Top Banner
Case 12: Conflicting Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from subscribers and audiences? Does the press have a legitimate advocacy function, or does it best serve democratic intermediary, a conduit of information and varying opinions? Should the press just mirror events or should they provide a map that leads ins audience to a particular destination?
17

Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

Dec 21, 2015

Download

Documents

Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

Case 12: Conflicting LoyaltiesCase 12: Conflicting LoyaltiesThe cases in this chapter examine conflicting

loyalties in public affairs.

• Does the media carry a particular mandate from subscribers and audiences?

•Does the press have a legitimate advocacy function, or does it best serve democratic intermediary, a conduit of information and varying opinions?

• Should the press just mirror events or should they provide a map that leads ins audience to a particular destination?

Page 2: Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

Chapter 12 CasesChapter 12 Cases

• Case 52: A New Client?

• Case 53: Case I: Friends? Case II: The Friendly Journalist

• Case 54: Politician Pitching Pills?

• Case 55: All Too Human?

• Case 56: The Long-Distance Client

Page 3: Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

Case 51: A New Client?Case 51: A New Client?

• Facts – Empirical Definition• Values• Principles• Loyalties

Alcohol ads can either promote abuse or responsibility.

Page 4: Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

•Should employees compromise their values from past experiences for the companies they work for and clients they campaign for?

• Is it possible to balance personal values that result from a bad past experience with alcohol with promoting a campaign for alcoholic beverages?

•What about a scenario with tobacco?

abuse responsibility

Extremes of advertising alcohol. Alcohol’s presentation can be the factor for either abuse or responsibility. +—

Page 5: Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

Case 51: Additional linksCase 51: Additional links

Does it work? — An abstract from research of pro-social message effectiveness.

Pro-social ad campaign — This article is directed towards youth and decision-making. It also covers the effectiveness of pro-social advertisements.

Counter-advertising — Review about alcohol counter-advertising and the media.

Blue Valley Vineyards — winery website.

Page 6: Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

Case 52: Case 1: Friends? Case 52: Case 1: Friends? Case 2: The Friendly Case 2: The Friendly

Journalist?Journalist?• Facts – Empirical Definition• Values• Principles• Loyalties

Not what you know, but who you know.

Friendship interference with job responsibilities.

OR

Page 7: Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

The scale for following business ethics, which are ranked from most important to least important.

• Is it disloyal to allow friendships to interfere with job responsibilities?

• In these two cases, is there a preferential treatment of friends?

•What about an ethical distinction between financial matters as opposed to information access?

• How does the Judeo-Christian “Golden Rule” fit these two cases?

Page 8: Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

Case 52: Additional linksCase 52: Additional linksEthics Officer Association — This site provides the

association’s historical background, what it is about and its value and mission statement. – United States Sentencing Commission.

Organizational ethics — This is the Ethics Resource Center’s ethic philosophy in the workplace.– About ERC.– Recent study of workplace ethics conducted by

the ERC.The case of Enron — The case of Enron is an example

of unethical practices in the workplace. This article discusses the ethical culture in the workplace and whether or not it is disappearing.

Page 9: Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

Case 53: Politician Case 53: Politician Pitching PillsPitching Pills

• Facts – Empirical Definition

•Values

• Principles

• Loyalties

Former Senator

Bob Dole

Viagra

Page 10: Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

Former Senator Bob Dole endorsed Pfizer’s pharmaceutical drug Viagra.

•Would the American public want all active politicians—even those just out of office—to become spokespeople for categories of goods and services they recently regulated?

•What ethical principles should guide the behavior of those who endorse products, and, in particular, such critical products as prescription drugs?

Page 11: Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

Case 53: Additional linksCase 53: Additional linksSpeaking out — This is a transcript of an interview

among Larry King, Bob and Elizabeth Dole. Halfway through the interview, they began talking about the Viagra ads Bob Dole represented.

Regulating DTC ads — This article discusses the FTC’s comments made to the FDA for improving their direct-to consumer advertisements. Included is a link of the full text comment.

Rules of endorsement — This is the FTC guidelines for endorsements and testimonials in advertising.

Page 12: Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

Case 54: Case 54: All Too Human?All Too Human?• Facts – Empirical Definition• Values• Principles• Loyalties

George Stephanopoulos: former advisor to former president, Bill Clinton

Stephanopoulos and Clinton before All Too Human

Page 13: Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

All Too Human illustrates the application of the Golden-mean decision

•What ethical principles and values should a spokesperson consider when revealing information about former clients?

•How does this correlate with expectations of confidentiality?

•Furthermore, what are the ethical implications of major news organizations hiring intimate political allies of public leaders as news commentators?

Reveal everything

All Too Human between the two

extremes

No revelation

Page 14: Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

Case 54: Additional linksCase 54: Additional linksBetween loyalty and betrayal — this article examines

the controversy behind Stephanopoulos’ book All Too Human and the evaluation of his loyalty.

“Kiss and Tell?” — transcript from “NewsHour,” which features Stephanopoulos as a guest; the hosts discuss the matter of loyalty to the President. An audio clip of this segment is available.

Chapter 1 — excerpt from Chapter 1 in All Too HumanAll too absurd? — a critical look at George

StephanopoulosLife as a news anchor — Background information of

George Stephanopoulos provided by the ABC network.

Page 15: Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

Case 55: The Long-Distance Case 55: The Long-Distance ClientClient

• Facts – Empirical Definition• Values• Principles• Loyalties

Page 16: Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

At the left is an example of international public relations between Ruder Finn and the government of Herzegovina (President Alija Izetbegovic).

• What ethical guidelines do corporations need to follow when they campaign for long-distance clients?

• Is it right for practitioners to seek to persuade Congress to take action on behalf of another nation?

Page 17: Case 12: Conflicting Loyalties The cases in this chapter examine conflicting loyalties in public affairs. Does the media carry a particular mandate from.

Case 55: Additional linksCase 55: Additional linksCode of Ethics — This is a link within the PSRA for the

organization’s Code of Ethics for public relations. It also includes links to other ethical resources.

Mission of the International Federation of Communications Association.

On the Move — Ruder Finn connections in public affairs and global issues, featuring GlobeComm. There is also a list of clients served through Ruder Finn.– “Why Not Bosnia?” — Ruder Finn won the PRSA Silver Anvil

Award.International Association of Business Communicators — This site

provides information about the organization, including its vision, theme and structure for communication.– Code of Ethics for professional communicators.

Unethical media practices — Examples provided by the IPRA that violate the IPRA’s code of conduct.– Press releases for media transparency.– Code of Venice