Top Banner

of 22

Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

Apr 03, 2018

Download

Documents

Rahul Reddy
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    1/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 46

    Unit 3 Operations Strategy

    Structure:

    3.1 Introduction

    Objectives

    3..2 Operations Strategy

    3. 3 Competitive Capabilities and Core Competencies

    3. 4 Operations Strategy as a Competitive Weapon

    Product/service expertise

    Quick delivery

    Flexibility in production

    Low cost production and processes

    Product variety and product mixQuality

    3.5 Linkage Between Corporate, Business, and Operations Strategy

    3.6 Developing Operations Strategy

    3.7 Elements or Components of Operations Strategy

    Designing of the production system

    Facilities for production and services

    Product or service design and development

    Technology selection and process development

    Allocation of resources

    Facility, capacity, and layout planning3.8 Competitive Priorities

    Cost

    Quality

    Time

    Flexibility

    3.9 Manufacturing Strategies

    Make-to-stock strategy

    Assemble-to-order strategy

    Make-to-order strategy

    3.10 Service Strategies3.11 Global Strategies and Role of Operations Strategy

    Strategic alliance

    Locating the operations abroad and after sales support

    3.12 Case-let 1

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    2/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 47

    3.13 Case-let 2

    3.14 Summary3.15 Glossary

    3.16 Terminal Questions

    3.17 Answers

    3.18 Answers to Caselets 1 & 2

    3.1 Introduction

    In the previous unit, we dealt with operations management and strategy,

    tools for implementation of operations, and industry best practices. In this

    unit, we will deal with operations strategy as a competitive weapon;

    competitive capabilities and core competencies; linkage between corporate,business, and operations strategy; developing operations strategy; elements

    or components of operations strategy; competitive priorities; manufacturing

    strategies; service strategies; and global strategies and role of operations

    strategy.

    To succeed in a competitive business environment, organisations should

    evolve sound strategies with which they can achieve their business

    objectives. The strategies that are planned for implemention should be long

    term and broad based to achieve the set of objectives. The normal practice

    is to develop organisational strategies at three levels of operations namely

    a) corporate level, b) business level, and c) functional level.

    While the corporate strategy looks into organisational goals, developing the

    core competence and achieving the competitive advantage for their

    products, the business level strategy looks at market segmentation and

    competitive priorities to be considered for their products or services. The

    functional level strategy looks at operations to produce these products by

    managing the capability, productivity, quality, flexibility, cost of production,

    delivery, and finally after sales and services.

    Organisations achieve competitive advanatge over its competitors by

    providing products or services that meet the customer requirements of cost,quality, performance, durability, etc. The corporate strategy determines the

    customers to be served, the new products or services to be produced, and

    the suitable strategies to be met in competitions from both domestic and

    international markets.

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    3/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 48

    Hence, the operations strategy is a set of decisions taken across the

    organisation to help support the implementation of the competitive businessstrategies. The operations strategy links both its long-term and short-term

    operational decisions to corporate strategy. Operations strategy is a process

    by which the key operations decisions are made and should always be

    consistent with the overall strategic objectives of the organisation.

    Objectives:

    Affter studying this unit, you should be able to:

    explain why organisations formulate and develop startegies to gain

    competitive advantage

    describe the linkage that exists between corporate strategy, business

    level strategy, and functional and operations strategy outline the role of operations strategy as a competitive weapon in

    domestic and global markets

    explain the formation and development of operations strategy

    describe the elements of operations strategy and linking operations and

    marketing strategy

    explain how to set competitive priorities

    identify the operations strategies in manufacturing and services

    describe global strategies

    3.2 Operations Strategy

    Operations strategy is defined as the set of decisions that are warranted in

    the operational processes in order to support the competitive strategies of

    the business. The objectives stated above will give the firm a competitive

    advanatage in the products or services that are served to the customers.

    Operations strategy is a long-range business plan for the companys

    products and will provide a road map for the operational functions to be

    pursued. Therefore, the strategic decisions include the capacity to be built

    into the production system, the type of processess and manufacturing

    technology to be adopted, the nature of products to be produced, and thetype of material flow and other logistics required to achieve the level of

    performance.

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    4/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 49

    Planning of operations strategy is very essentail as it will enable the

    organisation to respond to the market needs in an effective manner. It alsogives the opportunity to align the resources and manufacturing activities to

    produce and deliver the products and become successful in the market.

    3.3 Competitive Capabilities and Core Competencies

    The operations strategies are evolved based on the business strategies.

    Some of the business strategies that has a direct bearing to manufacture

    are:

    To serve a defined product to the stable market

    To provide high product variety and customise the design to meet the

    specific requirements

    To provide rapid response to the market through in-built flexibility and

    produce different products to keep abreast with the environmental

    changes

    To serve these business strategies, the firm should emphasise on achieving

    quality, productivity, flexibility, low cost, constant innovation in designs, and

    short development cycle for introducing new products and being highly

    responsive to the changes in that competitive environment.

    Building core competencies and gaining competitive advantage for its

    products are great strategies. The core competencies are the unique

    resources and strengths that are required to be developed, practised, and

    constantly improved upon. This competence becomes the capability when

    the strategy is successful and the set objectives of competing is met.

    To achieve the competitive advantage, the organisations must provide the

    customers with what they want, know when they want, what quality they

    prefer and what cost, and how better they serve the customer than their

    competitors.

    3.4 Operations Strategy as a Competitive Weapon

    The important objective of any business is to occupy a position from where

    the organisation is able to attract more customers than its competitors. For

    this, they should identify the distictive competencies that will give the leading

    position in the market segments.

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    5/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 50

    Competitiveness is one of the crucial factors that decides the survival and

    growth of a firm. This competitiveness is how effectively an organisationmeets the needs of its consumers as compared to its immediate

    competitors. For such competitions, the organisations look into their

    operational strengths and equip themselves effectively to use their strengths

    and opportunities as competitive weapons.

    These competitive weapons are explained below in detail.

    3.4.1 Product/services expertise

    Expertise gained through operational strengths in the areas of functionalities

    and process capabilities will make them the market leaders for such

    products.

    3.4.2 Quick delivery

    The flexible capacity built into the production line and the process adopted

    to produce and supply in time will all together provide the much desired

    customer satisfaction. This strategy will help sustain the product and its

    market lead.

    3.4.3 Flexibility in production

    The organisation has to develop a capability for change. The adaptation to

    change begins with environmental scanning by which trends can be

    monitored to suit the needs of the society. There may be a threat to the

    product if competotors gain an edge over the broadening product lines,improved quality, or lowering costs. New entrants into the market or

    competiitors offering substitute product may also throw challenges to the

    dominant product. To counter this, the desired flexibilty in production must

    be built in and operations strategy must be modified accordingly.

    3.4.4 Low cost production and processes

    The unit cost of each product is required to be lowered to meet the

    competition. The cost review on labour, material, and overhead costs of

    production lines are to be assessed. An organisation with an efficient and

    effective production system will provide such feasibilities to reduce costs.

    The operations strategy should also facilitate the processing of products at

    lower costs.

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    6/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 51

    3.4.5 Product variety and product mix

    The organisations are producing multiple products to provide variety tocustomers. Here the size of operations matters. Higher the volume, lower

    the production costs. Accordingly, operational strategy is to be fine tuned to

    suit the desired product mix.

    3.4.6 Quality

    The operations strategy should ensure that the desired quality level is

    maintained, and it meets the customer needs. Competing in the quality of

    the product is one of the most important corporate strategies.

    3.5 Linkage Between Corporate, Business, and Operations

    Strategy

    The mission statement is unique to an organisation. It contains a set of long-

    range goals. It details the kind of business the company wants to be in, the

    type of customers they serve, the basic beliefs of their business, and the

    expected goals and profitability.

    Similarly, business strategy is a long-range plan and serves as a raod map

    to achieve the above-said corporate mission. These plans encompass many

    functional areas like production, marketing, finance, human resources, etc.

    Operations strategy translates all the decision processes that supports the

    business strategy. How these operating strategies work under the corporate

    strategies and serve the business strategy is explained in Developing

    Operations Strategy below.

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    7/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 52

    3.6 Developing Operations Strategy

    Fig. 3.1: Developing Operations Strategy

    Figure 3.1 above depicts how the operations strategy is developed under

    the umbrella of the corporate strategy. It shows the factors that go into the

    operations strategy and shows the link between the corporate, business,

    and the competitive priorities under the operations strategy. Here, the long-

    term operations strategic decisions are directly connected to developing

    new products, determining production capacity, establishing facilities,

    adopting new technologies, locating plants appropriately, and taking suitable

    decisons on building and sustaining the quality of products.

    The operations strategy translates the product plans and competitive

    priorities into decision making processes. The operation decisions

    determine the processes required to handle the volume and variety to be

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    8/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 53

    produced for each market segement. Hence, these decisions govern the

    design of the processes, systems, and the procedures that help theoperations strategy.

    Selection of the market is another key element. To suit the market

    requirements, operation managers develop appropriate processes and

    designs to achieve the set objectives. The operations strategy should be

    flexible enough to support a product or service throughout its life cycle and

    for future changes in the market demand. The operations strategy should

    also be consistent with the other functional strategies of marketing, finance,

    and human resources.

    3.7 Elements or Components of Operations Strategy

    The six elements of operations strategy are:

    1) Designing of the production system

    2) Facilities for production and services

    3) Product or service design and development

    4) Technology selection, development, and process development

    5) Allocation of resources

    6) Focus on facilities planning

    3.7.1 Designing of the production system

    The designing of the production system involves the selection of the type ofproduct design, processing system, inventory plan for finished goods, etc.

    The product design has two varieties. They are:

    Customised product design The design is customised when the

    volume is low and special features are inbuilt. Examples: Industrial

    products like turbines, boilers, air compressors, etc.

    Standard product design The designer adopt a universal design so

    that the product will have wide acceptance across the customers. Also

    the demand is more and quantity is high. Examples: Air conditioners,

    TV, fans, etc.

    There are two types of production systems. They are product focussed and

    process focussed. Product-focussed system is adopted where there is mass

    production by using a group of machines. For example, products like

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    9/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 54

    automobiles, computers, etc. In the process-focussed system, the design is

    based on a single task like painting, packing, heat treatment, etc.3.7.2 Facilities for production and services

    Certain specialisation in production allows the firm to provide the customers

    with products of lower cost, faster delivery, on-time delivery, high product

    quality, and flexibility. Here, overheads will be less and the firm can

    outperform compared to the competitors. While planning the specialised

    lines, the economies of scale and the continuous demand are to be looked

    into. For example, Nikon Cameras plan and establish special lines for each

    model and manufacture huge quantities for the global market. Here, the

    economies of scale and the continuous demand matters.

    3.7.3 Product or service design and development

    The stages followed in developing a product are:

    1. Generating the idea

    2. Creating the feasiblity reports

    3. Designing the prototype and testing

    4. Preparing a production model

    5. Evaluating the economies of scale for production

    6. Testing the product in the market

    7. Obtaining feedback

    8. Creating the final design and starting the production.

    Any product designed and introduced into the market has its own life cycle.

    The various stages of life cycle are:

    1) Introduction stage

    2) Growth stage

    3) Maturity stage

    4) Decline stage

    Let us now discuss these stages in brief.

    In the introduction stage, the sales depends on promotion and marketing

    efforts. The product which is successful at this stage will enter the next

    stage of growth, where the organisation takes the decisions on the capacity

    to be augmented and the investments to be made. During the maturity

    stage, the organisation focuses on improving the efficiency of the

    processes, minimising the costs, etc. At declining stage, the product may

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    10/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 55

    meet the obsolesence both in technology and in customer requirments, thus

    warranting the stop of production. There are many products that lost itsmarket after going through athe above stages. For example, pagers, floppy

    drives, tapes for recording and palying, click-type cameras, typewriters, etc.

    3.7.4 Technology selection and process development

    A product selected for production will be analysed for the process and the

    applicable technology for optimal production. There are many challenges

    faced by the operations managers in this decision as the alternatives are

    many. The techno-economic analysis for each alternatives will help to

    decide the required technology. Combining high technology production

    equipments with conventional machines and using robotics, flexible

    manufacturing systems, automated devices for material movements, etchave given an edge to the production units to excel in quality, flexibility,

    production at economic costs, etc thus enabling the firm to meet the

    competitions.

    3.7.5 Allocation of resources

    The production units face continuous problems of allocating the scarce

    resources like capital, machines, equipments, materials, manpower,

    services, etc. Allocation at the right time to the right place of production

    indicates the efficiency of the production planners. Optimal use of resources

    will enable economical production. Minimising waste, optimal utilisation of

    resources, and the best quality product demand a sound operations

    strategy.

    3.7.6 Facility, capacity, and layout planning

    The location, layout, and facilities creation for the production are the key

    decision areas for the operations manager. These are critical for achieving

    the competitiveness. The decision also influences the future expansion of

    the plant. While evaluating the aternatives, the operations manager will

    consider the availbility of raw materials, access to market, etc. Enormous

    capital requirement is required and the planning is always long range. Here,

    the production process adopted and the technology pursued dictates thevolume, quality, and cost of production.

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    11/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 56

    3.8 Competitive Priorities

    Operations stategy reflects the long-term goals of an organisation in itscorporate strategy. To achive good results, a clear understanding of the

    operating advantages and a good cross functional coordination between

    functional areas of marketing, production, finance, and human resources

    departments are required. Operating advantages depend on its processes

    and competitive priorities considered while establishing the capabilities. The

    basic competitive priorities are:

    Cost

    Quality

    Time

    Flexibility

    3.8.1 Cost

    Cost is one of the primary considerations while marketing a product or a

    service. Being a low cost producer, the product accepted by the customer

    offers sustainability and can outperform competitors. Lower price and better

    quality of a product will ensure higher demand and higher profitability. To

    estimate the actual cost of production, the operations manager must

    address labour, materials, scrap generations, overhead and other initial cost

    of design and development, etc.

    3.8.2 QualityQuality is defined by the customer. The operations manager looks into two

    important aspects namely high performance design and consisitent quality.

    High performance design includes superior features, greater durability,

    convenience to services, etc where as consistent design measures the

    frequency with which the product meets its design specifications and

    performs best.

    3.8.3 Time

    Faster delivery time, on-time delivery, and speedy development cycle are

    the time factors that operations strategy looks into. Faster delivery time is

    the time lapsed between the customer order and the delivery. On-time

    delivery is the frequecy with which the product is delivered on time. The

    developemnt speed is the elapsed time from the idea generation up to the

    final design and production of products.

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    12/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 57

    3.8.4 Flexibility

    Flexibility is the ability to provide a wide variety of products, and it measureshow fast the manufacturer can convert its process line used for one product

    to produce another product after making the required changes. The two

    types of flexibilities are:

    Customisation

    Volume flexibility

    While customisation is the ability of the firm to satisfy the specific needs of

    each its customer, the volume flexibility is the ability to accelerate or

    decelerate the rate of production to handle the fluctuations in demand. For

    example, the production of fertilisers of different specifications and

    applications.

    3.9 Manufacturing Strategies

    There are many types of competitive priorities for processes used in the

    manufacturing of products. The manufacturing industry adopts systems

    based on demand. The production systems practised are:

    Batch production

    Mass production

    Customised production

    Assemble products, test them, and supply

    For these, the manufacturing strategies adopted are decided by the

    operations manager. The manufacturing strategies differ from industry to

    industry and the applicable situations demand and supply. The following are

    the three dominant manufacturing strategies:

    Make-to-stock

    Assemble-to-order

    Make-toorder

    Let us now discuss these strategies in detail.

    3.9.1 Make-to-stock strategy

    The manufacturing firms adopt this strategy to ensure immediate delivery of

    the products, thereby minimising the delivery times. This straegy is feasible

    for standardised products with high volumes and where forecast is

    reasonably accurate. To accomplish this, the production units should hold

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    13/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 58

    good inventory of stocks. For example, chemicals, soft drinks, electronic

    components, etc.3.9.2 Assemble-toorder strategy

    This strategy serves as a competitive priority of customisation and ensures

    fast delivery. This goes with the apporoach to produce customised products

    from sub-assemblies and components after the customer orders are

    received. This involves assembly processes, fabrication processes, painting,

    cleaning, etc. Here, the appropriate inventory of parts and aggregates are

    created for smooth functioning of processes. The operations manager

    should ensure that the optimal finsihed goods inventory is mainatained as

    excess inventory increases the inventory carrying cost and less finished

    goods inventory may hamper the delivery of products in time to thecustomers. For example, paints to colours, furnitures, fabricated structures,

    etc.

    3.9.3 Make-to-order strategy

    When products are manufactured to the customer specification, the

    tendency is to follow the strategy of make-to-order. The firms evolve a set

    of processes that suits the manufacture based on the customer

    requirements. This strategy gives a higher degree of customisation, one of

    the major competitive priority. The firm can accommodate flexibility and

    offer variety. For example, special medical equipments, forgings and

    castings, house construction, etc.

    3.10 Service Strategies

    Here too, the standardised services, customised services, and assemble-to-

    order strategies are used for processing as in the case of manufacturing.

    The service strategy is the use of processes that provides little variety in

    high volumes and mostly customised. For example, FedEx, postal servcies,

    etc.

    The strategy adopted for designing the operations is to include the

    processes that produce a set of standardised services to specific customers.For example, credit cards, Internet, etc.

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    14/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 59

    3.11 Global Strategies and Role of Operations Strategy

    A global strategy pursued by organisations at the corporate level mayinclude buying foriegn parts or servcies and combat traditional domestic

    competitions. The firms should also ward off threats from foreign markets as

    they can directly supply to the domestic customers. Hence, identifying the

    opportunities and threats and evolving the operations strategy require a

    global perspective. The other factors to be analysed are the market

    segmentation like demographic factors, psychological factors, industry

    factors, etc and also identify the needs of product, delivery, volume, and any

    other need of the customer.

    While evolving the business strategy, the business units considers the

    prevailing global conditions along with their existing strengths, weaknesses,

    and competencies. The global conditions include factors like market

    potential; existing competitions; and economic, political, technological, and

    social developments across the countries being considered for their

    business strategy.

    Two effective strategies adopted by the firms exposed to products being

    marketed world over are strategic alliance and locating operations abroad

    and after sales service.

    3.11.1 Strategic alliance

    A strategic alliance is an agreement between the two parties as jointpartners to promote the products. This alliance may be in any form, but

    widely accepted are 1) collaboration, 2) joint venture, and 3) technology

    transfer and licencing.

    Collaboration

    A collaboration arrangement beween two parties arises when one firm is

    having core competency in a particular product which the other firm wants to

    promote in its country. Instead of duplicating the product with their own

    design, the local firm and the collobarator join together for their mutual

    interest and promote the product. Invariably, the operations strategy

    followed by the collaborated company is followed by the domestic company

    to keep up the reputation of products. For example, Nikon, IBM, HP, etc.

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    15/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 60

    Joint venture

    Joint venture is an agreement between the two firms to produce jointly. Thisapproach is used to gain access to foreign markets and quickly promote

    their interest. Here, the outside firm supplies the technology and expertise

    and the local firm provide the required resources for the operations,

    processing, human resoucres, infrastructure, etc. For example, Maruti

    Suzuki, Hero Honda, etc.

    Technology transfer and licencing

    Technology transfer is the term used to describe the processes by which

    technological knowledge moves within or between organisations. The

    technological knowledge that is transferred can assume various forms. It

    can be embodied in goods (including physical goods, plant and animalorganisms), services and people, and organisational arrangements, or

    codified in blueprints, designs and technical documents.

    Licensing is a business arrangement in which one company gives another

    company permission to manufacture its product for a specified payment.

    While licensing agreements are mainly used in commercialization of a

    technology, they are also used by franchisers to promote sales of goods and

    services.

    3.11.2. Locating the operations abroad and after sales support

    Locating the manufacturing operation in a foreign country is another way ofpenetrating the new markets. Since economical and political environment

    will be different and the customers needs vary, it is essential for firms to

    have a detailed techno-economic survey before planning the entry. The

    operations strategy will be different from what the company is presently

    practising. If it is a standardised product to be sold in the foriegn country, the

    methodology and operational strategy could be the same. For example,

    McDonalds, Dominos Pizza, etc.

    Self Assessment Questions

    1. Select correct answer out of the alternatives given

    i. While formulating the corporate objectives, the manager considersa) Market conditions

    b) Political and social environments

    c) Economic environment

    d) all the above

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    16/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 61

    ii. Nirma manufactures different varieties of soaps for the market and

    the production system followed is aa) Customised production

    b) Standardised production

    c) Stock-to-order

    d) Assemble-to-order

    iii. When products are produced well in advance and stored for

    marketing, the operations strategy is known as

    a) Produce-to-stock

    b) Produce-to-order

    c) Custom-to-order

    2. Which of these is not an operation strategy?a) Production systems

    b) Product plans

    c) Collaboration for production

    d) Process decisions

    e) Capacity decisions

    3. Fill up the blanks with appropriate word/words

    i. Operations strategy is defined as the set of decisions that are

    warranted in the operational processes, which supports the

    _____________of the business.

    ii. The six elements of operations strategy that has a direct bearing on

    the corporate strategy are:

    1) Designing of the production system

    2) Facilities for production and services

    3) ________________________________

    4) Technology selection, development, and process development

    5) Allocation of resources

    6) Focus on facilities planning

    iii. The following three manufacturing strategies are dominant inindustries:

    1) Make-to-stock strategy

    2) ____________________

    3) Make-to-order strategy

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    17/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 62

    iv. A strategic alliance is an agreement betwen the two parties as joint

    partners to promote the products. This alliance may be in any of theforms, but widely accepted are:

    1) Collaboration

    2) ______________

    3) Technology transfer and licencing

    3.12 Case-let 1

    Strategic Decisions of Microsoft

    Microsoft operates in a very competitive industry. It was dominating in theDOS and held almost 90% of the market in PC operating system. It

    invested futher in developing the next generation OS like Windows 95,

    Windows NT, etc to keep the lead and to take advantage of the

    profitability in this evergreen DOS segment. Before the competition builds

    up for DOS, Microsoft had two thoughts whether to harvest the existing

    DOS as it is like a cash cow or bring in different systems to keep away

    the competitors. Bill Gates, the co-founder and CEO of Microsoft realised

    that if his company is not replacing its own product with a better product,

    some other company like IBM would come out and they may loose the

    market leadership position. They decided to go forward aggressively tothe next competitive advantage before any other competitors does and

    introduced many new products. Microsoft still enjoys the market

    leadership position in the operating system.

    Discussion Questions:

    a) The strategic decision to develop new products to keep the market

    leadership - is it a corporate strategy or a business strategy? Discuss

    b) The strategy of developing new products to counter the anticipated

    competition instead of harvesting their existing cash cow product - is

    this correct and in this decision, what is the strategy that is involved?c) Explain briefly why Bill Gates believed in the aggressive strategy to

    gain the competitive advantage and how has it benefitted the

    company?

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    18/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 63

    3.13 Case-let 2

    Tata Motors-Development of New Products to Gain Competitive

    Advantage

    Designing indegenously, building and marketing a new car is a very

    complex process and very few corporates take such a decision. Tata

    motors, one of the leading manufacturers of automobiles in India, took

    this drive forward in developing the first indegenously designed and

    developed car in Indica as a competing model to the then prevailing cars

    like Maruti 800 and Zen. This strategy by Tata was a tradeoff between

    the price and the features.

    Indica car was a success story, and it did give the desired competition toMaruti Suzuki. The target audiance for Tata was the middle class and

    fuel efficiency and price were the other primary considerations to woo the

    customers. After the design and test runs were satisfactorily done,

    benchmarking Indica car for final pricing and positioning in the market

    was again a big challenge. Here, the operations strategy adopted was to

    offer the first indigenous car at the lowest price possible and with the best

    quality. Hence the investment, processes, systems, and procedures for

    manufacture of such a car required a total relook by their operations

    manager, it was a really big task for the entire Tata Motors.

    With the confidence reposed after the success of designing, developing,and marketing Indica cars to Indian roads, Tata Motors embarked on

    another ambitious project of their chairman in bringing the prestigious

    peoples car, Nano, to Indian roads. Here, the decision to bring out a

    peoples car from Tata Motors stable was purely based on the sale price

    of Rs. one lakh per car. This challenge was taken up seriously by the

    operations managers and the task was accomplished successfully by

    offering Nano cars at the declared price.

    In the above two success stories,

    a) What do you feel are the corporate strategies?

    b) What manufacturing priorities might have been pursued by the

    operation managers?

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    19/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 64

    3.14 Summary

    Let us recapitulate the important concepts discussed in this unit: Operations strategy is a decision making process of selecting the

    suitable manufacturing strategies and manufacturing priorities. This

    exercise will enable the organisation to respond to the market needs in

    the most effective manner by aligning the resources and activities of the

    organisation to deliver the products that are likely to succeed in the

    market.

    Operations strategy involves planning, organising, and allocating of all

    the resources to gain the competitive advantage.

    Operations strategy is defined as the set of decisions that are warranted

    in the operational processes which supports the competitive strategiesof the business. It is a long-range business plan for the companys

    products and will provide a road map for the operational functions to be

    pursued for achieving business strategies.

    Strategic decisions include capacity building; evolving production

    systems, type of processes, manufacturing technology to be adopted,

    nature of products to be produced, type of material flow and other

    logistics, and the means to achieve the required level of performance.

    Corporate strategy involves monitoring and making changes to suit the

    external environment and exploiting the core competencies.

    Competitiveness is one of the crucial factors that decides the survival

    and growth of a firm. Organisations will look into their operational

    strengths and use them effectively as competitive weapons.

    There are six elements of operations. They are designing of the

    production system; facilities for production and services; product or

    service design and development; technology selection, development,

    and process development; allocation of resources; and focus on facilities

    planning.

    Operating strategy should also analyse the competitive priorities like

    cost, quality, time, and flexibility which are the capabilities to be built in

    to meet the market expectations.

    The three dominant manufacturing strategies are make-to-stock

    strategy, assemble-to-order strategy, and make-to-order strategy. These

    systems are practised for categories of batch production; mass

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    20/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 65

    production; customised production; and assemble the product, test it,

    and supply. A global strategy pursued at the corporate level may include buying

    foriegn parts or servcies and combat traditional domestic competitions.

    Other factors analysed here are the market segmentation like

    demographic factors, psychological factors, industry factors, etc and

    identify the needs of product, delivery, volume, and any other

    requirement of the customer.

    3.15 Glossary

    Cash cow products: Cash cow products provide lots of cash for the

    firms. They have high market share, and they are always in the growing

    market.

    Competitive advantages: Organisations achieve competitive

    advantages by providing their customers what they want and better or

    more effective products than their competitors and take the lead

    Core competence: The organisations resources and capabilities are

    the sources of their unique competencies

    Customisation: Customisation is the ability of a firm to satisfy the

    specific needs of each customer.

    3.16 Terminal Questions

    1. What is meant by operations strategy? How is it related to corporate

    strategy?

    2. What is meant by core competence and competitive advantage?

    3. What are the types of competitive weapons that a firm can use to meet

    the objectives of the operations strategy?

    4. How do you develop operations strategy? Explain briefly the relationship

    that exists between corporate strategy, business strategy, and

    operations strategy.

    5. Explain briefly the elements of operations strategy.6. Explain the basic competitive priorities considered while formulating

    operations strategy by a firm?

    7. What are the manufacturing strategies that can be applied by a firm to

    meet the operations strategy?

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    21/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 66

    8. Under global strategies, explain the salient features of the collaboration

    arrangement and the joint venture policies for gaining competitiveadvantage.

    3.17 Answers

    Self Assessment Questions

    1. (i) d. All the above

    (ii) b. Standardised production

    (iii) a. Produce-to-stock

    2. c. Collaboration for production3. (i) Competitive strategies

    (ii) 3. Product design and development

    (iii) 2. Assemble-to-order

    (iv) 2. Joint venture

    Terminal Questions

    1. Refer section 3.2

    2. Refer section 3.3

    3. Refer section 3.4

    4. Refer section 3.5 & 3.6

    5. Refer section 3.7

    6. Refer section 3.8

    7. Refer section 3.9

    8. Refer section 3.11

    3.18 Answers to Caselets 1 & 2

    Caselet-1 a It is a corporate strategy, planned with a long-term

    vision, not only to sustain the existing business but also

    to keep the competitive advantage.

    b Todays cash cow product may not be so in the future.

    The development lead time required to immediately

    bring new product should be borne in mind. Hence, the

    decision taken to bring new versions made Microsoft to

  • 7/28/2019 Mb0044 Unit 03 Slm

    22/22

    Production and Operations Management Unit 3

    Sikkim Manipal University Page No. 67

    keep the competitive edge over its competitors.

    c Bill Gates aggressive policy of keeping the competitive

    advantage has benefitted the company as they are,

    even today, the front runners and has many first-mover

    products to their credit.

    Caselet-2 a The vital decision to indigenously design and develop a

    new car, Indica and compete with the existing models

    and also bringing out similarly the Nano as the peoplescar with the price band fixed at Rs. one lakh per car

    are the corporate strategies.

    b Low cost, high volume production of cars to suit the

    Indain roads, and also build with many features for

    satisfying the customer, that too, within the price band

    fixed were all the challenges faced by the operations

    manager. To achieve this, they created facilities,

    production systems, and all other procedures.

    Reference:

    Frazier, G., and Gaither, N. (2002. Operations Management South

    Western/Thomson Learning.

    Ronald, E. J. And Everett, A.E. (2009). Production & Operations

    Management Phi Learning.