Top Banner

Click here to load reader

Straw Dogs: Thoughts on Humans and Other Animals - John Gray

Feb 18, 2016

ReportDownload

Documents

Thoughts on Humans and Other Animals - John Gray

  • _QLk~)da;:kkad~a;~ sdab:3~,JarHJl~/l~ lJ:~$a^7a^~+6JaaW~a;~ 6a^a\K6k~ !:~ Kk~ lJ:~ /rlJad~ a;~ at:d~ /~ 7a{:^~ 5aaUk~ M^6Wr7L^H~1`
  • [email protected]^J4nBDnwNr4cePnJ(r4urDl4ra4>bDnD>ppauNpuuN4vQwpbB>[email protected] @pnupb4vRpnuB4l/NRcdQqu

    3pJNlPoBDB4nBDnwDrw4QnQnJwNQuQuqpqc4rqNPcpupqN4wQwu>Duw3NDlprDpBRu4JrDDSvN` pNn(r4ul4Pn cPnD pF 4rJlDnv vNDlprDp238J4QnFrplNPl2qbDnBPB%pn$qQww

    (r4 rDnBDru qNPcpupqN [email protected]@DuuP>bD wp wND c4l4n &pr wNpuDNpcSaD wNDQrqN\pupqNF=w4nBFrPpu"{p1kDwQu [email protected][email protected]@[email protected]*4n3Nplupne9vDDtpnDuNpbB>DqrppaDB>vNQu>[email protected]>DnpNQJNDrqr4QuD [email protected])pjp4"8ka1e

    )DQvDu=ND*8PwNwNDDNPb4r4}nJNQJNrPuarJDnApF [email protected] @Nppa rD D rD8d wN4v BPFFDrDnw Frpl 4nQl4du sDD rD4cc uqDrQpr (r4u >ppal4aDu [email protected]@QnJ4rJlDnwFprvNDpqqpuQwD QD"e94(!'8%>c^

    3ND >ppa Qu @N4bbDnJPnJ 4nB DkrUwwDn(r4 DqrDuuDu NQu [email protected]@[email protected]|prQx"{[email protected]^uupl4n4rrDuwQnJqpQnwu4nBwNpJNwqrppaRoJQBD=wN4wQwuN4rBwp]4JQnD4n rD4BDrnpw>DPoJlpDBk8w

  • .TNQVNW Bd

  • G&BL(["[email protected]&OEBK[8&BER0H[%&H/[!E0>[#E&/[B/EB[![8[

    6HKL[FP,=6K50/[6B[G0&L[G7L&8D[,U[G*L&[EE;K[8$57K[0/6L6EB[FP,>7K50/[,U[G&BL&[EE[H745L[PB/0H[L50[EFW745L[0K64BK[(B/["&L0BLK[.L[ [LE[+0[

    7/0BL:0/['K[M50[&PL5EG[E2[ L58K[SEG;[

    =[G645LK[G0K0J0/[!E[G0FGE/Q.N7EB[.EFU[EH[LG&BKA7KK6EB[E2[ L57K[FP,=6.&L7EB[A&U[+0[A&/0[S6L5EQL[SH6LL0B[F0GA7KK7EB[!E[F&H&4H&F5[E1[M57K[FQ+=7.&L6EB[A&U[+0[H0FHE/Q.0/[.EF70/[EG[LH&BKA6LL0/[K&R0[S7L5[SG7LL0B[F0HA6KK6EB[EH[6B[&..EG/&B.0[S6L5[L50[FHER6K6EBK[E3[ L50[EFVH745L[.L[ [&K[)0B/0/[DU[F0HKEB[S5E[/E0K[&BU[QC&QN5EIY0/[&.L[ 6B[G0?&L6EB[LE[L57K[FP,>7.&L7EB[A&U[,0[>6&+>0[LE[.H6A9B&>[FGEK0.QL7EB[&B/[

    .6R6>[.=&6AK[2EG[ /(A&40K[

    ["[.&L&=E4Q0[G0.EG/[2EH[L56K[,EE&,>0[3HEA[L50[G6L6K5[9,H&HU[

    8 [ [ [ 8 [ [ [

    $UF0K0L[-U[ [#Q=0K["H7BL0/[&B/[,EPB/[7B[G0&L[G7L&7B[,U[

    &.;&UK[E3[ 5&N5&A[

  • "

    "7=>I9(%-(;(=FDW*>B(I>B%WF>WF0([email protected]@(B "7W(%3F3>=W

    W F0(W0G;=WW F0(W%("(@F4>=WW F0(WH3"(DW>*W;>B:3FLW% F0(WG=DH(%WW =>[email protected]>-B(DDW' DW3FW3DW

    *GBF0(BWB(%3=-W3=%(JW

    3JW

    J3W

    WWWWWW

    WW

  • 1LALr ArILA{UA|L |UhL ArI {LAUL pAIH{LA|L8 {AIwT

    c7 {

  • "

    2sUWFwwe2UAL }WLJwy}LLsAXLwN UWsTWsUWHUUpAs A}L sw HLs}Ai 8 UwTU A}L y}LLsLJ Ws N}ATpLs F UL A}L sw sLpAWH 2 UwyL UL HAs FL}LAJwsL ANL} ULwUL} w} JWyyLJWswA\ki 2 UALpAJL}AUL} LLsXLLwN zwAWws sw2FLiXLL Wsw}JL}wiLsJAUw}[wAssNApYiXA}AwN UXseZsT FayiwXii}AL UA XpXTUpLAs >UL swL A UL FAHe wN ULFwweUALULApLAWp

    =LL}Ai yLwyiL UAL TWLs pL Xpi AJWHL AsJLsHw}ATLpLs /HUAsTL XU4ApL 7wLiwHe ULiyLJHiA}WN p UWseZsT ws UL 0AWA UywULW

  • `e]s~V.`~

    pA UAM TWMr UM FwweW IMIWHAMI w 8WMew [UwUwpW wlIrwUAM FMMr[Mr

    8

  • """""

    6 D ] 8[ 'N']^'.BQN ]60jN]68NB8N4-0E802[ Q2 ^68NB8N4R0QRD0#Q/'vE8-0T'E6jL'O8[L6'[`0R0Tm'[8m0RQo0T]7'^o'[ QN.0 RQ[[0[[0/ -v T0m0'D0/ T0E849QN jL'N8[][ D8C0 ]Q]68PB ]60v6'm0 ' T']8QN'E m80o Q2 ]60oQTE/ -j^ ]608T .QT0-0D802 8N RTQ4T0[[ 8[ ' [jR0T[]8]8QN 2jT]60T 2TQL ]60 ]Tj^6'-Qj^^606jL'N'N8L'E]7'N'NvQ2 ]60oQVD/[T0E849QN[ j][8/0 Q2 [.80N.0 RTQ4T0[[ 8[ [8LREv ' L{6 N [QL0

    T0'/0T[ Q2 6 D ] ^68[ Q-[0Z']8QN [00L[ ]Q 6'm0 RTQ}/j.0/ 'LQT'D R'N8. "jT0Dx ]60v'[B NQ QN0 .'NSj0[^8QN^70.0N^T'E'T^8.D0Q2 2'8]7Q2 E8-0T'D[Q.80]90[&8]6Qj^8^o0NQ^/0[R'8T 8B0^T0L-D8N4%8.]QT8'N[ ^0TY0/Q2 EQ[8N4^608U2'8^6 ^60[06jL'N8[^[.E9P4 ]Q ]60LQ]60'^0N-TQ.'/0Q2 RTQ4T0[[8m06QR0#Q/'vT0E849Qj[-0E80m0T['T0LQT02T00}]68NB9N4T8m0N]Q]70L'T49P[Q2 '.jFfT08Po68.6[.80N.0.E'8L['j]6QT9hQm0TQ2 6jL'NBNQoD0/40^70v6'm06'/^Q.jF^8m']0' .'R'.8^w2QT /Qj-] N.QN^T'[^ [0.jE'T -0D80m}0T[ 60E/2'[^-v]60.QNm0N]8QN'Eo8[/QLQ2 ^60 ]8M0 'T09N^604T8RQ2 jN0u'L8N0//Q4L'[#60 RT0m'8E8P4[0.jF'ToQTD/m80o8['R'[]8.60Q2 .jTT0N]

    [.80Nd.QT]6Q/Quv'N/R8Qj[6QR0['Tq6'[[6Qs^7']o0'T0'N8L'D[-j^ '[6jL'N8[][N0m0T]8T0Q2 RT0'.68N4~6Qo o0 E8m0 8[ jR ]Q j[ $NE8B0 'Nv Q]60T 'N8M'D o0 'T0

    7%8

  • `e]s~V.`~

    sc=A4yAByAAscQA4A;OssA3AOAQ=A4sB ByAA=sAps;skABysk;QAp;A ( syQJRp 4yA QpyAdQJQsp ps` 4p yAdQJQsp : OA !OyQQ4p B4QO 4J4Rp OQ;OOk4pQ y4Tcss:AQAc(pOA4p;QApsyc=OA$tR;yA4ptA;c4A=4:s OA

    tsQ:QdQ O4 skAAApk4:Ap;4A=:OA:AcQABO4Ok4p4yAk4zaA=sGBysk4dfsOAy4pRk4d:O4JByAAQ4!O4pTpOAyQ4p;A"4TpOAsysf=psO4A;4A=;O4;4p=4cO4=R:AApBsyke4A=Qp'^=(p=Q4 04sQ!OQp4 sy 4pQkR;4 $w4cc Q Q spc Qpts!OyQQ4p ;gyA O4tORfsstOAy c4:sy s tQscsyA;sp;[A;QApZ;=AAyopQkQO4:AdQAB QpOApQwA;4t4;QsB Ok4ps;OssAOA4OAdQA0OAQyspsBA4pJAcQ;4c "4ypQk R O4 Q A ;QAp;A s ttsy 4QAsB Ok4pQO4;skA ByskyAcQJQsp/skAyA4=AyO4AAAp6D ]84p4Akts4ttd

    "4zQpQksAOQ;4p=tsdQQ;:psOAyA=sA QJJAO4p

  • (V]%sV]~

    WsLsLI UL U|xTU ULW|WpyAHxs5xVs=A|8YljULpAILhWGL|AjWpULLHhA|H|LLIWWxIA>U|xTUULXILLyXsPjLsHLxs6A|j8AUL ULjyLI UAyL HXLsXQH xHWAjXp 2|xsXHAjl Ox| =A^s=_pxsAsI-xpLL|LQL|HLH|WHxO reS_SLHxsxp^HULAhx Yty_LIVLjALLs]LUHLsHhxO ULTjxGAjO|LL pA|fL 2 UAL xjI UW yA|AIxXHAj AsI xOLs OA|HXHAhx| Wsp Gxxfp3SODDyOBD(/SDyoS/OSy

    1pAsXpW sx HXLsHL G|Lj^TWxs ULyx-V|YAsOAWUUAUpAsHAs pAfL AxjIGLL|UBsAs Yt VWHUVLVALxOAjXLI 2sy|L-V|WAs/|xyLXA AfLs Ox|T|AsLI UAUL O|L xjIGLhYfL ULyA 6sxjLITL AsIWtLsxs pWTV AIAsHL G L]H xlI |LpAb pHU ULApL 1_x| AALLxO HHjLUsx xL|AlhpLAvT

    *TAXs UWyATEWL -U|WAs sIL|xxIUWx|AAx| xO Ws AsI |LILpyWxs 1pAsWp X UL |AsOx|pAWxs xO UW -U|XWAsIxH|WsLxO AjAWxs Wsx A y|xdLH xOsWL|Aj UpAs LpAsHWyAXxs >VL WILA xO y|xT|L W ALHjA|L|XxsxO UL-U|WWAsGLjWLO Xsy|xXILsHL >UAWUApxsTULAsHWLsyATAs WAsftxs

    ,LjWLO Ws y|xT|L UA AsxUL| x|HL 2s HXLsHL ULT|xU xO fsxjLITL X HpjAWL , UpAs jXOL A AUxjLWsxAHpjAXLAHWW' UAWTAWsLI_txsLTLsL|AXxs pA GL jx Xs VL sL 2s HXLsHL gxjLITL X AsspcLITxxI(WsLUWHAsIyxjW]HXXGAIALlhATxxI=HWLsHL_sH|LALVpAsyxL| AsIpATsXQLULPjAWsVpAssA|L 2 LsAGjL x jWL jxsTL AsI VAL UXTUL|

    7%%% 8

  • `e]s~V.`~

    E:_=L8jTW(L/(Q/TjW9(Lj:LjW92jO(TWjWjW92jT(J2jW>K2j:Wj(EENaTj\TjWNjaR2(Dj/2TWQ\-W:NLj NLj2(-9jNW92Qj(L/jW92j(QW9j NLj(j

    E(Q82QjT-(E2jW9(Lj2_2Qj,23NQ2j#92j:/2(jN3j OQN8R2TTjQ2TWTjNLjW92j,2E:23j W9(WjW92j8QNaW9jN3j

    DLNaE2/82j(L/j W92j (/_(L-2j N3j W92j TO2-:2Tj 8Nj WN82W92Qj :3jLNWjLNajW92Lj:LjW92jENL8jQ\Lj#92j,:,E:-(EjJfW9jN3j W92j(FEjN3j

    (Lj-NLW(ATjW92j3NQ,://2Lj[W9jLNaE2/82j/N2TjLNWjJ(D2j\Tj3Q22jWjE2(_2Tj\Tj(Tja2j9(_2j(Ea(fTj,22LjOQ2fjWNj2_2QfjD=L/jN3j 3NFEhj#92jT(J2jZ\W9j:Tj3N\L/j>LjQ22DjJfW9j #92jO\Li:T9J2LWj N3j QNJ2W92\Tj-9(:L2/j WNj (j QN-Dj 3NQj TW2(EA8j 5

  • (V]%sV]~

    !QG:_:.'E '._8QN6'[ .QL1 _Q -1 ' [kWWQ4'_1 2QW ['Em'_8QN-k_NQRQE8_8.'GRWQA1._.'N/1H8m1X6kL'N:_v2WQL8_[N'^kW'G.QN/8_:QNQo1m1WW'/8.'ERQG8_:.'ERWQ51['W11uR1/81N^[ LQ/1[_/1m:.1[2QW.QR8N4p_6W1.kWW:[email protected][141Et8_1[[QL1o61W1_6'_6kL'N:^v-1.QN_1N_QNGvo61N8_Km1[ 8N ' oQWE/ Q2 8_[ QoN L'B;N4 N .QN_W'[_ 6 ]'W4k1[2QW'[682_2WQL6kL'N[QE:R[8[LkL+[.'NNQ_['m1_61oQUG/ -k_ _68[ 8[ NQ W1'[QN 2QW /1[R'8W _/Q1[NQ_N11/['m8N4'RR8Ex 6kL'N[N1m1W G:m1 8N ' oQWG/ Q2 _618UQoNL'B8N4

    Q6NW'x'v>22_

    8

  • ""

    ;ENTNO9=2Tj(L/j2_2Lj(jO(SWjN3j T.=2L.2jW2TYjWNjW92j^La2(Sf=L8j92SN=.j26NSWjN3jJ(LD=L/j/2TO2S(W2Ifj/2Lf=L8j=WTj.NLW=L82L.fj

    C!%Vjjl

  • W

    `3%S%~q%]`o`~0oQS3`Q~

    B__ZN uyu_ V_qN_Xz_uNXNW_N_ ` y Z_y Guy y `N{u Xz_X_! K_ Z _N ` N y_ u_ uO_ qyN V_ N_ `u_yZ_yy_ Kuu_uN2

    K_ Z __Z 7N| __ uN _V_q u u_NyN j y_ V_Ny ` y_ _NZ u_N_ XXy" Fy yX_ Xz_X_ uN ZN N NuyuNX__y_X_XNyO__uN7Ny_NXu_uN _Xy_N_ N_Vy_aq__y_NXyqN NZu_NXu u_ NZ u_y uy`yq_y_#F_Xy_ XNX u_y `N_" F_Xy_ Z _y$ GuyN__NuN M_zz`q_u_____S` u_q_` NyZ Gu_uN_u_y`QuyNNWNXyuN _Zuy` Ryq_y y`y__ `_Z ` XNbc6uyyNu_%

    =` 7Ny ZyX_ uNZ W__ NZ_ y N GNy Fuy

  • `d]s~V.`~

    > u__ `Nyu uN N[ u_ NyN N_ 5 YN Nzyq Nq 6uzzN u _ uN V_[ u_yquyqyyqq__[NVy_Y_ uNNq_ uz [N >JyYyN_ uzNNYnyY V___6uyyN N[ V_y__& G[N y y Nq_[ V___uNyN[u_`_u[_N[uNuNYN_V_N_ ` u_y[_yuNN u_NyN!

  • d0%~0oQS~

    W

    d0%~Q3].%~ V(~VS`3Vo`~%qVKoe3VS~

  • `d^s~ V.`~

    '[.T8-0 .QN[.8Qj[N0[[ 'N/ RjTRQ[0 ]Q ]60 [R0.

  • d0%~0oQS~

    :k4p;QApQ:AhQAA OAk4Ap;Qsp4PA}AgsD 4kAAs}VA;shdU=UpJQOOA$4}O0s=4uA;QA4}A=Q4uuA4}QpJ 4 4 }4A O4 Q A s }u4 O4 d4 J}A4AQp;Qsp 0OA ;4A Q ps 4p ;skQ; ;44}suOA )sAds;a4QQ4uh4JAsD uAsuhA#4}p=Q;AO4A}sdgA=:4=dDs} $4}O 2UgspusQq

    s 0OA h;a O}s O4 :}sJO OAOk4p uA;QA s Qu}AApusA}O9kA4p }Qq Ds};sphAsOA} dVDA Ds}k2OApPr4p4}}QA=QpOA+A2sh=4}sp=AhAOs4p= A4} 4Js OA ;spQpAp 4:sp=A= Qp k4kksOk4s=sp;7AdKQ4pJ}sp=dsO4p==sApsD TkUg4}uA;QA *s sD OAA Qp=QJAps uA;QA A}A OpA= sAQq;Qsp+s}OkA}V;4 dssA} R2uA} ;Ap 4p=/sOlA}Q;4 G2 uA} ;Ap sD Q h4}JA k4kk4d 4;;s}=QpJ s#Q4ksp=0OA=A};Usp sD OAp4}4ds}h= Q ps OA }Ah sD

    Jds:4h ;4uQ4dQk Qq=}Q4hQ4Qsp 2AA}p ;QQ4Qsp s}8Ed4QqOr4pTqsp (Q4;spAxAp;AsD OAAsdQsp4} ;;A sD 4p A;AuQsp4dh }4u4;Qs u}Qk4A0O}sJOs 6h sD OQs4p= u}AOQs} Ok4p 4=4p;AO4;sQq;Q=A=VOA;sdsJV;4h=A44Qsp([email protected]=Qp:4h4p;AVP

    OA$4}ODs}hspJuAs=0OA(pQ4p=OA OlApk:dA=Qps4sD dQDA QpOQ;O OAQ} Dssu}Tq4 hQJO2A;4ppsA4=OA$4}OsdQJOh'w~5vYO4:A;skAsspkA}s0OA = sD usud4Qsp Q ps 4 A} A4; ;QAp;A +s

    spADs}A;4OAusud4Qsp;sdh4uAO4 Qs;;}}UpJTqus;smlpT$}suA8.Q4s}OA;6AsD OAD6gTqDA}

    6

  • `e]s~V.`~

    uNyZ_NzXu` u_Z Hu_Nqy` _zXNXN` `_yNZz`___XNXzNq_!9_N `u_ Nq_ yX_N_ y z_yNV_$~Bz V__9_?j_N_NZ_XzyqVyuN_Z_XzN`NXNZ Nzyq Z_Nu N_ Z_ NNyZy_N_ NZ q_XyZ_u___qVNNy` _ZVyzyqV N_N Q 1>VzyV u__N>2K2DE

    3 uN Ny ` NNXuyq G Vyy XN V_NzNy_Z V Z_Nyq u_ 9Nu* =` yZ uNVzN zqz__uNXNyNZuNVyNzz` Ny`_XN V_ _Z z q__ Z__ y` q__zX _qy__yq_NV_ __uzqu__Z V_ __Z `u_ uzyqz u_ uN uN_ X_N_Z ` u___ N _q_qyXN _N u_ 9_yX u_9N` FyZ_ y uyXuz__Ny u_9Nu V u___NZu_u_yX__ uN__u_ Ny_$

    =zNuzZ_zzVyy NyquN_* 9yu_ u_9Nu_`_qNyq_XuNy z N_ u_ N_ _uNVyNV_`uNu_zZ__bc_X` u_yNXy_Xuu_X_ quyu_zV_$

    A_X