Top Banner
DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 1 4 Residential Zones Sub. Name FS.Name Sub. Point FS. Point Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning Property Council of New Zealand 11.02 4 Residential Zones Support Accept the Ruakura Variation in its entirety. Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.20 Oppose Reject FS3.20 is rejected as submission 11.02 is accepted in part. Tainui Group Holdings Limited FS16.115 Support Accept in Part FS16.115 is accepted as submission 11.02 is accepted in part. Chedworth Properties Limited FS17.81 Support Accept in Part FS17.81 is accepted as submission 11.02 is accepted in part. Waikato Regional Council 21.02 4 Residential Zones Support Ensure that the Variation is consistent with the provisions of the Proposed Waikato Regional Policy Statement. Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.21 Oppose Reject FS3.21 is rejected as submission 21.02 is accepted in part. William Roy and Raewyn Mary Cowie FS4.2 Oppose Reject FS4.2 is rejected as submission 21.02 is accepted in part. Tainui Group Holdings Limited FS16.116 Support Accept in Part FS16.116 is accepted as submission 21.02 is accepted in part. Chedworth Properties Limited FS17.82 Support Accept in Part FS17.82 is accepted as submission 21.02 is accepted in part. Waikato-Tainui Te Kauhanganui Incorporated 27.03 4 Residential Zones Support Insert Chapter 4 of the Ruakura Variation into the District Plan. Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1 Tainui Group Holdings Limited FS16.112 Support Accept in Part FS16.112 is accepted as submission 27.03 is accepted in part. Future Proof Implementation Committee 28.02 4 Residential Zones Support Retain the Residential Zone provisions as notified. Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1
24

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

Jan 06, 2020

Download

Documents

dariahiddleston
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

1

4 Residential Zones

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Property Council of New Zealand

11.02 4 Residential Zones Support Accept the Ruakura Variation in its entirety. Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association

FS3.20 Oppose Reject FS3.20 is rejected as submission 11.02 is accepted in part.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.115 Support Accept in Part FS16.115 is accepted as submission 11.02 is accepted in part.

Chedworth Properties Limited

FS17.81 Support Accept in Part FS17.81 is accepted as submission 11.02 is accepted in part.

Waikato Regional Council

21.02 4 Residential Zones Support Ensure that the Variation is consistent with the provisions of the Proposed Waikato Regional Policy Statement.

Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association

FS3.21 Oppose Reject FS3.21 is rejected as submission 21.02 is accepted in part.

William Roy and Raewyn Mary Cowie

FS4.2 Oppose Reject FS4.2 is rejected as submission 21.02 is accepted in part.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.116 Support Accept in Part FS16.116 is accepted as submission 21.02 is accepted in part.

Chedworth Properties Limited

FS17.82 Support Accept in Part FS17.82 is accepted as submission 21.02 is accepted in part.

Waikato-Tainui Te Kauhanganui Incorporated

27.03 4 Residential Zones Support Insert Chapter 4 of the Ruakura Variation into the District Plan.

Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.112 Support Accept in Part FS16.112 is accepted as submission 27.03 is accepted in part.

Future Proof Implementation Committee

28.02 4 Residential Zones Support Retain the Residential Zone provisions as notified.

Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Page 2: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

2

Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association

FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission 28.02 is accepted in part.

William Roy and Raewyn Mary Cowie

FS4.3 Oppose Reject FS4.3 is rejected as submission 28.02 is accepted in part.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.113 Support Accept in Part FS16.113 is accepted as submission 28.02 is accepted in part.

Chedworth Properties Limited

FS17.79 Support Accept in Part FS17.79 is accepted as submission 28.02 is accepted in part.

Chedworth Properties Limited

33.02 4 Residential Zones Support in part

Any changes to the Variation to achieve consistency with the September 2014 Board of Inquiry Decision.

Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga

44.02 4 Residential Zones Support in part

Amend to include an archaeological assessment or as an alternative advice is placed on the Council's record system to assist with predevelopment discussions. Amend to include a review of historic heritage buildings and places and include within Appendix 8, Schedule 8A; Built Heritage of the Proposed District Plan.

Reject See Paragraph 7.10 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Kellaway, Laura; Beaumont, Louise; and Adam, John P

FS6.1 Support Reject FS6.1 is rejected as submission 44.02 is rejected.

AgResearch Ltd FS13.2 Oppose Accept FS13.2 is accepted as submission 44.02 is rejected.

Waikato Innovation Park Limited

FS14.2 Oppose Accept FS14.2 is accepted as submission 44.02 is rejected.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.114 Oppose Accept FS16.114 is accepted as submission 44.02 is rejected.

Chedworth Properties Limited

FS17.80 Oppose Accept FS17.80 is accepted as submission 44.02 is rejected.

The New Zealand Institute for Plant & Food Research Ltd

FS18.2 Oppose Accept FS18.2 is accepted as submission 44.02 is rejected.

Page 3: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

3

Jennifer West FS19.29 Support Reject FS19.29 is rejected as submission 44.02 is rejected.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

48.02 4 Residential Zones Support in part

Any changes to the Variation to achieve consistency in detail and approach with the September 2014 Board of Inquiry Decision on the Proposed Ruakura Development Plan Change. Add a new Rule 4.4.3 Percival/ Ryburn Roads Ruakura Structure Plan Area Internal Acoustic Insulation; or in the alternative amend Rule 4.4.1 and Rule 23.7.1 so minimum net site area and allotment size and shape are 2ha for the Percival / Ryburn Road area.

Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1

The Waikato Tree Trust

FS2.1 Oppose N/A FS2.1 is not relevant to submission 48.02.

Ruakura Residents Group

FS15.7 Oppose Reject FS15.7 is rejected as submission 48.02 is accepted in part.

Jennifer West FS19.31 Oppose Reject FS19.31 is rejected as submission 48.02 is accepted in part.

Hamilton City Council – Late Submission

51.02 4 Residential Zones Support in part

Amend chapter 4 to ensure that the provisions relating to LDPs are vires and consistent with the principles of recent case law regarding the status and use of “development plans”; Amend reference to Land Development Plans to Land Development Consents; and Any relevant consequential amendments.

Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1

AgResearch Ltd FS20 Support in Part

Accept in Part FS20 is accepted in part as submission 51.02 is accepted in part.

Chedworth Properties Limited

FS21 Support Accept in Part FS21 is accepted in part as submission 51.02 is accepted in part.

Waikato Innovation Park Limited

FS22 Support in Part

Accept in Part FS22 is accepted in part as submission 51.02 is accepted in part.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS23 Support Accept in Part FS23 is accepted in part as submission 51.02 is accepted in part.

Page 4: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

4

4.1 Purpose

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Chedworth Properties Limited

33.28 4.1 Purpose Oppose Delete 4.1f) which relates to a Land Development Plan being approved prior to development in the Ruakura Medium Density Residential Zone.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

48.31 4.1 Purpose Oppose Delete 4.1f) which relates to a Land Development Plan being approved prior to development in the Ruakura Medium Density Residential Zone.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

The Waikato Tree Trust

FS2.1 Oppose N/A FS2.1 is not relevant to submission 48.31.

Jennifer West FS19.46 Oppose Accept FS19.46 is accepted as submission 48.31 is rejected.

Ruakura Residents Group and William Roy Cowie

D1275.009 4.1 Purpose Support in part

4.1 Purpose-Retain Large Lot Residential zone and amend Chapter 4 to remove reference to transitional use of land as large lot residential and future use as Ruakura Logistics; retain same development rights as currently permitted; if unacceptable rezone 100m buffer as Open Space.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

SL & ANG Clarke DFS255 Support Reject DFS255 is rejected as submission D1275.009 is rejected.

Waikato Krishna Limited

DFS187.004

Oppose Accept DFS187.004 is accepted as submission D1275.009 is rejected.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

DFS196.054

Oppose Accept DFS196.054 is accepted as submission D1275.009 is rejected.

4.1.3 Medium-Density Residential Zone

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Gibbons, Matthew 06.02 4.1.3 Medium-Density Residential Zone

Oppose Amend to recognise the need for more residential housing near the university and close to the central city.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Page 5: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

5

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.117 Oppose Accept FS16.117 is accepted as submission 06.02 is rejected.

Chedworth Properties Limited

FS17.83 Oppose Accept FS17.83 is accepted as submission 06.02 is rejected.

4.1.4 Large Lot Residential Zone

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

KiwiRail Holdings Limited

17.04 4.1.4 Large Lot Residential Zone

Support Retain provision 4.1.4a)ii. which references the ECMT as a boundary for the Large Lot Residential Zone.

Accept See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Marsters, Derrick and Robyn

18.04 4.1.4 Large Lot Residential Zone

Oppose Remove all reference to a future Ruakura Logistics Zone or other employment zone for the Percival / Ryburn Road residential land.

Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.120 Oppose Accept FS16.120 is accepted as submission 18.04 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.11 Support Reject FS19.11 is rejected as submission 18.04 is rejected.

Carmichael, Natasha and Bryce

19.02 4.1.4 Large Lot Residential Zone

Oppose Retain the Large Lot Residential Zoning for the Percival / Ryburn Roads area and remove any reference to deferred logistics for this area. Amend so no heavy vehicle movements be given access to logistics sites from Percival or Ryburn Roads.

Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.119 Oppose Accept FS16.119 is accepted as submission 19.02 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.5 Support Reject FS19.5 is rejected as submission 19.02 is rejected.

Cowie, William 30.04 4.1.4 Large Lot Residential Zone

Oppose Remove all reference to a future Ruakura Logistics Zone or other employment zone for the Percival / Ryburn Road residential land.

Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.121 Oppose Accept FS16.121 is accepted as submission 30.04 is opposed.

Jennifer West FS19.3 Support Reject FS19.3 is rejected as submission 30.04 is opposed.

Chibnall, David 31.04 4.1.4 Large Lot Oppose Remove all reference to a future Ruakura Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Page 6: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

6

Evan and Karlene Residential Zone Logistics Zone or other employment zone for the Percival / Ryburn Road residential land.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.124 Oppose Accept FS16.124 is accepted as submission 31.04 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.6 Support Reject FS19.6 is rejected as submission 31.04 is rejected.

Madarang, Domingo

35.04 4.1.4 Large Lot Residential Zone

Oppose Remove all reference to a future Ruakura Logistics Zone or other employment zone for the Percival / Ryburn Road residential land.

Reject See Paragraph 7.1 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.122 Oppose Accept FS16.122 is accepted as submission 35.04 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.10 Support Reject FS19.10 is rejected as submission 35.04 is rejected.

Spirig, Wendy and Roland

36.04 4.1.4 Large Lot Residential Zone

Oppose Remove all reference to a future Ruakura Logistics Zone or other employment zone for the Percival / Ryburn Road residential land.

Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.118 Oppose Accept FS16.118 is accepted as submission 36.04 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.12 Support Reject FS19.12 is rejected as submission 36.04 is rejected.

Wang, Yun-Chin and Kung-Yao Lin

40.04 4.1.4 Large Lot Residential Zone

Oppose Remove all reference to a future Ruakura Logistics Zone or other employment zone for the Percival / Ryburn Road residential land.

Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.125 Oppose Accept FS16.125 is accepted as submission 40.04 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.9 Support Reject FS19.9 is rejected as submission 40.04 is rejected.

Fellowship Baptist Church

45.04 4.1.4 Large Lot Residential Zone

Oppose Remove all reference to a future Ruakura Logistics Zone or other employment zone for the Percival / Ryburn Road residential land.

Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.123 Oppose Accept FS16.123 is accepted as submission 45.04 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.7 Support Reject FS19.7 is rejected as submission 45.04 is rejected.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

48.32 4.1.4 Large Lot Residential Zone

Support in part

Amend Rule 4.1.4 Large Lot Residential Zone to remove text providing context of the enclave at Percival and Ryburn Roads.

Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Page 7: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

7

Delete 'Future subdivision of this area into further large lot residential lots, therefore, is not encouraged'. Amend text to remove reference to 10.5.4 and 11.5.3 and refer to interface measures to avoid, remedy or mitigate significant adverse effects. Amend to avoid adverse reverse sensitivity effects from the residential area on the establishment and operation of the inland port and the logistics and industrial park zones and include requirements for internal acoustic insulation and no-complaints covenants. Delete the establishment of a buffer as a pre-condition to future development.

The Waikato Tree Trust

FS2.1 Oppose N/A FS2.1 is not relevant to submission 48.32.

Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association

FS3.13 Oppose Reject FS3.13 is rejected as submission 48.32 is accepted in part.

William Roy and Raewyn Mary Cowie

FS4.6 Oppose Reject FS4.6 is rejected as submission 48.32 is accepted in part.

Ruakura Residents Group

FS15.9 Oppose Reject FS15.9 is rejected as submission 48.32 is accepted in part.

Jennifer West FS19.48 Oppose Reject FS19.48 is rejected as submission 48.32 is accepted in part.

Kerry & Donna Willmott

D1257.001 4.1.4 Large Lot Residential Zone

Oppose Opposes the Ruakura Industrial zone. Either purchase the property or amend the plan to allow semi-commercial use on 63 Ryburn Road

Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Objective 4.2.10

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Carmichael, 19.03 Objective 4.2.10 Support in Amend to require plantings a minimum of 10 Accept in Part See Paragraphs 7.1, 7.2, 7.13, 7.25 Decision Report and

Page 8: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

8

Natasha and Bryce part metres high along Ryburn Road. Add a new provision to provide a sound proof wall or barrier. Add a new provision to provide a 40 metre buffer strip and planted bund down all of Percival Road. Add a new provision that prevents access of heavy vehicle movements to logistics sites from Percival or Ryburn Roads.

Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.130 Oppose Reject FS16.130 is rejected as submission 19.03 is accepted in part.

Jennifer West FS19.5 Support Accept in Part FS19.5 is accepted as submission 19.03 is accepted in part.

Waikato Regional Council

21.30 Objective 4.2.10 Support Retain objectives 4.2.10 and 4.2.11 and polices 4.2.10a – 4.2.10e and 4.2.11a.

Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association

FS3.21 Oppose Reject FS3.21 is rejected as submission 21.30 is accepted in part

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.126 Support Accept in Part FS16.126 is accepted as submission 21.30 is accepted in part.

Chedworth Properties Limited

FS17.84 Support Accept in Part FS17.84 is accepted as submission 21.30 is accepted in part.

Julian, Alan and Barbara

29.10 Objective 4.2.10 Support in part

Amend to recognise the amenity values of the existing Percival and Ryburn Road area.

Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.128 Oppose Reject FS16.128 is rejected as submission 29.10 is accepted in part.

Jennifer West FS19.8 Support Accept in Part FS19.8 is accepted as submission 29.10 is accepted in part.

Hamilton City Council

32.17 Objective 4.2.10 Support Replace existing Policy 4.2.10c with a new policy.

Accept See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Jennifer West FS19.1 Support Accept FS19.1 is accepted as submission 32.17 is accepted.

Ruakura Residents Group

37.09 Objective 4.2.10 Support in part

Amend policies 4.2.10b, 10.2.3(a)(iv) and 11.2.3(a)(iii) to avoid heavy vehicle movements on Percival Road and to avoid,

Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Page 9: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

9

minimise or mitigate noise and vibration to manage effects on residential amenity values. Ensure noise and vibration infringements are subject to the normal tests for notification. Review Policies 4.2.10d-e, Rule 10.5.4 and Rule 11.5.3 to ensure they are effective and clear, including referencing the correct Land Development sub-areas shown on Figure 2-16.

Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association

FS3.22 Support Accept in Part FS3.22 is accepted as submission 37.09 is accepted in part.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.127 Oppose Reject FS16.127 is rejected as submission 37.09 is accepted in part.

Jennifer West FS19.2 Support Accept in Part FS19.2 is accepted as submission 37.09 is accepted in part.

Wang, Meggie 42.10 Objective 4.2.10 Support in part

Amend to recognise the amenity values of the existing Percival and Ryburn Road area.

Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.129 Oppose Reject FS16.129 is rejected as submission 42.10 is accepted.

Jennifer West FS19.13 Support Accept FS19.13 is accepted as submission 42.10 is accepted.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

48.33 Objective 4.2.10 Support in part

Objective 4.2.10 delete 'protect' and insert 'avoid, remedy or mitigate adverse effects on' the amenity values of the Percival - Ryburn Road area. Delete Policy 4.2.10b and replace with a new policy that relates to avoiding reverse sensitivity effects in the Percival - Ryburn Road area. Delete Policy 4.2.10d regarding the establishment of a buffer along Percival Road. Delete Policy 4.2.10e regarding plane trees being an integral part of the buffer. Amend 4.2.10 Explanation to delete reference to intensity of future residential land use and

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Page 10: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

10

insert new text to reflect the need to manage the subdivision, use and development of the area.

The Waikato Tree Trust

FS2.1 Oppose N/A FS2.1 is not relevant to submission 48.33.

Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association

FS3.14 Oppose Accept FS3.14 is accepted as submission 48.33 is rejected.

Ruakura Residents Group

FS15.10 Oppose Accept FS15.10 is accepted as submission 48.33 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.47 Oppose Accept FS19.47 is accepted as submission 48.33 is rejected.

Objective 4.2.11

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Marsters, Derrick and Robyn

18.05 Objective 4.2.11 Oppose Remove all reference to a future Ruakura Logistics Zone or other employment zone for the Percival / Ryburn Road residential land.

Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.132 Oppose Accept FS16.132 is accepted as submission 18.05 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.11 Support Reject FS19.11 is rejected as submission 18.05 is rejected.

Carmichael, Natasha and Bryce

19.04 Objective 4.2.11 Oppose Delete Objective 4.2.11 which relates to development within the Large Lot Residential Zone.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.131 Oppose Accept FS16.131 is accepted as submission 19.04 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.5 Support Reject FS19.5 is rejected as submission 19.04 is rejected.

Waikato Regional Council

21.31 Objective 4.2.11 Support Retain objectives 4.2.10 and 4.2.11 and polices 4.2.10a – 4.2.10e and 4.2.11a.

Accept See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association

FS3.21 Oppose Reject FS3.21 is rejected as submission 21.31 is accepted.

Page 11: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

11

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.142 Support Accept FS16.142 is accepted as submission 21.31 is accepted.

Chedworth Properties Limited

FS17.85 Support Accept FS17.85 is accepted as submission 21.31 is accepted.

Julian, Alan and Barbara

29.06 Objective 4.2.11 Oppose Remove all reference to a future Ruakura Logistics Zone or other employment zone for the Percival / Ryburn Road residential land.

Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.135 Oppose Accept FS16.135 is accepted as submission 29.06 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.8 Support Reject FS19.8 is rejected as submission 29.06 is rejected.

Cowie, William 30.05 Objective 4.2.11 Oppose Remove all reference to a future Ruakura Logistics Zone or other employment zone for the Percival / Ryburn Road residential land.

Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.137 Oppose Accept FS16.137 is accepted as submission 30.05 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.3 Support Reject FS19.3 is rejected as submission 30.05 is rejected.

Chibnall, David Evan and Karlene

31.05 Objective 4.2.11 Oppose Remove all reference to a future Ruakura Logistics Zone or other employment zone for the Percival / Ryburn Road residential land.

Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.141 Oppose Accept FS16.141 is accepted as submission 31.05 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.6 Support Reject FS19.6 is rejected as submission 39.6 is rejected.

Madarang, Domingo

35.05 Objective 4.2.11 Oppose Remove all reference to a future Ruakura Logistics Zone or other employment zone for the Percival / Ryburn Road residential land.

Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.138 Oppose Accept FS16.138 is accepted as submission 35.05 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.10 Support Reject FS19.10 is accepted as submission 35.05 is rejected.

Spirig, Wendy and Roland

36.05 Objective 4.2.11 Oppose Remove all reference to a future Ruakura Logistics Zone or other employment zone for the Percival / Ryburn Road residential land.

Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group FS16.133 Oppose Accept FS16.133 is accepted as submission 36.05 is rejected.

Page 12: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

12

Holdings Limited

Jennifer West FS19.12 Support Reject FS19.12 is rejected as submission 36.05 is rejected.

Ruakura Residents Group

37.03 Objective 4.2.11 Oppose Remove all reference to a future Ruakura Logistics Zone or other employment zone for the Percival / Ryburn Road residential land, including Rule 3.7.1.6(b), Objective 4.2.11 and Policy 4.2.11a.

Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association

FS3.22 Support Reject FS3.22 is rejected as submission 37.03 is rejected.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.139 Oppose Accept FS16.139 is accepted as submission 37.03 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.2 Support Reject FS19.2 is rejected as submission 37.03 is rejected.

Wang, Yun-Chin and Kung-Yao Lin

40.05 Objective 4.2.11 Oppose Remove all reference to a future Ruakura Logistics Zone or other employment zone for the Percival / Ryburn Road residential land.

Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.140 Oppose Accept FS16.140 is accepted as submission 40.05 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.9 Support Reject FS19.9 is rejected as submission 40.05 is rejected.

Wang, Meggie 42.06 Objective 4.2.11 Oppose Remove all reference to a future Ruakura Logistics Zone or other employment zone for the Percival / Ryburn Road residential land.

Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.134 Oppose Accept FS16.134 is accepted as submission 42.06 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.13 Support Reject FS19.13 is rejected as submission 42.06 is rejected.

Fellowship Baptist Church

45.05 Objective 4.2.11 Oppose Remove all reference to a future Ruakura Logistics Zone or other employment zone for the Percival / Ryburn Road residential land.

Reject See Paragraph 7.1, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.136 Oppose Accept FS16.136 is accepted as submission 45.05 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.7 Support Reject FS19.7 is rejected as submission 45.05 is rejected.

Page 13: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

13

Objective 4.2.12

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Chedworth Properties Limited

33.29 Objective 4.2.12 Support in part

Amend 4.2.12 Explanation to delete reference to 'a limited range' and 'essentially serve a walk in population' when describing the Integrated Retail Development Centre. Delete that 'the shop sizes are typically between 100-400m² GFA'.

Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1

4.3 Rules – General Residential, Residential Intensification and Large Lot Residential Zones

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

48.34 4.3 Rules – General Residential, Residential Intensification and Large Lot Residential Zones

Support in part

Amend 4.3.1 Activity Status Table – General Residential Zone, Residential Intensification Zone and Large Lot Residential Zone by adding a new provision where the use of buildings for residential activities is permitted subject to a restrictive non-complaint covenant or use of buildings without a restrictive non-complaint covenant is discretionary. Insert a note clarifying how a 'restrictive non-complaint covenant' is defined. In the alternative, amend Rule 4.4.1 Density and 23.7.1 Allotment Size and Shape for the Large Lot Residential Zone at Percival / Ryburn Road Area to 2ha.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

The Waikato Tree Trust

FS2.1 Oppose N/A FS2.1 is not relevant to submission 48.34.

Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association

FS3.15 Oppose Accept FS3.15 is accepted as submission 48.34 is rejected.

William Roy and Raewyn Mary Cowie

FS4.7 Oppose Accept FS4.7 is accepted as submission 48.34 is rejected.

Page 14: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

14

Ruakura Residents Group

FS15.11 Oppose Accept FS15.11 is accepted as submission 48.34 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.49 Oppose Accept FS19.49 is accepted as submission 48.34 is rejected.

Tainui Group Holdings Ltd

D913.023 4.3.1 Activity Status Table – General Residential Zone, Residential Intensification Zone and Large Lot Residential Zone

Oppose Amend Rule 4.3.1(b) and (g) to make apartment buildings and duplex dwellings in the Large Lot Residential Area non-complying activities.

Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1

William Roy and Raewyn Mary Cowie

DFS143.002 Oppose Accept in Part DFS143.002 is accepted in part as submission D913.023 is accepted in part.

Natasha Anne and Bryce Ian Carmichael

DFS156.002

Oppose Accept in Part DFS156.002 is accepted in part as submission D913.023 is accepted in part.

William Cornelis Engelander

DFS160.001

Oppose Accept in Part DFS160.001 is accepted in part as submission D913.023 is accepted in part.

James Hely and Heather Montgomerie -

DFS161.001

Oppose Accept in Part DFS161.001 is accepted in part as submission D913.023 is accepted in part.

Ruakura Residents Group and William Roy Cowie

DFS167.015

Oppose Accept in Part DFS167.015 is accepted in part as submission D913.023 is accepted in part.

Waikato Krishna Limited

DFS187.002 Support Accept in Part DFS187.002 is accepted in part as submission D913.023 is accepted in part.

4.4.1 Density

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Marsters, Derrick and Robyn

18.06 4.4.1 Density Oppose Amend the Large Lot Residential Zone Rules to provide for a 2,500m² minimum lot size to the Percival / Ryburn Road area.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Page 15: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

15

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.143 Oppose Accept FS16.143 is accepted as submission 18.06 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.11 Support Reject FS19.11 is rejected as submission 18.06 is rejected.

Carmichael, Natasha and Bryce

19.05 4.4.1 Density Oppose Amend 4.4.1a)i. to provide for minimum net site area of 2500m² for Percival and Ryburn Road properties.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.144 Oppose Accept FS16.144 is accepted as submission 19.05 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.5 Support Reject FS19.5 is rejected as submission 19.05 is rejected.

Julian, Alan and Barbara

29.03 4.4.1 Density Support in part

Amend the Large Lot Residential Zone Rules to provide for a 2,500m² minimum lot size to the Percival / Ryburn Road area. Seek protection of amenity values for Percival/Ryburn Road.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.151 Oppose Accept FS16.151 is accepted as submission 29.03 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.8 Support Reject FS19.8 is rejected as submission 29.03 is rejected.

Cowie, William 30.06 4.4.1 Density Oppose Amend the Large Lot Residential Zone Rules to provide for a 2,500m² minimum lot size to the Percival / Ryburn Road area.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.153 Oppose Accept FS16.153 is accepted as submission 30.06 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.3 Support Reject FS19.3 is rejected as submission 30.06 is rejected.

Chibnall, David Evan and Karlene

31.06 4.4.1 Density Oppose Amend the Large Lot Residential Zone Rules to provide for a 2,500m² minimum lot size to the Percival / Ryburn Road area.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.149 Oppose Accept FS16.149 is accepted as submission 31.06 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.6 Support Reject FS19.6 is rejected as submission 31.06 is rejected.

Madarang, Domingo

35.06 4.4.1 Density Oppose Amend the Large Lot Residential Zone Rules to provide for a 2,500m² minimum lot size to the Percival / Ryburn Road area.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Page 16: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

16

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.154 Oppose Accept FS16.154 is accepted as submission 35.06 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.10 Support Reject FS19.10 is rejected as submission 35.06 is rejected.

Spirig, Wendy and Roland

36.06 4.4.1 Density Oppose Amend the Large Lot Residential Zone Rules to provide for a 2,500m² minimum lot size to the Percival / Ryburn Road area.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.145 Oppose Accept FS16.145 is accepted as submission 36.06 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.12 Support Reject FS19.12 is rejected as submission 36.06 is rejected.

Ruakura Residents Group

37.04 4.4.1 Density Oppose Amend the Large Lot Residential Zone Rules to provide for a 2,500m² minimum lot size to the Percival / Ryburn Road area.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association

FS3.22 Support Reject FS3.22 is rejected as submission 37.04 is rejected.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.147 Oppose Accept FS16.147 is accepted as submission 37.04 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.2 Support Reject FS19.2 is rejected as submission 37.04 is rejected.

Wang, Yun-Chin and Kung-Yao Lin

40.06 4.4.1 Density Oppose Amend the Large Lot Residential Zone Rules to provide for a 2,500m² minimum lot size to the Percival / Ryburn Road area.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.146 Oppose Accept FS16.146 is accepted as submission 40.06 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.9 Support Reject FS19.9 is rejected as submission 40.06 is rejected.

Alexander, Deanna-Rose

41.03 4.4.1 Density Support in part

Amend the Large Lot Residential Zone Rules to provide for a 2,500m² minimum lot size to the Percival / Ryburn Road area.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.148 Oppose Accept FS16.148 is accepted as submission 41.03 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.4 Support Reject FS19.4 is rejected as submission 41.03 is rejected.

Wang, Meggie 42.03 4.4.1 Density Support in part

Amend the Large Lot Residential Zone Rules to provide for a 2,500m² minimum lot size to the

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Page 17: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

17

Percival / Ryburn Road area. Seek protection of amenity values for Percival/Ryburn Road.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.152 Oppose Accept FS16.152 is accepted as submission 42.03 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.13 Support Reject FS19.13 is rejected as submission 42.03 is rejected.

Fellowship Baptist Church

45.06 4.4.1 Density Oppose Amend the Large Lot Residential Zone Rules to provide for a 2,500m² minimum lot size to the Percival / Ryburn Road area.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.150 Oppose Accept FS16.150 is accepted as submission 45.06 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.7 Support Reject FS19.7 is rejected as submission 45.06 is rejected.

Ruakura Residents Group and William Roy Cowie

D1275.010 4.4.1 Density Support in part

Amend Rule 4.4.1 to provide for residential density at 1 dwelling per 2500m² as per the southern Ruakura Structure Plan Large Lot Residential zone; retain same development rights as currently permitted; if unacceptable rezone 100m buffer as Open Space.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

DFS196.055

Oppose Accept DFS196.055 is accepted as submissionD1275.010 is rejected.

4.5.1 Comprehensive Development Plan Process

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Chedworth Properties Limited

33.30 4.5.1 Comprehensive Development Plan Process

Support in part

Amend 4.5.1a to delete reference to Figure 2-16 and Land Development Plan Areas.

Reject See Paragraph 7.19, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association

43.29 4.5.1 Comprehensive Development Plan Process

Oppose Delete 4.5.1a) Comprehensive Development Plan Process.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Page 18: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

18

Jennifer West FS19.26 Support Reject FS19.26 is rejected as submission 43.29 is rejected.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

48.35 4.5.1 Comprehensive Development Plan Process

Support in part

Amend 4.5.1a to delete reference to Figure 2-16 and Land Development Plan Areas.

Reject See Paragraph 7.19, 7.25 Decision Report and Appendix 1

The Waikato Tree Trust

FS2.1 Oppose N/A FS2.1 is not relevant to submission 48.35.

Jennifer West FS19.31 Oppose Accept FS19.11 is accepted as submission 48.35 is rejected.

4.5.3 Activity Status Table – Medium-Density Residential Zone (excluding Ruakura)

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Hamilton City Council

32.18 4.5.3 Activity Status Table – Medium-Density Residential Zone (excluding Ruakura)

Support Delete activity 4.5.3w) which refers to Integrated Retail Development.

Accept See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Jennifer West FS19.1 Support Accept FS19.1 is accepted as submission 32.18 is accepted.

PRS Planning Services Limited

D929.032 4.5.3 Activity Status Table – Medium-Density Residential Zone

Oppose Delete Rule 4.5.3 z) Integrated Retail Development (Ruakura CDP Area A only) from the Activity Status Table as there is no justification for such a provision and is contrary to the Proposed District Plan.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Parkwood Gateway Limited

D977.005 4.5.3 Activity Status Table – Medium-Density Residential Zone

Oppose Delete Rule 4.5.3 z) Integrated Retail Development (Ruakura CDP Area A only) from the Activity Status Table as there is no justification for such a provision and is contrary to the Proposed District Plan.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

DFS196.049 Oppose Reject DFS196.049 is rejected as submission D977.005 is accepted in part.

Chedworth Properties Limited

DFS197.006 Oppose Reject DFS197.006 is rejected as submission D977.005 is accepted in part.

Portland Park Limited

D984.005 4.5.3 Activity Status Table – Medium-Density Residential

Oppose Delete Rule 4.5.3 z) Integrated Retail Development (Ruakura CDP Area A only) from the Activity Status Table as there is no

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Page 19: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

19

Zone justification for such a provision and is contrary to the Proposed District Plan.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

DFS196.051 Oppose Reject DFS196.051 is rejected as submission D984.005 is accepted in part.

Chedworth Properties Limited

DFS197.008 Oppose Reject DFS197.008 is rejected as submission D984.005 is accepted in part.

4.5.4 Activity Status Table – Ruakura Medium-Density Residential Zone

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Eastside Apostolic Foundation, Hamilton

12.10 4.5.4 Activity Status Table – Ruakura Medium-Density Residential Zone

Support in part

Retain Rule 4.5.4(a)(b) and (c) as proposed; and Amend Rule 4.5.4 so the following are restricted discretionary; managed care facilities, residential centre, rest home, place of assembly and place of worship. Retain Rule 4.5.4; and amend all associated plans so that the EAF Site is zoned Medium Density Residential.

Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.156 Oppose Reject FS16.156 is rejected as submission 12.10 is accepted in part.

Chedworth Properties Limited

FS17.86 Oppose Reject FS17.86 is rejected as submission 12.10 is accepted in part.

Waikato-Tainui Te Kauhanganui Incorporated

27.04 4.5.4 Activity Status Table – Ruakura Medium-Density Residential Zone

Support in part

Amend 4.5.4 f) to provide for Papakainga as a restricted discretionary activity.

Accept See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.155 Support Accept FS16.155 is accepted as submission 27.04 is accepted.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

48.36 4.5.4 Activity Status Table – Ruakura Medium-Density Residential Zone

Support in part

Amend 4.5.4 Activity Status Table to provide; Residential buildings on sites 250m² or greater as permitted; Residential buildings on sites less than 249m² as restricted discretionary; and Semi-detached, duplex and terrace housing as

Accept in Part

See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Page 20: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

20

permitted.

The Waikato Tree Trust

FS2.1 Oppose N/A FS2.1 is not relevant to submission 48.36.

Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association

FS3.16 Oppose Accept in Part FS3.16 is accepted in part as submission 48.36 is accepted in part.

Jennifer West FS19.31 Oppose Accept in Part FS19.31 is accepted in part as submission 48.36 is accepted in part.

Chedworth Properties Limited

33.54 4.5.4 Activity Status Table – Ruakura Medium-Density Residential Zone

Support in part

Amend 4.5.4 Activity Status Table to provide; Residential buildings on sites 250m² or greater as permitted; Residential buildings on sites less than 249m² as restricted discretionary; and Semi-detached, duplex and terrace housing as permitted.

Accept in Part

See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Jennifer West FS19.64 Oppose Accept in Part FS19.64 is accepted in part as submission 33.54 is accepted in part.

4.5.5 Rule – Ruakura Structure Plan Area – Staging

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Eastside Apostolic Foundation, Hamilton

12.21 4.5.5 Rule – Ruakura Structure Plan Area – Staging

Support in part

Amend Rule 4.5.5.a) so that it also applies to the EAF Site.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.157 Oppose Accept FS16.157 is accepted as submission 12.21 is rejected.

Chedworth Properties Limited

FS17.87 Oppose Accept FS17.87 is accepted as submission 12.21 is rejected.

4.6.6 Site Coverage

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Tainui Group 48.37 4.6.6 Site Coverage Support in Amend Rule 4.6.6 Site Coverage from a Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Page 21: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

21

Holdings Limited part maximum of 50% to 45%.

The Waikato Tree Trust

FS2.1 Oppose N/A FS2.1 is not relevant to submission 48.37.

Chedworth Properties Limited

FS17.88 Oppose Accept FS17.88 is accepted as submission 48.37 is rejected.

Jennifer West FS19.50 Oppose Accept FS19.50 is accepted as submission 48.37 is rejected.

4.6.7 Building Height

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

48.38 4.6.7 Building Height

Support in part

Amend Rule 4.6.7 Building Height from 10m to a maximum height of 12m.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

The Waikato Tree Trust

FS2.33 Oppose N/A FS2.33 is not relevant to submission 48.38.

Jennifer West FS19.51 Oppose Accept FS19.51 is accepted as submission 48.38 is rejected.

4.8.1 One Integrated Retail Development (see Figure 2-14 in Appendix 2)

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Future Proof Implementation Committee

28.03 4.8.1 One Integrated Retail Development (see Figure 2-14 in Appendix 2)

Support Retain Provision 4.8.1 which provides for one integrated retail development.

Accept See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association

FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission 28.03 is accepted.

PRS Planning Services Limited

D929.033 4.8.1 Integrated Retail Development (Ruakura CDP Area A only)

Oppose Delete 4.8.1 Integrated Retail Development (Ruakura CDP Area A only) in its entirety as there is no justification in terms of objectives and policies in either the Residential Zone or centres hierarchy for the establishment of such a retail development.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Page 22: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

22

Noting also - this submission MUST not be used as the basis for inserting objectives or policies into the District Plan which provide for the establishment of an integrated retail activity within the Medium Density Residential Zone.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

DFS196.048

Oppose Accept DFS196.048 is accepted as submission D929.033 is rejected.

Chedworth Properties Limited

DFS197.005

Oppose Accept DFS197.005 is accepted as submission D929.033 is rejected.

Parkwood Gateway Limited

D977.006 4.8.1 Integrated Retail Development (Ruakura CDP Area A only)

Oppose Delete 4.8.1 Integrated Retail Development (Ruakura CDP Area A only) in its entirety as there is no justification in terms of objectives and policies in either the Residential Zone or centres hierarchy for the establishment of such a retail development. Noting also - this submission MUST not be used as the basis for inserting objectives or policies into the District Plan which provide for the establishment of an integrated retail activity within the Medium Density Residential Zone.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

DFS196.05

Oppose Accept DFS196.05 is accepted as submission D977.006 is rejected.

Chedworth Properties Limited

DFS197.007

Oppose Accept DFS197.007 is accepted as submission D977.006 is rejected.

Portland Park Limited

D984.006 4.8.1 Integrated Retail Development (Ruakura CDP Area A only)

Oppose Delete 4.8.1 Integrated Retail Development (Ruakura CDP Area A only) in its entirety as there is no justification in terms of objectives and policies in either the Residential Zone or centres hierarchy for the establishment of such a retail development.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Page 23: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

23

Noting also - this submission MUST not be used as the basis for inserting objectives or policies into the District Plan which provide for the establishment of an integrated retail activity within the Medium Density Residential Zone.

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS196.052

Oppose Accept FS196.052 is accepted as submission D984.006 is rejected.

Chedworth Properties Limited

FS197.009

Oppose Accept FS197.009 is accepted as submission D984.006 is rejected.

4.8.2 Building Setbacks

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Chedworth Properties Limited

33.31 4.8.2 Building Setbacks

Support in part

Amend Rule 4.8.2 to delete c) relating to the boundary of a Land Development Area or Area Boundary.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

48.39 4.8.2 Building Setbacks

Support in part

Amend Rule 4.8.2 to delete c) relating to the boundary of a Land Development Area or Area Boundary.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

The Waikato Tree Trust

FS2.1 Oppose N/A FS2.1 is not relevant to submission 48.39.

Jennifer West FS19.31 Oppose Accept FS19.31 is accepted as submission 48.39 is rejected.

4.11 Restricted Discretionary Activities Matters of Discretion and Assessment Criteria

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Waikato-Tainui Te Kauhanganui Incorporated

27.05 4.11 Restricted Discretionary Activities Matters of Discretion and Assessment Criteria

Oppose Amend Provision 4.11 to provide new assessment criteria for Papakainga.

Reject See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Page 24: DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones...DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones 2 Fairview Downs Residents and Owners Association FS3.24 Oppose Reject FS3.24 is rejected as submission

DECISIONS - Chapter 4 Residential Zones

24

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.158 Support Reject FS16.158 is rejected as submission 27.05 is rejected.

4.12 Other Resource Consent Information

Sub. Name FS.Name

Sub. Point FS. Point

Plan Provision Sub. Type Summary Decision Reasoning

Bothwell, Jenny 04.03 4.12 Other Resource Consent Information

Support in part

Remove the T intersection from the plans for the subdivision off Powells Road.

Accept in Part See Decision Report and Appendix 1

Tainui Group Holdings Limited

FS16.159 Oppose Reject FS16.159 is rejected as submission 04.03 is accepted in part.

Chedworth Properties Limited

FS17.89 Oppose Reject FS17.89 is rejected as submission 04.03 is accepted in part.