Top Banner
Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global Immunization Addresses by: George R. Siber, M.D. and John B. Robbins, M.D. On the Occasion of the Presentation of the Albert B. Sabin Gold Medal to John B. Robbins, M.D. April 23, 2001 – Crystal City, Virginia
24

Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

Jul 19, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

1

Recognition of Excellencein Vaccinology

and Global ImmunizationAddresses by:

George R. Siber, M.D.and John B. Robbins, M.D.

On the Occasion of thePresentation of the

Albert B. Sabin Gold Medalto John B. Robbins, M.D.

April 23, 2001 – Crystal City, Virginia

Page 2: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

2

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

The Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute gratefully acknowl-edges the generous support of: Aventis Pasteur, Aviron,Baxter International, MedImmune, Merck & Co., GlaxoSmithKline, and Wyeth Lederle Vaccines for unrestrictedgrants used to underwrite the 2001 Albert B. Sabin GoldMedal ceremony and this publication.

John B. Robbins, M.D.

Page 3: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

3

Each year the Sabin Vaccine Institute and the en-tire vaccine community gathers to salute an ex-emplary leader in the field of vaccinology. With

the Albert B. Sabin Gold Medal, we recognize anindividual who embodies the spirit and dedication ofDr. Sabin, who touched the lives of most human beingsalive today through his oral polio vaccine.

Thanks to vaccines, polio was eradicated from theUnited States in 1975 and from the entire WesternHemisphere in 1991. Polio will soon join smallpox as asubject in history, wiped out by a global effort involvingmultiple partnerships among public and privateagencies of all nations and ideologies, who have cometogether in a common cause, armed with the diseasefighting weapon invented by Dr. Sabin.

Sabin was both a physician and a scientist. He wasdriven by a passion to transform scientific knowledgeinto practical tools to benefit humankind, what wenow call translational research. In addition toconquering polio, Sabin developed vaccines forencephalitis and dengue fever. He was a trailblazer,investigating links between viruses and cancer, a fieldof great excitement and promise in today’sunderstanding of molecular biology.

John B. Robbins, M.D., is an extraordinary physician,scientist, and public servant. His entire career has beendevoted to continuing Albert Sabin’s quest to conquerdisease with vaccines and immunization. His research

Introduction

By H. R. ShepherdChairman

Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute

Page 4: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

4

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

has concentrated on protecting infants and childrenfrom disease, most notably meningitis and pertussis.Millions of people worldwide owe their good health tohis work.

Dr. Robbins shares with Albert Sabin not only a passionfor vaccines, but also a common training ground, havingobtained his medical degree from the New YorkUniversity Medical School in 1959—twenty-eight yearsafter Sabin obtained his. In that regard, the awardingof the Sabin Gold Medal this year to John Robbins alsoreflects on the excellence of the academic institutionwhich prepared both of these men for their illustriouscareers of science in service to humanity.

Dr. Robbins is already the recipient, along with hiscolleague Dr. Rachel Schneerson, of two of medicine’smost prestigious awards: the Pasteur and LaskerAwards. In view of his achievements, it is most fittingthat we ask him to leave his beloved laboratory onthis occasion to present him with the Albert B. SabinGold Medal.

Page 5: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

5

Tribute to John B. Robbins, M.D.

By George R. Siber, M.D.Senior Vice President and Chief Scientific Officer

Wyeth Lederle Vaccines

John Robbins shares with Albert Sabin a deeppassion for vaccines, for all aspects –– from basicresearch on microbial pathogenesis and antigenic

analytical methods, to characterizing the immuneresponse, to implementing immunization programs, andto ensuring that all those who need vaccines get them.

Both men applied volcanic energy to their work.Both had broad interests but are best known for theirsingular and crowning achievements: the developmentof oral polio vaccine for Albert Sabin and thedevelopment of Haemophilus type b conjugate vaccinefor John Robbins. It is thus most fitting that JohnRobbins be the ninth recipient of the Albert B. SabinGold Medal.

Now, many of us in this room know John Robbins,and know that he is not a very formal person. Indeed,this may be the first time I’ve ever seen John wear a tie.So I think it’s appropriate before mentioning John’smany scientific accomplishments, to tell you a little bitabout the person behind them.

You may not know that John is an expert in manyareas besides vaccines. For example, he has anencyclopedic knowledge of baseball, and in particularof the Brooklyn Dodgers. This is a result of many visitsto Ebbet’s Field during his childhood years growingup in post-depression Brooklyn. The trolley ride was anickel, and admission a quarter. Often John wouldwalk the six miles to save that nickel and spend it on a

Page 6: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

6

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to haveleft John forever hungry, which perhaps explains hisvoracious appetite, not only for knowledge but alsofor food. It’s fair to say that John has a deeplyomnivorous expertise in all cuisines but particularlyin Chinese, Thai, and Jewish deli.

Another area of expertise is in Oriental rugs. Hislong time colleague Rachel Schneerson recounts a storywhich illustrates the extraordinary intensity withwhich John pursues his passions. During a formal visitto the State Department, John became absorbed in awonderful Persian runner, and while examining it withminute care, followed it through a door into a well-appointed gilt-mirrored room. Here he was promptlyaccosted by a female security guard who demandedto know in stentorian tones whom he was looking forin the ladies’ room.

Returning to medicine, you may also not knowthat John Robbins, early in his career, was thiscountry’s first clinical expert in Pneumocystis cariniipneumonia. While at the University of Florida inGainesville, he made the first microbiologic diagnosisof pneumocystis by silver stain in a patient withagammaglobulinemia and treated the patientsuccessfully with pentamidine, the first such therapyin the US. This patient was described in a 1965publication in the New England Journal of Medicine andsubsequently John wrote a half dozen papers onpneumocystis and its clinical management.

The major portion of John’s prodigious scientificefforts have, however, been directed to vaccines, and inparticular to bacterial polysaccharides and polysaccharideconjugate vaccines. I think it’s fair to say that JohnRobbins has never met a polysaccharide he didn’t like.He approaches each new sugar molecule with an

Page 7: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

7

appraising glint in his eye to see if it might havevaccine potential.

And I might mention parenthetically that he seemsto approach people in the same way. If they share hispassion for vaccines and have potential to contribute tovaccinology, they become his friends for life.

The people who most influenced John, his mentorsand closest colleagues, were not only superb scientistsbut also great vaccinologists, people like Chandler Stetsonand Lewis Thomas at NYU, Margaret Pittman at FDA,Emil Gotschlich at Rockefeller University and BobAustrian at the University of Pennsylvania.

With those who share his commitment, John isextraordinarily generous with his time and ideas. Therehave been many, many guest workers from all over theworld who have spent time in his lab, from Sweden,Finland, France, China, India, Africa, Czechoslovakia,Indonesia, Egypt and Israel and many other countries.John has also been extraordinarily generous to many ofus with his supply of valuable reagents. Many yearsago, John devised a scheme for raising high antibodytiters in equines. Those of us who worked on Hib arelikely to have received aliquots of hyperimmune serumfrom Burro 132, who literally had grams of anti-PRPantibody coursing through its veins. Over the years,John tells me that he distributed 173 liters of serum fromthis remarkable beast and many hundreds of liters ofserum from Horse 46, an enormous Clydesdale whowas hyperimmunized with meningococcus B.

Despite an early love affair with IgM classantibodies, which John described as especiallytalented, powerful, and versatile in killing Salmonellain an important 1965 publication in the Journal ofExperimental Medicine, he eventually concluded that the

Page 8: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

8

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

real workhorse of vaccine-induced immunity was IgGclass antibody. IgG is not only highly protective andfaithfully persistent, but also seeps out of thebloodstream into mucosal surfaces to neutralize thepathogenic inoculum and protect there as well. Hechallenged humoral and cellular immunologists todemonstrate that mucosal IgA antibodies and cellularimmune mechanisms are truly important primarymediators of the protection conferred by the currentlyavailable vaccines. Arguably, this challenge has yetto be convincingly answered.

The most remarkable achievement in a lifetime ofintense, creative work is that John Robbins, together withRachel Schneerson and a small number of coworkers,developed and tested in man an extraordinarily largenumber of bacterial vaccines. The list of these, most ofwhich are polysaccharides or polysaccharide conjugates,includes: the Hib polysaccharide and Hib conjugate, type6B pneumococcal conjugate, O-acetyl negativeMeningococcus C conjugate, the Salmonella Vipolysaccharide and recently a Vi conjugate which hasjust been shown to have 92 percent efficacy in field trialsin Vietnamese children, Salmonella paratyphi LPSconjugate, E. coli 0157 conjugate designed to preventhemorrhagic colitis and its most serious complication,hemolytic uremic syndrome, Staphylococcus aureus type5 and 8 conjugates recently shown effective inhemodialysis patients, group B strep conjugates,cryptococcal conjugate, cholera LPS Inaba conjugate,non-typable haemophilus LPS conjugate, Shigella flexneriand sonnei conjugates, the latter of which was shownefficacious in Israeli soldiers; and the list goes on!

John and his colleagues have been the pointers ofthe vaccine hunt. They have led the chase many times,shown what is possible for the first time not just inanimals but in humans, and thus led the way for

Page 9: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

9

commercial companies to take up the vaccine’sdevelopment and market a commercial product. John’swork has led directly to at least three licensed vaccines:the Hib tetanus toxoid conjugate, the Vi-polysaccharidebased typhoid vaccine, and the pertussis toxoid vaccine.His work has also contributed in a major way to themeningococcal C conjugate vaccines introduced in theUK in 1999, and to the pneumococcal conjugate whichbecame available to all US children last year and is nowbeing introduced in Europe.

Of all these achievements, the Hib conjugate isJohn’s crowning accomplishment. Hib was the mostimportant cause of bacterial meningitis, with terriblecomplications of hearing loss, paralysis, mentalretardation, and death. When many of us began ourtraining, it was one of the most common and seriousinfections for which babies were hospitalized. Thedisease has now essentially disappeared in everycountry that has introduced the vaccine.

For this accomplishment John Robbins and hiscolleague Rachel Schneerson, together with PorterAnderson and David Smith, were awarded the LaskerClinical Medical Research Award in 1996 and theWorld Health Organization/Children’s VaccineInitiative’s Pasteur Award.

John’s passion and strength of conviction havebecome legendary. He has never run from controversy.He loves a good fight. A prime example of this is thesingle component pertussis toxoid vaccine developedin his lab. Despite the prevailing dogma that multiplecomponents are needed for an effective vaccine, Johnand his colleagues in Goteborg, Sweden, persisted anddemonstrated the efficacy of pertussis toxoid, and mostrecently are showing that this vaccine, once it is widelyused in a geographic area, can essentially eradicate the

Page 10: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

10

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

disease not only in children but in all age groups.

Like all great scientific controversies, it may turnout that both sides are right; yes, pertactin andfimbriae may demonstrably contribute protection ina setting of strong epidemic pressure of disease; andyes, pertussis toxoid, like diphtheria toxoid, issufficient for population immunity when there is highvaccine uptake.

Since this pertussis toxoid vaccine is the simplestand arguably the safest acellular pertussis vaccine, itmay yet have its day in this age when vaccine safety isbecoming of paramount concern.

It’s safe to predict that this is not the lastcontroversial position that John Robbins will take. Myadvice to you all, even if you disagree with him, isalways to take his arguments seriously and considerthem thoughtfully, because John Robbins’s recordshows - and I am borrowing one of his own favoritephrases - John Robbins’s record shows that he hasmade “a habit of being right”.

Page 11: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

11

Remarks Upon Acceptance of theAlbert B. Sabin Gold Medal

by John B. Robbins, M.D.National Institutes of Health

Bethesda, MD

I would like to express thanks to the Committee, rec-ognition to my family and Rachel, special thanks tomy colleagues at the Laboratory of Developmental

and Molecular Immunity, National Institutes of Health,the Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research andCenters for Disease Control including Louis D.Rodrigues, J.C. Parke, Osmar Barrera, Ann Sutton,William Egan, and Willie Vann. In addition, I wishto thank our special gurus: Meir Wilchek, PorterAnderson, Robert Austrian and Emil C. Gotschlich.

Not commonly known was that Dr. Sabin waselected to the National Academy of Sciences before hedeveloped poliovirus vaccine, based upon his work ondengue fever and toxoplasmosis. Albert Sabin was alsoa president of the United Bialystockers, an organizationof immigrants and refugees from Bialystock, Polandthat collected money to bring friends and relatives fromtheir town to the United States. Fund raising wasdifficult in those years, because most immigrants fromeastern Europe were poor and their kinsmen in Polandwere in precarious condition.

The formalin-inactivated poliovirus vaccinedeveloped by Salk and his colleagues, licensed in 1954,induced less than optimal immunity, and productionwas marginal. Sabin’s orally-administered vaccinebecame available in 1965. Routine vaccination with theattenuated poliovirus was soon implemented in the US,

Page 12: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

12

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

Canada, and most of the developed countries in thelate 1960s. But, paralytic polio continued to occur inmost of Central and South America, Africa, andSoutheast Asia. The inability to vaccinate all childrenagainst polio was blamed largely upon the limitedpersonnel and funds available to public healthprograms. Stimulated by the failure of manydeveloping countries to achieve universal poliovaccination, Sabin campaigned for concentratingresources by supplementing public health personnelwith volunteers, to focus nation-wide publicity to ashort period each year.

This approach was successful in several countriesincluding Brazil and Cuba. In the late 1980s, Sabin’sscheme was adopted by the Pan American HealthOrganization under the direction of Dr. Ciro deQuadros, who received the Sabin Gold Medal Awardlast year for eliminating wild-type poliovirus from theAmericas. Sabin’s approach to eliminating poliovirusinfection was ultimately adopted in the 1990s.Although delayed by conflicts in parts of Africa andAsia, elimination of paralytic polio will be achieved,but only about half a century after polio vaccinebecame available. Notable was the fact that the WorldHealth Organization initially opposed Mass PolioVaccination Days, stating that these could interferewith existing routine vaccination programs. Thesuccess of Polio Mass Vaccination strengthened ratherthan weakened programs for immunization ofchildren. As it has been said, “Nothing smells sweeterthan the sweet smell of success.”

My remarks tonight are not directed towards thedevelopment of Haemophilus influenzae type b conjugate--its successes are well known. My best recollections aboutthose years are the wonderful people I met and the helpand advice given to Rachel and me by our colleagues.

Page 13: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

13

Rather than dwell on old hat, I will speak about acurrent problem of vaccination that shames ourprofession - - that of group A meningococcal meningitisin Africa. My presumption in presenting this topic wasstimulated by the experience of Dr. Albert Sabin andhis colleagues in bringing polio vaccine to all children.

Dr. Rachel Schneerson of our Laboratory and Dr.Emil C. Gotschlich of the Rockefeller University and Ihave encountered similar inertia on the part of theWorld Health Organization, to recommend routineimmunization against endemic and epidemic groupA meningococcal meningitis in the “meningitis belt”of Africa. Their recommendation for epidemic controlonly is based upon distortions of both the immunologicdata and clinical experience with group Apolysaccharide, and is claimed to be justified by theslightly different schedule required for group Apolysaccharide vaccine, which would compromiseexisting programs.

Meningococci are capsulated: three capsularpolysaccharides denoted as group antigens, A, B, and Ccomprise most of the cases. Each has unique immunologicproperties that distinguish them from all other medicallyimportant bacterial polysaccharides. Group Ameningococci have caused epidemics throughout theworld during the past century. Unlike any otherpolysaccharide, Group A induces a booster responsebetween 3 months and 2 years of age. This regimeinduced protective levels of antibodies and preventedmeningitis in infants and young children in Finland andNew Zealand. Groups B and C cause endemic meningitisand occasionally acute and protracted outbreaks. GroupB polysaccharide is non-immunogenic. Group Cpolysaccharide does not induce protective antibody levelsup to the age of 2 years, and reinjection inducessuppression in this age group. In older children and

Page 14: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

14

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

young adults, a single injection of groups A, C, W135and Y polysaccharides elicits a protective serum antibodyresponse that is probably lifelong.

The problem of epidemic group A meningococcalmeningitis has been described by the WHO. Reportedcases of meningococcal disease in African countries inthe 10 year period 1988 - 1997 total 704,000, a figurewhich is likely to be a significant underestimate of thetrue number. About 100,000 people have died as aresult of the disease during this period. In 1996, anepidemic involving more that 180,000 reported casestook place, the largest epidemic ever recorded.Epidemics on this scale cannot be ignored. In additionto epidemics, group A meningococci regularly causeabout 30,000 cases of meningitis annually. This“endemic” rate is considered epidemic inindustrialized countries. The mortality is at least 10percent. At least 30 percent of “cured” patients, evenunder optimal conditions, suffer permanent centralnervous system damage including impairment or lossof hearing, mental retardation, seizures, and blindness.Despite antibiotics and other supportive therapy,meningococcal meningitis remains a serious disease.Obviously, prevention is preferred to treatment.

To combat this terrible problem, the WHO strategyattempts to predict an epidemic by detecting the numberof meningitis cases to be >15/100,000 per week for twoweeks in several villages. When this information isconfirmed, mass vaccination is initiated with oneinjection of bivalent groups A and C meningococcalpolysaccharide vaccine to the “at-risk” population. Thissentinel strategy failed to prevent the worst recordedepidemic of group A meningococcal meningitis in 1996.Again in 1997, Sudan endured an epidemic of 32,000cases and 2,200 deaths, and Ghana of 18,703 cases andabout 1,400 deaths. The WHO vaccination campaign

Page 15: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

15

in Ghana was tardy, despite five weeks of warning froman epidemic in adjacent Togo. Had mass vaccination inGhana started 6 months earlier, there would have beenno epidemic. But even with optimal detection andmobilization of personnel and resources, all authoritiesagree that at best, the WHO strategy will prevent only50% of cases during an epidemic.

We and African workers have proposed that massvaccination of the entire population, followed by routinevaccination of infants with group A polysaccharide willprevent both epidemic and endemic meningococcalmeningitis. Two examples are cited.

First, vaccination with group A polysaccharidewas started in 3 northern provinces of Benin, withabout 50 percent coverage between 1993 and 1996.During that period, Benin had no epidemics in thisarea, whereas neighboring Burkina Faso and Togosuffered epidemics in 1996 and 1997.

Second are the severe epidemics of group Ameningococcal meningitis which were reported in Chinain 1957, 1966, and 1976. Thereafter, routine vaccinationof infants and school children was initiated in 1980. Sincethen there have been relatively few cases and noepidemics. The situation was different in adjacentMongolia. As in China, in 1976 a severe epidemic inMongolia was halted by a trial of group A polysaccharidevaccine. But there was no follow-through ofimmunization. Mongolia experienced a severe epidemicin 1995 through 1997, with an overall attack rate of 1percent. Only after the worst part of the epidemicoccurred did the WHO initiate mass vaccination.

The keystone of the WHO’s failure to recommendthis safe, stable, inexpensive, available, and highlyeffective vaccine for routine vaccination is justified

Page 16: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

16

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

largely in a report in the Lancet, July 20th, 1985. Becauseit is so pivotal to the discussion, I summarize this reportand urge all of you to read it.

The West African country of Burkina Faso hasendured epidemics about every 8 to 12 yearsthroughout the 20th century. During the first 3 monthsof 1981, 3,800 cases of group A meningococcusmeningitis were reported. This prompted wide-scalevaccination with one dose of bivalent group A and Cvaccine; about 103,000 children were vaccinated. Inits capital city, approximately 48,000 children, betweenthe ages of 7 and 12 years were vaccinated orapproximately 98 percent of children who were inschool. Approximately 45 percent of the estimated55,000 younger children between the ages of 3 monthsand 6 years were vaccinated once. Because of logisticalconstraints, vaccination cards were given to only someof the vaccinees, making future evaluation of thevaccine’s effect difficult. In 1983, another 25,000 doseswere given mainly to unvaccinated schoolchildren.Incomplete records were kept, because the number ofvaccinees is expressed as approximate in thousandsrather than in exact numbers.

The nature of and who conducted thesurveillance is not described. About half of theconfirmed cases in the capital’s main hospital werediscarded from the analysis.

There were no serologic studies.

In 1982, one year after the main vaccinationprogram, the CDC evaluated the efficacy of the vaccineusing a case control method.

Three years after vaccination, the efficacy was92 percent in the 4 to 7 year-olds and 75 percent in

Page 17: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

17

the 8 to 16 year-olds: the difference between the agegroups was not statistically significant. As expectedfrom the extensive studies of group A polysaccharide,the efficacy in 1 to 3 year-olds after one year was 89percent, which declined to about 22 percent afterthree years.

Several aspects of this report should be mentioned.First, there was no comment on the usefulness of thevaccine for the 5 to 16 year-olds, the very age groupwith the highest attack rate of meningitis in this and allother epidemics in Africa. Second, the authors failedto mention that the package insert recommended thattwo injections, spaced several months apart, should begiven during 3 month to 2 years of age, with anadditional booster about one year later. The authors’conclusion about the limited degree and extent ofimmunity conferred by one injection of group Ameningococcal polysaccharide to infants and youngchildren, therefore, is invalid. Would we discuss theimmunity to diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussis conferredby one injection of DTP? Of course not!

Lastly, the authors state, “Although routinevaccination of children at four years of age mightincrease the duration of protection and hence mighthave an impact on this pattern of disease, the costand logistic problems involved in instituting such aprogramme may be prohibitive.” The authors statethat a group A meningococcal polysaccharideconjugate vaccine is needed for routine vaccinationof Africa. We can hardly be accused of ignoring thepotential of polysaccharide conjugate vaccine. But aconjugate will not be widely available for at least fiveyears, its cost will be considerably higher than thepolysaccharide, and as with all conjugates, it mustbe administered more than once during the first yearof life. Thus, conjugates will increase the cost of

Page 18: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

18

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

routine vaccination against group A meningococcalmeningitis compared to that of the polysaccharidealone. What will the WHO do then?

This article describes the hasty response of anation reacting to epidemic meningococcal meningitisby mass vaccination and not a scientifically designedand meticulously executed study. This study certainlyshould not be used to formulate an international policyfor prevention of this serious, poorly treated, andcommon disease. Nevertheless, the authors extracteddata from this trial that showed a high level of efficacyin older children and a rate of protection for infantsand children that, as predicted from previous data,declined rapidly. Our conclusions from this study areexactly opposite from those drawn by the WHO--group A meningococcal polysaccharide, whenadministered as directed, would be an effectivemethod for preventing both endemic and epidemicgroup A meningococcal meningitis. Therecommendation that group A meningococcalpolysaccharide should be used for epidemic controlonly is not based upon sound data, experience, or logic.It is based upon what the WHO and CDC think canbe done, rather than on what should be done.

Although there are as yet only incomplete data, inJanuary and April of this year, severe outbreaks inEthiopia, Sudan, Benin, Burkina Faso, Cameroon, Chad,Nigeria, and Niger have been reported -- anotherepidemic may have occurred this year.

During the next five years, at least 125,000African children will contract group A meningococcalmeningitis if there is only endemic disease -- thenumber could double or triple if there is an epidemic.Without exception, data from all over the worldgathered over the past 25 years allows the prediction

Page 19: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

19

that endemic and epidemic meningococcal meningitisin Africa can be prevented now by mass vaccinationfollowed by routine vaccination with group Ameningococcal polysaccharide vaccine.

Our plea is simple. Dr. Albert Sabin’s experiencewith the WHO should not be lost. We urge the vaccinecommunity and those interested in the care of Africanchildren to read the references on this subject and tourge the Director of the WHO to review andreconsider her failed program. With such a review,we predict that the WHO will recommend preventionby routine vaccination rather than the control ofepidemic meningitis.

Page 20: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

20

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

John B. Robbins was born in Brooklyn in 1932. He graduatedfrom New York University College and Medical School. He was

an intern and resident in pediatrics at the Massachusetts GeneralHospital. In 1970, after nine years in academia at the University of

Florida, the Weizmann Institute ofScience in Rehovot, Israel and the AlbertEinstein College of Medicine, Dr. Robbinswas appointed Clinical Director of theNational Institute of Child Health andHuman Development in Bethesda,Maryland. In 1973, he became Director ofBacterial Vaccines at the Food and DrugAdministration. He returned to theNational Institute of Child Health andHuman Development in 1983 as Chief ofthe Laboratory of Development andMolecular Immunity. Dr. Robbins prides

himself on having never served on a committee during his career.Initially under the guidance of Dr. Richard T. Smith at the

University of Florida, Dr. Robbins worked along with Drs. JosephA. Bellanti and John J. Cebra on the problems of immunity ininfants. He concentrated on developing vaccines for diseases ofinfants and children. He has worked together with Dr. RachelSchneerson since 1968 on vaccine development. Both Drs. Robbinsand Schneerson credit Drs. Robert Austrian, Emil C. Gotschlich,William Egan, and Willie Vann for their advice and guidance.

Their novel acellular vaccine for pertussis, composed of per-tussis toxoid only, has been licensed in the U.S. and in severalcountries in Europe. Recently, Drs. Robbins, Schneerson, ShousunSzu, and Kimi Lin and their colleagues developed a new vaccinefor typhoid fever that achieved a 92 percent efficacy in two-yearold children. Currently, their group is developing vaccines fornon-typhoidal Salmonella, Shigella, Escherichia coli 0157,Clostridium difficile, and anthrax. Based on the success of theirpupil, Dr. Ali Fattom, who developed their Staphylococcus aureusvaccine for preventing bacteremia in hemodialysis patients, thisgroup is planning to develop a vaccine for opportunistic patho-gens. They were instrumental in the development of theHaemophilus influenzae type B (Hib) conjugate vaccine that is usedthroughout the world. The use of this vaccine has dramaticallyreduced meningitis among infants and children, as well as othersystemic infections such as osteomyelitis and pneumonia.

Page 21: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

21

George R. Siber, MDCM joined Wyeth Lederle Vaccines asVice President and Chief Scientific Officer in August,

1996. He was named Senior Vice President in August, 1999.In this capacity, Dr. Siber is responsible for discovery

research in bacterial vaccines, viralvaccines, immunology and geneticvaccines, process development,clinical development, projectmanagement and scientific affairs forWyeth Lederle Vaccines.

Prior to joining Wyeth, Dr.Siber was Director of the MassachusettsPublic Health Biologic Laboratories andAssociate Professor of Medicine withthe Harvard Medical School and DanaFarber Cancer Institute. During this timeDr. Siber oversaw research on acellular

pertussis and Hib vaccines, the development and licensing ofCytomegalovirus(CMV) Immune Globulin (Cytogam®) andRespiratory Synchtial Virus (RSV) Immune Globulin(Respigam®) and the production of DTP vaccines andimmunoglobulins.

Dr. Siber’s research interests have included theevaluation of the human immune response to polysaccharideand protein antigens, the development of vaccines andimmuno globulins against Hib, pneumococci, meningococci,pertussis, RSV, and maternal immunization to preventperinatal and early neonatal infections. Dr. Siber hasauthored more than 200 scientific articles, abstracts, bookchapters, and reviews.

Dr. Siber received a B.Sc. degree from Bishop’sUniversity and a MDCM degree from McGill University, bothin Quebec, Canada. Dr. Siber trained as a medical intern andresident at Rush Presbyterian Medical Center in Chicago, andas a senior resident and infectious disease specialist at BethIsrael Hospital and Children’s Hospital in Boston.

Drs. Robbins and Schneerson gratefully acknowledge the inspi-ration and contributions of the late Dr. Margaret Pittman totheir research program.

Page 22: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

22

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

ALBERT B. SABIN VACCINE INSTITUTE

Mission

The Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute’s mission isto save lives by stimulating development of newvaccines and increasing immunization rates.

The nonprofit institute was founded in 1993 to carryon Albert Sabin’s quest to prevent human sufferingand economic hardship. Dr. Sabin developed theworld’s first oral vaccine, which simplifiedimmunization and sped the eradication of polio inmost of the world. He was a tireless advocate forvaccines as the most humane and cost-effectiveform of medical intervention ever devised.

The Sabin Vaccine Institute has successfullyadvocated for intensified HIV/AIDS vaccineresearch; accelerated the development of vaccinesto treat and prevent cancer; brought together globalleaders to devise new immunization strategies fordeveloping countries; and raised public awarenessof the safety, benefits, and value of vaccines.

Page 23: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

23

ALBERT B. SABIN GOLD MEDAL

The Albert B. Sabin Gold Medal recognizes andhonors those who have made extraordinarycontributions to the field of vaccinology.

Honorees include:

Donald A. Henderson, M.D., M.P.H., 1994Robert M. Chanock, M.D., 1995

Joseph L. Melnick, Ph.D., D.Sc.,1996(1914-2001)

Maurice R. Hilleman, Ph.D., D.Sc., 1997Myron M. Levine, M.D., D.T.P.H., 1998

Allen C. Steere, M.D., 1998Philip K. Russell, M.D., 1999

Ciro A. de Quadros, M.D., M.P.H., 2000John B. Robbins, M.D., 2001

Page 24: Recognition of Excellence in Vaccinology and Global ... · couple of knishes instead. Those times appear to have left John forever hungry, which perhaps explains his voracious appetite,

24

© 2001 Albert B. Sabin Vaccine Institute, Inc.

ALBERT B. SABIN VACCINE INSTITUTECHAIRMAN’S OFFICE

58 Pine Street New Canaan, Connecticut 06840

Telephone 203-972-7907 Fax 203-966-4763

ALBERT B. SABIN VACCINE INSTITUTEPRESIDENT’S OFFICE

1901 Pennsylvania Avenue NW, Suite 601Washington, DC 20006-3405

Telephone 202-659-1595 Fax 202-659-1597

ALBERT B. SABIN VACCINE INSTITUTE HOOKWORM VACCINE INITIATIVE

6290 Montrose Road, Suite 1000BRockville, Maryland 20852-4163

Telephone 301-231-7092 Fax 301-231-7095

www.sabin.org