Top Banner
7:50am, Apr 11, 2011 Two Roanoke County Planning Commissioners, staff and I prepare to leave the Roanoke County Admin Center parking lot to visit the Beech Ridge industrial scale wind turbine installation.
26

Beech Ridge Wind Farm

Jan 16, 2015

Download

Education

A Roanoke County Planning Commision Field Trip to Beech Knob, WV
Welcome message from author
This document is posted to help you gain knowledge. Please leave a comment to let me know what you think about it! Share it to your friends and learn new things together.
Transcript
Page 1: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

7:50am, Apr 11, 2011Two Roanoke County Planning Commissioners, staff and I prepare to leave the Roanoke County Admin Center parking lot to visit the Beech Ridge industrial scale wind turbine installation.

Page 2: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

Three Roanoke County Planning Commissioners + additional staff load onto the county van at Mill Mountain Coffee & Tea in Daleville.

Page 3: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

As we reach Clifton Forge, we all make note of the landmark rock outcroppings along Route 220 and the Jackson River just North of the Head of the James

We then proceed on Interstate 64 West past the paper mill in Covington and speed through the vast stretches of the George Washington National Forest where logging has long been the primary industry. We’ll soon be going by White Sulpher Springs, West Virginia.

Page 4: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

As conscientious land use planners, we must learn to protect the sustainability of our natural environment. The George Washington and Jefferson National Forest cover a broad area of the Appalachian Mountains.

Page 5: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

Ah-h-h, wild & wonderful West Virginia! Look at all those golf courses we missed.And we could have come back and eaten a late afternoon lunch @ The Greenbrier. But no-o, “County’s on a tight budget” Arby’s @Lewisburg

Page 6: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

We continued West past Lewisburg, WV

The Arby’s, where we later stopped for lunch was down about there

Page 7: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

Continuing West on the Interstate, we past many clear cut ridge tops, similar to the one on the right; of which, we were completely unaware due to relative elevation difference.

As industries have become increasingly mechanized, the impact to our natural environment has multiplied dramatically. The cost of well-managed land restoration has been more expensive than we have been willing to pay for. Poorly “cared-for” lands become “hotbeds” for invasive species and completely disrupt the natural ecosystem. LAND USE PLANNING 2011

Page 8: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

We left I-64 at Sam Black Church and headed North thru Crawley WV to Shawver’s Crossing, where there’s a big, big logging yard.

Page 9: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

Shawver’s Crossing, where the RR track crosses old US Route 60, is on the way to Rupert, WV where we’ll travel northeast toward Beech Knob.

Page 10: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

Rupert, WV Our driver got a little confused as we reached the corner in Rupert as shown below. It’s hard to get lost in Rupert, so we quickly recovered and got on our way out Anjean Road to the northeast.

Page 11: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

BIG CLEAR CREEK CHURCH

Rupert, WV If I remember correctly, Big Clear Creek Church was a landmark that signaled the driver, he was on the correct road.Further along the road, we became aware of the meaning of Big Clear Creek. For about half of this distance on the 16 mile drive to Beech Knob, we traveled along a 30’ - 60’ wide beautiful rushing creek.

Page 12: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

1997

2003

2007

2009

Just North of Kessler WV on Anjean Rd we passed by a coal transfer station with a tipple leading back up into the mountain.Below are aerial images of that mining operation over the past 14 years.

From Kessler, a little over 2 miles back we saw very few dwellings. Those that we did see appeared to “hunting cabins.”

Page 13: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

Beech Ridge Wind Energy CenterWhile on the trip, I had little sense of scale. Afterwards, I estimate that we only toured about ¼ of the 10,000 acre installation.This aerial view describe the 16 mile route from Rupert to Beech Knob where we entered the Wind Energy Center

Page 14: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

Discovering Duo, WV (and Cobb & Clearco)While studying the area after our return from the trip I discovered some small unincorporated communities in the hollows around the wind farm. Duo is a small coal camp, that is still inhabited.

Page 15: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

The tiny community of Duo is dominated by nearby wind turbines as close as 3000 feet.The WV Public Service Commission, WV governing authority, conditioned developers to a one mile distance from any opposing residence for the 1.5 MW turbines. 2.5 to 4 MW turbines would require greater distances from residences (Canada & WHO: 2-3 miles)The residents of Duo, Cobb and Clearco agreed prior to the installation. Fortunately, they are predominantly upwind of the closest turbines.

Historic Photo of Duo Coal Camp

Page 16: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

Beech Ridge Wind Energy Center, LLCThe destination of our field trip. We were welcomed by Supervisor Ed Elswick, Maryellen Goodlatte, Atty., and Invenergy staff. We were told that the current online facility consisted of 67-1.5 MW wind turbines and construction would soon proceed to add 33 more, and likely up to a 186 MW “Nameplate Capacity” their licensed maximum. No current production data is available. Such data is expected to be made available after the project has been fully operational for one full year.The purple path is the on-site tour route.

Page 17: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

Beech Ridge Wind Energy Center, LLCHere we look back at the first two turbines we drove by. One commissioner was equipped with a decibel meter. I didn’t hear him discuss the hertz levels or filters he was using in his measurements.Now that I think about it, I’m not sure if the round cap on the top of it screwed off or not

Page 18: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

Here’s a Google simulation of turbines, JO1 & JO2

Page 19: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

Beech Ridge Wind Energy Center, LLCNear the site of JO3, the first turbine, where we disembarked our vehicles, Invenergy staff describes our location, our relationship to other turbines, and answers to a few questions. The wind speed on this knoll seemed to be between 25 – 30 mph. In this location we heard little other than the sound of the wind.

Page 20: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

The substation seems to have been planned for more capacity. In this area we heard some noise from turbines, the whoosh, whoosh sound as many people describe it. Here again it did not seem something to fear. Yet, to some the area had a harsh ominous feel to it: industrial.

Page 21: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

Here’s a Google simulation of turbines, J01, J02, J03 and the substation

Page 22: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

As we loaded up and travelled on the next stop, several noted the extraordinarily wide clear-cuts for roadways. Invenergy staff recalled their concerns with “choke” points in their path when moving components of the mammoth structures. 2-126’ blades to the truck are moved with one driver in the main cab and an auxiliary driver steering rear wheels, much like a Hook and Ladder truck.Extremely sparse topsoil in restoration areas

Page 23: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

Here’s a Google simulation of one of the turbines on Smokehouse Ridge above Duo, WV

Page 24: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

The next turbine we visited was on Smokehouse Ridge just above the coal camp of Duo, WV Invenergy staff called Chicago to have operators there shut down the turbines we were under for “safety concerns.”

Decibel meter readings here provided unimpressive readings

Page 25: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

As we were winding up our tour, we paused and disembarked from our vehicles. We were in a high hollow between 2 ridges. We were approx 1700 feet and 1800 feet from 2 turbines. We were upwind of them and heard no distinct noise from them. Higher up and over 3600 feet away, we heard the constant, regular, whooshing sounds of the blades from 3 other turbines. We were downwind of those and the terrain funneled the sound toward us. I think the Commissioners were just beginning to get an understanding of the nuisance potential of the noise as we were leaving. That’s a workman on top of that nacelle over 3600 feet away from us.

Page 26: Beech Ridge Wind Farm

As we left our hosts, all noticed a gateway to a neighbor’s property with some ominous looking icons higher up the hill. The turbines dominate the landscape and enough variables are involved that conditions will occur where sound, shadow flicker and environmental domination render such installations to be a significant nuisance and imposition upon residents’ lives, prohibiting them from continuing the peaceful enjoyment of their property.Setbacks from non-participating property lines must be a factor of turbine size. For protection of Roanoke County citizens; 3500’ of setback per 1MW of name plate capacity should be an absolute minimum standard based upon current wind turbine technology. Any reduction of setback should only be through

a judicially oriented variance process.