Top Banner

Click here to load reader

1 Is Section 363 All You Need to Know about Chapter 11? Breaking it Down and Recent Developments Jonathan N. Helfat David W. Morse

Mar 28, 2015



  • Slide 1

1 Is Section 363 All You Need to Know about Chapter 11? Breaking it Down and Recent Developments Jonathan N. Helfat David W. Morse Slide 2 2 Overview The New Chapter 11 Paradigm? 363 Sales replace the Plan of ReorganizationHow did we get here? The 363 Sale Process What is it? Why is it so popular? What do you need to know about it? Whats a credit bid and how does it work? Chrysler in perspective: What really happened? Your rights under the loan documents when it comes to a sale of the business Slide 3 3 Why Are We Talking About 363 Sales? How Did We Get Here? Once upon a timeCompanies spent months and years in Chapter 11 Now30, 60, 90 daysThen, a sale of the business Why? The Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act of 2005 (BAPCPA) Too much leverage Slide 4 4 What about the 2005 Amendments Led to This? Utilities protection: Additional adequate assurance for utilities Vendor protection: Additional reclamation claims for vendors Employee protection: Increase in monetary limits on priority claims for wages, etc. Post-petition claims for ad valorem taxes priming secured and administrative claims Accessing value of real estate: Timing for acceptance or rejection of leases Limiting exclusivity period Slide 5 5 The Debt Laden Balance Sheet Access to credit allows weak companies to survive longer Companies arrive in Chapter 11 with more debt Where are the assets to generate liquidity to support the restructure? No reason for secured lenders to take risk to provide liquidity unless certainty of collateral values Scarcity of capital generally Loss of value of real estate and leases Slide 6 6 What is a Section 363 Sale? Section 363(b): Chapter 11 Debtor may only sell assets--other than in the ordinary course of business with approval of the Bankruptcy Court after notice and a hearing Sales can be of any assets or all or substantially all of the assets Highest and best price Good faith: Sale in good faith in an arms length transaction Slide 7 7 The Section 363 Sale Process Step 1Debtor markets assets Step 2Prospective buyers offer LOIs Step 3First Auction: Debtor selects stalking horse Step 4Debtor and stalking horse negotiate: Purchase agreement Deal protections Bidding procedures Step 5Debtor files motion to approve sale and bidding procedures Step 620 days later: Court approves bid procedures Step 7Second Auction: Highest and best Step 8Order entered to approve sale Step 910 days after sale order, if no objections order becomes final and non-appealable, unless waived by court Step 10Closing Slide 8 8 Why a Section 363 Sale? Reason #1: Speed Timing: Faster than a plan process Origins of 363: The melting ice cube metaphor 1983 Second Circuit Lionel decision: Is the asset increasing or decreasing in value? Proper business justification Sub rosa plan argument Some courts have problem with speed Slide 9 9 Why a Section 363 Sale? Reason #2: Transfer of Executory Contracts Buyers have ability to obtain some contracts and leases and not others Anti-assignment clauses otherwise enforceable, not enforceable in bankruptcy Requirements for Debtor to assume and assign Cure any defaults Adequate assurance of future performance Slide 10 10 Why a Section 363 Sale? Reason #3: Sale Free and Clear of Liens Section 363 allows sales free and clear of liens with or without consent of lienholder But under Section 363(f) one of following conditions must be satisfied: Applicable non-bankruptcy law permits sale of such property free and clear of interest the lienholder consents The sale price of the property is greater than the aggregate value of all liens on such property The interest in the sold property is in a bona fide dispute The lienholder could be compelled, in a legal or equitable proceeding, to accept a money satisfaction of its interest Slide 11 11 Why a Section 363 Sale? Other Limitations on Sale Free and Clear Lienholder must receive proper notice of sale Some liabilities cannot be eliminated Environmental liabilities Successor liability for labor and tort claims Assets outside of the United States Assumption of liabilities New caveat of Clear Channel Slide 12 12 Reason #4: Finality of Sale--Good Faith Purchaser Protection Court examines conduct of buyerabsence of: Fraud Collusion between buyer and seller Unfair advantage of other bidders Bribes to insiders of debtor Sale order must expressly state: buyer is good faith purchaser What are protections? Waiver of automatic 10 day stay period after sale order Statutory mootness: Sale cannot be modified or overturned, unless the sale is stayed pending appeal Slide 13 13 Trouble in Paradise: Good Faith Purchaser Protection Meets Clear Channel DB Burbank, LLC makes $40 million loan to PW secured by 18 parcels of real estate Borrower defaults DB Burbank starts foreclosure PW files Chapter 11; Chapter 11 trustee appointed DB becomes stalking horse bidder with credit bid equal to its $40 million debt DB is winning bidder; assets sold free and clear of all liensincluding junior lien of Clear Channel Slide 14 14 The Clear Channel Problem: So What Happened? Clear Channel had objected to sale Bankruptcy Court Overruled objection Denied request for a stay and Sale went forward Credit bid did not result in any cash to bankruptcy estateClear Channel receives nothing Sale Order says DB Burbank, LLC is good faith purchaser On appeal, Bankruptcy Appellate Panel says: Sale is valid But not free and clear: Clear Channel junior lien continues Remands back to Bankruptcy Court Slide 15 15 The Clear Channel Problem: So What Does this Mean? Intercreditor Agreement any one? New tool for junior lienholders? Delay closing until appeals are settled? Provisions in purchase agreements to protect purchasers Lower purchase price Present the evidence: Need 1 of 5 ways to satisfy 363(f) to allow lien release Clear Channel decision not binding outside 9 th Circuit Slide 16 16 Why a 363 Sale? Other Reasons No fraudulent transfer liability risk No bulk transfer liability Ability to bind non-consenting stockholders Less diligence on liabilities since sold free and clear Ability to credit bid Slide 17 17 Consent to the Sale and Credit Bidding: What is Credit Bidding? Section 363(k) Secured creditor right to bid at 363 sale Offset claim against purchase price Credit bids using senior secured claims are like cash bids Bid total face amount of claim Impact on highest and best requirement Results in transfer of collateral to Lender in exercise of remedies by Lender Slide 18 18 Key Points for the Secured Lender in a 363 Sale: You May Not Get it All! Estate cannot be left administratively insolvent Assignment and assumption of contracts Other creditors to be paid Funding of business from filing to sale Transfer of trademark licenses Slide 19 19 Chrysler: What Really Happened? April 30: Chrysler and 24 subs file Chapter 11 May 1: Debtor engage financial consulting and advisory firms and investment bankers May 1: Debtors seek approval for an expedited hearing on motion to approve bidding procedures and schedule sale hearing May 31: Bankruptcy Court renders opinion approving the Debtors motion seeking authority to sell substantially all of its assets Slide 20 20 Chrysler: What Happened to the Sale Proceeds? $10 billion first lien facility provided by syndicate of lenders $2 billion second lien facility provided by Daimler Financial and Cerberus $4 billion third lien facility provided by US Treasury $4.96 billion DIP financing provided by US Treasury and Export Development Canada Slide 21 21 Chrysler: So What is the Issue? Equity owners of New Chrysler VEBA owns 55% US Treasury owns 8% Export Development Canada owns 2% Fiat owns 20% What rights would these parties have had in a plan? Bankruptcy Court and secured lenders have no say over who owns the purchaser Slide 22 22 The Real Issue: What are Your Rights under the Loan Documents? Consent to Sale Credit Bid Slide 23 23 Your Rights under the Loan Documents: Background Origins of syndicated loan structure Appointment of Agent Agents discretionary rights Rights of individual Lenders to enforce rights Amendments and Waivers Forgive principal Extend maturity Release all or substantially all of collateral or guarantees Slide 24 24 Rights under the Loan Documents: The Beal Case New York Court of Appeals March 2007 Parent gives a keep-well agreement Agent and Lenders with 95.5% of debt enter into settlement agreement Settlement agreement includes forbearance from calling on keep-well agreement Beal holds outstarts unilateral action to collect payment under keep-well agreement Slide 25 25 The Beal Case: NY Court of Appeals Says Collective Enforcement Mechanism For Beal: Keep-well agreement says it is for the benefit of and shall be enforceable by the Agent and each Lender Credit Agreement says no amendment, modification or waiver so as to release the Sponsors under the Keep-Well Agreementwithout the consent of all Lenders For Agent and Other Lenders: Credit Agreement says, if any Event of Default occursAgent, upon direction of Required Lendersshall exercise any or all rights and remedies, including recover judgment on the Keep-Well Agreement Credit Agreement authorizes Agent to act on behalf of Lenders and to exercise powers delegated to it Slide 26 26 Consent to Sale: Enforcement Provisions Chrysler (May 31, 2009) Each lender designated Agent to act as such lenders agent in exercising powers delegated to Agent During default, Agent has power to take any Collateral Enforcement Actions including to realize upon the Collateral No secured party will take any Collateral Enforcement Action without consent of Agent Metaldyne (August 12, 2009) Each lender appoints Agent to take such action on its behalf as are delegated to the Agent by terms of the Loan Documents Agent may exercise all rights afforded a secured party, including the right to sell or otherwise dispose of the Collateral Slide 27 27 Amendment Provisions v. Enfo