Top Banner
METHODOLOGIES EXPLAINED How to Conduct Systematic Political Research 1
35

methodologies EXPLAINED

Mar 21, 2016

Download

Documents

kerryn

methodologies EXPLAINED. How to Conduct Systematic Political Research. Lecture Structure. Aims Methods of Comparison Quantitative vs. Qualitative Research Applying or Referring to Theory. Methods of Comparison. Methodology. Definition: - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: methodologies EXPLAINED

1

METHODOLOGIES EXPLAINED

How to Conduct Systematic Political Research

Page 2: methodologies EXPLAINED

2

Lecture Structure Aims Methods of Comparison Quantitative vs. Qualitative Research Applying or Referring to Theory

Page 3: methodologies EXPLAINED

3 Methods of Comparison

Page 4: methodologies EXPLAINED

4

MethodologyDefinition: A body of methods, rules, and postulates

employed by a discipline: a particular procedure or set of procedures.

The analysis of the principles of inquiry in a particular field.

(Merriam-Webster Dictionary)

Page 5: methodologies EXPLAINED

5

Questions addressed in this course

What is the study of the International Political Economy?

How do politics and economics interrelate?

How does international trade impact on development?

What is the structure of the International Political Economy?

Neil Berry
These questions refer specifically to IPE and therefore you may wish to change them to better suit your course content.
Page 6: methodologies EXPLAINED

6

Comparing Literature

NEED two literature samples that feature different methodologies.

Neil Berry
In this section, you should add references to two course specific texts that illustrate the two difference methodologies.
Page 7: methodologies EXPLAINED

7

Comparing Literature Literature 1 (year)

Topic Year Qualitative evidence

Literature 2 (year) Topic timescale Quantitative evidence

Neil Berry
On this slide you should present a breakdown for each of the two preceding texts, completing the relevant data highlighted below.
Page 8: methodologies EXPLAINED

8

Methods of ComparisonThree basic approaches to answering a research question: Large-n: > 50 cases. Small-n: 2-20 cases. Single case study: 1 case.

n = number of cases/observations.

Page 9: methodologies EXPLAINED

9

Large-n Compares political phenomena across a

large number of countries and/or cases. > 50 cases. Empirical data Statistical techniques

Generally applied to quantitative analysis of data on a large number of variables, which uses statistical methods to achieve ‘control’.

Page 10: methodologies EXPLAINED

10

Large-n Example:

“National Autonomy and Economic Development: Critical Perspectives on Multinational Corporations in Poor Countries.” Peter B. Evans, 1971.

This paper explores the economic importance of multinational corporations in less developed countries (LDCs) throughout Africa, Asia and Latin America. Uses finance in- and out- flows to/from LDCs and corporate earnings data.

(Peter B. Evans (1971). National Autonomy and Economic Development: Critical Perspectives on Multinational Corporations in Poor Countries. International Organization, 25, pp 675-692 doi:10.1017/S0020818300026382)

Neil Berry
This example is specific to an IPE course. You may want to replace it with a reading relevant to your course.
Page 11: methodologies EXPLAINED

11

Small-n

Cases are intentionally selected in order to establish ‘control.’

compare political phenomena across a selected number of countries and/or cases. 2-20 cases.

Often called the ‘comparative method.’

Page 12: methodologies EXPLAINED

12

Small-n Example:

“The Structure of Dependence” Theotonio dos Santos, 1970.

This paper explores the dependence of the 19 countries of Latin American countries on trade partners in the global North. Uses data on Foreign Direct Investments and remittance.

(Theotonio dos Santos (1970). The Structure of Dependence. The American Economic Review, 60:2, pp 231-236)

Neil Berry
This example is specific to an IPE course. You may want to replace it with a reading relevant to your course.
Page 13: methodologies EXPLAINED

13

Single Case Study Intensive study of a single country

and/or case (i.e. n=1).

Single observation/case: Time: historical period or

years/months/days. Space: sub-national political units. Level of analysis: state, groups, individuals.

Page 14: methodologies EXPLAINED

14

Single Case Study Example:

“Economic Policy and Power Relations in South Africa’s Transition to Democracy.” Adam Habib and Vishnu Padayachee, 2000.

This paper focuses solely on one nation state, South Africa.

(Adam Habib & Vishnu Padayachee (2000). Economic Policy and Power Relations in South Africa's Transition to Democracy, World Development, Volume 28, Issue 2, February 2000, Pages 245-263, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0305-750X(99)00130-8.)

Neil Berry
This example is specific to an IPE course. You may want to replace it with a reading relevant to your course.
Page 15: methodologies EXPLAINED

15 Quantitative vs. Qualitative

Page 16: methodologies EXPLAINED

Quantitative vs. Qualitative Approaches

Ask and answer different questions by conceptualising ideas/phenomena differently.

Quantitative approaches require quantifiable concepts.

Qualitative approaches allow for broader conceptualisations.

16

Page 17: methodologies EXPLAINED

Qualitative Quantitative

Exercise: Conceptualising “Democracy” for a Qualitative and a Quantitative Study17

Page 18: methodologies EXPLAINED

18

Quantitative vs. Qualitative Research

Some Common Assumptions

Quantitative Research is…

Qualitative Research is…

More scientific

More objective

More methodologically rigorous

Less scientific

More subjective

Less methodologically rigorous

Page 19: methodologies EXPLAINED

19

Quantitative vs. Qualitative Research

When looking at Quantitative Research What are the assumptions behind the

approach? What questions are asked and why?

How quantifiable variables chosen? Data may not be perfect!

How is the data interpreted? What claims are made? Numbers never speak for themselves!

Page 20: methodologies EXPLAINED

20

Quantitative vs. Qualitative Research

When looking at Qualitative Research Who are the participants, do they have

ulterior motives? How does the researcher relate to the

participants? How is the data interpreted? What claims are

made? How transparent is the author about the

interpretation? Does the data support the generalisations?

Page 21: methodologies EXPLAINED

21

Quantitative vs. Qualitative Research

Whether quantitative or qualitative, good research is: Open about assumptions, theoretical

background and limitations. Transparent and rigorous in

methodology. Clear on interpretation and conclusions. Does not make unsubstantiated claims.

Page 22: methodologies EXPLAINED

22

Empirical Analysis Concepts in this Course

Trade Aid Resources Growth Recession Dependence Inequality

Neil Berry
The themes listed here are based on the study of IPE. You may wish to change them.
Page 23: methodologies EXPLAINED

23

Concept vs. Variable Concept = abstract.

Variable = observable/measurable.

Page 24: methodologies EXPLAINED

Variables Variables are concepts that are defined

to be observed and/or measured.

Variables can be evaluated in terms of their validity and reliability.

Distinguish between dependent and independent variables.

24

Page 25: methodologies EXPLAINED

25

Dependent and Independent Variables

Dependent Variables Can be changed by other factors.

Independent Variables Are not affected by changes in other factors

(Independent variable) causes a change in (dependent variable) and it isn’t possible that (dependent variable) could cause a change in (independent variable)(National Centre for Education Studies, USA)

Page 26: methodologies EXPLAINED

26

Dependent and Independent Variables

Whilst FDI can cause a change in government revenue, it isn’t possible for government revenue to cause a change in FDI.

Neil Berry
This is an IPE specific example, which you may choose to change.
Page 27: methodologies EXPLAINED

Exercise: Variables for concept measurement

27

TradeGrowthDependence Inequality

Neil Berry
The themes listed here are based on the study of IPE. You may wish to change them.
Page 28: methodologies EXPLAINED

28

Statistical Techniques Identify patterns between variables.

Correlation: relationship between two variables.

Correlation is not the same as causation! Example: ice cream and warm weather.

Page 29: methodologies EXPLAINED

29

Limitations Cannot prove causation.

Limited interpretive ability (i.e. explaining why these relationships exist).

Use of proxies – alternatives to what we can not measure.

Page 30: methodologies EXPLAINED

30

Analysing CASE STUDYQ: Does XXX prevalence explain YYY?

Steps to follow: How did the author operationalise and

measure these concepts? Do these proxies make sense? Is there

correlation? In other words – what do we see happening to the likelihood of YYY variable when we look at different natural resource/GDP values.

Neil Berry
Here you will want to insert features of a relevant case study.
Page 31: methodologies EXPLAINED

• How have they created proxies for these variables?

• What is the measurement?• Do these proxies make sense? • Is there correlation?

Exercise: Analysing CASE STUDY – does XXX prevalence explain the onset of YYYY? 31

Neil Berry
Here you will want to insert the features of a relevant case study from the previous slide.
Page 32: methodologies EXPLAINED

32 Applying or Referring to Theory

Page 33: methodologies EXPLAINED

33

Applying Theory Systematically

Logic of theory

Language that a theory demands

Units of analysis

Consistency through the paper

Acknowledging limitations

Page 34: methodologies EXPLAINED

34

Referring to Theory as Evidence

Not constrained by the logic of the theory Used to add to understanding, or to hold

theory up to criticism or praise Can compare explanations offered by

different theories

Page 35: methodologies EXPLAINED

35

This presentation is licenced under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 South Africa License. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.5/za/ 

Or

send a letter to Creative Commons, 171 Second Street, Suite 300, San Francisco, California 94105, USA.