Ncaa Brief

8/13/2019 Ncaa Brief

1/44

No. 13M54

WILSON-EPES PRINTINGCO.,INC. (202)789-0096 WASHINGTON,D.C.20002

IN THESupreme ourt of the United States

NATIONAL COLLEGIATEATHLETICASSOCIATION,Petitioner,

v.SAMUEL MICHAEL KELLER,et al.,

Respondent.

On Petition for Writ of Certiorari to theUnited States Court of Appeals

for the Ninth Circuit

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE BRIEF OF A&ETELEVISION NETWORKS, THE ASSOCIATED

PRESS, BLOOMBERG L.P., DISCOVERYCOMMUNICATIONS, LLC, DOW JONES &

COMPANY, INC., ESPN, INC., THE HEARSTCORPORATION, NATIONAL PUBLIC RADIO,

INC., NEWS CORPORATION, RADIOTELEVISION DIGITAL NEWS ASSOCIATION,

AND REPORTERS COMMITTEE FOR

FREEDOM OF THE PRESS ASAMICI CURIAEIN SUPPORT OF PETITIONERS MOTION FOR

LEAVE TO INTERVENE

*Counsel of Record

NATHAN E.SIEGEL*SHAINA JONES WARDLEVINE SULLIVAN KOCH &

SCHULZ,LLP1899 L Street, NW, Suite 200Washington, DC 20036(202) [email protected]

Counsel for Amici Curiae

[Additional Counsel Listed on Inside Cover]


2/44

Of Counsel:

DARCI J.BAILEYA&ETELEVISIONNETWORKS235 East 45th StreetNew York, NY 10017

Counsel for A&E TelevisionNetworks, LLC

LAURA MALONEKAREN KAISER

THEASSOCIATED PRESS450 West 33rd StreetNew York, NY 10001

Counsel for TheAssociated Press

RANDY L.SHAPIROBLOOMBERG L.P.731 Lexington AvenueNew York, NY 10022

Counsel for

Bloomberg L.P.

SAVALLE SIMSDISCOVERY

COMMUNICATIONS,LLCOne Discovery PlaceSilver Spring, MD 20910

Counsel DiscoveryCommunications, LLC

MARK H.JACKSONJASON P.CONTIJACOB P.GOLDSTEINDOW JONES &

COMPANY,INC.1211AVENUE OF THEAMERICAS7TH FLOORNEWYORK,NY10036

Counsel for Dow Jones &Company, Inc.

DAVID PAHLELEANOR DEVANEESPN,INC.ESPN PlazaBristol, CT 06011

Counsel for ESPN, Inc.

EVE BURTONJONATHAN DONNELLANTHE HEARST CORPORATION

300 West 57th StreetNew York, NY 10019

Counsel for The HearstCorporation

KATHLEEN KIRBYWILEY REIN LLP1776 K Street NWWashington, DC 20006

Counsel for Radio TelevisionDigital News Association


3/44

MARK

H.JACKSON

EUGENIE C.GAVENCHAKNEWS CORPORATION1211 Avenue of theAmericasNew York, NY 10036

Counsel for NewsCorporation

DENISE LEARYASHLEY MESSENGERNATIONAL PUBLIC RADIO,

INC.1111 N. Capitol Street NEWashington, DC 20002

Counsel for National PublicRadio, Inc.

BRUCE

BROWN

GREGG P.LESLIEREPORTERS COMMITTEE FOR

FREEDOM OF THE PRESS1101 Wilson BlvdSuite 1100Arlington, VA 22209

Counsel for ReportersCommittee for Freedom ofthe Press


4/44

OTION OR LEAVE TOOTION OR LEAVE TOOTION OR LEAVE TOOTION OR LEAVE TOILE AICUS CURIAE =RIEILE AICUS CURIAE =RIEILE AICUS CURIAE =RIEILE AICUS CURIAE =RIE

P5750nt t3 S5F7e4e C357t R5-e #@.!, A&ETe-e:++3n Net37/, The A32+0te P7e,=-334e7 L.P., D+23:e7 C3445n+20t+3n, LLC,D3 J3ne & C34F0n, In2., ESPN, In2., The He07tC37F370t+3n, R0+3 Te-e:++3n D++t0- Ne

A32+0t+3n, 0n ReF37te7 C344+ttee 637 7ee3436 the P7e 7eFe2t65-- 43:e th+ C357t 637Fe74++3n t3 0 6+-e 0 7+e6 04+25* 257+0e +n 5FF37t

36 Pet+t+3ne7 3t+3n 637 Le0:e t3 Inte7:ene t3 +-e 0Pet+t+3n 637 W7+t 36 Ce7t+3707+.1

P73F3e 04+2+ 07e 234F0n+e th0t 27e0te 0n+e4+n0te 0 +e :07+et 36 602t50-, 6+2t+3n0-, 0neF7e+:e 23ntent, 0-3n +th n3n(F736+t370n+0t+3n h3e 4e4e7 07e 23ntent 27e0t37.P73F3e 04+2+ 0the7 0n 7eF37t ne) F7352e 0ne:e-3F 6+-4 0n te-e:++3n F73704) 7+te 6+2t+3n0n n3n(6+2t+3n) F5-+h 400+ne) 0n 75n e+te+th +n63740t+3n0-, e520t+3n0- 0n ente7t0+n4ent

23ntent, 043n 3the7 th+n.A 23ntent 27e0t37, 0-- F73F3e 04+2+eFen

23n+e70-e 7e3572e +n 0n e6637t t3 234F- +th

1P5750nt t3 S5F. Ct. R. #@.! 0n #@.$, n3 235ne- 637 0 F07t05th37e th+ 7+e6 +n h3-e 37 +n F07t. N3 F07t 37 the+7235ne- 40e 0n 43net07 23nt7+5t+3n t3 65n theF7eF070t+3n 37 54++3n 36 th+ 7+e6. The 04+2+ 257+0eF73:+e 0-- 65n 5e 637 the F7eF070t+3n 0n 54++3n 36th+ 7+e6. C35ne- 36 7e237 7e2e+:e t+4e- n3t+2e 36 the +ntentt3 6+-e th+ 7+e6. C35ne- 637 Pet+t+3ne7 NCAA 23nent t3 the6+-+n 36 th+ 7+e6, h+-e C35ne- 637 ReF3nent S045e- Ke--e73e n3t 23nent. I6 E-e2t73n+2 A7t F3+t+3n + 7e-e:0nt, +t23nent.


5/44

h0t 04+2+ 23nten 07e :05e 0n 5nF7e+2t0-e-e0- t0n07 th0t F7eent- 3:e7n the 7+ht 36F5-+2+t +n the -3e7 2357t. P73F3e 04+2+ee/ t36+-e the 02234F0n+n 7+e6 t3 0/ th+ C357t t3 70ntPet+t+3ne7 43t+3n t3 +nte7:ene t3 6+-e 0 Fet+t+3n 362e7t+3707+ 3 th0t the C357t 40 2-07+6 th3et0n07 +n 0 40nne7 th0t + 23n+tent +th the+7t A4en4ent. 0n 36 the F73F3e 04+2+ 6+-e0n 04+25 7+e6 +n the 2357t e-3, Ke--e7 :.

E-e2t73n+2 A7t*, N+nth C+7. N3. 1"(1'#8@, 0 e-- 0+n =73n :. E-e2t73n+2 A7t*, N+nth C+7. N3. "('$$@'.

The N+nth C+725+t e2++3n e-3, 0 e-- 0the Th+7 C+725+t 7e2ent e2++3n +n 0 :+7t50--+ent+20- 20e, H07t :. E-e2t73n+2 A7t*, In2.,@1@ .# 1?1 %# C+7. !"1#, 07e the 43t +n+6+20nt20e e2+e t3 0te the C+725+t 23n2e7n+n the7e-0t+3nh+F eteen the 7+ht 36 F5-+2+t 0n the+7t A4en4ent. The F73F3e 7+e6 04+25* 257+0e+25e h3 the +4F02t 36 thee 20e eten 607

e3n the+7 e66e2t 3n the 02t50- F07t+e +n the N+nthC+725+t. P73F3e 04+2+ 54+t th0t 23n+e70t+3n 36the +5e +25e +n the F73F3e 7+e6 + the7e637eF07t+25-07- 7e-e:0nt t3 th+ C357t e2++3n7e07+n hethe7 +t +-- 70nt the 43t+3n t3+nte7:ene 36 0 F07t th0t + n3t F07t+2+F0te +n theN+nth C+725+t 0FFe0-.

A4+2+ h0:e 7e:+ee the 0754ent 40e +nthe F73F3e Fet+t+3n 6+-e the Pet+t+3ne7, 0ne-+e:e th0t the F3+nt 40e 7e07+n the -e0-+5e F7eente th+ 20e, 0n the Fe7Fe2t+:e366e7e, 3 n3t 5F-+20te the Fet+t+3n. Th+ 7+e66325e 3n 366e7+n the C357t 0 730e7 Fe7Fe2t+:e


6/44

3n the 7e-0t+3nh+F eteen the 7+ht 36 F5-+2+t,+nte--e2t50- F73Fe7t -0, 0n the +7t A4en4ent,0 +t h0 066e2te F7352e7 0n +e4+n0t37 36eF7e+3n, -+/e thee F73F3e 04+2+, 3:e7 the F0te:e70- e20e. The F73F3e 04+2+ 7eFe2t65--5et th0t the+7 7+e6, 07e+n the 23n2e7n 36thee 23ntent F73:+e7, +-- 0+ the C357t 0 +t23n+e7 the Pet+t+3ne7 43t+3n 0n F73F3eFet+t+3n.

Th+ 43t+3n + e+n 6+-e +th+n #" 0 36 thePet+t+3ne7 6+-+n 36 +t 3t+3n t3 Inte7:ene, 0n ten0 e637e the ReF3nent 7eF3ne t3 th0t 43t+3n+ 5e t3 e 6+-e. The ReF3nent +-- the7e637eh0:e 0 65-- 3FF37t5n+t t3 07e 0n 36 the F3+nt70+e th+ F73F3e 7+e6, 0n +-- 566e7 n3F7e5+2e +6 the C357t 70nt th+ 43t+3n 637 -e0:e t36+-e.


7/44

Whe7e637e, F73F3e 04+2+ 7eFe2t65--

7e5et th+ C357t t3 70nt +t 43t+3n 637 -e0:e t3 6+-ethe+7 02234F0n+n =7+e6 A4+25 C57+0e.

ReFe2t65-- 54+tte,

N0th0n E. S+ee-C35n*e- 36 Re2378Sh0+n0 J3ne W07

LEVINE SULLIVAN KOCH &SCHULZ, LLP18 L St7eet NW, S5+te !""W0h+nt3n, DC !""#$!"!('"8(11""n+ee--/-0.234

Att37ne* 637 P73F3*e8 A4+2+


8/44

+TA=LE O CONTENTSTA=LE O CONTENTSTA=LE O CONTENTSTA=LE O CONTENTS

INTEREST O$AMICI CURIAE%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &

SUMMAR' O$ ARGUMENT %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &

I% THE RELATIONSHIP (ETWEEN THE

RIGHT O$ PU(LICIT' AN) THE $IRST

AMEN)MENT NEE)S TO (E

A))RESSE) (' THIS COURT %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% *

II% THE )ECISION (ELOW SU(STATIALL'

INCREASES THE RISK O$ PRO)UCING

CONTENT PROTECTE) (' THE $IRST

AMEN)MENT %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% +

III% THE TRANS$ORMATI-E USE. TEST

$AILS TO SATIS$' $IRST AMEN)MENT

SCRUTIN' %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% /

A% The Transfor0ati1e Use. Test

I0!ro!er"2 E3ates Co!2ri4ht La5 and

the Ri4ht of P6"i#it2 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 7

a% The !r!ose of #o!2ri4ht "a5 is to

fa#i"itate e8!ression %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 7

6% Co!2ri4ht "a5 in#"des 0"ti!"e

s!ee#h9!rote#ti1e do#trines 6e2ond

transfor0ation. %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &&

#% Co!2ri4ht:s transfor0ati1e test #annot

!ra#ti#a""2 6e trans!osed onto theri4ht of !6"i#it2 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &*


9/44

++(% The Transfor0ati1e Test Ma2 More

A!!ro!riate"2 Re"ate to Mer#handisin4.

Cases%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &+

C% (orro5in4 fro0 Co!2ri4ht La5 Misreads

;a##hini %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &/

)% The Transfor0ati1e Test is Inherent"2

-a4e %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &7

I-% THE APPROPRIATE $IRST AMEN)MENTANAL'SIS %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &7

CONCLUSION %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% LIST O$ AMICI %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &a


10/44

+++

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

P"#$%&'

C"&$&

20th Century Music Corp. v. Aiken,

=


11/44

+:Co"edy III Productions Inc. v. Class

Pu(lications Inc.,

&77 WL


12/44

:5art v. Electronic Arts Inc.,

/&/ $%*d &=& ?*d Cir%


13/44

:+Pal"er v. ,chonhorn Enterprises,


14/44

:++United ,tates v. ,tevens,

++7 U%S% = ?


15/44

:+++Restate"ent :hird; o+ the &a' o+ Un+air

Co"petition%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% &,


16/44

INTEREST OINTEREST OINTEREST OINTEREST OAICI CURIAEAICI CURIAEAICI CURIAEAICI CURIAEA4+2+ 07e 370n+0t+3n th0t 27e0te 0n

+e4+n0te Fee2h t3 the F5-+2, +n2-5+n ne,3254ent07+e, 6+-4, te-e:++3n F73704, 60nt0F37t 04e, 0n 3the7 23ntent. P5750nt t3 S5F.Ct. R. #@.!%0, 235ne- 36 7e237 637 0-- F07t+e7e2e+:e t+4e- n3t+2e 36 the +ntent t3 6+-e th+ 7+e6,0n ReF3nent + n3t 23nent.1

SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT

It + n3 e0e70t+3n t3 5et th0t the7e 40

e n3 3the7 +5e +n 23nte4F3707 +7t A4en4ent57+F75en2e th0t h0 een the 5e2t 36 0 452h-+t+0t+3n +n -3e7 2357t, +th 0 -+tt-e 5+0n2e 6734th+ C357t, 0 the 7e-0t+3nh+F eteen the 7+ht 36F5-+2+t 0n the +7t A4en4ent. R+ht 36F5-+2+t -05+t h0:e 7040t+20-- +n27e0e 3:e7the F0t e:e70- e20e. >et 0 the NCAAF73F3e Fet+t+3n eF-0+n, the -3e7 2357t h0:eF7352e 0 2h03t+2 23--e2t+3n 36 tetM th0t 20n 7e5-t+n the 04e tFe 36 eF7e+:e 37/ e+n

23nt+t5t+3n0-- F73te2te +n 3ne 57++2t+3n, 5t02t+3n0-e +n 0n3the7. Th+ t0te 36 0660+7 h05t0nt+0-- +n27e0e the 7+/ 0n 23t 032+0te

1P5750nt t3 S5F. Ct. R. #@.! 0n #@.$, n3 235ne- 637 0 F07t05th37e th+ 7+e6 +n h3-e 37 +n F07t. N3 F07t 37 the+7235ne- 40e 0n 43net07 23nt7+5t+3n t3 65n theF7eF070t+3n 37 54++3n 36 th+ 7+e6. The 04+2+ 257+0eF73:+e 0-- 65n 5e 637 the F7eF070t+3n 0n 54++3n 36th+ 7+e6. C35ne- 36 7e237 7e2e+:e t+4e- n3t+2e 36 the +ntentt3 6+-e th+ 7+e6. C35ne- 637 Pet+t+3ne7 NCAA 23nent t3 the6+-+n 36 th+ 7+e6, h+-e C35ne- 637 ReF3nent S045e- Ke--e7

3e n3t 23nent. I6 E-e2t73n+2 A7t F3+t+3n + 7e-e:0nt, +t23nent.


17/44

!

+th F5-+h+n eF7e+:e 37/, 0n h0 een+n+6+20nt- e02e70te the N+nth C+725+te2++3n th0t + the 5e2t 36 the NCAA Pet+t+3n%Ke--e7M, 0 e-- 0 the Th+7 C+725+t 7e-0tee2++3n +n H07t :. E-e2t73n+2 A7t*, In2., @1@ .# 1?1%# C+7. !"1# %H07tM.

Ke--e7 0n H07t 07e the 43t +n+6+20nte2++3n t3 0te +n the 6ee70- 2+725+t t3 07e the7+ht 36 F5-+2+t, et the+7 0FF7302h 3 e:en 437e23n65+3n +n the -0 0n h3-- 60+- t3 0t+6 +7t

A4en4ent t0n07. =3th 2+725+t 40+nt0+neth0t the t70n63740t+:e 5eM tet the 0FF-+e t7e0t:+e3 04e the 04e 0 3the7 4e+0 -+/e 33/,43:+e, 0n neF0Fe7. In 7e NCAA St58ent(

Ath-ete N04e & L+/ene** L+2en*+n L+t+0t+3n, @!?.# 1!$8, 1!@ n.1" %th C+7. !"1#) H07t, @1@ .#0t 1$'. >et 0t the 04e t+4e the F7e+2te the tet35- F7352e 0 +66e7ent 7e5-t hen 0FF-+e t3 the-0tte7 37/. I8. =3th F73F3+t+3n 20nn3t 23he7ent-e 7e23n2+-e, 0n the 7e5-t he7e 07e 0t 3 +the20e 36 +7t A4en4ent F73te2t+3n 637 n3n(

e6040t37 Fee2h, e +t 602t, 6+2t+3n, 37 0234+n0t+3n 36 3th.

The 65n04ent0- e7737 2344+tte N+nthC+725+t + th0t +t 0n0-+ F7e54e 0 7e-0t+3nh+Feteen the 7+ht 36 F5-+2+t 0n the -0 3623F7+ht th0t 3e n3t e+t. A 0 7e5-t, +t 3773the 23F7+ht(0e t70n63740t+:e 5eM 32t7+neth0t, hen 0FF-+e t3 the :e7 +66e7ent +5eF7eente 43t 7+ht 36 F5-+2+t +F5te,e:e7e- 5ne7:0-5e the +7t A4en4ent +nte7et

36 23ntent F7352e7.R0the7 th0n 23n+e7+n t70n63740t+3n,M the

0FF73F7+0te 0 t3 0FF- +7t A4en4ent 275t+n


18/44

#

+ t3 6+7t 23n+e7 hethe7 0n eF7e+:e 37/e66e2t+:e- 7ene7 the 37++n0- Fe763740n2e 36 theF-0+nt+66 5Fe76-535, 0 the C357t 635n +nZ022h+n+:. S27+FF*(H3078 =730820*t+n C3., ?## U.S. '$!,'@8 %1@@ %Z022h+n+M. Net, 2357t h35-ete74+ne hethe7 the e6en0nt 5e the F-0+nt+66+ent+t 0 0 +5+e 4e0n 36 F7343t+n 0 F7352t37 34e 3the7 eF7e+:e 37/, 36ten 7e6e77e t3 0the R3e7*tet. Ne+the7 23n2e7n + F7eente he7e.

I.I.I.I. THE RELATIONSHIP =ETWEEN THETHE RELATIONSHIP =ETWEEN THETHE RELATIONSHIP =ETWEEN THETHE RELATIONSHIP =ETWEEN THERIGHT O PU=LICIT> AND THE IRSTRIGHT O PU=LICIT> AND THE IRSTRIGHT O PU=LICIT> AND THE IRSTRIGHT O PU=LICIT> AND THE IRST

AENDENT NEEDS TO =E ADDRESSEDAENDENT NEEDS TO =E ADDRESSEDAENDENT NEEDS TO =E ADDRESSEDAENDENT NEEDS TO =E ADDRESSED=> THIS COURT=> THIS COURT=> THIS COURT=> THIS COURT

The F73F3e Fet+t+3n e27+e h3, +n thee20e +n2e Z022h+n+, the7e h0:e een 237e 3620e +n h+2h -3e7 2357t h0:e 0tte4Fte t30-0n2e the +7t A4en4ent 0n the 7+ht 36F5-+2+t +n the 23ntet 36 -05+t 2h0--en+nneF0Fe7, 33/, 400+ne, 43:+e,3254ent07+e, 7e0-+t te-e:++3n, 234+2 33/, 3n,60nt0 F37t 04e, e+te, 0n 0-- 40nne7 36

4e+0 23ntent. E:en 437e t7+/+n + the t07/-+n23n+tent 7e5-t th0t h0:e een F7352e 637 the04e tFe 36 37/.

37 e04F-e, h+-e the C0-+637n+0 S5F7e4eC357t 0FF-+e the t70n63740t+:e 5e tet t3 +4+0 2-0+4 23n2e7n+n t3 234+2 33/ 2h0702te7 h3en04e %J3hnn 0n E07 A5t54nM e:3/e theF-0+nt+66 45+2+0n %J3hnn 0n E07 W+nte7M, *eeW+nte7 :. D.C. C34+2*, $ P.# ?@#, ?@ %C0-. !""#,the +357+ S5F7e4e C357t 0FF-+e the

F7e34+n0nt 5eM tet t3 5Fh3- 0 1' 4+--+3n 57:e7+2t +n 60:37 36 0 h32/e F-0e7 %T3n T+tMh3 3e2te t3 0 4+n37 234+2 33/ 2h0702te7 +th 0


19/44

?

+4+-07 n04e %T3n T+te--+M, 205+n theF5-+he7 t3 6+-e 637 0n/75Ft2. D3e :. TCIC0-e:+*+3n, 11" S.W.# #$#, #@? %3. !""#.S+4+-07-, 0-th35h the N+nth C+725+t he- th0t 07eet+n 207 4+ht n3t e t70n63740t+:e e205ethe 0+2 ett+n 90; the 04eM 0 0 2ene +n P07+H+-t3n te-e:++3n h3, H+-t3n :. H0--407/ C078*,' .# 8?, 11 %th C+7. !"1", the S+th C+725+t635n th0t 0 F0+nt+n 36 T+e7 W33 57735ne 3the7 60435 3-6e7 0 F73te2te the +7t

A4en4ent, e:en th35h the +ent 075e th0t

the +40e 36 W33 0 ne07- +ent+20-M t3 060435 N+/e F3te7. ETW C37F. :. J+7eh P5-, In2.,##! .# 1', ' %$th C+7. !""# %C-0, J.,+ent+n. An +th 7eFe2t t3 60nt0 F37t04e, e07- 307 04e :e7+3n e7e ee4e t3 e02t+3n0-e, *ee Uh-0en8e7 :. Hen7+2/*en, #1$ .S5FF. 1!@@, 1!8# %D. +nn. 1@") P0-4e7 :.S2h3nh37n Ente7*., !#! A.! ?'8, ?$! %N.J. S5Fe7.Ct. Ch. D+:. 1$@, 43e7n 234F5te7(0e 04eh0:e een F73te2te, *ee C.=.C. D+*t7+5t+3n &/t., In2. :. 037 Le05e =0*e0-- A8:0n2e8e8+0, L.P.,'"' .# 818, 8!! %8th C+7. !""@) C=SInte702t+:e In2. :. N0t+3n0- 33t0-- Le05e P-0e7*

A**n, In2., !' .R.D. #8, ?1@ %D. +nn. !"", 0n437e 7e2ent- 2357t h0:e 7e02he the 3FF3+te7e5-t +th 7eFe2t t3 eent+0-- the 04e :+e304e. C34F07e R340nt+2* :. A2t+:+*+3n P5-,In2., '@? . S5FF. ! @'8 %E.D. +2h. !""8 0n N3D35t :. A2t+:+*+3n P5-, In2., 1!! C0-. RFt7. ##@, 1"18 %C0-. Ct. AFF. !"11.

Thee +n23he7ent 7e5-t F73:+e -+tt-e

5+0n2e t3 27e0t37 36 eF7e+:e 37/, eFe2+0--th3e -+/e thee 04+2+ h3 +t7+5te the+7 23ntentn0t+3n0-- 0n the7e637e 07e 5e2t t3 the 36ten


20/44

'

23n6-+2t+n 57+F75en2e 36 45-t+F-e 57++2t+3n.The7e 20n e -+tt-e 35t th0t the F7+n2+F0- 7e03n 637the 2577ent 6702t57e t0te 36 the -0 + the -02/ 360n 5+0n2e 6734 th+ C357t.

II.II.II.II. THE DECISION =ELOW SU=STANTIALL>THE DECISION =ELOW SU=STANTIALL>THE DECISION =ELOW SU=STANTIALL>THE DECISION =ELOW SU=STANTIALL>INCREASES THE RISK O PRODUCINCREASES THE RISK O PRODUCINCREASES THE RISK O PRODUCINCREASES THE RISK O PRODUCINGINGINGINGCONTENT PROTECTED => THE IRSTCONTENT PROTECTED => THE IRSTCONTENT PROTECTED => THE IRSTCONTENT PROTECTED => THE IRST

AENDENTAENDENTAENDENTAENDENT

The F7eent t0te 36 the -0 +4F3e 0

5t0nt+0- F702t+20- 23t 3n the 27e0t+3n 36eF7e+:e 37/ 7e-0te t3 F3F5-07 6+57e, 0 t7enthe e2++3n e-3 + 2e7t0+n t3 e02e70te. Ke--e70n H07th3-, +n e66e2t, th0t the +7t A4en4ent-e0:e t0te 67ee t3 e2+e th0t 4e+0 7e-0te t3 7e0-Fe73n 45t e+the7 3t0+n Fe74++3n t3 4ent+3nthe+7 n04e 37 -+/ene, 37 t70n6374M the4. >etn54e735 37/, 70n+n 6734 neF0Fe7 t3+370Fh+e t3 3254ent07+e t3 43:+e, t7+:e t302h+e:e F7e2+e- h0t thee e2++3n 635n3e2t+3n0-e e02t eF+2t+3n 36 97e0- Fe3F-e;

3+n e02t- h0t the 3 0 2e-e7+t+eM, Ke--e7, @!?.# 0t 1!@$, 53t+n N3 D35t, 1!! C0-. RFt7. # 0t?11 0n 357 25-t57e 7+ht- en23570e 52heF7e+3n. Inee, the 43t 7e0-+t+2 F37t700- 362e-e7+t+e 36ten 7e2e+:e the 43t 27+t+20- 022-0+4,-+/e J04+e 3 A20e4 A07(+nn+n F37t700-36 the 45+2+0n R0 Ch07-e +n the 43:+e R037 =enK+n-e Fe763740n2e +n G0n8h+.

O:e7 the F0t e:e70- e20e, -05+t00+nt 437e t70+t+3n0- 4e+0 52h 0 43:+e,

33/, 0n 400+ne h0:e 3n the h3-e een -e522e65- th0n 34e 2h0--en+n 3the7 6374 36eF7e+:e 37/, th35h e:en the7e the 7e5-t h0:e


21/44

$

n3t een 23n+tent. See, e.., P07/* :. L002eRe2378*, #! .# ?#@, ??! %$th C+7. !""# %3n he-t3 e 02t+3n0-e) S3-0n3 :. P-0+7-, In2., !! .#1"@8, 1"" %th C+7. !""! %04e 637 0 400+ne23:e7) D7e7 :. N0t+3n0- 33t0-- Le05e, $8 .S5FF. ! 111#, 11!" %D. +nn. !"1" %04e 6373254ent07+e) Se0-e :. G7044e72 P+2t57e*, ? .S5FF. ##1, #?" %E.D. P0. 1$ %43:+e ee4e t3 e23nt+t5t+3n0-- F73te2te, 5t CD 23nt0+n+n the43:+e 35nt702/ he- t3 e 02t+3n0-e) N+e:e* :.H34e =3 O66+2e, In2., 81@ N.>.S.! !!@, !!8 %N.>.

AFF. D+:. !""$ %7e0-+t te-e:++3n F73704. >et the-3e7 2357t h0:e ne:e7 F73:+e 0n Fe750+:e70t+3n0-e 637 +4F-+2+t- t7e0t+n 4e+0 -+/e 234+233/ 37 F37t70+t 07t +66e7ent- th0n 7e5-07 33/37 0n+40te 43:+e.

=3th Ke--e7 0n H07t 5t0nt+0-- 37enth+ t0te 36 0660+7. =3th ee4 t3 7e23n+e th0tthe+7 23nt752t+3n 36 the t70n63740t+:e tet 0FFe07+n23n+tent +th +7t A4en4ent F7+n2+F-e th0th0:e 550-- F73te2te n3n(6+2t+3n 4e+0 52h 0

33/ 0n 6+-4. At the 04e t+4e, 3th 2357t02/n3-ee th0t F5750nt t3 =73n :.Ente7t0+n4ent e72h0nt* A**32+0t+3n, 1#1 S. Ct.!@?#, !@! %!"11, :+e3 04e 40 n3t e t7e0te+66e7ent- th0n 3the7 6374 36 eF7e+3n. Ke--e7,@!? .# 0t 1!@") H07t, @1@ .# 0t 1?8. =3thF57F37te t3 7e3-:e th0t 32t7+n0- ten+3n +4F-F7e+2t+n th0t h+-e thee :+e3 04e 07eF57F37te- n3t t70n63740t+:e, 3the7 4e+0 th0t 5e7e0- Fe3F-e 35- e +6 the 04e tet e7e 0FF-+e.See, e.., Ke--e7, @!? .# 0t 1!@ n.1" %Ce7t0+n-

th+ -e0:e 7334 637 +t+n5+h+n eteen th+20ehe7e e h0:e e4Fh0+e EA F7+407e4Fh0+ 3n 7eF7352+n 7e0-+t0n 20e


22/44

@

+n:3-:+n 3the7 /+n 36 eF7e+:e 37/.M) *ee 0-*3H07t, @1@ .# 0t 1?8. =5t ne+the7 e2++3n F73:+e0n 23he7ent eF-0n0t+3n 0 t3 h3 th0t 235- e 3.

The 7e5-t + the F73:e7+0- 37t 36 0-- 37-,e205e 0 e2++3n 0 730- 6704e 0 Ke--e7en57e th0t the7e +-- 23nt+n5e t3 e 0 te0t7e04 36 2-0+4 2h0--en+n 0-- 3the7 6374 36eF7e+:e 37/. S34e 2e-e7+t+e h3 ee/ 0 h07e36 :+e3 04e F736+t +-- -+/e- n3 5e :+e3 04eF7352e7 %0n Fe7h0F 3the7 6374 36 ne 4e+00n ee/ t3 0FF- h0t 0FFe07 t3 e, 8e 602t3, the+F070te t7e0t4ent 637 :+e3 04e 0FF-+e the2357t e-3. Othe7 5nh0FF +th the+7 eF+2t+3n+n 437e t70+t+3n0- 6374 36 4e+0 +-- e 437ee43-ene t3 5e 23ntent 27e0t37 -+/e thee 04+2+637 0--ee 60+-57e t3 t70n6374M the4, 075+n th0t5ne7 =73n33/ 0n 6+-4 20nn3t 23nt+t5t+3n0--h0:e 0n 437e -+2ene t3 7e0-+t+20-- eF+2t the+75e2t th0n E-e2t73n+2 A7t 3e. See, e.., 337e:. We+n*te+n C3., LLC, ((( . AFF. (((, !"1# WL'8#!#@', 0t *# %$th C+7. O2t. #1, !"1#. Th5, 5n-e

th+ C357t teF +n, the 7+/ 0n 23t 032+0te+th F7352+n 0-- 7e0-+t(0e 23ntent +--23nt+n5e t3 +n27e0e.

III.III.III.III. THE TRANSORATIVE USEM TESTTHE TRANSORATIVE USEM TESTTHE TRANSORATIVE USEM TESTTHE TRANSORATIVE USEM TESTAILS TO SATIS> IRST AENDENTAILS TO SATIS> IRST AENDENTAILS TO SATIS> IRST AENDENTAILS TO SATIS> IRST AENDENTSCRUTIN>SCRUTIN>SCRUTIN>SCRUTIN>

5n04ent0--, the 23n2-5+3n th0t the +7tA4en4ent F7e6e7 th0t eF7e+:e 37/t70n6374M 7e0- Fe3F-e eF+2t+n the4 60nt0t+20- 4e0n 52h 0 0 h0-6(374, h0-6 h540n

366F7+n,M 70the7 th0n eF+2t the4 022570te-, h0n3 F-05+-e 0+. Ke--e7, @!? .# 0t 1!@?, 53t+nW+nte7, $ P.# 0t ?@$. The -3+2 36 thee e2++3n


23/44

8

e:en 5et th0t 23ntent F7352e7 h35- en0e+n F3+nt-e 04e40nh+F t3 0-te7 2e-e7+t+e0FFe070n2e 0n the 23ntetM +n h+2h the 0FFe07,

5t en35h t3 F73n35n2e the4 t70n6374e.MInee, th0t F7e4+e + +4F-+2+t +n the :e723nt752t+3n 36 the 2-0+4 +n Ke--e7.

The F-0+nt+66 e6+n+t+3n 36 the F5t0t+:e 2-0+n Ke--e7 F3+nte- e2-5e 0-- 0th-ete h3e2377eF3n+n 0:0t07 +n NCAA 33t0-- 07e n3t+th+n 3ne +n2h 36 the F-0e7 73te7 he+ht 0n . . . .+th+n 1"Q 36 the F-0e7 73te7 e+ht.M Ke--e7C34F-0+nt '. Th+ +4F-+e th0t +6 022+ent 37e+n E-e2t73n+2 A7t h0 40e +t 0:0t07 -+ht-t0--e7 37 th+nne7, the C3nt+t5t+3n 35- e 0t+6+e.Th+ tFe 36 70n34, 23ntent(0e +t+n2t+3n20nn3t e 507e +th +7t A4en4ent F7+n2+F-e.Un+te8 St0te* :. P-03 Ente7t0+n4ent G735F,'!U.S. 8"#, 818 %!""" %ethet+2 0n 4370- 54ent035t 07t 0n -+te70t57e . . . 07e 637 the +n+:+50- t340/e, n3t 637 the G3:e7n4ent t3 e27ee.M.

The 65n04ent0- e7737 2344+tte Ke--e7

0n H07t0 t3 e-e:0te the t70n63740t+:e 5eM tet+nt3 0n 0--(F57F3e 4e0n 36 0-0n2+n 0n 7+ht 36F5-+2+t 2-0+4 +th the +7t A4en4ent. It + n323+n2+en2e th0t the tet 0 6+7t 07t+25-0te +n the23ntet 36 0 +F5te 035t the 4e72h0n++n 36 0t0n+-e F7352t %t(h+7t th0t eF+2te 0 t0n(0-3ne F37t70+t. See C34e8 III P738*., In2. :. G07S08e75F, In2., !' C0-. ?th #8@ %C0-. !""1. A+25e 657the7 e-3, the tet 4+ht 0750-h0:e 34e 7e-e:0n2e +6 -+4+te t3 th0t Fe2+6+2

23ntet. H3e:e7, the 23n2eFt 36 t70n63740t+3nMh0 n3 7e-e:0n2e t3 43t 7+ht 36 F5-+2+t +F5te,


24/44

+n2-5+n th+ 3ne, 0n +t 0FF-+20t+3n 7e5-t 673470+n 4+F-02e 0n0-3+e t3 23F7+ht -0.

A.A.A.A. The T70n63740t+:e UeM TetThe T70n63740t+:e UeM TetThe T70n63740t+:e UeM TetThe T70n63740t+:e UeM TetI4F73Fe7- E50teI4F73Fe7- E50teI4F73Fe7- E50teI4F73Fe7- E50te 0 C3F7+ht 0n0 C3F7+ht 0n0 C3F7+ht 0n0 C3F7+ht 0nthe R+ht 36 P5-+2+tthe R+ht 36 P5-+2+tthe R+ht 36 P5-+2+tthe R+ht 36 P5-+2+t

The F7e4+e 36 the t70n63740t+:e 5eM tet +th0t 5+n n04e 0n -+/enee + 0n0-335 t323F+n 23F7+hte eF7e+3n. See H07t, @1@ .#0t 1'8) C34e8 III P738*., !' C0-. ?th 0t ?"?.H3e:e7, 0 0 n54e7 36 2357t 0n 2344ent0t37

h0:e 7e23n+e, 35t+e the :e7 -+4+te 23ntet 36the tFe 36 2-0+4 F7eente +n Z022h+n+th+ F7e4+e+ 65n04ent0-- 6-0e. See, e.., C.=.C.D+*t7+5t+3n & /t., '"' .# 0t 8!!) C078t33n*,L.C. :. 037 Le05e =0*e0-- P-0e7* A**n, ' .#', @$ %1"th C+7. 1$ %The 5t+6+20t+3n 637 the7+ht 36 F5-+2+t 07e n3t ne07- 0 234Fe--+n 0th3e 366e7e 637 3the7 6374 36 +nte--e2t50-F73Fe7tM) S. D30n & . Le4-e, Wh0t the R+ht 36P5-+2+t C0n Le07n 6734 T708e407/ L0, '8 St0n.L. Re:. 11$1, 11$#($? %!""$. A 0 7e5-t, 3773+n

-e0- t0n07 6734 23F7+ht -0 5t0nt+0--5ne7:0-5e the +7t A4en4ent +nte7et 0t t0/e+n 7+ht 36 F5-+2+t 20e. The 43t +4F37t0nt+t+n2t+3n eteen 0 23F7+ht 0n the 7+ht 36F5-+2+t +n2-5eet +n 23F7+ht -0, ete74+n+nhethe7 the e23n, 0--ee- +n67+n+n 37/ 4e7+t


30/44

1'

23F7+ht F73te2t+3n + the h3-e F3+nt 36 the 60+7 5e+n5+7.

It + n3t 57F7++n, the7e637e, th0t the 7e5-t36 th+ 07t+6+2+0- ee72+e + the t70ne F73F3+t+3nth0t 6+2t+3n0-+e eF+2t+3n 36 7e0- Fe3F-e h35- een23570e +n eF7e+:e 4e+0, h+-e 437e 7e0-+t+2eF+2t+3n h35- n3t e, 0 F7+n2+F0- th0t e7:e n335n 32+0- F57F3e 0n h0 n3 0+ +n +7t

A4en4ent 32t7+ne. 37 0-- thee 7e03n, Ke--e703Ft+3n 36 the t70n63740t+:e 5eM tet + 0n e773736 5t0nt+0- 23nt+t5t+3n0- +n+6+20n2e th0t 4e7+t7e:+e th+ C357t.

=.=.=.=. The T70n63740t+:e Tet 0 37eThe T70n63740t+:e Tet 0 37eThe T70n63740t+:e Tet 0 37eThe T70n63740t+:e Tet 0 37eAFF73F7+0te- Re-0te t3AFF73F7+0te- Re-0te t3AFF73F7+0te- Re-0te t3AFF73F7+0te- Re-0te t3e72h0n++nM C0ee72h0n++nM C0ee72h0n++nM C0ee72h0n++nM C0e

R0the7 th0n F3+t+n 0 ene70-+e7e-0t+3nh+F eteen t3 +F070te 32t7+ne, theC0-+637n+0 S5F7e4e C357t 37++n0- 6325 3nt70n63740t+3nM 4+ht 437e 0FF73F7+0te- h0:eeen -+4+te t3 the Fe2+6+2 602t 36 C34e8 III,

h+2h 23n2e7ne the 40 4e72h0n++n 36 0F7352t %t(h+7t th0t +F-0e 23F+e 36 t+-- +40e36 the Th7ee St33e. The 23n2e7n 70+e the4e72h0n++nM 36 t+-- +40e 3n t0n+-e F7352t+ th0t 0 2e-e7+t F+2t57e + n3t 7e0-- 5e 637 0neF7e+:e F57F3e 0t 0--, 5t + 4e7e- e+n 3- t3037n 0 Fh+20- +te4 36 4e72h0n+e. A 0 7e5-t, +t0 0 e--(et0-+he 5(en7e 36 7+ht 36 F5-+2+t-0 -3n e637e C34e8 III. See, e.., =+(R+teEnte7*., In2. :. =5tt3n 0*te7, ''' . S5FF. 1188,11$ %S.D.N.>. 18#) W+nte7-0n8 C3n2e**+3n C3. :.

S+-e3, '!8 . S5FF. 1!"1, 1!1? %N.D. I--. 181, 0668,8#" .! 1' %@th C+7. 18?.


31/44

1$

In the 4e72h0n++n 23ntet +t 40 e7e-e:0nt t3 23n+e7 hethe7 0 t+-- +40e 3n 0 t(h+7t, 5tt3n 37 2366ee 45 h0 34e +neFenent07t+t+2 :0-5e, 0n 23n+e7+n +t t70n63740t+:eMn0t57e 4+ht e 3ne 4e0n %th35h n3t ne2e07+-the 3n- 3ne 36 e:0-50t+n th0t. =5t hen theF7352tM +n237F370t+n the F-0+nt+66 +40e + n3t 0n+te4 36 4e72h0n+e, 5t 70the7 + +te-6 0neF7e+:e 37/ 52h 0 0 neF0Fe7, 43:+e 37 :+e304e, the 04e 23n2e7n 035t 4e72h0n++n+40e 3n t0n+-e F7352t 07e n3t F7eente.

E-e2t73n+2 A7t + n3t +n 0n ene 4e72h0n++nthe Fh+20- 04e +2 037ne +th 0 t+-- +40e 360 F-0e7. R0the7, +t + e--+n the 23ntent th0t0FFe07 hen the +2 + e-e2t73n+20-- 022ee.N3t0-, the Re*t0te4ent %Th+78 36 the L0 36Un60+7 C34Fet+t+3n %Re*t0te4entM 7e23n+e th0t4e72h0n++nM 20e 40 0770nt +66e7ent 7e5-tth0n th3e +n:3-:+n +nte70te eF7e+:e 37/.!

In the 23ntet 36 F57e- eF7e+:e 37/, the23n2eFt 36 t70n63740t+3n h0 n3 -3+20- 23nne2t+3n

t3 0-0n2+n the 7+ht 36 F5-+2+t 0n the +7tA4en4ent. Inee, +t + t7+/+n th0t the Th+7C+725+t e773ne35- 7e6e77e t3 thee :+e3 04e 0+6 the e7e 4e7e- F7352t -+/e te04 e7e,

!The 0-e 36 4e72h0n+e e07+n 0 Fe73n n04e 37 -+/ene37+n07+- 23nt+t5te 0 5e 36 the +ent+t 637 F57F3e 36 t70e5ne7 the 75-e t0te +n ?$. An 5n05th37+e 0FF73F7+0t+3n 360n3the7 n04e 37 -+/ene 637 5e 3n F3te7, 5tt3n, 37 3the74e4370+-+0 + th5 37+n07+- 02t+3n0-e 0 0n +n67+ne4ent 36the 7+ht 36 F5-+2+t. Atte4Ft t3 e6en the 0-e 36 52h4e72h0n+e 3n 6+7t 04en4ent 735n th735h 0n0-3+e t3the 407/et+n 36 33/, 400+ne, 0n 3the7 t70+t+3n0- 4e+036 23445n+20t+3n . . . h0:e tF+20-- een 7ee2te.M I8.0t ?@,24t. .


32/44

1@

70the7 th0n eF7e+:e 37/. @1@ .# 0t 1'@('8.%AFFe--0nt 207ee7 0 0 23--ee 633t0-- F-0e75et th0t the t07et 05+en2e 637 h+4e72h0n+e 0n Fe763740n2e %e.., h+ 02t50-40t2he 35- e F37t 60n.M. See 0-*3 D0:+* :.E-e2t73n+2 A7t*, In2., !"1! WL #8$"81, 0t *' %N.D.C0-. 07. !, !"1! %2h0702te7++n EA 088enNL:+e3 04e 0 the ++t0- e5+:0-ent 36 . . . 0 t(h+7t.M.

C.C.C.C. =3773+n 6734 C3F7+ht L0=3773+n 6734 C3F7+ht L0=3773+n 6734 C3F7+ht L0=3773+n 6734 C3F7+ht L0+7e+7e+7e+7e0000 Z022h+n+Z022h+n+Z022h+n+Z022h+n+

The eeF+n 0n0-3 34e -3e7 2357t h0:e40e eteen the 7+ht 36 F5-+2+t 0n 23F7+ht7e5-t +n F07t 6734 3:e7(7e0+n Z022h+n+, h+2h0 the t07t+n F3+nt 637 the 0n0-+ th0t F7352ethe t70n63740t+:e tet. C34e8 III, !' C0-. ?th 0t?"?. Z022h+n+ F3+te 0 t73n 7e-0t+3nh+F eteenthe en 36 23F7+ht -0 0n the 7+ht t3 theF5-+2+t :0-5e 36 h+ Fe763740n2eM 2-0+4 0e7te +nth0t F07t+25-07 20e. I8. 0t '$!. Th0t 0n0-3,h3e:e7, h0 een +e- 4++nte7F7ete +n2e.

A th+ C357t eF7e- 7e23n+e, Z022h+n+0 0n 5n550- 20e 5+te 5n-+/e 43t 7+ht 36F5-+2+t 20e. See +8.0t '@# n.1" %the 20e e637e5 + 437e -+4+te th0n the 730 20te37 36-05+t th0t 40 07+e 5ne7 the he0+n 360FF73F7+0t+3nM. In 43t 7+ht 36 F5-+2+t 20e,+n2-5+n Ke--e7 0n H07t, the F-0+nt+66 2h0--enethe e6en0nt 5e 36 h+ 37 he7 Fe73n0 t3 0--ee-enh0n2e the :0-5e 36 the e6en0nt eF7e+:e37/. The F-0+nt+66 +n Z022h+n+, h3e:e7, 0 n3t

7e0-- 234F-0+n+n th0t h+ n04e 0n -+/ene 0eF+2te 3n the ne. A th+ C357t n3te, he 9+;n3t 4e7e- 0e7t th0t 34e ene70- 5e, 52h 0


33/44

18

0:e7t++n, 0 40e 36 h+ n04e 37 -+/ene.M I8.R0the7, he 7e-+e9; 3n the 452h n0773e7 2-0+4 th0t7eF3nent te-e:+e 0n ent+7e 02t th0t he 37+n07+-et F0+ t3 Fe76374,M th5 th7e0ten+n h+-+:e-+h33. I8.

Th3e 602t F7eente 0 2-0+4 th0t 0 452h-+/e 0n 2-0+4 637 23F7+ht +n67+ne4ent +n:3-:+nthe -+te70- 7eF7352t+3n 36 0n ent+7e 23F7+hteFe763740n2e. Inee, 0 the 20e 40e +t 0th735h the Oh+3 5+2+07, the t0te 2357t the7e+07ee 035t hethe7 the 2-0+4 h35- e:en een34+n0te 3ne 637 7+ht 36 F5-+2+tM 37, +nte0, 02-0+4 637 23n:e7+3n 0n 23443n(-0 23F7+ht+n67+ne4ent. Z022h+n+ :. S27+FF*(H3078 =7308.C3., #'1 N.E.! ?'?, ?'$ %Oh+3 1@$. A 34e2344ent0t37 h0:e F3+nte 35t,*ee D. Z+44e740n,3ne 0* 0 Th54 3n the C3n*t+t5t+3n0- S20-eSISANAL>SISANAL>SISANAL>SIS

R0the7 th0n 23n+e7+n t70n63740t+3n, the6+7t teF +n 0FF-+n +7t A4en4ent 275t+n t3


35/44

!"

7+ht 36 F5-+2+t 2-0+4 h35- e t3 0/ hethe7 the602t 36 0 F07t+25-07 20e F7eent the 04eFe763740n2e 5t+t5t+3n 23n2e7n 0 Z022h+n+ +.Wh+-e 52h 20e 07e -+/e- t3 e :e7 707e, the4+ht +n2-5e 34e 36 the hF3thet+20- 2en07+370+e 57+n 0754ent +n the 2357t e-3 035tthe F3tent+0- 4+5e 36 ++t0- 0:0t07. 37 e04F-e,+6 43:+e t5+3 e0n F7352+n J04e* =3n843:+e5+n 0 ++t0- 7eF-+20 36 Se0n C3nne7 70the7 th0n02t50-- h+7+n h+4, th0t 4+ht F7eent 0 2en07+30n0-335 t3 Z022h+n+.

H3e:e7, the 23n2e7n 70+e th0thF3thet+20- 35- n3t e 0 5FF3e 60+-57e t3t70n6374M 7. C3nne7. The7e 07e n54e7352en07+3 +n h+2h ++t0-- 7eF-+20t+n the 02t50-Fe763740n2e 36 0 2e-e7+t 02t37 35- e Fe76e2t-0FF73F7+0te, 52h 0 t3 27e0te 0 +370Fh 373257040 035t the 02t37 +n ++t0- 6374. R0the7,the t0te +nte7et +n 7e23n++n 0 205e 36 02t+3n35- e th0t ++t0-- 7eF-+20t+n 02t37 637 theFe2+6+2 F57F3e 36 0:3++n e:e7 5+n 7e0- 02t37

235- eF7+:e the4 36 the 3FF37t5n+t t3 F702t+2ethe+7 F736e+3n 0t 0--. Th0t 23n2e7n + n3t+4F-+20te he7e.

The net +n5+7 h35- e hethe7 thee6en0nt 37/ + 0 +5+e 4e0n 36 F7343t+ne+the7 0 F7352t 37 0n 5n7e-0te eF7e+:e 37/.Wh+-e the Fet+t+3n 7e6e7 t3 th+ +n5+7 0 theR3e7* tet,M +t 0-3 2377e2t- n3te th0t theF07t+25-07 tet e4F-3e +n R3e7* :. G7+40-8+, 8@'.! ? %! C+7. 18 + 5t 3ne 63745-0t+3n 36 0

23443n F7+n2+F-e 0FF-+e 45-t+F-e -3e7 2357t,3th e637e 0n 06te7 R3e7*< th0t eF7e+:e23ntent h35- e 02t+3n0-e 3n- he7e 0 F-0+nt+66


36/44

!1

-+/ene + en5+ne- 5t 0 F-3 t3 407/et 34e3the7 5n7e-0te F7352t 37 23ntent. See, e.., +ne7:. O4n+ P5-n* Int-, Lt8.,'$$ N.E.! 1?1, 1?# %N.>.1" %eF7e+:e 37/ 07e n3t 0 t70e 5eM 5ne7Ne >37/ 4+0FF73F7+0t+3n t0t5te 5n-e theF-0+nt+66 -+/ene h0 n3 7e0- 7e-0t+3nh+FM t3 the5ne7-+n 23ntent 37 the 23ntent +te-6 + 7e0-- 0n0:e7t+e4ent +n +5+e.M.

The Re*t0te4ent t7e0t4ent 36 the 7+ht 36F5-+2+t + F07t+25-07- n3te37th, e205e +tt7+/e 0 0-0n2e th0t Fe0/ +7e2t- t3 the +5e +nth+ 20e. The Re*t0te4ent F7e54e th0t 5e +nente7t0+n4ent 0n 3the7 27e0t+:e 37/ +Fe74+tte,M 5n-e the n04e 37 -+/ene + 5e3-e- t3 0tt702t 0ttent+3n t3 0 37/ th0t + n3t7e-0te t3 the +ent+6+e Fe73n.M Re*t0te4ent ?@,24t. 2. 37e3:e7, the Re*t0te4ent +60:3723n+e7+n t70n63740t+3n.M I8.0t ?@, 24t. %In20e 36 +4+t0t+3n, the F5-+2 +nte7et +n 234Fet+t+3n0n +n 0:3++n the 43n3F3-+0t+3n 36 522e65-t-e . . . +-- 37+n07+- 35te+h 0n 0:e7e e66e2t

3n the F-0+nt+66 407/et.M. At the 04e t+4e, +t7e23n+e th0t 4e72h0n++n 20e 40 F7eent5n+5e +5e.

T3 +--5t70te h3 thee F7+n2+F-e 4+ht 0FF-,+6 0 7et0570nt 2h0+n 3Fene S04 Ke--e7Ret0570ntM +th35t Ke--e7 23nent, +t 35- -+0-e637 5+n h+ n04e t3 F7343te 0 5+ne.

A-te7n0t+:e-, +6 0 33/ F5-+he7 7e-e0e S045e-Ke--e7 C33/33/M 4e7e- t3 5e Ke--e7 n04e t3e-- 7e2+Fe th0t h0 n3th+n t3 3 +th h+4, th0t

4+ht 0-3 60+- th+ tet.#

=5t eF7e+:e 37/#I4F37t0nt-, th3e hF3thet+20- 2en07+3 07e +t+n2t 6734 the5e 36 0 Fe73n n04e 37 +40e +n 0:e7t++n 637 0n eF7e+:e


37/44

!!

7e-0te t3 23--ee 633t0--, +n2-5+n :+e3 04e,35- n3t.

Th+ 0FF7302h 35- 0FF73F7+0te- 0-0n2ethe 7+ht 36 F5-+2+t 0n the +7t A4en4ent. It35- F73te2t the 7+ht t3 eF-3+t th3e 02t+:+t+e43t t70+t+3n0-- 032+0te +th the e23n34+27e07 36 2e-e7+t< the F702t+20- 0+-+t t3 F702t+2e3ne 2706t %+6 0n +n the 6+7t F-02e, 0n t3 F736+t6734 604e -en+n 3ne n04e 37 +40e t3 en37e3the7 F7352t, e7:+2e, 37 e:en eF7e+:e 37/.Th3e 3FF37t5n+t+e 07e 0-3 607 437e 7e-0te t3+n2ent+:++n 0n 02h+e:e4ent th0t 4+ht e032+0te +th 0+n+n 2e-e7+t th0n the F3++-+tth0t 3ne 4+ht e:ent50-- e +n2-5e +n 0 43:+e 37:+e3 04e. 37e3:e7, Fee2h th0t 5e 2e-e7+t+e637 +5+e 0:e7t++n F57F3e + 437e -+/e- t3e 2344e72+0-- 4+-e0+n, 0n th5 -e ee7:+n36 +7t A4en4ent F73te2t+3n. I0ne :. -0. DeFt36 =5*. 0n8 P736- Re5-0t+3n, =8. 36 A2235nt0n2,'1! U.S. 1#$, 1?! %1?.

Inee, +:en th0t the 7+ht 36 F5-+2+t

eent+0-- 23n2e7n the F73te2t+3n 36 Fe73n0-+t70n,M +6 the7e + 0n 0n0-3 t3 3the7 +nte--e2t50-F73Fe7t 7+ht +t 35- 437e 0FF73F7+0te- e t3t70e407/ -0, he7e the R3e7* tet + 437e +e-

37/ th0t 7e-0te t3 th0t Fe73n. 37 e04F-e, 0 F5-+he7407/et+n 0 +370Fh 36 Ke--e7 235- 5e h+ n04e 37 +40e t3F7343te the 33/. L3e7 2357t h0:e 23n+tent- 7e23n+eth0t tFe 36 F7343t+3n0- 5e + +n2+ent0- t3 F5-+h+neF7e+:e 37/, 0n h35- e 23nt+t5t+3n0-- F73te2te t3the 04e etent 0 the 5ne7-+n 37/. See. e.. 3nt0n0 :.S0n J3*e e7257 Ne*, In2., #? C0-. AFF. ?th @", @$ %C0-.1') N040th :. SF37t* I--5*t70te8, #@1 N.>.S.! 1", 1! %N.>.AFF. D+:. 1@'.


38/44

!#

63--3e the -3e7 2357t, +n2-5+n the N+nthC+725+t h+2h 0FF-+e +t t3 eent+0-- the 04e :+e304e. =73n :. E-e2t73n+2 A7t*,In2., @!? .# 1!#',1!# %th C+7. !"1#. The Th+7 C+725+t 7ee2te the0n0-3 t3 t70e407/ -0 e205e +t n3te th0t the7+ht 36 F5-+2+t + 730e7 0n, eten+3n,F73te2t 0 7e0te7 0th 36 F73Fe7t +nte7etM th0n3e t70e407/ -0, h+2h 437e n0773- 07ee23n54e7 23n65+3n. Th5, H07t 23n2-5e th0t 0-e Fee2h(F73te2t+:e tet th0n the 3ne 0FF-+e t3t70e407/ 2-0+4 + 0770nte. @1@ .# 0t 1'8.

Th0t -3+2 t57n the ee72+e 36 23nt+t5t+3n0-275t+n 3n +t he0. The 7e0th 36 0 t0te -020nn3t +2t0te the 7e5++te -e:e- 36 +7t

A4en4ent 275t+n) 70the7 the +7t A4en4ent23nt70+n the Fe74++-e 23Fe 36 t0te -0. Un+te8St0te* :. Ste:en*, '' U.S. ?$", ?$!($# %!"1". Thet0te +nte7et +n F73te2t+n the ene70- F5-+2 673423n54e7 23n65+3n + 57e- 607 437e 234Fe--+nth0n the +nte7et +n 40+4++n the e23n34+27e07 36 +n+:+50- 2e-e7+t. See, e..,

Re*t0te4ent ?$, 24t. 2 %The 70t+3n0-e 5ne7-+n7e23n+t+3n 36 0 7+ht 36 F5-+2+t 07e ene70-- -e234Fe--+n th0n th3e th0t 5t+6 7+ht +nt70e407/ 37 t70e e27etM) R3e7*, 8@' .! 0t1""?. >et the -3+2 36 Ke--e7 0n H07t + th0t the+7t A4en4ent 5070ntee 437e 67ee34 t3en0e +n Fee2h th0t e2e+:e 23n54e7 th0n +t3e t3 27e0te eF7e+:e 37/ th0t 7e-0te t32e-e7+t+e.


39/44

!?

CONCLUSIONCONCLUSIONCONCLUSIONCONCLUSION37 the 637e3+n 7e03n, the e2++3n e-3

65n04ent0-- 5ne7:0-5e the +7t A4en4ent7+ht 36 23ntent 27e0t37 -+/e thee 04+2+. The3:e77++n +4F37t0n2e 36 the +5e F7eente th5eten 607 e3n the F07t+e +n the N+nth C+725+t,0n th+ C357t h35- 70nt the NCAA 3t+3n t3Inte7:ene.

ReFe2t65-- 54+tte,

N0th0n E. S+ee-C35n*e- 36 Re2378Sh0+n0 J3ne W07LEVINE SULLIVAN KOCH &SCHULZ, LLP18 L St7eet NW, S5+te !""W0h+nt3n, DC !""#$!"!('"8(11""n+ee--/-0.234

Att37ne* 637 P73F3*e8 A4+2+


40/44

APPENDIX


41/44

APPENDIXA E Television Networks, LLC (AETN) iscomprised of television networks including A&E,HISTORY, Lifetime, Bio., Military HISTORY,and Crime & Investigation Network, among others.

The Associated Press (AP) is a not-for-profitmutual news cooperative. The members of AP aremore than 1,500 newspapers and more than 5,000television and radio stations throughout the UnitedStates. AP also serves thousands of subscribing

newspapers, news networks and other publishersand distributors of news worldwide. Founded in1848, AP is now the largest newsgatheringorganization in the world.

Bloomberg L.P. d/b/a Bloomberg Newsis one ofthe worlds largest newsgathering organizations,comprised of more than 2,500 journalists around theworld in more than 120 bureaus. Bloombergprovides business, legal and financial news throughthe Bloomberg Professional Service, Bloombergs

website and Bloomberg Television.Discovery Communications, LLC is a leading,global nonfiction media company that reaches morethan 1.8 billion cumulative subscribers in 218countries and territories. Discovery has more than150 worldwide television networks, includingDiscovery Channel, TLC, Animal Planet, Science andInvestigation Discovery, as well as joint venturenetworks OWN: Oprah Winfrey Network, The Hub,and 3net.

Dow Jones Company, Inc., (Dow Jones) aglobal provider of news and business information, isthe publisher of The Wall Street Journal, Barrons,


42/44

2a

MarketWatch, Dow Jones Newswires, and otherpublications. Dow Jones maintains one of theworlds largest newsgathering operations, withnearly 2,000 journalists in more than fifty countriespublishing news in several different languages. DowJones also provides information services, includingDow Jones Factiva, Dow Jones Risk & Compliance,and Dow Jones VentureSource. Dow Jones is a NewsCorporation Company.

ESPN, Inc. (ESPN) is the largest sports mediacompany in the world. In the United States, it ownsand operates multiple cable television networks, aradio network, multiple sports internet sites, abroadband network, a magazine, and a programsyndication business. ESPN produces news,documentaries, and fantasy sports games amongmany other forms of content.

The Hearst Corporation is one of the nationslargest diversified media companies. Its major

interests include the following: ownership of 15 dailyand more than 30 weekly newspapers, including theHouston Chronicle, San Francisco Chronicle and

Albany Times Union; nearly 300 magazines aroundthe world, including Good Housekeeping,Housekeeping, Cosmopolitan and O, The OprahMagazine; 29 television stations, which reach acombined 18% of U.S. viewers; ownership in leadingcable networks, including Lifetime, A&E and ESPN;business publishing, including a joint ventureinterest in Fitch Ratings; and Internet businesses,television production, newspaper featuresdistribution and real estate.


43/44

3aNational Public Radio, Inc. (NPR) is a Districtof Columbia non-profit membership corporation. Itproduces and distributes its radio programmingthrough, and provides trade association services to,nearly 800 public radio member stations locatedthroughout the United States and in many U.S.territories. NPRs award-winning programs includeMorning Edition, and All Things Considered, andserve a growing broadcast audience of over 23

million Americans weekly. NPR also distributes itsbroadcast programming online, in foreign countries,through satellite, and to U.S. Military installationsvia the American Forces Radio and TelevisionService.

News Corporation is a global, diversified mediaand information services company focused oncreating and distributing authoritative and engagingcontent to consumers throughout the world.The company comprises leading businesses across a

range of media, including: news and informationservices, digital real estate services, book publishing,digital education, and sports programming and pay-TV distribution.

The Radio Television Digital News Association(RTDNA), is based in Washington, D.C., and is theworlds largest professional organization devotedexclusively to electronic journalism. RTDNArepresents local and network news directors andexecutives, news associates, educators and studentsin broadcasting, cable and other electronic media inover 30 countries. RTDNA is committed to


44/44

4a

encouraging excellence in electronic journalism andupholding First Amendment freedoms.

Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press isan unincorporated association of reporters andeditors which works to defend First Amendmentrights and freedom of information interests of thenews media. The Reporters Committee has providedrepresentation, guidance and research in First

Amendment litigation since 1970.

Ncaa Brief

Documents