Top Banner
NSB NSB DOE/NETL DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA Steve MacRae, Kent Grinage, NSB Steve MacRae, Kent Grinage, NSB ANS Field Project Kickoff Meeting ANS Field Project Kickoff Meeting 1/22/08 1/22/08
79

NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Mar 20, 2018

Download

Documents

trinhnhi
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

NSB NSB –– DOE/NETL DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate ProjectBarrow Methane Hydrate Project

TomTom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRAMike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Steve MacRae, Kent Grinage, NSBSteve MacRae, Kent Grinage, NSBANS Field Project Kickoff MeetingANS Field Project Kickoff Meeting

1/22/081/22/08

Page 2: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

IntroductionPhase 1 Summary

Stability/Material Balance/Full-field modelingPhase 2 Objectives

Prove existence of hydratesProve production from hydratesData gathering objectives

Core/LWD/WirelinePressure/temp

Schedule and PMP OverviewWell modelingWell designProject Execution

Procurement/Logistics/Operational ProceduresCore handling/Data acquisition specs/Decision point criteria

Page 3: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Phase II Org Chart 12/31/08Phase II Org Chart 12/31/08

PRA Principal InvestigatorThomas Walsh

DOE/NETLProject Officer

NSB Grants Division

NSBProject ManagerSteve MacRae

Organization Chart

PRA Principal InvestigatorThomas Walsh

DOE/NETLProject Officer

NSB Grants Division

NSBProject ManagerSteve MacRae

Organization Chart

PRA Principal InvestigatorThomas Walsh

DOE/NETLProject Officer

NSB Grants Division

NSBProject ManagerSteve MacRae

Organization Chart

NSBProject ManagerSteve MacRae

PRA Principal InvestigatorThomas Walsh

Technical Advisory Group

DOE/NETLProject Officer

NSB Grants Division

NSBProject ManagerSteve MacRae

Organization Chart

PRA Principal InvestigatorThomas Walsh

DOE/NETLProject Officer

NSB Grants Division

NSBProject ManagerSteve MacRae

Organization Chart

PRA Principal InvestigatorThomas Walsh

DOE/NETLProject Officer

NSB Grants Division

NSBProject ManagerSteve MacRae

Organization Chart

NSBProject ManagerSteve MacRae

PRA Principal InvestigatorThomas Walsh

DOE/NETLProject Officer

NSB Grants Division

NSBProject ManagerSteve MacRae

Organization ChartDOE/NETL

Project Officer

NSB Grants Division

NSBProject ManagerSteve MacRae

Organization ChartDOE/NETL

Project Officer

NSB Grants Division

NSBProject ManagerSteve MacRae

NSB Administration

ProjectManagement

Jim Hailey

Rsvr, Pet & Drlg. Engr.UAF Professors &

Grad Students

GeophysicistTom Morahan

GeologistChristine Livesey

PetrophysicistDavid Greet

Drlg/Prod EngineersMichael Cook

Mike Dunn

ReservoirEngineer

Mike DunnPraveen Singh

PetroleumEngineers

Peter StokesPraveen Singh.

Page 4: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Barrow Gas FieldsBarrow Gas Fields

North Slope Borough GISNorth Slope Borough GIS

Avak Impact Crater

Page 5: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Regional Structure MapRegional Structure MapLCU Subsea DepthC.I. = 50 ft

Avak Crater

East BarrowField

South Barrow Field

Sikulik Field

Walakpa Field

Iko Bay Fault

Barrow High

Page 6: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Barrow Gas FieldsBarrow Gas Fields

•• Original exploration by US Navy 1944Original exploration by US Navy 1944--4949•• Further Investigations by Department of Further Investigations by Department of

the Interior in the 1970the Interior in the 1970’’ss•• Congress transfers BGF to North Slope Congress transfers BGF to North Slope

Borough in 1984.Borough in 1984.•• Local control (NSB) since 1984Local control (NSB) since 1984

Page 7: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Barrow Gas FieldsBarrow Gas Fields

•• East Barrow Gas FieldEast Barrow Gas Field–– Discovered in 1949 by U.S. NavyDiscovered in 1949 by U.S. Navy

•• South Barrow Gas FieldSouth Barrow Gas Field–– Discovered in 1974Discovered in 1974

•• Walakpa Gas FieldWalakpa Gas Field–– Discovered 1980 by Husky for U.S. DOIDiscovered 1980 by Husky for U.S. DOI

Page 8: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Project ObjectivesProject Objectives

•• DOEDOE--NETL/NSB 80NETL/NSB 80--20% Funded Research20% Funded Research•• Characterize and Quantify Methane Characterize and Quantify Methane

Hydrate Resource Associated With Barrow Hydrate Resource Associated With Barrow Gas FieldsGas Fields

•• Contribute to Global Research Effort Contribute to Global Research Effort Through Practical Research Through Practical Research

•• Advance North Slope BoroughAdvance North Slope Borough’’s s Understanding of ItUnderstanding of It’’s Energy Supply s Energy Supply

•• Prove Hydrate ProductivityProve Hydrate Productivity•• Add Gas Reserves and ProductionAdd Gas Reserves and Production

Page 9: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

ScopeScope

•• Integrated Study (Seismic, Well Log, Integrated Study (Seismic, Well Log, Production History, Geochem)Production History, Geochem)

•• Focus on Barrow Gas FieldsFocus on Barrow Gas Fields——East Field, East Field, South Field, WalakpaSouth Field, Walakpa

•• Phased ApproachPhased Approach•• Integrate Prior Research Efforts/Current Integrate Prior Research Efforts/Current

KnowledgeKnowledge

Page 10: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Project StatusProject Status

•• Project start Nov. 14, 2006Project start Nov. 14, 2006•• Phase 1A completed in July, 2007, with positive Phase 1A completed in July, 2007, with positive

results from Hydrate Stability Modelresults from Hydrate Stability Model•• Phase 1B initiated August 1, 2007 and Phase 1B initiated August 1, 2007 and

completed March 2008. Supported decision to completed March 2008. Supported decision to proceed to Phase 2proceed to Phase 2

•• Phase 2 initiated December 1, 2008. Design and Phase 2 initiated December 1, 2008. Design and drill dedicated hydrate production test and drill dedicated hydrate production test and observation wellobservation well

Page 11: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Phase 1A ResultsPhase 1A Results

•• Temperature Gradients and Hydrate Stability Zone Temperature Gradients and Hydrate Stability Zone Modeling support Hydrate Stability Zone in East Barrow Modeling support Hydrate Stability Zone in East Barrow and Walakpa Fieldsand Walakpa Fields

•• Material Balance studies in East Barrow and Walakpa Material Balance studies in East Barrow and Walakpa Field suggest external recharge but with no water Field suggest external recharge but with no water production or breakthrough. production or breakthrough. –– Suggests pressure support by methane hydrate dissociationSuggests pressure support by methane hydrate dissociation

•• Objectives for Phase 1A of the Study have been met, Objectives for Phase 1A of the Study have been met, and support further reservoir study.and support further reservoir study.

Page 12: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Temp Gradient & Hydrate Stability Zone

Walakpa Gas Field

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

1600

1800

2000

2200

2400

2600

10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80

Temperature (F)

Cor

rect

ed D

epth

(fts

)Walakpa Gas Wells Completions Top: -2000', Base -2600'

Currently Mapped Top of Walakpa Sand -1700'

Methane Hydrate Stability

Stability Zone ModelingStability Zone Modeling

Methane Hydrate Stability Zone Modeling for East Barrow and Walakpa Gas Fields

Page 13: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

EMB Model – Pressure (P) vs. Time plot and P/Z vs. Gp plot for East Barrow gas reservoir

Material BalanceMaterial Balance

Page 14: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Water in Influx Model - (GpBg + WpBw) / (Bg − Bgi) vs. Gp plot

Water Influx Model, E. BarrowWater Influx Model, E. Barrow

Page 15: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Hydrate Model: P/Z vs. Gp and Pressure vs. Time comparison for Darvish model

Material Balance, E. BarrowMaterial Balance, E. Barrow

Page 16: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Phase I B ResultsPhase I B Results

•• Geologic ModelGeologic Model–– Completed mapping and log analysis of Completed mapping and log analysis of

Walakpa, E&S Barrow Pool reservoirsWalakpa, E&S Barrow Pool reservoirs–– 33--D geostatistical model built for E. Barrow D geostatistical model built for E. Barrow

and Walakpa Fieldsand Walakpa Fields

•• Reservoir ModelingReservoir Modeling–– Material balance and fullMaterial balance and full--field reservoir field reservoir

simulation results support hydrate influencesimulation results support hydrate influence

Page 17: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Depth Grid on Top Walakpa Sandstone, Walakpa Gas Field

Depth grid on Top Upper Barrow Sandstone, E Barrow Field

Depth MappingDepth Mapping

Page 18: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

100 100

200 200

300 300

400 400

500 500

Amplitude

-600000.000

-400000.000

-200000.000

0.000

200000.000

400000.000

600000.000

ShotCMP

ShotCMP

90846

90 80766

80 70686

70 60606

60

12S BARROW

"A" ProposedEAST BARROW

T-E-72_scn T-M-72_scn T-F-72_scnU-B6-78HRU-B6a-78HR

HRZ

LCU

U. Barrow ss

Base Barrow

Sag R Ss

U. Barrow ss

Base Barrow

Seismic Line through Proposed East Barrow Hydrate Test Well Location

Map of East Barrow Gas Field with Proposed Hydrate Test Well Location

Seismic Seismic InterpInterp, E. Barrow, E. Barrow

Page 19: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Seismic Line through Proposed Walakpa Hydrate Test Well Location

200 200

300 300

400 400

500 500

600 600

Amplitude

-600000.000

-400000.000

-200000.000

0.000

200000.000

400000.000

600000.000

ShotCMP

ShotCMP1100 1200 1300

9WALAKPA

10WALAKPA

"A" ProposedWalakpaNSB-89 18 U-r-5_migration NSB-89 24 NSB-89 20 U-B24-78 NSB-89 22

HRZ

Walakpa ssLCU

Walakpa ssLCU

Walakpa ss

Map of Walakpa Gas Field with Proposed Hydrate Test Well Location

Seismic Seismic InterpInterp, Walakpa, Walakpa

Page 20: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Barrow Field Average Reservoir Pressure and Cumulative Production History Match

Pressure and Production Pressure and Production History Match, E. BarrowHistory Match, E. Barrow

Page 21: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

History match EB# 14 well Figure 16. Fieldwide Average Pressure History Match[NETL1]

History match EB# 14 well Fieldwide Average Pressure History Match

E. Barrow #14 History MatchE. Barrow #14 History Match

Page 22: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

E. Barrow Best Case Model InputE. Barrow Best Case Model Input

•• 55--24% Porosity24% Porosity•• 55% Bound water55% Bound water•• 45% Free gas saturation below BHSZ45% Free gas saturation below BHSZ•• 31% Hydrate saturation above BHSZ31% Hydrate saturation above BHSZ•• 14% Free gas above BHSZ14% Free gas above BHSZ•• 11--50 50 mDmD permeabilitypermeability•• BHSZ 2050BHSZ 2050’’ sstvdsstvd•• GWC 2080GWC 2080’’ sstvdsstvd

Page 23: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Conclusions of ModelingConclusions of Modeling

•• 100% of 26 BSCF of MH will be produced 100% of 26 BSCF of MH will be produced in E. Barrow through depressurization in E. Barrow through depressurization from 1981from 1981--20372037

•• 20% of 284 BSCF (56BSCF) of MH will be 20% of 284 BSCF (56BSCF) of MH will be produced in Walakpa from 1981produced in Walakpa from 1981--2037 2037 assuming current well set and ratesassuming current well set and rates

Page 24: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Phase II ObjectivesPhase II Objectives

•• Prove existence of in situ methane hydratesProve existence of in situ methane hydrates•• Prove hydrate dissociation and productionProve hydrate dissociation and production•• Design and drill methane hydrate production Design and drill methane hydrate production

test welltest well–– E. Barrow in Q3E. Barrow in Q3--20102010

•• If hydrates are encountered, complete and testIf hydrates are encountered, complete and test•• If no hydrates, move to Walakpa for hydrate testIf no hydrates, move to Walakpa for hydrate test

–– Walakpa Well Q1Walakpa Well Q1--20112011•• If hydrates are encountered, complete and testIf hydrates are encountered, complete and test

Page 25: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

E Barrow Hydrate Test WellConceptual Design

Base of HydratesTop Lower Barrow Sand

Base Lower Barrow Sand

13-3/8” or 20” Conductor @ 60’

9-5/8” or 13-3/8” Casing @ 1400’

7” or 9-5/8” Casing at 2100’

Kick Off ShoeArmored Wire with Thermistors strapped externally to casing.

5-1/2” or 7” slotted liner across 1000’ ofhorizontal section wired with downholeresistance heater and Thermistors.

Note: Not to scale

Base of Permafrost

Hydratein sandstone

Free gas in sandstone

Page 26: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

ScheduleSchedule•• Commence Phase 2 Dec. 1, 2008Commence Phase 2 Dec. 1, 2008•• December December ’’08 08 –– September September ‘‘0909

–– Design wellDesign well–– Acquire permitsAcquire permits–– Select ContractorsSelect Contractors

•• October October ’’0909--August August ’’1010–– Secure contracts for operator, drilling contractor, rig, equipmeSecure contracts for operator, drilling contractor, rig, equipment nt

spreadspread–– Plan and oversee logistics Plan and oversee logistics

•• September September ’’10 10 –– April April ’’1111–– Drill and complete hydrate test Drill and complete hydrate test well(swell(s))–– Recover core in hydrate stability zone and analyze, make Recover core in hydrate stability zone and analyze, make

decision on program completiondecision on program completion•• May May ’’11 11 –– September September ’’1313

–– Production surveillance of hydrate test wellProduction surveillance of hydrate test well–– Collect samples and data from well and analyze resultsCollect samples and data from well and analyze results

Page 27: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

NSB Hydrates Phase 2 PlanNSB Hydrates Phase 2 Plan

Well Design

RFQ / RFPAFE

Drill E Barrow

Test Well

HydratesComplete

E BarrowTest Well

No Hydrates AbandonE Barrow

Drill Walakpa

Hydrates

Complete Walakpa

Test Well

No HydratesAbandon

WalakpaWell

Budgeted Case

Page 28: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Well Modeling SimulationWell Modeling Simulation

••BackgroundBackground••Simulation ResultsSimulation Results••Impacts on Well Location/DesignImpacts on Well Location/Design

Page 29: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Barrow Gas FieldsBarrow Gas Fields

North Slope Borough GISNorth Slope Borough GIS

Avak Impact Crater

Page 30: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Structure Map Top Barrow SandStructure Map Top Barrow Sand

Top Barrow ss missing (LCU 

erosion)

Top Barrow ssSubsea DepthC.I. = 20 ft

Avak Crater

Page 31: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Top Barrow ssSubsea Depth(tied to wells)C.I. = 20 ft500 ft grid

Avak Crater

East Barrow Field Area

Line B11a-78HR

Page 32: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

100 100

200 200

300 300

400 400

500 500

ShotCMP

ShotCMP

90846

90 80766

80 70686

70 60606

60

12S BARROW

"A" ProposedEAST BARROW

T-E-72_scn T-M-72_scn T-F-72_scnU-B6-78HRU-B6a-78HR

HRZ

LCU

U. Barrow ss

Base Barrow

Sag R Ss

U. Barrow ss

Base Barrow

Page 33: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Modeled most likely hydrate stability zone depth in East Barrow Field

Page 34: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

East Barrow Field Structural Cross‐Section(no horizontal scale)

U. Barrow ss

L. Barrow ss

Walakpa ss

HRZ sh

Subsea ft. Subsea ft.

Page 35: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Results from Phase I BResults from Phase I B•• Material Balance modeling in E. Barrow indicates the Material Balance modeling in E. Barrow indicates the

pressure response can not be explained with pressure response can not be explained with conventional pressure depletion and/or aquifer support. conventional pressure depletion and/or aquifer support. Explanation: the free gas zone is being recharged by Explanation: the free gas zone is being recharged by hydrates.hydrates.

•• Geologic mapping and analyses was performed resulting Geologic mapping and analyses was performed resulting in a robust geologic (static) model for reservoir in a robust geologic (static) model for reservoir simulation.simulation.

•• Full Field reservoir simulation with CMG STARS was Full Field reservoir simulation with CMG STARS was performed with a history match on production and performed with a history match on production and pressure, confirming likelihood of methane hydrates in E. pressure, confirming likelihood of methane hydrates in E. Barrow and Walakpa fields.Barrow and Walakpa fields.

•• Narrowed the selection of locations for hydrate test wells Narrowed the selection of locations for hydrate test wells in E. Barrow and Walakpa.in E. Barrow and Walakpa.

Page 36: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Control Wells for Pilot, Lateral

East Barrow Infrastructure and Well Control

Page 37: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Producing Class I Deposits: AnalogsProducing Class I Deposits: AnalogsMessoyakha Field1 E. Barrow Field2

1. Makogan, Grover, Moridis, et. al. 2. Stokes, Singh, Walsh

Page 38: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Objectives of Phase 2Objectives of Phase 2•• Support hydrate production with additional simulationSupport hydrate production with additional simulation

–– Well level modeling. Preliminary results presented here.Well level modeling. Preliminary results presented here.

•• Confirm physical presence of hydrates Confirm physical presence of hydrates –– Drill a stratigraphic test well; core and logDrill a stratigraphic test well; core and log

•• Produce free gas below the interface, monitor hydrates, Produce free gas below the interface, monitor hydrates, prove that gas production is supported by hydrate prove that gas production is supported by hydrate disassociationdisassociation–– Transect Hydrate/Free gas interface with 1Transect Hydrate/Free gas interface with 1stst or 2or 2ndnd pilot holepilot hole–– Produce methane through conventional techniques at rates that Produce methane through conventional techniques at rates that

will disassociate hydrate in the observation well in less than 5will disassociate hydrate in the observation well in less than 5years.years.

–– Conduct periodic and ongoing production surveillanceConduct periodic and ongoing production surveillance•• RealReal--time temperature/pressure changes time temperature/pressure changes –– history matchhistory match•• TimeTime--lapse Neutron and Sonic logging to monitor change in hydratelapse Neutron and Sonic logging to monitor change in hydrate•• Water/gas ratio changesWater/gas ratio changes•• Water/gas compositional changesWater/gas compositional changes

Page 39: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Fine Grid Simulation Work PlanFine Grid Simulation Work PlanObjectives:Objectives:1.1. Use fine grid simulation to determine optimal location of observUse fine grid simulation to determine optimal location of observation well and ation well and

production well, and production well, and 2.2. Estimate the response at the observation well due to production Estimate the response at the observation well due to production (pressure reduction) (pressure reduction)

from the high angle producer.from the high angle producer.

•• Task 1 Task 1 –– Pick a general area that is best suited to see a movement or chPick a general area that is best suited to see a movement or change in the ange in the hydrate as gas is removed down dip.hydrate as gas is removed down dip.–– Result: the area around wells #15 and #19 were chosen due to adeResult: the area around wells #15 and #19 were chosen due to adequate well & quate well &

seismic control and relatively high dip angle.seismic control and relatively high dip angle.•• Task 2 Task 2 -- apply local grid refinement around the area between wells #15 aapply local grid refinement around the area between wells #15 and #19 and nd #19 and

simulate the hydrate layer at time 0 and current time over a brosimulate the hydrate layer at time 0 and current time over a broad area. Run the ad area. Run the expected case and create expected case and create ““artificial casesartificial cases”” to account for other possible scenarios.to account for other possible scenarios.

•• Task 3 Task 3 –– Simulate the response at the observation well, due to productioSimulate the response at the observation well, due to production from a n from a high angle producer in the free gas leg.high angle producer in the free gas leg.

Page 40: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA
Page 41: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

18

19

20

21

22I-Layers

I-Layers

FOR ALL CASES

Page 42: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Fine Grid Simulation Work Summary Fine Grid Simulation Work Summary –– Task 2Task 2

•• The history matched full field coarse gridded (600The history matched full field coarse gridded (600’’ X 600X 600’’) model ) model was used as the basis for finewas used as the basis for fine--gridded (100gridded (100’’ X 100X 100’’) , well level ) , well level model.model.

•• Time 0 is field startTime 0 is field start--up. Time 1 is proposed time of completion of up. Time 1 is proposed time of completion of observation well.observation well.

•• Production ongoing with well EB#14 continuing to produce at a Production ongoing with well EB#14 continuing to produce at a constant rate of 625 MSCF/Dayconstant rate of 625 MSCF/Day

•• Case A is the Case A is the expected case expected case with all history matched properties with all history matched properties assumed.assumed.

•• Case B is an Case B is an ““artificial caseartificial case”” to depict a scenario with a full column to depict a scenario with a full column of hydrate still intact at the location of the observation well.of hydrate still intact at the location of the observation well. Note: Note: This does not history match.This does not history match.

•• Case D is an Case D is an ““artificial caseartificial case”” to depict a scenario where the hydrate to depict a scenario where the hydrate column is almost gone at the location of the observation well. column is almost gone at the location of the observation well. Note: Note: This does not history match.This does not history match.

Page 43: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-A (Base Case: Time 0)

Page 44: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-A (Base Case: Time 1)

Page 45: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-B: Time 0

Page 46: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-B: Time 1

Page 47: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-D: Time 0

Page 48: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-D: Time 1

Page 49: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Observations of Task 2 Observations of Task 2 -- Simulation Work to Pick Simulation Work to Pick Well Location based on Time 0 and Current Time Well Location based on Time 0 and Current Time

•• The expected case shows hydrate decomposition from below (from tThe expected case shows hydrate decomposition from below (from the he original free gas/hydrate interface), and from the overburden anoriginal free gas/hydrate interface), and from the overburden and d underburdenunderburden. At the time the observation well is drilled, at least one . At the time the observation well is drilled, at least one interface is expected.interface is expected.

•• As a practical matter, other possible scenarios may be found at As a practical matter, other possible scenarios may be found at the the observation well including 2.) a full column of hydrate, with noobservation well including 2.) a full column of hydrate, with no interface. interface. Or, 3.) very little to no hydrate.Or, 3.) very little to no hydrate.

•• The full column of hydrate case was artificially created by turnThe full column of hydrate case was artificially created by turning off ing off thermal properties of the overburden and thermal properties of the overburden and underburdenunderburden. This could have . This could have also been created by tweaking other input values.also been created by tweaking other input values.

•• The smaller column of hydrate was created by using a higher tempThe smaller column of hydrate was created by using a higher temperature erature of overburden and of overburden and underburdenunderburden, leading to more hydrate dissociation. , leading to more hydrate dissociation.

•• This work suggests that an observation well near EB#19 is a goodThis work suggests that an observation well near EB#19 is a good location location and is expected to see adequate hydrate and an interface to moniand is expected to see adequate hydrate and an interface to monitor. tor. However, the best placement of the producer well, and/or relocatHowever, the best placement of the producer well, and/or relocation of the ion of the observation well is dependent on what is found in the pilot (strobservation well is dependent on what is found in the pilot (stratigraphic) atigraphic) hole.hole.

Page 50: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Work Scope of FineWork Scope of Fine--Grid Simulation Task 3Grid Simulation Task 3

•• Uncertainty and actual location of hydrate Uncertainty and actual location of hydrate column/interface must be acknowledged.column/interface must be acknowledged.

•• Create simulation models with two sets of an Create simulation models with two sets of an observation well and a producer well to account for observation well and a producer well to account for these uncertainties.these uncertainties.

•• Run the simulation out 5 years (duration of surveillance Run the simulation out 5 years (duration of surveillance program) to show the response in the observation well program) to show the response in the observation well due to due to downdipdowndip production in the free gas leg.production in the free gas leg.

•• Use simulation results and observations to plan the well Use simulation results and observations to plan the well design. design.

Page 51: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-AWELL IJ PLANE VIEW

Page 52: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-A(HYD SATURATION @ TIME t = 0)

Page 53: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-A(HYD SATURATION @ TIME t = 1 year)

Page 54: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-A(HYD SATURATION @ TIME t = 2 years)

Page 55: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-A(HYD SATURATION @ TIME t = 3 years)

Page 56: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-A(HYD SATURATION @ TIME t = 4 years)

Page 57: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-A(HYD SATURATION @ TIME t = 5 years)

Page 58: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-BWELL IJ PLANE VIEW

Page 59: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-B(HYD SATURATION @ TIME t = 0)

1. Stratigraphic Test Well

2. HAW completed as a producer

3. Observation Well

Page 60: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-B(HYD SATURATION @ TIME t = 1 year)

Page 61: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-B(HYD SATURATION @ TIME t = 2 years)

Page 62: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-B(HYD SATURATION @ TIME t = 3 years)

Page 63: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-B(HYD SATURATION @ TIME t = 4 years)

Page 64: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

CASE-B(HYD SATURATION @ TIME t = 5 years)

Page 65: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Temperature Response in Observation WellTemperature Response in Observation Well

Page 66: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Decision Tree from Results of Stratigraphic Decision Tree from Results of Stratigraphic Test WellTest Well

Drill Stratigraphic Test Well (Pilot) at Location 1

Find H

ydrat

e with

Inter

face

Find Full Column of Hydrate

Find No Hydrates

1. Complete Stratigraphic Well as an Observation Well;

2. Drill HAW downdip to free gas leg and produce.

1. Sidetrack and drill a HAW downdip to intersect interface; complete the well as a producer in the free gas leg.

2. Drill an observation well offset to the producer and intersect the interface.

• Move to Walakpa, drill stratigraphic test well in crest of structure.

A

B

C

Page 67: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Well Design ObjectivesWell Design Objectives

•• Producer can produce at sufficient rates to Producer can produce at sufficient rates to change the hydrate layer at the change the hydrate layer at the observation well.observation well.

•• The response at the observation well The response at the observation well should not be affected by near wellbore should not be affected by near wellbore production affects.production affects.

•• Conclusion Conclusion –– Dedicated single wells, Dedicated single wells, producer drilled as a high angle or producer drilled as a high angle or horizontal well.horizontal well.

Page 68: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Coring and Data AcquisitionCoring and Data Acquisition

•• Logging: LWD and Logging: LWD and WirelineWireline•• Coring best practices from Coring best practices from MallikMallik and Mt. and Mt.

ElbertElbert–– TAG TAG member(smember(s) to be selected from those ) to be selected from those

involvedinvolved–– Interviewing of technologists for state of artInterviewing of technologists for state of art–– Lead and support functions to be workedLead and support functions to be worked

Page 69: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Cored, Loggedand completed with

5-1/2” Casinginstrumented with DTS

7-5/8” Surface Casing

5-1/2” Slotted Production Liner

E Barrow Methane Hydrate Well E Barrow Methane Hydrate Well Drilling/Completion Sequence Drilling/Completion Sequence Scenario AScenario A

Hydrate

Free Gas

Penetration #1Stratigraphic and Monitoring Well

Penetration #2Production Well

9-5/8” Surface Casing

Base Methane HydrateStability

Zone

Hydrate/Free GasInterface Observed

fromcurrent

Dissociation

Page 70: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

9-5/8” Casing

Penetration #1 Cored, Loggedand plugged back.

5-1/2” Slotted Liner Completed as producer

7-5/8” Casing

5-1/2” CasingInstrumented

with DTS

Hydrate

E Barrow Methane Hydrate Well E Barrow Methane Hydrate Well Drilling/Completion Sequence Drilling/Completion Sequence Scenario BScenario B

Free Gas

Base Methane HydrateStability

Zone

Penetration #’s 1 & 2Stratigraphic and Production Well

Penetration #3Observation Well

Page 71: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Well Design AlternativesWell Design Alternatives

A very high level cost and economic evaluation suggests that two wells are required, one to produce and one to observe and to find hydrate interface.

The state of art of multilateral technology is still being investigated to see what is possible.

It is likely at this shallow depth, the cost and simplification of completion may suggest two wellbores are preferred to one well with multi-lateral completions.

Page 72: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Program 2010 Program 2010 --20112011Operations/Logistics ProfileOperations/Logistics Profile

•Stage Rig and Support Services in Prudhoe Bay•Barge operating Spread to Barrow•Mobilize to E. Barrow•Ice/Snow road to Walakpa (if necessary)•Demob rig and support back to Prudhoe Bay

Page 73: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Methane Hydrate Methane Hydrate -- East Barrow Gas FieldEast Barrow Gas FieldLogistics Supply Chain ManagementLogistics Supply Chain Management

Critical Planning ElementsCritical Planning ElementsBeaufort Sea Beaufort Sea -- seasonal barging transit period from PRB to seasonal barging transit period from PRB to Barrow,AkBarrow,AkFederal/BLM and State of Alaska Tundra travel access limitationsFederal/BLM and State of Alaska Tundra travel access limitationsRemote Arctic drilling, completions, testing operations requirinRemote Arctic drilling, completions, testing operations requiring g continuous logistical support. continuous logistical support. Logistics operations assets will include barges, aircraft, helicLogistics operations assets will include barges, aircraft, helicopter & opter & vehicles vehicles –– air/land/sea.air/land/sea.Service sector representation to approach 23Service sector representation to approach 23--25 different 25 different companies with varying logistics support requirementscompanies with varying logistics support requirementsNeed for identifying logistic synergies Need for identifying logistic synergies amoungamoung service providers service providers and ensuring proper integration from point of manufacture to endand ensuring proper integration from point of manufacture to enduseruserLogistics support equipment inventory will be non static. AssetsLogistics support equipment inventory will be non static. Assets will will be debe de--mobilized as required back to PRBmobilized as required back to PRBFuel burn management : rig/camp/vehicles/lighting/heatersFuel burn management : rig/camp/vehicles/lighting/heatersWell Construction supply chain inventory management Well Construction supply chain inventory management Walakpa access : snow Walakpa access : snow pakpak trail vs. ice roadtrail vs. ice roadField Environmental Coordination (FEC) monitoring and reporting Field Environmental Coordination (FEC) monitoring and reporting of of tundra travel routestundra travel routes

Page 74: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

NSB Hydrates Phase 2 PlanNSB Hydrates Phase 2 Plan

Well Design

RFQ / RFPAFE

Drill E Barrow

Test Well

HydratesComplete

E BarrowTest Well

No Hydrates AbandonE Barrow

Drill Walakpa

Hydrates

Complete Walakpa

Test Well

No HydratesAbandon

WalakpaWell

Budgeted Case

Page 75: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

NSB Hydrates Phase 2 PMP GanttNSB Hydrates Phase 2 PMP Gantt

Page 76: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Task 3: Well Design GanttTask 3: Well Design Gantt

Page 77: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Task 4: Monitoring / Surveillance GanttTask 4: Monitoring / Surveillance Gantt

Page 78: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Task 5: Procurement GanttTask 5: Procurement Gantt

Page 79: NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Library/Research/Oil-Gas/methane...NSB – DOE/NETL Barrow Methane Hydrate Project Tom Walsh, Pete Stokes, Mike Dunn, Mike Cook, PRA

Task 6: Permitting GanttTask 6: Permitting Gantt