An Interdisciplinary Journal of Philosophy

INQUIRY An Interdisciplinary Journal of Philosophy

Founder

ARNE NAESS

Editor

ALASTAIR HANNAY

SCANDINAVIAN UNIVERSITY PRESS

INQUIRY ; An Interdisciplinary Journal of Philosophy

EDITOR Alastair Hannay FOUNDED BY Arne Naess

EDITORIAL BOARD Paul M. Churchland, University of California, San Diego; Stephen R. L. Clark, University of Liverpool; G. A. Cohen, All Souls College, Oxford; Hubert L. Dreyfus, University of California, Berkeley; Jon Elster, University of Chicago; Dagfinn Fgllesdal, Stanford University and University of Oslo; Helge Hgibraaten, University of Trondheim; Anthony O’Hear, University of

Bradford; Charles Taylor, McGill University

EDITORIAL POLICY Practice and theory in all areas depend on basic assumptions in the background of discussion. /nquiry gives precedence to articles and discussions which bring these assumptions into focus and which place questions of policy or theory in the wider context of traditional philosophical concerns. Preference is also given to papers composed in a style that renders their content accessible to non-specialists. Times will as a rule be published within one year of receipt. / Reviews are confined to extended discussions of books selected for their special interest. Books sent for review are listed in each issue. / Instructions for authors are given on the inside back-cover.

TYPESCRIPTS for consideration and books for review should be addressed to:

The Editor, Inquiry, Department of Philosophy, P.O. Box 1024 Blindern, N-0315 Oslo 3, Norway

PUBLISHER Correspondence concerning subscriptions and orders for offprints should be sent to the Publisher: Scandinavian University Press, P.O. Box 2959 Toyen, N-0608 Oslo 6, Norway. American office: c/o Publications Expediting Inc., 200 Meacham Ave., Elmont, NY 11003, USA. Inquiry is published with grants from the Norwegian Research Council for Science and the Humanities.

SUBSCRIPTION PRICE per volume (four issues — airmail postage included): Institutions USD 106.00. Individuals USD 50.00. Nordic countries only: Institutions NOK 595,-. Individuals NOK 295,—. Visa/American Express/Mastercard/Eurocard accepted.

In Japan, all subscriptions should be ordered through the Maruzen Co. Ltd., 3-10 Nihonbashi 2-Chome, Chuo-ku, Tokyo, Japan.

This journal can be ordered in microform from University Microfilms International, 300 North Zeeb Road, Dept. P.R., Ann Arbor, Mi. 48106, USA.

Inquiry is indexed/abstracted in: ABC POL SCI, Am. Hist. Life (1972-), Arts & Humanit. Citation Ind., Current Contents/Arts & Humanit., Exp. Acad. Index, Hist. Abstr., Part A, Mod. Hist. Abstr. (1972-), Hist. Abstr., Part B, Twent. Century Abstr. (1972-), Index Book Rev. Humanit., Intern. Bibliogr. Soc. Sc., Intern. Current Awaren. Serv., Periodica Islamica, Philos. Index, Soc. Plan. Policy Dev. Abstr., Sociol. Abstr.

Published quarterly by Scandinavian University Press, Oslo, Norway. Annual subscription USD 106.00/50.00. Second Class Postage is paid at Jamaica, NY 11431. U.S. Postmasters: Send address changes to Inquiry, Publications Expediting Inc., 200 Meacham Ave., Elmont, NY 11003. Air freight mailing in the U.S. by Publications Expediting Inc., 200 Meacham Ave., Elmont, NY 11003.

Typeset and printed in Great Britain by ——— Page Bros, Norwich

CONTENTS

ALLISON, HENRY E.: Spinoza and the Philosophy of Immanence: Reflections on Yovel’s The Adventures of Immanence

AMERIKS, KARL: Kant and Hegel on Freedom: Two New Interpretations

BORGMANN, ALBERT: The Moral Significance of the Material Culture

CALLICOTT, J. BAIRD: Can a Theory of Moral Sentiments Support a Genuinely Normative ST ins nk irnduiidstevhsnaesalahienmiersesbencivnnes

COLLIER, CHARLES W-.: Intellectual Authority and Institutional Authority

DUMOUCHEL, PAUL: Gilbert Simondon’s Plea for a Philosophy of Technology

EZRAHI, YARON: Technology and the Civil

Epistemology of Democracy FALK, BARRIE: Wittgenstein on What One Meant and

What One Would Have Said FEENBERG, ANDREW: Subversive Rationalization:

Technology, Power, and Democracy

FELDMAN, SEYMOUR: Spinoza: A Marrano of IIIT si blichAdninitibecrendicdbebiihaeh ide dslinsbiteasonntpberencetene

IHDE, DON: Image Technologies and Traditional Culture KLEIN, DANIEL B.: Go Ahead and Let Him Try: A

Plea for Egonomic Laissez-faire LONGINO, HELEN E.: Knowledge, Bodies, and Values:

Reproductive Technologies and their Scientific Context .. POOLE, ROSS: Living with Reason SCHACHT, RICHARD: Adventures of Immanence

Revisited TIJMES, PIETER: The Archimedean Point and

Eccentricity: Hannah Arendt’s Philosophy of Science and Technology

WINNER, LANGDON: Citizen Virtues in a

Technological Order YOVEL, YIRMIYAHU: Spinoza and Other Heretics:

Reply to Critics

Review Discussions CODY, ARTHUR B.: Sharpe Paratactics (Robert A.

Sharpe, Making the Human Mind)

CONTENTS

COOPER, DAVID E.: Inverting the Image: Dreyfus’s Commentary on Heidegger (Hubert L. Dreyfus, Being-

in-the-World: A Commentary on Heidegger’s Being and

Time, Division 1) GILLETT, GRANT: Unpacking the Black Box of

Cognition (D. W. Hamlyn, Jn and Out of the Black Box:

On the Philosophy of Cognition)

GRANT, ROBERT: The Politics of Equilibrium

(Torbjérn Tannsj6, Conservatism for Our Time) LUNTLEY, MICHAEL: Practice Makes Knowledge?

(Pierre Bourdieu, The Logic of Practice) PERSSON, INGMAR: The Indeterminacy and

Insignificance of Personal Identity (Peter Unger,

Identity, Consciousness and Value) SANFORD, DAVID H.: The Anastylosis of Reason:

Fitting Together Stich’s Fragments (Stephen P. Stich, The Fragmentation of Reason: Preface to a Pragmatic Theory of Cognitive Evaluation)

Books Received

Symposia Yirmiyahu Yove'’s Spinoza and Other Heretics Symposium on Technology and Human Values 291-421