1 Am J Kidney Dis. 2014;63(1):76-83
Prehypertension and Incidence of ESRD: A SystematicReview and Meta-analysis
Yuli Huang, MD,1 Xiaoyan Cai, MD,2 Jianyu Zhang, MD,1 Weiyi Mai, MD, PhD,3 Sheng Wang, MD,1 Yunzhao Hu, MD, PhD,2 Hao Ren, MD,4 and Dingli Xu, MD1
Background: Studies of the association of prehypertension with the incidence of end-stage renal disease (ESRD) after adjusting for other cardiovascular risk factors have shown controversial results.
Study Design: Systematic review and meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies.Setting & Population: Adults with prehypertension.Selection Criteria for Studies: Studies evaluating the association of prehypertension with the incidence of
ESRD identified by searches in PubMed, EMBASE, and Cochrane Library databases and conference pro-ceedings, without language restriction.
Predictor: Prehypertension.Outcomes: The relative risks (RRs) of ESRD were calculated and reported with 95% CIs. Subgroup an-
alyses were conducted according to blood pressure (BP), age, sex, ethnicity, and study characteristics.Results: Data from 1,003,793 participants were derived from 6 prospective cohort studies. Compared with
optimal BP, prehypertension significantly increased the risk of ESRD (RR, 1.59; 95% CI, 1.39-1.91). In sub -group analyses, prehypertension significantly predicted higher ESRD risk across age, sex, ethnicity, and study characteristics. Even low-range (BP, 120-129/80-84 mm Hg) prehypertension increased the risk of ESRD compared with optimal BP (RR, 1.44; 95% CI, 1.19-1.74), and the risk increased further with high-range (BP, 130-139/85-89 mm Hg) prehypertension (RR, 2.02; 95% CI, 1.70-2.40). The RR was significantly higher in the high-range compared with the low-range prehypertensive population (P = 0.01).
Limitations: No access to individual patient-level data.Conclusions: Prehypertension is associated with incident ESRD. The increased risk is driven largely by
high-range prehypertension.Am J Kidney Dis. 63(1):76-83. 2013 by the National Kidney Foundation, Inc. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
INDEX WORDS: Prehypertension; end-stage renal disease; meta-analysis; kidney failure; high-normal blood pressure; chronic kidney disease (CKD).
he incidences of chronic kidney disease (CKD) and end-stage renal disease (ESRD)
areincreasing and represent a major worldwide public health problem.1,2 It has been reported that CKD affects 10%-15% of the adult population worldwide.3 People with CKD have decreased life expectancy, and those
From the 1Department of Cardiology, Nanfang Hospital, Southern Medical University, Guangzhou; 2Clinical Medicine Research Institute, the First People 's Hospital of Shunde (the Af liated Hospital at Shunde, Southern Medical University), Foshan; 3Department of Cardiology, the First Af liated Hospital of Sun Yat-sen University; and 4Department of Nephrology, Nanfang Hospital, Southern Medical University, Guangzhou, People's Republic of China.
Received April 24, 2013. Accepted in revised form July 31, 2013. Originally published online September 30, 2013.
Address correspondence to Dingli Xu, MD, Department of Cardiology, Nanfang Hospital, Southern Medical University, 1838 North Guangzhou Avenue, Guangzhou 510515, China (e-mail: dinglixu@ mmu.com) or Hao Ren, MD, Department of Nephrology, Nanfang Hospital, Southern Medical University, Guangzhou 510515, China (e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org).
2013 by the National Kidney Foundation, Inc. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
0272-6386/36.00http://dx.doi.org/10.1053/j.aj d.2013.07.024 with ESRD
who are receiving hemodialysis have a 20-fold higher mortality rate than that of age- and sex- matched individuals with normal kidney function.4 Accordingly, identi cation and treatment of risk factors for CKD should be a public health priority.
Prehypertension, which is de ned in the Seventh Report of the Joint National Committee on Prevention, Detection, Evaluation, and Treatment of High Blood Pressure (JNC7), is associated with a risk of developing hypertension and also is related to cardiovascular disease morbidity and mortality.5 Data from cross-sectional studies also have shown that prehypertension, particularly high-range normal blood pressure (BP), is associated with CKD and ESRD.- However, it is dif cult to establish the detrimental effects of prehypertension on the kidneys from cross-sectional studies because kidney diseases per se can elevate BP. Some prospective cohort studies have indicated that prehypertension is related to the incidence of ESRD,10,11 whereas other studies have shown that the association is not statistically signi cant.12-15 The differences in results among these studies may be explained by the incidence rate of ESRD being low; thus, small and short-term studies fail to show this association. Furthermore,
3 Am J Kidney Dis. 2014;63(1):76-83
Prehypertension and ESRD
arguments against using the term prehypertension also include the fact that there is inhomogeneity within this category; the risk of progression to hypertension and development of cardiovascular disease is higher in individuals with BP of 130-139/85- 89 mm Hg (high-range prehypertension) than in those with BP of 120-129/80-84 mm Hg (low-range prehypertension).16 This inhomogeneity also may be present in the association between prehypertension and CKD.12,13
Given these inconsistent results, a systematic review and meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies that examined the association of prehypertension with ESRD risk may help clarify this issue. The objective of the present study was to evaluate the association of prehypertension with the incidence of ESRD.
METHODSSearch Strategy and Selection Criteria
Electronic databases (PubMed, EMBASE, and the Cochrane Library) were searched for cohort studies to January 28, 2013, using the terms "prehypertension," "prehypertensive," "pre- hypertension," "pre-hypertensive," "blood pressure," "borderline hypertension" and "chronic kidney disease," "chronic kidney failure," "chronic kidney insuf ciency," "chronic kidney dysfunction," "chronic renal failure," "chronic renal insuf ciency," "chronic renal dysfunction," "end-stage kidney disease" or "end- stage renal disease," and "risk factors." Terms were explored when possible within each database. There were no language or publication form restrictions. In addition, reference lists of potentially relevant studies were searched manually. The detailed search syntax for the database PubMed is shown in Item S1 (provided as online supplementary material).The syntax for other databases was similar but was adapted when necessary.
Studies were included if they met the following criteria: (1) prospective cohort study involving participants 18 years or older; (2) baseline evaluation of BP and other cardiovascular risk factors, for example, age, diabetes mellitus, body mass index, dyslipidemia, and smoking; (3) follow-up of 1 year or longer with assessment of ESRD; and (4) reporting of multivariate-adjusted relative risks (RRs) and 95% con dence
intervals (CIs) for events associated with prehypertension (BP, 120-139/80-89 mm Hg) versus reference (optimal BP,
Prehypertension and ESRD
Selected Studies and Characteristics
Two independent reviewers determined that of the initial 2,358 study report abstracts reviewed, 22 quali ed for full review (Fig 1). The primary analysis included data for 1,003,793 participants derived from 6 prospective cohort studies that reported an association between prehypertension and the incidence of ESRD.10-15 Of the 6 studies, 2 were from Asia10,14 and 4 were from the United States and Europe
Am J Kidney Dis. 2014;63(1):76-83 5
Huang et al
Figure 1. Flow of selection for studies through review. Abbreviations: BP, blood pressure; Cls, confidence intervals; CKD, chronic kidney disease; ESRD, end-stage renal disease; RRs, relative risks.
(Table 1).11-13,15 The proportion of Asians was 25.6%, the prevalence of prehypertension was 34.5%14 to 46.7%,12 and follow-up was 8.314 to 26 years.11 One study enrolled only men,12 and all other studies enrolled both sexes. According to the prede ned quality assessment criteria, 4 studies were graded as good11,12,14,15 and 2 studies did not meet our criteria for adequate adjustment of potential confounders and were graded as fair.10,13 Details of the quality assessment are presented in Table S 1 .
Primary Outcomes and Subgroup AnalysesThe data have high homogeneity (J2 = 5%; P = 0.4); therefore, xed-effects models were used for the analyses.
Overall, prehypertension was associated with increased risk of ESRD (RR, 1.59; 95% CI, 1.39-1.91; P < 0.001; Fig 2). There was no evidence of publication bias identi ed by visual inspection of the funnel plot (Fig S1) or
indicated by Begg's test (P = 0.9) and Egger's test (P = 0.8).In subgroup analyses, prehypertension signi cantly predicted higher ESRD risk across subgroups with
analyses conducted according to BP range; participant's age, sex, and ethnicity; and study quality (Table 2). Even low-range prehypertension increased the risk of ESRD compared with optimal BP (RR, 1.44; 95% CI, 1.19-1.74), and the risk increased further with high-range prehypertension (RR, 2.02; 95% CI, 1.70-2.40). The RR was
higher in the high-versus low-range prehypertensive populations (x2 = 6.57; P = 0.01; Fig 3). We found no signi cant differences in the other subgroups (Table 2).
Multiple methods were used to test sensitivity, and the primary results were not in uenced by the use of xed-effect models compared with random-effect models, odds ratios compared with RRs, or recalculation by omitting one study at a time.
DISCUSSIONAfter controlling for multiple cardiovascular risk factors, a robust and statistically signi cant association
between prehypertension and long-term risk of ESRD was found in this meta-analysis. Results were consistent across age, sex, trial characteristics, and ethnicity.
6 Am J Kidney Dis. 2014;63(1):76-83
Huang et al
Since the JNC 7 proposal, the term prehypertension has been contentious.21 The term has not been adopted by other national and international hypertension guidelines, which have elected to keep the older BP classi cation systems.16 For example, the 2007 report from the Task Force for the Management of Arterial Hypertension of the European Society of Hypertension and European Society of Cardiology preferred to classify BP of 120-129/80-84 mm Hg as normal and BP of 130-139/85-89 mm Hg as high-normal.22 One of the most important arguments against using the term prehypertension is that the risks of progression to hypertension and
development of cardiovascular events differ between patients with BP in the 130- 139/85-89mm Hg range and those with BP in the 120-129/80-84mm Hg range. Our study had suf - cient power to show that the risk of ESRD is increased even with fairly mild elevations of BP. In particular, we found that individuals with low-range pre- hypertension were 44% more likely to develop ESRD than those with optimal BP, and this risk was increased further in high-range prehypertension (RR, 2.02). Therefore, our ndings reaf rm the importance of the de nition of prehypertension. However, our results further show the great heterogeneity of the prehypertension subcategory. This information is important to health professionals and those engaged in the primary prevention of CKD.
Our study was supported by the recently reported Ohasama Study from Japan, which demonstrated a signi cant association between prehypertension and the development of CKD in a general population (de ned as estimated glomerular ltration rate < 60 mL/min/1.73 m2 or the presence of proteinuria).23 However, during a mean follow-up of 9.9 years in a study of 3,313 Iranian adults without
7 Am J Kidney Dis. 2014;63(1):76-83
Am J Kidney Dis. 2014;63(1):76-83 79Prehypertension and ESRD
Huang et alFigure 2. Forest plot of comparison: prehypertension versus optimal blood pressure, outcome: end-stage renal disease. Abbrevi-
ations: BP, blood pressure; CI, confidence interval; CNHS, China National Hypertension Survey; HUNT I, the first Health Study in Nord-Trondelag; MRFIT, Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial; NA, not available; OKIDS, the Okinawa Dialysis Study.
9 Am J Kidney Dis. 2014;63(1):76-83
CKD, Tohidi et al24 determined that people with prehypertension, even those with high normal BP, did not have a signi cantly increased risk of developing CKD (de ned as estimated glomerular ltration rate < 60 ml./min/1.73 m2) than those with optimal BP. The differences in results of these studies may be due to the different cohort samples, follow-up durations, and de nitions of CKD.
Because most of the included studies lacked longitudinal BP follow-up, the association of pre- hypertension and ESRD detected in our study may be confounded because prehypertension is a stage on the progression to hypertension and only those who
Table 2. Subgroup Analyses of End-Stage Renal Disease in
Subgroup RR (95% CI) P
Blood pressure range 0.01
Low-range prehypertension 1.44 (1.19-1.74)High-range prehypertension 2.02 (1.70-2.40)
Sex 0.7Male 1.62 (1.17-2.24)Female 1.79 (1.17-2.75)
Race/ethnicity 0.2Asian 1.44 (1.16-1.79)Non-Asian 1.71 (1.47-1.98)
Participant's average age 0.21 million) and that results were consistent across age, sex, trial characteristics, and ethnicity. Furthermore, inclusion criteria in our study were restricted to prospective cohort studies with reported multivariate-adjusted RRs. Prehypertension is associated commonly with other cardiovascular risk factors,16,26,27 especially obesity and metabolic syndrome,28,29 which also accelerate the development and progression of CKD.28-30 Whether the mild elevation of BP directly increases the risk of CKD or whether the increased incidence is caused by susceptibility to other concurrent risk factors remains unclear.31,32 In our study, most of the included studies were adjusted adequately for other risk factors. These adjustments reduce the possibility that confounders in uenced the association between prehypertension and ESRD.
Important clinical and public health implications come from these ndings. First, considering the robust evidence of an association between pre- hypertension and long-term risk of ESRD shown in our study, consideration of earlier interventions for prehypertension is preferable to prevent the progression of CKD in the general population. Currently, lifestyle modi cation is the mainstay of treatment for prehypertension in the general population. However, high-risk subpopulations with prehypertension,
10 Am J Kidney Dis. 2014;63(1):76-83
Prehypertension and ESRD
Figure 3. Forest plot of comparison: subgroup analyses of primary outcomes conducted according to the level of blood pressure (BP; low-range prehypertension vs high-range prehypertension). Abbreviations: CI, confidence interval; MRFIT, Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial; NA, not available; OKIDS, the Okinawa Dialysis Study.
11 Am J Kidney Dis. 2014;63(1):76-83
Huang et al
assess whether the competing risk of death affected the incidence of the ESRD outcome.
In conclusion, prehypertension is associated with increased long-term risk of ESRD. The increased risk is driven largely by higher BPs within the pre- hypertensive range. This nding reaf rms the impor-tance of the de nition of prehypertension, as well as the heterogeneity of the prehypertension subcategory. This information is important to health professionals and those engaged in the prevention of CKD.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTSSupport: The project was supported by the Medical Scienti c Research Grant of Health Ministry of Guangdong province, China
(Nos. B2011310, A2012663, and B2012343), Cardiovascular Medicine Research Fund of Guangdong, China (Nos. 2009X20 and 2011X38), and Scienti c Research Fund of Foshan, Guangdong, China (Nos. 201208227 and 201208210).
Financial Disclosure: The authors declare that they have no other relevant nancial interests.
SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIALTable S1: Quality assessment of the included studies.Figure S1: Funnel plot of prehypertension versus optimal blood pressure.Item S1: Literature search strategy for PubMed.Note: The supplementary material accompanying this article (http://dx.doi.org/10.1053/j.ajkd.2013.07.024) is available at
REFERENCES1. Coresh J, Selvin E, Stevens LA, et al. Prevalence of chronic kidney disease in the United States. JAMA.
2. Kiberd B. The chronic kidney disease epidemic: stepping back and looking forward. JAm Soc Nephrol. 2006;17(11):2967- 2973.
3. Hall YN, Hsu CY, Iribarren C, Darbinian J, McCulloch CE, Go AS. The conundrum of increased burden of end-stage renal disease in Asians. Kidney Int. 2005;68(5):2310-2316.
4. Lowrie EG, Lew NL. Death risk in hemodialysis patients: the predictive value of commonly measured variables and an evaluation of death rate differences between facilities. Am J Kidney Dis. 1990;15(5):458-482.
5. Chobanian AV, Bakris GL, Black HR, et al. The Seventh Report of the Joint National Committee on Prevention, Detection, Evaluation, and Treatment of High Blood Pressure: the JNC 7 report. JAMA. 2003;289(19):2560-2572.
6. Crews DC, Plantinga LC, Miller ER, et al. Prevalence of chronic kidney disease in persons with undiagnosed or pre- hypertension in the United States. Hypertension. 2010;55(5):1102- 1109.
7. Kim MJ, Lim NK, Park HY. Relationship between pre- hypertension and chronic kidney disease in middle-aged people in Korea: the Korean Genome and Epidemiology Study. BMC Public Health. 2012;12:960.
8. Yano Y, Fujimoto S, Sato Y, et al. Association between prehypertension and chronic kidney disease in the Japanese general population. Kidney Int. 2012;81(3):293-299.
9. Yan P, Zhu X, Li H, et al. Association of high blood pressure with renal insuf ciency: role of albuminuria, from NHANES, 1999-2006. PLoS One. 2012;7(7).
1. Tozawa M, Iseki K, Iseki C, Kinjo K, Ikemiya Y, Takishita S. Blood pressure predicts risk of developing end-stage renal disease in men and women. Hypertension. 2003;41(6):1341- 1345.
2. Hsu CY, McCulloch CE, Darbinian J, Go AS, Iribarren C. Elevated blood pressure and risk of end-stage renal disease in subjects without baseline kidney disease. Arch Intern Med. 2005 ;165(8): 923-928.
3. Klag MJ, Whelton PK, Randall BL, et al. Blood pressure and end-stage renal disease in men. N Engl J Med. 1996;334(1): 13-18.
4. Haroun MK, Jaar BG, Hoffman SC, Comstock GW, Klag MJ, Coresh J. Risk factors for chronic kidney disease: a prospective study of 23,534 men and women in Washington County, Maryland. JAm Soc Nephrol. 2003;14(11):2934-2941.
5. Reynolds K, Gu D, Muntner P, et al. A population-based, prospective study of blood pressure and risk for end-stage renal disease in China. JAm Soc Nephrol. 2007;18(6):1928-1935.
6. Munkhaugen J, Lydersen S, Wideroe TE, Hallan S. Pre- hypertension, obesity, and risk of kidney disease: 20-year follow- up of the HUNT I Study in Norway. Am J Kidney Dis. 2009;54(4): 638-646.
7. Elliott WJ, Black HR. Prehypertension. Nat Clin Pract Cardiovasc Med. 2007;4(10):538-548.Am J Kidney Dis. 2014;63(1):76-83 13
8. Harris RP, Helfand M, Woolf SH, et al. Current methods of the US Preventive Services Task Force: a review of the process. Am J Prev Med. 2001;20(3)(suppl 1):21-35.
9. Lee M, Saver JL, Chang KH, Liao HW, Chang SC, Ovbiagele B. Low glomerular ltration rate and risk of stroke: meta-analysis. BMJ. 2010;341:c4249.
10. Lee M, Saver JL, Chang B, Chang KH, Hao Q, Ovbiagele B. Presence of baseline prehypertension and risk of incident stroke: a meta-analysis. Neurology. 2011;77(14):1330- 1337.
11. Higgins JP, Thompson SG, Deeks JJ, Altman DG. Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses. BMJ. 2003;327(7414): 557-560.
12. Tow ghi A, Kelley G. The (pre)hypertension limbo: is it time to lower the treatment bar? Neurology. 2011;77(14):1322- 1323.
13. Mancia G, De Backer G, Dominiczak A, et al. 2007 ESHESC Practice Guidelines for the Management of Arterial Hyper-tension: ESH-ESC Task Force on the Management of Arterial Hypertension. J Hypertens. 2007 ;25(9): 1751-1762.
14. Kanno A, Kikuya M, Ohkubo T, et al. Pre-hypertension as a signi cant predictor of chronic kidney disease in a general population: the Ohasama Study. Nephrol Dial Transplant. 2012;27(8):3218-3223.
15. Tohidi M, Hasheminia M, Mohebi R, et al. Incidence of chronic kidney disease and its risk factors, results of over 10 year follow up in an Iranian cohort. PLoS One. 2012;7(9):e45304.
16. Ninomiya T, Kubo M, Doi Y, et al. Prehypertension increases the risk for renal arteriosclerosis in autopsies: the Hisayama Study. JAm Soc Nephrol. 2007;18(7):2135-2142.
17. Egan BM, Lackland DT, Jones DW. Prehypertension: an opportunity for a new public health paradigm. Cardiol Clin. 2010;28(4):561-569.
18. Pimenta E, Oparil S. Prehypertension: epidemiology, consequences and treatment. Nat Rev Nephrol. 2010;6(1):21-30.19. Cordero A, Laclaustra M, Leon M, et al. Prehypertension is associated with insulin resistance state and not with an initial
renal function impairment. A Metabolic Syndrome in Active Subjects in Spain (MESYAS) Registry substudy. Am J Hypertens. 2006;19(2): 189-198.
Am J Kidney Dis. 2014;63(1):76-83 14
Prehypertension and ESRD
29. Wang Y, Wang QJ. The prevalence of prehypertension and hypertension among US adults according to the new Joint National Committee guidelines: new challenges of the old problem. Arch Intern Med. 2004;164(19):2126-2134.
30. Chen J, Muntner P, Hamm LL, et al. The metabolic syn-drome and chronic kidney disease in U.S. adults. Ann Intern Med. 2004;140(3): 167 -174.
31. Anand S, Arce CM, Sainani KL. Obesity and the rela-tionship between pre-hypertension and chronic kidney disease: can we really isolate the effect of pre-hypertension? Kidney Int. 2012;82(4):489.
29. Middleton JP, Crowley SD. Prehypertension and chronic kidney disease: the ox or the plow? Kidney Int. 2012;81(3): 229-232.
30. Wheeler DC, Becker GJ. Summary of KDIGO guideline. What do we really know about management of blood pressure in patients with chronic kidney disease? Kidney Int. 2013;83(3): 377-383.
31. Upadhyay A, Earley A, Haynes SM, Uhlig K. Systematic review: blood pressure target in chronic kidney disease and proteinuria as an effect modi er. Ann Intern Med. 2011;154(8): 541-548.
15 Am J Kidney Dis. 2014;63(1):76-83