Student Success Programs at Ryerson: Two Modes of Delivery Don Kinder Bob Jackson Ryerson University Library.

Student Success Programs at Ryerson: Two Modes of Delivery

Don Kinder

Bob Jackson

Ryerson University Library

Ryerson University

Established as a university in 1993

Former Polytechnic Institute (est. 1948)

19,000 FTEs (comparable to McMaster)

Very Urban campus Commuter campus

Largest Continuing Education program in Canada

12 Graduate programs (including 5 PhD)

Ryerson Library

81 staff Includes 22 librarians Most librarians have

subject specialties besides a regular portfolio

Session Outline

Background: Student Success courses at Ryerson, library involvement, collaboration with faculty

Library’s experience with: Business 100 (BUS100) “Strategies for Success” Arts and Contemporary Studies 102 (ACS102)

“Learning and Development Strategies”

Student Success & Retention: Backround Student success courses relatively new at

Ryerson (last 4 years)

Student Retention: driving force behind student success courses

Significant attrition problems at Ryerson in certain programs, e.g. Business, Sciences/ Engineering

Student Success at Ryerson Ryerson Task Force on Student Retention

struck by VP Academic in 2002. Met for 6 months Released Final Report of recommendations,

Oct. 2002. www.ryerson.ca/lt/resources/task_force/finalrep.pdf (Report)

www.ryerson.ca/lt/resources/task_force/ (Appendices)

Task Force on Student Retention 14 members

Faculty, students, Student Services, Registrar, Secretary for Academic Council (Senate), CE, Library, Learning and Teaching Office (chair)

Task Force tasks:

Reviewed retention strategies Ryerson/others Interviewed departments and schools Examined retention/attrition data Conducted literature review, incl. best

practices for student success (incl. student success courses)

Came up with 7 goals and 80 objectives. Library involved in 10 objectives

Task Force Objectives (Library involvement) and Partners

Assess need for, and develop/implement student success courses,, and assess the effectiveness of these programs. (Library, Program Dean, Student Services)

Promote collaboration between faculty and librarians (e.g. integration of IL standards into curriculum, assignment design.) (Library, Learning and Teaching Office, Depts/Schools/Programs)

Provide seminars for faculty on the incorporation of retention strategies into course design (e.g. IL, assignment design, academic integrity) (Library, Learning and Teaching Office.)

Selected Best Practices: Student Success Courses (Implementation/Delivery) Front load the program (offer it in first term or

first year) First six weeks critical Small class size--no more than 25 students(!) Course should be required (vs. elective) Course should carry academic credit that

applies toward graduation Collaborative effort. Should involve Library,

student support services, Writing Centre, etc.

Where did the Library end up in all of this? Higher profile of library and its services. Recognition as a player in

university endeavours through…

Collaborative work on Task Force with faculty, Student Services, Learning and Teaching Office, VP Academic’s Office, Digital Media Library/Student Services, Library/Writing Centre,

New Arts and Contemporary Studies program (Fall ’03) developed a student success course as a result of the recommendations of the Task Force (ACS102) (Library involvement in planning process from inception)

Increased recognition of role of library in BUS 100

BUS 100 Backgrounder Pre-dated Task Force on Student Retention Proposal for course released Oct. 2000 by the director

of Student Support Services and the Business School Meant primarily to address retention issues Focuses on the development of university-level skills Library not included, initially (had to “force” our way in) Mandatory course for all incoming business students.

Non-credit. Pass/Fail.

BUS 100 (Lab-based Delivery) 430 students (2001 and 2002) 10 sections, 40+ students Hands-on labs with exercises 4 hours (4 weeks) 10 librarians involved Quizzes (4), 2 linked directly to core courses (ACC

and Stats), pre/post test, and online tutorials Quizzes graded (P/F). Created in collaboration with

professors WebCT for online content and quizzes

BUS 100 (Lecture Theatre Delivery) 850 students 2003 (double cohort) and 2004 One large class in theatre Drop-in sessions (2003) 5 weeks for library module, 10-15 minute

presentations 4 librarians involved Quizzes (4), 2 linked directly to core courses (ACC

and Stats), pre/post test, and online tutorials Quizzes graded (P/F). Created in collaboration with

professors Blackboard for online content and quizzes

Course Objectives (all years)

Raise awareness of Library resources & services

Develop library research skills

Identify relevant information sources

Formulate effective search strategies

Course Integration (all years)

Integrated with two first semester courses

ACC 100 : Introductory Financial Accounting (SEDAR)

QMS 102 : Business Statistics (Statistics Canada)

Faculty/Library collaboration in developing course content and quizzes

Course Evaluation (all years)

Pre-Test – designed to assess students knowledge of library resources prior to taking Business 100

Four graded multiple choice quizzes – OPAC, ABI, SEDAR & Statistics Canada

Post-Test - designed to assess students knowledge of library resources after taking Business 100

Delivery using Blackboard Integral to the course given lecture-based teaching

environment

Used widely by Ryerson Business faculty for course delivery

A simple interface well suited to the needs of novice users

Supports the delivery and grading of multiple-choice quizzes

Easy linking to course content

Blackboard Business 100 Site

Assignments

Ryerson Library Links

Library Links : Bizlib

Bizlib : Tutorials

Lectures : Instruction or Entertainment? Delivered Monday mornings in the Ryerson Theatre

Up to 850 first-year students (without coffee!)

Not a lecture theatre (no writing surfaces, etc.)

Shared “air-time” with other performers

Presentations limited to 10-15 minutes

Lectures : Breaking the Ice

Emphasis on Accessibility & Service

Frequent use images to augment lecture content

Pop-cultural references used for emphasis

Infomercial format – short “sight bites”

Lectures : The Top Ten …

The Top Ten reasons why you may benefit from the Library’s Business 100 program….

http://www.dandersonillustration.com/car_David_Letterman_big.jpg

[for graphic]

10 …

The last time you visited a library, Barney was still your favourite TV show

www.cs.utah.edu/ ~riloff/personal.html

[for graphic]

8 …

The last time you used a library card was to pick a lock

http://www.ahajokes.com/crt891.html

[for graphic]

7 …

[Graphic of Conrad Black]

You think that peer review refers to the recent trials and tribulations of a well known author and publisher

5 …

You’ve attempted to use a style guide to coordinate your wardrobe

http://www.waynewolfe.com/images/Drag%20Queen.jpg

[for graphic]

Lectures : Illustrating the Basic Concepts of Library Research

Using images to convey empathy and accessibility

Using pop-cultural imagery to illustrate the basics of library research – defining a topic, developing a search strategy

Reinforced through brief real-time demos of library-based resources

You Begin by Defining Your Topic

Definition is important! Which words or concepts best define or describe your research topic?

[Graphic of very well-defined male and female]

Then Developing a Search Strategy

Often combining 2 or more single concepts…

[graphic]

Jlo AND Ben

To obtain specific results…

[graphic]

Jlo AND Ben

[graphic]

Jlo OR Ben

[graphic]

Jlo NOT Ben

Assessing the Outcome

Comparison of Pre-test and Post-test results

Reviewing student ratings

Reviewing student comments

BUS 100: Fall 2002 (Hands-On Format) N=430 Q3:Google will satisfy

most of my info needs Q4: What is a scholarly

journal? Q5: Boolean operators Q6: Formation of a

strategy using Boolean Q8 Citing resources on

the web

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

Q3 Q4 Q5 Q6 Q8

PrePost

BUS 100: Fall 2003 (Lecture Hall) N=850 Q3:Google will satisfy

most of my info needs Q4: What is a scholarly

journal? Q5: Boolean operators Q6: Formation of a

strategy using Boolean Q8 Citing resources on

the web 0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

Q3 Q4 Q5 Q6 Q8

PrePost

Data Comparison: 2002 to 2003 2003 data (less improvement evident

between pre- and post test) may reflect increased class size (430 in 2002 to 850 in 2003)

Lecture format (2003) with little or no personal contact with student. (Lab-based format (2002) allowed for smaller classes of 40 students, hands-on practice, personal help with assignments

How would you rate the Library Sessions?2003 BUS100 Satisfaction

14%

30%

35%

16%

3% 2%

Very Useful

Useful

Slightly useful

Not at all useful

Can't say

No answer

How would you rate the four library assignments? 2003

BUS 100 Satisfaction

9%

30%

31%

23%

4% 3%

Very Useful

Useful

Slightly Useful

Not at all Useful

Can't say

No answer

I feel that the library sessions were:(2003)

37%

10%

41%

6% 6%

Too long

Too Short

About right

Can't Say

No answer

Next Time?

Reduce the number of quizzes

Create a library-specific discussion board on the Business 100 Blackboard site

Embed library-specific discussions on other first-year courses offered through Blackboard

Offer virtual office hours through MSN

Revise online tutorials with Camtasia

Business Students and Additional Library Instruction Library instruction statistics consistently highest for the Business

Program (years 1-4) Saw 3000+ students in library classes in 2004/05 year in addition

to the 850 BUS 100 students 3 Business librarians Can afford to spend less time with students in BUS 100 because

we’ll see them all again in 2nd, 3rd, 4th years when library-based assignments play a greater role in program

BUS 100 intended to introduce some library concepts, and to show a “friendly face”

As a Student Success program—not intended to scare them or present assignments that are too difficult

Arts and Contemporary Studies (ACS102)

New BA program Fall 2003

265 incoming students (’03 and ’04)

Arts/Humanities-focused program

14-week required Credit Course

ACS 102 (“Learning and Developing Strategies”) Course Objectives “Assuming that the 21st century will be led by those

who learn best, the objective of this course is to equip students to realize their full potential in the program, as well as prepare them for life long learning. The course will include opportunities for self-assessment, team work, application and skill development.”

Study skills, information literacy/library skills, group work survival, time management, stress management,, writing skills, self assessment, career planning, equity/diversity, etc.

ACS 102 Library Component Library was part of the curriculum planning

process from the beginning Faculty identified students as having difficulty

grasping differences between scholarly and popular sources, reasons why one would be used over other

Also differences between scholarly finding aids (databases) and Google

ACS 102 Library Component Didn’t want to overwhelm the students with

every possible library research angle

4+ hours contact time, plus library assignment (other departments got 1 or 2 hours)

“Low tech” approach (no Blackboard)

ACS 102 Library Component (Lecture/Presentation) First 2-hour session (265 students)

1 hour presentation on identifying & evaluating information sources (see accompanying PowerPoint presentation) Types of info, relevance, authority, thinking critically

“Small” Group exercise: divided into groups of 10 Distributed magazine, scholarly journal, web site,

or newspaper article Assessed their publication using criteria covered

in presentation (simulating the assignment they would be getting)

“Small” Big Group Exercise1. Who was this written for? Or Who would read this? 2. Who are the authors? 3. Publisher or organization? 4. Where can you find this or buy this? 5. What does it look like – physical characteristics? 6. What distinguishes the magazine/journal/website from the

other sources? 7. When and why would you use each type of source in your

assignments, essays, etc.

ACS 102 Library Component (lab) Second 2-hour session (hands-on lab) 8 sections, 30+ students (2 librarians and 1

TA) Introduced databases and searching

techniques Distributed assignment. Chance for students

to work on it with librarians

ACS 102 Assignment (objectives) Learn to identify scholarly, non-scholarly and

popular sources Learn to identify biases within writing Learn to identify sources that are not appropriate for

university papers Learn to use information legally and ethically

through proper citing and bibliographic style guides Learn to use library databases to find articles in

periodicals

ACS 102 Library Assignment Worth 12% of final course grade Topics chosen by librarians (collaboratively with

faculty) 50 unique topics (2004) (only 5 people/265 with same topic, no one sharing topic in section)

Topics pre-tested to ensure scholarly articles existed in databases

Sample topics: feminism and hiphop culture, police and racial profiling, conflict resolution in schools, sustainable development and corporations, film and depiction of race, celebrity culture, globalization and nation state, animals and mental health (human)

ACS 102 Library Assignment (Questions) (see accompanying Word document for full assignment) What is the purpose of each article or web site

and/or the author’s intent? ( Is the information you have found, fact, opinion, propaganda, advocacy or commercially oriented?)

Who is the intended audience for each article and web site?

Is information about the author available? What are the author’s credentials: is he or she an expert in the field? Are they associated with a reputable institution or organization?

ACS 102 Library Assignment (Questions) Are statements made by the author supported by

real evidence, (studies, research, data gathering, or is the evidence anecdotal?)

Is there a publication date? Does the publication date matter to the information? Is it current or out of date?

Are there any other factors you deem important? For example, writing style, grammatical errors, cultural perspective, etc.

Which source(s) would you use in a research paper? Why or why not for each

ACS 102 Library Assignment (Questions) 1 week to do assignment Marked by librarians (2004) TAs (2003)

Allowed us to determine problems in assignment Marathon sessions together in same room

TAs briefed (most did assignment) Class average: 7.5/10 (2004), 7.3/10 (2003) 14 complaints about marks

ACS 102 Assessment (Library Component) No formal course assessment (pre/post test) Anecdotal evidence: Professors (3) and TAs

(8) very pleased. Student feedback very positive

Ryerson’s experience has been that GPA dips in the first term Students in the ACS program showed an increase

in GPA

ACS 102 Assessment (Library Component)

Fall 2005: ACS Faculty member (Psychology) to administer a series of scales (pre/post tests, tracking students throughout 4 year program) Includes emotional intelligence, reading skills,

beliefs around failure, academic resourcefulness, information literacy, student success, etc.

ACS 102: Best Practices

Front load the program (offer it in first term or first year) First six weeks critical YES

Small class size--no more than 25 students

Course should be required (vs. elective)

Course should carry academic credit that applies toward graduation

Collaborative effort. Should involve Library, student support services, Writing Centre, etc.

YES

30 students/section

YES

YES

YES

Where to? Challenges.

More student success courses? New General Science (BSc) starts Fall 2005. Looking at

starting a student success course for 2006. Director on side, some faculty resistance Workload issues (faculty, librarians, students) Getting everyone together: Collaborative issues with

departments & services Distance Education? Continuing Education? (Camtasia,

Macromedia Breeze, Virtual Office hours)

ASSESSMENT (library component and overall course)

A Selection of Other Library/Ryerson Community Collaborative Efforts “Foundations of Social Work” Tutorialhttp://www.ryerson.ca/library/tutorial/sw/

Ryerson Academic Integrity Model Campus-wide initiative—resources for students, faculty, parents

(all web-based). Will be branded, heavily publicized. Graphical online tutorial for students, with quizzes In time, may be mandatory upon entry to Ryerson Library asked to chair Planning Committee: Director of Provost’s

Office, Student Services, Learning and Teaching Office, Digital Media Office

www.ryerson.ca/acadcouncil/acadintegmodel.pdf

Contacts:

Don Kinder

Coordinator, Library Education

Ryerson University Library

[email protected]

Bob Jackson

Manager, Ronald G. Besse Information and Learning Commons

Ryerson University Library

[email protected]

www.library.ryerson.ca