WG11 Snapshot July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 1

WG11 Snapshot July 2012Date: 16 -July-2012

Authors:

Name Company Address Phone email Bruce Kraemer Marvell 5488 Marvell Ln

Santa Clara, CA 95054

+1-321-427-4098

[email protected]

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

802.11 Meeting Documents• Agenda 11-12-

0720rx• Snapshots 11-12-

0721rx• Supplementary 11-12-

0722rx• Adrian’s Vice Chair report 11-12-0038r3• Jon’s Vice Chair report 11-12-0626• Treasury report 11-12-0685• Publicity report 11-12-0590• Newcomers material 11-12-0628• IMAT for attendance 11-12-0652

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 2

??

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 3

PAR Expiration/Renewal ScheduleProject PAR Expiration Date

Revision - MB 31-DEC-2012AA 31-DEC-2012AC 31-DEC-2012AD 31-DEC-2012AE 31-DEC-2013AF 31-DEC-2013AH 31-DEC-2014AI 31-DEC-2014

https://development.standards.ieee.org/pub/active-pars?n=22&o=1a0a2a3d

https://development.standards.ieee.org/pub/active-pars?n=22&o=1a0a2a3d

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 4

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 5

802.11 Appointments

• WG Secretary – Stephen McCann• Treasurer – Jon Rosdahl• Publicity – Stephen McCann• ANA Authority – Adrian Stephens• WG Technical Editors – Adrian Stephens, Peter Ecclesine

Monday Agenda Item 4.1.2

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 6

WG11 Task & Study Group Officers – July 2012Cat Group Chair Vice Chair Technical Editor SecretaryWG WG11 Bruce Kraemer Jon Rosdahl

Adrian StephensAdrian Stephens Peter Ecclesine

Stephen McCann

TG AC Osama Aboul-Magd Menzo Wentink, Joonsuk Kim

Robert Stacey David Yang

TG AD Eldad Perahia James Yee Carlos Cordeiro -OPEN-

TG AF Richard Kennedy Peter Ecclesine, Zhou Lan

Peter Ecclesine Zhou Lan

TG AH Dave Halasz Yongho Seok Minyoung Park Joseph Teo Chee Ming

TG AI Hiroshi Mano Marc Emmelmann,Gabor Bajko

Tom Siep Hitoshi Morioka

SC WNG Clint Chaplin Jim LansfordSC ARC Mark Hamilton David BagbySC JTC1 Andrew MylesSC REG Richard Kennedy

NYRQ = Not yet required, nominations are not open OPEN = Candidate Nominations are open

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 7

WG11 Task & Study Group Officers – July 2012 adjCat Group Chair Vice Chair Technical Editor SecretaryWG WG11 Bruce Kraemer Jon Rosdahl

Adrian StephensAdrian Stephens Peter Ecclesine

Stephen McCann

TG AC Osama Aboul-Magd Menzo Wentink, Joonsuk Kim

Robert Stacey David Yang

TG AD Eldad Perahia James Yee Carlos Cordeiro -OPEN-

TG AF Richard Kennedy Peter Ecclesine, Zhou Lan

Peter Ecclesine Zhou Lan

TG AH Dave Halasz Yongho Seok Minyoung Park Joseph Teo Chee Ming

TG AI Hiroshi Mano Marc Emmelmann,Gabor Bajko

Tom Siep Hitoshi Morioka

SC WNG Clint Chaplin Jim LansfordSC ARC Mark Hamilton David BagbySC JTC1 Andrew MylesSC REG Richard Kennedy

NYRQ = Not yet required, nominations are not open OPEN = Candidate Nominations are open

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 8

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

Adrian Stephe

ns, Intel

Corporation

Slide 9

Current Membership Status - July

Data as of 2012-06-06

Definitions: Aspirant: a member who has attended 1 qualifying meetingPotential Voter: a member who has attended 2 qualifying meetings and will become a voter at the start of the next plenary they attend

Status NumberAspirant 114

Potential Voter 52Voter 294

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July Pre-Meeting Registration

July 2012

Adrian Stephe

ns, Intel

Corporation

Slide 10

Working Group Number802.11 258 802.3 275 802.xx 20 802.15 112 802.1 73 none 30

802.18 3 802.19 19 802.16 27 802.21 11 802.22 9

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

Adrian Stephe

ns, Intel

Corporation

Slide 11

Recent voting member history

Date Event Gained Lost # Voters2011-03-18 After Mar plenary 40 8 3152011-06-28 LB178 13 3022011-07-22 After July plenary 26 29 2992011-09-23 Adjustment 1 2982011-11-11 After Nov plenary 27 25 3002012-01-19 LB187 2 2982012-03-20 After Mar plenary 36 40 294

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission Slide 12

IEEE 802.11 Standards Pipeline

PHY

SponsorBallot

MAC

Study groups

802.11kRRM

802.11rFast Roam

802.11 (’99)2.4GHz

PublishedStandard

g54 Mbps2.4GHz

eQoS

iSecurity

f Inter AP

hDFS & TPC

802.11VNetwork

Management

802.11uWIEN

802.11YContention

BasedProtocol

WG Letter Ballot

802.11 -2007

802.11aaVideo Transport

802.11acVHT 5GHz

TG without Approved draft

Discussion Topics

PublishedAmendment

802.11nHigh

Throughput(>100 Mbps)

802.11WManagement

Frame Security

802.11zTDLS

802.11pWAVE

802.11afTVWS

Smart Grid

802.11aiFILS

802.11 ah802.11mb

RevisionWNG

jJP bands

802.11 -2003

a54 Mbps

5GHz

b11Mbps 2.4 GHz

d

July 2012

Slide 12

802.11sMesh

802.11aeQoS Mgt Frames

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

802.11adVHT 60 GHz

IDS

CMMW

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission Slide 13


PHY

SponsorBallot

MAC

Study groups Published

StandardWG

Letter Ballot

802.11 -2012


802.11acVHT 5GHz


Discussion Topics Published

Amendment

802.11afTVWS

Smart Grid

802.11aiFILS

802.11 ahWNG

July 2012

Slide 13


Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

802.11adVHT 60 GHz

IDS

CMMW

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission Slide 14


PHY

SponsorBallot

MAC

Study groups Published

StandardWG

Letter Ballot

802.11 -2012


802.11acVHT 5GHz


Discussion Topics Published

Amendment

802.11afTVWS

Smart Grid

802.11aiFILS

802.11 ahWNG

July 2012

Slide 14


Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

802.11adVHT 60 GHz

IDS

CMMW

802.11-2015

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission Slide 15

IEEE 802.11 Revisions

802.11kRRM

802.11rFast Roam

a 54 Mbps5GHz

b11 Mbps2.4GHz

dIntl roaming

802.11VNetwork

Management

802.11sMesh

802.11uWIEN

802.11YContention

BasedProtocol

802.11nHigh

Throughput(>100 Mbps)

802.11WManagement

Frame Security

802.11zTDLS

802.11pWAVE

802.11 -1999

PHY

MAC

802.11-2012

802.11-2007



802.11ah<1GHz

802.11acVery High

Throughput6Gbps @ 5GHz

802.11aiFILS

802.11adVery High

Throughput6Gbps @ 60GHz

802.11afTV Whitespace

802.11-2003

g54 Mbps2.4GHz

eQoS

iSecurity

hDFS & TPC

jJP bands

f Inter AP

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 15

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

Type of Groups

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 16

Type of Group DescriptionWG Working GroupTG Task GroupSG Study GroupSC Standing

Committee

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

GroupsJuly 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 17

Type Group Description ChairWG WG11 The IEEE 802.11 Working Group Bruce Kraemer

TG MB Maintenance – Revision “mb” Dorothy StanleyTG AA Robust video Graham SmithTG AC Very High Throughput (<6 GHz bands) Osama Aboul-Magd

TG AD Very High Throughput (60 GHz) Eldad PerahiaTG AE QoS for Management Frames Michael MontemurroTG AF Operation in TV Whitespace bands Richard KennedyTG AH Operation in 900 MHz bands Dave Halasz TG AI Fast Initial Link Setup Hiroshi ManoSG C60G China 60 GHz Eldad Perahia + Xiaoming PengSG ISD Infrastructure Service Discovery Stephen McCannSC WNG Wireless Next Generation Clint ChaplinSC ARC Architecture Mark HamiltonSC JTC1 ISO/IEC/JTC1/SC6 shadow committee Andrew MylesSC REG Regulatory Richard KennedySC SG Smart Grid Bruce Kraemer

??

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 18Slide 18

WG11 Editor Abstract / Agenda – July 2012

• Roll Call / Contacts / Reflector• Go round table and get brief status report• ANA Status / Process / What is administered• Numbering Alignment process / Spreadsheet• Amendment Ordering / Draft Snapshots• Style Guide for 802.11 • Editor succession REVmc – schedule/amendments• Editor backup practices

July 2012

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

WNG SC – July 2012• Review of objectives• Tuesday AM1 (08:00-10:00)

– General 802.11 Links (11-12-0589-0?-0wng-general-802-11-link.pptx) – Donald Eastlake 3rd

– Related MU-MIMO – Shoichi Kitazawa– Carrier-Grade WIFI for Cellular Offload – Laurent Cariou– Key Centric Identity – Edward Au

• Tuesday Eve (19:30-21:30)– 6-10 GHz Extensions to 802.11ac, Part 4 (11-12-0493-00-0wng-6-10gh-extensions-to-802-

11ac-part4.pptx) – Richard Edgar– Compatibility of 6-10GHz Extensions with the 802.11ac PHY (11-12-0653-00-0wng-

compatibility-of-6-10ghz-extensions-with-the-802-11ac-phy.ppt) – Jim Landsford– 6-10GHz – Jongsup Baek– 6-10GHz – Vinko Erceg

• Wednesday PM1 (13:30-15:30)– Review of OBSS Status and IEEE 802.11 Solutions – Xavier Perez Costa– Spectrum Efficiency for the Next Generation WLAN (11-12-xxxx-00-0wng-10Gbps-WLAN-

beyond-802.11ac.pptx) – Yasuhiko Inoue– Security Framework (11-12-0766-00-0wng) – Paul Lambert

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 19

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

802.11 ARC – July, 2012• Administration

– Approve Agenda, Attendance, Policies • 802 Overview & Architecture ballot

– 802 ballot closed July 6, 802.11 comments here: 11-12/0756r1– If overall comments or any proposed resolutions ready, review

• 802.11 “General links” discussion • 802.1AC (MAC Service definition) update, discussion• 802.1 Joint meeting (Thursday AM1)

• Liaisons (802, 802.11, IETF)• TRILL• 802.11 and bridging

• Future sessions / SC activities

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 20

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 21Slide 21

TGmb - July 2012• TGmb D12.0

– Received Revcom Approval January 23, 2012– Received Standards Board Approval – February 6,

2012

• Published March 28, 2012• No Meetings• Awards on Wednesday

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

IEEE 802.11 TGaa – July 2012

• Goals for the Meeting:Submitted to RevComApproved by RevComApproved by Standards Board

• No Meetings• Awards on Wednesday

.Bruce Kraemer, MarvellSlide 22

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 23

IEEE 802.11ac – July 2012• A 20-day recirculation ballot (LB 188) on draft D3.0 ended on

June 25 with approval rate of 90.66%• Total number of comments received is 854 comments. Almost 575

comments are technical– Comment spreadsheet is available at:

https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/12/11-12-0752-03-00ac-lb188-comments-tgac-d3-0.xls

• The focus of this meeting is to continue with the resolution of comments received on draft D3.0

• A TG Ad Hoc meeting was held in San Diego during the period of July 11-13 with the objective to achieve progress on LB 188 comments resolution.– Ad Hoc meeting Agenda is available in document11-12/0763r0.

• Agenda for this meeting is available in document 11-12/0764r0.



doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

TGad – July 2012 Meeting Goals

• Comment resolution on recirculation sponsor ballot

• Prepare for EC conditional approval

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 24

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 25

TGae July 2012Status:• Submitted report to EC for P802.11ae REVCOM approval.Objectives:• EC Approval of P802.11ae submission to REVCOM• Approved by RevCom• Approved by Standards Board

• Published April 26, 2012• Awards Wednesday

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

Bruce Kraemer, MarvellSlide 26Slide 26

TGaf – Meeting Goals July 2012

• Approve meeting and teleconference minutes• Review the results of LB171• Approve speculative draft D1.08• Review the progress since May• Complete Clause 23 (PHY) and changes required in other

clauses required by the addition of Clause 23• Complete all remaining LB 171 PHY comment resolutions• Plan for draft D2.0• Review regulatory landscape• Plan for September meeting and teleconferences

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

IEEE 802.11ah Snapshot July 2012• Targeting January for Internal TG Letter

Ballot• Primary focus

– Continue work on the specification framework document.

• Prepare to work on draft text• Timeline review & Teleconference schedule

July 2012

David Halasz, Motorola MobilitySlide 27

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

IEEE 802.11 FILS TGai – San DiegoJuly 2012

• Goals for the Meeting:– Approve minutes of past meeting and teleconference– Continue work on Spec framework documentation– Finish and approve the 1st release of the Spec

framework documentation– Call for draft amending text for Spec text– Approve Timeline– Approve Teleconference schedule– Approve Plan for September

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er (Marve

ll)

Slide 28

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er (Marve

ll)

Slide 29

IEEE JTC1 ad hoc – July 2012

• The agenda items that will be addressed this week are:– Review status of 802.11 WG draft liaisons to SC6– Review status of ballot on IEEE 802.11-2012 by JTC1– Review draft SC6/WG1 agenda for meeting in September in Austria– Appoint and empower IEEE 802 delegation to SC6 meeting– Develop final responses as part of process to develop an agreement

related extensions by SC6 to IEEE 802 standards• Based on a 2nd round of questions & comments by Swiss & Chinese NBs

– Review any changes to status of proposals to SC6 related to IEEE 802• WAPI, TLSEC, TePA-AC, EUHT, etc

– Consider IEEE 802 response to Swiss NB input to SC6 on process improvements after WAPI experience

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

Regulatory Standing Committee Meeting Goals July 2012

• The regulatory summaries• Regulatory issues status

– Opening the 5350 – 5470 MHz band– ETSI Liaison on 5600 to 5650 MHz in the EU– Ofcom TVWS meetings outcome– SRdoc on DA2GC change

• Critical issues actions– Overall support for the 5 GHz bands for 802.11ac

• EU• US

• Other– Should we have a formal Regulatory liaison with the other

organizations?

July 2012

Slide 30

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

China Millimeter Wave (CMMW) Study Group – July Meeting Goals

• Complete Task Group guidelines document

• Complete PAR and 5 Criteria• TG, WG, EC approval of PAR and 5

Criteria

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er (Marve

ll)

Slide 32

IEEE 802.11 ISD SG – July 2012• Presentations• Finalise scope for the SG• Update use case & requirements document (11-12-

0433r2)• Start on the PAR and 5C documents• Agenda for this meeting is 11-12/0757r0.

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 33

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 34

Year Inter meeting Period

Ballots Completed

WG Sponsor

2011 Jan - Mar 3 22011 Mar - May 3 32011 May - July 4 22011 July - Sept 4 32011 Sept - Nov 1 3

2011/2012 Nov - Jan 1 62012 Jan - Mar 1 02012 Mar - May 0 22012 May - July 1 1

Recent Ballot History

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

802.11 Ballot #188 was a 20 day Working Group technical Ballot asking the question "Should P802.11ac D3.0 be forwarded to Sponsor Ballot?". The Official results are:Ballot Opening Date: Tuesday June 05, 2012- 23:59 ETBallot Closing Date: Monday June 25, 2012 - 23:59 ET RESPONSES:

300 eligible people are in this ballot group. 233 affirmative votes 24 negative votes 14 abstention votes 2 negative vote without comments=== 273 votes received = 91.0 % valid returns = 5.1 % valid abstentions APPROVAL RATE:233 affirmative votes = 90.7 % affirmative 24 total negative votes = 9.3 % negativeThe 75% affirmation requirement has been met, Motion PASSES.There were 854 comments received.

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 35

doc.: IEEE 802.11-12/0721r0

Submission

The third IEEE P802.11ad (Very High Throughput 60GHz) 15 day recirculation Sponsor Ballot asked the question “Should P802.11ad Draft 8.0 be forwarded to RevCom?” The official results for this Sponsor Ballot follow:Ballot Opening Date: Friday June 01, 2012 - 23:59 ETBallot Closing Date: Saturday June 16, 2012 - 23:59 ET BALLOT RESULTS:

214 eligible people are in this ballot group. 170 affirmative votes 6 negative votes with comments 0 negative vote without comments 12 abstention votes ======= 188 votes received = 87.9 % valid returns = 6.4% valid abstentions APPROVAL RATE:170 affirmative votes = 96.6 % affirmative 6 total negative votes = 3.4 % negative The motion passes.There were 47 ballot comments received.

July 2012

Bruce Kraem

er, Marvel

l

Slide 36

WG11 Snapshot July 2012

Documents

marvellslide 1wg11 snapshot

candidate nominations

report snapshots

treasury report

approval ofextension

0038r3jons vice chair

rxadrians vice chair

marvell ln santa clara