Top Banner

of 16

Reneging a Promise

Jun 01, 2018

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
  • 8/9/2019 Reneging a Promise

    1/16

    Reneging a Promise

    Gomez, Pablo, Sanchez, Ymasa, Yu,Zambales

  • 8/9/2019 Reneging a Promise

    2/16

    FRAME THE ETHICAL ISSUE:

    To accept Foot and

    Balances ofer andrenege his promise to

    Tick and Check or not

  • 8/9/2019 Reneging a Promise

    3/16

    FACTS F THE CASE:

    PART A:

    Received a jo ofer !rom Tick " Check #anted to $ork at Foot and Balance

    %o ofer !rom Foot " Balance &et

    'as a !riend at Foot and Balance

  • 8/9/2019 Reneging a Promise

    4/16

    %ot &et committed to Tick " Check )*st asking !or jo ofers !orthcoming

    )*st *sing his connections+ has opport*nities

    ,es- .ho*ld eca*se

    Q1: Should Billy call his friend? Whyshould or should not?

  • 8/9/2019 Reneging a Promise

    5/16

    Q2: Is there any other action yousuggest Billy take prior to deciding on

    the o er of Tick and Check? Why do youreco end?

    Inquire to Foot and Balance through its HR

    Department

    Explain his situation to Tick and Check

    Ask advice o his parents! previous

    pro essors! and riends" amil#

  • 8/9/2019 Reneging a Promise

    6/16

    FACTS F THE CASE:

    PART B:

    Called his !riend

    Accepted TCs oferReceived a call !rom FB

    / $eek to decide

    %ot &et signed an& contracts $ith TC

  • 8/9/2019 Reneging a Promise

    7/16

    Q!: "o you think it is e#er right to $ack out ofa pro ise you ga#e to so eone else? If so%

    under &hat circu stances? If not% &hy?

    P!om"se # comm"$men$ b% someone $o &o o! no$ $o

    &o

    '( Solemn P!om"ses # ma!!"a)e *o+s( Le)al con$!ac$s - en.o!ceable b% la+

    /( Fa"!% Tale P!om"ses # !e)!e$$able an& &"0cul$ a$$he $"me $he% mus$ be hono!e&1( Elec$"on P!om"ses

  • 8/9/2019 Reneging a Promise

    8/16

    Ch!"s$"an"$% # oa$h3*o+, ma4"n) Go& as+"$ness

    Islam # .o!b"&s $o b!ea4 5!om"se, Allah as+"$ness,

    'eligions ha#e si ilar #ie&s a$out pro ises

  • 8/9/2019 Reneging a Promise

    9/16

    Immanuel 6an$ # 5!om"ses shoul& al+a%s be 4e5$

    Conse7uen$"al"s$ # shoul& be b!o4en ". $he!e a!ebene8$s

    (hilosophy

  • 8/9/2019 Reneging a Promise

    10/16

    TC 9 F Com5an% # h"!e $he bes$

    a55l"can$

    "ll% 9 $he! a55l"can$s # +o!4 "n $hecom5an% $ha$ 5!o*"&e $he"! bes$

    "n$e!es$s

    F!"en&s 9 Fam"l%

    Sha!ehol&e!s 9 Em5lo%ees

    Identify the stakeholders andinterests)o$ligations

  • 8/9/2019 Reneging a Promise

    11/16

    ALTER;ATIe!

    Rene)e h"s 5!om"se $o T"c4 9 Chec4 an&acce5$ Foo$ 9 alance=s o>e!

    Re?ec$ bo$h

  • 8/9/2019 Reneging a Promise

    12/16

    @ECISI ;:Rene)e h"s 5!om"se $o T"c4 9 Chec4 an& acce5$ Foo$ 9 alance=s

    o>e!

    EG ISM

    ha$e*e! ac$"on a 5e!son ma% &o "s.o! h"s o! he! o+n )oal(

    Peo5leBs ac$"ons a!e ma"nl%mo$"*a$e& b% $he"! o+n "n$e!es$s an&&es"!es(

    Sense o. sel. "m5o!$ance

    0ntention: to get the *o$ that he&ants

    Character: Billy ought to do &hat is$est for hi

  • 8/9/2019 Reneging a Promise

    13/16

    @ECISI ;:Rene)e h"s 5!om"se $o T"c4 9 Chec4 an& acce5$ Foo$ 9 alance=s

    o>e!

  • 8/9/2019 Reneging a Promise

    14/16

    @ECISI ;:Con$"nue +o!4"n) a$ T"c4 9 Chec4 an& &ecl"ne Foo$ 9 alance=s

    o>e!

    6A;TIA; ETHICS

    @u$%-o!"en$e& #ma"n )oal "s $o&e$e!m"ne +ha$ +e a!e obl")a$e&

    $o &oFo!mal"sm # .ocuses on $hes$!uc$u!e o. a mo!al ?u&)men$

    Mo!al"$% "s no$ base& on h%5o$he$"cal"m5e!a$"*e bu$ !a$he! on a ca$e)o!"cal

    "m5e!a$"*eD

  • 8/9/2019 Reneging a Promise

    15/16

    @ECISI ;:Con$"nue +o!4"n) a$ T"c4 9 Chec4 an& &ecl"ne Foo$ 9 alance=s

    o>e!

    1eontological 2thics # conce!ne&+"$h +ha$ 5eo5le &o, no$ +"$h $heconse7uences o. $he"! ac$"ons

    @o $he !")h$ $h"n) &o "$ because "$ "s$he !")h$ $h"n) $o &o@o no$ &o $he +!on) $h"n) a*o"& "$because "$ "s +!on)

    You shoul& ac$ !e)a!&less o. %ou! o+n "n$en$"ons- 6an$

    You canno$ ?us$".% an ac$"on b% sho+"n)$ha$ "$ 5!o&uce& )oo& conse7uencesD

  • 8/9/2019 Reneging a Promise

    16/16

    @ECISI ;:Con$"nue +o!4"n) a$ T"c4 9 Chec4 an& &ecl"ne Foo$ 9 alance=s

    o>e!

    6A;TIA; ETHICS:

    0ntention: To keep the pro ise orco it ent ade to Tick and Checksince the pro ise is $inding $et&een thet&o parties in#ol#ed

    Character: Bill e $odies loyalty andco it ent