatically from one

campaign to the next depending largely on media and

the complexity of your accelerated contagion plan.

CHALLENGES TO IMPLEMENTATION Both word of mouth and viral marketing are often a

tough sell to management because it reflects a major

change in the status quo. Budgeting for ads, direct mail,

and websites is done every day. But word of mouth

marketing? What’s that? It wasn’t invented here.

Remember also that an ideavirus adores a vacuum.

You’ve got to be first. If you’ve got a product and it’s not

unique, consider changing the product—or the playing

field. Your idea needs to be inherently unique, or

positioned to appear so.

However, viral marketing can solve some BIG

marketing problems. Like achieving quarterly revenue

goals. Increasing the numbers of qualified leads.

Shortening of selling cycles. Reducing the overall costs

of marketing. And inspiring employee and vendor

evangelism.

THE DELIVERABLES FROM WOM MARKETING

Depending on whether you opt for influentials,

shockviruses, or ideaviruses the deliverables may vary

slightly but from any of the approaches you should

receive:

• Development of a newsworthy product

• Database of power influencers

• Message development

• An accelerated contagion strategy

LAUNCHING A WOM PROGRAM

One approach is the Marcom Engine from which

evolves the Communications Support Plan. The

Marcom Engine blends the disciplines of Business

Process Reengineering (BPR) with Integrated

Marketing Communications (IMC) as well as concepts

from Geoffrey Moore‘s TALC (technology adoption life

cycle) approach in Crossing the Chasm. It drives

revenue enhancement by fine tuning the value

proposition into the most compelling reason to buy, and

by reducing the waste and inefficiency of the typical

random task approach to marketing. Plus … it is the

single most efficient way to manage a product launch.

The Marcom Engine typically consists of six modules,

three for Planning and three for Execution but can be

shortened for convenience to three:

• Audit and Strategy: Do your homework. Build a

marcom team. Develop a plan. Identify network hubs

• Creative and Arsenal: Develop virus-worthiness

messaging, copy and art. Build the arsenal.

• Deployment and Monitoring: Define a media plan;

expose the virus through mega/regular hubs. Then

plan support with accelerated contagion. Monitor.

Start by creating small movements first. The big one

follows. A paradox of word of mouth marketing is that

before creating one contagious movement you have to

create many small movements first. This means that

before you can fan the flames you have to ignite the

fire.

Igniting the fire means that first you must understand

the “Law of the Few”. Spreading the word depends on

people who are either experts or possessed with a rare

set of social gifts. They’re called power influencers and

evangelists. And they are found as spokes in your

Network Hubs and are further refined as Regular Hubs

(non-media people), and Mega Hubs (media people).

UNDERSTANDING NETWORK HUBS

The following section on Network Hubs was extracted

from Emanuel Rosen’s The Anatomy of Buzz, and

Malcolm Gladwell’s The Tipping Point, and then edited

by Keith Bates.

14

Page 15: Word of Mouth White Paper

NETWORK HUBS

Network hubs are individuals who communicate with

more people about a certain product than the average

person does. Researchers have traditionally referred to

them as “opinion leaders.” In industry they’re called

”influencers,” “lead users,” or sometimes “power users.”

There are two major types of “Network Hubs”: Regular

Hubs, acting as regular folks who serve as sources of

information and influence in a certain product category

and may be connected to only a few other individuals--

or to several dozens. And Mega Hubs, which refers to

the press, celebrities, analysts, and politicians. Both

these categories have subsets, known as Mavens and

Connectors.

Mavens (those who accumulate knowledge) are

listened to because they have demonstrated significant

knowledge of a certain area (at the very least, they

have convinced others of their authority on a subject).

Mavens tend to specialize in one narrow field of interest

(movies, computers, corporate governance, and

litigation).

Connectors are those people in every group who are

more central because they are charismatic, are trusted

by their peers, or are simply more socially active.

Connectors know lots of the right kind of people.

Let me offer an easy acronym you can use to

remember them: network hubs are ACTIVE. They are

Ahead in adoption, Connected, Travelers, Information-

hungry, Vocal, and Exposed to the media more than

others. Network hubs are usually not the first to adopt a

new product, but they are at least slightly ahead of the

rest in their networks.

The fact is, not much is definitively known about

network hubs; moreover, the nature of network hubs

may differ from industry to industry. You won’t find their

names and addresses in any directory—identifying

network hubs is substantially more complex than

renting a mailing list. But the rewards for paying

attention to these people can be huge.

WHERE DOES ONE FIND NETWORK HUBS?

There are four methods commonly used:

1. Letting network hubs identify themselves. This

means capturing the names of those who visit

your website, or ask questions via email/snail

mail.

2. Identifying categories of network hubs.

Responses from ads in trade publications,

or attendance at conferences, trade shows.

However, these efforts primarily gather titles

only.

3. Spotting network hubs in the field. To do this

you must join a community, or solicit help from

those already inside the community.

4. Identifying network hubs through surveys.

Studies can be done online using such

resources as RoperASW, Greenfield Online, or

Opinion Research. Surveys can be subdivided

into socio-metric, informant ratings, or self

designating.

HOW TO WORK WITH NETWORK HUBS

Mega hub tactics—“the media”—are well known by

publicity people, and I have little new to offer here.

What others do not usually discuss is how to go about

reaching the millions of regular hubs who can spread

news about a product. So I will focus here on reaching

regular hubs.

Regular hub tactics first challenge is keeping track of

them. Building a system to record information about

hubs is mostly a matter of making everyone at your

organization aware of them. The database you build

should have telephone numbers, e-mail addresses,

regular mailing addresses, as well as information about

the scope and source of their influence and the nature

of the networks they belong to.

Timing is important, seeding is often required, targeting

hubs first (before PR and ads), give them something to

talk about, stimulate them to teach others, give them

the facts, don’t abuse the relationships, be sure people

15

Page 16: Word of Mouth White Paper

see hubs using your product, and beware Mega Hub

bias.

WARNING: FAILURE TO EXPLORE ALL THREE WORD OF MOUTH OPTIONS COULD BE HAZARDOUS TO YOUR MARKETING HEALTH. Each of these approaches, whether Ideavirus,

Shockvirus, or Influentials, has different underlying

strategies, tactics and costs. Be sure to explore them

carefully before making a choice as they are quite

different in nature.

RANDOM COMMENTS FROM PRACTITIONERS AND AUTHORS Plus FRIENDS AT BOTH WOMMA (Word of Mouth Marketing Assn.) AND VBMA (Viral+Buzz Marketing Assn.)

Linda Zimmer: “What makes metrics a tough nut to

crack is that viral/buzz marketing must focus on all

types of modern media not just web, email, or Internet.

It has to reach the customer where they are, when they

want it, and in the manner in which they want it (my

term is liquid media). That can be SMS, a podcast,

social networks, or smart tags. If sales is the ultimate

goal, sales/revenue is the final measurement. But, over

what period of time? During the campaign, 3 months

afterwards, one year? A great viral campaign can

influence me to buy months down the road.

Dr. Paul Marsden: “Keith, hi - the idea that WOM is a

C2C phenomenon is ill-informed and plain wrong. The

business classic Diffusion of Innovations (which author

Everett Rogers attributes to WOM) is full of B2B

examples, as is Tom Peter's Thriving on Chaos. The

whole area of change management is a B2B offer and

the entire healthcare industry is based on B2B

programs between drugs companies and healthcare

providers. All are based around the simple idea that

product placement research (seeding trials) with

internal decision makers is the solution to igniting

WOM. There are probably more B2B case studies of

WOM than C2C. I suggest you liberate case studies

from Diffusion of Innovations, Thriving on Chaos,

Secrets of WOMM, and Anatomy of Buzz - the books

are full of them.”

Dr. Paul Marsden: “However, I predict that alternative

marketing campaign success will be measured in terms

of the impact on customer recommendation rates and

the correlation between the increasing instances of

these and sales, rather than being based on a simple

CPM model.”

Justin Kirby in response to Keith Bates request for

B2B examples: “Obviously (your audience) never heard

of Phase IV research in health care marketing where

influentials are seeded with products in the name of

research. It helped Prozac become the biggest selling

prescribed drug ever. Yes consumers use the product

but the marketing is B2B.

Justin Kirby: As you probably all know by know I

recently chaired the Alternative Marketing & Advertising

Conference in Melbourne Australia mostly thanks to my

colleague Piers Hogarth-Scot at DMC Australia bringing

me up as co-founder of the VBMA. I've also chaired

Marketing Week's Non-Traditional Marketing

Conference in London in December, and been a

panelist at Ad:Tech New York and DM Show in London

in November. As you can imagine, I've seen a Heinz 57

variety of alternative marketing techniques being

presented as the antidote to the fragmented and

cluttered media landscape advertisers are now faced

with.

Online viral marketing’s three main purposes and

benefits from a strategic viewpoint are:

1. To maintain or boost a cost-effective level of

brand awareness during ATL media spend 'downtime',

usually by releasing web-only viral material that retains

the brand and campaign themes.

2. To kickstart new marcom activity, which often

means releasing a web-first viral edit of a mainstream

16

Page 17: Word of Mouth White Paper

ad before it hits TV, in order to create a buzz and

exploit the exclusivity factor.

3. As an effective standalone marketing tool for

brands that either can't afford ATL marketing, or that

require only online distribution to a widespread target

group.

It's also worth bearing in mind that integrating online

viral marketing within the overall marketing mix doesn't

mean making sure the campaign's graphics and

straplines are the same across all media. It means

telling a similar campaign story in slightly different ways

across the media used, depending on the specific

channel and audience. Online viral marketing is simply

another way of telling a story, but in a manner that is

appropriate to the peer-to-peer and file-sharing

activities that web users engage in.

George Silverman, Secrets of Word-of-Mouth Marketing: Word of mouth among business people

and professionals (such as physicians, pharmacists,

architects, and financial advisors) is very different from

word of mouth for relatively low-ticket consumer

products. The more expensive and complicated a

product is, the more word of mouth comes into play.

This is true because these products are more risky in

terms of time, money, and potential damage to

professional reputation. High-ticket products are not as

easily tried as simple consumer products. People have

to rely on other people's experience to substitute for all

or part of the experience they would get in a trial.

Emanuel Rosen, The Anatomy of Buzz: My own

experience with buzz has been mostly in the software

industry …

For buzz to spread, you need two things: a contagious

product--one that has some inherent value that makes

people talk—and someone behind the scenes who

accelerates natural contagion. Yes, there are cases

where having a great product or service alone is

enough, but these typically occur when capacity is

limited.

Technology markets, for example, are almost like

presidential election campaigns, where there's no prize

for second place. Winner takes all. In these markets the

natural spread of word of mouth must be accelerated.

Having a good product is not enough.

Don’t be concerned about boring expert hubs. Dell

Computer Corporation came to realize that network

hubs are willing to spend twenty minutes with an ad and

go through the specs and the features. That’s why

Dell’s ads look like catalogs.

What kind of products lend themselves to buzz?

Products that somehow create high involvement among

customers: Innovative products—like Netscape, and

Complex products—like software.

The more connected your customers are to each other,

the more you depend on their buzz for future business.

To see the full impact of this, look at a company like

Cisco that has always served a tightly connected

customer base. Cisco sells the hardware devices that

glue the Internet together; almost by definition, all of its

customers (network administrators and information

technology managers) are heavy users of the Internet.

"Our company started by word of mouth. There was no

advertising," says Keith Fox, vice president of corporate

marketing at Cisco. Since 1984, buzz about Cisco has

been spreading relentlessly on the Net. Several Internet

newsgroups are dedicated to Cisco's products.

How do you identify network hubs? Use the acronym

ACTIVE. They are Ahead in adoption, Connected,

Travelers, Information-hungry, Vocal, and Exposed to

the media more than others. On the topic of connected

for example…network hubs in the high-tech industry

tend to gravitate toward other network hubs from whom

they can get more information (which they then will

transmit within their cluster). To find these other

17

Page 18: Word of Mouth White Paper

network hubs, they go to trade shows, join user groups,

and hang out in on-line forums that discuss the topics

they are interested in. These activities result in

additional links to the outside world.

Gabriel Weimann traces the notion of (WOM) all the

way back to the Bible. When Moses complained to God

that he could no longer control the people of Israel, God

told him to gather “seventy men of the elders of Israel”

and use them to spread the word to the rest of the

people.

If you subscribe to the belief that we’re all connected by

a chain of no more than six mutual acquaintances then

you might want to consider Emanuel’s math: “Even in a

small network that consists of only 100 people, there

are 4,950 possible links among them. In a network with

just 1,000 members there are almost half a million

possible links!”

The spread of buzz, since it is not always easy to trace,

tends to be neglected. To learn how to help create

buzz, you should be able to answer these questions:

• From whom do your clients or customers typically

learn about your product?

• What do people say when they recommend your

product?

• How fast does information about your product

spread compared with other products?

• Who are the network hubs?

• Where doest the information hit a roadblock?

• How many sources of information does a

customer rely on? Which ones are more important?

• What other kinds of information spread through

the same networks?

It’s crucial to understand that buzz about a product

never spreads as simply as the two-step flow model

would indicate—from company to media and mega-

hubs, and from these hubs to the public. Yet the two-

step model has been blithely assumed by countless

companies over the years. There are two traps

companies can fall into. The first is thinking that

creating buzz is all about network hubs. If you

exclusively focus on the two-step flow model, you can

leap to the dangerous conclusion that direct

communications with your customers is not important.

The second potential trap lies in a narrow interpretation

of the term “network hubs.” Almost all companies try to

go after network hubs. But there’s a big difference

between going after an elite group of forty influencers

and going after a broad, less visible population of four

thousand of them. Numbers make a big difference in

getting the word out. Many experts agree that the

percentage of opinion leaders on average in the

population is about 10 to 15 percent. But in practice,

marketers sometimes target just a handful of

“influencers”—not the full 10%.

The best buzz comes not from clever PR or advertising

but rather from attributes inherent to the product itself.

Contagious products can be grouped into six

categories, as follows:

1. Products that evoke an emotional response.

For most products and services it is usually the

feeling of excitement and delight you get when

your expectations are exceeded.

2. Products that advertise themselves. This type

of product creates visual buzz by generating

excitement simply by people viewing them in

action.

3. Products that leave traces. These are products

that self-propagate by leaving traces of

themselves behind—paper trails or other

evidence of their passing.

4. Products that become more useful as more

people use them. Telephone, fax, and email

are examples.

5. Products that are compatible. Products that fit

peoples preexisting beliefs spread faster.

6. Products that “do the rest”. Products that are

easy to use spread faster because customers

are hungry for simplicity. Example: Kodak’s

18

Page 19: Word of Mouth White Paper

first camera copy line, “You press the button,

we do the rest.” When a customer has to

explain just one step, her likelihood of

completing the ‘sales pitch’ successfully is

much higher than if she had to describe seven

steps.

ALWAYS EXCEED EXPECTATIONS!

Cisco Systems, for example, serves network

administrators who virtually live online, so you’d expect

Cisco to use online methods to spread the word about

its products. They do. But Cisco doesn’t limit itself to the

online world. The company organizes more than one

thousand seminars every year to meet potential

customers face to face, they organize networking

events for their current customers, and they attend

dozens of trade shows. Relationships with many

customers start via face-to-face communication. The

Net is used to maintain those relationships.

DOES MADISON AVENUE STILL MATTER?

The truth is that very few products can rely on buzz

alone. When used correctly, advertising can help buzz.

However, it’s also worth noting that ads can sometimes

hurt genuine word of mouth. So in this chapter I want to

focus on answering three questions:

1. Can advertising stimulate buzz? Absolutely. A

good ad can help get people talking. (The

shockvirus approach). It does so by jump-

starting the process, reaching hubs, reassuring

buyers, and getting the facts straight.

2. Can advertising simulate buzz? What about

ads that masquerade as word of mouth? This

is a tricky topic. You have to understand that

an ad can hardly ever enjoy the credibility of

buzz. Consider the “friendly” tone, testimonial

advertising.

3. Can advertising kill buzz? Although there are

many good reasons to advertise, advertising is

a tool that should be used very cautiously if

you want to promote buzz. Because

advertising can also kill buzz when people feel

that someone is shoving the message down

their throats.

The six rules about ads and buzz:

1. Keep it simple. Message needs to be simple to

be easily passed along.

2. Tell us what’s new. Fluff doesn’t travel well.

Keep it relevant and news worthy.

3. Don’t make claims you can’t support. Don’t tell

customers you care without proving it.

4. Ask your customers to articulate what’s special

about your product or service. Just ask!

5. Start measuring buzz. Very few ad agencies

pretest for conversational impact. Helpful to

ask two questions: Will the ad help network

hubs answer questions they may get from

other people in the networks? Will the ad

stimulate members of the network to seek

information from network hubs?

6. Listen to buzz. Monitor the network. Improve

messaging.

The extensive buzz about high tech products is also

driven by their complexity which makes them difficult to

evaluate. Talking with current users of a certain

software package helps customers reduce the risk

associated with the purchase.

Seth Godin, Unleashing the Ideavirus: Why do some

viruses burn out more quickly than others? The simplest

reason is that marketers get greedy and forget that a

short-term virus is not the end of the process, it’s the

beginning. By nurturing the attention you receive, you

can build a self reinforcing virus that lasts and lasts and

benefits all involved. Admit that few viruses last forever.

Embrace the lifestyle of the virus.

REPORT ON THE FIRST EVER WOMMA SUMMIT Held in Chicago on March 29, 30 was the first ever

summit meeting for the newly formed Word Of Mouth

19

Page 20: Word of Mouth White Paper

Marketing Association. (Reprinted from my weblog at

www.keithbates.blogspot.com on March 31, 2005)

First WOMMA Summit (March 29-30, 2005) a smashing success. Word of mouth marketing is obviously an idea whose time has come.

On day one of the Summit, in the opening letter from

my WOMMA folder I found a message, “There’s a

sense of history in the air. Can you feel it?”

I felt it. And what followed was two of the most

rewarding days I’ve had in years.

As I wrapped up my role of moderator for the last two

sessions of an incredible two days I sensed a

reluctance to leave among the 350 attendees who

jammed Chicago’s Intercontinental Hotel. The heart

warming camaraderie was coming to a close as the

world’s first-ever word of mouth marketing conference

came to an end. WOMMA CEO Andy Sernovitz

([email protected]) had just pulled off what seemed

like an impossible, Herculean task.

The closing of the first day’s session, the halfway point, found nearly 300 people, not at all tired from a day’s worth of marathon speeches but full of enthusiasm, hopping onto a bus for a long evening of storytelling at the beautiful downtown Chicago Reza’s restaurant on West Ontario. This event ran until 10:00 (your author, a little older than most of the crowd, went home at 9:00)

In only a few short months of existence WOMMA (Word

of Mouth Marketing Association) www.womma.com,

generated over 100 charter members and rounded up

attendees from all over the world (Austria, Brazil,

Canada, Poland, Singapore are only a few of the dozen

the author can recall) to fill the Grand Ballroom. With no

advertising, using word of mouth only, WOMMA

outgrew the original venue and had to relocate at the

last minute. The last two days represented an incredible

learning experience even to me who has immersed

himself in word of mouth and viral marketing for the

past four years.

One of the things I learned, somewhat to my consternation, is that Viral Marketing, which is what I

have been pursuing aggressively, is not the end-all of

WOM, but in fact a subset of this awesome

communications tactic. In a very well done hand-out

from Greg Wester of Soapbox Marketing he makes the

point that we, as WOM practitioners, need to go beyond

viral marketing pointing out that VM is “a form of

marketing reliant upon the transfer of a pre-fabricated

marketing message between and amongst consumers,

a form of digital marketing hyped by email technology

providers and advergame developers.” He goes on to

say that “the result of this confusion is that marketers

wise enough to focus on improving word of mouth often

unwisely limit their scope to ‘viral’ marketing. Word of

mouth marketing includes any marketing where

consumers are responsible for the message’s content

and/or message distribution. ‘Viral’ is only one form.”

This WOMMA conference was the forming of a new industry in America, complete with ethics code, standards council, education council, and buyers guide … all readily available at www.womma.org.

A blue ribbon panel of speakers included a stirring

presentation by Apple evangelist Guy Kawasaki, best

selling authors Emanuel Rosen, Ben McConnell and

Jackie Huba, Ed Keller, George Silverman and Mark

Hughes … plus 47 other luminaries from the world of

marketing, advertising and public relations including my

friend Paul Rand, head of Ketchum’s global technology

practice and developer of IRM (Influencer Relations

Management).

An exhilarating time was had by all. In addition to the

exciting presentations, and very-well done (and brief)

PowerPoints, was an exciting luncheon exercise put on

by Jackie Huba, co-author of Creating Customer

20

Page 21: Word of Mouth White Paper

Evangelists. Jackie and Ben have written a small

paperback supplement to their big book and handed out

copies to everyone over a box lunch on Wednesday to

support a little exercise. Each person was assigned a

table and then a chapter within the book to study and

discuss per a round table discussion. The comments

and results were then gathered for review by the

WOMMA group for publishing. It made for a very vocal,

fun filled lunch hour.

One point made repeatedly that I think is important to

share is the issue of whether WOM is a BtoC or BtoB

phenomenon. The answer is both! It is equally effective

whether consumer or business focused. Because the

consumer approach is so highly visible it gets most of

the press (Subservient Chicken, Oprah’s Pontiac’s) but

there were endless exciting BtoB stories covering

businesses ranging from the pharmaceutical industry to

a Chicago area Automotive Consulting Group. When

Emanuel Rosen announced from the stage that I was

developing a white paper on WOM to be published by

the newly formed ITA (Illinois Information Technology

Association-- formerly the Chicago Software

Association), I was approached by innumerable people

offering me their cards with promises of BtoB stories to

share.

Another important point that was made is that WOM is now a mainstream marketing tool, part of the total marcom mix, not necessarily limited to the domain of PR firms, or marketing companies, or ad agencies … but to anyone who has an interest in marketing communications that can put the process in motion. It’s not always the fastest, but it is by far the most potent. And in fact it is typically better started by an internal company evangelist and then supported, or sustained, by outside professionals.

A title that should soon be appearing on the client side,

in addition to VP or Director of Marketing, should be

Online Community Manager, Customer Evangelist, or

perhaps most appropriately traditional Product

Managers should morph into, or assume the additional

duties of, Word of Mouth Manager. I think the key issue

is that full responsibility must reside with a single

empowered individual who should be as close to the

CEO as the CMO … or closer!

Today’s blog is totally inadequate for presenting all the

great material that speakers shared with the audience

but a few that stood out from my own personal

perspective were the following:

From Andy Sernovitz, WOMMA CEO, in his opening

remarks: … there are two visions of the future

concerning what we do, our industry, and our jobs …

and we must make a conscious choice regarding each

as we move forward. Do we, as WOM practitioners,

want to be viewed as the voice of the consumer—or

manipulators? As partners in a unified WOM industry—

or isolated niche specialists? As marketing pros—or

experimenters on the edge? In order for the WOM

industry to grow and flourish it is obvious that we must

vigorously pursue the former alternative in each case,

and vigorously reject the latter.

From Pete Blackshaw of Intelliseek, cofounder of

WOMMA: Consumer-Generated Media (CGM)

describes a variety of new sources of online information

that are created, initiated, circulated and used by

consumers intent on educating each other about

products, brands, services, personalities and issues.

Ever growing in number and format on the Internet,

CGM refers to any number of online word-of-mouth

vehicles, including but not limited to: consumer-to-

consumer email, postings on public Internet discussion

boards and forums, consumer ratings web sites or

forums, blogs (short for weblogs, or digital diaries),

moblogs (sites where users post digital

images/photos/movies), social networking web sites

and individual web sites. Although influenced or

stimulated by traditional marketers and marketing

21

Page 22: Word of Mouth White Paper

activities, online word of mouth is nonetheless owned

and controlled by consumers, and it often carries far

higher credibility and trust than traditional media,

especially as media channels become more fragmented

and less trusted. The growth of its influence poses

challenges and opportunities for marketers.

From Emanuel Rosen, ten questions to ask yourself

before your next marcom campaign: 1) Does this

product lend itself to WOM? 2) Are we reinforcing the

concept and the message behind the product? 3) Can

we release information gradually? 4) Are we giving our

customers something to talk about? 5) Do we give them

an opportunity to get involved? 6) Are we making it

easy to spread the word? 7) Can we stimulate

interaction between customers? 8) Can we identify

network hubs by category? By their activism? Through

surveys? 9) Are we seeding the networks? 10) How is

this campaign going to affect the network hubs

credibility?

Another note: For all of us who grew up in direct response you may want to know that WOM lends itself particularly well to test marketing. In other words build a small flame first, and then use it to fan the flames of a conflagration…after learning what your market responds to.

And in taking your product to market keep in mind that

while case studies are important, stories resonate

better, because all people are innate story tellers.

From David Ries of DEI, eight simple rules of WOM: 1)

treat people like they’re smart and savvy—because

they are. 2) relate to people as individuals. 3) reach

people on their terms. 4) give people a way to tell you

what they think—and take it seriously when they do. 5)

conversation/test is the new medium. 6) useful

information is the currency of influence. 7) let go of

corporate control of the message. 8) you get what you

pay for.

From Rick Murray of Edelman, five words to consider:

Insight, into consumers. Creativity, bellwether of great

campaigns. Integration, of PR, ads, clients.

Measurement, because we need to know what a home

run looks like before we start the game. Courage, to

break with tradition.

From Keith Bates: If you’re reading my blog regularly

you know that it was established almost two years ago

to share my knowledge and experience with both viral

marketing and word of mouth and that it’s goal has

been to help readers understand the process well

enough to know where to turn for help. Awareness of

word of mouth is growing exponentially in the press and

in the marketplace…and now you have the best

resource anywhere ... www.womma.org.

Visit their site, join the organization. Read the

PowerPoint PDF’s soon to be available from the

Summit. Tell Andy that Keith sent you. Participate, and

share your experiences so that all of us who believe in

the power of WOM can do an even better job for our

clients and our customers. A big two thumbs up for WOMMA, and for Andy Sernovitz. WOMMA published its draft Ethics Code for the word of mouth marketing industry on February 9, 2005. This is a first step in the complicated process of

building an industry based on consumer respect and

fundamental ethical principles. The essence of the

WOMMA Code comes down to the Honesty ROI:

• Honesty of Relationship: You say who you're

speaking for

• Honesty of Opinion: You say what you believe

• Honesty of Identity: You never obscure your

identity.

For more information visit www.womma.org

22

Page 23: Word of Mouth White Paper

WOM’S NATURE as prescribed by its authors

and practitioners

Regis McKenna, Word of Mouth Malcolm Gladwell, The Tipping Point Seth Godin, Unleashing the Ideavirus

Emanuel Rosen, The Anatomy of Buzz George Silverman, The Secrets of Word of Mouth Marketing

Jackie Huba/Ben McConnell, Creating Customer Evangelists Ed Keller and Jon Berry, The Influentials

Paul Rand, Ketchum Viral+Buzz Marketing Association

Andy Sernovitz, WOMMA

Keith Bates is personally acquainted with nearly all of the people above,

many of whom have had a powerful influence in shaping his knowledge and

opinions regarding word of mouth and viral marketing over the past four years.

23

Page 24: Word of Mouth White Paper

Regis McKenna, Word of Mouth The difference between word of mouth and all other forms of communication include:

• It is an experienced process, rather than an observed one. The

message in word of mouth is embodied in a living, breathing, emotional

person.

• The message is tuned to the individual listener. It is changed, simplified,

altered, embellished and verified for each person.

• The credibility of the speaker carries over to the message immediately.

• Experts can be used in this medium without the negative effect of

commercializing his or her position and message.

• Efficiency; While word of mouth takes time to disseminate, the message

is delivered directly to those who must use me information and act on it.

• Feedback is instantaneous: agreement, disagreement, understanding,

not understanding.

THE 90-10 RULE

By now one might be saying, "Okay, by talking to everyone in the world we

can better communicate our message. That's not practical or possible:' Right!

But the 90-10 rule states that 90 percent of the world is influenced by the

other 10 percent.

There are probably no more than 20 or 30 people in any one industry who

have a major impact on trends, standards, opinion and a company's image or

character.

Certainly we know this is true in the media and financial community. While

there may be dozens of magazines and mountains of analysis covering an

industry, only several have real influence and impact.

This is true within companies as well. A relatively few people hold the key to

power in any organization. This is not to say that these key influences are

easy to reach. A memo may reach them easier, but credible word-of-mouth

approach will be far more influential and effective.

HOW TO START A WORD-OF-MOUTH CAMPAIGN

The Message. Word of mouth is not appropriate for all communication. The message itself has to be developed and analyzed. Word of mouth is most effective when one wants to build credibility and establish lasting ties or when com- mitment is most critical. It is effective when the message must carry intangibles such as commitment, credibility appeal, adaptability and support.

Segmentation. You must break down the network into manageable pieces and identify major influences within each segment. This task must be done by knowledgeable, experi- enced people. Unlike other promotional tools, word of mouth requires someone who "knows" the influencing factors.

Analyze the segment. Ask the question, "How does information pass within each segment and how are the segments linked?" Then ask, "Who are the most influential people within each segment?"

Pick the targets. Make a list of the 20 or 30 major influences and assign the most credible members of the organization to deliver the message.

24

Page 25: Word of Mouth White Paper

Malcolm Gladwell, The Tipping Point In this brilliant and groundbreaking book, New Yorker writer Malcolm

Gladwell looks at why major changes in our society so often happen

suddenly and unexpectedly. Ideas, behavior, messages, and products, he

argues, often spread like outbreaks of infectious disease. Just as a single

sick person can start an epidemic of the flu, so too can a few fare-beaters

and graffiti artists fuel a subway crime wave, or a satisfied customer fill the

empty tables of a new restaurant. These are social epidemics, and the

moment when they take off, when they reach their critical mass, is the

Tipping Point.

Gladwell introduces us to the particular personality types who are natural

pollinators of new ideas and trends, the people who create the phenomenon

of word of mouth. He analyzes fashion trends, smoking, children's

television, direct mail, and the early days of the American Revolution for

clues about making ideas infectious, and visits a religious commune, a

successful high-tech company, and one of the world's greatest salesmen to

show how to start and sustain social epidemics.

What You'll Learn In The Tipping Point:

Directions for reaching a Tipping Point. You'll learn how the three rules of

the Tipping Point -- the Law of the Few, the Stickiness Factor, and the

Power of Context -- offer a way of making sense of epidemics.

How to choose the people who will spread the epidemic. Spreading the

word depends on people who are either experts or possessed with a rare

set of social gifts. You'll learn how to identify mavens, connectors, and

salesmen (persuaders).

The importance of memorable product exposure. The Presentation is

everything. If your product is not inherently exciting you must position your

message so that it is, and has the ability to move people.

Understanding the power of context. You'll learn to become sensitive to the

circumstances and conditions of times and places, those specific and

relatively small elements in the environment can serve as Tipping Points.

The paradox of the epidemic (viral marketing) is that in order to create one

contagious movement; you often have to create many small movements

first.

CONTENTS 1. The Three Rules of Epidemics.

2. The Law of the Few: Connectors, Mavens, and Salesmen

3. The Stickiness Factor: Sesame Street, Blue's Clues, and the Educational Virus

4. The Power of Context (Part One): Bernie Goetz and the Rise and Fall of New York City Crime

5. The Power of Context (Part Two): The Magic Number One Hundred and Fifty

6. Case Study: Rumors, Sneakers, and the Power of Translation

7. Case Study: Suicide, Smoking, and the Search for the Unsticky Cigarette

8. Conclusion: Focus, Test, and Believe

25

Page 26: Word of Mouth White Paper

Seth Godin, Unleashing the Ideavirus

If you don't have time to read the whole book, here's what it says: Marketing by interrupting people isn't cost-effective anymore. You can't afford

to seek out people and send them unwanted marketing messages, in large

groups, and hope that some will send you money. Instead, the future belongs

to marketers who establish a foundation and process where interested people

can market to each other. Ignite consumer networks and then get out of the

way and let them talk.

Why Ideas Matter. The holy grail for anyone who traffics in ideas is this: to

unleash an ideavirus. An idea that just sits there is worthless. But an idea that

moves and grows and infects everyone it touches ...that's an ideavirus. An

ideavirus is a big idea that runs amok across the target audience. Word of

mouth is not new it's just different now. Ideaviruses give us increasing

returns, word of mouth dies out, but ideaviruses get bigger. And finally,

ideaviruses are the currency of the future. While ideaviruses aren't new,

they're important because we're obsessed with the new, and an ideavirus is

always about the new.

The key steps for Internet companies looking to build a virus are:

• Create a newsworthy online experience that's either totally new or

makes the user's life much better. Or makes an offline experience

better/faster/cheaper so that switching is worth the hassle.

• Have the idea behind your online experience go viral, bringing you a

large chunk of the group you're targeting without having to spend a

fortune advertising the new service.

• Fill the vacuum in the marketplace with your version of the idea, so

that competitors now have a very difficult time of un-teaching your

virus and starting their own.

• Achieve "lock in" by creating larger and larger costs to switching

from your service to someone else's.

• Get permission from users to maintain an ongoing dialogue so you

can turn the original attention into a beneficial experience for users

and an ongoing profit stream for you.

• Continue creating noteworthy online experiences to further spread

new viruses, starting with your core audience of raving fans.

What You’ll Learn In Unleashing The Ideavirus Why ideas matter. In this section you'll learn about the holy grail for people who deal in ideas, how to create an environment where consumers market to each other, the key steps to building a virus, 6 reasons why ideaviruses are so important, 5 things ideaviruses have in common, and 7 ways an ideavirus can help you.

How to unleash an ideavirus. Learn why you must focus on "sneezers" those people best qualified to start an epidemic, why unleashing and ideavirus is more than simple word of mouth, and thirteen question ideavirus marketers must have answered.

Understanding the ideavirus formula. How to tweak the formula and make it work plus a look at the eight underlying variables that impact success.

26

Page 27: Word of Mouth White Paper

Emanuel Rosen, The Anatomy of Buzz

Emanuel Rosen, with nine years experience as Marketing VP for a Silicon

Valley software company, here illuminates the reality of how "buzz" can be

launched and managed so as to more rapidly reach a critical mass (the

tipping point) of adopters for one's innovation.

What You'll Learn In The Anatomy of Buzz

How buzz spreads. You'll learn that buzz is all the word of mouth about a

brand, which it spreads through invisible networks of very special people,

that we talk because we're programmed to talk, and that nothing happens

without the establishment of network hubs. You'll also learn the structure of

these networks and about the energy and credibility required to make it

work.

How to assure success. You'll learn that some products evoke and

emotional response, some advertise themselves, some leave traces, others

become more useful as people use them, products that are compatible, that

"do the rest", and the power of gossip. And you'll learn that there's still a

need for traditional advertising, promotion and PR to accelerate the whole

process but that the timing of this stuff is critical. It's called Leapfrogging,

and it builds momentum.

How to stimulate the spread of buzz. You'll learn how to identify and

nurture network hubs, the importance and techniques of "seeding", the

importance of having a good story. You'll learn to think of viral marketing as

a buzz accelerator and that very few products can rely on buzz alone. But

ads can hurt as well as help. Plus skills at channel deployment. And lastly

examples of people who did it and how, followed by a Buzz Workshop

chapter that Seth Godin says "by itself is worth the entire price of the book!"

Does Madison Avenue still matter? Yes! The truth is that very few

products can rely on buzz alone. Six rules about ads and buzz: keep it

simple, tell us what's new, don't make claims you can't support, ask your

customers to articulate what's special about your product or service, start

measuring buzz, and listen to the buzz. Can advertising kill buzz? Yes, if it's

shoved down their throats, or perceived to be dishonest.

CONTENTS

Part One. How Buzz Spreads

1. What is Buzz? 2. The Invisible Networks 3. Why We Talk 4. Network Hubs 5. It's a Small World. So What? 6. How Buzz Spreads Part Two. Success In The Networks

7. Contagious Products 8. Accelerating Natural Contagion Part Three. Stimulating Buzz 9. Working with Network Hubs 10. Active Seeding 11. The Elements of a Good Story 12. Viral Marketing 13. Does Madison Avenue Still Matter? 14. Buzz in Distribution Channels 15. Putting It Together 16. Buzz Workshop

27

Page 28: Word of Mouth White Paper

George Silverman, The Secrets of Word of Mouth Marketing Twenty-Eight Secrets of Word-of-Mouth Marketing #1. Selling is mostly an illusion. #2. By influencing word of mouth directly, sales can routinely be increased three to ten times or more! #3. Single most effective method for speeding up decisions is word of mouth. #4. Word of mouth is as easy to structure and use as traditional advertising. #5. Word of mouth is literally thousands of times as powerful as advertising. #6. Word of mouth is paradoxically the most powerful and most neglected force in marketing. #7. It is almost impossible for your product to succeed unless it has massive positive word of mouth. #8. Word of mouth either explodes at an exponential rate or it fizzles. #9. There are over a dozen reasons why word of mouth is so powerful. All of these reasons, once understood, can be turned to your advantage. #10. The overriding characteristic that gives word of mouth its power: word of #11. There are many different types of word of mouth, all potentially controllable.#12. Different types of decision makers need different types of word of mouth at each stage of the decision cycle. #13. As important as content is, the sequence and source are just as important. #14. There are basically two levels of word of mouth, expert and peer, and their relative power varies at different stages of the decision cycle. #15. In word of mouth marketing, confirmation and verification are more important that information. #16. In word of mouth marketing, you are navigating spheres of influence. #17. Experts are more approachable that ordinary people, but only through total honesty. #18. Credibility is more important in an expert than fame. #19. There are many reliable mechanisms for delivering word of mouth. #20. Word of mouth must be approach systematically, as a campaign. #21. The word of mouth among your sales force can be more important than the word of mouth among your customers. #22. There is a specific way to research the naturally occurring word of mouth so that you can identify exactly what your customers are actually saying. #23. There is a way to experiment with ways to influence the natural word of mouth and verify that it is in fact persuasive. #24. There are many ways of producing and delivering "canned" word of mouth that are almost as powerful as live, spontaneous word of mouth. #25. Paradoxically, in word of mouth, unlike in conventional marketing, negatives can be more reassuring than positives about the product. #26. "Word-of-mouth advertising is a contradiction in terms. #27. In word of mouth marketing, any perceived attempt to influence the content will totally invalidate the communication. #28. The usual rules of advertising and salesmanship are often counterproductive in word of mouth marketing.

CONTENTS CHAPTER 1-Dominating Your Market By Shortening The Customer Decision Cycle CHAPTER 2-The Power of Word of Mouth CHAPTER 3-The Nine Levels of Word of Mouth CHAPTER 4-Harnessing Word of Mouth CHAPTER 5-Using Word of Mouth to Speed the Decision Process CHAPTER 6-Delivering the Message CHAPTER 7-Viral Marketing CHAPTER 8-Researching Word of Mouth CHAPTER 9-Constructing a Word-of-Mouth Campaign CHAPTER 10-Word of Mouth, the "Tried and True" Way CHAPTER 11-Campaign Methods That Work Best t CHAPTER 12-Practical Tips and Suggestions CHAPTER 13-The Secrets of Word-of-Mouth Marketing CHAPTER 14-An Allegory: The Emperor's New Marketing CHAPTER 15-The Future

28

Page 29: Word of Mouth White Paper

Jackie Huba/Ben McConnell, Creating Customer Evangelists You are an evangelist. You tell others what movie to see, which computer to purchase, what restaurant to visit, which dentist you prefer, which cell phone to buy, which books to read, which clubs to join. Your recommendations are sincere. Passionate, perhaps. Perhaps you didn't realize that you are an evangelist-a bringer of glad tidings-but your sphere of influence, made up of friends, family, colleagues, and professional communities, realizes it.

HOW TO SPOT EVANGELISTS AND WHAT TO DO WITH TH EM People talk about you. They talk about your company, your products and services, and your personality. Many say nice things, and some are absolutely gushy with their praise. Would you like to know who they are? How do you find your evangelists? Short of spy cams and hidden microphones, it's not difficult to find your evangelists. Here are a few ideas.

Scan the Web using your favorite search engine and discover where you are mentioned online and by whom. Make note of everyone who compliments your products and services and everyone who criticizes them. For the people who love you, send them a hand-written thank-you note. Invite them in to a special club with other evangelists where they get inside information about products and services. Make them feel extra special. For those who take issue with your products or services, find a way to contact them via e-mail or ask if it's OK to talk on the phone. The difference between an unhappy customer and an evangelist is often just a phone call. More than anything, unhappy customers just want to be heard and acknowledged. Grant an unhappy customer that wish.

Ask prospective customers specifically how they discovered you. If it was from a friend or colleague, ask the prospect for the name of the referrer. Keep detailed records of how people discovered you. With some of our clients, we create a Buzz Map, which illustrates the actual routes of how they landed customers via word of mouth. A map of customer connections quickly illuminates your biggest evangelists.

If you have an opt-in e-mail list, add a field that asks how people discovered you. Continually refine the quantifiable nature of this field. You want to gather as much information as possible from this field, especially if the referrals are from people. Those are your evangelists!

Be an active participant in e-mail discussion lists and online bulletin boards that your customers frequent. Watch for customers who post recommendations about you. Cultivate relationships with them. Keep them in your loop.

Use Web site tracking software to understand how Web site visitors discover you. If customers, prospects, fans, or evangelists link to your site, do not send them a cease-and-desist letter. This creates customer vigilantes, not customer evangelists. Do not let your corporate counsel argue that fan sites contribute to brand dilution. This is pure crap espoused by prosecutorial-minded lawyers intent on making customers play by ridiculous notions of trademark protection. (Note: Protect your trademarks against competitors, not customers.) En- courage links to your site, wherever fans would like to create them. Provide fans with pictures of your products, logos, movies, animations-anything that makes them feel connected to you. They are your volunteer sales force.

From their research into the best practices of some of the most forward-thinking companies, McConnell and Huba outline and explain the six basic tenets of creating customer evangelists:

Customer plus-delta: Continuously gather customer feedback.

Napsterize knowledge: Make it a point to share knowledge freely.

Build the buzz: Expertly build word-of-mouth networks.

Create community: Encourage communities of customers to meet and share.

Make bite-size chunks: Devise specialized, smaller offering to get customers to bite.

Create a cause: Focus on making the world, or your industry, better.

And from Guy Kawasaki…

“Sales is rooted in what’s good for me. Evangelism is rooted in what’s good for you.”

29

Page 30: Word of Mouth White Paper

Ed Keller and Jon Berry, The Influentials One American in ten tells the other nine how to vote, where to eat, and what to

buy. They are The Influentials.

Who are they? The most influential Americans-- the ones who tell their

neighbors what to buy, which politicians to support, and where to vacation--are

not necessarily the people you'd expect. They're not America's most affluent 10

percent or best-educated 10 percent. They're not the "early adopters," always

the first to try everything from Franco-Polynesian fusion cooking to digital

cameras. They are, however, the 10 percent of Americans most engaged in

their local communities . . . and they wield a huge amount of influence within

those communities. They're the campaigners for open-space initiatives. They're

church vestrymen and friends of the local public library. They're the Influentials

. . . and whether or not they are familiar to you, they're very well known to the

researchers at RoperASW. For decades, these researchers have been on a

quest for marketing's holy grail: that elusive but supremely powerful channel

known as word of mouth. What they've learned is that even more important

than the "word"--what is said, is the "mouth"--who says it.

SIX RULES FOR GETTING INTO THE CONVERSATION

WHAT'S YOUR INFLUENTIAL STRATEGY?" If you've not asked yourself this

question already, you should. To succeed today, you need to connect with the

people who are at the center of the conversation. Business, government, and

nonprofit organizations need to have influential strategies just as they need

marketing, advertising, public relations, promotion, or Internet strategies.

Specifically, you should make sure you are reaching the decision makers who

are influential in others' decisions. You should know where the opinion leaders

get their ideas--the kinds of publications they read, the programs they watch,

the radio stations they listen to, and the Web sites they go to. You should make

sure you don't have the door shut when opinion leaders come to you with a

complaint or question. You should be out in the community to make sure you're

listening to opinion leaders' concerns. You should pay attention to what's

happening in opinion leaders' lives, the issues that opinion leaders are reading

up on, the problems they are focused on, and their short-and long-term goals.

Companies should be asking themselves if their products and services,

environmental stance, and corporate practices are consonant with opinion

leaders' expectations. What the opinion leaders say and think about companies

has more of an impact on what their customers are thinking and doing than

companies realize.

CONTENTS

1. Who Are The Influentials?

2. The Influential Personality.

3. The Influence Spiral: How Influentials Get And Spread Ideas.

4. The Message Of Influentials: The Age Of Autonomy And The Rise Of Self-Reliance.

5. The Influential Vision: Seven Trends For The Future.

6. Developing An Influential Strategy: Six Rules For Getting Into The Conversation.

30

Page 31: Word of Mouth White Paper

"In a time when people drown in information, influentials play a crucial role in how people think and act. They serve to filter and validate information for people who want trusted counsel," said Paul M. Rand, a Ketchum partner and leader of the IRM development team. "Ketchum IRM becomes a marketer's new currency in strengthening relationships with its most powerful and vocal advocates." Ketchum used to draw up lists of 2,000-3,000 names, but the IRM system focuses on 150-200- "the cream of the crop," said Paul Rand, director of Ketchum's global technology practice in Chicago and head of the IRM practice. 'We as an industry are going through a big evolution; what typically worked in the past does not necessarily work today," said Rand.

31

Paul Rand, Partner, Director, Global Technology Practice, and Managing Director, Chicago office

Ketchum Public Relations NEW YORK, Sept. 15, 2003 - Ketchum, capturing the growing importance

of influencers in shaping buying decisions, today launched Ketchum Influencer

Relationship ManagementSM (Ketchum IRM). The proprietary program identifies

and reaches that select group of people who, for each company or organization,

mold the perceptions and behaviors of customers and decision makers. The

global initiative features a customized Web-based portal to manage and

measure relationships with these influencers.

Ketchum IRM embraces a proven seven-step process and a proprietary

technology infrastructure. The secure portal database, overseen by a certified

Ketchum team, captures key data on each influencer, making it simple to

manage the program's progress.

The offering reflects Ketchum's extensive experience helping companies

work more closely with the key individuals and small groups that can affect --

positively or negatively -- broad market perceptions and behaviors quickly and

directly. Several Fortune 500 companies have piloted the program successfully

to accelerate the effectiveness of their overall marketing campaigns.

Ketchum IRM extends far beyond traditional influencers such as media,

government and analysts to include others whose opinions and advice people

trust highly. Researchers at RoperASW indicate that consumers and buyers

increasingly look to this mix of key individuals or small groups possessing

specific, relevant knowledge that can help simplify how they think and act.

"Today, a fragmented market has made it possible for buyers and

decision makers to opt out of mass-market advertising, which means a different

route must be taken to capture their hearts and minds," said Ed Keller, chief

executive officer of RoperASW and co-author of The Influentials: One American

in Ten Tells the Other Nine How to Vote, Where to Eat, and What to Buy. "The

Ketchum IRM program is a thoughtful and organized approach to help get

influencers on your side."

Directly reaching consumers, buyers and other key targets is getting

tougher. The typical consumer faces information overload, bombarded by

10,000 to 30,000 commercial messages daily, plus an additional 200 or so

personalized messages in the form of phone calls, e-mails, faxes and memos.

Add recent questioning of corporate credibility to this mix and it's easy to

see why an outbreak of recent books, articles and stories question the value of

simply using current mass-advertising and mass-marketing strategies while

highlighting the growing importance of influencers.

Page 32: Word of Mouth White Paper

32

The Viral & Buzz Marketing Association (VBMA) is an international group for the development, validation and promotion of consumer-oriented marketing trends and techniques.

Our members are viral and buzz marketing practitioners and academics who specialize in consumer-focused marketing. We aim to create international collaborations, swap case studies, develop best practice and dispel the myths surrounding viral and buzz marketing in order to help it become more widely accepted as a credible, key part of brands overall marketing activities.

If you would like to apply to join and help drive the VBMA, please click on www.vbma.net

All members of the VBMA share the conviction that Viral Marketing, Buzz Marketing and Word-of-Mouth Marketing (and other related marketing approaches that harness network-enhanced word of mouth) are based on the principles outlined on www.vbma.net/mission.html

viral+buzz marketing association

VBMA Global (Viral + Buzz Marketing Association) VBMA Manifesto 1: Mission and Affiliation

All members of the VBMA share the conviction that Viral Marketing, Buzz

Marketing and Word-of-Mouth Marketing (and other related marketing approaches

that harness network-enhanced word of mouth) are based on the principles

outlined below, and that we work constantly on improving these marketing

techniques:

1) We strive to identify only those people who will be interested in a particular

marketing message; deliver the message to them in a way that makes it an

enjoyable or valuable experience; provide it in a manner that encourages them to

share it with others.

We will therefore be providing a benefit to our audiences and their acquaintances

and in so doing, to the brands for which we work.

2) Our goal is to foster genuine enthusiasm about brands and brand

communications, which can spread through networks in a way that is enjoyed,

appreciated and / or valued.

3) We believe that network-enhanced word of mouth has a critical role to play in

the future of integrated marketing communications. Marketers need to offer

content in the media and through one-to-one connections that the recipients

themselves choose to propagate to those that they deem appropriate, thereby

eliminating irrelevant, untimely and (as a consequence) annoying marketing

messages.

4) We believe that whatever our target, we will always be dealing with educated

people who detect when they are being deceived.

These people appreciate brands that find smart ways to entertain, educate or

inform them. They are well-informed in the area of marketing, peer-to-peer

exchange and consumption, enabling them to function as partners and

stakeholders in marketing communication activities. As partners, we treat these

people with care and respect. We will not only develop or send information or

content to them, but will also listen to their opinions. We value their contributions.

Our audience-centric vision of connected marketing seeks to put the target

networks at the center of marketing.

These positions are unifying principles shared by all members of the VBMA. We

agree that working in this field is considered acceptable, professional and

valuable when these principles are respected.

Companies or individuals who do not adhere to these principles are not

considered to be carrying out viral/buzz/word-of-mouth marketing by the VBMA.

Page 33: Word of Mouth White Paper

Andy Sernovitz, WOMMA (Word of Mouth Marketing Association)

What is Word of Mouth Marketing?

Word of mouth is a pre-existing phenomenon that marketers are only now

learning how to harness, amplify, and improve. Word of mouth marketing isn't

about creating word of mouth -- it's learning how to make it work within a

marketing objective.

That said, word of mouth can be encouraged and facilitated. Companies can

work hard to make people happier, they can listen to consumers, they can

make it easier for them to tell their friends, and they can make certain that

influential individuals know about the good qualities of a product or service.

Word of mouth marketing empowers people to share their experiences. It's

harnessing the voice of the customer for the good of the brand. And it's

acknowledging that the unsatisfied customer is equally powerful.

Word of mouth can't be faked or invented. Attempting to fake word of mouth

is unethical and creates a backlash, damages the brand, and tarnishes the

corporate reputation. Legitimate word of mouth marketing acknowledges

consumers’ intelligence -- it never attempts to fool them. Ethical marketers

reject all tactics related to manipulation, deception, infiltration, or dishonesty.

All word of mouth marketing techniques are based on the concepts of

customer satisfaction, two-way dialog, and transparent communications. The

basic elements are:

• Educating people about your products and services

• Identifying people most likely to share their opinions

• Providing tools that make it easier to share information

• Studying how, where, and when opinions are being shared

• Listening and responding to supporters, detractors, and neutrals

WOMMA is Word of

Mouth Marketing, Andy Sernovitz its founding CEO. WOMMA is the official trade association for the word of mouth marketing industry. WOMMA’s mission is to promote and improve word of mouth marketing by: Protecting consumers

and the industry with strong ethical guidelines. Promoting WOM as an

effective marketing tool. Setting standards to

encourage its use. WOMMA members are building a prosperous word of mouth (WOM) marketing profession. Thriving markets are built on best practices, effective standards, and ethical leadership. Those are the qualities that bring WOMMA members together -- and we hope that you will join us if you share these values. You can explore WOMMA at www.womma.org.

33

Page 34: Word of Mouth White Paper

34

…to add wings to your marketing, spurs to your sales

Conclusion—Call to Action Now that we understand the concept behind word of mouth marketing and the various tools required for its implementation perhaps its time to consider putting it work for us.

Tell me again why I need WOMM.

It’s not an overnight panacea for inadequate lead flow

but it offers a powerful resource for adding credibility to

your marketing messages … something that is sorely

needed in a world that just doesn’t want to hear it

anymore from traditional marketers. It’s the secret

weapon behind qualified leads.

Why the departure from tradition? Traditional marketing

is just not effective anymore because the speed of

information diffusion, enabled by the Internet, is

weakening the ability of companies to communicate

with customers and strengthening the ability of

customers to communicate with customers. An effective

WOM campaign will establish a foundation process

where interested people market to each other.

Inspired by Metcalfe’s law, case studies, and practitioner’s comments… where do we begin?

You begin by making an assessment of your product,

your market and your needs. This leads to a choice of

which is best – a corporate contact program to

influentials, or a virals program employing customer

word of mouth.

First, the product. Before considering a viral marketing

program take a moment for introspection. What is the

buzz that your company wishes to spread, hopefully to

epidemic proportions? In ten words or less, what makes

your product virusworthy? If you can't come up with an

answer fix the product or reposition your marketing

message. Next the market. How great is the need? And

how will the perception of your message be received,

i.e. is your product/service really innovative or just

incrementally better? And lastly your needs, which are

influenced to a certain degree by marketing dollars

available. Would a low key, slower moving influencer

program do the job? Or do you want to gamble on a fast

return viral effort? Many people do both because there

is a similarity in the startup procedure relative to the

development of a customer and/or influencer database.

Creative is king when launching WOM!

Messaging concepts, copy, graphics will largely

determine the success of your venture … assuming you

have something the market needs, and can get excited

about. But remember to integrate that messaging within

an entire communications support plan … which must

embrace and include the sales force (whether direct,

channel, or OEM) as well.

Understanding network hubs

Without a good set of names, researched through both

primary and secondary research, you have no place to

begin. It’s critical that you understand network hubs, so

perhaps you should reread that section.

If you’re ready to put WOM into action revisit

www.womma.org not only for it’s wealth of information

but for the listings of resources among its membership.

Study the presentations from the recent WOMMA

Summit. Ask Andy Sernovitz, CEO, of WOMMA for

advice. He knows everybody in the business. Contact

him at [email protected].

For do-it-yourselfers read Rosen’s and Silverman’s books or at least keep copies handy for questions, and then follow the simple steps outlined on pages 11 through 14. Good luck!

Page 35: Word of Mouth White Paper

35

A KBA COMMUNICATIONS SUPPORT PLAN FOCUSED ON WOMM

PREFACE: Keep in mind that the most successful use of WOMM, whether Influential or Viral focused, is not as a standalone tactic but as an integrated part of a brand’s overall marketing strategy.

Note also that this Communications Support Plan should be preceded by the Market Development Strategy Checklist from Paul Wiefels The Chasm Companion, a fieldbook to Geoffrey Moore’s Crossing the Chasm and Inside the Tornado.

Why choose word of mouth marketing? Because traditional advertising is seriously lacking in credibility! And because the ROI metrics are poorly defined.

Word of mouth marketing, as defined by Regis McKenna, the guru of technology PR, is the planning and use of established person-to-person relationships.

While WOMM / Viral / Buzz are all the same thing there are nuances one should be aware of: • WOMM leverages social networks • Viral leverages digital networks • Buzz leverages media networks

Be sure to explore each carefully before making a choice as they can be quite different in nature.

The differences:

WOM-Influentials is long term and directed to known influentials within both social and media networks.

WOM-Viral is short term and directed to unknown user / prospect recipients after online seeding to a small known base.

Deliverables required for both influentials and viral recipients: • Prospect database • A noteworthy product/service • Powerful creative concepts

I. INTRODUCTION

Program Name, Brief Description, Definitions, Target Audiences, and Launch Date, Summary:

• WOM choice rationale • Influentials: The 90-10 Rule • Virals: The 3 Rules: stickiness,

law of the few, context • Developing network hubs • 7 Steps to an Influentials plan • 7 Steps to a Virals plan II. PLANNING COMPONENTS OF THE KBA MARCOM ENGINE

One: AUDIT Marketing Focused Checklist • Target customer / influencer • Compelling reason to buy /

influence • Whole product, or a component • Partners and allies • Distribution • Pricing • Competition • Positioning Communications Focused Checklist • Segmentation of Network Hubs • External--one voice • Internal—shared vision

Two: STRATEGY

Communications audience—defined Reason to buy—the 5 whys Communications Objective • Create awareness, interest,

then buzz among key influentials in client community.

• Generate excitement, then enthusiasm for sharing of an online viral presentation.

Communications Strategies • Develop Strategy Statement

short forms for both Influencer Relations and Viral Advertising

• Key message / USP • Reasons to believe • Accelerated contagion / Blitz Influencer Relations Tactics • Segmentation of influencers • Influencer analysis • Benchmarking and metrics • Keeping in touch: personal and

impersonal • Measurement & management Viral Marketing Tactics • Create “viral agent” and how to

spread (text, image, or video). • Seeding: ID websites, blogs,

people to send email to.

• Tracking: monitor effect, assess the return from cost of developing viral agent and seeding.

Three: A CREATIVE REPOSITORY IS DEVELOPED TO SUPPORT THEME/IMAGE STANDARDS AND THE CREATIVE PLATFORM

• Craft messages for influencers. • Craft integrated ad messages

and images across all components of interactive and traditional marketing efforts.

• Craft mega hub/PR messages. • Craft seminar copy, speeches

to various market segment leaders, white papers, etc.

III. EXECUTION COMPONENTS OF THE KBA MARCOM ENGINE

One: ARSENAL

WOM-Influentials Personalized correspondence, e-mail, direct response efforts, samples, info kits, articles of interest, awards, conferences, briefings, webinars, road trips, lunch and dinners, group brainstorming, testimonials, facilities visit, CEO summit meetings at HQ.

WOM-Viral advertising 20 to 30 second viral, incentives to participate, email support Two: DEPLOYMENT OF THE PROCESS

Development of Time Lines and Scheduling • To seeding resources for virals • To network Hubs for influencers • Place ads, mail, email,

broadcast fax, telemarketing, etc. (elements of 90 Day Blitz)

• Promote seminars • Plan for trade shows • Build chat rooms Dependencies. Issues to Be Resolved. Three: TRACKING, TESTING & KEEPING BUZZ ALIVE • It’s hard to get it going, still

harder to maintain • Focus, test, and believe