Top Banner
Introduction to Introduction to Contract Contract
87

Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Mar 30, 2015

Download

Documents

Alexis Bester
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Introduction to Introduction to ContractContract

Introduction to Introduction to ContractContract

Page 2: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

JOIN KHALID AZIZ• ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS,

B.COM.• FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4

ICAP MODULE B, B.COM, BBA, MBA & PIPFA.• COST ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 2,3 ICAP

MODULE D, BBA, MBA & PIPFA.

• CONTACT:• 0322-3385752• 0312-2302870• R-1173,ALNOOR SOCIETY, BLOCK 19,F.B.AREA,

KARACHI, PAKISTAN

Page 3: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Classical contract theory: 3 threads

• Contract is a bargain

• Will of parties [consensus ad idem-agreement]

• Freedom of Contract is paramount

Page 4: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Development of Contract Law: Principles

• Law of obligations [vinculum juris]

Moral obligations contractual obligations

• Law of unjust enrichment

• Law of restitution [Injurious reliance]

Page 5: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Courts in EnglandWrit of performance

Writ of debt Writ of covenant writ of deceit

Quid pro quo

Pacta sunt servanda

Page 6: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Freedom of contract ?

• ‘Contract as an instrument of free bargaining between parties on the basis of equality’

Page 7: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Freedom: Need ?• To determine the primary

obligations of parties

• To understand the inequality of bargaining power

• To understand public utilities

Page 8: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Means of contract• Formal and Informal contracts• Bilateral and Unilateral contracts

Page 9: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Contractual terms: Formation

Performance

• Contract may be oral or written. • Representation

Express Implied Intermediate terms

• Terms/ Expressed in writing

Conditions/warranties Implied by Statute terms by customary usage Standard form of

contract

Page 10: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Object of Law of contract

• To avoid litigation

• To establish set of rules for compliance

• To penalize defaulters

Page 11: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Point of Legality• Valid Contract• Void Agreements : sec. 2(g)• Voidable contracts:• Illegal contracts

Page 12: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Law of torts and Contract

• Misfeasance• Malfeasance• Nonfeasance

Page 13: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Would an action stand in Tort when the Contract is

silent• Blackpool and Fylde Aero Club v Black pool Borough

Council 1990 WLR 1195 • Reid v Rush Tompkin Group 1990: Car accident

case.• Winterbottom v Wright 1842 152 Eng Rep 402

Page 14: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Digital contractsDigital contractsDigital contractsDigital contracts

Page 15: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Issues• Conceptual framework • Rules governing e-contracts• I T 2000• Digital signature• E-auction

Page 16: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Issues in E-contract• California Software Inc v Reliability Research

Inc, 1356 [C D Cal, 1986]• Beta Computers Ltd v Adobe Systems Ltd 1996

FSR 367• TCS v State of A. P• European Commission and ‘Product liability’ • Shrink wrap• Click-Wrap

– ProCD, Inc. v. Zeidenberg, 86 F.3d 1447 (7th Cir., 1996

Page 17: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Outsourcing Contract• Issues• Sections 13, 15 and 44A of the Indian

Civil Procedure Code and Section 41 of the Indian Evidence Act, govern the conclusiveness and enforcement of foreign judgments in India

• Liability of a software developer

Page 18: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Problems with E-contract

• Taxing E-commerce • Copyright or Patent of

software ? • UK Electronic Commerce Act 2002• Limitation of Digital Contracts

Page 19: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Indian PartnershipIndian PartnershipIndian PartnershipIndian Partnership

Page 20: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Essentials of Firm• 1. Association of two or more persons• 2. In pursuance of an agreement or contract• Re Fisher and Sons 1912 2 KB 491: difference

between Co-owners and partners • 3. To combine property, labor or skill• 4. In a business

– New Mofussil Co v Rustomji 1936– Coope v Eyre 1788

• 5. Carried on by all or any one of them on behalf of all– Firm name/Property– Miles v Clarke 1953 1 ALL ER 779

• 6. With a View to share Profits• Daulat Ram v Dharm Chand AIR 1934 Lah 110

Page 21: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Minor Partner• Sec. 30(1): ‘A person who is a minor according to the law

to which he is subject may not be a partner in a firm, but with the consent of all partners for the time being, may be admitted to the benefits of partnership’

– A A Khan v Amer Karium AIR 1952 Mys 131– Lachmi Narain v Beni Ram, AIR 1931 ALL 327

• Rights of minor: Questions– Tulsi das v Gangaram AIR 1925 Sund 272– Satya Narain v Juggal Kishore AIR 1958 All 312]

• Minor’s liabilities sec. 30(3)(5)(7)(9)– Sanyasi Charan Mandal v Asutosh Ghose 1915

42 Cal 225– CIT v Vijay Kumar Rajesh

• Liability of a minor after attaining majority

Page 22: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Types of partnership• Partnership at will :

– M O H Uduman v Ashurn AIR 1991 SC 1020:

– Karumuthu Thiagarajan Chettiar v Muthappa Chettiar AIR 1961 SC 1225

• Partnership for a fixed term• Particular partnership : • Limited Partnership : • Partnership by Holding out

– Sleeping partner– Nominal partner– Working partners

Page 23: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Rights of a partner• 1. Joint ownership of partnership property• 2. Right to take part in the management [sec. 12]

– Suresh Kumar v Amrit Kumar AIR 1982 Del 131– Right to Express opinion [sec. 12 c]

Lord Fldon in Const v Harris 1824 said “for a majority of partners to say, we do not care what one partner may say, we being the majority will do what we please is what a court of equity will not allow’.

– Dismissal of a servant– New business– Blisset v Daniel 1853

• 3. Access accounts and act during emergency– Re Martindale ex Truman 1832

Page 24: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

4. Right to profit– Mansa Ram v Tej Bhan AIR 1958 Punj 5 – Delhi Veopar Mandal v IT Commissioner

AIR 1967– Dawood Sahib v Sheik Mohiuddin Sahib

AIR 1938

• 5. No claim for interest of capital

• 6. Right to indemnity sec. 13(e)– Thomas v Atherton 1877

Page 25: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Rights of partners• 6. Right not to be expelled• 7. No new partner to be introduced:

right to prevent• 8. No liability before joining unless

with consent and expressly stated in the deed

• 9. Right to retire: 3 ways

Page 26: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Nature of Liability of partners

• Joint and several: sec. 25: every partner is liable jointly with all the other partners and also severally for all acts of the firm done while he is a partner’

• Test– Benefit of the partnership– Within the scope of authority

– Malyn v John Houston 1903 1 KB 81– Moreton v Harden 1825– Citizens Life Assurance v Brown 1905– R W Pathirana v Pathirana 1967 1 AC 233

Page 27: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Nature of Implied Authority

• 1. Authority to purchase and sell– Bond v Gibson [1808]

• 2. power to recover money due to firm/ borrow money on credit: – Higgins v Beauchamp 1914 2 KR 1992:

• 3. Authority to engage lawyers• 4. Authority to insure firm goods

Page 28: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Conditions for application of Implied authority

• 1. Act must be done in the capacity of a partner: – Gouthwaite v Duckworth [1810 104 ER

174]:

• 2. Act must be done on behalf of the firm and not on personal behalf

• 3. Act must relate to activities within the scope of business

• 4. Act must be done in the firms name

Page 29: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Does implied authority vary acc/ to type of

partnership• LLP, Will the concept of mutual

agency continue ?

Page 30: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Dissolution

• Of partnership of Firm

End of the term completion of business by death/insolvency by retirement

Page 31: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Dissolution of Firm• Without Court

– By Agreement– Compulsory dissolution– Dissolution on contingency– By notice

• By Court– Persistent misconduct or disregard to

partnership agreement– Unsoundness of partners– Business at loss

– Jurisdiction of the Courts to try dissolutionMD Hassen Hashmi v Kaberi Roy AIR 1993 Cal 70

Page 32: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Winding Up• Right to continue business• Good will• Restraint of trade

Page 33: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

What is a proposal/offer

• ‘I think I like your car and will try to buy it’

• I saw an advertisement for the sale of your car, will you sell your car to me?

• ‘I am willing to buy your car for a reasonable price’.

• Are these Offer ?

Page 34: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Invitation to Treat• Advertisements: General Offer• Display of goods for sale• Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co [1893] 1 QB 256 • Harvey v Facey [1893] AC 552

– ‘Will you sell us Bumper Hall pen, telegraph at what price’

– ‘lowest price for the pen is 100’

• Powell v Lee [1908] 99 L Y 284• MC Pherson v Appanna [AIR 1951 SC 184]

– ‘wont accept less than 10,000’.

Page 35: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Modes of Offer

• Time table

• Tenders and Auctions [Harris v Nickerson]

• Restaurant menu card

• ATM or vending machines

Page 36: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Offer: Communication• Gibbons v Proctor 1891 64 LTN S 594 [Reward

for a criminal]• Lalman Sukla v Gouri Dutt 1913ALJ 4891

[Missing boys case]• Tim v Hoffman 1873, 29 L T 271: cross offer is

no offer

• Counter Offer• Proposal must be made to another person

Page 37: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Termination of Offer• ‘An offer can be withdrawn at any time

before it is accepted’.• Distinction between lapse of offer and

revocation• Notice, Death, incapacity, lapse of time • Errington v Errington [1952] Father promises

to son and daughter in law that if they pay mortgage amount

of the property, the property would be theirs

Page 38: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Acceptance• Acceptance must be in toto: Mirror Image Rule • Manner/mode of acceptance [sec. 7]

By an act promise• Is Silence an acceptance ?

– Felthouse v Bindley 1862 11 CB 869.: Uncle tells his nephew– ‘If I hear no more from you, the horse in mine’.– The nephew during an auction stated to the auctioneer to reserve the

horse for his uncle• Silence and thereafter a ‘conduct’ of acceptance ?

– LIC of India v Vasireddy AIR 1984 SC 1014– 27th Dec. 1960 filing of proposal for LIC– Proposer died on 12th Jan 1961

• Can Acceptance be revoked ?

Page 39: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Acceptance: contd• Is Communication of Acceptance essential?• Acceptance through post: Mailbox rule

– Adams v Lindsell [1818 1 B& Ald. 681.- 2/9/1817, defendants offered to sell a quantity of wool at a

certain price and expected the answer by post, the letter reached the plaintiff on 5th, the same day, he posted the acceptance, which reached the defendants on 9th.

- The defendants waited till 7th and on 8th sold the same wool to another person

- Is there an acceptance ?

• Who can communicate the acceptance ?• When is a unilateral contract accepted ?

Page 40: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

When does the mailbox rule apply?

• Q. Is revocation of acceptance possible ?

• Henthorn v Fraser 1892– Secretary signed a note giving option to purchase for 14

days at P-750, next day withdraws through post at 12-1.00 pm, claimant posts the acceptance on the same day between 3-4 pm.

• Which ever communication reaches first is valid

Page 41: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Offer and Acceptance: Where the contract is

made?• It determines the time of forming the

contract• It stipulates the jurisdiction of the

court; and • It affixes the rights and obligations of

parties

• Is the contract complete at the instance and place of the acceptor or offeror?

Page 42: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Invitation to Treat• Advertisements: General Offer• Display of goods for sale• Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co [1893] 1 QB 256 • Harvey v Facey [1893] AC 552

– ‘Will you sell us Bumper Hall pen, telegraph at what price’

– ‘lowest price for the pen is 100’

• Powell v Lee [1908] 99 L Y 284• MC Pherson v Appanna [AIR 1951 SC 184]

– ‘wont accept less than 10,000’.

Page 43: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Modes of Offer

• Time table

• Tenders and Auctions [Harris v Nickerson]

• Restaurant menu card

• ATM or vending machines

Page 44: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Termination of Offer• ‘An offer can be withdrawn at any time

before it is accepted’.• Distinction between lapse of offer and

revocation• Notice, Death, incapacity, lapse of time • Errington v Errington [1952] Father promises

to son and daughter in law that if they pay mortgage amount

of the property, the property would be theirs

Page 45: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Acceptance• Acceptance must be in toto: Mirror Image Rule • Manner/mode of acceptance [sec. 7]

By an act promise• Is Silence an acceptance ?

– Felthouse v Bindley 1862 11 CB 869.: Uncle tells his nephew– ‘If I hear no more from you, the horse in mine’.– The nephew during an auction stated to the auctioneer to reserve the

horse for his uncle• Silence and thereafter a ‘conduct’ of acceptance ?

– LIC of India v Vasireddy AIR 1984 SC 1014– 27th Dec. 1960 filing of proposal for LIC– Proposer died on 12th Jan 1961

• Can Acceptance be revoked ?

Page 46: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Acceptance: contd• Is Communication of Acceptance essential?• Acceptance through post: Mailbox rule

– Adams v Lindsell [1818 1 B& Ald. 681.- 2/9/1817, defendants offered to sell a quantity of wool at a

certain price and expected the answer by post, the letter reached the plaintiff on 5th, the same day, he posted the acceptance, which reached the defendants on 9th.

- The defendants waited till 7th and on 8th sold the same wool to another person

- Is there an acceptance ?

• Who can communicate the acceptance ?• When is a unilateral contract accepted ?

Page 47: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

When does the mailbox rule apply?

• Q. Is revocation of acceptance possible ?

• Henthorn v Fraser 1892– Secretary signed a note giving option to purchase for 14

days at P-750, next day withdraws through post at 12-1.00 pm, claimant posts the acceptance on the same day between 3-4 pm.

• Which ever communication reaches first is valid

Page 48: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Offer and Acceptance: Where the contract is

made?• It determines the time of forming the

contract• It stipulates the jurisdiction of the

court; and • It affixes the rights and obligations of

parties

• Is the contract complete at the instance and place of the acceptor or offeror?

Page 49: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Chapter-3: Capacity to Contract

• Two kind of ‘persons’– Natural– Legal or juristic person

• Natural Person

Latent incapacity patent incapacity[infancy, unsoundness, lunacy] [B’cos of Status:

insolvency, alien enemy, Married]

Page 50: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Legal person

• Ultra vires winding up any other

Acts of sovereign, Corporate and companies

Page 51: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Liability of Minors in Contract

• Sec. 68: ‘if a person, incapable of entering into a contract is supplied with necessaries in life, the person who supplies is entitled to be reimbursed’

• Doyle v White City Stadium 1935 1 KB 110,

Page 52: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Insanity/lunacy• Inder Singh v Parmeshardhni

Singh AIR 1957 Pat. 49• Mathews v Baxter [1873, L R 8 Ex.

132]

Page 53: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Other Incapacities• Political Status

– Alien enemy– Foreign sovereigns and ambassadors

• Mighell v Sultan of Johore [1894, 1 QB 149] • [Also see sec. 86 of CPC which provides that in case of suit

against a foreign sovereign, the consent of the Central Govt is required]

• Corporation– Ashbury Railways Carriage Co. V Riche 1875, 7 HL

653. [an agreement for purchase of railways which was not mentioned in the MOA was held ultra vires]

– Q. Does Ultra vires means void contract ? Are third parties protected from such ultra vires acts ?

Page 54: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Other Incapacities• Married Status• Professional status: can an advocate

sue in contract, his client for fee ?

Page 55: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Chapter 4: Consideration

• Sec. 10 requires Lawful consideration as an essential factor for giving enforceability to an agreement.

• Sec. 25 an agreement without consideration is void [nudum pactum]

• Sec. 23 and 24 deal with circumstances in which the consideration will be treated unlawful

Page 56: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

What is consideration• Money [need not be adequate]• An act, abstinence or promise• Must be real [White v Bluett] • Performance of a legal duty is no

consideration

Page 57: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Why Consideration ?• Consideration only at the desire of the promisor

– Durga Prasad v Baldeo [Building a market place at the order of the Collector, Defendants, a tenant made a promise to pay, later refused, was held not liable to pay]

• Consideration by the promisee or any other person– Chinnaya v Ramaya [old lady granted an estate to the daughter

with a direction that the daughter should pay an annuity of Rs 653 to the lady’s brother. On the same day the daughter executed a promise to pay to the mother’s brother Rs 653. She failed and claimed that the brother had not given any consideration. Held: consideration by the mother is enough consideration]

• Consideration may be Past, Present or Future• Privity of contract

– A person may not give any consideration, but is a party to the contract may enforce the contract

– A stranger to a contract cannot sue : Suppose A and B enter into a contract for the benefit of C. The agreement between and A and B cannot be enforced by C.

– Tweddle v Atksinson : two father entered into an agreement to pay a new couple money on their marriage. The couple cannot sue for enforcement of the contract between the fathers.

Page 58: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Exceptions• Law of Trust/ Insurance

– Klause Mittelbachert v East India Hotels [pilot, head injuries during a dive at the swimming pool, contract between Lufthansa and hotel Oberoi, can the pilot claim damages, though the consideration was not moving from him ?]

• Conduct, Acknowledgment or Admission– Narayani Devi v Tagore Commercial Corporation [If the

defendants start the payment and then withdraws]• Provision for marriage expenses or maintenance under

family arrangement/– Veeramma v Appayya [daughter agreed to take care of the

father for which the father promised to convey property to her. Later when the father refused, the daughter sued successfully.

– Sundaraja Aiyangar v Lakshmiammal [partition deed between brothers to provide for marriage expenses of the sister, is enforceable by the sister]

• Subscription for a charitable purpose– Kedar Nath v Gorie Mahomed

Page 59: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Doctrine of Promissory Estoppel

• Central London Property trust Ltd V High Trees House Ltd 1947 KB 130.

• Rule in Pinnel Case [promise to pay less than the due amount] – D&C Builders v Rees 1966 2 QB 617– M P Sugar Mills v State of U PAIR 1979 SC 621

• Forbearance to sue is good consideration

Page 60: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

When Agreement without consideration is valid

• Natural love and affection• Compensation for past voluntary

services• Promise to pay a time barred debt• Creation of Agency does not

require consideration

Page 61: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Free Consent• Coercion: committing or threatening to

commit an act forbidden by IPC– Ranganayakamma v Alwar Setti [Adoption of son

by a widow]– Chikkan Ammiraju v Chikkam Seshama [Threat to

commit suicide]

• Economic duress– B& S Contracts & Designs v Victor Green Publications Ltd

1984 ICR 419 [erecting a stand, contractor claimed labour strike and increased amount]

Page 62: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Undue Influence: a Specie of fraud

• Taking of unfair advantage [sec. 16]• Misuse of influence• Abuse of trust and confidence• Connotation of impropriety

Classes of undue influence

Actual presumed undue influence

Based on proof

Page 63: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

What constitute undue influence

• Relationship of parties is such that one party is in a position to dominate the will of the other.

Real and apparent authority fiduciary relationship mental capacity, age, illness

• The party in the dominating position uses that position to obtain an unfair advantage

Page 64: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Presumption of undue influence: position of domination

• Parent and child• Guardian and ward• Trustee and beneficiary• Solicitor and client• Doctor and patient• Spiritual adviser and disciple

• The list does not include husband and wife nor does it include principal and agent, banker and customer or teacher and student

Page 65: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Illustration• Tate v Williamson 1866 LR 2 Ch.

App 55• Allcard v Skinner 1887 36 Ch.d

145

Page 66: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Rebutting the presumption of undue

influence• Whether the victim had independent and qualified

advise ?– Solicitors must give fair and disinterested advise– He must ensure that the decision of his client is proper and

to his benefit

• The victim understood the nature and consequences of the transaction ?– Disclosure of material facts

• Whether he was able to arrive at independent and informed decision/judgment.– Objective and conduct of parties

Page 67: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Fraud• False statement of facts• Mere silence is no fraud

– Duty to speak by law• P Sarojam v LIC [aliments were not disclosed in

the form]• Rajinder Singh v Pomilla [premartial status of a

party was a material fact]

– Active concealment• Shri Krishna v Kurukshetra University

Page 68: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Misrepresentation

• Fraudulent Negligent Innocent

Rescind claim damages[tort] no claim

Page 69: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Misrepresentation

Conditions [sec 12 (2) of the Sale of goods Act] Warranties

• A representation is a statement made at the time of the contract by way of affirmation, denial or description or presentation of a material fact to contract.

• It is more than the intention of parties and different from opinion– Smith v Land & House Property Corp (1884) 28 Ch D 7– The plaintiff put up his hotel for sale stating that it was let to a 'most desirable

tenant'. The defendants agreed to buy the hotel. The tenant was bankrupt. As a result, the defendants refused to complete the contract and were sued by the plaintiff for specific performance. The Court of Appeal held that the plaintiff's statement was not mere opinion, but was one of fact.

Page 70: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Representation• Must relate to fact and not law• Must relate to Fact and promise• There must be a representation or assertion• It must be made with the knowledge that it is false or without

belief in its truth• It must be acted upon• Damages must be suffered: No fraud no damages [sec. 17 read

with sec. 19 of ICA]

• Ex: Prospectus of a company• Sec. 55 of the TP Act requires the seller of immovable propery

to disclose to the buyer material defects in the property

Page 71: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Implied representation• Spice Girls v Aprilia World Service BV 2002 Ch D

– A entered an contract for endorsing product [scooter] with Spice Girls [a group of 5]. Within two weeks, ‘Ginger spice’ left the group, making the product vulnerable in the market. The Pop group did not disclose this to the Agency.

– Was the group split before endorsement ?– Was there an intention to split ? – Was there a misrepresentation that the group was together ?

– Held misrepresentation. [Carbolic smoke ball company]

Page 72: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Void agreementsVoid agreementsVoid agreementsVoid agreements

Page 73: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Mistake

Of Law Of Fact

Of ordinary law of foreign law of pvt rights

As to nature of contract as to persons contracted with as to subject matter

Page 74: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Mistake• 1. Mistake when there is no consensus ad idem

[Raffles v Wichelhuas 1864 ]• 2. Mistake as to a matter of fact essential to the

agreement– [sec. 20] Ayekam Angahal Singh v UOI Air 1970

• 3. Mistake of Law – Lakshman Prasad and Sons v Achuthan Nair AIR 1955 Mad

652

• 4. Mistake on subject matter: – Leaf v International Galleries [1950] 1 All ER 693

• 5. Mistake as to possibility of performance of the contract – Sheikh Bros v Ochsner 1957 AC 136 ---- Griffith v

Brymer (1903) 19 TLR 434• 6. Mistake as to identity of parties

– Boulton v Jones 1857--- Said v Butt 1920

Page 75: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Mistake: New developments

• Contract made inter praesentes – Phillips v Brooks 1919 – Ingram v Little [1960] 3 All ER 332

– Bell v Lever Bros Ltd. [1932 AC 161]

• Plea of ‘Non est factum’– Dularia Devi v Janardan Singh AIR

1990 SC 1173

Page 76: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Legality of object and Consideration

• 1. It is forbidden by law – Universal Plast Ltd v Santosh Kumar AIR 1985

• 2. Defeat the provision of any law – Ram Sewak v Ram AIR 1962 All 177 -Abdul Piojkhan Nabab v Hussenbi 1904

• 3. Injurious to person or property – Gurmukh Singh v Amar Singh 1991 2 SCC 79

• 4. Agreement Injurious to public policy – Sukha v Ninni AIR 1966 - Punnakotiah v Kallapalli Kolikamba AIR

1967 AP --- Mewa Ram v Ram Gopal ILR 1926• 5. Immoral

– Pearce v Brooks 1866-- Bai Viji v Nansa Nagar 1885 ----Narayani v Pyare Mohan AIR 1927

• 6. Agreement opposed to public policy Sec. 23– Trading with an enemy– Trafficking in public offices– Interference with the administration of justice– Marriage brokerage contracts: Herman v Charlesworth 1905 2 KB

123

Page 77: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Void Agreements• 1. Agreement in restraint of marriage: sec. 26

– Rao Rani v Gulab Rani AIR 1942• 2. Agreement in restraint of trade [sec. 27]

– Herbert Morris Ltd Saxelby 1916– Nordenfelt v Maxim Nordenfelt Guns and Ammunition Co

1894– Gujarat Bottling Co v Coca Cola Company Air 1995 SC 2372

• Exception to an agreement in restraint of trade– 1. Sale of Good will– 2. Exception under Indian Partnership Act– 3. Restraint by a contract of service [employment]

• Niranjan Shankar v Century Spinning and Manufacturing Co AIR 1967

• 4. Trade combinations– Sheikh Kalu v Ram Sharan Bhagat 1909 13 CNN 388

• 5. Agreement in restraint of legal proceedings: sec. 28– Ghose v Reliance Insurance Co 1934

• 6. Wagering Contracts

Page 78: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Quasi Contracts• 1. Claim for necessaries supplied to a person

incompetent to contract [sec. 68]• 2. Reimbursement of money paid due by another

– Exall v Patridge 1799 – Bansidhar Joshi v Chandrakumar AIR 1964 All 348

• 3. Obligation of person enjoying benefit of non-gratuitous act: [sec. 70]– Indu Mehta v State of UP AIR 1987 ALL 309

• 4. Enjoyment of benefit by the defendant is necessary:– P C Wadhwa v State of Punjab AIR 1987 PH 117

• 5. Finder of Lost goods: sec. 71

Page 79: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Discharges/ Remedies under Law of Contract

• 1. Performance of contract• 2. Quantum meruit

Page 80: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Performance of Contract

• Every such offer must fulfill the following conditions:-• 1) it must be unconditional

– Navin Chandra v Yogendra Nath

• 2) it must be made at a proper time and place– Start-up v Macdonald 1843

• 3) under such circumstances that the person to whom it is made may have a reasonable opportunity for inspection– Performance on death of a party– Performance by the promisor or his agent or representatives.

• 4) An offer to one of several joint promisees has the same legal consequences as an offer to all of them.

Page 81: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Remedies for Breach Remedies for Breach of Contractof Contract

Remedies for Breach Remedies for Breach of Contractof Contract

Page 82: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

The Law• Indian Contract Act 1872• Specific Relief Act • Law of obligation

– Law of Unjust enrichment– Law of Restitution

Page 83: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Plea• Non est factum

– Gallie v Lee

• Specific Performance/substantial performance – Dakin v Lee

• When ‘time’ is the essence of the contract: Right to rescind the contract– R K Saxena v Delhi Development Authority AIR 2002 SC 2340

• Impossibility of Performance– Taylor v Caldwell (1863) 3 B&S 826

• Doctrine of Frustation– Arti Sukhdev Kashyap v Daya Kishore Arora AIR 1994

Page 84: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Discharge of Contract• Bilateral discharge

– Accord and satisfaction– RESCISSION AND SUBSTITUTION and

Novation– VARIATION– WAIVER

Page 85: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Breach of contract• Anticipatory breach

– Hochster v De La Tour

• Liability of loss only due to CAUSATION [carpenter left the door unlocked]

• Remoteness of damages

• Mitigation of loss

Page 86: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

Breach• Rectification and cancellation of

Instrument• Damages

– Nominal– Penalty

• Injunction– Temporary– Permanent

Page 87: Introduction to Contract. JOIN KHALID AZIZ ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS, B.COM. FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4 ICAP MODULE B, B.COM,

JOIN KHALID AZIZ• ECONOMICS OF ICMAP, ICAP, MA-ECONOMICS,

B.COM.• FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 1,3,4

ICAP MODULE B, B.COM, BBA, MBA & PIPFA.• COST ACCOUNTING OF ICMAP STAGE 2,3 ICAP

MODULE D, BBA, MBA & PIPFA.

• CONTACT:• 0322-3385752• 0312-2302870• R-1173,ALNOOR SOCIETY, BLOCK 19,F.B.AREA,

KARACHI, PAKISTAN