(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd. LTE & WiMAX Evolution to 4G LTE & WiMAX Evolution to 4G Israel Mobile Association Event LTE vs. WiMAX: Complementing or Competing? 29 October 2008 Ehud Reshef, WiMAX Product Marketing Director
(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd.
LTE & WiMAX Evolution to 4GLTE & WiMAX Evolution to 4G
Israel Mobile Association Event
LTE vs. WiMAX: Complementing or Competing?
29 October 2008
Ehud Reshef, WiMAX Product Marketing Director
(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd.1
About Comsys
� Cellular baseband fabless company
� Field-proven solutions – over 30 million handsets use Comsys 2G/3G technologies
� Focused on 4G
� Unique Mobile-WiMAX / cellular chip
� Advanced multimode and multi-RAT co-existence techniques
� Developing 3GPP-LTE device
Over 30 million handsets enabled by Comsys cellular technology
(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd.2
Comsys Solutions
Mobile WiMAX, LTE Silicon / System
ComMAX™
EDGEware™
2G/3G System IP UEware™ EGGware™
2.5G PHY IP
200620042002 20082000 2010
IPS
ilicon
(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd.3
Managed network
OoS guarantee
Full mobility
Easy worldwide roaming
Mobile Broadband
All-IP network
Always on
Multiple deviceform factors
Internet connectivity
“4G”
(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd.4
Access Technologies Positioning
(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd.5
LTEAdvanced
802.16mR 2.0
Mobile Broadband Technology Evolution
WCDMA
3GPPHSDPA HSPA
Mobile
WiMAX802.16eR 1.0
EVDORev A
EVDORev B
CDMA 2000
3GPP2
LTE
802.16eR 1.5
2005 2009 20102006 2007 2008 2011 2012
CDMA based OFDMA based
R99
“4G”
IMT-Advanced
(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd.6
So What is “4G”?
� Still need to be defined by ITU – “IMT-Advanced”
� Expected targets
� True Mobile Broadband
� 1Gbps peak data rate for fixed services
� 100Mbps data rate for mobile services
� High mobility to 500Km/H
� Flat All-IP network architecture
� Specific Technologies and Spectrum allocations not identified
� WiMAX and 3GPP-LTE are not 4G technologies
� WiMAX TDD is part of the IMT-2000 family of standards
� 3GPP LTE expected to become part of IMT-2000
(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd.7
Technical Comparison Overview
Aspect LTE (3GPP R8) WiMAX R 1.0 (16e) WiMAX R 2.0 (16m)
Air Interface DL: OFDMA
UL: SC-FDMA
DL: OFDMA
UL: OFDMA
DL: OFDMA
UL: OFDMA
Duplexing FDD, TDD TDD TDD, FDD
Mobility /
Vehicular Speed
350 Km/H 60-120 Km/H 350 Km/H
Bandwidth 1.25, 1.6, 2.5, 5, 10, 15, 20
MHz
3.5, 5, 7, 8.75, 10 MHz 5, 10, 20, 40 MHz
Peak Data Rates DL: 302 Mbps (4x4)
UL: 75 Mbps (2x4)
@ 20 MHz FDD
DL: 46Mbps (2x2)
UL: 4Mbps (1x2)
@ 10MHz TDD 3:1
DL > 350 Mbps (4x4)
UL > 200 Mbps (2x4)
@ 20 MHz FDD
Average Sector Spectral Efficiency
DL: 1.91 bps/Hz (2x2)
UL: 0.72 bps/Hz (1x2)
DL: 1.91 bps/Hz (2x2)
UL: 0.84 bps/Hz (1x2)
DL > 2.6bps/Hz (4x2)
UL > 1.3bps/Hz (2x4)
Latency Link layer < 5 mSec
Handoff < 50 mSec
Link layer ~ 20 mSec
Handoff 35-50 mSec
Link layer < 10 mSec
Handoff < 30 mSec
VoIP Capacity 80 users / sector / FDD MHz 20 users / sector / TDD
MHz
> 30 users / sector / TDD MHz
(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd.8
Other Interesting Aspects
Multiple formats – PUSC, FUSC, AMCContiguous allocation blocksAllocation Schemes
FCH: CC, K=7, R=½
Control+Data: CTC, K=4, R=2/6, 480 bits/block
Control: CC, K=7, R=1/3Data: CTC, K=4, R=1/3, 6144 bits/block
Forward Error Correction
Aspect 3GPP – LTE Mobile WiMAX
Air Interface OFDMA based
QPSK – 64QAM
OFDMA based
QPSK – 64QAM
Core Network All-IP All-IP
Persistent Allocations Release 8.0 Release 1.5
Multicast/Broadcast Release 9.0 Release 1.0
UL PAPR Reduction SC-FDMA N/A
H-ARQ Incremental Redundancy Release 1.0 – Chase
Release 1.5 – Chase or IR
MIMO Models Spatial Multiplexing
Transmit Diversity (Alamouti, CDD)
UE specific beam-forming
Spatial Multiplexing
Transmit Diversity (Alamouti)
CDD – R 1.5
UE specific beam-forming
Collaborative UL SM
Multi Technology Support GERAN, UTRAN, non-3GPP
Non 3GPP: CDMA, WLAN, (WiMAX)
PMIP and IMS/VCC
CDMA, GERAN, UTRAN, WLAN
CMIP, PMIP, IMS
(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd.9
vNSPNAP hNSP
WiMAX Network Architecture
R1
R3
R6
R2
Internet
R5
CSN CSN
ASNASN
GW
BS
BS
MS
AAA Proxy
HAPF
AAA
PF
R3R4
R6
R6
ASNASN
GW
BS
BS
R6
(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd.10
Simplified 3GPP LTE Network Architecture
Internet
UE
eNB
eNB
Serving
GW
MME
SAE
AnchorLTE-Uu S1-u
S1-c
S1-u
S1-c
S5
S11
SGi
PDN
GW
X2
(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd.11
IMS
Core
Converged Network Architecture
R6
ASNASN
GW
BS
BS
R6
CSN
eNB
eNB
Serving
GW
MME
S1-u
S1-MME
S1-u
S1-MME
S11X2
SAE
Anchor
3GPP
Anchor
S5-b
GPRS
Core
S5
S5-a
S3
S4
GERAN
UTRAN
Gb
Iu
HSS
PCRF
InternetR3
PDNGW
S7
S6-a
SGSN
GSM/EDGE
UMTS
LTE
WiMAX
(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd.12
IMS Framework
IMS Centric Network Architecture
SIPApplication Server
Home SubscriberServer (HSS)
Call Session Control Function (CSCF)(SIP Proxy)
UMTS Packet Core Network
WiMAX WLAN DSL/Cable
Media Resource Function Control
Media Resource Gateway Control
Multiple Possible Access Networks
Diameter
SIP
(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd.13
IMS Centric Device Architecture
IMS Applications
IMS Service Enablers
IMS Enabling Protocol Layer
IMS Socket API
TCP/IP
VoIP, VCC IM
Video
PresenceMultimedia
Gaming
Multi-Standard Baseband
RFIC RFIC RFIC
Non-IMS Applications
(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd.14
Example Reference Platform
Smartphone evaluation platform
Multi-RF support, including WiMAX/WLAN/EDGE
Mobile IP and IMS/VCC for service continuity
(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd.15
Managed network
OoS guarantee
Full mobility
Easy worldwide roaming
Mobile Broadband
All-IP network
Always on
Multiple deviceform factors
Internet connectivity
“4G”
• LTE and WiMAX Mobile have strong commonalities in technology
• Containing many technologies that we will see with “4G” systems
• Specific differences relate to mobile vs. broadband origins
Conclusion
(c) 2008 Comsys Communication & Signal Processing Ltd.16
www.comsysmobile.com
WiMAX: [email protected]
LTE: [email protected]