-
ALLYN & BACON/LONGMANwww.ablongman.com
PUBLIC SPEAKING AND CIVICENGAGEMENT© 2008
J. Michael Hogan, Penn State UniversityJames R. Andrews, Indiana
UniversityPatricia Hayes Andrews, Indiana UniversityGlen Williams,
Southeast Missouri State University
ISBN-10: 0205562981ISBN-13: 9780205562985
S A M P L E C H A P T E RThe pages of this Sample Chapter may
have slight variations in final published form.
SA
MP
LE
CH
AP
TE
R
Visit www.ablongman.com/replocator to contact your local Allyn
& Bacon/Longman representative.
-
CHAPTER SURVEY
Public Speaking as CivicEngagement
Preparing Yourself to Speak
Speaking with Confidence
CHAPTER OBJECTIVES
After studying this chapter, youshould
1. Understand the meaning andimportance of
collaborativecommunication.
2. Be able to explain the natureand significance of
thespeaker-listener partnership.
3. Know the key principlesinvolved in preparing yourselfto
speak.
4. Understand how to deal withcommunication apprehensionand
preparing yourself tospeak with confidence.
C H A P T E R
Preparing to Speak withCommitment and Confidence
55
3
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 55
-
56 CHAPTER 3 Preparing to Speak with Commitment and
Confidence
Public Speaking as Civic EngagementPreview. Communication models
stress that the aim of communication is to get a response froman
audience. As a form of civic engagement, however, public speaking
is audience centered andassumes an equal, collaborative partnership
between the speaker and listeners. For a speech to be truly
successful, the audience as well as the speaker should derive some
benefit from the exchange.
Some view communication as a one-way street. If the speaker gets
what he or she isafter, according to this view, the speech is
effective. But that’s only part of the pic-ture. In a democratic
society, the true value of a speech must be judged by the out-come
for all parties involved in the communication process: the speaker
and thelisteners. In addition, a speech should be judged by its
larger contributions to soci-ety. Does it contribute something
useful to public discussion? Does it help the community resolve
important controversies, or does it motivate members of
thecommunity to do good things?
To communicate effectively, you must respect your listeners’
needs, sensitivities,and rights. You must know something about
their predispositions, tastes, prejudices,capabilities, and
knowledge. If you hope to get a response from your listeners,
youneed to consider what characteristics they share as a group and
what qualities indi-vidual members bring to the public speaking
situation. Seeing public speaking as amutually beneficial
experience for both speaker and listener means that taking
ad-vantage of an audience—getting them to do something that is
harmful to them, buysomething that is useless, or act in some
destructive way—should never be yourgoal. Public speaking is a way
of promoting the public good, and as such, it mustoccur within an
ethical framework.
The Speaker-Listener Partnership in a Democratic SocietyMore
than 40 years ago, communication scholar David Berlo, in his
groundbreakingbook The Process of Communication, argued that all
communication, includingpublic speaking, should be viewed as a
process.1 That process is a two-way, recipro-cal exchange in which
speaker and listeners exchange messages and negotiate mean-ings. In
other words, the speaker, while primarily a sender, is also a
receiver whoshould make adjustments based on the messages that come
back from the audience.Listeners, while primarily receivers, are
not passive—they send information abouttheir reactions to the
speaker. (See Figure 3.1.)
This view of communication fits well within a broader
perspective on publicspeaking as civic engagement. As a public
speaker in a democratic society, your goalshould never be to
manipulate your audience just to get your way. Rather, your
aimshould be to join with your fellow citizens in deliberating
about the best solutions toour common problems. During a
question-and-answer period, for example, audiencemembers might ask
questions, state their disagreement with the arguments
you’veadvanced, or suggest alternatives to your proposals. As a
speaker, you should recog-nize this exchange as an opportunity to
learn more about your audience’s concernsand reactions to your
speech. It is an opportunity to contemplate new informationand/or a
new perspective.
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 56
-
57Public Speaking as Civic Engagement
Speaker(Sender/Receiver)
CONTEXT
Listeners(Receivers/Senders)
NoiseMessage*
Feedback*
Noise
CHANNEL
*verbal andnonverbal
Response/Effect
Figure 3.1An Audience-Centered com-municationModel
This process, this exchange, must also be understood in light of
the variouschallenges it presents. For example, sometimes messages
flow smoothly. At othertimes, noise—any kind of interference, from
a squeaky microphone to hostile atti-tudes—may intervene to distort
or interrupt the message flow. A hot, stuffy roomwill offer a
greater challenge to a speaker than a comfortable setting.
Furthermore,all of us filter messages though our own beliefs and
values. We understand, believe,or act based partly on our own
experiences, the values we hold, our age or sex, orour cultural
practices. These factors will be discussed in detail in Chapter 5,
wherewe consider audience analysis and adaptation. For now, just
remember that the situ-ation in which you speak and the backgrounds
and interests of the listeners can in-fluence the way a message is
received. A good speaker will anticipate the nature andextent of
these influences.
This process must also be understood in light of situational
factors. Speeches al-ways take place in a context. If you were a
student at Tulane University or theUniversity of New Orleans, the
economic impact of hurricanes would be an inher-ently more
interesting topic to you than it would be to a student at
University ofWisconsin. If a fellow student was attacked at night
while walking across campus,the issue of safety would undoubtedly
concern you and other students in your audi-ence. If environmental
activists have tried to stop logging in a nearby state forest
byspiking trees or sabotaging equipment, you might expect students
on your campusto have some understanding of radical
environmentalism. In short, where and whenyou speak makes a big
difference. A speech must be designed not only for a
specificaudience, but also for a particular historical, political,
or social context.
Viewing public speaking from a process perspective and as a part
of human af-fairs yields important lessons. Both speakers and
listeners must be involved in thecommunication process, and both
also have some larger responsibilities to the com-munity. Speakers
have an obligation to address serious matters of public
concern,
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 57
-
58 CHAPTER 3 Preparing to Speak with Commitment and
Confidence
while listeners have the responsibility to listen attentively
and to critically yet fairlyevaluate the speaker’s ideas and
proposals. If the speaker has been successful, boththe speaker and
the listeners will benefit.
Much the same might be said about the speaker-listener
relationship. If you giveyour listeners information they can use,
then they will trust you to do the same onother occasions. Public
speaking should be viewed as a shared experience with posi-tive
results for all parties. As rhetorical scholar William Norwood
Brigance once ob-served, we all have a right to free speech, but we
also have a responsibility to deliver“useful goods to the
listener.”2
Public speaking, in short, connects the speaker to the audience
in an ongoing,collaborative partnership. It is not just something
that you do to an audience, butrather something that depends on the
active participation of the audience in thecommunication
process.
Preparing Yourself to SpeakPreview. The overview of the basic
principles of public speaking that follows will be developedin
detail throughout the rest of this book. These principles will
guide you in selecting a topic, es-tablishing credibility,
analyzing the audience, discovering relevant material, fashioning
argu-ments, delivering the speech, and determining the audience
response.
This book is designed to help you acquire the abilities you need
to speak. But,first, you must have some reason to speak. In your
public speaking class, youmay speak because you’ve been given an
assignment to do so. In life outside theclassroom, however, the
need to speak goes deeper than that: it is part of
yourresponsibilities as a citizen in a democracy. Our history is
filled with examples ofpeople who felt the need to speak out,
including some who risked their lives bydoing it. William Lloyd
Garrison, the fiery nineteenth-century abolitionist, for ex-ample,
spent much of his life speaking out against slavery, often facing
hostilemobs and threats against his life. More than 30 years before
the Civil War,Garrison described his determination to end slavery
in the first issue of his famous abolitionist periodical, the
Liberator: “I am in earnest—I will not equivocate—I will not
excuse—I will not retreat a single inch; and I will beheard!”3 Few
of us are as passionately involved with an issue as William
LloydGarrison. But as citizens in a democracy, we all have the
right and the responsi-bility to speak out on matters of public
concern.
Once you have made the decision to speak, you might think that
the next step isto write the speech itself. But what about
preparing yourself to speak? This is not justa trick of words. It
is important to think about what you need to do to get ready togive
a speech. Preparing yourself to speak means, first, making the
decision to speakin public, then learning about the principles of
effective and ethical public speaking.
Know YourselfYou are your most important asset as a public
speaker. Your own beliefs, abil-ity, knowledge, and potential are
the foundation on which any speech is built.However, very few
people have speeches in their heads just waiting to be deliv-
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 58
-
59Preparing Yourself to Speak
ered. Getting ready to give a speech is hard work;it involves
study, research, reflection, and a desireto contribute to the
public dialogue. It begins withwhat you know and care about. In
Chapter 6 weexamine ways to develop significant topics. Thekey word
here is significant. Your speeches oughtto be about things that
matter, things that are im-portant on your campus or in your
community,things that affect you and your audience
locally,nationally, or globally.
Many students react initially by thinking theydon’t have
anything to talk about. But when you startto consider what is
important to you—such as howthe knowledge you will gain as a
student of literatureor history, or as a prospective teacher,
lawyer, com-puter specialist, or manager will impact you and
oth-ers, what problems you and your friends face as youtry to get
an education, or what the future holds foryou and your audience in
a globalizing world filledwith both opportunities and serious
dangers—whenyou turn your attention to such matters, you willbegin
to generate ideas for issues that you can addressin your
speeches.
Although you might first canvass your own in-terests and
concerns in deciding what to talkabout, you also need to think
about another di-mension of yourself: your credibility. We’ve
allheard the expression “If you could only see your-self as others
see you.” As a speaker, you need todo just that—to try to see
yourself as others do. We use the word ethos, a con-cept developed
more than 2,000 years ago by the philosopher-rhetoricianAristotle,
to describe how an audience perceives the character, intelligence,
andmotives of a speaker.
Some speakers have a well-established ethos related to their
expertise or experi-ences. When Dwight Eisenhower ran for president
in 1952 and promised to bringthe Korean conflict to an end, people
believed him because he had led the alliedarmies that defeated Nazi
Germany in World War II. When space shuttle com-mander Eileen
Collins talks about the hazards of space travel, lay audiences are
in-clined to accept her views. These advantages of reputation,
however, are notafforded to most of us. What you do to prepare for
your speech and what you doduring the speech itself will most
affect how the audience perceives you. Being wellprepared lets the
audience know that you take them and your topic seriously andare in
command of the facts. Being able to communicate directly and easily
withyour audience reassures them that you can be trusted. In short,
in preparing yourselfto speak, you must consider how you will be
perceived and what you might do toimprove your own ethos.
Shuttle com-mander EileenCollins would likelybe very
effectivewhen talking aboutspace travel be-cause she is
berecognized by listeners as an expert.
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 59
-
60 CHAPTER 3 Preparing to Speak with Commitment and
Confidence
Know Your AudienceSpeeches are delivered to specific audiences,
and you must consider that audi-ence’s needs, interests, beliefs,
and knowledge. Your knowledge of yourself mustbe supplemented by
knowledge about those who will be listening to what youhave to
say.
Knowing your audience makes it possible to adapt to their
special needs or interests. If you wished to critique plans to
reform Social Security that included al-lowing contributions to be
invested in the stock market, for example, you might em-phasize
different points, depending on the age of the audience. If talking
to peopleabout to retire, you might emphasize the immediate impact
of the reform proposalon benefit payments. If, on the other hand,
you are talking to an audience of collegestudents, you might
emphasize instead the long-term solvency of the system—whether
Social Security will still be there for them when they retire in 40
or 50years. This doesn’t mean you would ignore the impact of the
plan on age groups notrepresented in your audience, but only that
the emphasis would change as you adaptto your listeners. Further,
the United States is a country that encompasses peoplefrom many
different cultures, not all of whom have the same priorities, the
samevalues, the same experiences, or the same set of normative
behaviors.
It would, however, be foolish to assume that everyone belonging
to a particulardemographic group, such as older people or college
students, will react in exactlythe same way to a particular
message. But it is possible to make limited generaliza-tions about
listeners based on their group characteristics. We’ll take this up
in detailin Chapter 5, but the point made here is that you must
consider carefully the char-acteristics of the audience that are
relevant to the speech and take this understand-ing into
account.
Adapting to your audience does not mean pandering to what your
listenersmight want to hear. For example, in 1950 the virulent
anticommunism spurred on by the Republican senator from Wisconsin,
Joseph McCarthy, led to vicious, un-substantiated personal attacks
on politicians, governmental officials, and other public figures,
seriously threatening freedom of speech and political
association.Criticism of McCarthyism was, however, considered very
dangerous, possibly lead-ing to the destruction of one’s career and
personal life. It was in such an atmospherethat Senator Margaret
Chase Smith of Maine rose in the Senate to introduce “ADeclaration
of Conscience.” “I speak,” she told her colleagues, “as a
Republican. Ispeak as a woman. I speak as a United States Senator.
I speak as an American.” Inspite of the risk of political backlash,
she asserted that “those of us who shout theloudest about
Americanism in making character assassinations are all too
frequentlythose who, by our own words and acts, ignore some of the
basic principles ofAmericanism: The right to criticize; the right
to hold unpopular beliefs; the right toprotest; the right of
independent thought. The exercise of these rights,” she went onto
say, “should not cost one single American citizen his reputation or
his right to alivelihood nor should he be in danger of losing his
reputation or livelihood merelybecause he happens to know someone
who holds unpopular beliefs.”4 Senator Smithdid not succeed in
stopping Senator McCarthy and his supporters from their cam-paign
of character assassination; it wasn’t until four years later that
the Senate for-
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 60
-
61Preparing Yourself to Speak
mally censured McCarthy. But in making her case, Smith reminded
her audience ofbasic values that they shared and offered hope to
those who wished to restore civil-ity in public discourse.
As a speaker, you never set out to deliberately alienate your
audience. In speak-ing your mind, however, you will sometimes tell
an audience something they don’tespecially want to hear. It is
important, of course, that controversial ideas be pre-sented
respectfully and supported with convincing arguments and strong
evidence.When presenting unpopular ideas, your persuasive challenge
becomes greater.
Know the SituationThe setting for a speech can significantly
influence how your audience responds toyou. You may be speaking in
a comfortable or an uncomfortable physical setting.Or you may be
close to your audience or separated from them by an orchestra
pit.You may be speaking directly to them or using a microphone. You
may be talking tothem first thing in the morning or right after
lunch. Your audience may be there be-cause they are interested in
what you have to say or because their attendance is re-quired. It
is to your advantage to know in advance something about the setting
inwhich you will be speaking so that you can anticipate potential
problems and capi-talize on advantages that the setting might
afford.
One of the most dramatic examples of the use of a setting by a
speaker occurredshortly after Woodrow Wilson was elected president
in 1912. What we now refer toas the State of the Union address was,
at the time, called the annual message. SinceThomas Jefferson’s
day, this message had been written out by the president, thensent
to Congress, where it was read aloud by a clerk. It usually did not
generatemuch excitement. Wilson decided to break with precedent and
appear in person be-fore a Joint Session of Congress to deliver his
annual message. While some deplored
Senator MargaretChase Smith ofMaine remindedher audience ofbasic
values as shestood up againstcharacter assassi-nation and reck-less
charges madeby SenatorMcCarthy and hisfollowers.
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 61
-
62 CHAPTER 3 Preparing to Speak with Commitment and
Confidence
the break with tradition, Wilson’s speech captured national
attention and generatedso much excitement that every president
since has followed his example.5
In addition to the setting, the temporal context of your speech
will influencehow it is received. Consider how much the events of
September 11, 2001, changedthe context for George W. Bush’s
speeches. After the terrorist attacks, political dis-agreements
suddenly seemed petty, and some even thought it disrespectful or
unpa-triotic to criticize the commander-in-chief. President Bush’s
speeches, at least for atime, received more respectful and less
partisan attention. By 2004, however, thecontext had changed again.
In the midst of an election year, people again felt free to
criticize the president on such issues as the War in Iraq and the
state of the econ-omy. In retrospect, some even felt free to
criticize how Bush had responded to theterrorist attacks.
On a smaller scale, you face the challenge of recognizing and
adapting to whatis going on in your listeners’ world. Imagine, for
example, that you are giving a classpresentation on the role of
government in student aid. The student newspaper hasjust published
a story detailing proposed cuts in student aid programs. It is
likelythat your audience will be aware of this turn of events and
will be listening for whatyou have to say about it. Before you
speak, you need to be aware of what is hap-pening in your
audience’s immediate world that is relevant to your topic.
Aim for Audience ResponseThink about the model of communication
we presented earlier in the chapter. As aspeaker, your goal is to
bring about some specific response from your audience.
Thisprinciple is fundamental to everything else you will learn
about public speaking, al-though it does not mean that you will
resort to any means necessary to get that re-sponse. Still, knowing
specifically what you want the audience to believe or do willhelp
you determine what ideas to include in your speech. Do you want
your audi-ence simply to understand a concept or to take a specific
action? For example, ifyou were giving a speech about UNICEF, you
could explain how and why it wasfounded and you could describe the
Trick-or-Treat for UNICEF and the UNICEFgreeting cards
programs—this might help listeners gain a better general
understand-ing of what UNICEF is. If, however, you were to ask for
donations, listeners wouldwant to know how their money will be
spent. In this case, the speaker might spendmuch less time on such
background information and concentrate instead on the dis-astrous
famine and fatal epidemics in Africa, explaining how they affect
young peo-ple, and describing in specific detail what UNICEF is
doing to help hungry, sick, anddying children there.
One of the first things you should do in preparing yourself to
speak is to deter-mine your specific purpose as precisely as
possible, since it will affect all your otherchoices. That choice
should be realistic, yet that does not mean you should neverthink
big or take a long-range view. Elizabeth Cady Stanton, who
organized the firstwomen’s rights convention in Seneca Falls, New
York, in 1848, advocated thatwomen should have the same rights as
men, including the right to vote. It would beanother seventy years
before women could vote in national elections, but Stanton atleast
raised the issue in 1848 and started a national debate over women’s
rights.6
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 62
-
63Preparing Yourself to Speak
There may be times when you will realize that yourviews are not
widely accepted and that it is unrealis-tic to think you can change
people’s mindsovernight. In such situations, you might aim for
amore modest response—to get your listeners toadmit that there is
some problem that needs to beaddressed, or to get them at least
thinking about anissue that concerns you.
Discover Relevant MaterialAs you begin to work on your chosen
speech topic,you will most likely have some information alreadyin
your head. You may be building on your knowl-edge of the stock
market, the frustrations with theeducational system that led your
family to choosehomeschooling, or your experiences when
volunteer-ing at a shelter for battered women. But even withthis
kind of initial experience or knowledge, you willhave to learn a
great deal more to become a crediblespeaker. Once you have decided
on the specific pur-pose for your speech, you will still need to
exploreother sources of information and supporting materialto back
up your ideas. It is especially important torealize that in the
process of learning more aboutyour topic, you might even change
your position. Asyou do research, you may find that some of your
preconceptions are wrong, or atleast questionable. As a public
speaker you should always be open to the possibilitythat your own
views may change.
Gathering pertinent information may begin with reading about an
issue in ageneral news magazine, such as Time or Newsweek. These
will give you a broadoverview and offer multiple perspectives. You
also might search for materials on theWorld Wide Web, although you
need to be careful when using information from theWeb. Since it is
relatively easy to post material, many websites present highly
biasedor even totally false information, rumors, or unsubstantiated
gossip. Even the namesof websites can be misleading. If, for
example, you were to come upon www.martinlutherking.org, you might
think you have found a good source of biographi-cal information
about the famous civil rights leader. In fact, that site is hosted
byStormfront, a white-supremacist hate group. The Southern Poverty
Law Center hasdescribed this site as “the first major hate site on
the Internet ... created by formerAlabama Klan leader Don Black in
1995.”7 Unless you know an online source to behighly reliable (a
government bureau, the New York Times or the Wall StreetJournal, or
a professional journal, for example), it is best to confirm
informationthrough other sources. Of course, you can always find
reliable articles, books, andgovernment publications in your campus
or local public library. You may also wantto interview experts,
depending on the subject of your speech. Experts can be
It is always impor-tant to craft specificpurposes that willhelp
you connectdirectly with youraudience and thatreflect your own
beliefs.
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 63
-
64 CHAPTER 3 Preparing to Speak with Commitment and
Confidence
quoted as sources, and often they can direct you to additional
resources. Whateversources you use, they must be authoritative,
reliable, and correctly cited, as we willdiscuss further in Chapter
8. The importance of using reliable sources and the crite-ria for
judging websites are also discussed in that chapter.
Any topic of importance calls for research. All speakers, no
matter how knowl-edgeable, can benefit from learning more about
their topic. Obviously some willneed to engage in more research
than others, but few can talk “off the top of theirhead” and hope
to be effective.
Present a Reasonable ArgumentWhen you have decided what you hope
to accomplish in your speech, you will needto set about framing
ideas and finding material that supports those ideas and buildsa
reasonable argument. You should seek information that will connect
your topicwith your audience’s feelings, needs, and emotions—what
is often referred to aspathos—and that makes logical sense.
Remember that public speaking is a process:your purpose may change
as you gather more information. As you learn more, how-ever, what
you hope to accomplish will become clearer.
Consider the following example of how to develop an argument.
You areabout to cast a vote in presidential elections for the first
time. As you try to sort out the issues and where the candidates
stand, you realize that there are alot of things going on in the
campaign that do not really encourage you to thinkfor yourself. You
would like to look at the issues and decide which personand/or
party would exert the best leadership. There are a lot of
irrelevant appealsfor your vote, however, and a lot of
misinformation has been disseminated. You might wonder, for
example, why you should vote for a candidate becauseyou are urged
to do so by your favorite rock star or country music singer. Yousee
the media paying a lot of attention to personal accusations and to
who isahead in the latest polls. Much of what the candidates say
about education orjobs is ignored by the media. You see 15- or
30-second ads that offer slogansand assertions with nothing to back
them up. This state of affairs seems to youto trivialize the
electoral process. As you mull this over, you determine that
youwant to talk about presidential campaigns and, more
specifically, about mediacoverage and advertising in presidential
campaigns. Finally, you shape this into aspecific
purpose—specifically describing the response you want from your
audi-ence: I want my audience to look critically at the political
information presentedto them during presidential campaigns and to
work harder to become well-in-formed voters.
You then ask yourself, Why do I believe this is so? Why should
my audienceagree with me? By answering these questions, you begin
to form main ideas—ideasthat will be convincing—such as the
following:
■ Relying on the advice of others can be a mistake.■ Campaign
ads may be technically true but still be very misleading.■ Campaign
news focuses on polls and other aspects of the “horserace”
rather
than on the issues.
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 64
-
65Preparing Yourself to Speak
As you then set about studying the topic, these ideas may be
modified ornew ones might emerge. As you conduct research, you will
find specific data orrelevant information that will help you make
these ideas more convincing to youraudience—that is, you collect
supporting material. You might support your firstidea, for example,
by
■ describing the lack of credentials and expertise among
well-known celebritieswho have been politically active
■ quoting from real political experts on the content and effects
of political ads andnews coverage
■ uncovering for your audience the sponsors of campaign material
that is hostileto one candidate or the other and explain those
sponsors’ stake in the election
This process helps you build your argument. As you begin to find
relevant material,this material helps you refine your ideas and
provides data to make those ideas moreconvincing to your audience.
Consulting several different kinds of sources and al-ways looking
for differing perspectives will help you build the strongest, most
com-pelling argument possible.
Give Your Message StructureWell-organized speeches make it easy
for the audience to follow the speaker’s argu-ment. They help the
audience remember what has been said, and they give clear
andconvincing reasons for responding as the speaker wishes. If your
audience perceivesthat you are disorganized—if they cannot follow
your ideas—they will have troubleaccepting your information and
arguments and may doubt your credibility.
For an audience to follow your ideas, your speech must have
structure. Yourideas must relate to one another logically. Taken
together, they must present a coher-ent case in support of your
argument. In an introduction, you will need to planways in which
you can relate your topic to an audience, gain their attention and
in-terest, and establish your own credibility. Usually you would
include a preview andstate your thesis. The body of your speech,
built around main ideas supported withevidence, needs to be planned
carefully. You can help listeners move with yousmoothly from one
idea to the next by devising strong transitions between yourideas
and selecting places where it makes sense to summarize what has
already beensaid. Finally, your conclusion, as the last word to the
audience, will repeat the thesisof your speech, summarize your main
ideas, and leave listeners with a memorablequotation or anecdote or
challenge them to act.
The speech must form a pattern that is clear to your audience.
Using ameaningful pattern of organization helps the audience take
mental notes as you speak and remember what you have said. Your
organizational pattern alsomakes clear to them how everything in
the speech fits together, points to the de-sired response, and
contributes to your ethos as a speaker. The many patternsavailable
to you will be discussed in more detail in Chapter 9, but an
example of a short speech that illustrates a simple organizational
structure appears inHighlighting Organization.
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 65
-
66 CHAPTER 3 Preparing to Speak with Commitment and
Confidence
Speak Directly with Your AudienceThe language you use and the
way you use it can have a great impact on your audi-ence and the
way it responds to your speech. By choosing language suitable to
theaudience and the occasion, and by developing a conversational
and direct speakingstyle, you will promote understanding and belief
on the part of the audience.Suitable language keeps both the
audience and your purpose in mind. It is languagethat is precise,
clear, interesting, and appropriate to the situation in which
yourspeech takes place. Beginning speakers sometimes believe that
public speaking al-ways demands formal language, with the result
that their speeches sound stiff. Wehave often had the experience of
talking with a student who describes a particularevent or personal
experience in an animated and natural way, then recounts thesame
story in a stiff, awkward way when speaking to an audience.
It may help to think of public speaking as an enlarged
conversation with friends.Speaking to an audience is not the same
as a casual conversation. After all, you plana speech in advance,
and it is more carefully organized than casual remarks. In aspeech,
you also should avoid language that is too informal, such as the
“fillers” wesometimes use in casual conversation—he “likes” and the
“you knows” that clutter
Highlighting Organization
SPECIFIC PURPOSE: I WANT MY AUDIENCE TO UNDERSTAND HOW THE USE
OFEMINENT DOMAIN ILLUSTRATES THE PROBLEM OF CONFLICTING INDIVIDUAL
VER-SUS COMMUNITY RIGHTS.
THESIS STATEMENT: THE GOVERNMENT’S USE OF EMINENT DOMAIN
RAISESQUESTIONS OF HOW TO PROTECT INDIVIDUALS WHILE FURTHERING
COMMUNITY
GOALS.
INTRODUCTIONI expect that there aren’t many people who don’t
knowhow the Michael Jackson trial came out a few years ago.And I
suppose most of us would be able to identify whatcelebrity movie
stars are getting together or breaking up.If you watch
television—the morning shows, the eveningnews, the talk shows—you
learn a lot about famous peo-ple and their public and private
lives. You also get someinformation on politics or international
affairs. But howabout eminent domain? Even if you do understand
what itis, do you get very excited about it? Probably not. Well,
itinterests me because it has affected people close to me,and it
could affect you and your family or friends. Theuse of eminent
domain raises serious issues about howindividual rights conflict
with community goals. Today I’d
like to tell you how I got interested in this problem, iden-tify
some of the issues it raises, and explain why thereare no easy
answers.
BODYI. I became interested in eminent domain for personal
rea-
sons.A. Eminent domain is the right of public bodies (like
the
city council) to condemn and buy property, even ifthe owner does
not want to sell. A Supreme Courtdecision in 2005 gave cities broad
power in exercis-ing eminent domain.
B. My grandparents live on a farm that was far out ofthe city
when they first moved in, but it is nowwithin the city limits and
the council is consideringallowing the school board to acquire
property (in-cluding that belonging to my grandparents) tobuild a
new regional school. My grandparents don’twant to sell their land
and move from the housewhere they’ve always lived. So the eminent
domainstory that took about 30 seconds to report on inthe nightly
news has a real impact on people that Icare about.
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 66
-
67Preparing Yourself to Speak
everyday speech. Yet the same conversational style that you use
in conversing withfriends may be perfectly appropriate in most
public speaking situations. In addition,many of the personal
experiences and stories you talk about with your friends mightwell
work in your speech, depending on the topic.
Of course, all situations do not call for the same style of
delivery. Some formaloccasions may call for manuscript speaking, in
which you read a carefully preparedspeech to an audience. At other
times you may be asked to speak on the spur of the moment, with
little or no time for preparation; this is called impromptu
speak-ing. On rare occasions, you may be expected to memorize your
whole speech. Most often, however, you will be speaking
extemporaneously—that is, with carefulpreparation but with minimal
notes and a less formal, more direct, and audience-centered
delivery.
No matter how much work you put into preparing yourself to
speak, what theaudience finally sees and hears will determine their
response. The best delivery doesnot call attention to itself; you
don’t want the audience to pay more attention tohow you talk than
to what you have to say. Good delivery, in most of the contextsin
which you will speak, should be conversational and relaxed. If the
delivery is
TRANSITION: SINCE I DO CARE ABOUT MY GRANDPARENTS, I’M
CONVINCEDTHAT THE LAW OF EMINENT DOMAIN IS WRONG, RIGHT? WELL,
MAYBE NOT.
II. The use of eminent domain raises serious questionsthat I
have to think about no matter how it affects mepersonally.A. I love
my grandparents, but I have to wonder if their
property rights outweigh the need to provide up-to-date
facilities that will help children learn.
B. On the other hand, I worry about whether the pricepaid to
owners will fairly compensate them for theloss of their
property—including the emotional cost.
C. I know that this law will affect a lot of people otherthan my
own grandparents, and the law can be usedto make way for Wal-Marts
or strip malls. I’m notsure that this will always be in the public
interest.
III. I raise these questions because this issue illustratesthat,
even if there are no simple solutions, there areproblems that we
have to face in our communities.A. I’m concerned about individual
rights—my grandpar-
ents’ and all those who might be forced to sell prop-erty they
want to keep.
B. But I’m also aware that there are needs that, if met,
will produce benefits for the entire community, suchas building
good public schools.
C. Basically, I believe that we need to question easy so-lutions
to problems—I recognize that, while the lawcould be good for a
community, it could be abusedfor the profit of a few and not for
the community as awhole.
CONCLUSIONBy the way, I don’t much care for Michael Jackson, but
I dolike music. I’m not into celebrity watching, but I enjoy
ad-venture movies and am really into special effects. More
im-portant, however, I believe that I—all of us, really—need
tounderstand that news stories that seem to get only
passingattention may mean a lot to all of us. I admit that I
don’thave a lot of answers. But in the days ahead in this
courseI’ll be searching for some answers as I prepare speechesthat
examine the big question that underlies this issue anda lot of
others that face us today. It’s a big question thatmatters a lot to
me: How can the rights of the communityand the rights of
individuals be reconciled? I hope that to-gether, in this class, we
might begin to answer it.
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 67
-
68 CHAPTER 3 Preparing to Speak with Commitment and
Confidence
good, listeners can hear and understand what you say and will
not find them-selves distracted by mannerisms, inappropriate
language, or an overly dramatic presentation.
The overview of principles we have been discussing in this
section will help youbecome an effective speaker and an engaged
citizen. While they will be developed inmore detail in the rest of
this book, they can serve as the foundation on which youcan begin
now to prepare yourself to speak.
One other important factor needs to be considered at the outset.
The prospectof getting up in front of an audience can make anyone
nervous. The degree of nerv-ousness may vary from person to person,
but feeling apprehensive is normal and tobe expected. This is
something a speaker must face and deal with; in the next sec-tion
we offer some practical advice on how to do just that.
Speaking with ConfidencePreview. Everyone experiences
communication apprehension. It order to deal with it, you willneed
to understand what communication apprehension is, ways to manage
it, and how it canbenefit you.
No one was more universally admired than our nation’s first
president, GeorgeWashington. Yet this heroic figure was extremely
nervous when delivering his firstinaugural address. One senator who
attended the ceremony observed that this“great man was agitated and
embarrassed more than ever he was by the leveledcanon or pointed
musket.”8 His successor, the second president of the United
States,was also terrified about delivering his inaugural address.
After a sleepless night,John Adams felt ill and was afraid he might
faint during his speech. He was soscared that he told his wife,
Abigail, he was “in great doubt whether to say any-thing” at all
“besides repeating the oath.”9
Understanding Communication ApprehensionWhen even national
heroes suffer from communication apprehension, it is not
sur-prising that the rest of us become nervous when asked to speak
in public. In one fa-mous survey, it was discovered that people are
more afraid of public speaking thanthey are of dying.10 Comedian
Jerry Seinfeld joked about this finding:
According to most studies, people’s number one fear is public
speaking. Numbertwo is death. Death is number two. Does that seem
right? That means to the av-erage person, if you have to go to a
funeral, you’re better off in the casket thandoing the
eulogy.11
However humorous this may sound, doctors at the Duke University
MedicalCenter consider public speaking sufficiently stressful that
they include it on a listof “mental stress tests.” Physicians use
these tests in identifying those most atrisk for future heart
problems.12 For many people, then, fear of public speakingis no
laughing matter.
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 68
-
69Speaking with Confidence
Whether you call it speech anxiety, stagefright, or
communication apprehension, youneed to understand this phenomenon
for severalreasons.13 Not only can it become a significantbarrier
to your personal success, but it can robyou of your voice as a
citizen. Indeed, if you areafraid to speak out, you have no voice
in ourdemocratic system.
Communication scholar James McCroskey,who has studied
communication apprehensionfor more than 30 years, defines it as “an
individ-ual’s level of fear or anxiety associated with either real
or anticipated communication withanother person or persons.”14 Most
of us ex-perience only mild to moderate communicationapprehension;
but for some, speaking anxietycan be quite severe—so severe, in
fact, that they may avoid speaking at all.15 Fortunately,we can all
learn to better manage our fears ofpublic speaking.
Managing Communication ApprehensionGreat leaders find ways to
overcome their fearof speaking, no matter how momentous the
oc-casion or how high the stakes. In 1859, for ex-ample, Abraham
Lincoln faced the biggestchallenge of his young political career
when he was invited to speak at the CooperUnion in New York City, a
traditional proving ground for presidential
candidates.Self-educated and with a “rough and tumble” style,16
Lincoln was hardly known asa great orator. Yet now his whole
future—indeed, the future of the nation—restedon this single
speech. A successful speech would make him a leading candidate
forpresident; a poorly received speech could doom his career. As
his law partner,William H. Herndon, recalled, “No former effort in
the line of speech-making hadcost so much time and thought as this
one.”17 In the end, that effort paid off. Afterputting off the
sponsors long enough to carefully research and prepare his
remarks,Lincoln delivered a tremendously successful speech—a speech
that Harold Holtzeraptly characterized in the subtitle of his book
Lincoln at Cooper Union: The SpeechThat Made Abraham Lincoln
President.
How did Lincoln do it? Part of the answer, of course, lies in
the extra time hetook to research and prepare his speech. But just
as important was his firm convic-tion that he was right in taking
the position he took: that the Republican Partyshould oppose the
further spread of slavery in America. In other words, Lincoln
wasthoroughly prepared and firmly believed in what he said, and
those are the mostcritical factors in dealing with communication
apprehension.
Sometimes speakers do not seem particularly invested in their
topics. Perhapsthey view the speech as merely a course requirement
or an unpleasant task
Lincoln was such asuccessful speakerbecause he pre-pared
carefully andspoke with convic-tion about mattersof
significance.
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 69
-
70 CHAPTER 3 Preparing to Speak with Commitment and
Confidence
they must perform for their job. So they select their topic
casually, giving very little thought to its importance to them or
whether the audience might find it interesting. At other times,
speeches fail because of inadequate preparation.Inadequate
preparation may stem from a failure to find and focus the
speechtopic early enough, or it could involve problems finding
relevant or current information. Still other speakers suffer from a
general tendency to procrastinate,putting things off until the last
minute. Either of these problems—lack of com-mitment to your topic
or inadequate preparation—may contribute to communi-cation
apprehension. This leads to the two most fundamental principles
incombating communication apprehension: addressing substantive
issues to whichyou are committed and being well prepared.
Address Substantive Issues to Which You Are CommittedA genuine
commitment to your topic can help you overcome the anxiety you
mighthave about speaking in public, since you are more likely to
speak with confidence ifyou are addressing a topic that really
matters to you and your audience. As part of acommunity forum on
health care, for example, an ER doctor might speak out on
thecritical importance of finding ways to care for the
uninsured—perhaps arguing thatuniversal health insurance would
assure that everyone who needed health carewould get it and thereby
create a more humane society. A student whose roommatehas been
attacked outside the school library might make an impassioned plea
to agroup of campus administrators, asking them to fund more
lighting, police patrols,and campus escort services. Because of the
commitment of these speakers to theirtopics, any communication
apprehension they may have felt at the start of theirspeeches would
likely fade as they focused on their arguments and the importance
of persuading their audiences.
Be Well PreparedThere is no better psychological defense for
dealing with communication apprehen-sion than honestly being able
to say to yourself that you are well prepared. Youhave selected a
topic of interest and value to you as well as your audience. You
havedone your homework, perhaps even conducting an audience survey.
You have de-voted significant time and effort to gathering
information and to broadening yourunderstanding of the subject. You
have carefully organized your speech into a clear,coherent, and
unified whole. You have practiced by going over your
speech—aloud—several times, timing yourself and fine-tuning your
ideas. You have askedfriends for feedback. You feel confident that
there is very little more you could havedone to prepare for your
speech.
Reminding yourself of your careful preparation can be reassuring
and evenliberating as you grapple with feelings of anxiety. Your
delivery will reflect yourcareful preparation, and the audience
will sense that you have worked hard outof respect for their time
and attention. Also remember that your audience
sharesresponsibility for the success of your speech. You have a
right to expect that.Just as you have prepared well and met your
responsibilities as a speaker, youraudience, too, has a
responsibility to listen carefully and constructively to whatyou
have to say.
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 70
-
71Speaking with Confidence
Focus on Civic Engagement
Speaking with Conviction
A small community in southern Indiana had begun to ex-perience a
serious problem with homelessness andpoverty. Although there were
three shelters for housingthe poor at night, during the day they
wandered thestreets—trying to find jobs, food, and warmth.
One woman, Shirley, had once worked as the directorof a day
shelter for the poor when she resided in Arizona.Now she was
convinced that such a shelter was urgentlyneeded in her new
hometown in Indiana. She decided toapproach the administrative
board of the church to whichshe belonged. Her goal was to persuade
them to donatesome space in the church’s basement, which had a
kitchenand restroom facilities, as well as a large dining hall,
sothat a day center for the poor could be established. As
sheprepared her presentation, she pored over figures onhomelessness
and poverty—studying the trends and look-ing specifically at how
and why the problem had grown inIndiana. She reflected on her
experiences in Arizona andreread some books on poverty by such
experts as RubyPayne and David Shipler. She carefully organized her
infor-mation and arguments and practiced her speech aloudseveral
times. She also knew her audience very well, sincethey were all
fellow members of her church. As a result,she was able to
anticipate some of the kinds of questionsand concerns they would
likely bring to the meeting. Howcould the church afford it? What
would be the risks? Howmight other citizens in the community react?
How wouldthis endeavor affect church membership?
On the day of her speech, Shirley felt somewhat anx-ious. She
knew she had to wait until the board’sevening meeting to make her
presentation, and the dayahead loomed long. She maintained her
routine thatday—eating lightly but well, taking a brisk walk,
andthen practicing her speech one last time. She remindedherself of
the gravity of the problem. She thought aboutthe human beings she
had encountered—each with adifferent story—those striving to get
their lives back ontrack following a period of incarceration, the
womenwho were escaping abusive relationships, the mentallyill who
needed structure and regular medication, andthe children who had
never known a home. Armed withher convictions, her painstaking
preparation, and herdeep desire to connect with the audience,
Shirleywalked toward the boardroom, determined to speak
asconvincingly as possible on behalf of those who couldnot speak
for themselves. She still felt some level ofanxiety, but she felt a
far greater desire to share herconvictions and ideas—and hopefully,
ultimately, tomove her audience to action.
Source: Personal narrative of one volunteer, Bloomington,
IN,June, 2005. For sources that informed this woman’s
knowledgeabout poverty, see Ruby K. Payne, A Framework
forUnderstanding Poverty (Highlands, TX: Aha! Process, 1996),and
David K. Shipler, The Working Poor: Invisible in America(New York:
Alfred A. Knopf, 2004).
The best way to reduce speech anxiety is to address topics that
genuinely con-cern you and to be well prepared for your
presentation. In addition, you might em-ploy a variety of other
strategies for managing communication apprehension. As yougive more
speeches, you will no doubt find strategies that work especially
well foryou. For now, however, let’s examine some of the specific
strategies that experiencedspeakers have found helpful for dealing
with communication apprehension.18
Develop a Positive AttitudeWhat do you think of when you imagine
yourself making a speech? Do you pic-ture yourself stumbling over
your own words, dropping your note cards, or freez-ing as you
attempt to respond to a listener’s question? Research has
clearly
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 71
-
72 CHAPTER 3 Preparing to Speak with Commitment and
Confidence
shown that people with high speech anxiety tend to have more
negative thoughtsbefore the delivery of a speech than people who
are comfortable speaking.19 Itstands to reason, then, that
developing more positive thoughts may help in man-aging or reducing
anxiety.
When you dread making a speech, when you think of it as a burden
or somethingthat you “have to do” for a class or for your job, you
are more likely to develop se-vere communication apprehension. What
if you learned to view it differently: as anopportunity to change
minds, to share what you know, or to make a real difference inthe
community where you live? The principle here is simple: speakers
who anticipatesuccess rather than failure suffer less apprehension
about speaking.
Practice Your SpeechIdeally, you should practice over a period
of a few days, not a few hours. It is al-ways a mistake to put off
rehearsing your speech until the last minute. Prepare yourspeech
well in advance and give yourself ample time to practice. You may
be able toget a friend or a few friends to listen to your speech.
Practicing early and often is thekey here. No one can tell you
exactly how many times to practice or what tech-niques might work
best for you. As you give more speeches over time, you will
learnwhat approach works best for you.
Anticipate the Speech SituationThere are times in life when it
is nice to be surprised, but before or during apublic speech is not
one of them. As we have said before, effective speakersknow their
audiences. Gathering information about your audience and the
speak-ing situation before you speak helps you to focus on the
audience right from thestart. Whenever someone invites you to make
a speech, try to obtain as much in-formation as you can. If you are
addressing a community group that holds regu-lar meetings, ask
permission to attend one of those meetings, to get a feel for
theroom and the typical audience, and to note how they interact. If
the organizationhas a Website, you will also want to visit that,
and you can ask the person whoinvited you to speak to respond to a
few questions before the speech. Figure 3.2provides some basic
questions that you might want to ask about your audienceand the
speech situation.
Practice Active ListeningActive listening can be a powerful tool
for managing communication apprehen-sion.20 Rarely do you make a
speech under circumstances in which you arrive,immediately stand up
and talk, then quickly depart. More likely, your speech willbe part
of a longer program, meeting, or banquet, and others will speak
beforeyou. Listening closely to those speakers will draw your
attention away from yourown anxieties and may even give you ideas
about last-minute changes to yourown speech. In your speech class,
you will be listening to other speakers beforeand after you make
your speech. Instead of fretting over your notes, strive to lis-ten
carefully to those who speak before you. You might learn something,
and
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 72
-
73Speaking with Confidence
hopefully you also will find yourself a bit more relaxed when it
is your turn tospeak. In addition, you might be able to reference
something in another speechthat complements your own in some
way.
Exercise for RelaxationIf you feel tense and nervous before you
speak, you can do some simple physical ex-ercises to relax. One
excellent way to relax is by breathing deeply. Deep breathingallows
you to take in a large quantity of air, giving you a good supply of
oxygenand the potential for enhanced vocal control. You will also
want to breathe deeplybefore you speak and to continue breathing
deeply and regularly while you are de-livering your speech for
better vocal support and ongoing relaxation.
Isometric exercise, which involves tensing and then relaxing
specific muscles,can also be a useful relaxation technique. Try
clenching and unclenching your fists,pressing your legs firmly
together and then relaxing them, or squeezing the palms ofyour
hands together as if you were trying to flatten a piece of clay.
Alternatively, you
Figure 3.2
Collecting Information about Your Audience
Some Guiding Questions
1. Does the audience expect me to address a particular aspect of
a topic?
2. What is the audience composition?a. audience sizeb. age
(range and distribution)c. sex (mixed or largely same sex)d.
race/ethnicitye. values (religious, political, economic, etc.)
3. What is the speaking environment like?a. size and arrangement
of roomb. availability of podium, blackboard, flip chart,
microphonec. degree of formalityd. location of building (do I need
to get a map?)e. parking issues?
4. Are there any time constraints?
5. Will questions follow the speech?
6. What is the anticipated length of the entire meeting? When
should I arrive?
7. Can I arrive early or check out the setting ahead of
time?
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 73
-
74 CHAPTER 3 Preparing to Speak with Commitment and
Confidence
can push your leg, arm, or foot against some immovable object,
such as a wall,table, or even the podium. After you have pressed
firmly, release the muscle, relax-ing it as completely as possible.
These isometric exercises are subtle—you can dothem without being
noticed, even in the middle of your speech. They can also beused
before and after the speech.
Finally, performing aerobic exercise before your speech can help
reduce com-munication apprehension. Aerobic exercise, such as
walking, jogging, running, orswimming, is not only good for your
cardiovascular system and general well-being,it also helps reduce
tension and brings communication apprehension into a manage-able
range.
Acknowledge the Potential Benefits of Moderate Communication
ApprehensionSome people have serious problems with speech anxiety
and are virtually incapaci-tated by their fear of speaking.21 Most
of us, however, can learn to manage ourspeech anxiety, and
experienced speakers even find ways to channel their nervousenergy
in positive directions. They are able to do this, in part, because
they have de-veloped specific techniques that work for them. Some
speakers, for example, begintheir speaking day with meditation,
prayer, a two-mile run, or a quiet walk.Everyone will benefit from
getting a good night’s rest and eating a light, nutritiousmeal
before making a speech. Wearing comfortable clothes that make you
feel goodabout yourself also will contribute to a positive mental
attitude. What is importantis to learn what helps you most in
managing your feelings of anxiety.
In most speaking situations, however, a little anxiety can be a
good thing, forthat little spurt of adrenaline can energize your
mind and body, keep you alert, andperhaps even contribute to a more
dynamic delivery. As you gain experience as apublic speaker, you
will become more comfortable and confident standing up beforean
audience, and eventually you might even come to anticipate and
welcome thatadrenaline rush that we all feel when we speak in
public.
Maintain a Sense of PerspectiveNo matter how well you prepare
for any speech, bad things can happen. The micro-phone may fail.
The person who introduces you may mispronounce your name. Youmay
get something under your contact lens, or drop one of your note
cards. By prepar-ing well you can reduce the likelihood that
something will go wrong, but you will neverhave complete control
over the situation. Do not be intimidated by that fact. The
un-predictability is what makes public speaking both challenging
and interesting.
You need to maintain a sense of perspective. Prepare well, do
your best, be flexi-ble, and pay attention to feedback from your
listeners. Even if, in your judgment, yourentire speech goes
badly—that is, you feel disappointed in your performance—youshould
view it as a learning experience. Concentrate on what you learned.
Get readyto have another go at it. No matter how brilliantly or
poorly you think you per-formed, it is important that you view each
speech as a chance for personal growth. Ifyou are truly committed
to speaking out, you will have other opportunities to speakon the
subject.
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 74
-
By employing any or all of these strategies for managing
communication appre-hension, you can become a more poised and
confident speaker.
Summary■ A speech is successful only if it benefits both speaker
and audience.
■ You must have a collaborative approach to preparing and
presenting your speech.
■ Basic principles for preparing yourself to speak:
■ examining your own knowledge, ability, beliefs, and potential
(know yourself)
■ discovering the audience’s needs, interests, beliefs, and
knowledge (know youraudience)
■ understanding how the setting and other outside factors may
influence thespeech (know the situation)
■ devising a clear purpose that reflects the desired response
(aim for audience re-sponse)
■ exploring potential sources of information (discover relevant
material)
■ using language and delivering the speech in a manner suitable
to the audienceand the occasion (speak directly with your
audience)
■ practicing a well-prepared presentation frequently enough to
give yourself oralcommand of the speech (develop confidence through
practice)
■ Understanding what communication apprehension is and how to
manage it willhelp you gain confidence.
■ Communication apprehension is a normal reaction to speaking in
public.
■ Commitment to your topic and thorough preparation are
fundamental to build-ing your confidence.
■ A positive attitude, practice, anticipating the situation,
listening actively, exer-cise, acknowledging the benefits of
apprehension, and maintaining a sense ofperspective will also help
you overcome apprehension.
QUESTIONS FOR REVIEW AND REFLECTION1. Explain the significance
of the speaker-listener partnership. Offer one example of how
the
speaker and listener are mutually interdependent.2. What are the
most important things you will do to prepare yourself to speak
responsibly
and ethically?3. In your view, are any of these elements more
important than others? Why or why not?4. As you learn to give
speeches, what do you imagine will be your greatest challenge?
How
might you begin to grapple with it?5. What is meant by
communication apprehension?6. This book suggests that commitment
and preparation are the most significant factors in
reducing communication apprehension. Do you agree or disagree?
Explain.
75Summary
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 75
-
ENDNOTES1. The process perspective is widely referred to as the
“transactional perspective.” David K.
Berlo, The Process of Communication (New York: Holt, Rinehart
and Winston, 1960).2. William Norwood Brigance, Speech: Its
Techniques and Disciplines in a Free Society, 2nd
ed. (New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts, 1961), 20.3. Cited by
James Brewer Stewart, Wendell Phillips: Liberty’s Hero (Baton
Rouge:
Louisiana State University Press, 1986), 46.4. Margaret Chase
Smith, “A Declaration of Conscience,” Washington, DC, June 1,
1950,
http://gos.sbc.edu/s/chasesmith.html (accessed August 29,
2005).5. Robert Alexander Kraig, Woodrow Wilson and the Lost World
of the Oratorical
Statesman (College Station: Texas A&M University Press,
2004), 131–33.6. See Karlyn Kohrs Campbell, Man Cannot Speak for
Her: A Critical Study of Early
Feminist Rhetoric, 2 vols. (New York: Praeger, 1989), 51–58.7.
T. K. Kim, “Electronic Storm: Stormfront Grows a Thriving Neo-Nazi
Community,
2005, www.splcenter.org/intel/intelreport/article.jsp?aid=551
(accessed August 20, 2005).8. James Thomas Flexner, George
Washington and the New Nation: 1783–1793. (Boston:
Little, Brown, 1969), 188.9. Letter to Abigail Adams, March 17,
1797, in John Adams: A Biography in His Own
Words, ed. James Bishop Peabody, 359 (New York: Harper and Row,
1973).10. “What Are Americans Afraid Of?” Bruskin Report 53 (July
1973): 8.11. Jerry Seinfeld, SeinLanguage (New York: Bantam Books,
1993), 120.12. “Mental Stress Test Indicator of Future Cardiac
Problems,” Bloomington Herald-Times
(June 5, 1996), A6.13. A great deal of research during the past
three decades has focused on communication ap-
prehension. See, for example, James C. McCroskey, “Oral
CommunicationApprehension: A Summary of Recent Theory and
Research,” Human CommunicationResearch 4 (1977): 78–96. More recent
articles include Ralph R. Behnke and Chris R.Sawyer, “Milestones of
Anticipatory Public Speaking Anxiety,” CommunicationEducation 48
(1999): 165–72; Behnke and Sawyer, “Public Speaking Anxiety as
aFunction of Sensitization and Habituation Processes,”
Communication Education 53(2004): 164–73; Amy M. Bippus and John A.
Daly, “What Do People Think CausesStage Fright? Naive Attributions
about the Reasons for Public Speaking Anxiety,”Communication
Education 48 (1999): 63–72; and Rebecca B. Rubin, Alan M. Rubin,and
Felecia F. Jordan, “Effects of Instruction on Communication
Apprehension andCommunication Competence,” Communication Education
46 (1997): 104–114.
14. McCroskey, “Oral Communication Apprehension,” 78.15. James
C. McCroskey and Virginia P. Richmond, “The Impact of
Communication
Apprehension on Individuals in Organizations,” Communication
Quarterly 27 (1979):55–61.
16. Waldo W. Braden, Abraham Lincoln: Public Speaker. (Baton
Rouge: Louisiana StateUniversity Press, 1988), 3.
17. Harold Holtzer, Lincoln at Cooper Union: The Speech That
Made Abraham LincolnPresident (New York: Simon and Schuster, 2004),
28.
18. See Joe Ayres, “Speech Preparation Processes and Speech
Apprehension,”Communication Education 45 (October 1996): 228–35,
for an interesting study on howthe nature of speaking preparation
is vital to the quality of the speech as delivered.
76 CHAPTER 3 Preparing to Speak with Commitment and
Confidence
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 76
-
19. Joe Ayres and Tim Hopf, Coping with Speech Anxiety (Norwood,
NJ: Ablex, 1993),5–21.
20. In the interpersonal communication and interviewing
literature, active listening refers toa listening approach in which
the listener participates in the conversation by summariz-ing,
paraphrasing, and occasionally interrupting the speaker with
clarifying, supportivequestions. We are using the term in a
different way here.
21. James McCroskey, An Introduction to Rhetorical
Communication, 7th ed. (Boston: Allynand Bacon, 1997), 39–61.
77Endnotes
M03_2981_HOGAN_01_SE_CH03.QXP 8/27/07 2:55 PM Page 77