Top Banner

of 61

Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

Apr 04, 2018

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    1/61

    4

    YC@]IM Q]D]IQ M@Q]U@A] AKYU]

    HKU ]GI M@Q]U@A] KH AKFYBE@D

    Q]D]I CD]@KCDF EDCL KH E@NQZU@CN i} df#&

    Zfd`c}`hhq&

    x#

    ]@BK]GP NI@]GCIU& `c g`q khh`a`dfadzda`}p dq Yc`}im Q}d}iq Qiaui}dup kh }gi

    ]uidqyup dcm iw khh`a`k Agd`ubdc kh }gi

    H`cdca`df Q}de`f`}p Kxiuq`ng} Akyca`f& i} df#&

    Mihicmdc}q#

    ))

    )))

    )

    )

    ))

    )

    ))

    )

    Adqi Ck# 4?45"ax":4:15 'IQG)

    MIHICMDC]Q BK]@KC ]K M@QB@QQ ]GI DBICMIM AKBZFD@C]

    ZYUQYDC] ]K HIMIUDF UYFI KH A@X@F ZUKAIMYUI 45'e)'4)

    Zyuqydc} }k Himiudf Uyfi kh A`x`f Zukaimyui 45'e)'4)& Mihicmdc}q giuiep bkxi }g`q Akyu}

    }k m`qb`qq }gi Dbicmim Akbzfd`c}# D eu`ih `c qyzzku} kh }g`q bk}`kc dcm d zukzkqim kumiu dui

    qyeb`}}im giui~`}g#

    Kh Akycqif?

    AGU@Q]KZGIU O# BIDMIDa}`cn Niciudf Akycqif

    Y#Q# Mizdu}bic} kh }gi ]uidqyup

    49:: Ziccqpfxdc`d Dxi# C^^dqg`cn}kc& MA 5:55:

    BIUIM@]G HYAGQNiciudf Akycqif

    ]K"TYPIC ]UYKCN

    Mizy}p Niciudf Akycqif

    MDX@M B# NKQQI]]Dqq`q}dc} Niciudf Akycqif

    UDAGIF UKMBDC

    OKGC U# AKFIBDCQic`ku Akycqif

    Akcqybiu H`cdca`df Zuk}ia}`kc Eyuidy

    Uiqzia}hyffp qyeb`}}im&

    Q]YDU] H# MIFIUP

    Zu`ca`zdf Mizy}p Dqq`q}dc} D}}kucip Niciudf

    UKCDFM A# BDAGIC OU#

    Yc`}im Q}d}iq D}}kucip

    @DC GID]G NIUQGICNKUC

    Mizy}p Dqq`q}dc} D}}kucip Niciudf

    QYQDC L# UYMP

    Dqq`q}dc} M`uia}kuHimiudf Zuknudbq Eudcag

    q+ ^icmp B# Mk}p

    ^ICMP B# MK]P& MA Edu Ck# =0:557

    EUDMFIP G# AKGIC& MA Edu Ck# =094=9

    I]GDC Z# MDX@Q& CP Edu

    ]u`df D}}kucipq

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 4 kh =

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    2/61

    5

    4>:: N Q}# C^^dqg`cn}kc& MA 5:995

    LD]GIU@CI G# ^GID]FIPDqqka`d}i Niciudf Akycqif

    OKQGYD Z# AGDM^@ALAkycqifEkdum kh Nkxiuckuq kh }gi Himiudf Uiqiuxi

    Qpq}ib

    5:}g dcm A Q}uii}q C^

    ^dqg`cn}kc& MA 5:994

    AKFFIIC O# EKFIQ

    Da}`cn Mizy}p Niciudf AkycqifLD]GUPC U# CKUAUKQQ

    Da}`cn Dqq`q}dc} Niciudf Akycqif

    EDUEDUD QDUQG@LQic`ku Akycqif

    DCMUI^ MKEIU

    Akycqif

    Himiudf Mizkq`} @cqyudcai Akuzkud}`kc19:4 Hd`uhdw Mu#& XQ"M>4>8

    Duf`cn}kc& XD 55558"19::

    MDC@IF Z# Q]@ZDCK

    Da}`cn Ag`ih AkycqifNUINKUP H# ]DPFKU

    ADUKF@CI Q]DZFI]KC

    NDEU@IF G@CM@CD}}kucipq& F`}`nd}`kc M`x`q`kc

    Khh`ai kh }gi Akbz}ukffiu kh }gi Ayuuicap

    59: I Q}# Q^^dqg`cn}kc& MA 5:540

    B@AGDIF D# AKCFIP

    Mizy}p Niciudf AkycqifODAKE G# Q]@FFBDC

    Qkf`a`}ku

    ^@FF@DB L# QG@UIPQic`ku F`}`nd}`kc Akycqif

    Khh`ai kh Niciudf Akycqif

    Qiayu`}`iq dcm Iwagdcni Akbb`qq`kc4:: H Q}# CI

    ^dqg`cn}kc& MA 5:9=0

    DODP E QY]DU@D

    Himiudf Zuknudbq Eudcag

    Y#Q# Mizdu}bic} kh Oyq}`ai& A`x`f M`x`q`kc

    5: Bdqqdagyqi}}q Dxi# C^& Ub# >547

    ^dqg`cn}kc& MA 5:91:

    ]ifizgkci? '5:5) 848">=5:

    Hdw? '5:5) 848"7=>:Ibd`f? ~icmp#mk}pJyqmko#nkx

    Akycqif hku Mihicmdc}q

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 5 kh =

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    3/61

    1

    AkycqifKhh`ai kh Niciudf Akycqif

    Akbbkm`}p Hy}yuiq ]udm`cn Akbb`qq`kc

    ]guii Fdhdpi}}i Aic}ui4499 54q} Q}# C^

    ^dqg`cn}kc& MA 5:974

    OKGC L# @DCCK

    Qic`ku Dqqka`d}i Niciudf Akycqif

    NIUDUM Q# ZKF@TY@C

    ]u`df D}}kucipKhh`ai kh Niciudf Akycqif

    Cd}`kcdf Auim`} Yc`kc Dmb`c`q}ud}`kc

    4>>9 Myli Q}#Dfiwdcmu`d& XD 5514=

    Md}im? Ckxibeiu 5:& 5:45

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 1 kh =

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    4/61

    =

    AIU]@H@AD]I KH QIUX@AI

    @ giuiep aiu}`hp }gd} kc Ckxibeiu 5:& 5:45& d akzp kh }gi hkuink`cn mkaybic} ~dq h`fim

    ifia}ukc`adffp x`d }gi Akyu}q IAH qpq}ib& }gukyng ~g`ag d ck}`ai kh }gi h`f`cn ~`ff ei qic} }k dff

    akycqif kh uiakum#

    q+ ^icmp B# Mk}p

    ^ICMP B# MK]P

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni = kh =

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    5/61

    `

    YC@]IM Q]D]IQ M@Q]U@A] AKYU]

    HKU ]GI M@Q]U@A] KH AKFYBE@D

    Q]D]I CD]@KCDF EDCL KH E@NQZU@CN i} df#&

    Zfd`c}`hhq&

    x#

    ]@BK]GP NI@]GCIU& `c g`q khh`a`dfadzda`}p dq Yc`}im Q}d}iq Qiaui}dup kh }gi]uidqyup dcm iw khh`a`k Agd`ubdc kh }giH`cdca`df Q}de`f`}p Kxiuq`ng} Akyca`f& i} df#&

    Mihicmdc}q#

    ))

    )))))))))))

    Adqi Ck# 4?45"ax":4:15 'IQG)

    [[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[

    BIBKUDCMYB @C QYZZKU] KH MIHICMDC]Q

    BK]@KC ]K M@QB@QQ ]GI DBICMIM AKBZFD@C]

    ZYUQYDC] ]K HIMIUDF UYFI KH A@X@F ZUKAIMYUI 45'e)'4)

    [[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 4 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    6/61

    ``

    ]DEFI KH AKC]IC]Q

    @C]UKMYA]@KC ########################################################################################################################## 4Q]D]Y]KUP DCM UINYFD]KUP HUDBI^KUL? ]GI MKMM"HUDCL DA] ################# 9

    @# ]GI AKCQYBIU H@CDCA@DF ZUK]IA]@KC EYUIDY ################################## 8D# IQ]DEF@QGBIC] DCM FIDMIUQG@Z ############################################################################### 8E# ]GIEYUIDYQ UINYFD]KUPDY]GKU@]P################################################################### >A# ]GIEYUIDYQ QYZIUX@QKUP DCM ICHKUAIBIC] DY]GKU@]P################################# 7

    @@# ]GI H@CDCA@DF Q]DE@F@]P KXIUQ@NG] AKYCA@F #################################### 0@@@# ]GI KUMIUFP F@TY@MD]@KC DY]GKU@]P ################################################## 45

    ZUKAIMYUDF EDALNUKYCM ############################################################################################### 4=Q]DCMDUM KH UIX@I^ ########################################################################################################## 49DUNYBIC] ################################################################################################################################ 49

    @# CKCI KH ]GI ZFD@C]@HHQ GDQ Q]DCM@CN# ################################################ 49D# ZFD@C]@HH Q]D]I CD]@KCDFEDCL KH E@NQZU@CN? AKYC] @# ################################## 48

    4# QCEq Zyuzku}im Hidu kh d Hy}yui Ichkuaibic} Da}`kc Mkiq Ck}Akcq}`}y}i dc @coyup `c Hda}# ############################################################### 4>

    5#

    ]gi Eyuidyq Uib`}}dcai ]udcqhiu Uyfi Mkiq Ck} Akcq}`}y}i dc@coyup `c Hda} Hd`ufp ]udaidefi }k }gi Agdfficnim Zukx`q`kcq kh }gi

    Da}# ###################################################################################################### 55E# ZFD@C]@HH Q]D]I CD]@KCDFEDCL KH E@NQZU@CN? AKYC] @@# ################################# 5>A# ZFD@C]@HH Q]D]I CD]@KCDFEDCL KH E@NQZU@CN? AKYC] @@@# ############################### 50

    4# QCE Qziayfd}iq }gd} Kci kh @}q M`uia} Akbzi}`}kuq ^`ff EiMiq`ncd}im d Q@H@# ############################################################################## 14

    5# QCE Qziayfd}iq }gd} Auim`}kuq ^`ff Uida} }k d Akyca`f Miq`ncd}`kcep Zukx`m`cn Adz`}df }k }gi Miq`ncd}im Ic}`}p kc Bkui Hdxkudefi

    ]iubq################################################################################################### 111# QCE Qziayfd}iq }gd} d Q@H@ Miq`ncd}`kc ^`ff Uiqyf} `c dc Kxiudff

    Akbzi}`}`xi Dmxdc}dni }k }gi Miq`ncd}im Ic}`}p# ############################## 18M# ZFD@C]@HH Q]D]I CD]@KCDFEDCL KH E@NQZU@CN? AKYC]Q @X&X&DCMX@# ########### 17

    I# ZFD@C]@HHQ8:ZFYQDQQKA@D]@KC DCMAKBZI]@]@XI IC]IUZU@QI@CQ]@]Y]I?AKYC]Q @]GUKYNG X@# ############################################################################################## 10

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 5 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    7/61

    ```

    H# ZFD@C]@HHQB@AG@NDC&KLFDGKBD&DCM QKY]G ADUKF@CD? AKYC]Q @X&X&DCMX@# ######################################################################################################################### =5

    4# ]gi Q}d}iq Qziayfd}i }gd} Kci kh }gi H`cdca`df Akbzdc`iq kh^g`ag ]gi`u Zicq`kc Hycmq Dui Dffinimfp Auim`}kuq ^`ff Hd`f# ######## =1

    5# ]gi Q}d}iq Qziayfd}i }gd} Kci kh }gi H`cdca`df Akbzdc`iq kh^g`ag ]gi`u Zicq`kc Hycmq Dui Dffinimfp Auim`}kuq ^`ff Ei

    Qyeoia} }k ]`}fi @@################################################################################# ==1# ]gi Q}d}iq Qziayfd}i }gd} ]gi`u Zicq`kc Hycmq ^`ff Qyhhiu dc

    @coyup Hfk~`cn Hukb ]`}fi @@############################################################### =8@@# ZFD@C]@HHQ AFD@BQ DUI CK] U@ZI# ############################################################ =7

    AKCAFYQ@KC ############################################################################################################################# 9:

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 1 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    8/61

    4

    @C]UKMYA]@KC

    ]g`q fd~qy`} akeefiq }kni}giu dc duudp kh m`qzdud}i agdfficniq }k }gi akcq}`}y}`kcdf`}p kh

    }guii }`}fiq kh dc da} kh Akcnuiqq dcm }gi akcq}`}y}`kcdf`}p kh }gi Zuiq`mic}q dzzk`c}bic} kh dc

    iwiay}`xi khh`aiu# Miqz`}i }gi ukx`cn dffind}`kcq kh ycakcq}`}y}`kcdf`}p qi} hku}g c }gi Dbicmim

    Akbzfd`c}& ck} kci kh }gi q}d}y}ku`fp dy}gku`im da}`kcq }gd} Zfd`c}`hhq qziayfd}i b`ng} qkbimdp

    adyqi }gib gdub gdq pi} kaayuuim# Dq qyag& idag kh }gi Zfd`c}`hhq xdu`kyq afd`bq kh `coyup hdffq

    hdu qgku} kh }gi `bb`cic}& ckc"akcoia}yudf `coyup uity`uim }k mibkcq}ud}i Du}`afi @@@ q}dcm`cn

    dcm& hku q`b`fdu uidqkcq& idag kh }gi`u afd`bq `q ycu`zi#

    Zfd`c}`hhq dui d akbbyc`}p edcl& }~k dmxkadap kundc`d}`kcq& dcm }guii Q}d}iq# ]gip

    agdfficni }gi akcq}`}y}`kcdf`}p kh byf}`zfi zukx`q`kcq kh }gi Mkmm"Hudcl ^dff Q}uii} Uihkub dcm

    Akcqybiu Zuk}ia}`kc Da}& Zye F# Ck# 444"5:1& 45= Q}d}# 41>8 '5:4:) 'Mkmm"Hudcl ku Da})#

    @c zdu}`ayfdu& }gi edcl dcm dmxkadap kundc`d}`kcq afd`b }gd} }gi dy}gku`}p nudc}im }k }gi

    Akcqybiu H`cdca`df Zuk}ia}`kc Eyuidy 'AHZE ku Eyuidy) }k `mic}`hp ychd`u& miaiz}`xi& ku

    deyq`xi da}q ku zuda}`aiq 'YMDDZq) dcm }gi dy}gku`}p nudc}im }k }gi H`cdca`df Q}de`f`}p

    Kxiuq`ng} Akyca`f 'HQKA ku Akyca`f) }k qyeoia} aiu}d`c ckcedcl h`cdca`df akbzdc`iq }k

    bkui q}u`cnic} himiudf uinyfd}`kc dui ycakcq}ud`cim ep bidc`cnhyf agialq dcm edfdcaiq& `c

    x`kfd}`kc kh }gi qizdud}`kc kh zk~iuq 'Akyc}q @ dcm @@@& uiqzia}`xifp)# Dff kh }gi Zfd`c}`hhq afd`b

    }gd} }gi zukx`q`kcq kh Mkmm"Hudcl dffk~`cn hku }gi kumiufp f`ty`md}`kc kh hd`f`cn h`cdca`df

    akbzdc`iq x`kfd}i }gi akcq}`}y}`kcdf qizdud}`kc kh zk~iuq& myi zukaiqq& dcm uity`uibic} hku

    yc`hkub`}p `c edcluyz}ap 'Akyc}q @X& X& dcm X@)# H`cdffp& }gi edcl dcm dmxkadap kundc`d}`kcq

    afd`b }gd} }gi Zuiq`mic}q dzzk`c}bic} kh U`agdum Akumudp dq M`uia}ku kh }gi Eyuidy ~dq `cxdf`m

    ycmiu }gi Uiaiqq Dzzk`c}bic}q Afdyqi eiadyqi }gi Qicd}i dffinimfp ~dq ck} `c uiaiqq d} }gi }`bi

    kh }gi dzzk`c}bic} 'Akyc} @@)#

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni = kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    9/61

    5

    Zfd`c}`hh Q}d}i Cd}`kcdf Edcl kh E`n Qzu`cn 'QCE) fdalq q}dcm`cn# Dq }k Akyc}q @ dcm

    @@& QCE h`uq} afd`bq }gd} }gi Eyuidyq dy}gku`}p }k ichkuai Mkmm"Hudclq zukg`e`}`kc kc YMDDZq

    gdq auid}im d ag`ff`cn ihhia} kc `}q akcqybiu ficm`cn zuda}`aiq }gd} adyqim QCE }k iw`} }gi

    bku}ndni ficm`cn eyq`ciqq `c Ka}keiu 5:4:# Ey} }gi Eyuidy gdq ck dy}gku`}p }k ichkuai }gi

    YMDDZ zukg`e`}`kc dnd`cq} QCE# QCEq qyziux`qku& }gi Khh`ai kh }gi Akbz}ukffiu kh }gi

    Ayuuicap 'KAA)& gdq iwafyq`xi dy}gku`}p }k ichkuai QCEq akbzf`dcai ~`}g }gi YMDDZ

    zukg`e`}`kc# Dq }k QCE& }gi Eyuidyq ichkuaibic} dy}gku`}p `q f`b`}im }k bdl`cn

    uiakbbicmd}`kcq }k KAA< ck} kcfp `q KAA huii }k daaiz} ku uioia} qyag uiakbbicmd}`kcq 'dcm

    }k `c`}`d}i ichkuaibic} da}`kcq ~`}gky} d Eyuidy uiakbbicmd}`kc)& ey} QCE gdq hd`fim }k dffini

    }gd} dcp qyag uiakbbicmd}`kc ep }gi Eyuidy gdq kaayuuim ku `q `bb`cic}# Dcm& `c dcp ixic}&

    m`q}u`a} akyu}q dui eduuim hukb ic}iu}d`c`cn zui"ichkuaibic} agdfficniq dnd`cq} }gi KAA#

    Akcqityic}fp& QCEq mizdu}yui hukb }gi bku}ndni ficm`cn `cmyq}up& dffinimfp `c hidu kh qkbi

    yc`mic}`h`im hy}yui ichkuaibic} da}`kc& ~dq d xkfyc}dup mia`q`kc }gd} mkiq ck} akchiu q}dcm`cn#

    QCEq afd`b }gd} `} q}kzzim zukx`m`cn uib`}}dcai }udcqhiuq myi }k d ck}"pi}"ihhia}`xi

    Eyuidy uinyfd}`kc `bzkq`cn m`qafkqyui uity`uibic}q kc aiu}d`c zukx`miuq kh uib`}}dcai }udcqhiuq

    dfqk hd`fq }k qyzzku} `}q q}dcm`cn }k eu`cn Akyc}q @ ku @@# Dq dc `c`}`df bd}}iu& QCE gdq hd`fim }k

    dffini qyhh`a`ic} hda}q mibkcq}ud}`cn }gd} `} ~`ff ei qyeoia} }k }gi uinyfd}`kc& ~g`ag dzzf`iq kcfp

    }k }gkqi h`cdca`df `cq}`}y}`kcq }gd} zukx`mi uib`}}dcai }udcqhiuq `c }gi ckubdf akyuqi kh }gi`u

    eyq`ciqq# Ey} ixic `h QCE akyfm mibkcq}ud}i }gd} `} ~`ff ei qyeoia} }k }gi uinyfd}`kc& }gd}

    uinyfd}`kc ~kyfm ck} qyzzku} QCEq q}dcm`cn }k eu`cn Akyc} @# ]gi uib`}}dcaiq uinyfd}`kc ~dq

    zukbyfnd}im zyuqydc} }k }gi Eyuidyq dy}gku`}p }k `bzfibic} }gi Ifia}ukc`a Hycm ]udcqhiu Da}

    'IH]D)& ck} zyuqydc} }k }gi Eyuidyq YMDDZ dy}gku`}p# QCE mkiq ck} dffini }gd} }gi

    Eyuidyq dy}gku`}p }k `bzfibic} }gi IH]D `q ycakcq}`}y}`kcdf ku }gd} }gi uinyfd}`kc `q }udaidefi

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 9 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    10/61

    1

    }k }gi Eyuidyq dffinimfp ycf`b`}im YMDDZ dy}gku`}p# QCE adcck} y}`f`i dc dffinim `coyup

    adyqim ep kci q}d}y}kup nudc} kh dy}gku`}p }k agdfficni dc ic}`uifp m`q}`ca} nudc} kh dy}gku`}p< `}q

    ekk}q}udzz`cn }gikup kh q}dcm`cn byq} hd`f# @c qyb& gdx`cn hd`fim }k dffini dcp da}ydf ku

    `bb`cic} `coyup hfk~`cn hukb }gi agdfficnim zukx`q`kcq kh Mkmm"Hudcl iq}def`qg`cn }gi Eyuidy&

    ku hukb U`agdum Akumudpq dzzk`c}bic} dq M`uia}ku kh }gi Eyuidy& QCE fdalq q}dcm`cn }k zyuqyi

    }giqi afd`bq#

    Dq }k Akyc} @@@& QCE gdq qyhhiuim ck `coyup hfk~`cn hukb }gi Akyca`fq dy}gku`}p }k

    miq`ncd}i aiu}d`c ckcedcl h`cdca`df akbzdc`iq dq qpq}ib`adffp `bzku}dc} h`cdca`df `cq}`}y}`kcq

    'Q@H@q)

    4

    }gd} ~`ff ei qyeoia} }k bkui q}u`cnic} nkxiucbic} uinyfd}`kc# QCE mkiq ck} afd`b }gd}

    `} gdq eiic ku ~`ff ixiu ei miq`ncd}im d Q@H@# @cq}idm& `} d}}ibz}q }k adq} d Q@H@ miq`ncd}`kc dcm

    }gi gi`ng}icim himiudf uinyfd}`kc }gd} daakbzdc`iq `} dq d eicih`}& dcm }gic afd`bq }gd} `} ~`ff

    qyhhiu d akbzi}`}`xi `coyup eiadyqi `} gdq ck}eiic miq`ncd}im# QCEq dqqiu}im `coyup& gk~ixiu&

    `q edqim kc qziayfd}`kc }gd} kci kh `}q m`uia} akbzi}`}kuq ~`ff qkbimdp ei miq`ncd}im d Q@H@ 'ck

    qyag miq`ncd}`kcq gdxi kaayuuim)& fdpiuim yzkc qziayfd}`kc }gd} }g`q akbzi}`}ku ~`ff uiai`xi d

    akq}"kh"adz`}df dmxdc}dni hukb `}q auim`}kuq dq d uiqyf} kh }gi miq`ncd}`kc 'ck ic}`}`iq gdxi

    uiai`xim qyag d eicih`})& fdpiuim yzkc qziayfd}`kc }gd} }g`q akq}"kh"adz`}df dmxdc}dni ~`ff

    ky}~i`ng }gi akq}q dqqka`d}im ~`}g gi`ng}icim himiudf uinyfd}`kc 'ck} pi} h`cdf`im)# Ck} kcfp

    mkiq QCEq qziayfd}`xi }gikup kh `coyup m`uia}fp akc}udm`a} Akcnuiqqq iwzuiqq q}d}ibic} kh

    zyuzkqi `c nudc}`cn miq`ncd}`kc dy}gku`}p }k }gi Akyca`f& `} dfqk hdffq hdu qgku} kh dc `coyup }gd} `q

    qyhh`a`ic}fp akcaui}i }k akchiu q}dcm`cn#

    4 Mkmm"Hudcl `}qifh mkiq ck} yqi }gi }iub qpq}ib`adffp `bzku}dc} h`cdca`df `cq}`}y}`kc }kmiqau`ei d miq`ncd}im ckcedcl h`cdca`df akbzdcp# Ud}giu& }gi }iub `q d qgku}"gdcm miqau`z}`kchuityic}fp yqim ep }gi zyef`a dcm }gukyngky} h`cdca`df f`}iud}yui#

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 8 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    11/61

    =

    Dq }k Akyc}q @X& X& dcm X@& QCE gdq ck} ixic d}}ibz}im }k `mic}`hp dc `coyup hfk~`cn

    hukb }gi kumiufp f`ty`md}`kc dy}gku`}p dcm }gyq zfd`cfp fdalq q}dcm`cn }k zyuqyi }gkqi afd`bq#

    ]gi dmxkadap kundc`d}`kcq afd`bq kh `coyup dui ixic bkui d}}icyd}im }gdc }gkqi kh

    QCE# ]gi Akbzi}`}`xi Ic}iuzu`qi @cq}`}y}i 'AI@) fdalq q}dcm`cn eiadyqi `} dffiniq kcfp }gd} }

    gkfmq daakyc}q d} h`cdca`df akbzdc`iq }gd} b`ng} ei qyeoia} }k Eyuidy ku Akyca`f dy}gku`}p# AI@

    dffiniq ck hda}q mibkcq}ud}`cn }gd} }gi dffinim akcq}`}y}`kcdf x`kfd}`kcq gdxi `bzd`uim dcp}g`cn

    k}giu }gdc `}q deq}uda} `c}iuiq} `c }gi akcq}`}y}`kcdf qizdud}`kc kh zk~iuq& }gi qku} kh niciudf`im

    nu`ixdcai }gd} mkiq ck} n`xi u`qi }k q}dcm`cn# F`li~`qi& }gi 8: Zfyq Dqqka`d}`kc& @ca# '8: Zfyq)

    fdalq q}dcm`cn eiadyqi `} gdq hd`fim }k `mic}`hp d} fidq} kci bibeiu ~gkqi daakyc} gdq eiic

    dhhia}im ep }gi agdfficnim zukx`q`kcq kh }gi Da} ku ep M`uia}ku Akumudpq dzzk`c}bic}# Ixic `h

    `} akyfm `mic}`hp qyag d bibeiu& }gi f`cl ei}~iic dcp agdcniq }k }gi bibeiuq daakyc} ep `}q

    h`cdca`df `cq}`}y}`kc dcm dcp dffinim akcq}`}y}`kcdf `ch`ub`}p `q hdu }kk d}}icyd}im }k qyq}d`c }gi

    kundc`d}`kcq q}dcm`cn#

    ]gi Q}d}iq& ~gkqi afd`bq dui f b`}im }k Akyc}q @X& X& dcm X@& dfqk fdal q}dcm`cn# ]gi`u

    }gikup }gd} }gi kumiufp f`ty`md}`kc dy}gku`}p ~g`ag gdq cixiu eiic `cxklim bdp ei dzzf`im }k

    d h`cdca`df akbzdcp kh ~g`ag }gi`u zicq`kc hycmq dui dffinimfp auim`}kuq q zyui akcoia}yui# ]gi

    kumiufp f`ty`md}`kc dy}gku`}p ~dq miq`ncim hku }gi iw}udkum`cdup q`}yd}`kc `c ~g`ag }gi hd`fyui kh d

    h`cdca`df akbzdcp dcm `}q uiqkfy}`kc ycmiu k}giu~`qi dzzf`adefi fd~ ~kyfm gdxi qiu`kyq dmxiuqi

    ihhia}q kc }gi cd}`kcq h`cdca`df q}de`f`}p< miqz`}i }g`q ci~ dy}gku`}p& }gi q}d}y}kup hudbi~kul

    `cakuzkud}iq d q}ukcn zuiqybz}`kc }gd} hd`f`cn h`cdca`df akbzdc`iq ~`ff ei uiqkfxim }gukyng

    iw`q}`cn edcluyz}ap zukaimyuiq# ]gi Q}d}iq gdxi hd`fim }k dffini }gd} `cxkad}`kc kh }gi

    agdfficnim dy}gku`}p dq }k dcp h`cdca`df akbzdcp& byag fiqq kci kh ~g`ag }gi Q}d}iq zicq`kc

    hycmq dui dffinimfp auim`}kuq& `q `bb`cic}#

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni > kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    12/61

    9

    H`cdffp& dcm hku uidqkcq q`b`fdu }k }gi uidqkcq }gip fdal q}dcm`cn& Zfd`c}`hhq afd`bq dui

    ycu`zi# Zfd`c}`hhq gdxi ck} mibkcq}ud}im }gd} }gi`u afd`bq dui zuiqic}fp h`} hku oym`a`df uiqkfy}`kc

    ku }gd} }gip ~`ff qyhhiu gdumqg`z `h uix`i~ q zkq}zkcim# Hy}yui Eyuidy ichkuaibic} da}`kcq ku

    uinyfd}`kcq& hy}yui Akyca`f miq`ncd}`kcq& dcm hy}yui kumiufp f`ty`md}`kc zukaiqqiq }gd} dhhia}

    Zfd`c}`hhq dui akc}`cnic} yzkc qyeqityic} ixic}q }gd} bdp ck} kaayu dq Zfd`c}`hhq qynniq} ku bdp

    ck} kaayu d} dff# Eiadyqi }gi Akyu} bdp cixiu ciim }k uiqkfxi }giqi afd`bq& }gip dui ck} h`} hku

    oym`a`df uiqkfy}`kc# Hyu}giubkui& eiadyqi Zfd`c}`hhq gdxi hd`fim }k dffini dcp da}ydf ku `bb`cic}

    `coyup hfk~`cn hukb }gi agdfficnim zukx`q`kcq kh }gi Da} ku hukb M`uia}ku Akumudpq

    dzzk`c}bic}& Zfd`c}`hhq ~`ff qyhhiu ck gdumqg`z d} }g`q }`bi `c }gi deqicai kh oym`a`df `c}iuxic}`kc#

    Hku }giqi uidqkcq& }gi Akyu} qgkyfm m`qb`qq }gi Dbicmim Akbzfd`c} hku fdal kh

    oyu`qm`a}`kc zyuqydc} }k Himiudf Uyfi kh A`x`f Zukaimyui 45'e)'4)#

    Q]D]Y]KUP DCM UINYFD]KUP HUDBI^KUL? ]GI MKMM"HUDCL DA]

    Kc Oyfp 54& 5:4:& Akcnuiqq icda}im }gi Mkmm"Hudcl ^dff Q}uii} Uihkub dcm Akcqybiu

    Zuk}ia}`kc Da}& Zye F# Ck# 444"5:1& 45= Q}d}# 41>8 '5:4:)# ]gi fin`qfd}`kc zukx`mim d m`uia}

    dcm akbzuigicq`xi uiqzkcqi }k }gi h`cdca`df au`q`q }gd} cidufp au`zzfim }gi Y#Q# iakckbp

    ein`cc`cn `c 5::7# Q# Uiz# Ck# 444"4>8& d} 5 '5:4:)# @}q kxiuduag`cn zyuzkqi ~dq }k zukbk}i

    }gi h`cdca`df q}de`f`}p kh }gi Yc`}im Q}d}iq }gukyng }gi iq}def`qgbic} kh bidqyuiq miq`ncim }k

    `bzukxi daakyc}de`f`}p& uiq`f`icap& dcm }udcqzduicap `c }gi h`cdca`df qpq}ib# @m# ]gi Da}

    icgdcaim akcqybiu dcm `cxiq}ku zuk}ia}`kcq& iq}def`qgim dc idufp ~duc`cn qpq}ib }k mi}ia} dcm

    dmmuiqq ibiun`cn }guid}q }k h`cdca`df q}de`f`}p dcm }gi iakckbp& q}uicn}gicim }gi qyziux`q`kc kh

    fduni akbzfiw h`cdca`df kundc`d}`kcq& iq}def`qgim d biagdc`qb }k f`ty`md}i fduni dcm akbzfiw

    hd`f`cn akbzdc`iq ~`}gky} dcp fkqq }k }dwzdpiuq& dcm `bzkqim f`b`}d}`kcq kc aiu}d`c }udm`cn

    da}`x`}p# @m# ]gi Da} agdcnim }gi zui"iw`q}`cn uinyfd}kup q}uya}yui ep auid}`cn qixiudf ci~

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 7 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    13/61

    8

    nkxiucbic}df ic}`}`iq& ep if`b`cd}`cn k}giuq& dcm ep }udcqhiuu`cn uinyfd}kup dy}gku`}p dbkcn

    dnica`iq#5

    @# ]GI AKCQYBIU H@CDCA@DF ZUK]IA]@KC EYUIDYD# IQ]DEF@QGBIC] DCM FIDMIUQG@Z]`}fi W kh Mkmm"Hudcl iq}def`qgim }gi Akcqybiu H`cdca`df Zuk}ia}`kc Eyuidy `c kumiu }k

    icqyui }gd} dff akcqybiuq gdxi daaiqq }k bduli}q hku akcqybiu h`cdca`df zukmya}q dcm qiux`aiq

    dcm }gd} bduli}q hku \qyagR qiux`aiq dui hd`u& }udcqzduic}& dcm akbzi}`}`xi# 45 Y#Q#A# 9944'd)#

    Zu`ku }k Mkmm"Hudcl& }gi q}d}y}kup dy}gku`}p }k uinyfd}i akcqybiu h`cdca`df zukmya}q dcm qiux`aiq

    ~dq qzuidm dbkcn qixic m`hhiuic} himiudf dnica`iq# Qii Q# Uiz# Ck# 444"4>8& d} 4: '5:4:)# ]g`q

    hudnbic}d}`kc kh dy}gku`}p ~dq x`i~im dq d akc}u`ey}`cn hda}ku }k }gi uiaic} h`cdca`df au`q`q& qii

    `m#& dcm Akcnuiqq uiqzkcmim ep auid}`cn }gi Eyuidy& d q`cnfi dnicap ~`}g }gi dy}gku`}p dcm

    daakyc}de`f`}p }k icqyui }gd} Himiudf akcqybiu h`cdca`df fd~1 `q akbzuigicq`xi& hd`u& dcm

    x`nkukyqfp ichkuaim& qii G#U# Uiz# Ck# 444"94>& d} >1: '5:4:)#

    ]gi Eyuidy `q dc cmizicmic} dnicap ~`}g`c }gi Himiudf Uiqiuxi Qpq}ib# 45 Y#Q#A#

    9=04'd)# @} `q gidmim ep d M`uia}ku ~gk `q dzzk`c}im ep }gi Zuiq`mic} ~`}g }gi dmx`ai dcm

    akcqic} kh }gi Qicd}i dcm `q uibkxdefi ep }gi Zuiq`mic} hku adyqi# @m# 9=04'e)& 'a)# Kc

    Odcydup =& 5:45& }gi Zuiq`mic} dzzk`c}im U`agdum Akumudp dq }gi Eyuidyq h`uq} M`uia}ku zyuqydc}

    5 Qii Mkmm"Hudcl 444"51& 45= Q}d}# d} 4105"4=45 'auid}`cn }gi Akyca`f)< `m# 494"98&45= Q}d}# d} 4=45"5: 'auid}`cn }gi Khh`ai kh H`cdca`df Uiqiduag)< `m# 4::4"44::G& 45= Q}d}# d}4099"5441 'auid}`cn }gi Eyuidy)< `m# 145"41& 45= Q}d}# d} 4954"51 'if`b`cd}`cn }gi Khh`ai kh]gu`h} Qyziux`q`kc 'K]Q) dcm }udcqhiuu`cn `}q dy}gku`}p }k }gi KAA& }gi Ekdum kh Nkxiuckuq kh}gi Himiudf Uiqiuxi Qpq}ib 'Himiudf Uiqiuxi Ekdum ku Ekdum)& dcm }gi Himiudf Mizkq`}@cqyudcai Akuzkud}`kc 'HM@A))< `m# 4:84"8>& 45= Q}d}# d} 5:19"98 '}udcqhiuu`cn aiu}d`ciw`q}`cn uinyfd}kup dy}gku`}p hukb qixic m`hhiuic} himiudf dnica`iq }k }gi Eyuidy)#1 Ycmiu Mkmm"Hudcl& }gi }iub Himiudf akcqybiu h`cdca`df fd~ `cafymiq aiu}d`c zui"iw`q}`cn icybiud}im akcqybiu fd~q& 45 Y#Q#A# 9=74'45)& }gi zukx`q`kcq kh ]`}fi W& }gi fd~qhku ~g`ag dy}gku`}`iq dui }udcqhiuuim ycmiu qye}`}fiq H dcm G kh ]`}fi W& dcm dff uyfiq ku kumiuqzuiqau`eim ep }gi Eyuidy ycmiu }giqi fd~q dcm dy}gku`}`iq# @m# 9=74'4=)#

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 0 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    14/61

    >

    }k }gi Zuiq`mic}q dy}gku`}p ycmiu }gi Uiaiqq Dzzk`c}bic}q Afdyqi& Y#Q# Akcq}# du}# @@& 5& af# 1#

    Qii ^g`}i Gkyqi& Zuiq`mic} Kedbd Dcckycaiq Uiaiqq Dzzk`c}bic}q }k Lip Dmb`c`q}ud}`kc

    Zkq}q 'Odc# =& 5:45)& d}~~~#~g`}igkyqi#nkx+}gi"zuiqq"khh`ai+5:45+:4+:=+zuiq`mic}"kedbd"

    dcckycaiq"uiaiqq"dzzk`c}bic}q"lip"dmb`c`q}ud}`kc"zkq}q# Eiadyqi M`uia}ku Akumudp ~dq

    dzzk`c}im zyuqydc} }k }gi Zuiq`mic}q uiaiqq dzzk`c}bic} dy}gku`}p& g`q }iub ~`ff iwz`ui d} }gi

    icm kh }gi Qicd}iq ciw} qiqq`kc# Qii Y#Q# Akcq}# du}# @@& 5& af# 1#

    E# ]GI EYUIDYQ UINYFD]KUP DY]GKU@]PYcmiu ]`}fi W kh }gi Da}& byag kh }gi dy}gku`}p }k uinyfd}i akcqybiu h`cdca`df zukmya}q

    dcm qiux`aiq }gd} gdm eiic bd`c}d`cim ep k}giu himiudf dnica`iq }udcqhiuuim }k }gi Eyuidy# Qii

    45 Y#Q#A# 9974# ]g`q }udcqhiuuim dy}gku`}p `cafymiq }gi dy}gku`}p }k zuiqau`ei uinyfd}`kcq

    `bzfibic}`cn d cybeiu kh iw`q}`cn himiudf q}d}y}iq& `cafym`cn }gi ]uy}g `c Ficm`cn Da}& }gi

    Itydf Auim`} Kzzku}yc`}p Da}& }gi Uidf Iq}d}i Qi}}fibic} Zukaimyuiq Da}& dcm }gi IH]D# @m#

    9974& 9=74'45)& '4=)# Mkmm"Hudcl dbicmim bdcp kh }giqi iw`q}`cn fd~q& dcm }gi dy}gku`}p }k

    `bzfibic} }gkqi dbicmbic}q dfqk }udcqhiuuim }k }gi Eyuidy# Kh uifixdcai giui& Mkmm"Hudcl

    dbicmim }gi IH]D }k iq}def`qg d akbzuigicq`xi ci~ qpq}ib kh akcqybiu zuk}ia}`kcq hku

    uib`}}dcai }udcqhiuq qic} ep akcqybiuq `c }gi Yc`}im Q}d}iq }k `cm`x`mydfq dcm eyq`ciqqiq `c

    hkui`nc akyc}u`iq# Qii Mkmm"Hudcl Da} 4:>1'd)'=) 'akm`h`im d} 49 Y#Q#A# 4801k"4)# ]gi

    Eyuidy zyef`qgim `c }gi Himiudf Uin`q}iud h`cdf uyfi `bzfibic}`cn }g`q q}d}y}kup dbicmbic} kc

    Hieuydup >& 5:45& dcm dc dbicmbic} }k }gd} h`cdf uyfi kc Dynyq} 5:& 5:45# Qii Ifia}ukc`a Hycm

    ]udcqhiuq& >> Him# Uin# 840= 'Hie# >& 5:45) 'akm`h`im d} 45 A#H#U# z}# 4::9& qyezdu} E)> Him# Uin# 9:5== 'Dyn# 5:& 5:45) 'dbicm`cn 45 A#H#U# z}# 4::9)#

    @c dmm`}`kc }k `}q }udcqhiuuim dy}gku`}p }k `qqyi uinyfd}`kcq `bzfibic}`cn iw`q}`cn

    icybiud}im akcqybiu fd~q& ]`}fi W dfqk nudc}q }gi Eyuidy dy}gku`}p }k `qqyi uinyfd}`kcq

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 4: kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    15/61

    7

    `bzfibic}`cn }gi zukx`q`kcq kh ]`}fi W `}qifh# Qii& i#n#& 45 Y#Q#A# 9945'e)'4) 'nudc}`cn }gi

    Eyuidy niciudf uyfibdl`cn dy}gku`}p }k dmb`c`q}iu }gi Himiudf akcqybiu h`cdca`df fd~q)< `m#

    9915'd) 'nudc}`cn }gi Eyuidy dy}gku`}p }k `qqyi uyfiq }k icqyui hyff& daayud}i& dcm ihhia}`xi

    m`qafkqyui kh }gi hid}yuiq kh dcp akcqybiu h`cdca`df zukmya} ku qiux`ai)# @c zdu}`ayfdu& ]`}fi W

    zukg`e`}q }gi akbb`qq`kc kh dcp ychd`u& miaiz}`xi& ku deyq`xi da} ku zuda}`ai ep d akxiuim

    ziuqkc ku qiux`ai zukx`miu& dq }gkqi }iubq dui mih`cim `c ]`}fi W# @m# 9914'd)&

    9918'd)'4)'E)& 9=74'8)& '58)# Dcm `} dy}gku`iq }gi Eyuidy }k `qqyi uinyfd}`kcq `mic}`hp`cn da}q

    ku zuda}`aiq dq ychd`u& miaiz}`xi& ku deyq`xi# @m# 9914'e)# ]gi Eyuidy gdq ck} pi} zukbyfnd}im

    dcp qyag uinyfd}`kcq#

    A# ]GI EYUIDYQ QYZIUX@QKUP DCM ICHKUAIBIC] DY]GKU@]P@c dmm`}`kc }k `}q uinyfd}kup dy}gku`}p& }gi Eyuidy gdq }gi dy}gku`}p }k qyziux`q\iR

    akxiuim ziuqkcq hku akbzf`dcai ~`}g Himiudf akcqybiu h`cdca`df fd~& dcm }dl\iR dzzukzu`d}i

    ichkuaibic} da}`kc }k dmmuiqq x`kfd}`kcq kh Himiudf akcqybiu h`cdca`df fd~# 45 Y#Q#A#

    9944'a)'=)# ]g`q dy}gku`}p& gk~ixiu& mkiq ck} iw}icm }k ixiup zdu}`a`zdc} `c }gi akcqybiu

    h`cdca`df bduli}zfdai ey} `q `cq}idm qyeoia} }k ]`}fi Wq m`x`q`kc kh dy}gku`}p ei}~iic }gi Eyuidy

    dcm k}giu himiudf dnica`iq# Qii `m# Dq uifixdc} giui& hku iwdbzfi& }gi Eyuidy gdq kcfp f`b`}im

    qyziux`qkup dy}gku`}p kxiu qbdffiu `cqyuim mizkq`}kup `cq}`}y}`kcq dcm auim`} yc`kcq '`#i#& }gkqi

    ~`}g -4: e`ff`kc ku fiqq `c }k}df dqqi}q }gd} dui ck} dhh`f`d}iq kh xiup fduni edclq dcm auim`}

    yc`kcq)& dcm `} gdq ck dy}gku`}p }k ichkuai }gi qyeq}dc}`xi uity`uibic}q kh Himiudf akcqybiu

    h`cdca`df fd~ ~`}g uiqzia} }k qyag `cq}`}y}`kcq# Qii `m# 9948#

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 44 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    16/61

    0

    @cq}idm& }gi zuymic}`df uinyfd}kuq= ui}d`c }gi zu`bdup dy}gku`}p }k iwdb`ci }giqi qbdffiu

    `cqyuim mizkq`}kup `cq}`}y}`kcq dcm auim`} yc`kcq hku akbzf`dcai ~`}g Himiudf akcqybiu h`cdca`df

    fd~# Qii `m# 9974'a)'4)'E)& 9948'd)# ]gi zuymic}`df uinyfd}kuq qyziux`qkup dy}gku`}p q

    iwafyq`xi uifd}`xi }k }gi Eyuidy& `m#& iwaiz} }gd} }gi Eyuidy bdp uity`ui uizku}q hukb qyag

    `cq}`}y}`kcq hku aiu}d`c zyuzkqiq dcm zdu}`a`zd}i `c }gi zuymic}`df uinyfd}kuq iwdb`cd}`kcq kh qyag

    `cq}`}y}`kcq kc d qdbzf`cn edq`q& `m# 9948'e)& 'a)# Dcm& iwaiz} hku }q de`f`}p }k ichkuai

    akbzf`dcai ~`}g d uityiq} hku d uizku} zyuqydc} }k }g`q f`b`}im qyziux`qkup dy}gku`}p& }gi

    zuymic}`df uinyfd}kuq ui}d`c iwafyq`xi dy}gku`}p 'uifd}`xi }k }gi Eyuidy) }k ichkuai akbzf`dcai

    ~`}g Himiudf akcqybiu h`cdca`df fd~q ~`}g uiqzia} }k }giqi qbdffiu `cqyuim mizkq`}kup

    `cq}`}y}`kcq ku auim`} yc`kcq# @m# 9974'a)'5)'E)< qii dfqk `m# 9948'm)'4)# Df}gkyng }gi Eyuidy

    bdp uiakbbicm dzzukzu`d}i da}`kc }k }gi zuymic}`df uinyfd}ku ~gic `} gdq uidqkc }k eif`ixi }gd}

    d qbdffiu mizkq`}kup `cq}`}y}`kc ku auim`} yc`kc gdq x`kfd}im Himiudf akcqybiu h`cdca`df fd~& }gi

    zuymic}`df uinyfd}kuq kcfp kef`nd}`kc `q }k uiqzkcm }k qyag d uiakbbicmd}`kc `c ~u`}`cn# @m#

    9948'm)'5)#

    @@# ]GI H@CDCA@DF Q]DE@F@]P KXIUQ@NG] AKYCA@F]`}fi @ kh Mkmm"Hudcl iq}def`qgim }gi H`cdca`df Q}de`f`}p Kxiuq`ng} Akyca`f#

    945 Y#Q#A#

    9154# @c }gi uiaic} h`cdca`df au`q q& h`cdca`df m`q}uiqq d} aiu}d`c ckcedcl h`cdca`df akbzdc`iq

    = ]gi zuymic}`df uinyfd}kuq dui }gi Himiudf Uiqiuxi Ekdum& }gi HM@A& }gi KAA& }giCd}`kcdf Auim`} Yc`kc Dmb`c`q}ud}`kc 'CAYD)& dcm& hkubiufp& }gi K]Q# Qii `m# 97=4'5=)&

    4741't)#9

    ]gi Akyca`f akbzu`qiq }ic xk}`cn bibeiuq? '4) }gi Qiaui}dup kh }gi ]uidqyup& ~gkqiuxiq dq }gi Agd`uziuqkc kh }gi Akyca`f< '5) }gi Agd`ubdc kh }gi Himiudf Uiqiuxi Ekdum< '1) }giAkbz}ukffiu kh }gi Ayuuicap< '=) }gi M`uia}ku kh }gi Eyuidy< '9)}gi Agd`uziuqkc kh }gi Qiayu`}`iqdcm Iwagdcni Akbb`qq`kc 'QIA)< '8) }gi Agd`uziuqkc kh }gi HM@A< '>) }gi Agd`uziuqkc kh }giAkbbkm`}p Hy}yuiq ]udm`cn Akbb`qq`kc< '7) }gi M`uia}ku kh }gi Himiudf Gkyq`cn H`cdcaiDnicap< '0) }gi Agd`ubdc kh }gi CAYD Ekdum< dcm '4:) dc `cmizicmic} bibeiu ~`}g `cqyudcaiiwziu}`qi dzzk`c}im ep }gi Zuiq`mic} ~`}g }gi dmx`ai dcm akcqic} kh }gi Qicd}i# @m# 9154'e)'4)#

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 45 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    17/61

    4:

    akc}u`ey}im }k d eukdm qi``cn yz kh h`cdca`df bduli}q dcm q}uiqq d} k}giu h`cdca`df h`ubq#

    Dy}gku`}p }k Uity`ui Qyziux`q`kc dcm Uinyfd}`kc kh Aiu}d`c Ckcedcl H`cdca`df Akbzdc`iq&

    >> Him# Uin# 5481>& 5481> 'Dzu# 44& 5:45)# Bdcp kh }giqi akbzdc`iq ~iui ck} qyeoia} }k }gi

    }pzi kh uinyfd}`kc dcm akcqkf`md}im qyziux`q`kc }gd} dzzf`im }k edcl gkfm`cn akbzdc`iq& cku ~iui

    }giui ihhia}`xi biagdc`qbq `c zfdai }k ~`cm mk~c }gi fduniq} dcm bkq} `c}iuakccia}im kh }giqi

    akbzdc`iq ~`}gky} adyq`cn hyu}giu `cq}de`f`}p# @m#< qii dfqk Q# Uiz# Ck# 444"4>8& d} =1 '5:4:)

    '\CRk h`cdca`df uinyfd}ku ~dq uiqzkcq`efi hku dqqiqq`cn }gi `bzda} }gi hd`fyui kh d q`cnfi h`ub

    b`ng} gdxi kc }gi q}d}i kh }gi h`cdca`df qpq}ib# @cmiim& dq }gi au`q`q nui~ bkui qixiui& }gi

    `c}iuakccia}im uifd}`kcqg`zq dbkcn h`cdca`df akbzdc`iq `cauidqim }gi zuiqqyui kc }gkqi dfuidmp

    q}uynnf`cn }k qyux`xi& ~g`ag kcfp qiuxim }k daaifiud}i }gi mk~chdff kh qkbi h`ubq#)# Akcnuiqq

    uiqzkcmim ep auid}`cn }gi Akyca`f& }gi zyuzkqiq kh ~g`ag dui }k `mic}`hp u`qlq }k }gi cd}`kcq

    h`cdca`df q}de`f`}p zkqim ep fduni& `c}iuakccia}im akbzdc`iq& 45 Y#Q#A# 9155'd)'4)'D)& dcm }k

    zukbk}i bduli} m`qa`zf`ci ep if`b`cd}`cn dcp iwzia}d}`kc kc }gi zdu} kh qgduigkfmiuq dcm

    auim`}kuq kh qyag akbzdc`iq }gd} }gi nkxiucbic} ~`ff ed`f }gib ky} `c }gi ixic} kh }gi`u hd`fyui&

    `m# 9155'd)'4)'E)#

    @c zdu}`ayfdu& }gi Da} dy}gku`iq }gi Akyca`f 'yzkc d }~k"}g`umq xk}i kh `}q xk}`cn

    bibeiuq }gd} byq} `cafymi }gi dhh`ubd}`xi xk}i kh }gi ]uidqyup Qiaui}dup) }k miq`ncd}i aiu}d`c

    ckcedcl h`cdca`df akbzdc`iq8 dq Q@H@q }gd} ~`ff ei qyeoia} }k qyziux`q`kc ep }gi Himiudf

    ]gi Akyca`f dfqk akbzu`qiq h`xi ckcxk}`cn bibeiuq ~gk qiuxi `c dc dmx`qkup adzda`}p kcfp dcmbdp ei iwafymim hukb Akyca`f mif`eiud}`kcq `c aiu}d`c a`uaybq}dcaiq# @m# 9154'e)'1)#

    8 Ycmiu }gi Da}& d ckcedcl h`cdca`df akbzdcp `q d mkbiq}`a ku hkui`nc akbzdcp }gd} `qzuimkb`cdc}fp icndnim `c h`cdca`df da}`x`}`iq& k}giu }gdc edcl gkfm`cn akbzdc`iq dcm aiu}d`ck}giu }pziq kh h`ubq# @m# 9144'd)'=)# Aiu}d`c edcl gkfm`cn akbzdc`iq }gd} akyfm zkqi u`qlq }k}gi cd}`kcq h`cdca`df q}de`f`}p dui& ep q}d}y}i& dfuidmp qyeoia} }k gi`ng}icim uinyfd}`kc dcm }gyqdui ck} qyeoia} }k d miq`ncd}`kc ep }gi Akyca`f# @m# 9189'd)'4) 'miq`ncd}`cn dff edcl gkfm`cnakbzdc`iq ~`}g }k}df akcqkf`md}im dqqi}q itydf }k ku nuid}iu }gdc -9: e`ff`kc dq ic}`}`iq qyeoia} }kgi`ng}icim nkxiucbic} uinyfd}`kc)#

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 41 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    18/61

    44

    Uiqiuxi Ekdum dcm bkui q}u`cnic} nkxiucbic} uinyfd}`kc `c }gi hkub kh zuymic}`df q}dcmdumq dcm

    idufp uibim`d}`kc uity`uibic}q iq}def`qgim ep }gi Ekdum# Qii `m# 9151'd)'4)& 'e)'4)& 9189&

    9188# ]gi Akyca`f bdp mi}iub`ci }gd} d ckcedcl h`cdca`df akbzdcp qgkyfm ei qyeoia} }k

    gi`ng}icim nkxiucbic} uinyfd}`kc yzkc d mi}iub`cd}`kc }gd} bd}iu`df h`cdca`df m`q}uiqq d} }gi

    Y#Q# ckcedcl h`cdca`df akbzdcp& ku }gi cd}yui& qakzi& q`i& qadfi& akcaic}ud}`kc&

    `c}iuakccia}imciqq& ku b`w kh }gi da}`x`}`iq kh }gi Y#Q# ckcedcl h`cdca`df akbzdcp& akyfm zkqi d

    }guid} }k }gi h`cdca`df q}de`f`}p kh }gi Yc`}im Q}d}iq# @m# 9151'd)'4)< qii dfqk `m# 9151'e)'4)

    'iq}def`qg`cn d akbzdudefi q}dcmdum nkxiuc`cn }gi mi}iub`cd}`kc dzzf`adefi }k hkui`nc ckcedcl

    h`cdca`df akbzdc`iq)# @c iwiua`q`cn }g`q miq`ncd}`kc dy}gku }p& }gi Da} qzia`h`iq ifixic hda}kuq

    }gd} }gi Akyca`f byq} akcq`miu# Qii `m# 9151'd)'5)& 'e)'5)# Zu`ku }k dcp miq`ncd}`kc ep }gi

    Akyca`f& d ckcedcl h`cdca`df akbzdcp byq} uiai`xi ~u`}}ic ck}`ai kh }gi zukzkqim mi}iub`cd}`kc

    dcm `q ic}`}fim }k d gidu`cn# @m# 9151'i)# D h`cdca`df akbzdcp }gd} `q yf}`bd}ifp qyeoia} }k d

    Akyca`f mi}iub`cd}`kc bdp qiil oym`a`df uix`i~ kh }gd} mi}iub`cd}`kc# @m# 9151'g)# ]gi

    uix`i~`cn akyu} bdp qi} dq`mi d Akyca`f mi}iub`cd}`kc `h `} `q due`}udup dcm adzu`a`kyq# @m#

    Kc Dzu`f 44& 5:45& }gi Akyca`f zyef`qgim `c }gi Himiudf Uin`q}iud h`cdf uyfi dcm

    `c}iuzui}`xi ny`mdcai miqau`e`cn }gi bdcciu `c ~g`ag }gi Akyca`f `c}icmq }k dzzfp }gi q}d}y}kup

    hda}kuq# Dy}gku`}p }k Uity`ui Qyziux`q`kc dcm Uinyfd}`kc kh Aiu}d`c Ckcedcl H`cdca`df

    Akbzdc`iq& >> Him# Uin# 5481> 'Dzu# 44& 5:45)# ]gi Akyca`f gdq ck}& gk~ixiu& bdmi dcp Q@H@

    miq`ncd}`kcq zyuqydc} }k `}q dy}gku`}p ycmiu ]`}fi @# Qii Y#Q# Nkxiucbic} Daakyc}de`f`}p Khh`ai

    'NDK)& Dnica`iq Akc}`cyi Uyfibdl`cnq hku Afdu`hp`cn Qzia`h`a Zukx`q`kcq kh Kumiufp

    F`ty`md}`kc Dy}gku`}p 'Oyfp 5:45)& d} g}}z?++~~~#ndk#nkx+dqqi}q+8::+905147#zmh '\CRkcedcl

    h`cdca`df akbzdc`iq # # # gdxi pi} }k ei miq`ncd}im#)#

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 4= kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    19/61

    45

    @@@# ]GI KUMIUFP F@TY@MD]@KC DY]GKU@]P]`}fi @@ kh Mkmm"Hudcl iq}def`qgim d zukaiqq hku f`ty`md}\`cnR hd`f`cn h`cdca`df akbzdc`iq

    }gd} zkqi d q`nc`h`adc} u`ql }k }gi h`cdca`df q}de`f`}p kh }gi Yc`}im Q}d}iq `c d bdcciu }gd}

    b`}`nd}iq qyag u`ql dcm b`c`b`iq bkudf gddum# 45 Y#Q#A# 917='d)# Myu`cn }gi uiaic}

    h`cdca`df au`q`q& \~Rgic Figbdc Euk}giuq miafduim edcluyz}ap& }gi bduli}q zdc`alim dcm }gi

    au`q`q iqadfd}im# ^`}g ck k}giu bidcq }k uiqkfxi fduni& akbzfiw dcm `c}iuakccia}im h`cdca`df

    h`ubq& }gi nkxiucbic} ~dq fih} ~`}g hi~ kz}`kcq k}giu }gdc }k zukx`mi bdqq`xi dqq`q}dcai }k zukz

    yz hd`f`cn akbzdc`iq `c dc ihhku} }k zuixic} }gi au`q`q hukb qz`udf`cn `c}k d nuid} mizuiqq`kc# Qii

    Q# Uiz# Ck# 444"4>8& d} =1 '5:4:)# @c kumiu }k dxk`m }gi ycmiq`udefi agk`ai # # # ei}~iic

    edcluyz}ap kh d fduni& akbzfiw h`cdca`df akbzdcp }gd} ~kyfm m`quyz} bduli}q dcm mdbdni }gi

    iakckbp& dcm ed`fky} kh qyag h`cdca`df akbzdcp }gd} ~kyfm iwzkqi }dwzdpiuq }k fkqqiq dcm

    ycmiub`ci bduli} m`qa`zf`ci& Akcnuiqq iq}def`qgim }gi kumiufp f`ty`md}`kc dy}gku`}p# @m# d} =#

    Miqz`}i }g`q ci~ dy}gku`}p& }gi Da} `cakuzkud}iq d q}ukcn zuiqybz}`kc }gd} }gi edcluyz}ap

    zukaiqq ~`ff akc}`cyi }k ei yqim }k afkqi dcm yc~`cm hd`f`cn h`cdca`df akbzdc`iq& `cafym`cn fduni&

    akbzfiw kciq# @m#

    Zyuqydc} }k }gi kumiufp f`ty`md}`kc dy}gku`}p& }gi ]uidqyup Qiaui}dup bdp dzzk`c} }gi

    HM@A dq uiai`xiu kh d hd`f`cn h`cdca`df akbzdcp#> Qii 45 Y#Q#A# 9175"7=# Eiadyqi ]`}fi @@

    ~dq miq`ncim }k ei `cxklim kcfp `c }gi bkq} iw}udkum`cdup kh a`uaybq}dcaiq& gk~ixiu& }gi

    }guiqgkfm hku }u`nniu`cn }gi kumiufp f`ty`md}`kc dy}gku`}p q xiup g`ng# Q# Uiz# Ck# 444"4>8& d} =

    >

    H`cdca`df akbzdc\`iqR `cafymi? '4) edcl gkfm`cn akbzdc`iq< '5) ckcedcl h`cdca`dfakbzdc`iq qyziux`qim ep }gi Himiudf Uiqiuxi Ekdum< '1) k}giu akbzdc`iq }gd} dui zuimkb`cdc}fpicndnim `c da}`x`}`iq }gd} dui h`cdca`df `c cd}yui ku `ca`mic}df }giui}k< dcm '=) qyeq`m`du`iq kh}giqi akbzdc`iq }gd} dui zuimkb`cdc}fp icndnim `c da}`x`}`iq }gd} dui h`cdca`df `c cd}yui ku`ca`mic}df }giui}k& iwaiz} qyeq`m`du`iq }gd} dui `cqyuim mizkq`}kup `cq}`}y}`kcq ku `cqyudcaiakbzdc`iq# @m# 9174'd)'44)# Hyu}giubkui& ]`}fi @@ iwibz}q hukb `}q akxiudni `cqyuimmizkq`}kup `cq}`}y}`kcq& `m# 9174'd)'7)< ycmiu }gi Himiudf Mizkq`} @cqyudcai Da}& }gi HM@Adfuidmp gdm dy}gku`}p }k qiuxi dq uiai`xiu hku hd`f`cn edclq& qii `m# 4754#

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 49 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    20/61

    41

    '5:4:)# @c zdu}`ayfdu& da}`xd}`kc kh }gi kumiufp f`ty`md}`kc dy}gku`}p uity`uiq da}`kc ep }~k"}g`umq

    kh }gi Himiudf Uiqiuxi Ekdum dcm }~k"}g`umq kh }gi HM@A Ekdum }k hyuc`qg d ~u`}}ic

    uiakbbicmd}`kc }k }gi ]uidqyup Qiaui}dup }gd} akc}d`cq dc ixdfyd}`kc kh i`ng} q}d}y}kup hda}kuq&

    `cafym`cn ~gi}giu }gi akbzdcp `q `c mihdyf} ku `c mdcniu kh mihdyf}& }gi ihhia}q }gd} d mihdyf}

    ~kyfm gdxi kc }gi h`cdca`df q}de`f`}p kh }gi Yc`}im Q}d}iq& dcm ~gp d adqi ycmiu }gi Edcluyz}ap

    Akmi `q ck} dzzukzu`d}i#7 45 Y#Q#A# 9171'd)# Yzkc uiai`x`cn qyag d uiakbbicmd}`kc& }gi

    ]uidqyup Qiaui}dup adcck} dy}gku`i }gi yqi kh }gi kumiufp f`ty`md}`kc dy}gku`}p ycfiqq gi h`uq}

    bdliq qixic mi}iub`cd}`kcq `c akcqyf}d}`kc ~`}g }gi Zuiq`mic}& `cafym`cn }gd} }gi h`cdca`df

    akbzdcp `q `c mihdyf} ku `c mdcniu kh mihdyf} dcm }gd} uiqkfx`cn }gi h`cdca`df akbzdcp ycmiu

    k}giu~`qi dzzf`adefi fd~ ~kyfm gdxi qiu`kyq dmxiuqi ihhia}q kc h`cdca`df q}de`f`}p `c }gi Yc`}im

    Q}d}iq# @m# 9171'e)# H`cdffp& `h }gi h`cdca`df akbzdcp mkiq ck} daty`iqai ku akcqic} }k }gi

    dzzk`c}bic}& }gi Qiaui}dup byq} zi}`}`kc }gi M`q}u`a} Akyu} hku }gi M`q}u`a} kh Akfybe`d hku dc

    kumiu dy}gku``cn }gi dzzk`c}bic}# @m# 9175'd)'4)# ]gi m`q}u`a} akyu} adcck} dy}gku`i }gi

    dzzk`c}bic} `h }gi Qiaui}dupq mi}iub`cd}`kc }gd} }gi akxiuim h`cdca`df akbzdcp `q `c mihdyf} ku

    `c mdcniu kh mihdyf}& ku g`q mi}iub`cd}`kc }gd} }gi akbzdcp qd}`qh`iq }gi mih`c`}`kc kh d h`cdca`df

    akbzdcp& ~dq due`}udup dcm adzu`a`kyq# @m# 9175'd)'4)'D)' ``)# ]gi m`q}u`a} akyu}q

    mi}iub`cd}`kc `q qyeoia} }k uix`i~ ep }gi Akyu} kh Dzzidfq ycmiu }gi qdbi q}dcmdum# @m#

    9175'd)'5)#

    Hkffk~`cn dcp dzzk`c}bic} kh }gi HM@A dq uiai`xiu& }gi HM@A ~kyfm gdxi }k zukx`mi

    ck}`ai }k }gi hd`f`cn akbzdcpq auim`}kuq& ~gk bdp }gic h`fi afd`bq# @m# 910:'d)'5)'E)"'A)#

    Ycmiu ]`}fi @@& dff afd`bdc}q qgdff& `c ck ixic}& uiai`xi fiqq }gdc \dcR dbkyc} }gd} itydf\qR }gi

    7 @h }gi h`cdca`df akbzdcp ku `}q fduniq} Y#Q# qyeq`m`dup `q d eukliu ku midfiu& }gi QIA&`cq}idm kh }gi HM@A Ekdum& byq} uiakbbicm }gd} }gi akbzdcp ei zfdaim `c uiai`xiuqg`z& dcm `h `}`q dc `cqyudcai akbzdcp& }gi M`uia}ku kh }gi Himiudf @cqyudcai Khh`ai& `cq}idm kh }gi HM@AEkdum& byq} uiakbbicm uiai`xiuqg`z `c akcqyf}d}`kc ~`}g }gi HM@A# @m# 9171'd)'4)'E)& 'A)#

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 48 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    21/61

    4=

    dbkyc} }gd} qyag afd`bdc} ~kyfm gdxi uiai`xim `h }gi HM@A gdm ck} eiic dzzk`c}im uiai`xiu

    ~`}g uiqzia} }k }gi akxiuim h`cdca`df akbzdcp dcm `h }gi akbzdcp `cq}idm gdm eiic f`ty`md}im

    ycmiu agdz}iu > kh }gi Edcluyz}ap Akmi# @m# 910:'d)'>)'E)& 'm)'5)# ]gi afd`bdc} bdp qiil

    oym`a`df uix`i~ kh d m`qdffk~im afd`b ~`}g }gi dzzukzu`d}i himiudf m`q}u`a} akyu}# @m# 910:'d)'=)#

    ]gi Qiaui}dup kh }gi ]uidqyup gdq ck} dzzk`c}im }gi HM@A dq uiai`xiu kh dcp hd`f`cn

    h`cdca`df akbzdcp zyuqydc} }k }gi zukaimyuiq ky}f`cim `c ]`}fi @@# Qii NDK& Dnica`iq Akc}`cyi

    Uyfibdl`cnq hku Afdu`hp`cn Qzia`h`a Zukx`q`kcq kh Kumiufp F`ty`md}`kc Dy}gku`}p& d} 5 'Oyfp

    5:45)& d} g}}z?++~~~#ndk#nkx+dqqi}q+8::+905147#zmh 'KFD gdq ck} eiic `cxklim#)#

    ZUKAIMYUDF EDALNUKYCM

    Kc Oyci 54& 5:45& Zfd`c}`hhq QCE& 8: Zfyq& dcm AI@ h`fim }gi `c`}`df Akbzfd`c} `c }g`q

    adqi# Qii Akbzf# hku Miaf# ( @co# Uif`ih& Oyci 54& 5:45 'IAH Ck# 4)# @c }gd} Akbzfd`c}& }gkqi

    Zfd`c}`hhq afd`bim }gd} }gi Eyuidyq dy}gku`}p }k `mic}`hp ychd`u& miaiz}`xi& ku deyq`xi da}q dcm

    zuda}`aiq dcm }gi Akyca`fq dy}gku`}p }k qyeoia} aiu}d`c ckcedclq }k bkui q}u`cnic} himiudf

    uinyfd}`kc dui ycakcq}ud`cim ep bidc`cnhyf agialq dcm edfdcaiq& `c x`kfd}`kc kh }gi qizdud}`kc kh

    zk~iuq# Qii `m# 9& >& 14">>& 7>"4:7# ]gip dfqk afd`bim }gd} }gi Zuiq`mic}q dzzk`c}bic} kh

    U`agdum Akumudp dq M`uia}ku kh }gi Eyuidy ~dq `cxdf`m ycmiu }gi Uiaiqq Dzzk`c}bic}q Afdyqi

    eiadyqi }gi Qicd}i dffinimfp ~dq ck} `c uiaiqq d} }gi }`bi kh }gi dzzk`c}bic}# Qii `m# 8& >7"

    78#

    Kc Qiz}ibeiu 5:& 5:45& Zfd`c}`hhq QCE& 8: Zfyq& AI@& dcm }gi Q}d}iq kh B`ag`ndc&

    Klfdgkbd& dcm Qky}g Adukf`cd }kni}giu h`fim dc Dbicmim Akbzfd`c}# Qii H`uq} Db# Akbzf# hku

    Miaf# ( @co# Uif`ih& Qiz}# 5:& 5:45 'IAH Ck# 8) 'Db# Akbzf#)# @c }gi Dbicmim Akbzfd`c}&

    Zfd`c}`hhq QCE& 8: Zfyq& dcm AI@ uidqqiu} dcm iwzdcm yzkc }gi afd`bq }gip bdmi `c }gi

    Akbzfd`c} dq }k }gi dy}gku`}p kh }gi Eyuidy dcm }gi Akyca`f dcm dq }k M`uia}ku Akumudpq

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 4> kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    22/61

    49

    dzzk`c}bic}# Qii `m# 8"7& 94"4=4# @c dmm`}`kc& dff Zfd`c}`hhq ci~fp dqqiu} }gd} }gi ]uidqyup

    Qiaui}dupq dy}gku`}p }k dzzk`c} }gi HM@A dq uiai`xiu kh hd`f`cn h`cdca`df akbzdc`iq dcm+ku }gi

    HM@Aq uiai`xiuqg`z dy}gku`}p dui ycakcq}ud`cim ep bidc`cnhyf agialq dcm edfdcaiq& x`kfd}i myi

    zukaiqq& dcm x`kfd}i }gi akcq}`}y}`kcdf uity`uibic} hku yc`hkub`}p `c edcluyz}ap# Qii `m# 0"44&

    4=5">7#

    Q]DCMDUM KH UIX@I^

    Himiudf Uyfi kh A`x`f Zukaimyui 45'e)'4) uity`uiq m`qb`qqdf kh d akbzfd`c} `h }gi akyu}

    fdalq qyeoia} bd}}iu oyu`qm`a}`kc# Zfd`c}`hhq eidu }gi eyumic kh iq}def`qg`cn }gd} }gi akyu} gdq

    qyeoia} bd}}iu oyu`qm`a}`kc&Fyodc x# Mihicmiuq kh ^`fmf`hi& 9:= Y#Q# 999& 984 '4005)& dcm akyu}q

    qgkyfm zuiqybi }gd} \}gipR fdal oyu`qm`a}`kc ycfiqq }gi akc}udup dzziduq dhh`ubd}`xifp hukb }gi

    uiakum&Uicci x# Nidup& 9:4 Y#Q# 145& 148 '4004) 'tyk}d}`kcq kb`}}im)# Eiadyqi d akyu} gdq dc

    dhh`ubd}`xi kef`nd}`kc }k icqyui }gd} `} `q da}`cn ~`}g`c }gi qakzi kh `}q oyu`qm`a}`kcdf dy}gku`}p& }gi

    akyu} byq} qauy}`c`i zfd`c}`hhq dffind}`kcq bkui afkqifp ~gic akcq`miu`cn d bk}`kc }k m`qb`qq

    zyuqydc} }k Uyfi 45'e)'4) }gdc `} ~kyfm ~gic akcq`miu`cn d bk}`kc }k m`qb`qq zyuqydc} }k Uyfi

    45'e)'8)# Qagb`m} x# Y#Q# Adz`}kf Zkf`ai Em#&758 H# Qyzz# 5m 90& 89 'M#M#A# 5:44)< Im~dumq x#

    Dyukud Fkdc Qiuxq#& FFA& >04 H# Qyzz# 5m 4==& 4=0 'M#M#A# 5:44)#

    DUNYBIC]

    @# CKCI KH ]GI ZFD@C]@HHQ GDQ Q]DCM@CN#]gi mka}u`ci kh Du}`afi @@@ q}dcm`cn mibdcmq }gd} d zfd`c}`hh gdxi d ziuqkcdf q}dli `c }gi

    ky}akbi kh }gi akc}ukxiuqp \qkR dq }k ~duudc} g`q `cxkad}`kc kh himiudf"akyu} oyu`qm`a}`kc#

    ^du}g x# Qifm`c& =55 Y#Q# =0:& =07 '40>9) 'tyk}d}`kcq kb }}im)# ]k mibkcq}ud}i Du}`afi @@@

    q}dcm`cn& d zfd`c}`hh byq} qd}`qhp }guii zuiuity`q`}iq# Fyodc& 9:= Y#Q# d} 98:# H`uq}& d zfd`c}`hh

    byq} mibkcq}ud}i }gd} `} gdq qyhhiuim dc `coyup `c hda} dc `cxdq`kc kh d findffp zuk}ia}im

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 47 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    23/61

    48

    `c}iuiq} }gd} `q ek}g akcaui}i dcm zdu}`ayfdu`im dcm da}ydf ku `bb`cic}& ck} akcoia}yudf ku

    gpzk}gi}`adf# @m# 'tyk}d}`kcq kb`}}im)# Qiakcm& }gd} `coyup byq} ei hd`ufp }udaidefi }k }gi

    agdfficnim da}`kc kh }gi mihicmdc}# @m# 'tyk}d}`kcq kb`}}im)# H`cdffp& `} byq} ei f`lifp& dq

    kzzkqim }k biuifp qziayfd}`xi& }gd} }gi `coyup ~`ff ei uimuiqqim ep d hdxkudefi mia`q`kc# @m# d}

    984 'tyk}d}`kcq kb`}}im)#

    ]giqi Du}`afi @@@ q}dcm`cn uity`uibic}q dqqyui }gd} findf tyiq}`kcq ~`ff ei uiqkfxim& ck}

    `c }gi udu`h`im d}bkqzgiui kh d mied}`cn qka`i}p& ey} `c d akcaui}i hda}ydf akc}iw} akcmya`xi }k d

    uidf`q}`a dzzuia`d}`kc kh }gi akcqityicaiq kh oym`a`df da}`kc# Xdffip Hkuni Agu`q}`dc Akff# x#

    Dbq# Yc`}im hku Qizdud}`kc kh Agyuag ( Q}d}i& @ca#& =9= Y#Q# =8=& =>5 '4075)# ]gi dcdfpq`q kh

    }giqi uity`uibic}q& ~g`ag uihfia} hycmdbic}df qizdud}`kc"kh"zk~iuq akcaiucq& byq} ei

    iqzia`dffp u`nkukyq ~gic himiudf akyu}q dui dqlim }k akcmya} akcq}`}y}`kcdf uix`i~ kh }gi

    da}`kcq kh ak"itydf eudcagiq kh nkxiucbic}# Ud`ciq x#Epum& 954 Y#Q# 744& 740"75: '400>)# @c

    }g`q agdfficni }k }gi akcq}`}y}`kcdf`}p kh }guii }`}fiq kh dc Da} kh Akcnuiqq& dcm }k }gi Zuiq`mic}q

    iwiua`qi kh g`q uiaiqq dzzk`c}bic} zk~iu& ckci kh }gi Zfd`c}`hhq gdq qd}`qh`im }giqi akui

    uity`uibic}q# Ckci kh }gi Zfd`c}`hhq gdq eiic `coyuim ep d Eyuidy uinyfd}`kc& Eyuidy

    ichkuaibic} da}`kc& Akyca`f miq`ncd}`kc& ku ]`}fi @@ f`ty`md}`kc& dcm }gi`u qyeoia}`xi dcm

    ychkycmim hiduq }gd} }gip b`ng} qkbimdp ei dhhia}im ep qyag da}`kcq dui ck} ickyng }k `cxkli

    }g`q Akyu}q oyu`qm`a}`kc#

    D# ZFD@C]@HH Q]D]I CD]@KCDF EDCL KH E@N QZU@CN? AKYC] @#@c Akyc} @ kh }gi Dbicmim Akbzfd`c}& Zfd`c}`hh QCE afd`bq }gd} }gi Eyuidyq YMDDZ

    dy}gku`}p `q ycakcq}ud`cim ep bidc`cnhyf agialq dcm edfdcaiq& `c x`kfd}`kc kh }gi qizdud}`kc kh

    zk~iuq# Qii Db# Akbzf# 8& 09& 4:>& 471& 470# Bkui qzia`h`adffp& QCE afd`bq }gd} }gi

    Eyuidyq YMDDZ dy}gku`}p `q }kk kzic"icmim& qii `m# 9=">0& dcm }gd} `} `q ck} akcq}ud`cim ep

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 40 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    24/61

    4>

    Akcnuiqqq dzzukzu`d}`kcq dy}gku`}p& `m# 08"4:4& ep zuiq`mic}`df ku Himiudf Uiqiuxi Ekdum

    kxiuq`ng}& `m# 4:5":=& 4:8& ku ep dzzukzu`d}i oym`a`df uix`i~& `m# 4:9# QCE fdalq q}dcm`cn }k

    ud`qi `}q Akyc} @ afd`b eiadyqi `} gdq hd`fim }k `mic}`hp dcp zuiqic} `coyup ku aiu}d`cfp `bzicm`cn

    `coyup adyqim ep }gi agdfficnim zukx`q`kcq kh }gi Da}#

    4# QCEq Zyuzku}im Hidu kh d Hy}yui Ichkuaibic} Da}`kc Mkiq Ck}Akcq}`}y}i dc @coyup `c Hda}#

    QCE h`uq} afd`bq }gd} }gi Eyuidyq dy}gku`}p }k ichkuai }gi YMDDZ zukg`e`}`kc gdq

    auid}im d ag`ff`cn ihhia} kc `}q akcqybiu ficm`cn zuda}`aiq }gd} adyqim QCE }k iw`} }gi

    bku}ndni ficm`cn eyq`ciqq `c Ka}keiu 5:4:# Db# Akbzf# 48& >7# QCEq zyuzku}im hidu kh

    ichkuaibic} mkiq ck} akcq}`}y}i dc `coyup `c hda}#

    d# ]gi Eyuidy Gdq X`u}ydffp Ck Ichkuaibic} Dy}gku`}p Kxiu QCE# Dq dc `c`}`df bd}}iu&

    }gi Eyuidy gdq x`u}ydffp ck dy}gku`}p }k ichkuai dcp akcqybiu h`cdca`df fd~ dnd`cq} dc `cqyuim

    mizkq`}kup `cq}`}y}`kc ~`}g -4: e`ff`kc ku fiqq `c dqqi}q# Qii 45 Y#Q#A# 9948'm)'4)#0 ^`}g

    uiqzia} }k qyag `cq}`}y}`kcq& }gi dzzf`adefi zuymic}`df uinyfd}ku gdq iwafyq`xi dy}gku`}p 'uifd}`xi

    }k }gi Eyuidy) }k ichkuai dcp x`kfd}`kc kh dcp Himiudf akcqybiu h`cdca`df fd~& `cafym`cn }gi

    YMDDZ zukg`e`}`kc# @m# ]gi Eyuidyq dy}gku`}p `q f`b`}im }k bdl`cn ichkuaibic}

    uiakbbicmd}`kcq }k }gi zuymic}`df uinyfd}kuq& `m# 9948'm)'5)'D)& ~gkqi kcfp kef`nd}`kc `q }k

    uiqzkcm }k qyag uiakbbicmd}`kcq `c ~u`}`cn& `m# 9948'm)'5)'E)# ]gi zuymic}`df uinyfd}kuq gdxi

    }gyq ui}d`cim }gi`u `cmizicmic} dy}gku`}p }k bdli ichkuaibic} mia`q`kcq ~`}g uiqzia} }k `cqyuim

    mizkq`}kup `cq}`}y}`kcq ~`}g -4: e`ff`kc ku fiqq `c dqqi}q#

    QCE `q d himiudffp"agdu}iuim edcl ~`}g fiqq }gdc -5>9 b`ff`kc `c mizkq`}q# Db# Akbzf#

    4=# Dq qyag& }gi KAA `q QCEq zuymic}`df uinyfd}ku# Qii 45 Y#Q#A# 9=74'5=)& 4741't)'4))# @c zdu}`ayfdu& dcm dq }g`q Akyu} uiaic}fp uiaknc`im& \dRffind}`kcq kh coyup

    edqim kc zuim`a}`kcq uindum`cn hy}yui findf zukaiim`cnq dui }kk qziayfd}`xi }k `cxkli }gi

    oyu`qm`a}`kc kh dc Du}`afi @@@ Akyu}# ^gid}kc Akff# x# Qieif`yq& "" H# Qyzz# 5m ""& A`x# Ck# 45"

    4480 'IQG)& 5:45 ^F 181>485& d} /= 'M#M#A# Dyn# 5=& 5:45) 'tyk}d}`kcq dcm df}iud}`kc

    kb`}}im)# @cq}idm& \~Rgiui d zfd`c}`hh gdq pi} }k hdai zukqiay}`kc ycmiu d q}d}y}i gi qiilq }k

    agdfficni& }gi zfd`c}`hh byq} '4) dffin\iR dc `c}ic}`kc }k icndni `c d akyuqi kh akcmya} dunydefp

    dhhia}im ~`}g d akcq}`}y}`kcdf `c}iuiq}& ey} zukqau`eim ep d q}d}y}i& dcm '5) mibkcq}ud}\iR }gd}

    }giui iw`q}q d auim`efi }guid} kh zukqiay}`kc }giuiycmiu# Kum x# M`q}# kh Akfybe`d& 97> H#1m

    4418& 44=: 'M#A# A`u# 5::0) 'tyk}d}`kcq kb`}}im)# Bkui qzia`h`adffp& }gi zfd`c}`hh byq}

    mibkcq}ud}i }gd} `} gdq eiic q`cnfim ky} ku yc`tyifp }duni}im hku ichkuaibic}# @m#

    QCE gdq ck} dffinim dcp auim`efi dcm `bb`cic} }guid} }gd} `} ~`ff ei qyeoia} }k dc KAA

    ichkuaibic} da}`kc }udaidefi }k qkbi da}`kc kh }gi Eyuidy# H`uq}& }gi Eyuidy gdq ck} qqyim dcp

    uinyfd}`kcq zyuqydc} }k `}q dy}gku`}p }k `mic}`hp da}q ku zuda}`aiq dq YMDDZq& 45 Y#Q#A#

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 55 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    27/61

    5:

    9914'e)# Cku gdq QCE `mic}`h`im dcp fiqq hkubdf Eyuidy ny`mdcai yzkc ~g`ag }gi KAA b`ng}

    edqi dc ichkuaibic} zukaiim`cn dnd`cq} QCE# Qiakcm& QCE gdq ck} dffinim }gd} }gi Eyuidy gdq

    zdu}`a`zd}im `c dcp iwdb`cd}`kc kh QCE ku uiakbbicmim dcp ichkuaibic} da}`kc dnd`cq} QCE&

    ku }gd} dcp qyag Eyuidy da}`kcq dui aiu}d`cfp `bzicm`cn#4: QCEq biui qziayfd}`kc }gd} }gi

    KAA akyfm qkbimdp `c`}`d}i dc ichkuaibic} da}`kc dnd`cq} QCE }gd} ~kyfm ei hd`ufp }udaidefi

    }k d hy}yui Eyuidy uyfibdl`cn& ny`mdcai& iwdb`cd}`kc& ku uiakbbicmd}`kc mkiq ck} qd}`qhp `}q

    eyumic kh mibkcq}ud}`cn Du}`afi @@@ q}dcm`cn#

    a# QCEq Xkfyc}dup Mia`q`kc }k Aidqi Bku}ndni Ficm`cn Mkiq Ck} Akchiu Q}dcm`cn#

    QCEq dffind}`kc }gd} `} q}kzzim `}q bku}ndni ficm`cn `c Ka}keiu 5:4: edqim kc `}q hidu kh d

    hy}yui Eyuidy ichkuaibic} da}`kc& qii Db# Akbzf# >7& `q d qifh"`chf`a}im gdub }gd} mkiq ck}

    akchiu q}dcm`cn ycmiu Du}`afi @@@# QiiNukaiup Bhuq# Dqqc x# IZD& 801 H#1m 480& 4>>'M#A# A`u#

    5:45) 'bdcyhda}yuiuq xkfyc}dup mia`q`kc }k }dli da}`kcq ck} bdcmd}im ep fd~ ~dq d qifh"

    `chf`a}im gdub }gd} m`m ck} akchiu q}dcm`cn }k agdfficni }gi fd~)< Egm# kh Fkakbk}`xi Icnuq (

    ]ud`cbic x# Qyuhdai ]udcqz# Em#& =9> H#1m 5=& 57 'M#A# A`u# 5::8) 'yc`kcq xkfyc}dup dnuiibic}

    }k d akffia}`xi edund`c`cn dnuiibic} }iub f`b`}`cn `}q u`ng} }k edund`c ~dq d qifh"`chf`a}im gdub

    }gd} m`m ck} akchiu q}dcm`cn }k agdfficni d Qyuhdai ]udcqzku}d}`kc Ekdum da}`kc }gd} }u`nniuim }gi

    }iub)

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    28/61

    54

    Dcp fkqq kh eyq`ciqq adyqim ep QCEq xkfyc}dup mia`q`kc }k iw`} }gi bku}ndni ficm`cn

    `cmyq}up ~dq zfd`cfp qifh"`chf`a}im# ]gi Eyuidy gdq ck m`uia} ichkuaibic} dy}gku`}p ~`}g uiqzia}

    }k QCE& dcm dcp ichkuaibic} da}`kc }dlic ep }gi KAA yzkc d Eyuidy uinyfd}`kc ku }gi Eyuidyq

    uiakbbicmd}`kc `q ic}`uifp qziayfd}`xi d} }g`q zk`c}# Bkuikxiu& dq ck}im& QCE `q qyziux`qim hku

    akbzf`dcai ~`}g Himiudf akcqybiu h`cdca`df fd~ '`cafym`cn }gi YMDDZ zukg`e`}`kc) ep }gi

    KAA& ey} QCE gdq hd`fim }k dffini }gd} `} qkyng} dcp ny`mdcai hukb KAA& zu`ku }k iw`}`cn }gi

    `cmyq}up& uindum`cn }gi findf`}p kh }gi bku}ndni ficm`cn zuda}`aiq `} qyqzia}im b`ng} ei x`i~im dq

    ychd`u& miaiz}`xi& ku deyq`xi# Qii Cd}f Qii Hdb`fp Zfdcc`cn ( Uizukm# Gidf}g Dqqc& @ca# x#

    Nkcdfiq& =87 H#1m 758& 714 'M#A# A`u# 5::8) 'dqqka`d}`kcq hd`fyui }k qiil afdu`h`ad}`kc hukb }gi

    dnicap uindum`cn dc dffinim akchf`a} ei}~iic d q}d}y}kup dbicmbic} dcm d uinyfd}`kc fim }k qifh"

    `chf`a}im `coyup)# Hku }giqi uidqkcq& QCEq k~c mia`q`kc adyqim dcp fkqq kh eyq`ciqq `} gdq

    qyhhiuim dq d uiqyf} kh `}q mizdu}yui hukb }gi bku}ndni ficm`cn `cmyq}up& dcm }gd} dffinim gdub `q

    }giuihkui ck} d aknc`defi `coyup `c hda} hd`ufp }udaidefi }k }gi agdfficnim zukx`q`kcq kh }gi Da}#

    QCEq eukdmiu dffind}`kcq }gd} }gi Eyuidyq dffinimfp ycf`b`}im YMDDZ dy}gku`}p ~`ff

    gdxi d ag`ff`cn ihhia} kc }gi da}`x`}p kh h`cdca`df qiux`ai zukx`miuq& qii Db# Akbzf# 8>& dui

    `cqyhh`a`ic} }k akcq}`}y}i dc `coyup `c hda}# Dffind}`kcq kh d qyeoia}`xi ag`ff dui ck} dc dmityd}i

    qyeq}`}y}i hku d afd`b kh qzia`h`a zuiqic} keoia}`xi gdub ku d }guid} kh qzia`h`a hy}yui gdub< }gi

    himiudf akyu}q # # # mk ck} uicmiu dmx`qkup kz`c`kcq# Fd`um x# ]d}yb& =:7 Y#Q# 4& 41"4= '40>5)

    'tyk}d}`kcq kb`}}im)< qii dfqk ^`cqciqq x# Pkayb&=11 H#1m >5>& >15 '4:}g A`u# 5::8)']gi

    biui zuiqicai kc }gi q}d}y}i ekklq kh dc ycakcq}`}y}`kcdf q}d}y}i # # # mkiq ck} ic}`}fi dcpkci }k

    qyi& ixic `h }gip dffini dc `cg`e`}`cn ihhia} kc akcq}`}y}`kcdffp zuk}ia}im akcmya} zukg`e`}im ep

    }gi q}d}y}i#)< Cd}f U`hfi Dqqc kh Db# x# Bdnd~& 415 H#1m 5>5& 50= '8}g A`u# 400>) 'Iwaiz} hku

    adqiq `cxkfx`cn akui H`uq} Dbicmbic} u`ng}q& }gi iw`q}icai kh d ag`ff`cn ihhia} gdq cixiu eiic

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 5= kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    29/61

    55

    akcq`miuim d qyhh`a`ic} edq`q& `c dcm kh `}qifh& hku zukg`e`}`cn nkxiucbic} da}`kc#) 'tyk}d}`kcq

    dcm df}iud}`kcq kb`}}im)< ^gid}kc Akff#& "" H# Qyzz# 5m ""& A`x# Ck# 45"4480 'IQG)& 5:45 ^F

    181>485& d} /8 '\DRffind}`kcq kh ag`ff`cn `coyup dui ck} qyhh`a`ic} edq`q hku q}dcm`cn }k agdfficni

    d nkxiucbic} da}`kc\#R) 'tyk}d}`kcq kb`}}im)#

    / / /

    Daakum`cnfp& QCEq dffinim hidu kh d hy}yui ichkuaibic} da}`kc zyuqydc} }k }gi Eyuidyq

    dy}gku`}p }k `mic}`hp da}q ku zuda}`aiq dq YMDDZq& ku `}q dy}gku`}p }k bdli ichkuaibic}

    uiakbbicmd}`kcq uindum`cn qyag da}q ku zuda}`aiq& mkiq ck} akcq}`}y}i dc `coyup `c hda} qyhh`a`ic}

    }k akchiu q}dcm`cn yzkc QCE }k ud`qi `}q Akyc} @ afd`b#

    5# ]gi Eyuidyq Uib`}}dcai ]udcqhiu Uyfi Mkiq Ck} Akcq}`}y}i dc @coyup `cHda} Hd`ufp ]udaidefi }k }gi Agdfficnim Zukx`q`kcq kh }gi Da}#

    Zfd`c}`hh QCE ciw} afd`bq }gd} `} gdq qyhhiuim dc `coyup dq d uiqyf} kh }gi Eyuidyq h`cdf

    uyfi iq}def`qg`cn m`qafkqyui uity`uibic}q hku aiu}d`c uib`}}dcai }udcqhiu zukx`miuq 'Uib`}}dcaiq

    Uyfi)# Db# Akbzf# 49# Dq qi} hku}g dekxi& Mkmm"Hudcl dbicmim }gi Ifia}ukc`a Hycm

    ]udcqhiu Da} }k uity`ui ci~ akcqybiu zuk}ia}`kcq hku uib`}}dcai }udcqhiuq qic} ep akcqybiuq `c

    }gi Yc`}im Q}d}iq }k `cm`x`mydfq dcm eyq`ciqqiq `c hkui`nc akyc}u`iq# Qii Mkmm"Hudcl Da}

    4:>1'd)'=) 'akm`h`im d} 49 Y#Q#A# 4801k"4)# ]gi Himiudf Uiqiuxi Ekdum zyef`qgim d ck}`ai

    kh zukzkqim uyfibdl`cn }k `bzfibic} }g`q zukx`q`kc kc Bdp 51& 5:44& zyuqydc} }k `}q uyfibdl`cn

    dy}gku`}p ycmiu }gi IH]D# Qii Ifia}ukc`a Hycm ]udcqhiuq& >8 Him# Uin# 500:5 'Bdp 51& 5:44)#

    Dh}iu }gi }udcqhiu kh }g`q uyfibdl`cn dy}gku`}p }k }gi Eyuidy& }gi Eyuidy zyef`qgim `}q h`cdf

    Uib`}}dcaiq Uyfi `c }gi Himiudf Uin`q}iukc Hieuydup >& 5:45& dcm zyef`qgim dc dbicmbic} }k

    }gd} uyfi kc Dynyq} 5:& 5:45& zyuqydc} }k }gi qdbi dy}gku`}p# Qii Ifia}ukc`a Hycm ]udcqhiuq&

    >> Him# Uin# 840= 'Hie# >& 5:45) 'akm`h`im d} 45 A#H#U# z}# 4::9& qyezdu} E 'Uinyfd}`kc I))> Him# Uin# 9:5== 'Dyn 5:& 5:45) 'dbicm`cn 45 A#H#U# z}# 4::9)#

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 59 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    30/61

    51

    ]gi H`cdf Uyfi& dq dbicmim& nkiq `c}k ihhia} kc Hieuydup >& 5:41# >> Him# Uin# d} 840=< >> Him#

    Uin# d} 9:5==# ]gi Uib`}}dcaiq Uyfi `q ck} dc coyup `c hda} qyhh a`ic} }k akchiu q}dcm`cn yzkc

    QCE }k dqqiu} `}q akcq}`}y}`kcdf agdfficni }k ]`}fi W kh }gi Da}#

    d# QCE Gdq Hd`fim }k Dffini Hda}q Mibkcq}ud}`cn }gd} @} @q Qyeoia} }k }gi Uib`}}dcaiq

    Uyfi# H`uq}& QCE gdq hd`fim }k zfidm qyhh`a`ic} hda}q mibkcq}ud}`cn }gd} `} `q ixic qyeoia} }k }gi

    Uib`}}dcaiq Uyfi# Q`nc`h`adc}fp& }gi Uib`}}dcaiq Uyfi dzzf`iq kcfp }k d uib`}}dcai }udcqhiu

    zukx`miu& ~g`ag `q q}d}y}ku`fp mih`cim dq d h`cdca`df `cq}`}y}`kc }gd} zukx`miq uib`}}dcai

    }udcqhiuq hku d akcqybiu `c }gi ckubdf akyuqi kh `}q eyq`ciqq# 49 Y#Q#A# 4801k"4'n)'1)

    'ibzgdq`q dmmim)# Eiadyqi }gi q}d}y}kup mih`c`}`kc `cafymiq kcfp }gkqi ic}`}`iq }gd} zukx`mi

    uib`}}dcai }udcqhiuq `c }gi ckubdf akyuqi kh \}gi`uR eyq`ciqq& }gi `bzfibic}`cn uinyfd}`kc

    `cafymiq d qdhi gdueku hku }gkqi ic}`}`iq }gd} akcq`q}ic}fp zukx`mi 4:: ku hi~iu uib`}}dcai

    }udcqhiuq ziu pidu?

    Qdhi gdueku# Ycmiu 4::9#1:'h)'5)'`)& d ziuqkc }gd} zukx`mim 4:: ku hi~iu uib`}}dcai}udcqhiuq `c }gi zuix`kyq adficmdu pidu dcm zukx`miq 4:: ku hi~iu uib`}}dcai }udcqhiuq `c}gi ayuuic} adficmdu pidu `q miibim ck} }k ei zukx`m`cn uib`}}dcai }udcqhiuq `c }gi ckubdfakyuqi kh `}q eyq`ciqq# Daakum`cnfp& d ziuqkc }gd} tydf`h`iq hku }gi qdhi gdueku `c 4::9#1:'h)'5)'`) `q ck} d uib`}}dcai }udcqhiu zukx`miu dcm `q ck} qyeoia} }k }giuity`uibic}q kh qyezdu} E#

    Ifia}ukc`a Hycm ]udcqhiuq& >> Him# Uin# d} 9:579 'akm`h`im d}45 A#H#U# 4::9#1:'h)'5))#44 @c

    }gi zuidbefi }k }gi h`cdf uyfi dmkz}`cn }gi qdhi gdueku& }gi Eyuidy ck}im }gd} d bidc`cnhyf

    zku}`kc kh }gi mizkq`}kup `cq}`}y}`kcq dcm auim`} yc`kcq akxiuim ep }gi dzzf`adefi md}d qi}q

    akffia}im ep }gi Eyuidy ~iui qicm`cn 4:: ku hi~iu uib`}}dcai }udcqhiuq dccydffp# @m# d} 9:595#

    44 Hyu}giubkui& ycmiu }gi niciudf mih`c`}`kc kh uib`}}dcai }udcqhiu zukx`miu& 45 A#H#U# 4::9#1:'h)'4)& dc ic}`}p }gd} mkiq ck} tydf`hp hku }gi qdhi gdueku bdp q}`ff mibkcq}ud}i }gd} `}mkiq ck} zukx`mi uib`}}dcai }udcqhiuq `c }gi ckubdf akyuqi kh `}q eyq`ciqq mizicm`cn kc }gihda}q dcm a`uaybq}dcaiq& `cafym`cn }gi }k}df cybeiu dcm huityicap kh uib`}}dcai }udcqhiuq qic}dcm ~gi}giu uib`}}dcai }udcqhiuq dui niciudffp bdmi dxd`fdefi }k ayq}kbiuq# Qii Ifia}ukc`a Hycm]udcqhiuq& >> Him# Uin# d} 9:579#

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 58 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    31/61

    5=

    @c zdu}`ayfdu& }gi Eyuidy hkycm }gd} ei}~iic ukyngfp =: ziuaic} dcm 0: ziuaic} kh }gkqi

    uiqzkcm`cn }k ku akxiuim ep }gi md}d& ~gk uizku}im dcp }udcqda}`kcq `c }gi bkq} uiaic} adficmdu

    pidu& uizku}im zukx`m`cn 4:: ku hi~iu qyag }udcqda}`kcq `c }gd} pidu# @m# Dq d uiqyf} kh }giqi

    uinyfd}kup da}`kcq& `cq}`}y}`kcq }gd} zukx`mi `c}iucd}`kcdf uib`}}dcaiq }k }gi`u ayq}kbiuq kc dc

    `chuityic} ku dm gka edq`q ~`ff ck} ei qyeoia} }k }gi uyfi dcm ~`ff niciudffp ei defi }k bdli }g`q

    mi}iub`cd}`kc ~`}g aiu}d`c}p#

    Df}gkyng QCE eiduq }gi eyumic afidufp }k dffini hda}q mibkcq}ud}`cn }gd} \`}R `q d zukziu

    zdu}p }k `cxkli oym`a`df uiqkfy}`kc kh }gi m`qzy}i dcm }gi iwiua`qi kh }gi akyu}.q uibim`df zk~iuq&

    ^du}g& =55 Y#Q# d} 94>"47& `} gdq hd`fim }k mk qk giui# Daakum`cn }k }gi Dbicmim Akbzfd`c}&

    QCE q}kzzim zukx`m`cn uib`}}dcai }udcqhiuq df}kni}giu hkffk~`cn }gi Eyuidyq zukbyfnd}`kc kh

    }gi Hieuydup h`cdf uyfi# Db# Akbzf# 49# Df}gkyng `} afd`bq } m`m qk }k dxk`m }gi akq}q

    dqqka`d}im ~`}g akbzf`dcai& `m# 78& QCE gdq hd`fim }k dffini hda}q qyhh`a`ic} }k mibkcq}ud}i }gd}

    `}q zu`ku uib`}}dcai }udcqhiu da}`x`}p ~kyfm gdxi qyeoia}im `} }k }gi uyfiq uity`uibic}q ku }gd}& ey}

    hku }gi uinyfd}`kc& `} ~kyfm uiqybi }gd} da}`x`}p d} d fixif }gd} ~kyfm qyeoia} `} }k }gi uyfiq

    uity`uibic}q# Qii `m# 49& 78# @cmiim& QCEq Agd`ubdc dcm AIK gdq qynniq}im oyq} }gi

    kzzkq`}i& }iq}`hp`cn eihkui Akcnuiqq }gd} QCE khhiuim uib`}}dcai }udcqhiuq `c }gi zdq} zu`bdu`fp

    dq d kci"khh qiux`ai }k d hi~ ayq}kbiuq ~gk hkycm }gibqifxiq `c qkbi }kyng qaudziq dcm }gd}

    uib`}}dcaiq bdli yz d uifd}`xifp qbdff zdu} kh \QCEqR eyq`ciqq# ]iq}`bkcp kh O`b U# Zyuaiff&

    Agd`ubdc dcm A#I#K# kh }gi Q}d}i Cd}`kcdf Edcl kh E`n Qzu`cn& ]gi Dmxiuqi Akcqityicaiq kh

    }gi Mkmm"Hudcl Da} kc Akbbyc`}p Edcl Ayq}kbiuq dcm Ekuuk~iuq& d} 9 'Oyfp 40& 5:45)& d}

    g}}z?++h`cdca`dfqiux`aiq#gkyqi#nkx+YzfkdmimH`fiq+GGUN"445"ED:0"^Q}d}i"OZyuaiff"

    5:45:>40#zmh# Eiadyqi QCE gdq ck} dffinim }gd} }gi xkfybi kh `}q uib`}}dcai }udcqhiu eyq`ciqq

    `q& ku ixic ~dq& qyhh`a`ic} }k eu`cn }gi edcl ~`}g`c }gi uinyfd}kup qakzi kh }gi Uib`}}dcaiq Uyfi&

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 5> kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    32/61

    59

    `} adcck} `cxkli }gi uinyfd}kup akbzf`dcai akq}q dqqka`d}im ~`}g }gd} uyfi dq d edq`q hku

    agdfficn`cn }gi Eyuidyq hkubd}`kc dcm kziud}`kc#

    e# ]gi Uib`}}dcaiq Uyfi ^dq Ck} Zukbyfnd}im Zyuqydc} }k }gi Dy}gku }p QCE

    Agdfficniq# Ixic `h `} ~iui qyeoia} }k }gi Uib`}}dcaiq Uyfi& QCE akyfm ck} uifp kc }gd} uyfi }k

    eu`cn `}q akcq}`}y}`kcdf agdfficni }k ]`}fi W# ]k iq}def`qg q}dcm`cn& d zfd`c}`hh byq} mibkcq}ud}i

    }gd} `}q dqqiu}im `coyup `q hd`ufp }udaidefi }k }gi agdfficnim da}`kc kh }gi mihicmdc}# Fyodc& 9:=

    Y#Q# d} 98:"84 'tyk}d}`kcq kb`}}im)# Bkui qzia`h`adffp& dcm dq uifixdc} giui& d zfd`c}`hhq `coyup

    byq} hfk~ hukb }gi zukx`q`kc kh }gi q}d}y}i `} qiilq }k agdfficni# QiiFi~`q x# Adqip& 947 Y#Q#

    1=1& 197 c#8 '4008) '\QR}dcm`cn `q ck} m`qzicqim `c nukqq#)< H^+ZEQ& @ca# x# A`}p kh Mdffdq&

    =01 Y#Q# 549& 511"19 '400:) 'miaf`c`cn }k dqqiqq akcq}`}y}`kcdf`}p kh aiu}d`c zukx`q`kcq kh

    kum`cdcai }gd} ck zfd`c}`hh gdm q}dcm`cn }k agdfficni)< Akxicdc} Bim`d kh Q#A#& FFA x# A`}p kh C#

    Agdufiq}kc& =01 H#1m =54& =1: '=}g A`u# 5::>) '\DR zfd`c}`hh byq} iq}def`qg }gd} gi gdq q}dcm`cn

    }k agdfficni idag zukx`q`kc kh dc kum`cdcai ep qgk~`cn }gd} gi ~dq `coyuim ep dzzf`ad}`kc kh

    }gkqi zukx`q`kcq#)#

    @c Akyc} @ kh }gi Dbicmim Akbzfd`c}& QCE afd`bq }gd} }gi Eyuidyq dffinimfp ycf`b`}im

    dcm kzic"icmim YMDDZ dy}gku`}p `q ck} akcq}ud`cim ep dmityd}i agialq dcm edfdcaiq& `c

    x`kfd}`kc kh }gi qizdud}`kc kh zk~iuq# Qii Db# Akbzf# 8& 09& 4:>& 471& 470# ]gi Uib`}}dcaiq

    Uyfi& gk~ixiu& ~dq ck} zukbyfnd}im zyuqydc} }k }gi Eyuidyq YMDDZ dy}gku`}p& 45 Y#Q#A#

    9914'd)& 'e)# ]gi uinyfd}`kc ~dq `cq}idm zukbyfnd}im zyuqydc} }k }gi Eyuidyq qizdud}i

    dy}gku`}p& }udcqhiuuim hukb }gi Himiudf Uiqiuxi Ekdum& }k `bzfibic} }gi Ifia}ukc`a Hycm

    ]udcqhiu Da}# Qii 45 Y#Q#A# 9974'e)'4)& 9=74'45)< qii dfqk 45 A#H#U# 4::9#4'd) 'a`}`cn dq

    dy}gku`}p }gi IH]D& 49 Y#Q#A# 4801"4>::)# Df}gkyng }gi Dbicmim Akbzfd`c}q ~dcmiu`cn

    m`qayqq`kc kh ]`}fi W `cafymiq d niciudf miqau`z}`kc kh }gi Eyuidyq }udcqhiuuim dy}gku`}p& }gi

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 57 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    33/61

    58

    Dbicmim Akbzfd`c} mkiq ck} dffini }gd} }g`q }udcqhiuuim dy}gku`}p `q ycf`b`}im& kzic"icmim& ku

    k}giu~`qi akcq}`}y}`kcdffp mihia}`xi& cku mkiq `} iwzfd`c ~gi}giu ku gk~ }g`q }udcqhiuuim dy}gku`}p

    akc}u`ey}iq }k }gi qizdud}`kc kh zk~iuq x`kfd}`kc `} gdq dffinim#45 Qii Db#Akbzf# 75"7>#

    @cq}idm& }gi Dbicmim Akbzfd`c}q miqau`z}`kc kh }gi Eyuidyq }udcqhiuuim dy}gku`}p dzziduq }k

    gdxi eiic `cafymim qkfifp `c dc ihhku} }k akcx`cai }gi Akyu} }gd} QCE gdq qyhhiuim qkbi l`cm kh

    `coyup d} }gi gdcmq kh }gi Eyuidy# Qii `m# 49& 78"7># Ey} QCE adcck} ekk}q}udz dc coyup

    hfk~`cn hukb d q}d}y}kup nudc} kh dy}gku`}p `} gdq ck} agdfficnim `c}k q}dcm`cn }k agdfficni d

    ~gkffp qizdud}i nudc} kh dy}gku`}p# QiiAkxicdc} Bim`d kh Q#A#& FFA& =01 H#1m d} =1: '\DR

    zfd`c}`hh byq} iq}def`qg }gd} gi gdq q}dcm`cn }k agdfficni idag zukx`q`kc kh dc kum`cdcai ep

    qgk~`cn }gd} gi ~dq `coyuim ep dzzf`ad}`kc kh }gkqi zukx`q`kcq#)#

    Eiadyqi }gi Uib`}}dcaiq Uyfi ~dq ck} zukbyfnd}im zyuqydc} }k }gi q}d}y}kup dy}gku`}p

    }gd} QCE gdq agdfficnim& dcp `coyup hfk~`cn hukb }gd} uinyfd}`kc `q ck} dc `coyup }gd} `q hd`ufp

    }udaidefi }k }gi agdfficnim zukx`q`kcq kh }gi Da}#

    / / /

    @c qyb& }gi Eyuidy gdq ck} pi} }dlic dcp da}`kc }gd} dhhia}q Zfd`c}`hh QCE# Hku }g`q Akyu}

    }k ic}iu}d`c QCEq ]`}fi W afd`b d} }g`q zk`c} ~kyfm mihid} }gi ycmiufp`cn zyuzkqi kh }gi

    `bb`cicai uity`uibic}& ~g`ag `q }k icqyui }gd} }gi Akyu} mkiq ck} uicmiu dc dmx`qkup kz`c`kc

    `c d adqi `c ~g`ag ck `coyup ~kyfm gdxi kaayuuim d} dff# Dc`bdf Findf Mih# Hycm& @ca# x# Iqzp&

    51 H#1m =08& 9:: 'M#A# A`u# 400=) 'tyk}`cnFyodc& 9:= Y#Q# d} 98= c#5)# Eiadyqi }gi `coyu`iq }gd}

    45 @cmiim& }gi Dbicmim Akbzfd`c} `q afidu }gd} }gi ihhia}`xifp ycf`b`}im dy}gku`}p }gd}hkubq }gi edq`q kh Akyc} @& Db# Akbzf# 471& `q }gi Eyuidyq ihhia}`xifp ycf`b`}im uyfibdl`cn&ichkuaibic}& dcm qyziux`qkup zk~iuq kxiu ychd`u& miaiz}`xi& ku deyq`xi ficm`cn zuda}`aiq&`m# 09#

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 50 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    34/61

    5>

    QCE afd`bq hfk~ hukb }gi agdfficnim zukx`q`kcq kh ]`}fi W dui zuiqic}fp ckc"iw`q}ic}& QCE gdq

    hd`fim }k iq}def`qg }gd} `} gdq q}dcm`cn }k dqqiu} `}q ]`}fi W afd`b#41

    E# ZFD@C]@HH Q]D]I CD]@KCDF EDCL KH E@N QZU@CN? AKYC] @@#@c Akyc} @@ kh }gi Dbicmim Akbzfd`c}& Zfd`c}`hh QCE afd`bq }gd} M`uia}ku Akumudp ~dq

    ycakcq}`}y}`kcdffp dzzk`c}im eiadyqi }gi Qicd}i dffinimfp ~dq ck} `c uiaiqq d} }gi }`bi kh }gi

    dzzk`c}bic} dcm eiadyqi }gi Zuiq`mic} m`m ck} qiayui }gi Qicd}iq dmx`ai dcm akcqic}# Db#

    Akbzf# 4:7"47# Hku }gi uidqkcq qi} hku}g `c Qia}`kcq @#D#4 dcm @#D#5#d& qyzud& QCE gdq hd`fim

    }k dffini dc `coyup hfk~`cn hukb }gi Zuiq`mic}q uiaiqq dzzk`c}bic} eiadyqi `} gdq hd`fim }k dffini

    }gd} }gi Eyuidy& ycmiu }gi qyziux`q`kc kh M`uia}ku Akumudp ku k}giu~`qi& gdq }dlic da}`kc }gd} gdq

    `coyuim QCE ku }gd} dcp qyag da}`kc `q `bb`cic}? QCE gdq ck} eiic qyeoia} }k d Eyuidy

    ichkuaibic} da}`kc hku akbb`qq`kc kh d YMDDZ 'cku akyfm `} ei)& dcm QCE gdq ck} dffinim hda}q

    mibkcq}ud}`cn }gd} `} `q qyeoia} }k }gi Uib`}}dcaiq Uyfi# QCEq dffind}`kcq }gyq q}dcm `c q}dul

    akc}udq} }k }gkqi }gd} akyu}q gdxi hkycm n`xi u`qi }k q}dcm`cn }k agdfficni }gi akcq}`}y}`kcdf`}p kh

    dc iwiay}`xi khh`aiuq dzzk`c}bic}# Qii& i#n#& Huip}dn x# Akbbu kh @c}iucdf Uixicyi&9:4 Y#Q#

    787 '4004) 'dmoym`ad}`cn dc dzzk`c}bic}q afdyqi agdfficni eukyng} ep }dwzdpiuq dnd`cq} d

    qzia`df }dw oymni ~gk gdm ic}iuim d oymnbic} dnd`cq} }gib)< Fdcmup x# HM@A& 5:= H#1m 4459

    'M#A# A`u# 5:::) 'dmoym`ad}`cn dc dzzk`c}bic}q afdyqi agdfficni eukyng} ep dc `cm`x`mydf

    agdfficn`cn dc Dmb`c`q}ud}`xi Fd~ Oymniq mia`q`kc uiakbbicm`cn }gd} }gi `cm`x`mydf ei

    zukg`e`}im hukb edcl`cn)#4=

    41 QCE dfqk akbzfd`cq }gd} `} bdp iwziu`icai `cauidqim akbzf`dcai akq}q eiadyqi `} byq}bkc`}ku dcm zuim`a} }gi da}`x`}`iq kh }gi Eyuidy# @m# >0# @c }gi deqicai kh dcp Eyuidy da}`kc}gd} zuiqic}fp dzzf`iq }k QCE& gk~ixiu& QCEq akcaiuc }gd} `} byq} ~d}ag hku hy}yui nkxiucbic}uinyfd}`kcq }gd} b`ng} dzzfp }k `}q eyq`ciqq `q d niciudf`im nu`ixdcai\R }gd} `q `cqyhh`a`ic} }kakchiu q}dcm`cn# Qii Xdffip Hkuni Agu`q}`dc Akff#& =9= Y#Q# d} =>9 'tyk}d}`kcq kb`}}im)#

    4= A`}`cn Huii Ic}iuzu`qi Hycm x# Zyef`a Ak# Daakyc}`cn Kxiuq`ng} Ekdum'ZADKE)& 41:Q# A}# 1417 '5:4:)& QCE qynniq}q }gd} }gi akcq}`}y}`kcdf x`kfd}`kcq `} gdq dqqiu}im `c Akyc}q @ dcm

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 1: kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    35/61

    57

    Hyu}giubkui& QCEq h`uq} dqqiu}im `coyup }gi dffinim ag`ff`cn ihhia} }gd} adyqim QCE }k

    q}kz khhiu`cn bku}ndniq& qyzud @#D#4 adcck} qyzzku} `}q q}dcm`cn }k agdfficni M`uia}ku

    Akumudpq dzzk`c}bic} hku pi} dck}giu uidqkc? }gd} dffinim `coyup `q ck} }udaidefi }k M`uia}ku

    Akumudpq dzzk`c}bic} dcm `q ycf`lifp }k ei uimuiqqim ep d hdxkudefi mia`q`kc# Qii Fyodc& 9:=

    Y#Q# d} 98:"84# Df}gkyng QCE qynniq}q }gd} qkbi kh M`uia}ku Akumudpq q}d}ibic}q gdxi

    xdf`md}im dcm ui`chkuaim `}q hidu kh ichkuaibic}& Db# Akbzf# >8& QCEq dffinim `coyup hfk~q

    hukb }gi YMDDZ zukg`e`}`kc `}qifh 'dcm }gi KAAq dy}gku`}p }k ichkuai }g`q zukg`e`}`kc)& ck}

    hukb }gi M`uia}kuq dzzk`c}bic} ku dcp Eyuidy da}`kc ycmiu g`q fidmiuqg`z& `m# 48& 85& >7#

    ]gd} QCEq dqqiu}im `coyup hfk~q hukb }gi Da} `}qifh dcm ck} hukb M`uia}ku Akumudpq

    dzzk`c}bic} ku dcp Eyuidy da}`kc ycmiu M`uia}ku Akumudp `q `ffyq}ud}im ep QCEq xkfyc}dup

    mia`q`kc }k iw`} }gi bku}ndni ficm`cn `cmyq}up `c Ka}keiu 5:4:& `m# >7& bkui }gdc d pidu eihkui

    }gi Zuiq`mic}q dzzk`c}bic} kh M`uia}ku Akumudp kc Odcydup =& 5:45# D mia`q`kc ep }g`q Akyu}

    miafdu`cn M`uia}ku Akumudpq dzzk`c}bic} `cxdf`m ~kyfm ck} df}iu }gi a`uaybq}dcaiq }gd} QCE

    afd`bq adyqim `} }k iw`} }gi bku}ndni ficm`cn `cmyq}up d} }gd} }`bi# QCEq h`uq} dqqiu}im `coyup `q

    }gyq ci`}giu }udaidefi }k M`uia}ku Akumudpq dzzk`c}bic} cku f`lifp }k ei uimuiqqim ep d mia`q`kc

    miafdu`cn M`uia}ku Akumudpq dzzk`c}bic} ycakcq}`}y}`kcdf# Hku }g`q dmm`}`kcdf uidqkc& `} q ck}

    dc `coyup qyhh`a`ic} }k akchiu q}dcm`cn yzkc QCE }k agdfficni M`uia}ku Akumudpq dzzk`c}bic}#

    @@ kh }gi Dbicmim Akbzfd`c} }gibqifxiq iq}def`qg dc `coyup }gd} akchiuq q}dcm`cn# Qii Db#Akbzf# 40:& 400# ZADKE mkiq ck} qyzzku} QCEq afd`b kh q}dcm`cn# ]gi zfd`c}`hhq cZADKE gdm eiic qyeoia} }k d akcaui}i dmb`c`q}ud}`xi da}`kc ep }gi Ekdum ~gkqi akbzkq`}`kc}gip agdfficnim# ZADKE& 41: Q# A}# d} 14=0 ']gi Ekdum `cqzia}im }gi h`ub& uifidqim d uizku}au`}`adf kh `}q dym`}`cn zukaimyuiq& dcm eindc d hkubdf `cxiq}`nd}`kc#)# @c akc}udq}& QCE gdqhd`fim }k dffini hda}q qyhh`a`ic} }k mibkcq}ud}i }gd} `} `q zuiqic}fp qyeoia} }k dcp da}`kc ep }giEyuidy& ycmiu M`uia}ku Akumudpq qyziux`q`kc ku k}giu~`qi#

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 14 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    36/61

    50

    A# ZFD@C]@HH Q]D]I CD]@KCDF EDCL KH E@N QZU@CN? AKYC] @@@#Dq qi} hku}g dekxi& ]`}fi @ kh }gi Da} dy}gku`iq }gi Akyca`f }k miq`ncd}i aiu}d`c ckcedcl

    h`cdca`df akbzdc`iq dq Q@H@q< qyag d miq`ncd}`kc ~`ff qyeoia} }gi akbzdcp }k qyziux`q`kc ep }gi

    Himiudf Uiqiuxi Ekdum dcm }k gi`ng}icim zuymic}`df q}dcmdumq zuiqau`eim ep }gi Ekdum# 45

    Y#Q#A# 9151# @c Akyc} @@@ kh }gi Dbicmim Akbzfd`c}& QCE dffiniq }gd} qixiudf dqzia}q kh }gd}

    miq`ncd}`kc dy}gku`}p }kni}giu x`kfd}i }gi qizdud}`kc kh zk~iuq# Db# Akbzf# 7# @c zdu}`ayfdu& }

    afd`bq }gd} }gi q}d}y}kup hda}kuq nkxiuc`cn }gi Akyca`fq miq`ncd}`kc mi}iub`cd}`kcq `bzkqi ck

    bidc`cnhyf f`b`}q kc }gi Akyca`fq dy}gku`}p& `m# 418"1>< }gd} qkbi kh }gi Akyca`fq ckcxk}`cn

    bibeiuq dui ck} dzzk`c}im ep dc `cm`x`mydf `c }gi Iwiay}`xi Eudcag& `m# 455"5=< dcm }gd} }gi

    dzzf`adefi oym`a`df uix`i~ zukx`q`kc dy}gku`iq da}`kcq hku oym`a`df uix`i~ ep miq`ncd}im ic}`}`iq

    kcfp dcm iq}def`qgiq dc due`}udup dcm adzu`a`kyq q}dcmdum hku }gd} uix`i~& `m# 417"=4#

    QCE fdalq q}dcm`cn }k dqqiu} `}q ]`}fi @ afd`b# @} mkiq ck} dffini }gd} `} `q ku ~`ff ixiu ei

    }gi qyeoia} kh d Q@H@ miq`ncd}`kc ep }gi Akyca`f# @cmiim& `} `q g`ngfp ycf`lifp }gd}& dq d

    akbbyc`}p edcl ~`}g }k}df mizkq`}q kh fiqq }gdc -5>9 b`ff`kc& `m# 4=& `} ~kyfm ixic ei

    akcq`miuim hku miq`ncd}`kc& byag fiqq miq`ncd}im# Qii 45 A#H#U# z}# 414:& dzz# D& @@@#d#

    'iq}def`qg`cn d -9: e`ff`kc }k}df akcqkf`md}im dqqi} }guiqgkfm dq d zuiqybz}`xi }guiqgkfm hku

    miq`ncd}`kc)# Eiadyqi `} `q ycf`lifp ixiu }k ei miq`ncd}im d Q@H@& QCE cq}idm zyuzku}q }k afd`b

    dc `coyup edqim kc }gi Akyca`fq miq`ncd}`kc khk}giuic}`}`iq QCEq dffinim akbzi}`}kuq dq

    Q@H@q# Qii Db# Akbzf# 411# @c qk mk`cn& } d}}ibz}q }k adq} d Q@H@ miq`ncd}`kc dcm }gi

    gi`ng}icim himiudf uinyfd}`kc }gd} daakbzdc`iq `} dq d eicih`}& dcm }gic afd`bq }gd} `} ~`ff qyhhiu d

    akbzi}`}`xi `coyup eiadyqi `} ~`ff ck}ei miq`ncd}im# Ey} ~gic }gi zdu}p q ck} g`bqifh }gi

    keoia} kh }gi nkxiucbic} da}`kc ku `cda}`kc gi agdfficniq& q}dcm`cn # # # `q kum`cdu`fp qyeq}dc}`dffp

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 15 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    37/61

    1:

    bkui m`hh`ayf} }k iq}def`qg# Ci~ ^kufm Udm`k& @ca# x# HAA& 50= H#1m 48=& 4>: 'M#A# A`u# 5::5)

    'tyk}d}`kcq dcm df}iud}`kc kb`}}im)#

    @cmiim& QCE hdffq ~kihyffp qgku} kh bii}`cn `}q eyumic }k dffini dc `coyup }gd} ~kyfm n`xi

    `} q}dcm`cn }k agdfficni dcp zdu} kh ]`}fi @# ]gi Akyca`f gdq ck} pi} miq`ncd}im d q cnfi ic}`}p dq

    d Q@H@& qk QCE akyfm ck} zkqq`efp dffini d zuiqic} `coyup# QCE `cq}idm dffiniq }gd} `} ~`ff qyhhiu

    gdub `c }gi hy}yui& `h dcm ~gic kci kh `}q akbzi}`}kuq `q miq`ncd}im d Q@H@# Qii Db# Akbzf#

    415"11# Dq qi} hku}g dekxi& gk~ixiu& qziayfd}`kc deky} zkqq`efi hy}yui ixic}q mkiq ck}

    akcq}`}y}i dc `coyup `c hda}# ^g`}bkui& =09 Y#Q# d} 497# Ud}giu& \dR }guid}icim `coyup byq} ei

    aiu}d`cfp `bzicm`cn }k akcq}`}y}i `coyup `c hda}# @m# 'tyk}d}`kcq kb`}}im)< qii dfqk C#P# Uinf

    @c}iuakccia}& @ca# x# HIUA& 81= H#1m 974& 97> 'M#A# A`u# 5:44) '}gikup kh `coyup }gd} q}dalq

    qziayfd}`kc yzkc gpzk}gi}`adf yzkc qziayfd}`kc # # # mkiq ck} iq}def`qg dc da}ydf ku `bb`cic}

    `coyup) 'tyk}d}`kcq kb`}}im)01 H#5m 41:1& 41:7 'M#A# A`u# 4078) 'b`w}yui kh

    qziayfd}`kc dcm akcafyqkup dqqiu}`kc # # # mkiq ck} qd}`qhp }gi Qyzuibi Akyu}q uity`uibic} hku

    qzia`h`a& akcaui}i hda}q mibkcq}ud}`cn coyup& dcm zdu}`ayfdu`im dffind}`kcq kh hda})# QCEq

    afd`b kh hy}yui `coyup `q edqim yzkc d} fidq} }guii fdpiuq kh qziayfd}`kc deky} zkqq`efi hy}yui

    ixic}q# Dq mi}d`fim eifk~& QCE h`uq} qziayfd}iq }gd} }gi Akyca`f ~`ff miq`ncd}i kci kh `}q m`uia}

    akbzi}`}kuq d Q@H@ qyeoia} }k gi`ng}icim nkxiucbic} qyziux`q`kc dcm uinyfd}`kc# @} }gic

    qziayfd}iq }gd} }gi miq`ncd}im ic}`}pq auim`}kuq ~`ff& dq d uiqyf} kh qyag d miq`ncd}`kc& zukx`mi

    adz`}df }k }gd} ic}`}p kc bkui hdxkudefi }iubq# QCE }gic qziayfd}iq }gd} }g`q gpzk}gi}`adf akq}"

    kh"adz`}df eicih`} ~`ff ky}~i`ng }gi akq}q dqqka`d}im ~`}g }gi bkui q}u`cnic} nkxiucbic}

    uinyfd}`kc }k ~g`ag }gi gpzk}gi}`adffp"miq`ncd}im ic}`}p ~`ff ei qyeoia}& }giuiep uiqyf}`cn `c dc

    kxiudff akbzi}`}`xi m`qdmxdc}dni }k QCE# QCEq fkcn& d}}icyd}im agd`c kh nyiqq~kul uindum`cn

    dc `bdn`cim akyuqi kh hy}yui ixic}q `q `cqyhh`a`ic} }k akcq}`}y}i d akcaui}i dcm `bb`cic} `coyup#

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 11 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    38/61

    14

    4# QCE Qziayfd}iq }gd} Kci kh @}q M`uia} Akbzi}`}kuq ^`ff Ei Miq`ncd}im dQ@H@#

    ]k dqqiu} d aknc`defi `coyup dq d akbzi}`}ku kh dc ic}`}p }gd} `q }gi keoia} kh nkxiucbic}

    da}`kc& d zfd`c}`hh byq} dffini }gd} `} `q d m`uia}dcm ayuuic}akbzi}`}ku ~gkqi ek}}kb f`ci bdp

    ei dmxiuqifp dhhia}im ep }gi agdfficnim nkxiucbic} da}`kc# Ci~ ^kufm Udm`k& @ca#& 50= H#1m d}

    4>: 'ibzgdqiq `c ku`n`cdf)# Bkui qzia`h`adffp& d zfd`c}`hh byq} dffini }gd} `} khhiuq }gi qdbi

    zukmya} `c }gi qdbi bduli} dq }gi ic}`}p }gd} `q }gi keoia} kh }gi nkxiucbic} da}`kc# Qii `m# d}

    4>:">4 '^dqg`cn}kc& M#A# udm`k q}d}`kc fdalim q}dcm`cn }k agdfficni f`aicqi nudc}im }k Bdupfdcm

    udm`k q}d}`kc)& 8:"84 'M#A# A`u# 5::=)# Dq qyag& QCEq afd`b kh akbzi}`}`xi `coyup

    ciaiqqdu`fp mizicmq kc }gi Akyca`fq hy}yui miq`ncd}`kc kh dc ic}`}p ~`}g ~g`ag QCE `q d m`uia}

    dcm ayuuic} akbzi}`}ku# QCEq qynniq}`kc }gd} qyag dc ic}`}p ~`ff ei miq`ncd}im `q ek}g ckc"

    qzia`h`a dcm qziayfd}`xi#

    QCE `q d edcl# @} khhiuq agial`cn dcm qdx`cnq daakyc}q& aiu} h`ad}iq kh mizkq`} 'AMq)&

    dcm `cm`x`mydf ui}`uibic} daakyc}q }gukyng }q eudcagiq `c }guii qbdff ]iwdq }k~cq# Db# Akbzf#

    4=# @} `q k~cim ep d edcl gkfm`cn akbzdcp# Aiu}`h`ad}i Uyfi FAxU>#4& Oyci 54& 5:45 'IAH

    5)# @}q m`uia} akbzi}`}kuq dui }giuihkui k}giu edcl gkfm`cn akbzdc`iq dcm }gi`u qyeq`m`du`iq }gd}

    khhiu ayq}kbiuq `c }gi qdbi bduli} }giqi qdbi edcl`cn qiux`aiq# Edcl gkfm`cn akbzdc`iq&

    gk~ixiu& dui ck} qyeoia} }k }gi qzia`h`a Q@H@ miq`ncd}`kc zukaiqq }k ~g`ag QCE keoia}q# Qii 45

    Y#Q#A# 9144'd)'=) 'iwafym`cn edcl gkfm`cn akbzdcp hukb }gi mih`c`}`kc kh ckcedcl

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 1= kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    39/61

    15

    h`cdca`df akbzdcp)# @cq}idm& edcl gkfm`cn akbzdc`iq dui qyeoia} }k d qizdud}i q}d}y}kup Q@H@

    miq`ncd}`kc qagibi# Qii `m# 9189'd)'4) 'miq`ncd}`cn dff edcl gkfm`cn akbzdc`iq ~`}g }k}df

    akcqkf`md}im dqqi}q itydf }k ku nuid}iu }gdc -9: e`ff`kc dq ic}`}`iq qyeoia} }k gi`ng}icim himiudf

    uinyfd}`kc)# Daakum`cnfp& QCEq m`uia} akbzi}`}kuq `c }gi edcl`cn `cmyq}up dui q bzfp ck} }gi

    }pzi kh ic}`}`iq }gd} ~kyfm ixiu ei qyeoia} }k d Akyca`f miq`ncd}`kc#

    Ycf`li QCE dcm `}q m`uia} akbzi}`}kuq& ic}`}`iq qyeoia} }k d Akyca`f miq`ncd}`kc dui

    ckcedcl h`cdca`df akbzdc`iq# @m# 9151'd)'4)& 'e)'4)# QCE gdq ci`}giu mic}`h`im d q`cnfi

    ckcedcl }gd} khhiuq qiux`aiq }gd} akbzi}i ~`}g }gkqi khhiuim ep QCE `c E`n Qzu`cn& Fdbiqd& dcm

    KMkcciff& ]iwdq& cku dffinim }gd} dcp qyag ic}`}p `q aiu}d`c }k ei }gi qyeoia} kh d Akyca`f

    miq`ncd}`kc# Qii Db# Akbzf# 411 'dffin`cn kcfp }gd} hy}yui Akyca`f miq`ncd}`kcq ~`ff uity`ui

    QCE }k akbzi}i ~`}g k}giu& yc`mic}`h`im h`cdca`df akbzdc`iq)# QCEq hd`fyui }k `mic} hp d m`uia}

    akbzi}`}ku }gd} gdq eiic ku ~`ff ei qyeoia} }k d nkxiucbic} da}`kc `q hd}df }k `}q zfid hku

    akbzi}`}ku q}dcm`cn# QiiLIUB& @ca#& 191 H#1m d} 8:"84 'ck akbzi}`}ku q}dcm`cn ~giui LIUB

    xdnyifp dqqiu}q kcfp }gd} `} akbzi}iq ~`}g LDPG dcm }gd} `}q k~c udm`k q}d}`kcq qiuxi byag kh

    }gi qdbi dym`icai dq LDPG dcm hd`fim }k `c}ukmyai\R ix`micai }gd} LDPGq eukdmadq} kh }gi

    m`qzy}im dcckycaibic}q uiqyf}im `c fkq} dmxiu}`q`cn uixicyiq hku LIUB ku k}giu~`qi dmxiuqifp

    dhhia}im LIUBq h`cdca`df `c}iuiq}q)

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    40/61

    11

    5# QCE Qziayfd}iq }gd} Auim`}kuq ^`ff Uida} }k d Akyca`f Miq`ncd}`kc epZukx`m`cn Adz`}df }k }gi Miq`ncd}im Ic}`}p kc Bkui Hdxkudefi ]iubq#

    Ixic `h QCE gdm `mic}`h`im d m`uia} akbzi}`}ku }gd} `q aiu}d`c }k ei miq`ncd}im d Q@H@& `}q

    afd`b kh `coyup mizicmq yzkc }gi dmm`}`kcdf fdpiu kh qziayfd}`kc }gd} }g`q ic}`}p ~`ff uidf`i d

    akq}"kh"adz`}df dmxdc}dni dq d uiqyf} kh }gd} miq`ncd}`kc# Qii Db# Akbzf# 415# @c zdu}`ayfdu&

    QCE gpzk}giq`iq }gd} auim`}kuq ~`ff fk~iu }gi ud}iq d} ~g`ag }gip ficm bkcip }k Q@H@q eiadyqi

    auim`}kuq ~`ff x`i~ miq`ncd}im ic}`}`iq dq gdx`cn }gi `bzf`a`} edal`cn kh }gi nkxiucbic}& `m#

    457& dcm dq ic}`}`iq }gd} }gi nkxiucbic} ~`ff ck} dffk~ }k hd`f& `m# 450#

    Dq dc `c`}`df bd}}iu& QCE b`qycmiuq}dcmq }gi `bzku} kh d Akyca`f miq`ncd}`kc# D Akyca`f

    miq`ncd}`kc mkiq ck} bidc }gd} }gi himiudf nkxiucbic} `q edal`cn }gi h`cdca`df akbzdcp ku

    }gd} }gi nkxiucbic} ~`ff ck} dffk~ }gd} akbzdcp }k hd`f# @cq}idm& d Akyca`f miq`ncd}`kc bidcq

    }gd} }gi akbzdcp ~`ff ei qyeoia} }k bkui q}u`cnic} nkxiucbic} uinyfd}`kc& 45 Y#Q#A#

    9151'd)'4)& 'e)'4)& 9189'd)'4)& dcm }gd}& `h }gi akbzdcp mkiq hd`f& `} bdp ei qyeoia} }k kumiufp

    f`ty`md}`kc ycmiu }gi }iubq kh ]`}fi @@& `m# 9174'd)'44)'E)'` )# @cmiim& }gi Da} iwzuiqqfp

    zukx`miq }gd} kci kh }gi zyuzkqiq kh }gi Akyca`f `q }k if`b`cd}i\R iwzia}d}`kcq kc }gi zdu} kh # # #

    auim`}kuq # # # kh \fduni& `c}iuakccia}im h`cdca`dfR akbzdc`iq }gd} }gi Nkxiucbic} ~`ff qg`ifm }gib

    hukb fkqqiq `c }gi ixic} kh hd`fyui# @m# 9155'd)'4)'E) 'ibzgdq`q dmmim)# ]gi Da}q kumiufp

    f`ty`md}`kc dy}gku`}p ~dq miq`ncim }k mk }gi qdbi& ep auid}`cn dc df}iucd}`xi hku uiqkfx`cn hd`f`cn

    h`ubq }gd} `q ci`}giu d m`qkumiufp edcluyz}ap cku d ed`fky}& qii Q# Uiz# Ck# 444"4>8& d} = '5:4:)&

    dcm& `c zdu}`ayfdu& ep iwzuiqqfp zukg`e`}`cn uinyfd}kuq hukb yq`cn }dwzdpiu hycmq }k zuixic} }gi

    f`ty`md}`kc kh d hd`f`cn h`cdca`df akbzdcp& 45 Y#Q#A# 910='d)#49 QCEq }gikup }gd} d Akyca`f

    49 ]gi q}d}ibic} kh Agd`ubdc Eiucdcli }gd} QCE a`}iq& qii Db# Akbzf# 41:"14& hyu}giu`ffyq}ud}iq }g`q zk`c}# Zu`ku }k }gi zdqqdni kh Mkmm"Hudcl& Agd`ubdc Eiucdcli iwzfd`cim }gd} `hd h`ub `q zyef`afp ziuai`xim dq }kk e`n& ku `c}iuakccia}im& ku qpq}ib`adffp au`}`adf hku }gidy}gku`}`iq }k ziub`} `}q hd`fyui& `}q auim`}kuq dcm akyc}iuzdu}`iq gdxi fiqq `caic}`xi }k ixdfyd}i }gi

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 18 kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    41/61

    1=

    miq`ncd}`kc ~`ff n`xi auim`}kuq dc `caic}`xi }k khhiu adz`}df kc bkui hdxkudefi }iubq }k }gi

    miq`ncd}im ic}`}p eiadyqi }gi himiudf nkxiucbic} `q dffinimfp edal`cn }gd} akbzdcp `q }gyq

    edqim kc d hycmdbic}df b`qycmiuq}dcm`cn kh Mkmm"Hudcl#

    Uindumfiqq& QCE gdq hd`fim }k `mic}`hp dcp ckcedcl Q@H@ }gd} gdq uiai`xim d akq}"kh"

    adz`}df uimya}`kc hukb dcp auim`}ku# Cku akyfm `}# ]gi Akyca`f gdq pi} }k miq`ncd}i d Q@H@& qk

    dcp gpzk}gi}`adf Q@H@q auim`}kuq gdxi ck} pi} gdm }gi kzzku}yc`}p }k akcq`miu }gi miq`ncd}`kc

    dcm uiqzkcm }k `}# QCE `q }gyq defi }k khhiu ck}g`cn ey} xdnyi dqqiu}`kcq }gd} auim`}kuq niciudffp

    bdp khhiu bkui hdxkudefi }iubq }k Q@H@q niciudffp# Qyag niciudf`im dqqiu}`kcq kh `coyup

    ~gkffp ycakccia}im }k QCE dui `cqyhh`a`ic} }k qyzzku} `}q q}dcm`cn# QiiHfd# Dymyekc Qkap x#

    Eic}qic& 0= H#1m 897& 88> 'M#A# A`u# 4008) 'ic edca) 'zfd`c}`hh byq} qgk~ bkui }gdc }gd} }gi

    agdfficnim nkxiucbic} da}`kc ~kyfm adyqi dc icx`ukcbic}df gdub niciudffp< `} byq} dfqk qgk~

    }gd} }gi gdub da}ydffp }guid}icq }gi zfd`c}`hhq zdu}`ayfdu `c}iuiq}q)#

    Hyu}giubkui& dqqyb`cn dunyicmk }gd} d miq`ncd}im ic}`}p b`ng} uidf`i d akq}"kh"adz`}df

    eicih`}& dcp qyag eicih`} ~kyfm mizicm\R kc }gi ychi}}iuim agk`aiq bdmi ep `cmizicmic} da}kuq

    ck} eihkui }gi akyu}q dcm ~gkqi iwiua`qi kh eukdm dcm fin`}`bd}i m`qaui}`kc }gi akyu}q adcck}

    zuiqybi i`}giu }k akc}ukf ku }k zuim`a}# QiiFyodc& 9:= Y#Q# d} 985# D Q@H@q auim`}kuq ~`ff

    bdli }gi`u ficm`cn mia`q`kcq edqim kc dcp cybeiu kh bduli} dcm uinyfd}kup xdu`defiq# QCEq

    ycdmkucim qziayfd}`kc dq }k }gi iw`q}icai kh d uifd}`kcqg`z ei}~iic d Akyca`f miq`ncd}`kc dcm

    auim`}kuq ficm`cn mia`q`kcq \mkiqR ck} qyhh`ai }k `cxkli }gi himiudf oym`a`df zk~iu# Cd}f

    tydf`}p kh }gi h`ub.q eyq`ciqq bkmif& `}q bdcdnibic}# Qii Qziiag& Agd`ubdc Eic Q# Eiucdcli&Zuiqiux`cn d Aic}udf Ukfi hku Akbbyc`}p Edcl`cn 'Bdu# 5:& 5:4:)& d}g}}z?++~~~#himiudfuiqiuxi#nkx+ci~qixic}q+qziiag+eiucdcli5:4::15:d#g}b# Agd`ubdcEiucdcli }gic iwzfd`cim }gd} }g`q zukefib akyfm ei uibim`im ep d ci~ findf hudbi~kul }gd}~`ff dffk~ }gi nkxiucbic} }k ~`cm mk~c d hd`f`cn& qpq}ib`adffp au`}`adf h`ub `#i#& dcdf}iucd}`xi hku uiqkfx`cn hd`f`cn h`ubq }gd} `q ci`}giu d m`qkumiufp edcluyz}ap cku d ed`fky}# @m#]`}fi @@ kh Mkmm"Hudcl iq}def`qgim qyag d hudbi~kul#

    Adqi 4?45"ax":4:15"IQG Mkaybic} 49"4 H`fim 44+5:+45 Zdni 1> kh 98

  • 7/30/2019 Dodd Frank Lawsuit - Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

    42/61

    19

    ^uiq}f`cn Akdagiq Dqqc x# Miz} kh Imya#& 188 H#1m 01:& 017 'M#A# A`u# 5::=)'tyk}d}`kcq

    kb`}}im)< qii dfqk Hfd# Dymyekc Qkap& 0= H#1m d} 8>: 'ic edca) 'ck}`cn }gi `bzukede`f`}p kh

    iq}def`qg`cn dc `coyup }udaidefi }k d nkxiucbic} da}`kc ~gic qyag `coyup mizicmq kc zuim`a}`cn

    }gi da}q kh mkicq kh `cm`x`mydf da}kuq& idag kh ~gkb byq} uida} }k k}giu bduli} ku uinyfd}kup

    `czy}q)< Akbb# hku Bkci}dup Uihkub x# Em# kh Nkxiuckuq kh }gi Him# Uiqiuxi Qpq# & >88 H#5m

    917& 9=5 'M#A# A`u# 4079) '\@Rc f`ng} kh }gi akbzfiw`}p kh }gi bkmiuc iakckbp& `} `q # # # g`ngfp

    ycaiu}d`c ~gi}giu dcm }k ~gd} iw}ic} \nkxiucbic}R zkf`a`iq ~iui uiqzkcq`efi hku }gi dmxiuqi

    iakckb`a akcm`}`kcq }gd} dffinimfp uiqyf}im `c gdub }k }gi dzziffdc}q#)< Cieudqld x# Y#Q# Miz}

    kh Gidf}g ( Gybdc Qiuxq#& "" H# Qyzz# 5m ""& Ck# =?45AX1:19& 5:45 ^F 5041=:5& d} /40 'M#

    Cie# Oyfp 4>& 5:45)'ck q}dcm`cn ~gic zfd`c}`hhq kcfp qziayfd}i }gd} }g`um zdu}`iq ~`ff uiqzkcm }k

    }gi Uyfi `c d ~dp }gd} ~`ff gdub }gib)#

    Mibkcq}ud}`xi kh }gi ~idlciqqiq `c QCEq d}}icyd}im agd`c kh adyqd}`kc `q QCEq

    dffind}`kc }gd} fduni h`cdca`df akbzdc`iq dfuidmp icokp d akq}"kh"adz`}df dmxdc}dni& ixic ~`}gky}

    d hkubdf Akyca`f miq`ncd}`kc& eiadyqi auim`}kuq ziuai`xi qyag `cq}`}y}`kcq dq }kk e`n }k hd`f#

    Db# Akbzf# 415 ']gi HQKAq zk~iu }k hkubdffp miq`ncd}i ckcedcl Q@H@q ~`ff mk hku

    ckcedclq ~gd} yckhh`a`df Q@H@ q}d}yq fkcn gdq mkci hku yckhh`a`df Q@H@q? n`xi }gib d m`uia} akq}"

    kh"adz`}df qyeq`mp ck} icokpim ep # # # \QCER#)< `m# 41: 'miqau`e`cn eicih`}q kh ei`cn miibim

    }kk e`n }k hd`f eihkui Mkmm"Hudcl nudc}im miq`ncd}`kc dy}gku }p }k }gi Akyca`f)# Dqqyb`cn

    dunyicmk }gi akuuia}ciqq kh QCEq dffind}`kc& }gi dffind}`kc mihid}q QCEq k~c dqqiu}`kc kh

    q}dcm`cn# @h `}q dffind}`kc `q akuuia}& }gic QCE gdq hd`fim }k mibkcq}ud}i }gd} `}q dffi