Top Banner
QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography Departement of Geoscience University of Fribourg Switzerland [email protected] [email protected] www.unifr.ch/mineral/archmet
26

QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Apr 01, 2015

Download

Documents

Lorenzo Broxton
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIESBASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG

AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS

Vincent Serneels

Sébastien Perret

Mineralogy and PetrographyDepartement of Geoscience

University of FribourgSwitzerland

[email protected] [email protected]/mineral/archmet

Page 2: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

The Production Line of the Ancient Iron Metallurgy

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Production line :

Sequence of technical steps from the raw material to the finished object.

Page 3: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

The Production Line of the Ancient Iron Metallurgy

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Natural ore

Extracted ore

Extraction

Refuse

Page 4: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

The Production Line of the Ancient Iron Metallurgy

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Natural ore

Extracted ore

Extraction

Refuse

Concentrated ore

Processing

Refuse

Page 5: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

The Production Line of the Ancient Iron Metallurgy

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Natural ore

Extracted ore

Extraction

Refuse

Concentrated ore

Processing

Refuse

Raw iron

Reduction

Slag Direct method of reduction :

• Bloomery process

• Solid state

• FeO + CO Fe + CO2

Page 6: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

The Production Line of the Ancient Iron Metallurgy

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Natural ore

Extracted ore

Extraction

Refuse

Concentrated ore

Processing

Refuse

Raw iron

Reduction

Slag Direct method of reduction :

• Bloomery process

• Solid state

• FeO + CO Fe + CO2

Page 7: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

The Production Line of the Ancient Iron Metallurgy

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Natural ore

Extracted ore

Extraction

Refuse

Concentrated ore

Processing

Refuse

Raw iron

Reduction

Slag

Finished object

Smithing

Slag

• Plastic deformation (hammering / heating)

• Welding

• Heat treatment (annealing / quenching)

• Control of oxydation / carburization

Page 8: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Smithing

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Smithing depends on :

• Quality of the metal

Physical characteristics :

• Compact / homogenous

bar iron

• Uncompacted / heterogeneous

bloom iron

• Small pieces

scrap

Chemistry : • % carbon

• % other elements : P, S, N, Mn, Ni, 0...

Page 9: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Smithing

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Smithing depends on :

• Quality of the metal

• Type of object to produce

Kind of object :

• Simple nail

• Complex composite bladeiron + steel

Size of object :

• Small nail 10 g

knife 100 g

axe 1000 g

• Large anchor 10000 g

Sharpening, polishing, decoration

Page 10: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Smithing

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Smithing depends on :

• Quality of the metal

• Type of object to produce

• Know-how of the smith

Qualification :

• Heat treatments

- annealing

- quenching

• Welding

• etc...

Page 11: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Smithing slags

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Contribution to slag formation :

• Hot oxidation

FeO

• Related to time / temperature

• Related to the size of the section

Formation of a slag rich in iron oxides :

Page 12: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Smithing slags

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Contribution to slag formation :

• Hot oxidation

FeO

Formation of a slag rich in iron oxides :

• Related to time / temperature

• Related to the size of the section

Page 13: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Smithing slags

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Contribution to slag formation :

• Hot oxidation

FeO

• Poorly consolidated metal

Fe

Formation of a slag with iron particles :

Page 14: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Smithing slags

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Formation of a slag rich in silica :Contribution to slag formation :

• Hot oxidation

FeO

• Poorly consolidated metal

Fe

• Use of flux

SiO2

Page 15: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Smithing slags

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Other elements participate with various chemical elements :

Contribution to slag formation :

• Hot oxidation

FeO

• Poorly consolidated metal

Fe

• Use of flux

SiO2

• Other effects

K2O, CaO, SiO2 , Al2O3...

Page 16: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Smithing slags

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

PCB : Plano-convex bottom slags

• Characteristic morphology

• Most typical smithing residue

Page 17: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Smithing slags

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

PCB : Plano-convex bottom slags

• Characteristic morphology

• Most typical smithing residue

• 1 cooling structure

Formed between lighthing and extinguishing of the fire

• 1 unit of work

1 day ?

Page 18: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Smithing slags

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Variability of PCB slags :

• Dimensions and weight

As a general rule :

The weight is proportional to the quantity of work

Ø h weight

Small 5 cm 1 cm 50 gr

Normal 15 cm 3 cm 300 gr

Large 30 cm 10 cm 3000gr

Page 19: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Smithing slags

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Variability of PCB slags :

• Dimensions and weight

• Shape

Page 20: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Smithing slags

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Variability of PCB slags :

• Dimensions and weight

• Shape

Page 21: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Smithing slags

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Variability of PCB slags :

• Dimensions and weight

• Shape

• Composition

Page 22: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Smithing slags

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Page 23: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Smithing slags

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

PCB : Plano-convex bottom slags

• Weight of PCB = quantity of work

• Composition of PCB = Type of work

Assembly of PCBs activity of a workshop

Page 24: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Examples of PCB assemblies from Switzerland

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Page 25: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Examples of PCB assemblies from Switzerland

V. Serneels, S. Perret Mineralogy and Petrography - University of Fribourg

Page 26: QUANTIFICATION OF SMITHING ACTIVITIES BASED ON THE INVESTIGATION OF SLAG AND OTHER MATERIAL REMAINS Vincent Serneels Sébastien Perret Mineralogy and Petrography.

Vincent Serneels

Sébastien Perret

Mineralogy and PetrographyDepartement of Geoscience

University of FribourgSwitzerland

[email protected] [email protected]/mineral/archmet