Top Banner
Issues & Policies in US Politics Module 8.1: Theories of Justice
12
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Issues & Policies in US Politics Module 8.1: Theories of Justice.

Issues & Policies in US Politics

Module 8.1: Theories of Justice

Page 2: Issues & Policies in US Politics Module 8.1: Theories of Justice.

The Natural Rights Argument

• From the Declaration of Independence• Fundamental Human Equality• Endowment with “Certain Inalienable Rights”

– Life – Liberty– Pursuit of Happiness

• Rights neither created nor destroyed by human beings

• Purpose of government: secure rights• Measure of justice: the degree to which

government secures rights

Page 3: Issues & Policies in US Politics Module 8.1: Theories of Justice.

John Rawls

• Author of A Theory of Justice (1971)• Two factors inform the substance of justice

– The Veil of Ignorance in human choices (The liberty principle)– Natural human equality and societal inequality (the difference principle)

• Rawlsian Justice:– All societal benefits must be equally distributed UNLESS– An unequal distribution is to the advantage of the Least Favored in

society

Justice = Fairness

Page 4: Issues & Policies in US Politics Module 8.1: Theories of Justice.

Robert Nozick

• Author of Anarchy, State, and Utopia (1974)• Two factors inform the substance of justice

– Freedom of action– Coercive power of government

• Nozickean Justice– All individuals in society must remain free to pursue societal benefits

without coercionUNLESS– Such pursuit constitutes a willful injury to another

Justice = Freedom

Page 5: Issues & Policies in US Politics Module 8.1: Theories of Justice.

So what?

• Nozickean justice– Emphasizes liberty– Prescribes a

reactive government limited to resolving claims of willful injury

– May be blind to persistent inequality of unfairly marginalized individuals and groups

• Rawlsian justice– Emphasizes equality– Prescribes active

redistribution to benefit “least favored”

– May conflict with property rights and individual “pursuit of happiness”

Page 6: Issues & Policies in US Politics Module 8.1: Theories of Justice.

Civil Rights

• Natural Rights connection– Civil Rights are extensions of Natural Rights into civil society– Civil Rights are societal benefits

but– Civil Rights are not created by government– Civil Rights may, however, be recognized by government

• Rawls connection– Civil Rights are therefore to be distributed equally, unless

unequal distribution benefits least favored in society

• Nozick connection– Civil Rights may be pursued by individuals, unless doing so

willfully injures someone else

Page 7: Issues & Policies in US Politics Module 8.1: Theories of Justice.

Through the Lens of Equality• Rights of participation

– Voting– Legal standing– Jury participation– Speech, press, assembly and petition

• Equal protection of the laws– Due Process rights

• Security against unreasonable searches and seizures• Defensive silence• Security against bearing witness against oneself• Habeas corpus• Legal counsel• Speedy & public trial• Jury trial• Security against double jeopardy of life or limb • No excessive bails or fines; no cruel and unusual punishments

Page 8: Issues & Policies in US Politics Module 8.1: Theories of Justice.

Criminal Due Process• Major Stages

1. Search & Seizure

2. Investigation & Indictment

3. Trial & Verdict

4. Sentence & Execution

• Limits: Stage 1• Security against

unreasonable searches and seizures

– Probable cause

– Exclusionary rule

• Defensive silence• Security against bearing

witness against oneself• Security against excessive

bail

• Limits: Stage 2• Security against

unreasonable searches and seizures

• Defensive silence• Security against bearing

witness against oneself• Legal counsel• Indictment by Grand Jury

– Grand Jury must specify the crime committed according to the applicable Penal Code

– Grand Jury must decide if sufficient evidence exists to demonstrate guilt of the defendant

• Limits: Stage 3• Defensive silence• Security against bearing

witness against oneself• Habeas corpus• Legal counsel• Speedy & public trial• Jury trial• Security against double

jeopardy of life or limb

• Limits: Stage 4• Legal counsel• Security against double

jeopardy of life or limb • Security against excessive

fines• Security against cruel and

unusual punishment

• Limits: Arraignment• Legal counsel• Habeas corpus• Defensive silence• Plea

– Guilty

– Not guilty

– Nolo contendere (not available in felony cases)

• Plea bargaining

Page 9: Issues & Policies in US Politics Module 8.1: Theories of Justice.

Through the Lens of Equality

• Equal protection of the laws– Rights against discrimination

• Race• Religion• Ethnos• Sex• Handicap• Class?• Age?

Page 10: Issues & Policies in US Politics Module 8.1: Theories of Justice.

Civil Liberties

• Natural Rights connection– Civil Liberties are extensions of Natural Rights into civil society– Civil Liberties are societal benefits

but– Civil Liberties are not created by government– Civil Liberties must, however, be recognized by government– Civil Liberties restrain government action against individuals

• Rawls connection– Civil Liberties are therefore to be equally respected by

government, unless unequal respect benefits least favored in society

• Nozick connection– Civil Liberties may be enjoyed by individuals without interference

from government, unless doing so willfully injures someone else

Page 11: Issues & Policies in US Politics Module 8.1: Theories of Justice.

Through the Lens of Liberty• Freedoms of expression

– Religion

• No establishment

• Free exercise

• Religious practices unprotected if

– Practice requires legal injury

– Practice contradicts ‘overriding gov’t interest’ in public safety or health

– Peaceable Assembly & Petition

• Protected Assembly– Public demonstration– Organized Interest

Groups – Lobbying

• Unprotected Assembly– Riot– Collusion– Conspiracy– Racketeering

– Press

• Protected press– No prior restraint

» by Federal & state governments» Tribal governments may censor

press under their jurisdiction» Private sector may censor itself

– Partisan press– Investigative journalism

• Limits on press– “clear & present danger” (to national

security)– Equal time (eliminated in 1984)– Defamation

» Libel» Slander

– Speech

• Political expression

• Limits on speech– “clear & present danger”– “fighting words”– Incitement– Commercial speech

Page 12: Issues & Policies in US Politics Module 8.1: Theories of Justice.

Through the Lens of Liberty

• Private property rights– Against takings without “just compensation”

• Eminent domain– Security against unreasonable searches and seizures– Security against deprivation of life, liberty or property without due process

• Due Process restraints– Defensive silence– Security against bearing witness against oneself– Habeas corpus– Legal counsel– Speedy & public trial– Jury trial– Security against double jeopardy of life or limb – No excessive bails or fines; no cruel and unusual punishments